2016 Election Summary Independent Expenditures Committees (Aka Super Pacs)

2016 Election Summary Independent Expenditure Committees (aka Super PACs)

1. Total Receipts and Expenditures for 17 Independent Expenditure Committees

Independent Expenditure Committees Total Receipts Total Expenditures AiKea UNITE HERE $14.91 $13,559.95 BIA‐Hawaii Super PAC $3,725.00 $0.00 Coalition for Green Jobs NOW! $0.00 $0.00 Forward Progress $50,000.00 $50,000.00 Hawaii Center for Food Safety Action Fund $58,012.95 $54,753.73 Hawaii Realtors for Good Government $64,659.05 $44,172.05 HIRA Action $17,701.89 $16,494.34 Kauai Women's Caucus $150.00 $132.91 Kuleana Coalition for Change $2,327.36 $1,985.82 National Association of Realtors Fund $44,983.61 $44,983.61 NEA Advocacy Fund $0.00 $0.00 One Ohana Political Action Committee $380,380.00 $169,981.58 Planned Parenthood of Hawaii Action Network $23,045.26 $19,728.99 S.A.F.E. Sustainable Action Fund for the Environment $69,140.00 $64,351.80 SaveOurHonolulu.com $439.79 $3,685.50 Save Our City LLC $331,675.99 $213,636.99 Workers for a Better Hawaii $983,000.00 $966,014.56

Total ‐ $2,029,255.81 $1,663,481.83

2. Total Receipts (includes Contributions Received and Other Receipts) (Sorted in Descending Order)

Independent Expenditure Committees Total Receipts Workers for a Better Hawaii $983,000.00 One Ohana Political Action Committee $380,380.00 Save Our City LLC $331,675.99 S.A.F.E. Sustainable Action Fund for the Environment $69,140.00 Hawaii Realtors for Good Government $64,659.05 Hawaii Center for Food Safety Action Fund $58,012.95 Forward Progress $50,000.00 National Association of Realtors Fund $44,983.61 Planned Parenthood of Hawaii Action Network $23,045.26 HIRA Action $17,701.89 BIA‐Hawaii Super PAC $3,725.00 Kuleana Coalition for Change $2,327.36 SaveOurHonolulu.com $439.79 Kauai Women's Caucus $150.00 AiKea UNITE HERE $14.91 Coalition for Green Jobs NOW! $0.00 NEA Advocacy Fund $0.00

1 3. Total Expenditures (includes Expenditures Made and Expenditures Incurred) (Sorted in Descending Order)

Independent Expenditure Committees Total Expenditures Workers for a Better Hawaii $966,014.56 Save Our City LLC $213,636.99 One Ohana Political Action Committee $169,981.58 S.A.F.E. Sustainable Action Fund for the Environment $64,351.80 Hawaii Center for Food Safety Action Fund $54,753.73 Forward Progress $50,000.00 National Association of Realtors Fund $44,983.61 Hawaii Realtors for Good Government $44,172.05 Planned Parenthood of Hawaii Action Network $19,728.99 HIRA Action $16,494.34 AiKea UNITE HERE $13,559.95 SaveOurHonolulu.com $3,685.50 Kuleana Coalition for Change $1,985.82 Kauai Women's Caucus $132.91 BIA‐Hawaii Super PAC $0.00 Coalition for Green Jobs NOW! $0.00 NEA Advocacy Fund $0.00

4. Closing Cash, Unpaid Expenditures and Surplus/Deficit (as of November 8, 2016)

Independent Expenditure Committees Closing Cash Unpaid Expenditures Surplus/Deficit AiKea UNITE HERE $50,335.93 $0.00 $50,335.93 BIA‐Hawaii Super PAC $5,425.00 $0.00 $5,425.00 Coalition for Green Jobs NOW! $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 Forward Progress $98.67 $0.00 $98.67 Hawaii Center for Food Safety Action Fund $1,988.17 $4,543.65 ($2,555.48) Hawaii Realtors for Good Government $20,487.00 $0.00 $20,487.00 HIRA Action $12,605.25 $0.00 $12,605.25 Kauai Women's Caucus $118.86 $0.00 $118.86 Kuleana Coalition for Change $341.54 $0.00 $341.54 National Association of Realtors Fund $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 NEA Advocacy Fund $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 One Ohana Political Action Committee $699,965.77 $4,583.02 $695,382.75 Planned Parenthood of Hawaii Action Network $4,513.22 $1,103.78 $3,409.44 S.A.F.E. Sustainable Action Fund for the Environment $4,788.20 $0.00 $4,788.20 SaveOurHonolulu.com $0.00 $0.00 $0.00 Save Our City LLC $118,039.00 $0.00 $118,039.00 Workers for a Better Hawaii $30,439.77 $0.00 $30,439.77

2 5. Top Contributors of $10,000 or more (Sorted in Descending Order)

Independent Expenditure Committees Contributor Name Total Contributions Workers for a Better Hawaii Hawaii Regional Council of Carpenters $500,000.00 Workers for a Better Hawaii Hawaii Government Employees Association $208,000.00 Save Our City LLC Mitsunaga, Dennis $170,000.00 Workers for a Better Hawaii HAWAII STATE AFL‐CIO $150,000.00 Workers for a Better Hawaii AFSCME $100,000.00 Forward Progress Hawaii Carpenters Market Recovery Program $50,000.00 National Association of Realtors Fund NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS FUND $44,983.61 Hawaii Realtors for Good Government National Association of Realtors $43,659.05 S.A.F.E. Sustainable Action Fund for the Environment S.A.F.E. $43,640.00 Hawaii Center for Food Safety Action Fund Center for Food Safety Action Fund $33,188.75 Workers for a Better Hawaii Operating Engineers Local No 3 $25,000.00 Hawaii Realtors for Good Government Hawaii Association of Realtors $21,000.00 Save Our City LLC Amana Associates $20,000.00 Hawaii Center for Food Safety Action Fund Currier, Lavinia $17,500.00 Save Our City LLC Hyun, Sam $15,000.00 S.A.F.E. Sustainable Action Fund for the Environment Young, Scott "Genesis" & Solara $15,000.00 Planned Parenthood of Hawaii Action Network Planned Parenthood Votes Northwest and Hawaii $14,000.00 S.A.F.E. Sustainable Action Fund for the Environment Frost, Karin $10,000.00 Save Our City LLC Fujii, Aaron $10,000.00 Save Our City LLC McDonald, Michelle $10,000.00 Save Our City LLC Mitsunaga, Chan Ok $10,000.00 Save Our City LLC Mitsunaga, Lois $10,000.00 Save Our City LLC Plumbers and Pipefitters PAC Fund $10,000.00 Save Our City LLC Spencer, William $10,000.00 Save Our City LLC Yoshioka, Garren $10,000.00

6. 2016 Independent Expenditures by Category

Expenditure Category Count % Total % Advertising 141 73.82% $998,583.02 77.22% Bank Charges & Adjustments 1 0.52% $10,491.48 0.81% Postage/Mailing 13 6.81% $98,492.99 7.62% Printing 11 5.76% $136,470.30 10.55% Professional Services 24 12.57% $48,583.87 3.76% Surveys, Polls & Voter Lists 1 0.52% $500.00 0.04% Total 191 100.00% $1,293,121.66 100.00%

7. Independent Expenditures Supporting or Opposing Candidates (Total - $1,293,121.66)

Total Independent Expenditures Supporting Candidates - $857,478.86 (66% of $1,293,121.66) Total Independent Expenditures Opposing Candidates - $435,642.80 (34% of $1,293,121.66)

3 Sorted by Independent Expenditure Committees

Independent Expenditure Committees Candidate Name(s) Support/Oppose Total AiKea UNITE HERE John Mizuno Oppose $6,500.00 Alika Atay, Napua Greig‐Nakasone, Elle Cochran, Trinette Hawaii Center for Food Safety Action Fund Furtado Support $4,540.00 Alika Atay, Napua Greig‐Nakasone, Trinette Furtado, Keani Hawaii Center for Food Safety Action Fund Rawlins‐ Fernandez Support $2,180.88 Alika Atay, Trinette Furtado, Elle Cochran, Napua Greig‐ Hawaii Center for Food Safety Action Fund Nakasone Support $1,960.00 Hawaii Center for Food Safety Action Fund Fern Rosenstiel Support $4,699.66 Hawaii Center for Food Safety Action Fund Jonathan Wong Support $144.60 Hawaii Center for Food Safety Action Fund Tiare Lawrence Support $1,838.00 Hawaii Realtors for Good Government Karl Rhoads, Isaac Choy, Nadine Nakamura Support $43,659.05 HIRA Action Charles Djou Oppose $2,065.50 One Ohana Political Action Committee Joe Blackburn Oppose $337.73 One Ohana Political Action Committee Keith Regan Support $28,806.13 One Ohana Political Action Committee Keith Regan, Yuki Sugimura Support $33,406.55 One Ohana Political Action Committee Yuki Sugimura Support $15,054.38 Planned Parenthood of Hawaii Action Network Dale Kobayashi Support $3,820.94 Planned Parenthood of Hawaii Action Network Gregg Takayama, Kirk Caldwell, Karlen Ross, Stanley Chang Support $1,103.78 Planned Parenthood of Hawaii Action Network Kirk Caldwell, Stanley Chang Support $10,064.23 Planned Parenthood of Hawaii Action Network Tracy Arakaki Support $4,524.90 Alika Atay, Trinette Furtado, Napua Greig‐Nakasone, Keani Rawlins‐Fernandez, Elle Cochran, Don Guzman, Kelly King, S.A.F.E. Sustainable Action Fund for the Environment Shane Sinenci, Gabriel Johnson, Kaniela Ing, Nick Nikhilananda Support $42,307.91 Alika Atay, Trinette Furtado, Napua Greig‐Nakasone, Richard Deleon, Kelly King, Richard Abbett, Kaniela Ing, Tiare Lawerence, Alexander Haller, Elle Cochran, Don Guzman, S.A.F.E. Sustainable Action Fund for the Environment Shane Sinenci Support $20,111.16 Kaniela Ing, Alika Atay, Tiare Lawrance, Kelly King, Trinette Furtado, Richard Delon, Richard Abbet, Alexander Haller, Napua Greig‐Nakasone, Shane Sineci, Keani Rawlins‐ S.A.F.E. Sustainable Action Fund for the Environment Fernandez, Gabriel Johnson Support $784.06 Save Our City LLC Kirk Caldwell Oppose $213,636.99 Workers for a Better Hawaii Charles Djou Oppose $213,102.58 Workers for a Better Hawaii Harry Kim Support $12,791.16 Workers for a Better Hawaii Kirk Caldwell Support $613,616.17 Workers for a Better Hawaii Moana Kelii Support $4,120.55 Workers for a Better Hawaii Richard Onishi Support $4,641.05 Workers for a Better Hawaii Tom Brower Support $3,303.70

Total ‐ $1,293,121.66 Sorted by Candidate Name(s)

Independent Expenditure Committees Candidate Name(s) Support/Oppose Total Alika Atay, Napua Greig‐Nakasone, Elle Cochran, Trinette Hawaii Center for Food Safety Action Fund Furtado Support $4,540.00 Alika Atay, Napua Greig‐Nakasone, Trinette Furtado, Keani Hawaii Center for Food Safety Action Fund Rawlins‐ Fernandez Support $2,180.88 Alika Atay, Trinette Furtado, Elle Cochran, Napua Greig‐ Hawaii Center for Food Safety Action Fund Nakasone Support $1,960.00 Alika Atay, Trinette Furtado, Napua Greig‐Nakasone, Keani Rawlins‐Fernandez, Elle Cochran, Don Guzman, Kelly King, S.A.F.E. Sustainable Action Fund for the Environment Shane Sinenci, Gabriel Johnson, Kaniela Ing, Nick Nikhilananda Support $42,307.91

4 Alika Atay, Trinette Furtado, Napua Greig‐Nakasone, Richard Deleon, Kelly King, Richard Abbett, Kaniela Ing, Tiare Lawerence, Alexander Haller, Elle Cochran, Don Guzman, S.A.F.E. Sustainable Action Fund for the Environment Shane Sinenci Support $20,111.16 HIRA Action Charles Djou Oppose $2,065.50 Workers for a Better Hawaii Charles Djou Oppose $213,102.58 Planned Parenthood of Hawaii Action Network Dale Kobayashi Support $3,820.94 Hawaii Center for Food Safety Action Fund Fern Rosenstiel Support $4,699.66 Planned Parenthood of Hawaii Action Network Gregg Takayama, Kirk Caldwell, Karlen Ross, Stanley Chang Support $1,103.78 Workers for a Better Hawaii Harry Kim Support $12,791.16 One Ohana Political Action Committee Joe Blackburn Oppose $337.73 AiKea UNITE HERE John Mizuno Oppose $6,500.00 Hawaii Center for Food Safety Action Fund Jonathan Wong Support $144.60 Kaniela Ing, Alika Atay, Tiare Lawrance, Kelly King, Trinette Furtado, Richard Delon, Richard Abbet, Alexander Haller, Napua Greig‐Nakasone, Shane Sineci, Keani Rawlins‐Fernandez, S.A.F.E. Sustainable Action Fund for the Environment Gabriel Johnson Support $784.06 Hawaii Realtors for Good Government Karl Rhoads, Isaac Choy, Nadine Nakamura Support $43,659.05 One Ohana Political Action Committee Keith Regan Support $28,806.13 One Ohana Political Action Committee Keith Regan, Yuki Sugimura Support $33,406.55 Save Our City LLC Kirk Caldwell Oppose $213,636.99 Workers for a Better Hawaii Kirk Caldwell Support $613,616.17 Planned Parenthood of Hawaii Action Network Kirk Caldwell, Stanley Chang Support $10,064.23 Workers for a Better Hawaii Moana Kelii Support $4,120.55 Workers for a Better Hawaii Richard Onishi Support $4,641.05 Hawaii Center for Food Safety Action Fund Tiare Lawrence Support $1,838.00 Workers for a Better Hawaii Tom Brower Support $3,303.70 Planned Parenthood of Hawaii Action Network Tracy Arakaki Support $4,524.90 One Ohana Political Action Committee Yuki Sugimura Support $15,054.38

Total ‐ $1,293,121.66

8. Independent Expenditure Breakdown by Candidate (35 total)

Candidate Name Support Oppose Office Won Abbett, Richard $20,895.22 $0.00 House N Arakaki, Tracy $4,524.90 $0.00 House N Atay, Alika $71,884.01 $0.00 Maui Council Y Blackburn, Joe $0.00 $337.73 Maui Council N Brower, Tom $3,303.70 $0.00 House Y Caldwell, Kirk $624,784.18 $213,636.99 Honolulu Mayor Y Chang, Stanley $11,168.01 $0.00 Senate Y Choy, Isaac $43,659.05 $0.00 House Y Cochran, Elle $68,919.07 $0.00 Maui Council Y Deleon, Richard $20,895.22 $0.00 Maui Council N Djou, Charles $0.00 $215,168.08 Honolulu Mayor N Furtado, Trinette $71,884.01 $0.00 Maui Council N Greig‐Nakasone, Napua $71,884.01 $0.00 Maui Council N Guzman, Don $62,419.07 $0.00 Maui Council Y 5 Haller, Alexander $20,895.22 $0.00 House N Ing, Kaniela $63,203.13 $0.00 House Y Johnson, Gabriel $43,091.97 $0.00 Maui Council N Kelii, Moana $4,120.55 $0.00 Hawaii Council N Kim, Harry $12,791.16 $0.00 Hawaii Mayor Y King, Kelly $63,203.13 $0.00 Maui Council Y Kobayashi, Dale $3,820.94 $0.00 House N Lawrence, Tiare $22,733.22 $0.00 House N Mizuno, John $0.00 $6,500.00 House Y Nakamura, Nadine $43,659.05 $0.00 House Y Nikhilananda, Nick $42,307.91 $0.00 House N Onishi, Richard $4,641.05 $0.00 House Y Rawlins‐Fernandez, Keani $45,272.85 $0.00 Maui Council N Regan, Keith $62,212.68 $0.00 Maui Council N Rhoads, Karl $43,659.05 $0.00 Senate Y Rosenstiel, Fern $4,699.66 $0.00 House N Ross, Karlen $1,103.78 $0.00 House N Sinenci, Shane $63,203.13 $0.00 Maui Council N Sugimura, Yuki $48,460.93 $0.00 Maui Council Y Takayama, Gregg $1,103.78 $0.00 House Y Wong, Jonathan $144.60 $0.00 House N

Independent Expenditures to Support Candidates (32 total) (Sorted in Descending Order)

Candidate Name Support Office Won Caldwell, Kirk $624,784.18 Honolulu Mayor Y Atay, Alika $71,884.01 Maui Council Y Furtado, Trinette $71,884.01 Maui Council N Greig‐Nakasone, Napua $71,884.01 Maui Council N Cochran, Elle $68,919.07 Maui Council Y Ing, Kaniela $63,203.13 House Y King, Kelly $63,203.13 Maui Council Y Sinenci, Shane $63,203.13 Maui Council N Guzman, Don $62,419.07 Maui Council Y Regan, Keith $62,212.68 Maui Council N Sugimura, Yuki $48,460.93 Maui Council Y Rawlins‐Fernandez, Keani $45,272.85 Maui Council N Choy, Isaac $43,659.05 House Y Nakamura, Nadine $43,659.05 House Y Rhoads, Karl $43,659.05 Senate Y Johnson, Gabriel $43,091.97 Maui Council N Nikhilananda, Nick $42,307.91 House N Lawrence, Tiare $22,733.22 House N Abbett, Richard $20,895.22 House N Deleon, Richard $20,895.22 Maui Council N Haller, Alexander $20,895.22 House N 6 Kim, Harry $12,791.16 Hawaii Mayor Y Chang, Stanley $11,168.01 Senate Y Rosenstiel, Fern $4,699.66 House N Onishi, Richard $4,641.05 House Y Arakaki, Tracy $4,524.90 House N Kelii, Moana $4,120.55 Hawaii Council N Kobayashi, Dale $3,820.94 House N Brower, Tom $3,303.70 House Y Ross, Karlen $1,103.78 House N Takayama, Gregg $1,103.78 House Y Wong, Jonathan $144.60 House N

Independent Expenditures to Oppose Candidates (4 total) (Sorted in Descending Order)

Candidate Name Oppose Office Won Djou, Charles $215,168.08 Honolulu Mayor N Caldwell, Kirk $213,636.99 Honolulu Mayor Y Mizuno, John $6,500.00 House Y Blackburn, Joe $337.73 Maui Council N