ECLA, Washington and Inter-American Economic Relations, 1948–1968

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

ECLA, Washington and Inter-American Economic Relations, 1948–1968 ISSN 1728-5437 SERIES STUDIES AND PERSPECTIVES 20 ECLAC OFFICE IN WASHINGTON, D.C. ECLA, Washington and Inter-American Economic Relations, 1948–1968 Isaac Cohen Thank you for your interest in this ECLAC publication ECLAC Publications Please register if you would like to receive information on our editorial products and activities. When you register, you may specify your particular areas of interest and you will gain access to our products in other formats. www.cepal.org/en/publications ublicaciones www.cepal.org/apps 20 ECLA, Washington and Inter-American Economic Relations, 1948–1968 Isaac Cohen This document has been prepared by Isaac Cohen, former Director of ECLAC Washington Office, and President of INVERWAY, LLC, a consulting company based in Washington, D.C. The views expressed in this document, which has been reproduced without formal editing, are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Organization. United Nations publication ISSN: 1728-5437 (electronic version) ISSN: 1727-9909 (print version) LC/TS.2020/38 LC/WAS/TS.2020/1 Distribution: Lp Copyright © United Nations, 2020 All rights reserved Printed at United Nations, Santiago 20-00222 This publication should be cited as: I. Cohen, “ECLA, Washington and Inter-American Economic Relations, 1948–1968”, Studies and Perspectives series- ECLAC Office in Washington, D.C., No. 20 (LC/TS.2020/38-LC/WAS/TS.2020/1), Santiago, Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC), 2020. Applications for authorization to reproduce this work in whole or in part should be sent to the Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC), Publications and Web Services Division, [email protected]. Member States and their governmental institutions may reproduce this work without prior authorization, but are requested to mention the source and to inform ECLAC of such reproduction. ECLAC - Studies and Perspectives series-Washington, D.C. No. 20 ECLA, Washington … 3 Contents Abstract .............................................................................................................................................................................. 7 Abbreviations ................................................................................................................................................................... 9 Introduction ..................................................................................................................................................................... 11 References .................................................................................................................................................................. 13 Time line .......................................................................................................................................................................... 15 I. Creation and continuation, 1948–1951 ......................................................................................................... 23 A. Introduction ..................................................................................................................................................... 23 B. The creation of the Economic Commission for Latin America ....................................................... 23 C. Negotiations ....................................................................................................................................................24 1. Chilean diplomacy .....................................................................................................................................24 2. United States diplomacy ......................................................................................................................... 26 3. United States position .............................................................................................................................. 27 D. Concrete results in Montevideo ............................................................................................................... 30 1. Consultations .............................................................................................................................................. 30 2. Concrete steps............................................................................................................................................ 31 E. Changed circumstances ............................................................................................................................... 32 1. The primacy of security: Korea ............................................................................................................. 32 2. A new helmsman ....................................................................................................................................... 33 ECLAC - Studies and Perspectives series-Washington, D.C. No. 20 ECLA, Washington … 4 F. Solution in Mexico .........................................................................................................................................34 G. The Economic Commission for Latin America, Washington............................................................ 38 H. Epilogue............................................................................................................................................................. 39 References ..................................................................................................................................................................43 II. A place in the sun, 1952–1954 .........................................................................................................................45 A. Introduction .....................................................................................................................................................45 B. Recruitment ......................................................................................................................................................45 1. Building a team ..........................................................................................................................................46 2. Cold War compulsions ............................................................................................................................49 C. Breakthrough ...................................................................................................................................................54 D. On to Caracas .................................................................................................................................................. 56 E. The Caracas Conference .............................................................................................................................. 59 F. Evaluations ........................................................................................................................................................ 71 References .................................................................................................................................................................. 73 III. The road to Quitandinha, 1954 .................................................................................................................. 75 A. Introduction ..................................................................................................................................................... 75 B. Preparations ..................................................................................................................................................... 75 1. In the United States .................................................................................................................................. 76 2. In Latin America ....................................................................................................................................... 104 C. The Quitandinha Conference .................................................................................................................... 112 D. Epilogue............................................................................................................................................................ 117 References ................................................................................................................................................................. 118 IV. The road to Buenos Aires, 1955–1956 .................................................................................................... 121 A. Introduction ....................................................................................................................................................121 B. United States preparatory activities ........................................................................................................ 121 C. The role of the Economic Commission for Latin America.............................................................. 131 D. The Buenos Aires Economic Conference, 15 August–3 September 1957 .................................. 137 E. The outcome .................................................................................................................................................. 142 References ...............................................................................................................................................................
Recommended publications
  • Download Report
    COUNCIL ON FOREIGN RELATIONS AN NUAL RE PORT JULY 1, 2003-JUNE 30, 2004 Main Office Washington Office The Harold Pratt House 1779 Massachusetts Avenue, NW 58 East 68th Street, New York, NY 10021 Washington, DC 20036 Tel. (212) 434-9400; Fax (212) 434-9800 Tel. (202) 518-3400; Fax (202) 986-2984 Website www.cfr.org E-mail [email protected] OFFICERS and DIRECTORS 2004-2005 OFFICERS DIRECTORS Term Expiring 2009 Peter G. Peterson* Term Expiring 2005 Madeleine K. Albright Chairman of the Board Jessica P Einhorn Richard N. Fostert Carla A. Hills* Louis V Gerstner Jr. Maurice R. Greenbergt Vice Chairman Carla A. Hills*t Robert E. Rubin George J. Mitchell Vice Chairman Robert E. Rubin Joseph S. Nye Jr. Richard N. Haass Warren B. Rudman Fareed Zakaria President Andrew Young Michael R Peters Richard N. Haass ex officio Executive Vice President Term Expiring 2006 Janice L. Murray Jeffrey L. Bewkes Senior Vice President OFFICERS AND and Treasurer Henry S. Bienen DIRECTORS, EMERITUS David Kellogg Lee Cullum AND HONORARY Senior Vice President, Corporate Richard C. Holbrooke Leslie H. Gelb Affairs, and Publisher Joan E. Spero President Emeritus Irina A. Faskianos Vice President, Vin Weber Maurice R. Greenberg Honorary Vice Chairman National Program and Academic Outreach Term Expiring 2007 Charles McC. Mathias Jr. Elise Carlson Lewis Fouad Ajami Director Emeritus Vice President, Membership David Rockefeller Kenneth M. Duberstein and Fellowship Affairs Honorary Chairman Ronald L. Olson James M. Lindsay Robert A. Scalapino Vice President, Director of Peter G. Peterson* t Director Emeritus Studies, Maurice R. Creenberg Chair Lhomas R.
    [Show full text]
  • John F. Helliwell, Richard Layard and Jeffrey D. Sachs
    2018 John F. Helliwell, Richard Layard and Jeffrey D. Sachs Table of Contents World Happiness Report 2018 Editors: John F. Helliwell, Richard Layard, and Jeffrey D. Sachs Associate Editors: Jan-Emmanuel De Neve, Haifang Huang and Shun Wang 1 Happiness and Migration: An Overview . 3 John F. Helliwell, Richard Layard and Jeffrey D. Sachs 2 International Migration and World Happiness . 13 John F. Helliwell, Haifang Huang, Shun Wang and Hugh Shiplett 3 Do International Migrants Increase Their Happiness and That of Their Families by Migrating? . 45 Martijn Hendriks, Martijn J. Burger, Julie Ray and Neli Esipova 4 Rural-Urban Migration and Happiness in China . 67 John Knight and Ramani Gunatilaka 5 Happiness and International Migration in Latin America . 89 Carol Graham and Milena Nikolova 6 Happiness in Latin America Has Social Foundations . 115 Mariano Rojas 7 America’s Health Crisis and the Easterlin Paradox . 146 Jeffrey D. Sachs Annex: Migrant Acceptance Index: Do Migrants Have Better Lives in Countries That Accept Them? . 160 Neli Esipova, Julie Ray, John Fleming and Anita Pugliese The World Happiness Report was written by a group of independent experts acting in their personal capacities. Any views expressed in this report do not necessarily reflect the views of any organization, agency or programme of the United Nations. 2 Chapter 1 3 Happiness and Migration: An Overview John F. Helliwell, Vancouver School of Economics at the University of British Columbia, and Canadian Institute for Advanced Research Richard Layard, Wellbeing Programme, Centre for Economic Performance, at the London School of Economics and Political Science Jeffrey D. Sachs, Director, SDSN, and Director, Center for Sustainable Development, Columbia University The authors are grateful to the Ernesto Illy Foundation and the Canadian Institute for Advanced Research for research support, and to Gallup for data access and assistance.
    [Show full text]
  • Reports of Committees and Principal Sub-Committees
    UNITED NATIONS CONFERENCE ON TRADE AND EMPLOYMENT HELD AT HAVANA, CUBA FROM 21 NOVEMBER 1947 TO 24 MARCH 1948 REPORTS OF COMMITTEES AND PRINCIPAL SUB-COMMITTEES INTERIM COMMISSION FOR THE INTERNATIONAL TRADE ORGANIZATION GENEVA SEPTEMBER 1948 ICITO 1/8 September 1948 This collection of reports has been assembled and edited by the Secretariat of the Interim Commission. These reports are to be read in conjunction with The Final Act and Related Documents of the Havana Conference (United Nations document ICITO/1/4 or E/CONF. 2/78) and the Report of the Second Session of the Preparatory Committee (United Nations document E/PC/T/186). The texts of the Havana Charter and Resolutions appear in the former. The text of the " Geneva Draft " appears in the latte . TABLE OF CONTENTS Page Introduction .... ...... 5 I. Reports relating to the First Committee: Employment and Economic Activity. 7 II. Reports relating to the Second Committee: Economic Development .I9 III. Reports relating to the Third Committee: Commercial Policy .39 IV. Reports relating to the Fourth Committee: Restrictive Business Practices .120 V. Reports relating to the Fifth Committee: Inter-governmental Commodity Agreements.127 VI. Reports relating to the Sixth Committee: Organization .149 VII. Documents relating to the Co-ordinating Committee. 160 Reference List Identifying Proposals of Individual Delegations 164 Indices in terms of the Article, Section and Chapter Numbers of the Geneva Draft and of the Havana Charter . 177 INTRODUCTION The terms of reference of the Interim Commission for the International Trade Organization, after enumerating certain specific functions, provide that the Commission shall " generally perform such other functions as may be ancillary and necessary to the effective carrying out of the provisions of this Annex ".
    [Show full text]
  • Killing Hope U.S
    Killing Hope U.S. Military and CIA Interventions Since World War II – Part I William Blum Zed Books London Killing Hope was first published outside of North America by Zed Books Ltd, 7 Cynthia Street, London NI 9JF, UK in 2003. Second impression, 2004 Printed by Gopsons Papers Limited, Noida, India w w w.zedbooks .demon .co .uk Published in South Africa by Spearhead, a division of New Africa Books, PO Box 23408, Claremont 7735 This is a wholly revised, extended and updated edition of a book originally published under the title The CIA: A Forgotten History (Zed Books, 1986) Copyright © William Blum 2003 The right of William Blum to be identified as the author of this work has been asserted by him in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. Cover design by Andrew Corbett ISBN 1 84277 368 2 hb ISBN 1 84277 369 0 pb Spearhead ISBN 0 86486 560 0 pb 2 Contents PART I Introduction 6 1. China 1945 to 1960s: Was Mao Tse-tung just paranoid? 20 2. Italy 1947-1948: Free elections, Hollywood style 27 3. Greece 1947 to early 1950s: From cradle of democracy to client state 33 4. The Philippines 1940s and 1950s: America's oldest colony 38 5. Korea 1945-1953: Was it all that it appeared to be? 44 6. Albania 1949-1953: The proper English spy 54 7. Eastern Europe 1948-1956: Operation Splinter Factor 56 8. Germany 1950s: Everything from juvenile delinquency to terrorism 60 9. Iran 1953: Making it safe for the King of Kings 63 10.
    [Show full text]
  • The Kennedy Administration's Alliance for Progress and the Burdens Of
    The Kennedy Administration’s Alliance for Progress and the Burdens of the Marshall Plan Christopher Hickman Latin America is irrevocably committed to the quest for modernization.1 The Marshall Plan was, and the Alliance is, a joint enterprise undertaken by a group of nations with a common cultural heritage, a common opposition to communism and a strong community of interest in the specific goals of the program.2 History is more a storehouse of caveats than of patented remedies for the ills of mankind.3 The United States and its Marshall Plan (1948–1952), or European Recovery Program (ERP), helped create sturdy Cold War partners through the economic rebuilding of Europe. The Marshall Plan, even as mere symbol and sign of U.S. commitment, had a crucial role in re-vitalizing war-torn Europe and in capturing the allegiance of prospective allies. Instituting and carrying out the European recovery mea- sures involved, as Dean Acheson put it, “ac- tion in truly heroic mold.”4 The Marshall Plan quickly became, in every way, a paradigmatic “counter-force” George Kennan had requested in his influential July 1947 Foreign Affairs ar- President John F. Kennedy announces the ticle. Few historians would disagree with the Alliance for Progress on March 13, 1961. Christopher Hickman is a visiting assistant professor of history at the University of North Florida. I presented an earlier version of this paper at the 2008 Policy History Conference in St. Louis, Missouri. I appreciate the feedback of panel chair and panel commentator Robert McMahon of The Ohio State University. I also benefited from the kind financial assistance of the John F.
    [Show full text]
  • Part V the Organization, the Institution and the Future
    Part V The organization, the institution and the future Chapter 14 Leadership of the organization and management of the institution 503 Chapter 15 The future of the WTO 549 14 Leadership of the organization and management of the institution [Institutions] evolve incrementally, connecting the past with the present and the future; history in consequence is largely a story of institutional evolution in which the historical performance of economies can only be understood as a part of a sequential story. Institutions provide the incentive structure of an economy; as that structure evolves, it shapes the direction of economic change towards growth, stagnation, or decline. Douglass C. North “Institutions” (1991) Introduction In a happy coincidence of theory and practice, Douglass North wrote his seminal essay on “Institutions” at almost precisely the same time that the WTO was first proposed. “Institutions are the humanly devised constraints that structure political, economic and social interaction,” he wrote (1991: 97), and “consist of both informal constraints (sanctions, taboos, customs, traditions, and codes of conduct), and formal rules (constitutions, laws, property rights)” that CHAPTER 14 human beings have devised throughout history “to create order and reduce uncertainty in exchange.” That is as good a definition as any of the purposes of the WTO, which may be further distinguished according to its two halves. The WTO is at once an institution staffed by international civil servants and an organization to which members belong. While it is the organizational half of the WTO that is chiefly responsible for writing new rules, the institutional half not only facilitates those negotiations but also administers agreements, monitors the members’ compliance with the rules, and promotes the capacity of the developing members to participate more effectively in the organization and to take advantage of the opportunities that a more open market affords.
    [Show full text]
  • Just Before Bretton Woods: the Atlantic City Conference, June 1944
    JUST BEFORE BRETTON WOODS: THE ATLANTIC CITY CONFERENCE, JUNE 1944 Just Before Bretton Woods: The Atlantic City Conference, June 1944 Edited by Kurt Schuler and Gabrielle Canning CENTER FOR FINANCIAL STABILITY NEW YORK Copyright 2019 by Kurt Schuler and Gabrielle Canning. All rights reserved. Until 2030, no part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form without written permission from the authors. Send requests to Kurt Schuler, <[email protected]>. Starting in 2030, the authors permit anyone to reproduce the electronic edition of the book and the online companion files, provided that there is no alteration to the original content and that distribution to readers is free. The authors continue to reserve all other rights, including the rights to the print edition and translation rights. E-book and print editions published 2019 by the Center for Financial Stability, 1120 Avenue of the Americas, 4th floor, New York, NY 10036 Cover by Laneen Wells, Sublation Studio; front cover design inspired by the Claridge Hotel, Atlantic City Online companion files to this book are available at the Web site of the Center for Financial Stability, <www.centerforfinancialstability.org> Cataloging data will be available from the Library of Congress ISBN 978-1-941801-04-8 (e-book), 978-1-941801-05-5 (hardcover) The Center for Financial Stability (CFS) is a private, nonprofit institution focusing on global finance and markets. Its research is nonpartisan. This publication reflects the judgments of the authors. It does not necessarily represent the views of members of the Center’s Advisory Board or Trustees, or their affiliated organizations.
    [Show full text]
  • List of Presidents of the Presidents United Nations General Assembly
    Sixty-seventh session of the General Assembly To convene on United Nations 18 September 2012 List of Presidents of the Presidents United Nations General Assembly Session Year Name Country Sixty-seventh 2012 Mr. Vuk Jeremić (President-elect) Serbia Sixty-sixth 2011 Mr. Nassir Abdulaziz Al-Nasser Qatar Sixty-fifth 2010 Mr. Joseph Deiss Switzerland Sixty-fourth 2009 Dr. Ali Abdussalam Treki Libyan Arab Jamahiriya Tenth emergency special (resumed) 2009 Father Miguel d’Escoto Brockmann Nicaragua Sixty-third 2008 Father Miguel d’Escoto Brockmann Nicaragua Sixty-second 2007 Dr. Srgjan Kerim The former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia Tenth emergency special (resumed twice) 2006 Sheikha Haya Rashed Al Khalifa Bahrain Sixty-first 2006 Sheikha Haya Rashed Al Khalifa Bahrain Sixtieth 2005 Mr. Jan Eliasson Sweden Twenty-eighth special 2005 Mr. Jean Ping Gabon Fifty-ninth 2004 Mr. Jean Ping Gabon Tenth emergency special (resumed) 2004 Mr. Julian Robert Hunte Saint Lucia (resumed twice) 2003 Mr. Julian Robert Hunte Saint Lucia Fifty-eighth 2003 Mr. Julian Robert Hunte Saint Lucia Fifty-seventh 2002 Mr. Jan Kavan Czech Republic Twenty-seventh special 2002 Mr. Han Seung-soo Republic of Korea Tenth emergency special (resumed twice) 2002 Mr. Han Seung-soo Republic of Korea (resumed) 2001 Mr. Han Seung-soo Republic of Korea Fifty-sixth 2001 Mr. Han Seung-soo Republic of Korea Twenty-sixth special 2001 Mr. Harri Holkeri Finland Twenty-fifth special 2001 Mr. Harri Holkeri Finland Tenth emergency special (resumed) 2000 Mr. Harri Holkeri Finland Fifty-fifth 2000 Mr. Harri Holkeri Finland Twenty-fourth special 2000 Mr. Theo-Ben Gurirab Namibia Twenty-third special 2000 Mr.
    [Show full text]
  • CAROL LEE GRAHAM CURRENT POSITIONS Leo Pasvolsky
    CAROL LEE GRAHAM CURRENT POSITIONS Leo Pasvolsky Senior Fellow, Global Economy and Development Program, The Brookings Institution College Park Professor, School of Public Policy, University of Maryland Senior Scientist, The Gallup Organization Research Fellow, Institute for the Study of Labor (IZA), Bonn Expertise: poverty, inequality, subjective well-being, economics of happiness; development economics Regions: Latin American, Africa, Eastern Europe; U.S. PREVIOUS POSITIONS Professor, School of Public Policy, University of Maryland, 2005-2008. Co-Director, Center on Social and Economic Dynamics, and Senior Fellow, Economic Studies, The Brookings Institution, 1998-2006. Vice President and Director, Governance Studies Program, The Brookings Institution, July 2002-June 2004. Visiting Professor, Department of Economics, Johns Hopkins University, 1999-2000 Special Advisor to the Deputy Managing Director, International Monetary Fund Fall, 2001. Special Advisor to the Executive Vice President, Inter-American Development Bank, 1997-98. Visiting Fellow, World Bank, Office of the Chief Economist and Vice Presidency for Human Resources, 1994-95. Participated in design and implementation of safety net programs in Latin America and Eastern Europe. Developed comparative research project on political sustainability of reform. Georgetown University, Department of Government, Adjunct Professor, 1990-1994. Guest Scholar, Foreign Policy Studies, The Brookings Institution, 1990 - 1994. Research on safety nets and the sustainability of economic reform in Latin America, Africa, and Eastern Europe. Funded by World Bank, IDB, and the MacArthur Foundation. Carol Lee Graham/2 of 24 12/18/20 Duke University, Department of Political Science, Assistant Professor, August 1989 - May 1990. EDUCATION 1980-1984 Princeton University - A.B. (High Honors) Woodrow Wilson School of Public and International Affairs 1985-1986 The Johns Hopkins University School of Advanced International Studies - M.A.
    [Show full text]
  • The United Nations at 70 Isbn: 978-92-1-101322-1
    DOUBLESPECIAL DOUBLESPECIAL asdf The magazine of the United Nations BLE ISSUE UN Chronicle ISSUEIS 7PMVNF-**t/VNCFSTt Rio+20 THE UNITED NATIONS AT 70 ISBN: 978-92-1-101322-1 COVER.indd 2-3 8/19/15 11:07 AM UNDER-SECRETARY-GENERAL FOR COMMUNICATIONS AND PUBLIC INFORMATION Cristina Gallach DIRECTOR OF PUBLICATION Maher Nasser EDITOR-IN-CHIEF Ramu Damodaran EDITOR Federigo Magherini ART AND DESIGN Lavinia Choerab EDITORIAL ASSISTANTS Lyubov Ginzburg, Jennifer Payulert, Jason Pierce SOCIAL MEDIA ASSISTANT Maria Laura Placencia The UN Chronicle is published quarterly by the Outreach Division of the United Nations Department of Public Information. Please address all editorial correspondence: By e-mail [email protected] By phone 1 212 963-6333 By fax 1 917 367-6075 By mail UN Chronicle, United Nations, Room S-920 New York, NY 10017, USA Subscriptions: Customer service in the USA: United Nations Publications Turpin Distribution Service PO Box 486 New Milford, CT 06776-0486 USA Email: [email protected] Web: ebiz.turpin-distribution.com Tel +1-860-350-0041 Fax +1-860-350-0039 Customer service in the UK: United Nations Publications Turpin Distribution Service Pegasus Drive, Stratton Business Park Biggleswade SG18 8TQ United Kingdom Email: [email protected] Web: ebiz.turpin-distribution.com Tel +1 44 (0) 1767 604951 Fax +1 44 (0) 1767 601640 Reproduction: Articles contained in this issue may be reproduced for educational purposes in line with fair use. Please send a copy of the reprint to the editorial correspondence address shown above. However, no part may be reproduced for commercial purposes without the expressed written consent of the Secretary, Publications Board, United Nations, Room S-949 New York, NY 10017, USA © 2015 United Nations.
    [Show full text]
  • Papers of ADOLF A. SERLE, 1912-1974
    Papers of ADOLF A. SERLE, 1912-1974 Accession Numbers: Ms. 74-11 , Ms . 74-14, Ms . 75- 9, Ms . 83-11 , The papers were presented to the Library by Mrs. Adolf A. Serle in 1973, 1974, a nd 1982. Mrs. Be rle 's copyrigh t interest in these papers has been do­ nated to the' Un ited States Government. However, Mrs. Serle and Travis S. Jacobs published an edited version of Adolf A. Berle 's diary under the title Navigating the Rapids 1918-1971: From the Papers of Adolf A. Serle. Copy­ right to tha t part of the diary published in Navig a ting the Rapids, which amoun ts to approximately 20 percent of the total di ary fi le, has been retained by the publishe r Harcourt Srace Jovanovich, Inc. Researchers who wish to re­ produce or quote from copyrighted portio ns of the diary must. obta in permission from the publisher. Quantity: 98 linear feet (196,000 pages) Restrictions: These papers conta in documents restricted in accordance w ith Executive Order 12356, and material that might be used to e mba rrass, harass, or injure living persons has been c losed. Rela ted Material: Transcript of the interview with Adolf A. Serle conducted by the C olumbia Oral History Project. Permission to c ite or quote must be obtained from Mrs. Adolf A. Serle. Electros tptic copies of correspondence between Fletcher Warren and A. A. Serle from the Warren Papers in East Texas State Unive r­ si t y Library at Commerce, Texas 75428. I ADOLF A.
    [Show full text]
  • Analyzing the Marshall Plan
    III Analyzing the Marshall Plan n an atmosphere of great urgency the Economic Cooperation Admin- istration was designed and organized in 1948 to achieve explicit I economic objectives, as well as implicit psychological and politi- cal aims. In order to evaluate the extent to which the ECA succeeded or failed in accomplishing its goals, the ambitiousness of its architects and engineers must first be appreciated. Otherwise, too narrow a basis for pass- ing historical judgment results. An appropriately comprehensive basis for determining the Marshall Plan’s impact needs to be established next. What criteria, for instance, define success and failure? Is the Plan’s meaning in the short term or long run? Or in an economic, psychological, or political sense? If principally political, what stakes matter most? Are they the conflict between communism and anticommunism? Or perhaps a resolution of the postwar “German Problem” that required Germany’s reconciliation with its neighbors and France’s abandonment of its punitive German policy? Should the Plan also be judged in terms of whether it created European goodwill for America? Such issues have to be clarified prior to parsing evidence. This monograph is not intended to plunge into the deep end of the his- torical disagreements that have been erected on such analytical founda- tions. Suffice it to say that an era of generally sweeping superlatives, when an American writer once gushed about “the boldest, most successful, and certainly most expensive foreign policy initiative ever attempted in peace- time,” is essentially over. Among contemporary commentators, the German Professor of Public Finance who wrote in 2004 of the Marshall Plan as “amazingly successful” is probably in the minority.1 The last twenty years of scholarship on the Marshall Plan have expand- ed and refined the questions being asked of source material.
    [Show full text]