Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 30

1 ALLAN STEYER (Bar No. 100318) JILL M. MANNING (Bar No. 178849) 2 D. SCOTT MACRAE (Bar No. 104663) SUNEEL JAIN (Bar No. 314558) 3 STEYER LOWENTHAL BOODROOKAS 4 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP 235 Pine Street, 15th Floor 5 San Francisco, CA 94104 Telephone: (415) 424-3400 6 Facsimile: (415) 421-2234 [email protected] 7 [email protected] 8 [email protected] [email protected] 9 CLIFFORD H. PEARSON (Bar. No. 108523) 10 DANIEL L. WARSHAW (Bar No. 185365) THOMAS J. NOLAN (Bar No. 66992) 11 PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP 12 15165 Ventura Boulevard, Suite 400 Sherman Oaks, CA 91403 13 Telephone: (818) 788-8300 Facsimile: (818) 788-8104 14 [email protected] [email protected] 15 [email protected] 16 Counsel for Plaintiffs and the Class 17 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 18 NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 19 SAN JOSE DIVISION 20 CHRISTINA GRACE and KEN POTTER CASE NO. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC 21 Individually and on Behalf of All Others Similarly Situated, CLASS ACTION 22 Plaintiffs, NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION 23 FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, vs. REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES, AND 24 SERVICE AWARDS APPLE INC., 25 Date: February 8, 2021 Defendant. Time: 1:30 p.m. th 26 Courtroom: 8, 4 Floor Judge: The Honorable Lucy H. Koh 27

28 945562.1 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 30

1 TO ALL PARTIES AND THEIR RESPECTIVE ATTORNEYS OF RECORD: 2 PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that on February 8, 2021, at 1:30 p.m., or as soon thereafter as 3 the matter may be heard in the Courtroom of the Honorable Lucy H. Koh, United States District 4 Court, Northern District of California, San Jose Division, 280 South 1st Street, San Jose, CA 5 95113, Plaintiffs Christina Grace and Ken Potter (“Plaintiffs”) will and hereby do move the Court, 6 pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(h)(1) and 54(d)(2), for the entry of an Order 7 awarding the following in this action (the “Action”): 8 1. Attorneys’ fees to class counsel in this Action (“Class Counsel”) in the amount of 9 $5,400,000, which is 30% of the total settlement fund of $18 million; 10 2. Unreimbursed expenses Class Counsel necessarily incurred in connection with the 11 prosecution of this Action in the amount of $1,092,459.47; and 12 3. Service awards of $7,500 for each of the two Class Representatives, for a total of 13 $15,000. 14 This motion is based upon this Notice of Motion and accompanying Memorandum of 15 Points and Authorities; the Declaration of Jill M. Manning filed herewith; the Declaration of 16 Daniel L. Warshaw filed herewith; the Declaration of David F.E. Tejtel filed herewith; the 17 Declaration of John Austin Curry filed herewith; all exhibits thereto; argument by counsel at the 18 hearing before this Court; any papers filed in reply; the pleading and papers on file in this Action, 19 and such oral argument and documentary evidence as may be presented at the hearing on this 20 motion. 21 Date: November 24, 2020 Respectfully Submitted,

22 STEYER LOWENTHAL BOODROOKAS ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP 23

24 By: /s/ Jill M. Manning 25 Jill M. Manning

26 27 28 945562.1 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 3 of 30

1 TABLE OF CONTENTS Page 2

3 I. INTRODUCTION ...... 1

4 II. BACKGROUND ...... 2

5 A. The Action and the Claims Asserted Therein ...... 2

6 B. Class Counsel Prosecuted this Action Tenaciously and with Great Skill and Effectiveness ...... 3 7 C. Mediation and Settlement ...... 6 8 III. ARGUMENT ...... 6 9 A. The Requested Fee Is Reasonable and Appropriate ...... 7 10 1. The Court Should Calculate Class Counsel’s Fees as a Percentage of 11 the Common Fund ...... 8

12 2. The Court Should Award A Fee of Thirty Percent of the Common Fund ...... 9 13 (a) Class Counsel Achieved a Significant Benefit for the Class ...... 11 14 (b) Class Counsel Faced Significant Risk in Litigating the 15 Action ...... 11

16 (c) Substantial Effort and Skill Was Required to Prosecute this Action ...... 13 17 (d) Class Counsel Litigated this Action on a Purely Contingent 18 Basis ...... 16

19 (e) Awards in Similar Cases Support an Upward Adjustment ...... 16

20 3. A Lodestar-Multiplier “Cross-Check” Further Confirms the Reasonableness of the Requested Fee ...... 17 21 B. Class Counsel’s Expenses Are Reasonable and Should Be Reimbursed ...... 20 22 C. The Service Award Request Is Reasonable ...... 20 23 IV. CONCLUSION ...... 22 24

25 26 27 28 945562.1 i NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 4 of 30

1 TABLE OF AUTHORITIES

2 Page(s)

3 Cases

4 Acosta v. Frito-Lay, Inc., 5 No. 15-CV- 02128-JSC, 2018 WL 646691 (N.D. Cal. Jan. 31, 2018) ...... 20 6 Allapattah Servs., Inc. v. Exxon Corp., 454 F. Supp. 2d 1185 (S.D. Fla. 2006) ...... 17 7 Alvarez v. Farmers Ins. Exch., 8 No. 3:14-CV-00574-WHO, 2017 WL 2214585 (N.D. Cal. Jan. 18, 2017) ...... 22

9 In re Animation Workers Antitrust Litig., No. 14-CV-4062-LHK, 2016 WL 6663005 (N.D. Cal. Nov. 11, 2016) ...... 18 10 11 In re Anthem, Inc. Data Breach Litig., No. 15-MD-02617-LHK, 2018 WL 3960068 (N.D. Cal. Aug. 17, 2018) ...... passim 12 Bellinghausen v. Tractor Supply Co., 13 306 F.R.D. 245 (N.D. Cal. 2015) ...... 22

14 In re Bluetooth Headset Products Liab. Litig., 654 F.3d 935 (9th Cir. 2011) ...... 7, 11 15 16 Blum v. Stenson, 465 U.S. 886 (1984) ...... 9, 18 17 Boeing Co. v. Van Gemert, 18 444 U.S. 472 (1980) ...... 7

19 Castaneda v. Burger King Corp., No. C 08-04262 WHA, 2010 WL 2735091 (N.D. Cal. July 12, 2010) ...... 10 20 In re Cathode Ray Tube (CRT) Antitrust Litig., 21 No. 3:07-cv-5944 JST, 2016 WL 721680 (N.D. Cal. Jan. 28, 2016) ...... 10 22 de Mira v. Heartland Employment Serv., 23 LLC, No. 12-CV-04092 LHK, 2014 WL 1026282 (N.D. Cal. Mar. 13, 2014) ...... 15

24 Garner v. State Farm, No. CV 08 1365 CW, 2010 WL 1687829 (N.D. Cal. Apr. 22, 2010) ...... 10 25 Glass v. UBS Fin. Servs., Inc., 26 No. C-06-4068 MMC, 2007 WL 221862 (N.D. Cal. Jan. 26, 2007), aff’d, 331 F. 27 App’x 452 (9th Cir. 2009) ...... 13 28 945562.1 ii NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 5 of 30

1 In re Google LLC St. View Elec. Commc'ns Litig., No. 10-MD-02184-CRB, 2020 WL 1288377 (N.D. Cal. Mar. 18, 2020) ...... 8 2 Hendricks v. Starkist Co., 3 No. 13- 00729-HSG, 2016 WL 5462423 (N.D. Cal. Sept. 29, 2016), aff’d, 2018 4 WL 5115482 (9th Cir. Oct. 19, 2018) ...... 6 5 Hickcox-Huffman v. US Airways, Inc., No. 10-CV-05193-VKD, 2019 WL 1571877 (N.D. Cal. Apr. 11, 2019) ...... 22 6 In re High-Tech Employee Antitrust Litig., 7 2015 WL 5158730 (N.D. Cal. Sept. 2, 2015) ...... 17, 18, 20, 22

8 Hopkins v. Stryker Sales Corp., No. 11-CV-02786-LHK, 2013 WL 496358 (N.D. Cal. Feb. 6, 2013) ...... 10, 15 9 10 Johnson v. Quantum Learning Network, Inc., No. 15-CV-05013-LHK, 2017 WL 747462 (N.D. Cal. Feb. 27, 2017) ...... 8, 10, 15 11 Knight v. Red Door Salons, Inc., 12 No. 08–01520 SC, 2009 WL 248367 (N.D. Cal. Feb. 2, 2009) ...... 10, 12

13 Kurzweil v. Philip Morris Cos., No. 94 CIV. 2373 (MBM), 1999 WL 1076105 (S.D.N.Y. Nov. 30, 1999) ...... 17 14 15 In re Linerboard Antitrust Litig., No. CIV.A. 98-5055, 2004 WL 1221350 (E.D. Pa. Jun. 2, 2004) ...... 17 16 In re Media Vision Tech. Sec. Litig., 17 913 F. Supp. 1362 (N.D. Cal. 1995) ...... 20

18 In re National Collegiate Athletic Association Athletic Grant-in-Aid Cap Antitrust Litigation, 19 Case No. 4:14-md-2541-CW (N.D. Cal.), Dkt No. 1246 (Oct. 16, 2019) ...... 18 20 In re National Collegiate Athletic Association Athletic Grant-in-Aid Cap Antitrust 21 Litigation, Case No. 4:14-md-2541-CW (N.D. Cal.), Dkt. No. 1259 (Dec. 6, 2019) ...... 18 22 In re Nexus 6P Prod. Liab. Litig., 23 No. 17-CV-02185-BLF, 2019 WL 6622842 (N.D. Cal. Nov. 12, 2019) ...... 8, 10

24 In re Omnivision Techs., Inc., 559 F. Supp. 2d 1036 (N.D. Cal. 2007) ...... 10, 13, 14 25 26 In re Online DVD-Rental Antitrust Litig., 779 F.3d 934 (9th Cir. 2015) ...... 21 27 Paul, Johnson, Alston & Hunt v. Graulty, 28 886 F.2d 268 (9th Cir. 1989) ...... 15 945562.1 iii NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 6 of 30

1 In re Relafen Antitrust Litig., 231 F.R.D. 52 (D. Mass. 2005) ...... 17 2 Rodriguez v. W. Publ’g Corp., 3 563 F.3d 948 (9th Cir. 2009) ...... 7 4 Schneider v. Chipotle Mexican Grill, Inc., 5 No. 16-CV-02200-HSG, 2020 WL 6484833 (N.D. Cal. Nov. 4, 2020) ...... 8, 10 6 Six Mexican Workers v. Ariz. Citrus Growers, 904 F.2d 1301 (9th Cir. 1990) ...... 7, 9 7 Staton v. Boeing Co., 8 327 F.3d 938 (9th Cir. 2003) ...... 7, 21

9 Sullivan v. DB Invs., Inc., 10 667 F.3d 273 (3d Cir. 2011) ...... 20 11 In re Sumitomo Copper Litig., 74 F. Supp. 2d 393 (S.D.N.Y. 1999) ...... 17 12 In re Target Corp. Customer Data Sec. Breach Litig., 13 No. 14–2522 (PAM), 2017 WL 2178306 (D. Minn. May 17, 2017) ...... 17

14 In re TFT-LCD (Flat Panel) Antitrust Litig., 15 No. M 07-1827 SI, 2013 WL 149692 (N.D. Cal. Jan. 14, 2013) ...... 10 16 In re The Home Depot, Inc., Customer Data Sec. Breach Litig., No.: 1:14-md-02583-TWT, 2016 WL 6902351 (N.D. Ga. Aug. 23, 2016) ...... 17 17 Vedachalam v. Tata Consultancy Servs., Ltd., 18 No. C 06–0963 CW, 2013 WL 3941319 (N.D. Cal. July 18, 2013) ...... 10

19 Vincent v. Hughes Air W., Inc., 557 F.2d 759 (9th Cir. 1977) ...... 20 20 21 In re Vitamins Antitrust Litig., No. MDL 1285, 2001 WL 34312839 (D.D.C. July 16, 2001) ...... 17 22 Vizcaino v. Microsoft Corp., 23 290 F.3d 1043 (9th Cir. 2002) ...... passim

24 Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Visa U.S.A. Inc., 396 F.3d 96 (2d Cir. 2005) ...... 9 25 In re Wash. Pub. Power Supply System Sec. Litig., 26 19 F.3d 1291 (9th Cir. 1994) ...... 7, 16, 17 27 Wininger v. SI Mgmt. L.P., 28 301 F.3d 1115, 1121 (9th Cir. 2002) ...... 20 945562.1 iv NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 7 of 30

1 In re Yahoo Mail Litig., No. 13-CV-4980-LHK, 2016 WL 4474612 (N.D. Cal. Aug. 25, 2016) ...... 19 2 In re Yahoo! Inc. Customer Data Sec. Breach Litig., 3 No. 16-MD-02752-LHK, 2020 WL 4212811 (N.D. Cal. July 22, 2020) ...... 18, 21 4 Rules 5 Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(h) ...... 6 6 Other Authorities 7 5 Newberg on Class Actions §§ 15:62, 15:65 (5th ed. 2018) ...... 9 8

9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 945562.1 v NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 8 of 30

1 MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES

2 I. INTRODUCTION 3 With trial imminent after over three years of zealous and effective prosecution of this 4 action (the “Action”) against one of the most sophisticated and well-resourced corporations in the 5 world, Class Counsel1 achieved a significant result on behalf of the California class (the “Class”). 6 The $18 million settlement secured by Class Counsel following a proposal from a United States 7 District Court Magistrate Judge provides significant monetary relief to the Class in exchange for 8 release of their claims against Defendant Apple Inc. (“Apple”) relating to events that transpired in 9 2014. 10 To achieve this result, Class Counsel developed and asserted a legal theory described by 11 the Court as “novel,” then devoted substantial efforts and demonstrated significant skill in the 12 prosecution of this Action, including by: (i) amending the complaint in response to Apple’s initial 13 motion to dismiss; (ii) prevailing in full against Apple’s motion to dismiss the amended complaint; 14 (iii) litigating twelve motions to compel; (iv) obtaining Apple’s production of 1,025,596 pages of 15 documents, including databases each of which contained millions of records; (v) securing access 16 to and analyzing Apple’s highly-sensitive and technical programming source code; (vi) taking 17 seven depositions of Apple representatives, including two Rule 30(b)(6) depositions; (vii) taking 18 four depositions of non-parties; (viii) taking or defending against seven depositions of the parties’ 19 five experts; (ix) securing the certification of the California Class; (x) defeating Apple’s motion 20 for summary judgment; and (xi) preparing for trial, including through the filing of or defense 21 against six motions in limine and myriad other pre-trial tasks. Further, the significant benefit 22 achieved by Class Counsel was reached only after four Court-ordered, in-person mediation 23 sessions, first with a retired California state court judge and then with a current federal Magistrate 24 Judge, resulting in a final proposal crafted by the latter. 25

26 1 As used herein, “Class Counsel” means Pearson, Simon & Warshaw, LLP (“PSW”); Steyer 27 Lowenthal Boodrookas Alvarez & Smith LLP (“Steyer Lowenthal”); Caldwell Cassady & Curry (“CCC”); and Friedman Oster & Tejtel PLLC (“FOT”). Dkt. Nos. 269, 426. 28 945562.1 1 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 9 of 30

1 In compensation for their efforts, Class Counsel seek a fee award equal to 30% of the $18 2 million cash fund they achieved, amounting to $5,400,000. The reasonableness and propriety of 3 this upward adjustment from the Ninth Circuit’s 25% “benchmark” is confirmed by the fact that a 4 lodestar cross-check results in a .67 negative multiplier given the extensive efforts invested by 5 Class Counsel into this Action. Class Counsel also seeks a $1,092,459.47 reimbursement of 6 litigation costs reasonably expended in the prosecution of this Action, as well as service awards of 7 $7,500 (the “Service Awards”) for each of Plaintiffs Christina Grace and Ken Potter (together, the 8 “Class Representatives”) in recognition of their efforts and sacrifices in connection with this 9 Action.

10 II. BACKGROUND 11 A. The Action and the Claims Asserted Therein 12 Plaintiff Grace filed this Action on February 2, 2017 (Dkt. No. 1), and filed an amended 13 complaint (the “Amended Complaint”) adding Plaintiff Potter on April 5, 2017. Dkt. No. 36. The 14 Amended Complaint asserts “a consumer class action brought by Plaintiffs on behalf of 15 themselves and all others similarly situated who owned an Apple iPhone 4 or iPhone 4S that was 16 operating on iOS 6 or an earlier operating system, and therefore lost the ability to use Apple’s 17 ‘FaceTime’ video conferencing feature when Apple intentionally broke FaceTime for iOS 6 and 18 earlier operating systems on April 16, 2014.” Dkt. No. 36. Specifically, Plaintiffs alleged that 19 despite recognizing for months that a certificate necessary to the functioning of Apple’s popular 20 FaceTime feature would expire on April 16, 2014 (the “iPhone Device Sub-CA”), Apple 21 knowingly allowed the certificate to expire—and thus, FaceTime to break (the “FaceTime 22 Break”)—with respect to certain devices (e.g., Apple iPhone 4 and 4S devices) running on certain 23 versions of Apple’s operating software (i.e., iOS 6 and earlier) in order to reduce the company’s 24 costs. Id. 25 The atypical nature of the misconduct and harm alleged—i.e., Apple’s failure to prevent a 26 digital certificate expiration programmed years earlier, which required affected users to upgrade to 27 a new but problematic version of iOS in order to regain functionality and thus devalued their 28 devices—presented considerable difficulty in ascertaining an appropriate cause of action. 945562.1 2 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 10 of 30

1 Ultimately, after significant research and analysis, the Class Representatives and Class Counsel 2 settled upon a trespass to chattels claim under California law, see Dkt. No. 36, which the Court 3 subsequently described as “novel.” Dkt. No. 57, 12:16-18. Plaintiffs also asserted violations of 4 California’s Unfair Competition Law, Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code §§ 17200 et seq. (the “UCL”). Dkt. 5 No. 36. Plaintiffs’ Amended Complaint sought damages, restitution, and injunctive relief. Id. The 6 damages and restitution sought by Plaintiffs represented the diminution in value of the Class’s 7 iPhone 4 and 4S devices caused by the FaceTime Break by virtue of those devices either: (i) losing 8 the ability to use FaceTime, or (ii) suffering functionality impairment as a result of upgrading to 9 iOS 7 in order to regain the use of FaceTime. 10 Although the April 16, 2014 FaceTime Break was widely felt, recognized and reported 11 when it occurred, no claims relating thereto were ever asserted in the roughly 33 months that 12 elapsed between the FaceTime Break and the filing of this Action. Because California law 13 imposes a three-year statute of limitations for the Trespass to Chattels claim and a four-year 14 statute of limitations for the UCL claim, had the Class Representatives and Class Counsel not 15 pursued these claims and secured the benefit achieved thereby, it is highly unlikely that any other 16 plaintiff or plaintiff’s counsel would have done so, such that the conduct alleged in this Action 17 would never have been challenged or remedied.

18 B. Class Counsel Prosecuted this Action Tenaciously and with Great Skill 19 and Effectiveness 20 From the outset of this Action and for the ensuing more than three-year prosecution 21 thereof, Class Counsel litigated against Apple tenaciously and with great skill and effectiveness. 22 After months spent researching and investigating potentially actionable legal claims based on the 23 challenged misconduct and synthesizing those claims into a meritorious complaint, this Action 24 was filed on February 2, 2017. Dkt. No. 1. After Apple moved to dismiss the Action, Class 25 Counsel invested additional time and resources into drafting the Amended Complaint. Dkt. No. 26 36. In denying in full Apple’s motion to dismiss the Amended Complaint on July 28, 2017, the 27 Court accepted in substantial part Class Counsel’s arguments for rejection of Apple’s myriad 28 proffered bases for dismissal. Dkt. No. 65. 945562.1 3 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 11 of 30

1 The parties then entered the highly contentious discovery phase of the Action, which 2 required a substantial expenditure of Class Counsel’s time, effort and resources. The extensive 3 discovery process in this Action included: (i) twelve discovery motions, including six motions to 4 compel filed by Plaintiffs; (ii) 78 requests for production of documents; (iii) 68 interrogatories; 5 (iv) 42 requests for admission; (v) Apple’s production of 224,693 documents totaling over a 6 million pages; (vi) Plaintiffs’ review of databases produced in discovery that contained millions of 7 records; (vii) review and analysis of Apple’s source code; (viii) seventeen fact and expert 8 depositions, including eleven taken by Plaintiffs; (ix) forensic imaging of the Class 9 Representatives’ three iPhone devices; (x) full-day depositions of both Class Representatives; (xi) 10 numerous non-party document requests and deposition subpoenas, and (xii) countless meet-and- 11 confers between the parties. Declaration of Jill M. Manning in Support of Motion for Attorney’s 12 Fees, Reimbursement of Expenses and Service Awards (“Manning Decl.”), ¶¶ 6-11. 13 After receiving and analyzing Defendant and third-party discovery, Plaintiffs retained Dr. 14 Justine S. Hastings, Ph.D., to calculate aggregate class-wide damages measured by the diminution 15 in value of Class Members’ iPhone 4 and 4S devices caused by the FaceTime Break. Working 16 with Class Counsel, Dr. Hastings constructed an econometric damages model using transactional 17 data that Class Counsel secured from third-party resellers of smart phone devices through 18 discovery in this Action. Manning Decl., ¶ 12. Dr. Hastings used multivariate regression analysis 19 to compare smart phone prices during the time period affected by the FaceTime Break to prices 20 during the time when the market was unaffected. Dkt. No. 174. The model produced an estimate 21 of the impact of the FaceTime Break on prices of used iPhone 4 and 4S models and concluded that 22 Apple’s conduct impacted the prices by, on average, $18.30 per device. Class Counsel defended 23 against Apple’s vigorous attacks against Dr. Hastings’s model and methodology, which the Court 24 accepted in its orders on class certification and summary judgment. Dkt. Nos. 269, 306. 25 Plaintiffs also retained and worked with Dr. Mark T. Jones, who analyzed and rendered an 26 opinion and testimony regarding various highly specialized and technical aspects of Plaintiffs’ 27 claims, including (i) the fundamental purpose and functioning of digital certificates generally and, 28 more specifically, the specific certificate architecture surrounding FaceTime, including the iPhone 945562.1 4 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 12 of 30

1 Device Sub-CA; (ii) the options available to Apple in connection with the iPhone Device Sub-CA 2 expiration that caused the FaceTime Break; and (iii) actions that Apple could have taken -- but did 3 not take -- that might have mitigated the impact of the iPhone Device Sub-CA expiration. 4 Manning Decl., ¶ 13. 5 At the class certification phase, Class Counsel secured certification of a class pursuant to 6 Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(b)(3) defined as “[a]ll owners of non-jailbroken Apple iPhone 4 or Apple 7 iPhone 4S devices in California who on April 16, 2014, had iOS 6 or earlier operating systems on 8 their iPhone 4 or iPhone 4S devices.” Dkt. No. 269. Because the Court denied certification of a 9 nationwide class and did not certify an injunctive relief class under the UCL, Plaintiffs filed a 10 petition pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(f) seeking permission to appeal the Court’s denial of 11 certification of a nationwide class. Dkt. No. 290. Ultimately, the Ninth Circuit denied Plaintiffs 12 permission to appeal. Dkt. No. 295. 13 On October 4, 2018, Apple filed a motion seeking summary judgment in its favor on both 14 of Plaintiffs’ claims. Dkt. No. 278. Plaintiffs filed their opposition brief on October 18, 2018 15 (Dkt. No. 285), and on August 21, 2019, the Court denied Apple’s summary judgment motion for 16 substantially the same reasons set forth in Plaintiffs’ opposition brief. Dkt. No. 306. 17 Class Counsel then began preparing for trial, which was scheduled to commence on April 18 6, 2020. Dkt. No. 374. On December 12, 2019, Apple filed a Daubert motion seeking to exclude 19 from the Action the testimony and reports of Plaintiffs’ expert, Dr. Hastings. Dkt. No. 333. On 20 December 13, 2019, Plaintiffs and Apple each filed three motions in limine (Dkt. Nos. 334-39), 21 and on December 17, 2019, the parties filed their respective oppositions thereto. Dkt. Nos. 342- 22 47. Class Counsel thereafter engaged in various pre-trial activities, including creating trial exhibit 23 and witness lists, and drafting, negotiating and filing proposed verdict forms, voir dire and jury 24 instructions. Dkt. Nos. 348-50. On January 15, 2019, the Court held a pretrial conference at 25 which, among other things, the parties argued Apple’s Daubert motion. Dkt. No. 370. Class 26 Counsel then continued preparing the Action for trial, including through the filing of its witness 27 list and further revised jury instructions and verdict forms. Dkt. Nos. 387-91. 28 945562.1 5 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 13 of 30

1 C. Mediation and Settlement 2 Pursuant to the Court’s order, on November 9, 2018, the parties attended an all-day 3 mediation session before the Honorable William J. Cahill (Ret.), at JAMS in San Francisco. 4 Manning Decl., ¶ 18. The mediation did not result in a settlement. Id. 5 After denying Apple’s motion for summary judgment, the Court ordered the parties to 6 return to mediation. On October 22, 2019, the parties engaged in a second mediation before Judge 7 Cahill, and again could not reach agreement on a settlement. Id. 8 As the Action progressed closer to trial, the Court ordered the parties to attend a settlement 9 conference before the Honorable Nathanael M. Cousins. Dkt. No. 325. On December 5, 2019, 10 Magistrate Judge Cousins held an all-day settlement conference, but the parties were unable to 11 resolve the case. Manning Decl., ¶ 19. After extensive follow-up discussions, the parties attended 12 a second in-person settlement conference with Magistrate Judge Cousins on January 16, 2020, 13 which also failed to result in a settlement. Id. Magistrate Judge Cousins continued conferring 14 with the parties and, on January 31, 2020, made a proposal to settle the Action for $18 million, 15 which was accepted by the parties. Id. 16 In the months that followed, Class Counsel engaged in extensive and highly contentious 17 negotiations with Apple regarding various non-monetary aspects of the proposed settlement 18 brokered by Magistrate Judge Cousins. Manning Decl., ¶ 20. On April 27, 2020, Plaintiffs filed a 19 motion for preliminary approval of the $18 million settlement based on Magistrate Judge 20 Cousins’s mediator’s proposal (the “Settlement”). Dkt. No. 414. On September 10, 2020, the 21 Court preliminarily approved the Settlement. Dkt. No. 426.

22 III. ARGUMENT 23 In connection with a class action settlement, a court may award reasonable attorneys’ fees 24 as authorized by law or by the parties’ agreement. See Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(h); Hendricks v. Starkist 25 Co., No. 13- 00729-HSG, 2016 WL 5462423, at *10 (N.D. Cal. Sept. 29, 2016), aff’d, 2018 WL 26 5115482 (9th Cir. Oct. 19, 2018) (court may award reasonable attorneys’ fees and costs where “a 27 litigant proceeding in a representative capacity secures a ‘substantial benefit’ for a class of 28 persons”). 945562.1 6 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 14 of 30

1 The Ninth Circuit endorses the common fund doctrine, pursuant to which counsel have an 2 equitable right to receive compensation for their successful efforts in creating a common fund. 3 See Staton v. Boeing Co., 327 F.3d 938, 967-68 (9th Cir. 2003); Boeing Co. v. Van Gemert, 444 4 U.S. 472, 478 (1980) (“[A] litigant or a lawyer who recovers a common fund . . . is entitled to a 5 reasonable attorney’s fee from the fund as a whole”); In re Wash. Pub. Power Supply System Sec. 6 Litig., 19 F.3d 1291, 1300 (9th Cir. 1994) (same). 7 “Under Ninth Circuit law, the district court has discretion in common fund cases to choose 8 either the percentage-of-the-fund or the lodestar method.” Vizcaino v. Microsoft Corp., 290 F.3d 9 1043, 1047 (9th Cir. 2002); In re Bluetooth Headset Products Liab. Litig., 654 F.3d 935, 942 (9th 10 Cir. 2011) (same). “[T]he choice between lodestar and percentage calculation depends on the 11 circumstances, but [ ] ‘either method may ... have its place in determining what would be 12 reasonable compensation for creating a common fund.’” Six Mexican Workers v. Ariz. Citrus 13 Growers, 904 F.2d 1301, 1311 (9th Cir. 1990) (ellipsis in original) (quoting Paul, Johnson, Alston 14 & Hunt v. Graulty, 886 F.2d 268, 272 (9th Cir. 1989)). The Ninth Circuit also “encourage[s] 15 courts to guard against an unreasonable result by cross-checking their calculations against a 16 second method.” In re Bluetooth, 654 F.3d at 944-45. 17 Ultimately, the Ninth Circuit requires “only that fee awards be reasonable in the 18 circumstances.” Rodriguez v. W. Publ’g Corp., 563 F.3d 948, 967 (9th Cir. 2009).

19 A. The Requested Fee Is Reasonable and Appropriate 20 Class Counsel relentlessly litigated this novel and challenging case against one of the 21 world’s most sophisticated, aggressive and well-resourced corporations for over three years, 22 during which time Class Counsel sustained and developed their claims in the face of motions to 23 dismiss, a motion for summary judgment and opposition to certification of the Class. Those 24 victories could not have been possible absent Class Counsel’s substantial investment of time, 25 effort and resources into, among other things: (i) thoroughly researching and crafting the claims 26 asserted by Plaintiffs, (ii) defending those claims against the myriad arguments asserted against 27 them by Apple and its counsel, and (iii) developing an evidentiary record supporting Plaintiffs’ 28 claims through assiduous and tireless discovery efforts that included, inter alia, twelve discovery 945562.1 7 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 15 of 30

1 motions, seventeen depositions and review and analysis of hundreds of thousands of Apple and 2 third-party documents. These efforts culminated with the $18 million Settlement on the eve of 3 trial. 4 In sum, Class Counsel assumed substantial risks and devoted substantial resources in 5 pursuing a recovery for the Class through relentless—but efficient—litigation undertaken on a 6 fully contingent basis. These circumstances warrant a fee exceeding the 25 percent “benchmark” 7 applied in the Ninth Circuit in common fund cases. The reasonableness of Class Counsel’s 8 request for 30% of the Settlement amount is confirmed not only by the results achieved and efforts 9 expended by Class Counsel in this novel and challenging Action, but also by the .67 negative 10 multiplier produced by the relevant lodestar cross-check. See Schneider v. Chipotle Mexican 11 Grill, Inc., No. 16-CV-02200-HSG, 2020 WL 6484833, at *12 (N.D. Cal. Nov. 4, 2020) 12 (awarding 30% fee “based almost entirely on the negative lodestar multiplier (as opposed to on 13 anything about this case or Class Counsel’s work that warrants an upward adjustment from the 14 25% benchmark)”); In re Google LLC St. View Elec. Commc'ns Litig., No. 10-MD-02184-CRB, 15 2020 WL 1288377, at *9 (N.D. Cal. Mar. 18, 2020) (“A negative lodestar multiplier ‘strongly 16 suggests the reasonableness’ of the requested fee”); In re Nexus 6P Prod. Liab. Litig., No. 17-CV- 17 02185-BLF, 2019 WL 6622842, at *13 (N.D. Cal. Nov. 12, 2019) (30% award was reasonable 18 when the requested amount represented a negative lodestar multiplier); Johnson v. Quantum 19 Learning Network, Inc., No. 15-CV-05013-LHK, 2017 WL 747462, at *6 (N.D. Cal. Feb. 27, 20 2017) (negative lodestar multiplier supports upward adjustment of 25% benchmark). Further, the 21 requested fee comports with Ninth Circuit law directing that attorneys’ fees in class cases should 22 properly incentivize class counsel to take on difficult cases and pursue class members’ best 23 interests, as Class Counsel successfully did here.

24 1. The Court Should Calculate Class Counsel’s Fees as a 25 Percentage of the Common Fund 26 The nature and result of this Action warrants application of the percentage-of-the-fund 27 approach as the principal method of determining the reasonableness of Class Counsel’s fee 28 request. As this Court and other courts have recognized, this method “is commonly used in the 945562.1 8 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 16 of 30

1 legal marketplace to determine attorneys’ fees in contingency fee cases.” In re Anthem, Inc. Data 2 Breach Litig., No. 15-MD-02617-LHK, 2018 WL 3960068, at *5 (N.D. Cal. Aug. 17, 2018); see 3 also, e.g., Fed. Judicial Ctr., Awarding Attorneys’ Fees & Managing Fee Litig. at 73 (3d ed. 2015) 4 (percentage-of-the-fund method “helps ensure that the fee award will simulate marketplace rates, 5 since most common fund cases are the kinds of cases normally taken on a contingency fee basis, 6 by which counsel is promised a percentage of any recovery”). As such, the percentage-of-the-fund 7 method is the most appropriate way to calculate a reasonable fee where, as here, contingency fee 8 litigation has produced a cash common fund. Blum v. Stenson, 465 U.S. 886, 900 n.16 (1984); 9 Vizcaino, 290 F.3d at 1047; Six Mexican Workers, 904 F.2d at 1311 (common fund fee is 10 generally “calculated as a percentage of the recovery”). 11 Other considerations similarly militate for the percentage-of-the-fund approach here (and 12 generally), including: (i) replicating more accurately the manner in which plaintiffs’ lawyers 13 practice outside of the class action context, (ii) ensuring that class counsel’s interests are more 14 directly aligned with the interests of the class, (iii) rewarding counsel for assuming the risks and 15 costs of litigating a contingent matter, and (iv) avoiding certain unsavory byproducts sometimes 16 associated with the lodestar method, such as creating incentives for counsel to bill more time than 17 absolutely necessary. See 5 Newberg on Class Actions §§ 15:62, 15:65 (5th ed. 2018); see also In 18 re Anthem, 2018 WL 3960068, at *5-6. In short, the percentage-of-the-fund method beneficially 19 aligns class counsel’s interests with those of the class, and properly incentivizes capable counsel to 20 not only accept challenging cases, but to push to achieve the best possible result for the class in the 21 most efficient manner possible. See, e.g., Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Visa U.S.A. Inc., 396 F.3d 96, 22 122 (2d Cir. 2005) (percentage method “directly aligns the interests of the class and its counsel”) 23 (citation omitted).

24 2. The Court Should Award A Fee of Thirty Percent of the 25 Common Fund 26 To compensate Class Counsel for the time, resources and effort they expended in 27 prosecuting this Action and obtaining a significant benefit for the Class, Class Counsel seek a fee 28 award of $5,400,000, equal to 30% of the $18 million cash fund yielded by the Settlement. 945562.1 9 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 17 of 30

1 In applying the percentage-of-the-fund method, the Court “typically begins with the 9th 2 Circuit ‘benchmark’ of 25%, and then explains what special circumstances justify a deviation 3 upward or downward from that benchmark.” In re Cathode Ray Tube (CRT) Antitrust Litig., No. 4 3:07-cv-5944 JST, 2016 WL 721680, *34 (N.D. Cal. Jan. 28, 2016). Upward departures may be 5 warranted in various circumstances, and “downward departures may be warranted where there is 6 no ‘realistic risk of nonrecovery.’” In re Anthem, 2018 WL 396068, at *4 (quoting Perkins v. 7 LinkedIn Corp., No. 13-CV-04303-LHK, 2016 WL 613255, at *14 (N.D. Cal. Feb. 16, 2016)). 8 See also Johnson v. Quantum Learning Network, Inc., Case No. 15-CV-05013-LHK, 2017 WL 9 747462, at *4 (N.D. Cal. Feb. 27, 2017) (upwardly adjusting fee award to 28% of the common 10 fund created by the settlement in case where “Plaintiffs engaged in no motion practice other than 11 motions for settlement approval”). 12 Courts in the Ninth Circuit—including this Court—often award fees in excess of the 25 13 percent benchmark. See, e.g., Vizcaino, 290 F.3d at 1050 (affirming 28 percent award); In re 14 Omnivision Techs., Inc., 559 F. Supp. 2d 1036, 1047 (N.D. Cal. 2007) (“[I]n most common fund 15 cases, the award exceeds that [25%] benchmark.”); Schneider, 2020 WL 6484833, at *12 (30% 16 fee); In re Nexus, 2019 WL 6622842, at *13 (30% fee); Hopkins v. Stryker Sales Corp., No. 11- 17 CV-02786-LHK, 2013 WL 496358, at *1 (N.D. Cal. Feb. 6, 2013) (30% fee); Castaneda v. 18 Burger King Corp., No. C 08-04262 WHA, 2010 WL 2735091, at *1 (N.D. Cal. July 12, 2010) 19 (33% fee); Vedachalam v. Tata Consultancy Servs., Ltd., No. C 06–0963 CW, 2013 WL 3941319, 20 at *2-3 (N.D. Cal. July 18, 2013) (awarding 30% fee and citing cases where 30% awarded); In re 21 TFT-LCD (Flat Panel) Antitrust Litig., No. M 07-1827 SI, 2013 WL 149692, at *2 (N.D. Cal. Jan. 22 14, 2013) (30% fee); Garner v. State Farm, No. CV 08 1365 CW, 2010 WL 1687829, at *2 (N.D. 23 Cal. Apr. 22, 2010) (30% fee); Knight v. Red Door Salons, Inc., No. 08–01520 SC, 2009 WL 24 248367, *7 (N.D. Cal. Feb. 2, 2009) (30% fee). 25 In deciding whether to adjust the 25% benchmark in a common fund case such as this 26 Action, the Court considers the following criteria: (i) the results achieved for the Class; (ii) the risk 27 to counsel in litigating the action; (iii) the skill, experience and performance of counsel; (iv) the 28 contingent nature of the litigation; and (v) awards in similar cases. Vizcaino, 290 F.3d at 1048– 945562.1 10 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 18 of 30

1 1049; In re Bluetooth, 654 F.3d at 942. Consideration of those factors here militates strongly in 2 favor of a significant upward adjustment from the benchmark, and fully supports the 30% fee 3 requested here.

4 (a) Class Counsel Achieved a Significant Benefit for the Class 5 After more than three years of relentless, difficult and effective litigation of the “novel” 6 claims asserted by Plaintiffs in this Action, Class Counsel achieved a $18 million non- 7 reversionary common fund for the California class. The $18 million cash fund provides 8 significant monetary relief to the aggrieved Class Members, representing nearly 30 percent of the 9 total average damages initially estimated by Plaintiffs’ expert Dr. Hastings, and infinitely more 10 than the zero damages amount calculated by Apple’s expert.2 Class members will receive for each 11 qualifying iPhone 4 and 4S device they own an initial check for approximately $3, with the 12 possibility of an additional payment thereafter. Class Members need not submit a claim form to 13 receive payment and there is no reversion of settlement funds to Apple. If Class Members do 14 nothing in response to notice of the settlement, they will automatically receive an e-check (if they 15 were served notice by email), or a paper check if they received notice by regular mail. If all Class 16 Members cash their checks, the average damages amount received by each class member will be 17 nearly 20 percent of Dr. Hastings’ estimate of average per device diminution in value caused by 18 the FaceTime Break.

19 (b) Class Counsel Faced Significant Risk in Litigating the Action 20 This Action constitutes a quintessential example of litigation that imposes significant risk 21 on the plaintiff’s counsel who agree to prosecute it. The very nature of the challenged 22 misconduct—i.e., Apple’s failure to prevent the 2016 expiration of a digital certificate 23 programmed many years earlier—presented significant challenges in the identification and 24 25 26 2 Apple vigorously contests Plaintiffs’ damages model and contends that Dr. Hastings inflated damages by focusing on the “B to B” market rather than the consumer market. Apple filed a 27 Daubert motion seeking to exclude Dr. Hastings’ testimony and reports from the Action. Dkt. No. 333. The Court has not ruled on that motion. 28 945562.1 11 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 19 of 30

1 pleading of applicable causes of action, and required Plaintiffs to deploy a claim rarely used in the 2 consumer class action context. Indeed, the Court itself recognized the novel nature of Plaintiffs’ 3 claims, stating “I haven’t seen a trespass cause of action in one of these consumer class action” 4 (Dkt. No. 57 at 5:16-18), and that “this trespass to chattels claim seems novel[.]” Id. at 12:14-15. 5 The identity of the Defendant against whom these unique claims were asserted further 6 compounded the risk posed to Class Counsel by this Action. In addition to its exalted status as 7 one of the most sophisticated and well-resourced corporations in the world, Apple has developed a 8 reputation for its extremely zealous, effective and relentless approach to defending against 9 litigation. Indeed, when Plaintiffs filed this Action, in the preceding decade, CCC had engaged in 10 five trials in cases asserting claims against Apple. Class Counsel therefore fully recognized and 11 accepted that securing a meaningful benefit for the Class in this Action would require multiple 12 years of difficult, resource-intensive and successful litigation against an extremely capable, 13 resourced and litigious adversary. 14 Class Counsel faced and defeated multiple threats to the Action, the risk of which was 15 amplified by the atypical nature of Class Counsel’s legal theory and underlying claims. Those 16 threats included: (i) multiple case-dispositive arguments asserted in Apple’s motion to dismiss; (ii) 17 Apple’s challenge to certification of the Class; and (iii) multiple case-dispositive arguments 18 asserted in Apple’s motion for summary judgment. Class Counsel’s success in repelling Apple’s 19 attacks against Plaintiffs’ claims would have been pyrrhic had Class Counsel not also succeeded in 20 fending off Apple’s repeated challenges to Plaintiffs’ damages model. And yet, the Court’s 21 decision on Apple’s Daubert motion remains pending. Dkt. No. 333. Thus, Plaintiffs faced the 22 risk of proceeding to trial without an expert opinion or analysis calculating damages arising from 23 the FaceTime Break, which Apple’s expert has concluded are non-measurable and thus non- 24 existent. 25 Even after successfully navigating the Action to the eve of trial, Class Counsel faced 26 several other risks. Apple could move to decertify or otherwise limit the Class, and there is no 27 guarantee that Class Counsel would defeat such efforts. Additionally, although CCC has 28 historically enjoyed success at trial against Apple, trial victory is never assured and the different 945562.1 12 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 20 of 30

1 subject matter, claims and venue associated with this Action inject additional uncertainty. Apple 2 would have asserted myriad factual and legal defenses, likely including its ongoing arguments 3 that: (i) it never acted with the intent to interfere with FaceTime, (ii) the certificate expiration that 4 caused the FaceTime Break was purely a result of programming decisions made in 2007 and 2010 5 rather than any affirmative conduct, and (iii) in any event, Apple provided a fully satisfactory fix 6 in the form of an update to the latest version of its operating system (i.e., iOS 7). Apple has also 7 challenged Plaintiffs’ possession of an ownership interest in the personal property with which 8 Apple interfered given the iOS licensing agreement to which all Apple customers must agree, and 9 has claimed it is impossible to ascertain customers who suffered a significant interference with 10 FaceTime on a device they were actively using. Apple also would have presented various 11 affirmative defenses, including that: (i) Plaintiffs were estopped from claiming trespass to chattels; 12 (ii) in utilizing digital certificates in connection with FaceTime, Apple acted out of necessity to 13 prevent serious harm; (iii) Plaintiffs consented to the alleged interference; (iv) Plaintiffs failed to 14 mitigate damages because they could have, but did not, take action to lessen their alleged 15 damages; and (v) Apple’s conduct was necessary and had a substantial business justification. 16 Finally, even assuming Class Counsel were to prevail at trial, Apple undoubtedly would 17 have challenged any such outcome through post-trial appellate proceedings. See Glass v. UBS 18 Fin. Servs., Inc., No. C-06-4068 MMC, 2007 WL 221862, *4 (N.D. Cal. Jan. 26, 2007), aff’d, 331 19 F. App’x 452 (9th Cir. 2009) (“Regardless of how this Court might have ruled on the merits of the 20 legal issues, the losing party likely would have appealed, and the parties would have faced the 21 expense and uncertainty of litigating an appeal.”). 22 In sum, from the outset of and throughout this Action, Class Counsel faced substantial risk 23 associated with the novel, complex and nuanced claims, yet succeeded in conferring a significant 24 benefit on the Class.

25 (c) Substantial Effort and Skill Was Required to Prosecute this 26 Action 27 The effort, skill and performance of counsel and the complexity of the issues involved are 28 additional factors used in determining a proper fee. Vizcaino, 290 F.3d at 1048; In re Omnivision, 945562.1 13 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 21 of 30

1 559 F. Supp. 2d at 1046-47. These factors strongly support the fee requested here. Class Counsel 2 drew upon their deep experience to craft and litigate these “novel” claims against a formidable 3 litigation adversary. Those claims required Class Counsel to grapple with atypical challenges and 4 complexities, including: (i) the highly technical subject matter of the claims, which required, inter 5 alia, examination and analysis of Apple’s underlying source code relating to FaceTime and the 6 relevant digital certificate architecture, and a fulsome exploration of Apple’s internal processes 7 relating to the monitoring and remediation of issues relating to that architecture; and (ii) 8 demonstrating through the cultivation of the written and testimonial record that Apple’s actions 9 and/or omissions years after the programming of the iPhone Device Sub-CA constitutes 10 intentional conduct giving rise to liability under the claims asserted. Class Counsel also was 11 required to develop in conjunction with its expert a nuanced damages analysis that was 12 complicated by the fact that Apple extended to Class members the ability to restore FaceTime on 13 their devices by upgrading to iOS 7 (albeit, at significant cost to the functionality of any device 14 that did so). 15 Class Counsel assembled a team of four law firms with the necessary experience, 16 expertise, talent and resources to successfully engage in these battles against a highly capable and 17 challenging litigation adversary. In doing so, Class Counsel relied heavily on each of the four 18 firms’ respective particularized expertise. In particular, (i) CCC contributed not only substantial 19 expertise regarding technical issues, but also extensive experience and success in litigating highly 20 technical issues against Apple through (and beyond) trial (and re-trial); (ii) PSW and Steyer 21 Lowenthal contributed their many decades of collective expertise with respect to the prosecution 22 of consumer class action claims based on California law litigated in California courts; and (iii) 23 FOT contributed its expertise in identifying, crafting and refining meritorious claims and 24 arguments, and persuasively presenting them in pleadings and briefing capable of withstanding 25 dispositive motions. Given the substantial efforts necessary to effectively prosecute this Action 26 the roles and contributions of the four firms sometimes overlapped, for example in reviewing the 27 voluminous discovery record and undertaking the substantial endeavor of preparing the Action for 28 trial. Each firm has described its contributions to prosecution of the Action in greater detail in 945562.1 14 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 22 of 30

1 separate declarations submitted herewith. See Manning Decl., ¶¶ 52-71; Declaration of Daniel L. 2 Warshaw (“Warshaw Decl.”), ¶¶ 8-28; Declaration of David F.E. Tejtel (“Tejtel Decl.”), ¶ 8; 3 Declaration of John A. Curry (“Curry Decl.”), ¶¶ 7-19. The benefit achieved here—an $18 4 million cash settlement—would have been impossible absent the four firms’ substantial and 5 efficient efforts and support an award of 30% of the common fund. 6 The effort and skill of class counsel here more closely resembles those in Hopkins v. 7 Stryker Sales Corp., No. 11–CV–02786–LHK, 2013 WL 496358 (N.D. Cal. Feb. 6, 2013), where 8 this Court awarded a 30% fee, representing a 2.76 lodestar multiplier, than Johnson v. Quantum 9 Learning Network, Inc., No. 15-CV-05013-LHK, 2017 WL 747462 (N.D. Cal. Feb. 27, 2017), or 10 de Mira v. Heartland Employment Serv., LLC, No. 12-CV-04092 LHK, 2014 WL 1026282 (N.D. 11 Cal. Mar. 13, 2014), where this Court awarded 28% fees. 12 In Johnson, the case settled before plaintiffs opposed a motion to compel arbitration and 13 plaintiffs “engaged in no motion practice other than motions for settlement approval.” Johnson, 14 2017 WL 747462 at *6. This Court found that, despite the early settlement, the fact that the 15 requested fee was less than the lodestar amount “supports granting Class Counsel’s request of 16 33.33% of the common fund” but reduced the fee to 28% because counsel had filed two deficient 17 motions for preliminary approval. Id. In de Mira, this Court awarded a 28% fee, representing a 18 1.36 lodestar multiplier, although the plaintiffs “did not engage in motion practice before 19 settlement….” de Mira, 2014 WL 1026282 at *3. 20 Similar to this Action, in Hopkins, class counsel engaged in extensive investigation and 21 comprehensive discovery practice, faced “a defense firm that zealously litigated th[e] action,” 22 engaged expert witnesses and succeeded in certifying a class based on a complex class 23 certification motion. Hopkins, 2013 WL 496358 at *2. Here, as in Hopkins, Class Counsel 24 achieved an excellent result in a very difficult case winning a substantial settlement where “class 25 members do not have to submit claim forms in order to recover” and “there is no reverter.” Id. 26 Class Counsel respectfully submit that their effort, skill and performance uniformly and weigh 27 strongly in favor of the requested fee award.

28 945562.1 15 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 23 of 30

1 (d) Class Counsel Litigated this Action on a Purely Contingent 2 Basis 3 It is well-established—and Courts in the Ninth Circuit have long recognized—that the 4 public interest is served by rewarding attorneys who assume representation on a contingent basis 5 with an enhanced fee to compensate them for the risk that they might receive no payment or 6 reimbursement at all for their investment of time, resources and expense. See In re Wash., 19 F.3d 7 at 1299 (“Contingent fees that may far exceed the market value of the services if rendered on a 8 noncontingent basis are accepted in the legal profession as a legitimate way of assuring competent 9 representation for plaintiffs who could not afford to pay on an hourly basis regardless whether 10 they win or lose”); Vizcaino, 290 F.3d at 1051 (“[i]n common fund cases, ‘attorneys whose 11 compensation depends on their winning the case[ ] must make up in compensation in the cases 12 they win for the lack of compensation in the cases they lose.’” (citing In re Wash. Pub. Power 13 Supply Sys. Sec. Litig., 19 F.3d 1291, 1300-01 (9th Cir. 1994)). For well over three years, Class 14 Counsel have prosecuted this Action on a purely contingent basis, and advanced all expenses 15 associated therewith. This assumption of risk further justifies an upward departure from the Ninth 16 Circuit’s 25% “benchmark” for percentage-of-the-fund fee awards.

17 (e) Awards in Similar Cases Support an Upward Adjustment 18 The novelty of Plaintiffs’ legal theory and claims makes it difficult to identify similar cases 19 for purposes of comparing the fee awarded therein to the fee requested by Class Counsel here. 20 Indeed, Plaintiffs have been unable to identify any case in which a trespass to chattels theory akin 21 to that advanced in this Action produced a comparable recovery for the class on whose behalf it 22 was asserted. Standing alone, the unique result achieved through relentless and effective 23 prosecution of the claim novel claims asserted in this Action further supports an upward 24 adjustment from the Ninth Circuit’s 25% benchmark. 25 In the somewhat analogous realm of data breach actions, Courts have routinely awarded 26 27 28 945562.1 16 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 24 of 30

1 fees above the 25% benchmark.3 The frequency of those upward adjustments is particularly 2 noteworthy given that some of those results qualify as “megafund” settlements, where awarding 3 25% of the fund could “yield windfall profits for class counsel.”4 Indeed, more generally, the 4 percentage-of-the-fund awarded in megafund cases has often exceeded 25%.5 Here, an award of 5 30% would not yield a “windfall” to Class Counsel.

6 3. A Lodestar-Multiplier “Cross-Check” Further Confirms 7 the Reasonableness of the Requested Fee 8 “To guard against an unreasonable result, the Ninth Circuit encourages district courts to 9 ‘cross-check[] their calculations against a second method.’” In re High-Tech Employee Antitrust 10 Litig., 2015 WL 5158730, *6 (N.D. Cal. Sept. 2, 2015) (citations omitted). Here, the lodestar 11 cross-check constitutes compelling evidence supporting the reasonableness of Class Counsel’s fee 12 request. 13 Class Counsel successfully managed this litigation to ensure efficiency. Manning Decl., ¶¶ 14 38-43; Warshaw Decl., ¶ 32; Tejtel Decl., ¶ 12; Curry Decl., ¶ 23. Class Counsel’s cumulative 15 lodestar as of October 31, 2020 is $8,068,130.80 using historic billing rates. Manning Decl., ¶ 71; 16 Warshaw Decl., ¶ 32; Tejtel Decl., ¶ 12; Curry Decl., ¶ 23. See In re Wash., 19 F.3d at 1305 17 (courts apply each biller’s current rates for all hours of work performed, regardless of when the 18

19 3 See In re The Home Depot, Inc., Customer Data Sec. Breach Litig., No.: 1:14-md-02583-TWT, 20 2016 WL 6902351 (N.D. Ga. Aug. 23, 2016) (awarding $8.03 million fee on $28.4 million settlement, equal to 28.2% of the fund); In re Target Corp. Customer Data Sec. Breach Litig., No. 21 14–2522 (PAM), 2017 WL 2178306 (D. Minn. May 17, 2017) (awarding $6.75 million fee on 22 $23.3 million settlement, equal to 28.9% of the fund); In re Anthem, supra, 2018 WL 3960068 (awarding $31.05 million fee on $115 million settlement, equal to 27% of the fund). 23 4 In re Anthem, 2018 WL 396068 at *15 (quoting In re Bluetooth, 654 F.3d at 942). 5 See Vizcaino, 290 F.3d at 1052 & n.9 (survey of awards in cases with class settlements between 24 $50-200 million); Allapattah Servs., Inc. v. Exxon Corp., 454 F. Supp. 2d 1185, 1218 (S.D. Fla. 2006) (31 1/3% fee for settlement fund of over $1 billion); In re Linerboard Antitrust Litig., No. 25 CIV.A. 98-5055, 2004 WL 1221350, at *1 (E.D. Pa. Jun. 2, 2004) (30% fee; $202 million fund); 26 In re Relafen Antitrust Litig., 231 F.R.D. 52, 80-82 (D. Mass. 2005) (33 1/3% fee; $175 million fund); In re Vitamins Antitrust Litig., No. MDL 1285, 2001 WL 34312839, at *10 (D.D.C. July 27 16, 2001) (34.06% fee; $359 million fund); In re Sumitomo Copper Litig., 74 F. Supp. 2d 393, 400 (S.D.N.Y. 1999) (27.5% fee; $116 million fund); Kurzweil v. Philip Morris Cos., No. 94 CIV. 28 2373 (MBM), 1999 WL 1076105, at *1 (S.D.N.Y. Nov. 30, 1999) (30% fee; $123 million fund). 945562.1 17 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 25 of 30

1 work was performed, as a means of compensating for the “delay in payment.”); Vizcaino, 290 F.3d 2 at 1051 (affirming lodestar crosscheck using current billing rates). (See also Warshaw Decl., ¶ 31 3 (rates are PSW’s customary rates billed to clients and have been approved by numerous courts); 4 Manning Decl., ¶ 69 (same); Tejtel Decl., ¶ 10 (same); Curry Decl., ¶ 21 (same)). Class Counsel’s 5 rates are “in line with those [rates] prevailing in the community for similar services by lawyers of 6 reasonably comparable skill, experience, and reputation.” Blum, 465 U.S. at 895-96 n.11. Class 7 Counsel’s historical hourly rates, which range from $300 to $1190 for attorneys and from $195 to 8 $350 for paralegals, are reasonable for complex class litigation in this market. See In re National 9 Collegiate Athletic Association Athletic Grant-in-Aid Cap Antitrust Litigation, Case No. 4:14-md- 10 2541-CW (N.D. Cal.), Dkt. No. 12596 at 4 (Dec. 6, 2019) (approving partner rates at $1,150 and 11 $450 for associates); In re Yahoo! Inc. Customer Data Sec. Breach Litig., No. 16-MD-02752- 12 LHK, 2020 WL 4212811, at *26–27 (N.D. Cal. July 22, 2020) (approving billing rates of $450 to 13 $900 for partners; $160 to $850 for non-partner attorneys; and $50 to $380 for paralegals and 14 support staff); In re Anthem, 2018 WL 3960068, at *17 (approving billing rates of $400 to $970 15 for partners; $185 to $850 for non-partner attorneys; and $95 to $440 for paralegals, law clerks, 16 and litigation support staff); In re High-Tech Employee, 2015 WL 5158730, at *9 (approving 17 billing rates of $310 to $975 for attorneys and $190 to $430 for paralegals and support staff); In re 18 Animation Workers Antitrust Litig., No. 14-CV-4062-LHK, 2016 WL 6663005, at *6 (N.D. Cal. 19 Nov. 11, 2016) (finding rates of senior attorneys of between $845 to $1,200 per hour to be 20 reasonable). 21 The lodestar hours reflect the extremely hard work and the very efficient manner in which 22 Class Counsel prosecuted this Action. See Manning Decl., ¶¶ 49-71; Warshaw Decl., ¶¶ 8-32; 23 Tejtel Decl., ¶¶ 8-12; Curry Decl., ¶¶ 7-23. Indeed, Class Counsel took steps to ensure that the 24 lodestar submitted in support of the requested fee would be conservative relative to the time and 25

26 6 See also, In re National Collegiate Athletic Association Athletic Grant-in-Aid Cap Antitrust 27 Litigation, Case No. 4:14-md-2541-CW (N.D. Cal.), Dkt No. 1246 Exs. A and B (Oct. 16, 2019) (hourly rate schedule approved by court). 28 945562.1 18 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 26 of 30

1 resources Class Counsel expended in this Action. For example, in an attempt to be conservative, 2 Class Counsel have excluded from their lodestar calculation any hourly contract work conducted 3 in the prosecution of this Action. Tejtel Decl., ¶ 9. In doing so, Class Counsel have eliminated 4 from their lodestar over a thousand hours of contract attorney time dedicated to furthering the 5 prosecution of this Action. Id. 6 One of the primary functions of the lodestar cross-check is to guard against a large fee 7 award where counsel settled early and undertook only a minimal amount of work. Vizcaino, 290 8 F.3d at 1050. Clearly, no such concern is remotely present here. Class Counsel have aggressively 9 litigated the Action for well over three years, including by: (i) amending the complaint in response 10 to Apple’s initial motion to dismiss; (ii) defeating Apple’s motion to dismiss the Amended 11 Complaint; (iii) achieving certification of the California-only Class; (iv) pursuing a 23(f) petition 12 in an attempt to obtain a nationwide class; (v) engaging in highly contentious discovery that 13 involved twelve discovery motions, seventeen depositions and over a million pages of produced 14 documents; (vi) defeating Apple’s motion for summary judgment; (vii) incurring $1,092,459.47 in 15 out-of-pocket costs and expenses; (viii) engaging in substantial trial preparation activities; and (ix) 16 ultimately securing the $18 million settlement. 17 Class Counsel’s attorneys and staff have devoted more than 9,650 hours to the prosecution 18 of this Action, amounting to cumulative lodestar of approximately $8,068,130.80 using historic 19 billing rates. A fee in the amount of approximately 30% of the $18 million common fund 20 therefore represents an effective negative multiplier of .67 on Class Counsel’s cumulative lodestar. 21 This amount falls well below the range commonly approved in the Ninth Circuit, even 22 where the requested attorneys’ fee is substantially higher than that requested here. See, e.g., In re 23 Yahoo Mail Litig., No. 13-CV-4980-LHK, 2016 WL 4474612, at *11 (N.D. Cal. Aug. 25, 2016) 24 (discussing a survey of “attorney’s fees awards in common fund cases ranging from $50 to 200 25 million between 1996 and 2001” and finding that in “the vast majority of cases (20 of 24, or 83%), 26 the multiplier ranged from 1.0–4.0.”) (citing Vizcaino, 290 F.3d at 1052-54). 27 In sum, the lodestar “cross-check” strongly supports Class Counsel’s requested fee.

28 945562.1 19 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 27 of 30

1 B. Class Counsel’s Expenses Are Reasonable and Should Be Reimbursed 2 It is well-established in the Ninth Circuit that the reasonable expenses incurred by counsel 3 in obtaining a common fund for the class can and should be reimbursed. See Vincent v. Hughes 4 Air W., Inc., 557 F.2d 759, 769 (9th Cir. 1977); Acosta v. Frito-Lay, Inc., No. 15-CV- 02128-JSC, 5 2018 WL 646691, at *11 (N.D. Cal. Jan. 31, 2018) (“There is no doubt that an attorney who has 6 created a common fund for the benefit of the class is entitled to reimbursement of reasonable 7 litigation expenses from that fund.”) (citation omitted). Such expense awards comport with the 8 notion that the district court may “spread the costs of the litigation among the recipients of the 9 common benefit.” Wininger v. SI Mgmt. L.P., 301 F.3d 1115, 1121 (9th Cir. 2002); see also, e.g., 10 In re Media Vision Tech. Sec. Litig., 913 F. Supp. 1362, 1366 (N.D. Cal. 1995) (citing Mills v. 11 Elec. Auto-Lite Co., 396 U.S. 375, 391-92 (1970) (“Reasonable costs and expenses incurred by an 12 attorney who creates or preserves a common fund are reimbursed proportionately by those class 13 members who benefit[.]”). 14 Here, Class Counsel request the reimbursement of $1,092,459.47 in litigation costs and 15 expenses reasonably incurred. Warshaw Decl., ¶ 39. Attached to the declarations of Class 16 Counsel are detailed breakdowns of the unreimbursed expenses necessarily incurred by counsel in 17 the prosecution of this Action for which Class Counsel seek reimbursement. Manning Decl., Ex. 18 11; Warshaw Decl., Ex. 4; Tejtel Decl., Ex. 4; Curry Decl., Ex. 4. As with the lodestar, all 19 expenses were reported contemporaneously and carefully scrutinized. These expenses are in line 20 with those previously permitted by the Court. In re Anthem, 2018 WL 3960068, at *28; In re 21 High-Tech Employee, 2015 WL 5158730 at *16.

22 C. The Service Award Request Is Reasonable 23 Finally, Plaintiffs seek service awards of $7,500 for each Class Representative to be paid 24 from the Settlement Fund. The purpose of service awards is to “compensate named plaintiffs for 25 the services they provided and the risks they incurred during the course of class action litigation, 26 and to reward the public service of contributing to the enforcement of mandatory laws.” Sullivan 27 v. DB Invs., Inc., 667 F.3d 273, 333 n.65 (3d Cir. 2011) (en banc) (affirming antitrust class action 28 settlement with common fund of $295 million, providing for service awards of $85,000 to each of 945562.1 20 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 28 of 30

1 two class representatives) (citation and quotation omitted), cert. denied, 132 S. Ct. 1876 (2012). 2 See also, e.g., Staton, 327 F.3d at 977 (“[N]amed plaintiffs . . . are eligible for reasonable incentive 3 payments”). 4 The requested $7,500 service awards are reasonable and appropriate here. Both Class 5 Representatives have expended significant time and effort assisting Class Counsel with the 6 prosecution of the Class’s claims. Among other things, over the more than three-year span of this 7 Action, the Class Representatives have: (i) responded to and produced documents, including 8 personal text messages and emails, in response to Apple’s document requests; (ii) responded to 9 interrogatories; (iii) responded to RFAs; (iv) prepared for and endured full-day depositions during 10 which Apple probed into, inter alia, various topics of a personal nature; (v) surrendered their 11 iPhone devices for full forensic imaging—and subsequent searching—for a period of several 12 months, pursuant to which 370,000 files and all data and information regarding FaceTime, Wi-Fi 13 use, Wi-Fi connection history, and Wi-Fi networks was harvested from their devices; (vi) made 14 themselves available by telephone for consultation during each of the four mediation and 15 settlement conferences; and (vii) otherwise devoted many hours consulting with Class Counsel 16 regarding fact development and strategy. Manning Decl. ¶¶ 25-35. 17 More generally, both Class Representatives also incurred the risks associated with 18 assuming leadership roles in this highly visible and public litigation against one of the most 19 prominent technology companies in the world. 20 Finally, the requested service awards are appropriate when compared to the substantial 21 recovery achieved through their efforts. Courts assessing the reasonableness of requests for 22 service awards may compare the request against the size of the settlement fund. See, e.g., In re 23 Online DVD-Rental Antitrust Litig., 779 F.3d 934, 947 (9th Cir. 2015) (holding that awards 24 cumulatively representing 0.17% of the settlement fund were reasonable); In re Yahoo!, 2020 WL 25 4212811, at *44 ($87,500 in total service awards reasonable where they “represent less than .1% 26 of the Settlement Fund”). The requested service awards here collectively represent less than one 27 percent—i.e., 0.08333%—of the $18 million common fund. The requested service awards thus 28 comport with the range authorized by the Ninth Circuit and approved in this District. See, e.g., In 945562.1 21 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 29 of 30

1 re Yahoo!, 2020 WL 4212811 at *44 ($7,500 service awards to class representatives who were 2 deposed); In re High-Tech Employee, 2015 WL 5158730 (N.D. Cal. Sept. 2, 2015) (approving 3 service awards ranging from $20,000 to $120,000); Bellinghausen v. Tractor Supply Co., 306 4 F.R.D. 245, 266-67 (N.D. Cal. 2015) (collecting cases showing that incentive awards typically 5 range between $2,500 and $10,000); Hickcox-Huffman v. US Airways, Inc., No. 10-CV-05193- 6 VKD, 2019 WL 1571877, at *2 (N.D. Cal. Apr. 11, 2019) (“[T]he amount of $10,000.00 is fair 7 and reasonable in light of the amount of personal time devoted to fulfilling her duties as the class 8 representative in this action.”); Alvarez v. Farmers Ins. Exch., No. 3:14-CV-00574-WHO, 2017 9 WL 2214585, at *1 (N.D. Cal. Jan. 18, 2017) (finding a $10,000 service awards fair and 10 reasonable in light of the fact that the amount is a small percentage, (0.002%), of the overall 11 recovery); In re Anthem, 2018 WL 3960068, at *31 (awarding $7,500 incentive payments to the 12 29 representative plaintiffs who had their computers forensically examined).

13 IV. CONCLUSION 14 For the reasons set forth above, Plaintiffs respectfully request that the Court grant the 15 motion in its entirety. 16 DATED: November 24, 2020 Respectfully submitted,

17 STEYER LOWENTHAL BOODROOKAS ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP 18 19 By: /s/ Jill M. Manning 20 JILL M. MANNING 21 Allan Steyer (Bar No. 100318) 22 D. Scott Macrae (Bar No. 104663) Suneel Jain (Bar No. 314558) 23 235 Pine Street, 15th Floor San Francisco, CA 94104 24 Telephone: (415) 424-3400 25 [email protected] [email protected] 26 [email protected] [email protected] 27

28 945562.1 22 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429 Filed 11/24/20 Page 30 of 30

1 PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP Clifford H. Pearson (Bar No. 108523) 2 Daniel L. Warshaw (Bar No. 185365) Thomas J. Nolan (Bar No. 66992) 3 15165 Ventura Boulevard, Suite 400 4 Sherman Oaks, CA 91403 Telephone: (818) 788-8300 5 [email protected] [email protected] 6 [email protected]

7 FRIEDMAN OSTER & TEJTEL PLLC 8 David F.E. Tejtel (admitted pro hac vice) 493 Bedford Center Road, Suite 2D 9 Bedford Hills, NY 10507 Telephone: (646) 661-5881 10 [email protected] 11 CALDWELL CASSADY & CURRY 12 Bradley W. Caldwell (admitted pro hac vice) Jason D. Cassady (admitted pro hac vice) 13 John Austin Curry (admitted pro hac vice) 2121 N. Pearl Street, Suite 1200 14 Dallas, TX 75201 Telephone: (214) 888-4848 15 [email protected] 16 [email protected] [email protected] 17 Counsel for Plaintiffs and the Class 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 945562.1 23 NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-1 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 9

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

11 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 12 NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 13 SAN JOSE DIVISION

14 CHRISTINA GRACE and KEN POTTER, Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC Individually and on Behalf of All Others 15 Similarly Situated, CLASS ACTION 16 Plaintiffs, [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, 17 v. REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS 18 APPLE INC., 19 Defendant. 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28

[PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK-NC Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-1 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 9

1 On November 24, 2020, Plaintiffs filed a Motion for Attorney’s Fees, Reimbursement of 2 Expenses and Service Awards and supporting declarations and exhibits (the “Motion”). On 3 February 8, 2021, the Court held a hearing on the Motion. Having considered the Motion, the 4 attorney declarations and exhibits thereto, and the briefs and oral argument in this matter (the 5 “Action”) and in support of the Motion, the Court finds and orders as follows: 6 A. The Request for Attorney’s Fees is Reasonable 7 Class Counsel seek a fee award equal to 30% of the $18 million cash settlement fund they 8 achieved on behalf of the Class, amounting to $5,400,000. 9 1. The Request is Reasonable Under the Percentage-of-the-Fund Analysis 10 In connection with a class action settlement, a court may award reasonable attorneys’ fees 11 as authorized by law or by the parties’ agreement. See Fed. R. Civ. P. 23(h); Hendricks v. 12 Starkist Co., No. 13- 00729-HSG, 2016 WL 5462423, at *10 (N.D. Cal. Sept. 29, 2016), aff’d, 13 2018 WL 5115482 (9th Cir. Oct. 19, 2018) (court may award reasonable attorneys’ fees and costs 14 where “a litigant proceeding in a representative capacity secures a ‘substantial benefit’ for a class 15 of persons”). The Ninth Circuit endorses the common fund doctrine, pursuant to which counsel 16 have an equitable right to receive compensation for their successful efforts in creating a common 17 fund. See Staton v. Boeing Co., 327 F.3d 938, 967-68 (9th Cir. 2003); Boeing Co. v. Van Gemert, 18 444 U.S. 472, 478 (1980) (“[A] litigant or a lawyer who recovers a common fund . . . is entitled to 19 a reasonable attorney’s fee from the fund as a whole”); In re Wash. Pub. Power Supply System 20 Sec. Litig., 19 F.3d 1291, 1300 (9th Cir. 1994) (same). 21 In applying the percentage-of-the-fund method, the Court “typically begins with the 9th 22 Circuit ‘benchmark’ of 25%, and then explains what special circumstances justify a deviation 23 upward or downward from that benchmark.” In re Cathode Ray Tube (CRT) Antitrust Litig., No. 24 3:07-cv-5944 JST, 2016 WL 721680, *34 (N.D. Cal. Jan. 28, 2016). Upward departures may be 25 warranted in various circumstances, and “downward departures may be warranted where there is 26 no ‘realistic risk of nonrecovery.’” In re Anthem, 2018 WL 396068, at *4 (quoting Perkins v. 27 LinkedIn Corp., No. 13-CV-04303-LHK, 2016 WL 613255, at *14 (N.D. Cal. Feb. 16, 2016)). 28 In deciding whether to adjust the 25% benchmark in a common fund case such as this { 2 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK-NC Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-1 Filed 11/24/20 Page 3 of 9

1 Action, the Court considers the following criteria: (i) the results achieved for the Class; (ii) the 2 risk to counsel in litigating the action; (iii) the skill, experience and performance of counsel; (iv) 3 the contingent nature of the litigation; and (v) awards in similar cases. Vizcaino v. Microsoft 4 Corp., 290 F.3d 1043, 1048-49 (9th Cir. 2002); In re Bluetooth Headset Products Liab. Litig., 5 654 F.3d 935, 942 (9th Cir. 2011). Consideration of those factors here weighs in favor of an 6 upward adjustment from the benchmark and supports the requested 30% fee. 7 (a) The Results Achieved for the Class 8 After more than three years of litigation, defeating a motion to dismiss, obtaining 9 certification of a California class and overcoming Apple’s motion for summary judgment, Class 10 Counsel achieved an $18 million non-reversionary common fund for the Class Members. The 11 $18 million cash fund provides significant monetary relief to the aggrieved Class Members, 12 representing nearly 30 percent of the total average damages initially estimated by Plaintiffs’ 13 expert, Dr. Justine S. Hastings, Ph.D. Class members will receive for each qualifying iPhone 4 14 and 4S device they own an initial check for approximately $3, with the possibility of an additional 15 payment thereafter. Class Members need not submit a claim form to receive payment and there is 16 no reversion of settlement funds to Apple. If Class Members do nothing in response to notice of 17 the settlement, they will automatically receive an e-check (if they were served notice by email), or 18 a paper check if they received notice by regular mail. 19 (b) The Risk To Counsel In Litigating The Action 20 Class Counsel incurred significant risk in litigating this Action against one of the largest 21 and most profitable companies in the world. The nature of the challenged misconduct—i.e., 22 Apple’s failure to prevent the 2014 expiration of a digital certificate programmed many years 23 earlier—presented challenges in the identification and pleading of applicable causes of action, 24 and required Plaintiffs to deploy a claim rarely used in the consumer class action context. The 25 Court previously recognized the novel nature of Plaintiffs’ claims, stating “I haven’t seen a 26 trespass cause of action in one of these consumer class action” (Dkt. No. 57 at 5:16-18), and that 27 “this trespass to chattels claim seems novel[.]” Id. at 12:14-15. 28 Class Counsel faced and defeated multiple threats to the Action, including: (i) multiple { 3 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK-NC Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-1 Filed 11/24/20 Page 4 of 9

1 case-dispositive arguments asserted in Apple’s motion to dismiss; (ii) Apple’s challenge to 2 certification of the Class; (iii) multiple case-dispositive arguments asserted in Apple’s motion for 3 summary judgment; and (iv) a challenge to Plaintiffs’ damages model. Even after litigating this 4 Action to the eve of trial, Class Counsel faced several risks. Apple could move to decertify or 5 otherwise limit the Class, and there is no guarantee that Class Counsel would defeat such efforts. 6 Additionally, there is never a guarantee of victory at trial, and Apple could have asserted myriad 7 factual and legal defenses that presented the risk of a defense verdict if the case proceeded to trial. 8 (c) The Skill, Experience And Performance Of Counsel 9 Class Counsel assembled a team of four law firms with the necessary experience, 10 expertise, talent and resources to achieve a significant settlement on behalf of the Class. Class 11 Counsel drew upon their deep experience to litigate these “novel” claims. Those claims required 12 Class Counsel to grapple with atypical challenges and complexities, including: (i) the highly 13 technical subject matter of the claims, which required, inter alia, examination and analysis of 14 Apple’s underlying source code relating to FaceTime and the relevant digital certificate 15 architecture, and a fulsome exploration of Apple’s internal processes relating to the monitoring 16 and remediation of issues relating to that architecture; and (ii) demonstrating through the 17 cultivation of the written and testimonial record that Apple’s actions and/or omissions years after 18 the programming of the digital certificate necessary for the functioning of FaceTime (i.e., the 19 iPhone Device Sub-CA) constitutes intentional conduct giving rise to liability under the claims 20 asserted. Class Counsel also was required to develop in conjunction with its expert a nuanced 21 damages analysis that was complicated by the fact that Apple extended to Class members the 22 ability to restore FaceTime on their devices by upgrading to iOS 7 (albeit, at significant cost to 23 the functionality of any device that did so). 24 These firms contributed not only substantial expertise regarding technical issues, but also 25 extensive experience and success in litigating highly technical issues against Apple, many 26 decades of collective expertise with respect to the prosecution of consumer class action claims 27 based on California law litigated in California courts, and expertise in identifying, crafting and 28 refining meritorious claims and arguments, and persuasively presenting them in pleadings and { 4 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK-NC Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-1 Filed 11/24/20 Page 5 of 9

1 briefing capable of withstanding dispositive motions. 2 (d) The Contingent Nature Of The Litigation 3 The public interest is served by rewarding attorneys who assume representation on a 4 contingent basis with an enhanced fee to compensate them for the risk that they might receive no 5 payment or reimbursement at all for their investment of time, resources and expense. Vizcaino, 6 290 F.3d at 1051 (“[i]n common fund cases, ‘attorneys whose compensation depends on their 7 winning the case[ ] must make up in compensation in the cases they win for the lack of 8 compensation in the cases they lose’”) (citing In re Wash. Pub. Power Supply Sys. Sec. Litig., 19 9 F.3d 1291, 1300-01 (9th Cir.1994)). As set forth in the supporting attorney declarations, Class 10 Counsel have prosecuted this Action on a purely contingent basis, and advanced all expenses 11 associated therewith for over three years. 12 (e) Awards In Similar Cases 13 The novelty of Plaintiffs’ legal theory and claims makes it difficult to identify similar 14 cases for purposes of comparing the fee awarded therein to the fee requested by Class Counsel 15 here. Indeed, Plaintiffs have been unable to identify any case in which a trespass to chattels 16 theory akin to that advanced in this Action produced a comparable recovery for the class on 17 whose behalf it was asserted. In the somewhat analogous realm of data breach actions, Courts 18 have routinely awarded fees above the 25% benchmark. See In re National Collegiate Athletic 19 Association Athletic Grant-in-Aid Cap Antitrust Litigation, Case No. 4:14-md-2541-CW (N.D. 20 Cal.), Dkt. No. 1259 at 4 (Dec. 6, 2019) (approving partner rates at $1,150 and $450 for 21 associates); In re The Home Depot, Inc., Customer Data Sec. Breach Litig., No.: 1:14-md-02583- 22 TWT, 2016 WL 6902351 (N.D. Ga. Aug. 23, 2016) (awarding $8.03 million fee on $28.4 million 23 settlement, equal to 28.2% of the fund); In re Target Corp. Customer Data Sec. Breach Litig., 24 No. 14–2522 (PAM), 2017 WL 2178306 (D. Minn. May 17, 2017) (awarding $6.75 million fee 25 on $23.3 million settlement, equal to 28.9% of the fund); In re Anthem, supra, 2018 WL 3960068 26 (awarding $31.05 million fee on $115 million settlement, equal to 27% of the fund). The 27 frequency of those upward adjustments is particularly noteworthy given that some of those results 28 qualify as “megafund” settlements, where awarding 25% of the fund could “yield windfall profits { 5 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK-NC Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-1 Filed 11/24/20 Page 6 of 9

1 for class counsel.” In re Anthem, 2018 WL 396068 at *15 (quoting In re Bluetooth, 654 F.3d at 2 942). Here, an award of 30% would not yield a “windfall” to Class Counsel. 3 2. A Lodestar-Multiplier “Cross-Check” Further Confirms 4 the Reasonableness of the Requested Fee 5 “To guard against an unreasonable result, the Ninth Circuit encourages district courts to 6 ‘cross-check[] their calculations against a second method.’” In re High-Tech Employee Antitrust 7 Litig., 2015 WL 5158730, *6 (N.D. Cal. Sept. 2, 2015) (citations omitted). One of the primary 8 functions of the lodestar cross-check is to guard against a large fee award where counsel settled 9 early and undertook only a minimal amount of work. Vizcaino, 290 F.3d at 1050. Here, the 10 lodestar cross-check demonstrates the reasonableness of Class Counsel’s fee request. 11 As set forth in the supporting attorney declarations, Class Counsel successfully managed 12 this litigation to ensure efficiency. Class Counsel’s cumulative lodestar as of October 31, 2020 is 13 $8,068,130.80 using historic billing rates. Class Counsel’s rates are “in line with those [rates] 14 prevailing in the community for similar services by lawyers of reasonably comparable skill, 15 experience, and reputation.” Blum, 465 U.S. at 895-96 n.11. Class Counsel’s historical hourly 16 rates, which range from $300 to $1190 for attorneys and from $195 to $350 for paralegals, are 17 reasonable for complex class litigation in this market. See In re Yahoo! Inc. Customer Data Sec. 18 Breach Litig., No. 16-MD-02752-LHK, 2020 WL 4212811, at *26–27 (N.D. Cal. July 22, 2020) 19 (approving billing rates of $450 to $900 for partners; $160 to $850 for non-partner attorneys; and 20 $50 to $380 for paralegals and support staff); In re Anthem, 2018 WL 3960068, at *17 (approving 21 billing rates of $400 to $970 for partners; $185 to $850 for non-partner attorneys; and $95 to $440 22 for paralegals, law clerks, and litigation support staff); In re High-Tech Employee, 2015 WL 23 5158730, at *9 (approving billing rates of $310 to $975 for attorneys and $190 to $430 for 24 paralegals and support staff); In re Animation Workers Antitrust Litig., No. 14-CV-4062-LHK, 25 2016 WL 6663005, at *6 (N.D. Cal. Nov. 11, 2016) (finding rates of senior attorneys of between 26 $845 to $1,200 per hour to be reasonable). The attorney declarations submitted by Class Counsel 27 in connection with this Action demonstrate that the lodestar hours reflect the zealous and efficient 28 manner in which Class Counsel prosecuted this Action.

{ 6 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK-NC Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-1 Filed 11/24/20 Page 7 of 9

1 Class Counsel’s attorneys and staff have devoted more than 9,650 hours to the prosecution 2 of this Action, amounting to cumulative lodestar of approximately $8,068,130.80 using historic 3 billing rates. A fee in the amount of approximately 30% of the $18 million common fund 4 therefore represents an effective negative multiplier of .67 on Class Counsel’s cumulative 5 lodestar. 6 This amount falls well below the range commonly approved in the Ninth Circuit, even 7 where the requested attorneys’ fee is substantially higher than that requested here. See, e.g., In re 8 Yahoo Mail Litig., No. 13-CV-4980-LHK, 2016 WL 4474612, at *11 (N.D. Cal. Aug. 25, 2016) 9 (discussing a survey of “attorney’s fees awards in common fund cases ranging from $50 to 200 10 million between 1996 and 2001” and finding that in “the vast majority of cases (20 of 24, or 11 83%), the multiplier ranged from 1.0–4.0.”). 12 Accordingly, the reasonableness and propriety of this upward adjustment from the Ninth 13 Circuit’s 25% “benchmark” is confirmed by the fact that a lodestar cross-check results in a .67 14 negative multiplier given the efforts invested by Class Counsel into this Action. On the basis of 15 its review of the foregoing, the Court hereby awards $5,400,000 in attorneys’ fees, to be paid in 16 accordance with the provisions of the Settlement Agreement. 17 B. Class Counsel’s Expenses are Reasonable 18 It is well-established in the Ninth Circuit that the reasonable expenses incurred by counsel 19 in obtaining a common fund for the class can and should be reimbursed. See Vincent v. Hughes 20 Air W., Inc., 557 F.2d 759, 769 (9th Cir. 1977); Acosta v. Frito-Lay, Inc., No. 15-CV- 02128-JSC, 21 2018 WL 646691, at *11 (N.D. Cal. Jan. 31, 2018) (“There is no doubt that an attorney who has 22 created a common fund for the benefit of the class is entitled to reimbursement of reasonable 23 litigation expenses from that fund.”) (citation omitted). Such expense awards comport with the 24 notion that the district court may “spread the costs of the litigation among the recipients of the 25 common benefit.” Wininger v. SI Mgmt. L.P., 301 F.3d 1115, 1121 (9th Cir. 2002); see also, e.g., 26 In re Media Vision Tech. Sec. Litig., 913 F. Supp. 1362, 1366 (N.D. Cal. 1995) (citing Mills v. 27 Elec. Auto-Lite Co., 396 U.S. 375, 391-92 (1970) (“Reasonable costs and expenses incurred by an 28 attorney who creates or preserves a common fund are reimbursed proportionately by those class { 7 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK-NC Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-1 Filed 11/24/20 Page 8 of 9

1 members who benefit[.]”)). 2 Here, Class Counsel request the reimbursement of $1,092,459.47 in litigation costs and 3 expenses reasonably incurred. Class Counsel submitted as attachments to their declarations 4 detailed breakdowns of the unreimbursed expenses they necessarily incurred by in the 5 prosecution of this Action for which Class Counsel seek reimbursement. As with the lodestar, all 6 expenses were reported contemporaneously and carefully scrutinized. These expenses are both 7 reasonable and in line with those previously permitted by the Court. In re Anthem, 2018 WL 8 3960068, at *28; In re High-Tech Employee, 2015 WL 5158730 at *16. 9 On the basis of its review of the foregoing, the Court hereby awards $1,092,459.47 in 10 costs, to be paid in accordance with the provisions of the Settlement Agreement. 11 C. The Service Award Request Is Reasonable 12 Each Plaintiff (together, the “Class Representatives”) seeks a service award of $7,500 to 13 be paid from the Settlement Fund. The purpose of service awards is to “compensate named 14 plaintiffs for the services they provided and the risks they incurred during the course of class 15 action litigation, and to reward the public service of contributing to the enforcement of mandatory 16 laws.” Sullivan v. DB Invs., Inc., 667 F.3d 273, 333 n.65 (3d Cir. 2011) (en banc) (affirming 17 antitrust class action settlement with common fund of $295 million, providing for service awards 18 of $85,000 to each of two class representatives) (citation and quotation omitted), cert. denied, 132 19 S. Ct. 1876 (2012). See also, e.g., Staton, 327 F.3d at 977 (“[N]amed plaintiffs . . . are eligible 20 for reasonable incentive payments”). 21 The requested $7,500 service awards are reasonable and appropriate here. Both Class 22 Representatives have expended significant time and effort assisting Class Counsel with the 23 prosecution of the Class’s claims and the achievement of the $18 million benefit obtained through 24 this Action. Among other things, over the more than three-year span of this Action, the Class 25 Representatives have: (i) responded to document requests and produced documents, answered 26 interrogatories and responded to requests for admission; (ii) prepared for and endured full-day 27 depositions; (iii) surrendered their iPhone devices for full forensic imaging—and subsequent 28 searching—for a period of several months; (iv) made themselves available by telephone for { 8 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK-NC Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-1 Filed 11/24/20 Page 9 of 9

1 consultation during each of the four mediation and settlement conferences; and (v) otherwise 2 devoted many hours consulting with Class Counsel regarding fact development and strategy. 3 Manning Decl. ¶¶ 25-35. 4 The requested service awards are appropriate when compared to the recovery achieved on 5 behalf of the Class Members. Courts assessing the reasonableness of requests for service awards 6 may compare the request against the size of the settlement fund. See, e.g., In re Online DVD- 7 Rental Antitrust Litig., 779 F.3d 934, 947 (9th Cir. 2015) (holding that awards cumulatively 8 representing 0.17% of the settlement fund were reasonable); In re Yahoo!, 2020 WL 4212811, at 9 *44 ($87,500 in total service awards reasonable where they “represent less than .1% of the 10 Settlement Fund”). The requested service awards here collectively represent less than one 11 percent—i.e., 0.08333%—of the $18 million common fund. The requested service awards thus 12 comport with the range authorized by the Ninth Circuit and approved in this District. See, e.g., In 13 re Yahoo!, 2020 WL 4212811 at *44 ($7,500 service awards to class representatives who were 14 deposed); In re Anthem, 2018 WL 3960068, at *31 (awarding $7,500 incentive payments to the 15 29 representative plaintiffs who had their computers forensically examined). 16 On the basis of its review of the foregoing, the Court hereby awards Service Payments in 17 the amount of $7,500 per Class Representative, for a total cost of $15,000, to be paid in 18 accordance with the provisions of the Settlement Agreement. 19 IT IS SO ORDERED. 20 Dated: ______21 THE HONORABLE LUCY H. KOH 22 UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE 23 24 25 26 27 28

{ 9 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK-NC Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-2 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 17

1 ALLAN STEYER (Bar No. 100318) JILL M. MANNING (Bar No. 178849) 2 D. SCOTT MACRAE (Bar No. 104663) SUNEEL JAIN (Bar No. 314558) 3 STEYER LOWENTHAL BOODROOKAS ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP 4 235 Pine Street, Fifteenth Floor San Francisco, California 94104 5 Telephone: (415) 421-3400 Facsimile: (415) 421-2234 6 [email protected] [email protected] 7 [email protected] [email protected] 8 Counsel for Plaintiffs and the Class 9

10

11

12 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 13 NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 14 SAN JOSE DIVISION 15 CHRISTINA GRACE and KEN POTTER, Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC 16 Individually and on Behalf of All Others Similarly Situated, CLASS ACTION 17 Plaintiffs, DECLARATION OF JILL M. MANNING IN 18 SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ v. FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES 19 AND SERVICE AWARDS APPLE INC., 20 Date: February 8, 2021 Defendant. Time: 1:30pm 21 Ctrm: 8 – 4th Floor Judge: The Honorable Lucy H. Koh 22

23

24

25 26 27 28

DECLARATION OF JILL M. MANNING IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK-NC

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-2 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 17

1 DECLARATION OF JILL M. MANNING 2 I, Jill M. Manning, declare as follows:

3 1. I am a member in good standing of the California State Bar and admitted to 4 practice before this Court. I am a partner of the law firm of Steyer Lowenthal Boodrookas 5 Alvarez & Smith LLP (“SLBAS”) and court-appointed Co-Lead Counsel for the Class in this 6 certified class action. I submit this declaration in support of Plaintiffs’ Motion for Attorneys’ 7 Fees, Reimbursement of Expenses and Service Awards (the “Motion”). I make this declaration 8 based on personal knowledge and, if called as a witness, I could and would competently testify to 9 the matters stated herein.

10 2. The Motion seeks compensation for Class Counsel for work undertaken on behalf 11 of Plaintiffs and the Certified Class. Class Counsel seek compensation for time and expenses 12 advanced over the past almost four years of diligent prosecution of this case.

13 A. Class Counsel’s Work On The Action 14 3. Class Counsel began investigating this matter in the fall of 2016. We conducted 15 legal research on potential claims against Apple with respect to its conduct in causing the 16 FaceTime feature to stop working on iPhone 4 and 4S devices running on iOS6 or an earlier 17 version on April 16, 2014, and factual research on the technical aspects on how FaceTime worked 18 and was broken, Apple’s representations and conduct related thereto, and the merit of potential 19 legal claims related to Apple’s conduct. As part of the investigation, Class Counsel undertook 20 several economic evaluations and developed the case theory during the months preceding filing of 21 the original complaint in February of 2017.

22 4. We met with and interviewed potential class representatives and filed the initial 23 complaint on February 2, 2017, alleging two claims: Trespass to Chattels and violation of 24 California’s Unfair Competition Law (“UCL”). Dkt No. 1.

25 5. Apple filed a motion to dismiss Plaintiffs’ two claims on March 22, 2017. Dkt. No. 26 33. In response, Class Counsel filed an amended complaint adding Class Representative Ken 27 Potter and additional factual allegations. Dkt. No. 36. Apple filed a second motion to dismiss on 28 April 19, 2017. Dkt. No. 38. Class Counsel opposed Apple’s motion to dismiss, which required { 2 DECLARATION OF JILL M. MANNING IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK-NC

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-2 Filed 11/24/20 Page 3 of 17

1 extensive legal research and briefing on complex issues such as Article III standing and the legal 2 sufficiency of Plaintiffs’ trespass to chattels and Unfair Competition Law causes of action. Dkt. 3 No. 47. The Court denied Apple’s motion to dismiss. Dkt. No. 65.

4 6. Class Counsel spent significant time on discovery in this litigation. Class Counsel 5 served Apple with 65 Requests for Production, 43 Interrogatories, and 42 Requests for 6 Admission. Class Counsel served 8 subpoenas on third party resellers of smart phones (Amazon, 7 Brightstar, Verizon, Sprint, AT&T, T-Mobile, EcoATM, and Best Buy) to obtain sales data in 8 order to prepare a damages model.

9 7. Class Counsel took seven depositions of Apple, including two Rule 30(b)(6) 10 depositions, and four depositions of non-parties. Class Counsel filed two Case Management 11 Conference statements seeking permission to take additional depositions of Apple. Dkt. No. 67, 12 221. Both requests were denied. Dkt. Nos. 68, 222.

13 8. Class Counsel prepared the two class representatives for deposition and defended 14 their depositions, including traveling to San Diego for Mr. Potter’s deposition.

15 9. In response to Class Counsel’s Requests for Production of Documents, Apple 16 produced 224,693 documents totaling 1,025,596 pages. Class Counsel spent considerable time 17 searching, reviewing and analyzing these documents: (1) to prepare for and use at depositions; (2) 18 to analyze issues relating to class certification; (3) to oppose summary judgment; and (4) for use 19 as trial exhibits.

20 10. Class Counsel and their experts reviewed and analyzed Apple’s highly technical 21 data, including databases that contained millions of records and Apple’s confidential source code.

22 11. Class Counsel litigated numerous discovery disputes, including twelve discovery 23 motions, six of which were filed by Plaintiffs. Among other disputes, Class Counsel vigorously 24 opposed Apple’s motion to compel the two Class Representatives to produce their iPhone devices 25 for forensic examination and imaging. Class Counsel argued that the invasive nature of the 26 request outweighed the minimal relevance of the data sought by Apple. After Apple’s motion was 27 granted (Dkt. No. 154), the Class Representatives surrendered their devices for several months 28 into the custody of a neutral third party (“Neutral”) who conducted forensic imaging consistent { 3 DECLARATION OF JILL M. MANNING IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK-NC

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-2 Filed 11/24/20 Page 4 of 17

1 with the Court’s Order. The Neutral extracted and produced extensive data from the Class 2 Representatives’ devices, including all data and information regarding FaceTime and Wi-Fi use, 3 Wi-Fi connection history, and Wi-Fi networks. This production totaled over 370,000 files from 4 within the Settings, Diagnostics, and Usages tabs, or otherwise related to the phone settings in 5 general. Class Counsel devoted significant time to coordinating and negotiating the process by 6 which the devices would be examined, reviewing the data from the devices, objecting to the 7 production of certain data on privacy grounds, redacting information, and negotiating with Apple 8 regarding the production of data.

9 12. Class Counsel retained two experts in this matter. Dr. Justine S. Hastings, Ph.D., a 10 Professor of Economics and International and Public Affairs at Brown University, was retained to 11 determine whether reliable economic methodologies that would be used to calculate damages in 12 this matter are common to members of the Proposed Class and to calculate aggregate class-wide 13 damages measured by the diminution in value of Class Members’ iPhone 4 and 4S devices caused 14 by Apple’s conduct. Working with Class Counsel, Dr. Hastings constructed an econometric 15 damages model using transactional data that Class Counsel secured from third-party resellers of 16 smart phone devices through discovery in this Action. Dr. Hastings used multivariate regression 17 analysis to compare smart phone prices during the time period affected by the FaceTime Break to 18 prices during the time when the market was unaffected. Dkt. No. 174. The model produced an 19 estimate of the impact of the FaceTime Break on prices of used iPhone 4 and 4S models and 20 average per device damages.

21 13. Dr. Mark T. Jones, Ph.D., a professor in the College of Engineering at Virginia 22 Polytechnic University, was retained to analyze and render opinions regarding various highly 23 specialized and technical aspects of Plaintiffs’ claims, including (i) the purpose and functioning 24 of digital certificates generally and, more specifically, the specific certificate architecture 25 surrounding FaceTime, including the iPhone Device Sub-CA; (ii) the options available to Apple 26 in connection with the iPhone Device Sub-CA expiration that caused the FaceTime Break; and 27 (iii) actions that Apple could have but did not take that might have mitigated the impact of the 28 iPhone Device Sub-CA expiration. { 4 DECLARATION OF JILL M. MANNING IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK-NC

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-2 Filed 11/24/20 Page 5 of 17

1 14. There were seven depositions of the parties’ five experts. Plaintiffs’ experts, Dr. 2 Jones and Dr. Hastings, were deposed once and twice, respectively. Apple’s experts, Dana 3 Trexler, C.P.A. and Dr. Neil Malhotra, Ph.D., each were deposed once, and Dr. Avi Rubin, Ph.D., 4 was deposed twice.

5 15. Class certification involved highly contested briefing. Class counsel sought 6 certification of a nationwide class of iPhone 4 and 4S users who lost the ability to use the 7 FaceTime feature as a result of Apple’s conduct. The motion required in-depth legal research and 8 briefing on predominance, choice of law, damages, and other issues related to the Class. In 9 preparation for this motion, over the course of several months prior to filing, Plaintiffs’ counsel 10 diligently worked with their expert on the econometric modeling required for class certification.

11 16. The Court certified a California-only class. Dkt. No. 269. In response, Plaintiffs 12 filed a motion for reconsideration of the Court’s ruling denying certification of a nationwide 13 class. Dkt. No. 276. The Court denied the motion (Dkt. No. 287), and Plaintiffs filed a Rule 23(f) 14 petition asking the Ninth Circuit to review the Court’s order. Dkt. No. 290. The Ninth Circuit 15 denied the Petition. Dkt. No. 295.

16 17. Apple filed a motion for summary judgment seeking a ruling in its favor on 17 Plaintiffs’ two claims which, if granted, would have disposed of the case. Dkt. No. 278. Apple 18 argued that there was no trespass to chattels because Apple did not interfere with the devices; 19 rather it asserted that the FaceTime feature failed because of the way the devices were 20 programmed before they were purchased by Class Members. Apple further argued that the claim 21 was barred by the economic loss rule. Apple also sought to a ruling in its favor on Plaintiffs’ UCL 22 claim, arguing that Plaintiffs failed to submit evidence of overpayment in support of their theory 23 of restitution. In opposition to Apple’s motion, Plaintiffs submitted voluminous evidence in 24 support of both claims, demonstrating both the merits of the claims and the existence of material 25 issues of fact in dispute. Dkt. No. 285. The Court denied Apple’s motion in its entirely. Dkt. No. 26 306.

27 18. Settlement of the case involved extensive negotiations that took place between 28 November 9, 2018 and February 6, 2020. On November 9, 2018, the parties attended an all-day { 5 DECLARATION OF JILL M. MANNING IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK-NC

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-2 Filed 11/24/20 Page 6 of 17

1 mediation session before the Honorable William J. Cahill (Ret.), at JAMS in San Francisco. The 2 mediation failed to produce a settlement. After denying Apple’s motion for summary judgment, 3 the Court ordered the parties to return to mediation. On October 22, 2019, the parties again 4 engaged in mediation before Judge Cahill, and again could not reach agreement on a settlement.

5 19. As the litigation progressed closer to trial, the Court ordered the parties to attend a 6 settlement conference before the Honorable Nathanael M. Cousins. Dkt. No. 325. On December 7 5, 2019, Magistrate Judge Cousins held an all-day settlement conference, but the parties were 8 unable to resolve the case. After extensive follow-up discussions, the parties attended a second in- 9 person settlement conference with Magistrate Judge Cousins on January 16, 2020, which also 10 failed to result in a settlement. Magistrate Judge Cousins continued conferring with the parties 11 and, on January 31, 2020, made a proposal to settle the Action for $18 million. The proposal was 12 accepted by the parties.

13 20. In the months that followed, Class Counsel engaged in extensive and highly 14 contentious negotiations with Apple regarding various non-monetary aspects of the proposed 15 settlement.

16 21. During the time they were engaged in settlement negotiations and then drafting the 17 settlement agreement, Class Counsel simultaneously were preparing for trial, which was 18 scheduled to commence on April 6, 2020. Dkt. No. 374.

19 22. On December 12, 2019, Apple filed a Daubert motion seeking to exclude from the 20 Action the testimony and reports of Plaintiffs’ expert, Dr. Hastings. Dkt. No. 333. On December 21 13, 2019, Plaintiffs and Apple each filed three motions in limine, Dkt. Nos. 334-39, and on 22 December 17, 2019, the parties filed their respective oppositions thereto. Dkt. Nos. 342-47. Class 23 Counsel thereafter engaged in numerous pre-trial activities, including creating trial exhibit and 24 witness lists, drafting, negotiating and filing proposed verdict forms, voir dire and jury 25 instructions. Dkt. Nos. 348-50.

26 23. On January 15, 2019, the Court held a pretrial conference at which, among other 27 things, the parties argued Apple’s Daubert motion. Dkt. No. 370. Class Counsel then continued 28 preparing the Action for trial, including the filing of its witness list and further revised jury { 6 DECLARATION OF JILL M. MANNING IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK-NC

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-2 Filed 11/24/20 Page 7 of 17

1 instructions and verdict forms. Dkt. Nos. 387-91.

2 24. On April 27, 2020, Plaintiffs filed a motion for preliminary approval of the $18 3 million settlement based on Magistrate Judge Cousins’ mediator’s proposal. Dkt. No. 414. On 4 September 10, 2020, the Court granted preliminary approval of the Settlement. Dkt. No. 426.

5 B. Class Representative Service Awards 6 25. The two Class Representatives, Christina Grace and Ken Potter, played a 7 significant role in this case from the onset of the litigation through Preliminary Approval of the 8 Settlement.

9 26. At the beginning of the litigation, Ms. Grace and Mr. Potter participated in lengthy 10 fact-finding interviews with Class Counsel. Ms. Grace reviewed the allegations in the initial 11 Complaint and the First Amended Complaint, and Mr. Potter reviewed the allegations in the First 12 Amended Complaint.

13 27. The Class Representatives responded to multiple discovery requests. Each 14 responded to Requests for Production, Interrogatories and Requests for Admission. Apple’s 15 Requests for Production of Documents sought overly broad and sensitive information related to 16 the Class Representatives’ internet usage and browsing histories, and their personal texts and 17 emails. Responding to the requests required a substantial amount of time in order to sufficiently 18 search the devices for responsive data while preserving the Class Representatives’ privacy. For 19 example, the Requests required the Class Representatives to search their personal and work 20 emails, texts and internet browsing histories for responsive documents, data and communications.

21 28. Both Class representatives were deposed at full-day depositions. This required 22 them to take a full day off from work and drive to and from the deposition. In advance of the 23 depositions, both Class Representatives participated in lengthy preparation sessions with Class 24 Counsel.

25 29. The depositions included questions regarding private matters, including personal 26 phone usage, questions regarding minor children and family members, use of private social media 27 accounts, internet usage, communications with family members, personal email and device 28 account information. { 7 DECLARATION OF JILL M. MANNING IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK-NC

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-2 Filed 11/24/20 Page 8 of 17

1 30. Both Class Representatives were subject to lengthy and intrusive forensic 2 examinations of their iPhone 4 devices. This process involved the Class Representatives turning 3 over their iPhone 4 devices (Grace’s iPhone 4 and Potter’s two iPhone 4’s), to the Neutral for a 4 period of several months, as described above. This forfeiture was particularly disruptive to Mr. 5 Potter who used both of his iPhone 4 devices at that time. The forfeiture also involved an invasive 6 search of the data and information on the devices.

7 31. The Class Representatives participated in numerous telephone conferences and 8 meetings with Class Counsel throughout this litigation.

9 32. The Class Representatives stayed informed of significant developments in the 10 case. I personally consulted with both Ms. Grace and Mr. Potter before each of the mediations 11 and settlement conferences to discuss their positions on settlement and to update them on 12 developments. In addition, both remained available by telephone during each of the mediations 13 and settlement conferences in the event I needed to reach them for guidance or decision-making.

14 33. Both Class Representatives submitted declarations in support of class certification. 15 34. The Class Representatives were prepared to and planned to attend trial in the event 16 the case did not resolve through mediation.

17 35. Without the significant and time-consuming efforts of the Class Representatives 18 and their contributions to the case, Class Counsel would not have been able to negotiate the 19 settlement that will benefit all Class Members.

20 C. Lodestar 21 36. Class Counsel litigated this Class Action vigorously but also in an efficient 22 manner.

23 37. We faced tough adversaries in the three law firms hired by Apple to defend this 24 case: Kirkland & Ellis; Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher; and Durie Tangri, all of which have significant 25 class action litigation defense experience. In addition, the lawyers from Durie Tangri have 26 extensive experience in high tech litigation. As described above, Apple vigorously contested both 27 class certification and liability, devoted substantial resources to opposing Plaintiffs’ discovery 28 efforts, and served extensive and invasive discovery requests on Plaintiffs. Apple’s strong defense { 8 DECLARATION OF JILL M. MANNING IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK-NC

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-2 Filed 11/24/20 Page 9 of 17

1 required Class Counsel to devote extensive time and resources to this matter, to achieve a 2 settlement on behalf of the Class.

3 38. To ensure that all attorneys worked efficiently and did not duplicate efforts, we 4 held weekly conference calls that were typically one hour and included only the attorneys who 5 were actively working on the case. Each call often was preceded by a written agenda and 6 followed by a confirmatory email to ensure that all necessary work was completed in a timely and 7 efficient manner.

8 39. When weekly calls were unnecessary, they were postponed to eliminate 9 unnecessary meetings.

10 40. Throughout this litigation, Class Counsel divided up work assignments to avoid 11 duplication of efforts.

12 41. Consistent with the Court’s Order (Dkt. No. 270), no firms other than the four co- 13 lead firms billed any time to this case.

14 42. I exercised sound billing judgment to ensure that only justifiable, common benefit 15 time is included in the claimed lodestar. I required all firms to submit time and expenses on a 16 monthly basis to ensure that it was contemporaneously recorded and not duplicative or excessive. 17 Dkt. No. 270.

18 43. I reviewed the time billing entries of my three co-counsel’s firms and edited and 19 removed time that appeared excessive or duplicative.

20 44. The lodestar presented here is through October 31, 2020. Class Counsel have and 21 will continue to spend additional time in connection with preparing the Motion for Final 22 Approval and working with the Settlement Administrator in connection with settlement 23 administration.

24 D. SLBAS Attorney Time and Expenses 25 45. My firm regularly litigates complex and class action cases against entities involved 26 in business practices that affect consumers nationwide. My firm has served as lead counsel, co- 27 lead counsel or as a member of an executive committee or steering committee in numerous class 28 actions, including cases brought on behalf of consumers. A brief description of my firm and the { 9 DECLARATION OF JILL M. MANNING IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK-NC

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-2 Filed 11/24/20 Page 10 of 17

1 principal attorneys who worked on this case is attached as Exhibit 1. 2 46. SBLAS has prosecuted this litigation solely on a contingent fee basis and has been 3 at risk that it would not receive any compensation for its work in prosecuting the claims against 4 Apple. While my firm devoted its time and resources to this matter, it has foregone other legal 5 work for which it could have been compensated.

6 47. Throughout this litigation, SLBAS kept files contemporaneously documenting all 7 time spent, including tasks performed and expenses incurred. All of the time and expenses 8 reported by my firm were incurred for the benefit of the Settlement Class. I have reviewed every 9 time entry billed by each attorney and staff member from my firm, and edited and removed time 10 that appeared excessive or duplicative. None of my time reviewing attorney time entries is 11 included in my firm’s lodestar.

12 48. Throughout this litigation, my firm’s time and expenses were submitted on a 13 monthly basis to Pearson, Simon & Warshaw, LLP.

14 49. Attached hereto as Exhibit 2 is a chart setting forth, from inception through 15 October 31, 2020: (i) the attorneys and staff from this firm who worked on this case; (ii) the dates 16 of admission (attorneys) or years of experience (non-attorneys) for each individual who has 17 worked on this case; (iii) the billable rates charged by each individual, by year, for work 18 performed on this case; (iv) the total number of hours that each individual has worked on this 19 case, by year; and (v) the total hours and total lodestar for the firm. Attorneys and staff who 20 worked less than 25 hours on this matter are not included in SLBAS’s lodestar. Moreover, the 21 time submissions do not include any time devoted to preparing this declaration or otherwise 22 pertaining to this motion for attorney’s fees.

23 50. A total of seven attorneys and one paralegal from my firm billed time on this case. 24 Two attorneys – myself and Suneel Jain – billed 55% of the total attorney hours.

25 51. The attorneys and staff who worked on this case and their billable hours are listed 26 here:

27 Attorney Hours

28 Jill M. Manning 1,296.60 { 10 DECLARATION OF JILL M. MANNING IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK-NC

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-2 Filed 11/24/20 Page 11 of 17

1 Suneel Jain 1,127.30 2 Kristopher DiGiovanni 839.20 3 Cameron L. Weiss 659.00 4 D. Scott Macrae 311.60 5 Allan Steyer 146.10 6 Laura Gildengorin 25.20 7 Total Attorney Hours 4,405 8 Paralegal Hours 9 Paris Gravely 196.50 10 TOTAL HOURS 4,601.50 11

12 52. During the course of this litigation, SLBAS attorneys have been involved in the 13 following tasks and activities on behalf of the Settlement Class. 14 15 1. Jill Manning 16 a. Case management 53. I managed the day-to-day litigation of this case, including planning and running 17 weekly litigation meetings with co-counsel regarding case strategy and assignments. I attended 18 the initial Case Management Conference and worked with Apple to draft the litigation schedule. I 19 negotiated the protective order (Dkt. No. 61) with Apple’s counsel. I drafted all of the Joint Case 20 Management Statements and met and conferred with Apple’s counsel to finalize them. 21 22 b. Pleadings 54. I conducted legal research on potential claims and class certification issues, drafted 23 portions of the complaints and reviewed and edited them. I worked with the two Class 24 Representatives to draft their allegations in the complaints. 25 26 c. Client Communications 55. I met with and retained Christina Grace. I communicated regularly with both Class 27 Representatives from the outset of the litigation through the present. I worked with them to 28 { 11 DECLARATION OF JILL M. MANNING IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK-NC

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-2 Filed 11/24/20 Page 12 of 17

1 respond to discovery requests from Apple, met and prepared them for their depositions, gave 2 them updates about key case developments, and communicated with them before, during and after 3 mediations and settlement conferences.

4 d. Discovery 5 56. I drafted the Rule 26(f) Report and Plaintiffs’ discovery plan (Dkt. No. 49), 6 conducted the Rule 26(f) meeting with Apple’s counsel, and prepared Plaintiffs’ Initial 7 Disclosures. I assisted in drafting the discovery to Apple, including Requests for Production of 8 Documents, Interrogatories, Requests for Admission and Rule 30(b)(6) deposition notices. I 9 conducted meet and confer negotiations with Apple regarding their discovery responses and 10 Plaintiffs’ discovery responses. I drafted motion to compel letter briefs and oppositions to same, 11 and argued motions to compel before Judge Cousins. I worked closely with the two Class 12 Representatives in preparing their responses to discovery and production of documents and data, 13 including reviewing their productions, and preparing them for and defending their depositions 14 (including traveling to San Diego for Mr. Potter’s deposition). I was involved in creating and 15 setting up the document review process and tools, including creating the coding categories and 16 drafting a discovery training kit for the document reviewers.

17 e. Experts 18 57. I communicated with and retained the damages expert, Dr. Hastings, and assisted 19 in preparation of her class certification report, reply class certification report, and merits report. 20 With Mr. Warshaw, I prepared Dr. Hastings for her first deposition and assisted in defending the 21 deposition. I prepared for and took the deposition of Apple’s expert political economist, Dr. Neil 22 Malhotra.

23 f. Motions 24 58. I conducted legal research and drafted portions of the opposition to motion to 25 dismiss, the class certification brief and reply briefs, the summary judgment opposition, and 26 edited the briefs. I assisted with drafting the Rule 23(f) petition. I drafted the opposition to 27 Apple’s Daubert motion to exclude the testimony and opinions of Dr. Hastings. 28 { 12 DECLARATION OF JILL M. MANNING IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK-NC

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-2 Filed 11/24/20 Page 13 of 17

1 g. Mediation and Settlement Conferences 2 59. I assisted in drafting and editing the mediation statements. I prepared for and 3 attended all of the mediation sessions with Judge William Cahill (Ret.) and the settlement 4 conferences with Magistrate Judge Nathanael Cousins. I communicated with the class 5 representatives in advance of each conference, coordinated telephone conferences with them 6 during settlement discussions and provided them with updates following the mediations and 7 settlement conferences.

8 h. Trial Preparation 9 60. I was heavily involved in trial preparation, including reviewing documents for the 10 trial exhibit list; reviewing and editing draft jury instructions; drafting the verdict form; 11 negotiating with Apple regarding exchanging trial exhibits and sealing issues; drafting the joint 12 pretrial statement and conferring with Apple’s counsel regarding same; reviewing and editing 13 motions in limine; drafting and editing the proposed findings of fact for Plaintiffs’ UCL claim; 14 and preparing for and attending the pretrial conference and arguing the opposition to Apple’s 15 Daubert motion.

16 i. Settlement 17 61. I assisted in drafting the settlement agreement, participated in lengthy negotiations 18 with Apple’s counsel regarding same, and drafted portions of the motion for preliminary approval 19 of the settlement. I worked with the Settlement Administrator in drafting the settlement notices 20 and crafting the plan for notice of the settlement and distribution of settlement funds. 21 62. Allan Steyer. A founding partner of the firm, Mr. Steyer was involved in 22 investigating this matter, reviewing and editing the draft complaints, working with and retaining 23 the expert economist, and working on the damages model. He reviewed and edited key legal 24 briefings, including the opposition to motion to dismiss and class certification motions. He 25 participated in legal strategy sessions with co-counsel. He was involved in selecting the mediator, 26 and preparing for mediation and settlement conferences, as well as numerous communications 27 with the mediator regarding settlement negotiations. 28 63. Scott Macrae. Senior counsel to the firm, Mr. Macrae conducted legal research on { 13 DECLARATION OF JILL M. MANNING IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK-NC

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-2 Filed 11/24/20 Page 14 of 17

1 potential claims to assert in the complaint, including extensive research to evaluate and plead the 2 causes of action that were most suitable for class-wide litigation, including the claim for Trespass 3 to Chattels. He met with and retained Class Representative Ken Potter. Mr. Macrae researched, 4 drafted and edited the initial complaint and first amended complaint. He drafted portions of the 5 opposition to motion to dismiss, the legal section of the motion for class certification and reply 6 brief, the Rule 23(f) Petition, and portions of the opposition to summary judgment. Mr. Macrae 7 drafted the jury instructions for the Trespass to Chattels claim, assisted with motions in limine 8 and opposition to Apple’s Daubert motion. Mr. Macrae participated in legal strategy sessions 9 with co-counsel.

10 64. Suneel Jain. An associate with the firm, Mr. Jain was the primary associate 11 assigned to this case. He worked closely with the two Class Representatives in preparing written 12 responses to discovery and managing the process of production of their documents and data. He 13 was integrally involved in the forensic imaging process, including coordinating with the clients 14 and the third party neutral, and reviewing the imaged data for purposes of objecting to its 15 production. He drafted motions to compel and oppositions to motions to compel and argued one 16 motion to compel before Judge Cousins. He reviewed documents, performed legal research and 17 drafted legal memoranda, and assisted with trial preparation. He prepared or supervised most of 18 the filings in this case and the administrative motions to file under seal.

19 65. Cameron Weiss. An associate with the firm, Mr. Weiss worked on the discovery 20 phase of the litigation, including document review training, conducting document review, 21 cataloguing and analyzing hot documents, deposition preparation, examination of key individuals 22 and dates, and participating in strategy discussions. In addition, he worked on analyzing specific 23 factual issues raised in the litigation, searching for and reviewing relevant documents, and 24 drafting memoranda analyzing the issues and documents.

25 66. Kristopher DiGiovanni. An associate formerly with the firm, Mr. DiGiovanni 26 worked on the discovery phase of the litigation, including document review training, document 27 review, cataloguing and analyzing hot documents, deposition preparation, examination of key 28 individuals and dates, and participating in strategy discussions. In addition, he worked on { 14 DECLARATION OF JILL M. MANNING IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK-NC

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-2 Filed 11/24/20 Page 15 of 17

1 analyzing specific factual issues raised in the litigation, searching for and reviewing relevant 2 documents, and drafting memoranda analyzing the issues and documents.

3 67. Laura Gildengorin. An associate formerly with the firm, Ms. Gildengorin 4 researched and drafted legal memoranda.

5 68. Paris Gravley. Ms. Gravely worked on discovery, organized exhibits for 6 depositions, prepared working binders for counsel and assisted with filings.

7 69. My firm has submitted attorney fee petitions in other cases that have reported 8 hourly rates comparable to those sought herein, and courts have approved an award of attorneys’ 9 fees in such cases, including: 10 a. Maui Peaks Corporation, et al. v. Mission Street Development, et al. 11 (Millennium Towers), Case No. CGC-17-17-560322 (SF Sup. Ct.). In August 2020, the 12 court issued an attorneys’ fee award which included SLBAS attorneys and staff at rates of 13 $980 (2017 – 2018) and $995 (2019 – 2020) for Mr. Steyer; $895 (2017), $920 (2018) and 14 $960 (2019 – 2020) for Mr. Macrae; $380 (2019) for Mr. Weiss; $360 (2018) for Ms. 15 Gildengorin; and $195 (2017 – 2018) for Ms. Gravely. 16 b. In Re Conagra Foods, Inc., Case 2:11-cv-05379-CJC-AGR (C.D. Cal.). In 17 2019, the court issued an attorneys’ fees award which included SLBAS attorneys at rates 18 of $980 (2017-2018) and $995 (2019) for Mr. Steyer; $895 (2017), $920 (2018) and $960 19 (2019) for Mr. Macrae; and $750 (2016), $800 (2017), $820 (2018), and $880 (2019), for 20 Ms. Manning. 21 c. In Re Foreign Exchange Benchmark Rates Antitrust Litig., Case No. 1:2013-cv- 22 07789 (S.D.N.Y.). For the time period February 14, 2014 – December 31, 2017, the court 23 issued an attorneys’ fees award which included SLBAS attorneys at rates of $980 per hour 24 for Mr. Steyer, $895 per hour for Mr. Macrae, and $360 per hour for Mr. Weiss.

25 70. The lodestar calculation is based on my firm’s historical billing rates in effect at 26 the time services were performed. Exhibit 2 was prepared from contemporaneous time records 27 regularly prepared and maintained by my firm. The hourly rates for SLBAS partners, attorneys 28 and professional support staff included in Exhibit 2 were at the time the work was performed the { 15 DECLARATION OF JILL M. MANNING IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK-NC

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-2 Filed 11/24/20 Page 16 of 17

1 usual and customary hourly rates charged for their services in similar complex litigation.

2 71. The total number of hours reasonably expended on this litigation by my firm from

3 inception through October 31, 2020 is 4,601.50 hours. The total lodestar for SBLAS at historical 4 rates is $2,496,888.00. 5 72. Attached hereto as Exhibits 3 - 10 are true and correct copies of my firm’s daily 6 time records for each of the eight individuals at my firm who has billed time to this case and 7 which time is being submitted as a part of my firm’s lodestar.

8 73. Attached hereto as Exhibit 3 is a true and correct copy of Allan Steyer’s daily time 9 records.

10 74. Attached hereto as Exhibit 4 is a true and correct copy of Scott Macrae’s daily 11 time records.

12 75. Attached hereto as Exhibit 5 is a true and correct copy of Jill Manning’s daily 13 time records.

14 76. Attached hereto as Exhibit 6 is a true and correct copy of Suneel Jain’s daily time 15 records.

16 77. Attached hereto as Exhibit 7 is a true and correct copy of Cameron Weiss’s daily 17 time records.

18 78. Attached hereto as Exhibit 8 is a true and correct copy of Kristopher DiGiovanni’s 19 daily time records.

20 79. Attached hereto as Exhibit 9 is a true and correct copy of Laura Gildengorin’s 21 daily time records.

22 80. Attached hereto as Exhibit 10 is a true and correct copy of Paris Gravley’s daily 23 time records.

24 81. Each firm tracked its own internal expenses. SLBAS has expended a total of

25 $269,553.76 in unreimbursed costs and expenses in connection with the prosecution of this 26 litigation. The expenses incurred in this action are reflected on the books and records of my firm.

27 The expense report is attached hereto as Exhibit 11. 28 82. My firm is seeking reimbursement for reasonable travel expenses incurred in { 16 DECLARATION OF JILL M. MANNING IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK-NC

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-2 Filed 11/24/20 Page 17 of 17

1 connection with this litigation. I and my colleagues traveled to San Jose to attend court hearings 2 and settlement conferences, and I traveled to San Diego to meet with Ken Potter and defend his 3 deposition. I also hosted and attended meetings with co-counsel and experts in the San Francisco 4 bay area. For those trips, my firm is seeking reimbursement of the cost of a coach airfare ticket, 5 and reasonable hotel, meal, and parking expenses.

6 83. Eight-nine percent (89%) of the expenses my firm incurred in this litigation were 7 payments made to the litigation fund for court reporters, document review hosting, expert costs, 8 mediation fees, third party subpoena fees and bank fees.

9 84. These expenses were incurred on behalf of the Class by my firm on a contingent 10 basis and have not been reimbursed. 11 I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States and the State of 12 California that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed on this 24th day of November 2020, at 13 Tomales, California. 14 /s/ Jill M. Manning 15 Jill M. Manning 16

17

18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 { 17 DECLARATION OF JILL M. MANNING IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS CASE NO. 5:17-CV-00551-LHK-NC

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-3 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 7

EXHIBIT 1 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-3 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 7

STEYER LOWENTHAL BOODROOKAS ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP

FIRM SUMMARY

Steyer Lowenthal Boodrookas Alvarez & Smith LLP is a litigation boutique based in San

Francisco with an emphasis on complex and class action litigation. We have a twenty-seven year history of commitment to meeting the needs of our clients by providing a high level of service in an economical manner. We are experienced litigators and trial lawyers who approach each case with a singular goal: to achieve the best result for our client. The firm regularly litigates class action cases against entities involved in business practices that affect consumers nationwide.

We have developed a reputation for being honest, reasonable, collegial, collaborative and creative lawyers who advocate vigorously on behalf of our clients. With its high degree of professionalism and exceptional track record, the firm has earned an excellent reputation among attorneys and the judiciary in the Bay Area. To honor their responsibility to the community, the firm’s members place great importance on involvement in civic and community matters and serve as board members for local nonprofit organizations and public and independent schools.

Set forth below are biographies of the principal attorneys who worked on this matter, and examples of cases in which we represented businesses and consumers in complex and class action cases, including consumer class actions. For more information, please visit our website at www.steyerlaw.com.

1

235 Pine Street, 15th Floor phone 415-421-3400 San Francisco, CA 94104 fax 415-421-2234 www.steyerlaw.com

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-3 Filed 11/24/20 Page 3 of 7

STEYER LOWENTHAL BOODROOKAS ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP

ATTORNEYS

Allan Steyer. Mr. Steyer, a co-founding partner of the firm, is an experienced trial attorney, having tried cases for plaintiffs and defendants in federal and state courts. He has tried cases for the National Football League, Equity Office Properties, USS-POSCO Industries, the

founders/creators of the popular video game Ms. Pac Man, and ACC Lincoln bondholders (the

infamous case against Charles Keating and others). In Lipuma v. American Express (S.D. Fl.), he

served as co-lead counsel for plaintiffs in nationwide consumer class action challenging

deceptive business practices involving foreign currency conversion fees imposed on cardholders

that settled for $75 million. He is one of the attorneys who represented the plaintiffs in the

landmark case, O’Bannon v. NCAA, where the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed the

district court decision, following a three-week bench trial, finding the NCAA liable for

violation of the Sherman Act. In addition, Mr. Steyer has represented prominent entrepreneurs

including Eduardo Saverin, the co-founder of Facebook, and Kirk Perrin, the founder of Jamba

Juice. Mr. Steyer has been recognized as a “Super Lawyer” in Northern California every year

since 2004.

Jill M. Manning. Ms. Manning, a partner with the firm, brings over twenty years of

experience litigating complex and class action cases, with a focus on antitrust, unfair

competition, and consumer fraud cases. Ms. Manning was appointed co-lead counsel for the

certified class by Judge Lucy Koh in Grace v. Apple Inc. (N.D. Cal.), a consumer case

challenging Apple’s conduct of intentionally causing the FaceTime feature to stop working on

2 235 Pine Street, 15th Floor phone 415-421-3400 San Francisco, CA 94104 fax 415-421-2234 www.steyerlaw.com

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-3 Filed 11/24/20 Page 4 of 7

STEYER LOWENTHAL BOODROOKAS ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP

certain iPhone devices, causing the devices to lose value. Ms. Manning was appointed to the

Plaintiffs’ Steering Committee by Judge John Z. Lee in In re NCAA Student/Athlete Concussion

Injury Litig. – Single Sport/Single School (Football) (N.D. Ill.), a class action case against the

NCAA, member conferences and colleges on behalf of student athletes who sustained personal

injuries caused by concussions. Ms. Manning is a Court-appointed evaluator for the Northern

District of California’s Early Neutral Evaluation program. She served as Chair of the Executive

Committee of the Antitrust & Unfair Competition Law Section of the California Lawyers

Association (former California State Bar) for the 2017-2018 term, and presently serves as an

Advisor. Ms. Manning is an elected official, serving on the Board of Trustees of the Shoreline

Unified School District since 2009, and as President of the Board for the past five years.

D. Scott Macrae. Mr. Macrae, senior counsel to the firm, is a 1982 Boalt School of Law graduate with more than thirty-five years of legal experience. For twenty-five years, Mr. Macrae has worked with the firm in litigation and trial of complex cases, including consumer fraud, securities and antitrust class actions. Mr. Macrae focuses on legal issues, specializes in class litigation, and has prepared dozens of class certification motions. He also has drafted and argued summary judgment oppositions, and has prepared motions in limine, jury instructions, and trial briefs in many cases that went to trial or settled shortly before trial.

Suneel Jain. Mr. Jain earned his law degree from Georgetown University Law Center

(2015), where he served on the Georgetown Journal of Law and Public Policy and interned for

3

235 Pine Street, 15th Floor phone 415-421-3400 San Francisco, CA 94104 fax 415-421-2234 www.steyerlaw.com

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-3 Filed 11/24/20 Page 5 of 7

STEYER LOWENTHAL BOODROOKAS ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP

the law and policy organization ChangeLab Solutions in Oakland, CA. He received his B.A. in

Cognitive Science from the University of California, Berkeley (2010). Prior to joining the firm,

Mr. Jain worked with school districts on school food procurement in order to promote local and healthy eating. His practice focuses on antitrust class actions. Mr. Jain specializes in complex civil litigation in the fields of antitrust and consumer law.

Cameron Weiss. Mr. Weiss earned his law degree from the University of San Diego in

2013. Prior to law school, Cameron attended the University of Southern California, where he graduated with a Bachelor of Science in Business Administration in 2008. Mr. Weiss’s areas of practice include antitrust, corporate, and sports/entertainment law. In addition to practicing law,

Mr. Weiss is a licensed National Football League Players Association (NFLPA) Contract

Advisor and a Major League Baseball agent.

REPRESENTATIVE CASES

Maui Peaks Corp. v. Mission Street Development, LLC et al. (San Francisco Sup. Ct.) Co-lead counsel representing a putative class of Millennium Tower condominium owners in an action against the building’s developers and an adjacent government landowner for damages arising from the building’s undisclosed sinking and tilting; settlement pending approval.

Sidibe, et al. v. Sutter Health (N.D. Cal.) One of four firms representing a certified class of businesses and consumers of hospital/medical services in an antitrust tying case; trial scheduled for March 2021.

In re: Aluminum Warehousing Antitrust Litig. (S.D.N.Y) One of four firms representing opt out companies in an antitrust case involving alleged manipulation of aluminum markets; a summary judgment order dismissing the case was reversed by the Second Circuit.

In re: Broiler Chicken Antitrust Litig. (N.D. Ill.) Represent direct purchaser plaintiffs in an antitrust case against the leading suppliers of broiler chickens sold in the United States. 4 235 Pine Street, 15th Floor phone 415-421-3400 San Francisco, CA 94104 fax 415-421-2234 www.steyerlaw.com

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-3 Filed 11/24/20 Page 6 of 7

STEYER LOWENTHAL BOODROOKAS ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP

In re: Farm-Raised Salmon and Salmon Products Antitrust Litig. (S.D. Fl.) Appointed to Plaintiffs’ Executive Committee in a price-fixing case alleging anticompetitive conduct by the world’s dominant suppliers of farm-raised salmon.

In re: Foreign Exchange Benchmark Rates Antitrust Litig. (S.D.N.Y.) Represent a putative class in an antitrust case challenging price fixing in foreign exchange markets; $2.3 billion in partial settlements approved by the court.

In re: NCAA Student/Athlete Concussion Injury Litig. – Single Sport/Single School (Football) (N.D. Ill.) Appointed to Plaintiffs’ Steering Committee in case on behalf of former Division I football players against the NCAA, member conferences and member schools seeking recover damages for personal injuries caused by concussions.

In re: Packaged Seafood Products Antitrust Litig. (S.D. Cal.) Represent direct purchaser plaintiffs in an antitrust price-fixing case against manufacturers of packaged seafood products; District Court certified classes; Rule 23(f) petition pending in Ninth Circuit.

In re: TFT-LCD (Flat Panel) Antitrust Litig. (N.D. Cal.) Represented end-user plaintiffs in antitrust case; achieved a $1.082 billion all-cash settlement.

In re: Visa/Mastercard Currency Conversion Litig. (S.D.N.Y.) One of the core firms representing the plaintiff class in an antitrust/Truth In Lending Act action arising from imposition of foreign currency conversion fees by Visa, MasterCard, and banks; obtained a $780 million judgment after a six month trial in a related California state court case; cases settled for $336 million.

Lipuma v. American Express (S.D. Fl.) Co-lead counsel for plaintiffs in a nationwide consumer class action challenging deceptive business practices involving foreign currency conversion fees imposed on cardholders that settled for $75 million.

O’Bannon v. NCAA (N.D. Cal.) Represented plaintiffs in an antitrust case against the NCAA challenging its rules prohibiting student-athletes from being paid for the use of their names, images and likenesses; Ninth Circuit affirmed the district court’s judgment after a bench trial finding the NCAA liable for violation of the Sherman Act; achieved a $40 million settlement with co-Defendant Electronic Arts.

In re: Lithium Ion Batteries Antitrust Litig. (N.D. Cal.) Represented direct purchaser plaintiffs in a horizontal price-fixing case against manufacturers of lithium ion batteries; case settled for over $139.3 million.

5 235 Pine Street, 15th Floor phone 415-421-3400 San Francisco, CA 94104 fax 415-421-2234 www.steyerlaw.com

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-3 Filed 11/24/20 Page 7 of 7

STEYER LOWENTHAL BOODROOKAS ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP

In re: Dynamic Random Access Memory (DRAM) Antitrust Litig. (N.D. Cal.) Member of executive committee; represented indirect purchaser plaintiffs and achieved a settlement of $310 million.

In re: Processed Egg Products Antitrust Litig. (E.D. Pa.) Represented the certified class of direct purchaser plaintiffs in an antitrust case against suppliers of eggs and egg products; achieved $130 million in settlements.

In re: Static Random Access Memory (SRAM) Antitrust Litig. (N.D. Cal.) Member of the Plaintiffs Executive Committee; represented indirect purchaser plaintiffs and achieved a settlement of over $25 million.

In re: Fresh and Process Potatoes Antitrust Litig. (D. Idaho) Member of Plaintiffs Executive Committee; worked with lead counsel to secure a $18.5 million settlement and injunctive relief valued at over $1 billion on behalf of direct purchaser plaintiffs.

6

235 Pine Street, 15th Floor phone 415-421-3400 San Francisco, CA 94104 fax 415-421-2234 www.steyerlaw.com

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-4 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 2

EXHIBIT 2 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-4 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 2

GRACE v. APPLE, INC. TIME REPORT

FIRM NAME: STEYER LOWENTHAL BOODROOKAS ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP REPORTING PERIOD: INCEPTION THROUGH OCTOBER 2020

Status: (P) Partner (A) Associate * Pls note D. Scott Macrae is Senior Counsel (PL) Paralegal

BAR HOURLY CUMULATIVE CUMULATIVE NAME STATUS ADMITTANCE RATE HOURS LODESTAR ALLAN STEYER (2016) P 1981$ 980.00 29.20$ 28,616.00 ALLAN STEYER (2017) P 1981$ 980.00 33.50$ 32,830.00 ALLAN STEYER (2018) P 1981$ 980.00 43.90$ 43,022.00 ALLAN STEYER (2019) P 1981$ 995.00 29.90$ 29,750.50 ALLAN STEYER (2020) P 1981$ 1,060.00 9.60$ 10,176.00 JILL M. MANNING (2016) P 1995$ 750.00 25.00$ 18,750.00 JILL M. MANNING (2017) P 1995$ 800.00 356.20$ 284,960.00 JILL M. MANNING (2018) P 1995$ 820.00 700.80$ 574,656.00 JILL M. MANNING (2019) P 1995$ 880.00 118.10$ 103,928.00 JILL M. MANNING (2020) P 1995$ 910.00 96.50$ 87,815.00 D. SCOTT MACRAE (2016) A* 1982$ 850.00 53.20$ 45,220.00 D. SCOTT MACRAE (2017) A* 1982$ 895.00 97.40$ 87,173.00 D. SCOTT MACRAE (2018) A* 1982$ 920.00 128.20$ 117,944.00 D. SCOTT MACRAE (2019) A* 1982$ 960.00 24.80$ 23,808.00 D. SCOTT MACRAE (2020) A* 1982$ 990.00 8.00$ 7,920.00 CAMERON L. WEISS (2018) A 2013$ 380.00 659.00$ 250,420.00 KRISTOPHER M. DI GIOVANNI (2017) A 2012$ 340.00 85.60$ 29,104.00 KRISTOPHER M. DI GIOVANNI (2018) A 2012$ 360.00 753.60$ 271,296.00 SUNEEL JAIN (2016) A 2017$ 320.00 3.30$ 1,056.00 SUNEEL JAIN (2017) A 2017$ 340.00 313.90$ 106,726.00 SUNEEL JAIN (2018) A 2017$ 360.00 730.30$ 262,908.00 SUNEEL JAIN (2019) A 2017$ 390.00 43.60$ 17,004.00 SUNEEL JAIN (2020) A 2017$ 440.00 36.20$ 15,928.00 LAURA L. GILDENGORIN (2017) A 2016$ 300.00 25.20$ 7,560.00

ATTORNEY TOTALS 4,405.00$ 2,458,570.50 Experience PARIS GRAVLEY (2017) PL 1 Year$ 195.00 44.50$ 8,677.50 PARIS GRAVLEY (2018) PL 2 Years$ 195.00 152.00$ 29,640.00

NON-ATTORNEY TOTALS 196.50$ 38,317.50

TOTALS 4,601.50$ 2,496,888.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-5 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 38

EXHIBIT 3 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-5 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 38 STEYER LOWENTHAL BOODROOKAS 11/23/2020 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 1

Selection Criteria

Atto.Selection Include: AS Clie.Selection Include: APPLE.FACETIME Slip.Transaction Date Earliest - 10/31/2020 Slip.Billing Status Billable Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 3 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 2

Nickname APPLE.FACETIME | 4457-CONT Full Name CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) Address CONSUMER CLASS ACTION - APPLE RE FACETIME FEATURE Phone 1 Phone 2 Phone 3 Phone 4 In Ref To APPLE, INC. - IN REGARDING FACETIME FEATURE Fees Arrg. By billing value on each slip Expense Arrg. By billing value on each slip Tax Profile Exempt Last bill Last charge 9/15/2020 Last payment Amount $0.00

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 10/14/2016 AS 980.00 0.50 490.00 Billable 437581 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - D. TEJTEL.

10/21/2016 AS 980.00 1.00 980.00 Billable 437764 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - D. TEJTEL; S. MACRAE; BRIEF REVIEW -

MATERIALS.

10/28/2016 AS 980.00 3.50 3,430.00 Billable 438418 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE (MULTIPLE); LEGAL RESEARCH

REGARDING CASE; CONFERENCE CALL WITH D.

TEJTEL/COLLEAGUE/S. MACRAE.

10/31/2016 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 439350 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; UPDATE - J. LOWENTHAL.

11/2/2016 AS 980.00 0.50 490.00 Billable 439404 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; CONFER - J. MANNING; BRIEF REVIEW

OF MATERIALS.

11/3/2016 AS 980.00 2.00 1,960.00 Billable 439410 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH REGARDING CASE; READ S. MACRAE LENGTHY

MEMO; TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; READ DAMAGES INFORMATION

AND E-MAILS REGARDING SAME.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 4 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 3

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 11/4/2016 AS 980.00 0.50 490.00 Billable 439519 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; CONFER J. LOWENTHAL; E-MAILS

FROM CO-COUNSEL.

11/8/2016 AS 980.00 1.00 980.00 Billable 439705 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; PREPARE FOR AND PARTICIPATE IN

CONFERENCE CALL WITH D. TEJTEL/S. MACRAE; READ DRAFT

COMPLAINT.

11/11/2016 AS 980.00 1.00 980.00 Billable 439899 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT COMPLAINT.

11/13/2016 AS 980.00 2.10 2,058.00 Billable 439911 RESEARCH-A READ S. JAIN LENGTHY LEGAL MEMO REGARDING POTENTIAL

CAUSES/ACTION; TELEPHONE - D. TEJTEL./S. MACRAE.

11/14/2016 AS 980.00 0.50 490.00 Billable 439915 PLDS/MO-A TELEPHONE - J. MANNING; S. JAIN; REVIEW DRAFT COMPLAINT.

11/15/2016 AS 980.00 0.40 392.00 Billable 439982 EXPERTS-A TELEPHONE - POTENTIAL CONSULTANT/EXPERT; READ

DAMAGES INFORMATION.

11/16/2016 AS 980.00 0.50 490.00 Billable 440125 EXPERTS-A TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; D. TEJTEL; READ CONSULTANT'S

RESUME.

11/17/2016 AS 980.00 0.70 686.00 Billable 440132 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH DAMAGES; TELEPHONE - B. SIMON; CONFER - J.

MANNING.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 5 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 4

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 11/21/2016 AS 980.00 0.50 490.00 Billable 440404 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - D. TEJTEL/S. MACRAE; REVIEW E-MAILS.

11/28/2016 AS 980.00 1.40 1,372.00 Billable 440422 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; B. SIMON; D. TEJTEL; READ REVISED

DRAFT COMPLAINT; TELEPHONE - CONSULTANT.

11/29/2016 AS 980.00 1.10 1,078.00 Billable 440493 RESEARCH-A TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; CONSULTANT; ANALYZE DAMAGES.

11/30/2016 AS 980.00 1.50 1,470.00 Billable 440614 RESEARCH-A REVIEW/REVISE DRAFT COMPLAINT; READ S. MACRAE MEMO

REGARDING SAME; TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; CONFER - J.

MANNING; TELEPHONE - CONSULTANT; TELEPHONE

CONFERENCE WITH A. STEYER.

12/1/2016 AS 980.00 3.40 3,332.00 Billable 441395 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE FOR AND PARTICIPATE IN CONFERENCE CALLS WITH

CO-COUNSEL AND CONSULTANT; TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE.

12/5/2016 AS 980.00 1.00 980.00 Billable 441712 EXPERTS-A TELEPHONE - D. TETJEL; S. MACRAE; READ CONSULTANT'S

ANALYSIS.

12/6/2016 AS 980.00 2.00 1,960.00 Billable 441716 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; READ ARTICLES REGARDING IPHONE

MARKET; TELEPHONE - B. SIMON; D. TEJTEL.

12/9/2016 AS 980.00 1.00 980.00 Billable 442117 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE FOR AND PARTICIPATE IN CONFERENCE CALL WITH

CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW CONSULTANT'S MEMO. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 6 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 5

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

12/15/2016 AS 980.00 0.50 490.00 Billable 442143 PLDS/MO-A TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; D. TEJTEL; READ HIS E-MAIL MEMO

REGARDING DRAFT COMPLAINT; REVIEW COMPLAINT.

12/16/2016 AS 980.00 2.00 1,960.00 Billable 442241 PLDS/MO-A TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; REVIEW/EDIT REVISED DRAFT

COMPLAINT.

12/19/2016 AS 980.00 0.10 98.00 Billable 442397 PLDS/MO-A TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; REVIEW CURRENT DRAFT COMPLAINT.

12/21/2016 AS 980.00 0.10 98.00 Billable 442404 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - B. SIMON; S. MACRAE.

12/22/2016 AS 980.00 0.10 98.00 Billable 442424 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - D. TEJTEL; CONFER - J. MANNING.

12/27/2016 AS 980.00 0.10 98.00 Billable 442526 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - D. WARSHAW; REVIEW JOINT PROSECUTION

AGREEMENT.

1/9/2017 AS 980.00 0.10 98.00 Billable 444101 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; B. SIMON.

1/10/2017 AS 980.00 0.10 98.00 Billable 444114 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - J. MANNING; S. MACRAE.

1/11/2017 AS 980.00 0.10 98.00 Billable 444289 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFER - J. MANNING; READ E-MAILS.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 7 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 6

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 1/18/2017 AS 980.00 0.10 98.00 Billable 444466 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - D. TEJTEL; CONFER - J. MANNING.

1/20/2017 AS 980.00 1.50 1,470.00 Billable 444749 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE FOR AND ATTEND MEETING WITH D. TEJTEL (IN NEW

YORK CITY).

1/24/2017 AS 980.00 0.10 98.00 Billable 444796 PLDS/MO-A WORK REGARDING FINALIZING COMPLAINT; TELEPHONE - S.

MACRAE.

1/25/2017 AS 980.00 0.10 98.00 Billable 444853 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; B. SIMON; E-MAIL TO/FROM

CO-COUNSEL - D. TEJTEL.

1/27/2017 AS 980.00 0.50 490.00 Billable 445001 PLDS/MO-A READ CO-COUNSEL E-MAILS; REVIEW COMPLAINT.

2/2/2017 AS 980.00 1.00 980.00 Billable 446096 PLDS/MO-A E-MAILS TO/FROM CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW FILED COMPLAINT.

2/3/2017 AS 980.00 1.50 1,470.00 Billable 446716 PLDS/MO-A TELEPHONE - D. TEJTEL; S. MACRAE; B. SIMON; J. MANNING;

READ MEMO REGARDING JUDGES; READ FILED COMPLAINT.

2/6/2017 AS 980.00 0.40 392.00 Billable 446731 RESEARCH-A E-MAILS TO/FROM CO-COUNSEL; RESEARCH REGARDING

JUDGES.

2/7/2017 AS 980.00 1.00 980.00 Billable 446857 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; PREPARE FOR AND PARTICIPATE IN Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 8 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 7

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL; CONFER - L.

GILDENGORIN REGARDING RESEARCH.

2/9/2017 AS 980.00 0.50 490.00 Billable 446870 EXPERTS-A TELEPHONE - CONSULTANT.

2/10/2017 AS 980.00 0.10 98.00 Billable 447247 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - KEN POTTER; S. MACRAE.

2/13/2017 AS 980.00 0.40 392.00 Billable 447254 RESEARCH-A TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; RESEARCH REGARDING JUDGES;

READ L. GILDENGORIN MEMO; EDIT/FINALIZE MEMO; CONFER - J.

MANNING.

2/15/2017 AS 980.00 0.50 490.00 Billable 447322 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE FOR AND PARTICIPATE IN CO-COUNSEL CONFERENCE

CALL.

2/21/2017 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 448116 PLDS/MO-A TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; READ FILED STIPULATION REGARDING

TIME TO RESPOND - COMPLAINT.

2/22/2017 AS 980.00 0.10 98.00 Billable 448125 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW ORDER APPOINTING JUDGE FREEMAN; TELEPHONE -

CO-COUNSEL.

2/27/2017 AS 980.00 5.00 4,900.00 Billable 448673 CLIENT MEETING-A READ FILED COMPLAINT; TRAVEL TO SAN DIEGO; ATTEND

MEETING WITH S. MACRAE AND POTENTIAL CLIENT.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 9 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 8

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 2/28/2017 AS 980.00 0.40 392.00 Billable 448680 CLIENT MEETING-A RETURN TRAVEL - SF.

3/1/2017 AS 980.00 0.40 392.00 Billable 449075 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; CONFER - J. MANNING; READ

CO-COUNSEL E-MAILS; CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

3/2/2017 AS 980.00 0.10 98.00 Billable 449082 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAILS TO/FROM S. MACRAE.

3/6/2017 AS 980.00 0.10 98.00 Billable 449352 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - A. CURRY; REVIEW CALENDAR.

3/23/2017 AS 980.00 0.50 490.00 Billable 450081 RESEARCH-A TELEPHONE - J. MANNING; S. MACRAE/S. JAIN; READ E. DEELEY

DECLARATION AND IOS SOFTWARE AGREEMENT.

3/24/2017 AS 980.00 1.10 1,078.00 Billable 451234 PLDS/MO-A READ J. MANNING LEGAL MEMORANDUM; READ 12B6 MOTION,

REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE.

3/30/2017 AS 980.00 0.10 98.00 Billable 451235 ATTYMTG.STR - A READ CO-COUNSEL E-MAILS.

4/3/2017 AS 980.00 1.20 1,176.00 Billable 452114 RESEARCH-A TELEPHONE - CONSULTANT; J. MANNING; S. MACRAE; E-MAILS -

CO-COUNSEL AND J. MANNING; REVIEW/EDIT DRAFT AMENDED

COMPLAINT; READ CO-COUNSEL LEGAL MEMO REGARDING

RESTITUTION.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 10 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 9

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 4/3/2017 AS 980.00 1.20 1,176.00 Billable 452183 PLDS/MO-A TELEPHONE - CONSULTANT; J. MANNING; S. MACRAE; E-MAILS -

CO-COUNSEL AND J. MANNING; REVIEW/EDIT DRAFT AMENDED

COMPLAINT; READ CO-COUNSEL LEGAL MEMO REGARDING

RESTITUTION.

4/17/2017 AS 980.00 0.10 98.00 Billable 452573 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - D. WARSHAW; READ E-MAILS REGARDING 5/25

PROPOSED 12b6 HEARING.

4/19/2017 AS 980.00 0.10 98.00 Billable 452648 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - D. TEIJTL; S. MACRAE; E-MAILS TO/FROM

CO-COUNSEL.

4/25/2017 AS 980.00 0.50 490.00 Billable 452801 ATTYMTG.STR - A PARTICIPATE IN CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING DISCOVERY/PLEADINGS ISSUES; CONFER - J.

MANNING.

4/27/2017 AS 980.00 0.10 98.00 Billable 453844 PLDS/MO-A READ E-MAILS; BRIEF REVIEW OF DRAFT BRIEF.

4/29/2017 AS 980.00 1.00 980.00 Billable 453851 PLDS/MO-A READ/EDIT DRAFT 12b6 OPPOSITION BRIEF.

5/1/2017 AS 980.00 0.10 98.00 Billable 454256 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - J. MANNING; S. MACRAE; READ CO-COUNSEL

E-MAILS.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 11 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 10

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 5/4/2017 AS 980.00 1.40 1,372.00 Billable 454293 PLDS/MO-A READ 12b6 OPPOSITION BRIEF.

5/9/2017 AS 980.00 0.50 490.00 Billable 454571 DISCOVERY-A READ FIRST SET OF DOCUMENT REQUESTS TO DEFENDANT; (.2);

READ DRAFT JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE

STATEMENT; (.2); READ CO-COUNSEL E-MAILS (.1).

5/11/2017 AS 980.00 0.90 882.00 Billable 454736 PLDS/MO-A READ A. CURRY MEMO REGARDING 12b6 REPLY BRIEF; READ

APPLE REPLY BRIEF REGARDING 12b6 MOTION.

5/15/2017 AS 980.00 0.90 882.00 Billable 454817 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFER - J. MANNING; PREPARE FOR CO-COUNSEL 5/16

CONFERENCE CALL; READ JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT

CONFERENCE STATEMENT.

5/16/2017 AS 980.00 1.00 980.00 Billable 454820 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - B. SIMON; PREPARE FOR AND PARTICIPATE IN

CO-COUNSEL CONFERENCE CALL.

5/17/2017 AS 980.00 0.30 294.00 Billable 454968 DISCOVERY-A REVISE PROPOSED DISCOVERY SCHEDULE; CONFER BRIEFLY -

J. MANNING; READ DEFENSE COUNSEL LETTER REGARDING

26(A) DISCLOSURES.

5/18/2017 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 455366 ATTYMTG.STR - A READ E-MAILS AMONG CO-COUNSEL.

5/19/2017 AS 980.00 0.30 294.00 Billable 455373 CASEMNG-A READ CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER; CALENDAR DATES; E-MAILS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 12 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 11

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

WITH CO-COUNSEL.

5/22/2017 AS 980.00 0.70 686.00 Billable 455389 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE FOR AND PARTICIPATE IN CO-COUNSEL CONFERENCE

CALL; ORGANIZE WORKING BINDER.

6/14/2017 AS 980.00 0.10 98.00 Billable 457333 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFER - J. MANNING REGARDING PROTECTIVE ORDER.

7/26/2017 AS 980.00 0.10 98.00 Billable 460188 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; READ COURT'S ORDER REGARDING

7/27 HEARING; E-MAILS - CO-COUNSEL.

8/1/2017 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 460967 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - J. MANNING; CONFER S. JAIN.

8/2/2017 AS 980.00 2.00 1,960.00 Billable 461463 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE FOR AND PARTICIPATE IN CONFERENCE CALL WITH

CO-COUNSEL; CONFER - J. MANNING; REVIEW POTENTIAL

EXPERT RESUME; E-MAILS - CO-COUNSEL.

8/3/2017 AS 980.00 0.40 392.00 Billable 461472 CASEMNG-A READ CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER; CALENDAR DATES; CONFER

- S. JAIN.

8/8/2017 AS 980.00 1.10 1,078.00 Billable 461652 EXPERTS-A TELEPHONE - CONSULTANT; RESEARCH REGARDING POTENTIAL

EXPERTS; PARTICIPATE IN CONFERENCE CALL WITH

CO-COUNSEL.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 13 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 12

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 8/18/2017 AS 980.00 0.30 294.00 Billable 462389 CASEMNG-A READ JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT;

CALENDAR DATES; READ COURT'S ORDER CONTINUING

CONFERENCE.

8/31/2017 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 463294 EXPERTS-A READ CO-COUNSEL E-MAILS REGARDING POTENTIAL EXPERT;

E-MAILS TO/FROM J. MANNING REGARDING SAME.

9/13/2017 AS 980.00 0.30 294.00 Billable 464261 EXPERTS-A TELEPHONE - CONSULTANT.

9/18/2017 AS 980.00 0.40 392.00 Billable 464565 EXPERTS-A TELEPHONE - J. MANNING; POTENTIAL/CONSULTANT; READ

CO-COUNSEL E-MAILS.

9/27/2017 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 465038 EXPERTS-A TELEPHONE - CONSULTANT.

10/2/2017 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 466685 ATTYMTG.STR - A READ CO-COUNSEL E-MAILS.

10/16/2017 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 466692 EXPERTS-A REVIEW DRAFT EXPERT RETENTION AGREEMENT.

10/30/2017 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 467130 ATTYMTG.STR - A READ AGENDA FOR 11/1 CO-COUNSEL MEETING.

11/1/2017 AS 980.00 0.30 294.00 Billable 468190 ATTYMTG.STR - A STATUS UPDATE - CO-COUNSEL.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 14 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 13

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 11/27/2017 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 469488 EXPERTS-A TELEPHONE - POTENTIAL CONSULTANT.

12/6/2017 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 470591 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFER - J. MANNING REGARDING DISCOVERY, CLASS

CERTIFICATION DEADLINE/REQUEST FOR EXTENSION.

12/23/2017 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 472381 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - J. MANNING REGARDING CASE STATUS.

12/29/2017 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 472788 ATTYMTG.STR - A READ AND RESPOND TO E-MAILS REGARDING DOCUMENT

REVIEW/ATTORNEY ASSIGNMENTS.

1/2/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 472842 ATTYMTG.STR - A READ E-MAIL BETWEEN COUNSEL REGARDING MEET/CONFER;

CONFER - J. MANNING REGARDING CASE STATUS.

1/6/2018 AS 980.00 0.90 882.00 Billable 472921 PLDS/MO-A READ/EDIT DRAFT CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF.

1/9/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 472958 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE REGARDING CLASS CERTIFICATION.

1/28/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 474146 DISCOVERY-A READ A. CURRY E-MAIL.

2/6/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 475435 DISCOVERY-A CONFER - S. JAIN/J. MANNING REGARDING DISCOVERY/CLASS

CERTIFICATION.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 15 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 14

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 2/8/2018 AS 980.00 0.50 490.00 Billable 475479 PLDS/MO-A READ JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT.

2/20/2018 AS 980.00 1.10 1,078.00 Billable 476353 DISCOVERY-A EDIT CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF.

2/21/2018 AS 980.00 0.50 490.00 Billable 476374 EXPERTS-A TELEPHONE - J. MANNING; REVIEW EXPERT'S BILLS.

2/22/2018 AS 980.00 0.70 686.00 Billable 476422 EXPERTS-A REVIEW EXPERT BILLS; TELEPHONE - EXPERT; UPDATE J.

MANNING.

2/23/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 476600 DISCOVERY-A READ E-MAILS REGARDING CASE STATUS.

2/26/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 476609 DISCOVERY-A CONFER - S. JAIN REGARDING DISCOVERY/CLASS CERTIFICATION.

3/29/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 479133 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; CONFER - J. MANNING.

3/30/2018 AS 980.00 2.20 2,156.00 Billable 479696 PLDS/MO-A EDIT DRAFT CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF; E-MAIL - J. MANNING.

4/5/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 480490 DISCOVERY-A STATUS UPDATE - CLASS CERTIFICATION/DISCOVERY - S. JAIN.

4/10/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 480547 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; READ E-MAILS REGARDING CLASS

CERTIFICATION.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 16 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 15

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 4/13/2018 AS 980.00 1.70 1,666.00 Billable 480892 PLDS/MO-A EDIT CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF; TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE.

4/15/2018 AS 980.00 1.50 1,470.00 Billable 480975 EXPERTS-A READ DRAFT EXPERT REPORTS; PREPARE E-MAIL - J.

MANNING/S. MACRAE.

4/17/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 481232 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE.

4/20/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 481236 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFER - S. JAIN REGARDING CLASS CERTIFICATION MOTION

AND SUPPORTING EVIDENCE.

4/24/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 481259 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFER - J. MANNING/S. MACRAE REGARDING CLASS

CERTIFICATION MOTION.

4/27/2018 AS 980.00 1.00 980.00 Billable 481761 PLDS/MO-A READ AND EDIT DRAFT CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF.

4/28/2018 AS 980.00 0.60 588.00 Billable 481762 PLDS/MO-A EDIT CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF.

4/30/2018 AS 980.00 1.60 1,568.00 Billable 481767 EXPERTS-A TELEPHONE - J. MANNING; READ/EDIT DRAFT EXPERT REPORT.

5/31/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 484781 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - D. WARSHAW; READ COURT ORDERS.

7/10/2018 AS 980.00 0.30 294.00 Billable 488277 PLDS/MO-A TELEPHONE - C. WEISS; KRIS D.; CONFER S. JAIN/J. MANNING Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 17 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 16

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

REGARDING CLASS CERTIFICATION REPLY BRIEF.

7/10/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 488398 PLDS/MO-A CONFER - J. MANNING/S. JAIN REGARDING CLASS

CERTIFICATION/EXPERT WORK.

7/12/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 488401 PLDS/MO-A TELEPHONE - D. WARSHAW; READ E-MAILS REGARDING CLASS

CERTIFICATION HEARING.

7/23/2018 AS 980.00 0.30 294.00 Billable 489031 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - D. WARSHAW; C. WEISS; READ DEFENSE

COUNSEL LETTER REGARDING DAMAGES.

7/24/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 489333 DISCOVERY-A CONFER - S. JAIN REGARDING DISCOVERY; READ RECENT

FILINGS.

7/26/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 489344 CASEMNG-A TELEPHONE - CO-COUNSEL; READ COURT'S ORDER CANCELLING

CLASS CERTIFICATION HEARING (WILL RULE ON BRIEFS).

8/1/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 490870 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - D. TEITJEL; C. WEISS.

8/3/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 490884 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFER S. JAIN REGARDING DISCOVERY/SUMMARY JUDGMENT

MOTION/TRIAL PREPARATION.

8/7/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 490905 DISCOVERY-A READ STIPULATION/COURT ORDER REGARDING EXPERT Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 18 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 17

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

DEADLINES; CONFER - S. JAIN REGARDING DISCOVERY.

8/8/2018 AS 980.00 0.70 686.00 Billable 490917 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE - D. WARSHAW (MEDIATION/DAMAGES/EXPERTS);

POTENTIAL MEDIATORS; CONFER J. MANNING REGARDING

MEDIATION/TRIAL PREPARATION.

8/15/2018 AS 980.00 0.10 98.00 Billable 491264 PLDS/MO-A READ COURT FILING.

8/17/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 491290 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE - CO-COUNSEL D. WARSHAW (.1); READ COURT

FILING REGARDING DISCOVERY (.1).

8/27/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 491798 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE - C. WEISS; CONFER - S. JAIN REGARDING

DISCOVERY WORK/DEADLINES.

9/5/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 493329 DISCOVERY-A CONFER J. MANNING REGARDING MEDIATION/CLASS

CERTIFICATION; S. JAIN REGARDING DISCOVERY STATUS.

9/11/2018 AS 980.00 0.30 294.00 Billable 493563 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE - C. WEISS; CONFER - S. JAIN REGARDING

DISCOVERY/CLASS CERTIFICATION.

9/12/2018 AS 980.00 0.90 882.00 Billable 493603 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE - CO-COUNSEL REGARDING MEDIATORS;

TELEPHONE - JAMS.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 19 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 18

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 9/13/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 493621 SETTLE-A PREPARE - MEDIATION; E-MAILS FROM/TO CO-COUNSEL.

9/17/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 494119 SETTLE-A PREPARE FOR MEDIATION; TELEPHONE - MEDIATOR'S

ADMINISTRATOR.

9/18/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 494135 PLDS/MO-A READ LENGTHY COURT ORDER REGARDING MOTIONS TO FILE

CLASS CERTIFICATION PAPERS UNDER SEAL.

9/20/2018 AS 980.00 0.50 490.00 Billable 494267 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE - D. WARSHAW/MEDIATOR; D. WARSHAW.

9/24/2018 AS 980.00 1.40 1,372.00 Billable 494466 CASEMNG-A READ JUDGE KOH'S CLASS CERTIFICATION OPINION.

9/25/2018 AS 980.00 0.80 784.00 Billable 494763 SETTLE-A PREPARE FOR MEDIATION; CONFER - J. MANNING REGARDING

CASE/SETTLEMENT STRATEGY.

9/26/2018 AS 980.00 1.00 980.00 Billable 494852 SETTLE-A PREPARE FOR MEDIATION; OUTLINE KEY POINTS FROM COURT'S

CLASS CERTIFICATION DECISION; TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; C.

WEISS.

9/27/2018 AS 980.00 0.30 294.00 Billable 494864 SETTLE-A E-MAILS TO/FROM CO-COUNSEL REGARDING MEDIATION; READ

E-MAILS REGARDING SAME.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 20 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 19

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 9/28/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 495366 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAILS TO/FROM CO-COUNSEL AND READ E-MAILS REGARDING

MEDIATION.

10/1/2018 AS 980.00 0.40 392.00 Billable 495500 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - JAMS; C. WEISS; CONFER - S. JAIN REGARDING

MEDIATION/TRIAL PREPARATION.

10/2/2018 AS 980.00 0.50 490.00 Billable 495713 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - B. SIMON; CONFER - J. MANNING REGARDING

MEDIATION/SETTLEMENT/OUT OF STATE LAWSUITS.

10/3/2018 AS 980.00 0.50 490.00 Billable 495917 SETTLE-A CONFER - S. JAIN REGARDING SUMMARY JUDGMENT

MOTION/SETTLEMENT; TELEPHONE - MEDIATOR; S. MACRAE.

10/4/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 495922 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFER - J. MANNING REGARDING MEDIATION.

10/5/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 496077 ATTYMTG.STR - A DISCUSS SETTLEMENT STRATEGY WITH CO-COUNSEL.

10/11/2018 AS 980.00 0.30 294.00 Billable 496363 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFER J. MANNING REGARDING MEDIATION/TRIAL

PREPARATION.

11/1/2018 AS 980.00 0.30 294.00 Billable 498381 SETTLE-A PREPARE FOR MEDIATION; CONFER - J. MANNING REGARDING

SAME.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 21 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 20

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 11/2/2018 AS 980.00 1.50 1,470.00 Billable 498675 SETTLE-A PREPARE FOR 11/9 MEDIATION; READ DRAFT MEDIATION BRIEF;

TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; JAMS.

11/3/2018 AS 980.00 0.30 294.00 Billable 498682 SETTLE-A PREPARE - MEDIATION; BRIEF REVIEW - APPLE'S MEDIATION

BRIEF; TELEPHONE - MEDIATOR.

11/5/2018 AS 980.00 1.20 1,176.00 Billable 498690 SETTLE-A PREPARE FOR MEDIATION; READ APPLE MEDIATION BRIEF;

TELEPHONE - J. MANNING; EXPERT; C. PEARSON.

11/6/2018 AS 980.00 3.50 3,430.00 Billable 498692 SETTLE-A PREPARE FOR MEDIATION; TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; READ S.

MACRAE SUMMARY JUDGMENT BULLET POINTS MEMO; READ

MEDIATION BRIEFS; PARTICIPATE IN CONFERENCE CALL WITH

CO-COUNSEL.

11/7/2018 AS 980.00 0.30 294.00 Billable 498774 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; S. JAIN; PREPARE - MEDIATION;

CONFER - J. MANNING.

11/8/2018 AS 980.00 1.80 1,764.00 Billable 498819 SETTLE-A PREPARE FOR 11/9 MEDIATION; TELEPHONE - J. MANNING; S.

MACRAE; COMMUNICATE WITH MEDIATOR; RED RECENT ND CAL

CLASS SETTLEMENT DECISION.

11/9/2018 AS 980.00 5.70 5,586.00 Billable 498950 SETTLE-A PREPARE FOR AND ATTEND MEDIATION WITH JUDGE CAHILL;

READ COURT'S ORDER STAYING CASE. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 22 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 21

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

11/13/2018 AS 980.00 0.40 392.00 Billable 498991 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE - C. PEARSON; S. MACRAE; MEDIATOR; CALENDAR

NEW CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE DATES.

11/14/2018 AS 980.00 0.30 294.00 Billable 499055 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE - D. WARSHAW; JAMS.

11/15/2018 AS 980.00 0.30 294.00 Billable 499066 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE - MEDIATOR; J. MANNING; S. MACRAE.

11/19/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 499238 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - D. WARSHAW.

11/20/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 499368 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - B. SIMON - CASE STATUS; J. MANNING.

11/21/2018 AS 980.00 0.50 490.00 Billable 499397 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - D. TEJTEL; REVIEW NOTICE COSTS PROPOSAL.

11/28/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 499964 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - D. WARSHAW.

11/29/2018 AS 980.00 0.30 294.00 Billable 500077 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFER J. MANNING REGARDING CASE STATUS/23f/SUMMARY

JUDGMENT/TRIAL.

12/3/2018 AS 980.00 0.20 196.00 Billable 500686 EXPERTS-A TELEPHONE - POTENTIAL CLAIMS ADMINISTRATOR.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 23 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 22

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 12/21/2018 AS 980.00 0.30 294.00 Billable 501850 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE - MEDIATOR; UPDATE J. MANNING.

1/1/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 503208 CASEMNG-A REVIEW LODESTAR UPDATE.

1/16/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 503882 ATTYMTG.STR - A STATUS UPDATE - 23F, SUMMARY JUDGMENT/CLASS WITH J.

MANNING/S. JAIN.

2/4/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 505537 CASEMNG-A E-MAILS FROM/TO CLAIMS ADMINISTRATOR CANDIDATE.

2/11/2019 AS 995.00 0.10 99.50 Billable 506110 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE - MEDIATOR.

2/20/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 506785 PLDS/MO-A READ JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT

FILED WITH COURT.

2/26/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 507007 CASEMNG-A READ CO-COUNSEL E-MAILS REGARDING RECENT DECISION

ABOUT 23F APPEALS.

3/4/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 508205 CASEMNG-A REORGANIZE WORKING BINDER.

3/20/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 508918 CASEMNG-A READ NINTH CIRCUIT ORDER DENYING 23F APPEAL AND

CO-COUNSEL E-MAILS.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 24 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 23

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 3/21/2019 AS 995.00 0.10 99.50 Billable 509007 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE - MEDIATOR.

3/22/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 509011 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE -S. MACRAE; READ FILING WITH COURT.

4/1/2019 AS 995.00 0.10 99.50 Billable 509785 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFER - S. JAIN REGARDING CASE STATUS - SUMMARY

JUDGMENT MOTION.

4/3/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 509796 ATTYMTG.STR - A STATUS UPDATE - 23F/SJ MOTION/CMC) WITH J. MANNING.

4/8/2019 AS 995.00 0.50 497.50 Billable 510453 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - D. TETJEL; REVIEW WORKING BINDER.

4/22/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 511495 CT APPR - A PREPARE FOR 5/1 CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE; CONFER

WITH S. JAIN.

4/23/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 511490 CT APPR - A PREPARE FOR 5/1 CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE; CONFER

WITH J. MANNING/S. JAIN.

4/25/2019 AS 995.00 0.30 298.50 Billable 511957 PLDS/MO-A PREPARE CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE; READ JOINT CASE

MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT.

4/26/2019 AS 995.00 0.50 497.50 Billable 511961 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - D. WARSHAW; READ CALENDAR COURT'S ORDER

REGARDING PROPOSED CASE SCHEDULES; CONFER - S. JAIN Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 25 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 24

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt REGARDING STRATEGY; READ COURT'S SCHEDULE BETWEEN

NOW AND AUGUST.

4/29/2019 AS 995.00 0.60 597.00 Billable 512215 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - D. TEJTEL; CONFER - S. JAIN REGARDING

PROPOSED NEW TRIAL DATE.

5/6/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 513234 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE - MEDIATOR.

5/14/2019 AS 995.00 0.40 398.00 Billable 513627 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; READ D. TEJTEL E-MAIL MEMO;

CONFER - S. JAIN.

7/8/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 519306 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH J. MANNING; READ CO-COUNSEL E-MAIL.

8/1/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 521861 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH S. JAIN REGARDING (8/8) SUMMARY

JUDGMENT HEARING.

8/5/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 522172 PLDS/MO-A TELEPHONE WITH S. JAIN (REGARDING SUMMARY JUDGMENT

MOTION).

8/20/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 522782 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH MEDIATOR; REVIEW SUMMARY

JUDGMENT MOTIONS.

8/22/2019 AS 995.00 1.70 1,691.50 Billable 522917 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH C. PEARSON; MEDIATOR; CONFER WITH Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 26 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 25

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt J. MANNING REGARDING CASE STATUS; READ COURT'S

DECISION/ORDER.

8/23/2019 AS 995.00 1.50 1,492.50 Billable 523074 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH C. PEARSON; J. MANNING; PARTICIPATE

IN CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL; TELEPHONE CALL S.

MACRAE.

8/26/2019 AS 995.00 0.70 696.50 Billable 523232 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH J. MANNING; READ D. TEJTEL LEGAL

MEMO.

8/28/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 523502 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH J. MANNING; S. MACRAE.

8/29/2019 AS 995.00 0.90 895.50 Billable 523667 ATTYMTG.STR - A READ JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT;

PARTICIPATE IN CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL;

TELEPHONE CALL WITH S. MACRAE.

9/5/2019 AS 995.00 1.00 995.00 Billable 525132 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL AND J. MANNING/S.

MACRAE REGARDING CASE STATUS/MEDIATION; TELEPHONE

CALL WITH S. MACRAE; E-MAILS TO CO-COUNSEL/S. MACRAE.

9/16/2019 AS 995.00 0.50 497.50 Billable 525265 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH J. MANNING; S. MACRAE; MEDIATORS.

9/18/2019 AS 995.00 0.50 497.50 Billable 525708 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE - C. PEARSON; REVIEW "HOT DOCUMENTS" FOR

MEDIATION. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 27 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 26

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

9/19/2019 AS 995.00 0.50 497.50 Billable 525719 SETTLE-A PREPARE - MEDIATION; CONFER - S. JAIN REGARDING "HOT"

DOCUMENTS.

9/20/2019 AS 995.00 0.30 298.50 Billable 525724 SETTLE-A PREPARE FOR MEDIATION.

9/20/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 525731 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE - C. PEARSON.

9/23/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 525745 SETTLE-A PREPARE - MEDIATION; REVIEW HOT DOCUMENTS.

9/24/2019 AS 995.00 0.80 796.00 Billable 525748 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE (9/23); C. PEARSON; CONFER - J.

MANNING; TELEPHONE - MEDIATOR; PREPARE FOR MEETING

WITH MEDIATOR.

9/25/2019 AS 995.00 1.90 1,890.50 Billable 525756 SETTLE-A PREPARE FOR AND ATTEND MEETING (WITH J. MANNING) WITH

MEDIATOR.

9/26/2019 AS 995.00 0.40 398.00 Billable 525869 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - J. MANNING; C. PEARSON (9/25); READ E-MAILS.

10/1/2019 AS 995.00 0.90 895.50 Billable 527058 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH D. TEJTEL; CONFER WITH J. MANNING

REGARDING MEDIATION; REVIEW DRAFT LETTER TO MEDIATOR.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 28 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 27

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 10/7/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 527057 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH MEDIATOR.

10/8/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 527232 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH MEDIATOR; C. PEARSON.

10/10/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 527298 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING MEDIATION.

10/11/2019 AS 995.00 0.10 99.50 Billable 527405 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH C. PEARSON.

10/14/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 527410 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH C. PEARSON; REVIEW MEDIATION

BINDER.

10/15/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 527418 SETTLE-A PREPARE FOR MEDIATION; READ CO-COUNSEL E-MAILS

REGARDING MEDIATION.

10/16/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 527472 SETTLE-A PREPARE MEDIATION - CONFER WITH J. MANNING.

10/18/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 528077 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH C. PEARSON.

10/20/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 528571 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH MEDIATOR.

10/21/2019 AS 995.00 0.40 398.00 Billable 528575 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH J. MANNING; C. PEARSON.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 29 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 28

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 10/22/2019 AS 995.00 0.50 497.50 Billable 528593 SETTLE-A PARTICIPATE - MEDIATION VIA PHONE; TELEPHONE CALL WITH B.

SIMON; CO-COUNSEL.

10/23/2019 AS 995.00 0.80 796.00 Billable 528597 SETTLE-A PARTICIPATE IN CO-COUNSEL CONFERENCE CALL REGARDING

SETTLEMENT; TELEPHONE CALL WITH B. SIMON; C. PEARSON.

10/25/2019 AS 995.00 0.10 99.50 Billable 528619 SETTLE-A READ CO-COUNSEL E-MAILS REGARDING SETTLEMENT STATUS.

10/28/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 528245 SETTLE-A UPDATE REGARDING SETTLEMENT STATUS.

10/29/2019 AS 995.00 0.90 895.50 Billable 528551 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH C. PEARSON (10/28); PARTICIPATE IN

CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL; TELEPHONE CALL WITH

CO-COUNSEL.

10/30/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 528400 SETTLE-A UPDATE - J. MANNING.

10/31/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 528532 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL; MEDIATOR.

11/1/2019 AS 995.00 0.30 298.50 Billable 529093 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH MEDIATOR; C. PEARSON; READ E-MAILS.

11/3/2019 AS 995.00 0.30 298.50 Billable 529356 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH MEDIATOR; C. PEARSON.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 30 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 29

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 11/4/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 529358 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH C. PEARSON; S. MACRAE.

11/5/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 529379 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH C. PEARSON; READ E-MAILS.

11/6/2019 AS 995.00 0.60 597.00 Billable 529425 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH C. PEARSON; MEDIATOR/C. PEARSON;

READ CO-COUNSEL E-MAILS; TELEPHONE CALL WITH S. MACRAE.

11/7/2019 AS 995.00 0.40 398.00 Billable 529669 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH C. PEARSON; S. MACRAE; READ

CO-COUNSEL E-MAILS.

11/7/2019 AS 995.00 0.30 298.50 Billable 529676 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH S. MACRAE; C. PEARSON.

11/8/2019 AS 995.00 0.60 597.00 Billable 529665 SETTLE-A PARTICIPATE IN CO-COUNSEL CONFERENCE CALL ; READ

E-MAILS.

11/10/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 529677 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH S. MACRAE.

11/12/2019 AS 995.00 0.30 298.50 Billable 529710 SETTLE-A STATUS UPDATE - J. MANNING; READ CO-COUNSEL E-MAILS;

TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

11/13/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 529825 SETTLE-A STATUS UPDATE; READ JAMS AGREEMENT.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 31 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 30

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 11/15/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 530088 SETTLE-A STATUS UPDATE WITH J. MANNING.

11/20/2019 AS 995.00 0.10 99.50 Billable 530306 SETTLE-A STATUS UPDATE - MEDIATION.

11/20/2019 AS 995.00 0.10 99.50 Billable 530312 SETTLE-A STATUS UPDATE.

11/21/2019 AS 995.00 0.10 99.50 Billable 530363 SETTLE-A READ PARTIALLY FILED MEDIATION UPDATE STATEMENT.

11/22/2019 AS 995.00 0.30 298.50 Billable 531423 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE - C. PEARSON (11/21); CONFER WITH J. MANNING

REGARDING MEDIATION.

11/26/2019 AS 995.00 0.50 497.50 Billable 531448 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE - B. SIMON; C. PEARSON; D. TEITJEL.

12/2/2019 AS 995.00 0.30 298.50 Billable 531471 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH C. PEARSON; J. MANNING; S. MACRAE.

12/5/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 531809 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH C. PEARSON.

12/6/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 531766 SETTLE-A STATUS UPDATE - MEDIATION; READ J. MANNING AND

CO-COUNSEL E-MAILS.

12/9/2019 AS 995.00 0.70 696.50 Billable 531836 ATTYMTG.STR - A STATUS UPDATE; TELEPHONE CALL WITH J. MANNING;

PARTICIPATE IN CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL; Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 32 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 31

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

TELEPHONE CALL WITH S. MACRAE; READ D. TEIJTL E-MAIL.

12/12/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 532110 SETTLE-A READ CO-COUNSEL E-MAIL REGARDING

MEDIATION/SETTLEMENT; FILE STIPULATION (12/12).

12/16/2019 AS 995.00 0.20 199.00 Billable 532188 CASEMNG-A STATUS UPDATE - PRETRIAL FILINGS.

12/17/2019 AS 995.00 0.10 99.50 Billable 532285 PLDS/MO-A READ DEFENSE/ TP FILING REGARDING SEALING.

12/18/2019 AS 995.00 0.10 99.50 Billable 532647 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH C. PEARSON REGARDING STATUS.

1/2/2020 AS 1060.00 0.10 106.00 Billable 533938 TRIAL PREP-A READ PRE-TRIAL MOTION FILINGS.

1/10/2020 AS 1060.00 0.30 318.00 Billable 534296 PLDS/MO-A READ JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT.

1/17/2020 AS 1060.00 0.20 212.00 Billable 534666 TRIAL PREP-A READ CO-COUNSEL E-MAILS REGARDING SETTLEMENT/TRIAL

ISSUES.

1/21/2020 AS 1060.00 0.20 212.00 Billable 534686 TRIAL PREP-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH C. PEARSON (MEDIATION/TRIAL); READ

E-MAILS.

1/22/2020 AS 1060.00 0.20 212.00 Billable 534696 PLDS/MO-A READ JOINT STATEMENT TO COURT AND CO-COUNSEL E-MAILS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 33 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 32

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt REGARDING SAME.

1/29/2020 AS 1060.00 0.30 318.00 Billable 535657 SETTLE-A READ CO-COUNSEL E-MAILS REGARDING TRIAL/SETTLEMENT

PROCESS.

2/1/2020 AS 1060.00 0.20 212.00 Billable 535669 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH C. PEARSON; READ CO-COUNSEL

E-MAILS REGARDING TRIAL/MEDIATION.

2/2/2020 AS 1060.00 0.20 212.00 Billable 535623 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH J. MANNING REGARDING

SETTLEMENT/TRIAL.

2/3/2020 AS 1060.00 0.40 424.00 Billable 535736 SETTLE-A PARTICIPATE IN CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL AND

MEDIATORS; READ CO-COUNSEL E-MAILS REGARDING SAME.

2/6/2020 AS 1060.00 0.20 212.00 Billable 536630 SETTLE-A READ E-MAILS REGARDING SETTLEMENT; CONFER WITH J.

MANNING.

2/7/2020 AS 1060.00 0.50 530.00 Billable 536764 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH S. MACRAE; J. MOTTEK; E-MAILS

FROM/TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SETTLEMENT PROCESS.

2/11/2020 AS 1060.00 0.40 424.00 Billable 537102 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH D. WARSHAW; ANALYZE SETTLEMENT

PROCESS.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 34 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 33

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 2/12/2020 AS 1060.00 0.30 318.00 Billable 537050 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH S. MACRAE; J. MOTTEK.

2/13/2020 AS 1060.00 0.40 424.00 Billable 537124 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH S. MACRAE REGARDING DISTRIBUTION

TO CLASS MEMBERS OF SETTLEMENT FUNDS; TELEPHONE CALL

WITH J. MANNING REGARDING SAME.

2/18/2020 AS 1060.00 0.20 212.00 Billable 537156 SETTLE-A CONFER WITH J. MANNING REGARDING SETTLEMENT PROCESS

AND DISTRIBUTION OF SETTLEMENT FUNDS.

2/19/2020 AS 1060.00 0.20 212.00 Billable 537169 SETTLE-A STATUS UPDATE REGARDING SETTLEMENT COURT ORDER.

2/21/2020 AS 1060.00 0.20 212.00 Billable 537504 SETTLE-A READ CO-COUNSEL E-MAILS REGARDING SETTLEMENT

AGREEMENT.

2/24/2020 AS 1060.00 0.30 318.00 Billable 537607 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH J. MANNING REGARDING SETTLEMENT

AGREEMENT STATUS; BRIEF REVIEW OF AGREEMENT.

3/1/2020 AS 1060.00 0.20 212.00 Billable 539557 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE J. MANNING; READ CO-COUNSEL E-MAILS.

(FEBRUARY 28, 2020).

3/14/2020 AS 1060.00 0.20 212.00 Billable 539560 SETTLE-A STATUS UPDATE REGARDING SETTLEMENT AND/OR TRIAL.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 35 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 34

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 3/17/2020 AS 1060.00 0.20 212.00 Billable 540005 SETTLE-A E-MAILS TO/FROM CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

SETTLEMENT/PROCESS.

3/20/2020 AS 1060.00 0.20 212.00 Billable 540494 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH COUNSEL REGARDING OTHER CASE

REGARDING CLAIMS PROCESS; TELEPHONE - S. MACRAE; READ

J. MANNING STATUS E-MAIL AND FILING WITH COURT.

3/28/2020 AS 1060.00 0.20 212.00 Billable 541204 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE J. MOTTEK REGARDING SETTLEMENT DISTRIBUTION.

4/1/2020 AS 1060.00 0.20 212.00 Billable 542144 SETTLE-A E-MAILS FROM/TO J. MANNING REGARDING SETTLEMENT.

4/9/2020 AS 1060.00 0.20 212.00 Billable 542139 SETTLE-A E-MAILS TO/FROM J. MANNING REGARDING SETTLEMENT

STATUS; READ COURT ORDER.

4/15/2020 AS 1060.00 0.20 212.00 Billable 542338 SETTLE-A STATUS UPDATE - SETTLEMENT PAPERS; E-MAILS FROM/TO

CO-COUNSEL.

4/22/2020 AS 1060.00 0.20 212.00 Billable 542957 SETTLE-A E-MAILS FROM/TO J. MANNING REGARDING MOTION FOR

PRELIMINARY APPROVAL.

4/24/2020 AS 1060.00 0.20 212.00 Billable 543097 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH J. MANNING; READ COURT'S

ORDER REGARDING PRELIMINARY APPROVAL HEARING.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 36 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 35

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 4/28/2020 AS 1060.00 0.10 106.00 Billable 543538 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH C. PEARSON REGARDING CASE

STATUS.

6/3/2020 AS 1060.00 0.20 212.00 Billable 546906 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH S. JAIN; REVIEW FILINGS;

TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH D. WARSHAW.

6/4/2020 AS 1060.00 0.20 212.00 Billable 546717 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH D. WARSHAW.

6/7/2020 AS 1060.00 0.10 106.00 Billable 546741 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH S. MACRAE.

6/8/2020 AS 1060.00 0.20 212.00 Billable 547261 SETTLE-A ANALYZE STATUS - PRELIMINARY APPROVAL MOTION; E-MAIL J.

MANNING.

6/10/2020 AS 1060.00 0.10 106.00 Billable 547272 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH J. MOTTEK.

8/31/2020 AS 1060.00 0.20 212.00 Billable 553491 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH J. MANNING; C. PEARSON

REGARDING PRELIMINARY APPROVAL HEARING.

9/6/2020 AS 1060.00 0.30 318.00 Billable 554139 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH J. MANNING REGARDING

STRATEGY - PRELIMINARY APPROVAL MOTION.

9/7/2020 AS 1060.00 0.50 530.00 Billable 554141 CASEMNG-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH J. MANNING REGARDING CASE Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 37 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 36

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt ADMINISTRATION.

9/9/2020 AS 1060.00 0.50 530.00 Billable 554149 SETTLE-A READ FILED SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEF REGARDING PRELIMINARY

APPROVAL; E-MAIL J. MANNING.

9/15/2020 AS 1060.00 0.40 424.00 Billable 554312 SETTLE-A READ ORDER GRANTING PRELIMINARY APPROVAL OF

SETTLEMENT; CALENDAR DATES.

TOTAL Billable Fees 146.10 $144,394.50

Total of billable expense slips $0.00

Calculation of Fees and Costs

Amount Total Fees Bill Arrangement: Slips By billing value on each slip.

Total of billable time slips $144,394.50 Total of Fees (Time Charges) $144,394.50

Total of Costs (Expense Charges) $0.00

Total new charges $144,394.50

New Balance Current $144,394.50

Total New Balance $144,394.50

Funds Account: Default Previous account balance $0.00 Total added to account $0.00 Total removed from account $0.00

New account balance $0.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-5 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 38 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:07 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 37

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Amount Total Amount to replenish account to $0.00 $0.00

Attorney Summary

Attorney Rate Hours Charges Slip Value Adjustment AS 1060.00 9.60 $10,176.00 $10,176.00 0.00 AS 995.00 29.90 $29,750.50 $29,750.50 0.00 AS 980.00 106.60 $104,468.00 $104,468.00 0.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-6 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 49

EXHIBIT 4 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-6 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 49 STEYER LOWENTHAL BOODROOKAS 11/23/2020 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 1

Selection Criteria

Atto.Selection Include: DSM Clie.Selection Include: APPLE.FACETIME Slip.Transaction Date Earliest - 10/31/2020 Slip.Billing Status Billable Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 3 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 2

Nickname APPLE.FACETIME | 4457-CONT Full Name CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) Address CONSUMER CLASS ACTION - APPLE RE FACETIME FEATURE Phone 1 Phone 2 Phone 3 Phone 4 In Ref To APPLE, INC. - IN REGARDING FACETIME FEATURE Fees Arrg. By billing value on each slip Expense Arrg. By billing value on each slip Tax Profile Exempt Last bill Last charge 4/27/2020 Last payment Amount $0.00

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 10/21/2016 DSM 850.00 1.50 1,275.00 Billable 439624 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW MATERIALS FROM D. TEJTEL; TELECONFERENCE WITH

A. STEYER.

10/27/2016 DSM 850.00 0.50 425.00 Billable 439655 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFER WITH A. STEYER; E-MAIL REGARDING CONFERENCE

CALL.

10/28/2016 DSM 850.00 3.50 2,975.00 Billable 439657 RESEARCH-A CONFERENCE CALL WITH D. TEJTEL; LEGAL RESEARCH

REGARDING CAUSES OF ACTION.

10/31/2016 DSM 850.00 2.50 2,125.00 Billable 439666 RESEARCH-A LEGAL RESEARCH; TELECONFERENCE WITH A. STEYER; DRAFT

MEMORANDUM REGARDING LEGAL ISSUES; REVIEW E-MAIL

FROM D. TEJTEL.

11/1/2016 DSM 850.00 3.10 2,635.00 Billable 441875 RESEARCH-A E-MAIL AND TELECONFERENCE WITH D. TEJTEL; TELEPHONE

CALL WITH A. STEYER; REVIEW CONSULTANT REPORT SURVEY;

LEGAL RESEARCH; COMPLETE RESEARCH MEMO.

11/2/2016 DSM 850.00 2.10 1,785.00 Billable 441878 RESEARCH-A TELECONFERENCE WITH D. TEJTEL; E-MAIL AND Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 4 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 3

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

TELECONFERENCE WITH A. STEYER; REVISE RESEARCH MEMO;

REVIEW DAMAGES REPORT.

11/3/2016 DSM 850.00 2.50 2,125.00 Billable 441883 RESEARCH-A E-MAIL WITH D. TEJTEL AND A. STEYER; RESEARCH REGARDING

ARBITRATION OF CLAIMS AGAINST APPLE.

11/4/2016 DSM 850.00 3.50 2,975.00 Billable 441888 RESEARCH-A TELECONFERENCES AND E-MAIL WITH A. STEYER AND J.

LOWENTHAL; REVIEW APPLE USER AGREEMENTS; E-MAIL WITH

D. TEJTEL AND A. STEYER; LEGAL RESEARCH REGARDING

ARBITRATION.

11/7/2016 DSM 850.00 3.50 2,975.00 Billable 441893 RESEARCH-A REVIEW YASTRAB DECISIONS; LEGAL RESEARCH; REVIEW

DRAFT COMPLAINT; E-MAIL WITH A. STEYER AND J. LOWENTHAL;

ANALYZE LIMITATION OF LIABILITY PROVISION; CONFERENCE

CALL WITH D. TEJTEL.

11/8/2016 DSM 850.00 2.40 2,040.00 Billable 441901 RESEARCH-A E-MAIL WITH S. JAIN; REVIEW YASTREB MOTIONS TO DISMISS

BRIEFING; REVISE RESEARCH MEMO; CONFERENCE CALL WITH

D. TEJTEL AND CO-COUNSEL.

11/9/2016 DSM 850.00 3.00 2,550.00 Billable 441909 RESEARCH-A E-MAIL WITH S. JAIN AND D. TEJTEL; REVIEW JURY INSTRUCTION

FOR TRESPASS TO CHATTELS; REVIEW LEGAL RESEARCH MEMO

AND SEND TO CO-COUNSEL.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 5 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 4

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 11/11/2016 DSM 850.00 0.10 85.00 Billable 441920 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH A. STEYER AND D. TEJTEL.

11/12/2016 DSM 850.00 0.10 85.00 Billable 441923 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH D. TEJTEL, S. JAIN AND A. STEYER.

11/14/2016 DSM 850.00 0.10 85.00 Billable 441925 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH S. JAIN, A. STEYER AND D. TEJTEL.

11/16/2016 DSM 850.00 0.30 255.00 Billable 441937 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH A. STEYER AND CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

POTENTIAL CLIENTS; E-MAIL WITH D. TEJTEL.

11/18/2016 DSM 850.00 1.50 1,275.00 Billable 441949 RESEARCH-A REVIEW REVISED DRAFT COMPLAINT; TELECONFERENCE AND

E-MAIL WITH A. STEYER; E-MAIL WITH D. TEJTEL; REVISE

RESEARCH MEMORANDUM.

11/21/2016 DSM 850.00 0.50 425.00 Billable 441953 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL REGARDING POTENTIAL CLIENTS.

11/21/2016 DSM 850.00 1.50 1,275.00 Billable 441961 RESEARCH-A REVIEW MATERIALS FROM D. TEJTEL; TELECONFERENCE WITH

A. STEYER.

11/28/2016 DSM 850.00 2.40 2,040.00 Billable 441971 RESEARCH-A REVIEW B. SIMON COMMENTS REGARDING DRAFT COMPLAINT;

TELECONFERENCE WITH A. STEYER; LEGAL RESEARCH; E-MAIL

WITH A. STEYER AND D. TEJTEL.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 6 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 5

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 11/29/2016 DSM 850.00 0.50 425.00 Billable 441976 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFER WITH A. STEYER; E-MAIL REGARDING CONFERENCE

CALL.

11/29/2016 DSM 850.00 1.50 1,275.00 Billable 441979 RESEARCH-A E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL; LEGAL RESEARCH ON CAUSES OF

ACTION.

11/30/2016 DSM 850.00 2.10 1,785.00 Billable 441988 RESEARCH-A LEGAL RESEARCH; TELECONFERENCE WITH A. STEYER; DRAFT

RESPONSE TO B. SIMON COMMENTS; E-MAIL WITH D. WARSHAW

AND D. TEJTEL.

12/1/2016 DSM 850.00 2.50 2,125.00 Billable 444179 RESEARCH-A REVIEW TRADE IN VALUE DATA FROM CONSULTANT; REVIEW

CONSULTANT REPORT; E-MAIL AND TELECONFERENCE WITH A.

STEYER; TELECONFERENCES WITH POTENTIAL CLIENTS.

12/2/2016 DSM 850.00 2.50 2,125.00 Billable 444185 RESEARCH-A TELECONFERENCES WITH POTENTIAL CLIENTS; LEGAL

RESEARCH REGARDING CLASS DEFINITION.

12/7/2016 DSM 850.00 3.20 2,720.00 Billable 444204 RESEARCH-A E-MAIL WITH A. STEYER; LEGAL RESEARCH REGARDING

DAMAGES MEMO; DRAFT RESEARCH MEMO.

12/8/2016 DSM 850.00 1.20 1,020.00 Billable 444207 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL AND CONSULTANT;

E-MAIL WITH A. STEYER, D. WARSHAW AND D. TEJTEL.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 7 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 6

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 12/9/2016 DSM 850.00 0.40 340.00 Billable 444216 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

12/14/2016 DSM 850.00 1.50 1,275.00 Billable 444233 PLDS/MO-A E-MAIL WITH D. TEJTEL; REVIEW AND EDIT REVISED DRAFT

COMPLAINT.

12/15/2016 DSM 850.00 0.10 85.00 Billable 444239 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH D. TEJTEL.

12/16/2016 DSM 850.00 2.50 2,125.00 Billable 444248 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND REVISE DRAFT COMPLAINT; E-MAIL WITH A.

STEYER; REVIEW STEYER REVISIONS; E-MAIL WITH

CO-COUNSEL; LEGAL RESEARCH.

12/19/2016 DSM 850.00 0.50 425.00 Billable 444250 PLDS/MO-A E-MAIL REVISED COMPLAINT TO CO-COUNSEL; E-MAIL WITH J.

MANNING; TELECONFERENCE WITH A. STEYER.

12/22/2016 DSM 850.00 0.10 85.00 Billable 444268 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING POTENTIAL CLIENTS.

1/2/2017 DSM 895.00 0.10 89.50 Billable 446537 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH D. TEJTEL AND D. WARSHAW AND A. STEYER.

1/3/2017 DSM 895.00 2.00 1,790.00 Billable 446542 RESEARCH-A E-MAIL WITH D. TEJTEL, B. SIMON AND D. WARSHAW; REVIEW

EDITS TO DRAFT COMPLAINT; LEGAL RESEARCH REGARDING

POTENTIAL UNJUST ENRICHMENT CLAIM.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 8 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 7

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 1/4/2017 DSM 895.00 1.50 1,342.50 Billable 446546 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM A. CURRY; REVIEW REVISIONS TO

COMPLAINT; CONFERENCE CALL AND E-MAIL WITH

CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW REVISED COMPLAINT; TELECONFERENCE

WITH J. MANNING.

1/5/2017 DSM 895.00 0.70 626.50 Billable 446553 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELECONFERENCE AND E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING; RESEARCH

AND E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING INCLUDING OLDER IOS

VERSIONS.

1/12/2017 DSM 895.00 3.20 2,864.00 Billable 446591 RESEARCH-A E-MAIL WITH A. STEYER; LEGAL RESEARCH REGARDING

DIMINUTION IN DAMAGES; DRAFT RESEARCH MEMO.

1/14/2017 DSM 895.00 0.10 89.50 Billable 446597 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING AND A. STEYER REGARDING POTENTIAL

CLIENT.

1/20/2017 DSM 895.00 0.10 89.50 Billable 446618 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM D. TEJTEL AND A. STEYER;

TELECONFERENCE WITH A. STEYER.

1/20/2017 DSM 895.00 2.50 2,237.50 Billable 446625 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND REVISE DRAFT COMPLAINT; E-MAIL WITH A.

STEYER; REVIEW STEYER REVISIONS; E-MAIL WITH

CO-COUNSEL; LEGAL RESEARCH.

1/24/2017 DSM 895.00 2.20 1,969.00 Billable 446633 PLDS/MO-A REVISE COMPLAINT AND ADD CLIENT INFORMATION; E-MAIL Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 9 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 8

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt WITH J. MANNING; TELECONFERENCE WITH POTENTIAL CLIENT.

1/24/2017 DSM 895.00 1.20 1,074.00 Billable 446637 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT COMPLAINT.

1/25/2017 DSM 895.00 1.10 984.50 Billable 446639 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH POTENTIAL CLIENT; TELECONFERENCE WITH A.

STEYER; E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL; E-MAIL WITH D. TEJTEL;

REVIEW REVISIONS TO COMPLAINT.

1/26/2017 DSM 895.00 0.30 268.50 Billable 446646 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING COMPLAINT;

TELECONFERENCE WITH A. STEYER.

1/30/2017 DSM 895.00 0.10 89.50 Billable 446660 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL; TELECONFERENCE WITH POTENTIAL

CLIENT.

1/31/2017 DSM 895.00 1.00 895.00 Billable 446670 PLDS/MO-A PROOFREAD AND EDIT COMPLAINT; E-MAIL WITH S. JAIN, J.

MANNING, A. STEYER AND CO-COUNSEL.

2/1/2017 DSM 895.00 2.40 2,148.00 Billable 449224 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND FINALIZE DRAFT COMPLAINT; E-MAIL AND

TELECONFERENCES WITH J. MANNING AND S. JAIN; E-MAIL WITH

CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW CIVIL COVER SHEET.

2/2/2017 DSM 895.00 0.40 358.00 Billable 449226 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW FILING AND E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW

NOTICES OF APPEARANCE.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 10 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 9

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 2/3/2017 DSM 895.00 0.50 447.50 Billable 449232 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW ORDER SETTING INITIAL CASE MANAGEMENT; E-MAIL

WITH CO-COUNSEL; TELECONFERENCE WITH A. STEYER.

2/7/2017 DSM 895.00 2.50 2,237.50 Billable 449246 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW SUMMONS ISSUED; CONFERENCE CALL WITH

CO-COUNSEL; LEGAL RESEARCH REGARDING JUDGE DAVILA

CASES; E-MAIL WITH L. GILDENGOREN; RESEARCH REGARDING

MAGISTRATE COUSINS.

2/9/2017 DSM 895.00 3.00 2,685.00 Billable 449256 RESEARCH-A REVIEW MEMO REGARDING JUDGE FOGEL DECISIONS; FINALIZE

MEMO REGARDING JUDGE DAVILA DECISIONS; REVIEW

SUMMONS.

2/13/2017 DSM 895.00 0.50 447.50 Billable 449262 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELECONFERENCE WITH K. POTTER; E-MAIL WITH A. STEYER;

REVIEW MEMO REGARDING JUDGE FOGEL CASES.

2/14/2017 DSM 895.00 1.50 1,342.50 Billable 449270 RESEARCH-A REVISE AND FINALIZE MEMO REGARDING DAVILA'S CASES;

E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW MEMORANDA REGARDING

JUDGE FREEMAN AND JUDGE KOH.

2/15/2017 DSM 895.00 1.50 1,342.50 Billable 449274 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL; E-MAIL WITH D. TEJTEL;

E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING; PREPARE POTTER RETAINER

AGREEMENT; EMAIL WITH K. POTTER.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 11 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 10

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 2/20/2017 DSM 895.00 0.50 447.50 Billable 449289 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL AND TELECONFERENCE WITH K. POTTER.

2/21/2017 DSM 895.00 0.70 626.50 Billable 449293 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW STIPULATION REGARDING TIME TO RESPOND TO

COMPLAINT; E-MAIL WITH D. TEJTEL; SEND MODEL DISCOVERY

REQUESTS; E-MAIL TO K. POTTER.

2/22/2017 DSM 895.00 0.50 447.50 Billable 449297 PLDS/MO-A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING; REVIEW ORDERS ASSIGNING CASE;

E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

2/24/2017 DSM 895.00 0.40 358.00 Billable 449301 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW NOTICE FROM CLERK REGARDING CASE MANAGEMENT

CONFERENCE; E-MAIL WITH D. TEJTEL; REVIEW ORDER OF

RECUSAL; TELECONFERENCE TO K. POTTER; E-MAIL WITH A.

STEYER.

2/26/2017 DSM 895.00 0.30 268.50 Billable 449304 CLIENT MEETING-A TEXT WITH K. POTTER; E-MAIL WITH A. STEYER.

2/27/2017 DSM 895.00 2.50 2,237.50 Billable 449306 CLIENT MEETING-A MEET WITH A. STEYER; MEET WITH K. POTTER; TRAVEL TO

MIRAMAR.

2/28/2017 DSM 895.00 0.10 89.50 Billable 449311 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

3/1/2017 DSM 895.00 0.50 447.50 Billable 450450 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 12 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 11

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 3/4/2017 DSM 895.00 0.50 447.50 Billable 450480 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW ORDER SETTING INITIAL CASE MANAGEMENT; E-MAIL

WITH CO-COUNSEL; TELECONFERENCE WITH A. STEYER.

3/8/2017 DSM 895.00 0.30 268.50 Billable 450503 RESEARCH-A E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW BOSTON GLOBE ARTICLE

REGARDING AKAMAI.

3/9/2017 DSM 895.00 0.60 537.00 Billable 450523 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING AND CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW BIOS OF

SAN JOSE DIVISION JUDGES.

3/10/2017 DSM 895.00 0.30 268.50 Billable 450529 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW ARTICLE REGARDING JUDGE

KOH GOOGLE SCANNING ORDER.

3/13/2017 DSM 895.00 0.50 447.50 Billable 450537 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM D. TEJTEL AND REVISED DISCOVERY

REQUESTS.

3/14/2017 DSM 895.00 0.20 179.00 Billable 450541 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING.

3/15/2017 DSM 895.00 0.30 268.50 Billable 450546 RESEARCH-A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM CO-COUNSEL AND ARTICLE REGARDING

IPHONE SCREEN CASE.

3/16/2017 DSM 895.00 0.10 89.50 Billable 450553 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 13 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 12

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 3/21/2017 DSM 895.00 0.10 89.50 Billable 450572 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

3/22/2017 DSM 895.00 0.70 626.50 Billable 450584 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL TO K. POTTER; TELECONFERENCE WITH J. MANNING AND

S. JAIN.

3/23/2017 DSM 895.00 2.50 2,237.50 Billable 450587 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW MOTION TO DISMISS; READ CASES.

3/24/2017 DSM 895.00 2.50 2,237.50 Billable 450594 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW J. MANNING MEMO REGARDING MOTION TO DISMISS;

TEXT AND TELECONFERENCE WITH K. POTTER;

TELECONFERENCES AND E-MAILS WITH J. MANNING AND A.

STEYER; LEGAL RESEARCH; TELECONFERENCE WITH

CO-COUNSEL.

3/28/2017 DSM 895.00 0.50 447.50 Billable 451508 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM A. CURRY AND B. CALDWELL AND LETTER

FROM DEFENSE COUNSEL REGARDING PROTECTIVE ORDER;

REVIEW E-MAIL FROM D. TEJTEL AND LEGAL MEMO.

3/31/2017 DSM 895.00 1.00 895.00 Billable 451521 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW DRAFT AMENDED COMPLAINT AND E-MAIL FROM

CO-COUNSEL; E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING.

4/1/2017 DSM 895.00 0.50 447.50 Billable 453616 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW LETTER TO DEFENSE COUNSEL; E-MAIL TO A. CURRY;

REVIEW E-MAIL FROM D. TEJTEL AND CO-COUNSEL AND

REDLINED DRAFT AMENDED COMPLAINT. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 14 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 13

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

4/3/2017 DSM 895.00 3.20 2,864.00 Billable 453619 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW E-MAILS FROM A. CURRY, D. TETJEL, A. STEYER, J.

MANNING, AND LEGAL RESEARCH FROM J. SUMMERS;

TELECONFERENCE WITH A. STEYER; LEGAL RESEARCH;

CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL AND CONSULTANT;

REVIEW E-MAIL AND MEMO FROM S. JAIN.

4/4/2017 DSM 895.00 0.40 358.00 Billable 453919 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM J. MANNING AND REVISED DRAFT

AMENDED COMPLAINT; TELEPHONE - J. MANNING.

4/5/2017 DSM 895.00 0.50 447.50 Billable 453630 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW DRAFT AMENDED COMPLAINT; E-MAIL WITH D. TETJEL;

TELECONFERENCE WITH J. MANNING.

4/6/2017 DSM 895.00 0.50 447.50 Billable 453643 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW DOCUMENT REQUESTS; E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING;

REVIEW ORDER.

4/7/2017 DSM 895.00 0.10 89.50 Billable 453654 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW EDITS TO DOCUMENT REQUESTS.

4/12/2017 DSM 895.00 0.10 89.50 Billable 453678 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM A. CURRY AND J. CASSADY.

4/14/2017 DSM 895.00 0.10 89.50 Billable 453712 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM D. TEJTEL AND REVISED REQUESTS FOR

PRODUCTION..

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 15 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 14

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 4/17/2017 DSM 895.00 0.10 89.50 Billable 453715 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL, A. STEYER AND S. JAIN REGARDING

HEARING FOR MOTION TO DISMISS

4/17/2017 DSM 895.00 0.30 268.50 Billable 453719 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM D. TEJTEL AND REVISED DISCOVERY

REQUESTS.

4/19/2017 DSM 895.00 0.20 179.00 Billable 453731 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW E-MAIL FORM CO-COUNSEL.

4/20/2017 DSM 895.00 3.00 2,685.00 Billable 453740 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW MOTION TO DISMISS; E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL;

REVIEW MEMO FROM J. MANNING; TELECONFERENCE WITH

CO-COUNSEL; LEGAL RESEARCH; OUTLINE FOR UNFAIR

COMPETITION LAW SECTIONS OF MOTION TO DISMISS.

4/24/2017 DSM 895.00 2.50 2,237.50 Billable 453753 PLDS/MO-A E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL; LEGAL RESEARCH FOR MOTION TO

DISMISS OPPOSITION.

4/26/2017 DSM 895.00 4.00 3,580.00 Billable 453776 PLDS/MO-A LEGAL RESEARCH; DRAFT AND REVISE UNFAIR COMPETITION

LAW SECTIONS OF MOTION TO DISMISS OPPOSITION; E-MAIL

WITH CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW THEIR DRAFT SECTIONS OF

OPPOSITION BRIEF; REVIEW ADR CERTIFICATES; REVIEW

DRAFT ESI STIPULATION.

4/27/2017 DSM 895.00 4.50 4,027.50 Billable 453820 PLDS/MO-A COMPLETE UNFAIR COMPETITION LAW SECTIONS OF MOTION TO Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 16 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 15

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt DISMISS OPPOSITION; E-MAIL AND TELECONFERENCES WITH J.

MANNING, S. JAIN AND D. TEJTEL; REVIEW COMBINED DRAFT

BRIEF; REVIEW E-MAIL FROM A. CURRY AND DRAFT DISCOVERY

REQUESTS.

4/28/2017 DSM 895.00 4.50 4,027.50 Billable 453823 PLDS/MO-A REVISE AND EDIT MOTION TO DISMISS OPPOSITION; LEGAL

RESEARCH; E-MAIL WITH D. TEJTEL AND CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW

CLERK'S NOTICE REGARDING ADR CONFERENCE; REVIEW JOINT

DRAFT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT.

4/30/2017 DSM 895.00 0.50 447.50 Billable 453834 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM D. TEJTEL AND REVISED MOTION TO

COMPEL OPPOSITION.

5/1/2017 DSM 895.00 1.50 1,342.50 Billable 456559 PLDS/MO-A EDIT MOTION TO DISMISS OPPOSITION; TELECON WITH A.

STEYER; EMAIL WITH J. MANNING AND CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW

EDITS BY CO-COUNSEL.

5/2/2017 DSM 895.00 1.40 1,253.00 Billable 456568 PLDS/MO-A E-MAIL WITH S. JAIN; REVIEW MEMO RE CERTIFICATION OF

INTERESTED PARTIES; EMAIL WITH J. MANNING; EDIT SECTION

OF MTD OPPOSITION.

5/3/2017 DSM 895.00 1.50 1,342.50 Billable 456578 PLDS/MO-A EMAIL WITH J. MANNING AND CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW AND REVISE

OPPOSITION; WORK ON STANDING FACT INSERT; LEGAL

RESEARCH.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 17 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 16

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 5/4/2017 DSM 895.00 0.80 716.00 Billable 456583 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW EMAIL FROM J. MANNING AND REVISED DRAFT AMENDED

COMPLAINT; TELECON WITH

J. MANNING.

5/5/2017 DSM 895.00 0.70 626.50 Billable 456592 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW DRAFT AMENDED COMPLAINT; E-MAIL WITH D. TETJEL;

TELECON WITH J. MANNING.

5/8/2017 DSM 895.00 0.30 268.50 Billable 456601 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW DRAFT JOINT CMC STATEMENT AND E-MAIL FROM J.

MANNING; REVIEW DOCUMENT REQUESTS; EMAIL WITH

CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW CLERK'S NOTICE.

5/9/2017 DSM 895.00 0.30 268.50 Billable 456749 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW DRAFT INITIAL DISCLOSURES AND E-MAIL WITH

CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW APPLE'S DISCLOSURES.

5/10/2017 DSM 895.00 0.20 179.00 Billable 456751 CASEMNG-A REVIEW CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENTS.

5/11/2017 DSM 895.00 0.70 626.50 Billable 456762 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW REPLY ISO MOTION TO DISMISS AND E-MAIL WITH

CO-COUNSEL.

5/12/2017 DSM 895.00 0.30 268.50 Billable 456767 ATTYMTG.STR - A EMAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

5/15/2017 DSM 895.00 0.20 179.00 Billable 456774 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW REVISED ESI STIPULATION.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 18 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 17

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 5/16/2017 DSM 895.00 0.40 358.00 Billable 456777 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL AND EMAILS WITH CO-COUNSEL.

5/17/2017 DSM 895.00 0.40 358.00 Billable 456784 CASEMNG-A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM KE AND E-MAIL FROM J. MANNING

REGARDING HEARING; REVIEW CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER;

E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW PROPOSED DISCOVERY

SCHEDULE.

5/18/2017 DSM 895.00 0.30 268.50 Billable 456791 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW SCHEDULING ORDER AND E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

5/24/2017 DSM 895.00 0.20 179.00 Billable 456810 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM D. TEJTEL, B. SIMON, J. MANNING AND D.

WARSHAW REGARDING DRAFT PROTECTIVE ORDER.

5/25/2017 DSM 895.00 0.50 447.50 Billable 456817 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW DRAFT AMENDED DISCLOSURES; REVIEW HEARING

TRANSCRIPT; E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

5/30/2017 DSM 895.00 0.30 268.50 Billable 456831 CT APPR - A REVIEW OUTLINE OF ARTICLE III STANDING ISSUE FOR ORAL

ARGUMENT AND E-MAIL FROM D. TEJTEL.

6/5/2017 DSM 895.00 0.30 268.50 Billable 459087 CT APPR - A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM D. TEJTEL AND OUTLINE FOR STANDING

ORAL ARGUMENT.

6/12/2017 DSM 895.00 0.20 179.00 Billable 459118 ATTYMTG.STR - A EMAIL WITH J. MANNING AND CO-COUNSEL RE ORAL ARGUMENT.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 19 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 18

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 6/13/2017 DSM 895.00 0.20 179.00 Billable 459123 CT APPR - A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM A. SIMON AND OUTLINE FOR ORAL

ARGUMENT REGARDING STANDING FOR 4S OWNER AND

INJUNCTIVE RELIEF.

6/14/2017 DSM 895.00 0.30 268.50 Billable 459130 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW ESI STIPULATION AND PROTECTIVE ORDER; E-MAIL WITH

J. MANNING.

6/23/2017 DSM 895.00 1.10 984.50 Billable 459163 CT APPR - A REVIEW REPLY BRIEF; DRAFT ORAL ARGUMENT FOR UCL

UNFAIRNESS ISSUE; E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING AND S. JAIN.

6/26/2017 DSM 895.00 0.30 268.50 Billable 459165 CT APPR - A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM S. JAIN AND ORAL ARGUMENT OUTLINE

REGARDING TRESPASS TO CHATTELS.

6/28/2017 DSM 895.00 0.20 179.00 Billable 459179 RESEARCH-A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM A. STEYER REGARDING APPLE CREDIT FOR

USED PHONES.

6/30/2017 DSM 895.00 0.20 179.00 Billable 459187 ATTYMTG.STR - A EMAIL WITH J. MANNING RE K. POTTER.

7/13/2017 DSM 895.00 0.10 89.50 Billable 460896 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING MOTION TO DISMISS

HEARING.

7/24/2017 DSM 895.00 0.30 268.50 Billable 461419 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING AND K. POTTER.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 20 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 19

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 7/29/2017 DSM 895.00 0.20 179.00 Billable 461443 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING DECISION.

7/31/2017 DSM 895.00 1.10 984.50 Billable 461450 PLDS/MO-A READ ORDER DENYING MOTION TO DISMISS; SEND DECISION TO

K. POTTER; E-MAIL WITH K. POTTER; TELECOM WITH A. STEYER

AND J. MANNING; E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

8/1/2017 DSM 895.00 0.40 358.00 Billable 463301 CLIENT MEETING-A TELECONFERENCE WITH K. POTTER; E-MAIL TO J. MANNING.

8/2/2017 DSM 895.00 3.40 3,043.00 Billable 463308 RESEARCH-A LEGAL RESEARCH REGARDING CLASS CERTIFICATION OF

TRESPASS ON CHATTELS AND UNFAIR COMPETITION LAW

CLAIMS; REVIEW E-MAIL FROM A. CURRY REGARDING EXPERT;

CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW AGENDA AND

ACTION ITEMS; LEGAL RESEARCH REGARDING COMMON IMPACT

AND DAMAGES; REVIEW DRAFT CASE MANAGEMENT

CONFERENCE STATEMENT AND COMMENTS.

8/8/2017 DSM 895.00 0.10 89.50 Billable 463342 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM D. TEJTEL AND DRAFT ESI SEARCH TERMS.

8/11/2017 DSM 895.00 0.30 268.50 Billable 463373 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW ANSWER TO AMENDED COMPLAINT.

8/16/2017 DSM 895.00 0.20 179.00 Billable 463394 CASEMNG-A REVIEW JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 21 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 20

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 8/21/2017 DSM 895.00 0.30 268.50 Billable 463449 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM D. TEJTEL AND DRAFT INTERROGATORIES.

8/23/2017 DSM 895.00 0.20 179.00 Billable 463462 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM A. CURRY AND J. MANNING REGARDING

INTERROGATORIES.

8/25/2017 DSM 895.00 0.30 268.50 Billable 463470 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW REVISED INTERROGATORIES AND E-MAIL WITH

CO-COUNSEL.

8/29/2017 DSM 895.00 0.20 179.00 Billable 463518 ATTYMTG.STR - A EMAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

9/20/2017 DSM 895.00 0.20 179.00 Billable 465006 DISCOVERY-A TELECON WITH S. JAIN; REVIEW E-MAIL REGARDING CODING

TERMS.

9/21/2017 DSM 895.00 1.40 1,253.00 Billable 465008 RESEARCH-A LEGAL RESEARCH REGARDING IMPACT, DAMAGES, RESTITUTION

AND SURVEYS; CONFERENCE CALL WITH S. JAIN AND A. SIMON;

REVIEW E-MAILS REGARDING DOCUMENT CODING TERMS.

9/26/2017 DSM 895.00 1.00 895.00 Billable 465260 RESEARCH-A REVIEW CASES AND RESEARCH MEMORANDA REGARDING

MEASURABLE LOSS AND CLASSWIDE DAMAGES; E-MAIL WITH S.

JAIN AND A. SIMON.

10/3/2017 DSM 895.00 1.10 984.50 Billable 467379 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL AND TELEPHONE - S. JAIN; REVIEW APPLE BUYER SURVEY

AND EXPERT DECLARATION FROM SAMSUNG CASE. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 22 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 21

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

10/4/2017 DSM 895.00 1.70 1,521.50 Billable 467383 RESEARCH-A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING; LEGAL RESEARCH REGARDING

TRESPASS TO CHATTELS JURY INSTRUCTIONS; CONFERENCE

CALL WITH S. JAIN AND A. SIMON REGARDING DAMAGES ISSUES.

10/23/2017 DSM 895.00 0.40 358.00 Billable 467557 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW DOCUMENT REQUESTS, APPLE'S AMENDED RULE 26(a)(1)

INITIAL DISCLOSURE AND E-MAIL TO K. POTTER; E-MAIL WITH J.

MANNING .

10/25/2017 DSM 895.00 0.30 268.50 Billable 467564 CASEMNG-A REVIEW E-MAIL TO CLIENT REGARDING DOCUMENT REQUESTS

AND CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT; E-MAIL TO

J. MANNING.

10/30/2017 DSM 895.00 0.20 179.00 Billable 467935 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM J. MANNING REGARDING ACTION ITEMS.

11/2/2017 DSM 895.00 0.50 447.50 Billable 469216 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW DECISION IN IOS 9 4S CASE; E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

11/3/2017 DSM 895.00 0.20 179.00 Billable 469219 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

11/21/2017 DSM 895.00 0.20 179.00 Billable 469278 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW APPLE'S AMENDED RESPONSES TO REQUESTS FOR

PRODUCTION.

12/15/2017 DSM 895.00 0.50 447.50 Billable 471330 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM APPLE'S COUNSEL REGARDING Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 23 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 22

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

DOCUMENT PRODUCTION.

12/20/2017 DSM 895.00 0.20 179.00 Billable 472592 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM A. CURRY TO C. CASTILLO.

12/22/2017 DSM 895.00 0.40 358.00 Billable 472600 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW ORDER AND E-MAIL FROM J. MANNING; TELECON WITH

A. STEYER; REVIEW E-MAIL FROM A. CURRY AND KRISTIN

SHEFFIELD-WHITEHEAD.

12/28/2017 DSM 895.00 0.20 179.00 Billable 472617 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM A. CURRY TO APPLE COUNSEL.

1/3/2018 DSM 920.00 3.00 2,760.00 Billable 473944 PLDS/MO-A LEGAL RESEARCH REGARDING CLASS CERTIFICATION; DRAFT

LEGAL ARGUMENT; REVIEW E-MAIL WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL AND

DRAFT JOINT LETTER BRIEF.

1/4/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 473950 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW E-MAIL BETWEEN A. CURRY AND APPLE LAWYER.

1/5/2018 DSM 920.00 0.50 460.00 Billable 473957 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW E-MAIL REGARDING CUSTOMER CARE LOG

PRODUCTION; REVIEW PRIVILEGE LOG; REVIEW OBJECTIONS

TO 30(b)(6) DEPOSITION NOTICE.

1/8/2018 DSM 920.00 3.00 2,760.00 Billable 473971 PLDS/MO-A REVISE LEGAL ARGUMENT SECTION FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION

BRIEF; LEGAL RESEARCH; E-MAIL WITH A. STEYER AND S. JAIN.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 24 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 23

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 1/14/2018 DSM 920.00 0.40 368.00 Billable 474897 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL TO J. MANNING REGARDING MULTI-STATE CLASS

CERTIFICATION.

1/17/2018 DSM 920.00 0.30 276.00 Billable 474931 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING REGARDING CLASS CERTIFICATION

ISSUES.

1/18/2018 DSM 920.00 1.40 1,288.00 Billable 474937 PLDS/MO-A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING REGARDING JOINT LETTER BRIEF;

LEGAL RESEARCH; REVISE AND EDIT JOINT LETTER BRIEF;

REVIEW E-MAIL FROM D. WARSHAW AND J. MANNING

REGARDING NATIONWIDE CERTIFICATION OF UNFAIR

COMPETITION LAW CLAIMS; READ CASES.

1/18/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 474942 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM A. CURRY TO C. CASTILLO.

1/23/2018 DSM 920.00 0.50 460.00 Billable 474966 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM A. STEYER AND NEW HYUNDAI DECISION;

REVIEW APPLE SUBPOENA TO AT&T.

1/24/2018 DSM 920.00 1.00 920.00 Billable 474975 RESEARCH-A LEGAL RESEARCH REGARDING NATIONWIDE AND MULTI-STATE

CLASSES; E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING.

1/25/2018 DSM 920.00 0.40 368.00 Billable 474988 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL WITH D. WARSHAW, J. MANNING AND D. TEJTEL

REGARDING DISCOVERY AND IOS LICENSE CHOICE OF LAW

PROVISION. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 25 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 24

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

1/26/2018 DSM 920.00 0.30 276.00 Billable 475129 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM A. CURRY RE TRESPASS AND UCL ISSUES.

1/28/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 475140 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING; REVIEW E-MAIL FROM CO-COUNSEL.

1/29/2018 DSM 920.00 0.30 276.00 Billable 475144 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM J. MANNING AND 11 STATE CERTIFICATION

ORDER IN CONAGRA.

1/30/2018 DSM 920.00 0.30 276.00 Billable 475156 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW EMAIL FROM J. MANNING AND NEW SHAMRELL

DECERTIFICATION DECISION.

1/31/2018 DSM 920.00 0.40 368.00 Billable 475160 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM D. TEJTEL AND HP DECISION REGARDING

TRESPASS TO CHATTELS; REVIEW JOINT STATUS REPORT

REGARDING DISCOVERY DISPUTE.

2/1/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 477023 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM A. CURRY.

2/6/2018 DSM 920.00 0.30 276.00 Billable 477048 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING AND CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW JOINT

STATUS REPORT.

2/7/2018 DSM 920.00 0.40 368.00 Billable 477068 EXPERTS-A REVIEW DRAFT DAMAGES EXPERT REPORT; REVIEW APPLE'S

STATEMENT RE DISCOVERY DISPUTES.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 26 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 25

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 2/8/2018 DSM 920.00 0.40 368.00 Billable 477082 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM J. MANNING AND A. CURRY REGARDING

CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEFING; E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL;

REVIEW JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT.

2/9/2018 DSM 920.00 0.40 368.00 Billable 477091 PLDS/MO-A E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW INTERROGATORY

RESPONSES; REVIEW NOTICE REGARDING CASE MANAGEMENT

CONFERENCE.

2/13/2018 DSM 920.00 2.40 2,208.00 Billable 477103 DISCOVERY-A LEGAL RESEARCH FOR NATIONWIDE CERT SECTION OF CLASS

CERT MOTION; E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING.

2/15/2018 DSM 920.00 0.40 368.00 Billable 477118 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL TO J. MANNING RE MULTI-STATE CLASS CERTIFICATION.

2/16/2018 DSM 920.00 2.80 2,576.00 Billable 477122 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT AND REVISE ARGUMENT FOR CERTIFICATION OF

NATIONWIDE CLASS; E-MAIL TO J. MANNING AND A. STEYER;

LEGAL RESEARCH.

2/22/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 477146 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT AND E-MAIL

FROM APPLE COUNSEL.

2/23/2018 DSM 920.00 0.30 276.00 Billable 477149 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM J. MANNING RE BILLING; REVIEW ORDER

RE CLASS CERTIFICATION HEARING DATE AND CASE SCHEDULE;

REVIEW DISCOVERY ORDER. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 27 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 26

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

2/26/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 477154 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW LETTER FROM AKAMAI COUNSEL AND E-MAIL FROM T.

GREENE.

2/27/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 477162 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW JOINT STATUS REPORT RE DISCOVERY DISPUTES.

2/28/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 477490 PLDS/MO-A TELEPHONE - S. JAIN REGARDING CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF.

3/1/2018 DSM 920.00 1.00 920.00 Billable 480430 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW REVISED DRAFT CLASS CERTIFICATION MOTION; E-MAIL

J. MANNING (2/28/18).

3/2/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 480129 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW JOINT STATUS REPORT AND STATEMENT BY APPLE.

3/6/2018 DSM 920.00 0.30 276.00 Billable 480138 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING AND CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW JOINT

STATUS REPORT.

3/8/2018 DSM 920.00 0.40 368.00 Billable 480162 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM J. MANNING AND A. CURRY RE CLASS

CERTIFICATION BRIEFING; E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW

JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT.

3/9/2018 DSM 920.00 0.40 368.00 Billable 480168 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW INTERROGATORY

RESPONSES; REVIEW NOTICE RE CASE MANAGEMENT

CONFERENCE. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 28 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 27

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

3/15/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 480202 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW LETTER FROM APPLE TO JUDGE COUSINS RE K. POTTER.

3/20/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 480221 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM J. MANNING RE CLASS CERT ISSUES.

3/21/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 480224 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING RE CLASS CERT MOTION.

3/24/2018 DSM 920.00 0.30 276.00 Billable 480332 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW DISCOVERY LETTER BRIEF RE FACETIME LOGS.

3/27/2018 DSM 920.00 0.30 276.00 Billable 480424 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW DISCOVERY LETTER BRIEF AND THIRD SET OF

INTERROGATORIES TO PLAINTIFF.

3/28/2018 DSM 920.00 1.00 920.00 Billable 480458 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW REVISED DRAFT CLASS CERTIFICATION MOTION; E-MAIL

WITH J. MANNING.

3/29/2018 DSM 920.00 0.60 552.00 Billable 480431 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW REVISED DRAFT CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF;

TELEPHONE - A. STEYER; E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING; REVIEW

REVISION TO DRAFT REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION.

4/3/2018 DSM 920.00 0.30 276.00 Billable 481792 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW CLASS CERTIFICATION DRAFT STATEMENT OF FACTS

AND A. STEYER COMMENTS.

4/5/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 481808 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING AND D. WARSHAW REGARDING CLASS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 29 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 28

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

CERTIFICATION FILING.

4/10/2018 DSM 920.00 1.50 1,380.00 Billable 481822 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELECON AND E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING AND A. STEYER

REGARDING CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF AND POTTER

DEPOSITION; REVIEW NEW DRAFT OF CLASS CERTIFICATION

BRIEF.

4/11/2018 DSM 920.00 0.80 736.00 Billable 481830 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW HASTINGS DECLARATION; E-MAIL COMMENTS

REGARDING CLASS CERT BRIEF TO J. MANNING AND A. STEYER.

4/12/2018 DSM 920.00 1.00 920.00 Billable 481873 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING AND A. STEYER REGARDING CLASS

CERTIFICATION ISSUES; REVIEW HASTINGS REPORT.

4/13/2018 DSM 920.00 1.40 1,288.00 Billable 481884 RESEARCH-A E-MAIL COMMENTS REGARDING HASTINGS DECLARATION TO J.

MANNING AND A. STEYER; LEGAL RESEARCH REGARDING

REGRESSION ANALYSES IN UCL CLASS CERTIFICATION MOTION.

4/14/2018 DSM 920.00 0.10 92.00 Billable 481888 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING REGARDING HASTINGS REPORT.

4/16/2018 DSM 920.00 0.30 276.00 Billable 481891 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL WITH S. JAIN AND A. STEYER REGARDING E-MAIL AND

TEXTS WITH CLIENT FOR PRIVILEGE LOG; REVIEW ORDER

REGARDING PARTIES' PROPOSED ORDERS IN RESPONSE TO THE

COURT'S APRIL 4, 2018, MINUTE ORDER; E-MAIL WITH A. STEYER

REGARDING HASTINGS DECLARATION. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 30 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 29

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

4/19/2018 DSM 920.00 1.00 920.00 Billable 481905 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING; LEGAL RESEARCH REGARDING USE OF

AVERAGE PRICES IN CALCULATING AGGREGATE DAMAGES;

REVIEW AND REVISE DRAFT PLAINTIFFS DECLARATION.

4/26/2018 DSM 920.00 1.80 1,656.00 Billable 482622 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL AND EXPERTS; REVIEW

REVISED CLASS CERT BRIEF AND PLAINTIFF DECLARATIONS;

EMAIL WITH J. MANNING AND CO-COUNSEL; LEGAL RESEARCH

FOR CLASS CERT BRIEF; DRAFT INSERT.

4/27/2018 DSM 920.00 0.40 368.00 Billable 482628 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM S. JAIN AND REVISED K. POTTER

DECLARATION; REVIEW REVISED HASTINGS DECLARATION.

5/1/2018 DSM 920.00 1.70 1,564.00 Billable 484494 DISCOVERY-A E-MAILS WITH J MANNING; REVIEW REVISED HASTINGS REPORT;

LEGAL RESEARCH REGARDING NEED TO REQUEST ALTERNATIVE

CALIFORNIA CLASS AND REGRESSION ANALYSES; REVIEW E-MAIL

FROM A. SIMON AND DRAFT DECLARATION REGARDING THIRD

PARTY SUBPOENA.

5/2/2018 DSM 920.00 1.30 1,196.00 Billable 484503 DISCOVERY-A LEGAL RESEARCH REGARDING NATIONWIDE CERTIFICATION OF

TRESPASS TO CHATTELS CLAIM; E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING;

REVIEW UPDATED EXPERT REPORT AND CLASS CERT BRIEF.

5/3/2018 DSM 920.00 0.60 552.00 Billable 484508 PLDS/MO-A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING REGARDING CLASS CERT BRIEF; Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 31 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 30

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

REVIEW REVISED BRIEF AND DECLARATION; E-MAIL WITH

CO-COUNSEL.

5/4/2018 DSM 920.00 0.30 276.00 Billable 484514 PLDS/MO-A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING AND CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CLASS

CERT BRIEF AND NOTICE OF MOTION.

5/7/2018 DSM 920.00 0.70 644.00 Billable 484523 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT JURY INSTRUCTION REGARDING TRESPASS TO

CHATTELS; E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING.

5/17/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 484562 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW HASTINGS SUBPOENA.

5/24/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 484749 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW BEST BUY SUBPOENA.

5/31/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 485519 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW ORDER DENYING POTTER MOTION TO COMPEL.

6/18/2018 DSM 920.00 2.70 2,484.00 Billable 487069 PLDS/MO-A E-MAILS WITH J MANNING; LEGAL RESEARCH FOR CLASS CERT

REPLY AND DAUBERT ISSUES; CONFERENCE CALL WITH

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CERT REPLY.

6/19/2018 DSM 920.00 2.70 2,484.00 Billable 487075 PLDS/MO-A LEGAL RESEARCH FOR CERT REPLY; LEGAL RESEARCH

REGARDING POTENTIAL DAUBERT MOTION.

6/20/2018 DSM 920.00 1.50 1,380.00 Billable 487077 PLDS/MO-A TELECONS AND E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING AND S. JAIN Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 32 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 31

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

REGARDING CERT REPLY; LEGAL RESEARCH REGARDING

COMCAST ARGUMENT, EXPERT DAMAGE MODELS AND

DIMINUTION DAMAGES AND RESTITUTION; REVIEW ORDER

REGARDING MOTION TO COMPEL

6/25/2018 DSM 920.00 2.60 2,392.00 Billable 487093 PLDS/MO-A LEGAL RESEARCH; OUTLINE REPLY ARGUMENTS REGARDING

PREDOMINANCE AND DAMAGE MODEL; CONFERENCE CALL WITH

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING REPLY BRIEF.

6/26/2018 DSM 920.00 3.50 3,220.00 Billable 487095 PLDS/MO-A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CLASS CERT

REPLY; LEGAL RESEARCH; BEGIN DRAFTING DAMAGES MODEL

SECTION OF REPLY BRIEF.

6/27/2018 DSM 920.00 0.30 276.00 Billable 487580 PLDS/MO-A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING REGARDING DAMAGES SECTION OF

CLASS CERTIFICATION REPLY BRIEF.

6/28/2018 DSM 920.00 0.40 368.00 Billable 487594 PLDS/MO-A TELECON WITH J. MANNING REGARDING CHOICE-OF-LAW AND

DAMAGES SECTIONS OF REPLY BRIEF; E-MAIL WITH

CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW NEW CANADA DRY DECISION.

6/29/2018 DSM 920.00 0.40 368.00 Billable 487601 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM A. SIMON AND DRAFT CHOICE OF LAW

SECTION OF REPLY BRIEF; CONFER WITH J. MANNING.

7/1/2018 DSM 920.00 3.50 3,220.00 Billable 490404 PLDS/MO-A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING; LEGAL RESEARCH; EXPAND AND Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 33 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 32

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

REVISE DAMAGES SECTION FOR CERT REPLY.

7/2/2018 DSM 920.00 0.50 460.00 Billable 490408 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW E-MAILS FROM A. CURRY, B. POUYA AND J. MANNING;

REVIEW INJUNCTIVE RELIEF SECTION AND REVISED CHOICE OF

LAW SECTION FOR CERT REPLY.

7/5/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 490413 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING RE COMCAST ARGUMENT.

7/7/2018 DSM 920.00 1.90 1,748.00 Billable 490419 PLDS/MO-A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING; REVIEW REVISED DAMAGES AND

INJUNCTIVE RELIEF SECTIONS OF CERT REPLY; LEGAL

RESEARCH RE COMCAST ISSUE; REVIEW REVISED.

7/8/2018 DSM 920.00 4.40 4,048.00 Billable 490420 PLDS/MO-A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING RE CASES APPLYING COMCAST; REVISE

DAMAGES SECTION OF CERT REPLY; LEGAL RESEARCH.

7/9/2018 DSM 920.00 2.20 2,024.00 Billable 490422 PLDS/MO-A TELEPHONE - S. JAIN; E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING RE INJUNCTIVE

RELIEF SECTION OF CERT REPLY; REVIEW REVISED REPLY

BRIEF; LEGAL RESEARCH; REVISE INJUNCTIVE RELIEF SECTION;

REVIEW OUTLINE FOR DAUBERT MOTION.

7/17/2018 DSM 920.00 0.60 552.00 Billable 490445 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL AND CLERK RE MOTION TO

STRIKE; REVIEW FINAL CLASS CERT REPLY.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 34 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 33

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 7/26/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 490470 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW ORDER VACATING CERT ARGUMENT AND E-MAIL FROM

J. MANNING.

7/30/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 490479 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING RE 9TH CIR. REVIEW OF HYUNDAI.

8/8/2018 DSM 920.00 0.30 276.00 Billable 492909 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW LETTER FROM E. NOVKOV AND E-MAIL WITH

CO-COUNSEL FROM OF RESTITUTION SOUGHT.

8/13/2018 DSM 920.00 0.40 368.00 Billable 492923 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW NEW CLASS CERT DECISION BY JUDGE KOH; E-MAIL TO

J. MANNING AND CO-COUNSEL.

9/14/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 494036 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW DISCOVERY LETTER BRIEFS.

9/18/2018 DSM 920.00 0.50 460.00 Billable 494476 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW CLASS CERT DECISION; TELEPHONE CONFERENCES

WITH A. STEYER; E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING REGARDING HYUNDAI

CASE AND 23(F) APPEAL.

9/19/2018 DSM 920.00 0.80 736.00 Billable 494482 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING REGARDING HYUNDAI AND NATIONWIDE

CLASS OPTIONS; TELEPHONE - NINTH CIRCUIT CLERK

REGARDING REHEARING EN BANC; REVIEW ORDER REGARDING

TIME KEEPING.

9/20/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 494485 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING REGARDING NATIONWIDE AND Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 35 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 34

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

MULTI-STATE CLASS OPTIONS.

9/24/2018 DSM 920.00 0.40 368.00 Billable 495757 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING REGARDING MOTION FOR

RECONSIDERATION; REVIEW E-MAIL AND MATERIALS FROM D.

WARSHAW; TELECOM WITH A. STEYER REGARDING MEDIATION.

9/28/2018 DSM 920.00 3.40 3,128.00 Billable 495771 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELECON WITH A. SIMON; E-MAIL AND CONFERENCE CALL WITH

J. MANNING AND CO-COUNSEL; LEGAL RESEARCH REGARDING

TRESPASS TO CHATTELS.

9/30/2018 DSM 920.00 0.30 276.00 Billable 495773 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING LEGAL RESEARCH AND

COMMENTS REGARDING MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION.

10/1/2018 DSM 920.00 1.30 1,196.00 Billable 497394 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW DRAFT MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION AND E-MAIL

WITH CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW E-MAIL FROM J. MANNING; REVIEW

SCHEDULING ORDER; CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

10/2/2018 DSM 920.00 3.20 2,944.00 Billable 497401 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW NEW CHOICE-OF-LAW DECISION; TELECOM AND E-MAILS

WITH J. MANNING AND CO-COUNSEL; LEGAL RESEARCH

REGARDING SUBCLASSES; REVIEW AND REVISE MOTION FOR

RECONSIDERATION; REVIEW DRAFT SECOND AMENDED

COMPLAINT; REVIEW SUMMARY JUDGEMENT OPPOSITION

LEGAL RESEARCH MEMO; CONFERENCE CALL WITH

CO-COUNSEL. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 36 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 35

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

10/4/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 497415 PLDS/MO-A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING REGARDING APPLE MOTION FOR

SUMMARY JUDGMENT.

10/5/2018 DSM 920.00 0.70 644.00 Billable 497420 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW SUMMARY JUDGMENT MOTION AND EXPERT

DECLARATION.

10/8/2018 DSM 920.00 1.20 1,104.00 Billable 497426 PLDS/MO-A ANALYZE SUMMARY JUDGMENT BRIEF; E-MAIL WITH D. TEJTEL.

10/9/2018 DSM 920.00 3.20 2,944.00 Billable 497429 RESEARCH-A LEGAL RESEARCH REGARDING UCL RESTITUTION FOR DAMAGES

BRIEF; E-MAIL RESEARCH MEMO TO D. TEJTEL; TELECOM WITH

D. TEJTEL; E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING.

10/10/2018 DSM 920.00 0.30 276.00 Billable 497434 RESEARCH-A E-MAIL WITH D. TEJTEL; REVIEW MEMO RE STATUTES OF

LIMITATION.

10/10/2018 DSM 920.00 0.30 276.00 Billable 497437 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW LETTER FROM E. NOVKOV AND E-MAIL WITH

CO-COUNSEL FORM OF RESTITUTION SOUGHT.

10/15/2018 DSM 920.00 0.70 644.00 Billable 497452 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELECON AND E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING AND CO-COUNSEL RE

SUMMARY JUDGMENT OPPOSITION.

10/16/2018 DSM 920.00 1.40 1,288.00 Billable 497454 PLDS/MO-A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING AND D. TEJTEL; REVIEW DOCUMENTS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 37 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 36

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt FOR MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OPPOSITION; REVIEW

DRAFT SUMMARY JUDGMENT OPPOSITION; TELECON WITH J.

MANNING; REVIEW OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR

RECONSIDERATION.

10/17/2018 DSM 920.00 2.60 2,392.00 Billable 497457 PLDS/MO-A REVISE AND EDIT SUMMARY JUDGMENT OPPOSITION; LEGAL

RESEARCH; E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW JOINT CASE

MANAGEMENT STATEMENT.

10/18/2018 DSM 920.00 0.90 828.00 Billable 498101 PLDS/MO-A FINAL REVISIONS TO SUMMARY JUDGMENT OPPOSITION; E-MAIL

WITH D. TEJTEL AND CO-COUNSEL.

10/19/2018 DSM 920.00 0.50 460.00 Billable 498108 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

10/24/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 498118 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING AND CO-COUNSEL REGARDING 23(F)

PETITION.

10/25/2018 DSM 920.00 2.30 2,116.00 Billable 498123 PLDS/MO-A LEGAL RESEARCH FOR 23(F) PETITION; CONFERENCE CALL WITH

CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW DRAFT OUTLINE; REVIEW SUMMARY

JUDGMENT REPLY BRIEF.

10/26/2018 DSM 920.00 1.70 1,564.00 Billable 498130 PLDS/MO-A LEGAL RESEARCH FOR 23(F) PETITION; E-MAIL AND TELECON

WITH J. MANNING; REVIEW ANSWER TO QUALCOMM PETITION.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 38 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 37

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 10/29/2018 DSM 920.00 5.50 5,060.00 Billable 498134 PLDS/MO-A LEGAL RESEARCH FOR 23(F) PETITION; E-MAIL WITH D. TETJEL.

10/30/2018 DSM 920.00 7.50 6,900.00 Billable 498141 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT TRESPASS TO CHATTELS SECTION OF 23(F) PETITION;

REVIEW DRAFT PETITION; E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING AND

CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW DRAFT.

10/31/2018 DSM 920.00 3.50 3,220.00 Billable 498144 PLDS/MO-A REVISE 23(F) PETITION; LEGAL RESEARCH; E-MAIL WITH J.

MANNING; CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

11/1/2018 DSM 920.00 1.10 1,012.00 Billable 499158 SETTLE-A E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW REVISED 23(f) BRIEF AND

MEDIATION STATEMENT; E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING REGARDING

HYUNDAI.

11/2/2018 DSM 920.00 1.40 1,288.00 Billable 499168 SETTLE-A E-MAIL AND CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW

MEDIATION STATEMENTS; REVIEW REVISIONS TO 23(f) PETITION.

11/5/2018 DSM 920.00 0.50 460.00 Billable 499173 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW FINAL EDITS TO 23(f) PETITION; TELECON WITH A.

STEYER.

11/6/2018 DSM 920.00 0.80 736.00 Billable 499178 PLDS/MO-A TELECON WITH A. STEYER REGARDING MEDIATION; REVIEW

MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT REPLY; E-MAIL WITH S. JAIN;

DRAFT BULLET POINTS SUMMARIZING SUMMARY JUDGMENT

ARGUMENTS. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 39 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 38

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

11/7/2018 DSM 920.00 0.50 460.00 Billable 499181 PLDS/MO-A TELECON WITH A. STEYER; REVIEW 23(F) FILING.

11/8/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 499188 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELECON WITH A. STEYER.

11/9/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 499191 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING.

11/12/2018 DSM 920.00 0.70 644.00 Billable 499194 RESEARCH-A LEGAL RESEARCH REGARDING 23(f), SETTLEMENT AND

STANDING ISSUES; E-MAIL TO J. MANNING.

11/13/2018 DSM 920.00 0.50 460.00 Billable 499198 SETTLE-A TELECON AND E-MAIL WITH A. STEYER REGARDING MEDIATION

AND 23(F) PETITION.

11/16/2018 DSM 920.00 1.00 920.00 Billable 499213 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW 23(f) OPPOSITION; CONFERENCE CALL AND E-MAIL WITH

CO-COUNSEL

11/20/2018 DSM 920.00 0.30 276.00 Billable 500917 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM J. MANNING AND CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING 23(F) REPLY.

11/21/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 500920 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM J. MANNING AND D. PEARSON.

11/30/2018 DSM 920.00 2.70 2,484.00 Billable 500934 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND REVISE DRAFT 23(F) REPLY BRIEF; LEGAL

RESEARCH FOR REPLY; E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING AND Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 40 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 39

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

CO-COUNSEL.

12/2/2018 DSM 920.00 1.20 1,104.00 Billable 503103 PLDS/MO-A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING; LEGAL RESEARCH; REVISE 23(F) REPLY.

12/3/2018 DSM 920.00 3.20 2,944.00 Billable 503106 PLDS/MO-A REVISE 23(F) REPLY BRIEF; EMAIL WITH J. MANNING AND A.

CURRY.

12/5/2018 DSM 920.00 0.20 184.00 Billable 503117 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM J. MANNING AND CO-COUNSEL RE 23(F)

REPLY.

12/7/2018 DSM 920.00 1.80 1,656.00 Billable 503124 PLDS/MO-A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING AND D. WARSHAW; TELECOM WITH S.

JAIN; REVIEW AND REVISE 23(F) REPLY BRIEF.

12/12/2018 DSM 920.00 0.30 276.00 Billable 503138 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH S. JAIN; REVIEW 23(F) REPLY AS FILED.

2/20/2019 DSM 960.00 0.20 192.00 Billable 507361 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT.

2/26/2019 DSM 960.00 0.80 768.00 Billable 507377 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW USSC LAMBERT 23(F) DECISION; E-MAIL WITH A. STEYER;

REVIEW E-MAIL FROM D. WARSHAW AND J. MANNING.

3/21/2019 DSM 960.00 0.50 480.00 Billable 510384 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW 23(F) DENIAL; EMAIL WITH J. MANNING AND

CO-COUNSEL; TELEPHONE CALL WITH A. STEYER.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 41 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 40

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 3/22/2019 DSM 960.00 1.20 1,152.00 Billable 510389 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING; CONFERENCE CALL WITH

CO-COUNSEL; LEGAL RESEARCH; REVIEW JOINT STATEMENT RE

NINTH CIRCUIT RULING.

3/26/2019 DSM 960.00 0.20 192.00 Billable 510404 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW EMAIL FROM D. TEJTEL.

4/1/2019 DSM 960.00 0.20 192.00 Billable 512851 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING.

4/8/2019 DSM 960.00 0.20 192.00 Billable 512869 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH D. WARSHAW.

4/9/2019 DSM 960.00 0.30 288.00 Billable 512871 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM A. SIMON AND WEEKLY CALL AGENDA.

4/10/2019 DSM 960.00 0.50 480.00 Billable 512877 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

4/18/2019 DSM 960.00 0.50 480.00 Billable 513035 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

4/22/2019 DSM 960.00 0.20 192.00 Billable 513046 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW DRAFT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT

AND E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

4/26/2019 DSM 960.00 0.50 480.00 Billable 513068 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW ORDER; E-MAIL WITH A. STEYER AND J. MANNING;

CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 42 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 41

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 4/29/2019 DSM 960.00 0.20 192.00 Billable 513077 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW ORDERS LIFTING STAY AND CONTINUING CASE

MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE; TELECON WITH A. STEYER.

4/30/2019 DSM 960.00 0.30 288.00 Billable 513082 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW REVISED SCHEDULE; TELECON WITH A. STEYER.

5/13/2019 DSM 960.00 0.20 192.00 Billable 515025 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING.

5/15/2019 DSM 960.00 0.80 768.00 Billable 515659 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH J. MANNING AND CO-COUNSEL.

6/6/2019 DSM 960.00 0.50 480.00 Billable 518933 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM J. MANNING AND HYUNDAI EN BANC

DECISION.

6/19/2019 DSM 960.00 0.50 480.00 Billable 518982 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING AND CO-COUNSEL.

7/31/2019 DSM 960.00 0.50 480.00 Billable 522022 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S SUBMISSION OF RECENT AUTHORITY; E-MAIL

WITH CO-COUNSEL.

8/1/2019 DSM 960.00 0.20 192.00 Billable 523838 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW ORDER VACATING MSJ HEARING; CONFERENCE WITH J.

MANNING REGARDING SAME.

8/21/2019 DSM 960.00 0.20 192.00 Billable 523897 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING AND A. STEYER REGARDING SUMMARY

JUDGMENT DENIAL. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 43 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 42

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

8/22/2019 DSM 960.00 0.50 480.00 Billable 523907 PLDS/MO-A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING AND D. WARSHAW; REVIEW DRAFT

CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT; READ SUMMARY

JUDGMENT ORDER AND ORDER REFERRING PARTIES TO

MEDIATION.

8/23/2019 DSM 960.00 1.30 1,248.00 Billable 523909 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL; TELEPHONE - A.

STEYER; E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING.

8/28/2019 DSM 960.00 0.20 192.00 Billable 523924 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - A. STEYER.

8/30/2019 DSM 960.00 0.20 192.00 Billable 523937 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW ORDER CONTINUING CMC AND SCHEDULING ORDER.

9/12/2019 DSM 960.00 0.20 192.00 Billable 526762 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW JOINT SETTLEMENT STATUS UPDATE.

9/13/2019 DSM 960.00 0.30 288.00 Billable 526772 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL; TELEPHONE - A. STEYER.

9/23/2019 DSM 960.00 0.20 192.00 Billable 526800 SETTLE-A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM D. TEJTEL AND DRAFT MEDIATION

STATEMENT.

10/9/2019 DSM 960.00 0.20 192.00 Billable 529187 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE - A. STEYER REGARDING MEDIATION.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 44 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 43

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 10/11/2019 DSM 960.00 0.20 192.00 Billable 529213 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE - A. STEYER RE MEDIATION.

10/22/2019 DSM 960.00 0.20 192.00 Billable 529269 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE - A. STEYER REGARDING MEDIATION.

11/6/2019 DSM 960.00 0.20 192.00 Billable 530713 RESEARCH-A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING; REVIEW LEGAL RESEARCH.

11/8/2019 DSM 960.00 0.70 672.00 Billable 530723 PLDS/MO-A CONFERENCE CALL AND E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW

E-MAIL AND DRAFT STIPULATION FROM APPLE'S COUNSEL.

11/20/2019 DSM 960.00 0.20 192.00 Billable 530764 SETTLE-A REVIEW JOINT MEDIATION STATEMENT UPDATE.

11/21/2019 DSM 960.00 0.20 192.00 Billable 530876 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW STIPULATION RE BRIEFING TO EXCLUDE EXPERT

TESTIMONY.

11/22/2019 DSM 960.00 0.20 192.00 Billable 530880 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW ORDER.

11/25/2019 DSM 960.00 0.20 192.00 Billable 530889 SETTLE-A REVIEW ORDER REFERRING PARTIES TO MAGISTRATE JUDGE

SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE.

12/2/2019 DSM 960.00 0.20 192.00 Billable 533656 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW CONFIDENTIALITY STIPULATION; TELECON WITH A.

STEYER.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 45 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 44

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 12/4/2019 DSM 960.00 0.20 192.00 Billable 533666 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT.

12/5/2019 DSM 960.00 0.20 192.00 Billable 533676 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW COUSIN'S MINUTE ORDER AND ORDER CONTINUING

CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE

12/6/2019 DSM 960.00 2.70 2,592.00 Billable 533683 TRIAL PREP-A EMAIL WITH J. MANNING; DRAFT JURY INSTRUCTIONS.

12/10/2019 DSM 960.00 3.50 3,360.00 Billable 533698 TRIAL PREP-A DRAFT AND REVISE JURY INSTRUCTIONS; LEGAL RESEARCH;

EMAIL WITH J. MANNING AND D. WARSHAW.

12/11/2019 DSM 960.00 1.50 1,440.00 Billable 533701 TRIAL PREP-A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING; LEGAL RESEARCH; DRAFT ADDITIONAL

JURY INSTRUCTIONS; REVIEW REVISIONS FROM CO-COUNSEL.

12/12/2019 DSM 960.00 0.50 480.00 Billable 533709 SETTLE-A CONFER WITH J. MANNING; E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING AND

CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW JOINT SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE

STATEMENT.

12/13/2019 DSM 960.00 0.70 672.00 Billable 533712 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW MOTIONS IN LIMINE AND APPLE'S DAUBERT MOTION.

12/16/2019 DSM 960.00 0.20 192.00 Billable 533720 TRIAL PREP-A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING AND CO-COUNSEL.

12/17/2019 DSM 960.00 1.00 960.00 Billable 533727 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW OPPOSITIONS TO MOTIONS IN LIMINE; E-MAIL WITH J. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 46 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 45

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt MANNING AND LEGAL RESEARCH REGARDING DAUBERT

OPPOSITION.

12/28/2019 DSM 960.00 0.20 192.00 Billable 533880 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW DAUBERT OPPOSITION.

1/9/2020 DSM 990.00 0.20 198.00 Billable 536212 TRIAL PREP-A REVIEW CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT AND

WITNESS LIST.

1/15/2020 DSM 990.00 0.20 198.00 Billable 536372 TRIAL PREP-A REVIEW ORDERS RE PRETRIAL CONFERENCE STATEMENT

DISPUTES AND MOTIONS IN LIMINE; REVIEW NOTICE OF

FURTHER SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE.

1/16/2020 DSM 990.00 0.20 198.00 Billable 536375 TRIAL PREP-A REVIEW PRETRIAL CONFERENCE ORDER AND AMENDED

WITNESS LIST.

1/17/2020 DSM 990.00 0.20 198.00 Billable 536382 TRIAL PREP-A REVIEW ORDER REGARDING TRIAL EVIDENCE LIMIT AND

WITNESS LIST.

1/29/2020 DSM 990.00 0.20 198.00 Billable 536428 SETTLE-A REVIEW MINUTE ORDER OF TELEPHONIC SETTLEMENT

CONFERENCE; E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING.

2/4/2020 DSM 990.00 0.20 198.00 Billable 538874 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE’S OBJECTIONS TO WITNESS LIST.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 47 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 46

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 2/10/2020 DSM 990.00 0.20 198.00 Billable 538952 SETTLE-A REVIEW JUDGE COUSINS MINUTE ENTRY AND JOINT NOTICE OF

SETTLEMENT.

2/18/2020 DSM 990.00 0.20 198.00 Billable 538964 SETTLE-A TELECON WITH A. STEYER REGARDING CLASS NOTICE ISSUES;

REVIEW STIPULATION REGARDING SETTLEMENT BRIEFING.

2/19/2020 DSM 990.00 0.20 198.00 Billable 538966 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW ORDER DENYING STIPULATION; TELECON WITH A.

STEYER.

3/1/2020 DSM 990.00 0.20 198.00 Billable 541524 SETTLE-A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING REGARDING PRELIMINARY

SETTLEMENT APPROVAL.

3/2/2020 DSM 990.00 0.20 198.00 Billable 541527 SETTLE-A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING AND A. STEYER REGARDING

PRELIMINARY SETTLEMENT APPROVAL.

3/6/2020 DSM 990.00 0.80 792.00 Billable 541493 TRIAL PREP-A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING; REVIEW SUMMARY JUDGMENT ORDER;

DRAFT PROPOSED FINDINGS OF FACT REGARDING UNFAIR

COMPETITION LAW CLAIM; REVIEW FILED PROPOSED FINDINGS

OF FACT.

3/15/2020 DSM 990.00 0.20 198.00 Billable 541600 SETTLE-A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING AND CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

SETTLEMENT.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 48 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 47

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 3/17/2020 DSM 990.00 0.20 198.00 Billable 541603 SETTLE-A E-MAIL WITH A. STEYER, D. WARSHAW, AND CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING SETTLEMENT.

3/19/2020 DSM 990.00 1.50 1,485.00 Billable 541592 SETTLE-A E-MAILS WITH J. MANNING, J. MOTTECK AND A. STEYER

REGARDING INSERT FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL MOTION;

DRAFT INSERT FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL MOTION; REVIEW

JOINT STATUS REPORT REGARDING SETTLEMENT.

3/20/2020 DSM 990.00 0.20 198.00 Billable 541563 SETTLE-A REVIEW ORDER REGARDING MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY

APPROVAL.

3/25/2020 DSM 990.00 1.00 990.00 Billable 541502 SETTLE-A LEGAL RESEARCH FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL BRIEF; E-MAIL

WITH J. MANNING AND A. STEYER; REVISE PRELIMINARY

APPROVAL BRIEF.

3/26/2020 DSM 990.00 1.50 1,485.00 Billable 541611 SETTLE-A E-MAIL WITH J. MANNING; LEGAL RESEARCH; REVISE MOTION

FOR PRELIMINARY SETTLEMENT APPROVAL.

3/27/2020 DSM 990.00 0.20 198.00 Billable 541509 SETTLE-A E-MAIL TO J. MANNING REGARDING CASE TO ADD TO

PRELIMINARY APPROVAL BRIEF.

4/27/2020 DSM 990.00 0.20 198.00 Billable 544221 SETTLE-A REVIEW MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY SETTLEMENT APPROVAL;

TELECON WITH A. STEYER. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-6 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 49 of 49 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:08 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 48

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

TOTAL Billable Fees 311.60 $282,065.00

Total of billable expense slips $0.00

Calculation of Fees and Costs

Amount Total Fees Bill Arrangement: Slips By billing value on each slip.

Total of billable time slips $282,065.00 Total of Fees (Time Charges) $282,065.00

Total of Costs (Expense Charges) $0.00

Total new charges $282,065.00

New Balance Current $282,065.00

Total New Balance $282,065.00

Funds Account: Default Previous account balance $0.00 Total added to account $0.00 Total removed from account $0.00

New account balance $0.00

Amount to replenish account to $0.00 $0.00

Attorney Summary

Attorney Rate Hours Charges Slip Value Adjustment DSM 990.00 8.00 $7,920.00 $7,920.00 0.00 DSM 960.00 24.80 $23,808.00 $23,808.00 0.00 DSM 920.00 128.20 $117,944.00 $117,944.00 0.00 DSM 895.00 97.40 $87,173.00 $87,173.00 0.00 DSM 850.00 53.20 $45,220.00 $45,220.00 0.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-7 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 142

EXHIBIT 5 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-7 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 142 STEYER LOWENTHAL BOODROOKAS 11/23/2020 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 1

Selection Criteria

Atto.Selection Include: JMM Clie.Selection Include: APPLE.FACETIME Slip.Transaction Date Earliest - 10/31/2020 Slip.Billing Status Billable Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 3 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 2

Nickname APPLE.FACETIME | 4457-CONT Full Name CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) Address CONSUMER CLASS ACTION - APPLE RE FACETIME FEATURE Phone 1 Phone 2 Phone 3 Phone 4 In Ref To APPLE, INC. - IN REGARDING FACETIME FEATURE Fees Arrg. By billing value on each slip Expense Arrg. By billing value on each slip Tax Profile Exempt Last bill Last charge 10/12/2020 Last payment Amount $0.00

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 11/9/2016 JMM 750.00 4.00 3,000.00 Billable 440457 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON POTENTIAL FACETIME MATTER AGAINST APPLE,

REVIEW S. JAIN'S MEMO, RESEARCH ON ASCERTAINABILITY.

11/14/2016 JMM 750.00 6.00 4,500.00 Billable 440459 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON POTENTIAL FACETIME MATTER AGAINST APPLE,

REVIEW DRAFT COMPLAINT, LEGAL RESEARCH ON CLAIMS AND

CLASS ISSUES; TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH A. STEYER AND

S. JAIN REGARDING SAME.

11/29/2016 JMM 750.00 4.50 3,375.00 Billable 440563 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON POTENTIAL CASE AGAINST APPLE, DRAFT CLASS

ALLEGATIONS.

11/30/2016 JMM 750.00 3.00 2,250.00 Billable 440642 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON POTENTIAL MATTER AGAINST APPLE REGARDING

FACETIME; RESEARCH ON CLASS CERTIFICATION, DRAFT CLASS

CERTIFICATION ALLEGATIONS.

12/5/2016 JMM 750.00 0.40 300.00 Billable 443612 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON POTENTIAL MATTER AGAINST APPLE REGARDING

FACETIME, PHONE CALLS WITH POTENTIAL CLIENTS.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 4 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 3

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 12/15/2016 JMM 750.00 2.50 1,875.00 Billable 443646 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON POTENTIAL MATTER AGAINST FACETIME, CAUSES

OF ACTION AND DRAFT COMPLAINT.

12/17/2016 JMM 750.00 0.40 300.00 Billable 443657 DISCOVERY-A COMMUNICATIONS WITH POTENTIAL CLIENT REGARDING CASE.

12/19/2016 JMM 750.00 3.50 2,625.00 Billable 443660 RESEARCH-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT COMPLAINT, REVIEW RESEARCH

MEMORANDA, RESEARCH ON ASCERTAINABILITY; E-MAIL TO S.

MACRAE REGARDING SAME.

12/20/2016 JMM 750.00 0.40 300.00 Billable 443662 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT COMPLAINT.

12/20/2016 JMM 750.00 0.30 225.00 Billable 443663 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH POTENTIAL CLIENT REGARDING

POTENTIAL CASE.

1/3/2017 JMM 800.00 1.20 960.00 Billable 445902 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW DRAFT COMPLAINT AND LEGAL RESEARCH ON UNJUST

ENRICHMENT.

1/4/2017 JMM 800.00 0.20 160.00 Billable 445912 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH S. MACRAE.

1/5/2017 JMM 800.00 0.40 320.00 Billable 445913 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT COMPLAINT.

1/5/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 445917 DISCOVERY-A COMMUNICATIONS WITH POTENTIAL CLIENT CHRIS GRACE Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 5 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 4

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt REGARDING CASE; TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH S. MACRAE.

1/11/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 445938 DISCOVERY-A COMMUNICATIONS WITH POTENTIAL CLIENTS IN FACETIME

MATTER.

1/13/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 445948 DISCOVERY-A MEETING WITH POTENTIAL FACETIME CLIENT REGARDING CASE.

1/13/2017 JMM 800.00 0.40 320.00 Billable 445950 CLIENT MEETING-A DRAFT ATTORNEY-CLIENT AGREEMENT AND MEET WITH CLIENT

REGARDING SAME IN FACETIME MATTER.

1/17/2017 JMM 800.00 1.40 1,120.00 Billable 445953 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT COMPLAINT.

1/21/2017 JMM 800.00 1.20 960.00 Billable 445969 CLIENT MEETING-A MEETING WITH POTENTIAL CLIENT, DISCUSS CASE, REVIEW FEE

AGREEMENT.

1/24/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 445978 CLIENT MEETING-A MEETING WITH CHRIS GRACE REGARDING DRAFT COMPLAINT

AND CLIENT DUTIES; E-MAIL TO S. MACRAE REGARDING SAME.

1/25/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 445983 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT COMPLAINT.

1/31/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 446006 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT COMPLAINT.

1/31/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 446007 CLIENT MEETING-A MEETING WITH CLIENT TO REVIEW AND APPROVE COMPLAINT IN Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 6 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 5

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

FACETIME MATTER.

2/1/2017 JMM 800.00 3.50 2,800.00 Billable 448371 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW, EDIT AND FINALIZE COMPLAINT; MEETING WITH S. JAIN

REGARDING SAME; E-MAILS TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME,

MEET WITH LINDA REGARDING SAME.

2/2/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 448382 PLDS/MO-A FINAL REVIEW AND EDIT OF COMPLAINT, AND CIVIL COVER

SHEET, PREPARE FOR FILING.

2/2/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 448388 CLIENT MEETING-A E-MAIL TO CLIENT REGARDING FILED COMPLAINT.

2/6/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 448400 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON POTENTIAL ARTICLE III JUDGES, REVIEW

MEMORANDA

2/7/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 448403 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON APPLE CASE DISMISSED BY DAVILA, REVIEW

CASES.

2/7/2017 JMM 800.00 2.50 2,000.00 Billable 448405 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON RECENT UNFAIR COMPETITION LAW CASES IN ND

CAL AND 9TH CIRCUIT; DRAFT MEMO REGARDING SAME.

2/7/2017 JMM 800.00 0.40 320.00 Billable 448409 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE FOR, MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

ASSIGNMENT TO MAGISTRATE JUDGE.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 7 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 6

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 2/10/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 448488 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON FACTUAL ISSUES IN CASE.

2/13/2017 JMM 800.00 2.50 2,000.00 Billable 448499 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON UNFAIR COMPETITION LAW CASES IN ND CAL AND

9TH CIRCUIT.

2/13/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 448507 RESEARCH-A REVISE - REVIEW AND EDIT LAURA'S MEMO REGARDING JUDGE

FOGEL, DISTRIBUTE TO CO-COUNSEL.

2/15/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 448518 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW MEMORANDA ON ARTICLE III ND JUDGES, PREPARE FOR,

CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CONSENT/DECLINE TO

MAGISTRATE COUSINS.

2/17/2017 JMM 800.00 2.40 1,920.00 Billable 448533 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON MOTIONS TO DISMISS UNFAIR COMPETITION LAW

CASES IN ND CAL AND 9TH CIRCUIT, DRAFT MEMO.

2/21/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 448586 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT AND SEND DISCOVERY TO CO-COUNSEL.

2/21/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 448589 CLIENT MEETING-A SEND CLIENT UPDATE ON CASE STATUS.

2/22/2017 JMM 800.00 2.50 2,000.00 Billable 448593 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON MOTION TO DISMISS UNFAIR COMPETITION LAW

AND TRESPASS TO CHATTELS CLAIMS IN ND CAL AND 9TH CIR.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 8 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 7

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 2/28/2017 JMM 800.00 3.00 2,400.00 Billable 448616 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON MOTIONS TO DISMISS UNFAIR COMPETITION LAW

AND TRESPASS TO CHATTELS CLAIMS IN ND CAL AND 9TH CIR.

3/3/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 450677 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT EVIDENCE PRESERVATION LETTER TO CLIENTS.

3/13/2017 JMM 800.00 1.40 1,120.00 Billable 450717 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT DISCOVERY AND CIRCULATE TO

CO-COUNSEL.

3/14/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 450722 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON RESTITUTION UNDER 17200.

3/21/2017 JMM 800.00 1.40 1,120.00 Billable 451366 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON STANDING TO ASSERT CLAIMS.

3/22/2017 JMM 800.00 3.00 2,400.00 Billable 451374 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH ON OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO DISMISS.

3/22/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 451377 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH S. MACRAE AND S. JAIN REGARDING

MOTION TO DISMISS.

3/22/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 451378 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW MOTION TO DISMISS, REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE

AND EXHIBITS.

3/23/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 451382 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH A. STEYER REGARDING APPLE MOTION

TO DISMISS. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 9 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 8

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

3/23/2017 JMM 800.00 4.50 3,600.00 Billable 451384 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH ON MOTION TO DISMISS; UPDATE MEMO REGARDING

OPPOSITION AND AMENDING COMPLAINT.

3/23/2017 JMM 800.00 1.40 1,120.00 Billable 451388 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH ON STANDING FOR OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO

DISMISS.

3/24/2017 JMM 800.00 4.50 3,600.00 Billable 451392 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH AND FINALIZE MEMO TO COUNSEL REGARDING

OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO DISMISS AND AMENDING

COMPLAINT; TELEPHONE CALL WITH S. MACRAE REGARDING

SAME.

3/24/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 451393 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING MOTION TO

DISMISS AND AMENDING COMPLAINT.

3/27/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 451403 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH COUNSEL REGARDING MOTION TO

DISMISS.

3/27/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 451404 CLIENT MEETING-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CLIENT GRACE REGARDING MOTION AND

AMENDING COMPLAINT.

3/27/2017 JMM 800.00 3.00 2,400.00 Billable 451406 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON STANDING TO ASSERT CLAIMS AND UNDER 17200.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 10 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 9

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 3/27/2017 JMM 800.00 2.50 2,000.00 Billable 451409 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT AMENDMENTS TO COMPLAINT.

3/28/2017 JMM 800.00 1.10 880.00 Billable 451412 CLIENT MEETING-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CLIENT POTTER REGARDING HIS

ALLEGATIONS AND AMENDING THE COMPLAINT.

3/28/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 451413 CLIENT MEETING-A MEETING WITH CLIENT GRACE REGARDING MOTION TO DISMISS

AND AMENDING COMPLAINT.

3/29/2017 JMM 800.00 3.50 2,800.00 Billable 451470 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT AMENDMENTS TO COMPLAINT.

3/29/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 451474 CLIENT MEETING-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CLIENT GRACE REGARDING AMENDED

COMPLAINT.

3/30/2017 JMM 800.00 4.00 3,200.00 Billable 451480 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH AND DRAFT AMENDMENTS TO COMPLAINT AND

CIRCULATE TO CO-COUNSEL.

3/30/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 451481 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEET WITH S. JAIN REGARDING RESEARCH ON RESTITUTION

UNDER 17200.

3/31/2017 JMM 800.00 1.10 880.00 Billable 451495 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW D.TEJTEL'S PROPOSED EDITS AND COMMENTS;

TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING AMENDED

COMPLAINT.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 11 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 10

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 3/31/2017 JMM 800.00 2.50 2,000.00 Billable 451496 PLDS/MO-A FURTHER AMENDMENTS TO COMPLAINT.

4/1/2017 JMM 800.00 0.40 320.00 Billable 453007 CLIENT MEETING-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CLIENT POTTER AND UPDATE CLIENT

MEMO.

4/2/2017 JMM 800.00 0.40 320.00 Billable 453008 CLIENT MEETING-A MEETING WITH CLIENT GRACE REGARDING AMENDED

COMPLAINT.

4/2/2017 JMM 800.00 0.40 320.00 Billable 453009 CLIENT MEETING-A EDITS TO CLIENT MEMORANDA.

4/2/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 453010 CLIENT MEETING-A DRAFT CLIENT MEMO.

4/3/2017 JMM 800.00 0.40 320.00 Billable 453011 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW D. TEJTEL'S EDITS TO THE AMENDED COMPLAINT,

INCORPORATE INTO MASTER DOCUMENT, SEND TO CLIENTS FOR

REVIEW.

4/3/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 453012 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH A. STEYER REGARDING CASE, MOTION

TO DISMISS AND AMENDED COMPLAINT.

4/3/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 453015 PLDS/MO-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL AND CONSULTANT

REGARDING AMENDED COMPLAINT, RESTITUTION AND MEASURE

OF DAMAGES.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 12 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 11

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 4/3/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 453016 RESEARCH-A REVIEW S. JAIN'S RESEARCH MEMO ON 17200 AND J. CASSADY'S

E-MAIL REGARDING SAME, READ CASES.

4/3/2017 JMM 800.00 0.40 320.00 Billable 453018 CLIENT MEETING-A COMMUNICATIONS WITH CLIENTS GRACE AND POTTER

REGARDING AMENDED COMPLAINT.

4/4/2017 JMM 800.00 2.50 2,000.00 Billable 453023 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT AMENDED COMPLAINT, E-MAIL TO

CO-COUNSEL.

4/4/2017 JMM 800.00 0.40 320.00 Billable 453024 CLIENT MEETING-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CLIENT POTTER REGARDING AMENDED

COMPLAINT.

4/5/2017 JMM 800.00 2.10 1,680.00 Billable 453028 PLDS/MO-A EDITS TO AMENDED COMPLAINT, SEND TO COUNSEL AND

CLIENT; TELEPHONE CALL WITH D. TEJTEL REGARDING SAME;

TELEPHONE CALL WITH CLIENT POTTER REGARDING SAME;

TELEPHONE CALL WITH S. JAIN REGARDING SAME.

4/6/2017 JMM 800.00 0.40 320.00 Billable 453035 DISCOVERY-A EDITS TO DRAFT DOCUMENT REQUEST TO APPLE.

4/7/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 453045 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW S. JAIN'S EDITS TO DRAFT DOCUMENT REQUEST, SEND

TO D. TEJTEL.

4/14/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 453380 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AUSTIN'S E-MAIL AND DRAFT LETTER REGARDING Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 13 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 12

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

PROTECTIVE ORDER IN VIRNETX.

4/17/2017 JMM 800.00 0.40 320.00 Billable 453064 CASEMNG-A REVIEW LOCAL RULES FOR INITIAL DISCLOSURES, REVIEW

COURT'S ORDER AND E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING MEET

AND CONFER DEADLINE.

4/17/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 453067 CASEMNG-A PREPARE FOR RULE 26(F) MEETING.

4/18/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 453077 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT PROTECTIVE ORDER.

4/19/2017 JMM 800.00 2.00 1,600.00 Billable 453081 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S MOTION TO DISMISS AND REQUEST FOR

JUDICIAL NOTICE; DRAFT OUTLINE OF OPPOSITION AND ASSIGN

FIRMS SECTIONS, CIRCULATE TO CO-COUNSEL.

4/20/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 453084 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING DRAFTING

OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO DISMISS; TELEPHONE CALL WITH S.

MACRAE REGARDING SAME; TELEPHONE CALL WITH S. JAIN

REGARDING SAME.

4/20/2017 JMM 800.00 3.00 2,400.00 Billable 453086 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH AND DRAFT OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO DISMISS.

4/21/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 453089 CASEMNG-A PREPARATION FOR RULE 26(F) MEETING.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 14 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 13

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 4/21/2017 JMM 800.00 5.00 4,000.00 Billable 453090 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH AND DRAFT OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO DISMISS.

4/24/2017 JMM 800.00 2.50 2,000.00 Billable 453099 CASEMNG-A PREPARE FOR RULE 26(F) MEETING; E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING SAME; E-MAIL TO CLIENTS REGARDING SAME.

4/24/2017 JMM 800.00 3.00 2,400.00 Billable 453100 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH AND DRAFT OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO DISMISS.

4/25/2017 JMM 800.00 2.50 2,000.00 Billable 453108 CASEMNG-A PREPARE FOR, RULE 26(F) MEETING, FOLLOW UP CALL WITH

CO-COUNSEL.

4/25/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 453109 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW LOCAL RULES, DRAFT STIPULATION REGARDING ADR;

REVIEW NORTHERN DISTRICT ADR GUIDELINES.

4/25/2017 JMM 800.00 0.40 320.00 Billable 453110 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW LOCAL RULES, DRAFT ADR CERTIFICATION; E-MAIL TO

CLIENTS REGARDING SAME.

4/25/2017 JMM 800.00 0.20 160.00 Billable 453111 CLIENT MEETING-A COMMUNICATIONS WITH CLIENTS GRACE AND POTTER

REGARDING ADR CERTIFICATION.

4/25/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 453113 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT;

DRAFT DISCOVERY PLAN, REVIEW LOCAL RULES.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 15 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 14

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 4/26/2017 JMM 800.00 3.00 2,400.00 Billable 453123 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH AND DRAFT OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO DISMISS.

4/26/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 453124 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL REGARDING

STIPULATION REGARDING ADR, REVIEW NOTICE OF NEED FOR

ADR PHONE CALL.

4/26/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 453126 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH AND DRAFT OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO DISMISS.

4/26/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 453127 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT S. JAIN'S SECTION OF OPPOSITION TO MOTION

TO DISMISS ON TRESPASS TO CHATTELS.

4/27/2017 JMM 800.00 3.00 2,400.00 Billable 453134 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT

AND DISCOVERY PLAN.

4/27/2017 JMM 800.00 3.00 2,400.00 Billable 453135 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO DISMISS.

4/28/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 453151 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT

AND SEND TO CO-COUNSEL FOR REVIEW.

4/28/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 453155 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON DISCOVERY WHILE MOTION TO DISMISS IS

PENDING.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 16 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 15

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 4/28/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 453156 PLDS/MO-A PREPARE EDITS TO JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE

STATEMENT, SEND TO APPLE FOR COMMENT.

4/28/2017 JMM 800.00 0.20 160.00 Billable 453158 DISCOVERY-A PREPARE EDITS TO INTERROGATORIES.

4/30/2017 JMM 800.00 2.00 1,600.00 Billable 453167 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO DISMISS.

5/1/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 454854 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH A. STEYER REGARDING CASE AND

MOTION TO DISMISS.

5/5/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 454868 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON DISCOVERY WHILE MOTION TO DISMISS IS

PENDING; PREPARE FOR CALL WITH APPLE REGARDING DRAFT

CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT.

5/5/2017 JMM 800.00 0.30 240.00 Billable 454870 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW DOCUMENT REQUEST, E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING SAME.

5/8/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 454876 DISCOVERY-A PREPARE CLIENTS' INITIAL DISCLOSURES.

5/8/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 454877 PLDS/MO-A EDITS TO DRAFT JOINT CMS ON DISCOVERY AND PRESERVATION.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 17 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 16

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 5/8/2017 JMM 800.00 1.20 960.00 Billable 454881 CASEMNG-A PREPARE FOR, MEETING WITH APPLE REGARDING JOINT CMS.

5/8/2017 JMM 800.00 0.20 160.00 Billable 454882 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW DRAFT CERTIFICATES OF INTERESTED PARTIES, REVIEW

LOCAL RULES, EDIT FOR FILING.

5/9/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 454885 DISCOVERY-A FINALIZE INITIAL DISCLOSURES, REVIEW COMPLAINT FOR

WITNESSES, SERVE.

5/9/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 454886 CASEMNG-A FINALIZE DRAFT JOINT CMS AND SEND TO APPLE.

5/9/2017 JMM 800.00 0.40 320.00 Billable 454887 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AND EDIT INTERROGATORIES, SEND TO CO-COUNSEL,

REVIEW RULES ON SUBPARTS.

5/10/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 454894 CASEMNG-A REVIEW APPLE'S MULTIPLE ADDITIONS AND EDITS TO JOINT CMS,

REVIEW CASES, DRAFT RESPONSE, EDIT; TELEPHONE CALL WITH

APPLE'S COUNSEL REGARDING SAME, FINALIZE, FILE.

5/10/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 454896 CASEMNG-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING JOINT CMS.

5/11/2017 JMM 800.00 1.40 1,120.00 Billable 454899 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT ESI PROTOCOL, SEND TO CO-COUNSEL.

5/11/2017 JMM 800.00 2.00 1,600.00 Billable 454900 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S REPLY ON MOTION TO DISMISS AND READ Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 18 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 17

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt CASES, REVIEW E-MAIL FROM AUSTIN REGARDING SAME.

5/11/2017 JMM 800.00 2.00 1,600.00 Billable 454901 RESEARCH-A READ CASES CITED BY APPLE IN JOINT CMS REGARDING DISCO

STAY.

5/12/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 454905 CT APPR - A ADR PHONE CALL WITH COURT.

5/12/2017 JMM 800.00 3.00 2,400.00 Billable 454906 DISCOVERY-A REVISE DRAFT ESI PROTOCOL, REVIEW COURT'S MODEL.

5/12/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 454909 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON STAY OF DISCOVERY WHILE MOTION TO DISMISS

PENDING, REVIEW APPLE'S CASES.

5/15/2017 JMM 800.00 0.40 320.00 Billable 455961 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT ESI STIPULATION, FINALIZE, E-MAIL TO

APPLE'S COUNSEL FOR REVIEW.

5/15/2017 JMM 800.00 2.10 1,680.00 Billable 455964 CASEMNG-A PREPARE FOR CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE.

5/16/2017 JMM 800.00 2.20 1,760.00 Billable 455967 CASEMNG-A PREPARE FOR CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE, TELEPHONE

CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

5/16/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 455970 CASEMNG-A EDITS TO PROPOSED CASE SCHEDULE, REVIEW KOH

SCHEDULES IN OTHER CASES.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 19 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 18

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 5/17/2017 JMM 800.00 7.50 6,000.00 Billable 455975 CT APPR - A TRAVEL TO AND FROM SAN JOSE, MEETING WITH APPLE

REGARDING CASE SCHEDULE, CASE MANAGEMENT

CONFERENCE, MEETING WITH BRUCE SIMON FOLLOWING CASE

MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE.

5/17/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 455976 CASEMNG-A PREPARE FOR CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE.

5/22/2017 JMM 800.00 0.20 160.00 Billable 455998 CASEMNG-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE

MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE AND CASE.

5/22/2017 JMM 800.00 0.20 160.00 Billable 455999 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH AUSTIN CURRY REGARDING

CUSTODIANS.

5/22/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 456000 DISCOVERY-A RESEARCH ON POTENTIAL CUSTODIANS AND PREPARATION FOR

MEET AND CONFER REGARDING SAME.

5/23/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 456009 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT PROTECTIVE ORDER AND SEND TO

APPLE AND REQUEST TIME TO MEET AND CONFER REGARDING

SAME.

5/23/2017 JMM 800.00 1.20 960.00 Billable 456010 DISCOVERY-A PREPARE LIST OF CUSTODIANS.

5/24/2017 JMM 800.00 0.20 160.00 Billable 456026 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH AUSTIN CURRY REGARDING AMENDING Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 20 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 19

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

INITIAL DISCLOSURES AND CUSTODIANS.

5/24/2017 JMM 800.00 1.40 1,120.00 Billable 456027 DISCOVERY-A RESEARCH ON DOCUMENT CUSTODIANS.

5/25/2017 JMM 800.00 1.10 880.00 Billable 456040 DISCOVERY-A PREPARE AND CIRCULATE TO CO-COUNSEL AMENDED

DISCLOSURES, INSERT EDITS FROM DAVID TEJTEL.

5/26/2017 JMM 800.00 0.30 240.00 Billable 456051 CASEMNG-A REVIEW TRANSCRIPT OF CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE,

SEND TO CO-COUNSEL.

5/30/2017 JMM 800.00 2.00 1,600.00 Billable 456074 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH - REVIEW D. TEJTEL'S OUTLINE OF STANDING

ARGUMENT IN APPLE'S REPLY, REVIEW CASES.

5/31/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 456099 DISCOVERY-A RESEARCH ON APPLE'S WITNESSES IDENTIFIED IN INITIAL

DISCLOSURES.

6/1/2017 JMM 800.00 1.10 880.00 Billable 457848 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE FOR, MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL

REGARDING ESI STIPULATION AND PROTECTIVE ORDER;

TELEPHONE CALL WITH WARSHAW REGARDING SAME.

6/1/2017 JMM 800.00 1.40 1,120.00 Billable 457849 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON CUSTODIANS AND EDITS TO ESI STIPULATION.

6/1/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 457853 CLIENT MEETING-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CLIENT, POTTER, REGARDING Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 21 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 20

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

PRESERVATION OBLIGATIONS.

6/1/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 457854 CLIENT MEETING-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH GRACE REGARDING PRESERVATION

OBLIGATIONS.

6/1/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 457856 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON POTENTIAL CUSTODIANS.

6/2/2017 JMM 800.00 1.10 880.00 Billable 457860 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW APPLE'S PROPOSED EDITS TO ESI STIPULATION AND

PROTECTIVE ORDER AND SEND E-MAIL IN RESPONSE.

6/5/2017 JMM 800.00 3.10 2,480.00 Billable 457863 DISCOVERY-A COMPARE APPLE'S EDITS TO ESI STIPULATION AND PROTECTIVE

ORDER TO ND CAL MODEL FORMS; RESEARCH ON SCOPE OF

PRESERVATION; TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING SAME.

6/6/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 457867 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT LETTER TO APPLE REGARDING ESI STIPULATION,

CUSTODIANS AND PROTECTIVE ORDER; TELEPHONE CALL WITH

DAN WARSHAW REGARDING SAME.

6/6/2017 JMM 800.00 1.20 960.00 Billable 457868 DISCOVERY-A EDITS TO ESI STIPULATION AND PROTECTIVE ORDER.

6/6/2017 JMM 800.00 2.20 1,760.00 Billable 457870 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL REGARDING ESI

STIPULATION AND PROTECTIVE ORDER; FOLLOW UP E-MAIL. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 22 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 21

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

6/7/2017 JMM 800.00 1.10 880.00 Billable 457875 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT STIPULATION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILE ESI

STIPULATION AND PROTECTIVE ORDER AND SEND TO APPLE'S

COUNSEL FOR REVIEW; EDIT; FINALIZE AND FILE.

6/8/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 457882 DISCOVERY-A REVISE PROTECTIVE ORDER AND SEND TO APPLE'S COUNSEL.

6/12/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 457904 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEETING WITH A. STEYER REGARDING CASE.

6/12/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 457908 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW ESI STIPULATION; TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING SAME.

6/13/2017 JMM 800.00 1.10 880.00 Billable 457922 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW APPLE'S EDITS TO ESI STIPULATION; TELEPHONE CALL

WITH CO-COUNSEL AND E-MAILS REGARDING SAME.

6/14/2017 JMM 800.00 1.20 960.00 Billable 457934 PLDS/MO-A EDIT AND FINALIZE ESI STIPULATION; SEND TO APPLE; FILE.

6/14/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 457936 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL REGARDING ESI AND

PREPARATION OF.

6/14/2017 JMM 800.00 0.40 320.00 Billable 457937 RESEARCH-A REVIEW APPLE'S RESTRICTED COMPETITOR LIST; DISCUSS SAME

WITH A. STEYER; TELEPHONE CALL WITH JASON CASSADY,

E-MAIL TO CONSULTANT. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 23 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 22

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

6/16/2017 JMM 800.00 0.20 160.00 Billable 457960 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CONSULTANT REGARDING RESTRICTED

COMPETITORS LIST.

6/16/2017 JMM 800.00 1.10 880.00 Billable 457963 PLDS/MO-A EDIT AND FINALIZE PROTECTIVE ORDER, SEND TO APPLE, FILE.

6/19/2017 JMM 800.00 3.00 2,400.00 Billable 457985 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S REPLY BRIEF ON MOTION TO DISMISS, REVIEW

CASES, PREPARE OUTLINE OF ORAL ARGUMENT.

6/23/2017 JMM 800.00 2.50 2,000.00 Billable 458032 RESEARCH-A REVIEW S. JAIN'S OUTLINE OF TRESPASS TO CHATTELS

ARGUMENT FOR MOTION TO DISMISS HEARING, READ CASES.

6/23/2017 JMM 800.00 2.10 1,680.00 Billable 458033 RESEARCH-A REVIEW S. MACRAE'S OUTLINE OF UNFAIR COMPETITION LAW

ARGUMENT FOR MOTION TO DISMISS HEARING, READ CASES.

6/26/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 458505 CLIENT MEETING-A E-MAIL TO CLIENT POTTER REGARDING CASE STATUS.

6/26/2017 JMM 800.00 1.30 1,040.00 Billable 458506 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW MOTION TO DISMISS PAPERS AND PREPARE FOR

HEARING, READ CASES.

6/29/2017 JMM 800.00 4.00 3,200.00 Billable 458545 PLDS/MO-A PREPARE OUTLINE FOR MOTION TO DISMISS ARGUMENT,

REVIEW CASES.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 24 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 23

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 7/24/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 461284 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH SCOTT MACRAE REGARDING CASE.

7/24/2017 JMM 800.00 5.00 4,000.00 Billable 461289 CT APPR - A PREPARE ORAL ARGUMENT FOR HEARING ON MOTION TO

DISMISS.

7/28/2017 JMM 800.00 0.40 320.00 Billable 461308 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW KOH'S ORDER DENYING MOTION TO DISMISS, E-MAIL TO

COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

7/31/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 461309 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS.

7/31/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 461315 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT LIST OF ACTION ITEMS FOR CASE; PREPARE FOR

MEETING WITH COUNSEL.

7/31/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 461317 CLIENT MEETING-A MEET WITH CLIENT GRACE REGARDING CASE STATUS AND

MOTION TO DISMISS ORDER.

8/2/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 462034 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE AGENDA FOR, CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING CASE STATUS AND ASSIGNMENTS GOING FORWARD.

8/2/2017 JMM 800.00 0.20 160.00 Billable 462035 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT AND SEND E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

LITIGATION TEAMS AND TO-DO LIST.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 25 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 24

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 8/2/2017 JMM 800.00 2.00 1,600.00 Billable 462036 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT DISCOVERY PLAN FOR CASE.

8/2/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 462038 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL TO APPLE'S COUNSEL REGARDING DISCOVERY.

8/2/2017 JMM 800.00 0.20 160.00 Billable 462039 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH A. CURRY REGARDING DISCOVERY AND

EXPERTS.

8/3/2017 JMM 800.00 2.50 2,000.00 Billable 462045 CASEMNG-A DRAFT JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT AND DISCOVERY

PLAN.

8/7/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 462059 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT SEARCH TERMS.

8/7/2017 JMM 800.00 3.00 2,400.00 Billable 462060 CASEMNG-A DRAFT JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT AND DISCOVERY

PLAN; REVIEW DOCUMENT REQUEST AND CREATE PLAN TO

PRIORITIZE EARLY DISCOVERY.

8/8/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 462069 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

DISCOVERY AND EXPERTS.

8/8/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 462072 CASEMNG-A DRAFT AND EDIT DRAFT JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT

AND SEND TO APPLE.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 26 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 25

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 8/9/2017 JMM 800.00 0.20 160.00 Billable 462078 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL REGARDING SEARCH

TERMS AND DISCOVERY, E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

SAME

8/11/2017 JMM 800.00 2.50 2,000.00 Billable 462100 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW MEMO REGARDING PROBLEMS WITH UPGRADING TO

IOS7, REVIEW CUSTOMER COMPLAINTS, ADDITIONAL FACTUAL

RESEARCH.

8/14/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 462109 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW APPLE'S EDITS TO DRAFT JOINT CMS AND PREPARE FOR

MEET AND CONFER, MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE

REGARDING DRAFT JOINT CMS AND DISCOVERY, FOLLOW UP

CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

8/14/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 462110 PLDS/MO-A FURTHER EDITS TO DRAFT JOINT CMS AND RESPOND TO

APPLE'S STATEMENTS.

8/15/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 462271 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW LEGAL ASSISTANT'S MEMO REGARDING EVIDENCE OF

PROBLEMS FROM UPGRADING TO IOS7 AND OTHER ISSUES.

8/16/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 462284 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S EDITS TO JOINT CMS; E-MAILS TO CO-COUNSEL;

EDITS; PREPARE FOR FILING, FILE.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 27 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 26

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 8/16/2017 JMM 800.00 2.00 1,600.00 Billable 462286 DISCOVERY-A RESEARCH ON POTENTIAL WITNESSES.

8/17/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 462293 EXPERTS-A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH POTENTIAL EXPERT REGARDING

CASE.

8/25/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 463055 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH S. JAIN REGARDING CASE.

8/25/2017 JMM 800.00 1.20 960.00 Billable 463096 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AND EDIT INTERROGATORIES; E-MAILS TO COUNSEL

REGARDING SAME.

8/25/2017 JMM 800.00 1.10 880.00 Billable 463097 DISCOVERY-A TUTORIAL WITH DISCO; E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

SAME.

8/28/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 463045 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW APPLE'S PROPOSED MODIFICATIONS TO SEARCH TERMS.

8/28/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 463068 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW APPLE'S RESPONSES AND OBJECTIONS TO DOCUMENT

REQUEST.

8/29/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 463087 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SEARCH

TERMS, OBJECTIONS AND RESPONSES TO DOCUMENT REQUEST

AND INTERROGATORIES; MEET WITH S. JAIN REGARDING SAME.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 28 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 27

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 8/30/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 463423 EXPERTS-A PREPARE FOR AND TELEPHONE CALL WITH POTENTIAL EXPERT

DR. JUSTINE HASTINGS; E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

SAME.

8/30/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 463431 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW APPLE'S RESPONSES TO DOCUMENT REQUEST AND

CHART OUTLINING SAME, PREPARE FOR MEET AND CONFER.

9/1/2017 JMM 800.00 1.20 960.00 Billable 463968 DISCOVERY-A MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE REGARDING DRAFT SEARCH

TERMS AND RESPONSES TO DOCUMENT REQUEST.

9/1/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 463985 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH A. CURRY AND D. TEJTEL IN

PREPARATION FOR MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE REGARDING

DRAFT SEARCH TERMS AND RESPONSES TO DOCUMENT

REQUEST.

9/5/2017 JMM 800.00 0.20 160.00 Billable 463974 EXPERTS-A TELEPHONE CALL CO-COUNSEL AND POTENTIAL EXPERT.

9/11/2017 JMM 800.00 0.20 160.00 Billable 464306 CT APPR - A PHONE CALL WITH ADR COORDINATOR.

9/12/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 464294 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH INVENTUS AND CO-COUNSEL ABOUT

DOCUMENT REPOSITORY.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 29 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 28

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 9/13/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 464297 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW DOCUMENTS PRODUCED BY APPLE.

9/13/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 464309 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL; EDITS TO DRAFT MEET

AND CONFER LETTER.

9/14/2017 JMM 800.00 2.00 1,600.00 Billable 464300 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW DOCUMENTS PRODUCED BY APPLE AND MAKE EDITS TO

WITNESS LIST.

9/18/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 464816 EXPERTS-A TELEPHONE CALL A. STEYER REGARDING POTENTIAL EXPERT

FOR THIS MATTER.

9/18/2017 JMM 800.00 0.20 160.00 Billable 464834 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL WITH AGENDA FOR CONFERENCE CALL

TO DISCUSS OUTSTANDING MATTERS.

9/18/2017 JMM 800.00 1.10 880.00 Billable 464835 RESEARCH-A REVIEW YOUTUBE VIDEOS AND ON LINE COMPLAINTS ABOUT

IPHONE 4 AND 4S RUNNING IOS7, EDITS TO P. GRAVLEY'S MEMO,

E-MAIL MEMO TO CO-COUNSEL.

9/19/2017 JMM 800.00 2.50 2,000.00 Billable 464818 DOC REVIEW-A REVIEW DOCUMENTS PRODUCED BY POTENTIAL APPLE

WITNESSES AND UPDATE WITNESS LISTS.

9/19/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 464830 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE FOR, TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING OUTSTANDING ISSUES. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 30 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 29

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

9/19/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 464839 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW A. CURRY E-MAIL.

9/20/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 464822 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW DOCUMENTS AND MEETING WITH P. GRAVLEY TO

CREATE HOT DOCUMENTS BINDER.

9/20/2017 JMM 800.00 2.00 1,600.00 Billable 464824 DISCOVERY-A CREATE CODING CATEGORIES FOR DOCUMENT REVIEW.

9/20/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 464836 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW EDITS TO SEARCH TERMS, E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING SAME.

9/20/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 464837 RESEARCH-A REVIEW NEW CASE FROM ED CAL ABOUT PRODUCING

DISCOVERY WHILE NEGOTIATING SEARCH TERMS AND SEND TO

CO-COUNSEL.

9/20/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 464838 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT AND EDIT PROPOSED CODING CATEGORIES, SEND TO

CO-COUNSEL.

9/21/2017 JMM 800.00 0.20 160.00 Billable 464804 EXPERTS-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH POTENTIAL EXPERT REGARDING

MATTER.

9/21/2017 JMM 800.00 0.40 320.00 Billable 464805 EXPERTS-A REVIEW PROTECTIVE ORDER AND LANGUAGE REGARDING

COMPETITIVE EXPERT; DRAFT EXPERT RETAINER AGREEMENT. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 31 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 30

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

9/21/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 464806 DISCOVERY-A EDITS TO CODING CATEGORIES, SEND TO INVENTUS.

9/25/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 465580 DOC REVIEW-A PREPARE KIT FOR DOCUMENT REVIEW TRAINING.

9/25/2017 JMM 800.00 0.20 160.00 Billable 465594 EXPERTS-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH POTENTIAL EXPERT.

9/27/2017 JMM 800.00 2.00 1,600.00 Billable 465609 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING MEET AND

CONFER WITH APPLE, REVIEW DRAFT POSITION, REVIEW AND

EDIT PROPOSED TIME PERIODS FOR SEARCH TERMS, SEND TO

CO-COUNSEL.

9/29/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 465567 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW CO-COUNSEL'S PROPOSED EDITS TO DATE RANGES,

PROVIDE EDITS AND COMMENTS, E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL.

9/29/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 465568 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW APPLE'S RESPONSES AND OBJECTIONS TO

INTERROGATORIES.

9/29/2017 JMM 800.00 0.40 320.00 Billable 465612 DOC REVIEW-A INVENTUS RELATIVITY TRAINING.

10/2/2017 JMM 800.00 1.20 960.00 Billable 467680 DOC REVIEW-A PREPARE DOCUMENTS FOR DOCUMENT REVIEW PREPARATION

KIT; TELEPHONE CALL WITH WARSHAW REGARDING SAME;

TELEPHONE CALL WITH TEJTEL REGARDING SAME. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 32 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 31

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

10/2/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 467774 DOC REVIEW-A MEETING WITH MATT MASTERSON FROM INVENTUS REGARDING

DOCUMENT REVIEW.

10/3/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 467709 DOC REVIEW-A MEETING WITH MATTHEW MASTERSON OF INVENTUS

REGARDING DOCUMENT REVIEW.

10/4/2017 JMM 800.00 0.20 160.00 Billable 467781 DOC REVIEW-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH S. JAIN REGARDING DOCUMENT REVIEW;

E-MAIL TO COUNSEL REGARDING DOCUMENT REVIEW.

10/4/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 467786 DOC REVIEW-A PREPARE PACKET FOR DOCUMENT REVIEW TRAINING.

10/4/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 467787 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AND UPDATE ISSUE CODES.

10/5/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 467720 EXPERTS-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH POTENTIAL EXPERT.

10/6/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 467686 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT LIST OF THIRD PARTY DISCOVERY.

10/9/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 467725 DOC REVIEW-A E-MAIL DOCUMENT REVIEWERS REGARDING DOCUMENT REVIEW

TRAINING AND SEND MATERIALS.

10/10/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 467796 DOC REVIEW-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH KRIS DIGIOVANNI REGARDING APPLE Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 33 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 32

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt CASE AND DOCUMENT REVIEW.

10/11/2017 JMM 800.00 1.20 960.00 Billable 467629 DOC REVIEW-A PREPARE DOCUMENT CODING CHEAT SHEET AND TELEPHONE

CALL WITH DOCUMENT REVIEWERS REGARDING DOCUMENT

REVIEW.

10/11/2017 JMM 800.00 1.10 880.00 Billable 467646 ATTYMTG.STR - A WEEKLY MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE.

10/11/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 467800 DOC REVIEW-A MEETING WITH P. GRAVLEY REGARDING DOCUMENT REVIEW.

10/12/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 467656 EXPERTS-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT EXPERT AGREEMENT; E-MAIL TO

CO-COUNSEL FOR REVIEW.

10/13/2017 JMM 800.00 2.00 1,600.00 Billable 467696 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM APPLE, DRAFT E-MAIL IN RESPONSE;

E-MAILS TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

10/13/2017 JMM 800.00 2.00 1,600.00 Billable 467728 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW COURT'S STANDING ORDER AND ESI PROTOCOL AND

LEGAL RESEARCH ON MOTION TO COMPEL.

10/16/2017 JMM 800.00 0.20 160.00 Billable 467731 EXPERTS-A EDITS TO EXPERT AGREEMENT; SEND TO CO-COUNSEL; SEND TO

EXPERT.

10/17/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 467582 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE REGARDING OUTSTANDING Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 34 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 33

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt DISCOVERY ISSUES; FOLLOW UP CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING SAME.

10/18/2017 JMM 800.00 0.40 320.00 Billable 467654 ATTYMTG.STR - A WEEKLY MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE.

10/19/2017 JMM 800.00 2.00 1,600.00 Billable 467580 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT LETTER BRIEF MOTION TO COMPEL.

10/23/2017 JMM 800.00 2.00 1,600.00 Billable 467692 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AND DRAFT RESPONSES TO APPLE'S REQUEST FOR

PRODUCTION AND INTERROGATORIES TO PLAINTIFFS.

10/23/2017 JMM 800.00 3.00 2,400.00 Billable 467734 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT JOINT CMS AND CIRCULATE TO COUNSEL; TELEPHONE

CALL WITH APPLE REGARDING SAME; EDITS TO JOINT CMS AND

SEND TO APPLE.

10/24/2017 JMM 800.00 2.00 1,600.00 Billable 467663 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT MOTION TO COMPEL LETTER BRIEF AND SEND TO

CO-COUNSEL; REVIEW APPLE'S SECTION, REVIEW EXHIBITS.

10/25/2017 JMM 800.00 1.20 960.00 Billable 467586 PLDS/MO-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCES WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL, EDIT,

FINALIZE AND FILE JOINT CMS.

10/27/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 467588 PLDS/MO-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL REGARDING LETTER

BRIEF MOTION TO COMPEL.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 35 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 34

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 10/27/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 467753 PLDS/MO-A EDITS TO LETTER MOTION TO COMPEL AND UPDATE EXHIBIT

LIST; E-MAIL TO A. CURRY REGARDING FILING UNDER SEAL,

DRAFT ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION.

10/30/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 467593 CLIENT MEETING-A COMMUNICATIONS WITH CLIENTS GRACE AND POTTER

REGARDING MEETING TO DISCUSS DISCOVERY RESPONSES.

10/30/2017 JMM 800.00 0.20 160.00 Billable 467743 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL TO DISCUSS LETTER

BRIEF.

10/30/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 467756 ATTYMTG.STR - A DRAFT AGENDA FOR COUNSEL MEETING ON 11/1.

10/30/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 467757 PLDS/MO-A EDITS TO JOINT LETTER BRIEF, SEND TO APPLE'S COUNSEL.

10/31/2017 JMM 800.00 3.00 2,400.00 Billable 467705 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE FOR MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

11/1/2017 JMM 800.00 3.50 2,800.00 Billable 470337 ATTYMTG.STR - A IN-PERSON MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE

STRATEGY.

11/1/2017 JMM 800.00 2.50 2,000.00 Billable 470338 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 36 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 35

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 11/1/2017 JMM 800.00 2.00 1,600.00 Billable 470400 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE FOR MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

11/2/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 470379 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT RESPONSES TO APPLE'S INTERROGATORIES AND

DOCUMENT REQUESTS TO PLAINTIFFS.

11/2/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 470405 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S EDITS TO JOINT LETTER BRIEF; E-MAIL TO

CO-COUNSEL; E-MAIL TO APPLE; REVIEW AND EDIT

ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION AND PROPOSED ORDER.

11/2/2017 JMM 800.00 2.00 1,600.00 Billable 470418 CLIENT MEETING-A MEETING WITH CLIENT CHRISTINA GRACE TO REVIEW APPLE'S

DISCOVERY AND PREPARE RESPONSES.

11/3/2017 JMM 800.00 2.00 1,600.00 Billable 470421 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S EDITS TO JOINT LETTER BRIEF AND EXHIBITS;

EDITS TO ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION AND PREPARATION OF,

DRAFT CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE; TELEPHONE CALL WITH S. JAIN

REGARDING SAME; TELEPHONE CALL WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL

REGARDING SAME; FINALIZE FOR FILING.

11/6/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 470426 DISCOVERY-A RESEARCH AND DRAFT OBJECTIONS AND RESPONSES TO

APPLE'S DISCOVERY TO PLAINTIFFS.

11/7/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 470401 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL TO DISCUSS

DISCOVERY HEARING. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 37 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 36

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

11/7/2017 JMM 800.00 0.20 160.00 Billable 470403 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH SCOTT MACRAE REGARDING CASE.

11/7/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 470411 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT PROPOSED ORDER ON DISCOVERY

LETTER BRIEFS.

11/8/2017 JMM 800.00 2.00 1,600.00 Billable 470404 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT OBJECTIONS AND RESPONSES TO APPLE'S DISCOVERY

TO PLAINTIFFS.

11/8/2017 JMM 800.00 0.40 320.00 Billable 470412 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW D. TEJTEL'S E-MAIL; REVIEW REVISED DRAFT AND E-MAIL

TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME; REVIEW APPLE'S

PROPOSED ORDER.

11/8/2017 JMM 800.00 0.20 160.00 Billable 470425 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH S. JAIN AND A. CURRY REGARDING

APPLE'S PROPOSED ORDER AND HEARING STRATEGY.

11/13/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 470348 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW PROPOSED ORDER; E-MAIL TO COUNSEL REGARDING

SAME; TELEPHONE CALL WITH S. JAIN REGARDING SAME.

11/13/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 470388 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT RESPONSES AND OBJECTIONS TO APPLE'S DISCOVERY;

SEND TO PLAINTIFFS FOR REVIEW.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 38 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 37

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 11/13/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 470389 EXPERTS-A REVIEW DATA FOR EXPERT.

11/14/2017 JMM 800.00 0.20 160.00 Billable 470328 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW PROPOSED ORDER ON DISCOVERY DISPUTE AND

TELEPHONE CALL WITH S. JAIN REGARDING SAME.

11/14/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 470352 CLIENT MEETING-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CLIENT POTTER REGARDING

RESPONSES TO INTERROGATORIES.

11/15/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 470336 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT AND EDIT PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSES TO APPLE'S

DOCUMENT REQUEST, SEND TO CO-COUNSEL FOR REVIEW.

11/16/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 470335 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE FOR, WEEKLY MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

11/16/2017 JMM 800.00 1.10 880.00 Billable 470340 DISCOVERY-A EDITS TO PLAINTIFFS' DISCOVERY RESPONSES; TELEPHONE

CALL WITH S. JAIN REGARDING SAME.

11/16/2017 JMM 800.00 0.20 160.00 Billable 470408 EXPERTS-A COMMUNICATION WITH EXPERT REGARDING CASE.

11/17/2017 JMM 800.00 2.00 1,600.00 Billable 470356 EXPERTS-A REVIEW DOCUMENTS PRODUCED BY APPLE FOR EXPERT

REVIEW.

11/17/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 470427 CLIENT MEETING-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH POTTER AND E-MAILS TO BOTH CLIENTS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 39 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 38

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt REGARDING DISCOVERY RESPONSES.

11/17/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 470428 DISCOVERY-A EDIT AND FINALIZE DISCOVERY RESPONSES; SEND TO S. JAIN

FOR SERVICE.

11/20/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 470362 DISCOVERY-A MEET AND CONFER CALL WITH APPLE REGARDING

INTERROGATORIES AND DISCOVERY ISSUES.

11/20/2017 JMM 800.00 2.50 2,000.00 Billable 470365 EXPERTS-A REVIEW DOCUMENTS FOR EXPERT REGARDING DIMINUTION IN

VALUE.

11/28/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 470349 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT NOTICE OF 30(B)(6) DEPOSITION.

11/29/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 470377 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

11/29/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 470397 ATTYMTG.STR - A CIRCULATE AGENDA FOR LITIGATION MEETING CALL.

11/30/2017 JMM 800.00 2.00 1,600.00 Billable 470327 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON DAMAGES MODEL.

11/30/2017 JMM 800.00 2.00 1,600.00 Billable 470385 EXPERTS-A REVIEW MATERIALS TO SEND TO EXPERT; REVIEW MATERIALS

FROM EXPERT.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 40 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 39

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 12/1/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 472426 EXPERTS-A PREPARE MATERIALS FOR EXPERT.

12/4/2017 JMM 800.00 2.50 2,000.00 Billable 472413 EXPERTS-A REVIEW EXPERT DATA REGARDING DAMAGES.

12/6/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 472434 ATTYMTG.STR - A WEEKLY LITIGATION STRATEGY MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

12/7/2017 JMM 800.00 3.00 2,400.00 Billable 472395 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON CLASS CERTIFICATION DAMAGES STANDARD,

REVIEW KOH'S RECENT CLASS CERTIFICATION DECISIONS.

12/7/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 472440 EXPERTS-A REVIEW EXPERT DATA;TELEPHONE CALL WITH EXPERT

REGARDING SAME.

12/11/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 472409 EXPERTS-A PREPARE FOR MEETING WITH EXPERT.

12/11/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 472414 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT AND CIRCULATE STIPULATION EXTENDING CASE

SCHEDULE, EDIT AND SEND TO APPLE.

12/13/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 472472 EXPERTS-A REVIEW MATERIALS PROVIDED BY EXPERT IN PREPARATION OF

CALL WITH EXPERT.

12/13/2017 JMM 800.00 0.20 160.00 Billable 472473 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S EDITS TO STIPULATION TO EXTEND CASE

SCHEDULE; E-MAIL TO S. JAIN REGARDING SAME, REVIEW FOR Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 41 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 40

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt FILING.

12/13/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 472497 EXPERTS-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH EXPERT REGARDING CASE AND

FOLLOW UP CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

12/16/2017 JMM 800.00 3.00 2,400.00 Billable 472419 CLIENT MEETING-A MEETING WITH CLIENT TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS RESPONSIVE

TO APPLE'S REQUEST.

12/20/2017 JMM 800.00 0.40 320.00 Billable 472502 ATTYMTG.STR - A WEEKLY MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

12/21/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 472450 CLIENT MEETING-A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH CLIENT POTTER REGARDING

DOCUMENT PRODUCTION AND CASE UPDATE.

12/21/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 472504 EXPERTS-A MEETING WITH EXPERT TO REVIEW APPLE'S SOURCE CODE.

12/22/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 472474 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE.

12/22/2017 JMM 800.00 0.20 160.00 Billable 472486 CLIENT MEETING-A TELEPHONE CONVERSATIONS WITH PLAINTIFF GRACE

REGARDING APPLE'S DOCUMENT REQUEST.

12/22/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 472489 DISCOVERY-A PREPARE FOR, MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE REGARDING

PLAINTIFFS' DISCOVERY RESPONSES.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 42 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 41

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 12/27/2017 JMM 800.00 1.10 880.00 Billable 472410 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT LETTER BRIEF REGARDING DISCOVERY

ISSUES, E-MAILS TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

12/27/2017 JMM 800.00 1.50 1,200.00 Billable 472423 EXPERTS-A REVIEW DOCUMENTS CODED FOR EXPERT REVIEW, PREPARE

FOR MEETING WITH EXPERT.

12/29/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 472445 EXPERTS-A PREPARE FOR, REVIEW MEMO, CALL WITH EXPERT.

12/29/2017 JMM 800.00 0.50 400.00 Billable 472446 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL.

12/29/2017 JMM 800.00 1.00 800.00 Billable 472447 EXPERTS-A REVIEW DOCUMENTS FOR EXPERT.

12/29/2017 JMM 800.00 0.10 80.00 Billable 472460 CLIENT MEETING-A PHONE CALL WITH CLIENT REGARDING DOCUMENT

PRODUCTION; E-MAIL TO WARSHAW REGARDING SAME.

1/2/2018 JMM 820.00 2.00 1,640.00 Billable 473557 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW CLIENT GRACE'S PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS;

PREPARE FOR PRODUCTION.

1/2/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 473593 DISCOVERY-A MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL REGARDING

DISCOVERY.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 43 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 42

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 1/2/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 473601 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEETING WITH A. STEYER REGARDING CASE.

1/2/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 473602 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW SOURCE CODE DOCUMENT PRODUCTION, MEETING

WITH S. JAIN REGARDING SAME, REVIEW SOURCE CODE

PREPARATION OF REGARDING PROCEDURE FOR DISTRIBUTING

PRODUCTION.

1/3/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 473534 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT LETTER BRIEF REGARDING

RESPONSES TO INTERROGATORIES.

1/3/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 473588 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF.

1/4/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 473577 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW CHRISTINA GRACE'S E-MAILS FOR PRODUCTION;

CONFER WITH S. JAIN REGARDING SAME; TELEPHONE CALL TO

WARSHAW REGARDING SAME.

1/4/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 473616 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF; REVIEW KOH'S

DECISIONS ON CLASS CERTIFICATION.

1/4/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 473617 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT RESPONSE TO APPLE'S E-MAIL REGARDING PLAINTIFFS'

DISCOVERY RESPONSES.

1/7/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 473514 DISCOVERY-A PHONE CALL WITH CLIENT GRACE REGARDING APPLE'S Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 44 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 43

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

DISCOVERY REQUESTS.

1/8/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 473513 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT, REVIEW AND EDIT INTERROGATORIES, SET TWO; DRAFT

REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION, SET ONE.

1/8/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 473515 DISCOVERY-A PHONE CALL WITH CAMERON WEISS REGARDING DOCUMENT

REVIEW, BACKGROUND ON CASE, SEND MATERIALS REGARDING

SAME.

1/8/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 473517 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW KURT KNIGHT DOCUMENTS AND MEMO; TARGETED

SEARCH FOR DOCUMENTS REGARDING COMMUNICATIONS

ABOUT FACETIME BREAK.

1/8/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 473537 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF; SEND TO

CO-COUNSEL.

1/8/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 473596 DISCOVERY-A PHONE CALL WITH S. JAIN REGARDING SUBPOENAS AND

SERVICE, REGARDING KEN POTTER.

1/9/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 473538 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT AND COMPLETE CLIENT QUESTIONNAIRES FOR GRACE

AND POTTER.

1/9/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 473597 DISCOVERY-A MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE REGARDING NOTICE OF 30(B)(6) Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 45 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 44

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt DEPOSITION.

1/9/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 473598 PLDS/MO-A EDITS TO LETTER BRIEF REGARDING INTERROGATORY

RESPONSES; E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL.

1/9/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 473609 DISCOVERY-A EDIT, FINALIZE AND SERVE REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION.

1/10/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 473522 PLDS/MO-A EDITS TO MOTION TO COMPEL LETTER BRIEF, REVIEW EXHIBITS;

E-MAIL TO APPLE.

1/10/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 473546 CASEMNG-A DRAFT AND CIRCULATE AGENDA FOR WEEKLY MEETING WITH

CO-COUNSEL.

1/10/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 473581 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT LETTER TO APPLE REGARDING

DEFICIENCIES WITH PRIVILEGE LOG.

1/10/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 473611 CASEMNG-A WEEKLY MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

1/11/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 473574 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW CHRISTINA GRACE'S E-MAILS FOR RESPONSIVENESS

AND RELEVANT, PREPARE NOTES FOR PRODUCTION.

1/12/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 473612 PLDS/MO-A FINAL REVIEW OF MOTION TO COMPEL LETTER BRIEF AND

EXHIBITS; TELEPHONE CALL WITH S. JAIN. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 46 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 45

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

1/13/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 473545 DISCOVERY-A PREPARE FOR AND MEET WITH CLIENT CHRISTINA GRACE

REGARDING APPLE' REQUEST FOR DOCUMENTS; DRAFT AND

COMPLETE CLIENT QUESTIONNAIRE.

1/16/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 473820 CASEMNG-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH S. JAIN REGARDING MEETING WITH

PLAINTIFF POTTER AND PLAINTIFF POTTER'S DOCUMENT

SEARCH EFFORTS AND PRODUCTION.

1/17/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 473827 CASEMNG-A WEEKLY LITIGATION STRATEGY MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

1/17/2018 JMM 820.00 1.40 1,148.00 Billable 473863 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW CHRISTINA GRACE DOCUMENTS FOR PRODUCTION,

CODE, AND MAKE NOTES ABOUT REDACTIONS.

1/17/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 473881 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH APPLE'S MOTION TO COMPEL FORENSIC IMAGING OF

PLAINTIFFS' DEVICES; REVIEW CASES, DRAFT OPPOSITION.

1/17/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 473926 DISCOVERY-A BI-MONTHLY CONFERENCE CALL WITH DOCUMENT REVIEWERS

TO ANSWER QUESTIONS ABOUT REVIEW AND PROVIDE

GUIDANCE.

1/18/2018 JMM 820.00 3.40 2,788.00 Billable 473918 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH AND DRAFT PLAINTIFFS' SECTION IN OPPOSITION TO

APPLE'S MOTION TO COMPEL FORENSIC IMAGING OF PLAINTIFFS'

DEVICES, SEND TO CO-COUNSEL. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 47 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 46

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

1/18/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 473919 RESEARCH-A REVIEW CASE LAW ON CERTIFICATION OF 17200 NATIONWIDE

CLASS POST-MAZZA.

1/21/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 473833 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW, RESEARCH AND EDIT DRAFT SECTION OF JOINT LETTER

BRIEF ON ISSUE OF IMAGING PLAINTIFFS' DEVICES; REVIEW

CASES.

1/22/2018 JMM 820.00 2.40 1,968.00 Billable 473874 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH, DRAFT AND REVISE PLAINTIFFS' SECTION OF THE

JOINT LETTER BRIEF REGARDING IMAGING DEVICES, SEND TO

APPLE.

1/23/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 473826 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S REVISED JOINT LETTER BRIEFING REGARDING

IMAGING DEVICES; E-MAIL TO COUNSEL CONFIRMING AUTHORITY

TO FILE.

1/23/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 473830 CT APPR - A PREPARE FOR DISCOVERY HEARING ON PLAINTIFFS' MOTION TO

COMPEL ANSWERS TO INTERROGATORIES ON 1/24.

1/23/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 473831 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S SUBPOENAS TO VERIZON AND AT&T; REVIEW

DRAFT MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND PREPARE FOR

MEET AND CONFER REGARDING SAME.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 48 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 47

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 1/23/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 473876 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT AMENDED RESPONSES TO APPLE'S REQUEST FOR

PRODUCTION AND POTTER'S INTERROGATORIES.

1/23/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 473904 CLIENT MEETING-A PHONE CALL WITH PLAINTIFF POTTER REGARDING HIS SEARCH

FOR RESPONSIVE DOCUMENTS.

1/24/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 473821 CASEMNG-A WEEKLY LITIGATION STRATEGY MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

1/24/2018 JMM 820.00 6.00 4,920.00 Billable 473871 CT APPR - A PREPARE FOR, TRAVEL TO AND FROM SAN JOSE, AND ATTEND

DISCOVERY HEARING BEFORE COUSINS; MEET AND CONFER

WITH APPLE REGARDING SAME.

1/24/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 473872 DISCOVERY-A SERVE AMENDED NOTICE OF 30(B)(6) DEPOSITION.

1/28/2018 JMM 820.00 2.00 1,640.00 Billable 473849 DISCOVERY-A MEET WITH INVENTUS AT CLIENT GRACE'S HOME TO IMAGE HER

DEVICES.

1/28/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 473850 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AUSTIN'S E-MAIL REGARDING FACETIME BREAK; REVIEW

DRAFT DISCOVERY; E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

1/29/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 474186 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW DOCUMENTS REGARDING COMPENSATION FOR

INABILITY TO USE FACETIME FEATURE; REVIEW E-MAILS

REGARDING SAME. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 49 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 48

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

1/30/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 474499 CASEMNG-A REVIEW CAL APPELLATE DECISION DECERTIFYING CLASS

AGAINST APPLE; FORWARD TO S. MACRAE AND S. JAIN.

1/31/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 474517 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW JOINT SUBMISSION TO COURT REGARDING STATUS OF

MEET AND CONFER REGARDING IMAGING MOTION; EDIT AND

RETURN TO APPLE'S COUNSEL FOR FILING.

1/31/2018 JMM 820.00 1.10 902.00 Billable 474521 CASEMNG-A WEEKLY MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE.

2/1/2018 JMM 820.00 0.70 574.00 Billable 475392 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AUSTIN'S DRAFT DEPOSITION NOTICES AND SECOND

REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION, E-MAIL TO COUNSEL REGARDING

SAME.

2/2/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 475374 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT AND CIRCULATE 30(B)(6) DEPOSITION NOTICE.

2/3/2018 JMM 820.00 0.80 656.00 Billable 475370 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW APPLE'S PROPOSAL REGARDING IMAGING PLAINTIFFS'

DEVICES; DRAFT PROPOSED RESPONSE AND SEND TO

CO-COUNSEL.

2/4/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 475371 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW APPLE CUSTOMER CARE LOGS (.5); DRAFT

COUNTER-PROPOSAL REGARDING THE IMAGING DISPUTE (1.0).

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 50 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 49

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 2/5/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 475849 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH INVENTUS REGARDING IMAGING

OF GRACE'S DEVICES AND RUNNING SEARCHES; TELEPHONE

CALL WITH S. JAIN REGARDING SAME.

2/5/2018 JMM 820.00 2.10 1,722.00 Billable 475861 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT; SEND TO

CO-COUNSEL FOR REVIEW AND EDIT.

2/5/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 475862 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT RESPONSE TO APPLE'S PROPOSAL REGARDING IMAGING

PLAINTIFFS' DEVICES; RESEARCH ON APPLE CUSTOMER CARE

LOGS, E-MAIL TO APPLE REGARDING SAME.

2/6/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 475789 DISCOVERY-A MEET AND CONFER WITH ALEX PILMER REGARDING APPLE'S

IMAGING MOTION AND PROPOSAL.

2/6/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 475794 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT APPLE'S DRAFT JOINT SUBMISSION TO COURT

REGARDING IMAGING BRIEF; E-MAIL TO COUNSEL REGARDING

SAME.

2/6/2018 JMM 820.00 2.00 1,640.00 Billable 475875 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT;

E-MAILS TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME, E-MAIL TO APPLE

FOR INSERTION OF ITS SECTIONS.

2/7/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 475833 CASEMNG-A PREPARE AND CIRCULATE AGENDA FOR LITIGATION STRATEGY Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 51 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 50

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt MEETING AND MEETING WITH EXPERT.

2/7/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 475848 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW GRACE TEXTS THAT HIT ON SEARCH TERMS; E-MAIL TO

INVENTUS REGARDING SAME.

2/7/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 475893 EXPERTS-A MEET WITH EXPERT REGARDING STATUS OF WORK AND DRAFT

EXPERT REPORT.

2/7/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 475894 CASEMNG-A WEEKLY MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE.

2/7/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 475897 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S INSERTS FOR JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT

CONFERENCE STATEMENT; EDIT PLAINTIFF'S SECTION; SEND TO

APPLE; FINALIZE AND FILE.

2/7/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 475911 EXPERTS-A REVIEW DRAFT EXPERT REPORT.

2/8/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 475847 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH DAN WARSHAW REGARDING

30(B)(6) DEPOSITION.

2/9/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 475844 CLIENT MEETING-A MEETING WITH CLIENT CHRISTINA GRACE REGARDING CASE

UPDATE.

2/9/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 475870 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE DISCUSSION WITH DAN WARSHAW REGARDING Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 52 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 51

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt STRATEGY FOR UPCOMING 30(B)(6) DEPOSITION.

2/11/2018 JMM 820.00 3.40 2,788.00 Billable 475910 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW DRAFT CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF, RESEARCH ON

NATIONWIDE CLASS CERTIFICATION; EDIT BRIEF.

2/13/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 476114 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEET WITH DAN WARSHAW REGARDING 30(B)(6) DEPOSITION

AND CASE STRATEGY.

2/13/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 476117 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL TO APPLE'S COUNSEL ABOUT REQUEST FOR

PRODUCTION OF ESI AND CONFIRMATION ABOUT SOURCES OF

ESI SEARCHED.

2/14/2018 JMM 820.00 1.10 902.00 Billable 476106 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEET WITH ALEX PILMER AT KIRKLAND'S SF OFFICE TO MEET

AND CONFER REGARDING JOINT CMS, SUBPOENAS TO

PLAINTIFFS' CARRIERS, REQUEST FOR NATIONWIDE DATA,

IMAGING MOTION AND REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF TEXTS

AND IMS.

2/14/2018 JMM 820.00 2.50 2,050.00 Billable 476120 DISCOVERY-A RESEARCH AND EDIT CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF REGARDING

NATIONWIDE CERTIFICATION; REVIEW DOCUMENTS PRODUCED

BY APPLE REGARDING THE CONDUCT EMANATING FROM

CALIFORNIA.

2/15/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 476104 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT REVISED JOINT CMS, RESEARCH ON GOOD CAUSE TO Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 53 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 52

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt EXTEND CASE SCHEDULE AND TO ENLARGE NUMBER OF

DEPOSITIONS, AND SEND TO CO-COUNSEL FOR REVIEW.

2/16/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 476111 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT CMS, INCORPORATE COUNSEL'S EDITS;

E-MAIL TO APPLE'S COUNSEL.

2/16/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 476115 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING DRAFT

JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT AND REQUEST FOR

EXTENSION OF CLASS CERTIFICATION DEADLINE.

2/16/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 476116 ATTYMTG.STR - A DRAFT E-MAIL CONFIRMING MEET AND CONFER DISCUSSION

WITH PILMER ON 2/14.

2/16/2018 JMM 820.00 2.40 1,968.00 Billable 476122 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF; LEGAL

RESEARCH REGARDING SAME; CIRCULATE TO CO-COUNSEL FOR

REVIEW.

2/20/2018 JMM 820.00 1.40 1,148.00 Billable 476522 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE FOR 2/22 HEARING BEFORE JUDGE COUSINS ON

IMAGING MOTION AND MOTION TO COMPEL INTERROGATORY

RESPONSES, DRAFT OUTLINE.

2/21/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 476444 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH ALLAN STEYER REGARDING CASE,

EXPERT ISSUES AND SCHEDULING ISSUES.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 54 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 53

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 2/21/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 476472 EXPERTS-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL AND EXPERT

REGARDING DRAFT EXPERT REPORT FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION.

2/21/2018 JMM 820.00 1.10 902.00 Billable 476524 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S INSERTS IN JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT

STATEMENT, EDIT PLAINTIFFS' SECTION IN RESPONSE; E-MAIL TO

CO-COUNSEL FOR REVIEW; REVIEW AND EDIT SECOND DRAFT;

E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL FOR REVIEW.

2/21/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 476525 ATTYMTG.STR - A WEEKLY LITIGATION STRATEGY MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING CASE AND JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT.

2/22/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 476436 CLIENT MEETING-A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH CLIENT KEN POTTER REGARDING

THE IMAGING MOTION AND THE PROCESS OF SEARCHING HIS

DEVICES.

2/22/2018 JMM 820.00 4.10 3,362.00 Billable 476437 CT APPR - A ATTEND HEARING ON APPLE'S MOTION TO COMPEL PRODUCTION

OF PLAINTIFFS' DEVICES FOR FORENSIC IMAGING, MEETING

WITH APPLE COUNSEL FOLLOWING HEARING.

2/22/2018 JMM 820.00 2.00 1,640.00 Billable 476454 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE FOR HEARING ON APPLE'S MOTION TO COMPEL

PRODUCTION OF DEVICES FOR FORENSIC IMAGING, AND

FOLLOW UP ON MOTION TO COMPEL APPLE TO ANSWER

INTERROGATORIES.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 55 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 54

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 2/22/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 476493 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH ALLAN STEYER REGARDING

DISCOVERY HEARING.

2/22/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 476494 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CALL WITH SUNEEL JAIN REGARDING DISCOVERY

HEARING AND PREPARING JOINT PROPOSAL FOR INSPECTING

PLAINTIFFS' DEVICES.

2/23/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 476513 CLIENT MEETING-A PHONE CALL WITH CLIENT POTTER REGARDING HEARING ON

IMAGING MOTION AND PROPOSAL FOR INSPECTION OF DEVICES;

E-MAIL TO AUSTIN CURRY REGARDING SAME.

2/23/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 476537 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH AUSTIN CURRY REGARDING

DISCOVERY HEARING AND DRAFTING PROTOCOL FOR

INSPECTION OF DEVICES.

2/23/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 476540 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW CHRISTINA GRACE DOCUMENTS FOR PRODUCTION;

PHONE CALL WITH SUNEEL JAIN REGARDING SAME.

2/23/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 476545 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW APPLE'S PROPOSAL REGARDING FORENSIC IMAGING OF

PLAINTIFFS' DEVICES; EDIT, SEND TO CO-COUNSEL.

2/26/2018 JMM 820.00 2.10 1,722.00 Billable 477246 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT PROTOCOL FOR INSPECTION/IMAGING

DEVICES, REVIEW AUSTIN'S EDITS; E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 56 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 55

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt REGARDING SAME, FINALIZE AND SEND PROTOCOL TO APPLE.

2/26/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 477320 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW KEN POTTER'S E-MAILS FOR PRODUCTION.

2/27/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 477211 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT JOINT REPORT TO THE COURT

REGARDING STATUS OF MEET AND CONFER, SEND TO APPLE.

2/27/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 477212 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT RESPONSES TO APPLE'S SECOND SET OF

INTERROGATORIES AND FIRST SET OF REQUESTS FOR

ADMISSION TO PLAINTIFFS.

2/27/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 477248 ATTYMTG.STR - A DRAFT AND SEND TO CO-COUNSEL AGENDA FOR WEEKLY

MEETING.

2/27/2018 JMM 820.00 1.40 1,148.00 Billable 477364 CASEMNG-A MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE REGARDING PROTOCOL FOR

FORENSIC INSPECTION OF PLAINTIFFS' DEVICES.

2/28/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 477193 ATTYMTG.STR - A WEEKLY LITIGATION STRATEGY MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

2/28/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 477277 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AMAZON'S OBJECTIONS TO SUBPOENA;E-MAIL TO S. JAIN

REGARDING SAME.

2/28/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 477350 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW AUSTIN'S REVISED DRAFT PROTOCOL REGARDING Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 57 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 56

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt IMAGING OF PLAINTIFFS' DEVICES, EDITS TO SAME, E-MAIL BACK

TO AUSTIN.

3/1/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 477928 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CALL WITH S. JAIN REGARDING IMAGING PLAINTIFFS'

DEVICES AND REVIEWING POTTER'S E-MAILS.

3/1/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 477976 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S DRAFT PROTOCOL REGARDING FORENSIC

IMAGING, SEND TO AUSTIN, EDITS TO PLAINTIFFS' PROPOSAL,

SEND TO AUSTIN.

3/2/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 477919 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW KEN POTTER'S E-MAILS FOR PRODUCTION, TELEPHONE

CALL WITH S. JAIN REGARDING SAME.

3/2/2018 JMM 820.00 1.40 1,148.00 Billable 477961 PLDS/MO-A REVISE PLAINTIFFS' PROPOSAL FOR PROTOCOL FOR FORENSIC

INSPECTION OF PLAINTIFFS' DEVICES, REVIEW APPLE'S

PROPOSAL, E-MAIL TO PILMER REGARDING SAME.

3/5/2018 JMM 820.00 1.10 902.00 Billable 477934 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW POTTER DOCUMENTS FOR PRODUCTION; E-MAILS TO S.

JAIN REGARDING SAME.

3/5/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 477951 RESEARCH-A LEGAL RESEARCH ON RULE 30 AND TAKING CORPORATE

DEPOSITIONS MORE THAN ONE TIME, DRAFT MEET AND CONFER

E-MAIL TO APPLE REGARDING SAME.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 58 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 57

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 3/6/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 477956 ATTYMTG.STR - A DRAFT AND CIRCULATE AGENDA FOR WEEKLY LITIGATION

MEETING.

3/6/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 477963 DISCOVERY-A MEETING WITH S. JAIN TO REVIEW POTTER'S DOCUMENTS FOR

PRODUCTION.

3/7/2018 JMM 820.00 1.10 902.00 Billable 477958 CLIENT MEETING-A MEETING WITH CLIENT GRACE TO REVIEW RESPONSES TO

SECOND SET OF INTERROGATORIES AND FIRST SET OF RFAS,

OBTAIN VERIFICATION, DRIVE TO AND FROM.

3/7/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 477992 ATTYMTG.STR - A WEEKLY LITIGATION MEETING.

3/8/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 477942 DISCOVERY-A MEET WITH S. JAIN TO REVIEW REDACTED VERSIONS OF

POTTER'S TEXTS AND E-MAILS FOR PRODUCTION.

3/9/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 477943 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CALL WITH WARREN MCCARTY REGARDING CLASS

CERTIFICATION FACT SECTION AND BACKGROUND.

3/16/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 479038 CASEMNG-A REVIEW MEET AND CONFER E-MAIL FROM APPLE, E-MAIL TO

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

3/19/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 479290 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL DAVID TEJTEL IN PREPARATION OF

MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 59 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 58

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

3/19/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 479291 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE FOR MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE REGARDING

OUTSTANDING DISCOVERY ISSUES.

3/19/2018 JMM 820.00 2.00 1,640.00 Billable 479321 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT SECTION FOR JOINT LETTER BRIEF REGARDING

DISCOVERY DISPUTES.

3/19/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 479322 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT AMENDED RESPONSES TO APPLE'S INTERROGATORIES.

3/20/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 479218 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CALL WITH DAN WARSHAW REGARDING CASE ISSUES.

3/20/2018 JMM 820.00 3.00 2,460.00 Billable 479219 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT MOTION TO COMPEL LETTER BRIEF REGARDING APPLE'S

REFUSAL TO PRODUCE IMS AND TEXTS, AND A 30(B)(6) WITNESS,

RESPOND TO APPLE'S LETTER BRIEF.

3/20/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 479220 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT LETTER TO JUDGE COUSINS IN RESPONSE TO APPLE'S

REQUEST FOR SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEFING; EDITS TO S. JAIN'S

DRAFT LETTER BRIEF; FILE LETTER WITH COURT.

3/20/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 479222 INVESTIG-A REVIEW PURPORTED FACETIME CALL LOGS FROM PLAINTIFFS'

DEVICES, MEETING WITH S. JAIN REGARDING SAME.

3/21/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 479223 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT MANNING DECLARATION AND PROPOSED Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 60 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 59

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

ORDER IN SUPPORT OF ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO FILE

UNDER SEAL.

3/21/2018 JMM 820.00 1.10 902.00 Billable 479267 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT AMENDMENT TO CLASS DEFINITION; RESEARCH

REGARDING SAME.

3/21/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 479306 ATTYMTG.STR - A WEEKLY LITIGATION MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

3/22/2018 JMM 820.00 1.10 902.00 Billable 479260 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE

STRATEGY.

3/22/2018 JMM 820.00 1.40 1,148.00 Billable 479261 PLDS/MO-A REVISIONS TO JOINT LETTER BRIEF, REVIEW APPLE'S REVISIONS,

E-MAIL TO APPLE REGARDING SAME, EDIT SECTION.

3/26/2018 JMM 820.00 2.40 1,968.00 Billable 479225 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT JOINT LETTER BRIEF, E-MAILS TO

APPLE REGARDING SAME, EDIT BRIEF IN RESPONSE TO APPLE'S

EDITS, REVIEW EXHIBITS, EDIT ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION AND

DECLARATION.

3/26/2018 JMM 820.00 1.20 984.00 Billable 479342 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT AND EDIT OPPOSITION TO APPLE'S UNILATERAL LETTER

BRIEF MOTION TO COMPEL, REVIEW DAVE'S EDITS, REVIEW AND

EDIT FINAL DRAFT.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 61 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 60

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 3/27/2018 JMM 820.00 2.40 1,968.00 Billable 479253 RESEARCH-A LEGAL RESEARCH ON CLASS CERTIFICATION; EDITS TO BRIEF.

3/28/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 479269 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT CLASS CERTIFICATION MOTION,

BACKGROUND AND FACT SECTION.

3/28/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 479270 EXPERTS-A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH EXPERT REGARDING THIRD PARTY

DATA AND CLASS CERTIFICATION REPORT.

3/28/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 479274 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT SECOND SET OF REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION.

3/28/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 479336 EXPERTS-A PREPARE FOR MEETING WITH EXPERT.

3/28/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 479337 ATTYMTG.STR - A WEEKLY LITIGATION STRATEGY MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

3/28/2018 JMM 820.00 2.00 1,640.00 Billable 479338 RESEARCH-A LEGAL RESEARCH FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION MOTION AND

DISCOVERY.

3/29/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 479317 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW COURT'S ORDER REGARDING PROTOCOL FOR

FORENSIC IMAGING, E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

3/29/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 479324 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW D. TEJTEL'S EDITS TO REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION,

FINALIZE AND PREPARE TO SERVE. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 62 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 61

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

3/29/2018 JMM 820.00 2.00 1,640.00 Billable 479325 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE REGARDING OUTSTANDING

DISCOVERY DISPUTES.

3/29/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 479328 CLIENT MEETING-A E-MAILS TO CLIENTS REGARDING COURT ORDER REGARDING

FORENSIC IMAGING OF DEVICES.

3/29/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 479329 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEETING WITH A. STEYER REGARDING CASE.

3/29/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 479330 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW KEN POTTER'S DOCUMENTS FOR PRODUCTION,

MEETING WITH S. JAIN REGARDING SAME.

3/29/2018 JMM 820.00 3.50 2,870.00 Billable 479331 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW DOCUMENTS CITED IN SUPPORT OF DRAFT CLASS

CERTIFICATION BRIEF, EDITS TO BRIEF.

3/30/2018 JMM 820.00 1.20 984.00 Billable 479283 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AMENDED COMPLAINT

ADDING NEW PLAINTIFF.

3/30/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 479363 CLIENT MEETING-A MEETING WITH CLIENT GRACE REGARDING COUSINS' ORDER

REGARDING IMAGING DEVICE.

4/3/2018 JMM 820.00 1.20 984.00 Billable 481044 PLDS/MO-A PREPARE FOR HEARING BEFORE COUSINS ON MOTION TO

COMPEL 30(B)(6) DEPOSITION AND PRODUCTION OF TEXTS AND Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 63 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 62

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt IMS.

4/4/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 481017 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT COMPROMISE PROPOSAL REGARDING DISCOVERY ITEMS

IN DISPUTE FOR HEARING, E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

SAME, E-MAIL TO APPLE REGARDING SAME.

4/4/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 481018 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CALL WITH S. JAIN REGARDING OUTSTANDING

DISCOVERY ASSIGNMENTS.

4/4/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 481019 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CALL WITH DAVID TEJTEL REGARDING UPCOMING APPLE

DEPOSITIONS.

4/4/2018 JMM 820.00 4.70 3,854.00 Billable 481096 CT APPR - A TRAVEL TO, HEARING BEFORE JUDGE COUSINS ON LETTER

BRIEF MOTION TO COMPEL, MEETING WITH APPLE FOLLOWING

HEARING, TRAVEL BACK TO OFFICE.

4/5/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 481042 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AND EDIT PLAINTIFFS' AMENDED RESPONSES TO

INTERROGATORY 1; E-MAIL BACK TO S. JAIN.

4/5/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 481047 EXPERTS-A E-MAILS TO POTENTIAL NEUTRAL THIRD PARTY TO CONDUCT

FORENSIC IMAGING; SEND COUSINS ORDER.

4/5/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 481091 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT PROPOSAL TO RESOLVE DISCOVERY DISPUTE

REGARDING PRODUCTION OF TEXTS AND IMS, SEND TO Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 64 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 63

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

CO-COUNSEL FOR REVIEW, EDIT, SEND TO APPLE FOR REVIEW.

4/6/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 481024 PLDS/MO-A PREPARE TO DO LIST FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF AND

TIMELINE.

4/6/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 481025 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT AMENDED NOTICE OF 30(B)(6) DEPOSITION; E-MAIL TO S.

JAIN TO SERVE.

4/6/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 481067 ATTYMTG.STR - A WEEKLY LITIGATION MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

4/6/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 481068 DISCOVERY-A MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL PER COUSINS'

ORDER REGARDING APPLE'S PRODUCTION OF TEXTS AND IMS.

4/6/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 481069 PLDS/MO-A EDITS TO PROPOSED ORDER REGARDING PRODUCTION OF

TEXTS AND IMS, E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL, FURTHER EDITS AND

FINALIZE FOR FILING; DRAFT STATEMENT, REVIEW FOR FILING.

4/10/2018 JMM 820.00 4.00 3,280.00 Billable 481036 EXPERTS-A REVIEW REVISED HASTINGS REPORT AND MEMORANDUM

REGARDING BEST BUY DATA, INSERT EDITS AND QUESTIONS

ABOUT REPORT, E-MAIL SAME TO S. MACRAE AND A. STEYER.

4/10/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 481050 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW INFORMATION PROVIDED BY PROPOSED THIRD PARTY

NEUTRAL PURSUANT TO COUSINS' ORDER, FORWARD TO Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 65 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 64

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt CO-COUNSEL.

4/10/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 481051 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT AMENDED RESPONSES TO APPLE'S INTERROGATORY NO.

1, REVIEW DOCUMENTS PRODUCED BY APPLE REGARDING

DEVICES OWNED BY PLAINTIFFS.

4/11/2018 JMM 820.00 1.10 902.00 Billable 481037 EXPERTS-A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH DR. HASTINGS, CONFERENCE CALL

WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

4/11/2018 JMM 820.00 4.00 3,280.00 Billable 481054 DEP PREP-A REVIEW DALLAS DE ATLEY HOT DOCUMENTS FOR DOCUMENTS

RELATED TO TOPIC 1 OF 30(B)(6) NOTICE, DRAFT QUESTIONS.

4/12/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 481058 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT RESPONSE TO APPLE'S DISCOVERY QUESTIONS; E-MAIL

TO CO-COUNSEL.

4/13/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 481040 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CALL WITH SUNEEL JAIN REGARDING IMAGING OF

PLAINTIFFS DEVICES.

4/14/2018 JMM 820.00 7.00 5,740.00 Billable 481030 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH, REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT CLASS CERTIFICATION

BRIEF AND EXPERT REPORT, E-MAIL SAME TO CO-COUNSEL.

4/16/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 481029 ATTYMTG.STR - A WEEKLY LITIGATION MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 66 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 65

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 4/16/2018 JMM 820.00 2.20 1,804.00 Billable 481034 DEP PREP-A PREPARE FOR DALLAS DE ATLEY DEPOSITION, TOPIC 1.

4/17/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 481077 CLIENT MEETING-A PHONE CALL WITH KEN POTTER REGARDING DEVICE IMAGING.

4/17/2018 JMM 820.00 3.90 3,198.00 Billable 481084 DEP PREP-A PREPARE FOR DALLAS DE ATLEY DEPOSITION.

4/17/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 481088 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW DRAFT PRIVILEGE LOG, REVIEW COMMUNICATIONS,

EDITS TO PRIVILEGE LOG.

4/18/2018 JMM 820.00 9.20 7,544.00 Billable 481087 DEP TAKE/DEF-A ATTEND DEPOSITION OF DALLAS DE ATLEY, TRAVEL BACK TO SF.

4/19/2018 JMM 820.00 4.00 3,280.00 Billable 481031 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH ON TRESPASS TO CHATTELS CLAIM AND

ASCERTAINABILITY, EDITS TO DRAFT CLASS CERTIFICATION

BRIEF.

4/19/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 481065 EXPERTS-A MEETING WITH DR. HASTINGS REGARDING EXPERT REPORT.

4/19/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 481066 ATTYMTG.STR - A WEEKLY LITIGATION STRATEGY MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

4/19/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 481092 CLIENT MEETING-A MEETING WITH KEN POTTER AND CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

DEVICE IMAGING.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 67 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 66

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 4/19/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 481093 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW AUSTIN'S E-MAIL ABOUT FOLLOW UP DISCOVERY ITEMS,

E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

4/19/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 481095 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT CLIENT DECLARATIONS IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR

CLASS CERTIFICATION, E-MAIL TO CLIENT GRACE REGARDING

SAME, E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL FOR REVIEW.

4/20/2018 JMM 820.00 4.40 3,608.00 Billable 481642 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH AND EDIT CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF, AND DRAFT

MANNING DECLARATION WITH SUPPORTING EVIDENCE.

4/23/2018 JMM 820.00 4.20 3,444.00 Billable 481635 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH AND EDITS TO CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF, DRAFT

MANNING DECLARATION., EDITS TO PLAINTIFFS' DECLARATIONS.

4/24/2018 JMM 820.00 5.00 4,100.00 Billable 481624 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT AND EDIT CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF, DRAFT AND EDIT

PLAINTIFF DECLARATIONS.

4/25/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 481625 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEETING WITH S. JAIN REGARDING CASE.

4/26/2018 JMM 820.00 3.50 2,870.00 Billable 481627 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH AND EDITS TO CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF, E-MAIL

TO CO-COUNSEL FOR REVIEW.

4/26/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 481628 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S ESI DECLARATION, E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING SAME. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 68 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 67

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

4/26/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 481630 EXPERTS-A CONFERENCE CALL WITH EXPERT REGARDING REPORT AND

CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF.

4/27/2018 JMM 820.00 1.80 1,476.00 Billable 481621 ATTYMTG.STR - A WEEKLY LITIGATION MEETING, REVIEW AND DISCUSS REVISED

CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF AND REVISED EXPERT REPORT.

4/29/2018 JMM 820.00 2.00 1,640.00 Billable 481620 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH, REVIEW AND EDIT CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF;

FINALIZE POTTER AND GRACE DECLARATIONS.

4/29/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 481641 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW, EDIT AND FINALIZE SECTION OF LETTER BRIEF

REGARDING APPLE MOTION TO COMPEL.

4/30/2018 JMM 820.00 7.00 5,740.00 Billable 482849 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF, REVIEW AND

FINALIZE POTTER AND GRACE DECLARATIONS; REVIEW AND EDIT

HASTINGS DECLARATION.

4/30/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 482850 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW APPLE'S RESPONSES TO SECOND SET OF RFAS AND

THIRD SET OF ROGGS.

4/30/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 482851 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT STIPULATION TO FILE OVER-LENGTH BRIEF; REVIEW

LOCAL RULES REGARDING SAME; E-MAIL TO APPLE REGARDING

SAME. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 69 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 68

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

4/30/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 482888 PLDS/MO-A EDIT AND FINALIZE PLAINTIFFS' SECTION OF JOINT LETTER BRIEF

REGARDING APPLE'S MOTION TO COMPEL PRODUCTION OF

UNREDACTED TEXTS AND POSTS ON BLOGS; REVIEW POTTER

DOCUMENTS.

5/1/2018 JMM 820.00 4.40 3,608.00 Billable 482898 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH AND EDIT CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF; REVIEW AND

EDIT DRAFT SIMON DECLARATION; FINALIZE POTTER AND GRACE

DECLARATIONS AND E-MAIL TO CLIENTS; REVIEW AND EDIT

HASTINGS DECLARATION.

5/1/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 482899 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CALL WITH DAN WARSHAW REGARDING CLASS

CERTIFICATION BRIEF.

5/1/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 482900 CLIENT MEETING-A FINALIZE CLIENT DECLARATIONS FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION

BRIEF, E-MAILS TO CLIENTS REGARDING SAME.

5/2/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 482872 EXPERTS-A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH EXPERT REGARDING EXPERT

REPORT IN SUPPORT OF CLASS CERTIFICATION.

5/2/2018 JMM 820.00 4.50 3,690.00 Billable 482901 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT MANNING DECLARATION, REVIEW EXHIBITS;

REVIEW AND EDIT CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF; REVIEW AND

EDIT SIMON DECLARATION, REVIEW AND EDIT ADMINISTRATIVE

MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 70 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 69

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

5/3/2018 JMM 820.00 8.50 6,970.00 Billable 482887 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT MANNING DECLARATION AND EXHIBITS,

REVIEW AND EDIT CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF, REVIEW AND

EDIT ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL, REVIEW

SIMON DECLARATION; DRAFT DECLARATIONS PURSUANT TO

RULE 23(G), E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

5/3/2018 JMM 820.00 2.00 1,640.00 Billable 482891 EXPERTS-A REVIEW AND EDIT EXPERT REPORT, PHONE CALL WITH EXPERT

REGARDING SAME, E-MAIL TO COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

5/4/2018 JMM 820.00 7.50 6,150.00 Billable 482892 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW, EDIT AND FINALIZE BRIEF, MANNING DECLARATION,

ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION AND PROPOSED ORDER, REVIEW

REDACTIONS, PREPARE FOR FILING.

5/4/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 482907 EXPERTS-A REVIEW AND EDIT HASTINGS REPORT, E-MAIL TO HASTINGS

REGARDING SAME.

5/7/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 484606 EXPERTS-A REVIEW BACK UP MATERIALS TO HASTINGS REPORT, E-MAIL

SAME TO S. JAIN TO SERVE ON APPLE'S COUNSEL.

5/7/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 484607 ATTYMTG.STR - A DRAFT AND CIRCULATE AGENDA FOR LITIGATION MEETING ON

5/9.

5/8/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 484631 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW PLAINTIFFS' AMENDED PRIVILEGE LOG, E-MAIL TO S. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 71 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 70

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

JAIN REGARDING SAME.

5/9/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 484592 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW NEUTRAL'S PRODUCTION OF FACETIME CALL LOGS AND

WIFI RECORDS; E-MAIL TO SUNEEL JAIN REGARDING SAME;

E-MAIL TO AUSTIN REGARDING SAME; E-MAIL TO NEUTRAL

REGARDING INABILITY TO OPEN OR REVIEW DATA.

5/9/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 484615 ATTYMTG.STR - A WEEKLY LITIGATION STRATEGY MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

5/10/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 484612 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEET WITH A. STEYER REGARDING CASE.

5/14/2018 JMM 820.00 4.00 3,280.00 Billable 484649 DEP PREP-A PREPARE FOR, MEETING WITH CLIENT GRACE TO PREPARE FOR

HER DEPOSITION.

5/15/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 484837 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW, RESEARCH AND EDIT JOINT LETTER BRIEF REGARDING

APPLE'S MOTION TO COMPEL PRODUCTION OF UNREDACTED

DOCUMENTS AND POSTS ON BLOGS.

5/17/2018 JMM 820.00 2.40 1,968.00 Billable 484633 DEP PREP-A PREPARE FOR CHRISTINA GRACE DEPOSITION.

5/18/2018 JMM 820.00 9.50 7,790.00 Billable 484578 DEP TAKE/DEF-A PREPARE FOR GRACE DEPOSITION; DEFEND DEPOSITION; MEET

WITH CLIENT REGARDING DEPOSITION.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 72 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 71

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 5/20/2018 JMM 820.00 4.30 3,526.00 Billable 484907 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE FOR "DISCOVERY BOOTCAMP" MEETING WITH

CO-COUNSEL.

5/21/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 484853 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW, EDIT AND FINALIZE JOINT LETTER BRIEF, E-MAIL SAME

TO S. JAIN.

5/21/2018 JMM 820.00 7.50 6,150.00 Billable 484908 ATTYMTG.STR - A DISCOVERY BOOTCAMP MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL (5.5);

DINNER MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL (2.0).

5/22/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 484838 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING APPLE'S

SUBPOENAS TO NON-PARTY SMART PHONE RESELLERS AND

HOW TO RESPOND TO SAME AND STAFF DEPOSITIONS.

5/22/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 484854 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW SUBPOENAS TO NON-PARTY SMART PHONE RESELLERS,

E-MAIL SAME TO EXPERT.

5/22/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 484911 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE AND SEND E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL WITH LIST OF

FOLLOW UP ITEMS FROM DISCOVERY BOOTCAMP MEETING.

5/24/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 484920 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT E-MAIL TO APPLE'S COUNSEL REGARDING SCHEDULING

NON-PARTY SUBPOENAS, REVIEW LOCAL RULES AND RULES OF

PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT; REVIEW JUDGE COUSINS' REVISED

STANDING ORDER. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 73 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 72

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

5/25/2018 JMM 820.00 3.00 2,460.00 Billable 484840 DEP PREP-A PREPARE FOR POTTER DEPOSITION; REVIEW DOCUMENTS.

5/25/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 484893 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING NON-PARTY

DEPOSITIONS.

5/26/2018 JMM 820.00 4.00 3,280.00 Billable 484857 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW POTENTIAL DEPONENTS, PRIORITIZE FOR DEPOSITION,

PRIORITIZE FOR TOPICS.

5/29/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 484914 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL AND EXPERT

REGARDING BRIGHTSTAR AND OTHER NON-PARTY DEPOSITIONS.

5/29/2018 JMM 820.00 4.00 3,280.00 Billable 484915 CLIENT MEETING-A PREPARE FOR, MEETING WITH K. POTTER TO PREPARE FOR

DEPOSITION.

5/29/2018 JMM 820.00 3.20 2,624.00 Billable 484918 DEP TAKE/DEF-A TRAVEL TO SAN DIEGO FOR MEETING WITH CLIENT POTTER AND

POTTER DEPOSITION.

5/30/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 484900 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL AND CLIENT BEFORE DEPOSITION.

5/30/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 484901 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW APPLE'S THIRD AMENDED PRIVILEGE LOG; E-MAIL TO

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING ENTRIES TO MEET AND CONFER

ABOUT AND WHY. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 74 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 73

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

5/30/2018 JMM 820.00 9.30 7,626.00 Billable 484916 DEP TAKE/DEF-A DEFEND POTTER DEPOSITION.

5/30/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 484917 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL TO APPLE'S COUNSEL REGARDING DISCOVERY AND

DRAFT LETTER BRIEFS.

5/31/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 485126 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL TO PREPARE FOR MEET

AND CONFER WITH APPLE.

5/31/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 485141 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CALL WITH S. JAIN TO PREPARE FOR DISCOVERY

HEARING.

5/31/2018 JMM 820.00 4.50 3,690.00 Billable 485146 DEP TAKE/DEF-A TRAVEL BACK TO SF FROM SAN DIEGO FOLLOWING POTTER

DEPO (FLIGHTS CANCELED AND DELAYED).

6/1/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 486249 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW ROUGH TRANSCRIPT OF BRIGHTSTAR DEPOSITION.

6/1/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 486274 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW DRAFT MEET AND CONFER FOLLOW UP LETTER TO

APPLE, EDIT, SEND TO CO-COUNSEL; E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING DISCOVERY MATTERS.

6/2/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 486269 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT JOINT LETTER BRIEF REGARDING SEARCH

TERMS AND IMESSAGES; E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 75 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 74

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

6/2/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 486270 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW TRANSCRIPT OF DEPOSITION OF BRIGHTSTAR.

6/3/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 486286 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND FURTHER EDIT DRAFT LETTER BRIEF REGARDING

ESI PRODUCTION AND TEXT MESSAGES; E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING SAME.

6/4/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 486256 EXPERTS-A MEETING WITH DAN WARSHAW TO DISCUSS DEPOSITION

PREPARATION FOR HASTINGS DEPOSITION.

6/4/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 486261 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEETING WITH SUNEEL JAIN TO DISCUSS OUTSTANDING

DISCOVERY ISSUES.

6/4/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 486263 PLDS/MO-A FINALIZE DRAFT LETTER BRIEF, E-MAIL SAME TO APPLE.

6/4/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 486276 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING JOINT

LETTER BRIEF.

6/5/2018 JMM 820.00 2.10 1,722.00 Billable 486257 EXPERTS-A REVIEW HASTINGS' PRIOR TESTIMONY; PREPARE FOR HASTINGS

DEPOSITION.

6/5/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 486258 DISCOVERY-A EDIT AMENDED RESPONSES TO INTERROGATORY 8 REGARDING

DAMAGES AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF; E-MAIL SAME TO Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 76 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 75

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt CO-COUNSEL.

6/5/2018 JMM 820.00 1.10 902.00 Billable 486288 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL TO PREPARE FOR MEET AND

CONFER WITH APPLE; MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE

REGARDING OUTSTANDING DISCOVERY ISSUES RAISED BY

APPLE.

6/7/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 486268 DISCOVERY-A EDITS TO PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSES TO INTERROGATORIES;

REVIEW FINAL DRAFT.

6/7/2018 JMM 820.00 9.50 7,790.00 Billable 486290 DEP PREP-A PREPARE FOR MEETING (2.0); MEETING WITH EXPERT AND

CO-COUNSEL TO PREPARE EXPERT FOR DEPOSITION (5.5); MEET

WITH EXPERT (2.0).

6/8/2018 JMM 820.00 8.00 6,560.00 Billable 486266 DEP TAKE/DEF-A MEETING WITH DR. HASTINGS BEFORE DEPOSITION (1.0);

DEFEND DR. HASTINGS DEPOSITION (7.0).

6/11/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 486285 EXPERTS-A E-MAIL TO APPLE REGARDING PRODUCTION OF BACK UP

MATERIALS FOR EXPERT REPORT.

6/12/2018 JMM 820.00 2.50 2,050.00 Billable 486280 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S SECTION TO LETTER BRIEF, EDIT AND FINALIZE

BRIEF; REVIEW AND PREPARE EXHIBITS; E-MAIL TO APPLE FOR

FILING.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 77 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 76

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 6/12/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 486282 EXPERTS-A PHONE CALL WITH EXPERT REGARDING DATA PRODUCED TO

APPLE AND NON-PARTY DEPOSITIONS.

6/13/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 486291 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S EDITS TO JOINT LETTER BRIEF, FINALIZE AND

SEND TO S. JAIN FOR FILING.

6/13/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 486298 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE AND CIRCULATE AGENDA FOR WEEKLY TEAM MEETING.

6/13/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 486299 ATTYMTG.STR - A WEEKLY TEAM LITIGATION MEETING.

6/14/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 486272 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT PROPOSED ORDER AND DECLARATION

IN SUPPORT OF JOINT LETTER BRIEF, E-MAIL SAME TO

CO-COUNSEL.

6/17/2018 JMM 820.00 3.00 2,460.00 Billable 486265 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S OPPOSITION TO CLASS CERTIFICATION,

EXPERT REPORTS AND SUPPORTING MATERIALS, OUTLINE

REPLY.

6/18/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 487364 CLIENT MEETING-A PHONE CALL WITH CLIENT KEN POTTER REGARDING CASE

STATUS AND DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPT REVIEW.

6/18/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 487370 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE AGENDA FOR CONFERENCE CALL TO DISCUSS

PREPARING REPLY BRIEF, SEND TO CO-COUNSEL. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 78 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 77

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

6/18/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 487371 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL TO DISCUSS APPLE'S OPPOSITION

TO CLASS CERTIFICATION AND PREPARATION OF REPLY BRIEF

AND SUPPORTING PAPERS.

6/18/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 487390 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CALL WITH DAN WARSHAW REGARDING APPLE'S

OPPOSITION TO CLASS CERTIFICATION.

6/20/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 487328 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL TO DISCUSS APPLE'S

OPPOSITION, DEPOSITIONS OF EXPERTS AND OUTSTANDING

DISCOVERY ISSUES.

6/20/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 487383 EXPERTS-A CONFERENCE CALL WITH EXPERT TO DISCUSS APPLE'S

OPPOSITION AND EXPERT REPORT.

6/21/2018 JMM 820.00 1.40 1,148.00 Billable 487347 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH AND DRAFT REPLY IN SUPPORT OF CLASS

CERTIFICATION.

6/22/2018 JMM 820.00 3.00 2,460.00 Billable 487338 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH AND DRAFT REPLY IN SUPPORT OF CLASS

CERTIFICATION.

6/25/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 487357 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING REPLY CLASS

CERTIFICATION BRIEF AND OUTSTANDING DISCOVERY ISSUES. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 79 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 78

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

6/25/2018 JMM 820.00 3.20 2,624.00 Billable 487358 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH AND DRAFT SECTION ON REPLY REGARDING

HASTINGS' EXPERT REPORT.

6/26/2018 JMM 820.00 1.40 1,148.00 Billable 487393 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH AND DRAFT REPLY IN SUPPORT OF CLASS

CERTIFICATION REGARDING DAMAGES MODEL SECTION.

6/27/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 487332 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AND EDIT SUBPOENAS TO TREXLER AND VYRROS.

6/27/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 487351 EXPERTS-A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH EXPERT REGARDING REBUTTAL

REPORT AND ANALYSIS.

6/27/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 487352 CASEMNG-A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING LITIGATION

STRATEGY.

6/28/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 487382 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING REPLY

BRIEF SECTION ON CHOICE OF LAW ISSUES.

6/28/2018 JMM 820.00 3.00 2,460.00 Billable 487397 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH AND DRAFT REPLY IN SUPPORT OF CLASS

CERTIFICATION WITH RESPECT TO DAMAGES METHODOLOGY

AND EXPERT REPORT.

6/29/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 487396 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING REPLY Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 80 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 79

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF ON CHOICE OF LAW ISSUE.

6/30/2018 JMM 820.00 6.50 5,330.00 Billable 487333 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT REPLY SECTION ON DAMAGES MODEL; REVIEW AND EDIT

REPLY SECTIONS (BACKGROUND, CHOICE OF LAW, AND

TYPICALITY).

7/1/2018 JMM 820.00 3.30 2,706.00 Billable 488392 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT REPLY CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF, SECTION ON

DAMAGES MODEL.

7/2/2018 JMM 820.00 4.00 3,280.00 Billable 488344 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH AND DRAFT REPLY SECTION IN SUPPORT OF CLASS

CERTIFICATION ON DAMAGES MODEL.

7/2/2018 JMM 820.00 2.10 1,722.00 Billable 488366 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT, CIRCULATE TO

CO-COUNSEL FOR COMMENTS AND EDITS.

7/2/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 488371 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING REPLY

BRIEF SECTIONS AND UPCOMING CASE DEADLINES.

7/2/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 488383 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW, RESEARCH, AND EDIT MOTION FOR CLARIFICATION OR

RECONSIDERATION OF COURT'S JUNE 21 ORDER.

7/3/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 488345 EXPERTS-A PHONE CALL WITH EXPERT REGARDING REPLY REPORT AND

TREXLER REPORT.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 81 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 80

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 7/3/2018 JMM 820.00 2.00 1,640.00 Billable 488361 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT; E-MAIL TO

CO-COUNSEL FOR REVIEW AND EDITING.

7/3/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 488362 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT MOTION FOR CLARIFICATION; REVIEW

CIVIL LOCAL RULES AND FRCP REGARDING SAME; E-MAIL EDITS

TO S. JAIN; E-MAIL BRIEF TO CO-COUNSEL; EDIT AND FINALIZE

FOR FILING; REVIEW PROPOSED ORDER.

7/4/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 488364 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW TRANSCRIPT OF DEPOSITION OF AVI RUBIN; E-MAIL TO

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING FOLLOW UP ITEMS.

7/5/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 488346 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT THIRD REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION;

E-MAIL SAME TO CO-COUNSEL FOR REVIEW.

7/5/2018 JMM 820.00 7.00 5,740.00 Billable 488347 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH AND DRAFT REPLY CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF ON

DAMAGES MODEL AND INJUNCTIVE RELIEF.

7/5/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 488348 CASEMNG-A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL TO DISCUSS DRAFT

JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT, CASE

SCHEDULE AND FLING EXPERT REPORTS.

7/5/2018 JMM 820.00 2.00 1,640.00 Billable 488349 EXPERTS-A REVIEW EXPERT'S DRAFT REPLY REPORT, EDIT, INCORPORATE

INTO DRAFT REPLY BRIEF. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 82 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 81

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

7/6/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 488350 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING TREXLER

DEPOSITION AND REPLY CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF.

7/6/2018 JMM 820.00 3.30 2,706.00 Billable 488374 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH AND DRAFT REPLY CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF

DAMAGES MODEL SECTION; E-MAIL SAME TO CO-COUNSEL.

7/6/2018 JMM 820.00 4.20 3,444.00 Billable 488375 EXPERTS-A REVIEW AND EDIT EXPERT'S DRAFT REPLY REPORT (2.2);

REVIEW TREXLER REPORT; REVIEW EXPERT'S QUESTIONS FOR

TREXLER DEPOSITION, EDIT AND ADD ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS,

E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL (2.0).

7/7/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 488351 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT REPLY BRIEF SECTION ON INJUNCTIVE

RELIEF.

7/7/2018 JMM 820.00 3.70 3,034.00 Billable 488376 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH AND DRAFT MOTION TO EXCLUDE DANA TREXLER

REPORT.

7/8/2018 JMM 820.00 1.20 984.00 Billable 488379 DEP PREP-A DRAFT AND CIRCULATE QUESTIONS FOR DANA TREXLER

DEPOSITION.

7/8/2018 JMM 820.00 3.50 2,870.00 Billable 488380 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH, DRAFT AND EDIT REVISED REPLY BRIEF SECTIONS

ON DAMAGES, TYPICALITY AND CHOICE OF LAW.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 83 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 82

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 7/9/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 488808 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING REPLY

CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF, TREXLER DEPOSITION AND CASE

MANAGEMENT STATEMENT AND CASE SCHEDULE.

7/9/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 488818 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT AND EDIT JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE

STATEMENT, SEND TO CO-COUNSEL FOR REVIEW.

7/9/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 488821 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL REGARDING THE

JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT AND CASE SCHEDULE.

7/9/2018 JMM 820.00 3.30 2,706.00 Billable 488822 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH AND DRAFT MOTION TO EXCLUDE PORTIONS OF

TREXLER REPORT; REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT MOTION TO STRIKE.

7/9/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 488825 EXPERTS-A REVIEW AND EDIT HASTINGS REPLY REPORT.

7/10/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 488810 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEETING WITH A. STEYER AND S. JAIN REGARDING CASE, CASE

SCHEDULE, AND EXPERT MERITS REPORTS

7/10/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 488811 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT THIRD REQUEST FOR PRODUCTIONS,

E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

7/10/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 488812 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW, EDIT AND FINALIZE DRAFT CASE MANAGEMENT

CONFERENCE STATEMENT, E-MAIL TO APPLE. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 84 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 83

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

7/10/2018 JMM 820.00 6.30 5,166.00 Billable 488815 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT REPLY CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF;

REVIEW TREXLER DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPT, RESEARCH AND

DRAFT MOTION TO EXCLUDE; REVIEW HASTINGS REPLY REPORT.

7/10/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 488816 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEET WITH S. JAIN AND P. GRAVLEY REGARDING REPLY CLASS

CERTIFICATION BRIEF AND LOGISTICS FOR FILING.

7/10/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 488826 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW DRAFT MOTION TO STRIKE RUBIN REPORT, E-MAIL TO

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

7/11/2018 JMM 820.00 3.30 2,706.00 Billable 488813 EXPERTS-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT HASTINGS REPLY REPORT; E-MAIL

EDITS TO CO-COUNSEL FOR REVIEW; PHONE CALL WITH

HASTINGS REGARDING SAME.

7/11/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 488817 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING MOTION TO

STRIKE RUBIN REPORT; E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL WITH

PROPOSED EDITS TO MOTION.

7/11/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 488823 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING REPLY

BRIEF, HASTINGS REPLY REPORT, MOTION TO STRIKE, DAUBERT

MOTION AND CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 85 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 84

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 7/11/2018 JMM 820.00 6.00 4,920.00 Billable 488824 PLDS/MO-A EDIT DRAFT REPLY BRIEF, DRAFT MOTION TO STRIKE AND DRAFT

DAUBERT MOTION, E-MAIL ALL TO CO-COUNSEL FOR REVIEW.

7/12/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 488819 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL AND EXPERT

REGARDING REPLY EXPERT REPORT AND REPLY BRIEF.

7/12/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 488828 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEETING WITH S. JAIN AND P. GRAVLEY REGARDING REPLY

CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF.

7/12/2018 JMM 820.00 7.20 5,904.00 Billable 488829 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT REPLY CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF, MANNING

REPLY DECLARATION AND EXHIBITS, MOTION TO STRIKE,

ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL AND EXHIBITS.

7/12/2018 JMM 820.00 1.40 1,148.00 Billable 488830 EXPERTS-A REVIEW AND EDIT REPLY HASTINGS REPORT.

7/13/2018 JMM 820.00 8.20 6,724.00 Billable 488827 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW, EDIT AND FINALIZE REPLY CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF,

HASTINGS REPLY REPORT, MANNING REPLY DECLARATION AND

EXHIBITS, ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL,

PROPOSED ORDER, MOTION TO STRIKE, MOTION FOR AN ORDER

SHORTENING TIME, PROPOSED ORDER; PHONE CALLS WITH

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

7/23/2018 JMM 820.00 1.20 984.00 Billable 489372 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE FOR, LITIGATION STRATEGY MEETING WITH Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 86 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 85

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt CO-COUNSEL.

7/23/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 489376 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CALL WITH DAN WARSHAW REGARDING EXPERT

REPORTS AND TIMING.

7/23/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 489377 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO SHORTEN TIME

FOR HEARING ON MOTION TO STRIKE RUBIN DECLARATION.

7/24/2018 JMM 820.00 5.20 4,264.00 Billable 489373 PLDS/MO-A PREPARE OUTLINE OF ARGUMENT FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION

HEARING; PREPARE FOR ORAL ARGUMENT.

7/24/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 489381 EXPERTS-A PHONE CALL WITH DR. HASTINGS REGARDING EXPERT MERITS

REPORT SCHEDULE AND CLASS CERTIFICATION HEARING.

7/25/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 489370 EXPERTS-A REVIEW E-MAIL FROM J. LERNER ABOUT EXPERT DISCOVERY

SCHEDULE, E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME; E-MAIL

RESPONSE TO J. LERNER.

7/25/2018 JMM 820.00 5.20 4,264.00 Billable 489382 PLDS/MO-A PREPARE FOR HEARING ON CLASS CERTIFICATION; PREPARE

EXHIBITS FOR DEMONSTRATIVE.

7/26/2018 JMM 820.00 3.30 2,706.00 Billable 489378 PLDS/MO-A PREPARE FOR HEARING ON CLASS CERTIFICATION, DRAFT

OUTLINE, PREPARE DEMONSTRATIVE.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 87 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 86

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 7/27/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 489384 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT STIPULATION REGARDING ADMISSIBILITY OF EVIDENCE,

SEND TO APPLE.

7/27/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 489472 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW DRAFT STIPULATION REGARDING EXPERT REPORTS

AND DISCOVERY, E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME,

EDITS, E-MAIL TO APPLE REGARDING SAME.

7/31/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 489926 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING MEET AND CONFER

WITH APPLE ON OUTSTANDING DISCOVERY ISSUES.

7/31/2018 JMM 820.00 2.10 1,722.00 Billable 489935 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE FOR, AND MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE REGARDING

OUTSTANDING DISCOVERY ISSUES.

8/1/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 490652 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT E-MAIL TO APPLE REGARDING REQUEST FOR

TRANSACTIONAL TRADE-IN AND RESALE DATA, E-MAILS TO

EXPERT REGARDING SAME.

8/1/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 490678 EXPERTS-A CONFERENCE CALL WITH EXPERT TO DISCUSS TRADE-IN AND

RESALE DATA, AND EXPERT DAMAGES REPORT.

8/2/2018 JMM 820.00 1.30 1,066.00 Billable 490667 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEET WITH S. JAIN AND P. GRAVLEY REGARDING CASE.

8/2/2018 JMM 820.00 6.00 4,920.00 Billable 490671 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW HOT DOCUMENTS, APPLE'S RESPONSES TO DISCOVERY, Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 88 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 87

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

APPLE'S ANSWER, APPLE'S INITIAL DISCLOSURES, AND JURY

INSTRUCTIONS, AND DRAFT FOURTH SET OF REQUESTS FOR

PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS, THIRD SET OF

INTERROGATORIES AND THIRD SET OF REQUESTS FOR

ADMISSION.

8/3/2018 JMM 820.00 2.30 1,886.00 Billable 490674 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT LETTER BRIEF MOTIONS TO COMPEL WITNESSES TO

APPEAR FOR DEPOSITION, TO EXTEND 10-DEPOSITION LIMIT,

AND TO PRODUCE RESALE AND TRADE IN DATA; LEGAL

RESEARCH REGARDING SAME.

8/6/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 490656 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW EDITS TO RFAS AND INTERROGATORIES, MAKE

FURTHER EDITS AND RECIRCULATE TO CO-COUNSEL FOR

REVIEW.

8/6/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 490680 ATTYMTG.STR - A DRAFT AND CIRCULATE AGENDA FOR WEEKLY TEAM CALL.

8/6/2018 JMM 820.00 3.00 2,460.00 Billable 490681 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH AND DRAFT MOTION TO COMPEL APPLE TO PRODUCE

WITNESSES FOR DEPOSITION.

8/7/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 490644 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON POTENTIAL MEDIATORS, E-MAILS TO

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

8/7/2018 JMM 820.00 2.00 1,640.00 Billable 490669 EXPERTS-A RESEARCH ON EXPERT DAMAGES REPORTS IN CLASS ACTION Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 89 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 88

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

CASES.

8/8/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 490641 ATTYMTG.STR - A WEEKLY LITIGATION STRATEGY MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

8/8/2018 JMM 820.00 1.40 1,148.00 Billable 490643 PLDS/MO-A EDIT AND FINALIZE JOINT LETTER BRIEF MOTION TO COMPEL

APPLE TO PRODUCE WITNESSES FOR DEPOSITION, E-MAIL SAME

TO APPLE'S COUNSEL.

8/8/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 490646 RESEARCH-A REVIEW JUDGE BREYER'S DECISION GRANTING CLASS

CERTIFICATION IN TRANSPACIFIC AND CONSIDER WHETHER TO

FILE NOTICE OF RECENT AUTHORITY, REVIEW LOCAL RULES,

E-MAIL WITH COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

8/8/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 490650 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AND EDIT PLAINTIFFS' FOURTH REQUEST FOR

PRODUCTIONS, THIRD REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION AND FIRST

INTERROGATORIES, FINALIZE.

8/9/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 490860 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL AND CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING CHOOSING A MEDIATOR.

8/9/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 490861 EXPERTS-A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH EXPERT REGARDING MERITS

DAMAGES REPORT.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 90 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 89

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 8/13/2018 JMM 820.00 1.30 1,066.00 Billable 491349 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AND EDIT RESPONSES TO APPLE'S REQUESTS FOR

ADMISSION AND INTERROGATORIES, E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL

FOR REVIEW AND POSSIBLE EDIT.

8/13/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 491355 RESEARCH-A REVIEW JUDGE KOH'S CLASS CERTIFICATION DECISION IN ARRIS

CABLE CASE.

8/14/2018 JMM 820.00 0.70 574.00 Billable 491387 ATTYMTG.STR - A WEEKLY LITIGATION STRATEGY MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

8/14/2018 JMM 820.00 3.00 2,460.00 Billable 491388 EXPERTS-A REVIEW DRAFT EXPERT REPORT OF DR. MARK JONES; EDITS TO

DRAFT REPORT OF DR. HASTINGS.

8/14/2018 JMM 820.00 1.70 1,394.00 Billable 491389 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW, EDIT, FINALIZE AND FILE DRAFT LETTER BRIEF MOTION

TO COMPEL, REVIEW AND EDIT ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION TO FILE

UNDER SEAL.

8/17/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 491392 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT AND SEND LETTER TO APPLE REGARDING PLAINTIFFS'

REQUEST FOR CLASS MEMBER INFORMATION.

8/20/2018 JMM 820.00 0.70 574.00 Billable 491647 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT PLAINTIFFS' AMENDED DISCOVERY RESPONSES, E-MAIL

TO CO-COUNSEL FOR REVIEW.

8/20/2018 JMM 820.00 0.70 574.00 Billable 491657 EXPERTS-A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL AND DR. HASTINGS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 91 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 90

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

REGARDING EXPERT MERITS REPORT.

8/20/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 491658 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW PLAINTIFFS' AMENDED DISCOVERY RESPONSES.

8/21/2018 JMM 820.00 0.40 328.00 Billable 491648 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING HEARING

TOMORROW ON DISCOVERY DISPUTES.

8/23/2018 JMM 820.00 1.20 984.00 Billable 491641 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE AND CIRCULATE AGENDA (.1); PHONE CONFERENCE

WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS AND PROJECTS

(1.1).

8/23/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 491652 EXPERTS-A PHONE CALL WITH DR. HASTINGS REGARDING MERITS REPORT.

8/23/2018 JMM 820.00 2.00 1,640.00 Billable 491653 EXPERTS-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT MERITS DAMAGES REPORT OF DR.

HASTINGS.

8/24/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 491654 EXPERTS-A PHONE CALL WITH DR. HASTINGS REGARDING MERITS REPORT.

8/24/2018 JMM 820.00 4.30 3,526.00 Billable 491662 EXPERTS-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT MERITS REPORT OF JUSTINE

HASTINGS.

8/26/2018 JMM 820.00 6.40 5,248.00 Billable 491655 EXPERTS-A REVIEW AND EDIT HASTINGS MERITS REPORT, CIRCULATE TO

CO-COUNSEL, PHONE CALL WITH DR. HASTINGS REGARDING Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 92 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 91

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

SAME.

8/27/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 493244 EXPERTS-A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING DRAFT

HASTINGS MERITS REPORT (.5); PHONE CONFERENCE WITH DR.

HASTINGS REGARDING DRAFT MERITS REPORT (1.0).

8/27/2018 JMM 820.00 1.30 1,066.00 Billable 493245 EXPERTS-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT EXPERT REPORT OF DR. JONES.

8/27/2018 JMM 820.00 3.70 3,034.00 Billable 493246 EXPERTS-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT HASTINGS REPORT.

8/28/2018 JMM 820.00 3.30 2,706.00 Billable 493257 EXPERTS-A REVIEW AND EDIT REVISED HASTINGS REPORT; PHONE CALLS

WITH HASTINGS REGARDING SAME; E-MAILS TO CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING SAME; FINALIZE AND SERVE ON APPLE.

8/28/2018 JMM 820.00 2.50 2,050.00 Billable 493282 EXPERTS-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT JONES REPORT; REVIEW FINAL DRAFT;

E-MAILS TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

8/29/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 493258 ATTYMTG.STR - A DRAFT AND CIRCULATE AGENDA FOR WEEKLY LITIGATION

MEETING.

8/30/2018 JMM 820.00 0.70 574.00 Billable 493264 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT RESPONSES TO APPLE'S DISCOVERY.

8/30/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 493265 EXPERTS-A PHONE CALL WITH DR. HASTINGS REGARDING CASE SCHEDULE Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 93 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 92

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

AND POSSIBLE DEPOSITION.

8/30/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 493269 ATTYMTG.STR - A WEEKLY LITIGATION MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

8/31/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 493261 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL REGARDING

PRODUCTION OF CLASS MEMBER IDENTITIES AND INFORMATION

IDENTIFYING DEVICES.

9/4/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 494182 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH AND DRAFT STIPULATION REGARDING PRODUCTION

OF INFORMATION IDENTIFYING CLASS MEMBERS, E-MAIL TO

CO-COUNSEL FOR REVIEW, EDIT AND SEND TO APPLE.

9/5/2018 JMM 820.00 0.80 656.00 Billable 494146 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AND EDIT RESPONSES TO APPLE'S RFAS AND

INTERROGATORIES, E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

9/5/2018 JMM 820.00 1.10 902.00 Billable 494163 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE AND CIRCULATE AGENDA FOR (.1); WEEKLY LITIGATION

STRATEGY MEETING (1.0).

9/5/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 494164 CLIENT MEETING-A COMMUNICATION WITH CLIENT REGARDING INTERROGATORY

RESPONSES.

9/5/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 494181 ATTYMTG.STR - A RESEARCH ON APPLE'S PROPOSED MEDIATOR; E-MAIL TO

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 94 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 93

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

9/6/2018 JMM 820.00 1.10 902.00 Billable 494156 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW AND EDIT PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSES TO APPLE'S

INTERROGATORIES AND REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION; E-MAIL TO

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

9/6/2018 JMM 820.00 1.30 1,066.00 Billable 494157 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW EXAMPLES OF DOCUMENTS PRODUCED BY PLAINTIFFS

FOR WHICH APPLE IS REQUESTING REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION

TO ADMIT AUTHENTICITY, REVIEW DRAFT REQUESTS FOR

ADMISSION RESPONSES, REVIEW FEDERAL RULES AND EDIT

SAME.

9/6/2018 JMM 820.00 1.30 1,066.00 Billable 494179 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW APPLE'S NEW DOCUMENT PRODUCTION, E-MAILS TO

COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

9/10/2018 JMM 820.00 1.30 1,066.00 Billable 494175 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW TRANSCRIPTS OF DEPOSITIONS OF CALDBECK AND

VIDRINE.

9/11/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 494171 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW APPLE'S RESPONSES AND OBJECTIONS TO FOURTH SET

OF REQUEST FOR PRODUCTIONS, POTTER'S FIRST SET OF

INTERROGATORIES, AND PLAINTIFFS' THIRD SET OF REQUESTS

FOR ADMISSION, PREPARE FOR MEET AND CONFER.

9/11/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 494173 ATTYMTG.STR - A DRAFT AGENDA FOR WEEKLY LITIGATION MEETING, CIRCULATE

TO CO-COUNSEL. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 95 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 94

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

9/12/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 494147 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CALL WITH DAN WARSHAW REGARDING APPLE'S

PROPOSED MEDIATOR.

9/12/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 494159 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE FOR MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL (.3);

MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL REGARDING

APPLE'S DISCOVERY RESPONSES (.7).

9/12/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 494172 ATTYMTG.STR - A WEEKLY LITIGATION MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

9/13/2018 JMM 820.00 1.80 1,476.00 Billable 494143 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT LETTER BRIEF REGARDING

OUTSTANDING DISCOVERY DISPUTES WITH APPLE.

9/13/2018 JMM 820.00 0.70 574.00 Billable 494144 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S PROPOSED LETTER BRIEF REGARDING

FORENSIC IMAGING, MEETING WITH S. JAIN REGARDING SAME,

REVIEW AND EDIT PLAINTIFFS' SECTION.

9/14/2018 JMM 820.00 2.80 2,296.00 Billable 494138 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT, EDIT, FINALIZE AND FILE PLAINTIFFS' LETTER BRIEF

REGARDING DISCOVERY DISPUTE, REVIEW EXHIBITS, AND SERVE

ON APPLE.

9/14/2018 JMM 820.00 1.20 984.00 Billable 494139 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT OPPOSITION TO APPLE'S LETTER BRIEF

REGARDING FORENSIC IMAGING, E-MAILS TO CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING SAME. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 96 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 95

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

9/17/2018 JMM 820.00 2.50 2,050.00 Billable 494363 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW, RESEARCH, EDIT AND DRAFT LEGAL SECTION IN

RESPONSE TO APPLE'S LETTER BRIEF REGARDING IMAGING

PROCESS AND SANCTIONS, E-MAIL SAME TO CO-COUNSEL FOR

REVIEW.

9/17/2018 JMM 820.00 1.20 984.00 Billable 494364 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING APPLE'S

REBUTTAL REPORTS AND EXPERT DEPOSITIONS; PHONE CALL

WITH DAN WARSHAW REGARDING SAME.

9/18/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 494353 CLIENT MEETING-A E-MAILS TO CLIENT REGARDING CLASS CERTIFICATION DECISION.

9/18/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 494365 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW JUDGE KOH'S ORDER ON CLASS CERTIFICATION;

STRATEGY CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME; E-MAILS

TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

9/19/2018 JMM 820.00 2.30 1,886.00 Billable 494354 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON APPLICATION OF HYUNDAI DECISION TO

NATIONWIDE SETTLEMENTS, REVIEW CASE LAW.

9/19/2018 JMM 820.00 3.00 2,460.00 Billable 494374 EXPERTS-A REVIEW EXPERT REPORTS OF AVI RUBIN AND NEIL MALHOTRA.

9/21/2018 JMM 820.00 6.00 4,920.00 Billable 494381 DEP TAKE/DEF-A REVIEW MALHOTRA'S REPORT, REVIEW TREXLER DEPOSITION

TRANSCRIPT; PREPARE FOR MALHOTRA DEPOSITION; DRAFT Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 97 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 96

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt DEPOSITION OUTLINE.

9/21/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 494400 ATTYMTG.STR - A WEEKLY LITIGATION MEETING WITH COUNSEL.

9/22/2018 JMM 820.00 4.80 3,936.00 Billable 494502 DEP TAKE/DEF-A PREPARE FOR MALHOLTRA DEPOSITION; PHONE CALL WITH

EXPERTS REGARDING SAME.

9/22/2018 JMM 820.00 1.30 1,066.00 Billable 494511 EXPERTS-A REVIEW ROUGH TRANSCRIPT OF HASTINGS DEPOSITION IN

PREPARATION FOR MALHOTRA DEPOSITION.

9/23/2018 JMM 820.00 2.50 2,050.00 Billable 494514 EXPERTS-A REVIEW REVISED QUESTIONS FOR MALHOTRA FROM DR.

HASTINGS, DRAFT AND EDIT DEPOSITION OUTLINE.

9/24/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 495515 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL DAN WARSHAW REGARDING

CLASS NOTICE, MEDIATION AND CASE STRATEGY.

9/24/2018 JMM 820.00 4.40 3,608.00 Billable 495518 DEP PREP-A PREPARE FOR MALHOTRA DEPOSITION, REVIEW ROUGH OF

HASTING'S DEPOSITION, FINALIZE OUTLINE AND EXHIBITS.

9/25/2018 JMM 820.00 0.70 574.00 Billable 495510 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEETING WITH ALLAN REGARDING EXPERT DEPOSITION AND

UPCOMING MEDIATION.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 98 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 97

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 9/25/2018 JMM 820.00 7.50 6,150.00 Billable 495514 DEP TAKE/DEF-A TAKE DEPOSITION OF NEIL MALHOTRA.

9/25/2018 JMM 820.00 1.30 1,066.00 Billable 495519 DEP PREP-A PREPARE FOR MALHOTRA DEPOSITION.

9/26/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 495512 EXPERTS-A REVIEW ROUGH TRANSCRIPT OF MALHOTRA DEPOSITION; E-MAIL

SAME TO HASTINGS.

9/27/2018 JMM 820.00 2.00 1,640.00 Billable 495520 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT MEDIATION BRIEF.

10/1/2018 JMM 820.00 1.70 1,394.00 Billable 495998 ATTYMTG.STR - A DRAFT AND CIRCULATE AGENDA FOR LITIGATION MEETING (.3);

LITIGATION MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL (1.4).

10/1/2018 JMM 820.00 2.70 2,214.00 Billable 496001 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT MEDIATION BRIEF; SELECT DOCUMENTS FOR

DEMONSTRATIVE FOR MEDIATION.

10/1/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 496007 RESEARCH-A LEGAL RESEARCH ON TOLLING DEADLINE TO FILE 23(F) PETITION

(.5); LOCAL RULES ON TAKING DEPOSITIONS AFTER CLOSE OF

DISCOVERY (.3); LOCAL RULES FOR FILING MOTION FOR

RECONSIDERATION (.2).

10/1/2018 JMM 820.00 2.30 1,886.00 Billable 496039 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE MOTION

FOR RECONSIDERATION.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 99 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 98

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 10/1/2018 JMM 820.00 0.80 656.00 Billable 496046 DISCOVERY-A UPDATE PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSES TO INTERROGATORIES AND

REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION.

10/2/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 495995 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CALL WITH SCOTT MACRAE REGARDING MOTION FOR

RECONSIDERATION.

10/2/2018 JMM 820.00 5.20 4,264.00 Billable 496000 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION;

REVIEW LOCAL RULES; DRAFT PROPOSED ORDERS; PREPARE

FOR FILING; PROOF READ.

10/2/2018 JMM 820.00 2.70 2,214.00 Billable 496002 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW PLAINTIFFS' DISCOVERY RESPONSES AND PREPARE

UPDATED RESPONSES; PHONE CALL WITH CLIENT GRACE

REGARDING SAME.

10/2/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 496008 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL TO DISCUSS DRAFT

MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION AND ARGUMENTS THEREIN.

10/2/2018 JMM 820.00 0.70 574.00 Billable 496042 RESEARCH-A REVIEW DAVILA'S OPINION IN APPLE DEVICE PERFORMANCE

LITIGATION AND DRAFT SECTION REGARDING "NEW LAW" IN

MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION.

10/3/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 495993 DISCOVERY-A PHONE CALL WITH S. JAIN REGARDING UPDATES TO PLAINTIFFS'

DISCOVERY RESPONSES. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 100 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 99

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

10/3/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 496048 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CALL WITH D. WARSHAW REGARDING 23(F) APPEAL.

10/3/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 496061 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CHOOSING

LEAD TRIAL COUNSEL.

10/4/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 496017 CLIENT MEETING-A E-MAIL TO CLIENT GRACE REGARDING AMENDED DISCOVERY

RESPONSES.

10/4/2018 JMM 820.00 0.70 574.00 Billable 496034 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW PROPOSALS FROM POTENTIAL CLAIMS

ADMINISTRATORS RUST, EPIQ AND JND; PREPARE FOR MEETING

WITH D. WARSHAW REGARDING SAME.

10/5/2018 JMM 820.00 1.20 984.00 Billable 496021 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND

SUPPORTING DECLARATIONS AND DOCUMENTS.

10/9/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 496808 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL (A. PILMER)

REGARDING THE DISCOVERY ISSUES IN PLAINTIFFS' SEPT. 18

LETTER BRIEF, PER THE COURT'S ORDER.

10/9/2018 JMM 820.00 2.00 1,640.00 Billable 496809 TRIAL PREP-A REVIEW HOT DOCUMENTS AND PREPARE LIST OF TRIAL

EXHIBITS FOR AUTHENTICITY/BUSINESS RECORDS STIPULATION.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 101 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 100

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 10/9/2018 JMM 820.00 0.70 574.00 Billable 496810 EXPERTS-A REVIEW TRANSCRIPT OF DEPOSITION OF AVI RUBIN.

10/10/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 496818 ATTYMTG.STR - A WEEKLY LITIGATION MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

10/10/2018 JMM 820.00 1.70 1,394.00 Billable 496858 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH AND OUTLINE RULE 23(F) APPEAL.

10/11/2018 JMM 820.00 0.70 574.00 Billable 496861 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT; CIRCULATE TO

CO-COUNSEL.

10/14/2018 JMM 820.00 0.80 656.00 Billable 496844 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW PROPOSED EDITS TO JOINT CMS REGARDING CLASS

NOTICE; MAKE FURTHER EDITS TO JOINT CMS; CIRCULATE TO

CO-COUNSEL FOR REVIEW.

10/15/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 497232 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT OPPOSITION TO APPLE'S SUMMARY

JUDGMENT MOTION.

10/15/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 497234 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING JOINT

CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT.

10/15/2018 JMM 820.00 0.10 82.00 Billable 497250 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S DRAFT JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT.

10/15/2018 JMM 820.00 0.70 574.00 Billable 497251 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING DRAFT Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 102 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 101

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt OPPOSITION TO APPLE'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT.

10/16/2018 JMM 820.00 3.50 2,870.00 Billable 497240 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH, EDIT AND DRAFT PORTIONS OF OPPOSITION TO

APPLE'S SUMMARY JUDGMENT MOTION, RESTITUTION SECTION,

PHONE CALLS WITH SCOTT MACRAE REGARDING SAME.

10/16/2018 JMM 820.00 1.80 1,476.00 Billable 497244 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT MEDIATION BRIEF; REVIEW

DOCUMENTS TO ATTACH TO BRIEF AND FOR DEMONSTRATIVE

FOR MEDIATION.

10/17/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 497249 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S DRAFT INSERT FOR JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT

CONFERENCE (.2); EDIT PLAINTIFFS' SECTION (.3); PHONE CALLS

WITH S. JAIN REGARDING SAME (.3); REVIEW FINAL DRAFT

BEFORE FILING (.2).

10/18/2018 JMM 820.00 1.70 1,394.00 Billable 497241 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH AND DRAFT OUTLINE OF 23(F) APPEAL.

10/18/2018 JMM 820.00 0.70 574.00 Billable 497243 ATTYMTG.STR - A WEEKLY LITIGATION MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

10/18/2018 JMM 820.00 3.40 2,788.00 Billable 497245 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT OPPOSITION TO APPLE'S MOTION FOR

SUMMARY JUDGMENT (1.2); REVIEW AND EDIT MANNING

DECLARATION. (.8); PHONE CALLS WITH S. JAIN REGARDING

SAME (.4).

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 103 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 102

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 10/23/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 497720 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CALL WITH ATTORNEY D. WARSHAW REGARDING CASE

STRATEGY.

10/24/2018 JMM 820.00 1.00 820.00 Billable 497676 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE AND CIRCULATE AGENDA FOR, WEEKLY LITIGATION

MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

10/24/2018 JMM 820.00 2.30 1,886.00 Billable 497677 RESEARCH-A REVIEW RESEARCH MEMORANDUM ON 23(F) LEGAL ISSUES;

REVIEW CASES IN PREPARATION FOR CONFERENCE CALL WITH

CO-COUNSEL.

10/24/2018 JMM 820.00 0.80 656.00 Billable 497678 RESEARCH-A REVIEW RESEARCH MEMORANDUM ON STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS

AND DISCOVERY RULE IN VARIOUS STATES, REVIEW CASES IN

PREPARATION FOR CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

10/25/2018 JMM 820.00 0.70 574.00 Billable 497693 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING 23(F)

PETITION.

10/25/2018 JMM 820.00 2.30 1,886.00 Billable 497714 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON INJUNCTIVE RELIEF SECTION OF 23(F) PETITION,

REVIEW CASES.

10/26/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 497718 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S REPLY IN SUPPORT OF SUMMARY JUDGMENT.

10/26/2018 JMM 820.00 1.70 1,394.00 Billable 497750 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT 23(F) PETITION FOR REVIEW OF CLASS CERTIFICATION Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 104 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 103

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

ORDER.

10/26/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 497755 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH SCOTT MACRAE REGARDING THE

23(F) PETITION.

10/29/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 498240 SETTLE-A PRE-MEDIATION PHONE CONFERENCE WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL

R. PILMER AND J. LERNER.

10/29/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 498251 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL TEJTEL, CURRY, CALDWELL

AND WARSHAW REGARDING PRE-MEDIATION CALL WITH JAMS.

10/29/2018 JMM 820.00 4.50 3,690.00 Billable 498253 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH AND DRAFT RULE 23(F) PETITION FOR LEAVE TO

APPEAL CLASS CERTIFICATION ORDER.

10/30/2018 JMM 820.00 1.70 1,394.00 Billable 498288 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT MEDIATION STATEMENT.

10/30/2018 JMM 820.00 5.30 4,346.00 Billable 498299 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH AND DRAFT 23(F) PETITION, CIRCULATE TO

CO-COUNSEL.

10/31/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 498249 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT MEDIATION BRIEF.

10/31/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 498252 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON APPELLATE RULES FOR FILING 23(F) PETITION.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 105 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 104

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 10/31/2018 JMM 820.00 0.80 656.00 Billable 498280 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE AND CIRCULATE AGENDA FOR; WEEKLY MEETING WITH

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE.

10/31/2018 JMM 820.00 1.30 1,066.00 Billable 498326 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT REVIEW AND EDIT 23(F) PETITION.

11/1/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 499111 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEETING WITH A. STEYER REGARDING CASE, UPCOMING

MEDIATION AND STRATEGY FOR FILING ADDITIONAL CASES.

11/1/2018 JMM 820.00 0.50 410.00 Billable 499112 SETTLE-A PHONE CALL WITH D. WARSHAW REGARDING MEDIATION.

11/1/2018 JMM 820.00 1.30 1,066.00 Billable 499145 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT MEDIATION BRIEF.

11/2/2018 JMM 820.00 4.00 3,280.00 Billable 499126 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH, DRAFT, AND EDIT RULE 23(F) PETITION.

11/2/2018 JMM 820.00 0.80 656.00 Billable 499127 SETTLE-A REVIEW APPLE'S MEDIATION STATEMENT.

11/5/2018 JMM 820.00 4.70 3,854.00 Billable 499124 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW, EDIT, FINALIZE AND PREPARE FOR FILING 23(F)

PETITION; REVIEW RULES FOR FILING PETITION.

11/6/2018 JMM 820.00 3.50 2,870.00 Billable 499143 SETTLE-A PREPARE FOR MEDIATION.

11/6/2018 JMM 820.00 2.80 2,296.00 Billable 499148 SETTLE-A PREPARE FOR AND CIRCULATE AGENDA FOR, PRE-MEDIATION Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 106 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 105

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

VIDEO-CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL.

11/8/2018 JMM 820.00 2.30 1,886.00 Billable 499135 SETTLE-A PREPARE FOR MEDIATION WITH APPLE.

11/9/2018 JMM 820.00 5.30 4,346.00 Billable 499118 SETTLE-A PREPARE FOR AND ATTEND MEDIATION AT JAMS WITH APPLE.

11/9/2018 JMM 820.00 1.80 1,476.00 Billable 499147 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON CLASS NOTICE PROCEDURES, REVIEW MOTION

TO APPROVE NOTICE IN QUALCOMM; E-MAIL TO APPLE'S

COUNSEL REGARDING CLASS CONTACT INFORMATION.

11/15/2018 JMM 820.00 0.80 656.00 Billable 499664 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ON FILING REPLY IN SUPPORT OF 23(F) PETITION.

11/16/2018 JMM 820.00 0.70 574.00 Billable 499659 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S OPPOSITION TO 23(F) PETITION.

11/16/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 499685 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING 23(F)

PETITION.

11/16/2018 JMM 820.00 2.20 1,804.00 Billable 499687 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S OPPOSITION TO 23(F) PETITION, READ CASES,

RESEARCH ON RIGHT TO FILE A REPLY; OUTLINE REPLY.

11/28/2018 JMM 820.00 1.50 1,230.00 Billable 500743 SETTLE-A REVIEW ND CAL'S NEW RULE ON SETTLING CLASS ACTION

CASES; DRAFT MEMORANDUM REGARDING SAME.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 107 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 106

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 11/28/2018 JMM 820.00 0.30 246.00 Billable 500766 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH ATTORNEY D. PEARSON REGARDING

23(F) REPLY BRIEF.

12/5/2018 JMM 820.00 0.70 574.00 Billable 501815 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT REPLY IN SUPPORT OF 23(F) PETITION.

12/10/2018 JMM 820.00 3.50 2,870.00 Billable 501758 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW, EDIT AND FINALIZE MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE REPLY

AND REPLY BRIEF, PREPARE FOR FILING.

12/10/2018 JMM 820.00 0.20 164.00 Billable 501766 EXPERTS-A E-MAILS TO EXPERT REGARDING CASE STATUS AND SCHEDULE.

12/10/2018 JMM 820.00 1.70 1,394.00 Billable 501801 CLIENT MEETING-A MEETING WITH CLIENT CHRISTINA GRACE REGARDING CASE

STATUS AND SCHEDULE, TRAVEL TO AND FROM MEETING.

1/14/2019 JMM 880.00 2.50 2,200.00 Billable 504196 INVESTIG-A RESEARCH ON POTENTIAL CLAIMS ADMINISTRATORS AND CLASS

NOTICE IN RECENT CONSUMER CASES.

1/15/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 504191 INVESTIG-A PHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL D. WARSHAW REGARDING

CLAIMS ADMINISTRATION; REVIEW THE MOTION TO APPROVE

CLASS NOTICE FILED IN QUALCOMM CASE; E-MAIL TO WARSHAW

REGARDING SAME.

1/23/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 504197 CASEMNG-A REVIEW 9TH CIRCUIT ORDER GRANTING QUALCOMM'S 23(F)

PETITION; E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 108 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 107

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

1/29/2019 JMM 880.00 0.50 440.00 Billable 505479 CASEMNG-A REVIEW JUDGE KOH'S ORDER DENYING PRELIMINARY APPROVAL

OF SETTLEMENT IN YAHOO DATA BREACH CASE; E-MAIL TO D.

WARSHAW REGARDING SAME.

2/8/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 506284 CASEMNG-A E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS AND

REQUESTING TO SCHEDULE CONFERENCE CALL; REVIEW

COURT'S ORDER STAYING CASE AND SETTING NEXT CASE

MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE.

2/8/2019 JMM 880.00 2.00 1,760.00 Billable 506293 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT MOTION TO APPROVE FORM AND PROCESS OF NOTICE.

2/14/2019 JMM 880.00 1.20 1,056.00 Billable 506830 CASEMNG-A ANALYZE PROPOSALS FROM POTENTIAL CLAIMS

ADMINISTRATORS REGARDING CLASS NOTICE.

2/19/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 507401 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S PROPOSED JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT

CONFERENCE STATEMENT, EDITS TO SAME; E-MAIL REVISED

JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE BACK TO APPLE.

2/20/2019 JMM 880.00 2.00 1,760.00 Billable 507545 TRIAL PREP-A UPDATE HOT DOCUMENTS BINDER BY WITNESS.

2/22/2019 JMM 880.00 5.00 4,400.00 Billable 507544 TRIAL PREP-A UPDATE HOT DOCUMENTS BINDER BY WITNESS.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 109 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 108

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 2/26/2019 JMM 880.00 5.00 4,400.00 Billable 507541 TRIAL PREP-A REVIEW AND UPDATE HOT DOCUMENT LIST AND WITNESS LIST;

REVIEW DEPOSITION EXHIBITS.

3/4/2019 JMM 880.00 0.20 176.00 Billable 508789 CLIENT MEETING-A DRAFT E-MAIL TO CLIENT KEN POTTER WITH CASE UPDATE.

3/22/2019 JMM 880.00 0.80 704.00 Billable 509586 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING 9TH

CIRCUIT RULING AND STRATEGY FOR MOVING FORWARD WITH

PROSECUTION OF CASE.

3/25/2019 JMM 880.00 0.50 440.00 Billable 509568 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH D. WARSHAW AND NOTICE

ADMINISTRATOR REGARDING FORM AND PROCESS FOR GIVING

NOTICE TO THE CLASS.

3/25/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 509639 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CALL WITH A. CURRY REGARDING INFORMATION NEEDED

FROM APPLE TO PROVIDE NOTICE TO THE CLASS.

3/25/2019 JMM 880.00 0.20 176.00 Billable 509640 CASEMNG-A REVIEW PRIOR E-MAILS TO APPLE'S COUNSEL REGARDING

CLASS INFORMATION, E-MAIL TO APPLE'S COUNSEL REQUESTING

INFORMATION NEEDED TO PROVIDE NOTICE.

3/28/2019 JMM 880.00 0.60 528.00 Billable 509608 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CLASS

NOTICE FORM AND MANNER AND OTHER LEGAL ISSUES.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 110 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 109

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 4/15/2019 JMM 880.00 0.50 440.00 Billable 511288 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CALL WITH D. WARSHAW REGARDING CASE STATUS.

4/22/2019 JMM 880.00 0.20 176.00 Billable 511783 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW DRAFT JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE

STATEMENT; E-MAIL TO COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

4/23/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 511724 PLDS/MO-A ADD PARAGRAPH TO DRAFT JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT

CONFERENCE STATEMENT REGARDING DISPUTE WITH APPLE

ABOUT PRODUCING INFORMATION IDENTIFYING CA CLASS

MEMBERS.

4/24/2019 JMM 880.00 0.70 616.00 Billable 511718 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S INSERTION IN CASE MANAGEMENT

CONFERENCE STATEMENT, DRAFT ADDITIONAL LANGUAGE IN

RESPONSE; REVIEW COURT ORDERS ON DISCOVERY AND

TRANSCRIPTS OF SAME.

4/26/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 511682 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH D. WARSHAW REGARDING COURT

SCHEDULING ORDER; PHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING COURT SCHEDULING ORDER.

6/6/2019 JMM 880.00 0.50 440.00 Billable 516365 CASEMNG-A REVIEW NINTH CIRCUIT EN BANC DECISION IN HYUNDAI, E-MAIL

TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

6/11/2019 JMM 880.00 0.80 704.00 Billable 516689 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL REGARDING THE Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 111 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 110

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt INFORMATION NEEDED TO PROVIDE NOTICE TO THE CLASS;

DRAFT AND SEND CONFIRMATORY E-MAIL TO APPLE'S COUNSEL

REGARDING SAME.

7/10/2019 JMM 880.00 0.70 616.00 Billable 519962 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL J. LERNER

AND E. NOVOKOV REGARDING CLASS MEMBER IDENTIFYING

INFORMATION FOR PURPOSES OF PROVIDING NOTICE, AND

CLASS NOTICE ADMINISTRATORS (.3); E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING SAME (.2); CONFIRMING E-MAIL TO APPLE'S

COUNSEL REGARDING SAME (.2).

7/22/2019 JMM 880.00 0.70 616.00 Billable 520708 ATTYMTG.STR - A RESEARCH ON HEARING TRANSCRIPTS BEFORE JUDGE KOH IN

PREPARATION OF SUMMARY JUDGMENT HEARING; REVIEW

TRANSCRIPT; E-MAIL SAME TO CO-COUNSEL.

7/30/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 521087 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S NOTICE OF RECENT AUTHORITY AND

ATTACHED CASE.

8/19/2019 JMM 880.00 0.70 616.00 Billable 523288 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE,

CLASS NOTICE, AMENDING THE COMPLAINT, AND SUMMARY

JUDGMENT.

8/21/2019 JMM 880.00 1.50 1,320.00 Billable 523286 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT;

RESEARCH ON STANDARDS FOR FILING A MOTION FOR LEAVE TO

FILE AMENDED COMPLAINT; REVIEW PRIOR FILING. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 112 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 111

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

8/21/2019 JMM 880.00 0.70 616.00 Billable 523290 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW COURT'S ORDER DENYING APPLE'S MOTION FOR

SUMMARY JUDGMENT (.5); E-MAIL ORDER TO CLIENTS POTTER

AND GRACE (.2).

8/23/2019 JMM 880.00 1.00 880.00 Billable 523824 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

KOH'S ORDER ON SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND PROCEDURE FOR

MOVING FORWARD; DRAFT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE

STATEMENT AND MEDIATION.

8/26/2019 JMM 880.00 0.50 440.00 Billable 523778 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE

MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT AND MEDIATION AND

OTHER CASE ISSUES.

8/26/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 523792 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CALL WITH ATTORNEY A. STEYER REGARDING

MEDIATION AND OTHER CASE ISSUES.

8/27/2019 JMM 880.00 0.70 616.00 Billable 523806 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S DRAFT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE

STATEMENT, EDIT, SEND TO CO-COUNSEL.

8/27/2019 JMM 880.00 0.80 704.00 Billable 523823 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING APPLE'S

PROPOSED JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE

STATEMENT AND MEDIATION.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 113 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 112

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 8/28/2019 JMM 880.00 1.00 880.00 Billable 523827 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW DRAFT LETTER BRIEF REGARDING APPLE'S REFUSAL TO

PRODUCE UPDATED SPREADSHEETS; EDIT AND CIRCULATE TO

CO-COUNSEL.

9/3/2019 JMM 880.00 0.20 176.00 Billable 524762 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CALL WITH S. JAIN REGARDING CASE STATUS AND

PROJECTS.

9/11/2019 JMM 880.00 0.20 176.00 Billable 525557 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW MEMORANDUM REGARDING APPLE'S UPDATED

SPREADSHEETS IDENTIFYING CLASS MEMBERS; E-MAIL SAME TO

CO-COUNSEL.

9/12/2019 JMM 880.00 0.50 440.00 Billable 525553 PLDS/MO-A PREPARE JOINT SETTLEMENT STATUS UPDATE FOR THE COURT;

E-MAIL TO APPLE'S COUNSEL; FINALIZE AND FILE.

9/20/2019 JMM 880.00 0.70 616.00 Billable 525653 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CALL WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL J. LERNER AND G.

NOVIKOV REGARDING PROCESS AND SCHEDULE FOR OPT OUT

CLASS NOTICE; PHONE CALL WITH D. WARSHAW REGARDING

SAME.

9/24/2019 JMM 880.00 2.00 1,760.00 Billable 526537 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT MEDIATION BRIEF; REVIEW KEY

DOCUMENTS FOR SUBMISSION TO JUDGE CAHILL AT

PRE-MEDIATION MEETING NEXT WEEK.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 114 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 113

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 9/24/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 526570 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEETING WITH A. STEYER REGARDING CASE AND MEDIATION

STRATEGY.

9/25/2019 JMM 880.00 1.20 1,056.00 Billable 526542 SETTLE-A PREPARE FOR AND MEETING WITH JUDGE CAHILL REGARDING

UPCOMING MEDIATION.

9/25/2019 JMM 880.00 0.50 440.00 Billable 526580 SETTLE-A FURTHER EDITS TO DRAFT MEDIATION BRIEF; CIRCULATE TO

CO-COUNSEL FOR REVIEW AND COMMENT.

9/25/2019 JMM 880.00 0.50 440.00 Billable 526582 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

UPCOMING MEDIATION AND RANGE FOR DEMAND.

9/30/2019 JMM 880.00 1.30 1,144.00 Billable 526548 CLIENT MEETING-A MEETING WITH CLIENT CHRISTINA GRACE REGARDING CASE

STATUS, SCHEDULE AND POTENTIAL SETTLEMENT DEMAND.

9/30/2019 JMM 880.00 2.20 1,936.00 Billable 526567 SETTLE-A PREPARE DRAFT LETTER TO CAHILL WITH SETTLEMENT

DEMAND; CIRCULATE SAME TO CO-COUNSEL FOR REVIEW.

10/1/2019 JMM 880.00 0.50 440.00 Billable 527224 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

SETTLEMENT DEMAND.

10/1/2019 JMM 880.00 0.20 176.00 Billable 527225 SETTLE-A MEETING WITH A. STEYER REGARDING SETTLEMENT DEMAND TO

APPLE. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 115 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 114

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

10/10/2019 JMM 880.00 0.80 704.00 Billable 527584 SETTLE-A REVIEW DR. HASTINGS' REPORTS (CLASS CERTIFICATION AND

MERITS) IN PREPARATION FOR MEDIATION; REVIEW HER

DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPT.

10/10/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 527617 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT PLAINTIFFS' MEDIATION STATEMENT,

CIRCULATE TO CO-COUNSEL FOR REVIEW.

10/16/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 527610 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH JUDGE CAHILL REGARDING

UPCOMING MEDIATION WITH APPLE.

10/16/2019 JMM 880.00 0.50 440.00 Billable 527611 SETTLE-A REVIEW, EDIT AND FINALIZE MEDIATION STATEMENT; REVIEW

EXHIBITS; REVIEW REDACTIONS; REVIEW FINAL DRAFTS FOR

SERVICE.

10/16/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 527624 SETTLE-A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING PHONE

CALL WITH CAHILL AND UPCOMING MEDIATION.

10/21/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 528288 SETTLE-A PHONE MEETING WITH A. STEYER REGARDING MEDIATION.

10/21/2019 JMM 880.00 1.10 968.00 Billable 528324 SETTLE-A PREPARE FOR MEDIATION; REVIEW PLAINTIFFS' ORIGINAL AND

UPDATED MEDIATION BRIEFS; REVIEW APPLE'S ORIGINAL

MEDIATION BRIEF. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 116 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 115

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

10/22/2019 JMM 880.00 8.30 7,304.00 Billable 528372 SETTLE-A ATTEND MEDIATION BEFORE JUDGE CAHILL.

10/23/2019 JMM 880.00 0.70 616.00 Billable 528357 SETTLE-A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING DRAFT

TERM SHEET, SETTLEMENT AND FORM AND MANNER OF NOTICE

OF SETTLEMENT.

10/30/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 529399 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

DRAFT SETTLEMENT TERM SHEET; STRATEGY FOR MOVING

FORWARD.

11/5/2019 JMM 880.00 0.50 440.00 Billable 529742 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

APPLE POTENTIAL SETTLEMENT.

11/8/2019 JMM 880.00 1.80 1,584.00 Billable 529730 SETTLE-A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING APPLE'S

PROPOSED MEDIATION STATUS UPDATE, PREPARE EDITS TO

STATEMENT, REVIEW JUDGE KOH'S STANDING ORDER ON

SETTLEMENT CONFERENCES, REVIEW ADR RULES, CIRCULATE

TO CO-COUNSEL FOR REVIEW, SEND TO APPLE.

11/8/2019 JMM 880.00 0.50 440.00 Billable 529731 CLIENT MEETING-A PREPARE E-MAIL STATUS UPDATES FOR CLIENTS C. GRACE AND

K. POTTER, SEND E-MAILS TO CLIENTS.

11/12/2019 JMM 880.00 0.20 176.00 Billable 530274 SETTLE-A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH APPLE COUNSEL J. LERNER Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 117 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 116

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

REGARDING MEDIATION STATUS UPDATE.

11/12/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 530294 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING MY

PHONE CALL WITH J. LERNER AND THE MEDIATION STATUS

UPDATE.

11/13/2019 JMM 880.00 0.20 176.00 Billable 530277 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH D. WARSHAW AND C. PEARSON

REGARDING MEDIATION, SETTLEMENT STATUS, AND UPDATED

MEDIATION STATEMENT.

11/13/2019 JMM 880.00 0.70 616.00 Billable 530300 TRIAL PREP-A TRIAL PREPARATION TELEPHONE MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

11/15/2019 JMM 880.00 0.50 440.00 Billable 530278 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH APPLE COUNSEL GABE ZELDIN,

SCOTT MURRAY AND JOSH LERNER, AND D. WARSHAW AND C.

PEARSON, REGARDING MEDIATION STATUS UPDATE AND

REQUESTING A SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE; FOLLOW UP PHONE

CALL WITH D. WARSHAW AND C. PEARSON REGARDING SAME.

11/15/2019 JMM 880.00 0.20 176.00 Billable 530282 SETTLE-A REVIEW APPLE'S REVISED MEDIATION STATUS UPDATE, MAKE

FURTHER REVISIONS, SEND TO CO-COUNSEL FOR REVIEW.

11/19/2019 JMM 880.00 0.20 176.00 Billable 530556 SETTLE-A REVIEW APPLE'S REVISED JOINT MEDIATION STATUS UPDATE,

E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME, EDITS TO REVISED

DRAFT, E-MAIL SAME TO CO-COUNSEL, E-MAIL SAME TO APPLE. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 118 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 117

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

11/19/2019 JMM 880.00 1.00 880.00 Billable 530560 TRIAL PREP-A TELEPHONIC TRIAL PREPARATION MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

11/21/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 530647 CLIENT MEETING-A COMMUNICATIONS WITH CLIENTS GRACE AND POTTER

REGARDING ATTENDANCE AT SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE.

11/21/2019 JMM 880.00 0.20 176.00 Billable 530652 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE WITH JUDGE COUSINS.

11/22/2019 JMM 880.00 0.20 176.00 Billable 530564 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL JOSH

LERNER REGARDING SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE WITH JUDGE

COUSINS.

11/22/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 530615 SETTLE-A REVIEW APPLE'S EDITS TO MEDIATION STATUS UPDATE,

FINALIZE AND FILE.

11/22/2019 JMM 880.00 0.20 176.00 Billable 530654 SETTLE-A DRAFT FURTHER EDITS TO MEDIATION STATUS UPDATE

REGARDING PLAINTIFFS' UNAVAILABILITY, SEND TO CO-COUNSEL

FOR REVIEW.

11/26/2019 JMM 880.00 0.20 176.00 Billable 530649 SETTLE-A CONFERENCE CALL WITH JUDGE COUSINS REGARDING

SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 119 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 118

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 11/26/2019 JMM 880.00 0.20 176.00 Billable 530655 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT STIPULATED CONFIDENTIALITY

AGREEMENT REGARDING SETTLEMENT.

11/27/2019 JMM 880.00 1.20 1,056.00 Billable 530548 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE

STATEMENT, E-MAIL SAME TO CO-COUNSEL.

11/30/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 530657 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT NEXT DRAFT OF SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE

STATEMENT, E-MAIL SAME TO CO-COUNSEL.

12/2/2019 JMM 880.00 0.50 440.00 Billable 532514 ATTYMTG.STR - A TRIAL PREPARATION CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

12/3/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 532506 SETTLE-A REVIEW APPLE'S SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT.

12/3/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 532529 PLDS/MO-A PREPARE DRAFT JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT, E-MAIL

SAME TO APPLE.

12/4/2019 JMM 880.00 0.50 440.00 Billable 532518 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH D. WARSHAW AND C. PEARSON

REGARDING SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE.

12/4/2019 JMM 880.00 1.30 1,144.00 Billable 532544 SETTLE-A PREPARE FOR SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE; REVIEW CASES

CITED BY APPLE; REVIEW SETTLEMENT AGREEMENTS CITED BY

APPLE.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 120 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 119

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 12/5/2019 JMM 880.00 8.50 7,480.00 Billable 532548 SETTLE-A MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL PRIOR TO SETTLEMENT

CONFERENCE; SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE BEFORE JUDGE

COUSINS.

12/9/2019 JMM 880.00 0.70 616.00 Billable 532520 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING TRIAL

PREPARATION AND SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE.

12/9/2019 JMM 880.00 1.80 1,584.00 Billable 532527 TRIAL PREP-A REVIEW DRAFT JURY INSTRUCTIONS; REVIEW 9TH CIRCUIT JURY

INSTRUCTIONS; EDITS TO JURY INSTRUCTIONS FOR TRESPASS

TO CHATTELS.

12/10/2019 JMM 880.00 0.80 704.00 Billable 532540 CLIENT MEETING-A PHONE CALL WITH KEN POTTER REGARDING CASE STATUS,

SETTLEMENT DISCUSSIONS AND TRIAL; PHONE CALL WITH

CHRISTINA GRACE REGARDING CASE STATUS, SETTLEMENT

DISCUSSIONS, AND TRIAL PREPARATION.

12/10/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 532541 TRIAL PREP-A REVIEW, EDIT AND CIRCULATE DRAFT JURY INSTRUCTIONS.

12/11/2019 JMM 880.00 1.70 1,496.00 Billable 532539 TRIAL PREP-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT JURY INSTRUCTIONS, E-MAIL TO

CO-COUNSEL FOR REVIEW.

12/11/2019 JMM 880.00 0.80 704.00 Billable 532549 TRIAL PREP-A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING PRETRIAL

DEADLINES AND ASSIGNMENTS. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 121 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 120

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

12/11/2019 JMM 880.00 1.50 1,320.00 Billable 532550 TRIAL PREP-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT PRETRIAL STATEMENT; DRAFT

INSERTION FOR LEGAL ISSUES IN DISPUTE; REVIEW SUMMARY

JUDGMENT ORDER AND JURY INSTRUCTIONS.

12/11/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 532551 TRIAL PREP-A PHONE CALL WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL J. LERNER, J. RHO AND E.

NOVIKOV REGARDING PRETRIAL DEADLINES ON 12/13 AND

PROCESS FOR EXCHANGING DOCUMENTS AND SEALING ISSUES.

12/12/2019 JMM 880.00 0.20 176.00 Billable 532516 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT AND SEND TO APPLE JOINT SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE

STATUS UPDATE; PREPARE FOR FILING.

12/12/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 532536 TRIAL PREP-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT VERDICT FORM; PHONE CALL WITH

BRAD CALDWELL REGARDING SAME.

12/12/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 532537 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL REGARDING

SEALING APPLE'S DAUBERT MOTION; DRAFT AND FILE

DECLARATION REGARDING SAME.

12/13/2019 JMM 880.00 0.70 616.00 Billable 532515 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING TRIAL

PREPARATION DEADLINES AND ASSIGNMENTS.

12/13/2019 JMM 880.00 9.00 7,920.00 Billable 532535 TRIAL PREP-A REVIEW, EDIT AND FINALIZE PLAINTIFFS' PROPOSED JURY

INSTRUCTIONS, VOIR DIRE QUESTIONS AND VERDICT FORM AND Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 122 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 121

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

E-MAIL SAME TO APPLE (2.3); REVIEW AND EDIT PLAINTIFFS'

WITNESS LIST (.4); REVIEW, EDIT AND FINALIZE JOINT PRETRIAL

STATEMENT, CONFER WITH APPLE REGARDING SAME (1.8);

REVIEW AND EDIT EXHIBITS, PREPARE FOR SUBMISSION TO

COURT (1.5); REVIEW AND EDIT MOTIONS IN LIMINE; REVIEW

APPLE'S MOTIONS IN LIMINE (1.5); REVIEW APPLE'S PROPOSED

JURY INSTRUCTIONS, VOIR DIRE QUESTIONS AND VERDICT FORM

(1.5).

12/16/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 532509 ATTYMTG.STR - A WEEKLY TRIAL PREPARATION CONFERENCE CALL WITH

CO-COUNSEL.

12/16/2019 JMM 880.00 0.50 440.00 Billable 532510 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH JACQUI MOTTEK OF EPIQ

REGARDING OPT OUT NOTICE.

12/16/2019 JMM 880.00 2.30 2,024.00 Billable 532512 TRIAL PREP-A REVIEW JOINT PRETRIAL STATEMENT AND EXHIBITS FOR

SEALING ISSUES, E-MAIL TO APPLE'S COUNSEL REGARDING

SAME, REVIEW EXHIBIT LIST AND PHONE CALL WITH S. JAIN

ABOUT REMOVING DESCRIPTIONS, REVIEW REVISED EXHIBIT

LIST, EDITS TO WITNESS LIST, E-MAIL TO APPLE'S COUNSEL,

REVIEW FINAL DOCUMENTS FOR FILING.

12/16/2019 JMM 880.00 1.00 880.00 Billable 532513 TRIAL PREP-A REVIEW APPLE'S EXHIBIT LIST, WITNESS LIST, VERDICT FORM,

VOIR DIRE QUESTIONS.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 123 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 122

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 12/17/2019 JMM 880.00 0.70 616.00 Billable 532688 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT MOTIONS IN LIMINE, E-MAIL TO

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

12/19/2019 JMM 880.00 3.30 2,904.00 Billable 532693 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH AND DRAFT OPPOSITION TO APPLE'S DAUBERT

MOTION TO EXCLUDE EXPERT OPINIONS OF DR. HASTINGS.

12/20/2019 JMM 880.00 5.50 4,840.00 Billable 532685 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH AND DRAFT OPPOSITION TO APPLE'S MOTION TO

EXCLUDE OPINIONS OF DR. HASTINGS, SEND SAME TO

CO-COUNSEL FOR REVIEW AND EDIT.

12/23/2019 JMM 880.00 0.30 264.00 Billable 532873 ATTYMTG.STR - A WEEKLY TRIAL PREPARATION CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

12/23/2019 JMM 880.00 0.50 440.00 Billable 532919 TRIAL PREP-A REVIEW JOINT JURY INSTRUCTIONS.

12/23/2019 JMM 880.00 2.00 1,760.00 Billable 532920 TRIAL PREP-A REVIEW PLAINTIFFS' TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST AND PRIORITIZE TOP

DOCUMENTS.

12/26/2019 JMM 880.00 2.80 2,464.00 Billable 532872 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW, RESEARCH AND FURTHER EDIT DRAFT OPPOSITION TO

APPLE'S DAUBERT (2.0); PREPARING MANNING DECLARATION (.5);

PHONE CALL WITH DR. HASTINGS REGARDING SAME (.3).

12/26/2019 JMM 880.00 0.50 440.00 Billable 532949 TRIAL PREP-A REVIEW TRANSCRIPT OF PRETRIAL CONFERENCE IN APPLE V.

SAMSUNG, IN PREPARATION OF PRETRIAL CONFERENCE IN Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 124 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 123

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

JANUARY.

12/27/2019 JMM 880.00 0.80 704.00 Billable 532886 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT OPPOSITION TO DAUBERT MOTION, E-MAIL

SAME TO CO-COUNSEL; INPUT CITATIONS TO EVIDENCE.

12/29/2019 JMM 880.00 1.20 1,056.00 Billable 532913 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT, REVIEW AND EDIT STIPULATION REGARDING DAUBERT

BRIEFING SCHEDULE; REVIEW AND EDIT JAIN DECLARATION;

E-MAIL SAME TO CO-COUNSEL; E-MAIL SAME TO APPLE'S

COUNSEL.

1/3/2020 JMM 910.00 0.50 455.00 Billable 534488 ATTYMTG.STR - A TRIAL PREPARATION CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

1/6/2020 JMM 910.00 0.50 455.00 Billable 534633 TRIAL PREP-A WEEKLY CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

TRIAL PREPARATION.

1/8/2020 JMM 910.00 0.30 273.00 Billable 535300 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT;

E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL FOR REVIEW; E-MAIL TO APPLE.

1/8/2020 JMM 910.00 0.30 273.00 Billable 535365 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

STRATEGY FOR SETTLEMENT.

1/9/2020 JMM 910.00 1.00 910.00 Billable 534632 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S RESPONSES AND INSERTS TO THE JOINT CASE

MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT, E-MAIL TO Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 125 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 124

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME; CONFERENCE CALL WITH

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME; DRAFT RESPONSES TO APPLE'S

SECTIONS; REVIEW APPLE'S FURTHER EDITS; DRAFT FURTHER

EDITS; FINALIZE AND FILE.

1/9/2020 JMM 910.00 0.80 728.00 Billable 534653 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW BRIEFING ON APPLE'S DAUBERT MOTION IN

PREPARATION OF ORAL ARGUMENT.

1/15/2020 JMM 910.00 2.20 2,002.00 Billable 534607 PLDS/MO-A PREPARE OUTLINE OF ORAL ARGUMENTS FOR APPLE'S MOTION

IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE RELATED TO APPLE'S

MARKETING AND ADVERTISING OF FACETIME, AND APPLE'S

DAUBERT MOTION TO EXCLUDE TESTIMONY OF DR. HASTINGS;

AND PREPARE FOR PRETRIAL CONFERENCE.

1/15/2020 JMM 910.00 0.50 455.00 Billable 534608 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW COURT'S ORDER ON MOTIONS IN LIMINE AND PRETRIAL

ORDER.

1/15/2020 JMM 910.00 1.30 1,183.00 Billable 534630 CT APPR - A TRAVEL FROM SF TO SAN JOSE FOR SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE

AND PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE.

1/15/2020 JMM 910.00 0.30 273.00 Billable 534659 TRIAL PREP-A REVIEW COURT'S ORDER REQUIRING SUBMISSION OF AMENDED

WITNESS LIST; REVIEW PLAINTIFFS' WITNESS LIST AND APPLE'S

WITNESS LIST.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 126 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 125

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 1/16/2020 JMM 910.00 3.00 2,730.00 Billable 534596 SETTLE-A ATTEND SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE BEFORE JUDGE COUSINS

BEFORE PRETRIAL CONFERENCE (1.5), AND AFTER PRETRIAL

CONFERENCE (1.5).

1/16/2020 JMM 910.00 4.50 4,095.00 Billable 534597 CT APPR - A PREPARE FOR (1.0); ATTEND PRETRIAL CONFERENCE AND

ARGUE DAUBERT MOTION (2.0), TRAVEL BACK TO SF (1.5).

1/16/2020 JMM 910.00 1.00 910.00 Billable 534609 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW DRAFT AMENDED WITNESS LIST; EDITS TO SAME;

E-MAILS TO COUNSEL REGARDING SAME; REVIEW LEGAL

RESEARCH REGARDING SAME; REVIEW FINAL DOCUMENT FOR

FILING.

1/16/2020 JMM 910.00 1.00 910.00 Billable 534631 CT APPR - A MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL TO PREPARE FOR SETTLEMENT

CONFERENCE AND PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE.

1/20/2020 JMM 910.00 0.30 273.00 Billable 534627 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

RESPONDING TO APPLE'S E-MAIL ABOUT POTENTIAL

SETTLEMENT LANGUAGE.

1/22/2020 JMM 910.00 0.80 728.00 Billable 535381 ATTYMTG.STR - A WEEKLY MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING TRIAL

PREPARATION.

1/24/2020 JMM 910.00 0.50 455.00 Billable 535236 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT PLAINTIFFS' WITNESS PROFFER, REVIEW AND Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 127 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 126

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt EDIT CURRY DECLARATION, REVIEW FINAL DOCUMENTS PRIOR

TO FILING.

1/27/2020 JMM 910.00 0.20 182.00 Billable 535237 TRIAL PREP-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT JOINT LIST OF INDIVIDUALS AND

ENTITIES; FINALIZE FOR FILING.

1/27/2020 JMM 910.00 0.50 455.00 Billable 535378 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH D. WARSHAW, A. CURRY AND D.

TEJTEL REGARDING PROCEDURES FOR WORKING ON CASE

GOING FORWARD.

1/27/2020 JMM 910.00 0.70 637.00 Billable 535379 ATTYMTG.STR - A WEEKLY TRIAL PREPARATION MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL.

1/29/2020 JMM 910.00 0.20 182.00 Billable 535346 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW APPLE'S EDITS TO DRAFT STIPULATION REGARDING

FORM AND MANNER OF NOTICE; E-MAIL TO D. WARSHAW

REGARDING SAME.

1/31/2020 JMM 910.00 1.50 1,365.00 Billable 535259 CLIENT MEETING-A MEETING WITH CHRISTINA GRACE TO DISCUSS CASE STATUS,

TRIAL PREPARATION AND TRIAL TESTIMONY, DISCUSSION ABOUT

MEDIATOR'S PROPOSAL (1.0); TRAVEL TO AND FROM MEETING

(.5).

1/31/2020 JMM 910.00 0.30 273.00 Billable 535260 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL AND EPIQ

REGARDING CLASS NOTICE AND CLASS MEMBER INFORMATION.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 128 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 127

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 2/3/2020 JMM 910.00 0.70 637.00 Billable 537941 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

JUDGE COUSIN'S MEDIATOR'S PROPOSAL.

2/4/2020 JMM 910.00 0.30 273.00 Billable 537925 CLIENT MEETING-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CHRISTINA GRACE REGARDING

MEDIATOR'S PROPOSAL AND COUNSEL'S RECOMMENDATION.

2/5/2020 JMM 910.00 0.80 728.00 Billable 537924 CLIENT MEETING-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH KEN POTTER REGARDING MEDIATOR'S

PROPOSAL AND COUNSEL'S RECOMMENDATION.

2/14/2020 JMM 910.00 0.30 273.00 Billable 538030 CT APPR - A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL AND JUDGE

COUSINS REGARDING EXTENDING PRETRIAL DEADLINES AND

FILING THE MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL; FOLLOW UP

CALL WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

2/17/2020 JMM 910.00 0.30 273.00 Billable 537971 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT STIPULATION TO CONTINUE TRIAL

DEADLINES; E-MAIL SAME TO APPLE'S COUNSEL; APPROVE FOR

FILING.

2/19/2020 JMM 910.00 0.30 273.00 Billable 537970 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH D. WARSHAW REGARDING POTENTIAL

NOTICE PLAN FOR SETTLEMENT.

2/19/2020 JMM 910.00 0.30 273.00 Billable 537991 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH EPIQ REGARDING POTENTIAL NOTICE

PLAN FOR SETTLEMENT. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 129 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 128

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

2/24/2020 JMM 910.00 0.70 637.00 Billable 537913 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

APPLE'S DRAFT SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT; REVIEW D.

WARSHAW'S REDLINES.

2/24/2020 JMM 910.00 1.20 1,092.00 Billable 537944 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT APPLE'S DRAFT SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT;

TELEPHONE CALL WITH D. WARSHAW REGARDING SAME; E-MAIL

REDLINE DRAFT TO APPLE'S COUNSEL.

2/25/2020 JMM 910.00 0.50 455.00 Billable 537911 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL J. LERNER AND E.

NOVIKOV AND CLASS COUNSEL D. WARSHAW REGARDING DRAFT

SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT AND PLAINTIFFS' RELINES.

2/26/2020 JMM 910.00 0.70 637.00 Billable 537956 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH D. WARSHAW AND EPIQ

REGARDING CLASS NOTICE, SETTLEMENT, AND MOTION FOR

PRELIMINARY APPROVAL; E-MAIL TO CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

SAME AND REQUEST TO SET UP A MEETING TO DISCUSS TRIAL

PREPARATION TASKS.

2/27/2020 JMM 910.00 0.20 182.00 Billable 537954 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH A. STEYER REGARDING SETTLEMENT

AGREEMENT AND PRETRIAL DEADLINES.

2/27/2020 JMM 910.00 0.30 273.00 Billable 537955 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CALL WITH D. WARSHAW REGARDING APPLE'S REDLINE

OF SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT; PREPARE FOR CALL WITH APPLE, Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 130 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 129

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt AND PRETRIAL ASSIGNMENTS.

2/27/2020 JMM 910.00 1.80 1,638.00 Billable 537996 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL J. LERNER

AND E. NOVIKOV AND CLASS COUNSEL D. WARSHAW REGARDING

DRAFT SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT; FOLLOW UP PHONE CALL

WITH SAME COUNSEL REGARDING SAME ISSUE.

2/27/2020 JMM 910.00 0.50 455.00 Billable 537997 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL D. WARSHAW, D.

TEJTEL AND J. CASSADY REGARDING PRETRIAL DEADLINES AND

WORK ASSIGNMENTS, AND STATUS OF SETTLEMENT

AGREEMENT.

2/27/2020 JMM 910.00 0.80 728.00 Billable 537998 SETTLE-A REVIEW SHAMRELL V. APPLE SETTLEMENT NOTICE AND

SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT; REVIEW ND GUIDELINES FOR CLASS

ACTION SETTLEMENTS IN PREPARATION OF CONFERENCE CALL

WITH APPLE REGARDING SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT AND NOTICE.

2/27/2020 JMM 910.00 2.00 1,820.00 Billable 538027 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL

OF SETTLEMENT.

2/28/2020 JMM 910.00 0.50 455.00 Billable 537907 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL AND EPIQ

REGARDING PROPOSED FORM, CONTENT AND PROCESS FOR

NOTICE AND SETTLEMENT FUND DISBURSEMENT.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 131 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 130

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 2/28/2020 JMM 910.00 1.30 1,183.00 Billable 537953 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL;

SEND REDLINE EDITS TO D. WARSHAW AND A. SIMON TO TURN

NEXT DRAFT.

2/28/2020 JMM 910.00 0.30 273.00 Billable 537972 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL REGARDING

DRAFT SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT.

2/28/2020 JMM 910.00 0.30 273.00 Billable 538028 SETTLE-A CONFERENCE CALL WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL REGARDING

SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT, NOTICE AND ADMINISTRATION OF

SETTLEMENT FUNDS.

2/29/2020 JMM 910.00 4.00 3,640.00 Billable 537961 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT NEXT VERSION OF DRAFT MOTION FOR

PRELIMINARY APPROVAL; LEGAL RESEARCH; CIRCULATE NEXT

DRAFT TO A. SIMON AND D. WARSHAW FOR NEXT ROUND OF

EDITS.

3/1/2020 JMM 910.00 0.70 637.00 Billable 539714 SETTLE-A CONFERENCE CALL WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL J. LERNER AND E.

NOVIKOV, AND D. WARSHAW REGARDING DRAFT SETTLEMENT

AGREEMENT; PHONE CALL WITH D. WARSHAW REGARDING SAME.

3/2/2020 JMM 910.00 0.50 455.00 Billable 539709 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

OPEN ISSUES IN SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT; PHONE CALL WITH

APPLE'S COUNSEL J. LERNER REGARDING SAME.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 132 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 131

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 3/2/2020 JMM 910.00 1.30 1,183.00 Billable 539727 TRIAL PREP-A DRAFT FINDINGS OF FACT FOR 17200 CLAIM.

3/2/2020 JMM 910.00 1.30 1,183.00 Billable 539793 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL.

3/3/2020 JMM 910.00 1.00 910.00 Billable 539729 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

SETTLEMENT AND TRIAL PREPARATION TASKS AND FILINGS.

3/3/2020 JMM 910.00 1.20 1,092.00 Billable 539792 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

SETTLEMENT AND TRIAL PREPARATION TASKS AND FILINGS.

3/4/2020 JMM 910.00 2.00 1,820.00 Billable 539706 TRIAL PREP-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT FINDINGS OF FACT REGARDING UNFAIR

COMPETITION LAW CLAIM, E-MAIL SAME TO S. JAIN TO REDACT.

3/5/2020 JMM 910.00 1.20 1,092.00 Billable 539674 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

OUTSTANDING SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT ISSUES AND TRIAL

PREPARATION TASKS AND DEADLINES.

3/6/2020 JMM 910.00 0.20 182.00 Billable 539656 SETTLE-A CONFERENCE CALL WITH D. WARSHAW AND EPIQ REGARDING

THE PROCESS FOR DISTRIBUTING SETTLEMENT FUNDS TO THE

CLASS.

3/6/2020 JMM 910.00 0.80 728.00 Billable 539657 SETTLE-A RESEARCH ON CASE LAW APPROVING SETTLEMENTS WITH

SECOND DISTRIBUTIONS OF RESIDUE; E-MAIL TO D. WARSHAW Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 133 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 132

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

REGARDING SAME.

3/6/2020 JMM 910.00 1.70 1,547.00 Billable 539732 TRIAL PREP-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS

OF LAW REGARDING UNFAIR COMPETITION LAW CLAIM, E-MAIL

SAME TO S. JAIN TO REDACT AND SEND TO APPLE.

3/8/2020 JMM 910.00 0.50 455.00 Billable 539686 SETTLE-A REVIEW DRAFT SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT, EDIT AND SEND BACK

TO D. WARSHAW TO REVIEW AND SEND TO APPLE'S COUNSEL.

3/9/2020 JMM 910.00 0.30 273.00 Billable 539734 SETTLE-A REVIEW DRAFT MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL, E-MAIL

TO D. WARSHAW REGARDING SAME AND TO SCHEDULE A CALL

WITH APPLE TO DISCUSS PROPOSED EDITS.

3/9/2020 JMM 910.00 0.50 455.00 Billable 539784 SETTLE-A REVIEW CASE LAW REGARDING SECOND DISTRIBUTION OF

RESIDUE FROM UNCASHED CHECKS, E-MAIL TO D. WARSHAW

REGARDING SAME.

3/11/2020 JMM 910.00 0.80 728.00 Billable 539787 SETTLE-A REVIEW APPLE'S PROPOSED NOTICE DOCUMENTS AND EDIT.

3/12/2020 JMM 910.00 1.30 1,183.00 Billable 539702 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL,

E-MAIL SAME TO D. WARSHAW TO REVIEW.

3/16/2020 JMM 910.00 0.30 273.00 Billable 539687 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH D. WARSHAW AND J. LERNER Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 134 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 133

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt TO DISCUSS OPEN ISSUES REGARDING SETTLEMENT

AGREEMENT, NOTICES, AND MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY

APPROVAL.

3/16/2020 JMM 910.00 2.00 1,820.00 Billable 539728 SETTLE-A ZOOM MEETING WITH D. WARSHAW TO REVIEW AND EDIT

NOTICE DOCUMENTS AND SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT; FURTHER

REVIEW AND EDIT DOCUMENTS AND E-MAIL SAME TO D.

WARSHAW.

3/16/2020 JMM 910.00 0.70 637.00 Billable 539739 SETTLE-A REVIEW CASES CITED IN ALEX SIMON'S MEMO REGARDING

INCENTIVE AWARDS; E-MAIL TO J. LERNER REGARDING SAME.

3/17/2020 JMM 910.00 0.50 455.00 Billable 539722 CLIENT MEETING-A E-MAILS TO CLIENTS GRACE AND POTTER REGARDING

SETTLEMENT; PHONE CALL WITH GRACE REGARDING

SETTLEMENT.

3/17/2020 JMM 910.00 0.30 273.00 Billable 539733 SETTLE-A PHONE CONFERENCE WITH APPLE'S COUNSEL AND EPIQ

REGARDING THE SETTLEMENT NOTICE AND CLAIMS PROCESS.

3/18/2020 JMM 910.00 0.40 364.00 Billable 539698 SETTLE-A RESEARCH ON POTENTIAL NON-PROFITS FOR CY PRES, E-MAIL

TO D. WARSHAW AND J. LERNER REGARDING SAME.

3/18/2020 JMM 910.00 0.20 182.00 Billable 539705 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT INSERT REGARDING A SIMILAR CASE

PER ND CAL'S GUIDELINES, E-MAIL BACK TO D. WARSHAW FOR Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 135 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 134

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt REVIEW.

3/18/2020 JMM 910.00 0.70 637.00 Billable 539774 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH D. WARSHAW AND J. LERNER

REGARDING SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT, MEMORANDUM OF

POINTS AND AUTHORITIES, NOTICES AND SETTLEMENT

ADMINISTRATION; FOLLOW UP CALL WITH D. WARSHAW.

3/20/2020 JMM 910.00 0.30 273.00 Billable 539659 ATTYMTG.STR - A PHONE CALL WITH D. WARSHAW REGARDING KOH ORDER ON

STIPULATIONS; PHONE CALL WITH D. WARSHAW AND J. LERNER

REGARDING SAME.

3/21/2020 JMM 910.00 1.70 1,547.00 Billable 539658 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL;

SEND TO D. WARSHAW FOR FURTHER REVIEW AND EDITING;

REVIEW DRAFT NOTICES; REVIEW BID FROM EPIQ.

3/23/2020 JMM 910.00 0.30 273.00 Billable 540398 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND FURTHER EDIT DRAFT MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY

APPROVAL, E-MAIL BACK TO D. WARSHAW.

3/25/2020 JMM 910.00 2.50 2,275.00 Billable 540415 SETTLE-A REVIEW APPLE'S EDITS TO SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT, LONG

FORM NOTICE, AND MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL;

PHONE CALL WITH D. WARSHAW REGARDING SAME; FURTHER

EDITS TO MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL.

3/25/2020 JMM 910.00 0.50 455.00 Billable 540448 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH D. WARSHAW AND APPLE'S Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 136 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 135

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt COUNSEL REGARDING THE SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT, NOTICE

DOCUMENTS AND MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL.

3/26/2020 JMM 910.00 0.30 273.00 Billable 540556 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT NOTICES; E-MAIL TO D. WARSHAW

REGARDING SAME.

3/27/2020 JMM 910.00 1.30 1,183.00 Billable 540568 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH D. WARSHAW AND APPLE'S

COUNSEL REGARDING THE SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT, NOTICE

DOCUMENTS AND MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL;

FURTHER EDITS TO SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT, NOTICE

DOCUMENTS, AND REQUEST FOR INCLUSION IN SETTLEMENT

CLASS, E-MAIL SAME TO D. WARSHAW FOR REVIEW.

3/30/2020 JMM 910.00 1.10 1,001.00 Billable 540987 SETTLE-A PHONE CALL WITH D. WARSHAW AND J. LERNER REGARDING

SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT AND NOTICES (.2); PHONE CALL WITH

D. WARSHAW REGARDING MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL

(.2); REVIEW AND EDIT MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL (.7).

3/31/2020 JMM 910.00 2.30 2,093.00 Billable 540995 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL;

REVIEW WARSHAW DECLARATION; REVIEW PROPOSED ORDER;

REVIEW AND EDIT NOTICES; REVIEW AND EDIT SETTLEMENT

AGREEMENT; PHONE CALL WITH D. WARSHAW REGARDING SAME.

3/31/2020 JMM 910.00 1.00 910.00 Billable 540996 CLIENT MEETING-A PHONE CALL WITH KEN POTTER TO REVIEW SETTLEMENT

AGREEMENT AND GET APPROVAL FOR SIGNATURE; PHONE CALL Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 137 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 136

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

WITH CHRISTINA GRACE TO REVIEW SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT

AND GET APPROVAL FOR SIGNATURE.

4/1/2020 JMM 910.00 0.50 455.00 Billable 542040 SETTLE-A REVIEW APPLE'S DRAFT SETTLEMENT STATUS UPDATE, EDIT;

PHONE CALL WITH D. WARSHAW REGARDING SAME; EDITS TO

LONG FORM NOTICE, SEND TO APPLE.

4/2/2020 JMM 910.00 1.00 910.00 Billable 542030 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT PROPOSED ORDER GRANTING MOTION

FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL; REVIEW JUDGE KOH'S ORDER IN

ANTHEM; E-MAIL REDLINED DRAFT TO D. WARSHAW AND A.

SIMON.

4/2/2020 JMM 910.00 0.20 182.00 Billable 542039 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT SETTLEMENT STATUS UPDATE, E-MAIL

SAME TO APPLE'S COUNSEL.

4/3/2020 JMM 910.00 0.20 182.00 Billable 542029 CLIENT MEETING-A E-MAILS TO CLIENTS GRACE AND POTTER REGARDING

POTENTIAL CY PRES RECIPIENT.

4/3/2020 JMM 910.00 0.50 455.00 Billable 542037 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT CURRENT VERSION OF SETTLEMENT

AGREEMENT, E-MAIL SAME TO D. WARSHAW FOR REVIEW OF

REDLINES.

4/5/2020 JMM 910.00 2.70 2,457.00 Billable 542055 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL;

LEGAL RESEARCH ON CY PRES LAW IN 9TH CIRCUIT. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 138 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 137

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

4/8/2020 JMM 910.00 0.70 637.00 Billable 542042 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

STATUS OF SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT AND MOTION FOR

PRELIMINARY APPROVAL; DISCUSS EDITS TO DRAFT MOTION

FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL.

4/8/2020 JMM 910.00 1.20 1,092.00 Billable 542047 SETTLE-A REVIEW D. TEJTEL'S PROPOSED EDITS TO MOTION FOR

PRELIMINARY APPROVAL, MAKE FURTHER EDITS, E-MAIL

REVISED DRAFT TO APPLE'S COUNSEL.

4/8/2020 JMM 910.00 1.00 910.00 Billable 542060 SETTLE-A REVIEW APPLE'S REVISED DRAFT SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT AND

MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL, E-MAIL TO D. WARSHAW

REGARDING SAME.

4/9/2020 JMM 910.00 0.30 273.00 Billable 542043 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH D. WARSHAW AND APPLE'S

COUNSEL REGARDING POTENTIAL CY PRES RECIPIENT AND

LANGUAGE REGARDING SAME IN SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT AND

PRELIMINARY APPROVAL MOTION.

4/16/2020 JMM 910.00 0.50 455.00 Billable 542465 SETTLE-A REVIEW FINAL DRAFT OF SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT FROM

APPLE, E-MAIL TO APPLE AND CLIENTS REGARDING SAME.

4/17/2020 JMM 910.00 1.50 1,365.00 Billable 542472 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL

OF SETTLEMENT; REVIEW APPLE'S EDITS TO PROPOSED ORDER. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 139 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 138

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

4/20/2020 JMM 910.00 1.20 1,092.00 Billable 543367 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT DRAFT MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL;

E-MAIL REVISED DRAFT TO D. WARSHAW.

4/21/2020 JMM 910.00 0.50 455.00 Billable 543363 SETTLE-A REVIEW AND EDIT FINAL DRAFT OF MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY

APPROVAL; SEND EDITS TO D. WARSHAW.

4/22/2020 JMM 910.00 0.70 637.00 Billable 543380 CLIENT MEETING-A PHONE CALL WITH CHRISTINA GRACE REGARDING EXECUTION

OF SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT AND FILING MOTION FOR

PRELIMINARY APPROVAL; PHONE CALL WITH KEN POTTER

REGARDING SAME.

4/24/2020 JMM 910.00 0.50 455.00 Billable 543373 SETTLE-A REVIEW FRCP 23(E)(3) REGARDING DISCLOSURE OF

AGREEMENTS, REVIEW LANGUAGE IN DRAFT BRIEF, AND SEND

E-MAIL TO APPLE'S COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

4/25/2020 JMM 910.00 0.30 273.00 Billable 543359 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH D. WARSHAW AND J. LERNER

REGARDING HEARING ON MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL.

7/22/2020 JMM 910.00 0.70 637.00 Billable 550572 SETTLE-A REVIEW ORDER ON FINAL APPROVAL AND ATTORNEY FEES IN

YAHOO DATA BREACH CASE; E-MAIL SAME TO CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING PREPARATION FOR FINAL APPROVAL.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 140 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 139

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 8/25/2020 JMM 910.00 0.50 455.00 Billable 553469 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

HEARING ON PRELIMINARY APPROVAL MOTION.

8/31/2020 JMM 910.00 2.00 1,820.00 Billable 553495 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW PRELIMINARY APPROVAL MOTION AND NOTICE

DOCUMENTS; REVIEW CASE LAW ON CLASS NOTICE AND LEVEL

OF RECOVERY IN SETTLEMENTS; DRAFT NOTES FOR ORAL

ARGUMENT.

9/2/2020 JMM 910.00 1.50 1,365.00 Billable 554988 PLDS/MO-A PREPARE FOR HEARING ON PRELIMINARY APPROVAL OF

SETTLEMENT.

9/3/2020 JMM 910.00 0.30 273.00 Billable 554222 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE WITH CO-COUNSEL FOLLOWING

HEARING REGARDING SUBMISSION DUE ON TUESDAY.

9/3/2020 JMM 910.00 2.20 2,002.00 Billable 554242 CT APPR - A PREPARE FOR; REVIEW OUTLINE; ATTEND HEARING ON MOTION

FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL OF SETTLEMENT.

9/7/2020 JMM 910.00 0.50 455.00 Billable 554238 SETTLE-A E-MAIL TO D. WARSHAW AND APPLE'S COUNSEL REGARDING CY

PRES RECIPIENT; RESEARCH ON POTENTIAL CY PRES

RECIPIENTS RELATED TO SUBJECT MATTER OF LITIGATION.

9/7/2020 JMM 910.00 0.50 455.00 Billable 554247 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW DRAFT SUPPLEMENTAL SUBMISSION TO COURT; EDIT;

E-MAIL REVISIONS TO CO-COUNSEL. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 141 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 140

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

9/11/2020 JMM 910.00 1.30 1,183.00 Billable 554239 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW COURT'S ORDER GRANTING PRELIMINARY APPROVAL OF

SETTLEMENT; DRAFT CHART OF CASE DEADLINES PER THE

ORDER; PHONE CALL WITH EPIQ AND D. WARSHAW REGARDING

NOTICE AND FINAL APPROVAL; REVIEW AND EDIT EPIQ CHART

9/25/2020 JMM 910.00 0.50 455.00 Billable 554997 SETTLE-A REVIEW DRAFT WEBSITE AND SCRIPT FOR SETTLEMENT

ADMINISTRATOR; E-MAIL EDITS TO EPIQ AND APPLE.

10/10/2020 JMM 910.00 0.30 273.00 Billable 556333 CLIENT MEETING-A REVIEW NOTICE OF SETTLEMENT; E-MAILS TO CLIENTS

REGARDING NOTICE OF SETTLEMENT.

10/12/2020 JMM 910.00 0.70 637.00 Billable 556369 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW E-MAILS FROM CLASS MEMBERS AND POTENTIAL CLASS

MEMBERS ABOUT CLASS NOTICE; RESPOND TO E-MAILS; E-MAILS

TO SETTLEMENT ADMINISTRATOR REGARDING SAME.

TOTAL Billable Fees 1296.60 $1,070,109.00

Total of billable expense slips $0.00

Calculation of Fees and Costs

Amount Total Fees Bill Arrangement: Slips By billing value on each slip.

Total of billable time slips $1,070,109.00 Total of Fees (Time Charges) $1,070,109.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-7 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 142 of 142 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:10 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 141

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Amount Total Total of Costs (Expense Charges) $0.00

Total new charges $1,070,109.00

New Balance Current $1,070,109.00

Total New Balance $1,070,109.00

Funds Account: Default Previous account balance $0.00 Total added to account $0.00 Total removed from account $0.00

New account balance $0.00

Amount to replenish account to $0.00 $0.00

Attorney Summary

Attorney Rate Hours Charges Slip Value Adjustment JMM 910.00 96.50 $87,815.00 $87,815.00 0.00 JMM 880.00 118.10 $103,928.00 $103,928.00 0.00 JMM 820.00 700.80 $574,656.00 $574,656.00 0.00 JMM 800.00 356.20 $284,960.00 $284,960.00 0.00 JMM 750.00 25.00 $18,750.00 $18,750.00 0.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-8 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 76

EXHIBIT 6 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-8 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 76 STEYER LOWENTHAL BOODROOKAS 11/23/2020 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 1

Selection Criteria

Atto.Selection Include: SJ Clie.Selection Include: APPLE.FACETIME Slip.Transaction Date Earliest - 10/31/2020 Slip.Billing Status Billable Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 3 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 2

Nickname APPLE.FACETIME | 4457-CONT Full Name CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) Address CONSUMER CLASS ACTION - APPLE RE FACETIME FEATURE Phone 1 Phone 2 Phone 3 Phone 4 In Ref To APPLE, INC. - IN REGARDING FACETIME FEATURE Fees Arrg. By billing value on each slip Expense Arrg. By billing value on each slip Tax Profile Exempt Last bill Last charge 9/8/2020 Last payment Amount $0.00

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 11/1/2016 SJ 320.00 1.10 352.00 Billable 440029 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH REGARDING VENUE AND DIVISION RULES.

11/8/2016 SJ 320.00 0.10 32.00 Billable 440040 RESEARCH-A ASSIST S. MACRAE WITH RESEARCH MEMO.

11/9/2016 SJ 320.00 2.10 672.00 Billable 440044 RESEARCH-A EDIT MEMO REGARDING POTENTIAL CAUSES OF ACTION.

1/24/2017 SJ 340.00 2.20 748.00 Billable 445818 PLDS/MO-A REVISE AND COMMENT ON DRAFT COMPLAINT.

1/31/2017 SJ 340.00 1.00 340.00 Billable 445884 PLDS/MO-A REVISE DRAFT COMPLAINT.

1/31/2017 SJ 340.00 0.30 102.00 Billable 445885 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL A. STEYER REGARDING VENUE FOR CASE.

2/1/2017 SJ 340.00 4.20 1,428.00 Billable 448432 PLDS/MO-A EDIT DRAFTS OF COMPLAINT AND PREPARED COMPLAINT FOR

FILING.

2/2/2017 SJ 340.00 1.20 408.00 Billable 448436 PLDS/MO-A PREPARE COMPLAINT FOR FILING.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 4 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 3

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 2/7/2017 SJ 340.00 0.30 102.00 Billable 448460 PLDS/MO-A PREPARE SUMMONS FOR FILING.

2/7/2017 SJ 340.00 1.50 510.00 Billable 448462 PLDS/MO-A BEGAN PREPARING SUMMONS FOR SERVICE ON APPLE.

2/8/2017 SJ 340.00 2.00 680.00 Billable 448467 PLDS/MO-A PREPARE SUMMONS DOCUMENTS FOR SERVICE AND FILING.

3/3/2017 SJ 340.00 0.10 34.00 Billable 450946 DISCOVERY-A CONFER WITH A. STEYER REGARDING SERVICE OF DISCOVERY

REQUESTS ON APPLE ACCORDING TO LOCAL RULES.

3/3/2017 SJ 340.00 0.60 204.00 Billable 450947 DISCOVERY-A RESEARCH LOCAL RULES ON TIMING FOR DISCOVERY

REQUESTS.

3/13/2017 SJ 340.00 1.80 612.00 Billable 451001 DISCOVERY-A REVISE DISCOVERY REQUESTS TO BE SENT TO APPLE.

3/14/2017 SJ 340.00 1.30 442.00 Billable 451003 DISCOVERY-A REVISE DISCOVERY REQUESTS - REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION

AND INTERROGATORIES - TO BE SENT TO APPLE.

3/15/2017 SJ 340.00 0.60 204.00 Billable 451007 DISCOVERY-A REVISE AND E-MAIL J. MANNING EDITS TO APPLE DISCOVERY

REQUESTS.

3/22/2017 SJ 340.00 0.20 68.00 Billable 451034 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFER WITH J. MANNING REGARDING APPLE MOTION TO

DISMISS. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 5 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 4

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

3/22/2017 SJ 340.00 0.20 68.00 Billable 451035 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - J. MANNING, S. MACRAE REGARDING APPLE

MOTION TO DISMISS AND PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSE VIA

OPPOSITION OR AMENDED COMPLAINT.

3/30/2017 SJ 340.00 0.40 136.00 Billable 451059 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFER WITH J. MANNING REGARDING RESEARCH ON

RESTITUTION UNDER UNFAIR COMPETITION LAW.

3/30/2017 SJ 340.00 4.50 1,530.00 Billable 451060 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH REGARDING WHETHER RESTITUTION IS AVAILABLE

AND WHETHER SUCH AWARDS ARE APPLICABLE IN CASE; BEGIN

REVIEW OF CASES CITED BY DEFENDANT.

3/31/2017 SJ 340.00 0.10 34.00 Billable 451064 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE WITH J. MANNING AND D. TEJTEL REGARDING

AMENDED COMPLAINT.

3/31/2017 SJ 340.00 0.70 238.00 Billable 451065 PLDS/MO-A REVISE AMENDED COMPLAINT.

3/31/2017 SJ 340.00 2.40 816.00 Billable 451066 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH REGARDING APPLICABILITY OF RESTITUTION

AWARDS; REVIEW OF UNFAIR COMPETITION LAW DECISIONS.

4/3/2017 SJ 340.00 5.90 2,006.00 Billable 452765 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH REGARDING WHETHER RESTITUTION AVAILABLE AS

AN AWARD UNDER UNFAIR COMPETITION LAW (3.0); DRAFT

MEMO REGARDING AVAILABILITY OF RESTITUTION AS AN AWARD

(2.0); CONFERENCE CALL WITH J. MANNING, S. MACRAE, Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 6 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 5

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING APPLE'S MOTION TO DISMISS (.4); CALL

WITH J. MANNING REGARDING RESTITUTION (.5).

4/4/2017 SJ 340.00 4.20 1,428.00 Billable 452770 RESEARCH-A CONTINUE RESEARCH REGARDING RESTITUTION CLAIM (2.5);

REVISE AMENDED COMPLAINT (1.7).

4/5/2017 SJ 340.00 2.80 952.00 Billable 452773 PLDS/MO-A REVISE AMENDED COMPLAINT (2.5); TELEPHONE - J. MANNING

REGARDING REVISIONS TO AMENDED COMPLAINT (.3).

4/7/2017 SJ 340.00 1.30 442.00 Billable 452777 DISCOVERY-A EDIT REVISED REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS.

4/10/2017 SJ 340.00 0.70 238.00 Billable 452783 ATTYMTG.STR - A RESEARCH AND E-MAIL J. MANNING AND ALEX SIMON

REGARDING MEET AND CONFER AND DISCLOSURE

REQUIREMENTS.

4/17/2017 SJ 340.00 0.40 136.00 Billable 453387 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH REGARDING LOCAL DISCOVERY RULES AND

TIMELINES.

4/20/2017 SJ 340.00 1.50 510.00 Billable 453395 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - J. MANNING, S. MACRAE REGARDING APPLE'S

MOTION TO DISMISS (.3);

CONFER WITH J. MANNING REGARDING APPLE'S MOTION TO

DISMISS (.2); REVIEW APPLE'S MOTION TO DISMISS (1.0).

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 7 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 6

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 4/21/2017 SJ 340.00 3.00 1,020.00 Billable 453400 PLDS/MO-A BEGIN RESEARCH REGARDING OPPOSITION TO APPLE'S MOTION

TO DISMISS - TRESPASS TO CHATTELS SECTIONS; REVIEW S.

MACRAE MEMO ON TRESPASS TO CHATTELS, BEGIN REVIEW OF

AUTHORITIES CITED BY APPLE.

4/24/2017 SJ 340.00 2.50 850.00 Billable 453563 PLDS/MO-A CONTINUE RESEARCH RELATED TO APPLE'S CITED

AUTHORITIES; BEGIN OUTLINE OF OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO

DISMISS - TRESPASS TO CHATTELS SECTION.

4/25/2017 SJ 340.00 2.60 884.00 Billable 453571 PLDS/MO-A CONTINUE RESEARCH REGARDING TRESPASS TO CHATTELS -

APPLE'S CITED AUTHORITIES AND RELATED CASES;

AUTHORITIES AND RELATED CASES IN S. MACRAE MEMO (2.2);

CALL WITH J. MANNING, S. MACRAE, CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

DISCOVERY/DISCLOSURES (.4).

4/26/2017 SJ 340.00 6.70 2,278.00 Billable 453576 PLDS/MO-A FINISH RESEARCH REGARDING TRESPASS TO CHATTELS

SECTION - REGARDING UNCONSCIONABLE AGREEMENTS,

ADEQUATE HARM - AND PREPARE BRIEF IN OPPOSITION.

4/27/2017 SJ 340.00 2.40 816.00 Billable 453582 RESEARCH-A DRAFT MEMO REGARDING JUDGE KOH ON DISCOVERY STAYS

DURING PENDING MOTIONS TO DISMISS. (1.6); EDIT S. MACRAE

BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO DISMISS. (.8).

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 8 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 7

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 4/28/2017 SJ 340.00 0.20 68.00 Billable 453588 DISCOVERY-A PREPARE CERTIFICATE OF INTERESTED PARTIES.

5/1/2017 SJ 340.00 2.80 952.00 Billable 456112 PLDS/MO-A EDIT AND REVIEW OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO DISMISS.

5/2/2017 SJ 340.00 0.10 34.00 Billable 456115 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE WITH J. MANNING REGARDING OPPOSITION TO

MOTION TO DISMISS.

5/3/2017 SJ 340.00 4.20 1,428.00 Billable 456119 PLDS/MO-A REVISE OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO DISMISS AND PREPARE FOR

FILING.

5/8/2017 SJ 340.00 0.20 68.00 Billable 456450 DISCOVERY-A PREPARE CERTIFICATE OF INTEREST PARTIES.

5/10/2017 SJ 340.00 4.30 1,462.00 Billable 456453 CASEMNG-A REVISE CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT (.8); REVISE INITIAL

DISCLOSURES (.7); RESEARCH REGARDING DATA PRESERVATION

FOR CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT (2.0); FINAL REVISION OF

CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT (.8).

5/11/2017 SJ 340.00 0.70 238.00 Billable 456457 CASEMNG-A RESEARCH LOCAL RULES FOR FILING OF CASE MANAGEMENT

STATEMENT.

5/12/2017 SJ 340.00 0.20 68.00 Billable 456459 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH PROCEDURE FOR TELEPHONIC APPEARANCE.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 9 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 8

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 5/12/2017 SJ 340.00 3.00 1,020.00 Billable 456460 RESEARCH-A BEGAN RESEARCH REGARDING 9TH CIRCUIT LAW ON A

DISCOVERY STAY PENDING A MOTION TO DISMISS.

5/15/2017 SJ 340.00 3.50 1,190.00 Billable 456608 RESEARCH-A COMPLETE RESEARCH AND DRAFT MEMORANDUM ON

DISCOVERY STAYS PENDING A MOTION TO DISMISS.

5/16/2017 SJ 340.00 4.20 1,428.00 Billable 456610 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH REGARDING PARTY LIMITS FOR INTERROGATORIES

(4.5); MEMO REGARDING PROPOSED SCHEDULE (.8).

5/17/2017 SJ 340.00 0.40 136.00 Billable 456614 DISCOVERY-A REVISE PROPOSED DISCOVERY SCHEDULE.

5/19/2017 SJ 340.00 0.60 204.00 Billable 456621 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT AND FILE TRANSCRIPT REQUEST.

6/6/2017 SJ 340.00 3.40 1,156.00 Billable 458483 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE REGARDING ESI AND

PROTECTIVE ORDER (2.2); REVIEW LETTER REGARDING ESI AND

PROTECTIVE ORDER AND PREPARE FOR MEET AND CONFER

(1.0); CONFER WITH J. MANNING AFTER MEET AND CONFER (.2).

6/7/2017 SJ 340.00 2.00 680.00 Billable 458487 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH ESI AND PROTECTIVE ORDERS UNDER JUDGE KOH.

6/14/2017 SJ 340.00 0.30 102.00 Billable 459257 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW ORDERS REGARDING FILING STATEMENT ON ESI AND

PROTECTIVE ORDER AND E-MAIL J. MANNING.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 10 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 9

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 6/22/2017 SJ 340.00 4.20 1,428.00 Billable 459274 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT REPLY CHART FOR MOTION TO DISMISS HEARING

REGARDING TRESPASS TO CHATTELS.

6/23/2017 SJ 340.00 3.30 1,122.00 Billable 459277 PLDS/MO-A COMPLETE DRAFT OF TRESPASS TO CHATTELS CHART FOR

MOTION TO DISMISS HEARING.

6/26/2017 SJ 340.00 3.80 1,292.00 Billable 459280 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT TALKING POINTS FOR TRESPASS TO CHATTELS

ARGUMENT.

7/25/2017 SJ 340.00 0.10 34.00 Billable 460816 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE - J. MANNING REGARDING MOTION TO DISMISS

HEARING.

7/31/2017 SJ 340.00 0.90 306.00 Billable 460831 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW ORDER DENYING MOTION TO DISMISS (.8); TELEPHONE -

J. MANNING REGARDING ORDER (.1).

8/1/2017 SJ 340.00 0.40 136.00 Billable 462862 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH CUSTOMER COMPLAINTS ON IPHONE FACETIME;

E-MAIL P. GRAVELY REGARDING SAME.

8/2/2017 SJ 340.00 1.20 408.00 Billable 462886 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE CALL REGARDING DISCOVERY, CERTIFICATION, ESI

(.7); PRIOR REVIEW REGARDING SAME (.3); CONFER WITH J.

MANNING AND P. GRAVELY ON APPLE CUSTOMER COMPLAINTS

(.2).

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 11 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 10

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 8/7/2017 SJ 340.00 1.10 374.00 Billable 462880 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW DRAFT ESI TERMS (.9); CONFER WITH P. GRAVLEY

REGARDING SAME (.2).

8/8/2017 SJ 340.00 1.50 510.00 Billable 462881 CASEMNG-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING JOINT CASE

MANAGEMENT STATEMENT (1.0); EDIT DRAFT ESI TERMS (.5).

8/9/2017 SJ 340.00 0.90 306.00 Billable 462867 DISCOVERY-A EDIT MEMO REGARDING CUSTOMER COMPLAINTS AND CONFER

REGARDING SAME WITH P. GRAVLEY.

8/10/2017 SJ 340.00 0.30 102.00 Billable 462869 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW UPDATED ESI SEARCH TERMS.

8/11/2017 SJ 340.00 0.30 102.00 Billable 462872 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW ANSWER TO COMPLAINT.

8/14/2017 SJ 340.00 1.10 374.00 Billable 463038 CASEMNG-A REVIEW JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT (.3); CALL

REGARDING ESI AND JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT (.5);

EDIT ESI TERMS (.3).

8/16/2017 SJ 340.00 0.50 170.00 Billable 463035 CASEMNG-A REVISE JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT.

8/24/2017 SJ 340.00 1.30 442.00 Billable 463137 DISCOVERY-A REVISE DRAFT INTERROGATORIES.

8/25/2017 SJ 340.00 2.40 816.00 Billable 463411 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE CALL REGARDING DISCO E-DISCOVERY PLATFORM Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 12 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 11

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt (.8); REVISE INTERROGATORIES (1.5); TELEPHONE - J. MANNING

REGARDING DISCOVERY (.1).

8/28/2017 SJ 340.00 0.30 102.00 Billable 463413 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW E-DISCOVERY COSTS AND META-E PROPOSAL.

8/29/2017 SJ 340.00 1.10 374.00 Billable 463439 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE CONFERENCE CALL REGARDING DISCOVERY,

INTERROGATORIES, ESI (.4); REVIEW APPLE DOCUMENT

PRODUCTION (.3); REVIEW INTERROGATORIES (.3); CONFER WITH

J. MANNING REGARDING DOCUMENT PRODUCTION, DISCOVERY,

INTERROGATORIES (.1).

9/1/2017 SJ 340.00 1.40 476.00 Billable 465728 DISCOVERY-A MEET AND CONFER REGARDING ESI TERMS AND APPLE

RESPONSES TO REQUEST FOR PRODUCTIONS.

9/5/2017 SJ 340.00 1.90 646.00 Billable 465740 DISCOVERY-A MEET AND CONFER REGARDING APPLE'S RESPONSE TO

PLAINTIFFS DOCUMENT REQUEST (1.5); TELEPHONE CALL WITH

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING MEET AND CONFER (.4).

9/6/2017 SJ 340.00 1.50 510.00 Billable 465741 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT MEMO REGARDING APPLE RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS

REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION IN MEET AND CONFER.

9/7/2017 SJ 340.00 1.00 340.00 Billable 465703 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL COUNSEL REGARDING PREVIOUS MEET AND CONFER

WITH APPLE REGARDING ESI SEARCH TERMS.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 13 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 12

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 9/12/2017 SJ 340.00 2.50 850.00 Billable 465705 PLDS/MO-A REVISE LIST OF POTENTIAL ISSUES ON MOTION TO COMPEL (2.0);

E-MAIL - J. MANNING REGARDING POTENTIAL ISSUES ON MOTION

TO COMPEL (.5).

9/13/2017 SJ 340.00 1.20 408.00 Billable 465706 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW DRAFT MEET AND CONFER E-MAIL.

9/14/2017 SJ 340.00 1.00 340.00 Billable 465744 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW E-MAIL TO APPLE REGARDING MEET AND CONFER ON

ESI AND CO-COUNSEL EDITS.

9/18/2017 SJ 340.00 0.70 238.00 Billable 465310 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW EDITED ESI PROTOCOL.

9/19/2017 SJ 340.00 1.60 544.00 Billable 465311 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SOURCE

CODE PROTECTIVE ORDER, REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION, ESI

SEARCH TERMS, DISCOVERY, DOCUMENT REVIEW, EXPERTS,

LEGAL RESEARCH ON DAMAGES (.6); BEGIN RESEARCH

REGARDING DAMAGES (1.0).

9/20/2017 SJ 340.00 1.00 340.00 Billable 465357 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW CODING ISSUE TAGS (.5); REVIEW ESI SEARCH TERMS

(.5).

9/21/2017 SJ 340.00 2.20 748.00 Billable 465330 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH A. SIMON, S. MACRAE REGARDING

RESEARCH ON DAMAGES (.4); RESEARCH REGARDING PROOF OF

DAMAGES UNDER UNFAIR COMPETITION LAW (1.5); RESEARCH Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 14 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 13

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt APPLE'S DISCOVERY MOTIONS IN QUALCOMM (.3).

9/25/2017 SJ 340.00 1.50 510.00 Billable 465308 RESEARCH-A CONTINUE RESEARCH REGARDING PROOF OF DAMAGES.

9/27/2017 SJ 340.00 1.50 510.00 Billable 465348 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH REGARDING PROOF OF DAMAGES.

9/29/2017 SJ 340.00 5.20 1,768.00 Billable 465722 DISCOVERY-A MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE REGARDING RESPONSES TO

REQUEST FOR PRODUCTIONS AND INTERROGATORIES (2.2);

RELATIVITY TRAINING FOR REVIEW OF APPLE PRODUCTION (.7);

RESEARCH REGARDING DAMAGES CALCULATION UNDER UNFAIR

COMPETITION LAW (2.3).

9/30/2017 SJ 340.00 9.00 3,060.00 Billable 465714 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH REGARDING DAMAGES CALCULATIONS UNDER

UNFAIR COMPETITION LAW (6.5); DRAFT MEMO REGARDING MEET

AND CONFER (2.5).

10/2/2017 SJ 340.00 4.80 1,632.00 Billable 467331 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH REGARDING CALCULATION OF DAMAGES (4.5); E-MAIL

- J. MANNING REGARDING BUYER SURVEY (.1); REVIEW APPLE

E-MAIL REGARDING OBJECTIONS TO REQUEST FOR

PRODUCTIONS (.2).

10/3/2017 SJ 340.00 3.30 1,122.00 Billable 467339 RESEARCH-A E-MAIL - S. MACRAE REGARDING BUYER SURVEY (.3); E-MAIL - J.

MANNING ANALYSIS OF APPLE'S RESPONSE REGARDING

REQUEST FOR PRODUCTIONS (.8); CONTINUE RESEARCH Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 15 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 14

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt REGARDING CALCULATION OF DAMAGES (2.2).

10/4/2017 SJ 340.00 5.70 1,938.00 Billable 467347 RESEARCH-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH S. MACRAE, A. SIMON REGARDING

DAMAGES CALCULATION (.5); REVIEW E-MAILS REGARDING

PROTECTIVE ORDER (.2); COMPLETE RESEARCH REGARDING

DAMAGES CALCULATION (5).

10/6/2017 SJ 340.00 1.70 578.00 Billable 467341 RESEARCH-A BEGIN DRAFTING MEMO REGARDING CALCULATION OF DAMAGES.

10/10/2017 SJ 340.00 5.80 1,972.00 Billable 467342 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH REGARDING PROPRIETY OF GENERAL OBJECTION

FOR MOTION TO COMPEL.

10/11/2017 SJ 340.00 5.50 1,870.00 Billable 467343 RESEARCH-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING DISCOVERY

STATUS, DAMAGES RESEARCH (.6); CONFER WITH P. GRAVELY

REGARDING WITNESSES LIST (.2); REVIEW TRADE-IN DATA (.5);

REVIEW APPLE E-MAIL REGARDING REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION

RESPONSES (.2); RESEARCH REGARDING DAMAGES

CALCULATION IN APPLE V. SAMSUNG (1.0); CONTINUE RESEARCH

REGARDING MOTION TO COMPEL REGARDING GENERAL

OBJECTIONS, REQUESTS FOR DOCUMENTS RELATED TO CLASS

CERTIFICATION (3.0).

10/12/2017 SJ 340.00 6.60 2,244.00 Billable 467435 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW APPLE RESPONSES TO REQUEST FOR PRODUCTIONS

(4.0); BEGIN DRAFTING MEMO REGARDING APPLE RESPONSES TO

REQUEST FOR PRODUCTIONS (2.3); E-MAIL - N. GALPER Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 16 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 15

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

REGARDING APPLE REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION RESPONSES (.3).

10/13/2017 SJ 340.00 7.80 2,652.00 Billable 467436 DISCOVERY-A PREPARE DRAFT MOTION TO COMPEL (6.0); FINALIZE MEMO

REGARDING APPLE'S RESPONSES TO REQUEST FOR

PRODUCTIONS (1.8).

10/17/2017 SJ 340.00 5.50 1,870.00 Billable 467429 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH LOCAL DISCOVERY RULES (.7); TELEPHONE CALL

REGARDING REQUEST FOR PRODUCTIONS (.5); RESEARCH

JUDGE COUSINS DECISIONS ON MOTIONS TO COMPEL (4.3).

10/18/2017 SJ 340.00 6.10 2,074.00 Billable 467449 DISCOVERY-A FINISH RESEARCH REGARDING JUDGE COUSINS ORDER

REGARDING MOTION TO COMPEL (3.0); DRAFT MEMO REGARDING

MOTION TO COMPEL (1.3); EDIT JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT

CONFERENCE LETTER (1.8).

10/19/2017 SJ 340.00 2.80 952.00 Billable 467424 DISCOVERY-A FILE SOURCE CODE PROTECTIVE ORDER (.5); RESEARCH LOCAL

CIVIL RULES (.5); EDIT JOINT MOTION TO COMPEL LETTER (1.8).

10/23/2017 SJ 340.00 0.80 272.00 Billable 467455 CASEMNG-A REVISE JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT.

10/24/2017 SJ 340.00 2.30 782.00 Billable 467763 DISCOVERY-A EDIT JOINT DISCOVERY LETTER (.5); PREPARE EXHIBITS FOR

MOTION TO COMPEL (1.8).

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 17 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 16

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 10/30/2017 SJ 340.00 1.30 442.00 Billable 467765 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW PROTECTIVE ORDERS AND E-MAIL J. MANNING

REGARDING SAME (.6); REVIEW APPLE DISCOVERY REQUESTS

(.7).

10/31/2017 SJ 340.00 3.00 1,020.00 Billable 467768 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL.

11/1/2017 SJ 340.00 6.00 2,040.00 Billable 469569 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL TO DISCUSS CASE STATUS AND

UPCOMING ASSIGNMENTS AND STRATEGY; PREPARED NOTES

REGARDING RESEARCH AND DISCOVERY FOR SAME.

11/2/2017 SJ 340.00 4.00 1,360.00 Billable 469572 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT AND REVISE MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL (2), JOINT

LETTER BRIEF (1.5); REVIEW IOS 9 CASE AND EXPERT DATA (.5).

11/3/2017 SJ 340.00 3.50 1,190.00 Billable 469565 PLDS/MO-A FINALIZE JOINT LETTER BRIEF AND MOTION TO FILE UNDER

SEAL, AND PREPARE TO FILE; CONFER WITH J. MANNING, E-MAIL

APPLE COUNSEL REGARDING SAME.

11/6/2017 SJ 340.00 0.30 102.00 Billable 469566 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW JOINT MOTION COURTESY COPY.

11/7/2017 SJ 340.00 1.60 544.00 Billable 469575 CT APPR - A TELEPHONE CO-COUNSEL REGARDING DISCOVERY HEARING (.4);

REVIEW PROPOSED ORDER (.3); RESEARCH JUDGE COUSINS

DISCOVERY ORDERS (.4); PREPARE DISCOVERY MATERIALS FOR

HEARING (.5). Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 18 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 17

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

11/8/2017 SJ 340.00 9.10 3,094.00 Billable 469568 CT APPR - A DISCOVERY HEARING (4.0); FINALIZE PROPOSED ORDER AND

FILE (1.2); REVIEW APPLE PROPOSED ORDER (.5); MEET AND

CONFER WITH APPLE COUNSEL REGARDING DISCOVERY

DEADLINES AND ESI PROTOCOL (1.5); DRAFT AMENDED

PROPOSED ORDER AND E-MAIL COUNSEL REGARDING HEARING

(1.5); TELEPHONE - J. MANNING REGARDING DISCOVERY

HEARING (.4).

11/9/2017 SJ 340.00 0.80 272.00 Billable 469578 CT APPR - A TELEPHONE CALL REGARDING DISCOVERY HEARING (.6); E-MAIL -

J. MANNING REGARDING STATUS OF PLAINTIFFS' DISCOVERY

RESPONSES (.1); E-MAIL - A. STEYER REGARDING COUNSEL

RESEARCH (.1).

11/10/2017 SJ 340.00 2.70 918.00 Billable 469579 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE - D. TEJTEL AND E-MAIL J. MANNING, APPLE

COUNSEL REGARDING PLAINTIFFS RESPONSES TO DISCOVERY

RESPONSES (1.0); REVISE PROPOSED ORDER (.2); DRAFT

OBJECTIONS TO INTERROGATORIES (1.5).

11/13/2017 SJ 340.00 1.50 510.00 Billable 469581 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW APPLE SEARCH TERM ANALYSIS AND E-MAIL

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME (1.0); FILE PROPOSED ORDER

(.3); TELEPHONE - COURT CLERK REGARDING AMENDING

PROPOSED ORDER (.2).

11/14/2017 SJ 340.00 3.70 1,258.00 Billable 469592 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH REGARDING 30(B)(6) NOTICES (.4); REVISE PROPOSED Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 19 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 18

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

ORDER (1.3); REVIEW E-MAIL REGARDING SEARCH TERM

ANALYSIS (.2); RESEARCH REGARDING AUTHENTICATION OF

ONLINE MATERIAL (1.8).

11/15/2017 SJ 340.00 3.50 1,190.00 Billable 469586 DISCOVERY-A REVISE PROPOSED ORDER - CALL A. CURRY, APPLE COUNSEL

(2.2); REVISE PLAINTIFFS' DISCOVERY RESPONSES (1.3).

11/16/2017 SJ 340.00 3.00 1,020.00 Billable 469552 DISCOVERY-A REVISE PLAINTIFFS' DISCOVERY RESPONSES (2.5); TELEPHONE

CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING DISCOVERY HEARING,

DISCOVERY RESPONSES (.5).

11/17/2017 SJ 340.00 2.30 782.00 Billable 469558 DISCOVERY-A REVISE PLAINTIFFS' DISCOVERY RESPONSES (2.0); REVIEW

DRAFT JOINT LETTER ON APPLE'S RESPONSES TO

INTERROGATORIES (.3).

11/20/2017 SJ 340.00 5.20 1,768.00 Billable 469553 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH REGARDING AUTHENTICATION OF ONLINE

MATERIALS (3.5); MEET AND CONFER REGARDING ESI,

DISCOVERY (.5); TELEPHONE - K. POTTER REGARDING

INTERROGATORY RESPONSES (1.0); REVISE INTERROGATORY

RESPONSE (.2).

11/22/2017 SJ 340.00 0.70 238.00 Billable 469550 DISCOVERY-A CONFER REGARDING APPLE DOCUMENT PRODUCTION (.5);

TELEPHONE - APPLE COUNSEL REGARDING APPLE DOCUMENT

PRODUCTION (.2). Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 20 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 19

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

11/23/2017 SJ 340.00 0.50 170.00 Billable 469596 CLIENT MEETING-A TELEPHONE - K. POTTER REGARDING INTERROGATORY

RESPONSE.

11/24/2017 SJ 340.00 2.00 680.00 Billable 469551 CLIENT MEETING-A TELEPHONE - K. POTTER REGARDING INTERROGATORY

RESPONSE AND REVISE INTERROGATORY RESPONSE.

11/26/2017 SJ 340.00 0.50 170.00 Billable 469597 CLIENT MEETING-A TELEPHONE - K. POTTER REGARDING INTERROGATORY

RESPONSE.

11/27/2017 SJ 340.00 1.20 408.00 Billable 469845 CLIENT MEETING-A TELEPHONE - KEN POTTER REGARDING INTERROGATORY

RESPONSES (.7); REVISE INTERROGATORY RESPONSES (.3);

CONFER WITH J. MANNING REGARDING INTERROGATORY

RESPONSES (.2).

11/29/2017 SJ 340.00 0.20 68.00 Billable 469847 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL - J. MANNING, APPLE COUNSEL AMENDED

INTERROGATORIES.

11/30/2017 SJ 340.00 0.40 136.00 Billable 469840 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFER WITH J. MANNING REGARDING PRODUCTION FOR

DISCOVERY RESPONSE (.2); E-MAIL J. MANNING DOCUMENTS FOR

EXPERT REVIEW (.2).

12/1/2017 SJ 340.00 0.50 170.00 Billable 471887 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL - P. GRAVLEY REGARDING EXPERT DOCUMENTS (.1);

TELEPHONE CALL - S. MACRAE REGARDING JURY INSTRUCTIONS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 21 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 20

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

AND CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF (.2); REVIEW E-MAILS

REGARDING APPLE DOCUMENT PRODUCTION (.2).

12/4/2017 SJ 340.00 1.30 442.00 Billable 471889 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL - P. GRAVELY, V. GLAZE, M. DELANEY REGARDING APPLE

DOCUMENT PRODUCTION (.3); REVIEW DOCUMENT PRODUCTION

(1.0).

12/5/2017 SJ 340.00 3.70 1,258.00 Billable 471898 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL J. MANNING REGARDING EXPERT BINDER (.3); REVIEW

APPLE DOCUMENT PRODUCTION AND E-MAIL J. MANNING

REGARDING ITUNES TRANSACTION DATABASE REPORTS (3.0);

E-MAIL - P. GRAVELY REGARDING ANALYSIS OF ITUNES

TRANSACTION DATABASE REPORTS (.4).

12/6/2017 SJ 340.00 5.30 1,802.00 Billable 471905 RESEARCH-A CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL (1.0); REVIEW APPLE PRODUCTION AND

MEMO REGARDING DISCOVERY RESPONSES (.8); RESEARCH

REGARDING AUTHENTICATION OF WEB MATERIALS (3.5).

12/8/2017 SJ 340.00 6.80 2,312.00 Billable 471803 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH JUDGE KOH DECISIONS ON CLASS CERTIFICATION

(4.5); MEET AND CONFER REGARDING APPLE RESPONSES TO

PLAINTIFFS DISCOVERY REQUESTS (1.5); E-MAIL COUNSEL

REGARDING MEET AND CONFER (.8).

12/11/2017 SJ 340.00 2.20 748.00 Billable 471840 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE CALL - KEN POTTER REGARDING PLAINTIFFS'

DOCUMENT PRODUCTION (.2); REVIEW DRAFT STIPULATION Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 22 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 21

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt REGARDING EXTENSION OF DEADLINES (.25); REVIEW E-MAILS

REGARDING APPLE DISCOVERY PRODUCTION (.5); REVIEW

SEARCH TERM ANALYTICS (1.25).

12/12/2017 SJ 340.00 4.00 1,360.00 Billable 471808 RESEARCH-A REVIEW SEARCH TERM ANALYTICS AND E-MAIL CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING SAME (2.25); REVIEW D. TEJTEL LETTER REGARDING

SEARCH TERM ANALYTICS (.25); RESEARCH AND REVIEW NOTES

REGARDING AUTHENTICATION OF WEB MATERIALS (1.5).

12/13/2017 SJ 340.00 7.00 2,380.00 Billable 471809 DISCOVERY-A MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE REGARDING SEARCH TERMS

(.75); E-MAIL CO-COUNSEL REGARDING MEET AND CONFER (.25);

DRAFT REVISED SEARCH TERMS (1.0); REVISE AND FILED

STIPULATION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME (1.0); REVIEW

INDIVIDUALIZED SEARCH TERMS ANALYTICS (3.0); TELEPHONE

CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS (.5);

TELEPHONE CALL WITH EXPERT REGARDING DAMAGES

ASSESSMENT (.5).

12/14/2017 SJ 340.00 3.50 1,190.00 Billable 471813 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT MEMORANDA REGARDING POTENTIAL SEARCH TERM

REVISIONS AND QUESTIONS REGARDING APPLE SEARCH TERM

ANALYTICS.

12/15/2017 SJ 340.00 2.40 816.00 Billable 471815 RESEARCH-A REVIEW SEARCH TERMS (1.2); RESEARCH REGARDING CLASS

CERTIFICATION OF TRESPASS TO CHATTELS CLAIMS (1.2).

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 23 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 22

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 12/18/2017 SJ 340.00 2.00 680.00 Billable 471818 DISCOVERY-A REVISE SEARCH TERMS.

12/19/2017 SJ 340.00 6.00 2,040.00 Billable 471821 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH REGARDING DAMAGES (.5); RESEARCH REGARDING

CLASS CERTIFICATION OF TRESPASS TO CHATTELS CLAIM (5.0);

EDIT REVISED SEARCH TERMS (.5).

12/20/2017 SJ 340.00 2.40 816.00 Billable 471823 DISCOVERY-A MEET AND CONFER REGARDING APPLE'S REQUEST FOR

PRODUCTION RESPONSES (2.0); TELEPHONE CALL WITH

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS (.4).

12/22/2017 SJ 340.00 2.00 680.00 Billable 471827 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS

(1.0); TELEPHONE CALL - J. MANNING REGARDING JUDGE KOH

ORDER, PLAINTIFF PRODUCTION, DEPOSITION NOTICE (.25);

REVISE DEPOSITION NOTICE (.25); PREPARE KEN POTTER

DOCUMENTS FOR PRODUCTION (.5).

12/29/2017 SJ 340.00 1.50 510.00 Billable 471830 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH APPLE CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE

STATUS (.5); TELEPHONE CALL WITH EXPERT DR. HASTINGS

REGARDING DAMAGES ASSESSMENT (.4); TELEPHONE CALL WITH

C. GRACE REGARDING PRODUCTION OF PLAINTIFF'S MATERIAL

(.1); REVIEW SOURCE CODE PROTECTIVE ORDER FOR SHARING

OF PRODUCED DOCUMENTS AND E-MAIL J. MANNING REGARDING

SAME (.5).

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 24 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 23

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 1/2/2018 SJ 360.00 5.00 1,800.00 Billable 473814 DISCOVERY-A MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE REGARDING ESI SEARCH

TERMS, DISCOVERY PRODUCTION (1.0); CONFER WITH P.

GRAVELY REGARDING THIRD PARTY SUBPOENAS (.2); CONFER

WITH J. MANNING REGARDING THIRD PARTY SUBPOENAS, CASE

STATUS (.3); CONFER WITH J. MANNING REGARDING SOURCE

CODE PROTECTIVE ORDER (.2); DRAFT LETTERS REGARDING

SOURCE CODE PRODUCTION (.4); E-MAIL CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING SOURCE CODE PRODUCTION (.2); CONFER WITH P.

GRAVELY REGARDING SOURCE CODE PRODUCTION (.2);

RESEARCH REGARDING CLASS CERTIFICATION OF TRESPASS TO

CHATTEL CLAIMS (2.5).

1/3/2018 SJ 360.00 6.70 2,412.00 Billable 473883 DISCOVERY-A RESEARCH REGARDING CLASS CERTIFICATION OF TRESPASS TO

CHATTELS CLAIMS (3.5); REVISE CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF

(1.3); CONFER WITH R. FISHMAN REGARDING REVIEW OF GRACE

E-MAILS (.2); REVIEW DISCOVERY LETTER BRIEF (.3); REVIEW

CHART REGARDING SUBPOENAS TO NON-PARTIES (.3); REVIEW

APPLE ESI SEARCH TERMS (.2); REVIEW GRACE E-MAILS (.7);

REVISE LETTERS REGARDING SOURCE CODE PRODUCTION (.2).

1/4/2018 SJ 360.00 2.90 1,044.00 Billable 473886 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT NON-PARTY SUBPOENAS (1.4); CONFER WITH D.

WARSHAW, J. MANNING REGARDING SEARCH PLAINTIFF'S

DOCUMENTS (.5); CONFER WITH J. MANNING REGARDING GRACE

PRODUCTION (.2); REVISE POTTER RESPONSES TO

INTERROGATORIES (.3); REVIEW APPLE ESI SEARCH TERMS AND Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 25 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 24

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt RESEARCH REGARDING SAME (.5).

1/5/2018 SJ 360.00 3.10 1,116.00 Billable 473887 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE - D. TEJTEL REGARDING ESI SEARCH TERMS (.2);

REVIEW ESI SEARCH TERMS AND E-MAILS REGARDING SAME (.6);

TELEPHONE - J. MANNING REGARDING ESI, PLAINTIFFS

DISCOVERY (.2); REVISE NON-PARTY SUBPOENAS AND DRAFT

SUBPOENA ATTACHMENTS (1.8); E-MAIL E-DISCOVERY

REGARDING SEARCH TERMS (.3).

1/6/2018 SJ 360.00 0.80 288.00 Billable 473909 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE AND E-MAIL - K. POTTER REGARDING DISCOVERY

PRODUCTION.

1/8/2018 SJ 360.00 2.10 756.00 Billable 473888 DISCOVERY-A REVISE CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF (.4); TELEPHONE - J.

MANNING REGARDING PLAINTIFF'S DISCOVERY PRODUCTION (.2);

CONFER WITH P. GRAVELY REGARDING PLAINTIFF'S DISCOVERY

PRODUCTION (.1); REVISE SUBPOENAS (.8); REVIEW SEARCH HIT

REPORT FOR PLAINTIFFS (.4); CONFER REGARDING NON-PARTY

SUBPOENAS (.2).

1/9/2018 SJ 360.00 2.80 1,008.00 Billable 473891 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE MEET AND CONFER REGARDING INTERROGATORIES

(1.0); E-MAIL - K. POTTER REGARDING DISCOVERY PRODUCTION

(.1); E-MAIL - J. MANNING REGARDING NON-PARTY SUBPOENAS

(.4); REVIEW SEARCH HITS ON PLAINTIFF PRODUCTION AND

E-MAIL J. MANNING REGARDING SAME (.6); REVISE NON-PARTY

SUBPOENAS (.2). Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 26 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 25

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

1/10/2018 SJ 360.00 3.80 1,368.00 Billable 473912 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL E. BUNTAIN REGARDING GRACE DOCUMENT REVIEW (.5);

REVIEW D. TEJTEL E-MAIL REGARDING FT BREAK (.3); REVISE

NON-PARTY SUBPOENAS (.7); DRAFT SECOND AMENDED

INTERROGATORIES RESPONSE, E-MAIL K. POTTER REGARDING

SAME (.8); REVIEW REVISED INTERROGATORIES (.4); REVIEW

EXHIBITS FOR JOINT LETTER BRIEF (.1); TELEPHONE CALL WITH

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS (1.0).

1/11/2018 SJ 360.00 7.10 2,556.00 Billable 473914 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW C. GRACE DOCUMENT PRODUCTION (5.0); E-MAIL E.

BUNTAIN REGARDING GRACE DOCUMENTS (.3); TELEPHONE CALL

WITH K. POTTER REGARDING INTERROGATORY RESPONSES (.3);

DRAFT MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL (1.2); REVISE JOINT LETTER

BRIEF (.3).

1/12/2018 SJ 360.00 4.90 1,764.00 Billable 473924 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE WITH K. POTTER REGARDING DISCOVERY

RESPONSES (.8); TELEPHONE CALL WITH A. CURRY REGARDING

FILING OF LETTER BRIEF (.2); REVISE JOINT LETTER BRIEF (.3);

FILE JOINT LETTER BRIEF (.5); REVIEW C. GRACE DOCUMENTS

(3.0); TELEPHONE CALL WITH J. MANNING REGARDING LETTER

BRIEF (.1).

1/15/2018 SJ 360.00 2.60 936.00 Billable 474192 CLIENT MEETING-A MEETING WITH K. POTTER REGARDING DISCOVERY

PRODUCTION (2.2); TELEPHONE WITH K. POTTER REGARDING

SAME (.4). Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 27 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 26

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

1/16/2018 SJ 360.00 0.50 180.00 Billable 474194 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE A. SIMON REGARDING SUBPOENAS (.2); TELEPHONE

J. MANNING REGARDING PLAINTIFFS' DISCOVERY (.2); E-MAIL

COUNSEL REGARDING SUBPOENAS (.1).

1/17/2018 SJ 360.00 1.80 648.00 Billable 474176 DISCOVERY-A REVISE RESPONSE TO INTERROGATORY AND TO REQUEST FOR

PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS.

1/18/2018 SJ 360.00 5.20 1,872.00 Billable 474178 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW GRACE PRODUCTION AND PREPARE FOR PRODUCTION

TO APPLE (3.5); REVISE LETTER BRIEF REGARDING IMAGING OF

DEVICES (1.7).

1/19/2018 SJ 360.00 2.90 1,044.00 Billable 474196 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW APPLE'S REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION RESPONSES (1.5);

CONFER WITH P. GRAVELY REGARDING APPLE REQUEST FOR

PRODUCTION RESPONSE (.2); E-MAIL INVENTUS REGARDING

IMAGING (.5); REVIEW GRACE 2015 DOCUMENTS (.4); CONFER

WITH J. MANNING REGARDING GRACE PRODUCTION (.3).

1/22/2018 SJ 360.00 0.90 324.00 Billable 474166 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL CO-COUNSEL REGARDING NON-PARTY SUBPOENA (.7);

PREPARE EXHIBITS FOR SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEF (.2).

1/23/2018 SJ 360.00 3.10 1,116.00 Billable 474168 PLDS/MO-A E-MAIL CO-COUNSEL REGARDING APPLE SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEF

(.7); E-MAIL A. CURRY REGARDING APPLE DIAGNOSTIC TRACKING

(.5); CONFER WITH J. MANNING REGARDING APPLE DIAGNOSTIC Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 28 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 27

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt TRACKING (.2); CALL WITH INVENTUS REGARDING IMAGING OF

DEVICES (.4); PREPARE GRACE DOCUMENTS FOR PRODUCTION

AND E-MAIL INVENTUS REGARDING SAME (.5); FILE

SUPPLEMENTAL LETTER BRIEF (.8).

1/24/2018 SJ 360.00 1.50 540.00 Billable 473847 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS (1.0);

CONFER WITH J. MANNING REGARDING ORDER ON

INTERROGATORIES AND IMAGING DISCOVERY BRIEF (.6); REVIEW

HIT COUNT FOR FACETIME (.1); MEETING WITH S. HAJEK

REGARDING IMAGING OF PLAINTIFF'S DEVICES (.8).

1/25/2018 SJ 360.00 0.50 180.00 Billable 473859 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL L. ROREM REGARDING TRANSCRIPT ORDER (.2); E-MAIL P.

GRAVELY REGARDING RESEARCH ON CLASS CERTIFICATION (.2);

CONFER WITH P. GRAVELY REGARDING RESEARCH ON CLASS

CERTIFICATION (.1).

1/26/2018 SJ 360.00 0.70 252.00 Billable 473882 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH KEN POTTER REGARDING SECOND

AMENDED INTERROGATORIES (.5); REVISE SECOND AMENDED

INTERROGATORIES (.2).

2/1/2018 SJ 360.00 0.50 180.00 Billable 475902 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW DRAFT LETTER BRIEF REGARDING PLAINTIFFS'

REQUEST FOR PRODUCTIONS.

2/2/2018 SJ 360.00 3.50 1,260.00 Billable 476811 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW E-MAILS REGARDING IMAGING (.2); REVIEW APPLE'S

REQUESTS FOR ADMISSIONS AND INTERROGATORIES (.7); Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 29 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 28

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

REVIEW VERIZON RESPONSE TO SUBPOENA (.1); DOCUMENT

REVIEW OF CHRISTINA GRACE E-MAILS (2.5).

2/5/2018 SJ 360.00 4.20 1,512.00 Billable 475793 DOC REVIEW-A DOCUMENT REVIEW OF PLAINTIFF GRACE'S E-MAILS AND

PREPARE SAME FOR PRODUCTION TO APPLE (2.3); TELEPHONE

CALL WITH K. POTTER REGARDING INTERROGATORY RESPONSE

AND SEARCH OF DEVICES (.2); TELEPHONE CALL WITH INVENTUS

REGARDING SEARCH OF PLAINTIFF DEVICES (.3); TELEPHONE

CALL WITH J. MANNING REGARDING PLAINTIFF'S DISCOVERY (.2);

REVIEW APPLE PRODUCTION AND CONFER WITH P. GRAVLEY

REGARDING SAME (.5); E-MAIL - D. TEJTEL REGARDING REQUEST

FOR PRODUCTION IMPASSE (.3); E-MAIL - A. SIMON, L. ROREM

REGARDING NON-PARTY SUBPOENAS (.2); REVIEW E-MAILS

REGARDING IMAGING OF DEVICES, PLAINTIFF'S BRIEF

REGARDING REQUEST FOR PRODUCTIONS (.2).

2/6/2018 SJ 360.00 4.90 1,764.00 Billable 475819 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH INVENTUS REGARDING COLLECTION OF

E-MAILS (.5); TELEPHONE CALL WITH INVENTUS, K. POTTER

REGARDING COLLECTION OF E-MAILS (3.5); REVISE DRAFT CASE

MANAGEMENT STATEMENT (.5); E-MAIL - INVENTUS AND

MESSAGE K. POTTER REGARDING COLLECTION OF E-MAILS (.4).

2/7/2018 SJ 360.00 6.20 2,232.00 Billable 475799 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL COUNSEL PLAINTIFFS DOCUMENT PRODUCTION (.1);

REVISE 30(B)(6) DEPOSITION NOTICE (.1);TELEPHONE CALL WITH

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS, DAMAGES, CLASS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 30 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 29

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt CERTIFICATION (1.7); REVIEW MEMO REGARDING DAMAGES (.4);

E-MAIL - A. SIMON, L. ROREM REGARDING HEARING TRANSCRIPT,

NON-PARTY SUBPOENAS (.5); E-MAIL - J. MANNING REGARDING

JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT (.8);

REVIEW FINAL CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT

(.2); TELEPHONE CALL WITH K. POTTER, INVENTUS REGARDING

COLLECTION OF PLAINTIFF E-MAILS (2.0); REVIEW C. GRACE TEXT

MESSAGES (.1);

E-MAIL AND MESSAGE - K. POTTER, INVENTUS REGARDING

PLAINTIFF'S DOCUMENT COLLECTION (.3).

2/8/2018 SJ 360.00 4.30 1,548.00 Billable 475807 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH K. POTTER REGARDING E-MAIL

COLLECTION (.3); TELEPHONE CALL WITH INVENTUS REGARDING

E-MAIL COLLECTION (.2); TELEPHONE CALL WITH K. POTTER,

INVENTUS REGARDING E-MAIL COLLECTION (.4); TELEPHONE

CALL WITH K. POTTER, INVENTUS REGARDING E-MAIL

COLLECTION (1.5); TELEPHONE CALL WITH A. SIMON REGARDING

NON-PARTY SUBPOENA NEGOTIATION (.2); CONFER WITH P.

GRAVLEY REGARDING NON-PARTY SUBPOENAS (.2); CONFER

WITH J. MANNING REGARDING CASE MANAGEMENT

CONFERENCE STATEMENT, E-MAIL COLLECTION (.2); REVIEW

AMAZON OBJECTIONS TO SUBPOENA AND CALL AMAZON

REGARDING SAME (.3); REVIEW NON-PARTY SUBPOENA AND

NEGOTIATION MATERIALS (.4); DRAFT MEMO REGARDING E-MAIL

COLLECTION PROCESS (.6).

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 31 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 30

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 2/9/2018 SJ 360.00 2.10 756.00 Billable 475826 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH J. MANNING REGARDING COLLECTION OF

K. POTTER DOCUMENTS (.1); TELEPHONE CALL AND MESSAGES

WITH K. POTTER REGARDING COLLECTION OF E-MAILS (.4);

TELEPHONE CALL WITH INVENTUS REGARDING COLLECTION OF

K. POTTER E-MAILS (.2);

E-MAIL INVENTUS REGARDING COLLECTION OF K. POTTER

E-MAILS, TEXTS (.5); REVIEW JUDGE KOH ORDER ON APPLE

SANCTIONS IN QUALCOMM MATTER (.2); REVIEW OUTLINE FOR

30(B)(6) DEPOSITION (.3); REVIEW HOT DOCUMENTS (.4).

2/12/2018 SJ 360.00 6.60 2,376.00 Billable 475829 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL INVENTUS REGARDING E-MAIL REVIEW (.3); TELEPHONE

CALL WITH INVENTUS REGARDING COLLECTION OF PHONE

INFORMATION (.5); RESEARCH REGARDING APPLE CUSTODIANS

(.4); REVIEW DISCOVERY PRODUCTION SOURCE DOMAINS FOR

E-MAILS (.2); REVIEW AMENDED RESPONSE TO APPLE REQUEST

FOR PRODUCTION (.2); REVIEW POTTER E-MAILS (2.5); BEGIN

DRAFTING RESPONSES TO APPLE'S SECOND SET OF

INTERROGATORIES AND REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION (2.5).

2/13/2018 SJ 360.00 6.40 2,304.00 Billable 475912 DISCOVERY-A REVISE DEPOSITION OUTLINE FOR KELLERMANN DEPOSITION

(2.5); E-MAIL KEN POTTER REGARDING COLLECTION OF PHONE

DOCUMENTS (.3); E-MAIL INVENTUS REGARDING COLLECTION OF

POTTER DOCUMENTS (.3); REVIEW KELLERMANN DEPOSITION

EXHIBITS (.4)

REVIEW DEPOSITION OUTLINE (.4); MEETING WITH J. MANNING, D. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 32 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 31

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt WARSHAW REGARDING DEPOSITION (.5); CONTINUE DRAFTING

RESPONSE TO APPLE'S INTERROGATORIES AND REQUESTS FOR

ADMISSION (2.0).

2/14/2018 SJ 360.00 9.50 3,420.00 Billable 475831 DEP TAKE/DEF-A ATTEND DEPOSITION OF BETH KELLERMANN (6.5); FINALIZE

DRAFTS OF RESPONSES TO APPLE INTERROGATORIES AND

REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION (3.0).

2/15/2018 SJ 360.00 4.60 1,656.00 Billable 476800 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE WITH INVENTUS, K. POTTER REGARDING

COLLECTION OF ESI (2.5); REVIEW JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT

STATEMENT (.3); DRAFT MEMO REGARDING B. KELLERMANN

DEPOSITION AND APPLE CUSTOMER DATABASES (1.8).

2/16/2018 SJ 360.00 1.40 504.00 Billable 476740 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING B. KELLERMANN

DEPOSITION (.5); REVISE JOINT CMS (.3); REVIEW KELLERMANN

TRANSCRIPT (.2); TELEPHONE - AMAZON REGARDING SUBPOENA

(.4).

2/20/2018 SJ 360.00 3.40 1,224.00 Billable 476803 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE WITH INVENTUS, K. POTTER TO COLLECTION

POTTER ESI (2.9); REVISE SUBPOENAS FOR AMAZON AND

BRIGHTSTAR (.5).

2/21/2018 SJ 360.00 9.00 3,240.00 Billable 476744 PLDS/MO-A REVISE DRAFT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT

AND FILE (4.0); E-MAIL AMAZON REGARDING SUBPOENA (.2); CALL

WITH K. POTTER, INVENTUS TO COLLECT ESI FROM APPLE Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 33 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 32

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

DEVICES (2.5); TELEPHONE CALL WITH EXPERT AND

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING EXPERT REPORT AND CASE STATUS

(1.5); RESEARCH REGARDING STATE VARIATION IN UNFAIR

COMPETITION LAW (.8).

2/22/2018 SJ 360.00 7.00 2,520.00 Billable 476793 DOC REVIEW-A DOCUMENT REVIEW OF C. GRACE ESI (6.0); FILE AMENDMENTS

TO CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT (.3); E-MAIL

AND CONFER REGARDING CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE

FILLING AND DELIVERY TO COURT (.2); RESEARCH REGARDING

PROTOCOL FOR INSPECTION OF ELECTRONIC DEVICES (.5).

2/23/2018 SJ 360.00 5.90 2,124.00 Billable 476790 DOC REVIEW-A DOCUMENT REVIEW OF K. POTTER E-MAILS (4.0); REVIEW AND

PREPARE FOR PRODUCTION C. GRACE ESI (1.5); E-MAIL - J.

MANNING REGARDING FORENSIC IMAGING PROPOSAL (.4).

2/26/2018 SJ 360.00 7.80 2,808.00 Billable 476837 DISCOVERY-A REVISE PROPOSAL REGARDING IMAGING OF DEVICES (1.2);

TELEPHONE CALL WITH TECHDATA REGARDING SUBPOENA TO

BRIGHTSTAR (.2); CALL WITH A. SIMON REGARDING NON-PARTY

SUBPOENAS (.4); DOCUMENT REVIEW OF K. POTTER E-MAILS

(2.0); E-MAIL REGARDING NON-PARTY SUBPOENAS (.2); E-MAIL - P.

GRAVLEY REGARDING DISCOVERY PRODUCTION (.3); CALL WITH

INVENTUS, K. POTTER TO CONDUCT SEARCH TERM ANALYSIS ON

ESI (3.5).

2/27/2018 SJ 360.00 4.60 1,656.00 Billable 477189 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE WITH J. BUI REGARDING ESI COLLECTION (.2); Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 34 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 33

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

DOCUMENT REVIEW OF KEN POTTER ESI (4.0); TELEPHONE -

AMAZON, COURT CORP REGARDING NON-PARTY SUBPOENAS (.4).

2/28/2018 SJ 360.00 8.00 2,880.00 Billable 477362 DOC REVIEW-A DOCUMENT REVIEW OF KEN POTTER ESI (6.5); TELEPHONE CALL

WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS (1.0); DRAFT

MEMO REGARDING NON-PARTY SUBPOENAS (.2); E-MAIL J.

MANNING REGARDING KEN POTTER ESI (.2); E-MAIL AMAZON

REGARDING NON-PARTY SUBPOENA (.1).

3/1/2018 SJ 360.00 9.20 3,312.00 Billable 479611 DISCOVERY-A CALL WITH AMAZON REGARDING SUBPOENA (.6); CALL WITH A.

SIMON REGARDING AMAZON SUBPOENA (.2); CALL WITH COURT

CORP REGARDING BRIGHTSTAR SUBPOENA (.2); REVIEW OF KEN

POTTER ESI (E-MAILS) (8.0); E-MAIL INVENTUS REGARDING KEN

POTTER DEVICE INFORMATION (.2).

3/2/2018 SJ 360.00 7.50 2,700.00 Billable 479587 DOC REVIEW-A REVIEW KEN POTTER ESI (E-MAIL, APPLE DEVICES) (7.0); E-MAIL J.

MANNING REGARDING PLAINTIFFS' PRODUCTION (.5).

3/4/2018 SJ 360.00 0.60 216.00 Billable 479612 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSES TO REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION

AND INTERROGATORIES.

3/5/2018 SJ 360.00 3.10 1,116.00 Billable 479588 DISCOVERY-A REVISE PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSES TO APPLE'S INTERROGATORIES

AND REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION (1.0); RESEARCH REGARDING

30(B)(6) WITNESS ADEQUACY (1.5); E-MAIL INVENTUS REGARDING Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 35 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 34

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt FACETIME-RELATED ESI OF PLAINTIFFS (.1); REVIEW

FACETIME-RELATED ESI (.5).

3/6/2018 SJ 360.00 2.00 720.00 Billable 479610 DOC REVIEW-A CONFER REGARDING KEN POTTER DOCUMENT PRODUCTION

WITH J. MANNING (.5); REVIEW AND PREPARE REDACTIONS FOR

PLAINTIFFS' DOCUMENT PRODUCTION (1.5).

3/7/2018 SJ 360.00 5.50 1,980.00 Billable 479579 DOC REVIEW-A CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS (1); REVIEW

KEN POTTER ESI AND REDACTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' PRODUCTION

(4.5).

3/8/2018 SJ 360.00 3.10 1,116.00 Billable 479581 DISCOVERY-A CALL A. SIMON REGARDING SUBPOENA TO

BRIGHTSTAR/ASSURANT (.1); E-MAIL P. GRAVLEY REGARDING

ASSURANT SUBPOENA AND RESEARCH REGARDING SAME (.4);

DRAFT SUBPOENA TO ASSURANT (.1); REVIEW PLAINTIFFS'

DOCUMENT PRODUCTION WITH J. MANNING (1.5); REVISE

PLAINTIFFS' DOCUMENT PRODUCTION (1.0).

3/9/2018 SJ 360.00 5.20 1,872.00 Billable 479582 DOC REVIEW-A FINALIZE PLAINTIFFS' DOCUMENT PRODUCTION AND REVIEW

PRIVILEGE, REDACTIONS, RELEVANCE (4.5); E-MAIL INVENTUS

REGARDING PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS (.7).

3/11/2018 SJ 360.00 1.00 360.00 Billable 479576 DOC REVIEW-A DOCUMENT REVIEW OF ADDITIONAL PLAINTIFFS DOCUMENTS

AND PREPARE FOR PRODUCTION.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 36 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 35

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 3/12/2018 SJ 360.00 3.30 1,188.00 Billable 479577 DOC REVIEW-A MEET AND CONFER REGARDING DISCOVERY ISSUES (2.5);

REVIEW PLAINTIFFS' DOCUMENT PRODUCTION AND E-MAIL

COUNSEL PRODUCTION (.6); E-MAIL CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

STATUS OF PLAINTIFFS' PRODUCTION (.1); E-MAIL AMAZON

REGARDING 30(B)(6) SUBPOENA (.1).

3/13/2018 SJ 360.00 6.60 2,376.00 Billable 479616 DOC REVIEW-A REVIEW AMAZON OBJECTIONS TO 30(B)(6) SUBPOENA (.3); E-MAIL

INVENTUS REGARDING LIST OF PLAINTIFFS' DEVICES (.1);

REVIEW T. GREENE E-MAIL REGARDING DISCOVERY ISSUES (.2);

REVIEW ADDITIONAL PLAINTIFFS' DOCUMENTS (KEN POTTER,

NON-APPLE ESI) (6.0).

3/14/2018 SJ 360.00 8.50 3,060.00 Billable 479617 DOC REVIEW-A CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS (.5); E-MAIL

CO-COUNSEL COMMENTS TO T. GREENE E-MAIL ON DISCOVERY

ISSUES (1.0); CONTINUE REVIEW OF ADDITIONAL PLAINTIFFS'

DOCUMENTS (KEN POTTER, NON-APPLE ESI) (7.0).

3/15/2018 SJ 360.00 7.40 2,664.00 Billable 479592 DOC REVIEW-A E-MAIL INVENTUS REGARDING LIST OF PLAINTIFFS' DEVICES AND

DEVICES WITH KEN POTTER (.4); COMPLETE REVIEW OF

ADDITIONAL PLAINTIFFS' DOCUMENTS (KEN POTTER, NON-APPLE

ESI) (7.0).

3/16/2018 SJ 360.00 5.70 2,052.00 Billable 479605 DOC REVIEW-A MEETING WITH INVENTUS (1.0); REVIEW APPLE LETTER

REGARDING EVIDENCE (.2); REVIEW KEN POTTER DOCUMENTS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 37 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 36

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt (1.5); COMPLETE REVIEW OF KEN POTTER NON-APPLE ESI (3.0).

3/19/2018 SJ 360.00 6.60 2,376.00 Billable 479381 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE WITH AMAZON REGARDING SUBPOENA (.5); MEET

AND CONFER WITH APPLE (2.0); E-MAIL CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

APPLE'S EMPLOYEE COMMUNICATION METHODS, PLAINTIFFS'

DISCOVERY STATUS (.3); REVIEW APPLE LETTER BRIEF (.3);

REVIEW PLAINTIFFS' FACETIME-RELATED ESI (1.0); BEGIN

DRAFTING LETTER IN RESPONSE TO APPLE REGARDING IMAGING

OF DEVICE (2.5).

3/20/2018 SJ 360.00 6.80 2,448.00 Billable 479408 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT LETTER IN RESPONSE TO APPLE BRIEF ON IMAGING

DEVICE (2.5); E-MAIL AMAZON REGARDING SUBPOENA (.8);

REVIEW PLAINTIFFS' FACETIME-RELATED ESI AND E-MAIL

INVENTUS REGARDING KEN POTTER PRODUCTION (1.8);

AMENDED DEPOSITION NOTICE FOR GOKUL THIRUMALAI (.2);

REVISE JOINT LETTER BRIEF AND FILE (1.5).

3/21/2018 SJ 360.00 6.40 2,304.00 Billable 479378 DISCOVERY-A CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS (1.0);

REVIEW PLAINTIFFS' DOCUMENT PRODUCTION AND E-MAIL

INVENTUS REGARDING POTTER ESI (1.0); DRAFT DECLARATION

IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL (.7); FINALIZE

DRAFT REGARDING MEMO ON BETH KELLERMANN WITNESS

ADEQUACY (2.5); REVIEW DRAFT JOINT LETTER BRIEF AND

E-MAILS FROM APPLE REGARDING SAME (1.2).

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 38 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 37

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 3/22/2018 SJ 360.00 6.00 2,160.00 Billable 479374 DISCOVERY-A REVISE AND PREPARE EXHIBITS FOR JOINT LETTER BRIEF (4.5);

CONFER WITH J. MANNING REGARDING PLAINTIFFS' DISCOVERY

PRODUCTION (.5); REVISE AMENDED REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION

(1.0).

3/23/2018 SJ 360.00 1.10 396.00 Billable 479373 DISCOVERY-A REVISE KEN POTTER'S THIRD AMENDED RESPONSES TO

INTERROGATORIES (.6); E-MAIL INVENTUS REGARDING GRACE

ESI (.5).

3/26/2018 SJ 360.00 3.50 1,260.00 Billable 479371 DISCOVERY-A REVISE JOINT LETTER BRIEF, EXHIBITS TO BRIEF, AND PREPARE

REDACTIONS TO BRIEF.

3/27/2018 SJ 360.00 6.60 2,376.00 Billable 479370 DISCOVERY-A AMAZON CALL (.5); REVIEW AMAZON OBJECTIONS TO SUBPOENA

(.3); E-MAIL P. GRAVLEY REGARDING FILING OF LETTER BRIEF (.3);

FILE JOINT LETTER BRIEF AND MOTION TO FILE BRIEF UNDER

SEAL (1.0); E-MAIL J. MANNING REGARDING JOINT LETTER BRIEF

(.3); REVISE JOINT LETTER BRIEF (.8); REVISE EXHIBITS TO JOINT

LETTER BRIEF (.7); REVIEW MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL (1.2);

DRAFT MEMO REGARDING BETH KELLERMANN DEPOSITION

INADEQUACY (1.5).

3/28/2018 SJ 360.00 4.40 1,584.00 Billable 479396 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH EXPERT AND CO-COUNSEL REGARDING

DAMAGES MODEL AND CASE STATUS (1.4); REVIEW KEN POTTER

DISCOVERY PRODUCTION (.5); E-MAIL COUNSEL REGARDING Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 39 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 38

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt RESPONSES TO APPLE ON DISCOVERY ISSUES (.6); BEGIN

RESEARCH AND DRAFTING MEMO REGARDING APPLE'S FAILURE

TO PROVIDE ADEQUATE 30(B)(6) WITNESS (1.7); E-MAIL J.

MANNING REGARDING MOTION TO AMEND (.2).

3/29/2018 SJ 360.00 7.30 2,628.00 Billable 479407 DISCOVERY-A RESEARCH REGARDING APPLE'S FAILURE TO PRODUCE AN

ADEQUATE 30(B)(6) WITNESS (2.0); DRAFT MEMO REGARDING

APPLE'S FAILURE TO PRODUCE AN ADEQUATE 30(B)(6) WITNESS

(1.5); DRAFT LETTER TO APPLE REGARDING APPLE'S FAILURE TO

PRODUCE AN ADEQUATE 30(B)(6) WITNESS (1.5); DRAFT AND FILE

DECLARATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL (.6);

REVIEW KEN POTTER DOCUMENT PRODUCTION AND CONFER

WITH J. MANNING REGARDING SAME (1.0); REVISE PLAINTIFFS

SECOND SET OF REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION AND

INTERROGATORY NO. 18 (.4); E-MAIL COUNSEL REGARDING

DISCOVERY UPDATE TO APPLE'S MEET AND CONFER QUESTIONS

(.3).

3/30/2018 SJ 360.00 3.60 1,296.00 Billable 479596 DISCOVERY-A RESEARCH REGARDING CLASS CERTIFICATION DAMAGES MODEL

REQUIREMENTS (2.0); SEARCH KEN POTTER DOCUMENTS FOR

APPLE DEVICE DOCUMENTS (1.0); CALL CLERK REGARDING

ORDER ON MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL, CALL WITH J. MANNING

REGARDING SAME (.6).

4/2/2018 SJ 360.00 4.10 1,476.00 Billable 482011 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL P. GRAVLEY REGARDING RESEARCH ON APPLE

EXECUTIVES (.5); RESEARCH REGARDING REDACTION OF Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 40 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 39

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

PLEADINGS (1.2); REVIEW EXPERT QUESTIONS FOR BEST BUY

(.2); REVIEW REVISED SEARCH TERMS FOR APPLE ESI (.4);

RESEARCH REGARDING PLAINTIFF DEVICE INFORMATION (1.8).

4/3/2018 SJ 360.00 6.00 2,160.00 Billable 482010 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW PLAINTIFFS DOCUMENTS REGARDING APPLE USER

AGREEMENTS AND E-MAIL J. MANNING REGARDING SAME (3.5);

REVISE SEARCH TERMS FOR DISCOVERY FROM APPLE (1.5);

REVIEW APPLE'S THIRD AMENDED RESPONSES TO REQUEST

FOR PRODUCTIONS AND E-MAIL CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME

(.8); CONFER WITH J. MANNING REGARDING PLAINTIFFS'

PRODUCTION OF APPLE DOCUMENTS (.2).

4/4/2018 SJ 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 482015 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL - J. MANNING REGARDING THIRD PARTY FORENSICS

SPECIALISTS (.2); E-MAIL - L. ROREM REGARDING DISCOVERY

HEARING (.2); RESEARCH AND REVIEW MEMO ON APPLE

EXECUTIVES (1.5); REVIEW E-MAIL REGARDING APPLE

CERTIFICATE EXPIRATION (.3); RESEARCH REGARDING DEVICE

INFORMATION FOR PLAINTIFFS (2.0); TELEPHONE - J. MANNING

REGARDING DISCOVERY HEARING, 30(B)(6) SUBPOENAS (.3).

4/5/2018 SJ 360.00 1.20 432.00 Billable 482009 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL L. ROREM REGARDING DISCOVERY HEARING (.3); E-MAIL

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING APPLE EMPLOYEES IDENTIFIED IN

INITIAL DISCLOSURES (.4); E-MAIL - E. BUNTAIN REGARDING

PRODUCTION OF PLAINTIFFS' DOCUMENTS (.5).

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 41 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 40

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 4/6/2018 SJ 360.00 2.00 720.00 Billable 482014 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS

(.4); REVISE PLAINTIFFS' AMENDED INTERROGATORY

RESPONSES (.2); REVISE LETTER REGARDING WITNESS

ADEQUACY OF BETH KELLERMANN (.5); DRAFT PLAINTIFFS'

STATEMENT IN RESPONSE TO COURT'S APRIL 4, 2018 MINUTE

ORDER (.2); FILE PROPOSED ORDER RESOLVING DISCOVERY

DISPUTE (.2); E-MAIL - J. MANNING, L. ROREM REGARDING

DISCOVERY HEARING (.2); TELEPHONE - K. POTTER REGARDING

IMAGING OF DEVICES (.3).

4/8/2018 SJ 360.00 1.00 360.00 Billable 482012 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE - K. POTTER REGARDING IMAGING OF DEVICES.

4/9/2018 SJ 360.00 3.30 1,188.00 Billable 482004 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT AMENDED INTERROGATORY RESPONSES FOR PLAINTIFFS

TO APPLE'S INTERROGATORIES (.5); DRAFT AMENDED 30(B)(6)

DEPOSITION NOTICE (.2); E-MAIL - J. MANNING REGARDING

APPLE'S DISCOVERY ISSUES REGARDING BLOG POSTS,

INTERROGATORY RESPONSES, REDACTIONS OF MESSAGES,

AND IDENTIFICATION OF DEVICES (1.8); REVIEW PLAINTIFFS'

DEVICE INFORMATION AND DISCOVERY RESPONSES (.8).

4/10/2018 SJ 360.00 3.20 1,152.00 Billable 482022 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSE TO APPLE'S THIRD SET OF

INTERROGATORIES (.8); CONFER WITH P. GRAVLEY REGARDING

DALLAS DE ATLEY HOT DOCUMENTS, AND REVIEW SAME (1.0);

TELEPHONE - K. POTTER REGARDING IMAGING OF DEVICES (.4);

REVIEW PLAINTIFFS' DEVICES (1.0). Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 42 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 41

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

4/11/2018 SJ 360.00 1.20 432.00 Billable 482021 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE - CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS (1.0);

CONFER WITH P. GRAVLEY REGARDING DALLAS DE ATLEY HOT

DOCUMENTS (.2).

4/12/2018 SJ 360.00 6.60 2,376.00 Billable 482003 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL - J. MANNING REGARDING APPLE'S DISCOVERY ISSUES

(.6); REVISE PLAINTIFFS AMENDED INTERROGATORY RESPONSES

(1.0); RESEARCH REGARDING PLAINTIFF'S DEVICES IN APPLE

SPREADSHEETS FOR CLASS MEMBERS (1.5); REVIEW K. POTTER

PRODUCTION AND BLOG POSTS (3.5).

4/16/2018 SJ 360.00 2.90 1,044.00 Billable 482001 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE - K. POTTER REGARDING IMAGING OF PHONE

DEVICES, DEPOSITION DATES (.4); CONFER WITH A. ZAKIMI

REGARDING IMAGING OF IPHONE DEVICES (.3); CALL WITH

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS (1.0); REVIEW APPLE

PRODUCTION FOR DOCUMENTS REGARDING PLAINTIFFS

ASCERTAINABILITY (1.2).

4/17/2018 SJ 360.00 4.60 1,656.00 Billable 481997 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT PRIVILEGE LOG FOR PLAINTIFFS' PRODUCTION (.5);

REVIEW DOCUMENTS FOR PRIVILEGE (3.0); REVISE PRIVILEGE

LOG (.5); TELEPHONE - K. POTTER REGARDING IMAGING OF

PHONES (.3); REVIEW T. GREENE E-MAIL REGARDING ESI AND

E-MAIL D. TEJTEL REGARDING SEARCH TERMS (.3).

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 43 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 42

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 4/18/2018 SJ 360.00 0.20 72.00 Billable 481986 DISCOVERY-A REVISE PLAINTIFFS' PRIVILEGE LOG.

4/21/2018 SJ 360.00 0.20 72.00 Billable 481982 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL - T. GREENE REGARDING PRIVILEGE LOG (.1); REVIEW

E-MAIL REGARDING OPEN DISCOVERY ISSUES (.1).

4/24/2018 SJ 360.00 3.20 1,152.00 Billable 481981 DISCOVERY-A CONFER WITH J. MANNING REGARDING CLASS CERTIFICATION

MOTION, K. POTTER DEVICES (.6); E-MAIL J. MANNING

REGARDING APPLE PLEADINGS (.1); E-MAIL J. MANNING

REGARDING JUDGE COUSINS DISCOVERY ORDER (.1); RESEARCH

REGARDING REDACTIONS OF PRODUCED DOCUMENTS (1.8);

REVIEW POTTER AND GRACE DECLARATIONS (.3); TELEPHONE -

K. POTTER REGARDING PHONE IMAGING (.3).

4/25/2018 SJ 360.00 4.10 1,476.00 Billable 481977 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL - J. MANNING REGARDING APPLE'S DECLARATION

REGARDING ESI PRESERVATION (.6); RESEARCH REGARDING

LETTER BRIEF REGARDING REDACTIONS AND BLOG POSTS (3.5).

4/26/2018 SJ 360.00 4.40 1,584.00 Billable 481991 DISCOVERY-A REVISE PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSES TO THIRD INTERROGATORIES

AND E-MAIL TO APPLE COUNSEL (.8); REVIEW APPLE

SPREADSHEETS REGARDING IPHONE 4 USERS (1.0); E-MAIL J.

MANNING REGARDING PLAINTIFFS' DEVICES (.1); TELEPHONE - K.

POTTER REGARDING CLASS CERTIFICATION DECLARATION (2.0);

REVIEW K. POTTER IPHONE FILE DIRECTORY (.5).

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 44 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 43

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 4/27/2018 SJ 360.00 7.50 2,700.00 Billable 481972 DISCOVERY-A CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS (1.8); E-MAIL

- K. POTTER REGARDING DEVICE DIRECTORY TREES (.2); E-MAIL -

D. AHN REGARDING AMAZON SUBPOENA (.2); REVISE PLAINTIFF

DECLARATIONS FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION (.3); E-MAIL A. SIMON

REGARDING NON-PARTY SUBPOENAS (.7); E-MAIL - J. MANNING

REGARDING LETTER BRIEF ON PLAINTIFFS REDACTIONS (.3);

REVISE K. POTTER DECLARATION (.2); DRAFT PLAINTIFFS'

STATEMENT FOR LETTER BRIEF REGARDING PLAINTIFFS

REDACTIONS (3.0); REVIEW DR. HASTINGS EXPERT REPORT (.8).

4/28/2018 SJ 360.00 3.90 1,404.00 Billable 481990 DISCOVERY-A REVISE JOINT LETTER BRIEF REGARDING PLAINTIFFS'

REDACTIONS TO PRODUCTION (1.2); REVIEW APPLE'S PRODUCED

DOCUMENTS RELATING TO KEN POTTER (2.5); E-MAIL KEN

POTTER AND CALL WITH KEN POTTER REGARDING

IDENTIFICATION DETAILS (.2).

4/29/2018 SJ 360.00 2.00 720.00 Billable 481989 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW DOCUMENTS RELATED TO KEN POTTER AND E-MAIL J.

MANNING REGARDING SAME (.5); REVIEW SEARCH TERMS USED

BY APPLE AND E-MAIL CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME (1.5).

4/30/2018 SJ 360.00 5.90 2,124.00 Billable 481996 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE WITH K. POTTER REGARDING PRODUCTION OF

IPHONE FILE DIRECTORY, CLASS CERTIFICATION DECLARATION

(1.0); CONFER WITH P. GRAVELY REGARDING CLASS

CERTIFICATION MOTION (.2); REVISE LETTER BRIEF REGARDING

REDACTIONS AND BLOG POSTS (.5); REVIEW PRIVILEGE STATUS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 45 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 44

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

FOR POTTER PRODUCTION (2.5); CONFER WITH J. MANNING

REGARDING LETTER BRIEF AND MOTION FOR CLASS

CERTIFICATION (.2); REVISE CLASS CERTIFICATION MOTION AND

REVIEW DE ATLEY DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPT FOR SAME (1.5).

5/1/2018 SJ 360.00 4.30 1,548.00 Billable 482909 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE WITH K. POTTER REGARDING REDACTIONS TO FILE

DIRECTORY TREES (1.5); REDACT DIRECTORY TREES WITH

REDACTIONS TO MEDIA FILES (1.0); REVIEW UNREDACTED TEXT

AND E-MAIL COMMUNICATIONS FOR PRODUCTION TO APPLE AND

E-MAIL P. GRAVELY REGARDING SAME (.5); REVISE CLASS

CERTIFICATION BRIEF (1.3).

5/2/2018 SJ 360.00 5.00 1,800.00 Billable 482866 DISCOVERY-A REVISE A. SIMON DECLARATION REGARDING THIRD PARTY

SUBPOENAS (.3); TELEPHONE CALL WITH K. POTTER REGARDING

PRODUCTION OF FILE DIRECTORY TREES (1.0); REVIEW FILE

DIRECTORY TREES FOR PRODUCTION TO APPLE (1.0); REVIEW

PRODUCTION OF UNREDACTED TEXT COMMUNICATIONS AND

E-MAILS, AND E-MAIL E. BUNTAIN REGARDING SAME (1.2);

REVIEW CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF AND EXPERT REPORT (1.5).

5/3/2018 SJ 360.00 10.80 3,888.00 Billable 482864 PLDS/MO-A REVISE CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF (4.5); DRAFT MOTION TO

FILE UNDER SEAL (1.5); REVIEW FIGURES FOR NUMEROSITY IN

CLASS CERTIFICATION (1.5); DRAFT MANUAL FILING

NOTIFICATIONS (1.3); REVIEW EXPERT REPORT (1.0); REVIEW

FILE TREES AND REDACTED SPREADSHEETS OF PLAINTIFFS' FILE Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 46 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 45

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt DIRECTORIES FOR IMAGED DEVICES (.5); CONFER WITH J.

MANNING REGARDING CLASS CERTIFICATION MOTION (.5).

5/4/2018 SJ 360.00 9.00 3,240.00 Billable 482860 PLDS/MO-A REVISE AND FILE MOTION FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION AND

SUPPORTING EXPERT REPORT, DECLARATIONS, EXHIBITS (8.5);

TELEPHONE AND E-MAIL - T. GREENE AND ANVITA P. REGARDING

REDACTION OF BLOG POSTS AND COMMUNICATIONS (.5).

5/8/2018 SJ 360.00 2.20 792.00 Billable 484316 DISCOVERY-A REVISE PLAINTIFFS' PRIVILEGE LOG (1.0); REVIEW DEVICE

IMAGING FILES REGARDING FACETIME AND WIFI USAGE, E-MAIL

REGARDING SAME WITH R. FISHMAN, J. MANNING, A. CURRY (1.2).

5/9/2018 SJ 360.00 2.20 792.00 Billable 484319 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS

(1.0); CONFER WITH P. GRAVLEY REGARDING RESEARCH ON

APPLE RELAY USAGE (.5); E-MAIL P. GRAVLEY REGARDING CLASS

REPRESENTATIVES'' DEPOSITIONS (.7).

5/10/2018 SJ 360.00 0.60 216.00 Billable 484311 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL CO-COUNSEL AND CONFER WITH J. MANNING REGARDING

PRODUCTION OF IMAGING DATA FROM PLAINTIFFS' DEVICES.

5/11/2018 SJ 360.00 1.50 540.00 Billable 484318 DISCOVERY-A REVISE PLAINTIFFS' AMENDED RESPONSE TO SECOND SET OF

INTERROGATORIES (1); E-MAIL REGARDING OBJECTION TO

DISCLOSURE OF IMAGING DATA (.5).

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 47 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 46

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 5/14/2018 SJ 360.00 0.80 288.00 Billable 484333 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW FACETIME CALL LOGS FOR KEN POTTER (.5); E-MAIL

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING REDACTIONS AND PRODUCTION OF

PLAINTIFFS' DATA (.3).

5/15/2018 SJ 360.00 0.30 108.00 Billable 484335 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT REDACTED FACETIME LOG FOR PRODUCTION TO APPLE

COUNSEL.

5/16/2018 SJ 360.00 0.70 252.00 Billable 484329 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL - APPLE REGARDING FACETIME LOGS (.2); TELEPHONE

CALL - K. POTTER REGARDING FACETIME LOG (.5).

5/17/2018 SJ 360.00 2.30 828.00 Billable 484338 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH K. POTTER REGARDING FACETIME LOG

(.5); DRAFT REDACTED FACETIME LOG FOR PRODUCTION TO

APPLE (.5); TELEPHONE CALL WITH V. GLAZE REGARDING HOT

DOCUMENT REVIEW (.5); E-MAIL - V. GLAZE, P. GRAVLEY

REGARDING HOT DOCUMENT REVIEW (.8).

5/18/2018 SJ 360.00 4.30 1,548.00 Billable 484332 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL - APPLE COUNSEL REGARDING FACETIME LOGS (.2);

REVIEW SDDF PROPOSAL REGARDING DEVICE IMAGING AND

E-MAIL CO-COUNSEL REGARDING SAME (.5); EDIT MEMO

REGARDING PROTECTIVE ORDER (.8); EDIT MEMO REGARDING

SEARCH TERM MISREPRESENTATION (.5); E-MAIL - P. GRAVLEY

REGARDING JURY INSTRUCTIONS (.2); REVIEW HOT DOCUMENTS

LOG (1.5); E-MAIL - P. GRAVLEY REGARDING UPCOMING TEAM

MEETING (.6). Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 48 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 47

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

5/21/2018 SJ 360.00 7.50 2,700.00 Billable 484339 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEETING WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STRATEGY, HOT

DOCUMENT REVIEW, CASE STATUS, AND PREPARATION

REGARDING SAME (6.5); REVISE LETTER BRIEF REGARDING

REDACTIONS AND BLOG POSTS (1.0).

5/22/2018 SJ 360.00 2.40 864.00 Billable 484345 DISCOVERY-A REVISE LETTER BRIEF REGARDING REDACTIONS AND BLOG

POSTS (.5); E-MAIL - P. GRAVLEY REGARDING K. POTTER

DEPOSITION (.8); RESEARCH REGARDING INTERROGATORY

VERIFICATIONS (.6); E-MAIL - APPLE REGARDING

INTERROGATORY VERIFICATIONS (.2); CONFER WITH B. KURLAND

REGARDING RESEARCH ON VERIFICATIONS (.3).

5/23/2018 SJ 360.00 2.50 900.00 Billable 484347 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW PRODUCED DOCUMENTS PER APPLE CLAWBACK (1.0);

CONFER WITH B. KURLAND REGARDING RESEARCH FOR ISSUE

ON SEARCH TERM MISREPRESENTATION (.2); REVIEW MEMO

REGARDING VERIFICATIONS (.5); TELEPHONE CALL WITH

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS (.5); CONFER WITH J.

MANNING REGARDING DEVICE IMAGING (.3).

5/24/2018 SJ 360.00 1.20 432.00 Billable 484349 DISCOVERY-A REVISE DRAFT BRIEF REGARDING REDACTIONS AND BLOG

POSTS (.7); REVIEW APPLE DOCUMENTS PER CLAWBACK (.5).

5/25/2018 SJ 360.00 2.40 864.00 Billable 484344 DISCOVERY-A RESEARCH REGARDING SEARCH TERM MISREPRESENTATION

(.6); FINISH REVIEW OF DOCUMENTS PER APPLE CLAWBACK (1.0); Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 49 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 48

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

REVIEW BRIEF REGARDING REDACTIONS AND BLOG POSTS (.3);

TEAM CALL REGARDING NON-PARTY DEPOSITIONS (.5).

5/28/2018 SJ 360.00 0.20 72.00 Billable 485106 DEP PREP-A TELEPHONE WITH K. POTTER REGARDING POTTER DEPOSITION.

5/29/2018 SJ 360.00 4.30 1,548.00 Billable 485168 DEP PREP-A REVIEW K. POTTER DOCUMENTS PRODUCED BY APPLE IN

PREPARATION FOR POTTER DEPOSITION AND E-MAIL J. MANNING

REGARDING SAME (2.8); REVIEW SETTINGS DATA FROM IMAGED

DEVICES (.5); CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING BRIGHTSTAR

SUBPOENA (1.0).

5/30/2018 SJ 360.00 3.00 1,080.00 Billable 485112 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW SETTINGS DATA FROM IMAGED DEVICES.

5/31/2018 SJ 360.00 7.20 2,592.00 Billable 485135 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL CO-COUNSEL REGARDING DEVICE IMAGING DISCOVERY

ISSUES AND CALL REGARDING SAME (1.2); REVIEW BRIEF

REGARDING DISCOVERY ISSUES PERTAINING TO REDACTIONS

AND PRODUCED MATERIALS IN PREPARATION FOR HEARING,

AND ATTEND HEARING (6.0).

6/1/2018 SJ 360.00 6.50 2,340.00 Billable 487270 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT DECLARATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO FILE UNDER

SEAL (4.0); REVIEW LETTER BRIEF AND E-MAILS REGARDING ESI

(.5); REVIEW OF SETTINGS DATA TO BE PRODUCED (2.0).

6/4/2018 SJ 360.00 7.50 2,700.00 Billable 487258 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW SETTING DATA DOCUMENTS TO BE PRODUCED FOR Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 50 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 49

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

PRIVACY OBJECTIONS (5.5); REVIEW LETTER BRIEF REGARDING

FILE LIST REDACTIONS AND CONFER WITH AND E-MAIL J.

MANNING AND A. CURRY REGARDING SAME (2.0).

6/5/2018 SJ 360.00 2.50 900.00 Billable 487259 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW SETTINGS DATA FOR OBJECTIONS TO PRODUCTION AND

E-MAIL APPLE, FORENSICS IMAGING CONSULTANTS REGARDING

SAME.

6/6/2018 SJ 360.00 2.00 720.00 Billable 487250 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW DIAGNOSTIC AND USAGE DATA FILES AND E-MAIL APPLE

REGARDING OBJECTION TO PRODUCTION (1.0); TELEPHONE CALL

WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS (1.0).

6/7/2018 SJ 360.00 2.00 720.00 Billable 487274 DEP PREP-A DEPOSITION PREPARATION WITH DR. HASTINGS, J. MANNING, D.

WARSHAW.

6/8/2018 SJ 360.00 3.10 1,116.00 Billable 487273 DEP TAKE/DEF-A DEPOSITION OF DR. HASTINGS (3.0); CONFER WITH J. LERNER

REGARDING REDACTIONS TO IMAGING DOCUMENTS (.1).

6/11/2018 SJ 360.00 1.80 648.00 Billable 487261 DISCOVERY-A REVISE PLAINTIFFS' FURTHER REVISED INTERROGATORY

RESPONSES TO APPLE'S SECOND SET OF INTERROGATORIES

(.8); E-MAIL - J. MANNING REGARDING ESI LETTER BRIEF (1.0).

6/13/2018 SJ 360.00 2.20 792.00 Billable 487239 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS (1.0);

REVIEW DR. HASTINGS DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPT AND E-MAIL Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 51 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 50

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING REFERENCE TO APPLE SALES DATA

(.7); E-MAIL - P. GRAVELY REGARDING DISCOVERY BRIEFS (.5).

6/14/2018 SJ 360.00 0.50 180.00 Billable 487241 DISCOVERY-A REVISE LETTER BRIEF REGARDING SECOND REQUEST FOR

PRODUCTIONS.

6/18/2018 SJ 360.00 3.00 1,080.00 Billable 487243 PLDS/MO-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING APPLE

OPPOSITION TO CLASS CERTIFICATION (1.0); REVIEW APPLE'S

OPPOSITION TO CLASS CERTIFICATION (2.0).

6/19/2018 SJ 360.00 5.00 1,800.00 Billable 487495 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW OPPOSITION TO CLASS CERTIFICATION AND BEGIN

PREPARING DECLARATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO SEAL

(2.0); REVIEW FOR REDACTION CELLEBRITE PRODUCTION OF

SETTINGS DATA (3.0).

6/20/2018 SJ 360.00 2.60 936.00 Billable 487480 PLDS/MO-A BEGIN DRAFTING DECLARATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO

SEAL APPLE'S OPPOSITION TO CLASS CERTIFICATION (2.5);

TELEPHONE CALL WITH S. MACRAE INJUNCTIVE RELIEF PORTION

OF REPLY REGARDING CLASS CERTIFICATION BRIEF (.1).

6/21/2018 SJ 360.00 3.00 1,080.00 Billable 487496 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH REGARDING SEALING OF PERSONAL INFORMATION

AND FINALIZE DECLARATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO SEAL

APPLE'S OPPOSITION TO CLASS CERTIFICATION.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 52 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 51

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 6/22/2018 SJ 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 487490 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW CELLEBRITE PRODUCTION OF SETTINGS DATA AND

E-MAIL COUNSEL, SDDF REGARDING REDACTIONS.

6/25/2018 SJ 360.00 1.20 432.00 Billable 487491 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL - M. DELANEY REGARDING APPLE'S OPPOSITION TO

CLASS CERTIFICATION (.2); TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING CASE STATUS AND REPLY REGARDING CLASS

CERTIFICATION (1.0).

6/28/2018 SJ 360.00 1.40 504.00 Billable 487492 RESEARCH-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CHOICE OF

LAW ANALYSIS FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION (.4); RESEARCH

REGARDING CERTIFICATION OF 23(B)(2) CLASS (1.0).

6/29/2018 SJ 360.00 2.50 900.00 Billable 487488 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH REGARDING CERTIFICATION OF RULE 23(B)(2) CLASS.

7/2/2018 SJ 360.00 6.20 2,232.00 Billable 490023 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT SECTION ON INJUNCTIVE RELIEF FOR CLASS

CERTIFICATION REPLY MOTION (3.0); TELEPHONE CALL WITH

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS AND CLASS

CERTIFICATION REPLY MOTION (.7); RESEARCH REGARDING

MOTION FOR CLARIFICATION AND DRAFT MOTION FOR

CLARIFICATION (2.5).

7/3/2018 SJ 360.00 3.90 1,404.00 Billable 490030 PLDS/MO-A REVISE MOTION FOR CLARIFICATION (1.2); RESEARCH ON

INJUNCTIVE RELIEF HYBRID CLASS AND REVISE SAME SECTION

IN CLASS CERTIFICATION REPLY (2.5); DRAFT PROPOSED ORDER Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 53 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 52

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

FOR MOTION FOR CLARIFICATION (.2).

7/5/2018 SJ 360.00 1.50 540.00 Billable 490050 PLDS/MO-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING MOTION TO

STRIKE (.5); REVIEW DRAFT FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION REPLY

AND DRAFT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT (1.0).

7/6/2018 SJ 360.00 3.50 1,260.00 Billable 490032 PLDS/MO-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING TREXLER

DEPOSITION (.5); RESEARCH REGARDING INJUNCTIVE RELIEF

HYBRID CLASS AND REVISE CLASS CERTIFICATION REPLY BRIEF

(2.0); REVIEW APPLE PRODUCTION ON AT&T AND BEST BUY

ANALYSIS (1.0).

7/9/2018 SJ 360.00 2.30 828.00 Billable 490039 PLDS/MO-A REVISE CLASS CERTIFICATION REPLY BRIEF (1.5); TELEPHONE

CALL WITH S. MACRAE REGARDING INJUNCTIVE RELIEF

ARGUMENT (.2); REVIEW MOTION TO STRIKE DECLARATION OF

AVI RUBIN (.6).

7/10/2018 SJ 360.00 4.00 1,440.00 Billable 490052 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH REGARDING IPHONE CARRIER MARKET SHARE (2.0);

DRAFT EXHIBITS TO J. MANNING DECLARATION IN SUPPORT OF

CLASS CERTIFICATION REPLY BRIEF (1.0); REVIEW AND REVISE

MOTION TO STRIKE AVI RUBIN (.5); E-MAIL CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING TREXLER DEPOSITION (.5).

7/11/2018 SJ 360.00 5.70 2,052.00 Billable 490040 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 54 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 53

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt REPLY BRIEF, PROPOSED ORDER TO STRIKE DECLARATION OF

AVI RUBIN, DECLARATION OF J. MANNING IN SUPPORT OF CLASS

CERTIFICATION REPLY (5.0); REVISE AND FILE JOINT CASE

MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT (.7).

7/12/2018 SJ 360.00 7.00 2,520.00 Billable 490059 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH REGARDING MOTION TO SHORTEN TIME (1.0); DRAFT

MOTION TO SHORTEN TIME (4.0); E-MAIL - J. MANNING

REGARDING EXHIBITS TO CLASS CERTIFICATION REPLY BRIEF

(.5); REVISE MOTION TO STRIKE (1.5).

7/13/2018 SJ 360.00 13.00 4,680.00 Billable 490024 PLDS/MO-A REVISE CLASS CERTIFICATION REPLY AND EXHIBITS AND FILE

BRIEF (7.0); REVISE AND REVIEW MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL,

MOTION TO STRIKE, MOTION TO SHORTEN TIME (3.5); DRAFT

REDACTED VERSIONS OF CLASS CERTIFICATION REPLY (2.5).

7/16/2018 SJ 360.00 4.40 1,584.00 Billable 490035 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW SDDF PRODUCTION REGARDING DATA AND SETTINGS

INFORMATION ON GRACE DEVICE (1.2); TELEPHONE CALL WITH T.

GREENE REGARDING REVIEW OF SDDF PRODUCTION (.2); DRAFT

COPIES OF FILED CONFIDENTIAL MATERIALS AND E-MAIL

NON-PARTIES REGARDING SAME (3.0).

7/17/2018 SJ 360.00 2.50 900.00 Billable 490026 PLDS/MO-A E-MAIL AND CALL WITH P. PHILLIPS REGARDING SEALING AT&T

MATERIAL (.8); EDIT MOTION TO STRIKE DECLARATION OF AVI

RUBIN (1.0); E-MAIL AKAMAI REGARDING SEALING FILED

MATERIALS (.5); E-MAIL J. LERNER REGARDING REVIEW OF SDDF Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 55 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 54

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt PRODUCTION (.2).

7/18/2018 SJ 360.00 2.80 1,008.00 Billable 490047 PLDS/MO-A E-MAIL W. BORNSTEIN REGARDING SEALING OF BEST BUY FILED

MATERIALS (.8); REVIEW SDDF03 PRODUCTION REGARDING DATA

AND SETTINGS TABS (2.0).

7/19/2018 SJ 360.00 3.00 1,080.00 Billable 490027 PLDS/MO-A REVISE MOTION TO STRIKE DECLARATION OF AVI RUBIN, DRAFT

DECLARATION REGARDING SAME, DRAFT MOTION TO FILE

UNDER SEAL REGARDING SAME, REVISE MOTION TO SHORTEN

TIME REGARDING SAME.

7/20/2018 SJ 360.00 6.00 2,160.00 Billable 490056 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW SDDF03 PRODUCTION REGARDING DATA AND SETTINGS

TABS.

7/21/2018 SJ 360.00 7.00 2,520.00 Billable 490036 DOC REVIEW-A DOCUMENT REVIEW OF SDDF03 DATA AND SETTINGS TABS.

7/22/2018 SJ 360.00 7.00 2,520.00 Billable 490019 DOC REVIEW-A DOCUMENT REVIEW OF SDDF03 DATA AND SETTINGS TABS.

7/23/2018 SJ 360.00 1.00 360.00 Billable 490038 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS.

7/24/2018 SJ 360.00 0.70 252.00 Billable 490057 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL P. GRAVLEY REGARDING CLASS CERTIFICATION HEARING

(.5); E-MAIL - D. AHN REGARDING PRODUCTION OF AMAZON DATA

(.2).

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 56 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 55

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 7/25/2018 SJ 360.00 3.00 1,080.00 Billable 490065 DOC REVIEW-A FINISH DOCUMENT REVIEW OF SDDF03 DATA AND SETTINGS

PRODUCTION.

7/31/2018 SJ 360.00 2.40 864.00 Billable 490071 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH AMAZON REGARDING PRODUCTION OF

RESALE DATA (.5); REVIEW E-MAIL REGARDING AKAMAI

PRODUCTION (.1); TELEPHONE CALL WITH A. SIMON REGARDING

AMAZON PRODUCTION (.1); MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE

REGARDING DISCOVERY ISSUES (1.5); REVIEW SUBPOENA TO

AMAZON (.2).

8/1/2018 SJ 360.00 0.40 144.00 Billable 492018 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH J. HASTINGS, A. SIMON REGARDING DATA

FOR DAMAGES MODEL

8/2/2018 SJ 360.00 6.20 2,232.00 Billable 492006 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW HOT DOCUMENTS, DISCOVERY, AND CASE STATUS (4.5);

DRAFT RESPONSES TO APPLE'S INTERROGATORIES AND

REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION (1.5); E-MAIL AMAZON REGARDING

SUBPOENA (.2).

8/3/2018 SJ 360.00 0.20 72.00 Billable 492021 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL - J. MANNING REGARDING SDDF PRODUCTION.

8/6/2018 SJ 360.00 0.80 288.00 Billable 492030 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL - J. MANNING, A. CURRY, W. MCCARTY REGARDING

MOTION TO STRIKE AND MOTION TO SEAL MOTION TO STRIKE

(.2); REVISE PLAINTIFFS' INTERROGATORIES AND REQUESTS FOR

ADMISSION (.4); E-MAIL - SDDF, J. LERNER REGARDING Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 57 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 56

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

PRODUCTION OF SDDF DOCUMENTS (.2).

8/7/2018 SJ 360.00 1.00 360.00 Billable 492022 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL - P. GRAVELY REGARDING HOT DOCUMENTS AND

REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION RESPONSES (.5); TELEPHONE CALL

WITH J. MANNING, DOCUMENT REVIEW TEAM REGARDING CASE

STATUS (.5).

8/8/2018 SJ 360.00 2.00 720.00 Billable 492034 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL - P. GRAVELY REGARDING PLAINTIFFS' REQUESTS FOR

ADMISSION (.2); REVISE AND FINALIZE PLAINTIFFS'

INTERROGATORIES, REQUEST FOR PRODUCTIONS, AND

REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION TO APPLE (1.0); E-MAIL - J. LERNER

REGARDING SDDF PRODUCTION (.2); DRAFT RESPONSES TO

APPLE REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION AND INTERROGATORIES (1.5).

8/9/2018 SJ 360.00 7.70 2,772.00 Billable 492175 DISCOVERY-A REVISE AND FINALIZE PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSES TO

INTERROGATORIES AND REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION (5.0);

REDACT SDDF PRODUCTION (2.0); DRAFT MOTION TO FILE

UNDER SEAL PLAINTIFFS' REPLY TO MOTION TO STRIKE (.7).

8/10/2018 SJ 360.00 3.00 1,080.00 Billable 492172 DISCOVERY-A DRAFT PLAINTIFFS' SECOND PRIVILEGE LOG (1.5); REDACT SDDF

PRODUCTION (1.5).

8/13/2018 SJ 360.00 2.00 720.00 Billable 492203 DISCOVERY-A TELEPHONE MEET AND CONFER WITH APPLE REGARDING

DISCOVERY ISSUES (1.0); REVISE PLAINTIFFS' DISCOVERY Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 58 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 57

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt RESPONSES (1.0).

8/14/2018 SJ 360.00 1.00 360.00 Billable 492185 DISCOVERY-A REVISE JOINT DISCOVERY LETTER BRIEF (.5); DRAFT MOTION TO

FILE UNDER SEAL (.5).

8/16/2018 SJ 360.00 1.00 360.00 Billable 492211 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL JOINT LETTER BRIEF (.8);

REVIEW JOINT LETTER BRIEF (.2).

8/17/2018 SJ 360.00 1.40 504.00 Billable 492217 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL J. MANNING REGARDING POTTER TESTIMONY ON

FACETIME BREAK (1.2); E-MAIL - A. SIMON, M. DELANEY

REGARDING THIRD PARTY SUBPOENAS (.2).

8/20/2018 SJ 360.00 2.80 1,008.00 Billable 492194 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL - M. DELANEY REGARDING DISCOVERY BRIEF EXHIBITS

(.5); RESEARCH REGARDING KEN POTTER TESTIMONY ON IOS 7

PERFORMANCE (2.0); REVIEW PLAINTIFFS' AMENDED RESPONSE

TO APPLE'S THIRD SET OF INTERROGATORIES (.3).

8/21/2018 SJ 360.00 0.30 108.00 Billable 492193 DISCOVERY-A REVISE PLAINTIFFS' AMENDED INTERROGATORY RESPONSES.

8/23/2018 SJ 360.00 1.20 432.00 Billable 492170 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW APPLE PRODUCTION REGARDING CLASS MEMBERS (.3);

E-MAIL - J. MANNING REGARDING DOCUMENTS RELATED TO

ASCERTAINABILITY OF CLASS MEMBERS (.2); RESEARCH

REGARDING CLASS MEMBERS (.7).

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 59 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 58

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 8/27/2018 SJ 360.00 1.00 360.00 Billable 492411 EXPERTS-A REVIEW HASTINGS EXPERT REPORT.

8/28/2018 SJ 360.00 4.00 1,440.00 Billable 492412 EXPERTS-A REVISE HASTINGS EXPERT REPORT (2.0); E-MAIL EXPERT,

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING EXHIBITS TO EXPERT REPORT (.5);

REVIEW SDDF DOCUMENT PRODUCTION (1.5).

8/29/2018 SJ 360.00 0.50 180.00 Billable 492537 EXPERTS-A REVISE HASTINGS EXPERT REPORT.

8/30/2018 SJ 360.00 4.00 1,440.00 Billable 492487 DOC REVIEW-A REVIEW SDDF PRODUCTION OF SETTINGS DATA.

9/1/2018 SJ 360.00 4.00 1,440.00 Billable 495235 DOC REVIEW-A DOCUMENT REVIEW OF SETTINGS TAB FILES OF PLAINTIFFS'

DEVICES.

9/2/2018 SJ 360.00 7.00 2,520.00 Billable 495321 DOC REVIEW-A DOCUMENT REVIEW OF SETTINGS TAB FILES OF PLAINTIFFS'

DEVICES.

9/3/2018 SJ 360.00 4.00 1,440.00 Billable 495322 DOC REVIEW-A DOCUMENT REVIEW OF SETTINGS TAB FILES OF PLAINTIFFS'

DEVICES.

9/4/2018 SJ 360.00 4.10 1,476.00 Billable 495323 DOC REVIEW-A E-MAIL - P. GRAVELY REGARDING PLAINTIFFS' DISCOVERY

RESPONSES AND DOCUMENT PRODUCTION (.3); REVISE DRAFT

STIPULATION REGARDING CLASS MEMBER IDENTIFICATION (.6);

E-MAIL CO-COUNSEL REGARDING APPLE PRODUCTION (.2); Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 60 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 59

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

DOCUMENT REVIEW OF SETTINGS TAB FILES OF PLAINTIFFS'

DEVICES (3.0).

9/5/2018 SJ 360.00 8.30 2,988.00 Billable 495182 DOC REVIEW-A E-MAIL - J. MANNING REGARDING CASE STATUS (.1); DRAFT

RESPONSES TO REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION 23 AND

INTERROGATORIES 14-15 (3.0); CONFER WITH J. MANNING

REGARDING RESPONSE TO REQUESTS FOR AUTHENTICATION

(.2); COMPLETE DOCUMENT REVIEW OF SETTINGS TAB FILES OF

PLAINTIFFS' DEVICES (3.5); REVIEW PLAINTIFFS'

INTERROGATORY AND REQUESTS FOR ADMISSION RESPONSES

(.5); TELEPHONE CALL REGARDING CASE STATUS WITH

CO-COUNSEL (1.0).

9/6/2018 SJ 360.00 0.80 288.00 Billable 495324 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL - J. MANNING REGARDING AUTHENTICATION OF

PLAINTIFFS' DOCUMENTS.

9/7/2018 SJ 360.00 0.60 216.00 Billable 495244 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL CLASS REPRESENTATIVES REGARDING DISCOVERY

RESPONSES.

9/10/2018 SJ 360.00 0.50 180.00 Billable 495327 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL - P. GRAVELY REGARDING VERIFICATIONS OF DISCOVERY

RESPONSES.

9/11/2018 SJ 360.00 6.50 2,340.00 Billable 495184 DOC REVIEW-A E-MAIL - J. MANNING REGARDING SDDF PRODUCTION (.5);

DOCUMENT REVIEW OF SDDF PRODUCTION OF CRASH LOGS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 61 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 60

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt (6.0).

9/12/2018 SJ 360.00 8.20 2,952.00 Billable 495329 DOC REVIEW-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH COUNSEL FOR APPLE REGARDING

PLAINTIFFS' OBJECTIONS TO SDDF PRODUCTION (1.0); REVIEW

SDDF PRODUCTION IN PREPARATION FOR MEET AND CONFER

(1.2); TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE

STATUS (1.0); DOCUMENT REVIEW OF SDDF PRODUCTION OF

CRASH LOGS (5.0).

9/13/2018 SJ 360.00 7.00 2,520.00 Billable 495245 DISCOVERY-A DOCUMENT REVIEW OF SDDF PRODUCTION OF CRASH LOGS

(3.0); DRAFT BRIEF REGARDING AUTHENTICATION, APPLE'S

DISCOVERY RESPONSES (3.5); REVISE BRIEF REGARDING

AUTHENTICATION AND APPLE'S DISCOVERY RESPONSES (.5).

9/18/2018 SJ 360.00 2.70 972.00 Billable 495186 ATTYMTG.STR - A REVIEW ORDER REGARDING CLASS CERTIFICATION (1.0);

REVIEW ORDER REGARDING SEALING (.7); TELEPHONE CALL

WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS AND CLASS

CERTIFICATION ORDER (1.0).

9/19/2018 SJ 360.00 0.40 144.00 Billable 495247 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFER WITH J. MANNING REGARDING SDDF PRODUCTION (.2);

E-MAIL J. MANNING REGARDING FORENSIC IMAGING LETTER

BRIEF (.2).

9/24/2018 SJ 360.00 1.30 468.00 Billable 495190 EXPERTS-A REVIEW MALHOTRA EXPERT REPORT AND MATERIALS

CONSIDERED. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 62 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 61

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

9/25/2018 SJ 360.00 2.50 900.00 Billable 495191 EXPERTS-A REVIEW MALHOTRA EXPERT REPORT AND MATERIALS

CONSIDERED.

9/28/2018 SJ 360.00 1.00 360.00 Billable 495197 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL CO-COUNSEL REGARDING ECOATM SUBPOENA.

10/1/2018 SJ 360.00 0.30 108.00 Billable 497980 DISCOVERY-A REVIEW PLAINTIFFS' DISCOVERY RESPONSES.

10/2/2018 SJ 360.00 6.00 2,160.00 Billable 497988 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT NOTICE OF MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION AND

PROPOSED ORDERS FOR MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE A SECOND

AMENDED COMPLAINT, MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION, AND

MOTION TO AMEND CLASS (2.5); CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION (1.0); REVISE

MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION (2.5).

10/3/2018 SJ 360.00 5.60 2,016.00 Billable 497995 DISCOVERY-A REVISED PLAINTIFFS' DISCOVERY RESPONSES (4.5); CONFER

WITH P. GRAVELY REGARDING DISCOVERY RESPONSES (.2);

CALL WITH J. MANNING REGARDING PLAINTIFFS' DISCOVERY

RESPONSES (.2); REVIEW PLAINTIFF'S DISCOVERY RESPONSES

AND VERIFICATIONS OF INTERROGATORIES AND REQUESTS FOR

ADMISSION RESPONSES (.7).

10/4/2018 SJ 360.00 2.20 792.00 Billable 497997 DISCOVERY-A REVISE PLAINTIFFS' DISCOVERY RESPONSES AND

VERIFICATIONS OF INTERROGATORIES (2.0); E-MAIL - S. ELKIND Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 63 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 62

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

REGARDING SDDF PRODUCTION (.2).

10/5/2018 SJ 360.00 1.00 360.00 Billable 497999 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT.

10/11/2018 SJ 360.00 0.60 216.00 Billable 498546 RESEARCH-A REVIEW RESEARCH ON STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS.

10/12/2018 SJ 360.00 3.50 1,260.00 Billable 498566 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND DRAFT

OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT.

10/15/2018 SJ 360.00 2.30 828.00 Billable 498541 PLDS/MO-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS

(.7); REVISE DRAFT JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT (1.0);

REVIEW REVISED DRAFT OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY

JUDGMENT (.6).

10/16/2018 SJ 360.00 2.40 864.00 Billable 498543 PLDS/MO-A CONFER WITH P. GRAVELY REGARDING OPPOSITION TO MOTION

FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT (.2); REVIEW SDDF PRODUCTION

DOCUMENTS PROVIDED TO APPLE (1.0); E-MAIL W. MCCARTY

REGARDING SEALING FOR OPPOSITION TO SUMMARY JUDGMENT

(.2); RESEARCH REGARDING DAMAGES FOR OPPOSITION TO

MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT (1.0).

10/17/2018 SJ 360.00 2.90 1,044.00 Billable 498542 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL COUNSEL FOR APPLE REGARDING SDDF PRODUCTION

(.4); REVIEW SDDF PRODUCTION DOCUMENTS PROVIDED TO

APPLE (1.0); REVISE JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 64 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 63

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

STATEMENT (2.5).

10/18/2018 SJ 360.00 10.10 3,636.00 Billable 498544 PLDS/MO-A REVISE MOTION IN OPPOSITION TO SUMMARY JUDGMENT (3.0);

DRAFT REDACTED OPPOSITION TO SUMMARY JUDGMENT (4.0);

REVIEW SEALING ORDERS RELATED TO EXHIBITS IN OPPOSITION

TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT (1.5); DRAFT

DECLARATION IN SUPPORT OF OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR

SUMMARY JUDGMENT (.4); REVISE MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL

AND DECLARATIONS IN SUPPORT THEREOF (.7); CONFER WITH P.

GRAVELY REGARDING PRODUCTION OF SDDF DOCUMENTS (.5).

10/19/2018 SJ 360.00 0.40 144.00 Billable 498558 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT PROPOSED ORDER FOR MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL

(.2); DRAFT PROPOSED REDACTIONS FOR AKAMAI TO

OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL (.2).

10/24/2018 SJ 360.00 2.40 864.00 Billable 498547 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS

(1.0); E-MAIL - P. GRAVELY REGARDING EXHIBITS FOR MEDIATION

(.4); REVIEW EXHIBITS FOR USE IN MEDIATION (1.0).

10/25/2018 SJ 360.00 1.00 360.00 Billable 498550 PLDS/MO-A TELEPHONE CALL REGARDING 23(F) PETITION (.5); REVIEW

DRAFT 23(F) PETITION OUTLINE (.5).

10/31/2018 SJ 360.00 1.00 360.00 Billable 498555 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 65 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 64

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 11/1/2018 SJ 360.00 1.30 468.00 Billable 500157 PLDS/MO-A TELEPHONE CALL REGARDING 23(F) PETITION (.5); REVIEW

DRAFT 23(F) PETITION (.8).

11/2/2018 SJ 360.00 6.00 2,160.00 Billable 500158 PLDS/MO-A REVISE 23(F) PETITION TO APPEAL.

11/5/2018 SJ 360.00 6.20 2,232.00 Billable 500159 PLDS/MO-A REVISE 23(F) PETITION TO APPEAL (6.0); E-MAIL P. GRAVELY

REGARDING MEDIATION STATEMENT (.2).

11/6/2018 SJ 360.00 2.80 1,008.00 Billable 500161 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING MEDIATION.

11/6/2018 SJ 360.00 1.50 540.00 Billable 500401 PLDS/MO-A FILE ORDERS SUPPLEMENTING 23(F) PETITION.

11/7/2018 SJ 360.00 2.00 720.00 Billable 500125 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT LETTER TO COURT REGARDING ORDERS TO REVIEW FOR

23(F) APPEAL.

11/14/2018 SJ 360.00 0.20 72.00 Billable 500169 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL - SDDF REGARDING DEVICE IMAGING.

12/7/2018 SJ 360.00 3.00 1,080.00 Billable 502805 PLDS/MO-A REVISE AND REVIEW REPLY BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF 23(F)

PETITION AND QUALCOMM 23(F) REPLY PETITION.

12/10/2018 SJ 360.00 1.50 540.00 Billable 502817 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW FINALIZED 23(F) REPLY PETITION.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 66 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 65

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 3/5/2019 SJ 390.00 0.20 78.00 Billable 509473 DISCOVERY-A E-MAIL - J. MANNING REGARDING APEX WITNESS DISCOVERY

BRIEF.

3/19/2019 SJ 390.00 0.30 117.00 Billable 509593 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL - J. MANNING REGARDING 23(F) PETITION.

3/20/2019 SJ 390.00 1.50 585.00 Billable 509594 PLDS/MO-A CONFER WITH J. MANNING REGARDING ORDER ON 23(F)

PETITION; DRAFT JOINT STATEMENT TO COURT REGARDING

23(F) PETITION; REVIEW SUMMARY JUDGMENT MOTION.

3/22/2019 SJ 390.00 0.70 273.00 Billable 509645 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS.

3/25/2019 SJ 390.00 0.40 156.00 Billable 509621 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL - J. MANNING REGARDING CLASS NOTICE.

3/28/2019 SJ 390.00 0.60 234.00 Billable 509646 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS.

4/10/2019 SJ 390.00 0.50 195.00 Billable 512062 ATTYMTG.STR - A CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS.

4/24/2019 SJ 390.00 1.30 507.00 Billable 512108 PLDS/MO-A REVISE JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT.

4/29/2019 SJ 390.00 0.70 273.00 Billable 512120 ATTYMTG.STR - A CONFER WITH A. STEYER REGARDING TRIAL SCHEDULE (.5);

CONFER WITH J. MANNING REGARDING TRIAL SCHEDULE (.1);

CONFER WITH D. WARSHAW REGARDING TRIAL SCHEDULE (.1). Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 67 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 66

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

5/15/2019 SJ 390.00 0.50 195.00 Billable 514365 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS.

5/24/2019 SJ 390.00 2.50 975.00 Billable 514574 RESEARCH-A REVIEW FINDINGS OF FACT IN QUALCOMM.

6/6/2019 SJ 390.00 0.30 117.00 Billable 517338 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW HYUNDAI OPINION REGARDING NATIONWIDE

SETTLEMENT CLASS.

7/18/2019 SJ 390.00 1.70 663.00 Billable 520699 PLDS/MO-A CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING MOTION FOR SUMMARY

JUDGMENT HEARING (.5); REVIEW MOTION FOR SUMMARY

JUDGMENT BRIEFING (.7); CALL WITH K. POTTER REGARDING

CASE STATUS (.5).

7/31/2019 SJ 390.00 0.50 195.00 Billable 521210 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH REGARDING STATEMENT OF SUPPLEMENTAL

AUTHORITY.

8/21/2019 SJ 390.00 1.50 585.00 Billable 523329 PLDS/MO-A E-MAIL - J. MANNING REGARDING CASE MANAGEMENT

CONFERENCE STATEMENT; REVIEW ORDER DENYING MOTION

FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT.

8/22/2019 SJ 390.00 2.50 975.00 Billable 523330 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW ORDER REGARDING SEALING OF MOTION FOR

SUMMARY JUDGMENT PAPERS; REVISE MOTION FOR SUMMARY

JUDGMENT PLEADINGS IN ACCORDANCE WITH SEALING ORDER;

CONFER WITH A. STEYER, J. MANNING REGARDING MOTION FOR Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 68 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 67

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

SUMMARY JUDGMENT ORDER.

8/27/2019 SJ 390.00 0.70 273.00 Billable 523946 PLDS/MO-A FILE NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ADDRESS; REVISE JOINT CASE

MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENT.

8/28/2019 SJ 390.00 1.50 585.00 Billable 523948 PLDS/MO-A REVISE MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT PLEADINGS IN

ACCORDANCE WITH ORDER ON SEALING.

9/18/2019 SJ 390.00 2.70 1,053.00 Billable 526970 SETTLE-A REVIEW EXHIBITS FOR MEDIATION; CONFER WITH A. STEYER

REGARDING EXHIBITS FOR MEDIATION.

9/19/2019 SJ 390.00 0.40 156.00 Billable 526988 SETTLE-A CONFER WITH A. STEYER REGARDING EXHIBITS FOR MEDIATION.

9/20/2019 SJ 390.00 0.20 78.00 Billable 526990 SETTLE-A E-MAIL - J. MANNING REGARDING EXHIBITS FOR MEDIATION.

9/24/2019 SJ 390.00 0.80 312.00 Billable 526994 SETTLE-A REVIEW DRAFT MEDIATION STATEMENT; REVISE EXCERPTED

EXHIBITS FOR JUDGE CAHILL.

10/16/2019 SJ 390.00 0.50 195.00 Billable 528341 SETTLE-A E-MAIL - J. MANNING REGARDING MEDIATION STATEMENT.

10/24/2019 SJ 390.00 0.40 156.00 Billable 528320 SETTLE-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH J. MANNING REGARDING POTENTIAL

SETTLEMENT.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 69 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 68

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 10/30/2019 SJ 390.00 0.30 117.00 Billable 528519 SETTLE-A CONFER WITH J. MANNING REGARDING SETTLEMENT.

11/13/2019 SJ 390.00 1.00 390.00 Billable 530593 ATTYMTG.STR - A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING CASE STATUS.

12/2/2019 SJ 390.00 0.50 195.00 Billable 532701 ATTYMTG.STR - A E-MAIL J. MANNING REGARDING INITIAL DISCLOSURES.

12/9/2019 SJ 390.00 1.20 468.00 Billable 532714 TRIAL PREP-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING TRIAL

PREPARATION; E-MAIL M. DELANEY REGARDING EXPERT

REPORTS.

12/11/2019 SJ 390.00 0.50 195.00 Billable 532721 TRIAL PREP-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING TRIAL

PREPARATION.

12/13/2019 SJ 390.00 2.30 897.00 Billable 532733 TRIAL PREP-A REVIEW EXHIBITS IN PREPARATION FOR TRIAL; REVISE JURY

INSTRUCTIONS; REVISE PROPOSED VERDICT FORM; REVISE

PROPOSED VOIR DIRE; REVISE EXHIBIT LIST.

12/16/2019 SJ 390.00 2.50 975.00 Billable 532891 TRIAL PREP-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING JOINT

PRE-TRIAL STATEMENT; REVIEW PRE-TRIAL STATEMENT AND

EXHIBITS FOR SEALING; REVISE EXHIBIT LIST AND EXHIBITS TO

JOINT PRE-TRIAL STATEMENT.

12/23/2019 SJ 390.00 0.50 195.00 Billable 532881 TRIAL PREP-A E-MAIL - M. TERRY, J. CASSADY REGARDING PRE-TRIAL Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 70 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 69

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

CONFERENCE.

12/27/2019 SJ 390.00 6.80 2,652.00 Billable 532882 PLDS/MO-A REVIEW OPPOSITION TO DAUBERT MOTION AND EXHIBITS FOR

SEALING; DRAFT MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL OPPOSITION TO

DAUBERT MOTION; E-MAIL CO-COUNSEL REGARDING EXHIBITS

TO OPPOSITION TO DAUBERT MOTION; E-MAIL J. LERNER

REGARDING SEALING OF OPPOSITION TO DAUBERT MOTION;

TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING OPPOSITION

TO DAUBERT MOTION; MEET AND CONFER CALL WITH JOSH

LERNER, D. WARSHAW REGARDING SEALING OF OPPOSITION TO

DAUBERT MOTION; REVISE OPPOSITION TO DAUBERT MOTION;

REVISE MOTION TO SEAL AND DRAFT REDACTED VERSIONS OF

OPPOSITION TO DAUBERT MOTION.

12/28/2019 SJ 390.00 2.80 1,092.00 Billable 532958 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH REGARDING IMPACT OF LATE FILING; DRAFT

STIPULATION REGARDING EXTENSION OF TIME FOR DAUBERT

OPPOSITION.

12/29/2019 SJ 390.00 1.50 585.00 Billable 532883 PLDS/MO-A REVISE STIPULATION AND DECLARATION REGARDING

EXTENSION OF TIME FOR DAUBERT OPPOSITION.

12/30/2019 SJ 390.00 0.80 312.00 Billable 532960 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT CORRECTED DECLARATION TO DAUBERT OPPOSITION;

CONFER WITH A. STEYER REGARDING OPPOSITION TO DAUBERT

MOTION, PRE-TRIAL BRIEFING.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 71 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 70

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 1/2/2020 SJ 440.00 3.30 1,452.00 Billable 536301 TRIAL PREP-A E-MAIL - S. PHUONG REGARDING TRIAL PREPARATION; DRAFT

ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION FOR RELIEF FOR LATE FILING; REVISE

ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION FOR RELIEF FOR LATE FILING; DRAFT

PROPOSED ORDER AND EXHIBITS FOR ADMINISTRATIVE MOTION

FOR LATE FILING.

1/3/2020 SJ 440.00 4.50 1,980.00 Billable 536323 TRIAL PREP-A REVIEW PROPOSED MATERIALS TO BE SEALED FOR APPLE

DAUBERT REPLY; DRAFT REDACTED EXHIBITS FOR NON-PARTY

REVIEW OF SEALING; TELEPHONE CALL WITH V. WEATHERFORD,

J. LERNER REGARDING SEALING OF APPLE REPLY TO ITS

DAUBERT MOTION; TELEPHONE CALL WITH V. WEATHERFORD, J.

LERNER REGARDING SEALING OF APPLE REPLY TO ITS DAUBERT

MOTION; E-MAIL COUNSEL FOR BEST BUY, ECOATM, AT&T

REGARDING SEALING OF INFORMATION IN APPLE REPLY TO

DAUBERT MOTION; TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING TRIAL PREPARATION; TELEPHONE CALL WITH AT&T

COUNSEL REGARDING SEALING INFORMATION IN APPLE

DAUBERT REPLY; REVIEW ORDER REGARDING SEALING

PROTOCOL; DRAFT DECLARATION IN SUPPORT OF SEALING

APPLE DAUBERT REPLY.

1/6/2020 SJ 440.00 1.00 440.00 Billable 536304 TRIAL PREP-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING TRIAL

PREPARATION; E-MAIL - V. WEATHERFORD REGARDING AT&T

DECLARATION IN SUPPORT OF SEALING APPLE DAUBERT REPLY.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 72 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 71

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 1/9/2020 SJ 440.00 0.40 176.00 Billable 536327 PLDS/MO-A E-MAIL - M. TERRY REGARDING DAUBERT BRIEFING; E-MAIL - A.

SIMON REGARDING OPPOSITION TO APPLE'S DAUBERT MOTION.

1/17/2020 SJ 440.00 0.20 88.00 Billable 536310 CASEMNG-A E-MAIL - M. TERRY REGARDING PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE.

1/21/2020 SJ 440.00 0.30 132.00 Billable 536318 TRIAL PREP-A E-MAIL - M. DELANEY REGARDING PLAINTIFFS' EXHIBIT LIST.

1/22/2020 SJ 440.00 0.80 352.00 Billable 536342 TRIAL PREP-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING TRIAL

PREPARATION.

1/23/2020 SJ 440.00 1.50 660.00 Billable 536313 TRIAL PREP-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH A. CURRY REGARDING SEALING OF

WITNESS PROFFER; DRAFT MOTION TO SEAL AND DECLARATION

IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO SEAL WITNESS PROFFER; REVIEW

EXHIBITS TO WITNESS PROFFER FOR SEALING; TELEPHONE

CALL WITH A. CURRY REGARDING SEALING OF WITNESS

PROFFER.

1/24/2020 SJ 440.00 1.60 704.00 Billable 536315 TRIAL PREP-A E-MAIL COUNSEL FOR AKAMAI REGARDING PROPOSED SEALING

OF WITNESS PROFFER; REVISE MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL;

E-MAIL - E. NOVIKOV REGARDING SEALING OF WITNESS

PROFFER; DRAFT REDACTED WITNESS PROFFER; TELEPHONE

CALL WITH A. CURRY REGARDING WITNESS PROFFER FILING.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 73 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 72

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 1/27/2020 SJ 440.00 1.50 660.00 Billable 536344 TRIAL PREP-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL REGARDING TRIAL

PREPARATION; E-MAIL - J. LERNER REGARDING JOINT LIST OF

INDIVIDUALS AND ENTITIES; FILE JOINT LIST OF INDIVIDUALS AND

ENTITIES.

3/2/2020 SJ 440.00 3.50 1,540.00 Billable 540704 TRIAL PREP-A E-MAIL J. MANNING REGARDING FINDINGS OF FACT; E-MAIL - J.

MANNING REGARDING SEALING ORDERS; DRAFT PRETRIAL

PROPOSED FINDINGS OF FACT.

3/3/2020 SJ 440.00 2.50 1,100.00 Billable 540707 TRIAL PREP-A DRAFT PRETRIAL PROPOSED FINDINGS OF FACT.

3/4/2020 SJ 440.00 0.30 132.00 Billable 540709 TRIAL PREP-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH D. TEJTEL REGARDING PROPOSED

FINDINGS OF FACT AND LAW.

3/5/2020 SJ 440.00 2.00 880.00 Billable 540712 TRIAL PREP-A REVISE PRETRIAL PROPOSED FINDINGS OF FACT AND LAW;

DRAFT PROPOSED SEALING FOR PRETRIAL PROPOSED FINDINGS

OF FACT AND LAW.

3/6/2020 SJ 440.00 2.50 1,100.00 Billable 540716 TRIAL PREP-A REVISE PRETRIAL PROPROSED FINDINGS OF FACT AND LAW;

DRAFT MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL; E-MAIL COUNSEL FOR

APPLE AND AKAMAI REGARDING SEALING OF PROPOSED

FINDINGS OF FACT AND LAW; FILE PROPOSED FINDINGS OF FACT

AND LAW.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 74 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 73

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 3/9/2020 SJ 440.00 0.20 88.00 Billable 540718 TRIAL PREP-A TELEPHONE CALL WITH D. JUDSON REGARDING SEALING OF

AKAMAI INFORMATION IN PROPOSED FINDINGS OF FACT AND

LAW.

3/17/2020 SJ 440.00 0.70 308.00 Billable 540732 TRIAL PREP-A E-MAIL A. SIMON REGARDING MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY

APPROVAL; E-MAIL J. MANNING REGARDING PRE-TRIAL

DEADLINES.

3/25/2020 SJ 440.00 0.50 220.00 Billable 541185 SETTLE-A E-MAIL J. MANNING REGARDING MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY

APPROVAL.

3/30/2020 SJ 440.00 1.00 440.00 Billable 541182 SETTLE-A E-MAIL J. MANNING REGARDING MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY

APPROVAL; E-MAIL J. MANNING, D. WARSHAW REGARDING

PLAINTIFF PRODUCTION FOR MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY

APPROVAL.

4/10/2020 SJ 440.00 3.50 1,540.00 Billable 543022 PLDS/MO-A RESEARCH REGARDING DISCOVERY PROCEEDINGS FOR MOTION

FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL.

8/19/2020 SJ 440.00 0.20 88.00 Billable 553042 SETTLE-A E-MAIL - ANVITA P. REGARDING MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY

APPROVAL OF SETTLEMENT.

8/24/2020 SJ 440.00 0.50 220.00 Billable 553019 SETTLE-A E-MAIL - K. DIBBLE REGARDING MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 75 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 74

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt APPROVAL OF SETTLEMENT; E-MAIL - ANVITA P. REGARDING

MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL OF SETTLEMENT.

8/26/2020 SJ 440.00 0.50 220.00 Billable 553023 SETTLE-A E-MAIL K. DIBBLE REGARDING MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY

APPROVAL OF SETTLEMENT; E-MAIL ANVITA P. REGARDING

MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY APPROVAL OF SETTLEMENT.

9/4/2020 SJ 440.00 1.00 440.00 Billable 555069 PLDS/MO-A DRAFT MOTION TO SEAL CLASS NOTICE; E-MAIL - J. MANNING, D.

WARSHAW REGARDING SEALING REQUIREMENTS; TELEPHONE

CALL WITH J. MANNING REGARDING CLASS NOTICE.

9/7/2020 SJ 440.00 0.70 308.00 Billable 555049 PLDS/MO-A REVISE MOTION TO SEAL CLASS NOTICE.

9/8/2020 SJ 440.00 1.50 660.00 Billable 555071 PLDS/MO-A REVISE MOTION TO SEAL CLASS NOTICE; E-MAIL - D. WARSHAW

REGARDING MOTION TO SEAL CLASS NOTICE; FILE MOTION TO

APPROVE CLASS NOTICE.

TOTAL Billable Fees 1127.30 $403,622.00

Total of billable expense slips $0.00

Calculation of Fees and Costs

Amount Total Fees Bill Arrangement: Slips By billing value on each slip.

Total of billable time slips $403,622.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-8 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 76 of 76 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:12 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 75

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Amount Total Total of Fees (Time Charges) $403,622.00

Total of Costs (Expense Charges) $0.00

Total new charges $403,622.00

New Balance Current $403,622.00

Total New Balance $403,622.00

Funds Account: Default Previous account balance $0.00 Total added to account $0.00 Total removed from account $0.00

New account balance $0.00

Amount to replenish account to $0.00 $0.00

Attorney Summary

Attorney Rate Hours Charges Slip Value Adjustment SJ 440.00 36.20 $15,928.00 $15,928.00 0.00 SJ 390.00 43.60 $17,004.00 $17,004.00 0.00 SJ 360.00 730.30 $262,908.00 $262,908.00 0.00 SJ 340.00 313.90 $106,726.00 $106,726.00 0.00 SJ 320.00 3.30 $1,056.00 $1,056.00 0.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-9 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 28

EXHIBIT 7 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-9 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 28 STEYER LOWENTHAL BOODROOKAS 11/23/2020 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 1

Selection Criteria

Atto.Selection Include: CLW Clie.Selection Include: APPLE.FACETIME Slip.Transaction Date Earliest - 10/31/2020 Slip.Billing Status Billable Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-9 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 3 of 28 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 2

Nickname APPLE.FACETIME | 4457-CONT Full Name CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) Address CONSUMER CLASS ACTION - APPLE RE FACETIME FEATURE Phone 1 Phone 2 Phone 3 Phone 4 In Ref To APPLE, INC. - IN REGARDING FACETIME FEATURE Fees Arrg. By billing value on each slip Expense Arrg. By billing value on each slip Tax Profile Exempt Last bill Last charge 10/4/2018 Last payment Amount $0.00

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 1/8/2018 CLW 380.00 2.50 950.00 Billable 474030 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - INITIAL TELEPHONE CALL WITH J.

MANNING; REVIEW AND FAMILIARIZATION WITH RELATIVITY

DATABASE.

1/9/2018 CLW 380.00 6.40 2,432.00 Billable 474031 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - READ COMPLAINTS, ANSWER,

ORDER AND CODING GUIDE.

1/10/2018 CLW 380.00 2.00 760.00 Billable 474032 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

1-10.

1/11/2018 CLW 380.00 2.50 950.00 Billable 474033 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

11-33.

1/12/2018 CLW 380.00 3.00 1,140.00 Billable 474034 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

34-51.

1/15/2018 CLW 380.00 3.10 1,178.00 Billable 474035 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

52-83. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-9 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 4 of 28 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 3

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

1/16/2018 CLW 380.00 3.00 1,140.00 Billable 474036 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

84-109.

1/17/2018 CLW 380.00 3.00 1,140.00 Billable 474037 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

109-121; CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

1/18/2018 CLW 380.00 5.10 1,938.00 Billable 474038 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

158-202.

1/19/2018 CLW 380.00 4.50 1,710.00 Billable 474039 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

203-244.

1/22/2018 CLW 380.00 4.40 1,672.00 Billable 474040 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

245-284.

1/23/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 474041 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

285-312.

1/24/2018 CLW 380.00 6.10 2,318.00 Billable 474042 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

312-361.

1/25/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 474043 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-9 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 5 of 28 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 4

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

362-397.

1/26/2018 CLW 380.00 2.10 798.00 Billable 474044 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

397-410.

1/29/2018 CLW 380.00 3.10 1,178.00 Billable 475172 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

411-454.

1/30/2018 CLW 380.00 1.10 418.00 Billable 475173 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

454-469.

1/31/2018 CLW 380.00 3.40 1,292.00 Billable 475174 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

469-500, 1-32.

2/1/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 476141 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

411-464.

2/2/2018 CLW 380.00 3.00 1,140.00 Billable 476142 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

465-500.

2/5/2018 CLW 380.00 4.20 1,596.00 Billable 476143 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

1-68.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-9 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 6 of 28 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 5

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 2/6/2018 CLW 380.00 4.70 1,786.00 Billable 476144 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

69-128; PARTICIPATE IN CONFERENCE CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

2/7/2018 CLW 380.00 2.20 836.00 Billable 476145 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

129-144.

2/8/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 476146 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

1-44.

2/9/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 476147 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

45-90.

2/12/2018 CLW 380.00 3.00 1,140.00 Billable 476148 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

91-133.

2/13/2018 CLW 380.00 2.50 950.00 Billable 476149 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

133-164.

2/14/2018 CLW 380.00 3.20 1,216.00 Billable 476150 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

165-201.

2/15/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 477480 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

201-271. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-9 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 7 of 28 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 6

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

2/16/2018 CLW 380.00 3.20 1,216.00 Billable 477481 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW C.S. LOG DOCUMENTS

272-318.

2/19/2018 CLW 380.00 2.70 1,026.00 Billable 477482 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

DOC 1-47.

2/20/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 477483 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

DOC 48-114.

2/21/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 477484 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

DOC 115-181.

2/22/2018 CLW 380.00 3.20 1,216.00 Billable 477485 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

DOC 182-229.

2/23/2018 CLW 380.00 3.50 1,330.00 Billable 477486 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

DOC 229-279.

2/26/2018 CLW 380.00 3.70 1,406.00 Billable 477487 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

DOC 280-336.

2/27/2018 CLW 380.00 3.00 1,140.00 Billable 477488 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-9 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 8 of 28 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 7

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

DOC 337-366.

2/28/2018 CLW 380.00 2.20 836.00 Billable 477489 DOC REVIEW-A APL-GRACE-CCLOG00017679 - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

DOC 366-390.

3/1/2018 CLW 380.00 3.20 1,216.00 Billable 480098 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

DOC 391-500.

3/2/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 480099 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

DOC 1-121.

3/5/2018 CLW 380.00 4.50 1,710.00 Billable 480100 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

DOC 122-281.

3/6/2018 CLW 380.00 3.70 1,406.00 Billable 480101 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

DOC 282-400.

3/9/2018 CLW 380.00 4.50 1,710.00 Billable 480102 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

DOC 401-500, 1-56.

3/12/2018 CLW 380.00 4.20 1,596.00 Billable 480103 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

DOC 57-198.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-9 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 9 of 28 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 8

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 3/13/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 480104 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

DOC 199-317.

3/14/2018 CLW 380.00 4.20 1,596.00 Billable 480105 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

DOC 318-447; PREPARE FOR AND PARTICIPATE IN CO-COUNSEL

CONFERENCE CALL.

3/15/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 480106 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

DOC 448-500, 1-74.

3/16/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 480107 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

DOC 75-205.

3/19/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 480108 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

DOC 206-326.

3/20/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 480109 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

DOC 327-459.

3/21/2018 CLW 380.00 4.50 1,710.00 Billable 480110 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

DOC 460-500, 1-95; PREPARE FOR AND PARTICIPATE IN

CO-COUNSEL CONFERENCE CALL.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-9 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 10 of 28 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 9

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 3/22/2018 CLW 380.00 5.00 1,900.00 Billable 480111 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

DOC 96-315.

3/23/2018 CLW 380.00 4.70 1,786.00 Billable 480112 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

DOC 316-500.

3/26/2018 CLW 380.00 3.00 1,140.00 Billable 480113 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW CS LOGS DOC 1-81.

3/27/2018 CLW 380.00 4.20 1,596.00 Billable 480114 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW CS LOGS DOC 82-233.

3/28/2018 CLW 380.00 4.20 1,596.00 Billable 480115 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW CS LOGS DOC 234-365;

PREPARE FOR AND PARTICIPATE IN CO-COUNSEL CONFERENCE

CALL.

3/29/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 480116 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW CS LOGS DOC 366-500.

3/30/2018 CLW 380.00 3.50 1,330.00 Billable 480117 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW CS LOGS DOC 1-110.

4/2/2018 CLW 380.00 4.50 1,710.00 Billable 481875 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

DOCUMENT 110-374.

4/3/2018 CLW 380.00 4.20 1,596.00 Billable 481877 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-9 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 11 of 28 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 10

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt DOCUMENT 374-500, 1-200.

4/11/2018 CLW 380.00 5.10 1,938.00 Billable 481879 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - GOKUL DEPOSITION PREPARATION

DOCUMENT 1-227; TELEPHONE CALL WITH V. GLAZE.

4/12/2018 CLW 380.00 6.20 2,356.00 Billable 481880 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - GOKUL DEPOSITION PREPARATION

DOCUMENT 228-476.

4/13/2018 CLW 380.00 6.20 2,356.00 Billable 481928 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - GOKUL DEPOSITION PREPARATION

DOCUMENT 477-716.

4/16/2018 CLW 380.00 5.00 1,900.00 Billable 481929 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - GOKUL DEPOSITION PREPARATION

DOCUMENT 717-880.

4/17/2018 CLW 380.00 5.50 2,090.00 Billable 481930 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - GOKUL DEPOSITION PREPARATION

DOCUMENT 881-1001.

4/18/2018 CLW 380.00 5.70 2,166.00 Billable 481931 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - GOKUL DEPOSITION PREPARATION

DOCUMENT 1-194.

4/19/2018 CLW 380.00 5.50 2,090.00 Billable 481932 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - GOKUL DEPOSITION PREPARATION

DOCUMENT 195-370.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-9 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 12 of 28 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 11

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 4/20/2018 CLW 380.00 5.20 1,976.00 Billable 481933 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - GOKUL DEPOSITION PREPARATION

DOCUMENT 371-500.

4/23/2018 CLW 380.00 4.20 1,596.00 Billable 481934 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

1-184.

4/24/2018 CLW 380.00 4.20 1,596.00 Billable 481935 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

185-366.

4/25/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 481936 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

367-384.

4/26/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 481937 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

385-420.

4/27/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 481938 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW PRIORITY E-MAIL BATCH

421-501.

4/30/2018 CLW 380.00 4.10 1,558.00 Billable 481939 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW CS LOGS 1-139.

5/1/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 483631 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW CS LOGS 140-302.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-9 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 13 of 28 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 12

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 5/2/2018 CLW 380.00 3.70 1,406.00 Billable 483632 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - REVIEW CS LOGS 303-500.

5/3/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 483634 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES WOODS,

JEONG AND GATES.

5/4/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 483635 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES WOODS,

JEONG AND GATES.

5/7/2018 CLW 380.00 4.20 1,596.00 Billable 483636 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES WOODS,

JEONG AND GATES.

5/8/2018 CLW 380.00 4.20 1,596.00 Billable 483637 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES WOODS,

JEONG AND GATES.

5/9/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 483638 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES WOODS,

JEONG AND GATES.

5/10/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 483639 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-9 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 14 of 28 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 13

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES WOODS,

JEONG AND GATES.

5/11/2018 CLW 380.00 4.50 1,710.00 Billable 483640 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES WOODS,

JEONG AND GATES.

5/14/2018 CLW 380.00 4.50 1,710.00 Billable 485481 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES WOODS,

JEONG AND GATES.

5/15/2018 CLW 380.00 4.70 1,786.00 Billable 485482 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES WOODS,

JEONG AND GATES.

5/16/2018 CLW 380.00 4.70 1,786.00 Billable 485483 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES WOODS,

JEONG AND GATES.

5/17/2018 CLW 380.00 4.20 1,596.00 Billable 485484 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES WOODS,

JEONG AND GATES.

5/18/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 485485 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-9 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 15 of 28 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 14

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES WOODS,

JEONG AND GATES.

5/21/2018 CLW 380.00 4.20 1,596.00 Billable 485486 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES WOODS,

JEONG AND GATES.

5/22/2018 CLW 380.00 3.00 1,140.00 Billable 485487 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES WOODS,

JEONG AND GATES.

5/23/2018 CLW 380.00 3.50 1,330.00 Billable 485488 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES WOODS,

JEONG AND GATES.

5/24/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 485489 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES WOODS,

JEONG AND GATES.

5/25/2018 CLW 380.00 3.20 1,216.00 Billable 485490 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES WOODS,

JEONG AND GATES.

5/28/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 485491 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-9 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 16 of 28 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 15

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES WOODS,

JEONG AND GATES.

5/29/2018 CLW 380.00 4.20 1,596.00 Billable 485492 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES WOODS,

JEONG AND GATES.

5/30/2018 CLW 380.00 3.20 1,216.00 Billable 485493 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES IRANI,

VIDRINE, JOSWIAK, FEDEREGHI, CUE, VYRROS, WHALLEY.

5/31/2018 CLW 380.00 3.00 1,140.00 Billable 485494 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES IRANI,

VIDRINE, JOSWIAK, FEDEREGHI, CUE, VYRROS, WHALLEY.

6/1/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 487596 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES IRANI,

VIDRINE, JOSWIAK, FEDEREGHI, CUE, VYRROS, WHALLEY.

6/3/2018 CLW 380.00 4.20 1,596.00 Billable 487598 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES IRANI,

VIDRINE, JOSWIAK, FEDEREGHI, CUE, VYRROS, WHALLEY.

6/4/2018 CLW 380.00 3.00 1,140.00 Billable 487599 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-9 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 17 of 28 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 16

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES IRANI,

VIDRINE, JOSWIAK, FEDEREGHI, CUE, VYRROS, WHALLEY.

6/5/2018 CLW 380.00 2.50 950.00 Billable 487600 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES IRANI,

VIDRINE, JOSWIAK, FEDEREGHI, CUE, VYRROS, WHALLEY.

6/6/2018 CLW 380.00 2.20 836.00 Billable 487602 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES IRANI,

VIDRINE, JOSWIAK, FEDEREGHI, CUE, VYRROS, WHALLEY.

6/7/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 487604 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES IRANI,

VIDRINE, JOSWIAK, FEDEREGHI, CUE, VYRROS, WHALLEY.

6/10/2018 CLW 380.00 4.70 1,786.00 Billable 487605 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES IRANI,

VIDRINE, JOSWIAK, FEDEREGHI, CUE, VYRROS, WHALLEY.

6/11/2018 CLW 380.00 4.50 1,710.00 Billable 487607 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES IRANI,

VIDRINE, JOSWIAK, FEDEREGHI, CUE, VYRROS, WHALLEY.

6/12/2018 CLW 380.00 4.50 1,710.00 Billable 487608 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-9 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 18 of 28 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 17

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES IRANI,

VIDRINE, JOSWIAK, FEDEREGHI, CUE, VYRROS, WHALLEY.

6/13/2018 CLW 380.00 4.50 1,710.00 Billable 487609 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES IRANI,

VIDRINE, JOSWIAK, FEDEREGHI, CUE, VYRROS, WHALLEY.

6/14/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 487611 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES IRANI,

VIDRINE, JOSWIAK, FEDEREGHI, CUE, VYRROS, WHALLEY.

6/17/2018 CLW 380.00 4.20 1,596.00 Billable 487612 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES IRANI,

VIDRINE, JOSWIAK, FEDEREGHI, CUE, VYRROS, WHALLEY.

6/18/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 487613 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES IRANI,

VIDRINE, JOSWIAK, FEDEREGHI, CUE, VYRROS, WHALLEY.

6/19/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 487614 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES IRANI,

VIDRINE, JOSWIAK, FEDEREGHI, CUE, VYRROS, WHALLEY.

6/20/2018 CLW 380.00 4.20 1,596.00 Billable 487615 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-9 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 19 of 28 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 18

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES IRANI,

VIDRINE, JOSWIAK, FEDEREGHI, CUE, VYRROS, WHALLEY.

6/21/2018 CLW 380.00 4.70 1,786.00 Billable 487616 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES IRANI,

VIDRINE, JOSWIAK, FEDEREGHI, CUE, VYRROS, WHALLEY.

6/24/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 487617 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES IRANI,

VIDRINE, JOSWIAK, FEDEREGHI, CUE, VYRROS, WHALLEY.

6/25/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 487618 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES IRANI,

VIDRINE, JOSWIAK, FEDEREGHI, CUE, VYRROS, WHALLEY.

6/26/2018 CLW 380.00 4.70 1,786.00 Billable 487619 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES IRANI,

VIDRINE, JOSWIAK, FEDEREGHI, CUE, VYRROS, WHALLEY.

6/27/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 487620 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES IRANI,

VIDRINE, JOSWIAK, FEDEREGHI, CUE, VYRROS, WHALLEY.

6/28/2018 CLW 380.00 3.50 1,330.00 Billable 487621 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 1 REVIEW IN PREPARATION Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-9 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 20 of 28 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 19

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt FOR UPCOMING DEPOSITIONS OF APPLE EMPLOYEES IRANI,

VIDRINE, JOSWIAK, FEDEREGHI, CUE, VYRROS, WHALLEY.

7/2/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 490092 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING POTENTIAL DEPONENTS (VARIOUS).

7/3/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 490093 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING POTENTIAL DEPONENTS (VARIOUS).

7/4/2018 CLW 380.00 3.00 1,140.00 Billable 490094 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING POTENTIAL DEPONENTS (VARIOUS).

7/5/2018 CLW 380.00 3.00 1,140.00 Billable 490095 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING POTENTIAL DEPONENTS (VARIOUS).

7/6/2018 CLW 380.00 3.10 1,178.00 Billable 490096 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING POTENTIAL DEPONENTS (VARIOUS).

7/9/2018 CLW 380.00 3.50 1,330.00 Billable 490097 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING POTENTIAL DEPONENTS (VARIOUS).

7/10/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 490098 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING POTENTIAL DEPONENTS (VARIOUS).

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-9 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 21 of 28 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 20

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 7/11/2018 CLW 380.00 3.50 1,330.00 Billable 490099 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING POTENTIAL DEPONENTS (VARIOUS).

7/12/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 490100 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING POTENTIAL DEPONENTS (VARIOUS).

7/13/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 490101 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING POTENTIAL DEPONENTS (VARIOUS).

7/16/2018 CLW 380.00 3.30 1,254.00 Billable 490102 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING POTENTIAL DEPONENTS (VARIOUS).

7/17/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 490103 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING POTENTIAL DEPONENTS (VARIOUS).

7/18/2018 CLW 380.00 3.50 1,330.00 Billable 490104 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING POTENTIAL DEPONENTS (VARIOUS).

7/19/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 490105 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING POTENTIAL DEPONENTS (VARIOUS).

7/20/2018 CLW 380.00 3.20 1,216.00 Billable 490106 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING POTENTIAL DEPONENTS (VARIOUS). Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-9 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 22 of 28 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 21

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

7/23/2018 CLW 380.00 2.20 836.00 Billable 490107 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING POTENTIAL DEPONENTS (VARIOUS).

7/24/2018 CLW 380.00 2.00 760.00 Billable 490108 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING POTENTIAL DEPONENTS (VARIOUS).

7/25/2018 CLW 380.00 2.20 836.00 Billable 490110 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING POTENTIAL DEPONENTS (VARIOUS).

7/26/2018 CLW 380.00 2.00 760.00 Billable 490111 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING POTENTIAL DEPONENTS (VARIOUS).

7/27/2018 CLW 380.00 1.70 646.00 Billable 490112 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING POTENTIAL DEPONENTS (VARIOUS).

7/30/2018 CLW 380.00 1.50 570.00 Billable 490113 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING POTENTIAL DEPONENTS (VARIOUS).

7/31/2018 CLW 380.00 1.00 380.00 Billable 490114 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 REVIEW IN PREPARATION

FOR UPCOMING POTENTIAL DEPONENTS (VARIOUS).

8/1/2018 CLW 380.00 6.50 2,470.00 Billable 491135 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEVAPPLE - SEARCH, ANALYZE, CODE TIER 2 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-9 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 23 of 28 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 22

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

DOCUMENTS IN PREPARATION FOR POTENTIAL DEPONENTS

(VARIOUS).

8/2/2018 CLW 380.00 7.50 2,850.00 Billable 491138 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEVAPPLE - SEARCH, ANALYZE, CODE TIER 2

DOCUMENTS IN PREPARATION FOR POTENTIAL DEPONENTS

(VARIOUS).

8/3/2018 CLW 380.00 8.30 3,154.00 Billable 491170 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEVAPPLE - SEARCH, ANALYZE, CODE TIER 2

DOCUMENTS IN PREPARATION FOR POTENTIAL DEPONENTS

(VARIOUS).

8/6/2018 CLW 380.00 6.00 2,280.00 Billable 491143 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEVAPPLE - SEARCH, ANALYZE, CODE TIER 2

DOCUMENTS IN PREPARATION FOR POTENTIAL DEPONENTS

(VARIOUS).

8/7/2018 CLW 380.00 7.70 2,926.00 Billable 491162 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEVAPPLE - SEARCH, ANALYZE, CODE TIER 2

DOCUMENTS IN PREPARATION FOR POTENTIAL DEPONENTS

(VARIOUS); SLBAS CALL/PREPARATION REGARDING CASE

STATUS.

8/8/2018 CLW 380.00 6.00 2,280.00 Billable 491171 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEVAPPLE - SEARCH, ANALYZE, CODE TIER 2

DOCUMENTS IN PREPARATION FOR POTENTIAL DEPONENTS

(VARIOUS); REVIEW CASE DOCUMENTS (CLASS CERTIFICATION

MOTION, OPPOSITION, REPLY) IN PREPARATION FOR ISSUE Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-9 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 24 of 28 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 23

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt MEMO.

8/9/2018 CLW 380.00 8.30 3,154.00 Billable 491139 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEVAPPLE - SEARCH, ANALYZE, CODE TIER 2

DOCUMENTS IN PREPARATION FOR POTENTIAL DEPONENTS

(VARIOUS); TARGETED SEARCH AND REVIEW OF DOCUMENTS

RELATED TO IOS 7 ISSUE MEMO.

8/10/2018 CLW 380.00 7.80 2,964.00 Billable 491163 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEVAPPLE - SEARCH, ANALYZE, CODE TIER 2

DOCUMENTS IN PREPARATION FOR POTENTIAL DEPONENTS

(VARIOUS); TARGETED SEARCH AND REVIEW OF DOCUMENTS

RELATED TO IOS 7 ISSUE MEMO.

8/13/2018 CLW 380.00 3.80 1,444.00 Billable 492053 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEVAPPLE - SEARCH, ANALYZE, CODE TIER 2

DOCUMENTS IN PREPARATION FOR POTENTIAL DEPONENTS

(VARIOUS); TARGETED SEARCH AND REVIEW OF DOCUMENTS

RELATED TO IOS 7 ISSUE MEMO.

8/14/2018 CLW 380.00 3.70 1,406.00 Billable 492135 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEVAPPLE - SEARCH, ANALYZE, CODE TIER 2

DOCUMENTS IN PREPARATION FOR POTENTIAL DEPONENTS

(VARIOUS); TARGETED SEARCH AND REVIEW OF DOCUMENTS

RELATED TO IOS 7 ISSUE MEMO.

8/15/2018 CLW 380.00 4.80 1,824.00 Billable 492136 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEVAPPLE - SEARCH, ANALYZE, CODE TIER 2

DOCUMENTS IN PREPARATION FOR POTENTIAL DEPONENTS

(VARIOUS); TARGETED SEARCH AND REVIEW OF DOCUMENTS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-9 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 25 of 28 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 24

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

RELATED TO IOS 7 ISSUE MEMO; OUTLINE AND BEGIN IOS 7

ISSUE MEMO.

8/16/2018 CLW 380.00 3.80 1,444.00 Billable 492114 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEVAPPLE - SEARCH, ANALYZE, CODE TIER 2

DOCUMENTS IN PREPARATION FOR POTENTIAL DEPONENTS

(VARIOUS); TARGETED SEARCH AND REVIEW OF DOCUMENTS

RELATED TO IOS 7 ISSUE MEMO; FIRST DRAFT IOS 7 ISSUE MEMO.

8/17/2018 CLW 380.00 4.30 1,634.00 Billable 492143 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEVAPPLE - SEARCH, ANALYZE, CODE TIER 2

DOCUMENTS IN PREPARATION FOR POTENTIAL DEPONENTS

(VARIOUS); TARGETED SEARCH AND REVIEW OF DOCUMENTS

RELATED TO IOS 7 ISSUE MEMO; FIRST DRAFT IOS 7 ISSUE MEMO.

8/20/2018 CLW 380.00 4.20 1,596.00 Billable 492144 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEVAPPLE - SEARCH, ANALYZE, CODE TIER 2

DOCUMENTS IN PREPARATION FOR POTENTIAL DEPONENTS

(VARIOUS); TARGETED SEARCH AND REVIEW OF DOCUMENTS

RELATED TO IOS 7 ISSUE MEMO; FIRST DRAFT IOS 7 ISSUE MEMO.

8/21/2018 CLW 380.00 4.20 1,596.00 Billable 492105 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEVAPPLE - SEARCH, ANALYZE, CODE TIER 2

DOCUMENTS IN PREPARATION FOR POTENTIAL DEPONENTS

(VARIOUS); TARGETED SEARCH AND REVIEW OF DOCUMENTS

RELATED TO IOS 7 ISSUE MEMO; OUTLINE AND BEGIN IOS 7

ISSUE MEMO.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-9 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 26 of 28 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 25

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 8/22/2018 CLW 380.00 2.00 760.00 Billable 492146 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEVAPPLE - TARGETED SEARCH AND REVIEW

OF DOCUMENTS RELATED TO IOS 7 ISSUE MEMO; DRAFT IOS 7

ISSUE MEMO.

9/20/2018 CLW 380.00 2.00 760.00 Billable 494966 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEVAPPLE - TARGETED SEARCH AND REVIEW

OF DOCUMENTS RELATED TO IOS 7 ISSUE MEMO; DRAFT OF

ISSUE MEMORANDUM.

9/21/2018 CLW 380.00 2.00 760.00 Billable 494967 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEVAPPLE - TARGETED SEARCH AND REVIEW

OF DOCUMENTS RELATED TO IOS 7 ISSUE MEMO; DRAFT OF

ISSUE MEMORANDUM.

9/24/2018 CLW 380.00 3.70 1,406.00 Billable 494959 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEVAPPLE - TARGETED SEARCH AND REVIEW

OF DOCUMENTS RELATED TO IOS 7 ISSUE MEMO; DRAFT OF

ISSUE MEMORANDUM.

9/25/2018 CLW 380.00 4.00 1,520.00 Billable 494957 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEVAPPLE - TARGETED SEARCH AND REVIEW

OF DOCUMENTS RELATED TO IOS 7 ISSUE MEMO; DRAFT OF

ISSUE MEMORANDUM.

9/26/2018 CLW 380.00 8.00 3,040.00 Billable 494960 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEVAPPLE - TARGETED SEARCH AND REVIEW

OF DOCUMENTS RELATED TO IOS 7 ISSUE MEMO; DRAFT OF

ISSUE MEMORANDUM.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-9 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 27 of 28 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 26

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 9/27/2018 CLW 380.00 8.00 3,040.00 Billable 494961 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEVAPPLE - TARGETED SEARCH AND REVIEW

OF DOCUMENTS RELATED TO IOS 7 ISSUE MEMO; DRAFT OF

ISSUE MEMORANDUM.

9/28/2018 CLW 380.00 2.50 950.00 Billable 494956 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEVAPPLE - TARGETED SEARCH AND REVIEW

OF DOCUMENTS RELATED TO IOS 7 ISSUE MEMO; DRAFT OF

ISSUE MEMORANDUM.

10/4/2018 CLW 380.00 8.20 3,116.00 Billable 497145 DOC REVIEW-A RANK, CODE, AND REVIEW NEWLY-PRODUCED DOCUMENTS

(2015-PRES) FOR INCLUSION IN FURTHER REVIEW FOR

PRIVILEGE AND CONFIDENTIALITY; E-MAIL WITH CO-COUNSEL

REGARDING REVIEW STATUS.

TOTAL Billable Fees 659.00 $250,420.00

Total of billable expense slips $0.00

Calculation of Fees and Costs

Amount Total Fees Bill Arrangement: Slips By billing value on each slip.

Total of billable time slips $250,420.00 Total of Fees (Time Charges) $250,420.00

Total of Costs (Expense Charges) $0.00

Total new charges $250,420.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-9 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 28 of 28 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/23/2020 11:11 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 27

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Amount Total New Balance Current $250,420.00

Total New Balance $250,420.00

Funds Account: Default Previous account balance $0.00 Total added to account $0.00 Total removed from account $0.00

New account balance $0.00

Amount to replenish account to $0.00 $0.00

Attorney Summary

Attorney Rate Hours Charges Slip Value Adjustment CLW 380.00 659.00 $250,420.00 $250,420.00 0.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-10 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 38

EXHIBIT 8 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-10 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 38 STEYER LOWENTHAL BOODROOKAS 11/24/2020 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 1

Selection Criteria

Atto.Selection Include: KMD Clie.Selection Include: APPLE.FACETIME Slip.Transaction Date Earliest - 10/31/2020 Slip.Billing Status Billable Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 3 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 2

Nickname APPLE.FACETIME | 4457-CONT Full Name CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) Address CONSUMER CLASS ACTION - APPLE RE FACETIME FEATURE Phone 1 Phone 2 Phone 3 Phone 4 In Ref To APPLE, INC. - IN REGARDING FACETIME FEATURE Fees Arrg. By billing value on each slip Expense Arrg. By billing value on each slip Tax Profile Exempt Last bill Last charge 9/19/2018 Last payment Amount $0.00

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 10/9/2017 KMD 340.00 3.50 1,190.00 Billable 468051 DOC REVIEW-A REVIEW CASE PLEADINGS IN PREPARATION FOR DOCUMENT

REVIEW.

10/10/2017 KMD 340.00 2.40 816.00 Billable 468052 DOC REVIEW-A REVIEW CASE PLEADINGS IN PREPARATION FOR DOCUMENT

REVIEW.

10/11/2017 KMD 340.00 3.00 1,020.00 Billable 468053 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 20171011 BATCHED FOR REVIEW _00002, SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CODE DOCUMENTS 1-25.

10/11/2017 KMD 340.00 1.20 408.00 Billable 468056 DOC REVIEW-A PREPARE FOR AND PARTICIPATE IN CO-COUNSEL CONFERENCE

CALL.

10/12/2017 KMD 340.00 3.50 1,190.00 Billable 468054 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 20171011 BATCHED FOR REVIEW _00002, SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CODE DOCUMENTS 26-49.

10/16/2017 KMD 340.00 3.40 1,156.00 Billable 468055 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 20171011 BATCHED FOR REVIEW _00002, SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CODE DOCUMENTS 50-72.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 4 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 3

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 10/18/2017 KMD 340.00 4.50 1,530.00 Billable 468057 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 20171014 BATCHED FOR REVIEW_00001, SEARCH, REVIEW

AND CODE DOCUMENTS 1-10; PREPARE FOR AND PARTICIPATE IN

CO-COUNSEL CONFERENCE CALL.

10/19/2017 KMD 340.00 4.00 1,360.00 Billable 468058 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 20171014 BATCHED FOR REVIEW_00001, SEARCH, REVIEW

AND CODE DOCUMENTS 11-20.

10/20/2017 KMD 340.00 3.40 1,156.00 Billable 468059 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 20171011 BATCHED FOR REVIEW_00003, SEARCH, REVIEW

AND CODE DOCUMENTS 1-15.

10/23/2017 KMD 340.00 4.10 1,394.00 Billable 468060 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 20171011 BATCHED FOR REVIEW_00003, SEARCH, REVIEW

AND CODE DOCUMENTS 16-30.

10/24/2017 KMD 340.00 3.50 1,190.00 Billable 468061 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 20171011 BATCHED FOR REVIEW_00003, SEARCH, REVIEW

AND CODE DOCUMENTS 31-46.

10/25/2017 KMD 340.00 4.20 1,428.00 Billable 468062 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 20171011 BATCHED FOR REVIEW_00003, SEARCH, REVIEW

AND CODE DOCUMENTS 47-72.

11/27/2017 KMD 340.00 2.00 680.00 Billable 469445 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 11.27.2017 FACETIME_00001; SEARCH, REVIEW AND CODE

DOCUMENTS 1-25.

11/28/2017 KMD 340.00 1.40 476.00 Billable 470097 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 11.27.2017 FACETIME_00001; SEARCH, REVIEW AND CODE Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 5 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 4

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

DOCUMENTS 26-36.

11/29/2017 KMD 340.00 2.00 680.00 Billable 470099 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 11.27.2017 FACETIME_00001; SEARCH, REVIEW AND CODE

DOCUMENTS 37-50.

12/1/2017 KMD 340.00 2.00 680.00 Billable 472516 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 11.27.2017 FACETIME_00001; SEARCH, REVIEW AND CODE

DOCUMENTS 51-64.

12/4/2017 KMD 340.00 1.40 476.00 Billable 472517 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 11.27.2017 FACETIME_00001; SEARCH, REVIEW AND CODE

DOCUMENTS 65-75.

12/5/2017 KMD 340.00 2.00 680.00 Billable 472518 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 11.27.2017 FACETIME_00001; SEARCH, REVIEW AND CODE

DOCUMENTS 76-86.

12/6/2017 KMD 340.00 2.00 680.00 Billable 472519 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 11.27.2017 FACETIME_00001; SEARCH, REVIEW AND CODE

DOCUMENTS 87-100.

12/7/2017 KMD 340.00 1.50 510.00 Billable 472520 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 11.27.2017 FACETIME_00004; SEARCH, REVIEW AND CODE

DOCUMENTS 1-15.

12/8/2017 KMD 340.00 1.40 476.00 Billable 472521 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 11.27.2017 FACETIME_00004; SEARCH, REVIEW AND CODE

DOCUMENTS 16-29.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 6 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 5

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 12/12/2017 KMD 340.00 1.50 510.00 Billable 472522 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 11.27.2017 FACETIME_00004; SEARCH, REVIEW AND CODE

DOCUMENTS 30-40.

12/13/2017 KMD 340.00 2.00 680.00 Billable 472523 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 11.27.2017 FACETIME_00004; SEARCH, REVIEW AND CODE

DOCUMENTS 41-62.

12/14/2017 KMD 340.00 1.40 476.00 Billable 472524 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00001; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CODE DOCUMENTS 1-15.

12/15/2017 KMD 340.00 2.00 680.00 Billable 472525 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00001; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CODE DOCUMENTS 16-28.

12/18/2017 KMD 340.00 2.00 680.00 Billable 472526 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00001; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CODE DOCUMENTS 29-45.

12/19/2017 KMD 340.00 2.50 850.00 Billable 472527 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00001; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CODE DOCUMENTS 46-72.

12/20/2017 KMD 340.00 2.50 850.00 Billable 472528 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00001; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CODE DOCUMENTS 73-100.

12/21/2017 KMD 340.00 2.50 850.00 Billable 472529 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00001; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CODE DOCUMENTS 101-150. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 7 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 6

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

12/22/2017 KMD 340.00 2.40 816.00 Billable 472530 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00001; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CODE DOCUMENTS 151-183.

12/26/2017 KMD 340.00 2.50 850.00 Billable 472531 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00001; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CODE DOCUMENTS 184-205.

12/27/2017 KMD 340.00 2.40 816.00 Billable 472532 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00001; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CODE DOCUMENTS 206-240.

12/28/2017 KMD 340.00 3.00 1,020.00 Billable 472533 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00001; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CODE DOCUMENTS 241-275.

12/29/2017 KMD 340.00 2.50 850.00 Billable 472534 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00001; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CODE DOCUMENTS 276-300.

1/2/2018 KMD 360.00 3.50 1,260.00 Billable 474075 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00001; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 301-30.

1/2/2018 KMD 360.00 3.00 1,080.00 Billable 474076 DOC REVIEW-A TARGETED KURT KNIGHT SEARCH PROJECT; SEARCH AND

ANALYZE DOCUMENTS; DRAFT AND EDIT MEMO.

1/3/2018 KMD 360.00 3.00 1,080.00 Billable 474077 DOC REVIEW-A TARGETED KURT KNIGHT SEARCH PROJECT; SEARCH AND Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 8 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 7

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

ANALYZE DOCUMENTS; DRAFT AND EDIT MEMO.

1/3/2018 KMD 360.00 2.00 720.00 Billable 474078 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00001; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 331-55.

1/4/2018 KMD 360.00 2.00 720.00 Billable 474079 DOC REVIEW-A TARGETED KURT KNIGHT SEARCH PROJECT; SEARCH AND

ANALYZE DOCUMENTS; DRAFT AND EDIT MEMO.

1/4/2018 KMD 360.00 3.10 1,116.00 Billable 474080 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00001; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 356-400.

1/5/2018 KMD 360.00 2.10 756.00 Billable 474081 DOC REVIEW-A TARGETED KURT KNIGHT SEARCH PROJECT; SEARCH AND

ANALYZE DOCUMENTS; DRAFT AND EDIT MEMO.

1/5/2018 KMD 360.00 2.40 864.00 Billable 474082 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00001; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 401-51.

1/8/2018 KMD 360.00 3.50 1,260.00 Billable 474083 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00001; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 452-84.

1/8/2018 KMD 360.00 2.10 756.00 Billable 474090 DOC REVIEW-A TARGETED KURT KNIGHT SEARCH PROJECT; SEARCH AND

ANALYZE DOCUMENTS; DRAFT AND EDIT MEMO.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 9 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 8

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 1/9/2018 KMD 360.00 1.00 360.00 Billable 474084 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00001; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 452-84.

1/9/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 474085 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00006; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-50.

1/10/2018 KMD 360.00 3.40 1,224.00 Billable 474086 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00006; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 51-92.

1/11/2018 KMD 360.00 3.40 1,224.00 Billable 474087 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00006; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 93-125.

1/12/2018 KMD 360.00 4.00 1,440.00 Billable 474088 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00006; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 126-76.

1/16/2018 KMD 360.00 3.40 1,224.00 Billable 474089 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00006; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 177-215.

1/17/2018 KMD 360.00 0.40 144.00 Billable 474091 DOC REVIEW-A PREPARE FOR AND PARTICIPATE IN BI-MONTHLY STATUS CALL

WITH CO-COUNSEL.

1/17/2018 KMD 360.00 3.10 1,116.00 Billable 474092 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00006; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 216-60. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 10 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 9

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

1/18/2018 KMD 360.00 3.50 1,260.00 Billable 474093 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00006; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 261-305.

1/19/2018 KMD 360.00 3.40 1,224.00 Billable 474094 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00006; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 306-66.

1/22/2018 KMD 360.00 4.10 1,476.00 Billable 474095 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00006; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 367-425.

1/23/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 474096 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00006; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 426-470.

1/24/2018 KMD 360.00 3.40 1,224.00 Billable 474097 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00006; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 471-500.

1/25/2018 KMD 360.00 3.50 1,260.00 Billable 474098 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00027; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-75.

1/25/2018 KMD 360.00 2.50 900.00 Billable 474100 DOC REVIEW-A TARGETED GREG JOSWIAK SEARCH PROJECT; SEARCH AND

ANALYZE DOCUMENTS; DRAFT AND EDIT MEMO.

1/26/2018 KMD 360.00 4.10 1,476.00 Billable 474099 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00027; SEARCH, REVIEW AND Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 11 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 10

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 76-150.

1/29/2018 KMD 360.00 4.00 1,440.00 Billable 475179 DOC REVIEW-A TARGETED GREG JOSWIAK SEARCH PROJECT; SEARCH,

CLASSIFY AND ANALYZE GREG JOSWIAK DOCUMENTS; DRAFT

AND EDIT MEMO.

1/30/2018 KMD 360.00 4.00 1,440.00 Billable 475180 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00027; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 151-252.

1/31/2018 KMD 360.00 8.00 2,880.00 Billable 475181 DOC REVIEW-A TARGETED GREG JOSWIAK SEARCH PROJECT; SEARCH,

CLASSIFY AND ANALYZE GREG JOSWIAK DOCUMENTS; DRAFT

AND EDIT MEMO.

2/1/2018 KMD 360.00 4.30 1,548.00 Billable 476355 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00027; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 253-350.

2/2/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 476356 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00027; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 351-430.

2/5/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 476357 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00027; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 431-500.

2/6/2018 KMD 360.00 3.50 1,260.00 Billable 476358 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00036; SEARCH, REVIEW AND Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 12 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 11

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-125.

2/7/2018 KMD 360.00 4.30 1,548.00 Billable 476366 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH - TARGETED SEARCH PHIL SCHILLER SEARCH PROJECT;

SEARCH AND ANALYZE PHIL SCHILLER DOCUMENTS; DRAFT/EDIT

MEMO; PREPARE FOR AND PARTICIPATE IN BIMONTHLY

CO-COUNSEL CONFERENCE CALL.

2/8/2018 KMD 360.00 4.30 1,548.00 Billable 476367 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH - TARGETED SEARCH PHIL SCHILLER SEARCH PROJECT;

SEARCH AND ANALYZE PHIL SCHILLER DOCUMENTS; DRAFT/EDIT

MEMO.

2/9/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 476359 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00036; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 126-256.

2/12/2018 KMD 360.00 3.40 1,224.00 Billable 476368 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH - TARGETED SEARCH PHIL SCHILLER SEARCH PROJECT;

SEARCH AND ANALYZE PHIL SCHILLER DOCUMENTS; DRAFT/EDIT

MEMO.

2/13/2018 KMD 360.00 4.30 1,548.00 Billable 476360 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00036; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 257-332.

2/14/2018 KMD 360.00 2.00 720.00 Billable 476361 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00036; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 333-399.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 13 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 12

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 2/14/2018 KMD 360.00 3.50 1,260.00 Billable 476371 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH - TARGETED SEARCH PHIL SCHILLER SEARCH PROJECT;

SEARCH AND ANALYZE PHIL SCHILLER DOCUMENTS; DRAFT/EDIT

MEMO.

2/15/2018 KMD 360.00 2.50 900.00 Billable 476362 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00036; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 400-500.

2/15/2018 KMD 360.00 2.30 828.00 Billable 476372 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH - TARGETED SEARCH PHIL SCHILLER SEARCH PROJECT;

SEARCH AND ANALYZE PHIL SCHILLER DOCUMENTS; DRAFT/EDIT

MEMO.

2/16/2018 KMD 360.00 4.00 1,440.00 Billable 476363 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 2017_12_14 FACETIME_00006; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 126-76.

2/20/2018 KMD 360.00 4.30 1,548.00 Billable 476364 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE 2.2.2018 PRODUCTION-EMAILS PARTI00003;

SEARCH, REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-85.

2/21/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 476365 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE 2.2.2018 PRODUCTION-EMAILS PARTI00003;

SEARCH, REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 86-175.

2/22/2018 KMD 360.00 4.80 1,728.00 Billable 477491 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE 2.2.2018 PRODUCTION-EMAILS PARTI00003;

SEARCH, REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 176-380.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 14 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 13

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 2/23/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 477492 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE 2.2.2018 PRODUCTION-EMAILS PARTI00003;

SEARCH, REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 381-600.

2/26/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 477493 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE 2.2.2018 PRODUCTION-EMAILS PARTI00003;

SEARCH, REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 601-800.

2/27/2018 KMD 360.00 4.40 1,584.00 Billable 477494 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE 2.2.2018 PRODUCTION-EMAILS PARTI00003;

SEARCH, REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 801-1000.

2/28/2018 KMD 360.00 4.70 1,692.00 Billable 477495 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE 2.2.2018 PRODUCTION-EMAILS PARTI00003;

SEARCH, REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1001-1250.

3/1/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 480052 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE 2.2.2018 PRODUCTION-EMAILS PARTI00003;

SEARCH, REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1251-1591.

3/2/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 480053 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE PRODUCTION SEARCHES 2.23-201800005; SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-250.

3/5/2018 KMD 360.00 2.30 828.00 Billable 480054 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH TARGETED APPLE SEARCH "GOKUL THIRUMALAI; SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY GOKUL THIRUMALAI DOCUMENTS;

DRAFT/EDIT MEMO.

3/5/2018 KMD 360.00 2.20 792.00 Billable 480055 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE PRODUCTION SEARCHES 2.23-201800005; SEARCH, Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 15 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 14

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 251-349.

3/6/2018 KMD 360.00 3.40 1,224.00 Billable 480056 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE PRODUCTION SEARCHES 2.23-201800005; SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 350-586; DRAFT BATCH

SUMMARY.

3/6/2018 KMD 360.00 1.50 540.00 Billable 480057 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE PRODUCTION SEARCHES 2.23-201800008; SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-75.

3/7/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 480058 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE PRODUCTION SEARCHES 2.23-201800008; SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 76-225.

3/8/2018 KMD 360.00 4.60 1,656.00 Billable 480059 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE PRODUCTION SEARCHES 2.23-201800008; SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 225-354.

3/9/2018 KMD 360.00 4.70 1,692.00 Billable 480060 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE PRODUCTION SEARCHES 2.23-201800008; SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 355-500; DRAFT BATCH

SUMMARY.

3/12/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 480061 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE PRODUCTION SEARCHES 2.23-201800011; SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-250.

3/13/2018 KMD 360.00 4.30 1,548.00 Billable 480062 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE PRODUCTION SEARCHES 2.23-201800011; SEARCH, Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 16 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 15

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 251-500; DRAFT BATCH

SUMMARY.

3/14/2018 KMD 360.00 0.50 180.00 Billable 480063 ATTYMTG.STR - A PREPARE FOR AND PARTICIPATE IN BI-MONTHLY CONFERENCE

CALL WITH CO-COUNSEL.

3/14/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 480064 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE PRODUCTION SEARCHES 2.23-201800013; SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-250.

3/15/2018 KMD 360.00 4.40 1,584.00 Billable 480065 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE PRODUCTION SEARCHES 2.23-201800013; SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 251-500; DRAFT BATCH

SUMMARY.

3/16/2018 KMD 360.00 4.20 1,512.00 Billable 480066 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE PRODUCTION SEARCHES 2.23-201800016; SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-250.

3/19/2018 KMD 360.00 4.00 1,440.00 Billable 480067 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE PRODUCTION SEARCHES 2.23-201800016; SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 251-500; DRAFT BATCH

SUMMARY.

3/20/2018 KMD 360.00 4.70 1,692.00 Billable 480068 DOC REVIEW-A SEARCH, REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-317.

3/21/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 480069 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH 3.15.2018APPLEBATCHES00007; SEARCH, REVIEW AND

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-250; DRAFT BATCH SUMMARY. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 17 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 16

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

3/22/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 480070 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE CONSUMER LOGS PRODUCED 2.2.2018 PART

1_00002; SEARCH, REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-250.

3/23/2018 KMD 360.00 4.60 1,656.00 Billable 480071 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE CONSUMER LOGS PRODUCED 2.2.2018 PART

1_00002; SEARCH, REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-250.

3/26/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 480073 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE CONSUMER LOGS PRODUCED 2.2.2018 PART

1_00005; SEARCH, REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-250.

3/27/2018 KMD 360.00 4.60 1,656.00 Billable 480072 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE CONSUMER LOGS PRODUCED 2.2.2018 PART

1_00005; SEARCH, REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 251-500.

3/28/2018 KMD 360.00 4.40 1,584.00 Billable 480074 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE CONSUMER LOGS PRODUCED 2.2.2018 PART

1_00006; SEARCH, REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-250.

3/29/2018 KMD 360.00 4.30 1,548.00 Billable 480075 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH APPLE CONSUMER LOGS PRODUCED 2.2.2018 PART

1_00006; SEARCH, REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 251-500.

4/2/2018 KMD 360.00 4.20 1,512.00 Billable 481815 DOC REVIEW-A 2.1.2018 FACETIME CUSTOMER LOGS_00049; SEARCH, REVIEW

AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-250.

4/3/2018 KMD 360.00 4.40 1,584.00 Billable 481816 DOC REVIEW-A 2.1.2018 FACETIME CUSTOMER LOGS_00049; SEARCH, REVIEW Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 18 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 17

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 251-500.

4/10/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 481821 DOC REVIEW-A DEATLEY_DEPOPREP_00002; SEARCH, REVIEW AND CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 1-200 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF WITNESS

DALLAS DE ATLEY; PARTICIPATE IN CONFERENCE CALL WITH

CO-COUNSEL REGARDING DEPOSITION PREPARATION

ASSIGNMENT (DALLAS DE ATLEY).

4/11/2018 KMD 360.00 4.20 1,512.00 Billable 481824 DOC REVIEW-A DEATLEY_DEPOPREP_00002; SEARCH, REVIEW AND CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 201-400 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF

WITNESS DALLAS DE ATLEY.

4/12/2018 KMD 360.00 4.40 1,584.00 Billable 481829 DOC REVIEW-A DEATLEY_DEPOPREP_00004; SEARCH, REVIEW AND CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 1-200 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF WITNESS

DALLAS DE ATLEY.

4/13/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 481831 DOC REVIEW-A DEATLEY_DEPOPREP_00004; SEARCH, REVIEW AND CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 201-400 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF

WITNESS DALLAS DE ATLEY.

4/16/2018 KMD 360.00 4.40 1,584.00 Billable 481835 DOC REVIEW-A GOKUL_DEPOPREP_00004; SEARCH, REVIEW AND CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 1-200 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF WITNESS

GOKUL THIRUMALAI.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 19 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 18

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 4/17/2018 KMD 360.00 4.30 1,548.00 Billable 481836 DOC REVIEW-A GOKUL_DEPOPREP_00004; SEARCH, REVIEW AND CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 201-400 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF

WITNESS GOKUL THIRUMALAI.

4/18/2018 KMD 360.00 4.40 1,584.00 Billable 481837 DOC REVIEW-A GOKUL_DEPOPREP_00008; SEARCH, REVIEW AND CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 1-200 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF WITNESS

GOKUL THIRUMALAI.

4/19/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 481838 DOC REVIEW-A GOKUL_DEPOPREP_00008; SEARCH, REVIEW AND CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 201-400 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF

WITNESS GOKUL THIRUMALAI.

4/20/2018 KMD 360.00 4.40 1,584.00 Billable 481839 DOC REVIEW-A 2.1.2018 FACETIME CUSTOMER LOGS_00045; SEARCH, REVIEW

AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-250.

4/23/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 481840 DOC REVIEW-A 2.1.2018 FACETIME CUSTOMER LOGS_00045; SEARCH, REVIEW

AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 251-500.

4/24/2018 KMD 360.00 4.30 1,548.00 Billable 481841 DOC REVIEW-A 2.1.2018 FACETIME CUSTOMER LOGS_00046; SEARCH, REVIEW

AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-250.

4/25/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 481842 DOC REVIEW-A 2.1.2018 FACETIME CUSTOMER LOGS_00046; SEARCH, REVIEW

AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 251-500. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 20 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 19

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

4/26/2018 KMD 360.00 4.30 1,548.00 Billable 481843 DOC REVIEW-A 2.1.2018 FACETIME CUSTOMER LOGS_00047; SEARCH, REVIEW

AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-250.

4/27/2018 KMD 360.00 4.40 1,584.00 Billable 481844 DOC REVIEW-A 2.1.2018 FACETIME CUSTOMER LOGS_00047; SEARCH, REVIEW

AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 251-500.

4/30/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 481845 DOC REVIEW-A 2.1.2018 FACETIME CUSTOMER LOGS_00048; SEARCH, REVIEW

AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-250.

5/1/2018 KMD 360.00 4.20 1,512.00 Billable 483581 DOC REVIEW-A 2.1.2018 FACETIME CUSTOMER LOGS_00044; SEARCH, REVIEW

AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-250.

5/2/2018 KMD 360.00 4.40 1,584.00 Billable 483582 DOC REVIEW-A 2.1.2018 FACETIME CUSTOMER LOGS_00044; SEARCH, REVIEW

AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 251-500.

5/3/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 483583 DOC REVIEW-A 2.1.2018 FACETIME CUSTOMER LOGS_00043; SEARCH, REVIEW

AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-250.

5/4/2018 KMD 360.00 4.30 1,548.00 Billable 483584 DOC REVIEW-A 2.1.2018 FACETIME CUSTOMER LOGS_00043; SEARCH, REVIEW

AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 251- 500.

5/7/2018 KMD 360.00 4.30 1,548.00 Billable 483585 DOC REVIEW-A 2.1.2018 FACETIME CUSTOMER LOGS_00042; SEARCH, REVIEW Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 21 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 20

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1- 250.

5/8/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 483586 DOC REVIEW-A 2.1.2018 FACETIME CUSTOMER LOGS_00042; SEARCH, REVIEW

AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 251- 500.

5/9/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 483587 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREP SAVED SEARCH; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 1-200 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF

WITNESSES PATRICK GATES, JUSTIN WOOD AND HYEONKUK

JEONG.

5/10/2018 KMD 360.00 4.40 1,584.00 Billable 483588 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREP SAVED SEARCH; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 201-400 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF

WITNESSES PATRICK GATES, JUSTIN WOOD AND HYEONKUK

JEONG.

5/11/2018 KMD 360.00 4.30 1,548.00 Billable 483589 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREP SAVED SEARCH; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 401-620 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF

WITNESSES PATRICK GATES, JUSTIN WOOD AND HYEONKUK

JEONG.

5/14/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 483590 DEP PREP-A GOKUL_DEPPREP_00008; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 621-866 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF

WITNESSES PATRICK GATES, JUSTIN WOOD AND HYEONKUK

JEONG.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 22 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 21

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 5/15/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 484654 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREP_STAGE 3_00004; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 1-200 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF

WITNESSES PATRICK GATES, JUSTIN WOOD AND HYEONKUK

JEONG.

5/16/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 484655 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREP_STAGE 3_00004; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 201-402 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF

WITNESSES PATRICK GATES, JUSTIN WOOD AND HYEONKUK

JEONG.

5/17/2018 KMD 360.00 2.30 828.00 Billable 484656 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREP_STAGE 3_00004; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 403-500 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF

WITNESSES PATRICK GATES, JUSTIN WOOD AND HYEONKUK

JEONG.

5/17/2018 KMD 360.00 2.00 720.00 Billable 484657 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREP_STAGE 3_00005; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 1-50 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF

WITNESSES PATRICK GATES, JUSTIN WOOD AND HYEONKUK

JEONG.

5/18/2018 KMD 360.00 4.10 1,476.00 Billable 484658 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREP_STAGE 3_00005; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 51-250 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF

WITNESSES PATRICK GATES, JUSTIN WOOD AND HYEONKUK

JEONG. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 23 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 22

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

5/21/2018 KMD 360.00 4.20 1,512.00 Billable 484659 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREP_STAGE 3_00005; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 251-500 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF

WITNESSES PATRICK GATES, JUSTIN WOOD AND HYEONKUK

JEONG.

5/22/2018 KMD 360.00 4.00 1,440.00 Billable 484660 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREP_STAGE 3_00008; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 1-200 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF

WITNESSES PATRICK GATES, JUSTIN WOOD AND HYEONKUK

JEONG.

5/23/2018 KMD 360.00 4.30 1,548.00 Billable 484661 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREP_STAGE 3_00008; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 201-400 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF

WITNESSES PATRICK GATES, JUSTIN WOOD AND HYEONKUK

JEONG.

5/24/2018 KMD 360.00 2.70 972.00 Billable 484662 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREP_STAGE 3_00008; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 400-500 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF

WITNESSES PATRICK GATES, JUSTIN WOOD AND HYEONKUK

JEONG.

5/25/2018 KMD 360.00 3.50 1,260.00 Billable 484663 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREP_STAGE 3_00010; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 1-200 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF

WITNESSES PATRICK GATES, JUSTIN WOOD AND HYEONKUK

JEONG. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 24 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 23

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

5/29/2018 KMD 360.00 4.00 1,440.00 Billable 484664 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREP_STAGE 3_00010; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 201-400 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF

WITNESSES PATRICK GATES, JUSTIN WOOD AND HYEONKUK

JEONG.

5/30/2018 KMD 360.00 2.00 720.00 Billable 484665 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREP_STAGE 3_00010; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 400-501 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF

WITNESSES PATRICK GATES, JUSTIN WOOD AND HYEONKUK

JEONG.

6/1/2018 KMD 360.00 4.30 1,548.00 Billable 486336 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREPLL_0000003; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 1-200 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF TEN

APPLE WITNESSES.

6/4/2018 KMD 360.00 4.20 1,512.00 Billable 486337 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREPLL_0000003; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 201-350 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF TEN

APPLE WITNESSES.

6/5/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 486338 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREPLL_0000003; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 351-500 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF TEN

APPLE WITNESSES.

6/6/2018 KMD 360.00 4.40 1,584.00 Billable 486339 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREPLL_0000004; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 25 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 24

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

DOCUMENTS 1-100 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF TEN

APPLE WITNESSES.

6/7/2018 KMD 360.00 4.30 1,548.00 Billable 486340 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREPLL_0000004; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 101-205 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF TEN

APPLE WITNESSES.

6/8/2018 KMD 360.00 4.40 1,584.00 Billable 486341 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREPLL_0000004; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 206-300 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF TEN

APPLE WITNESSES.

6/11/2018 KMD 360.00 4.20 1,512.00 Billable 486342 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREPLL_0000004; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 301-410 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF TEN

APPLE WITNESSES.

6/12/2018 KMD 360.00 4.00 1,440.00 Billable 487548 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREPLL_0000004; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS 411-500 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF TEN

APPLE WITNESSES.

6/13/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 487549 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREP KIT ASSIGNMENT; SEARCH, REVIEW AND DRAFT

DEPO PREPARATION NOTES FOR APPLE DEPONENT JUSTIN

WOOD.

6/14/2018 KMD 360.00 4.10 1,476.00 Billable 487550 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREP KIT ASSIGNMENT; SEARCH, REVIEW AND DRAFT Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 26 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 25

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

DEPO PREPARATION NOTES FOR APPLE DEPONENT JUSTIN

WOOD.

6/15/2018 KMD 360.00 4.00 1,440.00 Billable 487551 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREP KIT ASSIGNMENT; SEARCH, REVIEW AND DRAFT

DEPO PREPARATION NOTES FOR APPLE DEPONENT JUSTIN

WOOD.

6/18/2018 KMD 360.00 4.20 1,512.00 Billable 487552 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREP KIT ASSIGNMENT; SEARCH, REVIEW AND DRAFT

DEPO PREPARATION NOTES FOR APPLE DEPONENT JUSTIN

WOOD.

6/19/2018 KMD 360.00 4.40 1,584.00 Billable 487553 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREPLL_0000007; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS #1-100 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF TEN

APPLE WITNESSES.

6/20/2018 KMD 360.00 4.10 1,476.00 Billable 487554 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREPLL_0000007; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS #101-249 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF TEN

APPLE WITNESSES.

6/21/2018 KMD 360.00 4.30 1,548.00 Billable 487555 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREPLL_0000007; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS #250-350 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF TEN

APPLE WITNESSES.

6/22/2018 KMD 360.00 4.20 1,512.00 Billable 487556 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREPLL_0000007; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 27 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 26

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

DOCUMENTS #351-500 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF TEN

APPLE WITNESSES.

6/25/2018 KMD 360.00 4.00 1,440.00 Billable 487557 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREPLL_00000015; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS #1-100 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF TEN

APPLE WITNESSES.

6/26/2018 KMD 360.00 4.10 1,476.00 Billable 487558 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREPLL_00000015; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS #101-230 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF TEN

APPLE WITNESSES.

6/27/2018 KMD 360.00 3.50 1,260.00 Billable 487559 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREPLL_00000015; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS #231-300 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF TEN

APPLE WITNESSES.

6/28/2018 KMD 360.00 3.60 1,296.00 Billable 487560 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREPLL_00000015; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS #301-400 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF TEN

APPLE WITNESSES.

6/29/2018 KMD 360.00 3.10 1,116.00 Billable 487561 DEP PREP-A DEPO PREPLL_00000015; SEARCH, REVIEW CLASSIFY

DOCUMENTS #401-500 FOR DEPOSITION PREPARATION OF TEN

APPLE WITNESSES.

7/3/2018 KMD 360.00 4.30 1,548.00 Billable 490130 DEP PREP-A SEARCH, REVIEW, CLASSIFY AND DRAFT DEPOSITION Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 28 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 27

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

PREPARATION NOTES FOR EDDY CUE AND CRAIG FEDERIGHI.

7/5/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 490131 DEP PREP-A SEARCH, REVIEW, CLASSIFY AND DRAFT DEPOSITION

PREPARATION NOTES FOR EDDY CUE AND CRAIG FEDERIGHI.

7/6/2018 KMD 360.00 4.00 1,440.00 Billable 490132 DEP PREP-A SEARCH, REVIEW, CLASSIFY AND DRAFT DEPOSITION

PREPARATION NOTES FOR EDDY CUE AND CRAIG FEDERIGHI.

7/9/2018 KMD 360.00 4.20 1,512.00 Billable 490148 DEP PREP-A SEARCH, REVIEW, CLASSIFY AND DRAFT DEPOSITION

PREPARATION NOTES FOR EDDY CUE AND CRAIG FEDERIGHI.

7/10/2018 KMD 360.00 3.30 1,188.00 Billable 490133 DEP PREP-A SEARCH, REVIEW, CLASSIFY AND DRAFT DEPOSITION

PREPARATION NOTES FOR EDDY CUE AND CRAIG FEDERIGHI.

7/11/2018 KMD 360.00 8.80 3,168.00 Billable 490134 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH - UNREVIEWED APPLE PRODUCTIONS00002; SEARCH,

REVIEW, CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-500.

7/12/2018 KMD 360.00 8.80 3,168.00 Billable 490135 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH - 2017.12.22_APPLE PRODUCTION_00012; SEARCH,

REVIEW, CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-500.

7/13/2018 KMD 360.00 8.70 3,132.00 Billable 490136 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH - 2017.12.22_APPLE PRODUCTION_00013; SEARCH,

REVIEW, CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-500.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 29 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 28

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 7/16/2018 KMD 360.00 8.50 3,060.00 Billable 490137 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH - 1.29.2018 FACETIME PRODUCTION-CUSTOMER

LOGS00006; SEARCH, REVIEW, CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-500.

7/17/2018 KMD 360.00 8.20 2,952.00 Billable 490138 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH - 3.15.20108APPLEBATCHES00007; SEARCH, REVIEW,

CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-500.

7/18/2018 KMD 360.00 8.50 3,060.00 Billable 490139 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH - APPLE PRODUCTION SEARCHES 2.23.201800013;

SEARCH, REVIEW, CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-500.

7/19/2018 KMD 360.00 8.20 2,952.00 Billable 490140 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH - APPLE PRODUCTION SEARCHES 2.23.201800011;

SEARCH, REVIEW, CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-500.

7/20/2018 KMD 360.00 6.80 2,448.00 Billable 490141 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH - APPLE PRODUCTION SEARCHES 2.23.201800008;

SEARCH, REVIEW, CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-300.

7/23/2018 KMD 360.00 3.00 1,080.00 Billable 490142 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH - APPLE PRODUCTION SEARCHES 2.23.201800008;

SEARCH, REVIEW, CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 301-500.

7/24/2018 KMD 360.00 3.00 1,080.00 Billable 490143 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH - APPLE PRODUCTION SEARCHES 2.23.201800005;

SEARCH, REVIEW, CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-200.

7/25/2018 KMD 360.00 3.00 1,080.00 Billable 490144 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH - APPLE PRODUCTION SEARCHES 2.23.201800005;

SEARCH, REVIEW, CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 201-420. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 30 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 29

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

7/26/2018 KMD 360.00 3.00 1,080.00 Billable 490145 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH - APPLE PRODUCTION SEARCHES 2.23.201800005;

SEARCH, REVIEW, CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 421-586.

7/27/2018 KMD 360.00 3.00 1,080.00 Billable 490146 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH - 2.1.2018 FACETIME CUSTOMER LOGS_00048; SEARCH

REVIEW, CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 1-215.

7/30/2018 KMD 360.00 2.50 900.00 Billable 490147 DOC REVIEW-A BATCH - 2.1.2018 FACETIME CUSTOMER LOGS_00048; SEARCH

REVIEW, CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS 216-500.

8/1/2018 KMD 360.00 8.10 2,916.00 Billable 491155 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS IN BATCH [1.29.2018

FACETIME PRODUCTION- CUSTOMER LOGS00007].

8/2/2018 KMD 360.00 8.20 2,952.00 Billable 491156 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS IN BATCH [1.29.2018

FACETIME PRODUCTION- CUSTOMER LOGS00009].

8/3/2018 KMD 360.00 7.80 2,808.00 Billable 491158 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS IN BATCH [2017_12_14

FACETIME_00007].

8/6/2018 KMD 360.00 7.70 2,772.00 Billable 491152 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - SEARCH, Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 31 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 30

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS IN BATCH [2017.12.22

_APPLE PRODUCTION_00020].

8/7/2018 KMD 360.00 1.00 360.00 Billable 490747 DOC REVIEW-A PREPARE AND PARTICIPATE IN TELEPHONE CALL WITH

CO-COUNSEL; JILL MANNING, SUNEEL JAIN AND CAMERON WEISS.

8/7/2018 KMD 360.00 0.50 180.00 Billable 491151 DEP PREP-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 DOCUMENT REVIEW -

SEARCH AND CREATE CRAIG FEDERIGHI SPECIFIC DEPOSITION

DOCUMENTS SAVED SEARCH ON RELATIVITY AS REQUESTED BY

JILL MANNING.

8/7/2018 KMD 360.00 8.00 2,880.00 Billable 491159 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS IN BATCH [2017.12.22

_APPLE PRODUCTION_00019].

8/8/2018 KMD 360.00 2.00 720.00 Billable 490734 DOC REVIEW-A REVIEW THE MOTION FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION, OPPOSITION

BRIEF AND REPLY BRIEF IN PREPARATION FOR DOCUMENT

REVIEW.

8/8/2018 KMD 360.00 5.40 1,944.00 Billable 491160 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS IN BATCH [2017.12.22

_APPLE PRODUCTION_00021].

8/9/2018 KMD 360.00 4.30 1,548.00 Billable 491147 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - SEARCH, Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 32 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 31

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS IN BATCH [2017.12.22

_APPLE PRODUCTION_00021].

8/9/2018 KMD 360.00 4.00 1,440.00 Billable 491153 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 DOCUMENT REVIEW -

PERFORM TARGETED SEARCH OF DOCUMENTS RELATED TO

APPLE EFFORTS TO REDUCE RELAY USAGE AND DRAFT/EDIT

NARRATIVE MEMO.

8/10/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 491148 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 DOCUMENT REVIEW -

PERFORM TARGETED SEARCH OF DOCUMENTS RELATED TO

APPLE EFFORTS TO REDUCE RELAY USAGE AND DRAFT/EDIT

NARRATIVE MEMO.

8/13/2018 KMD 360.00 4.20 1,512.00 Billable 491149 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 DOCUMENT REVIEW -

PERFORM TARGETED SEARCH OF DOCUMENTS RELATED TO

APPLE EFFORTS TO REDUCE RELAY USAGE AND DRAFT/EDIT

NARRATIVE MEMO.

8/13/2018 KMD 360.00 4.20 1,512.00 Billable 491169 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS IN BATCH [1.29.2018

FACETIME PRODUCTION- CUSTOMER LOGS00010].

8/14/2018 KMD 360.00 4.40 1,584.00 Billable 491145 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS IN BATCH [1.29.2018

FACETIME PRODUCTION- CUSTOMER LOGS00010]. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 33 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 32

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

8/15/2018 KMD 360.00 4.50 1,620.00 Billable 491150 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - TIER 2 DOCUMENT REVIEW -

PERFORM TARGETED SEARCH OF DOCUMENTS RELATED TO

APPLE EFFORTS TO REDUCE RELAY USAGE AND DRAFT/EDIT

NARRATIVE MEMO.

8/16/2018 KMD 360.00 3.50 1,260.00 Billable 492177 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY [BATCH 8343_CUSTOMERLOGS00007].

8/17/2018 KMD 360.00 3.70 1,332.00 Billable 492173 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY [BATCH 8343_CUSTOMERLOGS00007].

8/20/2018 KMD 360.00 1.70 612.00 Billable 492174 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - TARGETED

SEARCH REDUCE RELAY USAGE/DRAFT AND EDIT ISSUE MEMO.

8/21/2018 KMD 360.00 1.80 648.00 Billable 492196 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - TARGETED

SEARCH REDUCE RELAY USAGE/DRAFT AND EDIT ISSUE MEMO.

8/22/2018 KMD 360.00 2.10 756.00 Billable 492197 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - TARGETED

SEARCH REDUCE RELAY USAGE/DRAFT AND EDIT ISSUE MEMO.

8/23/2018 KMD 360.00 1.80 648.00 Billable 492219 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - TARGETED

SEARCH REDUCE RELAY USAGE/DRAFT AND EDIT ISSUE MEMO. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 34 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 33

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

8/24/2018 KMD 360.00 2.00 720.00 Billable 492198 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - TARGETED

SEARCH REDUCE RELAY USAGE/DRAFT AND EDIT ISSUE MEMO.

8/27/2018 KMD 360.00 2.00 720.00 Billable 492220 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY [BATCH 2017.12.22 _APPLE

PRODUCTION_00014].

8/28/2018 KMD 360.00 2.10 756.00 Billable 492178 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY [BATCH 2017.12.22 _APPLE

PRODUCTION_00014].

8/29/2018 KMD 360.00 2.00 720.00 Billable 492199 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY [BATCH 2017.12.22 _APPLE

PRODUCTION_00014].

8/30/2018 KMD 360.00 1.90 684.00 Billable 492221 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY [BATCH 2017.12.22 _APPLE

PRODUCTION_00014].

8/31/2018 KMD 360.00 1.00 360.00 Billable 492179 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY [BATCH 2017.12.22 _APPLE

PRODUCTION_00014].

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 35 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 34

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 8/31/2018 KMD 360.00 2.00 720.00 Billable 492222 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - TARGETED

SEARCH REDUCE RELAY USAGE/DRAFT AND EDIT ISSUE MEMO.

9/4/2018 KMD 360.00 2.00 720.00 Billable 493966 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS [1.29.2018 FACETIME

PRODUCTION - CUSTOMER LOGS00012].

9/5/2018 KMD 360.00 2.00 720.00 Billable 493965 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS [1.29.2018 FACETIME

PRODUCTION - CUSTOMER LOGS00012].

9/6/2018 KMD 360.00 1.90 684.00 Billable 493972 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS [1.29.2018 FACETIME

PRODUCTION - CUSTOMER LOGS00012].

9/7/2018 KMD 360.00 2.20 792.00 Billable 493973 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - SEARCH,

REVIEW, CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS [1.29.2018 FACETIME

PRODUCTION - CUSTOMER LOGS00012].

9/10/2018 KMD 360.00 2.00 720.00 Billable 493970 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - PERFORM

TARGETED SEARCH OF DOCUMENTS RELATED TO APPLE'S

EFFORT TO REDUCE RELAY USAGE AND DRAFT/EDIT MEMO.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 36 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 35

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 9/10/2018 KMD 360.00 0.20 72.00 Billable 493974 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - E-MAIL WITH

JILL MANNING AND CAM WEISS REGARDING CASE UPDATE AND

ONGOING MEMO PROJECT STATUS.

9/11/2018 KMD 360.00 2.00 720.00 Billable 493975 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS [APPLE CUSTOMER LOGS

PRODUCED 2.2.2018 PART 1_00004.

9/12/2018 KMD 360.00 2.00 720.00 Billable 493967 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS [APPLE CUSTOMER LOGS

PRODUCED 2.2.2018 PART 1_00004].

9/13/2018 KMD 360.00 2.00 720.00 Billable 493969 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS [APPLE CUSTOMER LOGS

PRODUCED 2.2.2018 PART 1_00004.

9/14/2018 KMD 360.00 1.90 684.00 Billable 493968 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - SEARCH,

REVIEW AND CLASSIFY DOCUMENTS [APPLE CUSTOMER LOGS

PRODUCED 2.2.2018 PART 1_00004].

9/19/2018 KMD 360.00 3.00 1,080.00 Billable 494388 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACE v APPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - PERFORM

TARGETED SEARCH OF DOCUMENTS RELATED TO APPLE'S

EFFORT TO REDUCE RELAY USAGE; DRAFT/EDIT ISSUES

MEMORANDUM. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 37 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 36

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

9/19/2018 KMD 360.00 0.30 108.00 Billable 494392 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACEvAPPLE - CONFERENCE CALL WITH JILL

MANNING AND CAM WEISS REGARDING CASE UPDATE/CA CLASS

CERTIFICATION; FINALIZE ISSUE MEMO.

9/19/2018 KMD 360.00 0.20 72.00 Billable 494395 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACE v APPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - E-MAIL WITH

JILL MANNING AND CAM WEISS REGARDING FINALIZING ISSUE

MEMORANDA FOR APPLE'S ATTEMPT TO REDUCE RELAY USAGE.

9/19/2018 KMD 360.00 0.90 324.00 Billable 494396 DOC REVIEW-A APL-PW0006-GRACE v APPLE - DOCUMENT REVIEW - REVIEW OF

JUDGE KOH'S ORDER GRANTING IN PART AND DENYING IN PART

MOTION FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION.

TOTAL Billable Fees 839.20 $300,400.00

Total of billable expense slips $0.00

Calculation of Fees and Costs

Amount Total Fees Bill Arrangement: Slips By billing value on each slip.

Total of billable time slips $300,400.00 Total of Fees (Time Charges) $300,400.00

Total of Costs (Expense Charges) $0.00

Total new charges $300,400.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-10 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 38 of 38 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:51 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 37

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Amount Total New Balance Current $300,400.00

Total New Balance $300,400.00

Funds Account: Default Previous account balance $0.00 Total added to account $0.00 Total removed from account $0.00

New account balance $0.00

Amount to replenish account to $0.00 $0.00

Attorney Summary

Attorney Rate Hours Charges Slip Value Adjustment KMD 360.00 753.60 $271,296.00 $271,296.00 0.00 KMD 340.00 85.60 $29,104.00 $29,104.00 0.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-11 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 5

EXHIBIT 9 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-11 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 5 STEYER LOWENTHAL BOODROOKAS 11/24/2020 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11:55 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 1

Selection Criteria

Atto.Selection Include: LLG Clie.Selection Include: APPLE.FACETIME Slip.Transaction Date Earliest - 10/31/2020 Slip.Billing Status Billable Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-11 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 3 of 5 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:55 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 2

Nickname APPLE.FACETIME | 4457-CONT Full Name CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) Address CONSUMER CLASS ACTION - APPLE RE FACETIME FEATURE Phone 1 Phone 2 Phone 3 Phone 4 In Ref To APPLE, INC. - IN REGARDING FACETIME FEATURE Fees Arrg. By billing value on each slip Expense Arrg. By billing value on each slip Tax Profile Exempt Last bill Last charge 2/13/2017 Last payment Amount $0.00

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 2/6/2017 LLG 300.00 2.00 600.00 Billable 447051 RESEARCH-A PREPARE MEMO FOR A. STEYER REGARDING DISTRICT COURT

JUDGES DAVILA AND FOGEL.

2/7/2017 LLG 300.00 0.40 120.00 Billable 447071 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEETING WITH A. STEYER TO DISCUSS CASE STATUS AND NEW

ASSIGNMENT.

2/7/2017 LLG 300.00 1.30 390.00 Billable 447072 RESEARCH-A REVIEW CASE DOCUMENTS.

2/8/2017 LLG 300.00 6.00 1,800.00 Billable 447089 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH JUDGE FOGEL'S CLASS CERTIFICATION CASES.

2/9/2017 LLG 300.00 4.10 1,230.00 Billable 447090 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH JUDGE FOGEL'S PRIOR CLASS ACTION CASES.

2/9/2017 LLG 300.00 3.00 900.00 Billable 447091 RESEARCH-A PREPARE MEMO ON JUDGE FOGEL'S PRIOR CLASS ACTION

CASES.

2/10/2017 LLG 300.00 5.00 1,500.00 Billable 447119 RESEARCH-A PREPARE MEMO REGARDING JUDGE JEREMY FOGEL.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-11 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 4 of 5 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:55 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 3

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 2/13/2017 LLG 300.00 0.40 120.00 Billable 447265 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEETING WITH A. STEYER TO REVIEW JUDGE FOGEL MEMO AND

DISCUSS CHANGES.

2/13/2017 LLG 300.00 3.00 900.00 Billable 447266 RESEARCH-A REVISE JUDGE FOGEL MEMO WITH ADDITIONAL CASE RESEARCH.

TOTAL Billable Fees 25.20 $7,560.00

Total of billable expense slips $0.00

Calculation of Fees and Costs

Amount Total Fees Bill Arrangement: Slips By billing value on each slip.

Total of billable time slips $7,560.00 Total of Fees (Time Charges) $7,560.00

Total of Costs (Expense Charges) $0.00

Total new charges $7,560.00

New Balance Current $7,560.00

Total New Balance $7,560.00

Funds Account: Default Previous account balance $0.00 Total added to account $0.00 Total removed from account $0.00

New account balance $0.00

Amount to replenish account to $0.00 $0.00

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-11 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 5 of 5 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:55 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 4

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Attorney Summary

Attorney Rate Hours Charges Slip Value Adjustment LLG 300.00 25.20 $7,560.00 $7,560.00 0.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-12 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 13

EXHIBIT 10 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-12 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 13 STEYER LOWENTHAL BOODROOKAS 11/24/2020 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11:53 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 1

Selection Criteria

Atto.Selection Include: PG Clie.Selection Include: APPLE.FACETIME Slip.Transaction Date Earliest - 10/31/2020 Slip.Billing Status Billable Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-12 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 3 of 13 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:53 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 2

Nickname APPLE.FACETIME | 4457-CONT Full Name CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) Address CONSUMER CLASS ACTION - APPLE RE FACETIME FEATURE Phone 1 Phone 2 Phone 3 Phone 4 In Ref To APPLE, INC. - IN REGARDING FACETIME FEATURE Fees Arrg. By billing value on each slip Expense Arrg. By billing value on each slip Tax Profile Exempt Last bill Last charge 10/26/2018 Last payment Amount $0.00

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 8/1/2017 PG 195.00 1.50 292.50 Billable 463241 PLDS/MO-A READ COMPLAINT AND MOTION TO DISMISS.

8/2/2017 PG 195.00 1.00 195.00 Billable 463242 PLDS/MO-A READ FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT AND MOTION TO DISMISS.

8/4/2017 PG 195.00 1.50 292.50 Billable 463248 DISCOVERY-A TESTIMONY RESEARCH; GATHER AND ORGANIZE ON-LINE

COMPLAINTS REGARDING IPHONE4 AND IOS7.

8/7/2017 PG 195.00 6.40 1,248.00 Billable 463249 DISCOVERY-A TESTIMONY RESEARCH; GATHER AND ORGANIZE ON-LINE

COMPLAINTS REGARDING IPHONE4 AND IOS7.

8/8/2017 PG 195.00 5.00 975.00 Billable 463250 DISCOVERY-A TESTIMONY RESEARCH; GATHER AND ORGANIZE ON-LINE

COMPLAINTS REGARDING IPHONE4 AND IOS7; DETERMINE MOST

COMMON WORDS IN COMPLAINT TO PREPARE DATA SEARCH

TERMS.

8/9/2017 PG 195.00 6.10 1,189.50 Billable 463251 DISCOVERY-A TESTIMONY RESEARCH; GATHER AND ORGANIZE ON-LINE

COMPLAINTS REGARDING IPHONE4 AND IOS7 ; DISCUSSION

REGARDING SAME. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-12 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 4 of 13 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:53 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 3

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

8/10/2017 PG 195.00 3.10 604.50 Billable 463252 DISCOVERY-A TESTIMONY RESEARCH; GATHER AND ORGANIZE ON-LINE

COMPLAINTS REGARDING IPHONE4 AND IOS7.

8/11/2017 PG 195.00 4.00 780.00 Billable 463253 DISCOVERY-A PREPARE DEFENDANT WITNESS CHART.

8/15/2017 PG 195.00 2.10 409.50 Billable 463255 DISCOVERY-A PREPARE TESTIMONY RESEARCH MEMORANDUM; RESEARCH;

PREPARE MEMORANDUM.

9/29/2017 PG 195.00 0.40 78.00 Billable 468282 DOC REVIEW-A RELATIVITY TRAINING FOR DOCUMENT REVIEW.

10/10/2017 PG 195.00 4.00 780.00 Billable 468293 DOC REVIEW-A PREPARE FOR RELATIVITY TRAINING.

10/11/2017 PG 195.00 3.00 585.00 Billable 468294 DOC REVIEW-A DOCUMENT REVIEW MEETING AND TUTORIAL.

10/12/2017 PG 195.00 1.50 292.50 Billable 468296 DOC REVIEW-A DOCUMENT REVIEW REGARDING DOCS APL-GRACE_ 00000001 -

APL-GRACE_00000267.

10/16/2017 PG 195.00 1.00 195.00 Billable 468297 DOC REVIEW-A DOCUMENT REVIEW REGARDING DOCS APL-GRACE_ 00000001 -

APL-GRACE_00000267.

10/18/2017 PG 195.00 0.50 97.50 Billable 468298 DOC REVIEW-A DOCUMENT REVIEW REGARDING DOCS APL-GRACE_ 00000001 - Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-12 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 5 of 13 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:53 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 4

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt APL-GRACE_00000267.

10/24/2017 PG 195.00 0.40 78.00 Billable 468299 DISCOVERY-A UPDATE WITNESS LIST.

12/5/2017 PG 195.00 1.50 292.50 Billable 473017 DISCOVERY-A DETERMINE IF DOCUMENT PRODUCTION 4 CONTAINS ANY

DUPLICATE SERIAL NUMBERS.

12/6/2017 PG 195.00 1.50 292.50 Billable 473018 DISCOVERY-A CHECK FOR DUPLICATE SERIAL NUMBERS.

1/4/2018 PG 195.00 0.50 97.50 Billable 473029 DISCOVERY-A PREPARE CASE LAW BINDER FOR J. MANNING CLASS

CERTIFICATION BRIEF.

1/8/2018 PG 195.00 0.20 39.00 Billable 475266 DISCOVERY-A INVESTIGATE ABILITY TO SEARCH TEXT MESSAGES.

1/8/2018 PG 195.00 0.50 97.50 Billable 475267 DISCOVERY-A PREPARE HOT/EXCERPT RELATIVITY DOCUMENTS FOR J.

MANNING; CREATE SHAREFILE.

1/8/2018 PG 195.00 0.20 39.00 Billable 475269 DISCOVERY-A PREPARE SUBPOENAS.

1/9/2018 PG 195.00 0.50 97.50 Billable 475271 DISCOVERY-A PREPARE SUBPOENAS.

1/30/2018 PG 195.00 3.00 585.00 Billable 475697 RESEARCH-A CLASS CERTIFICATION CASE LAW RESEARCH.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-12 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 6 of 13 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:53 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 5

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 1/31/2018 PG 195.00 0.70 136.50 Billable 475699 RESEARCH-A CLASS CERTIFICATION CASE LAW RESEARCH.

2/1/2018 PG 195.00 0.50 97.50 Billable 475701 DISCOVERY-A LOCATE DOCUMENTS FROM RELATIVITY; PREPARE SHAREFILE.

2/5/2018 PG 195.00 0.50 97.50 Billable 475710 DISCOVERY-A OPEN RAR DOCUMENT; PREPARE SHAREFILE.

2/20/2018 PG 195.00 0.50 97.50 Billable 476556 DISCOVERY-A ADDRESS RESEARCH FOR SERVICE OF PROCESS.

3/2/2018 PG 195.00 2.00 390.00 Billable 477601 DISCOVERY-A PREPARE "PRODUCED DOCUMENTS" LOG FOR CLIENT'S

DOCUMENT PRODUCTION.

3/6/2018 PG 195.00 1.00 195.00 Billable 480154 DISCOVERY-A PRODUCE KEN POTTER'S LATEST PRODUCTION.

3/7/2018 PG 195.00 2.00 390.00 Billable 480159 DISCOVERY-A REDACT K. POTTER DOCUMENT PRODUCTION.

3/8/2018 PG 195.00 4.50 877.50 Billable 480161 DISCOVERY-A REDACT K. POTTER DOCUMENT PRODUCTION.

3/20/2018 PG 195.00 1.00 195.00 Billable 480194 DISCOVERY-A ORGANIZE KEN POTTER'S FACETIME LOGS.

4/3/2018 PG 195.00 3.50 682.50 Billable 483199 DISCOVERY-A RESEARCH ON APPLE EXECUTIVES.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-12 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 7 of 13 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:53 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 6

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 4/4/2018 PG 195.00 1.70 331.50 Billable 483200 DISCOVERY-A RESEARCH ON APPLE EXECUTIVES.

4/10/2018 PG 195.00 2.50 487.50 Billable 483201 RESEARCH-A SEARCH, CULL AND INVENTORY HOT DOCUMENTS THAT

MENTION DALLAS DE ATLEY.

4/11/2018 PG 195.00 0.50 97.50 Billable 483202 DISCOVERY-A UPDATE INVENTORY FOR HOT DOCUMENTS (DALLAS DE ATLEY).

4/11/2018 PG 195.00 3.70 721.50 Billable 483203 DISCOVERY-A PRINT, INVENTORY AND ORGANIZE DALLAS DE ARTLEY

DOCUMENTS.

4/12/2018 PG 195.00 4.50 877.50 Billable 483204 DISCOVERY-A PRINT, INVENTORY AND ORGANIZE DALLAS DE ATLEY

DOCUMENTS.

4/24/2018 PG 195.00 3.00 585.00 Billable 483205 PLDS/MO-A ADD REFERENCES TO CERTIFICATION BRIEF.

4/25/2018 PG 195.00 2.00 390.00 Billable 483206 PLDS/MO-A DOWNLOAD CORRESPONDING DOCUMENTS FOR CLASS

CERTIFICATION BRIEF.

4/26/2018 PG 195.00 0.20 39.00 Billable 483207 PLDS/MO-A UPLOAD DOCUMENTS FOR J. MANNING DECLARATION.

5/9/2018 PG 195.00 5.00 975.00 Billable 483681 DISCOVERY-A RUN RELATIVITY SEARCHES ON PATRICK GATES; PREPARE

DEPOSITION BINDERS FOR KEN POTTER AND CHRISTINA GRACE. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-12 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 8 of 13 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:53 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 7

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

5/10/2018 PG 195.00 5.00 975.00 Billable 483684 DEP PREP-A PREPARE DEPOSITION BINDERS FOR KEN POTTER AND

CHRISTINA GRACE.

5/11/2018 PG 195.00 3.00 585.00 Billable 483686 DEP PREP-A RAN RELATIVITY SEARCHES FOR KEN POTTER RELATED

DOCUMENTS.

5/18/2018 PG 195.00 4.50 877.50 Billable 483694 PLDS/MO-A PREPARE MATERIALS FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION MEETING.

6/6/2018 PG 195.00 5.00 975.00 Billable 486435 EXPERTS-A PREPARE HASTINGS REPORT BINDER FOR J. MANNING.

6/13/2018 PG 195.00 1.00 195.00 Billable 486430 PLDS/MO-A PREPARE UNREDACTED VERSIONS OF PLEADINGS FOR

CO-COUNSEL.

6/18/2018 PG 220.00 0.50 110.00 Billable 488714 DEP PREP-A PREPARE HASTINGS DEPOSITION BINDER.

7/10/2018 PG 195.00 3.70 721.50 Billable 489292 ATTYMTG.STR - A MEET WITH J. MANNING AND S. JAIN REGARDING REPLY

MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES ISO CLASS

CERTIFICATION; ORGANIZE EXHIBIT DOCUMENTS TO SAME.

7/11/2018 PG 195.00 0.50 97.50 Billable 489297 PLDS/MO-A ORGANIZE EXHIBIT DOCUMENTS FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION

FILING.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-12 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 9 of 13 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:53 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 8

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt 7/12/2018 PG 195.00 3.70 721.50 Billable 489298 PLDS/MO-A ORGANIZE EXHIBIT DOCUMENTS FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION

FILING.

7/24/2018 PG 195.00 5.50 1,072.50 Billable 489624 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH DEMONSTRATIVE HEARING RULES; INDEX ALL

WORKS CITED IN CLASS CERTIFICATION.

7/25/2018 PG 195.00 1.50 292.50 Billable 489625 RESEARCH-A RESEARCH DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBIT RULES; FINALIZE ALL

WORKS CITED IN CLASS CERTIFICATION SPREADSHEET.

8/2/2018 PG 195.00 6.00 1,170.00 Billable 493406 DISCOVERY-A PREPARE DOCUMENTS FOR FURTHER DISCOVERY REQUESTS.

8/7/2018 PG 195.00 2.00 390.00 Billable 493408 DISCOVERY-A AMEND HOT DOCUMENT LIST FROM CLASS CERTIFICATION

BRIEFS.

8/8/2018 PG 195.00 4.70 916.50 Billable 493409 DISCOVERY-A COMPARE CLASS CERTIFICATION DOCUMENTS TO AUTHORIZED

DOCUMENTS; ORGANIZE JOINT CASE MANAGEMENT LETTER

DOCUMENTS.

8/9/2018 PG 195.00 3.00 585.00 Billable 493410 DISCOVERY-A LOCATE PLAINTIFF TESTIMONY PERTAINING TO FUNCTIONALITY

OF PHONE.

8/21/2018 PG 195.00 0.50 97.50 Billable 493415 PLDS/MO-A PREPARE EXHIBITS TO JOINT LETTER BRIEF FOR S. JAIN AND

CO-COUNSEL. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-12 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 10 of 13 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:53 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 9

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

8/30/2018 PG 195.00 3.00 585.00 Billable 493421 DISCOVERY-A LOCATE APPLE IPHONE 4/4S RECEIPTS FOR PLAINTIFFS IN

RELATIVITY.

9/4/2018 PG 195.00 4.20 819.00 Billable 495666 DOC REVIEW-A PREPARE SDDF PRODUCTION.

9/5/2018 PG 195.00 6.80 1,326.00 Billable 495667 DOC REVIEW-A PREPARE SDDF PRODUCTION.

9/13/2018 PG 195.00 3.00 585.00 Billable 495668 DOC REVIEW-A SDDF DOCUMENT REVIEW.

9/18/2018 PG 195.00 0.30 58.50 Billable 495669 DISCOVERY-A READ CLASS CERTIFICATION ORDER; SEARCH FOR DISCOVERY

VERIFICATIONS FOR S. JAIN.

9/20/2018 PG 195.00 2.20 429.00 Billable 495670 DOC REVIEW-A DETERMINE NUMBER OF FILES IN SDDF PRODUCTION.

9/21/2018 PG 195.00 0.50 97.50 Billable 495671 DISCOVERY-A SEARCH FOR DOCUMENTS FOR CO-COUNSEL; DETERMINE

NUMBER OF FILES IN SDDF PRODUCTION.

9/24/2018 PG 195.00 2.20 429.00 Billable 495672 DEP PREP-A PREPARE DOCUMENTS FOR J. MANNING DEPOSITIONS; PREPARE

DOCUMENTS CITED IN MALHOUTRA'S EXPERT REPORT.

10/1/2018 PG 195.00 2.00 390.00 Billable 498568 DISCOVERY-A COORDINATE WITH S. JAIN REGARDING DISCOVERY Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-12 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 11 of 13 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:53 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 10

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt VERIFICATIONS; PRINT RECENT DISCOVERY RESPONSES FOR J.

MANNING; ORGANIZE ELECTRONIC DISCOVERY FOLDER.

10/3/2018 PG 195.00 1.20 234.00 Billable 498569 DISCOVERY-A UPDATE DISCOVERY RESPONSES; PREPARE COURTESY COPY

FOR JUDGE KOH.

10/4/2018 PG 195.00 1.50 292.50 Billable 498570 DISCOVERY-A COMPILE LATEST DISCOVERY RESPONSES AND VERIFICATION

FOR J. MANNING.

10/5/2018 PG 195.00 0.70 136.50 Billable 498571 PLDS/MO-A ORGANIZE MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT; FINISH

ORGANIZATION OF DISCOVERY RESPONSES.

10/16/2018 PG 195.00 2.50 487.50 Billable 498572 PLDS/MO-A PREPARE EXHIBITS TO THE OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR

SUMMARY JUDGMENT; PREPARE INDEX OF EXHIBITS.

10/17/2018 PG 195.00 3.20 624.00 Billable 498573 PLDS/MO-A ORGANIZE EXHIBITS TO OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY

JUDGMENT; CITE CHECK CASE LAW; PREPARE SHAREFILE WITH

PERTINENT EXHIBITS.

10/18/2018 PG 195.00 8.70 1,696.50 Billable 498574 PLDS/MO-A CITE CHECK OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT;

ORGANIZE EXHIBITS; ASSIST WITH DECLARATIONS REGARDING

ISO MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL.

10/19/2018 PG 195.00 5.50 1,072.50 Billable 498575 PLDS/MO-A ORGANIZE COURTESY COPIES OF OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-12 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 12 of 13 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:53 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 11

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Date Attorney Rate Hours Amount Total ID Task Markup % DNB Time DNB Amt

SUMMARY JUDGMENT, MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL AND

PROPOSED ORDER FOR COURT.

10/24/2018 PG 195.00 2.20 429.00 Billable 498576 SETTLE-A ASSIST WITH MEDIATION DEMONSTRATIVE.

10/25/2018 PG 195.00 3.50 682.50 Billable 498577 SETTLE-A PREPARE MEDIATION DEMONSTRATIVE.

10/26/2018 PG 195.00 4.50 877.50 Billable 498578 SETTLE-A PREPARE MEDIATION DEMONSTRATIVE.

TOTAL Billable Fees 196.50 $38,330.00

Total of billable expense slips $0.00

Calculation of Fees and Costs

Amount Total Fees Bill Arrangement: Slips By billing value on each slip.

Total of billable time slips $38,330.00 Total of Fees (Time Charges) $38,330.00

Total of Costs (Expense Charges) $0.00

Total new charges $38,330.00

New Balance Current $38,330.00

Total New Balance $38,330.00

Funds Account: Default Previous account balance $0.00 Total added to account $0.00 Total removed from account $0.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHKSTEYER Document LOWENTHAL 429-12 BOODROOKAS Filed 11/24/20 Page 13 of 13 ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP ATTORNEYS 11/24/2020 11:53 AM Pre-bill Worksheet Page 12

APPLE.FACETIME:CHRISTINA GRACE (AS 4457-CONT) (continued)

Amount Total

New account balance $0.00

Amount to replenish account to $0.00 $0.00

Attorney Summary

Attorney Rate Hours Charges Slip Value Adjustment PG 220.00 0.50 $110.00 $110.00 0.00 PG 195.00 196.00 $38,220.00 $38,220.00 0.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-13 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 2

EXHIBIT 11 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-13 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 2

STEYER LOWENTHAL BOODROOKAS ALVAREZ & SMITH LLP

GRACE V. APPLE INC.

Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC

LITIGATION COST AND EXPENSE SUMMARY

EXPENSES BY CATEGORY AMOUNT

1. Litigation Fund $240,700.00 2. Copying (in house) $43.80 3. Court Costs/Filing Fees $400.00 4. Court Reporter/Transcripts $1,173.55 5. Computer Legal Research $11,861.13 6. Delivery/Courier $5,526.11 7. Service of Process $3,145.55 8. Telephone $388.20 9. Travel: Airfare $164.40 10. Travel: Car rental/taxi/parking $727.61 11. Travel: Lodging $2,749.68 12. Travel: Conference/Meeting Meals $2,313.73 13. Witness Fees $360.00

TOTAL $269,553.76

235 Pine Street, 15th Floor phone 415-421-3400 San Francisco, CA 94104 fax 415-421-2234 www.steyerlaw.com

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-14 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 8

1 David F.E Tejtel (admitted pro hac vice) Jeremy S. Friedman 2 Spencer M. Oster FRIEDMAN OSTER & TEJTEL PLLC 3 493 Bedford Center Road Suite 2D 4 Bedford Hills, NY 10507 Telephone: 646-661-5881 5 [email protected] [email protected] 6 [email protected] 7 Counsel for Plaintiffs and the Class 8 9 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 10 NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 11 SAN JOSE DIVISION 12 CHRISTINA GRACE AND KEN POTTER, Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC Individually and on Behalf of All Others 13 Similarly Situated, CLASS ACTION 14 Plaintiffs, DECLARATION OF DAVID F.E. TEJTEL IN SUPPORT OF 15 v. PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, 16 APPLE, INC., REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS 17 Defendant. Date: February 8, 2021 18 Time: 1:30pm Court: 8, 4th Floor 19 Judge: The Honorable Lucy H. Koh 20

21 22 I, David F.E. Tejtel, declare as follows: 23 1. I am a member of Friedman Oster & Tejtel PLLC, co-counsel for Plaintiffs 24 Christina Grace and Ken Potter (collectively, “Plaintiffs”) in this class action against Defendant 25 Apple, Inc. (the “Action”). I am admitted to practice before this Court, and I am a member in 26 good standing of the bar of the State of New York, and am also admitted to practice in the United 27 States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, and the United States District Court for the 28

DECLARATION OF DAVID F.E. TEJTEL IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES, AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-14 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 8

1 Southern District of New York. 2 2. I submit this declaration in support of Plaintiffs’ Motion for Attorneys’ Fees, 3 Reimbursement of Expenses and Service Awards (the “Motion”). I make this declaration based 4 on personal knowledge and, if called as a witness, I could and would competently testify to the 5 matters stated herein. 6 3. My firm has served as counsel for Plaintiffs throughout the course of this Action. 7 My firm specializes in complex class action and derivative litigation, primarily in the Court of 8 Chancery of the State of Delaware. Since its inception in 2014, my firm has served as co-lead 9 counsel in numerous class and/or derivative actions that achieved significant beneficial results.

10 A brief description of my firm and the attorneys who worked on this Action is attached as 11 Exhibit 1. 12 4. FOT has prosecuted this Action on a fully contingent basis, has expended 13 $248,871.78 in out-of-pocket costs and expenses, and at all times has been at risk that it would 14 not receive any compensation for its work nor any reimbursement for its costs. Had FOT not 15 prosecuted this Action, the time and resources the firm invested in this Action could—and 16 would—have been invested in other matters. 17 5. Throughout this Action, FOT kept files contemporaneously documenting all time 18 spent, including tasks performed and expenses incurred. All of the time and expenses reported 19 by my firm were incurred for the benefit of the class (the “Class”) on whose behalf the Action 20 was prosecuted. I have personally reviewed every time entry billed by each attorney from my

21 firm submitted in connection with the Motion, and edited and removed time that appeared 22 excessive or unnecessarily duplicative. Throughout this Action, my firm’s expenses were 23 submitted on a monthly basis to our co-counsel in this Action, i.e., Pearson, Simon & Warshaw, 24 LLP. Subsequent to the Court’s order regarding class counsel (Dkt. No. 270), my firm also 25 reported its time to Jill Manning. 26 6. Attached hereto as Exhibit 2 is a chart setting forth, form inception of the Action 27 through October 31, 2020: (i) the attorneys from FOT who contributed significant work to this 28 2 DECLARATION OF DAVID F.E. TEJTEL IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES, AND SERVICE AWARDS Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-14 Filed 11/24/20 Page 3 of 8

1 Action; (ii) the dates of admission for each such attorney; (iii) the billable rates charged by each 2 such attorney, by year, for work performed on this Action; (iv) the total number of hours that 3 each such attorney has worked on this Action, by year; and (v) the total hours and total lodestar 4 for FOT. Attorneys who worked less than 25 hours on this matter have been excluded from 5 FOT’s lodestar. Moreover, the time submissions do not include any time devoted to preparing 6 this declaration or otherwise pertaining to the instant Motion. 7 7. The following four attorneys from my firm billed significant time to this Action, 8 such that their time is being submitted in connection with and in support of the instant Motion: 9 ATTORNEYS

10 Jeremy Friedman 136.3 hours 11 Spencer Oster 69.9 hours 12 David Tejtel 1,629.9 hours 13 Michael Lee 187.5 hours 14 8. During the course of this Action, FOT attorneys have been involved in the 15 following tasks and activities on behalf of the Settlement Class: 16 David Tejtel. 17 a. Case Development 18 I researched the facts relating to and underlying the April 16, 2014 FaceTime Break, 19 developed the theory of the case, identified the appropriate jurisdiction and venue for the filing 20 of the Action, and identified through significant research the appropriate causes of action given

21 the challenged misconduct. I then substantially drafted the initial Complaint, synthesizing the 22 facts and crafting the claims into a meritorious pleading capable of surviving a motion to 23 dismiss. 24 b. Motion to Dismiss 25 I was one of the primary attorneys responsible for drafting the amended complaint in 26 response to Apple’s initial motion to dismiss. After Apple moved to dismiss the amended 27 complaint, I was one of the primary architects of the arguments asserted in opposition to that 28 3 DECLARATION OF DAVID F.E. TEJTEL IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES, AND SERVICE AWARDS Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-14 Filed 11/24/20 Page 4 of 8

1 motion, and one of the primary drafters of Plaintiffs’ brief in opposition to Apple’s motion to 2 dismiss. 3 c. Discovery 4 I was significantly involved in drafting discovery to Apple and in drafting responses to 5 discovery that Apple served on Plaintiffs. I also engaged in dozens of meet-and-confers and 6 negotiations with defense counsel regarding numerous discovery issues. When some of those 7 discovery disputes reached impasse, I was heavily involved in the drafting of motions to compel 8 discovery. I also took the deposition of Gigi Choy, during which I elicited critical testimony 9 establishing that Apple’s failure to provide a fix for the April 16, 2014 expiration of the iPhone

10 Device Sub-CA reflected a significant, intentional and affirmative deviation from Apple’s 11 standard protocol with respect to digital certificates. 12 d. Class Certification 13 Although I was not a primary architect of Plaintiffs’ class certification arguments or 14 substantially involved in the class certification briefing, I did provide input with respect to the 15 arguments and revisions to the briefing. 16 e. Experts 17 I assisted (i) in the preparation of the reports submitted by Plaintiffs’ experts, (ii) 18 prepared Dr. Justine S. Hastings, Ph.D. for her deposition during expert discovery, and (iii) 19 defended Dr. Hastings’s deposition during expert discovery. 20 f. Summary Judgment

21 I was the primary architect of the arguments in opposition to Apple’s motion for 22 summary judgment and the primary drafter of the brief in opposition to that motion. I also 23 prepared for the argument on the summary judgment motion, which the Court ultimately took off 24 calendar. 25 26 27 28 4 DECLARATION OF DAVID F.E. TEJTEL IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES, AND SERVICE AWARDS Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-14 Filed 11/24/20 Page 5 of 8

1 g. Mediation and Settlement Conferences 2 I was the primary drafter of the mediation statement for the initial mediation with the 3 Honorable William J. Cahill (Ret.), and was responsible at that mediation for addressing on 4 behalf of Plaintiffs the arguments asserted by Apple in support of its then-pending summary 5 judgment motion. I also prepared for and attended the second mediation session with Judge 6 Cahill, and each of the mediation sessions with Magistrate Judge Nathanael Cousins. 7 h. Trial Preparation 8 I was heavily involved in trial preparation, focusing on tasks that included drafting 9 briefing on Plaintiffs’ and Apple’s motions in limine, drafting proposed findings of fact and

10 conclusions of law, and drafting jury instructions. 11 Jeremy Friedman. A founding partner of the firm, Mr. Friedman played a role in 12 various facets of litigating the Action, with a particular focus on overall strategy, crafting the 13 theory of the case and the damages theory, and providing guidance regarding negotiations related 14 to various issues from discovery disputes to settlement. 15 Spencer Oster. A founding partner of the firm, Mr. Oster played a role in various facets 16 of litigating the Action, providing support, guidance and strategic input regarding myriad issues. 17 Michael Lee. In his capacity as Of Counsel to FOT, Mr. Lee was heavily involved in 18 various legal research and analysis issues (including issues raised in connection with mediation 19 of the Action), and in trial preparation. 20 9. In addition to the above-listed attorneys, FOT engaged contract attorneys who

21 collectively devoted 1,041.3 hours to the prosecution of the Action, and who FOT paid out-of- 22 pocket at hourly rates between $40 per hour and $53 per hour. FOT has received no 23 reimbursement for any of those costs. FOT has excluded all such time from its lodestar 24 calculation submitted in support of Plaintiffs’ fee request, and has excluded the cost of the 25 contract attorneys from its expense submission. 26 10. Hourly attorney rates charged in this Action by FOT have been paid by clients 27 and have been awarded by other courts in class action and derivative cases. My firm has 28 5 DECLARATION OF DAVID F.E. TEJTEL IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES, AND SERVICE AWARDS Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-14 Filed 11/24/20 Page 6 of 8

1 submitted attorney fee petitions in other cases that have reported hourly rates identical to those 2 sought herein, and in which courts have approved an award of attorneys’ fees, including:

3  In Appel v. Berkman, et al., Case No. 12844-VC (Del. Ch.) for the time period of 4 2016 through 2019, the Court issued an attorneys’ fees award that included FOT at the rates of 5 $700 per hour for Mr. Friedman, $650 per hour for Mr. Oster, $650 for Mr. Tejtel and $550 per 6 hour for Mr. Lee.

7  In In re Tangoe, Inc. Stockholder Litigation, Cons. Case No. 2017-0650-JRS 8 (Del. Ch.), the Court issued an attorneys’ fees award for the time period of 2017 through 2019 at 9 the rates of $700 per hour for Mr. Friedman, $650 per hour for Mr. Oster, $650 for Mr. Tejtel

10 and $550 per hour for Mr. Lee.

11  In H&N Management Group, Inc. & Aff Cos Frozen Money Purchase Plan v. 12 Couch, et al., C.A. No. 12847-VCMR, the Court issued an attorneys’ fees award for the time 13 period of 2016 through 2019 at the rates of $700 per hour for Mr. Friedman, $650 per hour for 14 Mr. Oster, $650 for Mr. Tejtel and $550 per hour for Mr. Lee.

15  In In re Calamos Asset Management, Inc. Stockholder Litigation, C.A. No. 2017- 16 0058-JTL (Del. Ch.), the Court issued an attorneys’ fees award for the time period of 2017 17 through 2019 at the rates of $700 per hour for Mr. Friedman, $650 per hour for Mr. Oster, $650 18 for Mr. Tejtel and $350 per hour for Mr. Lee.

19  In Aldridge v. Blackmore, et al., C.A. No. 12196-CB (Del. Ch.), the Court issued 20 an attorneys’ fees award for the time period of 2016 through 2017 at the rates of $650 per hour

21 for Mr. Friedman, $600 per hour for Mr. Oster and $600 for Mr. Tejtel.

22  In Haverhill Retirement System v. Kerley, et al., C.A. No. 11149-VCL (Del. Ch.), 23 the Court issued an attorneys’ fees award for the time period of 2015 through 2017 at the rates of 24 $650 per hour for Mr. Friedman, $600 per hour for Mr. Oster and $600 for Mr. Tejtel.

25  In Tharp v. Cognate Bioservices, Inc., et al., C.A. No. 11179-VCG (Del. Ch.), the 26 Court issued an attorneys’ fees award for the time period of 2015 through 2017 at the rates of 27 $650 per hour for Mr. Friedman, $600 per hour for Mr. Oster and $600 for Mr. Tejtel. 28 6 DECLARATION OF DAVID F.E. TEJTEL IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES, AND SERVICE AWARDS Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-14 Filed 11/24/20 Page 7 of 8

1  In In re VAALCO Energy Inc., Consolidated Stockholder Litigation, C.A. No. 2 11775-VCL (Del. Ch.), the Court issued an attorneys’ fees award for the time period of 2015 3 through 2017 at the rates of $600 per hour for Mr. Friedman, $550 per hour for Mr. Oster and 4 $550 for Mr. Tejtel. 5 11. The lodestar calculation is based on my firm’s historical billing rates in effect at 6 the time the services were performed. Exhibit 2 was prepared from contemporaneous time 7 records regularly prepared and maintained by my firm. The hourly rates for FOT attorneys 8 included in Exhibit 2 were, at the time the work was performed, the usual and customary hourly 9 rates charged for those attorneys’ services in similarly complex class and/or derivative litigation.

10 12. The total number of hours reasonably expended on this Action by my firm from 11 inception through October 31, 2020—excluding the over 1,000 hours devoted by contract 12 attorneys and certain other time devoted by FOT attorneys—is 2,023.6 hours. The total lodestar 13 corresponding to those 2,023.6 hours at historical rates is $1,278,205.00. 14 13. Attached hereto as Exhibit 3 is a true and correct copy of my firm’s daily time 15 records for every individual who has billed time to this Action that is being submitted as a part of 16 my firm’s lodestar. 17 14. Each firm tracked its own internal expenses. FOT has expended a total of 18 $248,871.78 in unreimbursed costs and expenses in connection with the prosecution of this 19 Action. These costs and expenses are listed in the chart attached hereto as Exhibit 4. Each such 20 cost and expense was incurred on behalf of the Class by my firm on a contingent basis and has

21 not been reimbursed. The expenses incurred in this Action are reflected on the books and 22 records of my firm. 23 15. My firm is seeking reimbursement for reasonable travel expenses incurred in 24 connection with this Action. I occasionally traveled from New York to California to attend 25 Court hearings, settlement conferences and one strategy meeting that was scheduled in 26 conjunction with a Court hearing. For those trips, my firm is seeking reimbursement of the cost 27 of a coach airfare ticket, and reasonable hotel, meal, ground transportation, and parking 28 7 DECLARATION OF DAVID F.E. TEJTEL IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES, AND SERVICE AWARDS Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-14 Filed 11/24/20 Page 8 of 8

1 expenses.

2 16. Roughly 96.7% of the expenses my firm incurred in this Action were payments

3 made to the litigation fund for expert costs, document review hosting, court reporters, mediation 4 fees, third party subpoena fees and bank fees. 5 17. All of the costs and expenses reflected in Exhibit 4 were incurred on behalf of the 6 Class by my firm on a contingent basis and have not been reimbursed. 7

8 I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States and the State of

9 California that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed on this 24th day of November 2020, at 10 493 Bedford Center Road, Suite 2D, Bedford Hills, New York 10507. 11 12 13

14 David F.E. Tejtel 15

16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23

24 25 26 27 28 8 DECLARATION OF DAVID F.E. TEJTEL LN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR AI FORNEYS' FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES, AND SERVICE AWARDS Case No. 5:17-ev-00551-LHK-NC Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-15 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 8

EXHIBIT 1 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-15 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 8

FRIEDMAN OSTER & TEJTEL PLLC FIRM RESUME

Friedman Oster & Tejtel PLLC (“FOT” or the “Firm”) is a New York-based litigation boutique, founded in 2014, that specializes in stockholder rights and corporate governance litigation, primarily in the Court of Chancery of the State of Delaware.

FOT was co-lead counsel in a stockholder class and derivative action captioned Lacey v. Larrea, et al., C.A. No. 11779-VCG (Delaware Court of Chancery), which recovered a $50 million cash payment to the minority stockholders of the aggrieved company (Southern Copper Corporation).

The Firm was co-lead counsel in a derivative action captioned H&N Management Group, Inc. & Aff. Cos Frozen Money Purchase Plan v. Couch, et al., C.A. No. 12847-VCMR (Delaware Court of Chancery), which recovered a $35.5 million cash payment to the injured company (AGNC Investment Corp.).

The Firm was co-lead counsel in a direct action captioned Appel v. Berkman, et al., C.A. No. 12844-VCF (Delaware Court of Chancery), which recovered a $25.5 million cash fund for the stockholder class.

The Firm was co-lead counsel in a direct action captioned Chester County Employees’ Retirement Fund v. KCG Holdings, Inc., et al., C.A. No. 2017-0421-KSJM (Delaware Court of Chancery), which recovered a $22 million cash fund for the stockholder class.

The Firm was part of the litigation team in a stockholder class action captioned In re Calamos Asset Management, Inc. Stockholder Litigation, C.A. No. 2017-0058-JTL (Delaware Court of Chancery), which recovered a roughly $22 million cash fund for the stockholder class.

The Firm was co-lead counsel in a stockholder derivative action captioned Aldridge v. Blackmore, et al., C.A. No. 12196-CB (Delaware Court of Chancery), which recovered a $20 million cash payment to the aggrieved company (TerraForm Global, Inc.).

FOT was co-lead counsel in a stockholder derivative action captioned Vero Beach Police Officers’ Retirement Fund v. Bettino, et al., C.A. No. 2017-0624-JRS (Delaware Court of Chancery), which recovered a $17.95 million cash fund for TD Ameritrade Holding Corporation and its stockholders.

The Firm was part of the litigation team that recovered a $12.5 million cash common fund for stockholders in In re Tangoe, Inc. Stockholders Litigation, C.A. No. 2017-0650-JRS (Delaware Court of Chancery).

FOT was part of the litigation team that recovered a $12 million cash common fund for stockholders in In re ArthroCare Stockholder Litigation, Consolidated C.A. 9313-VCL (Delaware Chancery Court).

The Firm was co-lead counsel in a class and derivative action captioned Haverhill Retirement System v. Kerley, et al., C.A. No. 11149-VCL (Delaware Court of Chancery), which recovered, among other things, a $10 million cash common fund.

1

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-15 Filed 11/24/20 Page 3 of 8

FOT was co-lead counsel in a stockholder class action captioned In re DreamWorks Animation SKG, Inc., C.A. No. 12619-CB (Delaware Court of Chancery), which recovered a $4.5 million cash common fund.

The Firm was part of the litigation team that successfully challenged unlawful charter and bylaw provisions on behalf of corporate stockholders in In re VAALCO Energy, Inc. Consolidated Stockholder Litigation, C.A. No. 11775-VCL (Delaware Court of Chancery). The offending provisions violated Section 141(k) of the Delaware General Corporation Law, which allows stockholders to remove directors from the board with or without cause subject to certain narrow and inapplicable exceptions.

The Firm successfully challenged the unlawful composition of a classified board of directors in City of Riviera Beach General Employees Retirement System v. Aaron’s Inc., et al., Civil Action No. 14-A-02626-4 (Super. Ct. Gwinnet County, Georgia). The litigation alleged a violation of the Georgia corporate code and Aaron’s, Inc. (“Aaron’s”) charter due to disproportionately sized director classes. The action compelled Aaron’s to reconfigure its board classes to bring the company back into compliance with law.

FOT prosecuted Norfolk County Retirement System v. Cardoso, et al., No. 3:15-cv-01507-AWT (D. Conn.) which challenged the reclassification of Hubbell Incorporated and resulted in a settlement that included stock sale restrictions on certain defendants in order to preserve the value the company’s publicly traded stock.

FOT represented stockholders in Miller v. Bolduc, et al. (Commonwealth of Massachusetts Superior Court) (C.A. No. 15-0807-BLS), which successfully challenged a corporate board of directors’ refusal to hold an annual meeting for over five years and put to a shareholder vote a compensation plan amendment that allowed for significant stock options to company insiders.

Currently, FOT is prosecuting a number of actions alleging fraud, abuse of power, self-dealing, usurpation of corporate opportunity and other misconduct against various corporate insiders, controllers or other wrongdoers. Among its active matters, FOT is presently litigating:

• In re Dell Technologies Inc. Class V Stockholders Litigation, C.A. No. 2018-0816-JTL (Delaware Court of Chancery), a class action challenging Dell Technologies Inc.’s multi- billion dollar reclassification of its stock. On March 18, 2019, the Court substantially denied the defendants’ motions to dismiss the action, which is now in the discovery phase.

• Tornetta v. Musk, et al., C.A. No. 2019-0408-JRS (Delaware Court of Chancery), a derivative action challenging an executive compensation plan for Elon Musk with a grant date fair value of $2.6 billion to $3.7 billion, and a potential value of approximately $55 billion. On September 20, 2019, the Court denied in full the defendants' motions to dismiss. The action is now in the discovery phase.

2

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-15 Filed 11/24/20 Page 4 of 8

• In re Baker Hughes, a GE Company Derivative Litigation, C.A. No. 2019-0201-AGB (Delaware Court of Chancery), a derivative action challenging a series of transactions entered into between Baker Hughes, a GE Company and General Electric Company. After the Court denied in substantial part the defendants’ motions to dismiss, the Baker Hughes board of directors created a special litigation committee to investigate Plaintiffs’ claims.

• Olenik v. Lodzinski, et al., C.A. No. 2017-0414-JRS (Delaware Court of Chancery), a class and derivative action challenging the merger of Earthstone Energy, Inc. and Bold Energy III LLC. In a decision dated April 5, 2019, the Delaware Supreme Court reversed the trial court’s dismissal of the action, which is now in the discovery phase.

• In re AmTrust Financial Services, Inc. Stockholder Litigation, C.A. No. 2018-0396-AGB (Delaware Court of Chancery), a stockholder class action challenging AmTrust Financial Services, Inc.’s November 29, 2018 going-private merger with Evergreen Parent L.P., including for failure to secure adequate value for derivative claims alleging a usurpation of corporate opportunity by the controlling stockholder group of AmTrust in connection with the 2014 acquisition of property and casualty insurer Tower Group International. On February 26, 2020, the Court substantially denied the defendants’ motions to dismiss the action, which is now in the discovery phase.

• Lacey v. Larrea, et al., C.A. No. 2019-0312-VCG (Delaware Court of Chancery), a derivative action challenging related-party transactions between Southern Copper Corporation and its controlling stockholder. On July 16, 2020, the Court denied in part the defendants’ motions to dismiss the action, which is now in the discovery phase.

• Voigt v. Metcalf, et al., C.A. No. 2018-0828-JTL (Delaware Court of Chancery), a class and derivative action challenging the November 2018 merger of NCI Building Systems, Inc. and Ply Gem Parent, LLC. On February 10, 2020, the Court substantially denied the defendants’ motions to dismiss the action, which is now in the discovery phase.

• In re Coty Inc. Stockholder Litigation, C.A. No. 2019-0336-AGB (Delaware Court of Chancery), a class and derivative action challenging JAB Holding Company’s acquisition of voting control of Coty Inc. through a tender offer consummated on April 30, 2019. On August 17, 2020, the Court denied in full the defendants’ motions to dismiss the action, which is now in the discovery phase.

• In re HomeFed Corporation Stockholder Litigation, C.A. No. 2019-AGB (Delaware Court of Chancery), a class action challenging the 2019 merger of HomeFed Corporation and Jefferies Financial Group Inc. In a decision dated July 13, 2020, the Court denied in full the defendants’ motion to dismiss the action, which is now in the discovery phase.

• Salladay v. Lev, et al., C.A. No. 2019-0045-SG (Delaware Court of Chancery), a class action challenging the going-private merger of Intersections Inc. with WC SACD One., Inc., which was consummated on January 11, 2019. On February 27, 2020, the Court denied in full the defendants’ motion to dismiss the action, which is now in the discovery phase. 3

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-15 Filed 11/24/20 Page 5 of 8

• Tornetta v. Maffei, et al., C.A. No. 2019-0649-AGB (Delaware Court of Chancery), a class action challenging Sirius XM Holdings Inc.’s 2019 acquisition of Pandora Media, Inc. The action is in the motion to dismiss phase.

• Asbestos Workers’ Philadelphia Pension Fund v. Avril, et. al., C.A. No. 2019-0633-SG (Delaware Court of Chancery), a class and derivative action challenging a series of transactions between Liberty Tax, Inc. and Vintage Capital Management that allowed Vintage Capital to obtain majority control over Liberty Tax without paying a premium to Liberty Tax’s public stockholders.

• City of Dearborn Police and Fire Revised Retirement System (Chapter 23) v. Brookfield Asset Management, Inc., et al., C.A. No. 2020-0050-VCG, a class and derivative action challenging an unfair related-party private placement between TerraForm Power, Inc. and its controlling stockholder, Brookfield Asset Management, Inc. On October 30, 2020, the Court denied the defendants’ motion to dismiss the direct claims asserted in the action.

• Morris v. Spectra Energy Partners (DE) GP, LP, C.A. No. 2019-0097-VCG (Delaware Court of Chancery), a class action challenging the roll-up of Spectra Energy Partners by its parent, Spectra Energy Corp., including for failure to secure value for derivative claims relating to a prior drop-down transaction between Spectra Energy Partners and its parent. FOT is currently appealing the Court of Chancery’s dismissal of the action.

FOT Attorneys Who Litigated Grace v. Apple, Inc., Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC

Jeremy S. Friedman (Member)

Jeremy S. Friedman specializes in corporate takeover litigation, breach of fiduciary duty actions and securities litigation. Mr. Friedman’s experience as a litigator, transactional attorney and in- house counsel provide him unique perspective in identifying and prosecuting corporate malfeasance.

Mr. Friedman received his law degree from New York University magna cum laude. After law school, Mr. Friedman joined Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP as a corporate lawyer, specializing in mergers & acquisitions, debt financings and securities offerings. Mr. Friedman then joined Bernstein Litowitz Berger & Grossmann LLP, where he transitioned from a successful transactional attorney into a seasoned litigator.

At Bernstein Litowitz, Mr. Friedman helped secure the recovery of hundreds of millions of dollars on behalf of shareholders. For example, Mr. Friedman helped prosecute In re El Paso Corp. Shareholder Litigation, which challenged a conflict-ridden transaction and secured a $110 million settlement for shareholders. In In re Delphi Financial Group Shareholder Litigation, Mr. Friedman was a key member of the team that challenged a founder and controlling shareholder’s unlawful demand for an additional $55 million in connection with the sale of a public company. The litigation resulted in a $49 million recovery for Delphi shareholders. Mr. Friedman also played a central role in the initiation and litigation of In re Clear Channel Outdoor Holdings, Inc. Shareholder Litigation, a derivative lawsuit challenging an abuse of power by a parent 4

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-15 Filed 11/24/20 Page 6 of 8

company in securing a below market loan from its publicly-traded subsidiary. The resulting settlement provided for, among other things, an immediate $200 million dividend to the subsidiary’s shareholders. Other noteworthy prosecutions to which Mr. Friedman contributed include In re News Corp. Shareholder Litigation, a landmark derivative action that resulted in a $139 million settlement and extensive corporate governance reform, and In re Ancestry.com Inc. Shareholder Litigation, a merger challenge in which plaintiffs’ counsel successfully enjoined consummation of a private equity buyout until the target company disclosed certain material information to shareholders. Mr. Friedman has presented on corporate governance developments and has co-authored several articles on topics ranging from deposition witness coaching to multi- jurisdictional litigation.

In addition to his litigation practice, Mr. Friedman serves as general counsel for a medical aesthetics business specializing in non-surgical medical procedures, and formerly served as associate counsel for the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights’ Election Protection Program.

Spencer M. Oster (Member)

Spencer Oster has well over a decade of experience prosecuting and defending complex class actions, fiduciary duty claims and pharmaceutical fraud. Mr. Oster specializes in corporate governance and transactional litigation, and excels at every stage of litigation from investigation to enforcement. Mr. Oster is an expert in electronic discovery, and brings a sensible and resourceful approach to shareholder advocacy.

Before co-founding Friedman Oster & Tejtel PLLC, Mr. Oster spent six years at Bernstein Litowitz Berger & Grossmann LLP. While there, Mr. Oster helped prosecute dozens of shareholder class actions in a myriad of jurisdictions, including Louisiana Municipal Police Employee Retirement System v. Crawford, which arose out of CVS’s acquisition of Caremark and resulted in over $3 billion in additional merger consideration for Caremark shareholders. Additionally, Mr. Oster has helped obtain some of the most significant shareholder recoveries in Delaware Court of Chancery Court history, including In re News Corp. Shareholder Litigation, In re El Paso Corp. Shareholder Litigation, and In re Delphi Financial Group Shareholder Litigation. Mr. Oster was also a member of the teams that successfully prosecuted In re ACS Shareholder Litigation, In re Landry’s Restaurants, Inc. Shareholders Litigation, In re J.Crew Group Shareholder Litigation and In re Data Domain Shareholder Litigation. Mr. Oster began his legal career at Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison LLP, representing a global financial institution in securities cases stemming from the Enron bankruptcy. Upon joining the plaintiffs’ bar in 2005, Spencer litigated a number of high profile securities cases including In re Williams Securities Litigation and In re BISYS Securities Litigation. Mr. Oster also prosecuted average wholesale pricing claims on behalf of various States’ Attorney Generals.

In addition to litigation, Mr. Oster has worked on behalf of various non-profit organizations, including New York’s Police Athletic League and Lighthouse International.

David F.E. Tejtel (Member)

David F.E. Tejtel is a seasoned litigator with extensive and expansive experience in federal and state court. He specializes in breach of fiduciary duty, corporate takeover and securities litigation, 5

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-15 Filed 11/24/20 Page 7 of 8

having represented plaintiffs and defendants in high-stakes engagements within those categories and others. Mr. Tejtel’s broad plaintiff- and defense-side experience makes him a particularly savvy litigator and a superb legal strategist. He excels in all facets of litigation, from case investigation/inception to appellate litigation, and his affinity for writing has translated into successful briefing before state, federal district and federal appellate courts.

Mr. Tejtel earned his undergraduate and Juris Doctor degrees from the University of Virginia. After graduating from law school, Mr. Tejtel clerked under the Honorable Louise W. Flanagan, United States District Court Judge for the Eastern District of North Carolina. Thereafter, Mr. Tejtel joined the litigation department of Simpson Thacher & Bartlett LLP. His legal experience also includes acting as the Senior Director of Litigation of one of the preeminent trial consulting firms in the nation. Over the course of his career, Mr. Tejtel has helped deliver outstanding results in numerous high-profile shareholder and securities actions. He has also played a critical role in crafting litigation and trial strategies that have helped plaintiffs recover billions of dollars, and have helped defendants secure the dismissal of similarly high-stakes claims brought against them.

In addition, Mr. Tejtel has counseled on a pro bono basis various non-profit entities, for-profit entities and individuals in connection with all manner of legal issues. His award-winning pro bono practice has included receipt of inMotion’s Commitment to Justice Award for Outstanding Legal Team.

Michael Lee (Of Counsel)

Michael Lee specializes in breach of fiduciary duty, corporate takeover and securities litigation. Mr. Lee’s experience as a litigator both defending and prosecuting stockholder actions gives him a unique perspective to effectively prosecute corporate wrongdoing.

Mr. Lee received his law degree from the University of Michigan Law School magna cum laude. After law school, Mr. Lee joined Cravath, Swaine & Moore LLP as a litigation associate specializing in securities and intellectual property litigation and appeals. Mr. Lee has represented corporations and stockholders in a variety of cases, assisting Milberg Phillips Grossman LLP, Bernstein Litowitz Berger & Grossmann LLP and Robins Kaplan LLP.

Mr. Lee has extensive pro bono experience, including representing high-risk inmates against the State of New York to secure discharge planning and advocating for domestic helpers in employment, criminal and human trafficking cases.

Lindsay La Marca (Associate)

Lindsay La Marca has an extensive background advocating on behalf of stockholders in complex litigation, including securities and breach of fiduciary duty matters. Ms. La Marca’s experience spans all aspects of litigation, including high-profile trial work.

Before joining Friedman Oster & Tejtel PLLC, Ms. La Marca was a litigator at Robbins Geller Rudman & Dowd LLP, where she primarily represented stockholders in securities fraud class

6

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-15 Filed 11/24/20 Page 8 of 8

actions. She began her career at Brewer, Attorneys & Counselors, where she worked on various complex matters, including in the corporate governance realm.

Ms. La Marca received her Juris Doctor degree from the Maurice A. Deane School of Law at Hofstra University, magna cum laude, where she served on the executive board of the Hofstra Law Review. Ms. La Marca earned her undergraduate degree from Stony Brook University in Spanish and Italian. She remains fluent in those languages. Ms. La Marca is admitted to practice in New York State and the United States District Court for the Eastern and Southern Districts of New York.

7

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-16 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 2

EXHIBIT 2 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-16 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 2

Grace v. Apple, Inc. Time Report Friedman Oster & Tejtel PLLC Report Period: Inception through October 31, 2020 Status: (M) Member (OC) Of Counsel

NAME STATUS BAR ADMITTANCE HOURLY RATE CUMULATIVE HOURS CUMULATIVE LODESTAR Jeremy Friedman (2016) M 2008 $650 25.80 $16,770.00 Jeremy Friedman (2017) M 2008 $650 45.00 $29,250.00 Jeremy Friedman (2018) M 2008 $700 23.60 $16,520.00 Jeremy Friedman (2019) M 2008 $700 31.30 $21,910.00 Jeremy Friedman (2020) M 2008 $700 10.60 $7,420.00 Spencer Oster (2016) M 2004 $600 16.60 $9,960.00 Spencer Oster (2017) M 2004 $600 32.80 $19,680.00 Spencer Oster (2018) M 2004 $650 16.00 $10,400.00 Spencer Oster (2019) M 2004 $650 3.50 $2,275.00 Spencer Oster (2020) M 2004 $650 1.00 $650.00 David Tejtel (2016) M 2009 $600 124.70 $74,820.00 David Tejtel (2017) M 2009 $600 259.10 $155,460.00 David Tejtel (2018) M 2009 $650 826.10 $536,965.00 David Tejtel (2019) M 2009 $650 251.50 $163,475.00 David Tejtel (2020) M 2009 $650 168.50 $109,525.00 Michael Lee (2019) OC 2006 $550 133.70 $73,535.00 Michael Lee (2020) OC 2006 $550 53.80 $29,590.00

ATTORNEY TOTALS 2,023.60 $1,278,205.00

NON-ATTORNEY TOTALS N/A

TOTALS 2,023.60 $1,278,205.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 55

EXHIBIT 3 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 55

GRACE v. APPLE, INC. Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC

FRIEDMAN OSTER & TEJTEL PLLC

ATTORNEY DAILY TIME ENTRIES

TAB A – Jeremy Friedman

TAB B – Spencer Oster

TAB C – David Tejtel

TAB D – Michael Lee

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 3 of 55

TAB A

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 4 of 55

Jeremy Friedman Time Detail Grace v. Apple, Inc. -- No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Inception through 10.31.20

Date Task Hours Hourly Rate Amount 8/25/16 Emails w/ FOT team re: potential Apple/FaceTime matter 0.5 $650 $325.00 8/26/16 Preparing for and call w/ FOT team re: potential Apple/FaceTime matter 0.7 $650 $455.00 8/26/16 Investigating potential Apple/FaceTime matter 1 $650 $650.00 9/1/16 Reviewing compiled research for potential Apple/Facetime matter 0.8 $650 $520.00 9/1/16 Emails w/ FOT team re: potential Apple/Facetime matter 0.5 $650 $325.00 9/2/16 Preparing for and call w/ D. Tejtel re: potential Apple/Facetime complaint 0.5 $650 $325.00 9/7/16 Reviewing emails re: potential Apple/FaceTime action 0.6 $650 $390.00 9/13/16 Preparing for and call w/ D. Tejtel re: potential Apple/FaceTime matter 0.5 $650 $325.00 9/14/16 Emails w/ FOT team re: potential Apple/FaceTime action 0.4 $650 $260.00 9/17/16 Emails w/ FOT team re: Apple/FaceTime strategy 0.6 $650 $390.00 9/17/16 Reviewing emails from FOT team re: Apple/FaceTime call w/ potential co-counsel 0.5 $650 $325.00 9/18/16 Emails w/ FOT team re: Apple/FaceTime strategy 0.3 $650 $195.00 9/18/16 Emails re: potential Apple/FaceTime action 0.8 $650 $520.00 9/21/16 Preparing for and call w/ potential co-counsel re: potential Apple/FaceTime action 0.5 $650 $325.00 9/22/16 Preparing for and call w/ potential co-counsel re: potential Apple/FaceTime case 0.5 $650 $325.00 9/23/16 Emails w/ FOT team re: potential Apple/FaceTime action; call w/ D. Tejtel re: same 0.6 $650 $390.00 9/24/16 Emails w/ FOT team re: potential Apple/FaceTime action 1 $650 $650.00 9/30/16 Emails w/ FOT team re: Apple/Facetime strategy 0.7 $650 $455.00 9/30/16 Emails w/ potential co-counsel re: potential Apple/Facetime complaint 0.5 $650 $325.00 10/3/16 Preparing for and call w/ potential co-counsel re: potential complaint+B57 0.5 $650 $325.00 10/5/16 Preparing for and call w/ potential co-counsel re: potential Apple/FaceTime case 0.5 $650 $325.00 10/11/16 Reviewing emails re: potential Apple/FaceTime matter 1 $650 $650.00 10/19/16 Reviewing emails re: potential Apple/FaceTime matter 0.4 $650 $260.00 10/28/16 Preparing for and call w/ potential co-counsel re: Apple/FaceTime 0.5 $650 $325.00 11/1/16 Watching FaceTime clips; emails w/ FOT team re: same 0.6 $650 $390.00 11/6/16 Work on Apple/FaceTime complaint 2.3 $650 $1,495.00 11/11/16 Emails w/ FOT team re: Apple/FaceTime 0.5 $650 $325.00 11/12/16 Reviewing emails from D. Tejtel re: Apple/FaceTime 0.5 $650 $325.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 5 of 55

11/13/16 Emails w/ FOT team re: Apple/FaceTime update and strategy 0.6 $650 $390.00 11/18/16 Work on Apple/FaceTime complaint 1.3 $650 $845.00 12/6/16 Reviewing emails from D. Tejtel re: Apple/FaceTime updates 0.5 $650 $325.00 12/8/16 Reviewing damages memo prepared by S. Macrae 0.5 $650 $325.00 12/14/16 Work on Apple/FaceTime complaint 3.5 $650 $2,275.00 12/19/16 Reviewing S. Macrae’s edits to Apple/FaceTime complaint 0.6 $650 $390.00 12/22/16 Reviewing emails from D. Tejtel re: Apple/FaceTime updates 0.5 $650 $325.00 1/3/17 Reviewing Apple/FaceTime emails 0.5 $650 $325.00 1/26/17 Reviewing Apple/FaceTime JPA 0.2 $650 $130.00 1/27/17 Reviewing Apple/FaceTime JPA 0.4 $650 $260.00 2/3/17 Reviewing emails re: Apple/FaceTime complaint 0.5 $650 $325.00 2/6/17 Emails w/ FOT team re: media outreach 0.5 $650 $325.00 2/13/17 Reviewing Apple/FaceTime research memo re: judges 0.6 $650 $390.00 2/28/17 Work on Apple/FaceTime discovery requests 1.3 $650 $845.00 3/1/17 Preparing for and call w/ co-counsel re: Apple/FaceTime strategy 0.5 $650 $325.00 3/2/17 Reviewing Apple/FaceTime interrogatories 0.9 $650 $585.00 3/3/17 Reviewing Apple/FaceTime discovery requests 0.5 $650 $325.00 3/13/17 Reviewing revised Apple/Facetime discovery requests 0.7 $650 $455.00 3/22/17 Reviewing Apple’s MTD; emails w/ FOT team re: same 0.8 $650 $520.00 3/23/17 Reviewing articles re: Apple/FaceTime 0.5 $650 $325.00 3/24/17 Reviewing emails from co-counsel re: Apple/FaceTime strategy 0.7 $650 $455.00 3/24/17 Reviewing emails re: Apple/FaceTime strategy 0.1 $650 $65.00 3/28/17 Work on memo re: iOS contractual arguments 0.8 $650 $520.00 3/28/17 Reviewing emails re: iOS 6.1.6 0.2 $650 $130.00 3/31/17 Preparing for and call w/ co-counsel re: Apple/FaceTime strategy 1 $650 $650.00 3/31/17 Work on Apple/FaceTime amended complaint 0.5 $650 $325.00 4/1/17 Work on Apple/FaceTime amended complaint 0.9 $650 $585.00 4/4/17 Reviewing draft Apple/FaceTime amended complaint 1.2 $650 $780.00 4/4/17 Reviewing revised draft amended complaint 0.5 $650 $325.00 4/5/17 Reviewing Apple/FaceTime amended complaint 0.8 $650 $520.00 4/9/17 Reviewing revised Apple/FaceTime doc requests 0.5 $650 $325.00 4/19/17 Reading Apple/FaceTime MTD brief 0.8 $650 $520.00 4/20/17 Emails w/ FOT team re: Apple/FaceTime opposition to MTD 0.2 $650 $130.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 6 of 55

4/21/17 Emails w/ FOT team re: Apple/FaceTime opposition to MTD brief 0.1 $650 $65.00 4/25/17 Work on Apple/FaceTime opposition to MTD 0.5 $650 $325.00 4/26/17 Work on Apple/FaceTime opposition to MTD 1 $650 $650.00 4/26/17 Work on Apple/FaceTime opposition to MTD 1.2 $650 $780.00 4/28/17 Reviewing draft joint CMC statement 0.7 $650 $455.00 5/2/17 Emails w/ FOT team re: ESI stipulation 0.5 $650 $325.00 5/24/17 Reviewing draft protective order 0.5 $650 $325.00 5/26/17 Work on MTD argument prep 1 $650 $650.00 5/26/17 Reviewing amended initial disclosures 0.4 $650 $260.00 6/12/17 Reviewing emails re: protective order and ESI stipulation 0.5 $650 $325.00 7/25/17 Emails re: cancellation of oral argument on MTD 0.2 $650 $130.00 7/28/17 Reviewing Apple/FaceTime opinion denying MTD; call w/ D. Tejtel re: same 1.3 $650 $845.00 7/31/17 Reviewing news coverage of denial of MTD in Apple/FaceTime 0.2 $650 $130.00 8/2/17 Reviewing email from J. Manning re: agenda items for conference call 0.2 $650 $130.00 8/2/17 Emails w/ D. Tejtel re: potential Apple/FaceTime expert issues and costs 0.2 $650 $130.00 8/3/17 Work on proposed ESI search terms 0.6 $650 $390.00 8/8/17 Work on joint case management statement 0.8 $650 $520.00 8/10/17 Reviewing revised Apple/FaceTime search term list 0.3 $650 $195.00 8/10/17 Emails w/ FOT team re: expert engagement letter 0.3 $650 $195.00 8/11/17 Reviewing emails from D. Tejtel re: Apple/FaceTime proposed search terms 0.2 $650 $130.00 8/14/17 Reviewing emails from D. Tejtel re: meet-and-confer with Kirkland 0.5 $650 $325.00 8/14/17 Emails w/ FOT team re: revised joint CMS 0.3 $650 $195.00 8/15/17 Reviewing revised joint CMS 0.8 $650 $520.00 8/16/17 Reviewing emails from D. Tejtel and co-counsel re: CMC statement 0.2 $650 $130.00 8/18/17 Emails w/ FOT team re: cancellation of case management conference 0.2 $650 $130.00 8/25/17 Reviewing emails from co-counsel re: rogs 0.3 $650 $195.00 8/25/17 Training on DISCO 1.3 $650 $845.00 8/25/17 Emails w/ D. Tejtel re: doc hosting platform pricing 0.3 $650 $195.00 8/27/17 Work on chart comparing doc hosting platform pricing 0.8 $650 $520.00 8/28/17 Emails w/ FOT team re: doc hosting platform 0.5 $650 $325.00 8/29/17 Reviewing emails from co-counsel re: rogs 0.2 $650 $130.00 8/29/17 Reviewing summary of Apple doc production (FaceTime) 0.3 $650 $195.00 8/29/17 Reviewing summary of Apple doc production 0.3 $650 $195.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 7 of 55

8/30/17 Emails w/ FOT team re: doc review platform 0.5 $650 $325.00 9/5/17 Emails w/ FOT team re: lit fund 0.3 $650 $195.00 9/9/17 Reviewing proposed email to Joe Loy 0.2 $650 $130.00 9/12/17 Inventus kick-off call 0.5 $650 $325.00 9/13/17 Reviewing draft email summarizing meet-and-confers 0.5 $650 $325.00 9/19/17 Preparing for and call w/ co-counsel re: case strategy 1 $650 $650.00 9/20/17 Reviewing revised search term proposal 0.3 $650 $195.00 9/29/17 Relativity training 0.8 $650 $520.00 10/11/17 Reviewing D. Tejtel’s summary of Apple/FaceTime call w/ co-counsel 0.1 $650 $65.00 10/12/17 Work on expert engagement letter 0.3 $650 $195.00 10/14/17 Reviewing D. Tejtel’s summary of Apple/FaceTime doc production 0.2 $650 $130.00 10/18/17 Work on MTC joint letter 0.4 $650 $260.00 10/23/17 Reviewing draft joint case management statement 0.3 $650 $195.00 10/25/17 Work on joint discovery letter to magistrate 0.5 $650 $325.00 10/31/17 Reviewing motion to file under seal 0.2 $650 $130.00 11/2/17 Reviewing emails from D. Tejtel re: damages analysis 0.2 $650 $130.00 11/4/17 Emails among FOT team re: hearing on MTC 0.2 $650 $130.00 11/7/17 Reviewing draft proposed discovery order; emails w/ D. Tejtel re: same 0.5 $650 $325.00 11/8/17 Reviewing proposed discovery order 0.3 $650 $195.00 11/9/17 Reviewing summary of FaceTime call w/ co-counsel 0.2 $650 $130.00 11/10/17 Reviewing emails from co-counsel re: discovery responses 0.3 $650 $195.00 11/17/17 Reviewing letter to magistrate re: rog issues 0.2 $650 $130.00 11/21/17 Work on draft 30(b)(6) notice 0.5 $650 $325.00 11/21/17 Emails w/ D. Tejtel re: Apple/FaceTime discovery issues 0.2 $650 $130.00 11/27/17 Reviewing issues chart re: Apple’s amended responses and objections to RPFs 0.9 $650 $585.00 11/29/17 Reviewing summary of Apple/FaceTime call w/ co-counsel 0.2 $650 $130.00 12/8/17 Reviewing summary of Apple/FaceTime meet-and-confer 0.2 $650 $130.00 12/14/17 Email w/ D. Tejtel re: Apple/Facetime doc production 0.1 $650 $65.00 12/21/17 Reviewing emails and articles re: intentional slow-down of iPhones 0.8 $650 $520.00 12/26/17 Emails w/ FOT team re: Apple complaint 0.3 $650 $195.00 12/27/17 Reviewing email from A. Curry re: source code review 0.5 $650 $325.00 12/27/17 Reviewing emails among FOT team re: Apple complaint 0.5 $650 $325.00 1/18/18 Reviewing draft MTC 0.5 $700 $350.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 8 of 55

1/25/18 Reviewing draft letter brief re: transcripts from VirnetX action 0.7 $700 $490.00 1/26/18 Preparing for and call w/ S. Oster re: Apple/FaceTime strategy 0.5 $700 $350.00 1/26/18 Reviewing email from A. Curry re: Apple/FaceTime strategy 0.2 $700 $140.00 1/30/18 Emails w/ D. Tejtel re: class size 0.2 $700 $140.00 1/31/18 Emails w/ FOT team re: Apple/FaceTime expert bills 0.3 $700 $210.00 2/1/18 Preparing for and call w/ D. Tejtel re: Apple/FaceTime strategy 0.5 $700 $350.00 2/2/18 Preparing for and call w/ FOT team re: potential exploration of lit finance 0.5 $700 $350.00 2/5/18 Emails w/ FOT team re: potential exploration of lit financing 0.3 $700 $210.00 2/8/18 Reviewing emails re: expiration of certificate 0.6 $700 $420.00 2/9/18 Reviewing emails re: hot docs 0.5 $700 $350.00 2/21/18 Reviewing M. Lee’s summary of hot docs 0.3 $700 $210.00 2/28/18 Reviewing D. Tejtel’s summary of Apple/FaceTime team call 0.2 $700 $140.00 3/7/18 Review email from D. Tejtel w/ summary of Apple/FaceTime weekly strategy call 0.1 $700 $70.00 3/22/18 Preparing for and call w/ D. Tejtel re: Apple/FaceTime strategy 0.2 $700 $140.00 3/27/18 Emails w/ D. Tejtel re: ADR 0.1 $700 $70.00 3/28/18 Reviewing email from D. Tejtel re: co-counsel call summary 0.2 $700 $140.00 4/12/18 Preparing for and call w/ D. Tejtel re: Apple/FaceTime update 0.2 $700 $140.00 4/19/18 Reviewing emails from D. Tejtel re: Apple/FaceTime update 0.5 $700 $350.00 5/18/18 Reviewing summary of client depo 0.2 $700 $140.00 5/30/18 Reviewing emails re: discovery issues 0.5 $700 $350.00 5/31/18 Emails w/ D. Tejtel re: victory on MTC 0.2 $700 $140.00 6/18/18 Reviewing summary of call w/ co-counsel re: Apple’s class cert papers 0.2 $700 $140.00 6/20/18 Emails w/ D. Tejtel re: MTC hearing 0.2 $700 $140.00 8/1/18 Emails w/ D. Tejtel re: potential mediators 0.4 $700 $280.00 8/29/18 Preparing for and call w/ D. Tejtel re: damages issues 0.5 $700 $350.00 9/5/18 Research on potential mediator; emails w/ FOT team re: same 0.5 $700 $350.00 9/18/18 Reviewing order re: motions to seal 0.5 $700 $350.00 9/18/18 Reviewing class cert opinion 0.8 $700 $560.00 9/18/18 Preparing for and call w/ co-counsel re: class cert opinion 1 $700 $700.00 9/25/18 Preparing for and call w/ D. Tejtel re: case strategy 1 $700 $700.00 9/26/18 Preparing for and call w/ D. Tejtel and M. Lee re: SoL issues 1 $700 $700.00 9/26/18 Reviewing memo prepared by M. Lee 0.5 $700 $350.00 9/27/18 Reviewing emails re: Apple/FaceTime mediation postponement 0.5 $700 $350.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 9 of 55

10/4/18 Updating Apple/FaceTime chart and spreadsheet 0.5 $700 $350.00 10/5/18 Reviewing D. Tejtel’s summary of Apple’s SJ brief 0.2 $700 $140.00 10/24/18 Preparing for and call w/ D. Tejtel and M. Lee re: strategy 1 $700 $700.00 10/29/18 Preparing for and call w/ D. Tejtel re: mediation issues 0.8 $700 $560.00 10/29/18 Emails w/ FOT team re: upcoming mediation 0.4 $700 $280.00 11/1/18 Reviewing emails from co-counsel re: mediation submission and 23f petition 0.5 $700 $350.00 11/5/18 Looking into case expense-related issues 1.5 $700 $1,050.00 11/5/18 Preparing for and call w/ D. Tejtel re: mediation and case strategy 1.5 $700 $1,050.00 11/8/18 Emails w/ D. Tejtel re: mediation strategy 0.3 $700 $210.00 11/9/18 Reviewing emails from D. Tejtel re: mediation 0.2 $700 $140.00 11/9/18 Preparing for and call w/ D. Tejtel re: mediation and case expenses 0.7 $700 $490.00 11/16/18 Preparing for and call w/ co-counsel re: 23(f) petition 0.8 $700 $560.00 11/28/18 Emails w/ D. Tejtel re: expected notice costs 0.1 $700 $70.00 12/15/18 Work on chart and spreadsheet 0.5 $700 $350.00 1/29/19 Reviewing email from M. Lee re: SoL issues 0.2 $700 $140.00 1/29/19 Reviewing article re: denial of data breach preliminary approval in Yahoo 0.1 $700 $70.00 3/20/19 Reviewing emails re: decision on 23(f) motion 0.2 $700 $140.00 3/22/19 Preparing for and call w/ co-counsel re: strategy 0.7 $700 $490.00 3/22/19 Reviewing SoL research 0.2 $700 $140.00 3/25/19 Reviewing emails from FOT team re: damages calculations 0.2 $700 $140.00 3/25/19 Call w/ D. Tejtel re: statute of limitations issues 0.2 $700 $140.00 4/3/19 Reviewing memo re: SOL research 0.5 $700 $350.00 4/4/19 Preparing for and call w/ D. Tejtel re: strategy 0.6 $700 $420.00 4/4/19 Preparing for and call w/ D. Tejtel re: strategy 0.2 $700 $140.00 4/10/19 Reviewing summary of call w/ co-counsel; call w/ D. Tejtel re: same 0.5 $700 $350.00 4/26/19 Reviewing emails re: SJ and trial schedule 0.1 $700 $70.00 4/26/19 Reviewing D. Tejtel’s summary of call w/ co-counsel 0.2 $700 $140.00 4/29/19 Emails w/ D. Tejtel re: strategy 0.1 $700 $70.00 4/29/19 Reviewing emails from co-counsel re: draft joint submission 0.3 $700 $210.00 4/30/19 Emails w/ D. Tejtel re: strategy 0.1 $700 $70.00 5/14/19 Preparing for and call w/ D. Tejtel re: summary judgment argument 0.5 $700 $350.00 5/15/19 Reviewing draft email re: strategy 0.1 $700 $70.00 5/15/19 Call w/ co-counsel re: strategy; call w/ D. Tejtel re: same 0.7 $700 $490.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 10 of 55

5/16/19 Compiling chart and spreadsheet 0.7 $700 $490.00 6/19/19 Reviewing emails from co-counsel re: sub-classes and amended complaint 0.3 $700 $210.00 8/1/19 Emails re: cancellation of SJ hearing 0.2 $700 $140.00 8/22/19 Reviewing SJ opinion; emails w/ FOT team re: same 1 $700 $700.00 8/22/19 Reviewing motion to seal decision 0.3 $700 $210.00 8/26/19 Reviewing memo prepared by D. Tejtel; emails re: same 0.5 $700 $350.00 8/26/19 Preparing for and call w/ co-counsel re: strategy 0.7 $700 $490.00 9/6/19 Call w/ FOT team re: strategy; call w/ co-counsel re: same 1 $700 $700.00 9/18/19 Reviewing emails from FOT team re: prejudgment interest calculations 0.3 $700 $210.00 9/18/19 Work on mediation statement 0.8 $700 $560.00 9/25/19 Preparing for and call w/ co-counsel re: mediation submission and strategy 0.8 $700 $560.00 9/26/19 Reviewing emails re: negotiating strategy 0.2 $700 $140.00 10/1/19 Preparing for and call w/ co-counsel re: mediation strategy and settlement demand 1 $700 $700.00 10/10/19 Updating time entries chart and spreadsheet 0.4 $700 $280.00 10/10/19 Work on mediation submission 0.5 $700 $350.00 10/11/19 Reviewing emails re: mediation submission 0.1 $700 $70.00 10/13/19 Emails w/ D. Tejtel re: mediation 0.1 $700 $70.00 10/16/19 Reviewing summary of mediation strategy call 0.1 $700 $70.00 10/22/19 Reviewing emails re: mediation settlement negotiations 0.2 $700 $140.00 10/22/19 Communications w/ D. Tejtel re: mediation 0.5 $700 $350.00 10/23/19 Research re: proposed settlement terms 0.3 $700 $210.00 10/23/19 Preparing for and call w/ D. Tejtel re: mediation 0.7 $700 $490.00 10/23/19 Calls w/ FOT, all co-counsel, and D. Tejtel re: strategy/settlement 2.2 $700 $1,540.00 10/26/19 Emails w/ D. Tejtel re: Westlaw report 0.1 $700 $70.00 10/29/19 Preparing for and call w/ co-counsel re: settlement discussions 1 $700 $700.00 10/30/19 Call w/ co-counsel re: strategy 0.7 $700 $490.00 11/8/19 Preparing for and call w/ co-counsel re: settlement issues 0.8 $700 $560.00 11/12/19 Call w/ co-counsel re: settlement issues 0.5 $700 $350.00 11/12/19 Reviewing memo re: mediation privilege 0.3 $700 $210.00 11/22/19 Preparing for and call w/ D. Tejtel re: settlement issues 0.5 $700 $350.00 11/28/19 Reviewing draft settlement conference statement; reviewing emails re: same 0.6 $700 $420.00 12/1/19 Reviewing emails re: settlement negotiation strategy 0.5 $700 $350.00 12/2/19 Reviewing Apple’s settlement conference statement; emails w/ FOT team 0.5 $700 $350.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 11 of 55

12/3/19 Call w/ M. Lee re: strategy 1 $700 $700.00 12/5/19 Reviewing emails from D. Tejtel re: settlement conference 0.2 $700 $140.00 12/5/19 Preparing for and call w/ D. Tejtel re: settlement conference 0.7 $700 $490.00 12/6/19 Reviewing emails to/from co-counsel re: settlement issues 0.5 $700 $350.00 12/6/19 Preparing for and call w/ D. Tejtel re: strategy 0.4 $700 $280.00 12/6/19 Emails w/ D. Tejtel re: trial prep 0.2 $700 $140.00 12/9/19 Work on email to group re: CJT 0.1 $700 $70.00 12/12/19 Reviewing emails re: motions in limine and other pre-trial issues 0.5 $700 $350.00 12/13/19 Reviewing emails re: motions in limine and trial prep 0.7 $700 $490.00 12/13/19 Preparing for and call w/ D. Tejtel re: strategy 0.5 $700 $350.00 12/16/19 Call w/ D. Tejtel re: strategy 0.5 $700 $350.00 12/19/19 Reviewing emails re: jury instructions 0.4 $700 $280.00 12/28/19 Reviewing emails re: technical glitch and late filing 1.5 $700 $1,050.00 1/15/20 Emails w/ D. Tejtel re: settlement conference 0.3 $700 $210.00 1/15/20 Reviewing emails re: pre-trial issues 1 $700 $700.00 1/16/20 Reviewing emails from co-counsel re: witness list 0.5 $700 $350.00 1/16/20 Communications w/ D. Tejtel re: settlement and pre-trial conference 0.8 $700 $560.00 1/20/20 Reviewing emails and memo re: SOL issues 0.6 $700 $420.00 1/22/20 Preparing for and call w/ D. Tejtel re: settlement strategy 0.5 $700 $350.00 1/24/20 Emails w/ D. Tejtel re: settlement negotiations 0.5 $700 $350.00 1/24/20 Reviewing emails re: limiting instruction 0.4 $700 $280.00 1/31/20 Call w/ D. Tejtel re: notice costs and strategy 0.5 $700 $350.00 1/31/20 Emails w/ FOT team re: revised settlement proposal 0.2 $700 $140.00 2/2/20 Reviewing emails from co-counsel re: judge’s proposal 0.5 $700 $350.00 2/3/20 Preparing for and call w/ co-counsel re: judge’s proposal 1 $700 $700.00 2/5/20 Emails w/ D. Tejtel re: notice costs 0.1 $700 $70.00 2/7/20 Reviewing emails from co-counsel re: settlement 0.5 $700 $350.00 2/25/20 Reviewing emails re: settlement agreement issues 0.2 $700 $140.00 3/2/20 Preparing for and call w/ co-counsel re: settlement agreement issues 0.7 $700 $490.00 3/5/20 Preparing for and call w/ co-counsel re: settlement issues 1 $700 $700.00 3/9/20 Reviewing emails re: status of settlement documentation 0.2 $700 $140.00 3/9/20 Reviewing emails re: settlement issues 0.1 $700 $70.00 3/15/20 Reviewing emails from co-counsel re: settlement status 0.2 $700 $140.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 12 of 55

3/17/20 Reviewing emails re: settlement documentation status 0.2 $700 $140.00 3/25/20 Reviewing emails re: settlement status 0.1 $700 $70.00 4/21/20 Emails re: executing settlement agreement 0.1 $700 $70.00 4/24/20 Reviewing emails from co-counsel re: settlement status 0.1 $700 $70.00 9/3/20 Preparing for and call w/ D. Tejtel re: preliminary approval hearing 0.3 $700 $210.00

Total 136.3 $91,870.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 13 of 55

TAB B

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 14 of 55

Spencer Oster Time Detail Grace v. Apple, Inc. -- No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Inception through 10.31.20

Date Task Hours Hourly Rate Amount 8/25/16 Email with group regarding FaceTime matter 0.2 $600 $120.00 8/26/16 Research and email regarding potential claims 2 $600 $1,200.00 8/26/16 Group call regarding potential claims 0.5 $600 $300.00 9/1/16 Review of background for potential FaceTime claims, email with group 0.5 $600 $300.00 9/2/16 Review articles and messages regarding Facetime and iOS 1.5 $600 $900.00 9/6/16 Research regarding potential class in FaceTime case 0.5 $600 $300.00 9/7/16 Email with group regarding FaceTime claims 0.2 $600 $120.00 9/9/16 Call with group regarding potential claims 0.2 $600 $120.00 9/14/16 Email with group regarding FaceTime claims 0.2 $600 $120.00 9/17/16 Email with group regarding FaceTime claims 0.5 $600 $300.00 9/17/16 Call with group regarding potential claims, emails regarding same 0.5 $600 $300.00 9/18/16 Email with group regarding FaceTime claims 0.5 $600 $300.00 9/23/16 Email with group regarding FaceTime claims 0.3 $600 $180.00 9/24/16 Email with group regarding FaceTime claims 0.5 $600 $300.00 9/30/16 Email with group regarding FaceTime claims 0.5 $600 $300.00 10/21/16 Email with group regarding FaceTime claims 0.2 $600 $120.00 11/1/16 Email with group regarding FaceTime claims 0.5 $600 $300.00 11/4/16 Research and edit facts for complaint 2 $600 $1,200.00 11/11/16 Email with group regarding FaceTime complaint 0.2 $600 $120.00 11/13/16 Email with group regarding FaceTime complaint 0.6 $600 $360.00 11/17/16 Research and edit complaint 2 $600 $1,200.00 12/2/16 Email with group regarding damages 0.5 $600 $300.00 12/14/16 Review complaint, email with group regarding edits and allegations 2 $600 $1,200.00 1/5/17 Review emails among group regarding claims and damages 0.8 $600 $480.00 1/20/17 Review of hot docs, group emails regarding discovery and potential witnesses 2 $600 $1,200.00 2/5/17 Review Apple emails among group 0.3 $600 $180.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 15 of 55

2/6/17 Email among group regarding Apple proceedings; review memo on Court 1 $600 $600.00 2/14/17 Review of Caldwell Cassady Curry memo regarding Court 2 $600 $1,200.00 2/28/17 Review Apple document requests 0.2 $600 $120.00 3/3/17 Review draft interrogatories and document requests 0.6 $600 $360.00 3/13/17 Review draft interrogatories and document requests 0.2 $600 $120.00 3/22/17 Email with group regarding Apple’s Motion to Dismiss 2 $600 $1,200.00 3/28/17 Review of Apple’s Motion to Dismiss, complaint 3 $600 $1,800.00 3/29/17 Review of Apple’s Motion to Dismiss 1.5 $600 $900.00 4/20/17 Email with group regarding discovery 0.2 $600 $120.00 4/25/17 Review FOT/CCC Sections of Motion to Dismiss Opposition Brief 2 $600 $1,200.00 4/26/17 Review FOT/CCC Sections of Motion to Dismiss Opposition Brief 2 $600 $1,200.00 5/2/17 Email with group regarding discovery 0.3 $600 $180.00 7/31/17 Review Motion to Dismiss decision, related email 0.5 $600 $300.00 8/2/17 Email with group regarding case prosecution and related expenses 0.2 $600 $120.00 8/10/17 Email with group regarding expert 0.1 $600 $60.00 8/3/17 Review and edit Case Management Order 0.5 $600 $300.00 8/14/17 Email with group regarding meet and confer and case management 0.5 $600 $300.00 8/21/17 Review revised interrogatories 0.5 $600 $300.00 8/25/17 Document review training, and review of production summary 2 $600 $1,200.00 8/28/17 Review of Apple’s discovery responses and objections 0.5 $600 $300.00 8/29/17 Email with group regarding discovery 0.2 $600 $120.00 8/30/17 Edits to responses and objections chart 1 $600 $600.00 9/5/17 Email with group regarding litigation expenses 0.1 $600 $60.00 9/20/17 Review of emails regarding discovery and proposed list of search terms 0.5 $600 $300.00 9/27/17 Review and edit memo regarding electronic privacy act 0.5 $600 $300.00 9/29/17 Document review training call 0.7 $600 $420.00 10/11/17 Document review call, and review of initial disclosures 1 $600 $600.00 10/6/17 Call with David Tejtel and Mike Lee, and review of discovery emails 1 $600 $600.00 10/12/17 Email with Mike Lee regarding discovery 0.5 $600 $300.00 10/17/17 Read revised letter to opposing counsel regarding discovery 0.2 $600 $120.00 10/18/17 Review of motion to compel, email with group 1 $600 $600.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 16 of 55

11/4/17 Email with group regarding claims 0.2 $600 $120.00 11/9/17 Email with group regarding discovery 0.2 $600 $120.00 11/16/17 Review of Responses and Objections to document requests and interrogatories 0.8 $600 $480.00 11/17/17 Review letter brief to Judge Cousins 0.5 $600 $300.00 11/27/17 Review discovery Responses and Objections chart 0.5 $600 $300.00 12/8/17 Review email regarding discovery 0.5 $600 $300.00 12/27/17 Review letter brief to Judge Cousins 0.5 $600 $300.00 1/9/18 Email with group regarding discovery 0.1 $650 $65.00 1/12/18 Review Motion to Compel 0.5 $650 $325.00 1/19/18 Email with group regarding 1 $650 $650.00 1/24/18 Review of discovery issues, and email with group regarding hearing and strategy 0.8 $650 $520.00 1/31/18 Email with group regarding case expenses 0.3 $650 $195.00 2/1/18 Review options for staffing, expenses 0.5 $650 $325.00 2/2/18 Email with group regarding experts and staffing 0.5 $650 $325.00 2/5/18 Email with group regarding case expenses 0.2 $650 $130.00 2/8/18 Reviewing emails regarding expiration of digital certificate 0.6 $650 $390.00 2/9/18 Review emails regarding discovery and hot documents 0.3 $650 $195.00 2/21/18 Review emails re: discovery and draft case management conference statement 1.5 $650 $975.00 2/28/18 Email with group regarding class certification 0.5 $650 $325.00 3/25/18 Review email regarding hot documents produced by Apple 0.5 $650 $325.00 3/31/18 Review of Apple filing, and email regarding response 0.5 $650 $325.00 4/12/18 Review of email regarding discovery update 0.5 $650 $325.00 4/23/18 Review of Gokul Thirumalai 30(b)(1) email 0.5 $650 $325.00 5/3/18 Review of McCarty/Pilmer letters, and related emails 1 $650 $650.00 6/25/18 Review of summary of Justin Wood deposition 0.3 $650 $195.00 7/2/18 Review of reply brief in support of class certification 0.5 $650 $325.00 7/9/18 Review of reply brief in support of class certification 0.8 $650 $520.00 7/13/18 Review of Motion to Strike Rubin testimony 0.5 $650 $325.00 8/7/18 Review Choy deposition transcript 0.3 $650 $195.00 8/28/18 Review expert reports 1 $650 $650.00 9/14/18 Review of letter brief regarding discovery 0.3 $650 $195.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 17 of 55

10/30/18 Review draft mediation statement, related email 1 $650 $650.00 11/2/18 Review mediation statement, supporting docs, related email 1.5 $650 $975.00 11/5/18 Review of 23(f) petition 0.5 $650 $325.00 10/23/19 Calls to discuss potential resolution 1 $650 $650.00 11/6/19 Email regarding settlement 0.5 $650 $325.00 11/19/19 Email regarding settlement 0.5 $650 $325.00 12/5/19 Review settlement emails, email with Mike Lee 1 $650 $650.00 1/28/20 Review settlement terms, related emails 0.5 $650 $325.00 2/1/20 Review settlement emails, email with Mike Lee 0.5 $650 $325.00

Total 69.9 $42,965.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 18 of 55

TAB C

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 19 of 55

David Tejtel Time Detail Grace v. Apple, Inc. -- No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Inception through 10.31.20

Date Task Hours Hourly Rate Amount 8.26.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 5.2 $600 $3,120.00 8.29.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 6.5 $600 $3,900.00 8.31.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 4.7 $600 $2,820.00 9.1.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 3.1 $600 $1,860.00 9.2.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 0.8 $600 $480.00 9.6.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 2.5 $600 $1,500.00 9.7.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 2.3 $600 $1,380.00 9.9.16 Communications with co-counsel re: potential action 1.3 $600 $780.00 9.13.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 2.2 $600 $1,320.00 9.15.16 Communications with co-counsel re: potential action 1.6 $600 $960.00 9.16.16 Communications with co-counsel re: potential action 2 $600 $1,200.00 9.17.16 Communications with co-counsel re: potential action 1.5 $600 $900.00 9.18.16 Communications with co-counsel re: potential action 1.7 $600 $1,020.00 9.19.16 Communications with co-counsel re: potential action 1.5 $600 $900.00 9.20.16 Research re: potential claims arising from FaceTime Break 1.1 $600 $660.00 9.21.16 Research re: potential claims arising from FaceTime Break 2.8 $600 $1,680.00 9.22.16 Research re: potential claims arising from FaceTime Break 3.1 $600 $1,860.00 9.22.16 Communications with co-counsel re: potential lawsuit re: FaceTime Break 2.4 $600 $1,440.00 9.23.16 Communications with co-counsel re: potential lawsuit re: FaceTime Break 1.7 $600 $1,020.00 9.29.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 1.2 $600 $720.00 9.30.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 0.3 $600 $180.00 10.3.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 1.5 $600 $900.00 10.3.16 Communications with co-counsel re: potential action 0.6 $600 $360.00 10.5.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 1.1 $600 $660.00 10.5.16 Communications with co-counsel re: potential lawsuit re: FaceTime Break 0.5 $600 $300.00 10.11.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 0.3 $600 $180.00 10.14.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 1.6 $600 $960.00 10.21.16 Communications with co-counsel re: potential lawsuit re: FaceTime Break 0.5 $600 $300.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 20 of 55

10.26.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 1.1 $600 $660.00 10.28.16 Strategy communications re: claims and initial pleadings 3 $600 $1,800.00 10.31.16 Drafting complaint 1.8 $600 $1,080.00 10.31.16 Strategy communications re: claims and initial pleadings 0.2 $600 $120.00 11.1.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 3.1 $600 $1,860.00 11.1.16 Drafting complaint 2.8 $600 $1,680.00 11.2.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 1.3 $600 $780.00 11.2.16 Drafting complaint 2 $600 $1,200.00 11.3.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 2.2 $600 $1,320.00 11.3.16 Drafting complaint 3.2 $600 $1,920.00 11.4.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 1.2 $600 $720.00 11.4.16 Drafting complaint 3.3 $600 $1,980.00 11.5.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 1 $600 $600.00 11.5.16 Drafting complaint 3.8 $600 $2,280.00 11.6.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 1.7 $600 $1,020.00 11.6.16 Drafting complaint 2 $600 $1,200.00 11.8.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 2.6 $600 $1,560.00 11.8.16 Communications with co-counsel re: potential action, and prep for same 1.1 $600 $660.00 11.10.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 0.6 $600 $360.00 11.12.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 0.2 $600 $120.00 11.12.16 Communications with co-counsel re: potential action, and prep for same 0.8 $600 $480.00 11.13.16 Communications with co-counsel re: potential action, and prep for same 1.5 $600 $900.00 11.15.16 Drafting complaint 1.9 $600 $1,140.00 11.16.16 Drafting complaint 5 $600 $3,000.00 11.17.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 1.6 $600 $960.00 11.18.16 Drafting/revision of complaint 2 $600 $1,200.00 11.21.16 Communications with co-counsel re: potential action, and prep for same 0.3 $600 $180.00 11.28.16 Review/revise complaint 1.2 $600 $720.00 11.30.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 0.4 $600 $240.00 12.1.16 Communications with co-counsel re: potential action, and prep for same 2.7 $600 $1,620.00 12.2.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 0.8 $600 $480.00 12.7.16 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 0.5 $600 $300.00 12.8.16 Communications with co-counsel re: potential action, and prep for same 1.6 $600 $960.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 21 of 55

12.9.16 Communications with co-counsel re: potential action, and prep for same 1.4 $600 $840.00 12.13.16 Review/revise complaint 1.3 $600 $780.00 12.14.16 Review/revise complaint 5.5 $600 $3,300.00 12.15.16 Communications with co-counsel re: potential action, and prep for same 0.2 $600 $120.00 12.22.16 Emails and call with co-counsel re: potential case, including prep for call 1.2 $600 $720.00 12.31.16 Review/revise complaint 1 $600 $600.00 1.2.17 Legal research re: potential claims 0.9 $600 $540.00 1.3.17 Review/revise complaint 2.5 $600 $1,500.00 1.3.17 Communications with co-counsel re: potential action, and prep for same 0.8 $600 $480.00 1.4.17 Review/revise complaint 1.5 $600 $900.00 1.4.17 Communications with co-counsel re: potential action, and prep for same 2.1 $600 $1,260.00 1.20.17 Communications with co-counsel re: potential action, and prep for same 1.3 $600 $780.00 1.25.17 Review/revise complaint 1.8 $600 $1,080.00 1.25.17 Communications with co-counsel re: potential action, and prep for same 0.7 $600 $420.00 1.26.17 Communications with co-counsel re: potential action, and prep for same 1 $600 $600.00 1.31.17 Communications with co-counsel re: potential action, and prep for same 0.5 $600 $300.00 2.1.17 Review/revise complaint 1.4 $600 $840.00 2.3.17 Communications with co-counsel re: potential action 0.3 $600 $180.00 2.6.17 Research re: underlying facts re: FaceTime Break, and claims arising therefrom 0.9 $600 $540.00 2.7.17 Communications with co-counsel re: strategy, and prep for same 0.7 $600 $420.00 2.14.17 Research re: venue and local rules 1.1 $600 $660.00 2.15.17 Communications with co-counsel re: strategy, and prep for same 1.5 $600 $900.00 2.27.17 Draft/review discovery requests 3.5 $600 $2,100.00 2.28.17 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery 0.3 $600 $180.00 3.1.17 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery and strategy, and prep for same 1.2 $600 $720.00 3.2.17 Review/revise discovery requests 2.6 $600 $1,560.00 3.3.17 Review/revise discovery requests 1.8 $600 $1,080.00 3.13.17 Review/revise discovery requests 1 $600 $600.00 3.16.17 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery and strategy 0.2 $600 $120.00 3.20.17 Review/revise discovery requests 0.8 $600 $480.00 3.22.17 Review/analyze motion to dismiss briefing 2.7 $600 $1,620.00 3.23.17 Review/analyze motion to dismiss briefing 1 $600 $600.00 3.24.17 Review/analyze MTD briefing and communications with co-counsel re: same 1.4 $600 $840.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 22 of 55

3.25.17 Draft motion to dismiss opposition brief 2.6 $600 $1,560.00 3.26.17 Draft motion to dismiss opposition brief 3.3 $600 $1,980.00 3.27.17 Review/revise draft motion to dismiss opposition brief 0.6 $600 $360.00 3.27.17 Communications with co-counsel re: MTD opposition brief, and prep for same 0.4 $600 $240.00 3.28.17 Legal research re: motion to dismiss opposition arguments 3.7 $600 $2,220.00 3.30.17 Draft amended complaint 0.5 $600 $300.00 3.31.17 Draft amended complaint 1.2 $600 $720.00 3.31.17 Legal research re: amended complaint 0.4 $600 $240.00 4.1.17 Review/revise amended complaint 3.2 $600 $1,920.00 4.3.17 Review/revise amended complaint 1.5 $600 $900.00 4.4.17 Review/revise amended complaint 1.2 $600 $720.00 4.5.17 Review/revise amended complaint 1 $600 $600.00 4.8.17 Review/revise discovery requests 0.6 $600 $360.00 4.9.17 Review/revise discovery requests 0.3 $600 $180.00 4.19.17 Draft/revise draft motion to dismiss opposition brief 2 $600 $1,200.00 4.20.17 Draft/revise draft motion to dismiss opposition brief 1.4 $600 $840.00 4.23.17 Draft/revise draft motion to dismiss opposition brief 2.7 $600 $1,620.00 4.24.17 Draft/revise draft motion to dismiss opposition brief 4 $600 $2,400.00 4.25.17 Draft/revise draft motion to dismiss opposition brief 2.8 $600 $1,680.00 4.25.17 Legal research re: motion to dismiss opposition arguments 1.9 $600 $1,140.00 4.25.17 Communications with co-counsel re: MTD opposition brief, and prep for same 1.3 $600 $780.00 4.26.17 Review/revise draft motion to dismiss opposition brief 3.2 $600 $1,920.00 4.26.17 Legal research re: motion to dismiss opposition arguments 2.6 $600 $1,560.00 4.27.17 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery and strategy 0.2 $600 $120.00 4.27.17 Review/revise motion to dismiss opposition brief 2.5 $600 $1,500.00 4.28.17 Review/revise motion to dismiss opposition brief 5.5 $600 $3,300.00 4.28.17 Communications with co-counsel re: motion to dismiss opposition brief 2.3 $600 $1,380.00 4.30.17 Review/revise motion to dismiss opposition brief 2 $600 $1,200.00 5.1.17 Review/revise draft ESI protocol 1.4 $600 $840.00 5.2.17 Review/revise motion to dismiss opposition brief 0.6 $600 $360.00 5.3.17 Review/revise motion to dismiss opposition brief 3.7 $600 $2,220.00 5.4.17 Communications with co-counsel re: meet and confers 0.2 $600 $120.00 5.8.17 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery 0.7 $600 $420.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 23 of 55

5.9.17 Review/revise of case management statement and initial disclosures 1.5 $600 $900.00 5.9.17 Communications with co-counsel re: case management statement/initial disclosures 0.8 $600 $480.00 5.10.17 Review/revise case management statement and initial disclosures 0.7 $600 $420.00 5.10.17 Communications with co-counsel re: case management statement/initial disclosures 0.4 $600 $240.00 5.11.17 Review/analyze motion to dismiss reply 1.3 $600 $780.00 5.13.17 Review/revise draft ESI protocol 0.9 $600 $540.00 5.13.17 Review/revise draft ESI protocol 0.4 $600 $240.00 5.15.17 Review/revise draft ESI protocol 0.5 $600 $300.00 5.17.17 Communications with co-counsel re: case management statement/initial disclosures 1 $600 $600.00 5.17.17 Review of letters from opposing counsel re: discovery 0.2 $600 $120.00 5.18.17 Communications with co-counsel re: case management conference and strategy 0.6 $600 $360.00 5.22.17 Communications with co-counsel re: case management conference and strategy 1.1 $600 $660.00 5.23.17 Draft motion to dismiss argument outline 1.4 $600 $840.00 5.24.17 Draft motion to dismiss argument outline 5.2 $600 $3,120.00 5.24.17 Research re: motion to dismiss argument issues 1.3 $600 $780.00 5.24.17 Draft/revise stipulated protective order, and communications re: same 1.2 $600 $720.00 5.26.17 Revise draft motion to dismiss argument outline 0.3 $600 $180.00 5.30.17 Review/analyze case management conference transcript 0.2 $600 $120.00 6.1.17 prep for motion to dismiss argument 1.7 $600 $1,020.00 6.1.17 Meet and confer with opposing counsel re: discovery, and prep for same 1 $600 $600.00 6.1.17 Communications with co-counsel re: protective order and ESI, and prep for same 1.8 $600 $1,080.00 6.6.17 Revise letter to Apple re: protective order and ESI protocol 0.6 $600 $360.00 6.6.17 Meet and confer with Apple re: protective order and ESI protocol, and prep for same 2.5 $600 $1,500.00 6.7.17 Communications with co-counsel re: ESI protocol 0.2 $600 $120.00 6.7.17 Review proposed ESI stipulation and emails re: same 0.3 $600 $180.00 6.12.17 Review/revise ESI stipulation, and communications with co-counsel re: same 1.4 $600 $840.00 6.13.17 Review/revise ESI stipulation, and communications with co-counsel re: same 2.4 $600 $1,440.00 6.14.17 Revise ESI stipulation, and emails with co-counsel and opposing counsel re: same 3.7 $600 $2,220.00 7.29.17 Communications with co-counsel re: motion to dismiss order/opinion 0.2 $600 $120.00 7.30.17 Communications with co-counsel re: motion to dismiss order/opinion 1.2 $600 $720.00 7.31.17 Strategy communications with co-counsel re: case coordination 0.5 $600 $300.00 8.1.17 Strategy communications with co-counsel re: case coordination 0.3 $600 $180.00 8.2.17 Strategy call with co-counsel re: discovery and overall strategy 1.2 $600 $720.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 24 of 55

8.2.17 Fact research re: iOS versions 1.6 $600 $960.00 8.3.17 Draft/revise ESI search terms, and communications re: same 2 $600 $1,200.00 8.8.17 Communications with co-counsel re: ESI search terms 1.4 $600 $840.00 8.10.17 Review/revise proposed search terms, and communications re: same 1.9 $600 $1,140.00 8.11.17 Review/analyze Apple's answer 0.5 $600 $300.00 8.11.17 Draft/revise ESI search terms, and communications re: same 0.5 $600 $300.00 8.13.17 Draft/revise ESI search terms, and communications re: same 0.3 $600 $180.00 8.15.17 Review/revise joint case submission, and communications with co-counsel re: same 0.7 $600 $420.00 8.16.17 Review/revise joint case submission, and communications with co-counsel re: same 1.6 $600 $960.00 8.17.17 Communications with co-counsel re: interrogatories 0.2 $600 $120.00 8.18.17 Communications with co-counsel re: status conference 0.4 $600 $240.00 8.21.17 Review/revise discovery requests, and communications with co-counsel re: same 2.8 $600 $1,680.00 8.23.17 Review/revise discovery requests, and communications with co-counsel re: same 0.3 $600 $180.00 8.25.17 Communications with co-counsel re: document review 1.1 $600 $660.00 8.25.17 Review/revise interrogatories, and communications with co-counsel re: same 0.5 $600 $300.00 8.25.17 Review/analyze proposed search terms 0.3 $600 $180.00 8.27.17 Exploration of discovery vendor options and communications with co-counsel re: same 2.3 $600 $1,380.00 8.28.17 Exploration of discovery vendor options and communications with co-counsel re: same 0.6 $600 $360.00 8.29.17 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery, and prep for same 1.2 $600 $720.00 8.29.17 Review/analyze Apple's discovery responses, and emails with co-counsel re: same 3.7 $600 $2,220.00 8.29.17 Review/revise draft interrogatories 0.3 $600 $180.00 8.30.17 Review/analysis of Apple's discovery requests, and draft responses to same 1.1 $600 $660.00 8.30.17 Review/analysis of produced documents 1.5 $600 $900.00 8.31.17 prep for meet and confer re: discovery 1 $600 $600.00 8.31.17 Communications with co-counsel re: potential experts 0.2 $600 $120.00 9.1.17 Meet and confer with opposing counsel re: discovery, and prep for same 2.8 $600 $1,680.00 9.5.17 Meet and confer with opposing counsel re: discovery, and prep for same 2.5 $600 $1,500.00 9.5.17 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery disputes 0.2 $600 $120.00 9.6.17 Discussion with co-counsel re: document review 0.3 $600 $180.00 9.7.17 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery disputes 0.3 $600 $180.00 9.8.17 Communications with co-counsel re: case coordination 0.2 $600 $120.00 9.9.17 Analyze discovery disputes and communications with co-counsel re: same 0.8 $600 $480.00 9.12.17 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery 0.7 $600 $420.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 25 of 55

9.12.17 Communications with discovery vendor 0.5 $600 $300.00 9.13.17 Analyze discovery issues 1.9 $600 $1,140.00 9.13.17 Draft/revise letter to Apple re: discovery issues 1 $600 $600.00 9.14.17 Revise meet and confer letter, and communications with co-counsel re: same 2 $600 $1,200.00 9.18.17 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.2 $600 $120.00 9.19.17 Strategy call with co-counsel re: discovery and overall strategy, and prep for same 0.7 $600 $420.00 9.19.17 Communications with co-counsel re: motion to compel discovery 0.5 $600 $300.00 9.20.17 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.3 $600 $180.00 9.20.17 Revise search terms, and discussions with co-counsel and opposing counsel re: same 1.6 $600 $960.00 9.21.17 Review/revise document review coding protocol 1 $600 $600.00 9.22.17 Review/analyze Apple's discovery response letter 0.4 $600 $240.00 9.26.17 Analyze letter from Apple re: discovery issues and draft response 1.8 $600 $1,080.00 9.27.17 Coordination of meet and confer re: discovery issues 0.2 $600 $120.00 9.27.17 Draft/revise memo re: privacy implications of class member identification 2.2 $600 $1,320.00 9.27.17 Analyze discovery issues 0.5 $600 $300.00 9.28.17 Review/analyze discovery responses 0.7 $600 $420.00 9.29.17 Meet and confer with opposing counsel re: discovery, and prep for same 3.7 $600 $2,220.00 9.31.17 Draft/revise email to opposing counsel re: discovery 1 $600 $600.00 10.2.17 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery 0.6 $600 $360.00 10.3.17 Review/analyze email from opposing counsel re: discovery 0.3 $600 $180.00 10.3.17 Draft/revise emails to opposing counsel re: discovery 1.2 $600 $720.00 10.6.17 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery 0.7 $600 $420.00 10.10.17 Communications with co-counsel and opposing counsel re: discovery 0.5 $600 $300.00 10.11.17 Strategy call with co-counsel re: discovery and overall strategy 1.6 $600 $960.00 10.11.17 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.4 $600 $240.00 10.11.17 Review damages-related data 0.3 $600 $180.00 10.12.17 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery 0.5 $600 $300.00 10.12.17 Revise expert engagement letter 0.3 $600 $180.00 10.12.17 Review/analyze Apple's discovery requests 0.4 $600 $240.00 10.13.17 Strategy communications with co-counsel re: discovery 0.7 $600 $420.00 10.14.17 Review/analyze hot documents produced by Apple 0.8 $600 $480.00 10.16.17 Communications with co-counsel and opposing counsel re: discovery 0.5 $600 $300.00 10.17.17 Meet and confer with opposing counsel re: discovery, and prep for same 1.1 $600 $660.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 26 of 55

10.17.17 Review/revise motion to compel 0.6 $600 $360.00 10.18.17 Strategy call with co-counsel re: discovery and overall strategy 0.8 $600 $480.00 10.18.17 Review/revise motion to compel 2.8 $600 $1,680.00 10.23.17 Review/analyze Apple's supplemental disclosures 0.3 $600 $180.00 10.23.17 Strategy communications re: joint discovery letter re: disputed issues 0.2 $600 $120.00 10.25.17 Strategy call with experts and prep for same 0.7 $600 $420.00 10.25.17 Review/revise joint letter brief re: discovery disputes 0.8 $600 $480.00 11.1.17 Strategy call with co-counsel re: discovery and overall strategy, and summary of same 3.1 $600 $1,860.00 11.1.17 Strategy meeting and travel thereto 5.2 $600 $3,120.00 11.2.17 Travel from strategy meeting 2.4 $600 $1,440.00 11.2.17 Review/revise joint letter brief re: discovery disputes. 0.4 $600 $240.00 11.3.17 Strategy communications re: discovery 0.2 $600 $120.00 11.3.17 Communications with co-counsel re: third-party subpoenas 0.2 $600 $120.00 11.3.17 Communications with co-counsel re: third-party subpoenas 0.3 $600 $180.00 11.7.17 Strategy call with co-counsel re: discovery and overall strategy, and prep for same 1.1 $600 $660.00 11.7.17 Draft proposed order for motion to compel 0.8 $600 $480.00 11.8.17 Review/revise proposed order re: motion to compel, and emails re: same 1.3 $600 $780.00 11.8.17 Strategy communications with co-counsel re: discovery hearing 0.5 $600 $300.00 11.9.17 Analysis of open cases issues and communications with co-counsel re: same 0.4 $600 $240.00 11.9.17 Review/revise proposed order 0.3 $600 $180.00 11.9.17 Strategy call with co-counsel re: discovery and overall strategy 0.8 $600 $480.00 11.10.17 Review/analyze proposed search terms and ESI protocol 0.8 $600 $480.00 11.10.17 Communications with co-counsel re: responses to discovery requests 0.4 $600 $240.00 11.16.17 Strategy call with co-counsel re: discovery and overall strategy, and prep: for same 0.7 $600 $420.00 11.16.17 Review/revise responses to Apple's discovery responses 1 $600 $600.00 11.16.17 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.2 $600 $120.00 11.17.17 Review/revise joint letter submission re: Apple's interrogatory responses 1 $600 $600.00 11.20.17 Meet and confer with opposing counsel re: discovery, and prep for same 1.1 $600 $660.00 11.21.17 Draft/revise 30(b)(6) notice 1.2 $600 $720.00 11.21.17 Review/analyze Apple's amended discovery responses 0.4 $600 $240.00 11.27.17 Review/analyze Apple's discovery responses, and drafting of summary re: same 2.9 $600 $1,740.00 11.29.17 Strategy call with co-counsel re: discovery and overall strategy 0.5 $600 $300.00 12.1.17 Communications with co-counsel and opposing counsel re: discovery 0.4 $600 $240.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 27 of 55

12.6.17 Strategy call with co-counsel re: discovery and overall strategy 0.7 $600 $420.00 12.6.17 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.3 $600 $180.00 12.8.17 Meet and confer with opposing counsel re: discovery, and prep for same 2.8 $600 $1,680.00 12.11.17 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery 0.4 $600 $240.00 12.12.17 Communications with co-counsel and opposing counsel re: discovery 2.7 $600 $1,620.00 12.12.17 Revise Akamai subpoena 0.4 $600 $240.00 12.12.17 Revise 30(b)(6) notice, and discussion re: same 0.5 $600 $300.00 12.13.17 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.3 $600 $180.00 12.13.17 Meet and confer with opposing counsel re: discovery, and prep for same 1.3 $600 $780.00 12.13.17 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.6 $600 $360.00 12.18.17 Review/revise ESI search terms 0.8 $600 $480.00 12.19.17 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.5 $600 $300.00 12.20.17 Meet and confer with opposing counsel re: discovery, and prep for same 3 $600 $1,800.00 12.20.17 Strategy call with co-counsel re: discovery and overall strategy 0.7 $600 $420.00 12.20.17 Communications with co-counsel re: damages and discovery, and prep: for same 0.5 $600 $300.00 12.20.17 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.3 $600 $180.00 12.22.17 Communications with co-counsel re: stay denial and discovery, and prep: for same 0.8 $600 $480.00 12.22.17 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 1.2 $600 $720.00 12.22.17 Draft proposed revisions to Apple's discovery requests, and emails re: same 1.5 $600 $900.00 12.22.17 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery 0.3 $600 $180.00 12.23.17 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.6 $600 $360.00 12.23.17 Communications with co-counsel re: ESI search terms 0.4 $600 $240.00 12.27.17 Communications with co-counsel re: expert and discovery issues 0.8 $600 $480.00 12.28.17 Review/revise motion to compel joint letter brief 1 $600 $600.00 12.29.17 Discussion with expert and prep for same 0.8 $600 $480.00 12.29.17 Strategy call with co-counsel re: discovery and overall strategy 0.5 $600 $300.00 12.29.17 Draft email summary re: strategy call 0.4 $600 $240.00 12.29.17 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery issues 0.3 $600 $180.00 1.2.18 Meet and confer with opposing counsel and prep for same 1.2 $650 $780.00 1.14.18 Draft discovery requests 0.5 $650 $325.00 1.5.18 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery issues 0.7 $650 $455.00 1.6.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.4 $650 $260.00 1.6.18 Review/revise third-party discovery requests 0.6 $650 $390.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 28 of 55

1.9.18 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery 0.5 $650 $325.00 1.10.18 Review/revise third-party discovery requests 0.4 $650 $260.00 1.10.18 Review/revise discovery requests to Apple 0.8 $650 $520.00 1.10.18 Review/revise class certification brief 0.5 $650 $325.00 1.10.18 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery issues 0.3 $650 $195.00 1.10.18 Draft joint letter brief re: discovery disputes 1.5 $650 $975.00 1.10.18 Strategy call with co-counsel re: discovery and overall strategy, and prep: for same 1.3 $650 $845.00 1.10.18 Revise joint letter brief re: discovery responses, and communications re: same 0.8 $650 $520.00 1.10.18 Review/revise discovery requests 0.4 $650 $260.00 1.11.18 Revise joint letter brief re: interrogatory responses, and communications re: same 0.7 $650 $455.00 1.12.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 1.2 $650 $780.00 1.12.18 Review/revise letter to opposing counsel re: privilege issues 0.9 $650 $585.00 1.12.18 Review/revise joint letter brief 0.5 $650 $325.00 1.13.18 Communications with co-counsel re: hearing on discovery issues 0.3 $650 $195.00 1.16.18 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery issues 0.6 $650 $390.00 1.17.18 Strategy call with co-counsel re: discovery and overall strategy 0.9 $650 $585.00 1.18.18 Draft/revise joint letter brief re: document requests, and research re: same 2.5 $650 $1,625.00 1.18.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.3 $650 $195.00 1.19.18 Review/revise joint letter brief re: forensic imaging 1.1 $650 $715.00 1.20.18 Communications with opposing counsel and co-counsel re: discovery issues 0.7 $650 $455.00 1.20.18 Communications with opposing counsel and co-counsel re: discovery issues 1 $650 $650.00 1.22.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.2 $650 $130.00 1.22.18 Review/revise supplemental motion to compel brief and proposed order 1.3 $650 $845.00 1.23.18 Strategy call with co-counsel re: discovery and overall strategy 0.6 $650 $390.00 1.23.18 Review/analyze Apple's supplemental motion to compel submission 0.7 $650 $455.00 1.24.18 Communications with co-counsel re: motion to compel hearing 0.5 $650 $325.00 1.24.18 Strategy call with co-counsel re: discovery and overall strategy, and prep: for same 1.2 $650 $780.00 1.25.18 Draft/revise joint letter brief re: document requests 2.8 $650 $1,820.00 1.25.18 Research/analysis re: class cert issues, and communications with co-counsel re: same 2 $650 $1,300.00 1.26.18 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery record to-date 0.4 $650 $260.00 1.26.18 Research re: elements of claims asserted by Plaintiffs 0.7 $650 $455.00 1.29.18 Strategy communications with co-counsel re: claims, and research re: same 0.5 $650 $325.00 1.31.18 Call with co-counsel re: document review progress and findings, and prep: for same 0.6 $650 $390.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 29 of 55

1.31.18 Strategy call with co-counsel re: discovery and overall strategy, and prep: for same 1.6 $650 $1,040.00 2.1.18 Communications with co-counsel re: document review 0.2 $650 $130.00 2.1.18 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery and class cert 0.8 $650 $520.00 2.2.18 Review/revise discovery requests 1.9 $650 $1,235.00 2.2.18 Strategy communications with co-counsel re: discovery and case prospects 2.2 $650 $1,430.00 2.2.18 Review/revise joint letter brief, and email to opposing counsel re: joint letter brief 0.8 $650 $520.00 2.3.18 Review/analyze Apple's discovery responses 1.3 $650 $845.00 2.5.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.5 $650 $325.00 2.5.18 Communications with co-counsel re: document review 1.1 $650 $715.00 2.6.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 1.4 $650 $910.00 2.6.18 Review/revise case management conference statement, and emails re: same 1.3 $650 $845.00 2.6.18 Meet and confer with opposing counsel re: discovery issues, and emails re: same 1.8 $650 $1,170.00 2.7.18 Call with expert and prep for same 1.3 $650 $845.00 2.7.18 Strategy call with co-counsel re: discovery and overall strategy, and emails re: same 0.7 $650 $455.00 2.7.18 Communications with co-counsel re: case strategy and discovery disputes 0.6 $650 $390.00 2.7.18 Review/revise case management conference statement, and emails re: same 1.2 $650 $780.00 2.8.18 Review/analyze Apple's discovery requests and responses 1.4 $650 $910.00 2.8.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.2 $650 $130.00 2.8.18 Review/analysis of hot documents produced by Apple 1.1 $650 $715.00 2.9.18 Meet and confer with opposing counsel and prep for same 0.7 $650 $455.00 2.9.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues, and research re: same 1 $650 $650.00 2.9.18 Review/analyze hot documents, and communications with co-counsel re: same 1.3 $650 $845.00 2.10.18 Review/analyze Apple's discovery responses 0.6 $650 $390.00 2.12.18 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery disputes 0.3 $650 $195.00 2.13.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.2 $650 $130.00 2.13.18 Research re: class certification arguments 2.7 $650 $1,755.00 2.13.18 Review/revise deposition 30(b)(6) outline 2.3 $650 $1,495.00 2.13.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.5 $650 $325.00 2.15.18 Review/analyze third-party valuation data 0.9 $650 $585.00 2.15.18 Review/analyze summary of 30(b)(6) deposition 0.3 $650 $195.00 2.16.18 Review/revise case management conference statement, and emails s re: same 1.2 $650 $780.00 2.16.18 Call re: case management conference statement, and prep for same 0.4 $650 $260.00 2.20.18 Communications with co-counsel re: damages 0.5 $650 $325.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 30 of 55

2.21.18 Strategy call with co-counsel re: discovery and overall strategy, and prep for same 1.3 $650 $845.00 2.21.18 Review/revise case management conference statement, and emails re: same 1.9 $650 $1,235.00 2.26.18 Meet and confer with opposing counsel and prep for same 0.5 $650 $325.00 2.27.18 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery 0.4 $650 $260.00 2.21.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery 0.2 $650 $130.00 2.28.18 Strategy call with co-counsel re: discovery and overall strategy, and prep for same 1.2 $650 $780.00 3.1.18 Draft/revise discovery responses 1.5 $650 $975.00 3.1.18 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery responses 0.8 $650 $520.00 3.2.18 Draft/revise discovery responses 1.3 $650 $845.00 3.2.18 Review hot documents produced by Apple 1.9 $650 $1,235.00 3.3.18 Draft/revise discovery responses 2.4 $650 $1,560.00 3.3.18 Review hot documents produced by Apple 3.5 $650 $2,275.00 3.4.18 Draft/revise discovery responses 1.3 $650 $845.00 3.4.18 Review hot documents produced by Apple 2.8 $650 $1,820.00 3.5.18 Draft/revise discovery responses 0.6 $650 $390.00 3.5.18 Review hot documents produced by Apple 2.3 $650 $1,495.00 3.5.18 Communications with co-counsel re: deposition strategy 0.2 $650 $130.00 3.6.18 Strategy call with co-counsel re: discovery and overall strategy, and prep for same 1.1 $650 $715.00 3.6.18 Emails with co-counsel and opposing counsel re: discovery issues and meet and confer 0.3 $650 $195.00 3.9.18 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery issues 0.3 $650 $195.00 3.10.18 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery issues 0.7 $650 $455.00 3.12.18 Meet and confer with opposing counsel and prep for same 3.3 $650 $2,145.00 3.13.18 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery issues 0.2 $650 $130.00 3.14.18 Strategy call with co-counsel re: discovery and overall strategy, and prep for same 0.8 $650 $520.00 3.15.18 Communications with co-counsel and opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.3 $650 $195.00 3.16.18 Communications with co-counsel and opposing counsel re: discovery 1.7 $650 $1,105.00 3.18.18 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery issues 0.2 $650 $130.00 3.19.18 Meet and confer with opposing counsel and prep for same 2.2 $650 $1,430.00 3.19.18 Review hot documents produced by Apple 1.3 $650 $845.00 3.21.18 Review/revise joint letter brief, and communications re: same 2.8 $650 $1,820.00 3.21.18 Review/revise responses to requests for admission, and communications re: same 0.9 $650 $585.00 3.22.18 Strategy call with co-counsel re: class certification and other issues, and prep for same 1.5 $650 $975.00 3.22.18 Strategy call with A. Curry re: class certification and other issues, and prep for same 0.7 $650 $455.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 31 of 55

3.22.18 Review/analyze Apple's revisions to joint letter brief 0.4 $650 $260.00 3.22.18 Communications with W. McCarty re: class cert brief, and prep for same 0.6 $650 $390.00 3.22.18 Draft/revise class certification brief 2.9 $650 $1,885.00 3.23.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.4 $650 $260.00 3.23.18 Communications with co-counsel re: class certification issues 0.2 $650 $130.00 3.23.18 Draft/revise class certification brief 2.2 $650 $1,430.00 3.23.18 Review/analysis of hot documents produced by Apple 3.1 $650 $2,015.00 3.23.18 Review/analysis of Apple's motion to compel submission 0.5 $650 $325.00 3.24.18 Draft/revise class certification brief 4.6 $650 $2,990.00 3.24.18 Review/analysis of hot documents produced by Apple 2.8 $650 $1,820.00 3.25.18 Draft/revise class certification brief 3.9 $650 $2,535.00 3.25.18 Review/analysis of hot documents produced by Apple 1.1 $650 $715.00 3.26.18 Analysis of open discovery issues and communications with co-counsel re same 0.7 $650 $455.00 3.26.18 Draft/revise response to Apple's joint letter brief re: FaceTime logs 1.4 $650 $910.00 3.26.18 Draft/revise joint letter brief re: texts/instant messages and 30(b)(6) deposition 2.6 $650 $1,690.00 3.27.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.2 $650 $130.00 3.28.18 Review/analyze Apple's discovery responses 0.7 $650 $455.00 3.28.18 Weekly strategy call with co-counsel re: discovery and damages, and prep for same 1.6 $650 $1,040.00 3.29.18 Review/revise discovery requests to Apple 1 $650 $650.00 3.29.18 Meet and confer with opposing counsel and prep for same 2.7 $650 $1,755.00 4.2.18 Review/analysis of hot documents produced by Apple 1.3 $650 $845.00 4.2.18 Draft proposed production protocol for 2nd RFPs, and communications re same 1.8 $650 $1,170.00 4.3.18 Draft proposed production protocol for 2nd RFPs, and communications re same 1.1 $650 $715.00 4.3.18 Review/analysis of hot documents produced by Apple 0.5 $650 $325.00 4.3.18 Communications with A. Curry and W. McCarty re: discovery 0.3 $650 $195.00 4.4.18 Communications with J. Manning re: discovery hearing, and research re: same 1.7 $650 $1,105.00 4.5.18 Revise proposal re: text message/IM discovery issue 0.5 $650 $325.00 4.6.18 Weekly strategy call with co-counsel, and prep for same 1.1 $650 $715.00 4.6.18 Meet and confer with opposing counsel and prep for same 1.3 $650 $845.00 4.6.18 Revise proposal for Plaintiffs' 2nd RFPs 0.4 $650 $260.00 4.6.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.6 $650 $390.00 4.6.18 Revise proposal re: text message/IM discovery issue 0.8 $650 $520.00 4.7.18 Communications with A. Curry re: discovery, damages and strategy 0.5 $650 $325.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 32 of 55

4.9.18 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery 0.2 $650 $130.00 4.10.18 Review/analyze letter to Apple re: 30(b)(6) deficiency 0.3 $650 $195.00 4.10.18 Review/analyze email from Apple re: discovery disputes 0.2 $650 $130.00 4.10.18 Review/analyze materials from expert 1 $650 $650.00 4.11.18 Weekly strategy call with co-counsel, and prep for same 1.3 $650 $845.00 4.11.18 Emails with co-counsel re: discovery 0.4 $650 $260.00 4.12.18 Revise discovery responses and emails re: same 0.4 $650 $260.00 4.12.18 Communications with A. Curry re: discovery and strategy, and draft email re: same 0.8 $650 $520.00 4.13.18 Review/revise class certification brief and supporting papers 2.9 $650 $1,885.00 4.16.18 Email to opposing counsel re: discovery 0.2 $650 $130.00 4.18.18 Analysis of discovery issues re: RFP Nos. 29-32, and draft email re same 0.5 $650 $325.00 4.19.18 Communications with expert and co-counsel re: damages, and prep re: same 0.7 $650 $455.00 4.12.18 Review/analyze Apple joint letter brief re: discovery responses, and emails re: same 0.6 $650 $390.00 4.22.18 Email to opposing counsel re: joint letter brief 0.2 $650 $130.00 4.23.18 Review/revise class certification brief and supporting papers 0.7 $650 $455.00 4.23.18 Review/revise letter to opposing counsel re: discovery 0.4 $650 $260.00 4.24.18 Review/revise discovery letter to Apple 0.3 $650 $195.00 4.24.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.3 $650 $195.00 4.24.18 Review/revise class certification brief 0.6 $650 $390.00 4.24.18 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery issues 0.8 $650 $520.00 4.26.18 Communications with opposing counsel and co-counsel re: discovery issues 1.7 $650 $1,105.00 4.27.18 Weekly strategy call with co-counsel, and prep for same 1.9 $650 $1,235.00 4.27.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.3 $650 $195.00 4.28.18 Review/revise class certification brief 1.5 $650 $975.00 4.29.18 Review/revise joint letter brief 1.1 $650 $715.00 4.29.18 Review/analyze discovery issues re: ESI search terms used, and emails re: same 2.8 $650 $1,820.00 4.30.18 Review/revise class certification brief 3 $650 $1,950.00 5.1.18 Review/analyze discovery responses 0.4 $650 $260.00 5.1.18 Draft letter to Apple re: ESI search term issue, and communications re: same 1.2 $650 $780.00 5.2.18 Review/revise class certification brief and supporting papers 4.3 $650 $2,795.00 5.3.18 Review/revise class certification brief and supporting papers 6.1 $650 $3,965.00 5.3.18 Draft/revise letter to Apple re: discovery issues, and emails with co-counsel re: same 0.9 $650 $585.00 5.4.18 Review/revise class certification brief and supporting papers 2.7 $650 $1,755.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 33 of 55

5.4.18 Communications with A. Curry re: discovery and strategy 0.5 $650 $325.00 5.5.18 Draft revised discovery responses 3 $650 $1,950.00 5.6.18 Draft revised discovery responses 2.2 $650 $1,430.00 5.6.18 Review/analysis of hot documents produced by Apple 2.4 $650 $1,560.00 5.6.18 Communications with A. Curry re: discovery 0.3 $650 $195.00 5.9.18 Review/revised discovery responses, and communications with co-counsel re: same 3.1 $650 $2,015.00 5.9.18 Review/analysis of hot documents produced by Apple 4 $650 $2,600.00 5.9.18 Weekly strategy call with co-counsel, and prep for same 1.2 $650 $780.00 5.10.18 Review/revised discovery responses, and communications with co-counsel re: same 4.3 $650 $2,795.00 5.10.18 Review/analysis of hot documents produced by Apple 2.8 $650 $1,820.00 5.10.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.6 $650 $390.00 5.11.18 Review/revise discovery requests, and communications with co-counsel re: same 4.2 $650 $2,730.00 5.12.18 Emails with opposing counsel re: discovery 0.2 $650 $130.00 5.15.18 Review/analyze emails re: document imaging issues 1.1 $650 $715.00 5.15.18 Review/analyze letter re: discovery issues 0.4 $650 $260.00 5.17.18 Draft/revise letter to Apple re: search term issue, and communications re: same 1.3 $650 $845.00 5.18.18 Draft/revise letter to Apple re: search term issue, and communications re: same 2.6 $650 $1,690.00 5.18.18 Draft/revise motion for protective order 1.8 $650 $1,170.00 5.18.18 Communications with co-counsel re: Grace deposition 0.2 $650 $130.00 5.19.18 Review/analysis of hot documents produced by Apple 2.5 $650 $1,625.00 5.20.18 Review/analysis of hot documents produced by Apple 1.2 $650 $780.00 5.21.18 Discovery meeting, and prep for same 7.4 $650 $4,810.00 5.23.18 Weekly strategy call with co-counsel, and prep for same 0.5 $650 $325.00 5.23.18 Communications with co-counsel and opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.8 $650 $520.00 5.23.18 Research re: elements of claims asserted by Plaintiffs, and communications re: same 0.6 $650 $390.00 5.24.18 Draft letter brief re: search term issue 1.9 $650 $1,235.00 5.24.18 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery issues 0.3 $650 $195.00 5.25.18 Draft letter brief re: search term issue, and communications with co-counsel re: same 3.6 $650 $2,340.00 5.25.18 Communications with co-counsel re: third-party discovery, and prep for same 1 $650 $650.00 5.28.18 Communications with co-counsel and opposing counsel re: meet and confer 0.4 $650 $260.00 5.29.18 Review/revise discovery responses and communications re: same 0.6 $650 $390.00 5.31.18 Meet and confer with opposing counsel and prep for same 5.2 $650 $3,380.00 5.31.18 Communications with co-counsel re: meet and confer 0.5 $650 $325.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 34 of 55

6.1.18 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery 0.3 $650 $195.00 6.1.18 Draft memo re: meet and confer and open discovery issues 3.6 $650 $2,340.00 6.1.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: meet and confer and open discovery issues 1 $650 $650.00 6.2.18 Draft letter brief re: search term issue, and communications with co-counsel re: same 2.3 $650 $1,495.00 6.3.18 Draft letter brief re: search term issue, and communications with co-counsel re: same 1.7 $650 $1,105.00 6.4.18 Draft/revise joint letter brief re: search term issue, and emails with co-counsel re: same 2.5 $650 $1,625.00 6.6.18 Weekly strategy call with co-counsel, and prep for same 0.8 $650 $520.00 6.11.18 Email to opposing counsel re: discovery 0.2 $650 $130.00 6.12.18 Draft letter re: ESI preservation deficiencies 2.6 $650 $1,690.00 6.12.18 Review/analyze joint letter brief, and emails with co-counsel re: same 2.1 $650 $1,365.00 6.13.18 Weekly strategy call with co-counsel, and prep for same 1.5 $650 $975.00 6.13.18 Review/analyze Potter deposition transcript 2.9 $650 $1,885.00 6.14.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.8 $650 $520.00 6.14.18 Draft joint letter brief re: 2nd RFPs 3 $650 $1,950.00 6.14.18 Draft proposed order and declaration in support of joint letter brief 5.6 $650 $3,640.00 6.15.18 Draft/revise declaration in support of joint letter brief, and communications re: same 4.7 $650 $3,055.00 6.15.18 Revise proposed order in support of joint letter brief, and communications re: same 1.5 $650 $975.00 6.16.18 Review/analyze class certification opposition brief 0.7 $650 $455.00 6.18.18 Communications re: class certification briefing, and prep for same 3.4 $650 $2,210.00 6.19.18 Review/analyze class cert opposition, and draft reply re: same, and emails re: same 4.3 $650 $2,795.00 6.19.18 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery issues 0.2 $650 $130.00 6.20.18 Communications with W. McCarty re: class certification reply 0.4 $650 $260.00 6.20.18 Communications with A. Curry re: discovery hearing, and email to co-counsel re: same 0.8 $650 $520.00 6.20.18 Call with expert and prep for same 1.3 $650 $845.00 6.21.18 Review discovery hearing oral transcript 0.8 $650 $520.00 6.22.18 Communicatios with A. Curry re: case issues 1.1 $650 $715.00 6.22.18 Draft/revise class certification reply 6.9 $650 $4,485.00 6.22.18 Communications with co-counsel and opposing counsel re: discovery 0.3 $650 $195.00 6.22.18 Revise Choy depo notice 0.2 $650 $130.00 6.23.18 Draft/revise class certification reply 3.8 $650 $2,470.00 6.24.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.5 $650 $325.00 6.24.18 Draft/revise class certification reply 1.6 $650 $1,040.00 6.25.18 Communications re: class certification reply and prep for same 1.2 $650 $780.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 35 of 55

6.26.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery 0.4 $650 $260.00 6.26.18 Draft/revise class certification reply 0.7 $650 $455.00 6.27.18 Communications with expert, and prep for same 1.2 $650 $780.00 6.27.18 Meet and confer with opposing counsel and prep for same 2 $650 $1,300.00 6.28.18 Draft summary re: meet and confer, and email to opposing counsel re: open discovery issues 1.1 $650 $715.00 6.28.18 Research prior testimony from Apple's expert, and communications re: same 1.5 $650 $975.00 6.28.18 Communications re: class certification reply, and prep for same 1 $650 $650.00 6.29.18 Draft/revise class certification reply 1.6 $650 $1,040.00 6.29.18 Emails with opposing counsel re: discovery 1.3 $650 $845.00 6.29.18 Research and communications with co-counsel re: discovery issues 0.8 $650 $520.00 6.29.18 Communications with co-counsel re: class certification reply 0.5 $650 $325.00 6.30.18 Research and communications with co-counsel re: discovery issues 1.5 $650 $975.00 7.2.18 Revise class certification brief and communications re: same 3.2 $650 $2,080.00 7.2.18 Research and communications with co-counsel re: discovery issues 2.4 $650 $1,560.00 7.2.18 Strategy call re: class certification reply and discovery and prep for same 0.7 $650 $455.00 7.3.18 Draft/revise class certification reply 2.4 $650 $1,560.00 7.3.18 Draft/revise motion for clarification 0.5 $650 $325.00 7.3.18 Prepare for Choy deposition 0.6 $650 $390.00 7.4.18 Review/revise case management statement 0.9 $650 $585.00 7.5.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.2 $650 $130.00 7.6.18 Review/revise joint letter brief re: iOS 7 performance documents 2.5 $650 $1,625.00 7.6.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.2 $650 $130.00 7.6.18 Review/revise discovery requests to Apple 0.6 $650 $390.00 7.6.18 Prepare for Choy deposition 2.8 $650 $1,820.00 7.6.18 Communications re: Trexler depo and other case issues, and prep for same 1.1 $650 $715.00 7.7.18 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery 0.4 $650 $260.00 7.8.18 Review/revise class certification reply 2.2 $650 $1,430.00 7.9.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 1.3 $650 $845.00 7.9.18 Meet and confer with opposing counsel and prep for same 1 $650 $650.00 7.9.18 Emails with co-counsel re: class cert and motions to strike, and prep for same 0.8 $650 $520.00 7.9.18 Review case management conference statement, and communications re: same 0.9 $650 $585.00 7.10.18 Review/revise motion to strike 1.2 $650 $780.00 7.10.18 Review case management conference statement, and communications re: same 1.4 $650 $910.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 36 of 55

7.11.18 Communications re: class certification reply and motion to strike, and prep for same 1.7 $650 $1,105.00 7.11.18 Review case management conference statement, and communications re: same 0.6 $650 $390.00 7.11.18 Review/revise class certification reply papers 2.5 $650 $1,625.00 7.12.18 Review/revise class certification reply papers 5.1 $650 $3,315.00 7.14.18 Prepare for Choy deposition 4.9 $650 $3,185.00 7.15.18 Prepare for Choy deposition 5.5 $650 $3,575.00 7.15.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.4 $650 $260.00 7.16.8 Prepare for Choy deposition 9.8 $650 $6,370.00 7.17.18 Prepare for Choy deposition 14.3 $650 $9,295.00 7.17.18 Review/revise motion to strike 0.8 $650 $520.00 7.18.18 Prepare for Choy deposition and travel to deposition 10.7 $650 $6,955.00 7.19.18 Choy deposition, and prep for same 12.1 $650 $7,865.00 7.20.18 Travel from Choy deposition 3.4 $650 $2,210.00 7.23.18 Review/analyze Apple objection 0.5 $650 $325.00 7.23.18 Weekly strategy call with co-counsel, and prep for same 1.2 $650 $780.00 7.24.18 Communications with co-counsel and opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.8 $650 $520.00 7.25.18 Communications with co-counsel re: expert discovery schedule 0.4 $650 $260.00 7.26.18 Communications re: class certification 0.2 $650 $130.00 7.27.18 Review/revise authentication stipulation 0.6 $650 $390.00 7.27.18 Review/revise expert stipulation 0.3 $650 $195.00 7.30.18 prep for meet and confer re: discovery 1.1 $650 $715.00 7.31.18 Meet and confer with opposing counsel and prep for same 6 $650 $3,900.00 7.31.18 Review/analysis of hot documents produced by Apple 0.7 $650 $455.00 7.31.18 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery issues 0.3 $650 $195.00 8.1.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.9 $650 $585.00 8.1.18 Draft joint letter brief re: 2nd RFPs 2.5 $650 $1,625.00 8.1.18 Communications with co-counsel re: case strategy 0.4 $650 $260.00 8.3.18 Review/revise discovery requests 1.3 $650 $845.00 8.6.18 Draft/revise joint letter brief re: 2nd RFPs, and email to opposing counsel re: same 1.6 $650 $1,040.00 8.6.18 Review/revise discovery requests 1.1 $650 $715.00 8.8.18 Review/revise joint letter brief re: depositions 2.2 $650 $1,430.00 8.8.18 Weekly strategy call with co-counsel, and prep for same 1 $650 $650.00 8.8.18 Communications re: case administration 0.3 $650 $195.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 37 of 55

8.8.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery 0.3 $650 $195.00 8.8.18 Review/revise discovery requests 0.8 $650 $520.00 8.8.18 Communications re: potential mediators 0.2 $650 $130.00 8.9.18 Review/analyze Apple's discovery requests 1.9 $650 $1,235.00 8.9.18 Review/analyze recent class certification case law, and communications re: same 1.4 $650 $910.00 8.9.18 Review/revise reply in support of motion to strike Apple's expert 3.5 $650 $2,275.00 8.10.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery issues 0.2 $650 $130.00 8.13.18 Research re: recent class certification case law 0.7 $650 $455.00 8.13.18 Review/revise discovery requests 1.6 $650 $1,040.00 8.13.18 Meet and confer with opposing counsel and prep for same 1.3 $650 $845.00 8.14.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: discovery disputes 0.4 $650 $260.00 8.14.18 Weekly strategy call with co-counsel, and prep for same 0.7 $650 $455.00 8.15.18 Review/analyze Jones report 3.1 $650 $2,015.00 8.15.18 Review/analyze Apple's secton of joint letter brief re: depos 0.5 $650 $325.00 8.15.18 Review/revise joint letter brief re: 2nd RFPs 0.8 $650 $520.00 8.16.18 Communications with co-counsel and opposing counsel re: joint letter brief 0.2 $650 $130.00 8.20.18 Review/revise discovery responses 0.6 $650 $390.00 8.20.18 prep for discovery hearing, including communications with J. Cassady and W. McCarty 0.3 $650 $195.00 8.21.18 prep for discovery hearing, including communications with J. Cassady and W. McCarty 1.1 $650 $715.00 8.21.18 Review/revise discovery responses 0.8 $650 $520.00 8.23.18 Weekly strategy call with co-counsel, and prep for same 0.7 $650 $455.00 8.23.18 Collection of materials for experts 0.9 $650 $585.00 8.24.18 Collection of materials for experts 2 $650 $1,300.00 8.26.18 Draft/revise discovery responses 1.2 $650 $780.00 8.27.18 Review/analyze expert report 2.3 $650 $1,495.00 8.27.18 Communications with co-counsel re: expert report 2 $650 $1,300.00 8.27.18 Draft/revise responses to discovery requests, and research re: same 1.7 $650 $1,105.00 8.28.18 Review/analyze expert reports 4.8 $650 $3,120.00 8.28.18 Draft/revise responses to discovery requests 2.6 $650 $1,690.00 8.29.18 Draft/revise responses to discovery requests 3.5 $650 $2,275.00 8.29.18 Communications with co-counsel re: case developments and strategy 1.2 $650 $780.00 8.30.18 Draft/revise responses to discovery requests 3.4 $650 $2,210.00 9.1.18 Communications with co-counsel re: mediation and settlement 0.3 $650 $195.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 38 of 55

9.4.18 Review/revise discovery responses 0.8 $650 $520.00 9.5.18 Weekly strategy call with co-counsel, and prep for same 1.2 $650 $780.00 9.5.18 Review/revise draft stipulation 0.4 $650 $260.00 9.6.18 Review/analysis of hot documents produced by Apple 0.5 $650 $325.00 9.7.18 Review/analyze Vidrine and Caldbeck deposition transcripts 5.6 $650 $3,640.00 9.10.18 Research re: summary judgment arguments 2.7 $650 $1,755.00 9.11.18 Review/analyze Apple's discovery responses 2.9 $650 $1,885.00 9.11.18 Research re: summary judgment arguments 4.6 $650 $2,990.00 9.12.18 Weekly strategy call with co-counsel, and prep for same 1 $650 $650.00 9.12.18 Research re: summary judgment arguments 3.3 $650 $2,145.00 9.13.18 Research re: summary judgment arguments 1.9 $650 $1,235.00 9.14.18 Draft/revise discovery letter brief, and communicatios re: same 3.4 $650 $2,210.00 9.14.18 Research re: summary judgment arguments 2 $650 $1,300.00 9.15.18 Research re: summary judgment arguments 0.8 $650 $520.00 9.16.18 prep for Hastings deposition 0.4 $650 $260.00 9.16.18 Research re: summary judgment arguments 1.1 $650 $715.00 9.17.18 prep for Hastings deposition 4.7 $650 $3,055.00 9.18.18 prep for Hastings deposition 2.9 $650 $1,885.00 9.18.18 Review/analyze class cert decision, and communications re same 2.8 $650 $1,820.00 9.19.18 prep and travel for Hastings depo 7.2 $650 $4,680.00 9.19.18 Communications re: class certification decision and strategy re same 0.5 $650 $325.00 9.20.18 Hastings depo, prep for same, and travel from same 12.3 $650 $7,995.00 9.21.18 Communications with co-counsel re: class certification strategy 2 $650 $1,300.00 9.21.18 Communications with mediator re: mediation logistics 0.3 $650 $195.00 9.22.18 prep for Malhotra deposition 1.2 $650 $780.00 9.23.18 Research re: summary judgment arguments 1.3 $650 $845.00 9.24.18 Communications re: legal research re: causes of action and SOL 0.6 $650 $390.00 9.25.18 Communications with co-counsel re: class certification and settlement 1.5 $650 $975.00 9.25.18 Draft mediation statement 2.4 $650 $1,560.00 9.26.18 Draft mediation statement 11.8 $650 $7,670.00 9.26.18 Research and communications re: SOL issues, and draft/revise memo re: same 3.6 $650 $2,340.00 9.27.18 Draft mediation statement 4.3 $650 $2,795.00 9.27.18 Legal research re: SJ issues and SOL issues 3.7 $650 $2,405.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 39 of 55

9.27.18 Strategy discussions re: mediation 0.5 $650 $325.00 9.28.18 Draft memo re: summary judgment arguments and issues 8 $650 $5,200.00 9.28.18 Revise stipulation re: mediation deadline, and communications re: same 0.7 $650 $455.00 9.28.18 Review/revise research memo re: SOL issues, and communications re: same 2.4 $650 $1,560.00 9.29.18 Draft memo re: summary judgment arguments and issues 2.9 $650 $1,885.00 9.29.18 Communications with co-counsel re: discovery issues 0.4 $650 $260.00 9.30.18 Draft memo re: summary judgment arguments and issues 3.3 $650 $2,145.00 10.1.18 Draft memo re: summary judgment arguments and issues 5.1 $650 $3,315.00 10.1.18 Emailswith co-counsel and research re: motion for reconsideration and discovery 1.6 $650 $1,040.00 10.1.18 Review/revise papers re: motion for reconsideration and/or amendment 2.5 $650 $1,625.00 10.2.18 Draft memo re: summary judgment arguments and issues 5.8 $650 $3,770.00 10.2.18 Communications with co-counsel re: motion for reconsideration and/or amendment 1.4 $650 $910.00 10.2.18 Review/revise papers re: motion for reconsideration and/or amendment 3.7 $650 $2,405.00 10.2.18 Communications with expert 0.2 $650 $130.00 10.3.18 Communications with co-counsel re: trial strategy 0.7 $650 $455.00 10.3.18 Case management 0.5 $650 $325.00 10.4.18 Review/revise discovery responses 2.2 $650 $1,430.00 10.4.18 Communications re: trial strategy 0.4 $650 $260.00 10.5.18 Review/analyze SJ brief, including legal research and communications re: same 6.7 $650 $4,355.00 10.6.18 Draft SJ opposition, and legal research and communications re: same 6.1 $650 $3,965.00 10.8.18 Draft SJ opposition, and legal research and communications re: same 6.8 $650 $4,420.00 10.9.18 Draft SJ opposition, and legal research re: same 10.7 $650 $6,955.00 10.9.18 Communications with co-counsel re: summary judgment opposition 0.8 $650 $520.00 10.10.18 Draft summary judgment opposition, and legal research re: same 9.9 $650 $6,435.00 10.10.18 Weekly strategy call with co-counsel, and prep for same 1.2 $650 $780.00 10.10.18 Communications with co-counsel re: summary judgment opposition 0.6 $650 $390.00 10.11.18 Draft summary judgment opposition 12.3 $650 $7,995.00 10.12.18 Draft summary judgment opposition 5.4 $650 $3,510.00 10.14.18 Draft summary judgment opposition 1.6 $650 $1,040.00 10.14.18 Communications with co-counsel re: summary judgment opposition 1.2 $650 $780.00 10.15.18 Revise summary judgment opposition 8.5 $650 $5,525.00 10.15.18 Review/revise case management statement, and communications re: same 0.9 $650 $585.00 10.16.18 Revise summary judgment opposition, and communications re: same 6 $650 $3,900.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 40 of 55

10.16.18 Weekly strategy call with co-counsel, and prep for same 0.8 $650 $520.00 10.24.18 Communications with co-counsel re: cross-jurisdictional tolling 2.6 $650 $1,690.00 10.24.18 Weekly strategy call with co-counsel, and prep for same 0.8 $650 $520.00 10.24.18 Legal research re: cross-jurisdictional tolling 1.3 $650 $845.00 10.25.18 Communications re: cross-jurisdictional tolling issues 0.7 $650 $455.00 10.25.18 Legal research re: summary judgment arguments 0.3 $650 $195.00 10.25.18 Review/analyze summary judgment reply 1 $650 $650.00 10.26.18 Legal research re: nationwide classes, and communications with co-counsel re: same 0.5 $650 $325.00 10.29.18 Communications with co-counsel re: mediation strategy 2.3 $650 $1,495.00 10.29.18 Communications with opposing counsel re: mediation, and prep for same 0.6 $650 $390.00 10.29.18 Draft/revise mediation statement, and communications re: same 5.3 $650 $3,445.00 10.30.18 Draft/revise mediation statement, and communications re: same 3.5 $650 $2,275.00 10.30.18 Communications with co-counsel re: mediation strategy 1.1 $650 $715.00 10.30.18 Review Hastings errata, and communications re: same 0.4 $650 $260.00 10.31.18 Weekly strategy call with co-counsel, and prep for same 0.9 $650 $585.00 10.31.18 Communications with co-counsel re: mediation strategy 0.2 $650 $130.00 11.1.18 Draft mediation statement, and communications re: same 6.6 $650 $4,290.00 11.1.18 Draft/revise Rule 23(f) petition, and communications re: same 3 $650 $1,950.00 11.2.18 Draft mediation statement, and communications re: same 9.1 $650 $5,915.00 11.2.18 Communications re: 23(f) petition and mediation statement, and prep for same 0.7 $650 $455.00 11.2.18 Draft/revise Rule 23(f) petition, and communications re: same 1.2 $650 $780.00 11.2.18 Communications with expert re: errata 0.4 $650 $260.00 11.2.18 Communications with co-counsel and opposing counsel re: mediation 0.5 $650 $325.00 11.3.18 Communications re: Apple's mediation statement 0.3 $650 $195.00 11.5.18 Review/revise 23(f) petition 1.8 $650 $1,170.00 11.5.18 Emails with co-counsel re: case strategy including new claims, and research re: same 2 $650 $1,300.00 11.6.18 Communications with co-counsel re: mediation, and prep for same 2.4 $650 $1,560.00 11.6.18 Communications with co-counsel re: case strategy 0.7 $650 $455.00 11.6.18 Communications re: Hastings errata 0.3 $650 $195.00 11.6.18 prep for mediation 3.3 $650 $2,145.00 11.7.18 prep for mediation 8 $650 $5,200.00 11.8.18 prep for mediation, and travel to mediation 13.1 $650 $8,515.00 11.9.18 Mediation, prep for same, and travel from same 10.7 $650 $6,955.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 41 of 55

11.9.18 Communications with co-counsel re: case strategy 0.8 $650 $520.00 11.10.18 Travel from mediation 6.7 $650 $4,355.00 11.14.18 Communications with co-counsel re: case strategy including new claims 0.4 $650 $260.00 11.16.18 Communications re: 23(f) petition, including call and prep for same 0.6 $650 $390.00 11.16.18 Review/analyze Apple opposition to 23(f) petition 1.3 $650 $845.00 11.20.18 Communications re: 23(f) petition 0.4 $650 $260.00 11.21.18 Strategy discussions with co-counsel re case administration 0.8 $650 $520.00 11.26.18 Strategy discussions with co-counsel re case administration 1 $650 $650.00 12.4.18 Review/revise reply brief in support of 23(f) petition 3.1 $650 $2,015.00 12.6.18 Strategy discussions with co-counsel re case administration 1.3 $650 $845.00 12.10.18 Strategy discussions with co-counsel re case administration 0.4 $650 $260.00 12.11.18 Strategy discussions with co-counsel re case administration 0.5 $650 $325.00 12.17.18 Strategy discussions with co-counsel re case administration 0.3 $650 $195.00 1.25.19 Emails with opposing counsel and discovery vendors re: deposition transcripts 0.5 $650 $325.00 1.29.19 Research re: SOL issues, and communications re: same 1.1 $650 $715.00 2.19.19 Revise case management statement, and communications re: same 0.6 $650 $390.00 3.20.19 Communications re: 9th Circuit denial of interlocutory appeal 0.4 $650 $260.00 3.21.19 Communications with co-counsel re: case strategy going forward 0.3 $650 $195.00 3.22.19 Strategy call re: next steps and discovery, prep for same, and email re: same 1.2 $650 $780.00 3.22.19 Research/analysis re: statute of limitations issues, and communications re: same 1.3 $650 $845.00 3.25.19 Research re: statute of limitations issues and pre-judgment interest, and email re: same 3.2 $650 $2,080.00 3.26.19 Research re: statute of limitations issues and pre-judgment interest, and email re: same 0.3 $650 $195.00 3.28.19 Strategy call and prep for same 1.4 $650 $910.00 4.2.19 Communications and research re: statute of limitations and cross-jurisdictional tolling 0.7 $650 $455.00 4.2.19 Research re: multi-district litigation 2.3 $650 $1,495.00 4.3.19 Review/revise memo re: SoL and cross-jurisdictional tolling, and emails re: same 2.5 $650 $1,625.00 4.4.19 Strategy communications with co-counsel re: case trajectory and additional claims 2.2 $650 $1,430.00 4.8.19 Strategy call with A. Steyer, and communications with co-counsel re: same 0.8 $650 $520.00 4.9.19 Review articles re: Apple's use of digital certificates, and email re: same 0.4 $650 $260.00 4.10.19 Strategy call with co-counsel, and prep for same 1.2 $650 $780.00 4.18.19 Weekly strategy call, and prep for same 0.7 $650 $455.00 4.19.19 Review/revise case management conference report 0.3 $650 $195.00 4.23.19 Review/revise case management conference, and communications re: same 0.6 $650 $390.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 42 of 55

4.24.19 Review/revise case management conference, and communications re: same 0.5 $650 $325.00 4.26.19 Telephone conference re: case schedule and strategy, and prep for same 0.6 $650 $390.00 4.29.19 Call with co-counsel re: case strategy, prep for same, and emails re: same 0.8 $650 $520.00 4.29.19 Strategy communications with M. Lee re: new claims, and prep for same 1.2 $650 $780.00 4.29.19 Review/revise joint case management submission, and communications re: same 1.5 $650 $975.00 4.30.19 Call with D. Warshaw re: case strategy, prep for same, and email re: same 0.6 $650 $390.00 5.13.19 Strategy communications re: filing 0.2 $650 $130.00 5.14.19 Strategy communications re: SJ and potential new claims, and research re: same 0.8 $650 $520.00 5.15.19 Draft strategy memo re: next steps in litigation of case, and research re: same 1.1 $650 $715.00 5.15.19 Strategy call, and prep for same 0.9 $650 $585.00 5.15.19 Strategy communications with J. Friedman re: additional claims 0.4 $650 $260.00 6.2.19 Communications with co-counsel re: meet and confer re: class info 0.2 $650 $130.00 6.11.19 Communications with co-counsel re: notice administrator 0.4 $650 $260.00 6.11.19 Call with Apple re: class information and notice administrator, and prep for same 0.7 $650 $455.00 6.12.19 Communications w M. Lee re: call and cross-jurisdictional tolling research 0.2 $650 $130.00 6.18.19 Communications with co-counsel re: class information 0.3 $650 $195.00 6.19.19 Strategy communications with co-counsel re: new claims, and research re: same 0.8 $650 $520.00 7.18.19 Strategy call with co-counsel and prep for same 0.9 $650 $585.00 7.23.19 prep for SJ argument 1.6 $650 $1,040.00 7.26.19 Research re: case law impacting summary judgment 1.3 $650 $845.00 7.27.19 prep for summary judgment hearing 3.4 $650 $2,210.00 7.28.19 prep for summary judgment hearing 4 $650 $2,600.00 7.29.19 prep for summary judgment hearing 5.2 $650 $3,380.00 7.30.19 prep for summary judgment hearing, and communications re: same 2.5 $650 $1,625.00 7.30.19 Review/analyze Apple's Notice of Supplemental Authority, and emails re: same 0.9 $650 $585.00 7.31.19 prep for summary judgment hearing, and communications re: same 1.7 $650 $1,105.00 8.1.19 prep for summary judgment hearing, and communications re: same 8.8 $650 $5,720.00 8.21.19 Review/analyze summary judgment decision, and communications re: same 1.2 $650 $780.00 8.22.19 Review/analyze summary judgment decision, and communications re: same 0.7 $650 $455.00 8.23.19 Strategy calls with co-counsel re: strategy and potential settlement, and prepare for same 2.6 $650 $1,690.00 8.23.19 Draft/revise joint case management statement, and communications re: same 1 $650 $650.00 8.24.19 Draft memo re: going-forward case strategy, and research for same 2.8 $650 $1,820.00 8.25.19 Draft memo re: going-forward case strategy, and research for same 3.5 $650 $2,275.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 43 of 55

8.26.19 Draft memo re: going-forward case strategy, and research for same 2.6 $650 $1,690.00 8.26.19 Strategy call with co-counsel re: going-forward case strategy, and prep for same 0.9 $650 $585.00 8.26.19 Review/analyze Apple's draft case management conference statement 0.4 $650 $260.00 8.27.19 Call re: case strategy, including case management statement, and prep for same 0.7 $650 $455.00 8.27.19 Coordinate filing of Notice of Change of Address, and communications re: same 0.6 $650 $390.00 8.27.19 Review/analyze draft joint case management statement 0.5 $650 $325.00 8.28.19 Review/revise joint letter brief re: class info 1.1 $650 $715.00 8.29.19 Review/revise joint letter brief re: class info 0.8 $650 $520.00 9.4.19 Strategy communications re: damages and expert work 0.3 $650 $195.00 9.5.19 Strategy communications re: damages and expert work 0.2 $650 $130.00 9.6.19 Call with J. Friedman and M. Lee, then full group, re: case strategy, and prep for same 1.6 $650 $1,040.00 9.9.19 Communications with co-counsel re: case strategy 0.6 $650 $390.00 9.10.19 Communications re: mediation 0.3 $650 $195.00 9.11.19 Analysis of potential damages, and communications with FOT re: same 0.6 $650 $390.00 9.13.19 Calls with M. Lee and with full team re: case strategy, and prep for same 1.3 $650 $845.00 9.17.19 Draft/revise mediation statement 2.8 $650 $1,820.00 9.17.19 Communications re: client outreach 0.4 $650 $260.00 9.18.19 Draft/revise mediation statement 3.7 $650 $2,405.00 9.21.19 Communications with M. Lee re: class information produced by Apple. 0.4 $650 $260.00 9.22.19 Communications with M. Lee re: class information produced by Apple. 0.3 $650 $195.00 9.23.19 Draft/revise mediation statement, and communications re: same 2.7 $650 $1,755.00 9.24.19 Revise mediation statement, and communications re: same 1.3 $650 $845.00 9.25.19 Review/revise mediation statement 0.9 $650 $585.00 9.25.19 Telephone conference re: upcoming mediation and going-forward case strategy 1.2 $650 $780.00 9.26.19 Strategy communications re: upcoming mediation 0.8 $650 $520.00 9.30.19 Communications re: mediation and mediation brief 0.6 $650 $390.00 10.1.19 Strategy call re: mediation and prep for same 1.3 $650 $845.00 10.10.19 Review/revise mediation statement, and communications re: same 1.3 $650 $845.00 10.11.19 Review/revise mediation statement, and communications re: same 0.7 $650 $455.00 10.14.19 Research for upcoming mediation 1.2 $650 $780.00 10.16.19 Review/revise mediation statement, and communications re: same 1.2 $650 $780.00 10.16.19 Strategy call re mediation, and prep for same 0.5 $650 $325.00 10.20.19 Strategy communications re: mediation 0.2 $650 $130.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 44 of 55

10.21.19 prep for and travel to mediation 9.7 $650 $6,305.00 10.22.19 Mediation, including prep for same and travel from 11.4 $650 $7,410.00 10.23.19 Travel from mediation 6.4 $650 $4,160.00 10.23.19 Strategy calls withFOT, full co-counsel group, and A. Curry, and prep for same 2.9 $650 $1,885.00 10.23.19 Legal research re: issues re: potential settlement 1.5 $650 $975.00 10.25.19 Research re: potential settlement 1 $650 $650.00 10.26.19 Review/analysis of issues re: potential settlement, and emails re: same 0.8 $650 $520.00 10.28.19 Communications with co-counsel re: potential settlement 0.2 $650 $130.00 10.29.19 Emails and call with co-counsel re: potential settlement 1.8 $650 $1,170.00 10.30.19 Emails and call with co-counsel re: potential settlement 0.9 $650 $585.00 10.31.19 Communications with co-counsel re: potential settlement 0.2 $650 $130.00 11.05.19 Research re: potential claims in other jurisdictions, and emails with M. Lee re: same 0.8 $650 $520.00 11.05.19 Telephone conference with A. Curry re: potential settlement, and prep for same 0.6 $650 $390.00 11.05.19 Telephone conference with co-counsel re: potential settlement 0.7 $650 $455.00 11.08.19 Review/analyze pre-trial and trial schedule 0.6 $650 $390.00 11.08.19 Review/revise draft status update for Court, and communications re: same 0.3 $650 $195.00 11.08.19 Strategy calls with A. Curry and with full group re: potential settlement 1.5 $650 $975.00 11.12.19 Call re: potential settlement, and prep for same; review/analysis of memo 1.2 $650 $780.00 11.13.19 Telephone conference with co-counsel re: trial prep, and prep for same 0.9 $650 $585.00 11.13.19 Communications with co-counsel re: potential settlement 0.2 $650 $130.00 11.15.19 Communications with co-counsel re: potential settlement 0.2 $650 $130.00 11.18.19 Strategy communications with co-counsel 0.3 $650 $195.00 11.19.19 Strategy call re: trial prep, and prep for same 1 $650 $650.00 11.21.19 Strategy communications re: potential settlement, including call and prep for same 0.8 $650 $520.00 11.21.19 Strategy communications with co-counsel re: potential settlement 0.3 $650 $195.00 11.23.19 Communications with co-counsel re: potential settlement conference 0.2 $650 $130.00 11.25.19 Strategy call and emails re: potential settlement and trial prep, and prep for same 1.4 $650 $910.00 11.26.19 Telephone conference with A. Steyer re: potential settlement, and prep for same 0.5 $650 $325.00 11.26.19 Communications with co-counsel re: potential settlement conference 0.3 $650 $195.00 11.27.19 Call with A. Curry re: trial and potential settlement, and prep for same 0.7 $650 $455.00 11.28.19 Review/revise settlement conference statement, and communications re: same 1.3 $650 $845.00 11.29.19 Review/revise settlement conference statement, and communications re: same 0.6 $650 $390.00 12.01.19 Review/revise settlement conference statement, and communications re: same 1.1 $650 $715.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 45 of 55

12.01.19 Call with C. Pearson and D. Warshaw, and communications with co-counsel re: same 0.8 $650 $520.00 12.02.19 Emails and telephone conferences with co-counsel re: potential settlement 1.7 $650 $1,105.00 12.03.19 Review/revise case management conference statement 0.3 $650 $195.00 12.04.19 Travel to settlement conference, and prep for settlement conference 7.3 $650 $4,745.00 12.05.19 Settlement conference and prep for same, and call with J. Friedman re: same 12.6 $650 $8,190.00 12.06.19 Travel from settlement conference 9.2 $650 $5,980.00 12.06.19 Telephone conference with M. Lee re: potential settlement and case strategy 1 $650 $650.00 12.06.19 Communications with co-counsel re: potential settlement 0.8 $650 $520.00 12.09.19 Research re: statute of limitations issues, and communications re: same 2.1 $650 $1,365.00 12.09.19 Weekly trial prep call, and prep for same 1.3 $650 $845.00 12.10.19 Review/revise pre-trial statement, and communications re: same 2.8 $650 $1,820.00 12.11.19 Telephone conference with co-counsel re: trial issues, and prep for same 1.2 $650 $780.00 12.11.19 Review/revise jury instructions, and communications re: same 2 $650 $1,300.00 12.11.19 Review/revise pre-trial statement, and communications re: same 1.4 $650 $910.00 12.11.19 Communications re: potential motions in limine 0.4 $650 $260.00 12.11.19 Review/revise exhibit list, and communications re: same 0.6 $650 $390.00 12.12.19 Strategy communications re: potential settlement and trial, including joint settlement update statement0.4 $650 $260.00 12.13.19 Review/revise pre-trial filings and exchange documents 8.8 $650 $5,720.00 12.14.19 Review/analyze Apple's motions in limine 0.9 $650 $585.00 12.15.19 Analysis of potential new claims and communications with M. Lee re: same 0.3 $650 $195.00 12.16.19 Strategy communications re: potential other actions 0.5 $650 $325.00 12.16.19 Team call re: trial prep, and prep for same 0.8 $650 $520.00 12.16.19 Draft opposition to motion in limine, and research re: same 5.8 $650 $3,770.00 12.17.19 Strategy communications re: trial staffing 0.3 $650 $195.00 12.17.19 Review/revise oppositions to motions in limine, and communications re: same 3.3 $650 $2,145.00 12.18.19 Communications re: client issues 0.4 $650 $260.00 12.19.19 Review/revise jury instructions, and communications with A. Curry re: same 3.8 $650 $2,470.00 12.19.19 Communications re: client and client issues 0.3 $650 $195.00 12.20.19 Review/revise jury instructions, and communications with A. Curry re: same 7.3 $650 $4,745.00 12.23.19 Trial prep call, and prep for same 0.7 $650 $455.00 12.24.19 Communications re: opposition to Apple's Daubert motion, review of same 1 $650 $650.00 12.25.19 Review/revise draft opposition to Apple's Daubert motion 1.9 $650 $1,235.00 12.27.19 Draft/revise opposition to Daubert motion, and communications re: same 6.2 $650 $4,030.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 46 of 55

12.28.19 Strategy communications re: late filing 0.4 $650 $260.00 12.29.19 Review/revise declaration and stip re: late filing, and emails re: same 1 $650 $650.00 12.30.19 Strategy communications re: scheduling 0.3 $650 $195.00 01.02.20 Review/revise administrative motion re: Daubert opposition, and emails re: same 1.2 $650 $780.00 01.03.20 Review/analyze Apple's Daubert reply 0.9 $650 $585.00 01.03.20 Trial strategy call, and prep for same 0.7 $650 $455.00 01.06.20 Weekly trial prep call, and prep for same 0.8 $650 $520.00 01.07.20 prep for pre-trial conference 3.4 $650 $2,210.00 01.08.20 prep for pre-trial conference 4.3 $650 $2,795.00 01.08.20 Review/revise case management conference statement 0.4 $650 $260.00 01.08.20 Team strategy call and call with A. Curry re: settlement, research re:settlement 0.8 $650 $520.00 01.09.20 prep for pre-trial conference 2.2 $650 $1,430.00 01.09.20 Revise case management conference statement, and team strategy call re: same 0.8 $650 $520.00 01.10.20 prep for pre-trial conference 5.4 $650 $3,510.00 01.10.20 Review/revise notice materials 1.3 $650 $845.00 01.10.20 Draft/revise memo re: statutes of limitations, and emails with co-counsel re: same 4.5 $650 $2,925.00 01.11.20 Revise memo re: statutes of limitations, and emails with co-counsel re: same 1.1 $650 $715.00 01.11.20 prep for pre-trial conference 2.7 $650 $1,755.00 01.12.20 prep for pre-trial conference 6 $650 $3,900.00 01.13.20 prep for pre-trial conference 5.2 $650 $3,380.00 01.14.20 prep for pre-trial conference 4.4 $650 $2,860.00 01.15.20 Strategy communications re:settlement conference, including call with co-counsel 0.8 $650 $520.00 01.15.20 Prep for pre-trial conference (including drafting voir dire), and travel to same 11.7 $650 $7,605.00 01.16.20 Pre-trial conference and prep for same, and travel from same 8.4 $650 $5,460.00 01.16.20 Research re: excluding witnesses from trial, and drafting of memo re: same 3.8 $650 $2,470.00 01.16.20 Settlement conference with Judge Cousins 2.6 $650 $1,690.00 01.17.20 Travel from pre-trial conference 7.2 $650 $4,680.00 01.17.20 Analysis of Court order re: Apple witnesses, and communications re: same 0.3 $650 $195.00 01.17.20 Review/analyze pre-trial deadlines 0.8 $650 $520.00 01.20.20 Research re: statutes of limitations in non-California states 1.3 $650 $845.00 01.20.20 Draft proposed language for settlement agreement re: statutes of limitations 0.5 $650 $325.00 01.20.20 Strategy communications with co-counsel re: settlement, including group call 1.4 $650 $910.00 01.22.20 Communications with co-counsel re: settlement status update 0.4 $650 $260.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 47 of 55

01.22.20 Strategy communications with J. Friedman, M. Lee and A. Curry re: settlement 0.8 $650 $520.00 01.22.20 Weekly strategy call, and prep for same 0.7 $650 $455.00 01.23.20 Review/revise witness proffer, and communications re: same 2.7 $650 $1,755.00 01.24.20 Strategy communications with co-counsel re: potential settlement 0.7 $650 $455.00 01.24.20 Draft/revise limiting instruction, and argument re: same 5.8 $650 $3,770.00 01.24.20 Strategy communications with co-counsel re: witness proffer 0.5 $650 $325.00 01.25.20 Review/analyze proposed limiting instructions and arguments supporting same 0.8 $650 $520.00 01.27.20 Strategy call with J. Manning, A. Curry and D. Warshaw, and prep for same 0.6 $650 $390.00 01.27.20 Strategy call with full co-counsel group, and prep for same 1.1 $650 $715.00 01.27.20 Strategy call with A. Curry 0.8 $650 $520.00 01.27.20 Case discussion with L. La Marca and J. Friedman, and prep for same 0.6 $650 $390.00 01.28.20 Strategy communications with co-counsel re: potential settlement 0.3 $650 $195.00 01.29.20 Communications with co-counsel re: dissemination of opt-out notice 0.4 $650 $260.00 01.31.20 Emails with co-counsel re: potential settlement, and call with FOT re: same 0.8 $650 $520.00 01.31.20 Emails with co-counsel re: dissemination of opt-out notice, and research re: same 1 $650 $650.00 01.31.20 Research re: N.D. Cal. and Ninth Circuit rules and procedures re: settlement 1.3 $650 $845.00 01.31.20 Review/analyze settlement proposal, and communications with co-counsel re: same 0.3 $650 $195.00 02.01.20 Research re: Judge's settlement proposal, including SoL in non-California states 1.3 $650 $845.00 02.03.20 Telephone conference re: potential settlement, and prep for same 0.8 $650 $520.00 02.04.20 Communications with co-counsel re: potential settlement 0.2 $650 $130.00 02.04.20 Communications re: opt-out/settlement notice, including call with D. Warshaw 0.3 $650 $195.00 02.05.20 Communications re: opt-out/settlement notice, including call with D. Warshaw 0.6 $650 $390.00 02.06.20 Review/revise response to Apple's objections to witness proffer, and emails re: same 2.2 $650 $1,430.00 02.06.20 Communications with co-counsel re: settlement, including call with C. Pearson 0.5 $650 $325.00 02.07.20 Communications with co-counsel re: settlement, including call with C. Pearson 1.2 $650 $780.00 02.21.20 Communications with co-counsel re: potential settlement 0.3 $650 $195.00 02.24.20 Telephone conference with co-counsel re: potential settlement, and prep for same 0.8 $650 $520.00 02.25.20 Call with Apple re: settlement agreement, and prep for same, and emails re: same 1.1 $650 $715.00 02.25.20 Communications re: potential settlement 0.3 $650 $195.00 02.27.20 Communications with co-counsel and opposing counsel re: jury instructions 0.5 $650 $325.00 02.27.20 Prep and call with co-counsel re: trial prep, and call with D. Warshaw re: trial prep 2.2 $650 $1,430.00 02.28.20 Review/analyze draft settlement agreement 0.8 $650 $520.00 03.01.20 Communications with co-counsel re: potential settlement 0.4 $650 $260.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 48 of 55

03.02.20 Draft/revise jury instructions 1.6 $650 $1,040.00 03.02.20 Telephone conference with co-counsel re: potential settlement, and prep for same 0.8 $650 $520.00 03.03.20 Telephone conference with co-counsel re: potential settlement, and prep for same 1.4 $650 $910.00 03.04.20 Research re: sealing procedures, and telephone conference with S. Jain re: same 0.8 $650 $520.00 03.04.20 Research for findings of fact and conclusions of law 1.5 $650 $975.00 03.04.20 Draft/revise jury instructions 3.7 $650 $2,405.00 03.05.20 Strategy discussion with co-counsel re: trial prep and settlement, and prep for same 1.3 $650 $845.00 03.05.20 Communications with M. Lee re: FoF/CoL, and research re: same 1.9 $650 $1,235.00 03.05.20 Revise jury instructions, research re: same, and communications re: same 12.7 $650 $8,255.00 03.06.20 Review/analyze Apple's findings of fact and conclusions of law 0.8 $650 $520.00 03.06.20 Review/revise findings of facts and conclusions of law, and communications re: same 2.9 $650 $1,885.00 03.09.20 Review/revise memo re: class distributions, and research re: same 1.2 $650 $780.00 03.09.20 Strategy call re: trial and potential settlement, and prep for same 1.3 $650 $845.00 03.10.20 Strategy communications re: case strategy 0.4 $650 $260.00 03.11.20 Review/analysis of draft settlement agreement 0.8 $650 $520.00 03.23.20 Communications re: pre-trial stipulations 0.2 $650 $130.00 03.25.20 Review/revise settlement agreement 0.2 $650 $130.00 03.27.20 Communications re: proposed settlement 0.2 $650 $130.00 04.07.20 Review/revise motion for preliminary approval, and communications re:same 3.2 $650 $2,080.00 04.08.20 Review/analyze stay order, and communications re: same 0.3 $650 $195.00 04.08.20 Call re: preliminary approval brief, and prep for same 1 $650 $650.00 04.10.20 Communications re: proposed settlement 0.2 $650 $130.00 04.16.20 Communications re: potential settlement 0.2 $650 $130.00 04.24.20 Communications re: potential settlement 0.6 $650 $390.00 08.19.20 Communications with co-counsel re: preliminary approval hearing 0.3 $650 $195.00 08.25.20 Call re: preliminary approval hearing 0.4 $650 $260.00 09.03.20 Preliminary approval hearing, including prep for same 3.6 $650 $2,340.00 09.05.20 Communications and research re: submission in support of preliminary approval 1.7 $650 $1,105.00 09.07.20 Review/revise supplemental submission 1.1 $650 $715.00 09.08.20 Review/revise supplemental submission, and call with D. Warshaw re: same 4.2 $650 $2,730.00

Total 1629.9 $1,040,245.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 49 of 55

TAB D

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 50 of 55

Michael Lee Time Detail Grace v. Apple, Inc. -- No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK 1.1.19 through 10.31.20

Date Task Hours Hourly Rate Amount 1.28.19 Statute of limitations research 1.1 $550 $605.00 1.29.19 Research related to state SOLs and discovery rule 7.5 $550 $4,125.00 2.19.19 Correspondence related case management statement 0.1 $550 $55.00 3.23.19 Update on case status call from D. Tejtel 0.1 $550 $55.00 3.25.19 Correspondence and research related to PJI 1.7 $550 $935.00 3.25.19 Reviewed issue on PJI and correspondence 0.2 $550 $110.00 3.26.19 Reviewed PJI research and reviewed/commented on draft email to group 0.3 $550 $165.00 3.28.19 Weekly Facetime call and Prep 0.8 $550 $440.00 4.1.19 Review of SOL issues and discovery rule research 2.1 $550 $1,155.00 4.2.19 Research and correspondence related to American Pipe/China Agritech decision 1.5 $550 $825.00 4.3.19 Memo on state SOL research issues 11.2 $550 $6,160.00 4.3.19 Correspondence and case strategy call 1 $550 $550.00 4.10.19 Case call re: case strategy, prep, and follow up correspondence 1.8 $550 $990.00 4.18.19 Weekly call re: case strategy and correspondence. 0.5 $550 $275.00 4.24.19 Reviewed case management submission and correspondence 0.1 $550 $55.00 4.25.19 Correspondence related to court submission 0.1 $550 $55.00 4.27.19 Correspondence related to new case schedule 0.1 $550 $55.00 4.27.19 Correspondence related to case strategy call 0.1 $550 $55.00 4.30.19 Call with D. Tejtel re: case developments 0.7 $550 $385.00 4.30.19 Bullet points and research for D. Tejtel for call with A. Steyer 1 $550 $550.00 4.30.19 Correspondence re: D. Tejtel call with A. Steyer 0.1 $550 $55.00 5.15.19 Edits to Facetime email to group 0.3 $550 $165.00 5.20.19 Case management, including reviewing case status 1.7 $550 $935.00 6.11.19 Discussed case with J. Friedman and D. Tejtel 0.2 $550 $110.00 6.11.19 Meet and confer update and correspondence 0.2 $550 $110.00 6.14.19 Reviewed correspondence re: mailing 0.1 $550 $55.00 6.17.19 Correspondence re: D. Tejtel re: call 0.1 $550 $55.00 6.18.19 Prepared for call, researched issues on SOL and amendment 3.3 $550 $1,815.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 51 of 55

6.18.19 Call with Group re: various issue 0.7 $550 $385.00 6.19.19 Review of outreach strategy and comments 0.7 $550 $385.00 6.29.19 Correspondence re: meet and confer 0.1 $550 $55.00 7.4.19 Case management: file maintenance 2.3 $550 $1,265.00 7.8.19 Correspondence related to plaintiff search 0.1 $550 $55.00 7.10.19 Correspondence related to SJ hearing with D. Tejtel, and email to opposing counsel 0.1 $550 $55.00 7.11.19 Discussion with FOT related to mediation and emails related thereto 0.2 $550 $110.00 7.18.19 Group call re: SJ oral argument and case strategy 0.9 $550 $495.00 7.25.19 Discussed case issues with D. Tejtel 1 $550 $550.00 7.30.19 Reviewed Apple supp. authority case 0.2 $550 $110.00 7.31.19 Correspondence re: summary judgment, oral argument and supp. authority 0.2 $550 $110.00 8.1.19 Correspondence re: summary judgment and oral argument vacated 0.1 $550 $55.00 8.19.19 Calls with group and D. Tejtel re: amendment and new information and prep 1.1 $550 $605.00 8.21.19 Reviewed summary judgment order and correspondence 0.7 $550 $385.00 8.22.19 Correspondence with D. Tejtel re: SOL issues and amendment 0.2 $550 $110.00 8.22.19 Research re: class size 0.2 $550 $110.00 8.23.19 Case management edits and comments 0.9 $550 $495.00 8.24.19 Apple call with Group re: strategy, and prep for same 0.5 $550 $275.00 8.25.19 Research on statutes of limitations and cross-jurisdictional tolling 7.8 $550 $4,290.00 8.26.19 Research on statutes of limitations and cross-jurisdictional tolling 6 $550 $3,300.00 8.26.19 Draft/revise memo to co-counsel and emails with J. Friedman and D. Tejtel re: same 4.9 $550 $2,695.00 8.27.19 Reviewed Judge Koh’s standing orders 0.1 $550 $55.00 8.28.19 Correspondence related to letter brief 0.1 $550 $55.00 9.6.19 Call with Group re: strategy and prep 0.6 $550 $330.00 9.8.19 Correspondence re: mediator 0.1 $550 $55.00 9.11.19 Email re: damages and PJI 0.1 $550 $55.00 9.13.19 Call with D. Tejtel re: strategy 0.2 $550 $110.00 9.13.19 Discussion with group re: mediation; follow up 0.9 $550 $495.00 9.14.19 Email to D. Berger re: case strategy 0.1 $550 $55.00 9.18.19 Research on PJI and emails with D. Tejtel 2.6 $550 $1,430.00 9.21.19 Attempted to download database and emails 0.4 $550 $220.00 9.23.19 Review of mediation statement and comments 2.3 $550 $1,265.00 9.24.19 Call with D. Tejtel re: mediation statement 0.5 $550 $275.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 52 of 55

9.24.19 Emails with D. Tejtel re: mediation statement 0.2 $550 $110.00 9.24.19 Correspondence with A. Simon re: serial numbers 0.1 $550 $55.00 9.25.19 Update re: call from D. Tejtel 0.1 $550 $55.00 9.25.19 Emails related to demand number and PJI 0.1 $550 $55.00 9.29.19 Correspondence with A. Simon re: serial numbers 0.1 $550 $55.00 9.30.19 Correspondence re: database with D. Tejtel 0.1 $550 $55.00 10.1.19 Reviewed draft letter to Cahill 0.1 $550 $55.00 10.1.19 Reviewed A. Curry emails on alternative damages theory 0.2 $550 $110.00 10.1.19 Group call re: mediation strategy, demand and prep 0.8 $550 $440.00 10.10.19 Review of mediation statement and comments 1 $550 $550.00 10.10.19 Email to A. Simon re: database 0.1 $550 $55.00 10.11.19 Correspondence and emails related PJI and mediation issues, internal emails 0.2 $550 $110.00 10.12.19 Searched through spreadsheets re: serial numbers and correspondence re: same 2.5 $550 $1,375.00 10.14.19 Reviewed research from D. Tejtel re: Koh decisions and correspondence re: same 0.4 $550 $220.00 10.15.19 Reviewed final mediation statement and correspondence with D. Tejtel 0.2 $550 $110.00 10.16.19 Correspondence re: various issue related to mediation 0.2 $550 $110.00 10.22.19 Correspondence re: mediation 0.2 $550 $110.00 10.22.19 Reviewed Butler case for mediation 0.3 $550 $165.00 10.23.19 Call re: mediation/strategy with FOT and call with co-counsel re: mediation 2.3 $550 $1,265.00 11.5.19 Research on SOL for various states and correspondence 5.5 $550 $3,025.00 11.8.19 Call w/co-counsel re: mediation issues and prep 0.8 $550 $440.00 11.13.19 Update on call with co-counsel re: strategy 0.1 $550 $55.00 11.15.19 Update on settlement and other case issues and reviewed joint statement 0.1 $550 $55.00 11.18.19 Reviewed joint statement 0.3 $550 $165.00 11.23.19 Follow-up on open issues re: complaint and Apple’s public information 1.5 $550 $825.00 11.28.19 Reviewed law360 article on case 0.1 $550 $55.00 11.29.19 Reviewed mediation statement 1.5 $550 $825.00 12.1.19 Reviewed final draft of mediation statement 0.3 $550 $165.00 12.2.19 Revisions to Amended complaint and research on claims 5.2 $550 $2,860.00 12.2.19 Reviewed Apple’s settlement statement 0.3 $550 $165.00 12.3.19 Revisions to Amended complaint and research on claims 4.8 $550 $2,640.00 12.3.19 Call with J. Friedman re: case strategy 1 $550 $550.00 12.6.19 Update on mediation with Apple and call with D. Tejtel related thereto 1.1 $550 $605.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 53 of 55

12.8.19 SOL research 4.2 $550 $2,310.00 12.9.19 SOL research memo related to Chavez and other issues re: multi-district litigation 4.5 $550 $2,475.00 12.9.19 Call related to trial prep and preparation 1 $550 $550.00 12.10.19 Review of pre-trial statement 0.5 $550 $275.00 12.11.19 Review of trial exhibit list and draft jury instructions, and correspondence re: same 4.3 $550 $2,365.00 12.12.19 Correspondence related to instructions, schedule and settlement and joint report 0.2 $550 $110.00 12.13.19 Review of motions in limine 0.4 $550 $220.00 12.14.19 Reviewed Apple’s motions in limine 0.2 $550 $110.00 12.14.19 Correspondence re: witness list 0.2 $550 $110.00 12.16.19 Call with group re: trial prep and strategy 0.8 $550 $440.00 12.17.19 Review and edits to various MIL responses and follow up 5.2 $550 $2,860.00 12.18.19 Reviewed Apple’s MIL responses and correspondence related thereto 0.3 $550 $165.00 12.20.19 Reviewed jury instructions and arguments 0.7 $550 $385.00 12.27.19 Reviewed draft of Daubert opposition and relevant documents for inclusion 3 $550 $1,650.00 12.27.19 Call with D. Tejtel re: Daubert opposition 0.8 $550 $440.00 12.29.19 Correspondence related to late filing and other issues 0.7 $550 $385.00 1.4.20 Trial prep call with group, and prep for same 1 $550 $550.00 1.10.20 SOL research memo for Judge Cousins 4.5 $550 $2,475.00 1.11.20 Reviewed draft of SOL memo and research re: same 3.2 $550 $1,760.00 1.14.20 Correspondence re: trial prep issues 0.1 $550 $55.00 1.15.20 Updates on settlement issues 0.2 $550 $110.00 1.15.20 Reviewed rulings on MILs and other pre-trial issues and correspondence re: same 1 $550 $550.00 1.16.20 Correspondence related to pre-trial conference issues, witness list, and trial strategy 0.5 $550 $275.00 1.16.20 Update on mediation with Judge Cousins 0.1 $550 $55.00 1.17.20 Reviewed pre-trial order and update on conference 0.1 $550 $55.00 1.20.20 SOL research on Eighth Circuit states for TtC; correspondence re: settlement 4.7 $550 $2,585.00 1.20.20 Correspondence re: settlement 0.1 $550 $55.00 1.24.20 Correspondence re: filings issues, order, notice 0.2 $550 $110.00 1.24.20 Reviewed Apple declaration 0.2 $550 $110.00 1.25.20 Correspondence re: settlement 0.1 $550 $55.00 1.27.20 Call with group re: settlement strategy and prep, and prep time 1.2 $550 $660.00 1.31.20 Reviewed correspondence on settlement and pre-trial issues+B169 0.2 $550 $110.00 2.1.20 Discussed mediator recommendation with S. Oster 0.5 $550 $275.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 54 of 55

2.3.20 Correspondence re: settlement 0.1 $550 $55.00 2.3.20 Call with group re: settlement and prep 1 $550 $550.00 2.4.20 Reviewed Apple’s objections to Plaintiff’s witness proffer 0.1 $550 $55.00 2.5.20 Correspondence re: notice costs and reviewed response to witness proffer 0.1 $550 $55.00 2.6.20 Correspondence re: settlement 0.1 $550 $55.00 2.7.20 Update re: settlement 0.1 $550 $55.00 2.10.20 Issues re: notice of settlement and denial of motion to vacate 0.1 $550 $55.00 2.12.20 Case management issues 0.8 $550 $440.00 2.14.20 Correspondence re: pre-trial schedule 0.1 $550 $55.00 2.18.20 Correspondence re: pre-trial schedule 0.1 $550 $55.00 2.24.20 Reviewed draft settlement agreement and correspondence 0.3 $550 $165.00 2.25.20 Correspondence re: call with opposing counsel on settlement agreement 0.1 $550 $55.00 2.27.20 Reviewed draft settlement agreement and correspondence 0.3 $550 $165.00 2.27.20 Correspondence re: pretrial deadlines 0.1 $550 $55.00 3.1.20 Correspondence re: claims process 0.1 $550 $55.00 3.4.20 Update on settlement progress 0.1 $550 $55.00 3.4.20 Discussion with D. Tejtel re: conclusions of law 0.2 $550 $110.00 3.4.20 Reviewed prior motions and drafted conclusions of law 5.5 $550 $3,025.00 3.5.20 Drafted conclusions of law and reviewed finding of facts 13.5 $550 $7,425.00 3.5.20 Discussed case strategy issues with D. Tejtel 1 $550 $550.00 3.6.20 Reviewed jury instructions 0.5 $550 $275.00 3.6.20 Correspondence re: proffer and stipulations 0.1 $550 $55.00 3.6.20 Review of findings of fact and conclusions of law and related correspondence 3.5 $550 $1,925.00 3.6.20 Review of Apple’s findings of fact and conclusions of law 0.5 $550 $275.00 3.6.20 Review of motion for preliminary approval of settlement 1.5 $550 $825.00 3.9.20 Review of motion for preliminary approval of settlement 0.2 $550 $110.00 3.9.20 Updated settlement agreement and memo on distribution 0.3 $550 $165.00 3.15.20 Update re: Settlement discussions 0.1 $550 $55.00 3.19.20 Administrative matters 0.5 $550 $275.00 3.21.20 Reviewed stipulations 0.1 $550 $55.00 3.31.20 Reviewed cy pres charities and correspondence 0.2 $550 $110.00 4.8.20 Reviewed preliminary motion and call and correspondence related thereto 1 $550 $550.00 4.9.20 Reviewed stay and correspondence 0.1 $550 $55.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-17 Filed 11/24/20 Page 55 of 55

4.24.20 Correspondence re: preliminary approval 0.1 $550 $55.00 5.6.20 Correspondence re: preliminary approval 0.1 $550 $55.00 8.19.20 Reviewed order setting preliminary approval and related correspondence 0.1 $550 $55.00 8.26.20 Correspondence on preliminary approval scheduling 0.1 $550 $55.00 9.3.20 Hearing on preliminary approval and emails related thereto 1.4 $550 $770.00 9.3.20 Discussion with S. Oster re: hearing 0.3 $550 $165.00 9.5.20 Case Management; correspondence with D. Tejtel 1 $550 $550.00 9.8.20 Correspondence re: settlement approval 0.2 $550 $110.00 9.10.20 Correspondence on approval of preliminary approval 0.1 $550 $55.00 10.23.20 Reviewed various correspondence re: potential class member inquiries 0.1 $550 $55.00

Total 187.5 $103,125.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-18 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 2

EXHIBIT 4 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-18 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 2

FRIEDMAN OSTER & TEJTEL PLLC 493 BEDFORD CENTER ROAD, SUITE 2D BEDFORD HILLS, NY 10507

GRACE v. APPLE, INC. -- COST AND EXPENSE SUMMARY

In-House Printing $54.59

Legal Research $1,048.82

Out-of-Town Travel $6,456.91

Meal Expense $611.46

Assessment to Litigation Fund $240,700.00

TOTAL $248,871.78

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-19 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 10

1 CLIFFORD H. PEARSON (Bar. No. 108523) DANIEL L. WARSHAW (Bar No. 185365) 2 THOMAS J. NOLAN (Bar No. 66992) PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP 3 15165 Ventura Boulevard, Suite 400 4 Sherman Oaks, CA 91403 Telephone: (818) 788-8300 5 Facsimile: (818) 788-8104 [email protected] 6 [email protected] 7 [email protected]

8 Counsel for Plaintiffs and the Class 9

10 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA, SAN JOSE DIVISION

11

LLP 12 13 CHRISTINA GRACE and KEN POTTER CASE NO. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC Individually and on Behalf of All Others 14 Similarly Situated, CLASS ACTION

15 Plaintiffs, DECLARATION OF DANIEL L. WARSHAW IN SUPPORT OF MOTION 16 vs. FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES, AND 17 APPLE INC., SERVICE AWARDS

350 SANSOME STREET, SUITE 680 SUITE STREET, SANSOME 350 SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA 94104 CALIFORNIA FRANCISCO, SAN Defendant. Date: February 8, 2021 PEARSON, WARSHAW, & SIMON PEARSON, 18 Time: 1:30 p.m. 19 Crtrm.: 8, 4th Floor Judge: The Honorable Lucy H. Koh 20

21

22 23 24 25 26 27 28 945302.3 Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC DECLARATION OF DANIEL L. WARSHAW IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES,

REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES, AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-19 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 10

1 DECLARATION OF DANIEL L. WARSHAW IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR 2 ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES, AND SERVICE AWARDS 3 Daniel L. Warshaw declares: 4 1. I am an attorney duly admitted to practice before this Court. I am a partner in the 5 firm of Pearson, Simon & Warshaw, LLP (“PSW”), attorneys of record for Plaintiffs and the 6 Class. 7 2. I submit this declaration in support of Plaintiffs’ Motion for Attorneys’ Fees,

8 Reimbursement of Expenses and Service Awards. I am the attorney principally responsible for the 9 handling of this matter. I am personally familiar with the facts set forth in this declaration. If 10 called as a witness I could and would competently testify to the matters stated herein.

11 3. My firm began working on this matter in the fall of 2016. PSW has extensive

LLP 12 experience in litigating and managing consumer class action cases. PSW, along with co-counsel, 13 implemented controls to ensure the efficient prosecution of this case. PSW collected and 14 summarized each firm’s time on a monthly basis to ensure every timekeeper was working

15 efficiently with minimal overlap or duplication. To that end, class counsel typically had weekly 16 calls to discuss, inter alia, assignments and workflow.

17 PSW Attorney Time and Expenses

350 SANSOME STREET, SUITE 680 SUITE STREET, SANSOME 350 SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA 94104 CALIFORNIA FRANCISCO, SAN

PEARSON, WARSHAW, & SIMON PEARSON, 18 4. PSW served as counsel for Plaintiff and Class Representatives Christina Grace and 19 Ken Potter throughout the course of this litigation. PSW has extensive experience in class action, 20 multi-district, and complex litigation, and has the ability to litigate this case on a class-wide basis. 21 A complete profile of PSW’s attorneys and a summary of the numerous complex litigation matters

22 in which they have obtained successful results is set for in PSW’s firm resume, a true and correct 23 copy is attached hereto as Exhibit 1. 24 5. The attorneys at PSW have decades of experience handling complex consumer 25 class actions, including cases that involve the types of claims asserted in this case. PSW has 26 represented a wide range of clients in complex litigation and class actions and have obtained 27 approximately three billion dollars in settlements and verdicts on behalf of their clients. PSW 28 currently serves, or has served, as lead counsel in some of the most advanced, cutting-edge, class 945302.3 2 Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC DECLARATION OF DANIEL L. WARSHAW IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES,

REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES, AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-19 Filed 11/24/20 Page 3 of 10

1 actions in the country. See, Declaration of Daniel L. Warshaw in Support of Motion for Class 2 Certification, ECF No. 174-84. 3 6. PSW has prosecuted this litigation solely on a contingent fee basis and has been at 4 risk that it would not receive any compensation for its work—or reimbursement for its costs—in 5 prosecuting the claims against Apple. The time and resources my firm invested in this matter 6 could have been placed in other hourly or contingency matters. 7 7. During the pendency of this case, PSW kept contemporaneous time and expense

8 records which I reviewed on a monthly basis. All of the time and expenses performed by my firm 9 were done so for the benefit of the Settlement Class. In preparing this declaration, I again 10 reviewed every time entry billed by each attorney and the paralegal assigned to the case. When

11 appropriate, I removed entries that appeared to be excessive or duplicative. Subsequent to the

LLP 12 Court’s order regarding class counsel, PSW reported its time to Ms. Manning on a monthly basis. 13 ECF No. 270. As stated in paragraph 3 above, PSW collected and summarized the monthly time 14 reporting for each plaintiffs’ firm. Further, I reviewed every expense billed by my firm to ensure

15 that it was reasonable and incurred for the benefit of the settlement class. 16 8. During the course of this litigation, PSW attorneys have been involved in the

17 following tasks and activities on behalf of the Settlement Class:

350 SANSOME STREET, SUITE 680 SUITE STREET, SANSOME 350 SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA 94104 CALIFORNIA FRANCISCO, SAN

PEARSON, WARSHAW, & SIMON PEARSON, 18 Daniel L. Warshaw 19 a. Case Management 20 9. I am the PSW partner who managed the litigation on a daily basis. Along with my 21 co-counsel, I handled strategic litigation decisions and assignments. I was responsible for

22 ensuring that the case was appropriately staffed and supervised the work performed by PSW. 23 Further, I was responsible for collecting, maintaining and reporting on the time entries of all PSW 24 timekeepers and co-class counsel. I was also responsible for the litigation bank account 25 established to pay for common expenses incurred by the firms, such as experts, court reporters and 26 hosting the document review platform. These duties included making recommended assessments 27 to class counsel and the approval and payment of invoices. 28 / / / 945302.3 3 Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC DECLARATION OF DANIEL L. WARSHAW IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES,

REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES, AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-19 Filed 11/24/20 Page 4 of 10

1 b. Discovery 2 10. I am the primary attorney who oversees ESI issues for PSW litigation. Based on 3 this experience, I was responsible for the ESI Stipulation and document review in this case. I 4 revised and finalized the ESI Stipulation after my colleague Alexander L. Simon prepared the first 5 draft under my supervision. Along with co-counsel, I negotiated the ESI Stipulation with Apple. 6 11. I was also responsible for securing a document review hosting company, 7 negotiating the contract with the vendor and managing the data produced by Defendant. I served

8 as the liaison between class counsel and the document review vendor, developed the document 9 review protocol, customized the coding panels on the platform and worked on searching the 10 productions.

11 12. Apple produced large volumes of data relating to class member’s serial numbers

LLP 12 for iPhone 4 and 4S devices. I, with a vendor, was responsible for developing a database to 13 maintain, search and review this large amount of data. 14 13. I assisted in preparing Mr. Potter for his deposition and traveled to and attended his

15 deposition in San Diego. 16 14. I prepared for and took the deposition of Apple’s Rule 30(b)6) witness, Beth

17 Kellermann.

350 SANSOME STREET, SUITE 680 SUITE STREET, SANSOME 350 SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA 94104 CALIFORNIA FRANCISCO, SAN

PEARSON, WARSHAW, & SIMON PEARSON, 18 15. Alexander L. Simon and I researched and prepared requests for admissions 19 regarding the admissibility of documents. 20 c. Experts 21 16. While Ms. Manning was primarily responsible, I also worked with Dr. Hastings on

22 her class certification and merits reports. I prepared and defended Dr. Hastings at the first of her 23 two depositions. 24 d. Legal Briefing 25 17. I was responsible for the preparation of the motion for class certification motion. 26 27 28 945302.3 4 Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC DECLARATION OF DANIEL L. WARSHAW IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES,

REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES, AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-19 Filed 11/24/20 Page 5 of 10

1 My colleague Bobby Pouya1 and I prepared the first draft of the class certification rely 2 memorandum. I also worked on the motion for reconsideration of the order denying the 3 nationwide certification. PSW attorney Joseph Bourne was the primary drafter of the Rule 23(f) 4 appeal. However, I supervised the drafting and prepared subsequent versions of the same. 5 e. Mediation and Settlement Conferences 6 18. I was involved in all aspects of the settlement process. I assisted in drafting the 7 mediation briefs. My efforts included travelling to and attending the mediations with Judge

8 William Cahill (Ret.) and settlement conferences with Magistrate Judge Nathanael Cousins. 9 f. Trial Preparation 10 19. I was involved in all aspects of trial preparation. This included preparing for and

11 appearing at the pre-trial conference, drafting the motions and oppositions to motions in limine

LLP 12 and working on the opposition to motion to exclude the testimony of Dr. Hastings. 13 g. Settlement 14 20. I assisted drafting and negotiating the Settlement Agreement. Ms. Manning and I

15 worked with Epiq to handle all aspects of administrating the settlement process. I was primarily 16 responsible for the preparation of the motion for preliminary approval and presented argument

17 regarding the same.

350 SANSOME STREET, SUITE 680 SUITE STREET, SANSOME 350 SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA 94104 CALIFORNIA FRANCISCO, SAN

PEARSON, WARSHAW, & SIMON PEARSON, 18 21. Clifford H. Pearson. Mr. Pearson’s participation focused on mediation and 19 settlement. He assisted in settlement strategy and attended both mediations before Judge Cahill 20 (Ret.) and the settlement conferences held before Magistrate Judge Cousins. He also worked on 21 class settlement and claims administration issues.

22 22. Bruce L. Simon. Mr. Simon’s assisted with preparation of the complaint and 23 worked on long term case strategy. As he works out of PSW’s San Francisco office, he prepared 24 for and attended the Initial Case Management Conference with Ms. Manning. Mr. Simon 25 provided case strategy and input regarding the opposition to the motion to dismiss and plaintiffs’

26 27 1 Mr. Pouya’s time was not included in PSW’s fee application as he billed less than twenty-five hours. See paragraph 29 below. 28 945302.3 5 Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC DECLARATION OF DANIEL L. WARSHAW IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES,

REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES, AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-19 Filed 11/24/20 Page 6 of 10

1 motion for class certification. He also attended the second mediation before Judge Cahill. 2 23. Joseph C. Bourne. Mr. Bourne was primarily responsible for drafting plaintiffs’ 3 Rule 23(f) petition for permission to appeal denial of nationwide class certification, and the reply 4 brief in support of plaintiffs’ Rule 23(f) petition. 5 24. Veronica W. Glaze. Ms. Glaze was responsible for the day to day management of 6 the document review project. She had administrator level rights to the document review platform 7 and conducted targeted searches for tier 1 documents review, deposition preparation, expert

8 analysis and motion practice. Ms. Glaze also conducted quality control of the document coding to 9 ensure the documents were properly coded and reviewed in an efficient manner. She also 10 performed tier 1 and tier 2 document review.

11 25. Eric J. Mont. Mr. Mont performed document review for deposition preparation

LLP 12 and exhibits. 13 26. Matthew A. Pearson. Mr. Pearson performed tier 1 and tier 2 document review 14 He also performed targeted document review for deposition preparation and exhibits.

15 27. Alexander L. Simon. Mr. Simon was the primary associate at PSW assigned to 16 the case. He participated in most aspects of the litigation that were assigned to my firm. Mr.

17 Simon assisted drafting portions of, inter alia, the complaints, the opposition to the motion to

350 SANSOME STREET, SUITE 680 SUITE STREET, SANSOME 350 SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA 94104 CALIFORNIA FRANCISCO, SAN

PEARSON, WARSHAW, & SIMON PEARSON, 18 dismiss, the motion for class certification and opposition to the motion for summary judgment. He 19 also prepared the first draft of the motion for preliminary approval of the settlement. Mr. Simon 20 prepared and responded to written discovery including being responsible for preparing and 21 enforcing plaintiffs’ subpoenas seeking pricing information of the iPhone 4 and 4S such as

22 Assurant, Best Buy, Brightstar and ecoATM. Further, Mr. Simon prepared the first draft of the 23 ESI Stipulation. He also reviewed documents produced by Apple. Mr. Simon and I worked 24 together preparing for and taking the deposition of Apple’s Rule 30(b)(6) witness. Mr. Simon also 25 assisted me in pre-trial work such as working on the motions in limine. 26 28. Ellowene J. Grant. Ms. Grant was the paralegal assigned to the case. She 27 maintained the case calendar, finalized documents for filing and processed all electronic case 28 filing documents served in the case. 945302.3 6 Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC DECLARATION OF DANIEL L. WARSHAW IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES,

REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES, AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-19 Filed 11/24/20 Page 7 of 10

1 29. Attached hereto as Exhibit 2 is a chart setting forth, from inception through 2 October 31, 2020: (i) the individuals from this firm who have worked on this case; (ii) the dates of 3 admission (attorneys) or years of experience (paralegals) for each individual who has worked on 4 this case; (iii) the billable rates charged by each individual, by rate, for work performed on this 5 case; (iv) the total number of hours that each individual has worked on this case, by rate; and (v) 6 the total hours and total lodestar for the firm. Attorneys and staff who worked less than 25 hours 7 on this matter are not included in PSW’s lodestar. Moreover, the time submissions do not include

8 any time devoted to preparing this declaration or otherwise pertaining to the Plaintiffs’ motion for 9 attorney’s fees. The attorneys and staff who worked on this case are listed below: 10 ATTORNEYS

11 (1) Clifford H. Pearson 151.6 hours

LLP 12 (2) Bruce L. Simon 51.7 hours 13 (3) Daniel L. Warshaw 982.50 hours 14 (4) Joseph C. Bourne 50.0 hours

15 (5) Veronica W. Glaze 679.5 hours 16 (6) Eric J. Mont 30.8 hours

17 (7) Matthew A. Pearson 294.8 hours

350 SANSOME STREET, SUITE 680 SUITE STREET, SANSOME 350 SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA 94104 CALIFORNIA FRANCISCO, SAN

PEARSON, WARSHAW, & SIMON PEARSON, 18 (8) Alexander L. Simon 748.1 hours 19 PARALEGAL 20 (1) Ellowene Grant 42.4 hours 21 TOTAL 3,031.4 hours

22 30. PSW worked efficiently. The hours expended by me, Alexander L. Simon and 23 Veronica W. Glaze represent 79.5% of the total hours expended by PSW. The balance of the 24 hours expended for the remaining nine timekeepers represent only 20.5% of the total. 25 31. The attorneys of PSW billed this case at their usual and customary hourly billing 26 rates, which have been approved by courts presiding over similar complex class action lawsuits, 27 and which are commensurate with the prevailing market rates attorneys of comparable experience 28 and skill handling complex litigation, including: 945302.3 7 Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC DECLARATION OF DANIEL L. WARSHAW IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES,

REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES, AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-19 Filed 11/24/20 Page 8 of 10

1 • In re National Collegiate Athletic Association Athletic Grant-in-Aid Cap Antitrust 2 Litigation, Case No. 4:14-md-2541-CW (N.D. Cal.). In 2019, Magistrate Judge 3 Cousins issued an attorneys’ fees award finding the following that the following 4 PSW rates were reasonable: $985 (2016) and $1,035 (2017) for Clifford H. Pearson 5 and Bruce L. Simon and, $1,050 (2018) and $1,150 (2019) for Clifford H. Pearson, 6 Bruce L. Simon and Daniel L. Warshaw, $350 (2017) for Alexander L. Simon, and 7 $400 (2018) and $450 (2019) for Alexander L. Simon and Matthew A. Pearson.

8 This award was adopted in whole by Judge Claudia Wilken.

9 • In re Credit Default Swaps Antitrust Litigation, Case No. 1:13-md-02476-DLC 10 (S.D.N.Y). In 2016, the court issued an attorneys’ feed award which included PSW

11 at weighted average rates of $958.07 for Clifford H. Pearson, $ 935 Bruce L.

LLP 12 Simon, $827 for Daniel L. Warshaw, $472.75 for Veronica W. Glaze, and $385 for 13 Matthew A. Pearson.

14 • In re: Cathode Ray Tube (CRT) Antitrust Litigation, Case No. 3:07-cv-05944-JST 15 (N.D. Cal.). In 2016, the court issued an attorneys’ feed award which included 16 PSW at rates of $985 (2016) for Clifford H. Pearson, Bruce L. Simon and

17 Daniel L. Warshaw.

350 SANSOME STREET, SUITE 680 SUITE STREET, SANSOME 350 SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA 94104 CALIFORNIA FRANCISCO, SAN

PEARSON, WARSHAW, & SIMON PEARSON, 18 • James Eashoo v. Iovate Health Sciences U.S.A., Inc., Case No. 2:15-cv-01726- 19 BRO-PJW (C.D. Cal.). In 2016, the court issued an attorneys’ feed award which 20 included PSW at rates of $985 (2016) for Clifford H. Pearson and Daniel L. 21 Warshaw, $385 (2016) for Matthew A. Pearson.

22 • Patricia Weckwerth et al. v. Nissan North America, Inc., Case No. 3:18-cv-00588 23 (M.D. Tenn.). In 2020, the court issued an attorneys’ feed award which included 24 PSW at the rate of $1,150 (2019) for Daniel L. Warshaw, and $670 (2020) for 25 Joseph Bourne. 26 32. As of October 31, 2020, PSW expended a total of 3,031.4 hours on this case and 27 incurred a lodestar of $2,144,405.00. The lodestar calculation is based on my firm’s historical 28 billing rates in effect at the time services were performed. 945302.3 8 Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC DECLARATION OF DANIEL L. WARSHAW IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES,

REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES, AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-19 Filed 11/24/20 Page 9 of 10

1 33. Attached hereto as Exhibit 3 is a true and correct copy of my firm’s daily time 2 records for each of the individuals at my firm who has billed time to this case and which time is 3 being submitted as a part of my firm’s lodestar. 4 34. These records were prepared from contemporaneous time records regularly 5 prepared and maintained by my firm. The hourly rates for PSW partners, attorneys and 6 professional support staff are the usual and customary hourly rates charged for their services in 7 similar complex litigation.

8 35. PSW has expended a total of $252,167.75 in unreimbursed costs and expenses in 9 connection with the prosecution of this litigation. These costs and expenses are broken down in 10 the chart attached hereto as Exhibit 4. They were incurred on behalf of the Class by my firm on a

11 contingent basis and have not been reimbursed. The expenses incurred in this action are reflected

LLP 12 on the books and records of my firm. As noted in Exhibit 4, PSW contributed $240,700.00 to the 13 litigation fund account described in paragraph 37 below. 14 36. Ninety-five percent (95%) of the expenses my firm incurred in this litigation were

15 payments made to the litigation fund for court reporters, document review hosting, expert costs, 16 mediation fees, third party subpoena fees and bank fees.

17 37. PSW maintained a litigation fund account for the payment of common litigation

350 SANSOME STREET, SUITE 680 SUITE STREET, SANSOME 350 SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA 94104 CALIFORNIA FRANCISCO, SAN

PEARSON, WARSHAW, & SIMON PEARSON, 18 expenses incurred during the pendency of this case. The litigation fund account was funded by 19 class counsel, as indicated in their concurrently filed declarations. Attached as Exhibit 5 is a 20 recapitulation of the litigation fund account. As of October 31, 2020, Plaintiffs have expended 21 $961,976.03 from the litigation fund account for reasonable and necessary expenses, as reflected

22 in Exhibit 5. Experts, court reporters and document review hosting costs represent approximately 23 ninety-nine percent (99%) of the costs expended from the litigation fund account. The litigation 24 fund account has a balance of $823.97. This amount will be completely expended by the 25 payments of the $302.94 monthly charge for maintain the archived document review database 26 before this matter is closed. 27 38. Plaintiffs have an outstanding invoice payable to the document review hosting 28 vendor, Inventus, in the amount of $33,671.56 which has not been processed for payment as of the 945302.3 9 Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC DECLARATION OF DANIEL L. WARSHAW IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES,

REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES, AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-19 Filed 11/24/20 Page 10 of 10

1 date of the declaration. 2 39. Therefore Plaintiffs seek reimbursement of $1,092,459.47 in costs, as reported by 3 class counsel in their concurrently filed declarations, as summarized below: 4 Caldwell Cassady & Curry $288,194.62 5 Friedman Oster & Tejtel PLLC $248,871.78 6 Pearson, Simon & Warshaw, LLP $252,167.75 7 Steyer Lowenthal Boodrookas Alvarez & Smith LLP $269,553.76

8 Inventus $33,671.56 9 TOTAL $1,092,459.47 10

11 I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of America that the

LLP 12 foregoing is true and correct. 13 Executed on this 24th day of November, 2020, at Sherman Oaks, California. 14

15 Daniel L. Warshaw 16 17 350 SANSOME STREET, SUITE 680 SUITE STREET, 350 SANSOME SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA 94104 CALIFORNIA FRANCISCO, SAN

PEARSON, & WARSHAW, SIMON PEARSON, 18 19 20 21

22 23 24 25 26 27 28 945302.3 10 Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC DECLARATION OF DANIEL L. WARSHAW IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES,

REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES, AND SERVICE AWARDS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 29

EXHIBIT 1 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 29

LOS ANGELES SAN FRANCISCO MINNEAPOLIS 15165 Ventura Boulevard 350 Sansome Street 800 LaSalle Avenue Suite 400 Suite 680 Suite 2150 Sherman Oaks, CA 91403 San Francisco, CA 94104 Minneapolis, MN 55402 Tel (818) 788-8300 Tel (415) 433-9000 Tel (612) 389-0600 Fax (818) 788-8104 Fax (415) 433-9008 Fax (612) 389-0610

WWW.PSWLAW.COM

Pearson, Simon & Warshaw, LLP (“PSW”) is an AV-rated civil litigation firm with offices in Los Angeles, San Francisco and Minneapolis. The firm specializes in complex litigation, including state coordination cases and federal multi-district litigation. Its attorneys have extensive experience in antitrust, securities, consumer protection, and unlawful employment practices. The firm handles national and multi-national class actions that present cutting edge issues in both substantive and procedural areas. PSW attorneys understand how to litigate difficult and large cases in an efficient and cost-effective manner, and they have used these skills to obtain outstanding results for their clients, both through trial and negotiated settlement. They are recognized in their field for excellence and integrity, and are committed to seeking justice for their clients.

CASE PROFILES

PSW attorneys currently hold, or have held, a leadership role in the following representative cases:

• In re Credit Default Swaps Antitrust Litigation, Southern District of New York, MDL No. 2476. PSW attorneys recently served as co-lead counsel and represented the Los Angeles County Employee Retirement Association (“LACERA”) in a class action on behalf of all purchasers and sellers of Credit Default Swaps (“CDS”) against twelve of the world’s largest banks. The lawsuit alleged that the banks, along with other defendants who controlled the market infrastructure for CDS trading, conspired for years to restrain the efficient trading of CDS, thereby inflating the cost to trade CDS. The alleged antitrust conspiracy resulted in billions of dollars in economic harm to institutional investors such as pension funds, mutual funds, and insurance companies who used CDS to hedge credit risks on their fixed income portfolios. After nearly three years of litigation and many months of intensive settlement negotiations, PSW helped reach a settlement with the defendants totaling $1.86 billion plus injunctive relief. On April 15, 2016, the Honorable Denise L. Cote granted final approval to the settlement, which is one of the largest civil antitrust settlements in history.

• In re TFT-LCD (Flat Panel) Antitrust Litigation, Northern District of California, MDL No. 1827. PSW served as co-lead counsel for the direct purchaser plaintiffs in this multidistrict litigation arising from the price-fixing of thin film transistor liquid crystal display (“TFT-LCD”) panels. Worldwide, the TFT-LCD industry is a multi-billion dollar

943605.1

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 3 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

industry, and many believe that this was one of the largest price-fixing cases in the United States. PSW helped collect over $405 million in settlements before the case proceeded to trial against the last remaining defendant, Toshiba Corporation and its related entities. PSW partner Bruce L. Simon served as co-lead trial counsel, successfully marshaled numerous witnesses, and presented the opening argument. On July 3, 2012, PSW obtained a jury verdict of $87 million (before trebling) against Toshiba. PSW later settled with Toshiba and AU Optronics to bring the total to $473 million in settlements. In 2013, California Lawyer Magazine awarded Mr. Simon a California Lawyer of the Year Award for his work in the TFT-LCD case.

• In re Potash Antitrust Litigation (No. II), Northern District of Illinois, MDL No. 1996. PSW partner Bruce L. Simon served as interim co-lead counsel for the direct purchaser plaintiffs in this multidistrict litigation arising from the price-fixing of potash sold in the United States. After the plaintiffs defeated a motion to dismiss, the defendants appealed, and the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals agreed to hear the case en banc. Mr. Simon presented oral argument to the en banc panel and achieved a unanimous 8-0 decision in his favor. The case resulted in $90 million in settlements for the direct purchaser plaintiffs, and the Court’s opinion is one of the most significant regarding the scope of international antirust conspiracies. See Minn-Chem, Inc. v. Agrium Inc., 683 F. 3d 845 (7th Cir. 2012).

• In re National Collegiate Athletic Association Athletic Grant-in-Aid Cap Antitrust Litigation, Northern District of California, MDL No. 2451. PSW attorneys currently serve as interim co-lead counsel in this multidistrict litigation that alleges the NCAA and its member conferences violate the antitrust laws by restricting the value of grant-in-aid athletic scholarships and other benefits that college football and basketball players can receive. PSW settled the damages case, recently obtaining final approval to a $208 million dollar settlement. PSW attorneys with co-counsel have completed a bench trial for the injunctive portion of the case. A verdict for Plaintiffs was awarded, and the case is now on appeal.

• North American Soccer League, LLC v. United States Soccer Federation, Inc., and Major League Soccer, L.L.C., Eastern District of New York, Case No. 1:17-cv-05495-MKB-ST. PSW, along with co-counsel, represents the North American Soccer League in a matter against the United States Soccer Federation and Major League Soccer alleging antitrust violations. The complaint alleges that U.S. Soccer and MLS have driven NASL out of business and have prevented NASL from competing against MLS (the sole Division I league) and the United Soccer League (the sole Division II league), which is affiliated with MLS.

• In re Broiler Chicken Antitrust Litigation, Northern District of Illinois, Case No. 1:16-cv- 08637. PSW attorneys currently serve as interim co-lead counsel on behalf of direct purchaser plaintiffs. The complaint alleges that the nation’s largest broiler chicken

943605.1 2

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 4 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

producers violated antitrust laws by limiting production and manipulating the price indices.

• In re Pork Antitrust Litigation, District of Minnesota, Case No. 0:18-cv-01776. PSW attorneys currently serve as interim co-lead counsel on behalf of direct purchaser plaintiffs. The complaint alleges that the nation’s largest pork producers violated antitrust laws by limiting production and manipulating the price indices.

• Greg Kihn, et al. v. Bill Graham Archives, LLC, et al., Northern District of California Case No. 4:17-cv-05343-JSW. PSW attorneys currently serve as Class counsel in this certified copyright class action alleging that Defendants broadcasted, continue to broadcast, or otherwise make available to the public, copyrighted musical works of Plaintiffs and the Class without proper licenses, as required under the Copyright Act.

• Grace v. Apple, Inc., Northern District of California, 5:17-CV-00551. PSW partner Daniel L. Warshaw currently serves as class counsel in this California certified class action on behalf of consumers who allege Apple intentionally broke its “FaceTime” video conferencing feature for Apple iPhone 4 or iPhone 4S users operating on iOS 6 or earlier.

• Trepte v. Bionaire, Inc., Los Angeles County Superior Court, Case No. BC540110. PSW attorneys served as Class Counsel in this certified class action alleging that the defendant sold defective space heaters. The complaint alleged that defendant breached the warranty and falsely advertised the safety of the heaters due to design defects that cause the heaters to fail. As a result of the failure, the heaters may spark, smoke and catch fire. PSW negotiated a lucrative settlement and obtained final approval on behalf of the class.

• In re Santa Fe Natural Tobacco Company Marketing, Sales Practices, and Products Liability Litigation, District of New Mexico, Case No. 1:16-md-02695-JB-LF. PSW partner Melissa S. Weiner chairs the Executive Committee and PSW partner Daniel L. Warshaw serves on the executive committee. This class action alleges that Defendants’ “natural” and “additive free” claims on their tobacco products were false and misleading to consumers. PSW continues to vigorously litigate this important lawsuit.

• In re Keurig Green Mountain Single-Serving Coffee Antitrust Litigation, Southern District of New York, MDL No. 2542. In June 2014, Judge Vernon S. Broderick appointed PSW to serve as interim co-lead counsel on behalf of indirect purchaser plaintiffs in this multidistrict class action litigation. The case arises from the alleged unlawful monopolization of the United States market for single-serve coffee packs by Keurig Green Mountain, Inc. Keurig’s alleged anticompetitive conduct includes acquiring competitors, entering into exclusionary agreements with suppliers and distributors to prevent competitors from entering the market, engaging in sham patent infringement litigation, and redesigning the single-serve coffee pack products in the next version of its brewing system to lock out competitors’ products.

943605.1 3

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 5 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

• Senne, et al. v. Office of the Commissioner of Baseball, et al., Northern District of California, Case No. 14-cv-0608. PSW attorneys currently serve as interim co-lead counsel in this class action and FLSA collective action on behalf of minor league baseball players who allege that Major League Baseball and its member franchises violate the FLSA and state wage and hour laws by failing to pay minor league baseball players minimum wage and overtime. In 2019 the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the case should be certified on behalf of the FLSA collective and three state classes. The Supreme Court of the United States denied defendants’ petition for writ of certiorari.

• In re KIND LLC “Healthy and All Natural” Litigation, Southern District of New York, MDL No. 2645. PSW partner Daniel L. Warshaw currently serves as interim co-lead counsel in this putative nationwide class action on behalf of consumers who allege that they purchased KIND snack bars that were falsely advertised as “all natural,” “non- GMO,” and/or “healthy.”

• In re Carrier IQ Consumer Privacy Litigation, Northern District of California, MDL No. 2330. PSW attorneys served as interim co-lead counsel in this putative nationwide class action on behalf of consumers who allege privacy violations arising from software installed on their mobile devices that was logging text messages and other sensitive information.

• Sciortino, et al. v. PepsiCo, Inc., Northern District of California, Case No. 14-cv-0478. PSW attorneys served as interim co-lead counsel in this putative California class action on behalf of consumers who allege that PepsiCo failed to warn them that certain of its sodas contain excess levels of a chemical called 4-Methylimidazole in violation of Proposition 65 and California consumer protection statutes.

• James v. UMG Recordings, Inc., Northern District of California, Case No. 11-cv-01613. PSW partner Daniel L. Warshaw served as interim co-lead counsel in this putative nationwide class action on behalf of recording artists and music producers who alleged that they had been systematically underpaid royalties by the record company UMG.

• In re Warner Music Group Corp. Digital Downloads Litigation, Northern District of California, Case No. 12-cv-00559. PSW attorneys served as interim co-lead counsel, with partner Bruce L. Simon serving as chairman of a five-firm executive committee, in this putative nationwide class action on behalf of recording artists and music producers who alleged that they had been systematically underpaid royalties by the record company Warner Music Group.

• In re Dynamic Random Access Memory (DRAM) Antitrust Litigation, Northern District of California, MDL No. 1486. PSW partner Bruce L. Simon served as co-chair of discovery and as a member of the trial preparation team in this multidistrict litigation arising from the price-fixing of DRAM, a form of computer memory. Mr. Simon was responsible for supervising and coordinating the review of almost a terabyte of electronic documents,

943605.1 4

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 6 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

setting and taking depositions, establishing and implementing protocols for cooperation between the direct and indirect plaintiffs as well as the Department of Justice, presenting oral arguments on discovery matters, working with defendants on evidentiary issues in preparation for trial, and preparation of a comprehensive pretrial statement. Shortly before the scheduled trial, class counsel reached settlements with the last remaining defendants, bringing the total value of the class settlements to over $325 million.

• In re Methionine Antitrust Litigation, Northern District of California, MDL No. 1311. PSW partner Bruce L. Simon served as co-lead counsel in this nationwide antitrust class action involving a conspiracy to fix prices of, and allocate the markets for, methionine. Mr. Simon was personally responsible for many of the discovery aspects of the case including electronic document productions, coordination of document review teams, and depositions. Mr. Simon argued pretrial motions, prepared experts, and assisted in the preparation of most pleadings presented to the Court. This action resulted in over $100 million in settlement recovery for the Class.

• In re Sodium Gluconate Antitrust Litigation, Northern District of California, MDL No. 1226. PSW partner Bruce L. Simon served as class counsel in this consolidated antitrust class action arising from the price-fixing of sodium gluconate. Mr. Simon was selected by Judge Claudia Wilken to serve as lead counsel amongst many other candidates for that position, and successfully led the case to class certification and settlement.

• In re Citric Acid Antitrust Litigation, Northern District of California, MDL No. 1092. PSW partner Bruce L. Simon served as class counsel in antitrust class actions against Archer-Daniels Midland Co. and others for their conspiracy to fix the prices of citric acid, a food additive product. Mr. Simon was one of the principal attorneys involved in discovery in this matter. This proceeding resulted in over $80 million settlements for the direct purchasers.

• Olson v. Volkswagen of America, Inc., Central District of California, Case No. CV07- 05334. PSW attorneys brought this class action lawsuit against Volkswagen alleging that the service manual incorrectly stated the inspection and replacement intervals for timing belts on Audi and Volkswagen branded vehicles equipped with a 1.8 liter turbo-charged engine. This case resulted in a nationwide class settlement.

• Swain et al. v. Eel River Sawmills, Inc. et al., California Superior Court, DR-01-0216. Bruce L. Simon served as lead trial counsel for a class of former employees of a timber company whose retirement plan was lost through management’s investment of plan assets in an Employee Stock Ownership Plan. Mr. Simon negotiated a substantial settlement on the eve of trial resulting in a recovery of approximately 40% to 50% of plaintiffs’ damages after attorneys’ fees and costs.

943605.1 5

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 7 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

• In re Hawaiian and Guamanian Cabotage Antitrust Litigation, Western District of Washington, MDL No. 1972. PSW partner Bruce L. Simon served as interim co-lead counsel for the plaintiffs in this multidistrict litigation arising from violations of the federal antitrust laws with respect to domestic ocean shipping services between the continental United States and Hawaii and/or between the continental United States and the Territory of Guam.

• In re Homestore Litigation, Central District of California, Master File No. 01-11115. PSW attorneys served as liaison counsel and class counsel for plaintiff CalSTRS in this securities class action. The case resulted in over $100 million in settlements to the Class.

• In re MP3.Com, Inc., Securities Litigation, Southern District of California, Master File No. 00-CV-1873. PSW attorneys served as defense counsel in this class action involving alleged securities violations under Rule 10b-5.

• In re Automotive Refinishing Paint Cases, Alameda County Superior Court, Judicial Council Coordination Proceeding No. 4199. PSW attorneys served as class counsel with other law firms in this coordinated antitrust class action alleging a conspiracy by defendants to fix the price of automotive refinishing products.

• In re Beer Antitrust Litigation, Northern District of California, Case No. 97-20644 SW. PSW partner Bruce L. Simon served as primary counsel in this antitrust class action brought on behalf of independent micro-breweries against Anheuser-Busch, Inc., for its attempt to monopolize the beer industry in the United States by denying access to distribution channels.

• In re Commercial Tissue Products Public Entity Indirect Purchaser Antitrust Litigation, San Francisco Superior Court, Judicial Counsel Coordination Proceeding No. 4027. PSW partner Bruce L. Simon served as co-lead counsel for the public entity purchaser class in this antitrust action arising from the price-fixing of commercial sanitary paper products.

• Hart v. Central Sprinkler Corporation, Los Angeles County Superior Court, Case No. BC176727. PSW attorneys served as class counsel in this consumer class action arising from the sale of nine million defective fire sprinkler heads. This case resulted in a nationwide class settlement valued at approximately $37.5 million.

• Rueda v. Schlumberger Resources Management Services, Inc., Los Angeles County Superior Court, Case No. BC235471. PSW attorneys served as class counsel with other law firms representing customers of the Los Angeles Department of Water & Power (“LADWP”) who had lead leaching water meters installed on their properties. The Court granted final approval of the settlement whereby defendant would pay $1.5 million to a

943605.1 6

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 8 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

cy pres fund to benefit the Class and to make grants to LADWP to assist in implementing a replacement program to the effected water meters.

• In re Louisiana-Pacific Corp. Inner-Seal OSB Trade Practices Litigation, Northern District of California, MDL No. 1114. PSW partner Bruce L. Simon worked on this nationwide product defect class action brought under the Lanham Act. The proposed class was certified, and a class settlement was finally approved by Chief Judge Vaughn Walker.

• In re iPod nano Cases, Los Angeles County Superior Court, Judicial Counsel Coordination Proceeding No. 4469. PSW attorneys were appointed co-lead counsel for this class action brought on behalf of California consumers who own defective iPod nanos. The case resulted in a favorable settlement.

• Unity Entertainment Corp. v. MP3.Com, Central District of California, Case No. 00- 11868. PSW attorneys served as defense counsel in this class action alleging copyright infringement.

• Vallier v. Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Central District of California, Case No. CV97- 1171. PSW attorneys served as lead counsel in this toxic tort action involving 50 cancer victims and their families.

• Nguyen v. First USA N.A., Los Angeles County Superior Court, Case No. BC222846. PSW attorneys served as class counsel on behalf of approximately four million First USA credit card holders whose information was sold to third party vendors without their consent. This case ultimately settled for an extremely valuable permanent injunction plus disgorgement of profits to worthy charities.

• Morales v. Associates First Financial Capital Corporation, San Francisco Superior Court, Judicial Council Coordination Proceeding No. 4197. PSW attorneys served as class counsel in this case arising from the wrongful sale of credit insurance in connection with personal and real estate-secured loans. This case resulted in an extraordinary $240 million recovery for the Class.

• In re AEFA Overtime Cases, Los Angeles County Superior Court, Judicial Council Coordination Proceeding No. 4321. PSW attorneys served as class counsel in this overtime class action on behalf of American Express Financial Advisors, which resulted in an outstanding classwide settlement.

• Khan v. Denny’s Holdings, Inc., Los Angeles County Superior Court, Case No. BC177254. PSW attorneys settled a class action lawsuit against Denny’s for non- payment of overtime wages to its managers and general managers.

943605.1 7

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 9 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

• Kosnik v. Carrows Restaurants, Inc., Los Angeles County Superior Court, Case No. BC219809. PSW attorneys settled a class action lawsuit against Carrows Restaurants for non-payment of overtime wages to its assistant managers and managers.

• Castillo v. Pizza Hut, Inc., Los Angeles County Superior Court, Case No. BC318765. PSW attorneys served as lead class counsel in this California class action brought by delivery drivers who claimed they were not adequately compensated for use of their personally owned vehicles. This case resulted in a statewide class settlement.

• Baker v. Charles Schwab & Co., Inc., Los Angeles County Superior Court, Case No. BC286131. PSW attorneys served as class counsel for investors who were charged a fee for transferring out assets between June 1, 2002 and May 31, 2003. This case resulted in a nationwide class settlement.

• Eallonardo v. Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer, Inc., Los Angeles County Superior Court, Case No. BC286950. PSW attorneys served as class counsel on behalf a nationwide class of consumers who purchased DVDs manufactured by defendants. Plaintiffs alleged that defendants engaged in false and misleading advertising relating to the sale of its DVDs. This case resulted in a nationwide class settlement.

• Gaeta v. Centinela Feed, Inc., Los Angeles County Superior Court, Case No. BC342524. PSW attorneys served as defense counsel in this class action involving alleged failures to pay wages, overtime, employee expenses, waiting time penalties, and failure to provide meal and rest periods and to furnish timely and accurate wage statements.

• Leiber v. Consumer Empowerment Bv A/K/A Fasttrack, Central District of California, Case No. CV 01-09923. PSW attorneys served as defense counsel in this class action involving copyrighted music that was made available through a computer file sharing service without the publishers’ permission.

• Higgs v. SUSA California, Inc., Los Angeles County Superior Court Case No. BC372745. PSW attorneys are served as co-lead class counsel representing California consumers who entered into rental agreements for the use of self-storage facilities owned by defendants. In this certified class action, plaintiffs allege that defendants wrongfully denied access to the self-storage facility and/or charged excessive pre-foreclosure fees.

• Fournier v. Lockheed Litigation, Los Angeles County Superior Court. PSW attorneys served as counsel for 1,350 residents living at or near the Skunks-Works Facility in Burbank. The case resolved with a substantial confidential settlement for plaintiffs.

• Nasseri v. CytoSport, Inc., Los Angeles County Superior Court, Case No. 439181. PSW attorneys served as class counsel on behalf of a nationwide class of consumers who purchased CytoSport’s popular protein powders, ready to drink protein beverages, and

943605.1 8

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 10 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

other “supplement” products. Plaintiffs alleged that these supplements contain excessive amounts of lead, cadmium and arsenic in amounts that exceed Proposition 65 and negate CytoSport’s health claims regarding the products. The case resulted in a nationwide class action settlement which provided monetary relief to the class members and required the reformulation of CytoSport supplement products.

• In re Samsung Top-Load Washing Machine Marketing, Sales Practice and Products Liability Litigation, Western District of Oklahoma, Case No. 5:17-ml-02792-D. Plaintiffs allege that the top-load washing machines contain defects that cause them to leak and explode. PSW Partner Melissa S. Weiner was appointed to the Plaintiffs’ Steering Committee in this multi-district class action.

943605.1 9

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 11 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

ATTORNEY PROFILES

PARTNERS

CLIFFORD H. PEARSON

Clifford H. Pearson is a civil litigator and business lawyer focusing on complex litigation, class actions, and business law. In 2013 and 2016, Mr. Pearson was named by the Daily Journal as one of the Top 100 lawyers in California. Additionally, Mr. Pearson was named as one of the Daily Journal’s 2019 Top Plaintiff Lawyers. He was instrumental in negotiating a landmark settlement totaling $1.86 billion in In re Credit Default Swaps Antitrust Litigation, a case alleging a conspiracy among the world’s largest banks to maintain opacity of the credit default swaps market. Mr. Pearson also negotiated $473 million in combined settlements in In re TFT- LCD (Flat Panel) Antitrust Litigation, an antitrust case in the Northern District of California that alleged a decade-long conspiracy to fix the prices of TFT-LCD panels, $209 million in In re NCAA Grant-in-aid Antitrust Litigation, and over $90 million in In re Potash Antitrust Litigation, an antitrust case in the Northern District of Illinois that alleged price fixing by Russian, Belarusian and North American producers of potash, a main ingredient used in fertilizer.

Before creating the firm in 2006, Mr. Pearson was a partner at one of the largest firms in the San Fernando Valley, where he worked for 22 years. There, he represented aggrieved individuals, investors and employees in a wide variety of contexts, including toxic torts, consumer protection and wage and hour cases. Over his 35-plus year career, Mr. Pearson has successfully negotiated substantial settlements on behalf of consumers, small businesses and companies. In recognition of his outstanding work on behalf of clients, Mr. Pearson has been regularly selected by his peers as a Super Lawyer (representing the top 5% of practicing lawyers in Southern California). He has also attained Martindale-Hubbell’s highest rating (AV) for legal ability and ethical standards.

Mr. Pearson is an active member of the American Bar Association, Los Angeles County Bar Association, Consumer Attorneys of California, Consumer Attorneys Association of Los Angeles, and Association of Business Trial Lawyers.

Current Cases: • In re Broiler Chicken Antitrust Litigation (N.D. Ill.) • In Re Pork Antitrust Litigation (D. Minn.) • North American Soccer League, LLC v. United States Soccer Federation, Inc., and Major League Soccer, L.L.C. (E.D.N.Y.)

Education: • Whittier Law School, Los Angeles, California – J.D. – 1981 • University of Miami, Miami, Florida – M.B.A. – 1978

943605.1 10

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 12 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

• Carleton University, Ontario, Canada – B.A. – 1976

Bar Admissions: • California • Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals • U.S. District Court, Central District of California • U.S. District Court, Eastern District of California • U.S. District Court, Northern District of California • U.S. District Court, Southern District of California

Professional Associations and Memberships: • American Bar Association • Association of Business Trial Lawyers • Consumer Attorneys Association of Los Angeles • Consumer Attorneys of California • Los Angeles County Bar Association

BOBBY POUYA

Bobby Pouya is a partner in the firm’s Los Angeles office, focusing on complex litigation, class actions, and consumer protection. Mr. Pouya has been an attorney with Pearson, Simon & Warshaw, LLP since 2007, and has extensive experience in representing clients in a variety of contexts. He has served as a primary member of the litigation team in multiple cases that resulted in class certification or a class-wide settlement, including cases that involved high- technology products, price fixing, consumer safety and false and misleading advertising. The cases that Mr. Pouya has worked on have resulted in hundreds of millions of dollars in judgments and settlements on behalf of effected plaintiffs and class members.

Mr. Pouya has served as one of the attorneys representing direct purchaser plaintiffs in several complex antitrust cases, including In re Polyurethane Foam Antitrust Litigation (N.D. Ohio) and In re Fresh and Processed Potatoes Antitrust Litigation (D. Idaho). Mr. Pouya is currently actively involved in the prosecution of In re Broiler Chicken Antitrust Litigation (N.D. Ill), In re Pork Antitrust Litigation (D. Minn.), Senne, et al. v. Office of the Commissioner of Baseball, et al. (N.D. Cal.), as well as several prominent consumer class action lawsuits.

Mr. Pouya’s success has earned him recognition by his peers as a Super Lawyers Rising Star (representing the top 2.5% of lawyers in Southern California age 40 or younger or in practice for 10 years or less) every year since 2008. Mr. Pouya earned his Juris Doctorate from Pepperdine University School of Law in 2006, where he received a certificate in dispute resolution from the prestigious Straus Institute for Dispute Resolution and participated on the interschool trial and mediation advocacy teams, the Dispute Resolution Law Journal and the Moot Court Board.

943605.1 11

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 13 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

Current Cases: • In re Broiler Chicken Antitrust Litigation (N.D. Ill) • In Re Pork Antitrust Litigation (D. Minn.) • In Re Cattle Antitrust Litigation (D. Minn) • Senne, et al. v. Office of the Commissioner of Baseball, et al. (N.D. Cal.) • Greg Kihn, et al. v. Bill Graham Archives, LLC, et al. (N.D. Cal.)

Education: • Pepperdine University School of Law, Malibu, California – J.D. – 2006 • University of California, Santa Barbara, California – B.A., with honors – 2003

Publications: • Should Offers Moot Claims?, Daily Journal, Oct. 10, 2014 • Central District Local Rules Hinder Class Certification, Daily Journal, April 9, 2013

Bar Admissions: • California • Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals • U.S. District Court, Central District of California • U.S. District Court, Eastern District of California • U.S. District Court, Northern District of California • U.S. District Court, Southern District of California

Professional Associations and Memberships: • American Bar Association • Consumer Attorneys Association of Los Angeles • Consumer Attorneys of California • Los Angeles County Bar Association

BRUCE L. SIMON

Bruce L. Simon is a Partner Emeritus at Pearson, Simon & Warshaw, LLP and has lead the firm to national prominence. Mr. Simon specializes in complex cases involving antitrust, consumer fraud and securities. He has served as lead counsel in many business cases with national and global impact.

In 2019, Mr. Simon was named as one of the Daily Journal’s Top Plaintiff Lawyers. In 2018, Mr. Simon was awarded “Antitrust Lawyer of the Year” by the California Lawyers Association. In 2013 and 2016, Mr. Simon was chosen by the Daily Journal as one of the Top 100 attorneys in California. In 2013, he received the California Lawyer of the Year award from California Lawyer Magazine and was selected as one of seven finalists for Consumer Attorney of the Year by Consumer Attorneys of California for his work in In re TFT-LCD (Flat Panel) Antitrust Litigation, MDL No. 1827 (N.D. Cal.). That year, Mr. Simon was included in the Top

943605.1 12

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 14 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

100 of California’s “Super Lawyers” and has been named a “Super Lawyer” every year since 2003. He has attained Martindale-Hubbell's highest rating (AV) for legal ability and ethical standards.

Mr. Simon was co-lead class counsel in In re TFT-LCD (Flat Panel) Antitrust Litigation, a case that lasted over five years and resulted in $473 million recovered for the direct purchaser plaintiffs. Mr. Simon served as co-lead trial counsel and was instrumental in obtaining an $87 million jury verdict (before trebling). He presented the opening argument and marshalled numerous witnesses during the six-week trial.

Also, Mr. Simon was co-lead class counsel in In re Credit Default Swaps Antitrust Litigation, a case alleging a conspiracy among the world’s largest banks to maintain opacity of the credit default swaps market as a means of maintaining supracompetitive prices of bid/ask spreads. After three years of litigation and many months of intensive settlement negotiations, the parties in CDS reached a landmark settlement amounting to $1.86 billion. It is one of the largest civil antitrust settlements in history.

Mr. Simon was also co-lead class counsel in In re Potash Antitrust Litigation (II), MDL No. 1996 (N.D. Ill.), where he successfully argued an appeal of the district court’s order denying the defendants’ motions to dismiss to the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit. Mr. Simon presented oral argument during an en banc hearing before the Court and achieved a unanimous 8-0 decision in his favor. The case resulted in $90 million in settlements for the direct purchaser plaintiffs, and the Court’s opinion is one of the most significant regarding the scope of international antirust conspiracies.

More recently, Mr. Simon completed the trial seeking injunctive relief in the In re National Collegiate Athletic Association Athletic Grant-in-Aid Cap Antitrust Litigation. The plaintiffs allege that the NCAA and its member conferences violate the antitrust laws by restricting the value of grant-in-aid athletic scholarships and other benefits that college football and basketball players can receive.

Current Cases: • In re Broiler Chicken Antitrust Litigation (N.D. Ill.) • In re Keurig Green Mountain Single-Serving Coffee Antitrust Litigation (S.D.N.Y.) • In re National Collegiate Athletic Association Athletic Grant-in-Aid Cap Antitrust Litigation (N.D. Cal.) • In Re Pork Antitrust Litigation (D. Minn.) • Senne, et al. v. Office of the Commissioner of Baseball, et al. (N.D. Cal.) • North American Soccer League, LLC v. United States Soccer Federation, Inc., and Major League Soccer, L.L.C. (E.D.N.Y.)

Reported Cases: • Minn-Chem, Inc. et al. v. Agrium Inc., et al., 683 F.3d 845 (7th Cir. 2012)

943605.1 13

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 15 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

Education: • University of California, Hastings College of the Law, San Francisco, California – J.D. – 1980 • University of California, Berkeley, California – A.B. – 1977

Bar Admissions: • California • Supreme Court of the United States • Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals • Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals • U.S. District Court, Central District of California • U.S. District Court, Eastern District of California • U.S. District Court, Northern District of California • U.S. District Court, Southern District of California

Recent Publications: • Class Certification Procedure, Ch. V, ABA Antitrust Class Actions Handbook (3d ed.), (forthcoming) • Reverse Engineering Your Antitrust Case: Plan for Trial Even Before You File Your Case, Antitrust, Vol. 28, No. 2, Spring 2014 • The Ownership/Control Exception to Illinois Brick in Hi-Tech Component Cases: A Rule That Recognizes the Realities of Corporate Price Fixing, ABA International Cartel Workshop February 2014 • Matthew Bender Practice Guide: California Unfair Competition and Business Torts, LexisNexis, with Justice Conrad L. Rushing and Judge Elia Weinbach (Updated 2013) • The Questionable Use of Rule 11 Motions to Limit Discovery and Eliminate Allegations in Civil Antitrust Complaints in the United States, ABA International Cartel Workshop February 2012

Professional Associations and Memberships: • California State Bar Antitrust and Unfair Competition Section, Advisor and Past Chair • ABA Global Private Litigation Committee, Co-Chair • ABA International Cartel Workshop, Steering Committee • American Association for Justice, Business Torts Section, Past Chair • Business Torts Section of the American Trial Lawyers Association, Past Chair • Hastings College of the Law, Board of Directors (2003-2015), Past Chair (2009-2011)

943605.1 14

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 16 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

DANIEL L. WARSHAW

Daniel L. Warshaw is a civil litigator and trial lawyer who focuses on complex litigation, class actions, and consumer protection. Mr. Warshaw has held a lead role in numerous state and federal class actions, and obtained significant recoveries for class members in many cases. These cases have included, among other things, antitrust violations, high-technology products, automotive parts and false and misleading advertising. Mr. Warshaw has also represented employees in a variety of class actions, including wage and hour, misclassification and other Labor Code violations.

Mr. Warshaw played an integral role in In re TFT-LCD (Flat Panel) Antitrust Litigation, where he negotiated the ESI protocol and managed a document review process that featured nearly 8 million documents in multiple languages and 136 reviewers. He currently serves as interim co-lead counsel in a series of groundbreaking class actions involving the alleged underpayment of royalties to artists, producers and directors in the music and film industries. These cases have received significant attention in the press, and Mr. Warshaw has been profiled by the Daily Journal for his work in the digital download music cases. In 2019 and 2020, Mr. Warshaw was named as one of the Daily Journal’s Top Plaintiff Lawyers. Also in 2020 he was named as one the Daily Journal’s Top Antitrust Attorneys. Mr. Warshaw has been selected by his peers as a Super Lawyer (representing the top 5% of practicing lawyers in Southern California) every year since 2005. He has also attained Martindale-Hubbell's highest rating (AV) for legal ability and ethical standards.

Mr. Warshaw has assisted in the preparation of two Rutter Group practice guides: Federal Civil Trials & Evidence and Civil Claims and Defenses. Mr. Warshaw is the founder and Chair of the Class Action Roundtable. The purpose of the Roundtable is to facilitate a high- level exchange of ideas and in-depth dialogue on class action litigation.

Current Cases:

• Grace v. Apple, Inc. (N.D. Cal.) • Greg Kihn, et al. v. Bill Graham Archives, LLC, et al. (N.D. Cal.) • In re KIND LLC “Healthy and All Natural” Litigation (S.D.N.Y.) • In Re Pork Antitrust Litigation (D. Minn.) • In re. Santa Fe Natural Tobacco Company Marketing, Sales Practices, and Products Liability Litigation (D. N.M.) • Senne, et al. v. Office of the Commissioner of Baseball, et al. (N.D. Cal.) • North American Soccer League, LLC v. United States Soccer Federation, Inc., and Major League Soccer, L.L.C. (E.D.N.Y.) • In Re Cattle Antitrust Litigation (D. Minn.)

Education: • Whittier Law School, Los Angeles, California – J.D. – 1996

943605.1 15

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 17 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

• University of Southern California – B.A. – 1992 Bar Admissions: • California • Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals • U.S. District Court, Central District of California • U.S. District Court, Eastern District of California • U.S. District Court, Northern District of California • U.S. District Court, Southern District of California

Professional Associations and Memberships: • American Bar Association • Association of Business Trial Lawyers, Board Member • Consumer Attorneys Association of Los Angeles • Consumer Attorneys of California • Los Angeles County Bar Association, Complex Court Committee, Member • Plaintiffs’ Class Action Roundtable, Chair

MELISSA S. WEINER

Melissa S. Weiner is a Partner and civil litigator whose work is squarely focused on combating consumer deception. Her experience is expansive, including class actions related to consumer protection, product defect, intellectual property, automotive, false advertising and the Fair Credit Reporting Act. Ms. Weiner has taken a leadership role in numerous large class actions and MDLs in cases across the country.

A contributor to her professional community, Ms. Weiner serves on the Executive Board for Public Justice as the Co-Vice Chair of the Development Committee, former co-chair of the Mass Tort and Class Action Practice Group for the Minnesota Chapter of the Federal Bar Association and serves on the Minnesota Bar Association Food & Drug Law Council. In recognition of her outstanding efforts in the legal community, each year since 2012, Ms. Weiner has been named a Super Lawyers Rising Star by Minnesota Law & Politics.

Ms. Weiner has been appointed to leadership positions in the following MDLs:

• In Re: Fairlife Milk Products Marketing and Sales Practices Litigation, 1:19-cv-03924 (N.D. Ill.) (Appointed Interim Co-Lead Counsel); • In Re: Deva Concepts Products Liability Litigation, 1:20-cv-01234 (S.D.N.Y.) (Appointed Interim Co-Lead Counsel); • In Re Santa Fe Natural Tobacco Company Marketing & Sales Practices and Products Liability Litigation, 1:16-md-02695-JB-LF (D.N.M.) (chair of the Plaintiffs’ Steering Committee and member of the Plaintiffs’ Oversight Committee); • In Re Samsung Top-Load Washing Machine Marketing, Sales Practices & Product Liability Litigation, 5:17-md-02792 (W.D. Okla.), (appointed to Plaintiffs’ Executive

943605.1 16

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 18 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

Committee), a nationwide class action regarding a design defect in 2.8 million top loading washing machines, which resulted in a nationwide settlement. • In Re Windsor Wood Clad Window Product Liability Litigation, 16-MD-02688 (E.D. Wis.), a nationwide class action regarding allegedly defective windows, which resulted in a nationwide settlement.

Current Cases: • Aguilera v. NuWave, LLC (N.D. Ill.) (product defect and false advertising) • Ashour v. Arizona Beverages USA LLC et al. (S.D. NY) (false advertising/mislabeling) • Benson et al v. Newell Brands Inc., et al. (N.D. IL) (false advertising/mislabeling) • In Re: Deva Concepts Products Liability Litigation, 1:20-cv-01234 (S.D.N.Y.) (false advertising/mislabeling) • In Re Fairlife Milk Products Marketing and Sales Practices Litigation (N.D. IL) (false advertising) • Granucci v. KLN Enterprises, Inc. et al. (MN State Court, Ramsey County) (false advertising/mislabeling) • In Re Pork Antitrust Litigation (D. Minn.) • In Re Samsung Top-Load Washing Machine Marketing, Sales Practices, and Products Liability Litigation (W.D. Okla.) • In Re Santa Fe Natural Tobacco Company Marketing, Sales Practices, and Products Liability Litigation (D. N.M.) (false advertising/mislabeling) • Snarr et al v. Cento Fine Foods Inc. (N.D. Cal) (false advertising/mislabeling) • Snyder et al v. Greens Road of Florida, LLC (S.D. FL) (false advertising/mislabeling) • Stanton v. Sargento Foods, Inc. (N.D. Cal) (false advertising/mislabeling)

Education: • William Mitchell College of Law - J.D. – 2007 • University of Michigan – Ann Arbor - B.A. – 2004

Bar Admissions: • New York • Minnesota • Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals • U.S. District Court, District of Minnesota • U.S. District Court, Colorado • U.S. District Court, Northern District of Illinois • U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York Professional Associations and Memberships: • Minnesota State Bar Association • Federal Bar Association • Public Justice

943605.1 17

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 19 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

TRIAL COUNSEL

Thomas J. Nolan is Of Counsel in the Sherman Oaks office of Pearson, Simon & Warshaw, LLP.

Mr. Nolan is widely recognized as one of the nation’s leading trial attorneys, and has extensive civil and criminal trial experience representing corporations and individuals in complex litigation in state and federal courts.

Mr. Nolan is a former federal prosecutor and served as Chief of Fraud and Special Prosecutions in the Los Angeles United States Attorney’s Office. He has been a member of the defense bar since 1979.

Mr. Nolan has represented both corporate plaintiffs and defendants across a wide range of complex civil litigation matters including class actions; a wide variety of contract disputes, including a three-month jury trial against 63 insurance carriers; unfair business practices and consumer fraud; as well as antitrust and intellectual property issues. Mr. Nolan is also recognized as a leading lawyer for “first of their kind” trials. His diverse experience was cited by media reports on his arrival at Latham, such as this Bloomberg-BNA Law article.

Mr. Nolan has represented corporations and individuals in criminal DOJ prosecutions and SEC enforcement matters and in internal investigations involving FCPA allegations, securities fraud, money laundering, RICO, healthcare fraud, and insider trading violations.

He leverages extensive trial experience including winning jury verdicts of more than $1 billion for his clients and defeating claims exceeding $15 billion asserted against clients.

Notable Cases:

• Lead trial counsel for CashCall in defeating more than $275 million in restitution and monetary claims sought by the CFPB. • Served as lead trial counsel representing UBS Real Estate Securities Inc. in a closely watched three-week bench trial conducted in the US District Court, Southern District of New York.* • Served as lead trial counsel representing the home mortgage division of a major bank against class action claims of racial discrimination in mortgage lending* • Defended Peter Morton in securing a unanimous jury verdict awarding zero damages in a case alleging fraud, breach of fiduciary duty and invasion of privacy* • Represented the founders of Skype Technologies S.A., with a consortium of private equity and venture capital firms led by Silver Lake, in the $2.8 billion acquisition of Skype from eBay Inc.* • Represented Tyco International Ltd. in a litigation in the US District Court for the Southern District of New York brought by holders of $2.7 billion of notes issued by Tyco.*

943605.1 18

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 20 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

• Served as lead trial counsel representing the consortium of underwriters of WorldCom Securities in securing a settlement on the eve of jury selection in one of the largest securities class action cases in history.* • Represented Litton Industries in a high-profile monopoly antitrust lawsuit against Honeywell, Inc. in the US District Court for the Central District of California.*

*Represents experience from a previous law firms.

Accolades:

Mr. Nolan has served in numerous honorary positions and received numerous accolades over his extensive career, including:

• American College of Trial Lawyers – Fellow • International Academy of Trial Lawyers – Fellow • Loyola Marymount University – Board of Regents • Loyola University School of Law at Los Angeles – Board of Directors • Loyola University School of Law at Los Angeles – Champion of Justice Award • Beverly Hills Bar Association – Excellence in Advocacy Award • Association of Business Trial Lawyers – frequent lecturer • Federal Bar Association – frequent lecturer • California Bar Association – Pro Bono Lawyer of the Year • The Am Law Litigation Daily – Litigator of the Week

Mr. Nolan has been selected for inclusion in Chambers Global: The World’s Leading Lawyers for Business, and he is one of only 23 attorneys listed in the top tier of national trial attorneys by Chambers USA: America’s Leading Lawyers for Business, which also ranks him in its top tier for general commercial litigation. In addition, Mr. Nolan has been profiled for 12 different years as one of the Top 100 most influential lawyers in California and as one of the Top 30 Securities Litigators in California by the Daily Journal. He was named Best Lawyers’ 2015 Los Angeles Bet-the-Company Litigation Lawyer of the Year.

Education:

• Loyola Law School - Los Angeles, California - J.D. - 1975 • Loyola Marymount University, Los Angeles, California - B.B.A. -1971

Bar Admissions:

• California • Supreme Court of the United States • Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals • U.S. District Court, Central District of California

943605.1 19

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 21 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

• U.S. District Court, Eastern District of California • U.S. District Court, Northern District of California • U.S. District Court, Southern District of California • U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York

943605.1 20

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 22 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

OF COUNSEL

NEIL SWARTZBERG

Neil Swartzberg, Of Counsel to Pearson, Simon & Warshaw, LLP, has significant litigation and counseling experience, with a track record of providing advice and representation to individuals and companies on a variety of technology, consumer and finance related matters. He has expertise in complex and commercial litigation, including in the intellectual property, consumer protection, antitrust, securities and class action context. Practicing in both federal and state courts, he has litigated price-fixing class actions, securities fraud suits and other consumer protection cases, as well as patent infringement, trade secret misappropriation and related intellectual property matters. Mr. Swartzberg also has experience negotiating licenses and similar agreements to resolve disputes in technology areas such the Internet, online banking, and telecommunications.

Mr. Swartzberg was a leading attorney in the Direct Purchaser Plaintiff class action In re Static Random Access Memory (SRAM) Antitrust Litigation (N.D. Cal.). He was also actively involved in several other antitrust class actions, such as In re International Air Transportation Surcharge Antitrust Litigation (N.D. Cal.), Air Cargo Shipping Services Antitrust Litigation (E.D.N.Y.), In re Cathode Ray Tube (CRT) Antitrust Litigation (N.D. Cal.), and In re Optical Disk Drive (ODD) Antitrust Litigation (N.D. Cal.). He has represented patent owners and companies in infringement cases for patents covering video game controllers, Internet search functionality, secure mobile banking transactions, and telecommunications switches.

Current Cases: • In re Broiler Chicken Antitrust Litigation (N.D. Ill.) • In re: Santa Fe Natural Tobacco Company Marketing, Sales Practices, and Products Liability Litigation (D.N.M.) • North American Soccer League, LLC v. United States Soccer Federation, Inc., and Major League Soccer, L.L.C. (E.D.N.Y.)

Education: • University of California, Davis, School of Law, Davis, California – J.D. – 2001 • State University of New York, Buffalo, Buffalo, New York – M.A. – 1994 • Duke University, Durham, North Carolina – A.B. – 1991

Bar Admissions: • California • Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals • Federal Circuit Court of Appeals • U.S. District Court, Central District of California • U.S. District Court, Eastern District of California • U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Missouri

943605.1 21

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 23 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

• U.S. District Court, Western District of Pennsylvania

Publications and Presentations: • The Hard Cell, Mobile banking and the Federal Circuit's "divided infringement" decisions, Feb. 2013, Intellectual Property magazine, with Robert D. Becker.

Professional Associations and Memberships: • American Bar Association

Languages: • German (proficient)

943605.1 22

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 24 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

ASSOCIATES

JOSEPH C. BOURNE

Joseph C. Bourne is a litigator in the firm’s Minneapolis office. Mr. Bourne focuses his practice on complex class action litigation, with an emphasis on antitrust, consumer fraud, product defect, and data privacy and security practices. Before joining the firm in 2018, Mr. Bourne was a partner at a Minneapolis law firm where his practice similarly focused on representing plaintiffs in antitrust and class action litigation.

Mr. Bourne has been nominated by his peers and recognized by Super Lawyers Magazine as a Minnesota Rising Star in the area of antitrust litigation every year since 2014. He is active in the legal community, serving as a volunteer attorney through the District of Minnesota and Federal Bar Association’s Pro Se Project. In recognition of his commitment to pro bono work, Mr. Bourne was recognized as a North Star Lawyer by the Minnesota State Bar Association in 2013 and 2014.

Before entering private practice, Mr. Bourne served as a judicial law clerk to Judge Francis J. Connolly, and then to Chief Judge Edward Toussaint, Jr., at the Minnesota Court of Appeals. While in law school, Mr. Bourne served as an Articles Editor of the Minnesota Law Review.

Current Cases: • In re Pork Antitrust Litigation (D. Minn.) • In re Cattle Antitrust Litigation (D. Minn.) • In re Keurig Green Mountain Single-Serve Coffee Antitrust Litigation (S.D.N.Y.) • In re. Santa Fe Natural Tobacco Company Marketing, Sales Practices, and Products Liability Litigation (D.N.M.) • Aguilera v. NuWave, LLC (N.D. Ill.) • Young v. Cree, Inc. (N.D. Cal.)

Education: • University of Minnesota Law School – J.D., magna cum laude – 2009 • Emory University – B.A. – 2005

Publications: • Health Care’s Invisible Giants: Pharmacy Benefit Managers, The Federal Lawyer (2013) (Ellen Ahrens, coauthor) • Pro Se Litigation and the Costs of Access to Justice, 39 Wm. Mitchell L. Rev. 32 (2012) (Dan Gustafson and Karla Gluek, coauthors) • Prosecutorial Use of Forensic Science at Trial, 93 Minn. L. Rev. 1058 (2009)

943605.1 23

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 25 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

Bar Admissions: • Minnesota • California • Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals • U.S. District Court, District of Minnesota • U.S. District Court, Southern District of California • U.S. District Court, Central District of California

MICHAEL H. PEARSON

Michael H. Pearson is a civil litigator in the firm’s Los Angeles office, focusing on complex litigation, class actions, and consumer protection. Mr. Pearson has extensive experience in representing clients in a variety of contexts. He has served as a member of the litigation team in multiple cases that resulted in class certification or a classwide settlement, including cases that involved business litigation, complex financial products, high-technology products, consumer safety, and false and misleading advertising. Specifically, he was instrumental in managing the review of tens of millions of documents and drafting pleadings in In Re Credit Default Swaps Antitrust Litigation, which was settled for $1.86 billion, plus injunctive relief.

Mr. Pearson received his Bachelor of Science degree from Tulane University in 2008, majoring in Finance with an Energy Specialization. He received his Juris Doctorate from Loyola Law School Los Angeles in 2011. Mr. Pearson is an active member in a number of legal organizations, including the American, Los Angeles County and San Fernando Valley Bar Associations, Consumer Attorneys of California, the Consumer Attorneys Association of Los Angeles and the Association of Business Trial Lawyers.

Mr. Pearson’s success has earned him recognition by his peers as a Super Lawyers Rising Star (representing the top 2.5% of lawyers in Southern California age 40 or younger or in practice for 10 years or less) in 2017, 2018, 2019 and 2020.

Current Cases: • City of Oakland v. The Oakland Raiders, et al. (N.D. Cal.) • City of Oakland v. The Oakland Raiders, et al. (Cal. Sup. Ct.) • In re Broiler Chicken Antitrust Litigation (N.D. Ill.) • In Re Pork Antitrust Litigation (D. Minn.) • Senne, et al. v. Office of the Commissioner of Baseball, et al. (N.D. Cal.)

Education: • Loyola Law School Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California – J.D. – 2011 • Tulane University, New Orleans, Louisiana – B.S., magna cum laude – 2008

943605.1 24

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 26 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

Bar Admissions: • California • Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals • U.S. District Court, Central District of California • U.S. District Court, Eastern District of California • U.S. District Court, Northern District of California • U.S. District Court, Southern District of California

Professional Associations and Memberships: • American Bar Association • Association of Business Trial Lawyers • Consumer Attorneys Association of Los Angeles • Consumer Attorneys of California • Los Angeles County Bar Association • San Fernando Valley Bar Association

BENJAMIN E. SHIFTAN

Benjamin E. Shiftan is a litigator in the firm’s San Francisco office. Since joining the firm in 2014, Mr. Shiftan has focused on complex class action litigation, including antitrust, product defect, and consumer protection cases.

Prior to joining the firm, Mr. Shiftan litigated complex bad faith insurance cases for a national law firm. Before that, Mr. Shiftan served as a law clerk to the Honorable Peter G. Sheridan, United States District Court for the District of New Jersey, and worked for a mid-sized firm in San Diego.

Mr. Shiftan graduated from the University of San Diego School of Law in 2009. While in law school, he served as Lead Articles Editor of the San Diego International Law Journal and competed as a National Team Member on the Moot Court Board. Mr. Shiftan won the school's Paul A. McLennon, Sr. Honors Moot Court Competition. At graduation, he was one of ten students inducted into the Order of the Barristers. Mr. Shiftan graduated from the University of Virginia in 2006.

Current Cases: • In re Keurig Green Mountain Single-Serve Coffee Antitrust Litigation (S.D.N.Y.) • In re National Collegiate Athletic Association Athletic Grant-in-Aid Cap Antitrust Litigation (N.D. Cal.) • Senne, et al. v. Office of the Commissioner of Baseball, et al. (N.D. Cal.) • North American Soccer League, LLC v. United States Soccer Federation, Inc., and Major League Soccer, L.L.C. (E.D.N.Y.)

943605.1 25

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 27 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

Education: • University of San Diego School of Law, San Diego, CA – J.D. – 2009 • University of Virginia, Charlottesville, VA – B.A. – 2006

Bar Admissions: • California • Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals • U.S. District Court, Central District of California • U.S. District Court, Eastern District of California • U.S. District Court, Northern District of California • U.S. District Court, Southern District of California

Professional Associations and Memberships: • San Francisco County Bar Association

MATTHEW A. PEARSON

Matthew A. Pearson is an associate in the firm’s Los Angeles office focusing on antitrust, consumer protection, copyright, and business litigation. Mr. Pearson has represented clients in a variety of different matters and works closely with clients, co-counsel, and opposing counsel on all aspects of litigation.

In 2019, Mr. Pearson received the award for Outstanding Antitrust Litigation Achievement in Private Law Practice by the American Antitrust Institute for his work in the In re National Collegiate Athletic Association Athletic Grant-in-Aid Cap Antitrust Litigation (N.D. Cal.) trial, which took place in September of 2018 and resulted in a verdict in Plaintiffs’ favor. Additionally, in 2019, Mr. Pearson was selected by his peers as a Super Lawyer (representing the top 5% of practicing lawyers in Southern California).

Mr. Pearson received his Bachelor of Science degree from the University of Arizona in 2010, majoring in Business Management. He received his Juris Doctorate from Whittier Law School in 2013. Mr. Pearson is an active member in a number of legal organizations, including the American Bar Association, American Association for Justice, Association of Business Trial Lawyers, Consumer Attorneys Association of Los Angeles, Consumer Attorneys of California, and the Los Angeles County Bar Association.

Current Cases: • Grace v. Apple, Inc. (N.D. Cal.) • In re Keurig Green Mountain Single-Serving Coffee Antitrust Litigation (S.D.N.Y.) • Greg Kihn, et al. v. Bill Graham Archives, LLC, et al. (N.D. Cal.) • In re KIND LLC “Healthy and All Natural” Litigation (S.D.N.Y.) • In re National Collegiate Athletic Association Athletic Grant-in-Aid Cap Antitrust Litigation (N.D. Cal.)

943605.1 26

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 28 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

• North American Soccer League, LLC v. United States Soccer Federation, Inc., and Major League Soccer, L.L.C. (E.D.N.Y.) • In Re Cattle Antitrust Litigation (D. Minn.)

Education: • Whittier Law School, California – J.D. – 2013 • University of Arizona: Eller College of Management – B.S.– 2010

Bar Admissions: • California • Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals • U.S. District Court, Central District of California • U.S. District Court, Eastern District of California • U.S. District Court, Northern District of California • U.S. District Court, Southern District of California

Professional Associations and Memberships: • American Bar Association • American Association for Justice • Association of Business Trial Lawyers • Consumer Attorneys Association of Los Angeles • Consumer Attorneys of California • Los Angeles County Bar Association

NAVEED ABAIE

Naveed Abaie is an associate in the firm’s Los Angeles office focusing on consumer protection, antitrust, and business litigation.

He graduated from the University of San Diego, School of Law in 2017. While at the University of San Diego, Mr. Abaie earned his J.D. with a concentration in Business and Corporate Law. Mr. Abaie received his Bachelor’s degree from the University of California, Berkeley Haas School of Business in 2012.

Current Cases:

• In re Broiler Chicken Antitrust Litigation (N.D. Ill) • In Re Pork Antitrust Litigation (D. Minn.)

Education:

• University of San Diego, California – J.D. – 2017 • University of California, Berkeley, California – B.A.– 2012

943605.1 27

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-20 Filed 11/24/20 Page 29 of 29

PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP

Bar Admissions:

• California

Professional Associations and Memberships:

• Iranian American Bar Association

JESSOP STROMAN

Jessop Stroman is an associate in the firm’s Los Angeles office focusing on consumer protection, antitrust, and business litigation.

He graduated from UCLA School of Law in 2018, earning his J.D. with a specialization in Business Law and Policy. At UCLA, Mr. Stroman served as a Production Editor for UCLA’s Journal of International Law and Foreign Affairs. Prior to law school, Mr. Stroman worked in the mortgage industry as an account manager and a loan officer where he negotiated loan modifications, repayment plans, loan reinstatements, short sales, and deed-in-lieu of foreclosure transactions, as well as originating millions of dollars in new purchase and refinance loans. Mr. Stroman earned his B.A. in English and Creative Writing from Loyola University Chicago in 2012, graduating Magna Cum Laude.

Current Cases:

• In Re Pork Antitrust Litigation (D. Minn.) • North American Soccer League, LLC v. United States Soccer Federation, Inc., and Major League Soccer, L.L.C. (E.D.N.Y.) • Senne, et al. v. Office of the Commissioner of Baseball, et al. (N.D. Cal.) • In re Keurig Green Mountain Single-Serving Coffee Antitrust Litigation (S.D.N.Y.)

Education:

• UCLA School of Law, Los Angeles, California – J.D. – 2018 • Loyola University Chicago, Chicago, Illinois – B.A. – 2012

Bar Admissions:

• California

Professional Associations and Memberships:

• Los Angeles County Bar Association

943605.1 28

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-21 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 2

EXHIBIT 2 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-21 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 2 GRACE v. APPLE, INC. TIME REPORT Status: FIRM NAME: PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP (P) Partner REPORTING PERIOD: INCEPTION THRU 10/31/2020 (A) Associate (PL) Paralegal

BAR CUMULATIVE CUMULATIVE NAME STATUS HOURLY RATE ADMITTANCE HOURS LODESTAR Clifford H. Pearson P 1983 $ 1,050.00 24.5 $ 25,725.00 Clifford H. Pearson P 1983 $ 1,150.00 77.4 $ 89,010.00 Clifford H. Pearson P 1983 $ 1,190.00 49.7 $ 59,143.00 Bruce L. Simon P 1980 $ 1,035.00 33.9 $ 35,086.50 Bruce L. Simon P 1980 $ 1,050.00 1.8 $ 1,890.00 Bruce L. Simon P 1980 $ 1,150.00 16.0 $ 18,400.00 Daniel L. Warshaw P 1996 $ 985.00 127.7 $ 125,784.50 Daniel L. Warshaw P 1996 $ 1,050.00 419.2 $ 440,160.00 Daniel L. Warshaw P 1996 $ 1,150.00 171.3 $ 196,995.00 Daniel L. Warshaw P 1996 $ 1,190.00 264.3 $ 314,517.00 Joseph C. Bourne A 2009* $ 670.00 50.0 $ 33,500.00 Veronica W. Glaze A 2008 $ 520.00 679.5 $ 353,340.00 Eric J. Mont A 2017 $ 350.00 30.8 $ 10,780.00 Matthew A. Pearson A 2013 $ 400.00 293.8 $ 117,520.00 Matthew A. Pearson A 2013 $ 450.00 1.0 $ 450.00 Alexander L. Simon A 2015 $ 400.00 534.3 $ 213,720.00 Alexander L. Simon A 2015 $ 450.00 82.1 $ 36,945.00 Alexander L. Simon A 2015 $ 470.00 131.7 $ 61,899.00 ATTORNEY TOTALS 2,989.0 $ 2,134,865.00

EXPERIENCE Ellowene Grant PL 17 years $ 225.00 42.4 $ 9,540.00 NON-ATTORNEY TOTALS 42.4 $ 9,540.00

TOTALS 3,031.4 $ 2,144,405.00

*2009 admission to the State Bar of Minnesota and 2015 admission to the State Bar of California. Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-22 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 63

EXHIBIT 3 Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 63 Page: 1 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 1 Clifford H. Pearson 09/18/2018 1.00 1,050.00 Review lengthy Order regarding class certification. 09/20/2018 0.80 840.00 Review materials and conference with counsel regarding mediation plan. 09/26/2018 0.50 525.00 E-mail traffic and calls with counsel regarding mediation. 10/30/2018 1.00 1,050.00 Review mediation brief. 11/01/2018 1.00 1,050.00 Prepare for mediation. 11/05/2018 2.20 2,310.00 Prepare for mediation. Communication with counsel regarding same. 11/05/2018 0.70 735.00 Call with Attorney A. Steyer and Attorney B. Simon regarding mediation. 11/06/2018 2.80 2,940.00 Prepare for mediation. Conference call with all plaintiffs' counsel regarding mediation. 11/08/2018 3.00 3,150.00 Travel to and prepare for mediation. Communication with counsel. 11/09/2018 11.50 12,075.00 Attend mediation. Return travel to Los Angeles. 08/22/2019 1.10 1,265.00 Review Order on Motion for summary judgment and Mediation. Emails with counsel regarding same. 08/22/2019 0.30 345.00 Call with Attorney A. Steyer regarding mediation Order. 08/23/2019 1.50 1,725.00 Review Case Management Conference statement. Call with Attorney A. Steyer regarding same. Attend conference call with co-counsel regarding same. 08/26/2019 0.50 575.00 Review memorandum and emails regarding case strategy. 08/26/2019 0.90 1,035.00 Prepare for attend conference call with counsel. Calls with D. Warshaw. 09/09/2019 0.40 460.00 Conferences and emails with counsel regarding mediation. 09/18/2019 1.00 1,150.00 Call with Attorney A. Steyer. Conference with Attorney D. Warshaw. Review damage figures. 09/24/2019 0.60 690.00 Call with Attorney A. Steyer regarding mediation. Conference with Attorney D. Warshaw. Review damages. 09/25/2019 0.90 1,035.00 E-mail regarding damage model. Conference with Attorney D. Warshaw. Review draft mediation brief. 09/25/2019 0.70 805.00 Calls with mediator, Attorney A. Steyer and Attorney D. Warshaw. 09/30/2019 0.40 460.00 Review letter to mediator. Conference with Attorney D. Warshaw. 10/11/2019 1.00 1,150.00 Call with Attorney A. Steyer. Conference with D. Warshaw. Review and revise mediation brief. Review file regarding same. 10/14/2019 0.80 920.00 Work on issues related to mediation. Call with Attorney B. Simon. Conference with Attorney D. Warshaw. 10/16/2019 0.80 920.00 Final review of mediation brief. Communication with Attorney D. Warshaw. Review materials regarding brief. 10/17/2019 0.60 690.00 Work on issues related to upcoming mediation. Call with mediator. 10/20/2019 0.40 460.00 Review materials for mediation. 10/21/2019 1.40 1,610.00 Prepare for mediation. 10/22/2019 16.50 18,975.00 Travel to and attend mediation in San Francisco. Meet with counsel. Return to Los Angeles. 10/23/2019 1.80 2,070.00 Work on issues related to potential settlement including multiple calls and emails with counsel. Review term sheet. 10/28/2019 0.70 805.00 Multiple calls and emails with counsel regarding issues related to proposed settlement. 10/29/2019 1.00 1,150.00 Calls and emails with counsel and mediator regarding proposed settlement issues. 11/01/2019 0.60 690.00 Prepare for and attend call with mediator. Conference with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding settlement. E-mail to co-counsel regarding same. 11/03/2019 0.40 460.00 Work on settlement. 11/04/2019 1.30 1,495.00 Work on settlement issues. Calls with counsel and mediator. Conference with Attorney D. Warshaw. 11/05/2019 0.80 920.00 Prepare and review multiple emails regarding settlement. Conference call with counsel. Conference with Attorney D. Warshaw. 11/05/2019 1.40 1,610.00 Further evening work on settlement issues including emails and calls with counsel and mediator. 11/06/2019 1.90 2,185.00 Call with Attorney A. Steyer regarding settlement. Call with mediator and Attorney A. Steyer. Conference with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding settlement. Calls with mediator. Review and prepare related emails. 11/07/2019 0.60 690.00 Emails and conferences with counsel regarding settlement issues. Call with Attorney A. Steyer. 11/08/2019 0.80 920.00 Prepare for and attend conference call with counsel. 11/08/2019 0.30 345.00 Review draft stipulation from defendant and related e-mails. 11/08/2019 0.80 920.00 Work on issues related to confidentiality and mediation privilege. Conference with Attorney D. Warshaw. 11/12/2019 0.70 805.00 Review multiple emails regarding settlement issues. Call with Attorney D. Warshaw. 11/13/2019 0.70 805.00 Further review of emails regarding settlement. Review JAMS confidentiality agreement. 11/13/2019 1.00 1,150.00 Multiple additional emails, calls and conferences with counsel regarding settlement

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 3 of 63 Page: 2 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 1 Clifford H. Pearson issues. 11/14/2019 1.20 1,380.00 Work on issues related to settlement. Calls and emails with counsel regarding same. 11/15/2019 1.00 1,150.00 Prepare for and attend conference call with counsel and in-house counsel for Apple. Call with Attorney J. Manning. Conference with Attorney D. Warshaw. 11/15/2019 0.50 575.00 Review status conference report to court. Emails regarding same. Conference with Attorney D. Warshaw. 11/18/2019 0.40 460.00 Review e-mail from Apple's counsel regarding status report. Conference with Attorney D. Warshaw. Email regarding same. 11/19/2019 0.60 690.00 Review offers by Apple. Emails regarding same. Conference with Attorney D. Warshaw. 11/21/2019 0.80 920.00 Review Order. Conference with counsel. Conference call with counsel. 11/21/2019 0.40 460.00 Call with Attorney A. Steyer. 11/25/2019 0.60 690.00 Review court order and emails regarding same. Call with Attorney D. Warshaw. 11/26/2019 0.20 230.00 Call with Attorney A. Steyer regarding settlement conference. 11/26/2019 0.70 805.00 Prepare for and attend call with Court regarding mediation. Conference with Attorney D. Warshaw. 11/27/2019 2.00 2,300.00 Work on settlement brief. Conferences with Attorney D. Warshaw. 11/28/2019 1.20 1,380.00 Review multiple redlines of mediation brief. Call with Attorney D. Warshaw. Emails regarding same. 11/29/2019 1.20 1,380.00 Review latest drafts of mediation brief. Multiple calls with Attorney D. Warshaw. Emails regarding same. 11/30/2019 0.50 575.00 Finalize mediation brief. Emails regarding same. 12/01/2019 1.00 1,150.00 Further review and revision of mediation brief. Call with D. Tejtel and Attorney D. Warshaw. Call with Attorney D. Warshaw. Emails regarding settlement. 12/02/2019 0.60 690.00 Finalize mediation brief and conferences with Attorney D. Warshaw. 12/02/2019 0.40 460.00 Conference call with counsel regarding trial preparation and mediation. 12/02/2019 1.00 1,150.00 Further conference call with counsel regarding mediation. 12/02/2019 0.70 805.00 Review Apple's mediation brief. Call with Attorney D. Warshaw. 12/03/2019 1.30 1,495.00 Further review of mediation briefs. Prepare for mediation including conferences with Attorneys D. Warshaw and A. Simon. 12/04/2019 2.00 2,300.00 Prepare for mediation. Conferences with Attorney D. Warshaw. Call with Attorney J. Manning. Review caselaw. 12/05/2019 12.00 13,800.00 Travel to and attend mediation in San Jose. Return travel. 12/06/2019 1.00 1,150.00 Multiple calls and emails regarding potential settlement. Conferences with Attorney D. Warshaw. 12/09/2019 0.50 575.00 Conference with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding settlement. Emails regarding same. 12/12/2019 1.00 1,150.00 Review emails regarding settlement. Calls with Attorney D. Warshaw and Attorney J. Manning. Review proposed stipulation. 01/02/2020 1.40 1,666.00 Conferences with Attorneys D. Warshaw and T. Nolan. Emails with counsel Emails and call with mediator. Review file materials. 01/02/2020 0.30 357.00 Call with Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement. 01/03/2020 0.40 476.00 Conferences with Attorney D. Warshaw and A Simon regarding trial preparation. 01/08/2020 0.40 476.00 Conference with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding status of settlement and trial issues. 01/09/2020 0.50 595.00 Prepare for and attend call with counsel. Review Case Management Conference draft report. E-mail with mediator. 01/09/2020 0.50 595.00 Prepare for and attend call with mediator. Conference with Attorney D. Warshaw. 01/11/2020 0.40 476.00 Calls and emails with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding settlement. 01/12/2020 1.40 1,666.00 Review lengthy memorandum on statutes of limitations. Emails with Attorney D. Warshaw. Prepare e-mail to mediator. Additional research. 01/15/2020 2.00 2,380.00 Prepare for mediation. Conferences and calls with counsel. 01/16/2020 13.00 15,470.00 Travel to and attend mediation, pre trial hearing and meeting with counsel. 01/17/2020 1.00 1,190.00 Continue to work on settlement issues. 01/19/2020 1.00 1,190.00 Review e-mail from Attorney J. Lerner regarding statutes of limitations. Multiple emails with counsel and research regarding statute of limitations. 01/20/2020 1.40 1,666.00 Work on settlement issues. Call with Attorney D. Tejtel. Emails with counsel. 01/20/2020 0.70 833.00 Prepare for and attend conference call with co counsel. E-mails regarding same. 01/21/2020 0.50 595.00 Conference with Attorney D. Warshaw. Call with Attorney A. Steyer. 01/22/2020 0.60 714.00 Prepare for and attend call with all counsel regarding trial preparation. 01/22/2020 2.10 2,499.00 Work on settlement issues including calls and emails with counsel and preparation of status report. 01/24/2020 1.30 1,547.00 Work on potential settlement. Calls, emails and conferences with counsel. 01/27/2020 2.50 2,975.00 Calls and emails with counsel and mediator. Work on settlement issues. 01/28/2020 0.40 476.00 Review pleadings. 01/28/2020 1.40 1,666.00 Calls with counsel. Work on potential settlement.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 4 of 63 Page: 3 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 1 Clifford H. Pearson 01/29/2020 1.50 1,785.00 Work on settlement issues. 01/31/2020 1.50 1,785.00 Work on settlement issues. 02/02/2020 0.80 952.00 Calls and emails with counsel regarding mediator's proposal. 02/03/2020 1.00 1,190.00 Prepare for and attend call with counsel. Work on settlement issues. 02/06/2020 0.40 476.00 Communications with co-counsel regarding mediator's proposal. 02/07/2020 0.20 238.00 Review term sheet. 02/07/2020 0.60 714.00 Emails regarding settlement. 02/07/2020 0.20 238.00 Call with Attorneys D. Warshaw and D. Tejtel. 02/21/2020 0.80 952.00 Review draft settlement agreement. 02/21/2020 0.20 238.00 Emails and calls with counsel regarding settlement agreement. 03/02/2020 1.00 1,190.00 Multiple calls and emails with counsel regarding settlement terms. Multiple conferences with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding settlement agreement. 03/04/2020 0.80 952.00 Continue to work on settlement issues. 03/05/2020 1.20 1,428.00 Work on settlement issues including calls and emails with counsel and mediator. 03/06/2020 1.00 1,190.00 Work on settlement issues. 03/09/2020 0.40 476.00 Review brief regarding distribution. 03/09/2020 0.40 476.00 Calls and emails with counsel regarding brief regarding distribution and settlement issues. 03/10/2020 1.30 1,547.00 Multiple calls and emails with counsel regarding settlement agreement issues. 03/11/2020 1.00 1,190.00 Work on settlement agreement issues. 03/19/2020 0.10 119.00 Review of draft of status report to court. 03/20/2020 0.10 119.00 Review order regarding pretrial deadlines and motion for preliminary approval. 04/07/2020 0.50 595.00 Emails with mediator. Calls with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding status of settlement. 04/09/2020 0.70 833.00 Review redline draft of settlement agreement. 08/25/2020 0.40 476.00 Prepare for and attend conference call with counsel regarding motion for preliminary approval. 09/03/2020 0.40 476.00 Participate in post hearing conference call with counsel.

Total for Timekeeper 1 Billable 151.60 173,878.00 Clifford H. Pearson

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 5 of 63 Page: 4 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw 12/09/2016 1.60 1,576.00 Review of file materials in order to prepare for call with co-counsel. 12/09/2016 0.80 788.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding complaint. 12/27/2016 1.30 1,280.50 Work on complaint. 12/31/2016 2.10 2,068.50 Work on complaint. 01/03/2017 1.10 1,083.50 Work on complaint. 01/03/2017 1.20 1,182.00 Conduct research regarding unjust enrichment claim. 01/04/2017 1.60 1,576.00 Preparation for and attend telephone conference with co-counsel regarding complaint. 01/30/2017 0.40 394.00 Work on complaint. 02/01/2017 2.10 2,068.50 Complete preparation of complaint. 02/03/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of case assignment. 02/03/2017 0.10 98.50 Communicate (other outside counsel) exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding case assignment. 02/03/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of initial case management order. 02/06/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of biographies of district judges in San Jose court. 02/06/2017 0.10 98.50 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding Boston Globe story. 02/07/2017 1.20 1,182.00 Preparation for and attend telephone conference with co-counsel regarding case management and strategy. 02/14/2017 0.20 197.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding research of San Jose bench. 02/16/2017 0.10 98.50 Telephone call from Attorney E. Deeley regarding request for extension. 02/16/2017 0.20 197.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding defense counsel and request for extension. 02/16/2017 0.10 98.50 Follow up call to Attorney E. Deeley regarding request for extension. 02/16/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of Apple's declination to proceed before magistrate. 02/16/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of Apple's certificate of interested parties. 02/16/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of Apple's notice of appearance. 02/16/2017 0.10 98.50 Preparation of e-mail to co-counsel regarding Apple's declination to proceed before magistrate. 02/21/2017 0.10 98.50 Communicate (other outside counsel) Exchange e-mail with Attorney E. Deeley regarding stipulation to extend defendant's deadline to respond to complaint. 02/22/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of order reassigning case to Judge Freeman. 02/24/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of order of recusal. 02/24/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of order reassigning case. 02/24/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of notice assigning case to Judge Koh. 03/02/2017 0.10 98.50 Communicate (other outside counsel) Telephone conference with Attended E. Deeley regarding status of case. 03/03/2017 0.10 98.50 Exchange e-mail with Attorney E. Deeley regarding complaint. 03/03/2017 0.10 98.50 Preparation of e-mail to co-counsel regarding settlement in anti-poaching case before Judge Koh. 03/24/2017 0.20 197.00 Telephone conference with Attorney E. Deeley regarding motion to dismiss and case management issues. 03/24/2017 0.10 98.50 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding call with Attorney E. Deeley. 03/27/2017 0.40 394.00 Review of memorandum regarding opposition to motion to dismiss. 03/27/2017 0.40 394.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Preparation for and telephone conference with co-counsel regarding protective order in VirnetX case and amended complaint. 03/27/2017 0.10 98.50 Review correspondence regarding protective order from VirnetX litigation. 03/30/2017 0.40 394.00 Review of draft amended complaint. 03/31/2017 0.50 492.50 Review of co-counsel's proposed revisions to amended complaint. 03/31/2017 0.70 689.50 Communicate (other outside counsel) telephone conference with co-counsel regarding proposed amended complaint. 04/03/2017 0.30 295.50 Telephone conference with co-counsel and potential consultant. 04/05/2017 1.20 1,182.00 Work on draft amended complaint. 04/10/2017 0.30 295.50 Review of upcoming deadlines and court order regarding same. 04/10/2017 0.10 98.50 Telephone call to Attorney A. Simon regarding case management deadlines. 04/12/2017 0.20 197.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding protective order issue. 04/14/2017 0.40 394.00 Review/analyze revisions to demands for production. 04/17/2017 0.50 492.50 Communicate (other outside counsel) Telephone call from Attorney A. Steyer regarding case strategy and status. 04/18/2017 0.40 394.00 Numerous emails with defense counsel regarding scheduling motion to dismiss hearing and Rule 26(f) conference. 04/19/2017 0.30 295.50 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding scheduling of defendant's motion to dismiss. 04/19/2017 0.10 98.50 Exchange e-mail with defense counsel and court clerk regarding defendant's motion

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 6 of 63 Page: 5 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw to dismiss. 04/19/2017 3.10 3,053.50 Review of defendant's motion to dismiss and related filings. 04/20/2017 0.30 295.50 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding motion to dismiss and authority regarding injunctive relief and waivers of future tort actions. 04/20/2017 0.20 197.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney K. Whitehead regarding Rule 26(f) conference. 04/20/2017 0.30 295.50 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding motion to dismiss. 04/25/2017 0.80 788.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Preparation for and attend telephone conference with co-counsel regarding upcoming Rule 26(f) conference with defense counsel. 04/25/2017 0.30 295.50 Review/analyze e-mail from Attorney J. Manning regarding Rule 26(f) conference and ADR requirements. 04/25/2017 0.50 492.50 Communicate (other outside counsel) Preparation for and attend Rule 26(f) conference with all counsel. 04/25/2017 0.10 98.50 Communicate (other outside counsel) Follow up call with co-counsel regarding Rule 26(f) conference. 04/25/2017 0.30 295.50 Review/analyze Northern District ESI check list and guidelines. 04/25/2017 0.30 295.50 Review/analyze draft ESI stipulation. 04/26/2017 3.10 3,053.50 Draft ESI stipulation. 04/26/2017 0.60 591.00 Review of and revise opposition to motion to dismiss. 04/26/2017 0.40 394.00 Review of co-counsel's draft opposition to motion to dismiss. 04/28/2017 0.60 591.00 Review of draft Case Management Conference Statement. 04/28/2017 0.20 197.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding Case Management Conference Statement. 05/03/2017 0.80 788.00 Work on opposition to motion to dismiss. 05/12/2017 0.20 197.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding ADR conference. 05/12/2017 0.40 394.00 Preparation for and attend ADR conference call. 05/12/2017 0.30 295.50 Review of redlined ESI stipulation. 05/12/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of Apple's initial disclosures. 05/15/2017 0.50 492.50 Review of revised ESI stipulation. 05/16/2017 0.70 689.50 Work on ESI protocol. 05/16/2017 0.50 492.50 Review of Apple's opposition to request for stay in Apple v. Nokia. 05/17/2017 0.20 197.00 Review of proposed case schedule. 05/17/2017 0.20 197.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding modifications to proposed case schedule. 05/17/2017 0.10 98.50 Review correspondence from Attorney K. Sheffield-Whitehead regarding initial disclosures. 05/17/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of e-mail from Attorney J. Manning regarding Case Management Conference. 05/22/2017 0.30 295.50 Communicate (other outside counsel) Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding Case Management Conference and case status. 05/23/2017 0.50 492.50 Draft/revise stipulated protective order. 05/23/2017 0.10 98.50 Communicate (in firm) telephone conference with Attorney A. Simon regarding protective order. 05/30/2017 0.30 295.50 Review of memorandum regarding Article III standing issue. 06/01/2017 0.80 788.00 Plan and prepare for telephone conference with defense counsel regarding ESI stipulation, protective order and custodians. 06/01/2017 0.90 886.50 Communicate (other outside counsel) Telephone conference with co-counsel and Attorney E. Deeley regarding document preservation, ESI, protective order and custodians. 06/02/2017 0.90 886.50 Review of defendant's revisions to protective order ESI stipulation. 06/05/2017 1.50 1,477.50 Communicate (other outside counsel) Preparation for and telephone conference with co-counsel regarding case status. 06/05/2017 0.30 295.50 Review of outline for Article III standing for oral argument at motion to dismiss hearing. 06/06/2017 0.30 295.50 Work on letter to defense counsel regarding ESI stipulation and protective order. 06/06/2017 0.50 492.50 Preparation for meet and confer with defense counsel regarding ESI stipulation and protective order. 06/06/2017 2.40 2,364.00 Telephone conference with defense counsel regarding ESI stipulation and protective order. 06/06/2017 0.20 197.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding ESI stipulation and protective order. 06/07/2017 1.20 1,182.00 Review of ESI orders entered by Court in other class actions. 06/07/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of stipulation and proposed order regarding extension of time to file ESI stipulation and stipulated protective order. 06/07/2017 0.20 197.00 Exchange e-mail with all counsel regarding ESI stipulation.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 7 of 63 Page: 6 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw 06/08/2017 0.20 197.00 Review of redlined stipulated protective order. 06/09/2017 1.80 1,773.00 Conduct research regarding ESI protocol. 06/09/2017 2.60 2,561.00 Further work on ESI protocol. 06/09/2017 0.10 98.50 Preparation of e-mail to co-counsel regarding ESI protocol. 06/11/2017 1.10 1,083.50 Communicate (other outside counsel) Telephone conference with Attorney J. Cassady regarding revisions to ESI stipulation. 06/12/2017 0.40 394.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding ESI stipulation. 06/12/2017 2.60 2,561.00 Further preparation of revisions to ESI stipulation. 06/12/2017 0.30 295.50 Review of co-counsel's revisions to ESI stipulation. 06/13/2017 4.10 4,038.50 Review of revisions and work on further edits to ESI protocol. 06/14/2017 1.30 1,280.50 Preparation for and telephone conference with defense counsel regarding protective order and ESI stipulation. 06/14/2017 1.10 1,083.50 Communicate (other outside counsel) numerous communications with co-counsel regarding protective order and ESI stipulation. 06/14/2017 0.60 591.00 Further preparation of ESI stipulation. 06/23/2017 0.20 197.00 Review of outline regarding 17200 portion of motion to dismiss. 07/24/2017 3.50 3,447.50 Plan and prepare for hearing regarding motion to dismiss. 07/31/2017 0.70 689.50 Review/analyze order denying motion to dismiss. 08/02/2017 1.10 1,083.50 Communicate (other outside counsel) Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding case strategy. 08/07/2017 0.30 295.50 Review of proposed search terms. 08/08/2017 0.40 394.00 Plan and prepare for telephone conference with co-counsel regarding joint case management statement, discovery, plan and experts. 08/08/2017 0.60 591.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) telephone conference with co-counsel regarding joint case management statement, discovery, plan and experts. 08/08/2017 0.30 295.50 Work on search terms. 08/08/2017 1.10 1,083.50 Communicate (other outside counsel) Preparation for and telephone conference with co-counsel regarding Joint Case Management Conference Statement and discovery plan. 08/09/2017 0.40 394.00 Preparation of e-mails to vendors regarding online document review. 08/09/2017 1.60 1,576.00 Review of file in order to revise search terms. 08/09/2017 0.50 492.50 Telephone conference with Attorney D. Tejtel regarding search terms. 08/09/2017 0.30 295.50 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding search terms. 08/10/2017 0.50 492.50 Work on search terms. 08/10/2017 0.20 197.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding search terms. 08/10/2017 0.10 98.50 Telephone call from Attorney J. Manning regarding search terms. 08/10/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of e-mail from Attorney K. Sheffield-Whitehead regarding meet and confer and search terms. 08/11/2017 0.70 689.50 Review/analyze answer to complaint. 08/14/2017 0.30 295.50 Review of joint case management statement in preparation for call with defense counsel. 08/14/2017 0.20 197.00 Review of defendant's joint case management statement. 08/14/2017 0.50 492.50 Communicate (other outside counsel) telephone conference with co-counsel and Attorneys E. Deeley and K. Sheffield-Whitehead regarding joint case management statement. 08/14/2017 0.20 197.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding joint case management statement. 08/17/2017 0.30 295.50 Review of revisions to Case Management Conference Statement. 08/17/2017 0.20 197.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding Case Management Conference Statement. 08/17/2017 0.20 197.00 Exchange e-mail with defense counsel regarding Case Management Conference Statement. 08/25/2017 0.30 295.50 Review of revisions to interrogatories. 08/25/2017 0.20 197.00 Further preparation of interrogatories. 08/25/2017 0.10 98.50 Conference with Attorney A. Simon regarding revised interrogatories. 08/25/2017 0.20 197.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding document review platform. 08/29/2017 0.80 788.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Preparation for and participate in telephone conference with co-counsel regarding (1) Interrogatories, (2) Apple's Counter Proposal re Search Terms and (3) Proposals from DISCO and Meta-E. 08/29/2017 0.30 295.50 Communicate (other external) numerous telephone conferences with M. Masterson regarding Inventus pricing for document review. 08/29/2017 0.20 197.00 Retrieve Apple's first production of documents. 08/29/2017 0.20 197.00 Preparation of e-mail to co-counsel with link to Apple's production of documents.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 8 of 63 Page: 7 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw 08/29/2017 0.20 197.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding plaintiffs' first set of interrogatories. 08/29/2017 0.30 295.50 Review of draft interrogatories. 08/29/2017 0.10 98.50 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding potential experts. 08/30/2017 0.30 295.50 Review of memorandum analyzing defendant's responses to requests for production. 08/30/2017 0.20 197.00 Work on document review vendor pricing. 08/30/2017 0.20 197.00 Exchange e-mail with Inventus regarding pricing for document review. 08/30/2017 0.30 295.50 Review of e-mail from Attorney J. Manning regarding potential experts. 09/05/2017 0.40 394.00 Preparation for meet and confer call with Apple. 09/05/2017 1.50 1,477.50 Attend meet and confer call with Apple and co-counsel regarding Apple's responses to demands for production. 09/05/2017 0.30 295.50 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding meet and confer with Apple regarding its responses to demands for production. 09/05/2017 0.40 394.00 Preparation for and attend telephone conference with potential expert J. Hastings and co-counsel. 09/13/2017 0.20 197.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding discovery meet and confer. 09/13/2017 0.20 197.00 Review of and revise notes regarding Apple's responses to plaintiffs' demands for production. 09/18/2017 1.10 1,083.50 Revise search terms. 09/18/2017 0.10 98.50 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding status of meet and confer regarding source code and protective order issues. 09/18/2017 0.20 197.00 Review of memorandum regarding consumer complaints. 09/19/2017 1.00 985.00 Preparation for and telephone conference with co-counsel regarding case status, discovery, experts and search terms. 09/20/2017 0.30 295.50 Review of revisions to search terms. 09/20/2017 0.70 689.50 Revise document review coding sheet. 09/29/2017 0.70 689.50 Attend Relativity training. 09/29/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of date ranges for defendant's production. 10/03/2017 0.20 197.00 Review of e-mail from Attorney A. Curry regarding discovery status. 10/03/2017 0.20 197.00 Communicate (in firm) Conference with Attorney V. Glaze regarding document review protocol. 10/03/2017 0.10 98.50 Communicate (in firm) Preparation of e-mail to Attorney V. Glaze regarding relevant pleadings. 10/03/2017 1.10 1,083.50 Research fee petition and declarations in High-Tech case to determine billing rates for document reviewers. 10/03/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of e-mail from Attorney A. Curry to defense counsel regarding September 29, 2017 meet and confer. 10/03/2017 0.20 197.00 Review of e-mail traffic regarding Apple's storing of information relating to the reason for a return of an iPhone. 10/04/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of e-mail from Attorney J. Manning regarding coding panel for document review. 10/05/2017 0.20 197.00 Review of e-mail from Attorney A. Curry regarding source code protective order. 10/06/2017 0.20 197.00 Communicate (in firm) Conference with Attorney V. Glaze regarding document review protocol. 10/06/2017 0.20 197.00 Work on coding sheet for document review. 10/06/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of e-mail from Attorney K. Sheffield-Whitehead regarding discovery dispute. 10/06/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of e-mail from Attorney K. Sheffield- Whitehead regarding proposed date ranges for production. 10/06/2017 0.10 98.50 Exchange e-mail with Inventus regarding credentials for Attorney V. Glaze. 10/09/2017 0.20 197.00 Communicate (in firm) Conference with Attorney V. Glaze regarding document review protocol. 10/09/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of e-mail to defense counsel regarding discovery dispute relating to Apple's responses to interrogatories. 10/09/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of e-mail review to document reviewers regarding case materials and document review protocol. 10/10/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of e-mail from putative class member and exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding same. 10/10/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of e-mail from defense counsel regarding discovery issues. 10/10/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of cast of characters. 10/11/2017 1.50 1,477.50 Preparation for and attend telephone conference with co-counsel regarding case status. 10/11/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of e-mail exchange regarding discovery dispute and plaintiffs' request for production no. 20. 10/11/2017 0.80 788.00 Review of hot documents produced by Apple. 10/11/2017 1.00 985.00 Review of analysis regarding trade in value.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 9 of 63 Page: 8 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw 10/11/2017 0.20 197.00 Review of buyer's survey from Apple v. Samsung. 10/12/2017 0.30 295.50 Exchange e-mails with counsel regarding discovery dispute. 10/12/2017 0.10 98.50 Exchange e-mail with counsel regarding source code protective order. 10/13/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of e-mails from C. Castillo regarding document production. 10/13/2017 0.30 295.50 Download production number two from defense counsel and send to Inventus with instructions for batching to review team. 10/13/2017 0.20 197.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding Apple's document production number two. 10/13/2017 0.20 197.00 Exchange e-mail with team regarding batching documents to review team. 10/16/2017 0.40 394.00 Review of revised source code protective order. 10/16/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of e-mail from defense counsel regarding discovery dispute. 10/17/2017 0.20 197.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding case status. 10/17/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of Judge Cousins' standing order. 10/18/2017 0.40 394.00 Review of and revise draft letter brief regarding discovery dispute. 10/18/2017 0.30 295.50 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding case status. 10/18/2017 0.30 295.50 Review of draft stipulation regarding source code. 10/19/2017 0.10 98.50 Exchange e-mail with all counsel regarding source code protective order. 10/23/2017 0.20 197.00 Review of Apple's amended initial disclosures. 10/23/2017 0.20 197.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding timing of joint letter brief regarding discovery issues. 10/23/2017 0.20 197.00 Review of draft Joint Case Management Conference Statement. 10/24/2017 0.20 197.00 Review of Apple's portion of the joint letter regarding discover disputes. 10/25/2017 0.20 197.00 Review of revisions to draft Joint Case Management Statement. 10/25/2017 0.20 197.00 Review of revisions to joint letter regarding discovery dispute. 10/25/2017 0.50 492.50 Attend weekly call with co-counsel. 10/25/2017 0.30 295.50 Review of final version of Case Management Conference Statement. 10/25/2017 0.20 197.00 Work on Case Management Conference Statement. 10/31/2017 0.40 394.00 Preparation for meeting with co-counsel. 11/01/2017 4.10 4,038.50 Travel to San Francisco for attorney meeting. 11/01/2017 0.40 394.00 Review of e-mail and attachments from Attorney K. Whitehead regarding Apple's revisions to joint letter brief. 11/01/2017 3.60 3,546.00 Preparation for and attend conference with co-counsel regarding case strategy. 11/02/2017 4.50 4,432.50 Return travel to Los Angeles. 11/02/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of billing codes. 11/02/2017 0.20 197.00 Exchange e-mail with counsel regarding Apple's edits to joint letter brief. 11/02/2017 0.40 394.00 Review of Apple's sales data provided by plaintiffs' expert. 11/03/2017 0.20 197.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding Akamai subpoena. 11/03/2017 0.20 197.00 Exchange e-mail with all counsel regarding joint discovery letter brief. 11/03/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of order regarding discovery conference. 11/07/2017 0.10 98.50 Work on proposed order regarding discovery dispute. 11/08/2017 0.10 98.50 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding proposed order regarding discovery dispute. 11/09/2017 0.20 197.00 Review of proposed order regarding discovery dispute. 11/09/2017 0.50 492.50 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding proposed order regarding discovery dispute and upcoming assignments. 11/16/2017 0.60 591.00 Review of plaintiffs' draft responses to interrogatories and requests for production of documents. 11/16/2017 0.30 295.50 Communications with Attorney A. Simon regarding revisions to plaintiffs' draft responses to interrogatories and requests for production of documents. 11/16/2017 0.70 689.50 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding plaintiffs' discovery responses and case status. 11/16/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of e-mail from Attorney A. Simon regarding privacy objections. 11/17/2017 0.10 98.50 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding discovery conference. 11/17/2017 0.20 197.00 Review of revised letter brief regarding Apple's interrogatory responses. 11/21/2017 0.10 98.50 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding status of meet and confer regarding defendant's interrogatory responses. 11/21/2017 0.30 295.50 Process defendant's document production and transfer to Inventus for loading into document review platform. 11/29/2017 0.80 788.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Weekly telephone conference with co-counsel regarding case status. 12/01/2017 0.30 295.50 Download and transmit defendant's document production to co-counsel and Inventus. 12/05/2017 0.30 295.50 Revise 30(b)(6) notice.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 10 of 63 Page: 9 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw 12/06/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of e-mail to defense counsel regarding Apple's December 1, 2017 production. 12/06/2017 0.50 492.50 Communicate (other outside counsel) telephone conference with co-counsel regarding case status. 12/06/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of e-mail from co-counsel regarding Apple's production. 12/06/2017 0.20 197.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding Apple production. 12/06/2017 0.20 197.00 Review of emails regarding iTunes database spreadsheets. 12/06/2017 1.70 1,674.50 Review of iTunes database spreadsheets in order to evaluate possible consolidation of the data for analysis. 12/08/2017 0.20 197.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding meet and confer with Apple regarding discovery issues. 12/08/2017 0.20 197.00 Review of notes regarding meet and confer with Apple regarding discovery issues. 12/11/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of draft stipulation to extend case schedule. 12/11/2017 0.10 98.50 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding draft stipulation to extend case schedule. 12/12/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of draft Akamai subpoena. 12/12/2017 0.10 98.50 Emails with co-counsel regarding draft Akamai subpoena. 12/12/2017 0.20 197.00 Review of 30(b)(6) deposition notice. 12/12/2017 0.20 197.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding 30(b)(6) deposition notice. 12/12/2017 0.30 295.50 Review of emails and draft response e-mail to defense counsel regarding search terms. 12/18/2017 0.20 197.00 Review of revised search terms. 12/20/2017 0.70 689.50 Attend weekly call with co-counsel regarding case status. 12/20/2017 0.20 197.00 Emails regarding meet and confer regarding buyer surveys. 12/22/2017 0.60 591.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding case status and class certification strategy. 12/23/2017 0.30 295.50 Review of revised proposed search terms. 12/23/2017 0.10 98.50 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding search terms. 12/29/2017 0.10 98.50 Review of e-mail regarding meet and confer. 01/02/2018 1.00 1,050.00 Download and store emails from C. Grace's e-mail account for preservation. 01/02/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Manning regarding C. Grace's e-mail account. 01/03/2018 5.10 5,355.00 Work on deduplication of serial numbers produced by Apple by creating database. 01/04/2018 0.20 210.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding client emails for production. 01/04/2018 0.30 315.00 Telephone conference with D. Giambruno regarding spreadsheets produced by Apple. 01/04/2018 2.30 2,415.00 Work on creation of Microsoft Access database and importing Apple spreadsheets. 01/04/2018 0.20 210.00 Communicate with Attorney S. Jain regarding searching plaintiff's e-mail collection and searching. 01/04/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of e-mail to defense counsel regarding discovery dispute. 01/08/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of draft subpoena. 01/09/2018 0.40 420.00 Work on meet and confer issues relating to Apple's discovery responses. 01/09/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of draft interrogatories to Apple. 01/09/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of documents to be shared with expert. 01/10/2018 1.20 1,260.00 Preparation for and attend telephone conference with co-counsel regarding case status. 01/10/2018 0.20 210.00 Work on document review issues. 01/10/2018 0.50 525.00 Review of Apple's portion of joint letter brief. 01/11/2018 0.60 630.00 Communicate (other external) Communications with Inventus regarding collection of plaintiffs' ESI. 01/11/2018 0.20 210.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding collection of plaintiffs' ESI. 01/11/2018 0.50 525.00 Review of revisions to letter brief regarding discovery dispute with Apple's responses to written discovery. 01/11/2018 0.30 315.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding joint letter brief. 01/12/2018 0.60 630.00 Review of revisions to joint letter brief regarding Apple's discovery responses. 01/12/2018 0.30 315.00 E-mail traffic with defense counsel regarding discovery meet and confer. 01/17/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney V. Glaze regarding document review status. 01/17/2018 0.30 315.00 Supervise document review. 01/17/2018 0.90 945.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding case status. 01/17/2018 0.20 210.00 Telephone call from Attorney A. Simon regarding meet and confers regarding subpoenas. 01/17/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of subpoenas. 01/18/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of draft letter brief regarding Apple's responses to requests for production. 01/18/2018 0.70 735.00 Communications with Attorney A. Simon regarding motion for protective order.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 11 of 63 Page: 10 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw 01/18/2018 0.30 315.00 Conduct research regarding nationwide certification using California law. 01/18/2018 0.10 105.00 Preparation of e-mail to co-counsel regarding nationwide class action cases. 01/18/2018 0.50 525.00 Numerous emails with Attorney A. Simon regarding status of plaintiffs' subpoenas. 01/18/2018 0.30 315.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney S. Jain regarding production of plaintiffs' documents. 01/19/2018 2.60 2,730.00 Work on motion for protective order regarding subpoena to Verizon. 01/19/2018 0.60 630.00 Communicate (in firm) Numerous conferences with Attorney A. Simon regarding motion for protective order regarding Verizon subpoena. 01/19/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of and comment on joint letter brief regarding imaging plaintiffs' iPhones. 01/19/2018 1.70 1,785.00 Review of In Re: Batteries docket regarding subpoenas as they relate to the Verizon subpoena. 01/22/2018 0.40 420.00 Work on supplemental brief regarding discovery dispute. 01/22/2018 0.80 840.00 Work on motion for protective order. 01/22/2018 2.40 2,520.00 Research stored communications act and California law regarding disclosure of mobile phone data. 01/23/2018 0.60 630.00 Numerous communications with co-counsel regarding plaintiffs' subpoenas. 01/23/2018 0.70 735.00 Telephone conference with all co-counsel regarding subpoenas, motion to quash, and 30(b)(6) deposition. 01/23/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of Apple's supplemental letter brief regarding discovery dispute concerting plaintiffs' interrogatories. 01/23/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding Apple's supplemental letter brief. 01/23/2018 0.20 210.00 Telephone call from J. Hastings regarding plaintiffs' subpoenas. 01/23/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of Apple's Second Supplemental Responses to Interrogatories. 01/23/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with experts and co-counsel regarding data collection from third parties. 01/23/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of Apple's final version of the joint letter brief regarding imaging. 01/24/2018 0.20 210.00 Retrieve and upload Apple production to Inventus. 01/24/2018 1.00 1,050.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding case status, discovery conference, subpoenas and 30(b)(6) deposition. 01/24/2018 0.80 840.00 Review of In Re Qualcomm Antitrust Litigation decision regarding nationwide certification. 01/24/2018 1.60 1,680.00 Conduct research regarding nationwide class certification. 01/25/2018 0.30 315.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding class certification. 01/26/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of potential hot document and exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding same. 01/31/2018 1.20 1,260.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Attend weekly call with co-counsel regarding case status. 02/01/2018 0.30 315.00 Numerous conferences with Attorney A. Simon regarding status of subpoenas. 02/01/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of Verizon production. 02/01/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of order regarding joint discovery dispute. 02/01/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of e-mail and article regarding firmware. 02/01/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with Inventus regarding loading Apple production into document review platform. 02/01/2018 0.60 630.00 Review of draft deposition notices and second set of requests for production. 02/02/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of draft letter brief regarding Apple's response to requests for production. 02/02/2018 0.30 315.00 Communicate with PSW team regarding deposition preparation for Apple 30(b)(6). 02/05/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding class certification issues and discovery needed regarding same. 02/05/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of draft Case Management Conference Statement. 02/05/2018 0.10 105.00 Preparation of e-mail to Attorney V. Glaze and Attorney A. Simon regarding Case Management Conference Statement. 02/05/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of T-Mobile's objections and response to subpoena. 02/05/2018 0.10 105.00 E-mail regarding imaging plaintiffs' devices. 02/05/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of defendant's draft status report regarding discovery disputes. 02/07/2018 0.80 840.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel and experts regarding status. 02/08/2018 0.30 315.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding preparation for 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/08/2018 0.30 315.00 Numerous conferences with Attorney A. Simon and Attorney V. Glaze regarding deposition outline and document search for 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/08/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of draft deposition outline for 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/08/2018 0.30 315.00 Telephone conference with Attorney A. Simon regarding revisions to deposition outline for 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/08/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of Castillo Declaration (Dkt. No. 111) regarding documents related to value of Facetime. 02/08/2018 0.90 945.00 Review of exhibits regarding value of FaceTime.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 12 of 63 Page: 11 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw 02/09/2018 3.10 3,255.00 Work on deposition outline for 30(b)(6) deposition of Apple. 02/09/2018 0.30 315.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/12/2018 6.50 6,825.00 Review and revise deposition outline for Apple 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/13/2018 0.10 105.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/13/2018 3.70 3,885.00 Travel to San Francisco for Apple 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/13/2018 0.40 420.00 Conference with co-counsel regarding preparation for Apple 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/13/2018 2.50 2,625.00 Preparation for Apple 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/14/2018 0.80 840.00 Preparation of exhibits for deposition. 02/14/2018 5.90 6,195.00 Take Apple 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/14/2018 4.10 4,305.00 Return travel to Los Angeles from Apple 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/15/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of summary of 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/15/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/15/2018 0.30 315.00 Exchange e-mail with J. Hastings and Attorney A. Simon regarding Verizon production. 02/15/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding Verizon production. 02/16/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of draft Case Management Conference Statement. 02/16/2018 0.10 105.00 Preparation of e-mail to co-counsel regarding revisions to draft Case Management Conference Statement. 02/16/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/16/2018 0.50 525.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding Case Management Conference Statement and 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/16/2018 0.20 210.00 Telephone conference with Attorney S. Jain regarding revisions to Case Management Conference Statement. 02/16/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of revised Case Management Conference Statement. 02/16/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of e-mail to Attorney A. Pilmer re Case Management Conference Statement. 02/16/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of e-mail regarding Apple production. 02/16/2018 0.30 315.00 Download and transfer Apple production to Inventus for loading. 02/16/2018 0.10 105.00 Preparation of e-mail to co-counsel regarding Apple production. 02/20/2018 1.10 1,155.00 Review of Apple's Second Supplemental Responses and Objections to Plaintiffs' Interrogatories, Set 1; Apple's Third Supplemental Responses and Objections to Plaintiffs' Interrogatories, Set 1; and, Apple's Responses and Objections to Plaintiffs' Interrogatories, Set Two. 02/20/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with Inventus regarding Apple production. 02/21/2018 1.20 1,260.00 Attend weekly call with co-counsel and experts regarding case status, class certification and document review. 02/21/2018 0.40 420.00 Review of Apple's revisions to Case Management Conference Statement. 02/21/2018 0.40 420.00 Revise Case Management Conference Statement. 02/21/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of Apple's objections to 30(b)(6) deposition notice and 30(b)(1) deposition notice. 02/21/2018 0.20 210.00 Conference with Attorney V. Glaze regarding status of document review. 02/22/2018 2.20 2,310.00 Analyze document review status and develop plan to prioritize documents for review. 02/22/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of production from Sprint. 02/23/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of Order Amending Case Schedule. 02/23/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding Order Amending Case Schedule. 02/26/2018 0.10 105.00 Communicate (in firm) Conference with Attorney A. Simon regarding subpoena status. 02/28/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of document review report. 02/28/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney V. Glaze regarding document status. 02/28/2018 1.10 1,155.00 Weekly telephone conference with co-counsel regarding case status. 02/28/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of draft responses to defendant's interrogatories and requests for admissions in order to discuss on weekly call. 03/01/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding responses to requests for admissions. 03/02/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of draft insert regarding Verizon data. 03/02/2018 0.10 105.00 E-mail traffic with defense counsel regarding depositions of Apple. 03/05/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of revisions to draft responses to requests for admissions and interrogatories. 03/05/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding revisions to draft responses to requests for admissions and interrogatories. 03/07/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of document review status report. 03/07/2018 0.80 840.00 Attend weekly call with co-counsel regarding case status. 03/14/2018 1.00 1,050.00 Call with co-counsel regarding case status. 03/15/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of letter brief filed by Apple regarding inspection of plaintiffs' devices. 03/16/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of Amazon's objections to subpoena. 03/19/2018 0.40 420.00 Review of Apple's portion of joint letter brief relating to Apple's RFP No. 1 and Interrogatory Nos. 1 and 4.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 13 of 63 Page: 12 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw 03/19/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of memorandum regarding meet and confer regarding outstanding discovery issues. 03/20/2018 0.30 315.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding case status and class certification. 03/21/2018 1.30 1,365.00 Preparation for and attend weekly call with co-counsel regarding case status. 03/21/2018 0.20 210.00 Telephone conference with Attorney A. Simon regarding subpoena status. 03/21/2018 0.50 525.00 Telephone call to Attorney A. Chang regarding potential plaintiffs. 03/21/2018 0.10 105.00 Preparation of e-mail to Attorney A. Chang regarding potential plaintiffs. 03/21/2018 0.20 210.00 Telephone call to Attorney J. Manning regarding potential plaintiffs. 03/22/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of e-mail from Attorney D. Tejtel regarding certificate expiration. 03/22/2018 1.30 1,365.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding certificate expiration. 03/22/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of client's Facetime logs. 03/22/2018 0.10 105.00 Work on plaintiffs' request for admissions responses. 03/22/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of defendant's revisions to the joint letter brief. 03/22/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with all counsel regarding joint letter brief. 03/26/2018 0.20 210.00 Work on letter brief regarding facetime logs and interrogatories 1 and 4. 03/26/2018 0.30 315.00 Work on letter brief regarding Apple's ESI (text messages) and 30(b)(6) and individual depositions. 03/26/2018 0.30 315.00 Conference with Attorney A. Simon regarding Brightstar subpoena. 03/28/2018 0.20 210.00 Telephone conference with J. Manning regarding potential plaintiff. 03/28/2018 1.80 1,890.00 Preparation for and attend weekly strategy call with co-counsel. 03/28/2018 0.20 210.00 Conference with Attorney V. Glaze regarding hot documents for class certification brief. 03/29/2018 0.30 315.00 Work on second set of plaintiffs' requests for admissions. 03/29/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding plaintiffs' second set of requests for admissions. 04/02/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of proposed questions from J. Hastings to Best Buy. 04/02/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of revised search terms. 04/03/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of order granting motion to seal. 04/05/2018 0.30 315.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding proposal regarding Apple's production of text and instant messaging data. 04/05/2018 0.20 210.00 Work on proposal regarding Apple's production of text and instant messaging data. 04/05/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding documents to be filed with class certification brief. 04/05/2018 0.30 315.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding compromise proposal regarding 3/27 joint letter brief dispute. 04/06/2018 0.80 840.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Strategy call with co-counsel regarding class certification and case status. 04/06/2018 1.70 1,785.00 Work on motion for class certification. 04/06/2018 0.50 525.00 Numerous conferences with co-counsel regarding revisions to motion for class certification. 04/06/2018 0.30 315.00 Prepare correspondence to co-counsel regarding revisions to motion for class certification. 04/06/2018 0.30 315.00 Draft letter to Attorney A. Pilmer regarding 30(b)(6) deposition. 04/06/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of proposed search terms. 04/06/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of draft e-mail to defense counsel regarding open discovery issues. 04/10/2018 0.70 735.00 Review/analyze draft report of J. Hastings. 04/11/2018 1.20 1,260.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel and experts regarding class certification. 04/16/2018 1.10 1,155.00 Attend weekly call with co-counsel. 04/16/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of order regarding ESI dispute. 04/19/2018 0.60 630.00 Telephone conference with experts regarding class certification declaration. 04/19/2018 0.40 420.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding class certification. 04/19/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with A. Simon regarding password for ecoAtm production. 04/19/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney A. Simon regarding Best Buy questions. 04/19/2018 0.10 105.00 Preparation of e-mail to Attorney A. Simon regarding declaration in support of class certification. 04/19/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of e-mail from Best Buy concerning responses to questions regarding production. 04/19/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of Apple's letter brief regarding plaintiffs' interrogatory responses. 04/19/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding Apple's letter brief regarding plaintiffs' interrogatory responses. 04/20/2018 0.10 105.00 Conference with Attorney V. Glaze regarding running searches for documents relating to trade in value of class devices. 04/20/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding running searches for documents relating

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 14 of 63 Page: 13 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw to trade in value of class devices. 04/20/2018 0.50 525.00 Review of Apple's notice of subpoena on Akamai Technologies, Inc. 04/23/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of ecoATM production. 04/23/2018 0.10 105.00 Forward ecoATM production to plaintiffs' team and experts. 04/24/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of draft letter to defense counsel regarding 30(b)(6) deposition. 04/24/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of draft letter to defense counsel regarding Apple document production. 04/25/2018 3.00 3,150.00 Work on class certification brief. 04/25/2018 0.20 210.00 Preparation of e-mail to defense counsel regarding ecoATM production. 04/26/2018 0.50 525.00 Telephone conference with experts and co-counsel regarding expert report. 04/26/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of Best Buy's description of data produced per subpoena. 04/26/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding Best Buy's description of data produced. 04/26/2018 1.60 1,680.00 Conduct research regarding processor in iPhone 4 and 4s versus 5 and 5s. 04/26/2018 3.80 3,990.00 Further preparation of class certification brief. 04/26/2018 0.20 210.00 Telephone call to Attorney A. Curry regarding iPhone processors. 04/26/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of draft supplemental response to third set of interrogatories. 04/26/2018 0.30 315.00 Revise Simon declaration in support of motion for class certification. 04/27/2018 0.40 420.00 Review of revisions to class certification brief. 04/27/2018 1.50 1,575.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding class certification brief. 04/27/2018 0.10 105.00 Revise A. Simon declaration in support of class certification. 04/27/2018 1.30 1,365.00 Work on J. Hastings Report. 04/27/2018 1.80 1,890.00 Conduct research regarding iPhone performance issues to be included in class certification motion. 04/30/2018 0.80 840.00 Work on Hastings report. 04/30/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding choice of law provision in iOS agreements. 04/30/2018 0.80 840.00 Review of materials regarding choice of law provisions and court record regarding same. 04/30/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of expert costs and litigation fund accounting. 04/30/2018 0.10 105.00 Preparation of e-mail to Attorney A. Steyer and Attorney J. Manning regarding expert costs. 04/30/2018 0.40 420.00 Exchange e-mail with expert and co-counsel regarding ecoATM data and follow up questions. 04/30/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of Apple's First Supplemental Responses to Plaintiffs Second Set of Interrogatories. 04/30/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of Apple's Responses and Objections to 3rd Set of Interrogatories. 04/30/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of Apple's Responses and Objections to 2nd Set of RFAs. 05/01/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel and SDDF regarding data from plaintiffs' mobile devices. 05/01/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of order regarding motion to seal. 05/01/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding damages model for class certification. 05/01/2018 1.60 1,680.00 Review of draft Hastings Report. 05/01/2018 0.30 315.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney W. McCarty regarding documents produced by Apple concerning performance reports. 05/01/2018 0.50 525.00 Locate and transmit performance reports produced by Apple to co-counsel. 05/01/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of Potter deposition notice. 05/01/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding draft letter regarding ESI issues. 05/01/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of draft letter to Apple regarding ESI. 05/01/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail regarding page limits of class certification briefing. 05/01/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney A. Pilmer regarding Apple production issues. 05/01/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of and revise draft Attorney A. Simon declaration regarding subpoenas. 05/01/2018 0.30 315.00 Telephone call from Attorney J. Manning regarding class certification. 05/02/2018 0.60 630.00 Telephone conference with experts and co-counsel regarding class certification report. 05/02/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of e-mail from B. Barnes regarding production of plaintiffs' data. 05/02/2018 0.40 420.00 Review of documents identified in Apple's first supplemental responses and objections to plaintiffs' interrogatories, set two as they relate to class certification. 05/02/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney V. Glaze regarding documents supporting class certification. 05/02/2018 0.50 525.00 Review of Apple's responses to second and third set of interrogatories and second set of requests for admissions as they relate to class certification. 05/02/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding Apple's discovery responses as they relate to class certification. 05/02/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney A. Simon regarding ecoATM subpoena. 05/03/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with R. Barnes regarding objection to the production of plaintiffs'

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 15 of 63 Page: 14 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw data retrieved from mobile devices. 05/03/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney W. McCarty regarding performance testing documents produced by Apple. 05/03/2018 1.30 1,365.00 Preparation of Warshaw declaration in support of motion for final approval. 05/03/2018 2.60 2,730.00 Preparation of motion for class certification. 05/03/2018 0.70 735.00 Numerous emails with co-counsel regarding class certification brief. 05/03/2018 1.60 1,680.00 Conduct research regarding iOS and iPhone release dates and comparison of 32 bit versus 64 bit processors. 05/04/2018 2.40 2,520.00 Complete preparation of Hastings Report. 05/04/2018 1.50 1,575.00 Complete preparation of motion for class certification. 05/04/2018 0.30 315.00 Review correspondence from Attorney A. Pilmer regarding 30(b)(6) witness. 05/04/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of notices of appearance of Durie Tangri as counsel for Apple. 05/04/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding Durie Tangri. 05/07/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney A. Simon regarding Assurant subpoena. 05/09/2018 1.10 1,155.00 Attend weekly call with co-counsel. 05/09/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Manning regarding deposition of J. Hastings. 05/10/2018 0.30 315.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding draft email to R. Barnes regarding issues with production of plaintiffs' data. 05/11/2018 0.30 315.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding Plaintiffs' Amended Responses to Apple's 2nd Set of Interrogatories. 05/11/2018 0.40 420.00 Review of draft versions of Plaintiffs' Amended Responses to Apple's 2nd Set of Interrogatories. 05/14/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of Apple's portion of the letter brief regarding Potter's redactions and blog posts. 05/14/2018 0.30 315.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel and defense counsel regarding data imaged from plaintiffs' phones. 05/15/2018 0.40 420.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding data production protocol relating to plaintiffs' mobile devices. 05/15/2018 0.10 105.00 Review correspondence from Attorney E. Rejali regarding production of plaintiffs' data to Apple. 05/15/2018 0.20 210.00 Telephone conference with Attorney A. Steyer regarding expert's invoices. 05/15/2018 0.10 105.00 Preparation of e-mail to Attorney A. Curry regarding assessment payment. 05/15/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of emails from SDDF regarding production of raw data over plaintiffs' objections. 05/15/2018 0.50 525.00 Communications with co-counsel regarding motion for protective order regarding SDDF production. 05/15/2018 0.50 525.00 Review of file with Attorney A. Simon in order to prepare motion for protective order regarding SDDF production of plaintiffs' data. 05/15/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding proposal for handling SDDF production. 05/16/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of e-mail from Attorney A. Neglia regarding clawback and production of documents. 05/16/2018 0.30 315.00 Communications with Attorney V. Glaze regarding clawback and Potter documents. 05/16/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of draft motion for protective order. 05/18/2018 0.40 420.00 Review of multiple revisions to protective order. 05/18/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of objection to Wood deposition notice. 05/18/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Manning regarding Grace deposition objections. 05/18/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of letter regarding search terms. 05/18/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding search term letter. 05/18/2018 0.10 105.00 Review correspondence from Attorney T. Greene regarding ESI production. 05/18/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding ESI search terms. 05/21/2018 4.20 4,410.00 Travel to San Francisco for attorney meeting with co-counsel. 05/21/2018 5.80 6,090.00 Conference with co-counsel regarding case status and discovery. 05/22/2018 3.60 3,780.00 Return travel to Los Angeles. 05/23/2018 0.20 210.00 Process Akami productions and transmit to Inventus. 05/23/2018 0.30 315.00 Emails with all counsel and B. Barnes regarding production of data from plaintiffs' iPhones. 05/23/2018 0.20 210.00 Emails regarding meet and confer with defense counsel regarding search terms, collection and ESI. 05/23/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of e-mail from co-counsel regarding trespass to chattel and case law regarding same. 05/23/2018 0.40 420.00 Review of case law regarding trespass to chattle. 05/23/2018 2.10 2,205.00 Review of D. Hale deposition rough transcript. 05/23/2018 0.30 315.00 Conduct research regarding Akami contract and fixed fee issue. 05/23/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Manning regarding Akami contract.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 16 of 63 Page: 15 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw 05/24/2018 0.30 315.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding clawback and confirmation that documents have been purged. 05/24/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding joint letter brief regarding interrogatories. 05/24/2018 0.20 210.00 Work on joint letter brief regarding interrogatories. 05/24/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of e-mail from Attorney J. Lerner regarding production of data from Potter's devices and scheduling third party depositions. 05/25/2018 0.30 315.00 Exchange e-mail with counsel regarding third party depositions. 05/25/2018 0.70 735.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding Brightstar deposition. 05/25/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of draft e-mail to Attorney E. Novikov regarding Brightstar deposition. 05/25/2018 0.30 315.00 Work on letter brief regarding Apple's modification of search terms. 05/25/2018 0.20 210.00 Conference with Attorney V. Glaze regarding Akami contract and how it can be used in reply to class certification. 05/25/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of Akami contract regarding tiered usage. 05/25/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding Brightstar production. 05/29/2018 0.80 840.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel and J. Hastings regarding Brightstar deposition. 05/29/2018 2.20 2,310.00 Preparation for Potter deposition by reviewing discovery responses and class certification declaration. 05/29/2018 1.80 1,890.00 Review of C. Grace deposition transcript to prepare for Potter deposition. 05/29/2018 2.40 2,520.00 Travel to San Diego for Potter deposition. 05/30/2018 1.20 1,260.00 Preparation for deposition with Attorney J. Manning and K. Potter. 05/30/2018 9.60 10,080.00 Attend deposition of K. Potter. 05/30/2018 2.80 2,940.00 Return travel to Los Angeles from K. Potter deposition in San Diego. 06/01/2018 0.30 315.00 Draft/revise letter brief regarding search terms. 06/01/2018 0.20 210.00 Communicate (other outside counsel)exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding search term letter brief. 06/04/2018 0.70 735.00 Preparation for and telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding Hastings deposition preparation. 06/06/2018 7.20 7,560.00 Plan and prepare for deposition of J. Hastings. 06/07/2018 4.10 4,305.00 Travel to San Francisco for deposition of J. Hastings. 06/07/2018 4.80 5,040.00 Conference with co-counsel and J. Hastings regarding deposition preparation. 06/07/2018 2.30 2,415.00 Further review of materials to prepare for deposition of J. Hastings. 06/08/2018 1.00 1,050.00 Conference with J. Hastings and Attorney J. Manning to prepare for deposition of J. Hastings. 06/08/2018 9.00 9,450.00 Defend deposition of J. Hastings. 06/08/2018 4.60 4,830.00 Return travel to Los Angeles from deposition of J. Hastings. 06/15/2018 0.60 630.00 Work on Tejtel declaration and proposed order regarding joint discovery brief. 06/18/2018 1.00 1,050.00 Initial review of defendant's opposition to motion for class certification. 06/18/2018 0.90 945.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding opposition to motion for class certification. 06/19/2018 6.20 6,510.00 Review of defendant's opposition to class certification and related filings. 06/19/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of revised joint letter brief regarding second set of RFPs and related file materials. 06/19/2018 0.30 315.00 Work on ESI dispute. 06/20/2018 1.20 1,260.00 Preparation for call with J. Hastings regarding Trexler report. 06/20/2018 1.00 1,050.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel and J. Hastings regarding Trexler report. 06/20/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney S. Macrae regarding Theranos decision. 06/20/2018 0.70 735.00 Review of Theranos decision as it relates to class certification reply. 06/20/2018 0.70 735.00 Review of B. Plott deposition rough transcript. 06/20/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney A. Simon regarding Assurant subpoena. 06/22/2018 0.30 315.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding scheduling of depositions. 06/25/2018 0.40 420.00 Numerous telephone conferences with Attorney A. Simon regarding class certification reply brief. 06/25/2018 1.10 1,155.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding class certification reply brief. 06/25/2018 2.60 2,730.00 Conduct research regarding choice of law as it relates to reply class certification brief. 06/25/2018 0.40 420.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding class certification reply. 06/25/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of email and attached Apple document from A. Curry regarding J. Wood deposition. 06/26/2018 0.40 420.00 Work on choice of law section of class certification reply brief. 06/26/2018 0.50 525.00 Review of audio recording of hearing regarding ESI. 06/26/2018 0.10 105.00 Preparation of e-mail to co-counsel regarding ESI hearing. 06/27/2018 0.80 840.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel and J. Hastings regarding class certification reply. 06/27/2018 0.30 315.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding class certification reply and

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 17 of 63 Page: 16 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw discovery. 06/28/2018 0.60 630.00 Communicate (in firm) Numerous conferences with PSW team regarding choice of law section for reply brief. 06/28/2018 0.50 525.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding choice of law section in reply to class certification brief. 06/28/2018 0.40 420.00 Review of Apple's Terms of Service as it relates to choice of law. 06/28/2018 1.80 1,890.00 Work on class certification reply brief. 06/29/2018 1.20 1,260.00 Work on class certification reply brief. 07/09/2018 0.50 525.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding class certification reply, motion to strike expert declaration and Daubert motion. 07/09/2018 0.40 420.00 Review of draft motion to strike Rubin declaration. 07/09/2018 1.30 1,365.00 Review of and revise class certification reply brief. 07/09/2018 0.30 315.00 Communicate (in firm) Exchange e-mail with PSW team regarding choice of law section of class certification reply. 07/09/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of and revise Joint Case Management Conference Statement. 07/09/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of draft Daubert motion to exclude Trexler report. 07/10/2018 0.30 315.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding Trexler deposition and proposed line of questioning regarding Dr. Dutta; including preparing proposed questions. 07/10/2018 0.40 420.00 Review of multiple revisions to Motion to Strike Rubin. 07/10/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding Motion to Strike Rubin. 07/10/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding additional requests for production. 07/10/2018 0.20 210.00 Revise draft requests for production. 07/11/2018 0.70 735.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding class certification reply brief and related papers. 07/11/2018 0.50 525.00 Work on Case Management Conference Statement. 07/11/2018 1.80 1,890.00 Revise Hastings Report in support of class certification reply. 07/11/2018 2.10 2,205.00 Work on reply to class certification. 07/11/2018 0.70 735.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding motion to strike Rubin Declaration. 07/11/2018 0.60 630.00 Review of cite check and bluebook revisions to class certification reply. 07/12/2018 0.70 735.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding class certification reply. 07/12/2018 1.70 1,785.00 Further preparation of Hastings Report in support of class certification reply. 07/12/2018 0.30 315.00 E-mail traffic with court clerk and co-counsel regarding hearing date. 07/13/2018 2.30 2,415.00 Work on class certification reply brief. 07/13/2018 1.30 1,365.00 Work on motion to strike Rubin declaration. 07/13/2018 0.20 210.00 Work on motion to shorten time hearing on motion to strike Rubin declaration. 07/13/2018 2.60 2,730.00 Work on Hastings Report. 07/13/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding defendant's plan to amend Rubin declaration. 07/13/2018 0.50 525.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding class certification reply. 07/17/2018 0.10 105.00 Conference with co-counsel regarding questions for J. Hastings. 07/17/2018 0.10 105.00 E-mail with J. Hastings regarding Assurant data. 07/17/2018 0.80 840.00 Review of and revise motion to strike Rubin declaration. 07/23/2018 1.10 1,155.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding upcoming projects and deadlines. 07/23/2018 0.20 210.00 Telephone call from Attorney J. Manning regarding expert deadlines and case status. 08/01/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of draft joint letter brief regarding second set of RFPs. 08/01/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of e-mail to defense counsel regarding RFPs 17-19. 08/02/2018 1.20 1,260.00 Review of Wang deposition transcript. 08/02/2018 0.30 315.00 Conference with Attorney A. Simon regarding case status. 08/03/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of litigation fund accounting. 08/03/2018 0.70 735.00 Review of drafts of interrogatories and requests for admissions to Apple. 08/03/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of draft joint letter brief regarding plaintiffs' second request for production. 08/03/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding draft joint letter brief regarding plaintiffs' second request for production. 08/06/2018 0.30 315.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding stipulation regarding authenticity. 08/06/2018 0.40 420.00 Numerous conferences with Attorney A. Simon regarding authenticity requests for admissions. 08/06/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of e-mail from defense counsel regarding stipulation regarding authenticity. 08/07/2018 0.60 630.00 Review of and revise requests for admissions, interrogatories and requests for production. 08/07/2018 0.40 420.00 Numerous telephone conferences with Attorney A. Simon regarding admissibility requests for admissions. 08/07/2018 0.80 840.00 Conduct research regarding admissibility requests for admissions. 08/07/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding admissibility requests for admissions. 08/07/2018 0.30 315.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding potential mediators.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 18 of 63 Page: 17 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw 08/07/2018 0.30 315.00 Work on joint letter brief regarding Apple's refusal to produce deposition witnesses. 08/08/2018 0.90 945.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) telephone conference with co-counsel regarding case status and assignments. 08/08/2018 0.30 315.00 Telephone call from Attorney A. Steyer regarding case status and litigation fund. 08/08/2018 0.30 315.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding proposed mediators. 08/09/2018 0.50 525.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning and J. Hastings regarding expert report. 08/09/2018 0.30 315.00 Telephone conference with counsel regarding potential mediators. 08/10/2018 0.20 210.00 Receive and process document production 18. 08/10/2018 0.50 525.00 Exchange e-mail with counsel regarding discovery issues. 08/13/2018 0.40 420.00 Review of draft responses to interrogatories 10 and 11 and requests for admissions 9 and 10. 08/13/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of revisions to draft responses to interrogatories 10 and 11 and requests for admissions 9 and 10. 08/13/2018 0.50 525.00 Review of class certification order in the In Regarding Arris Cable Modem matter. 08/14/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of final version of discovery letter brief. 08/14/2018 0.30 315.00 Exchange e-mail with J. Mottek and co-counsel regarding class notice. 08/14/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of e-mail from Attorney W. McCarty to Attorney T. Greene regarding RFPs 33-56. 08/14/2018 0.10 105.00 E-mail regarding interrogatory no. 8. 08/14/2018 0.10 105.00 E-mail regarding joint letter brief concerning plaintiffs' second set of requests for production. 08/14/2018 1.80 1,890.00 Work on draft report of Dr. Jones. 08/15/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of discovery letter brief regarding depositions. 08/15/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney A. Simon regarding notice of filing recent decision. Review of local rule. 08/15/2018 0.10 105.00 Preparation of e-mail to Attorney J. Manning regarding recent decision local rule. 08/15/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of e-mail from Attorney T. Greene regarding requests for production nos. 33-56. 08/15/2018 0.80 840.00 Review of revisions to Jones Report. 08/16/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of joint discovery letter brief regarding certificate. 08/16/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding Best Buy subpoena. 08/16/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel and defense counsel regarding model information. 08/16/2018 0.30 315.00 Exchange e-mail with all counsel regarding discovery letter brief. 08/16/2018 0.20 210.00 Receive and process production 19. 08/16/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with J. Hastings regarding status of report. 08/17/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of Apple's joint letter brief regarding plaintiffs' responses to interrogatories 3 and 8. 08/18/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of e-mail to opposing counsel regarding ESI meet and confer, including attached search term order and proposal regarding requests for production. 08/20/2018 0.60 630.00 Telephone conference with J. Hastings and Attorney J. Manning regarding expert report. 08/20/2018 0.30 315.00 Communications with Attorney A. Simon and Attorney J. Manning regarding Best Buy data. 08/23/2018 1.10 1,155.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding status of case and assignments. 08/23/2018 0.20 210.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding Hastings report. 08/23/2018 2.20 2,310.00 Review of and comment on drafting Hastings report. 08/23/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding revisions to Hastings report. 08/23/2018 0.10 105.00 Receive and process Apple production for ingestion into document review platform. 08/23/2018 0.30 315.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding Apple's production and number of Phones identified. 08/23/2018 2.10 2,205.00 Review of previously produced spreadsheets to identify number of iPhones in class and to prepare e-mail to Apple regarding latest production. 08/23/2018 0.20 210.00 Process Assurant production. 08/23/2018 0.20 210.00 Transfer Assurant production to J. Hastings. 08/24/2018 2.20 2,310.00 Review of revised Hastings report. 08/27/2018 1.80 1,890.00 Preparation for and telephone conference with J. Hastings regarding report. 09/04/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding Apple's production. 09/04/2018 0.10 105.00 Preparation of e-mail to Attorney J. Lerner regarding potential mediators. 09/04/2018 0.40 420.00 Review of responses to Apple's Fifth Set of Rogs and Third Set of RFAs. 09/05/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of e-mail from Attorney J. Lerner regarding potential mediator. 09/05/2018 0.20 210.00 Communicate (in firm) exchange e-mail with Attorney C. Pearson, Attorney B. Simon and Attorney M. Weiner regarding Apple's proposed mediator. 09/05/2018 1.20 1,260.00 Preparation for and attend weekly strategy call.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 19 of 63 Page: 18 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw 09/05/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of stipulation regarding production of class member identifying information. 09/05/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Manning regarding Apple's proposed mediator. 09/05/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of revised responses to Apple's third set of RFAs and fifth set of interrogatories. 09/05/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of litigation fund accounting and payables in order to calculate further assessments. 09/06/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with mediator D. Rotman's office regarding prior experience and setting up call. 09/06/2018 0.10 105.00 Process Apple production number 22 for uploading into document review platform. 09/06/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of emails from Attorney W. McCarty regarding hot documents from Apple production 22. 09/07/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of Apple's supplemental response to interrogatory 13. 09/07/2018 0.30 315.00 Telephone conference with K. Kukla regarding mediator D. Rotman's experience. 09/07/2018 0.20 210.00 Process Apple production 23 for loading to document review platform. 09/07/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with counsel class member contact information. 09/07/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of draft letter brief regarding class member contact information. 09/07/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of Apple's letter brief regarding deposition of plaintiffs' experts. 09/07/2018 0.30 315.00 Work on Plaintiffs' portion of Apple's letter brief regarding deposition of plaintiffs' experts. 09/11/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding mediation and discovery issues in advance of weekly calls. 09/11/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Lerner regarding potential mediator. 09/11/2018 0.30 315.00 Communications with co-counsel regarding Apple's proposed mediator. 09/12/2018 0.30 315.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding potential mediators. 09/12/2018 1.20 1,260.00 Preparation for and attend weekly call with co-counsel. 09/12/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Lerner regarding potential mediators. 09/13/2018 1.80 1,890.00 Review of J. Vidrine deposition transcript. 09/13/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding mediation. 09/13/2018 0.10 105.00 Preparation of e-mail to Attorney J. Lerner re mediation. 09/13/2018 1.70 1,785.00 Review of D. Calbeck deposition transcript. 09/13/2018 0.20 210.00 Work on letter brief regarding RFAs 36-42. 09/14/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of revised letter brief regarding authenticity and RFAs 36-42. 09/14/2018 0.40 420.00 Review of multiple letter brief drafts regarding device imaging. 09/14/2018 0.20 210.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding device imaging letter brief. 09/17/2018 0.10 105.00 Telephone call from Attorney J. Manning regarding Hastings deposition. 09/17/2018 0.70 735.00 Preparation for and telephone conference with J. Hastings regarding deposition preparation. 09/17/2018 0.70 735.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding Hastings deposition preparation and strategy. 09/17/2018 0.70 735.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding case status and Hastings deposition. 09/17/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding preparing for and staffing deposition J. Hastings deposition. 09/17/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with J. Hastings and co-counsel regarding deposition preparation. 09/17/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Lerner regarding mediation. 09/17/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding mediation logistics. 09/17/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of revised letter brief imaging of plaintiffs' devices. 09/17/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of order on discovery briefs (Dkt. No. 267). 09/17/2018 0.40 420.00 Review of order regarding administrative motion to seal. 09/17/2018 0.30 315.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding case status and staffing. 09/17/2018 0.70 735.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding Hastings deposition preparation. 09/18/2018 0.20 210.00 Review letter brief filed by Defendant Apple Inc. 09/18/2018 0.10 105.00 Review Order on discovery briefs. 09/18/2018 1.20 1,260.00 Review of class certification order. 09/18/2018 2.50 2,625.00 Preparation for telephone conference with J. Hastings regarding deposition preparation. 09/18/2018 0.40 420.00 Telephone conference with J. Hastings regarding deposition preparation. 09/18/2018 0.90 945.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding class certification order. 09/18/2018 0.10 105.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding class certification order and how to handle nationwide claims. 09/20/2018 0.30 315.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding mediation and class certification. 09/20/2018 0.50 525.00 Telephone conference with J. Cahill regarding mediation and tolling agreement.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 20 of 63 Page: 19 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw 09/20/2018 1.80 1,890.00 Review of expert report of N. Malhorta. 09/20/2018 1.60 1,680.00 Review of expert report of A. Rubin. 09/20/2018 0.30 315.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding J. Hastings deposition. 09/21/2018 0.10 105.00 Review Notice of Deposition of Apple's Expert Neil Malhotra. 09/21/2018 0.10 105.00 Review Subpoena to Testify at a Deposition in a Civil Action to Neil Malhotra. 09/21/2018 1.50 1,575.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding class certification, settlement and statue of limitations issues. 09/21/2018 2.60 2,730.00 Conduct research regarding motion for reconsideration and Rule 23(f) appeal. 09/21/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Manning regarding requests for proposals from claims administration companies. 09/21/2018 0.10 105.00 Preparation of draft e-mail template to claims administrators regarding request for proposal. 09/22/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding request for proposal for claims administration. 09/23/2018 0.20 210.00 Preparation of e-mails to Rust and JND regarding requests for proposal. 09/23/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with J. Mottek regarding request for proposal. 09/24/2018 1.00 1,050.00 Preparation for and telephone conference with M. Potter of JND regarding request for proposal for claims administration. 09/24/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of order granting renewed request to file under seal. 09/24/2018 1.20 1,260.00 Conduct research regarding tolling the deadline to bring a Rule 23(f) appeal. 09/24/2018 0.70 735.00 Review of Lambert v. Nutraceutical opinion regarding motion for reconsideration. 09/24/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with J. Cahill regarding mediation. 09/24/2018 0.20 210.00 Telephone conference with Attorney A. Curry regarding motion for reconsideration of class certification order. 09/24/2018 0.10 105.00 Preparation of e-mail to co-counsel regarding motion for reconsideration of class certification order. 09/25/2018 1.40 1,470.00 Review of deposition transcript of M. Jones. 09/25/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of defendant's objections to N. Malhotra subpoena. 09/25/2018 0.30 315.00 Exchange e-mail with E. Bishop regarding request for proposal concerning claims administration. 09/25/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with J. Mottek regarding request for proposal concerning claims administration. 09/25/2018 0.80 840.00 Communications with co-counsel regarding motion for reconsideration. 09/25/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding tolling the statute of limitations. 09/26/2018 0.30 315.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Lerner regarding mediation. 09/26/2018 1.40 1,470.00 Attend weekly call with co-counsel. 09/26/2018 1.10 1,155.00 Conduct research regarding discovery rule. 09/26/2018 0.20 210.00 Telephone conference with Attorney A. Simon regarding second amended complaint. 09/27/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Lerner regarding mediation dates and stipulation to extend mediation start date. 09/27/2018 0.20 210.00 Revise stipulation to extend mediation start date. 09/27/2018 0.70 735.00 Review of and revise draft mediation brief. 09/27/2018 0.80 840.00 Numerous communications with co-counsel regarding mediation dates. 09/27/2018 0.30 315.00 Conference with Attorney A. Simon regarding research needed for Second Amended Complaint. 09/28/2018 3.60 3,780.00 Work on analysis of nationwide survey of trespass to chattel law. 09/28/2018 0.20 210.00 Review of ecoATM subpoena. 09/28/2018 0.30 315.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding ecoATM subpoena. 09/28/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of memorandum analyzing (i) statute of limitations for trespass to chattels, (ii) discovery rule and (iii) cross-jurisdictional tolling laws. 09/28/2018 1.10 1,155.00 Numerous telephone conferences with co-counsel regarding motion for reconsideration. 10/01/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding objecting to Apple's subpoena to ecoATM. 10/01/2018 1.60 1,680.00 Work on draft motion for reconsideration. 10/01/2018 1.30 1,365.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding motion for reconsideration. 10/01/2018 0.80 840.00 Further preparation of motion for reconsideration. 10/02/2018 3.60 3,780.00 Work on motion for reconsideration. 10/02/2018 0.30 315.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding motion for reconsideration. 10/02/2018 0.50 525.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding motion for reconsideration. 10/02/2018 1.20 1,260.00 Complete preparation of proposed second amended complaint. 10/02/2018 0.70 735.00 Review of order regarding motion to dismiss in the Apple Device Performance Litigation as it relates to the motion for reconsideration.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 21 of 63 Page: 20 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw 10/03/2018 0.60 630.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding designation of lead counsel. 10/04/2018 0.50 525.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding lead trial counsel designation. 10/05/2018 0.30 315.00 Exchange e-mail with M. Potter regarding JND proposal for notice and settlement. 10/05/2018 2.60 2,730.00 Review/analyze Defendant's motion for summary judgment. 10/10/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of litigation fund accounting and outstanding invoices to calculate additional assessments. 10/10/2018 1.10 1,155.00 Preparation for and attend weekly telephone conference with co-counsel. 10/17/2018 1.20 1,260.00 Review of Qualcomm 23(f) petition. 10/17/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with defense counsel regarding production of documents. 10/17/2018 0.10 105.00 Process document production. 10/17/2018 0.30 315.00 Review/analyze Apple's edits to the draft Case Management Conference Statement. 10/17/2018 0.20 210.00 Further revisions to Case Management Conference Statement. 10/17/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding proposed revisions to Case Management Conference Statement. 10/17/2018 5.10 5,355.00 Work on opposition to motion for summary judgment. 10/17/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding discovery issues to be resolved prior to filing Case Management Conference Statement. 10/18/2018 0.90 945.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding case status, opposition to motion for summary judgment, motion for reconsideration and mediation. 10/18/2018 4.60 4,830.00 Work on opposition to motion for summary judgment. 10/18/2018 0.60 630.00 Communications with co-counsel regarding opposition to motion for summary judgment. 10/23/2018 0.50 525.00 Telephone call to Attorney J. Manning regarding appeal and mediation. 10/23/2018 0.30 315.00 Communications with Attorney J. Bourne regarding 23(f) appeal. 10/23/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of documents to provide to Attorney J. Bourne to review in order to prepare 23(f) petition. 10/24/2018 0.90 945.00 Weekly call with co-counsel regarding case status. 10/24/2018 0.40 420.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding 23(f) petition. 10/25/2018 0.40 420.00 Preparation for telephone conference with co-counsel regarding appeal. 10/25/2018 0.10 105.00 Telephone call to Attorney J. Bourne regarding appeal. 10/25/2018 0.70 735.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding preparation of 23(f). 10/25/2018 1.60 1,680.00 Work on 23(f) appeal. 10/29/2018 0.20 210.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding mediation. 10/29/2018 0.30 315.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding 23(f) appeal. 10/29/2018 0.20 210.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding mediation. 10/29/2018 0.20 210.00 Telephone conference with all counsel regarding mediation. 10/30/2018 1.30 1,365.00 Work on 23(f) appellate brief. 10/31/2018 2.10 2,205.00 Further preparation of 23(f) brief. 10/31/2018 0.80 840.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding case status and appeal. 10/31/2018 2.30 2,415.00 Work on 23(f) petition. 11/02/2018 1.30 1,365.00 Preparation of 23(f) petition. 11/02/2018 0.50 525.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding 23(f) petition and mediation brief. 11/02/2018 0.70 735.00 Weekly telephone conference with co-counsel. 11/02/2018 0.80 840.00 Review of final version of mediation brief. 11/05/2018 0.30 315.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding 23(f) petition and mediation. 11/05/2018 1.30 1,365.00 Work on 23(f) petition. 11/06/2018 2.90 3,045.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Preparation for and telephone conference with co-counsel regarding mediation. 11/06/2018 0.30 315.00 Preparation of spreadsheet indicating settlement data points. 11/06/2018 2.30 2,415.00 Preparation for mediation. 11/08/2018 1.60 1,680.00 Preparation for mediation. 11/08/2018 3.20 3,360.00 Travel to San Francisco to attend mediation. 11/09/2018 5.20 5,460.00 Attend mediation. 11/09/2018 4.10 4,305.00 Return travel to Los Angeles from San Francisco. 11/14/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of e-mail from Attorney G. Novikov regarding class metrics. 11/16/2018 1.10 1,155.00 Review of Apple's response to Rule 23(f) petition. 11/16/2018 0.30 315.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding Apple's response to Rule 23(f) petition. 11/16/2018 0.20 210.00 Communications with PSW team regarding motion for reply to 23(f) petition. 11/20/2018 0.50 525.00 Conduct research regarding motion to file reply to 23(f) petition. 11/20/2018 0.10 105.00 Review of draft motion to file reply to 23(f) petition. 11/20/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding reply to 23(f) petition. 11/20/2018 0.20 210.00 Telephone call from Attorney J. Manning regarding 23(f) petition and mediation.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 22 of 63 Page: 21 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw 11/20/2018 0.20 210.00 Communicate with co-counsel regarding motion to file reply to 23(f) petition. 11/20/2018 0.10 105.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding preparation of 23(f) reply. 11/20/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of and revise motion to file reply to 23(f) petition. 11/20/2018 0.60 630.00 Review of FRAP regarding procedural requirements for relating to reply to 23(f) petition. 11/20/2018 0.60 630.00 Review of reply to 23(f) petition in the In Re Qualcomm matter. 11/21/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding reply to 23(f) petition. 11/28/2018 0.40 420.00 Telephone call from Attorney A. Steyer regarding case status. 12/03/2018 0.20 210.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding 23(f) reply. 12/05/2018 1.30 1,365.00 Review of draft 23(f) reply. 12/17/2018 0.30 315.00 Audit litigation account and assessments. 12/17/2018 0.20 210.00 Preparation of e-mail to co-counsel regarding accounting of litigation fund and assessments. 12/26/2018 0.30 315.00 Review of litigation account balance and upcoming expenditures. 12/26/2018 0.20 210.00 Preparation of e-mail to co-counsel regarding cost assessments. 01/15/2019 0.30 345.00 Telephone call from Attorney J. Manning regarding claims administration companies. 01/22/2019 0.70 805.00 Review of claims administration proposals from Angeion. 01/23/2019 0.10 115.00 Review of 23(f) order in Qualcomm case. 02/05/2019 0.20 230.00 Exchange e-mail with M. Potter of JND regarding class notice and potential settlement administration. 02/19/2019 0.10 115.00 Review of draft Case Management Conference Statement and revisions thereto. 02/26/2019 0.70 805.00 Review of SCOTUS Lambert decision regarding 23(f) and motion for reconsideration. 02/26/2019 0.20 230.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding Lambert decision. 03/08/2019 0.30 345.00 Review of litigation account register and assessments to date in order to calculate future assessments. 03/11/2019 0.20 230.00 Preparation of e-mail to co-counsel regarding status of litigation fund, assessments and expert's invoice. 03/20/2019 0.10 115.00 Review of order denying 23(f). 03/20/2019 0.20 230.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding order denying 23(f). 03/21/2019 0.70 805.00 Review of and prepare summary of bids to prepare opt put notice. 03/22/2019 1.30 1,495.00 Preparation for and telephone conference with co-counsel regarding case status. 03/25/2019 0.70 805.00 Preparation for and telephone conference with M. Potter and Attorney J. Manning regarding opt-out notice. 03/25/2019 0.20 230.00 Communicate (other external) Exchange e-mail with M. Potter regarding opt notice. 03/25/2019 0.10 115.00 Communicate (other external) exchange e-mail with Angeion regarding proposal for opt out notice. 03/25/2019 0.10 115.00 Communicate (other external) exchange e-mail with Rust regarding proposal for opt out notice. 04/01/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with M. Potter regarding opt out notice. 04/01/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Manning regarding opt out notice. 04/10/2019 0.50 575.00 Preparation for and telephone conference with E. Novikov regarding claims administration 04/10/2019 1.20 1,380.00 Preparation for and attend weekly call with co-counsel. 04/15/2019 0.50 575.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Telephone call from Attorney J. Manning regarding case status and schedule. 04/15/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding Case Management Conference. 04/18/2019 0.50 575.00 Attend weekly call with co-counsel regarding case status. 04/18/2019 0.30 345.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding allocation of work and case management conference. 04/22/2019 0.10 115.00 Review of and revise Case Management Conference Statement. 04/22/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding draft Case Management Conference Statement. 04/22/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with defense counsel regarding Case Management Conference Statement. 04/22/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney E. Novikov regarding claims administrators. 04/22/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Manning regarding class notice providers. 04/24/2019 0.20 230.00 Further preparation of Case Management Conference Statement. 04/24/2019 1.50 1,725.00 Review of file regarding Judge Cousin's discovery orders in order to raise discovery dispute with court in Case Management Conference Statement. 04/24/2019 0.20 230.00 Review of Apple's revisions to the Case Management Conference Statement. 04/24/2019 0.30 345.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding Apple's revisions to Case Management Conference Statement. 04/25/2019 0.30 345.00 Telephone conference with M. Potter regarding claims administration. 05/15/2019 0.60 690.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding case status.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 23 of 63 Page: 22 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw 05/15/2019 0.20 230.00 Exchange e-mail with M. Masterson regarding taking document review database offline to save costs. 05/15/2019 0.10 115.00 Analysis of options to save costs on document review database. 05/15/2019 0.10 115.00 Preparation of e-mail to Attorney J. Manning regarding document review database. 05/15/2019 0.20 230.00 Exchange e-mail with C. Chimicles of Angeion regarding bid for opt out notice. 05/15/2019 0.30 345.00 Telephone call from Attorney J. Manning regarding assignments and case status. 05/17/2019 1.20 1,380.00 Review of all proposals for opt out notice and settlement administration in preparation for call with C. Chimicles of Angeion. 05/17/2019 0.30 345.00 Telephone call from C. Chimicles of Angeion regarding claims administration and notice proposals. 06/06/2019 0.60 690.00 Review of Hyundai decision. 06/11/2019 0.30 345.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Telephone call to Attorney J. Manning regarding case status. 06/11/2019 0.10 115.00 Review of e-mail from Attorney J. Manning to defense counsel regarding meet and confer call concerning class data for notice, updated spreadsheets and notice provider. 06/18/2019 0.60 690.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding case status. 06/19/2019 0.20 230.00 Preparation for and telephone conference with J. Mottek regarding class notice. 07/10/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding meet and confer with defense counsel concerning class list, claims administration and pre-trial dates. 07/10/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with defense counsel regarding claims administration, class list and pre-trial dates. 07/18/2019 0.60 690.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding case management and motion for summary judgment hearing. 07/19/2019 1.60 1,840.00 Conduct research regarding hearing transcripts and order from motion for summary judgment hearings before Judge Koh. 07/23/2019 0.50 575.00 Review/analyze transcript from FTC v Qualcomm to prepare for motion for summary judgment hearing. 08/13/2019 0.20 230.00 Telephone call from Attorney J. Manning regarding case status. 08/13/2019 0.20 230.00 Telephone call from Attorney A. Curry regarding case status. 08/19/2019 0.70 805.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding case status. 08/19/2019 0.10 115.00 Plan and prepare for telephone conference with co-counsel. 08/21/2019 0.70 805.00 Review/analyze order denying Apple's motion for summary judgment. 08/21/2019 0.30 345.00 Communications with co-counsel regarding order denying Apple's motion for summary judgment. 08/23/2019 1.10 1,265.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding order on motion for summary judgment, case status and mediation. 08/26/2019 0.10 115.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney C. Pearson regarding amended complaint and mediation. 08/27/2019 0.10 115.00 Telephone conference with defense counsel regarding Case Management Conference Statement. 08/27/2019 0.10 115.00 Work on Case Management Conference Statement. 08/27/2019 1.60 1,840.00 Review of Epiq bids for opt-out notice and settlement administration (California and Nationwide) and compare to competing bids. 08/27/2019 0.70 805.00 Telephone conference with J. Mottek regarding Epiq bids. 08/28/2019 1.30 1,495.00 Preparation for and telephone conference with J. Mottek regarding Epiq bids for opt-out notice and class settlement. 08/28/2019 0.10 115.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding Case Management Conference Statement. 08/28/2019 0.20 230.00 Exchange e-mail with J. Mottek regarding opt-out notice. 08/28/2019 0.20 230.00 Review of and further preparation of draft letter brief regarding updated class list. 08/28/2019 0.10 115.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding letter brief concerning updated class list. 08/29/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with J. Mottek regarding opt-out notice. 08/29/2019 0.70 805.00 Review of Belanger v. Apple complaint. 08/29/2019 1.20 1,380.00 Numerous telephone conferences with co-counsel regarding Belanger complaint and mediation. 08/30/2019 0.40 460.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding Belanger complaint. 09/04/2019 0.30 345.00 Telephone call from Attorney J. Manning regarding mediation. 09/04/2019 0.30 345.00 Review of file and exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding size of California class. 09/05/2019 0.40 460.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with Attorneys J. Manning, A. Steyer and S. Macrae regarding case status. 09/06/2019 1.00 1,150.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding case status and mediation. 09/11/2019 0.20 230.00 Review of memorandum from Competition Economics regarding spreadsheets

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 24 of 63 Page: 23 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw produced by Apple. 09/11/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding memorandum from Competition Economics regarding spreadsheets produced by Apple. 09/13/2019 0.90 1,035.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding case status. 09/13/2019 0.30 345.00 Review of nationwide claims administration bid from Epiq. 09/13/2019 0.50 575.00 Review of and revise opt-out long form notice. 09/20/2019 0.30 345.00 Preparation for and telephone conference with Attorneys J. Lerner, E. Novikov, J. Lerner, J. Manning and A. Curry regarding class list and class notice. 09/20/2019 0.20 230.00 Telephone conference with J. Mottek regarding opt out notice. 09/20/2019 0.20 230.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding class size and notice. 09/20/2019 2.40 2,760.00 Conduct research regarding requirements for opt out notice and settlement notice. 09/24/2019 0.70 805.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding mediation and case status. 09/24/2019 0.80 920.00 Work on mediation brief. 09/25/2019 0.80 920.00 Preparation for and attend telephone conference with co-counsel regarding mediation and case status. 09/25/2019 0.20 230.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney C. Pearson regarding mediation and damages analysis. 09/25/2019 0.10 115.00 Review of damages analysis. 09/25/2019 0.50 575.00 Review of revised mediation brief. 09/26/2019 0.20 230.00 Telephone conference with Epiq regarding opt out notice. 09/26/2019 0.20 230.00 Telephone call from Attorney J. Manning regarding notice. 09/27/2019 0.30 345.00 Review of emails from co-counsel regarding settlement proposal. 09/27/2019 0.20 230.00 Conference with Attorney C. Pearson regarding settlement. 09/30/2019 0.10 115.00 Conference with Attorney C. Pearson regarding settlement demand. 09/30/2019 0.10 115.00 Telephone call from Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement demand. 10/01/2019 0.60 690.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding demand letter. 10/01/2019 0.30 345.00 Revise settlement demand letter. 10/01/2019 0.20 230.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding demand letter. 10/02/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel and defense counsel regarding class list. 10/02/2019 0.20 230.00 Conference with Attorney C. Pearson regarding damages analysis. 10/02/2019 0.10 115.00 Preparation of e-mail to Attorney C. Pearson regarding damages analysis. 10/11/2019 0.70 805.00 Work on mediation brief. 10/17/2019 0.20 230.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney C. Pearson regarding mediation strategy and demand. 10/21/2019 2.30 2,645.00 Plan and prepare for mediation. 10/22/2019 4.20 4,830.00 Travel to San Francisco for mediation. 10/22/2019 8.20 9,430.00 Attend mediation. 10/22/2019 4.10 4,715.00 Return travel to Los Angeles from mediation in San Francisco. 10/23/2019 0.80 920.00 Exchange numerous e-mails with co-counsel regarding post-mediation issues. 10/23/2019 0.30 345.00 Review of draft term sheet from defense counsel. 10/23/2019 0.20 230.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Lerner regarding post mediation tasks and term sheet. 10/23/2019 0.30 345.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement. 10/24/2019 0.20 230.00 Telephone call from Attorney J. Manning regarding term sheet. 10/24/2019 0.20 230.00 Telephone call from Attorney J. Lerner regarding term sheet. 10/24/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding litigation fund. 10/28/2019 0.20 230.00 Telephone conference with ethics counsel and Attorney C. Pearson regarding settlement and ethical issues. 10/29/2019 0.20 230.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding status of settlement. 10/29/2019 0.20 230.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Lerner regarding settlement. 10/30/2019 0.20 230.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Lerner regarding settlement. 10/30/2019 0.40 460.00 Preparation for and attend telephone conference with co-counsel regarding settlement. 10/31/2019 0.20 230.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Lerner regarding settlement. 10/31/2019 0.30 345.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding settlement 10/31/2019 0.30 345.00 Communications with co-counsel regarding settlement. 11/01/2019 0.20 230.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Lerner regarding settlement. 11/01/2019 0.20 230.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Lerner regarding settlement. 11/05/2019 0.30 345.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding settlement status. 11/05/2019 0.20 230.00 Telephone call from Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement and status. 11/05/2019 0.30 345.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding settlement issues. 11/06/2019 1.00 1,150.00 Telephone conference with Attorney C. Pearson and ethics counsel. 11/06/2019 0.20 230.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney C. Pearson regarding response to e-mail from Judge Cahill. 11/06/2019 0.10 115.00 Communicate (in firm) Preparation of e-mail to Judge Cahill regarding plaintiffs'

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 25 of 63 Page: 24 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw position. 11/06/2019 0.30 345.00 Review of e-mail from ethics counsel regarding consultation concerning settlement. 11/08/2019 1.20 1,380.00 Numerous communications with co-counsel regarding settlement. 11/08/2019 0.60 690.00 Numerous telephone conferences with Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement and report to court. 11/08/2019 0.80 920.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding settlement and report to court. 11/08/2019 0.10 115.00 Review of Court's Guidelines for Settlement Conferences. 11/08/2019 0.30 345.00 Preparation for schedule of trial deadlines and relevant orders regarding same. 11/08/2019 0.10 115.00 Preparation of e-mail to co-counsel regarding trial deadlines and attach relevant orders. 11/08/2019 0.30 345.00 Numerous conferences with Attorney C. Pearson regarding settlement and case status. 11/12/2019 0.30 345.00 Review of memorandum regarding mediation privilege. 11/12/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding mediation privilege. 11/12/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding Apple's position regarding a settlement conference. 11/12/2019 0.30 345.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding post mediation statement and settlement conference. 11/13/2019 0.10 115.00 Review of e-mail from Attorney E. Novikov regarding Daubert motions. 11/13/2019 0.30 345.00 Numerous emails with co-counsel regarding post-mediation report to the Court. 11/13/2019 0.10 115.00 Review of JAMS mediation confidentiality agreement. 11/13/2019 0.20 230.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding Apple's position regarding mediation privilege and settlement conference. 11/13/2019 0.40 460.00 Work on issues related to settlement conference. 11/14/2019 0.10 115.00 Review of proposed stipulation regarding Daubert motions. 11/14/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with counsel for Apple regarding Daubert motions. 11/15/2019 0.50 575.00 Preparation for and telephone conference with defense counsel, Apple in-house counsel and co-counsel regarding settlement. 11/15/2019 0.20 230.00 Telephone conference with Attorney C. Pearson and Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement. 11/15/2019 0.10 115.00 Review of revisions to joint mediation status update. 11/15/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with counsel regarding revisions to joint mediation status update. 11/18/2019 0.20 230.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement and trial preparation. 11/18/2019 0.10 115.00 Work on Joint Case Management Statement. 11/18/2019 0.20 230.00 Conference with Attorney C. Pearson regarding Joint Case Management Statement and settlement. 11/18/2019 0.10 115.00 Review of Apple's revisions and e-mail regarding joint mediation status update. 11/18/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding Apple's revisions and e-mail regarding joint mediation status update. 11/18/2019 0.20 230.00 Conference with Attorney C. Pearson regarding settlement conference request. 11/18/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding trial plan. 11/19/2019 1.30 1,495.00 Preparation for and telephone conference with co-counsel regarding trial preparation. 11/19/2019 0.20 230.00 Conference with Attorney C. Pearson regarding settlement. 11/20/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with Inventus regarding reactivating document review database. 11/20/2019 2.60 2,990.00 Review of hot documents to select for trial exhibits. 11/20/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with Inventus regarding document review database restoration. 11/20/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding document review database. 11/20/2019 0.10 115.00 Review of Apple's revisions to joint mediation status update. 11/20/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with defense counsel regarding Apple's revision to joint mediation status update. 11/21/2019 0.10 115.00 Review of order regarding settlement conference. 11/21/2019 0.10 115.00 Preparation of joint statement regarding settlement. 11/21/2019 0.20 230.00 Numerous conferences with Attorney C. Pearson regarding settlement conference. 11/21/2019 0.30 345.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding settlement conference. 11/21/2019 0.10 115.00 Review of Judge Cousins' settlement conference standing order. 11/21/2019 0.10 115.00 Review of order regarding joint mediation status report. 11/21/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding settlement conference. 11/21/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Manning regarding plaintiffs' availability for attendance at settlement conference. 11/21/2019 0.20 230.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Lerner and co-counsel regarding joint statement regarding settlement conference. 11/21/2019 0.30 345.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding settlement conference.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 26 of 63 Page: 25 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw 11/21/2019 1.20 1,380.00 Work on settlement strategy. 11/22/2019 0.10 115.00 Telephone call from Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement conference. 11/22/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Lerner regarding settlement conference. 11/22/2019 0.20 230.00 Telephone conference with Attorneys J. Manning, J. Lerner and E. Novikov regarding settlement conference. 11/22/2019 0.20 230.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding collection of time reports. 11/22/2019 0.10 115.00 Telephone conference with Attorney D. Tejtel regarding time report. 11/22/2019 0.20 230.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Manning regarding draft settlement conference report. 11/22/2019 0.20 230.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Manning and Attorney J. Lerner regarding draft settlement conference report. 11/25/2019 0.30 345.00 Preparation for and telephone conference with co-counsel regarding pre-trail and mediation. 11/25/2019 3.20 3,680.00 Begin preparation of settlement conference statement. 11/25/2019 0.10 115.00 Review of order referring parties to settlement conference. 11/25/2019 0.40 460.00 Communications with co-counsel regarding plaintiffs' availability for settlement conference. 11/25/2019 0.30 345.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorneys J. Lerner and J. Manning regarding logistics of settlement conference and setting up an advance call with Judge Cousins. 11/25/2019 0.20 230.00 Exchange e-mail with Clerk Harrell regarding settlement conference. 11/26/2019 0.30 345.00 Numerous telephone conferences with Attorney J. Manning regarding Settlement Conference and mediation privilege. 11/26/2019 0.20 230.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Lerner and Attorney E. Novikov regarding Settlement Conference and mediation privilege. 11/26/2019 0.10 115.00 Review of stipulation regarding mediation privilege. 11/26/2019 5.80 6,670.00 Work on settlement conference statement. 11/26/2019 0.10 115.00 Telephone conference with Judge Cousins and counsel regarding settlement conference. 11/27/2019 4.80 5,520.00 Complete preparation of first draft of settlement conference statement. 11/27/2019 0.30 345.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding revisions to settlement conference statement. 11/28/2019 0.50 575.00 Review of revisions to settlement conference statement. 11/28/2019 0.40 460.00 Conference with Attorney C. Pearson regarding revisions to settlement conference statement. 11/28/2019 0.10 115.00 Preparation of e-mail to co-counsel regarding settlement conference statement. 11/28/2019 1.20 1,380.00 Further preparation of settlement conference statement. 11/29/2019 0.40 460.00 Review of Attorney D. Tejtel's revisions to settlement conference statement. 11/29/2019 0.30 345.00 Further preparation of settlement conference statement. 11/29/2019 0.10 115.00 Preparation of e-mail to co-counsel regarding settlement conference statement. 11/30/2019 0.40 460.00 Further preparation of settlement conference statement. 12/01/2019 0.30 345.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding mediation strategy. 12/02/2019 0.50 575.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding trial preparation and settlement conference. 12/02/2019 0.40 460.00 Telephone conference with Attorney C. Pearson and ethics counsel regarding mediation. 12/02/2019 1.50 1,725.00 Further preparation of settlement conference statement. 12/02/2019 1.10 1,265.00 Complete preparation of settlement conference statement. 12/02/2019 1.00 1,150.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding settlement conference. 12/03/2019 0.10 115.00 Review of draft Case Management Conference Statement. 12/03/2019 0.60 690.00 Review of defendant's settlement conference statement. 12/04/2019 0.70 805.00 Telephone conference with Attorney C. Pearson and Attorney J. Manning in order to prepare for settlement conference. 12/04/2019 2.10 2,415.00 Preparation for mediation. 12/05/2019 3.80 4,370.00 Travel to San Jose for settlement conference. 12/05/2019 8.60 9,890.00 Conference with co-counsel and attend settlement conference. 12/05/2019 2.50 2,875.00 Return travel from San Jose to Los Angeles from settlement conference. 12/09/2019 0.90 1,035.00 Attend trial preparation call with co-counsel. 12/09/2019 0.20 230.00 Telephone conference with Attorney A. Curry regarding motion in limine. 12/10/2019 0.40 460.00 Review of and revise Joint Pretrial Order. 12/10/2019 0.60 690.00 Initial review of draft jury instructions and exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding same. 12/10/2019 0.60 690.00 Work on exhibit list. 12/11/2019 1.00 1,150.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding pre-trial preparation and documents to exchange with defense counsel.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 27 of 63 Page: 26 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw 12/11/2019 0.80 920.00 Preparation of jury instructions. 12/11/2019 0.20 230.00 Preparation of verdict form. 12/11/2019 0.90 1,035.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding trial documents. 12/12/2019 0.60 690.00 Numerous communications regarding pre-trail exchange. 12/12/2019 0.20 230.00 Review of court order regarding procedure for administrative motions to seal. 12/12/2019 0.20 230.00 Conference with Attorney A. Simon regarding meet and confer with defense counsel regarding proposed documents to be sealed as part of Daubert motion. 12/12/2019 0.30 345.00 Review of Apple's documents to be sealed. 12/12/2019 1.80 2,070.00 Conduct research regarding availability of injunctive relief in non-class context. 12/13/2019 0.70 805.00 Review of Apple's numerous revisions to Joint Pretrial Statement and Proposed Order. 12/13/2019 1.30 1,495.00 Draft/revise motions in limine. 12/13/2019 0.40 460.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding revisions to motions in limine. 12/13/2019 0.50 575.00 Work on joint pre-trial statement. 12/13/2019 0.80 920.00 Work on voir dire questions. 12/13/2019 0.30 345.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding voir dire. 12/13/2019 0.50 575.00 Revise jury instructions. 12/13/2019 0.30 345.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding proposed revisions to jury instructions. 12/13/2019 0.10 115.00 Review of final verdict form. 12/13/2019 0.20 230.00 Communications with co-counsel regarding verdict form. 12/13/2019 1.10 1,265.00 Review/analyze draft exhibit list. 12/13/2019 0.30 345.00 Review/analyze draft witness list. 12/13/2019 0.10 115.00 Communicate (other external) exchange e-mail with J. Mottek regarding opt out notice. 12/13/2019 0.10 115.00 Review of Court's standing order regarding motions in limine. 12/13/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Manning regarding finalization, formatting and Court's standing order on motions in limine. 12/13/2019 1.60 1,840.00 Complete preparation of motions in limine and attention to filing of same. 12/13/2019 0.20 230.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding revisions to joint pre-trial statement. 12/13/2019 0.30 345.00 Exchange e-mail with defense counsel regarding revisions to joint pre-trial statement and timing of exchange of pre-trial documents. 12/13/2019 0.50 575.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding pre-trial filings. 12/16/2019 0.30 345.00 Preparation of opposition to Apple's motions in limine. 12/17/2019 5.10 5,865.00 Preparation of oppositions to motions in limine. 12/17/2019 0.20 230.00 Review of estimate from Epiq for opt out notice. 12/18/2019 0.10 115.00 Exchange e-mail with J. Mottek regarding opt out notice schedule. 12/19/2019 0.80 920.00 Review of proposed jury instructions and verdict form. 12/23/2019 0.40 460.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding case status and pre-trial work. 12/23/2019 1.30 1,495.00 Preparation of opt out notices. 12/23/2019 1.60 1,840.00 Preparation of draft stipulation and proposed order regarding opt out notices. 12/25/2019 1.10 1,265.00 Review of and revise opposition to defendant's Daubert motion. 12/26/2019 0.40 460.00 Review of revisions to draft opposition to defendant's Daubert motion. 12/26/2019 0.20 230.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding draft opposition to defendant's Daubert motion. 12/26/2019 0.10 115.00 Preparation of e-mail to Attorney J. Lerner regarding opt-out notice. 12/26/2019 0.80 920.00 Review of transcript from pre-trial conference in Samsung v. Apple. 12/26/2019 1.80 2,070.00 Review of Hastings and Jones reports in order to prepare opposition to defendant's Daubert motion. 12/27/2019 0.40 460.00 Preparation of motion to seal opposition to defendant's Daubert motion. 12/27/2019 0.50 575.00 Preparation of Warshaw declaration in support of motion to seal opposition to defendant's Daubert motion. 12/27/2019 0.60 690.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Exchange e-mail with defense counsel regarding motion to seal opposition to defendant's Daubert motion. 12/27/2019 0.20 230.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Telephone meet and confer with Attorney J. Lerner regarding motion to seal opposition to Daubert motion. 12/27/2019 5.80 6,670.00 Work on opposition to Daubert motion. 12/27/2019 1.30 1,495.00 Numerous telephone conference with and emails with co-counsel regarding opposition to Daubert motion. 12/27/2019 1.10 1,265.00 Complete preparation of opposition to Daubert motion. 12/27/2019 0.40 460.00 Complete preparation of motion to seal. 12/31/2019 0.10 115.00 Preparation of e-mail to defense counsel regarding opt-out notice. 12/31/2019 0.20 230.00 Review of declaration of R. Meinz in support of motion to seal. 01/02/2020 0.30 357.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding stipulation concerning

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 28 of 63 Page: 27 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw opposition to Daubert motion. 01/02/2020 0.20 238.00 Review of and revise administrative motion regarding opposition to Daubert motion. 01/02/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding settlement representations and telephone conference with Judge Cousins. 01/02/2020 1.10 1,309.00 Conference with Attorney C. Pearson and Attorney T. Nolan regarding settlement. 01/03/2020 0.40 476.00 Conference with Attorney C. Pearson and Attorney A. Simon regarding trial preparation. 01/04/2020 0.10 119.00 Conference with Attorney A. Simon regarding trial preparation. 01/06/2020 0.50 595.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding trial preparation. 01/07/2020 0.50 595.00 Review of Apple's verdict form. 01/08/2020 0.20 238.00 Draft Case Management Conference Statement. 01/08/2020 0.30 357.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding settlement. 01/08/2020 0.40 476.00 Conference with Attorney C. Pearson regarding trial preparation and settlement. 01/09/2020 0.50 595.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding Case Management Conference Statement. 01/09/2020 0.60 714.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel and defense counsel regarding revisions to Case Management Conference Statement. 01/09/2020 0.20 238.00 Review of proposed revisions to Case Management Conference Statement. 01/09/2020 0.30 357.00 Further preparation of Case Management Conference Statement. 01/09/2020 0.30 357.00 Work on witness list. 01/09/2020 0.10 119.00 Conference with Attorney C. Pearson regarding settlement. 01/09/2020 0.10 119.00 Preparation of e-mail to Epiq and Apple's counsel regarding opt-out notice. 01/10/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding revisions to opt out notice. 01/10/2020 0.40 476.00 Revise opt out notices. 01/11/2020 1.00 1,190.00 Review of memoranda regarding statutes of limitations. 01/11/2020 0.40 476.00 Exchange e-mail with and telephone call from Attorney C. Pearson regarding settlement and memorandum regarding statutes of limitations. 01/12/2020 0.30 357.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney C. Pearson regarding memorandum to Judge Cousins regarding statutes of limitations. 01/15/2020 7.20 8,568.00 Preparation for pre-trial conference. 01/15/2020 1.60 1,904.00 Preparation for settlement conference. 01/16/2020 3.80 4,522.00 Travel to San Jose for pre-trial conference and settlement conference. 01/16/2020 2.00 2,380.00 Conference with co-counsel in preparation of pre-trial conference and settlement conference. 01/16/2020 3.10 3,689.00 Attend settlement conference. 01/16/2020 1.90 2,261.00 Attend pre-trial conference. 01/16/2020 2.20 2,618.00 Return travel to Los Angeles from pre-trial conference and settlement conference. 01/17/2020 0.20 238.00 Review of pre-trial order. 01/17/2020 0.10 119.00 Review of e-mail from Judge Cousins and exchange e-mail with Attorney C. Pearson regarding same. 01/20/2020 0.40 476.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding settlement. 01/20/2020 0.30 357.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding settlement issues. 01/20/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with Inventus regarding document review users. 01/20/2020 0.80 952.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding statute of limitations representation, research regarding same and proposed language to Judge Cousins. 01/21/2020 0.30 357.00 Conference with Attorney C. Pearson regarding case status. 01/22/2020 0.40 476.00 Numerous communications with co-counsel regarding settlement and report to Judge Cousins regarding same,. 01/22/2020 0.10 119.00 Review of report to Judge Cousins regarding settlement status. 01/22/2020 1.30 1,547.00 Numerous calls with co-counsel regarding trial preparation. 01/23/2020 1.20 1,428.00 Review of and revise witness proffer. 01/23/2020 0.20 238.00 Conference with co-counsel regarding settlement status. 01/24/2020 0.40 476.00 Review of and comment on limiting instruction. 01/24/2020 0.30 357.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding limiting instruction. 01/24/2020 0.50 595.00 Numerous telephone conferences with Attorney J. Manning regarding case management issues. 01/24/2020 0.10 119.00 Preparation of e-mail to defense counsel regarding opt-out notice. 01/24/2020 0.10 119.00 Telephone call from Attorney E. Novikov regarding opt-out notice. 01/24/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding opt-out notice. 01/24/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding limiting instruction. 01/27/2020 1.30 1,547.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding case management and handling of upcoming assignments. 01/27/2020 0.20 238.00 Conference with Attorney C. Pearson regarding settlement issues. 01/27/2020 0.20 238.00 Preparation of draft revised settlement preamble.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 29 of 63 Page: 28 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw 01/27/2020 0.40 476.00 Preparation of argument regarding Apple's revised proposed verdict form. 01/27/2020 0.10 119.00 Review of plaintiffs' revised verdict form. 01/27/2020 0.40 476.00 Numerous telephone conferences with co-counsel regarding verdict form. 01/27/2020 0.30 357.00 Conference with Attorney A. Simon regarding verdict forms. 01/27/2020 0.20 238.00 Review of Apple's revised verdict form. 01/27/2020 2.10 2,499.00 Work on objection to Apple's verdict form. 01/27/2020 0.30 357.00 Exchange e-mail with Apple's counsel regarding verdict form filing. 01/27/2020 0.70 833.00 Complete preparation of joint filing regarding verdict form. 01/27/2020 0.30 357.00 Work on Joint Case Management Conference Statement. 01/27/2020 1.20 1,428.00 Conduct research regarding Apple's verdict form argument concerning mixed legal and factual issues. 01/28/2020 0.20 238.00 Telephone call from Attorney J. Manning regarding case management issues. 01/28/2020 0.30 357.00 E-mail with co-counsel regarding settlement. 01/28/2020 0.20 238.00 Conference with Attorney C. Pearson regarding settlement terms. 01/28/2020 0.20 238.00 Draft proposed preamble to settlement agreement. 01/28/2020 0.10 119.00 Review of Apple's redlined stipulation regarding opt-out notice. 01/30/2020 0.30 357.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding opt-out notice. 01/30/2020 0.20 238.00 Review of Apple's proposed changes to the opt-out notice and stipulation regarding same; compare to class certification order. 01/30/2020 0.10 119.00 Conference with Attorney A. Simon regarding opt out forms and stipulation. 01/30/2020 0.10 119.00 Preparation of e-mail to co-counsel regarding opt out forms and stipulation. 01/31/2020 0.60 714.00 Telephone conference with Epiq, defense counsel, Attorney J. Manning and Attorney A. Simon regarding opt-out notice. 02/03/2020 0.40 476.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding mediator's proposal. 02/03/2020 0.30 357.00 Telephone call from Attorney D. Tejtel regarding settlement. 02/03/2020 0.30 357.00 Review of opt out and settlement administration bids. 02/03/2020 0.10 119.00 Preparation of e-mail to Epiq regarding class notice. 02/03/2020 0.70 833.00 Work on settlement issues. 02/03/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with Epiq regarding quotes for claims administration. 02/03/2020 0.30 357.00 Review of revised quote for settlement administration. 02/04/2020 0.20 238.00 Review of Apple's objection to witness proffer. 02/05/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney E. Novikov and co-counsel regarding opt-out notice. 02/05/2020 0.60 714.00 Numerous communications with J. Mottek regarding class notice. 02/05/2020 1.20 1,428.00 Work on opt out notice. 02/05/2020 2.20 2,618.00 Conduct research regarding dissemination of notice and due process requirements. 02/05/2020 0.20 238.00 Draft proposed language regarding the resolution of settlement disputes. 02/05/2020 0.10 119.00 Conference with Attorney C. Pearson regarding settlement. 02/05/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding settlement administrative costs based on class data. 02/05/2020 0.40 476.00 Work with Epiq to revise bid based on projected class composition. 02/06/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding mediator's proposal and settlement. 02/06/2020 0.50 595.00 Complete preparation of reply regarding proffer. 02/06/2020 0.20 238.00 Telephone conference with Attorneys J. Lerner, E. Novikov and J. Manning regarding notice of settlement. 02/06/2020 0.10 119.00 Preparation of notice of settlement. 02/06/2020 0.10 119.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement. 02/07/2020 0.60 714.00 Numerous communications with co-counsel and Attorneys J. Lerner and E. Novikov regarding settlement. 02/07/2020 0.20 238.00 Telephone conference with Attorney C. Pearson and Attorney D. Tejtel regarding settlement. 02/10/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Lerner and co-counsel regarding notice of settlement. 02/11/2020 0.30 357.00 Telephone call from Attorney A. Steyer regarding settlement structure. 02/11/2020 0.60 714.00 Work on settlement structure. 02/12/2020 0.70 833.00 Preparation of spreadsheet regarding settlement calculations. 02/12/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement spreadsheet and claims process. 02/12/2020 0.70 833.00 Exchange e-mail with telephone conference with J. Mottek, C. Azari and Attorney J. Manning regarding claims process. 02/12/2020 0.40 476.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding settlement negotiations. 02/12/2020 0.70 833.00 Numerous telephone conferences and emails with Attorney J. Manning regarding claims process. 02/18/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with Apple's counsel and Attorney J. Manning regarding stipulation to continue dates.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 30 of 63 Page: 29 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw 02/18/2020 0.10 119.00 Review of revisions to stipulation to continue dates. 02/18/2020 0.50 595.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement. 02/19/2020 0.10 119.00 Review of order denying stipulation to stay. 02/19/2020 0.60 714.00 Telephone conference with Epiq team and Attorney J. Manning regarding claims process. 02/19/2020 1.70 2,023.00 Conduct research regarding automatic payment of class claims. 02/20/2020 3.20 3,808.00 Work on motion for preliminary approval. 02/21/2020 0.30 357.00 Preliminary review of settlement agreement. 02/21/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding settlement agreement. 02/22/2020 0.50 595.00 Revise settlement agreement. 02/23/2020 1.20 1,428.00 Revise settlement agreement. 02/24/2020 3.50 4,165.00 Conduct research regarding issues relating to preliminary approval before Judge Koh and ND CAL guidelines; review of Hadley v. Kellogg order, ND CAL guidelines and SFBSC Management opinion. 02/24/2020 0.50 595.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding settlement agreement. 02/24/2020 0.20 238.00 Review of proposed revisions to settlement agreement. 02/24/2020 1.80 2,142.00 Further work on revisions to settlement agreement. 02/24/2020 0.80 952.00 Exchange e-mail and telephone conference with Epiq and co-counsel regarding settlement administration and costs. 02/25/2020 0.30 357.00 Preparation for telephone conference with Attorney E. Novikov regarding settlement agreement. 02/25/2020 0.50 595.00 Telephone conference with Attorney E. Novikov and co-counsel regarding settlement agreement. 02/25/2020 1.20 1,428.00 Conduct research regarding class notice. 02/25/2020 0.40 476.00 Preparation of e-mail with authorities to defense counsel regarding class notice requirements. 02/25/2020 0.50 595.00 Telephone call from Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement issues. 02/25/2020 3.20 3,808.00 Work on motion for preliminary approval and notice documents. 02/26/2020 0.80 952.00 Telephone conference with Epiq regarding claims administration and notice. 02/26/2020 0.30 357.00 Telephone call from Attorney J. Manning regarding claims administration and notice. 02/26/2020 0.60 714.00 Numerous telephone conferences with Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement terms. 02/26/2020 2.10 2,499.00 Conduct research regarding statistics for check negotiation compared to e-payments. 02/27/2020 0.60 714.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding case status, trial documents and settlement. 02/27/2020 0.70 833.00 Preparation for telephone conference with Attorneys J. Lerner, E. Novikov, J. Manning and A. Simon. 02/27/2020 1.50 1,785.00 Telephone conference with Attorneys J. Lerner, E. Novikov, J. Manning and A. Simon. 02/27/2020 0.30 357.00 Further telephone conference with Attorneys J. Lerner, E. Novikov, J. Manning and A. Simon. 02/27/2020 1.20 1,428.00 Review/analyze settlement agreement and related documents in Sharmell v. Apple. 02/27/2020 0.80 952.00 Numerous telephone conferences with co-counsel regarding settlement terms. 02/27/2020 1.20 1,428.00 Preparation of motion for preliminary approval. 02/28/2020 0.80 952.00 Numerous telephone conferences with co-counsel regarding settlement. 02/28/2020 0.40 476.00 Telephone conference with Attorneys J. Lerner, E. Novikov and J. Manning regarding settlement. 02/28/2020 0.50 595.00 Telephone conference with C. Azari, Attorneys J. Lerner, E. Novikov and J. Manning regarding claims administration process. 02/28/2020 2.60 3,094.00 Preparation of motion for preliminary approval. 02/28/2020 2.30 2,737.00 Work on settlement issues. 03/01/2020 1.30 1,547.00 Further preparation of motion for preliminary approval. 03/01/2020 0.70 833.00 Telephone conference with Attorneys J. Manning, J. Lerner and E. Novikov regarding settlement agreement terms. 03/02/2020 0.60 714.00 Numerous telephone conferences with Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement negotiations. 03/02/2020 0.30 357.00 Telephone calls from Attorney J. Lerner regarding settlement. 03/02/2020 0.60 714.00 Telephone conference with Attorneys C. Pearson, A. Simon, J. Manning, J. Cassidy and D. Tejtel regarding Apple's proposed settlement terms. 03/02/2020 5.60 6,664.00 Further preparation of motion for preliminary approval. 03/02/2020 0.90 1,071.00 Numerous telephone conferences with Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement terms. 03/02/2020 0.40 476.00 Numerous telephone conferences with Attorney J. Lerner regarding settlement terms. 03/02/2020 0.60 714.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding settlement status. 03/02/2020 0.70 833.00 Numerous telephone conferences with Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 31 of 63 Page: 30 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw 03/03/2020 2.10 2,499.00 Conduct research regarding comparable cases to be included in motion for preliminary approval. 03/03/2020 1.20 1,428.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding settlement and trial preparation. 03/03/2020 0.10 119.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning and Attorney J. Lerner regarding opt-out notice. 03/03/2020 0.30 357.00 Numerous telephone conferences with Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement and trial preparation. 03/03/2020 0.10 119.00 Telephone conference with Attorney C. Pearson regarding settlement. 03/04/2020 0.30 357.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding settlement. 03/05/2020 1.20 1,428.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding settlement and trial issues. 03/05/2020 3.10 3,689.00 Conduct research regarding settlement structure in other consumer cases. 03/05/2020 0.40 476.00 Exchange e-mail with counsel regarding Joint Exhibit List. 03/05/2020 0.80 952.00 Review of revised Joint Exhibit List. 03/05/2020 0.60 714.00 Work on Plaintiffs' Amended Trial Exhibit List. 03/05/2020 0.30 357.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel Plaintiffs' Amended Trial Exhibit List. 03/05/2020 0.50 595.00 Complete preparation of Plaintiffs' Amended Trial Exhibit List. 03/05/2020 0.20 238.00 Attention to filing Joint Exhibit List. 03/05/2020 0.20 238.00 Attention to filing Plaintiffs' Amended Exhibit List. 03/05/2020 0.10 119.00 Review of order regarding courtesy copies. 03/06/2020 1.20 1,428.00 Conduct research regarding cases supporting a second distribution. 03/06/2020 0.20 238.00 Conference with Attorney A. Simon regarding research and preparation of a memorandum regarding second distribution to class members. 03/06/2020 1.10 1,309.00 Review of and revise Plaintiffs' Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law. 03/06/2020 0.60 714.00 Review of An Empirical Look at Compensation in Consumer Class Actions regarding distribution of settlement funds. 03/07/2020 1.40 1,666.00 Further preparation of settlement agreement. 03/07/2020 1.90 2,261.00 Review of and revise long form, post card and e-mail notices. 03/07/2020 0.30 357.00 Review of and revise memorandum regarding second distribution to class members. 03/08/2020 1.10 1,309.00 Preparation of revisions to e-mail, long form and post card notice. 03/08/2020 0.80 952.00 Review of and revise memo regarding second distribution. 03/08/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Manning and Attorney A. Simon regarding second distribution memorandum. 03/08/2020 1.10 1,309.00 Review of and revise settlement agreement. 03/08/2020 0.20 238.00 Preparation of e-mail to co-counsel regarding proposed revisions to settlement agreement. 03/09/2020 0.30 357.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding settlement status. 03/09/2020 1.40 1,666.00 Complete preparation of memorandum regarding second distribution. 03/09/2020 0.10 119.00 Preparation of email correspondence to opposing counsel with memorandum regarding second distribution. 03/09/2020 0.30 357.00 Exchange e-mail with opposing counsel regarding settlement and motion for preliminary approval. 03/09/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding settlement. 03/09/2020 2.10 2,499.00 Review of opinions cited in memorandum regarding second distribution. 03/10/2020 0.30 357.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding revisions to motion for preliminary approval. 03/10/2020 0.50 595.00 Preparation for telephone conference with counsel regarding motion for preliminary approval, settlement agreement and class notice. 03/10/2020 0.90 1,071.00 Telephone conference with Attorneys J. Lerner, E. Novikiov and Attorney J. Manning regarding motion for preliminary approval, settlement agreement and class notice. 03/11/2020 2.10 2,499.00 Review of Apple's revisions to motion for preliminary approval and further revise. 03/11/2020 0.20 238.00 Telephone call from Attorney J. Lerner regarding settlement. 03/11/2020 0.40 476.00 Numerous telephone conferences with Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement and potential settlement conference. 03/11/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding settlement issues. 03/12/2020 4.20 4,998.00 Further preparation of motion for preliminary approval. 03/13/2020 0.30 357.00 Review of Apple's revisions to the motion for preliminary approval. 03/13/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Manning regarding Apple's revisions to the motion for preliminary approval. 03/13/2020 0.40 476.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Lerner and Attorney J. Manning regarding Apple's revisions to motion for preliminary approval. 03/13/2020 0.10 119.00 Telephone call from Attorney J. Manning regarding motion for preliminary approval and settlement. 03/13/2020 0.30 357.00 Review of Apple's revisions to motion for preliminary approval. 03/13/2020 0.50 595.00 Telephone conference with Attorneys J. Lerner, E. Novikov and J. Manning regarding

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 32 of 63 Page: 31 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw Apple's comments to motion for preliminary approval. 03/13/2020 0.30 357.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding settlement issues and trial preparation. 03/13/2020 1.30 1,547.00 Work on settlement. 03/15/2020 0.20 238.00 Telephone call from Attorney J. Lerner regarding settlement terms accepted, other than fees, costs and incentive awards. 03/15/2020 0.10 119.00 Telephone call to Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement acceptance. 03/15/2020 0.20 238.00 Telephone call to Attorney C. Pearson regarding settlement acceptance. 03/16/2020 0.50 595.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Telephone conference with Attorney J. Lerner and Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement documents. 03/16/2020 1.60 1,904.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning to finalize settlement agreement, class notices and inclusion form. 03/16/2020 1.80 2,142.00 Complete preparation of revisions to application for inclusion, e-mail notice, postcard notice and settlement agreement. 03/16/2020 0.10 119.00 Preparation of e-mail to defense counsel with revisions to application for inclusion, e-mail notice, postcard notice and settlement agreement. 03/16/2020 0.40 476.00 Review of research regarding incentive awards. 03/17/2020 0.40 476.00 Telephone conference with Epiq, Attorney J. Manning and Attorney J. Lerner regarding settlement administration. 03/17/2020 0.40 476.00 Telephone call from Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement status. 03/17/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Lerner and Attorney J. Manning regarding pre-trial deadlines and agreement regarding same. 03/17/2020 0.30 357.00 Review of pre-trial order regarding trigger dates for pre-trial deadlines. 03/17/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding settlement status. 03/17/2020 0.10 119.00 Review of Order to File Joint Settlement Status Report. 03/18/2020 0.60 714.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Lerner and Attorney J. Manning regarding motion for preliminary approval. 03/18/2020 0.20 238.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement. 03/18/2020 0.60 714.00 Review of revised notices. 03/18/2020 0.30 357.00 Communications with co-counsel regarding revisions to notice documents to include the dollar amount of settlement. 03/18/2020 0.30 357.00 Revise long form notice. 03/18/2020 0.40 476.00 Communications with Apple's counsel regarding revisions to notice documents and claim form. 03/18/2020 1.10 1,309.00 Conduct research regarding claim form and penalty of perjury requirement. 03/18/2020 0.50 595.00 Further preparation of motion for preliminary approval regarding comparable case. 03/18/2020 0.30 357.00 Review of revised estimate from Epiq. 03/19/2020 0.10 119.00 Review of status report filed by Apple. 03/19/2020 0.40 476.00 Exchange e-mail with defense counsel and Attorney J. Manning regarding proposed revisions to class notices and motion for preliminary approval. 03/20/2020 0.40 476.00 Review of Apple's revisions to the settlement agreement. 03/20/2020 0.50 595.00 Review of Apple's changes to motion for preliminary approval. 03/20/2020 0.40 476.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning and Attorney J. Lerner regarding settlement. 03/20/2020 1.20 1,428.00 Numerous communications with co-counsel regarding settlement. 03/20/2020 0.10 119.00 Review of Order Regarding: Pretrial Deadlines and Motion for Preliminary Approval. 03/20/2020 0.30 357.00 Exchange e-mail with and telephone call to Attorney J. Manning regarding Pretrial Deadlines and Motion for Preliminary Approval. 03/21/2020 1.30 1,547.00 Review of Apple's revisions to the Settlement Agreement, Inclusion Form and Long Form Notice and make further revisions to the same. 03/21/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Manning regarding revisions to settlement agreement and long form notice. 03/22/2020 1.10 1,309.00 Complete preparation of revisions to settlement agreement and long form notice. 03/22/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Lerner regarding settlement agreement and long form notice. 03/23/2020 0.10 119.00 Preparation of e-mail to Attorney J. Lerner regarding filing regarding trial stipulations. 03/23/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding filing regarding trial stipulations. 03/23/2020 0.30 357.00 Review of co-counsel's revisions to motion for preliminary approval. 03/23/2020 0.20 238.00 Review of further revisions to motion for preliminary approval by Attorney A. Simon. 03/24/2020 0.60 714.00 Numerous communications with Attorney J. Manning regarding revisions to settlement documents and motion for preliminary approval. 03/24/2020 0.30 357.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Lerner regarding examples of claim forms and notice from In Re: Carrier IQ. 03/24/2020 0.20 238.00 Review of Apple's revisions to long form notice. 03/24/2020 0.50 595.00 Review of Apple's revisions to motion for preliminary approval.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 33 of 63 Page: 32 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw 03/24/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with Inventus regarding taking document review platform offline. 03/25/2020 2.60 3,094.00 Work on motion for preliminary approval, settlement agreement, post card notice, e-mail notice and long form notice. 03/25/2020 0.70 833.00 Numerous communications with Attorney J. Manning regarding motion for preliminary approval, settlement agreement, post card notice, e-mail notice and long form notice. 03/25/2020 0.80 952.00 Preparation for and telephone conference with Attorneys J. Lerner, J. Rose, E. Novikov and J. Manning regarding settlement issues. 03/25/2020 0.70 833.00 Work on next turn of settlement agreement. 03/25/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding draft settlement agreement. 03/25/2020 0.30 357.00 Review of revisions Attorney D. Tejtel's revisions to settlement agreement. 03/25/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with M. Masterson regarding document review platform. 03/25/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with J. Hick at Inventus regarding page count and document count of documents produce by Apple. 03/25/2020 0.30 357.00 Verify document and page count of documents produced by Apple. 03/25/2020 1.70 2,023.00 Review of and revise Attorney J. Manning's revisions to motion for preliminary approval. 03/26/2020 0.30 357.00 Review of revisions to the motion for preliminary approval. 03/26/2020 1.10 1,309.00 Review of Apple's revisions to the long form notice, e-mail notice, post card notice, request for inclusion and settlement agreement. 03/27/2020 0.40 476.00 Preparation for telephone conference with Apple's counsel and co-counsel regarding settlement documents and motion for preliminary approval. 03/27/2020 0.50 595.00 Telephone conference with Apple's counsel and Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement documents and motion for preliminary approval. 03/27/2020 0.70 833.00 Preparation for and telephone conference with Attorney J. Lerner and Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement. 03/27/2020 0.60 714.00 Review of and revise Attorney J. Manning's revisions to class notices, application for inclusion and settlement agreement. 03/30/2020 9.40 11,186.00 Further preparation of motion for preliminary approval, Warshaw Declaration and Proposed Order. 03/31/2020 0.20 238.00 Telephone call from Attorney A. Simon regarding motion for preliminary approval. 03/31/2020 0.80 952.00 Review of and revise draft proposed order regarding motion for preliminary approval. 03/31/2020 0.30 357.00 Review of Apple's revisions to motion for preliminary approval. 03/31/2020 1.60 1,904.00 Work on Warshaw Declaration in support of motion for preliminary approval. 03/31/2020 0.70 833.00 Numerous communications with Apple's counsel and Attorney J. Manning regarding finalization of settlement and motion for preliminary approval. 04/01/2020 0.40 476.00 Telephone conferences with Attorney J. Manning regarding latest versions of class notice documents and proposed modifications to same. 04/01/2020 0.60 714.00 Review of latest versions of class notice documents and edit long form notice. 04/01/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorneys J. Lerner and J. Rose regarding notice documents. 04/01/2020 0.10 119.00 Review of draft joint settlement statement status report. 04/01/2020 0.10 119.00 Revise draft joint settlement statement status report. 04/01/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Manning regarding draft joint settlement statement status report. 04/01/2020 1.20 1,428.00 Conduct research regarding requirements to identify cy pres in notice documents. 04/01/2020 0.40 476.00 Review of Attorney A. Simon's research regarding requirements to identify cy pres in notice documents. 04/01/2020 0.30 357.00 Preparation of e-mail to Attorney J. Lerner summarizing law on requirement to identify cy pres recipient in notice documents and settlement agreement. 04/01/2020 0.20 238.00 Numerous telephone conferences with co-counsel regarding requirement to identify cy pres in notice documents and settlement agreement. 04/01/2020 0.40 476.00 Conference with Attorney A. Simon regarding motion for preliminary approval. 04/02/2020 2.60 3,094.00 Conduct research regarding the Rose Foundation as a potential cy pres recipient. 04/02/2020 0.30 357.00 Telephone call from Attorney A. Simon regarding settlement status and cy pres. 04/02/2020 0.60 714.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel and Attorney J. Lerner regarding cy pres. 04/02/2020 0.20 238.00 Review of Apple's revisions to the long form notice and post card notice. 04/02/2020 0.20 238.00 Review of revisions to settlement agreement concerning request for exclusion. 04/03/2020 0.30 357.00 Review of revised settlement agreement from Apple. 04/03/2020 0.30 357.00 Telephone call to Attorney J. Manning regarding revisions to settlement agreement. 04/03/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with counsel regarding revisions to settlement agreement. 04/03/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding cy pres and Rose Foundation affiliations. 04/06/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with defense counsel regarding status of settlement agreement and motion for preliminary approval. 04/07/2020 0.80 952.00 Further preparation of motion for preliminary approval.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 34 of 63 Page: 33 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw 04/07/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Rose regarding motion for preliminary approval revisions. 04/07/2020 0.10 119.00 Preparation of e-mail to co-counsel regarding motion for preliminary approval and relate documents. 04/07/2020 0.10 119.00 Review of e-mail from Judge Cousins. 04/07/2020 0.30 357.00 Communications with Attorney C. Pearson regarding e-mail from Judge Cousins. 04/08/2020 0.30 357.00 Review of Apple's revised settlement agreement. 04/08/2020 0.30 357.00 Review of Apple's revisions to the motion for preliminary approval. 04/08/2020 0.20 238.00 Review of order staying case. 04/08/2020 0.50 595.00 Communications with counsel regarding stay. 04/08/2020 1.00 1,190.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding settlement and motion for preliminary approval. 04/09/2020 0.20 238.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement status. 04/09/2020 0.30 357.00 Telephone conference with Attorneys J. Lerner, J. Rose, and J. Manning regarding cy pres. 04/09/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with Apple's counsel regarding latest version of settlement agreement and motion for preliminary approval. 04/09/2020 0.30 357.00 Communications with Attorney J. Manning regarding Apple's revisions to settlement agreement. 04/09/2020 0.40 476.00 Review of revised settlement agreement. 04/09/2020 0.40 476.00 Review of revised motion for preliminary approval. 04/09/2020 0.30 357.00 Telephone conference with Apple's counsel and Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement agreement and motion for preliminary approval. 04/10/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding verification of procedural history and discovery exchanged to be included in motion for preliminary approval. 04/13/2020 0.50 595.00 Telephone conference with T. Little of the Rose Foundation regarding cy pres program. 04/13/2020 0.20 238.00 Telephone call to Attorney J. Manning regarding cy pres. 04/13/2020 0.30 357.00 Conduct research regarding Rose Foundation approved as cy pres in the northern district. 04/14/2020 0.20 238.00 Review of revisions to Warshaw declaration and proposed order in support of motion for preliminary approval. 04/14/2020 1.20 1,428.00 Conduct research regarding cy pres candidates. 04/14/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with T. Little of Rose Foundation regarding structure of cy pres and previous court approvals. 04/14/2020 1.40 1,666.00 Review of materials provided by T. Little of Rose Foundation regarding applicable funds and appointments as cy pres. 04/15/2020 0.40 476.00 Create redline of Apple's final settlement agreement and review same. 04/15/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Manning regarding final settlement agreement. 04/15/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with defense counsel regarding final settlement agreement. 04/15/2020 1.20 1,428.00 Further preparation of motion for preliminary approval. 04/15/2020 0.10 119.00 Preparation of e-mail to Attorney J. Manning regarding motion for preliminary approval. 04/15/2020 0.20 238.00 Review of memorandum regarding procedural history to be included in MPA. 04/16/2020 0.30 357.00 Exchange e-mail with defense cancel regarding settlement agreement. 04/16/2020 0.30 357.00 Communicate with Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement status. 04/16/2020 0.30 357.00 Exchange e-mail with Apple's counsel and Attorney J. Manning regarding logistics for execution of final settlement agreement and timing. 04/17/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with Apple's counsel regarding status of execution of the settlement agreement. 04/20/2020 0.40 476.00 Communications with clients and co-counsel regarding executing settlement agreement. 04/20/2020 0.20 238.00 Preparation of settlement agreement for electronic signature. Process same. 04/20/2020 0.20 238.00 Review of revisions to motion for preliminary approval. 04/21/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Lerner regarding fully executed settlement and Apple's revisions to motion for preliminary approval. 04/22/2020 1.10 1,309.00 Further preparation of motion for preliminary approval. 04/22/2020 0.20 238.00 Further preparation of Warshaw declaration. 04/23/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorneys J. Lerner and J. Rose regarding motion for preliminary approval. 04/23/2020 0.30 357.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Manning regarding motion for preliminary approval. 04/24/2020 3.30 3,927.00 Complete preparation of motion for preliminary approval. 04/24/2020 0.20 238.00 Complete preparation of Warshaw declaration in support of motion for preliminary approval.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 35 of 63 Page: 34 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw 04/24/2020 0.20 238.00 Review of defendant's revisions to motion for preliminary approval. 04/24/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with defense counsel and co-counsel regarding motion for preliminary approval. 04/24/2020 0.20 238.00 Telephone call from Attorney D. Tejtel regarding case status. 04/24/2020 0.30 357.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Lerner and Attorney J. Manning regarding available hearing date for motion for preliminary approval and requirement to disclose all agreements per FRCP 23(e)(3). 04/24/2020 0.30 357.00 Review of Apple's revisions to motion for preliminary approval. 04/24/2020 1.10 1,309.00 Preparation of further revisions to motion for preliminary approval. 04/25/2020 0.20 238.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning and Attorney J. Lerner regarding hearing date for motion for preliminary approval. 04/27/2020 2.60 3,094.00 Preparation for motion for preliminary approval, Warshaw declaration and proposed order for filing. 04/27/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Lerner and Attorney J. Manning regarding hearing date for motion for preliminary approval. 04/29/2020 0.20 238.00 Review of administrative motion to seal confidential attachment to settlement. 05/08/2020 0.20 238.00 Review of CAFA notice. 06/09/2020 0.20 238.00 Telephone conference with J. Mottek regarding claims administration plan. 06/18/2020 0.30 357.00 Telephone call from M. Masterson of Inventus regarding document hosting. 06/19/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with T. Little from Rose Foundation regarding status of settlement. 06/19/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with M. Masterson of Inventus regarding document review hosting costs. 08/03/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Manning regarding hearing on motion for preliminary approval. 08/03/2020 0.10 119.00 Review of court's calendar and scheduling notes. 08/18/2020 0.10 119.00 Review of order regarding motion for preliminary approval and request for binder. 08/18/2020 0.10 119.00 Preparation of e-mail to Attorney J. Manning regarding court's request for binder. 08/25/2020 0.10 119.00 Review of Court's website regarding hearing information for motion for preliminary approval. 08/25/2020 0.60 714.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding motion for preliminary approval. 08/31/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding appearances at hearing on motion for preliminary approval. 09/01/2020 0.10 119.00 Telephone call from Attorney J. Lerner regarding class metrics. 09/01/2020 0.10 119.00 Review of e-mail from Epiq regarding class metrics. 09/01/2020 4.70 5,593.00 Plan and prepare for hearing on motion for preliminary approval. 09/02/2020 0.60 714.00 Telephone conference with Attorneys J. Manning, J. Lerner, and E. Novikov regarding hearing on motion for preliminary approval. 09/02/2020 0.20 238.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding motion for preliminary approval hearing. 09/02/2020 8.20 9,758.00 Plan and prepare for hearing on motion for preliminary approval. 09/03/2020 4.70 5,593.00 Plan and prepare for hearing on motion for preliminary approval. 09/03/2020 1.40 1,666.00 Attend hearing on motion for preliminary approval. 09/03/2020 0.50 595.00 Numerous telephone conferences with co-counsel regarding motion for preliminary approval hearing. 09/04/2020 0.20 238.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning and Attorney J. Lerner regarding cy pres. 09/07/2020 2.10 2,499.00 Preparation of redlined Angeion and JND proposals. 09/07/2020 0.50 595.00 Preparation of Supplemental Submission in Support of Motion for Preliminary Approval. 09/07/2020 0.20 238.00 Review of and revise administrative motion to seal Supplemental Submission in Support of Motion for Preliminary Approval. 09/07/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Manning regarding cy pres. 09/08/2020 0.90 1,071.00 Telephone conference with Attorney D. Tejtel regarding revisions to JND and Angeion proposals. 09/08/2020 2.10 2,499.00 Revise redlined JND and Angeion proposals to be submitted to the Court. 09/08/2020 0.60 714.00 Numerous communications with Attorney J. Lerner regarding cy pres, supplemental submission to court regarding motion for preliminary approval and motion to seal. 09/08/2020 1.20 1,428.00 Conduct research regarding Consumer Federation of America. 09/08/2020 0.10 119.00 Telephone call to Attorney J. Manning regarding cy pres recipients. 09/08/2020 0.30 357.00 Review of numerous revisions from Attorney J. Lerner to supplemental submission. 09/08/2020 0.70 833.00 Complete preparation of supplemental submission. 09/08/2020 0.30 357.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding revisions to plaintiffs' supplemental submission in support of motion for preliminary approval and administration motion to seal.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 36 of 63 Page: 35 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 3 Daniel L. Warshaw 09/09/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Manning regarding preliminary approval. 09/10/2020 0.20 238.00 Review of order granting preliminary approval. 09/10/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with co-counsel regarding order granting preliminary approval. 09/10/2020 0.40 476.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding order granting preliminary approval and next steps. 09/10/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with Epiq team regarding order granting motion for preliminary approval. 09/10/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with M. Potter of JND regarding declaration supporting motion to seal JND proposal. 09/11/2020 0.30 357.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning regarding settlement notice schedule. 09/11/2020 0.20 238.00 Preparation of timeline for notice and claims administration. 09/11/2020 0.50 595.00 Telephone conference with Attorney J. Manning and Epiq team regarding time line for notice and claims administration. 09/11/2020 0.20 238.00 Review of Epiq's time line for notice and claims administration. 09/14/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with S. Weisbrot of Angeion regarding declaration supporting motion to seal Angeion proposal. 09/16/2020 0.20 238.00 Numerous telephone conferences with Attorney J. Manning regarding schedule of events and assignments. 09/16/2020 0.20 238.00 Exchange e-mail with JND regarding timeline. 09/16/2020 0.20 238.00 Review of revised JND timeline. 09/17/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with Epiq, co-counsel and defense counsel regarding timeline of events. 09/21/2020 0.10 119.00 Preparation of e-mail to defense counsel regarding notice documents and settlement administrator e-mail address. 09/25/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Rose regarding online claims. 09/25/2020 0.10 119.00 Preparation of e-mail to B. Pinkerton regarding online claims. 09/25/2020 0.20 238.00 Review of IVR script. 09/25/2020 0.30 357.00 Review of settlement website. 09/29/2020 0.30 357.00 Review of revisions to postcard notice, IVR script and case website. 09/29/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Manning regarding revisions to notice documents, settlement website and IVR script. 09/29/2020 1.00 1,190.00 Exchange e-mail with B. Pinkerton, Attorney J. Manning and defense counsel regarding approval of notice documents, settlement website and IVR script. 10/06/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Manning regarding business class member claim form. 10/06/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail Attorney J. Rose regarding business class member claim form. 10/12/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with Attorney J. Manning regarding class member inquiry concerning claim form. 10/12/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with class member L. Garcia regarding claim update. 10/12/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with B. Pinkerton regarding L. Garcia claim. 10/12/2020 0.10 119.00 Exchange e-mail with class member K. Buchanan and B. Pinkerton regarding claim. 10/20/2020 0.30 357.00 Telephone conference with Attorneys J. Manning, J. Lerner, E. Novikov and J. Rose regarding claims process.

Total for Timekeeper 3 Billable 982.50 1,077,456.50 Daniel L. Warshaw

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 37 of 63 Page: 36 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 4 Matthew A. Pearson 01/09/2018 7.20 2,880.00 Document Review of batch 2017_12_14 Facetime_00010. 01/10/2018 6.10 2,440.00 Document Review of batch 2017_12_14 Facetime_00010. 01/10/2018 2.00 800.00 Document Review of batch 2017_12_14 Facetime_00013. 01/11/2018 8.00 3,200.00 Document Review of batch 2017_12_14 Facetime_00013. 01/17/2018 0.40 160.00 Conference call regarding document review. 01/17/2018 1.00 400.00 Document Review of batch 2017_12_14 Facetime_00013. 01/18/2018 2.20 880.00 Document Review of batch 2017_12_14 Facetime_00013. 01/19/2018 3.00 1,200.00 Document Review of batch 2017_12_14 Facetime_00013. 01/22/2018 5.90 2,360.00 Document Review of batch 2017_12_14 Facetime 13. 01/23/2018 7.10 2,840.00 Document Review of batch 2017_12_14 Facetime_00020. 01/24/2018 0.80 320.00 Document Review of batch 2017_12_14 Facetime_20. 01/25/2018 7.90 3,160.00 Document Review of batch 2017_12_14 Facetime_20. 01/26/2018 8.00 3,200.00 Document Review of batch 2017_12_14 Facetime_22. 01/29/2018 2.50 1,000.00 Document Review of batch 2017_12_14 Facetime_22. 01/30/2018 4.00 1,600.00 Document Review of batch 2017_12_14 Facetime_22. 01/30/2018 4.70 1,880.00 Document Review of batch 2017_12_14 Facetime_26. 01/31/2018 6.40 2,560.00 Document Review of batch 2017_12_14 Facetime_26. 01/31/2018 0.40 160.00 Weekly document review conference call. 02/01/2018 2.00 800.00 Document Review of batch 2017_12_14 Facetime_26. 02/02/2018 7.20 2,880.00 Document Review of batch 2017_12_14 Facetime_00029. 02/05/2018 3.90 1,560.00 Document Review of batch 2017_12_14 Facetime_00029. 02/05/2018 4.00 1,600.00 Document Review of batch 2017_12_14 Facetime_00032. 02/06/2018 6.20 2,480.00 Document Review of batch 2017_12_14 Facetime_0032. 02/06/2018 2.00 800.00 Document Review of batch 2017_12_14 Facetime_00034. 02/07/2018 3.70 1,480.00 Document Review of batch 2017_12_14 Facetime_00034. 02/07/2018 3.00 1,200.00 Tier 2 document review. 02/07/2018 0.30 120.00 Conference call regarding document review. 02/08/2018 4.00 1,600.00 Tier 2 Document Review of documents for 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/09/2018 4.80 1,920.00 Tier 2 document review of searches for 30(b)(6) deposition preparation. 02/09/2018 3.00 1,200.00 Document Review of batch 2017_12_14 Facetime_00034. 02/12/2018 2.00 800.00 Document Review of batch 2017_12_14 Facetime_00034. 02/13/2018 2.10 840.00 Tier 2 document review. 02/13/2018 4.00 1,600.00 Document Review of batch 2017_12_14 Facetime_00034. 02/13/2018 0.50 200.00 Document Review of batch Apple 2.2.2018 Production -Emails Part I00005. 02/14/2018 5.80 2,320.00 Document Review of batch Apple 2.2.2018 Production -Emails Part I00005. 02/15/2018 7.10 2,840.00 Document Review of batch Apple 2.2.2018 Production -Emails Part I00005. 02/16/2018 4.70 1,880.00 Document Review of batch Apple 2.2.2018 Production -Emails Part I00005. 02/16/2018 4.00 1,600.00 Document Review of batch Apple Customer Logs Produced 2.2.2018 Part 1_00001. 02/19/2018 2.80 1,120.00 Document Review of batch Apple Customer Logs Produced 2.2.2018 Part 1_00001. 02/20/2018 7.10 2,840.00 Document Review of batch Apple Customer Logs Produced 2.2.2018 Part 1_00001. 02/21/2018 4.60 1,840.00 Document Review of batch Apple Customer Logs Produced 2.2.2018 Part 1_00001. 02/22/2018 1.00 400.00 Document Review of batch Apple Customer Logs Produced 2.2.2018 Part 1_00001. 02/23/2018 3.60 1,440.00 Document Review of batch Apple Customer Logs Produced 2.2.2018 Part 1_00001. 02/23/2018 3.20 1,280.00 Document Review of batch Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800001. 02/26/2018 6.30 2,520.00 Document Review of batch Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800001. 02/27/2018 2.80 1,120.00 Document Review of batch Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800001. 02/27/2018 2.00 800.00 Document Review of batch Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800004 (double batch). 02/28/2018 4.10 1,640.00 Document Review of batch Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800004 (double batch). 03/07/2018 3.40 1,360.00 Document Review of batch Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800004 (double batch). 03/08/2018 1.90 760.00 Document Review of batch Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800004 (double batch). 03/09/2018 5.50 2,200.00 Document Review of batch Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800004 (double batch). 03/12/2018 7.90 3,160.00 Document Review of batch Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800010. 03/14/2018 4.70 1,880.00 Document Review of batch Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800010. 03/14/2018 1.20 480.00 Document Review of batch Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800014. 03/14/2018 0.20 80.00 Weekly call to discuss document review. 03/14/2018 0.20 80.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney V. Glaze regarding document review. 03/15/2018 0.60 240.00 Document Review of batch Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800014. 03/16/2018 2.70 1,080.00 Tier two Document Review of consumer log searches. 03/19/2018 1.00 400.00 Tier two Document Review of consumer log searches.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 38 of 63 Page: 37 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 4 Matthew A. Pearson 03/20/2018 0.80 320.00 Tier two Document Review of consumer log searches. 03/21/2018 1.40 560.00 Tier two Document Review of consumer log searches. 03/27/2018 3.40 1,360.00 Tier two Document Review of consumer log searches. 03/28/2018 5.50 2,200.00 Tier two document review of consumer logs. 03/29/2018 4.00 1,600.00 Document Review of searches of customer logs. 03/30/2018 3.00 1,200.00 Document Review of searches of customer logs. 04/03/2018 2.30 920.00 Tier two document review of customer logs. 04/03/2018 0.70 280.00 Document Review of batch 2017.12.22 _Apple Production_00004. 04/03/2018 0.50 200.00 Document Review of batch 2017.12.22 _Apple Production_00005. 04/03/2018 1.00 400.00 Document Review of batch 2017.12.22 _Apple Production_00006. 04/04/2018 5.90 2,360.00 Document Review of batch 2017.12.22 _Apple Production_00007. 04/05/2018 6.20 2,480.00 Document Review of batch 2017.12.22 _Apple Production_00007. 04/06/2018 3.80 1,520.00 Document Review of batch 2017.12.22 _Apple Production_00008. 04/06/2018 3.50 1,400.00 Document Review of batch 2017.12.22 _Apple Production_00009. 04/10/2018 1.90 760.00 Document Review of batch 2017.12.22 _Apple Production_00009. 04/30/2018 4.20 1,680.00 Document Review of batch 2017.12.22 _Apple Production_00009. 05/01/2018 5.10 2,040.00 Document Review of batch 2017.12.22 _Apple Production_00010. 05/01/2018 2.10 840.00 Document Review of batch 2017.12.22 _Apple Production_00009. 05/02/2018 2.00 800.00 Document Review of batch 2017.12.22 _Apple Production_00011 05/03/2018 0.90 360.00 Document Review of batch 2017.12.22 _Apple Production_00011. 05/08/2018 3.10 1,240.00 Document Review of batch 2017.12.22 _Apple Production_00011. 05/08/2018 1.00 400.00 Document Review of batch 1.29.2018 Facetime Production- Customer Logs00005. 05/09/2018 4.70 1,880.00 Document Review of batch 1.29.2018 Facetime Production- Customer Logs00005. 05/10/2018 4.10 1,640.00 Document Review of batch 1.29.2018 Facetime Production- Customer Logs00005. 05/11/2018 4.00 1,600.00 Document Review of batch 1.29.2018 Facetime Production- Customer Logs00005. 08/23/2019 1.00 450.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) strategy call with Plaintiffs' counsel.

Total for Timekeeper 4 Billable 294.80 117,970.00 Matthew A. Pearson

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 39 of 63 Page: 38 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 5 Veronica W. Glaze 10/03/2017 0.20 104.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding setting up the database and protocols that will be used to review documents produced by Defendant. 10/06/2017 0.20 104.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding setting up the database and protocols that will be used to review documents produced by Defendant. 10/08/2017 3.20 1,664.00 Review/analyze Complaint and the Court's Order regarding Motion to Dismiss. 10/09/2017 0.20 104.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding setting up the database and protocols that will be used to review documents produced by Defendant. 10/18/2017 0.30 156.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Attorneys D. Tejtel; K. DiGiovanni; M. Lee and paralegal P. Gravley regarding the status of the review of Defendant's documents. 10/19/2017 0.20 104.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Attorney K. DiGiovanni regarding how to code a particular document produced by Defendant. 10/31/2017 2.70 1,404.00 Draft/revise report of Hot documents in preparation of meeting with Co-Counsel. 11/02/2017 0.40 208.00 Communicate (other external) expert J. Hastings and Attorneys D. Warshaw and J. Manning regarding providing documents for expert analysis. 11/02/2017 0.70 364.00 Review/analyze documents needed for expert analysis. 12/22/2017 0.20 104.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding loading a Facetime production into Plaintiffs' document database. 12/28/2017 0.20 104.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Attorneys J. Manning and D. Warshaw regarding loading recent production into the document database and document review assignments. 12/28/2017 0.60 312.00 Manage and create batch assignments of recent productions. 01/08/2018 0.30 156.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Attorneys J. Manning and D. Warshaw regarding the management of the review of documents produced by Defendant. 01/08/2018 3.70 1,924.00 Review/analyze documents produced by Defendant. 01/10/2018 0.20 104.00 Communicate (other external) eDiscovery platform manager E. Buntain regarding running search terms. 01/10/2018 0.20 104.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Attorney J. Manning regarding the management of the review of Defendant's documents. 01/10/2018 2.20 1,144.00 Review/analyze Tier 1 documents produced by Defendant. 01/10/2018 1.00 520.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Attorney W. McCarty regarding training on how to review documents produced by Defendant in Relativity. 01/11/2018 0.30 156.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with Attorneys A. Simon, M. Pearson, K. DiGiovanni, M. Lee, W. McCarty, C. Weiss et al regarding the management of the review of Defendant's documents. 01/12/2018 0.60 312.00 Communicate (other external) eDiscovery platform manager E. Buntain regarding running search terms, creating reports and fixing technical difficulties in the system. 01/15/2018 7.80 4,056.00 Review/analyze documents produced by Defendant. 01/16/2018 8.90 4,628.00 Review/analyze documents produced by Defendant. 01/17/2018 10.20 5,304.00 Review/analyze documents produced by Defendant. 01/17/2018 0.30 156.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Co-Lead counsel and attorneys performing document review to discuss the status and pace of the review and answer questions on how to code documents. 01/18/2018 9.30 4,836.00 Review/analyze documents produced by Defendant. 01/19/2018 9.60 4,992.00 Review/analyze documents produced by Defendant. 01/22/2018 2.50 1,300.00 Perform quality control review of Defendant's documents coded by Plaintiffs counsel. 01/23/2018 0.20 104.00 Communicate (other external) Attorney D. Warshaw and database administrator E. Buntain regarding loading recent Apple productions into the e-discovery database for review. 01/23/2018 4.10 2,132.00 Perform quality control review of Defendant's documents coded by Plaintiffs counsel. 01/24/2018 0.30 156.00 Communicate (in firm) Attorneys A. Simon and D. Warshaw regarding the management of the review of documents produced by Defendant. 01/24/2018 0.20 104.00 Communicate (other external) Attorneys J. Manning and D. Warshaw and database administrator E. Buntain regarding loading recent Apple productions into the e-discovery database for review. 01/29/2018 7.70 4,004.00 Tier 2 Document Review of documents produced by Defendant. 01/30/2018 2.90 1,508.00 Tier 2 Document Review of documents produced by Defendant. 01/31/2018 5.80 3,016.00 Tier 2 Document Review of documents produced by Defendant. 01/31/2018 0.50 260.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Co-Lead counsel and attorneys performing document review to discuss the status and pace of the review and answer questions on how to code documents. 01/31/2018 0.30 156.00 Communicate (other external) Inventus representative and Attorney D. Warshaw to run statistics on the progress of the document review to date. 02/01/2018 8.30 4,316.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant. 02/02/2018 2.20 1,144.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 40 of 63 Page: 39 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 5 Veronica W. Glaze 02/02/2018 4.80 2,496.00 Review/analyze documents in preparation for Apple's 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/05/2018 6.30 3,276.00 Review/analyze documents in preparation for Apple's 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/06/2018 7.40 3,848.00 Review/analyze documents in preparation for Apple's 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/06/2018 0.60 312.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) for Plaintiffs regarding drafting and editing the Joint Case Management Statement. 02/07/2018 0.30 156.00 Communicate (other external) Inventus representative E. Buntain regarding running large search strings in documents produced by Defendant Apple. 02/07/2018 0.20 104.00 Communicate (other external) Inventus representative E. Buntain regarding running document review statistics reports. 02/07/2018 0.20 104.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney Matt Pearson regarding assignment to review documents in preparation for Apple's 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/07/2018 0.30 156.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney A. Simon regarding assignment to review documents in preparation for Apple's 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/07/2018 8.40 4,368.00 Review/analyze documents in preparation for Apple's 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/07/2018 0.50 260.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Counsel for Plaintiffs performing the review of documents produced by Apple regarding the status of the review, coding, and new assignments. 02/08/2018 0.30 156.00 Manage data/files and batch documents recently produced by Defendant Apple. 02/08/2018 0.50 260.00 Communicate (other external) Inventus representative E. Buntain regarding running large search strings in documents produced by Defendant Apple. 02/08/2018 7.20 3,744.00 Review/analyze documents in preparation for Apple's 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/08/2018 0.20 104.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney A. Simon regarding assignment to review documents in preparation for Apple's 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/08/2018 0.20 104.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorneys D. Warshaw and A. Simon regarding assignment to review documents in preparation for Apple's 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/09/2018 9.30 4,836.00 Tier 2 Review and analysis of documents in preparation for the Apple 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/12/2018 9.10 4,732.00 Tier 2 Review and analysis of documents in preparation for the Apple 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/13/2018 5.20 2,704.00 Tier 2 Review and analysis of documents in preparation for the Apple 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/13/2018 4.60 2,392.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant Apple. 02/14/2018 9.40 4,888.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Apple. 02/14/2018 0.30 156.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) document review attorneys regarding the status of the review, changes to coding procedures and future assignments. 02/15/2018 7.70 4,004.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Apple. 02/16/2018 7.50 3,900.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Apple. 02/20/2018 9.30 4,836.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Apple. 02/21/2018 7.20 3,744.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Apple. 02/21/2018 0.70 364.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Counsel for Plaintiffs' regarding strategy. 02/21/2018 0.10 52.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Plaintiffs' attorneys performing a review of documents produced by Apple concerning assignments and instructions. 02/22/2018 6.20 3,224.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Apple. 02/22/2018 0.20 104.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding management of the review of documents produced by Defendant Apple. 02/22/2018 0.10 52.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Plaintiffs' attorneys performing a review of documents produced by Apple concerning assignments and instructions. 02/23/2018 8.90 4,628.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Apple. 02/23/2018 0.20 104.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Plaintiffs' attorneys performing a review of documents produced by Apple concerning assignments and instructions. 02/26/2018 7.30 3,796.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant Apple. 02/27/2018 5.20 2,704.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant Apple. 02/28/2018 0.80 416.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant Apple. 02/28/2018 0.30 156.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding the status of Plaintiffs' review of documents produced by Defendant Apple. 02/28/2018 0.10 52.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Plaintiffs' document review attorneys regarding document review assignments for the week. 03/02/2018 9.10 4,732.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant Apple. 03/05/2018 9.40 4,888.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant Apple. 03/06/2018 8.20 4,264.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant Apple. 03/07/2018 8.80 4,576.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant Apple. 03/07/2018 0.20 104.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Plaintiffs' document review attorneys regarding document review assignments for the week. 03/07/2018 0.70 364.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Counsel for Plaintiffs' regarding strategy and

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 41 of 63 Page: 40 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 5 Veronica W. Glaze discovery matters. 03/08/2018 8.30 4,316.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant Apple. 03/09/2018 8.70 4,524.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant Apple. 03/12/2018 9.30 4,836.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant Apple. 03/13/2018 8.80 4,576.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant Apple. 03/14/2018 9.80 5,096.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant Apple. 03/15/2018 3.30 1,716.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant Apple. 03/16/2018 6.70 3,484.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant Apple. 03/19/2018 8.60 4,472.00 Review/analyze Tier 1 documents gathered using search terms produced by Defendant Apple. 03/20/2018 10.20 5,304.00 Review/analyze Tier 1 documents gathered using search terms produced by Defendant Apple. 03/21/2018 1.00 520.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Counsel for Plaintiffs J. Manning. S. Jain, D. Warshaw, A. Simon et al. regarding case strategy and assignments. 03/21/2018 7.40 3,848.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant Apple. 03/22/2018 8.00 4,160.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant Apple. 03/23/2018 9.90 5,148.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant Apple. 03/26/2018 8.10 4,212.00 Review/analyze second tier documents produced by Apple. 03/27/2018 9.60 4,992.00 Review/analyze second tier documents produced by Apple. 03/28/2018 0.70 364.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Counsel for Plaintiffs and J. Hastings regarding her current findings and additional discovery needed. 03/28/2018 0.30 156.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Attorneys D. Warshaw and J. Manning regarding the status of the review of documents produced by Apple. 03/28/2018 6.80 3,536.00 Review/analyze second tier documents produced by Apple. 03/29/2018 7.20 3,744.00 Review/analyze second tier documents produced by Apple. 03/30/2018 4.40 2,288.00 Review/analyze second tier documents produced by Apple. 04/02/2018 8.20 4,264.00 Perform Quality Control Review/analyze documents coded by Tier 1 document review attorneys. 04/03/2018 9.90 5,148.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents in preparation for the deposition of Dallas DeAtley. 04/04/2018 8.80 4,576.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents in preparation for the deposition of Dallas DeAtley. 04/04/2018 2.20 1,144.00 Draft/revise Plaintiffs' Motion for Class Certification 04/05/2018 7.20 3,744.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents in preparation for the deposition of Dallas DeAtley. 04/05/2018 0.80 416.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with co-counsel regarding case strategy and discovery matters. 04/06/2018 9.40 4,888.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents in preparation for the deposition of Dallas DeAtley. 04/09/2018 8.30 4,316.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents in preparation for the deposition of Dallas DeAtley. 04/10/2018 9.60 4,992.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents in preparation for the deposition of Dallas DeAtley. 04/11/2018 6.80 3,536.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents in preparation for the deposition of G. Thirumalai. 04/12/2018 7.20 3,744.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents in preparation for the deposition of G. Thirumalai. 04/12/2018 0.30 156.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) co-counsel regarding how to review and code documents in preparation of the deposition of G. Thirumalai. 04/12/2018 0.60 312.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Attorney W. McCarty regarding documents and information needed in preparation of the depositions of D. DeAtley and G. Thirumalai. 04/13/2018 8.90 4,628.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents in preparation for the deposition of G. Thirumalai. 04/16/2018 8.90 4,628.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents in preparation for the deposition of G. Thirumalai. 04/17/2018 8.70 4,524.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents in preparation for the deposition of G. Thirumalai. 04/18/2018 7.20 3,744.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents in preparation for the deposition of G. Thirumalai. 04/19/2018 1.50 780.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Counsel for Plaintiffs regarding case strategy and expert's report. 04/20/2018 7.60 3,952.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents looking for particular documents needed for Plaintiffs' Motion for Class Certification. 05/01/2018 0.60 312.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Counsel for Plaintiffs regarding case strategy, assignments, Apple's production and discovery responses. 05/07/2018 9.20 4,784.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant. 05/08/2018 7.60 3,952.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant. 05/09/2018 8.90 4,628.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant. 05/09/2018 1.10 572.00 Communicate with co-counsel regarding case strategy and assignments. 05/10/2018 7.80 4,056.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant in preparation for Discovery Bootcamp. 05/11/2018 9.40 4,888.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant in preparation for Discovery Bootcamp. 05/14/2018 9.40 4,888.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant. 05/15/2018 10.00 5,200.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 42 of 63 Page: 41 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 5 Veronica W. Glaze 05/16/2018 11.30 5,876.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant in preparation for Discovery Bootcamp. 05/17/2018 5.50 2,860.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant in preparation for Discovery Bootcamp. 05/18/2018 9.40 4,888.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendants in preparation for Discovery Bootcamp. 05/21/2018 5.20 2,704.00 Attend meeting with Plaintiffs' Counsel to discuss case strategy and ongoing discovery issues. 05/30/2018 2.10 1,092.00 Run searches and create batches in preparation for upcoming depositions. 05/31/2018 0.50 260.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Plaintiffs counsel regarding assignments that need to be performed in preparation for upcoming depositions. 06/13/2018 1.20 624.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with co-counsel regarding discovery matters and case strategy. 06/13/2018 3.80 1,976.00 Review/analyze documents in preparation for the deposition of J. Wood. 06/18/2018 0.90 468.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with co-counsel regarding response to Defendant's Opposition to Motion for Class Certification and strategy. 06/18/2018 1.30 676.00 Review/analyze documents in preparation for the deposition of J. Wood. 06/25/2018 6.20 3,224.00 Review/analyze documents in preparation for the deposition of Apple's G. Choy. 06/29/2018 4.80 2,496.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant Apple. 07/03/2018 4.20 2,184.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant Apple regarding E. Cue and C. Federeghi. 07/11/2018 7.70 4,004.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant. 07/12/2018 6.30 3,276.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant. 07/18/2018 6.20 3,224.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant. 07/19/2018 6.40 3,328.00 Review/analyze Tier 2 documents produced by Defendant. 07/23/2018 1.10 572.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with co-counsel regarding outstanding discovery matters, privilege logs, and the status of document review.

Total for Timekeeper 5 Billable 679.50 353,340.00 Veronica W. Glaze

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 43 of 63 Page: 42 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 10 Bruce L. Simon 11/23/2016 1.50 1,552.50 Review materials from Allan Steyer's office. 11/28/2016 3.20 3,312.00 Review research memorandum and draft complaint as well as comment thereon. 12/14/2016 3.00 3,105.00 Review latest version of draft complaint and further investigation. 12/19/2016 1.00 1,035.00 Review the latest draft of the complaint. 01/03/2017 1.50 1,552.50 Review current draft of complaint. 02/07/2017 1.50 1,552.50 Review materials relative to judicial assignment and telephone conference with co-counsel regarding same. 02/15/2017 2.50 2,587.50 Review research materials and discuss same with co-counsel. 04/03/2017 3.50 3,622.50 Review legal memorandum regarding restitution and draft amended complaint. 04/03/2017 0.50 517.50 Telephone conference with co-leads regarding amended complaint. 04/28/2017 1.70 1,759.50 Review case management materials. 05/15/2017 1.50 1,552.50 Review/analyze certain discovery materials including draft ESI protocol. 05/16/2017 1.00 1,035.00 Telephone conference with other plaintiffs' counsel regarding Case Management Conference. 05/17/2017 1.50 1,552.50 Meet and confer with defense counsel in advance of Case Management Conference. 05/17/2017 0.50 517.50 Meeting with Jill Manning in advance of Case Management Conference. 05/17/2017 3.00 3,105.00 Prepare for and attend Case Management Conference. 05/22/2017 1.00 1,035.00 Preparation for and telephone conference with other plaintiffs' counsel regarding Case Management Conference. 08/01/2017 1.50 1,552.50 Review order on motion to dismiss and follow up regarding same. 08/02/2017 1.00 1,035.00 Prepare for and participate in telephone conference with co-counsel regarding order on motion to dismiss. 08/14/2017 1.50 1,552.50 Review motion to dismiss order and e mails regarding same. 09/19/2017 1.50 1,552.50 Review status of discovery projects and telephone conference with co-counsel regarding same. 05/04/2018 0.30 315.00 Discuss status of class cert motion filing with Attorney A. Simon. 11/06/2018 1.50 1,575.00 Review mediation briefs and telephone conference with Attorney C. Pearson regarding strategy. 02/26/2019 0.40 460.00 E mails with co-counsel regarding SCOTUS case on 23(f). 10/14/2019 0.50 575.00 Telephone conference with Attorney C. Pearson and Attorney D. Warshaw regarding mediation and follow up on same. 10/21/2019 2.50 2,875.00 Review/analyze mediation materials and discuss with Attorney C. Pearson and Attorney D. Warshaw. 10/22/2019 9.80 11,270.00 Prepare for and attend mediation. 10/22/2019 1.30 1,495.00 Multiple e mails and discussions with co-counsel regarding settlement. 10/23/2019 0.50 575.00 E mails with co-counsel regarding term sheet. 10/23/2019 1.00 1,150.00 Telephone conference with co-counsel and follow up on items related to tentative settlement.

Total for Timekeeper 10 Billable 51.70 55,376.50 Bruce L. Simon

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 44 of 63 Page: 43 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 34 Ellowene Grant 02/03/2017 0.10 22.50 Review Civil Standing Order of Magistrate Judge Nathanael M. Cousins. 02/03/2017 0.20 45.00 Review Standing Order Regarding Case Management in Civil Cases (San Jose Division). 02/03/2017 0.10 22.50 Review Notice of Assignment to Magistrate Judge Cousins. 02/03/2017 0.30 67.50 Review Order Setting Initial Case Management Conference and ADR Deadlines. 02/07/2017 0.10 22.50 Review Proposed Summons in a Civil Action. 02/14/2017 0.10 22.50 Review Application for Admission of Attorney Pro Hac Vice (Bradley W. Caldwell). 02/14/2017 0.10 22.50 Review Application for Admission of Attorney Pro Hac Vice (Jason Cassady). 02/15/2017 0.10 22.50 Review Order Reassigning Case. 02/15/2017 0.30 67.50 Review Standing Order Regarding Civil Cases for District Judge Beth Labson Freeman. 02/16/2017 0.10 22.50 Review Notice of Appearance of Elizabeth Deeley. 02/16/2017 0.10 22.50 Review Notice of Appearance of Kristin I. Sheffield-Whitehead. 02/16/2017 0.10 22.50 Review Consent or Declination to Magistrate Judge Jurisdiction. 02/16/2017 0.10 22.50 Review Defendant Apple Inc.'s Corporate Disclosure Statement Pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 7.1. 02/16/2017 0.10 22.50 Review Defendant Apple Inc.'s Certification of Interested Entities or Persons Pursuant to Civil Local Rule 3-15. 02/21/2017 0.10 22.50 Review Joint Stipulation Extending Time for Apple Inc. to Respond to Complaint. 02/21/2017 0.10 22.50 Review Minute entry granting Motion for attorney Matthew Jason Singer to withdraw. 02/24/2017 0.10 22.50 Review Order Reassigning Case. 02/24/2017 0.10 22.50 Review Clerk's Notice Following Re-Assignment to the Honorable Lucy H. Koh. 02/28/2017 0.20 45.00 Review file in preparation of case status memorandum. 03/01/2017 0.10 22.50 Review Civil Standing order for Magistrate Judge Nathanael M. Cousins. 03/23/2017 1.40 315.00 Review Defendant Apple Inc.'s Notice of Motion and Motion to Dismiss Plaintiff's Complaint Under FRCP 12(b)(1) and 12(b)(6) and Memorandum in Support. 03/23/2017 0.10 22.50 Review [Proposed] Order Granting Defendant Apple Inc.'s Motion to Dismiss Plaintiff's Complaint. 03/23/2017 0.20 45.00 Review Defendant Apple Inc.'s Request for Judicial Notice. 03/23/2017 0.10 22.50 Review [Proposed] Order Granting Request for Judicial Notice in Support of Defendant Apple Inc.'s Motion to Dismiss Plaintiff's Complaint. 03/23/2017 1.70 382.50 Review Declaration of Elizabeth L. Deeley in Support of Defendant Apple Inc.'s Motion to Dismiss and Request for Judicial Notice. 04/06/2017 0.10 22.50 Review Order Denying as Moot Motion to Dismiss. 04/20/2017 0.20 45.00 Review Defendant Apple Inc.'s Request for Judicial Notice. 04/20/2017 0.70 157.50 Review Declaration of Elizabeth Deeley in Support of Defendant Apple Inc.'s Motion to Dismiss Plaintiffs' First Amended Complaint and Request for Judicial Notice. 04/20/2017 1.00 225.00 Review Defendant Apple Inc.'s Notice of Motion and Motion to Dismiss Plaintiffs' First Amended Complaint Under FRCP 12(b)(1) and 12(b)(6) and Memorandum in Support. 04/28/2017 0.20 45.00 Review ADR Phone Conference Scheduling Notice. 05/03/2017 1.30 292.50 Review Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendant Apple's Motion to Dismiss Plaintiffs' First Amended Complaint. 05/25/2017 0.20 45.00 Review Case Management Order. 06/08/2017 0.10 22.50 Review Stipulation and Order regarding Extension to File Stipulated Protective Order and ESI Stipulation. 06/19/2017 1.00 225.00 Review Stipulated Protective Order. 07/13/2017 1.00 225.00 Plan and prepare for hearing regarding Motion to Dismiss, including preparation of exhibit binder. 07/31/2017 1.20 270.00 Review Order Denying Apple's Motion to Dismiss. 08/14/2017 1.00 225.00 Review Apple's Answer to Amended Complaint. 08/30/2017 0.30 67.50 Review Plaintiff Grace's Interrogatories, Set One 09/29/2017 0.60 135.00 Review Defendant Apple Inc.'s Responses and Objections to Plaintiffs' Interrogatories Set One. 10/13/2017 0.20 45.00 Review Defendant's First Request for Production of Documents. 10/13/2017 0.20 45.00 Review Defendant's First Set of Interrogatories to Plaintiffs. 10/24/2017 0.70 157.50 Review Stipulated Source Code Protective Order. 10/26/2017 0.10 22.50 Review Clerk's Notice resetting November 1, 2017 Case Management Conference. 11/06/2017 0.10 22.50 Review Plaintiffs' Administrative Motion to File Under Seal Exhibit A to Joint Letter Brief Pursuant to Civil L.R. 7-11 and 79-5. 11/06/2017 0.30 67.50 Review joint letter brief. 11/06/2017 0.10 22.50 Review Declaration of John Austin Curry in Support of Plaintiffs' Administrative Motion to File Under Seal Exhibit A to Joint Letter Brief. 11/07/2017 0.10 22.50 Review Order in preparation for Discovery Hearing. 11/08/2017 0.20 45.00 Review Proposed Order on the Parties' Joint Letter Brief [ECF No. 75]. 11/08/2017 0.20 45.00 Review Proposed Order on Discovery Disputes.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 45 of 63 Page: 44 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 34 Ellowene Grant 11/08/2017 0.10 22.50 Review Order Granting Plaintiff's Administrative Motion to File Under Seal. 12/04/2017 0.30 67.50 Review Order on Discovery Disputes. 12/04/2017 0.10 22.50 Review Amended Order on Discovery Disputes. 01/02/2018 0.30 67.50 Review Plaintiffs' Notice of Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 30(b)(6) Deposition. 01/12/2018 0.50 112.50 Review Defendant Apple Inc.'s Responses and Objections to Plaintiffs' Notice of Fed. R. Civ. P. 30(b)(6) Deposition. 01/16/2018 0.10 22.50 Review objection to Subpoena from AT&T Corp. 01/16/2018 0.10 22.50 Review clerk's notice setting hearing regarding Joint Discovery Letter Brief. 01/18/2018 0.30 67.50 Review Subpoena to Testify at Deposition in a Civil Action to third party Verizon Wireless. 01/18/2018 1.40 315.00 Review Joint Discovery Letter Brief with attached exhibits. 01/19/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Order in Preparation for Discovery Hearing. 01/19/2018 1.10 247.50 Review Defendant Apple Inc.'s Second Amended Responses to Plaintiffs' First Request for Production of Documents. 01/23/2018 0.50 112.50 Review Subpoena from Defendant Apple, Inc. to AT&T Mobility, LLC. 01/23/2018 0.20 45.00 Review Declaration of Kristin Sheffield-Whitehead in Support of Plaintiffs' Administrative Motion to File Under Seal. 01/23/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Order Granting Plaintiffs' Administrative Motion to File Under Seal. 01/23/2018 0.20 45.00 Review Supplemental Brief regarding Joint Discovery Letter. 01/23/2018 0.20 45.00 Review Defendant's Supplemental Discovery Letter Brief. 01/24/2018 0.30 67.50 Review Defendant's Privilege Log. 01/24/2018 0.20 45.00 Review second supplemental responses and objections to Plaintiffs' Interrogatories, Set One. 01/25/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Amended Notice of 30(b)(6) Deposition of Defendant Apple Inc. 01/25/2018 0.60 135.00 Review January 24, 2018 Joint Discovery Letter Brief. 01/25/2018 0.20 45.00 Review Order on Discovery Disputes. 01/25/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Order Regarding January 24, 2018 Discovery Dispute. 02/07/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Joint Status Report regarding discovery dispute. 02/07/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Notice of Appearance of Tanya Louise Greene. 02/07/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Defendant's Notice of Intent to Redact January 24, 2018 Hearing Transcript. 02/07/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Notice of Deposition of Andrew Vyrros. 02/07/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Notice of Deposition of Gokul Thirumalai. 02/07/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Plaintiffs' 30(b)(6) deposition notice of Apple, Inc. 02/07/2018 0.70 157.50 Review Defendant Apple Inc.'s Third Supplemental Responses and Objections to Plaintiffs' Interrogatories, Set One. 02/07/2018 0.20 45.00 Review Defendant's First Set of Requests for Admission to Plaintiffs. 02/07/2018 0.20 45.00 Review Defendant's Second Set of Interrogatories to Plaintiffs. 02/07/2018 0.10 22.50 Review February 6, 2018 Joint Status Report Regarding Forensic Imaging. 02/07/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Statement Regarding Discovery Disputes. 02/07/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Declaration of Cynthia Castillo regarding Apple's search for documents related to the value of Facetime. 02/07/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Plaintiffs' Amended Notice of Fed. R. Civ. P. 30(b)(6) Deposition of Defendant Apple. 02/09/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Clerk's notice rescheduling February 14, 2018 Status Conference. 02/09/2018 0.30 67.50 Review Defendant's Responses and Objections to Plaintiff Christina Grace's Requests for Admissions, Set One. 02/14/2018 1.20 270.00 Review transcript of January 24, 2018 discovery hearing. 02/22/2018 0.30 67.50 Review Defendant Apple Inc.'s Responses and Objections to Plaintiffs' Notice of Fed. R. Civ. P. 30 (b)(6) Deposition. 02/22/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Defendant's Responses and Objections to Plaintiffs' 30(B)(1) Deposition Notice of Andrew Vyrros. 02/23/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Minutes of February 22, 2018 discovery hearing. 02/23/2018 0.20 45.00 Review Order Amending Case Schedule. 02/23/2018 0.30 67.50 Review Defendant Apple Inc's Responses and Objections to Plaintiffs' Interrogatories; Set Two, Nos. 11-17. 03/02/2018 0.20 45.00 Review Joint Status Report regarding Protocol for Forensic Inspection of Plaintiffs' Devices. 03/02/2018 0.20 45.00 Review Proposed Order regarding Protocol regarding Forensic Image Review of Plaintiffs' Devices. 03/02/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Proposed Protocol for Forensic Inspection of Plaintiffs' Devices 03/02/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Joint Status Report regarding Plaintiffs' request for further information regarding documents related to the value of Facetime. 03/02/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Declaration of R. Alexander Pilmer regarding Plaintiffs' Request for Information Regarding Apple's Search for and Production of Documents Related to

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 46 of 63 Page: 45 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 34 Ellowene Grant the Value of Facetime. 03/08/2018 0.30 67.50 Review Defendant Apple Inc.'s Responses and Objections to Plaintiffs' Second Request for Production of Documents. 03/27/2018 0.10 22.50 Review letter from counsel for Defendant to Magistrate Judge Cousins regarding forensic imaging of Plaintiffs' devices. 03/27/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Apple Inc.'s Administrative Motion to File Under Seal Apple's March 15, 2018 Supplemental Letter Brief and Exhibit A Attached Thereto Pursuant to Civil L.R. 7-11 and 79-5. 03/27/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Declaration of Alexander Pilmer in Support of Apple's Administrative Motion to File Under Seal. 03/27/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Declaration of Jill Manning in Support of Apple's Administrative Motion to File Under Seal Apple's March 15, 2018 Letter Brief and Exhibit A Thereto. 03/27/2018 0.20 45.00 Review Amazon's Objections to Subpoena. 03/27/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Apple Inc.'s Administrative Motion to File Under Seal Exhibits A and E to Apple's March 23, 2018 Letter Brief Pursuant to Civil L.R. 7-11 and 79-5. 03/28/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Defendant's Third Set of Interrogatories to Plaintiffs. 03/28/2018 1.00 225.00 Review Joint Discovery Letter Brief. 03/30/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Declaration of Jill Manning to Apple's Administrative Motion to File Under Seal. 03/30/2018 0.30 67.50 Review Order Regarding Protocol for Forensic Inspection of Plaintiffs' Devices and Resolving Related Discovery Disputes. 04/04/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Second Amended Notice of 30(b)(1) Deposition of Gokul Thirumalai. 04/09/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Amended 30(b)(6) Deposition Notice. 04/11/2018 0.50 112.50 Review Transcript of April 4, 2018 discovery hearing. 04/11/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Plaintiffs' Statement in Response to April 4, 2018 Minute Order (Dkt. 159). 04/11/2018 0.20 45.00 Review Proposed Order regarding Plaintiffs' Motion to Compel Further Discovery Responses from Apple. 04/16/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Order Addressing the Parties' Proposed Orders in Response to the Court's April 4, 2018, Minute Order. 04/16/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Defendant Apple Inc.'s 30(B)(1) Deposition Notice of Christina Grace. 04/26/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Declaration of Beth Kellerman Regarding Apple's ESI Preservation. 05/01/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Defendant Apple Inc.'s First Set of Supplemental Responses to Plaintiffs' Interrogatories, Set Tow, Interrogatory No. 14. 05/01/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Defendant Apple Inc's 30(B)(1) Deposition Notice of Ken Potter. 05/01/2018 0.30 67.50 Review Apple's Responses and Objections to Plaintiff Christina Grace's Requests for Admission, Set Two. 05/01/2018 0.20 45.00 Review Apple's Responses and Objections to Plaintiff Christina Grace's Interrogatories, Set Three, No. 18. 05/02/2018 0.40 90.00 Review Defendant Apple Inc.'s Notice of Service of Revised Subpoena and Subpoena to Akamai Technologies, Inc. 05/03/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Motion to Seal. 06/15/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Subpoena to Testify at Deposition in a Civil Action. 07/03/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Plaintiffs' Amended Notice of Deposition of Dana M. Trexler, CPA. 07/11/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Apple's Administrative Motion to Redact Transcript of May 31, 2018 Proceedings. 07/11/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Notice of Appearance by Ashley Neglia. 07/12/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Order Denying Motion to Redact; Order Denying Motion to Seal. 07/12/2018 0.70 157.50 Review Joint Case Management Statement. 07/13/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Order Continuing Case Management Conference; Denying Request to Amend Case Schedule; Denying Request to Increase Deposition Hours. 07/13/2018 0.10 22.50 Review Defendant's Second Set of Requests for Admission. 07/13/2018 0.20 45.00 Review Defendant's Fourth Set of Interrogatories to Plaintiffs. 07/19/2018 0.20 45.00 Review Declaration of Paula Phillips regarding Administrative Motion to Seal. 07/24/2018 2.50 562.50 Plan and prepare for hearing regarding Motion for Class Certification, including preparation of exhibit binders. 04/25/2019 0.20 45.00 Review Joint Case Management Statement. 04/29/2019 0.20 45.00 Review Order Continuing Case Management Conference and Adopting Case Schedule. 01/10/2020 2.00 450.00 Plan and prepare for January 16, 2020 Pre-Trial Conference, including preparation of Pre-Trial Exhibits. 08/27/2020 1.00 225.00 Plan and prepare for hearing regarding Motion for Preliminary Approval, including preparation of Exhibits.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 47 of 63 Page: 46 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 34 Ellowene Grant

Total for Timekeeper 34 Billable 42.40 9,540.00 Ellowene Grant

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 48 of 63 Page: 47 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 37 Alexander L. Simon 12/01/2016 2.40 960.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding potential apple facetime case. 02/01/2017 2.40 960.00 Draft/revise class action complaint. 02/02/2017 0.30 120.00 Review/analyze final filed complaint. 02/03/2017 0.20 80.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding judge assignment. 02/07/2017 1.30 520.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding potential judges. 02/08/2017 1.60 640.00 Research potential judges. 02/09/2017 2.70 1,080.00 Research potential judges. 02/13/2017 1.40 560.00 Research potential judges for case. 02/14/2017 6.50 2,600.00 Draft/revise memorandum regarding potential judges. 02/14/2017 0.50 200.00 Review/analyze memos from other firms regarding judges. 02/15/2017 0.90 360.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding potential judges in the case and next steps in case. 02/15/2017 3.50 1,400.00 Review/analyze potential examples of ESI protocols in preparation for drafting protocol in this case. 02/18/2017 0.20 80.00 Review/analyze stipulation by defendant to extend time to respond to complaint. 03/01/2017 0.40 160.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding current status of case. 03/03/2017 0.30 120.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding case status. 03/03/2017 0.90 360.00 Review/analyze drafts of first requests for production and interrogatories to be sent to defendant. 03/10/2017 0.30 120.00 Review/analyze relevant article from recent Judge Koh ruling. 03/14/2017 0.80 320.00 Review/analyze revised first requests for production and interrogatories. 03/15/2017 0.10 40.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding recent ruling by Judge Koh. 03/22/2017 0.30 120.00 Review/analyze defendant's motion to dismiss. 03/23/2017 1.80 720.00 Review/analyze motion to dismiss. 03/24/2017 0.20 80.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding Apple's recent motion to dismiss. 03/24/2017 0.50 200.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding Apple's motion to dismiss. 03/24/2017 0.20 80.00 Draft/revise summary e-mail regarding call. 03/31/2017 0.80 320.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding current status of amended complaint. 04/03/2017 0.90 360.00 Review/analyze new draft of 1st amended complaint. 04/03/2017 0.50 200.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding damages model. 04/03/2017 0.30 120.00 Review/analyze research regarding restitution and UCL claims. 04/04/2017 1.50 600.00 Review/analyze latest draft of amended complaint. 04/05/2017 0.80 320.00 Review/analyze second amended complaint. 04/06/2017 0.20 80.00 Review/analyze recent order regarding amended complaint from court. 04/10/2017 1.60 640.00 Draft/revise ESI protocol. 04/10/2017 0.50 200.00 Research impending discovery deadlines. 04/10/2017 0.20 80.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding impending discovery deadlines. 04/11/2017 0.30 120.00 Review/analyze e-mail from co-counsel regarding court dates. 04/12/2017 0.50 200.00 Review/analyze emails regarding current status of case. 04/19/2017 0.70 280.00 Draft/revise ESI protocol. 04/19/2017 0.20 80.00 Review/analyze emails regarding motion to dismiss hearing. 04/20/2017 2.10 840.00 Review/analyze defendant's motion to dismiss and other related documents. 04/20/2017 0.40 160.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding filing opposition defendant's motion to dismiss. 04/24/2017 3.20 1,280.00 Draft/revise portions of opposition to defendant's motion to dismiss. 04/25/2017 5.50 2,200.00 Draft/revise sections of opposition to motion to dismiss. 04/26/2017 4.80 1,920.00 Draft/revise sections of opposition to defendant's motion to dismiss. 04/26/2017 0.90 360.00 Draft/revise ESI protocol for review of co-counsel. 04/27/2017 2.70 1,080.00 Review/analyze drafts of first sets of interrogatories and requests for production. 04/28/2017 4.30 1,720.00 Draft/revise sections to opposition to Defendant's motion to dismiss. 04/28/2017 1.60 640.00 Research caselaw in support of opposition to motion to dismiss. 05/01/2017 3.20 1,280.00 Draft/revise Plaintiffs' opposition to Defendant's motion to dismiss. 05/02/2017 3.70 1,480.00 Draft/revise discovery requests. 05/02/2017 0.80 320.00 Draft/revise Plaintiffs' opposition to Defendant's motion to dismiss. 05/03/2017 1.70 680.00 Review/analyze latest draft of Plaintiffs' opposition to Defendant's motion to dismiss. 05/04/2017 1.60 640.00 Draft/revise discovery requests to defendant. 05/15/2017 0.60 240.00 Review/analyze documents for Initial Case Management Conference. 05/15/2017 0.50 200.00 Draft/revise stipulated protective order. 05/16/2017 0.90 360.00 Draft/revise stipulated protective order. 05/16/2017 2.90 1,160.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding Initial Case Management Conference. 05/17/2017 0.70 280.00 Review/analyze communications from co-counsel regarding Initial Case Management Conference.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 49 of 63 Page: 48 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 37 Alexander L. Simon 05/17/2017 0.90 360.00 Draft/revise protective order. 05/18/2017 0.40 160.00 Review/analyze communications regarding results from Initial Case Management Conference. 05/18/2017 1.20 480.00 Draft/revise protective order. 05/22/2017 0.20 80.00 Draft/revise protective order. 05/22/2017 0.60 240.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding Initial Case Management Conference. 05/22/2017 0.50 200.00 Draft/revise outline for motion to dismiss hearings. 05/23/2017 1.10 440.00 Draft/revise stipulated protective order. 05/24/2017 0.70 280.00 Review/analyze edits by co-counsel to the potential stipulated protective order. 05/24/2017 1.20 480.00 Draft/revise stipulated protective order. 05/25/2017 0.10 40.00 Review/analyze transcript from Initial Case Management Conference. 05/30/2017 0.60 240.00 Review/analyze transcript from initial Case Management Conference. 05/30/2017 0.70 280.00 Review/analyze initial disclosures to defendant. 05/30/2017 0.10 40.00 Review/analyze motion to dismiss argument outline. 06/12/2017 0.10 40.00 Review/analyze current status of case. 06/12/2017 2.30 920.00 Draft/revise assigned arguments in preparation for motion to dismiss hearing. 06/13/2017 0.40 160.00 Draft/revise outline for hearing on Defendant's motion to dismiss. 07/25/2017 0.10 40.00 Review/analyze order from court vacating hearing on motion to dismiss. 08/02/2017 1.10 440.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding current status of case, discovery plan, and next Case Management Conference. 08/25/2017 1.60 640.00 Draft/revise interrogatories set one. 08/29/2017 0.40 160.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding discovery requests and other case status issues. 09/12/2017 1.50 600.00 Review/analyze notes regarding Defendant's issues with Plaintiffs' requests for production. 09/14/2017 1.40 560.00 Review/analyze discovery letter to defendant regarding requests for production. 09/19/2017 0.90 360.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding current status of discovery and other case issues. 09/21/2017 0.50 200.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding proof of damages. 09/29/2017 0.80 320.00 Communicate (other external) regarding document review program. 09/29/2017 2.50 1,000.00 Communicate (opposing counsel) regarding current discovery issues. 10/02/2017 1.30 520.00 Research potential survey issues regarding damages. 10/04/2017 3.30 1,320.00 Research conjoint expert analysis. 10/04/2017 0.60 240.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding damage model findings. 10/09/2017 0.80 320.00 Review/sign protective order and obtain relativity credential in preparation for document review conference call. 10/09/2017 1.40 560.00 Communicate (with client) regarding current status of discovery. 10/11/2017 1.00 400.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding document review protocol for review of defendant's produced documents. 11/01/2017 2.90 1,160.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding current issues in case. 11/02/2017 0.30 120.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding decision against Apple with regard to IOS9 and the iPhone 4. 11/07/2017 0.40 160.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding upcoming discovery hearing. 11/16/2017 1.90 760.00 Review/analyze Plaintiff's discovery responses in preparation for call regarding the same. 11/16/2017 0.70 280.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding discovery responses. 11/16/2017 0.50 200.00 Research objections based on privacy. 12/08/2017 1.40 560.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding current status of Plaintiffs' request for production. 01/08/2018 0.30 120.00 Review/analyze third party subpoenas. 01/10/2018 0.30 120.00 Review/analyze Plaintiffs' insert for the letter brief regarding discovery dispute. 01/10/2018 1.00 400.00 Draft/revise class cert motion legal section. 01/10/2018 1.10 440.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding current case status. 01/16/2018 0.90 360.00 Review/analyze responses regarding third party subpoenas. 01/16/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding third party subpoenas. 01/17/2018 0.90 360.00 Review/analyze 3rd party subpoena in preparation for weekly call. 01/17/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding upcoming meet and confers regarding third party subpoenas. 01/17/2018 0.50 200.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding current status of document review. 01/17/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (with AT&T) regarding 3rd party subpoena meet and confer. 01/17/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (with Sprint) regarding 3rd party subpoena. 01/17/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (with Verizon) regarding third party subpoena. 01/17/2018 0.90 360.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding current status of case projects. 01/18/2018 1.00 400.00 Meet and confer with Verizon regarding third party subpoena.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 50 of 63 Page: 49 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 37 Alexander L. Simon 01/18/2018 0.20 80.00 Draft/revise contemporaneous notes regarding meet and confer with Verizon. 01/18/2018 1.60 640.00 Draft/revise motion for protective order in response to Defendant's subpoena to Verizon Wireless. 01/18/2018 0.50 200.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) at Sprint regarding third party subpoena. 01/18/2018 0.30 120.00 Draft/revise memorandum regarding meet and confer call with Sprint regarding third party subpoena. 01/18/2018 0.70 280.00 Draft/revise confirmatory e-mail regarding meet and confer with Sprint. 01/18/2018 0.60 240.00 Meet and confer with counsel from Best Buy regarding third party subpoena. 01/18/2018 3.10 1,240.00 Draft/revise motion for protective order in response to Defendant's third party subpoena. 01/19/2018 0.40 160.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding current status of third party subpoenas. 01/19/2018 0.40 160.00 Plan and prepare for third party subpoena call with AT&T. 01/19/2018 5.60 2,240.00 Draft/revise motion for protective order regarding Defendant's subpoena to Verizon. 01/19/2018 0.50 200.00 Plan and prepare for meet and confer call with ecoATM. 01/19/2018 0.80 320.00 Communicate with ecoATM regarding third party subpoena. 01/22/2018 4.50 1,800.00 Draft/revise motion for protective order regarding Verizon third party subpoena. 01/22/2018 0.50 200.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding third party subpoena to Verizon. 01/22/2018 0.50 200.00 Plan and prepare for meet and confer call with ecoATM. 01/22/2018 0.40 160.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding subpoena to third party T-Mobile. 01/23/2018 0.20 80.00 Review/analyze emails regarding current status of third party discovery issues. 01/23/2018 0.60 240.00 Communicate (with expert) regarding data from third parties. 01/23/2018 2.10 840.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding third party subpoenas and production of documents under those subpoenas. 01/23/2018 1.50 600.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding current status of discovery. 01/24/2018 0.50 200.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) from ecoATM regarding production of documents in response to subpoena. 01/24/2018 0.20 80.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) from AT&T regarding third party subpoena. 01/24/2018 1.30 520.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding results of discovery hearing and other discovery issues. 01/26/2018 0.40 160.00 Review/analyze responses regarding third party discovery. 01/29/2018 3.30 1,320.00 Document Review Batch ID 00024. 01/30/2018 1.00 400.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding third party subpoenas. 01/31/2018 3.10 1,240.00 Review/analyze required phones for production under third party subpoenas. 01/31/2018 0.40 160.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding current status of document review. 01/31/2018 1.20 480.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding current status of case. 02/01/2018 3.80 1,520.00 Meet and confer with Verizon, Sprint, T-Mobile, and BestBuy regarding our third party subpoenas. 02/01/2018 0.40 160.00 Draft/revise letter to non-responsive third parties who were issued subpoenas. 02/02/2018 1.30 520.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding Sprint and Verizon third party subpoenas. 02/02/2018 0.70 280.00 Draft/revise letters to third parties who have not responded to subpoenas. 02/02/2018 0.70 280.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding current status of subpoenas. 02/02/2018 0.40 160.00 Draft/revise communication to opposing counsel regarding production of third party documents. 02/02/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding service of third party subpoenas. 02/05/2018 0.20 80.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding subpoena to Sprint. 02/05/2018 0.90 360.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding third party subpoenas. 02/06/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding third party subpoena to Best Buy. 02/06/2018 0.50 200.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding third party subpoena to Best Buy. 02/06/2018 0.40 160.00 Draft/revise Case Management Conference Statement. 02/06/2018 0.10 40.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding case management statement. 02/06/2018 0.30 120.00 Draft/revise case management statement. 02/06/2018 0.80 320.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding third party subpoena to T-Mobile. 02/06/2018 2.40 960.00 Draft/revise outline for 30(b)(6) deposition. 02/07/2018 3.10 1,240.00 Draft/revise deposition outline for 30(b)(6). 02/07/2018 0.40 160.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding status of document review. 02/07/2018 1.70 680.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding experts and current status of discovery. 02/08/2018 5.70 2,280.00 Draft/revise 30(b)(6) deposition outline. 02/26/2018 1.00 400.00 Review/analyze progress of third party subpoenas. 02/26/2018 0.50 200.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding current status of ecoATM subpoena. 02/26/2018 0.40 160.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding subpoena to ecoATM. 02/26/2018 0.40 160.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with Tech Data Corp. regarding subpoena. 02/27/2018 3.60 1,440.00 Document Review Batch 275.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 51 of 63 Page: 50 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 37 Alexander L. Simon 02/28/2018 3.20 1,280.00 Document Review Batch Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800003. 02/28/2018 1.30 520.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding current status of case. 02/28/2018 0.50 200.00 Review/analyze current status of third-party subpoenas. 03/01/2018 0.20 80.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding Amazon subpoena. 03/01/2018 2.10 840.00 Document Review Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800003. 03/02/2018 1.80 720.00 Review/analyze production from AT&T. 03/02/2018 1.10 440.00 Document Review Batch Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800003. 03/05/2018 0.70 280.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding current status of third party subpoenas. 03/05/2018 0.60 240.00 Manage data/files productions from third party Best Buy. 03/07/2018 0.70 280.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding current status of the case. 03/07/2018 0.40 160.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding current status of T-Mobile and Brightstar subpoenas. 03/07/2018 0.20 80.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding ecoATM third party subpoena. 03/08/2018 0.10 40.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding T-Mobile third party subpoena. 03/08/2018 0.10 40.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with ecoATM regarding current status of third party subpoena. 03/08/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with Brightstar regarding current status of subpoena. 03/08/2018 0.60 240.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with T-Mobile regarding third party subpoena. 03/08/2018 0.70 280.00 Research T-Mobile third party buyback provider. 03/08/2018 0.70 280.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding potential third party subpoena to Assurant. 03/08/2018 1.20 480.00 Document Review Batch ID Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800003. 03/12/2018 0.50 200.00 Plan and prepare for call with Brightstar. 03/12/2018 0.60 240.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with Brightstar regarding third party subpoena. 03/12/2018 3.70 1,480.00 Document Review Batch ID Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800003. 03/13/2018 0.10 40.00 Communicate (with expert) regarding produced third party data. 03/13/2018 5.20 2,080.00 Document Review Batch ID Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800003. 03/14/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding status of document review. 03/14/2018 1.00 400.00 Communicate (all plaintiffs' counsel) regarding current status of case. 03/14/2018 1.80 720.00 Document Review Batch ID Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800003. 03/15/2018 3.80 1,520.00 Document Review Batch ID Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800003. 03/15/2018 2.30 920.00 Document Review Batch ID Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800015. 03/16/2018 1.00 400.00 Document Review Batch ID Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800015. 03/19/2018 1.00 400.00 Review/analyze current status of third party subpoenas. 03/19/2018 2.10 840.00 Document Review Batch ID Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800015. 03/19/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding status of third party subpoenas. 03/20/2018 1.90 760.00 Document Review Batch ID Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800015. 03/21/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with ecoATM regarding third party subpoena. 03/21/2018 1.00 400.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding current status of case. 03/21/2018 0.70 280.00 Document Review Batch ID Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800015. 03/21/2018 1.00 400.00 Review/analyze current status of ecoATM, Brightstar, and Assurant third party subpoenas. 03/22/2018 3.00 1,200.00 Document Review Batch ID Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800015. 03/23/2018 0.80 320.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding subpoena to Assurant. 03/23/2018 0.50 200.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding Brightstar subpoena. 03/23/2018 0.10 40.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding Brightstar subpoena. 03/23/2018 0.20 80.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding Assurant subpoena. 03/26/2018 0.50 200.00 Plan and prepare for call with Brightstar. 03/26/2018 0.40 160.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding third party subpoena with Brightstar. 03/26/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding Brightstar subpoena status. 03/26/2018 3.80 1,520.00 Document Review Batch ID Apple Production Searches 2.23.201800015. 03/27/2018 0.40 160.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding Brightstar subpoena. 03/27/2018 3.00 1,200.00 Document Review Batch ID Apple Customer Logs Produced 2.2.2018 Part 1_00003. 03/28/2018 1.70 680.00 Communicate (all plaintiffs' counsel) regarding current status of case. 03/28/2018 1.30 520.00 Document Review Batch ID Apple Customer Logs Produced 2.2.2018 Part 1_00003. 03/29/2018 0.10 40.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with Assurant regarding third party subpoena. 04/02/2018 0.90 360.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding outstanding subpoenas to Assurant, Brightstar, and T-Mobile. 04/02/2018 0.20 80.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with Best Buy regarding produced data pursuant to third party subpoena. 04/02/2018 0.40 160.00 Review/analyze expert's questions in preparation for call with Best Buy.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 52 of 63 Page: 51 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 37 Alexander L. Simon 04/03/2018 1.40 560.00 Review/analyze questions by expert regarding Best Buy data and draft e-mail to Best Buy regarding expert questions. 04/03/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with Assurant regarding third party subpoena. 04/03/2018 2.60 1,040.00 Document Review Batch ID Apple Customer Logs Produced 2.2.2018 Part 1_00003. 04/04/2018 3.10 1,240.00 Document Review Batch ID Apple Customer Logs Produced 2.2.2018 Part 1_00003. 04/05/2018 3.20 1,280.00 Document Review Batch ID Apple Customer Logs Produced 2.2.2018 Part 1_00003. 04/06/2018 0.70 280.00 Communicate (co-lead counsel) regarding current status of case. 04/06/2018 0.10 40.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding current status of class cert brief. 04/06/2018 2.70 1,080.00 Document Review Batch ID Apple Customer Logs Produced 2.2.2018 Part 1_00003. 04/06/2018 2.80 1,120.00 Revise class cert brief. 04/16/2018 1.00 400.00 Draft/revise attorney assignment section of expert brief. 04/16/2018 2.00 800.00 Research implications of adding new plaintiff prior to class cert. 04/16/2018 1.10 440.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding current status of class cert and other case issues. 04/17/2018 0.30 120.00 Receive and process production from ecoATM. 04/19/2018 0.20 80.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding expert questions to produce data. 04/19/2018 0.20 80.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) ecoATM regarding data production password. 04/20/2018 2.10 840.00 Draft/revise declaration in support of class cert motion. 04/20/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding third party subpoena to Assurant. 04/23/2018 0.50 200.00 Process production from ecoATM in preparation for distribution to experts. 04/24/2018 0.50 200.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with ecoATM regarding production of data to Defendant. 04/24/2018 0.60 240.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with Best Buy regarding questions in relation to production of data. 04/24/2018 1.40 560.00 Draft/revise Hastings Report, Table A. 04/24/2018 0.50 200.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding declaration regarding third party subpoenas in preparation for class certification brief. 04/24/2018 0.30 120.00 Review/analyze edits to expert assignment section of expert report. 04/24/2018 0.20 80.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding edits to expert report assignment section. 04/25/2018 0.70 280.00 Review/analyze status of third party subpoenas. 04/25/2018 1.60 640.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding Assurant third party subpoena. 04/26/2018 0.60 240.00 Communicate (other external) with expert regarding status of expert report for class certification. 04/26/2018 0.40 160.00 Communicate (other external) with Best Buy regarding answers to questions regarding produced data, communicate with expert regarding the same. 04/26/2018 0.70 280.00 Review/analyze answers to questions regarding Best Buy data. 04/26/2018 0.40 160.00 Communicate (other external) with expert regarding answer to questions regarding Best Buy data. 04/27/2018 1.90 760.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with all plaintiffs' counsel regarding current status of class certification brief and other case issues. 04/27/2018 0.50 200.00 Draft/revise declaration in support of class certification. 04/30/2018 0.40 160.00 Draft/revise Attorney A. Simon declaration in support of Class Certification. 04/30/2018 1.70 680.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding follow up questions regarding ecoATM production. 04/30/2018 0.50 200.00 Review/analyze subpoenas in preparation for drafting Attorney A. Simon declaration. 04/30/2018 1.10 440.00 Review/analyze expert questions for ecoATM regarding produced data set in preparation for call with ecoATM. 04/30/2018 0.70 280.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with ecoATM regarding expert questions on data. 04/30/2018 0.60 240.00 Communicate (other external) with expert regarding questions regarding ecoATM data. 05/02/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with ecoATM regarding expert questions regarding data produced. 05/02/2018 0.60 240.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding answers from ecoATM regarding expert questions. 05/02/2018 0.60 240.00 Communicate (other external) with expert regarding status of report. 05/02/2018 0.80 320.00 Draft/revise Attorney A. Simon declaration in support of class certification. 05/03/2018 2.30 920.00 Draft/revise Attorney A. Simon declaration in support of class certification. 05/04/2018 4.50 1,800.00 Draft/revise class certification brief in preparation for filing. 05/04/2018 0.20 80.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding Best Buy confidentiality designation. 05/04/2018 1.10 440.00 Review/analyze expert report in preparation for filing. 05/07/2018 0.40 160.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with Assurant regarding non-party subpoena. 05/09/2018 1.30 520.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding the current status of the case.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 53 of 63 Page: 52 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 37 Alexander L. Simon 05/14/2018 0.10 40.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with Brightstar regarding current status of subpoena. 05/15/2018 0.60 240.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding status of the subpoena to Brightstar. 05/15/2018 0.80 320.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding production of Plaintiff WiFi data from third party. 05/16/2018 3.40 1,360.00 Draft/revise motion for protective order regarding plaintiffs' raw data. 05/18/2018 3.10 1,240.00 Examine forensic data for plaintiff devices. 05/21/2018 7.00 2,800.00 Appear for/attend All Plaintiffs' Counsel discovery and case management meeting. 05/23/2018 0.60 240.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding current status of case. 05/23/2018 0.40 160.00 Draft/revise e-mail regarding Defendant's third party subpoenas to AT&T and Brightstar. 05/24/2018 0.30 120.00 Draft/revise e-mail regarding Defendant's non-party subpoenas. 05/25/2018 0.40 160.00 Draft/revise e-mail to Brightstar regarding current status of subpoena. 05/25/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding current status of Brightstar subpoena. 05/25/2018 0.20 80.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding current status of production from Brightstar. 05/25/2018 0.50 200.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding current status of Assurant subpoena. 05/25/2018 0.80 320.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding third party subpoenas. 05/29/2018 0.80 320.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding preparation for Brightstar deposition. 05/29/2018 2.00 800.00 Draft/revise questions in preparation for Brightstar deposition. 05/29/2018 0.60 240.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding preparation for Brightstar deposition. 05/29/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding potential production from Assurant. 05/31/2018 2.50 1,000.00 Appear for/attend deposition of Brightstar via telephone. 06/05/2018 0.10 40.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding status of Brightstar subpoena. 06/05/2018 0.20 80.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding status of Assurant subpoena. 06/06/2018 0.70 280.00 Communicate (all Plaintiffs' counsel) regarding the current status of the case. 06/06/2018 0.70 280.00 Draft/revise e-mail to Defendant Apple regarding scheduling of non-party depositions. 06/06/2018 1.40 560.00 Plan and prepare for deposition of non-party AT&T. 06/07/2018 4.80 1,920.00 Plan and prepare for Plaintiff expert deposition. 06/08/2018 0.40 160.00 Review/analyze communications with non-party regarding data production. 06/11/2018 8.60 3,440.00 Plan and prepare for AT&T Non-party deposition. 06/11/2018 4.00 1,600.00 Travel to Seattle for AT&T Non-Party Deposition. 06/12/2018 5.00 2,000.00 Appear for/attend Deposition of Non-Party AT&T. 06/12/2018 4.00 1,600.00 Travel to SFO back from AT&T Non-Party deposition. 06/13/2018 1.20 480.00 Communicate (All Plaintiffs' Counsel) regarding current status of the case. 06/19/2018 0.70 280.00 Review/analyze opposition to class certification filing by defendant. 06/19/2018 2.40 960.00 Research choice of law cases in California in preparation for drafting choice of law section of reply. 06/20/2018 1.90 760.00 Research California choice of law cases in preparation for drafting section of reply to Defendant's opposition to Plaintiffs' motion for class certification. 06/21/2018 2.80 1,120.00 Research California choice of law issues. 06/21/2018 0.60 240.00 Review/analyze recording of hearing regarding documents productions issues. 06/25/2018 4.80 1,920.00 Review/analyze current California choice of law issues in preparation for drafting class certification reply. 06/25/2018 1.10 440.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding current status of class certification reply and other discovery issues. 06/26/2018 5.90 2,360.00 Draft/revise choice of law section for reply brief to Defendant's opposition to class certification. 06/26/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding choice of law section to reply brief to Defendant's opposition to class certification. 06/26/2018 0.10 40.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding choice of law section to reply brief to Defendant's opposition to class certification. 06/26/2018 0.10 40.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding choice of law section to reply brief to Defendant's opposition to class certification. 06/27/2018 1.30 520.00 Communicate (Plaintiffs' counsel) regarding expert reply report. 06/27/2018 5.00 2,000.00 Draft/revise choice of law section to reply to Defendant's opposition to class certification. 06/28/2018 0.80 320.00 Research potential deposition testimony regarding defendant's expert Dana Trexler. 06/28/2018 4.10 1,640.00 Research Apple's terms of service in relation to choice of law issues. 06/28/2018 0.50 200.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney B. Pouya regarding choice of law issues for reply to defendant's opposition to class certification. 06/28/2018 0.10 40.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding choice of law issues pertaining to reply to defendant's opposition to class certification. 06/28/2018 1.10 440.00 Draft/revise choice of law section to reply to defendant's opposition to class

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 54 of 63 Page: 53 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 37 Alexander L. Simon certification. 06/29/2018 3.40 1,360.00 Draft/revise choice of law section for reply brief to defendant's opposition to class certification. 07/11/2018 3.00 1,200.00 Draft/revise reply to defendant's opposition to Plaintiffs' motion for class certification. 07/11/2018 0.70 280.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding current status of reply brief. 07/11/2018 0.20 80.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding Assurant subpoena. 07/12/2018 1.40 560.00 Draft/revise notice of motion and motion to strike Defendant's expert Rubin. 07/12/2018 0.80 320.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding current status of reply brief and motions to strike. 07/13/2018 0.80 320.00 Draft/revise Plaintiffs' reply to Defendant's opposition to class certification. 07/17/2018 0.70 280.00 Communicate (expert) regarding Assurant data production. 07/17/2018 2.00 800.00 Review/analyze recent communications with non-parties regarding subpoenas. 07/18/2018 0.20 80.00 Communicate (other external) Assurant regarding non-party subpoena. 07/19/2018 0.10 40.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding sending documents to expert. 07/19/2018 0.10 40.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with Assurant regarding non-party subpoena. 07/19/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with ecoATM regarding questions on produced data. 07/19/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (other external) experts regarding ecoATM data answers. 07/19/2018 0.40 160.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with Assurant regarding non-party subpoena. 07/23/2018 1.20 480.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding current status of case. 07/24/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding status of Apple's production of data. 07/24/2018 1.30 520.00 Review/analyze Apple's trade-in production. 07/24/2018 0.20 80.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding Apple's produced trade-in data. 07/25/2018 3.10 1,240.00 Review/analyze decisions regarding amount of data needed for regression models in class cases. 07/30/2018 1.20 480.00 Research issue regarding transactional data required for experts. 07/30/2018 2.00 800.00 Review/analyze production from Best Buy. 07/30/2018 0.50 200.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding upcoming meet and confer with Apple. 07/31/2018 0.20 80.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding impending meet and confer with Apple. 07/31/2018 0.20 80.00 Plan and prepare for meet and confer with Amazon. 07/31/2018 0.60 240.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding subpoena to Amazon. 07/31/2018 0.20 80.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding Amazon subpoena. 07/31/2018 0.20 80.00 Plan and prepare for call with co-counsel regarding meet and confer with Apple. 07/31/2018 1.20 480.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding meet and confer with Apple. 07/31/2018 1.70 680.00 Communicate (opposing counsel) regarding discovery issues. 07/31/2018 0.40 160.00 Communicate (with expert) regarding meet and confer with Amazon. 08/01/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (other external) with expert regarding Amazon data. 08/01/2018 0.80 320.00 Plan and prepare for call with expert. 08/01/2018 0.60 240.00 Communicate (other external) with expert regarding expert report. 08/02/2018 0.50 200.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding status of Assurant production. 08/02/2018 0.20 80.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding Amazon non-party subpoena. 08/02/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding recent updates in case. 08/06/2018 3.30 1,320.00 Research admissibility in preparation for drafting Plaintiffs' third set of requests for admissions. 08/06/2018 3.00 1,200.00 Review/analyze hot documents produced by Apple in preparation to draft Plaintiffs' third set of requests for admissions. 08/06/2018 1.00 400.00 Draft/revise Plaintiffs' third set of requests for admissions. 08/07/2018 3.00 1,200.00 Review/analyze authentication and admissibility issue of documents in preparation of discovery cut-off. 08/07/2018 3.80 1,520.00 Draft/revise requests for admissions set three and attachments. 08/07/2018 0.10 40.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding authentication and business records requests for admissions. 08/07/2018 0.10 40.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding authentication and business records requests for admissions. 08/07/2018 0.10 40.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding authentication and business records requests for admissions. 08/07/2018 0.40 160.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding authentication and business records requests for admissions. 08/07/2018 0.20 80.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding discovery requests and damages. 08/08/2018 1.10 440.00 Draft/revise requests for admissions regarding authenticity and the business records exception. 08/08/2018 0.40 160.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding the requests for admissions regarding authenticity and the business records exception. 08/08/2018 1.10 440.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding current status of projects for the case. 08/08/2018 0.10 40.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with Best Buy regarding produced data.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 55 of 63 Page: 54 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 37 Alexander L. Simon 08/08/2018 0.10 40.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding requests for admissions, set three. 08/08/2018 0.70 280.00 Draft/revise e-mail to Best Buy regarding data produce under non-party subpoena. 08/13/2018 0.20 80.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding Apple's recent production of documents. 08/14/2018 0.30 120.00 Plan and prepare for weekly call with all Plaintiffs' counsel. 08/14/2018 0.50 200.00 Communicate (All Plaintiffs' Counsel) regarding current status of discovery and case. 08/15/2018 0.90 360.00 Research and draft Statement of Decision in relation to Plaintiffs' pending motion on class certification. 08/15/2018 0.10 40.00 Communicate (other external) with Best Buy regarding produced data. 08/15/2018 0.80 320.00 Document Review of Apple's recent production of 57 documents. 08/16/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding subpoena to Best Buy. 08/17/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) Best Buy regarding subpoena. 08/17/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding status of subpoenas. 08/19/2018 0.70 280.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding Best Buy production of additional data. 08/20/2018 0.20 80.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding Best Buy data production. 08/20/2018 0.50 200.00 Review/analyze current need for additional data from Best Buy in preparation for e-mail to Best Buy. 08/20/2018 0.40 160.00 Draft/revise e-mail to Best Buy regarding additional data. 08/20/2018 0.20 80.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding e-mail for additional data to Best Buy. 08/20/2018 0.20 80.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with Assurant regarding status of data production. 08/21/2018 0.10 40.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding status of Best Buy Data collection. 08/23/2018 0.30 120.00 Plan and prepare for call with All Plaintiffs' counsel regarding status of case. 08/23/2018 1.10 440.00 Communicate (Co-Counsel) regarding current status of expert report and other issues. 08/23/2018 0.20 80.00 Review/analyze e-mail from Assurant regarding production pursuant to non-party subpoena. 08/27/2018 1.00 400.00 Communicate (with expert) regarding status of expert report. 08/29/2018 0.20 80.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) with Best Buy regarding additional data pursuant to subpoena. 08/30/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding status of Best Buy subpoena. 08/30/2018 1.30 520.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding the current status of the case. 09/12/2018 0.90 360.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding current status of case. 09/18/2018 1.20 480.00 Review/analyze class certification order from Court. 09/18/2018 1.50 600.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding status of case post class certification order by Court. 09/26/2018 1.70 680.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding amended complaint. 09/26/2018 1.90 760.00 Draft/revise second amended complaint in preparation for motion for reconsideration. 09/27/2018 8.10 3,240.00 Research state law regarding trespass to chattels in preparation for drafting second amended complaint. 09/27/2018 0.30 120.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding research on second amended complaint. 09/28/2018 9.50 3,800.00 Research jurisdictional trespass to chattels laws. 10/01/2018 1.20 480.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding status of case. 10/01/2018 0.40 160.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding status of ecoATM subpoena. 10/02/2018 4.80 1,920.00 Review/analyze draft motions for reconsideration. 10/02/2018 0.60 240.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding status of motion for reconsideration. 10/04/2018 0.10 40.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding discovery responses. 10/04/2018 1.60 640.00 Review/analyze amended discovery responses in preparation for service. 10/05/2018 2.00 800.00 Review/analyze defendant's motion for summary judgement. 10/05/2018 0.90 360.00 Review/analyze exhibits to Defendant's motion for summary judgment. 10/10/2018 1.10 440.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding current status of case. 10/12/2018 0.80 320.00 Draft/revise Case Management Conference statement. 10/14/2018 0.50 200.00 Draft/revise class notice section of case management conference statement. 10/15/2018 0.50 200.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding Case Management Conference statement issues. 10/15/2018 1.80 720.00 Review/analyze draft of opposition to defendant's motion for summary judgment. 10/15/2018 0.60 240.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding latest draft of opposition to Defendant's motion for summary judgment. 10/17/2018 3.30 1,320.00 Draft/revise opposition to Defendant's motion for summary judgment. 10/18/2018 3.00 1,200.00 Draft/revise Plaintiffs' opposition to Defendant's motion for summary judgment. 10/18/2018 0.70 280.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding current status of case. 10/22/2018 1.10 440.00 Review/analyze draft of Plaintiffs' reply to Defendant's opposition to Plaintiffs' motion

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 56 of 63 Page: 55 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 37 Alexander L. Simon for reconsideration. 10/22/2018 0.50 200.00 Review/analyze latest draft of second amended complaint. 10/23/2018 1.60 640.00 Draft/revise second amended complaint. 10/24/2018 0.90 360.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding the current status of the case. 10/25/2018 0.60 240.00 Review/analyze 23(f) standard in preparation for call regarding motion. 10/25/2018 0.90 360.00 Communicate (in firm) and with co-counsel regarding 23(f) motion. 10/25/2018 3.40 1,360.00 Research choice of law provisions in California. 10/29/2018 5.90 2,360.00 Draft/revise choice of law section of 23(f). 10/30/2018 5.00 2,000.00 Draft/revise choice of law section of 23(f). 11/03/2018 2.00 800.00 Draft/revise 23(f) petition. 11/06/2018 1.70 680.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding upcoming mediation. 11/16/2018 0.40 160.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding current status of 23(f). 12/05/2018 2.40 960.00 Draft/revise 23(f) reply. 01/29/2019 0.40 180.00 Review/analyze recent ruling by Judge Koh related to fees and loadstar. 02/20/2019 0.10 45.00 Review/analyze latest joint case management statement. 02/25/2019 0.10 45.00 Review/analyze clerk notice regarding continuance of Case Management Conference. 03/20/2019 0.20 90.00 Review/analyze 23(f) denial. 03/21/2019 0.10 45.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding 23(f) denial. 03/22/2019 1.20 540.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding status of case and upcoming trial. 03/25/2019 0.10 45.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding weekly case call. 03/26/2019 0.30 135.00 Review/analyze e-mail from co-counsel regarding potential Florida claim. 04/03/2019 0.20 90.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding potential for other cases in other states. 04/09/2019 0.20 90.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding weekly call agenda. 04/09/2019 1.10 495.00 Review/analyze status of case; draft/revise agenda for weekly litigation call. 04/10/2019 0.80 360.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding status of case. 04/18/2019 0.50 225.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding status of the case. 04/18/2019 0.20 90.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding Case Management Conference statement. 04/18/2019 0.70 315.00 Draft/revise case management statement for upcoming May 1st Case Management Conference. 04/19/2019 1.90 855.00 Draft/revise case management statement for upcoming May 1st Case Management Conference. 04/19/2019 0.30 135.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding joint case management statement for upcoming May 1st Case Management Conference. 04/23/2019 0.20 90.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding class notice issues. 04/24/2019 0.70 315.00 Review/analyze edits by Apple and Plaintiffs' counsel to Case Management Conference statement. 04/24/2019 1.70 765.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding Apple's and Plaintiffs' counsels edits to joint Case Management Conference. 04/25/2019 0.40 180.00 Review/analyze final filed case management statement. 04/26/2019 0.20 90.00 Review/analyze order regarding Case Management Conference. 04/26/2019 0.10 45.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding order regarding Case Management Conference. 04/26/2019 0.20 90.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding recent order by court regarding Case Management Conference. 04/26/2019 0.40 180.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding recent order by court regarding Case Management Conference. 05/15/2019 0.20 90.00 Plan and prepare for call regarding status of case. 05/15/2019 0.60 270.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding status of case and other potential cases. 05/23/2019 0.30 135.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding status of document review server and potential other cases. 07/18/2019 0.60 270.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding summary judgment hearing. 07/31/2019 0.20 90.00 Review/analyze notice of supplemental authority filed by defendant. 07/31/2019 0.20 90.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding supplemental authority filed by defendant. 08/22/2019 0.90 405.00 Review/analyze order on summary judgment and order to mediation by court. 08/22/2019 0.10 45.00 Review/analyze agenda for call regarding case status. 08/23/2019 0.70 315.00 Review/analyze joint case management statement and edits to joint case management statement in preparation for call with co-counsel. 08/23/2019 1.10 495.00 Communicate (co-counsel) regarding status of case and judge's order on summary judgment and mediation. 08/28/2019 0.80 360.00 Review/analyze memorandum regarding potential cases in other states. 08/28/2019 0.40 180.00 Review/analyze order regarding sealing of motion for summary judgment. 08/29/2019 0.50 225.00 Review/analyze final case management conference statement. 08/29/2019 0.20 90.00 Review/analyze complaint filed in Florida. 08/29/2019 0.90 405.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding status of Florida cases and case status.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 57 of 63 Page: 56 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 37 Alexander L. Simon 08/30/2019 0.10 45.00 Review/analyze order from court regarding case management conference. 08/30/2019 0.10 45.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding order from court regarding case management conference. 09/06/2019 1.10 495.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding status of case and mediation. 09/13/2019 0.20 90.00 Review/analyze memorandum regarding potential claims in preparation for call. 09/13/2019 0.90 405.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding class notice and mediation. 09/13/2019 0.70 315.00 Draft/revise draft of class notice. 09/13/2019 0.10 45.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding draft of class notice. 09/23/2019 1.60 720.00 Review/analyze latest draft of mediation statement. 09/23/2019 0.10 45.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding latest draft of mediation statement. 09/24/2019 1.30 585.00 Send recent production of spreadsheets from Apple to co-counsel. 09/26/2019 0.10 45.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding potential damages figures for mediation. 09/26/2019 0.10 45.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding status of mediation and damages. 10/10/2019 0.20 90.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding status of updated plaintiff database; communicate (in firm) regarding the same. 10/16/2019 0.80 360.00 Review/analyze draft of mediation statement. 10/21/2019 0.40 180.00 Research potential other preliminary approval orders in preparation for mediation for Attorney D. Warshaw. 10/23/2019 0.60 270.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding potential settlement agreement. 11/08/2019 1.10 495.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding potential settlement and issues coming up to trial. 11/25/2019 0.40 180.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding trial preparations. 12/02/2019 0.70 315.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding trial preparation. 12/02/2019 0.50 225.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding hot document list in preparation for trial. 12/02/2019 1.20 540.00 Draft/revise confidential settlement conference statement per Attorney D. Warshaw. 12/03/2019 0.80 360.00 Review/analyze Defendant's brief regarding settlement conference; communicate (in firm) regarding the same. 12/04/2019 3.50 1,575.00 Plan and prepare for settlement conference with magistrate. 12/06/2019 1.00 450.00 Draft/revise memorandum regarding pretrial assignments; communicate (in firm) regarding the same. 12/06/2019 0.90 405.00 Draft/revise jury verdict forms. 12/09/2019 1.40 630.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding latest issues for trial preparation. 12/11/2019 1.50 675.00 Draft/revise jury verdict form; communicate (outside counsel regarding the same). 12/11/2019 1.20 540.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding status of trial preparation. 12/11/2019 1.90 855.00 Review/analyze potential jury instructions; review drafts of the same. 12/12/2019 1.20 540.00 Review/analyze sealing order regarding Daubert motions; communicate (in firm) regarding the same. 12/12/2019 0.50 225.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding meet and confer on Daubert motions. 12/12/2019 0.20 90.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding motions in limine. 12/12/2019 0.70 315.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding redactions to Defendant's Daubert motions. 12/12/2019 1.10 495.00 Plan and prepare for meet and confer regarding redactions to Defendant's Daubert motions. 12/12/2019 0.20 90.00 Review/analyze draft of administrative motion to seal in relation to Defendant's Daubert motion; communicate (outside counsel) regarding the same. 12/12/2019 0.30 135.00 Review/analyze drafts of motions in limine. 12/12/2019 1.40 630.00 Research punitive damages in preparation for drafting a jury verdict form and plan for election of remedies. 12/12/2019 1.10 495.00 Review/analyze draft of administrative motion to seal in relation to Defendant's Daubert motion; communicate (in firm) regarding the same. 12/13/2019 1.20 540.00 Review/analyze Defendant's Daubert motion; communicate (in firm) regarding the same. 12/13/2019 4.80 2,160.00 Review/analyze Defendant's edits to joint pretrial statement; communicate (in firm) regarding the same; review other trial documents in preparation for exchange with Defendant. 12/13/2019 4.10 1,845.00 Draft/revise motions in limine, communicate (in firm) with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding the same. 12/16/2019 0.90 405.00 Plan and prepare list of most important documents/reports for new attorney and in preparation for trial. 12/16/2019 0.50 225.00 Review/analyze Defendant's motion in limine in preparation for call regarding drafting oppositions. 12/16/2019 1.40 630.00 Plan and prepare for call regarding latest trial preparation deadlines; communicate

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 58 of 63 Page: 57 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 37 Alexander L. Simon (outside counsel) regarding the same. 12/16/2019 9.00 4,050.00 Draft/revise opposition to Defendant's Motion in Limine No. 2. 12/17/2019 7.40 3,330.00 Draft/revise Plaintiffs' oppositions to Defendant's motion in limine. 12/20/2019 1.30 585.00 Draft/revise stipulation and order regarding opt-out notice to class. 12/20/2019 0.10 45.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding latest draft of Plaintiffs' opposition to Defendant's Daubert. 12/20/2019 0.20 90.00 Review/analyze draft of Plaintiffs' opposition to Defendant's Daubert motion. 01/02/2020 0.30 141.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding administrative motion for relief related to Plaintiffs' opposition to Defendant's Daubert motion. 01/03/2020 0.70 329.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding status of trial preparation and other pre-trial motions. 01/03/2020 0.10 47.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding preparations for trial. 01/06/2020 0.70 329.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding pre-trial counsel. 01/06/2020 0.30 141.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding opt-out notice content and procedure. 01/06/2020 0.10 47.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding pre-trial argument. 01/07/2020 1.30 611.00 Review/analyze verdict forms in preparation for oral arguments; communicate (in firm) regarding the same. 01/08/2020 0.80 376.00 Review/analyze draft of case management statement; communicate (outside counsel) regarding the same. 01/08/2020 0.90 423.00 Review/analyze Apple's edits to class notice; draft/revise class notice. 01/09/2020 1.80 846.00 Review/analyze edits to class notice; communicate (in firm) regarding the same. 01/09/2020 2.50 1,175.00 Review/analyze Apple's revisions to the case management conference statement; communicate (outside counsel) regarding the same. 01/13/2020 0.70 329.00 Plan and prepare for Attorney D. Warshaw's argument regarding verdict forms at pretrial conference. 01/14/2020 6.00 2,820.00 Draft/revise memorandum for Attorney D. Warshaw in preparation for pretrial conference. 01/15/2020 0.20 94.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding potential issues for pre-trial conference. 01/15/2020 2.20 1,034.00 Plan and prepare for pretrial conference; communicate (outside counsel) and (in firm) regarding the same. 01/15/2020 1.20 564.00 Review/analyze the Court's rulings on the motions in limine and other pre-conference motions; communicate (in firm) and (outside counsel) regarding the same. 01/16/2020 2.00 940.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding potential witness lists and pre-trial conference. 01/16/2020 0.30 141.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding logistics for trial. 01/16/2020 0.50 235.00 Review/analyze the Court's pre-trial order; communicate (in firm) regarding the same. 01/17/2020 0.10 47.00 Review/analyze order regarding trial evidence limit and witness list. 01/22/2020 0.50 235.00 Plan and prepare for call regarding upcoming trial deadlines. 01/22/2020 1.00 470.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding status of trial preparation. 01/22/2020 0.20 94.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding upcoming deadlines and class notice. 01/23/2020 0.70 329.00 Communicate (in firm) and (other outside counsel) regarding exhibits/witnesses meeting. 01/24/2020 1.10 517.00 Review/analyze motion for extension filed by Plaintiffs; communicate (in firm) regarding the same. 01/27/2020 2.00 940.00 Review/analyze transcript from pretrial hearing; plan and prepare filing of verdict forms. 01/27/2020 0.70 329.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding status of trial preparation. 01/27/2020 4.00 1,880.00 Research contract issue regarding verdict form; draft/revise argument section regarding the same. 01/27/2020 0.30 141.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding verdict form. 01/27/2020 2.10 987.00 Review/analyze Apple's argument and verdict form; communicate (outside counsel) regarding the same; draft/revise Plaintiffs' argument section or verdict form submission. 01/30/2020 0.70 329.00 Review/analyze Apple's edits to class notice; communicate (in firm) regarding the same. 01/31/2020 0.80 376.00 Communicate (other external) regarding class notice. 02/03/2020 0.40 188.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding mediator's proposal. 02/06/2020 0.90 423.00 Draft/revise Plaintiffs' responses to Apple's objections to Plaintiffs' proffer. 02/13/2020 5.30 2,491.00 Draft/revise motion for preliminary approval of class action settlement. 02/14/2020 2.30 1,081.00 Draft/revise motion for preliminary approval of class action settlement. 02/20/2020 1.90 893.00 Draft/revise motion for preliminary approval of class action settlement. 02/20/2020 0.30 141.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding status of settlement agreement.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 59 of 63 Page: 58 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 37 Alexander L. Simon 02/24/2020 0.40 188.00 Review/analyze latest draft of settlement agreement. 02/24/2020 0.50 235.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding status of settlement agreement with Defendant. 02/24/2020 0.20 94.00 Review/analyze recent decision on approval of settlement from Court. 02/26/2020 2.80 1,316.00 Draft/revise motion for preliminary approval of class action settlement. 02/27/2020 0.30 141.00 Review/analyze latest redlines to settlement agreement in preparation for call. 02/27/2020 0.80 376.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding status of settlement and upcoming deadlines. 02/27/2020 1.50 705.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding status of settlement agreement and preliminary approval briefing. 02/27/2020 3.70 1,739.00 Draft/revise motion for preliminary approval of class action settlement. 02/27/2020 0.40 188.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding status of settlement agreement and preliminary approval briefing. 02/27/2020 0.10 47.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding latest draft of motion for preliminary approval of class action settlement. 02/28/2020 6.60 3,102.00 Draft/revise motion for preliminary approval of class action settlement. 02/28/2020 0.80 376.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding status of settlement agreement. 03/01/2020 3.00 1,410.00 Draft/revise motion for preliminary approval of class action settlement; communicate (outside counsel) regarding the same. 03/02/2020 6.00 2,820.00 Draft/revise motion for preliminary approval of class action settlement; and supporting documents. 03/02/2020 0.60 282.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding status of settlement. 03/03/2020 3.90 1,833.00 Draft/revise motion for preliminary approval of class action settlement and supporting document; communicate (in firm) regarding the same. 03/06/2020 3.90 1,833.00 Research claims distribution issues in preparation for further settlement discussions. 03/06/2020 0.70 329.00 Draft/revise memorandum regarding claims distribution issues in preparation for further settlement discussion. 03/07/2020 2.10 987.00 Draft/revise memorandum regarding claims distributions issues in preparation for further settlement discussions. 03/07/2020 0.40 188.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding memorandum regarding claims distributions issues in preparation for further settlement discussions. 03/07/2020 0.30 141.00 Review/analyze latest edits to motion for preliminary approval of class action settlement; communicate (outside counsel) regarding the same. 03/08/2020 1.90 893.00 Draft/revise memorandum regarding claims distribution issues in preparation for further settlement discussions. 03/08/2020 0.20 94.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding memorandum regarding claims distribution issues. 03/09/2020 4.20 1,974.00 Draft/revise memorandum regarding claims distribution issues; communicate(in firm) regarding the same. 03/12/2020 0.90 423.00 Review/analyze discovery in preparation for edits to motion for preliminary approval. 03/13/2020 0.80 376.00 Review/analyze discovery in preparation for edits to motion for preliminary approval; communicate (outside counsel) regarding the same. 03/16/2020 0.20 94.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) and (in firm) regarding the latest status of settlement negotiations. 03/16/2020 3.10 1,457.00 Draft/revise proposed order and declaration in support of motion for preliminary approval of settlement. 03/16/2020 1.60 752.00 Research incentive awards in preparation for meet and confer with Apple; communicate (outside counsel) regarding the same. 03/17/2020 0.90 423.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding status of settlement. 03/17/2020 0.50 235.00 Draft/revise motion for preliminary approval and declaration of Attorney D. Warshaw in support of; communicate (in firm) regarding the same. 03/18/2020 0.40 188.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding status of settlement. 03/20/2020 0.30 141.00 Review/analyze from Court regarding settlement; communicate (in firm) regarding the same. 03/23/2020 1.80 846.00 Draft/revise motion for preliminary approval and declaration of Attorney D. Warshaw; communicate (in firm and outside counsel) regarding the same. 03/30/2020 2.40 1,128.00 Draft/revise declaration of Attorney D. Warshaw in support of motion for preliminary approval. 03/30/2020 2.40 1,128.00 Draft/revise proposed order for motion for preliminary approval. 03/30/2020 0.60 282.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding edits to and status of declaration of Attorney D. Warshaw in support of motion for preliminary approval. 03/31/2020 5.40 2,538.00 Draft/revise motion for preliminary approval of settlement. 03/31/2020 1.20 564.00 Draft/revise proposed order for motion for preliminary approval. 03/31/2020 2.10 987.00 Draft/revise declaration of Attorney D. Warshaw in support of motion for preliminary approval.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 60 of 63 Page: 59 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 37 Alexander L. Simon 03/31/2020 0.90 423.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding edits to and status of motion for preliminary approval and supporting documents. 04/01/2020 0.40 188.00 Communicate (in firm) regarding status of motion for preliminary approval. 04/01/2020 1.30 611.00 Research case law on the need to delineate cy pres beneficiaries in settlement agreements; communicate (outside counsel) regarding the same. 04/01/2020 1.60 752.00 Draft/revise response to Apple regarding cy pres settlement agreement issue; communicate (outside counsel) and (in firm) regarding the same. 04/01/2020 0.10 47.00 Review/analyze update to Court regarding status of motion for preliminary approval. 04/08/2020 0.60 282.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding status of motion to for preliminary approval and settlement agreement. 04/10/2020 3.60 1,692.00 Review/analyze history of discovery for motion for preliminary approval; communicate (outside counsel) regarding the same. 04/10/2020 0.30 141.00 Communicate (other outside counsel) regarding status of the settlement. 04/26/2020 0.10 47.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding motion for preliminary approval of settlement. 04/27/2020 2.80 1,316.00 Draft/revise motion for preliminary approval of class action settlement. 04/27/2020 1.20 564.00 Draft/revise declaration of Attorney D. Warshaw in support of motion for preliminary approval of class action settlement. 04/27/2020 0.40 188.00 Draft/revise proposed order for motion for preliminary approval of class action settlement. 04/27/2020 0.60 282.00 Communicate (in firm) with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding motion for preliminary approval of class actions settlement.

Total for Timekeeper 37 Billable 748.10 312,564.00 Alexander L. Simon

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 61 of 63 Page: 60 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 50 Eric J. Mont 05/16/2018 2.00 700.00 Review and analyze the First Amended Class Action Complaint and other case materials in preparation of document review. 05/22/2018 5.80 2,030.00 Analyze and code documents produced by Defendant in Batch Depo Prep_Stage3_00007. 05/23/2018 8.30 2,905.00 Analyze and code documents produced by Defendant in Batch Depo Prep_Stage3_00007. 05/24/2018 4.50 1,575.00 Analyze and code documents produced by Defendant in Batch Depo Prep_Stage3_00007. 05/29/2018 0.70 245.00 Analyze and code documents produced by Defendant in batch Depo Prep_Stage3_00011 05/30/2018 1.50 525.00 Analyze and code documents produced by Defendant in batch Depo Prep_Stage3_00011 06/21/2018 3.00 1,050.00 Review and analyze documents in targeted searches in preparation for the deposition of Apple's G. Choy. 06/22/2018 1.00 350.00 Draft memorandum on targeted searches in preparation for the deposition of Apple's G. Choy. 06/27/2018 0.50 175.00 Draft memorandum on targeted searches in preparation of the deposition of Gigi Choy per the direction of Attorney V. Glaze 07/10/2018 3.50 1,225.00 Analyze and code documents produced by Defendant in Batch Apple Productions 00001

Total for Timekeeper 50 Billable 30.80 10,780.00 Eric J. Mont

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 62 of 63 Page: 61 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 53 Joseph C. Bourne 10/22/2018 0.30 201.00 Telephone conference with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding class cert order, order denying reconsideration, and drafting Rule 23(f) petition. 10/23/2018 0.10 67.00 E-mail with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding background materials for drafting 23(f) petition. 10/24/2018 3.50 2,345.00 Review/analyze complaint, class cert briefing, and order on class certification in preparation for drafting 23(f) petition. 10/24/2018 0.30 201.00 Legal research regarding Rule 23(f) requirements in preparation for drafting 23(f) petition. 10/24/2018 0.90 603.00 Telephone conference with Attorney D. Warshaw, J. Manning and co-counsel regarding drafting 23(f) petition, filing additional complaints, and related issues. 10/25/2018 1.00 670.00 Review and analyze order on class certification, order on reconsideration, motion for reconsideration, and opposition to motion for reconsideration in preparation for drafting 23(f) petition. 10/25/2018 0.50 335.00 Legal research regarding choice of law clauses in preparation for call with co-counsel to discuss drafting 23(f) petition. 10/25/2018 0.60 402.00 Telephone conference with Attorney D. Warshaw, Attorney A. Simon, S. Macrae and J. Manning regarding briefing 23(f) petition. 10/25/2018 0.10 67.00 Telephone conference with Attorney D. Warshaw and Attorney A. Simon regarding preparation for drafting 23(f) petition. 10/25/2018 0.10 67.00 Telephone conference with Attorney A. Simon regarding drafting 23(f) petition. 10/25/2018 3.30 2,211.00 Legal research regarding Mazza standard and place of the harm in preparation for drafting 23(f) petition. 10/26/2018 0.10 67.00 E-mail with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding drafting 23(f) petition. 10/26/2018 6.60 4,422.00 Legal research regarding Mazza standard and place of the harm in preparation for drafting 23(f) petition. 10/28/2018 6.30 4,221.00 Legal research regarding California choice of law in preparation for drafting 23(f) petition. 10/29/2018 7.90 5,293.00 Draft California governmental interest test section of 23(f) petition. 10/29/2018 0.10 67.00 E-mail with Attorney A. Simon regarding draft 23(f) petition. 10/29/2018 0.20 134.00 Telephone conference with Attorney A. Simon regarding draft 23(f) petition. 10/29/2018 0.10 67.00 E-mail with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding draft 23(f) petition. 10/30/2018 6.60 4,422.00 Further research and preparation of 23(f) petition regarding choice of law. 10/30/2018 0.20 134.00 Telephone conference with Attorney A. Simon regarding briefing on California choice of law regarding 23(f) petition. 10/30/2018 0.10 67.00 E-mail with Attorney D. Warshaw, Attorney A. Simon and co-counsel regarding draft sections of 23(f) petition. 10/31/2018 0.80 536.00 Telephone conference with Attorney D. Warshaw, J. Manning, and co-counsel regarding 23(f) petition, mediation brief, plaintiff issues, class notice, and settlement and litigation strategy. 10/31/2018 0.50 335.00 Review/analyze combined 23(f) petition in preparation for call with co-counsel. 10/31/2018 0.10 67.00 E-mail with J. Manning and co-counsel regarding draft 23(f) petition. 10/31/2018 0.10 67.00 E-mail with Attorney D. Warshaw and Attorney A. Simon regarding draft 23(f) petition. 10/31/2018 0.60 402.00 Review/analyze draft sections of 23(f) petition from J. Manning regarding introduction, facts, and statement of issues. 10/31/2018 2.20 1,474.00 Draft and revise 23(f) petition sections regarding California choice of law and choice-of-law agreement. 11/01/2018 0.10 67.00 E-mail with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding nationwide class settlement issues in Ninth Circuit. 11/01/2018 0.70 469.00 Legal research regarding nationwide class settlement issues. 11/01/2018 0.40 268.00 Review/analyze edits from D. Tejtel to 23(f) petition. 11/02/2018 0.10 67.00 E-mail with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding edits to 23(f) petition. 11/02/2018 2.80 1,876.00 Further research and preparation of 23(f) petition. 11/02/2018 0.50 335.00 Telephone conference with Attorney D. Warshaw, J. Manning and co-counsel regarding final edits to 23(f) petition and mediation statement. 11/02/2018 0.10 67.00 E-mail with Attorney A. Simon, Attorney D. Warshaw and J. Manning regarding cite checking 23(f) petition. 11/03/2018 0.20 134.00 Review/analyze edits from Attorney A. Simon to 23(f) petition. 11/05/2018 0.30 201.00 Review/analyze edits from co-counsel to 23(f) petition. 11/05/2018 0.10 67.00 Telephone conference with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding finalizing and filing 23(f) petition. 11/16/2018 0.10 67.00 Telephone conference with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding reply in support of 23(f) petition. 11/20/2018 1.30 871.00 Draft motion for leave to file reply brief in support of 23(f) petition.

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Date: 10/31/2020 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Detail Document Fee Task Code 429-22 Billing Report Filed 11/24/20 Page 63 of 63 Page: 62 PEARSON | SIMON · WARSHAW, LLP

Trans Hours Date to Bill Amount Timekeeper 53 Joseph C. Bourne 11/20/2018 0.10 67.00 E-mail with Attorney D. Warshaw regarding motion for leave to file reply in support of 23(f) petition.

Total for Timekeeper 53 Billable 50.00 33,500.00 Joseph C. Bourne

GRAND TOTALS

Billable 3,031.40 2,144,405.00

DLW Monday 11/23/2020 12:00 pm Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-23 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 2

EXHIBIT 4 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-23 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 2

Law Offices PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP 1 5 1 6 5 VENTURA BOULEVARD , SUITE 4 0 0 SHERMAN OAKS, CALIFORNIA 9 140 3 ( 8 1 8 ) 7 8 8 - 8 3 0 0 FAX ( 8 1 8 ) 7 8 8 - 8 1 0 4 WWW. PSWLAW . COM

GRACE v. APPLE, INC.

COST AND EXPENSE SUMMARY

Conference Call Services $260.91 Legal Research $1,749.54 Delivery Service $543.43 Postage $1.38 Out of Town Travel $8,396.91 Meal Expense $515.58 Assessment to Litigation Fund $240,700.00 TOTAL $252,167.75

LOS ANGELES SAN FRANCISCO MINNEAPOLIS

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-24 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 2

EXHIBIT 5 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-24 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 2

Law Offices PEARSON, SIMON & WARSHAW, LLP 15165 VENTURA BOULEVARD, SUITE 400 SHERMAN OAKS, CALIFORNIA 9 140 3 (818) 788-8300 FAX (818) 788-8104 WWW.P S W L A W .C O M

GRACE v. APPLE, INC.

LITIGATION FUND COST AND EXPENSE SUMMARY

DEBITS

Bank Fees $ 150.56 Court Reporter $ 63,385.56 Data Consultant $ 396.00 Document Review Hosting $ 35,502.69 Experts $851,501.22 Mediation Fee $ 10,900.00 Third Party Subpoena Fee $ 140.00

TOTAL $961,976.03

CREDITS/ASSESSMENTS

Caldwell, Cassady & Curry $240,700.00 Friedman, Oster & Tejtel PLLC $240,700.00 Steyer Lowenthal Boodrookas Alvarez & Smith LLP $240,700.00 Pearson, Simon & Warshaw, LLP $240,700.00

TOTAL $962,800.00

ACCOUNT BALANCE TOTAL $ 823.97*

*Excludes unpaid invoice $33,671.56 for document review hosting.

LOS ANGELES SAN FRANCISCO MINNEAPOLIS Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-25 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 7

CALDWELL CASSADY & CURRY 1 Bradley W. Caldwell (admitted pro hac vice) Jason D. Cassady (admitted pro hac vice) 2 John Austin Curry (admitted pro hac vice) 2121 N. Pearl Street, Suite 1200 3 Dallas, TX 75201 Telephone: (214) 888-4848 4 [email protected] [email protected] 5 [email protected]

6 Counsel for Plaintiffs and the Class

7 8 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

9 NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

10 SAN JOSE DIVISION

11

12 CHRISTINA GRACE AND KEN POTTER, Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC Individually and on Behalf of All Others 13 Similarly Situated, CLASS ACTION

14 Plaintiffs, DECLARATION OF J. AUSTIN CURRY IN SUPPORT OF 15 v. PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, 16 APPLE, INC., REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES AND SERVICE AWARDS 17 Defendant. Date: February 8, 2021 18 Time: 1:30pm Court: 8, 4th Floor 19 Judge: The Honorable Lucy H. Koh

20

21

22

23 I, Austin Curry, declare as follows:

24 1. I am a partner of Caldwell Cassady & Curry, P.C., co-counsel for Plaintiffs in this class 25 action against Defendant Apple, Inc. I am admitted to practice before this Court, and I am a 26 member in good standing of the bar of the State of Texas.

27 2. I submit this declaration in support of Plaintiffs’ Motion for Attorneys’ Fees, 28

DECLARATION OF J. AUSTIN CURRY IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES, REIMBURSEMENT OF EXPENSES, AND SERVICE AWARDS Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-25 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 7

1 Reimbursement of Expenses and Service Awards. I make this declaration based on personal 2 knowledge and, if called as a witness, I could and would competently testify to the matters stated 3 herein.

4 A. CCC Attorney Time and Expenses 5 3. My firm has served as counsel for Plaintiff and Class Representatives Christina Grace 6 and Ken Potter throughout the course of this litigation. My firm typically handles patent 7 infringement litigation, but from time to time we are also retained in non-patent cases that 8 heavily involve technology. But at bottom, my firm is a trial firm. A brief description of my firm 9 is attached as Exhibit 1.

10 4. CCC has prosecuted this litigation solely on a contingent fee basis and has been at risk 11 that it would not receive any compensation for its work—or reimbursement for its costs—in 12 prosecuting the claims against Apple. The time and resources my firm invested in this matter 13 could have been placed in other hourly or contingency matters.

14 5. Throughout this litigation, CCC kept files contemporaneously documenting all time 15 spent, including tasks performed, and expenses incurred. All of the time and expenses reported 16 by my firm were incurred for the benefit of the Settlement Class. I have personally reviewed 17 every time entry billed by each attorneys and staff member from my firm, and edited and 18 removed time that appeared excessive or unnecessarily duplicative. Throughout this litigation, 19 my firm’s expenses were submitted on a monthly basis to Pearson, Simon & Warshaw, LLP. 20 Subsequent to the Court’s order regarding class counsel (Dkt. No. 270), my firm reported its time 21 to Jill Manning on a monthly basis.

22 6. During the course of this litigation, CCC attorneys have been involved in the following 23 tasks and activities on behalf of the Settlement Class:

24 7. Austin Curry. From the outset of this case, my work was focused on trial. In my 25 practice, trial preparation requires not only securing admissible evidence that supports my 26 client’s claim, but also exhausting areas of inquiry related to any possible defense or argument 27 my client’s adversaries might make. As it relates to this case specifically, my work was focused 28 2 DECLARATION OF J. AUSTIN CURRY IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION TO CERTIFY A NATIONWIDE CLASS Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-25 Filed 11/24/20 Page 3 of 7

1 on proving, not only that Apple broke FaceTime, but also understanding Apple’s options and 2 motivations during the relevant timeframes to head off arguments that we might have heard from 3 Apple at trial and arguments that Apple made in litigation before trial. As an example, Apple 4 argued that FaceTime broke because of a “bug,” that the FaceTime Break had nothing to do with 5 reducing FaceTime relay usage, that Apple could not have fixed FaceTime for iOS 6 users, that it 6 could not have provided a FaceTime app to its iOS 6 users, that the change to FaceTime was so 7 complex such that it could not have been made earlier, and that iOS 7 did not perform worse on 8 iPhone 4 and 4S devices. Responding to these arguments (as well as arguments that Apple might 9 have made at trial) required me to understand how FaceTime uses certificate chains to 10 authenticate calls, review Apple’s documents to distinguish between FaceTime failing because of 11 the FaceTime Break on the one hand, and the leaf certificate expiration on the other, identify 12 individuals at Apple involved in both reducing FaceTime’s relay usage and working on the 13 certificate chain for iOS 7, understand what Apple changed in the source code to address the 14 expired certificate, and review Apple’s documentation regarding its performance testing.

15 8. This work, as it relates to discovery, involved reviewing documents, identifying gaps in 16 Apple’s document production, conducting correspondence with Apple about missing discovery, 17 conferring with Apple’s lawyers to try to resolve discovery disputes, filing motions to compel, 18 arguing at discovery hearings, and taking depositions of Apple’s engineers (after identifying 19 which Apple engineers to depose). A related, but more isolated, discovery task that I handled 20 was working with the lawyers for Apple to obtain discovery that would identify class members 21 using the iTunes transaction database and then identifying how Apple’s criteria in creating the 22 first set of spreadsheets identifying class members was too narrow, omitted certain class 23 members, and pursuing complete discovery on that front (which also entailed motions practice). 24 And working with Jill Manning and Suneel Jain, I responded to Apple’s demands to have and 25 inspect all possible information on the class representatives’ iPhone devices—which posed an 26 unwarranted invasion into the class representatives’ privacy and, in turn, required me to review 27 28 3 DECLARATION OF J. AUSTIN CURRY IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION TO CERTIFY A NATIONWIDE CLASS Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-25 Filed 11/24/20 Page 4 of 7

1 massive amounts of data on those devices to prevent inadvertent disclosure of the class 2 representatives’ sensitive, personal information.

3 9. As it relates to experts, I worked closely with Dr. Mark Jones. My time spent with Dr. 4 Jones involved learning from him and what he observed in Apple’s source code as well as 5 assisting him in preparing his expert report. I defended Dr. Jones’s deposition in this case. As 6 our trial date neared, I was heavily involved in discussing trial themes, gathering evidence, 7 preparing witness outlines with the trial team. I also handled the joint jury instruction 8 submission with counsel for Apple and drafted motions in limine. I assisted in reviewing and 9 editing the mediation statements. I prepared for and attended the mediation sessions with Judge 10 William Cahill (Ret.) and the settlement conferences with Magistrate Judge Nathanael Cousins. I 11 was involved in discussing the terms of the settlement agreement and participated in lengthy 12 negotiations with Apple’s counsel regarding same.

13 10. Jason Cassady. Mr. Cassady was primarily involved in discovery disputes (including 14 arguing at discovery hearings) and trial preparation, such as exhibits, deposition designations, 15 motions in limine, and proposed jury instructions. Mr. Cassady also worked with Dr. Hastings in 16 the preparation of her report.

17 11. Bradley Caldwell. Mr. Caldwell was involved in investigating this matter, working with 18 Dr. Jones, identifying possible areas of inquiry with me, and preparing for trial. He reviewed key 19 legal briefings and all Court orders. He participated in legal strategy sessions with co-counsel

20 and was involved in mediation and settlement conferences. 21 12. Warren McCarty. Mr. McCarty assisted me in all of the work I did in developing the 22 facts of the case and heading off the areas of inquiry, as I outlined above. Mr. McCarty was 23 involved in assisting Dr. Jones preparing his report, and he took depositions of Apple’s fact and 24 expert witnesses.

25 13. Daniel Pearson. Mr. Pearson worked extensively on third party discovery, particularly 26 the third parties who produced evidence of how the market value of iPhone devices dropped after 27 28 4 DECLARATION OF J. AUSTIN CURRY IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION TO CERTIFY A NATIONWIDE CLASS Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-25 Filed 11/24/20 Page 5 of 7

1 the FaceTime Break. Mr. Pearson was also involved in assisting Dr. Hastings with her report as 2 well as trial preparation.

3 14. John Summers. Mr. Summers’s primary involvement was in legal research and writing 4 regarding nationwide certifiability, and he was also involved with other aspects of this litigation 5 as requested by other members of the team.

6 15. Hamad Hamad. Mr. Hamad, like Mr. McCarty, assisted me in fact development. 7 16. Seth Reich. Mr. Reich’s provided assistance to Mr. McCarty and me as we were helping 8 Dr. Jones prepare his expert report.

9 17. Bailey Blaies. Ms. Blaies conducted legal research regarding mediation confidentiality. 10 (I would like to say what prompted this research, but apparently I cannot.)

11 18. Nick Nestelbaum. Mr. Nestelbaum, a former associate at CCC, assisted in drafting 12 motions in limine.

13 19. Mike Delaney and Beverly DeFeo, paralegals at CCC, organized discovery, prepared 14 working binders for counsel, and assisted with targeted discovery projects. 15 * * *

16 20. Attached hereto as Exhibit 2 is a chart setting forth, form inception through October 31, 17 2020: (i) the individuals from this firm who have worked on this case; (ii) the dates of admission 18 (attorneys) or years of experience (non-attorneys) for each individual who has worked on this 19 case; (iii) the billable rates charged by each individual, by year, for work performed on this case; 20 (iv) the total number of hours that each individual has worked on this case, by year; and (v) the 21 total hours and total lodestar for the firm. Moreover, the time submissions do not include any 22 time devoted to preparing this declaration or otherwise pertaining to the Plaintiffs’ motion for 23 attorney’s fees. The attorneys and staff who worked on this case are listed below:

24 ATTORNEYS 25 (1) Austin Curry 1,202.6 hours 26 (2) Jason Cassady 390.8 hours 27 (3) Brad Caldwell 280.3 hours 28 5 DECLARATION OF J. AUSTIN CURRY IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION TO CERTIFY A NATIONWIDE CLASS Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-25 Filed 11/24/20 Page 6 of 7

1 (4) Warren McCarty 601.6 hours 2 (5) Daniel Pearson 239.9 hours 3 (6) John Summers 149.0 hours 4 (7) Hamad Hamad 118.3 hours 5 (8) Seth Reich 46.9 hours 6 (9) Bailey Blaies 20.1 hours 7 (10) Nick Nestelbaum 8.5 hours

8 9 LEGAL ASSISTANTS 10 (1) Mike Delaney 199.2 hours 11 (2) Beverly DeFeo 26.3 hours 12

13 21. This is my firm’s first class action case. As a result, no court has previously awarded my 14 firm its hourly rates. These rates, however, are rates that our clients have paid in our patent 15 infringement cases.

16 22. The lodestar calculation is based on my firm’s historical billing rates in effect at the time 17 services were performed. Exhibit 2 was prepared from contemporaneous time records regularly 18 prepared and maintained by my firm. The hourly rates for CCC partners, attorneys and 19 professional support staff included in Exhibit 2 were at the time the work was performed the 20 usual and customary hourly rates charged for their services in similar complex litigation.

21 23. The total number of hours reasonably expended on this litigation by my firm from 22 inception through October 31, 2020 is 3,283.30 hours. The total lodestar for CCC at historical 23 rates is $2,148,632.80. Attached hereto as Exhibit 3 is a true and correct copy of my firm’s daily 24 time records for each of the individuals at my firm who has billed time to this case and which 25 time is being submitted as a part of my firm’s lodestar.

26 24. CCC has expended a total of $278,182.99 in unreimbursed costs and expenses in 27 connection with the prosecution of this litigation. These costs and expenses are broken down in 28 6 DECLARATION OF J. AUSTIN CURRY IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION TO CERTIFY A NATIONWIDE CLASS Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-25 Filed 11/24/20 Page 7 of 7

1 the chart attached hereto as Exhibit 4. They were incurred on behalf of the Class by my firm on a 2 contingent basis and have not been reimbursed. The expenses incurred in this action are reflected 3 on the books and records of my firm. My firm is seeking reimbursement for reasonable travel 4 expenses incurred in connection with this litigation. I and my colleagues occasionally traveled to 5 San Jose and San Francisco to attend court hearings, mediations and settlement conferences, and 6 depositions. For those trips, my firm is seeking reimbursement of the cost of coach airfare tickets 7 and reasonable hotel and meal expenses.

8 I DECLARE UNDER PENALTY OF PERJURY UNDER THE LAWS OF THE UNITED STATES THAT

9 THE FOREGOING IS TRUE AND CORRECT. EXECUTED ON NOVEMBER 24, 2020, AT 2121 N. PEARL ST.,

10 SUITE 1200, DALLAS, TEXAS 75201. 11 ______12 J. Austin Curry 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 7 DECLARATION OF J. AUSTIN CURRY IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION TO CERTIFY A NATIONWIDE CLASS Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-26 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 6

EXHIBIT 1 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-26 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 6

CALDWELL CASSADY CURRY PC FIRM RESUME

Caldwell Cassady Curry PC (“CCC” or the “Firm”) is a Dallas-based litigation boutique, founded in 2013, that specializes in intellectual property and corporate litigation, with extensive experience in the Eastern and Northern Districts of Texas. CCC has also litigated cases across the country, including federal courts in Florida, California, Illinois, Delaware, Missouri, New Jersey, Utah, Virginia, Wisconsin, and the International Trade Commission. Attorneys at Caldwell Cassady Curry PC have litigated and tried cases involving a broad range of intellectual property and business disputes. The firm’s patent infringement cases have covered a variety of technologies, including electronics, computer science and architecture, signal processing, telecommunications, medical devices, and oilfield technology. In preparing these cases for claim construction and trial, our attorneys not only work closely with leading experts but also draw upon their own science and engineering backgrounds. The current engagements of Caldwell Cassady Curry PC—as well as prior, representative cases handled by the attorneys while at their previous law firms—include: VirnetX Inc. v. Apple Inc. Caldwell Cassady Curry PC represents VirnetX in the company’s patent infringement litigation against technology giant Apple Inc. In late 2012, we helped VirnetX win a $368 million verdict when a federal jury determined that Apple had infringed four VirnetX patents to produce the VPN On Demand and FaceTime features in the popular iPhone and other Apple products. After the case was sent back for a new trial on damages, we won again; securing a $625 million verdict for VirnetX in February 2016 after jurors in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas found that Apple continued to infringe VirnetX’s patents following the first trial in order to produce the FaceTime, and re-designed VPN On Demand features. The jury also found that Apple’s infringement was willful regarding FaceTime and VPN on Demand. The court later vacated its order to consolidate the matters and set the cases for two separate jury trials. In the first new trial heard in September 2016 pertaining to the earlier generations of products, we helped VirnetX win a $302 million verdict against Apple before a new Eastern Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-26 Filed 11/24/20 Page 3 of 6

District jury. The verdict was entered as a $439.7 million judgment in September 2017 and affirmed on appeal by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit. In the second new trial heard in April 2018 addressing the newer generations of products, a different Eastern District jury awarded a unanimous verdict of $502.6 million in favor of VirnetX after finding Apple’s infringement was willful. The entire verdict amount was entered as a judgment in August 2018. Morley v. Square Inc. The firm represented Washington University in St. Louis professor Dr. Robert Morley in his lawsuit against Square Inc., Jack Dorsey, and Jim McKelvey seeking to restore Dr. Morley’s co-ownership of Square Inc. The litigation in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Missouri included claims for patent infringement, breach of fiduciary duty, misappropriation of trade secrets, exclusion of Dr. Morley from Square, and related business torts after Dr. Morley invented the famous Square credit card reader and helped create the company. The parties reached a mutually agreeable settlement in 2016. Match Group, LLC v. Bumble Trading, Inc. The firm represents Match Group LLC, owner of numerous online dating brands including the iconic Tinder application, in a highly publicized intellectual property and business dispute with competitor Bumble Trading Inc. in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas. Acantha LLC v. DePuy Synthes Caldwell Cassady Curry PC successfully represented Acantha LLP in a patent infringement lawsuit against medical device manufacturer DePuy Synthes, a subsidiary of healthcare giant Johnson & Johnson. DePuy was sued based on its infringement of an Acantha patent that covers an orthopedic implant assembly used in surgical procedures. Following the August 2018 trial in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Wisconsin, a jury of five women and three men delivered a unanimous $8.2 million verdict in favor of the firm’s client. Cellular Communications Equipment LLC v. Apple Inc. Caldwell Cassady Curry PC represented Cellular Communications Equipment LLC in a patent infringement lawsuit against Apple Inc. over a network technology patent. Following a trial heard in September 2016 in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas, jurors Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-26 Filed 11/24/20 Page 4 of 6

found Apple to be a willful infringer and awarded a $22 million verdict in favor of CCE. The award represented a running royalty on Apple’s infringement through March 2016. Virnetx Inc. v. Microsoft Corp. Attorneys at the firm represented VirnetX in its patent infringement action against Microsoft involving virtual private network technology. In 2011, a jury awarded VirnetX a $105 million verdict after finding that Microsoft’s infringement was willful. The case settled after VirnetX moved for a permanent injunction. Caldwell Cassady Curry PC later represented VirnetX in subsequent litigation over additional infringement by Microsoft, and Microsoft settled before trial in 2014. Smartflash LLC v. Apple Inc., et al. and Smartflash LLC v. Samsung The firm represents Smartflash in its patent infringement actions involving Smartflash’s data storage and access system patents, which are infringed by Apple’s iTunes store and the Google Play feature in Samsung’s and HTC’s products. In February 2015, a jury awarded Smartflash $532,900,000 in its verdict and found that Apple’s infringement was willful. Summit 6 LLC v. Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd, Facebook Inc., et al. Mr. Caldwell represented Summit 6 in its patent infringement action in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas involving the company’s patents that cover the compression of images prior to uploading. All parties other than Samsung settled before a 2013 trial that ended with a Dallas jury awarding $15 million to Summit 6 in its verdict against Samsung. Metronic Inc. v. Boston Scientific Corp. Mr. Caldwell and Mr. Cassady have represented Medtronic in multiple patent infringement actions involving coronary catheterization, stent design, and drug-eluting stent technology pending in the Eastern District of Texas and elsewhere. In Medtronic, Inc. v. Boston Scientific Corp., Mr. Caldwell represented Medtronic in a jury trial which resulted in a $250 million verdict in Medtronic’s favor. This lawsuit settled after judgment was entered by the district court. i4i Limited Partnership v. Microsoft Corp. Mr. Curry represented i4i in a suit filed against Microsoft Corporation for patent infringement involving methods for compiling and maintaining the architecture and content of a document separate from each other. The jury awarded i4i $200 million in its verdict, and i4i Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-26 Filed 11/24/20 Page 5 of 6

successfully defeated all of Microsoft’s appeals—including Microsoft’s appeal to the Supreme Court of the United States, in which the Supreme Court affirmed the clear and convincing burden for challenging the validity of a patent. Varel International Independent LP Attorneys at the firm have represented and continue to represent Varel in various patent and commercial litigation matters, including defending Varel against ReedHycalog’s allegations of patent infringement. Opti Inc. v. Apple Inc. Mr. Cassady represented Opti in a patent infringement suit against Apple regarding its patent regarding a computer operation that enables a “pre-snooping” function designed to allow for the more efficient transfer of data. A jury found that Apple willfully infringed Opti’s patent and awarded $19 million in its verdict. The case settled shortly before completion of the appeal to the Federal Circuit. Wyeth and Cordis Corp. v. Medtronic Inc., et al. Mr. Caldwell represented Medtronic in defense of a patent infringement lawsuit pending in the District of New Jersey where local companies Wyeth and Cordis accused Medtronic of infringing patents pertaining to the use of the drug rapamycin (now commercially known as sirolimus) to treat restenosis—re-narrowing of an artery following an angioplasty procedure. The district court granted Medtronic’s motion for summary judgment invalidating the asserted patents. Halliburton Energy Services Inc. v. BJ Services Corp. Mr. Caldwell and Mr. Cassady represented Halliburton as trial counsel in an arbitration proceeding against BJ Services Corporation (now a part of Baker Hughes, Inc.) in a case pertaining to infringement of three Halliburton patents in the field of hydraulic fracturing. Mr. Caldwell tried the case before the American Arbitration Association. ReedHycalog LP v. US Synthetics Corp. Mr. Cassady represented US Synthetics in defending ReedHycalog’s allegations of patent infringement litigation regarding diamond cutter technology. Bedrock Computer Techs v. Google Inc. Mr. Curry and Mr. Cassady represented Bedrock in a suit filed against Google for patent infringement involving methods for efficiently removing expired data from information storage Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-26 Filed 11/24/20 Page 6 of 6

and retrieval systems. The case settled shortly after the jury awarded $5 million in favor of Bedrock. TGIP Inc. v. AT&T Corp. Mr. Caldwell represented TGIP in a patent-infringement action against AT&T, MCI/Verizon, and others pertaining to point-of-sale activated calling cards. AT&T remained in the lawsuit through a jury trial, and verdict in favor of TGIP was awarded by that jury. The case settled favorably for TGIP while an appeal was pending. Anascape Ltd. v. Nintendo of America Inc. and Microsoft Corp. Mr. Cassady represented Anascape in its patent infringement lawsuit against Microsoft and Nintendo involving video game controller technology. After a two week trial in the Eastern District of Texas, Anascape obtained a jury verdict against Nintendo. Microsoft and Anascape reached a confidential settlement on the eve of trial. i2 Technologies Inc. (now JDA Software Group) v. Oracle Corp. Mr. Caldwell represented i2 in a patent infringement action involving supply chain planning and application management patents. The parties reached a settlement agreement following the pretrial conference. JP Morgan Chase & Co. v. Affiliated Computer Services Inc. Mr. Caldwell defended ACS in a patent infringement lawsuit brought by JPMorgan Chase in the District of Delaware, focusing on three stored-value card patents asserted by JPMorgan. Before the close of discovery, JPMorgan unilaterally dropped all three of those patents from the lawsuit in the face of compelling noninfringement, invalidity, and inequitable conduct defenses.

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-27 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 3

EXHIBIT 2 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-27 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 3

Grace v. Apple, Inc. Time Report Caldwell Cassady Curry PC Report Period: Inception through October 31, 2020 Status: (P) Principal (A) Associate (PL) Paralegal

NAME STATUS BAR ADMITTANCE HOURLY RATE CUMULATIVE HOURS CUMULATIVE LODESTAR Bailey A. Blaies (2019) A 2018 $425 20.1 $8,542.50 Bailey A. Blaies (2020) A 2018 $525 0 $0.00 Bradley W. Caldwell (2017) P 2003 $825 29.7 $24,502.50 Bradley W. Caldwell (2018) P 2003 $825 113.3 $82,417.50 Bradley W. Caldwell (2019) P 2003 $875 11.2 $9,800.00 Bradley W. Caldwell (2020) P 2003 $975 126.1 $122,947.50 J. Austin Curry (2017) P 2007 $825 304.4 $251,190.00 J. Austin Curry (2018) P 2007 $825 637.1 $494,587.50 J. Austin Curry (2019) P 2007 $875 167.9 $146,912.50 J. Austin Curry (2020) P 2007 $975 93.2 $90,870.00 Jason D. Cassady (2017) P 2004 $825 8.5 $7,012.50 Jason D. Cassady (2018) P 2004 $825 78.4 $64,680.00 Jason D. Cassady (2019) P 2004 $875 116.7 $102,112.50 Jason D. Cassady (2020) P 2004 $975 187.2 $182,520.00 Hamad M. Hamad (2018) A 2009 $565 117.7 $66,500.50 Hamad M. Hamad (2019) P 2009 $615 0.4 $359.00 Hamad M. Hamad (2020) P 2009 $715 0 $0.00 Warren J. McCarty (2017) A 2013 $450 11.4 $5,130.00 Warren J. McCarty (2018) A 2013 $450 564.3 $212,490.00 Warren J. McCarty (2019) A 2013 $500 25.9 $12,950.00 Warren J. McCarty (2020) A 2013 $600 0 $0.00 Nicholas Nestelbaum (2019) A 2015 $475 8.5 $4,037.50 Nicholas Nestelbaum (2020) A 2015 $575 0 $0.00 Daniel R. Pearson (2018) A 2009 $500 239.9 $119,950.00 Daniel R. Pearson (2019) A 2009 $550 0 $0.00 Daniel R. Pearson (2020) P 2009 $650 0 $0.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-27 Filed 11/24/20 Page 3 of 3

R. Seth Reich (2018) A 2013 $450 46.9 $21,105.00 R. Seth Reich (2019) A 2013 $500 0 $0.00 R. Seth Reich (2020) A 2013 $600 0 $0.00 John F. Summers (2017) A 2011 $525 79.8 $36,409.80 John F. Summers (2018) A 2011 $525 69.2 $36,330.00 John F. Summers (2019) P 2011 $600 0 $0.00 John F. Summers (2020) P 2011 $700 0 $0.00 ATTORNEY TOTALS 3057.8 $2,103,356.80

Beverly J. DeFeo (2017) PL n/a $285 0.9 $256.50 Beverly J. DeFeo (2018) PL n/a $285 11.8 $3,363.00 Beverly J. DeFeo (2019) PL n/a $295 13.6 $4,012.00 Beverly J. DeFeo (2020) PL n/a $350 0 $0.00 Michael P. Delaney (2017) PL n/a $225 13.7 $3,082.50 Michael P. Delaney (2018) PL n/a $225 95.6 $12,073.50 Michael P. Delaney (2019) PL n/a $235 67.2 $15,792.00 Michael P. Delaney (2020) PL n/a $295 22.7 $6,696.50 NON-ATTORNEY TOTALS 225.5 $45,276.00

TOTALS 3283.3 $2,148,632.80

Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 106

EXHIBIT 3 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 106

GRACE v. APPLE, INC. Case No. 5:17-cv-00551-LHK-NC

CALDWELL CASSADY CURRY PC

ATTORNEY DAILY TIME ENTRIES

TAB A – Bailey Blaies

TAB B – Bradley W. Caldwell

TAB C – Jason D. Cassady

TAB D – J. Austin Curry

TAB E – Hamad M. Hamad

TAB F - Warren J. McCarty

TAB G - Nicholas Nestelbaum

TAB H - Daniel R. Pearson

TAB I - R. Seth Reich

TAB J – John F. Summers

NON -ATTORNEY DAILY TIME ENTRIES

TAB NA-1 - Beverly J. DeFeo

TAB NA-2 – Michael P. Delaney Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 3 of 106

TAB A Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 4 of 106

Bailey Blaies ‐ Time Detail Grace v. Apple, Inc. ‐‐ No. 5:17‐cv‐00551‐LHK Inception through 10.31.20

Date Name Task Rate Hours Confer with Austin Curry regarding research on the California and federal mediation privilege. Research the California and federal mediation privilege, and any local confidentiality 11/05/2019 Bailey Blaies requirements. 425 0.60 Confer with Austin Curry regarding research on the California and federal mediation privilege. Research the California and federal mediation privilege, and any local confidentiality 11/08/2019 Bailey Blaies requirements. 425 4.00 Research the California and federal mediation privilege, and any local confidentiality requirements. Prepare memo on the 11/11/2019 Bailey Blaies issue. 425 8.20 Research the California and federal mediation privilege, and any local confidentiality requirements. Prepare memo on the 11/12/2019 Bailey Blaies issue. 425 6.00 Research the California and federal mediation privilege, and any local confidentiality requirements. Prepare memo on the 11/17/2019 Bailey Blaies issue. 425 1.30 TOTAL: 20.10 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 5 of 106

TAB B Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 6 of 106

Bradley W. Caldwell ‐ Time Detail Grace v. Apple, Inc. ‐‐ No. 5:17‐cv‐00551‐LHK Inception through 10.31.20

Date Name Task Rate Hours Analyze Apple's motion to dismiss and consider responses; 03/23/2017 Bradley W. Caldwell discuss with A. Curry. 825 1.1 03/23/2017 Bradley W. Caldwell Identify likely misstatemens in Apple's motion. 825 0.7 03/27/2017 Bradley W. Caldwell Outline responses to protective order threats. 825 0.8

03/28/2017 Bradley W. Caldwell Review Apple's motion to dismiss; research related issues. 825 2.4 Review motion to dismiss and strategize about responses; 04/19/2017 Bradley W. Caldwell discuss with A. Curry. 825 1.3

04/19/2017 Bradley W. Caldwell Review and revise draft responses to motion to dismiss. 825 1.2 07/28/2017 Bradley W. Caldwell Review order denying motion to dismiss. 825 2 08/09/2017 Bradley W. Caldwell Work with A. Curry on protective order issues. 825 2.4 08/17/2017 Bradley W. Caldwell Review and edit interrogatories. 825 0.6 08/28/2017 Bradley W. Caldwell Review production documents identified by A. Curry. 825 1.2 08/29/2017 Bradley W. Caldwell Review production documents identified by A. Curry. 825 0.8 10/16/2017 Bradley W. Caldwell Review hot documents. 825 5.2 Meet with A. Curry to understand Apple's proposed manner of selecting documents to produce regarding identifying the class; identify flaws in their thinking and consider additional 11/03/2017 Bradley W. Caldwell ways to get at the actual facts. 825 1.6

11/07/2017 Bradley W. Caldwell Work with A. Curry to prepare for hearing with J. Cousins. 825 2.4 Review technical documents identified by A. Curry for M. 12/07/2017 Bradley W. Caldwell Jones. 825 2.8 Discuss the working strategy on implementation of the 12/27/2017 Bradley W. Caldwell Facetime break with A. Curry. 825 2 Discuss case issues with A. Curry; strategize about Apple's 12/27/2017 Bradley W. Caldwell motivation for the break. 825 1.2 01/22/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Assist A. Curry in preparing for hearing. 825 2.6 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 7 of 106

01/23/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Assist A. Curry in preparing for hearing. 825 3.1 02/02/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Discuss Apple's proposal for inspecting client devices. 825 0.8 Assist in preparation of D. DeAtley deposition and propose 04/16/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell questions for A. Curry 825 4.2 04/19/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Prepare for G. Thirumalai deposition 825 2.6

Attend G. Thirumalai deposition and assist W. McCarty based 04/20/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell on me having previously cross‐examined G. Thirumalai. 825 6.5 04/27/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Review and edit motion for class certification. 825 1.1 Review and study Facetime break chronology and supporting 05/04/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell documents. 825 3.4

05/04/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Review class certification briefing and discuss with A. Curry. 825 1.5 06/19/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Work with A. Curry to prepare for hearing. 825 3.7 Participate in hearing and in‐person conferences with Apple's 06/20/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell counsel. 825 4.6 07/09/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Work on reply regarding class certification. 825 3.6 07/10/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Work on reply regarding class certification. 825 3.4

07/12/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Review certification reply drafts and discuss with A. Curry. 825 4.1

Review order regarding class certification and analyze same; confer with A. Curry regarding how to handle the limits on certification and potential appeal points; email co‐counsel regarding the order and participate in group call regarding 09/18/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell same in order to suggest possible appeal points. 825 3.7

Continue analysis of how to proceed toward trial in this 09/19/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell matter while also appealing limits on class certification. 825 2.4 09/24/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Strategize about damages depositions. 825 1.8 Review M. Jones deposition transcript and discuss what 09/25/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell points Apple attempted to make with A. Curry. 825 4.3 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 8 of 106

Analyze whether it would be possible to get Judge Koh to reconsider and cover the entire nation in two classes based 09/25/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell on the two fundamental groups of state law. 825 2.5

09/26/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Work on mediation strategy per discussions with A. Curry. 825 1.9 Analyze ability to have this case broken into two classes that 09/26/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell make up the full nation. 825 1.4 Strategize with team regarding whether to file motion for 10/01/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell reconsideration 825 0.8

10/02/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Review and comment on draft motion for reconsideration. 825 2.5 Correspond and communicate with team regarding 10/03/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell designation of lead counsel. 825 0.9 10/03/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Review court’s order. 825 1.1 10/03/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Discuss Apple’s motion to seal with A. Curry. 825 1.2 Interview with co‐counsel firms for consideration as lead 10/04/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell counsel; debrief with team. 825 0.8 10/11/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Review draft summary judgment response. 825 3.3 Continue reviewing summary judgment response and confer 10/12/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell with A. Curry regarding same. 825 2.4

10/15/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Meet and confer with J. Lerner regarding motion to seal. 825 0.2

Group telephone call regarding case management 10/15/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell conference and Apple’s motion for summary judgment. 825 0.8

10/18/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Review Apple’s response to motion for reconsideration. 825 2 10/19/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Review team analysis of statutes of limitation. 825 0.5 10/22/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Review order denying reconsideration. 825 0.2 10/24/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Prepare for summary judgment argument. 825 2.8 Participate in team call; discuss me as the attorney to argue 10/24/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell summary judgment. 825 0.7 10/29/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Review and revise mediation brief. 825 3.2 10/29/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Discuss mediation strategy with co‐counsel. 825 1.7 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 9 of 106

10/30/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Prepare for summary judgment hearing. 825 4.1 10/31/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Prepare for summary judgment hearing. 825 2.4 11/06/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Participate in team call to prepare for mediation 825 2.5 11/07/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Prepare for summary judgment hearing. 825 4.1 11/08/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Prepare for mediation. 825 5.7 11/09/2018 Bradley W. Caldwell Participate in mediation. 825 6.2 Correspond with A. Curry regarding procedural history of 04/23/2019 Bradley W. Caldwell Plaintiffs' request for updated spreadsheets. 875 1.4

08/28/2019 Bradley W. Caldwell Discuss ideas for possible motions in limine with A. Curry. 875 2.4 09/26/2019 Bradley W. Caldwell Discuss mediation strategy with A. Curry. 875 3.6 Discuss trial themes and strategy and elements of proof with 10/02/2019 Bradley W. Caldwell A. Curry and W. McCarty. 875 3.8

1/4/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell Review daubert briefing seeking to strike Jones and Hastings 975 3.7 1/6/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell Discuss pretrial hearing assignments 975 1.2 Discuss pretrial hearing with J. Cassady and A. Curry; prepare 1/13/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell for hearing 975 4.1 1/14/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell Prepare for pretrial hearing 975 8.5 1/15/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell Prepare for pretrial hearing 975 12.2 Work on revised witness list; prepare for pretrial hearing and 1/16/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell attend hearing 975 5.7 Work with magistrate and team regarding settlement; work 1/16/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell with C. Pearson 975 5.3

1/17/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell Participate in follow‐up discussions regarding settlement 975 3 1/18/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell Strategize about settlement terms 975 3.6 Correspond with Judge Cousins about settlement; relay to 1/22/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell team; discuss same with team 975 2.1 1/23/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell Review and revise witness proffer 975 2.20 Telephone calls with J. Lerner about settlement; discuss same 1/24/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell with C. Pearson 975 3.50 1/24/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell Review and revise witness proffer 975 1.80 1/27/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell Work on cross outlines 975 7.7 1/28/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell Confer with co‐counsel about settlement terms 975 1.3 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 10 of 106

1/28/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell Review exhibits for cross and opening 975 2.5 1/29/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell Develop outline of opening 975 6.3 1/30/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell Participate in meet and confer 975 0.4 02/02/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell Prepare for opening 975 8.30 02/03/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell Discuss settlement issues with team 975 4.00

02/03/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell Review trial exhibits and continue to prepare for opening 975 9.60 Study report of M. Jones and prepare images for opening 02/04/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell from same; prepare for cross of G. Thirumalai 975 11.20 02/05/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell Continue cross preparation 975 0.90 Review and revise response to Apple's objections to 02/06/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell witnesses; continue cross preparation 975 6.50

02/07/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell Meet with team to discuss trial themes and presentation 975 6.30 02/07/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell Work on settlement issues 975 1.50 02/10/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell Participate in settlement discussions 975 1.10 02/18/2020 Bradley W. Caldwell Review settlement stipulation 975 1.60 TOTAL: 280.30 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 11 of 106

TAB C Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 12 of 106

Jason D. Cassady ‐ Time Detail Grace v. Apple, Inc. ‐‐ No. 5:17‐cv‐00551‐LHK Inception through 10.31.20

Date Name Task Rate Hours Review complaint; review D. Warshaw's edits to the 01/03/2017 Jason D. Cassady complaint; review Rule 11 memorandum. 825 2.1 Review joint prosecution agreement and discuss with B. 01/27/2017 Jason D. Cassady Caldwell and A. Curry. 825 0.3 Review publicly available VirnetX trial testimony related to to 02/02/2017 Jason D. Cassady relay usage. 825 1.1 Review Apple's motion to dismiss and discuss with B. 03/22/2017 Jason D. Cassady Caldwell and A. Curry. 825 1.1 Discuss Apple's protective order violation threats with A. 03/27/2017 Jason D. Cassady Curry and co‐counsel. 825 1.3 Discuss source code protective order provisions and disputes 08/08/2017 Jason D. Cassady with A. Curry. 825 0.6 Confer with A. Curry regarding Apple's improperly withheld 09/08/2017 Jason D. Cassady documents. 825 1.3 Discuss email from J. Loy regarding source code protective 10/03/2017 Jason D. Cassady order issues with A. Curry. 825 0.7 Meet with A. Curry and W. McCarty regarding written 05/29/2018 Jason D. Cassady discovery follow‐ups and future deposition notices. 825 0.6 Discuss preparations for hearing on Plaintiffs' discovery letter 08/16/2018 Jason D. Cassady briefs with W. McCarty. 825 0.9 08/19/2018 Jason D. Cassady Prepare for hearing regarding discovery letter briefs. 825 3.3 08/20/2018 Jason D. Cassady Prepare for hearing regarding discovery letter briefs. 825 4.9 Call with J. Manning and W. McCarty regarding discovery 08/21/2018 Jason D. Cassady letter brief issues and hearing presentation. 825 0.8 08/21/2018 Jason D. Cassady Prepare for hearing regarding discovery letter briefs. 825 5.5 Call with D. Tejtel and W. McCarty regarding discovery letter 08/21/2018 Jason D. Cassady brief issues and hearing presentation. 825 0.7 08/22/2018 Jason D. Cassady Prepare summary of hearing results for team. 825 0.5 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 13 of 106

08/22/2018 Jason D. Cassady Prepare for and present at the discovery letter brief hearing 825 7.4 08/23/2018 Jason D. Cassady Attend weekly litigation team meeting. 825 0.6 08/23/2018 Jason D. Cassady Discuss Hastings report with A. Curry and W. McCarty. 825 1.3 Discuss discovery options with co‐counsel as a result of the 08/23/2018 Jason D. Cassady hearing. 825 1.5 Meet and confer with opposing counsel per Court Order and 08/24/2018 Jason D. Cassady report to the Court. 825 3.1 Continue to meet and confer with opposing counsel regarding discovery letter brief issues per the Court's Order 08/27/2018 Jason D. Cassady and report to the Court 825 2.5 08/27/2018 Jason D. Cassady Review and analyze expert report of Justine Hastings. 825 6.9 Confer with W. McCarty and D. Pearson regarding additional 08/27/2018 Jason D. Cassady deposition requests to Apple. 825 0.4 08/28/2018 Jason D. Cassady Review and analyze expert report of Justine Hastings. 825 3.1

09/04/2018 Jason D. Cassady Confer with W. McCarty regarding deposition of D. Caldbeck. 825 0.8 09/04/2018 Jason D. Cassady Prepare for deposition of D. Caldbeck. 825 5.5 09/05/2018 Jason D. Cassady Prepare for deposition of D. Caldbeck. 825 7.1 09/06/2018 Jason D. Cassady Prepare for and conduct deposition of D. Caldbeck. 825 7.9 09/19/2018 Jason D. Cassady Prepare Justine Hastings for deposition. 825 2.9 Prepare for and assist in defending deposition of Justine 09/20/2018 Jason D. Cassady Hastings. 825 5.6 Discuss potential trial ramifications of Dr. Hasting's reliance 10/01/2018 Jason D. Cassady on information from A. Simon with A. Curry. 825 0.7

10/01/2018 Jason D. Cassady Continue reviewing and editing summary judgment response. 825 1.6 10/24/2018 Jason D. Cassady Team call to discuss tasks. 825 0.9 10/29/2018 Jason D. Cassady Review and edit mediation brief. 825 1.4 Discuss Apple’s continual efforts to ask for unlawful 11/1/2019 Jason D. Cassady suppression of legal representation with A. Curry. 875 3.1 Discuss Apple’s continual efforts to ask for unlawful 11/4/2019 Jason D. Cassady suppression of legal representation with team. 875 2.9 11/5/2019 Jason D. Cassady Research settlement issues. 875 3.6 12/10/2011 Jason D. Cassady Review settlement issues and discuss with team. 875 2.8 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 14 of 106

12/11/2011 Jason D. Cassady Review settlement issues and discuss with team. 875 2.1 Research jury instruction issues; work on motions in limine related issues; continue working on witness proffers and 12/2/2019 Jason D. Cassady exhibit list issues. 875 6.7 Research jury instruction issues; work on motions in limine related issues; continue working on witness proffers and 12/3/2019 Jason D. Cassady exhibit list issues. 875 9.8 Research jury instruction issues; work on motions in limine related issues; continue working on witness proffers and 12/4/2019 Jason D. Cassady exhibit list issues. 875 8.1 Research jury instruction issues; work on motions in limine related issues; continue working on witness proffers and 12/5/2019 Jason D. Cassady exhibit list issues. 875 7.9 Research jury instruction issues; work on motions in limine related issues; continue working on witness proffers and 12/6/2019 Jason D. Cassady exhibit list issues. 875 8.2 Research jury instruction issues; work on motions in limine related issues; continue working on witness proffers and 12/7/2019 Jason D. Cassady exhibit list issues. 875 7.9 Research jury instruction issues; work on motions in limine related issues; continue working on witness proffers and 12/8/2019 Jason D. Cassady exhibit list issues. 875 9.9 Research jury instruction issues; work on motions in limine related issues; continue working on witness proffers and 12/9/2019 Jason D. Cassady exhibit list issues. 875 8.8 Research jury instruction issues; work on motions in limine related issues; continue working on witness proffers and 12/10/2019 Jason D. Cassady exhibit list issues. 875 7.9 Research jury instruction issues; work on motions in limine related issues; continue working on witness proffers and 12/11/2019 Jason D. Cassady exhibit list issues. 875 9.6 Research jury instruction issues; work on motions in limine related issues; continue working on witness proffers and 12/12/2019 Jason D. Cassady exhibit list issues. 875 9.2 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 15 of 106

Research jury instruction issues; work on motions in limine related issues; continue working on witness proffers and 12/13/2019 Jason D. Cassady exhibit list issues. 875 8.2 Continue to review settlement issues and discuss same with 1/2/2020 Jason D. Cassady team. 975 3.2 Continue to review settlement issues and discuss same with 1/3/2020 Jason D. Cassady team. 975 2.9

1/6/2020 Jason D. Cassady Continue working on settlement determination issues. 975 3.9 1/6/2020 Jason D. Cassady Prepare for pretrial hearing. 975 3.6 1/6/2020 Jason D. Cassady Prepare witness outlines and exhibit issues. 975 2.3 1/7/2020 Jason D. Cassady Continue preparing for the pretrial hearing. 975 3.4 1/7/2020 Jason D. Cassady Prepare witness outlines and exhibit issues. 975 4.1 1/8/2020 Jason D. Cassady Prepare for pretrial hearing. 975 4.9

1/8/2020 Jason D. Cassady Continue preparing trial presentations and exhibit issues. 975 4.6 1/9/2020 Jason D. Cassady Prepare for pretrial hearing. 975 7.8 1/9/2020 Jason D. Cassady Prepare witness outlines and exhibit issues. 975 6.1 1/10/2020 Jason D. Cassady Prepare for pretrial hearing. 975 2.1 1/10/2020 Jason D. Cassady Prepare witness outlines and exhibit issues. 975 2.7 Continue preparing for the pretrial hearing and discuss same 1/13/2020 Jason D. Cassady with team 975 3.3 1/13/2020 Jason D. Cassady Prepare witness outlines and exhibit issues. 975 1.9 1/14/2020 Jason D. Cassady Prepare for pretrial hearing. 975 2.8 1/15/2020 Jason D. Cassady Prepare for pretrial hearing. 975 2.1 Prepare for, attend, and debrief with team regarding pretrial 1/16/2020 Jason D. Cassady hearing 975 4.9 Prepare witness outlines and discuss witness profer issues 1/17/2020 Jason D. Cassady with A. Curry; 975 3.3 1/20/2020 Jason D. Cassady Prepare witness outlines and exhibit issues. 975 2.2

2/1/2020 Jason D. Cassady Continue working on trial exhibit and witness outline issues. 975 5.3

2/2/2020 Jason D. Cassady Continue working on trial exhibit and witness outline issues. 975 4.9 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 16 of 106

2/3/2020 Jason D. Cassady Continue working on trial exhibit and witness outline issues. 975 6.6

2/3/2020 Jason D. Cassady Review settlement issues and discuss same with A. Curry. 975 2.6

2/4/2020 Jason D. Cassady Review settlement issues and discuss same with A. Curry. 975 2.3

2/4/2020 Jason D. Cassady Continue working on trial exhibit and witness outline issues. 975 6.4 2/5/2020 Jason D. Cassady Review settlement issues and discuss same with team 975 2.4

2/5/2020 Jason D. Cassady Continue working on trial exhibit and witness outline issues. 975 5.1

2/6/2020 Jason D. Cassady Continue working on trial exhibit and witness outline issues. 975 6.8 2/6/2020 Jason D. Cassady Review settlement issues and discuss same with team 975 2.6

2/7/2020 Jason D. Cassady Continue working on trial exhibit and witness outline issues. 975 6.4

2/10/2020 Jason D. Cassady Continue working on trial exhibit and witness outline issues. 975 6.6

2/11/2020 Jason D. Cassady Continue working on trial exhibit and witness outline issues. 975 5.5

2/12/2020 Jason D. Cassady Continue working on trial exhibit and witness outline issues. 975 6.1

2/13/2020 Jason D. Cassady Continue working on trial exhibit and witness outline issues. 975 5.8

2/14/2020 Jason D. Cassady Continue working on trial exhibit and witness outline issues. 975 5.6

2/17/2020 Jason D. Cassady Continue working on trial exhibit and witness outline issues. 975 5.4

2/18/2020 Jason D. Cassady Continue working on trial exhibit and witness outline issues. 975 5.9 Continue working with team regarding settlement status and 3/2/2020 Jason D. Cassady issues. 975 2.2

3/2/2020 Jason D. Cassady Work on trial exhibit and witness outline related issues. 975 2.6 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 17 of 106

Continue working with team regarding settlement status and 3.10 3/3/2020 Jason D. Cassady issues. 975 2.30 3/3/2020 Jason D. Cassady Work on trial exhibit and witness outline related issues. 975 Continue working with team regarding settlement status and 1.80 3/4/2020 Jason D. Cassady issues. 975 1.70 3/4/2020 Jason D. Cassady Work on trial exhibit and witness outline related issues. 975 Continue working with team regarding settlement status and 2.40 3/5/2020 Jason D. Cassady issues. 975

3/5/2020 Jason D. Cassady Work on trial exhibit and witness outline related issues. 975 3.2

3/6/2020 Jason D. Cassady Work on trial exhibit and witness outline related issues. 975 2.1 Discuss upcoming hearing regarding settlement approval with A. Curry; read and respond to emails with team 8/3/2020 Jason D. Cassady regarding same. 975 1.4 TOTAL: 390.8 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 18 of 106

TAB D Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 19 of 106

J. Austin Curry ‐ Time Detail Grace v. Apple, Inc. ‐‐ No. 5:17‐cv‐00551‐LHK Inception through 10.31.20

Date Name Task Rate Hours 01/01/2017 J. Austin Curry Begin reviewing complaint drafted by co‐counsel. 825 3.5 01/02/2017 J. Austin Curry Continue reviewing complaint. 825 2.1 Finish reviewing complaint and discuss timing of filing with D. Tejtel; circulate complaint to B. Caldwell, J. Cassady, and J. Summers; review edits to the complaint made by D. Warshaw; review Rule 11 memorandum prepared by D. 01/03/2017 J. Austin Curry Tejtel. 825 4.7 Review Rule 11 memorandum prepared by J. Summers and 01/05/2017 J. Austin Curry legal research regarding same. 825 6.8 Review joint prosecution agreement and discuss with B. Caldwell and J. Cassady; discuss representation agreement 01/27/2017 J. Austin Curry questions with D. Tejtel. 825 0.4 Call with co‐counsel about prefiling issues; review legal research work product prepared by J. Summers regarding additional, potential causes of action and suggest additional 01/04/2017 J. Austin Curry lines of inquiry. 825 3.8 01/30/2017 J. Austin Curry Organize case materials. 825 0.5 02/01/2017 J. Austin Curry Review complaint and provide feedback. 825 6.4

02/03/2017 J. Austin Curry Discuss whether to consent to decline magistrate with team. 825 3.7 02/06/2017 J. Austin Curry Discuss press issues with the team. 825 0.7

Correspond with co‐counsel regarding Kirkland's request for 02/28/2017 J. Austin Curry documents and the deceptive nature of the request. 825 0.6

Review interrogatories prepared by D. Tejtel; review requests 03/09/2017 J. Austin Curry for document production prepared by D. Tejtel. 825 1.2 03/10/2017 J. Austin Curry Discuss discovery requests with D. Tejtel. 825 0.8 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 20 of 106

Review Apple's motion to dismiss and discuss with B. 03/22/2017 J. Austin Curry Caldwell and J. Cassady. 825 1.8 Discuss the accuracy of Apple's factual allegations in its 03/23/2017 J. Austin Curry motion to dismiss with M. Jones. 825 3.5 Review memorandum prepared by J. Manning regarding Apple's motion to dismiss and possible counterarguments; call with co‐counsel to discuss arguments raised in Apple's 03/24/2017 J. Austin Curry motion to dismiss. 825 1.9 Call with co‐counsel to discuss arguments raised in Apple's 03/24/2017 J. Austin Curry motion to dismiss. 825 0.3 Research system requirements for iOS 6.1.6 to disprove Apple's misleading suggestion to Judge Koh that iOS 6.1.6 was available for iPhone 4 and 4S and share findings with co‐ 03/27/2017 J. Austin Curry counsel. 825 1.2 Discuss Apple's protective order violation threats with J. 03/27/2017 J. Austin Curry Cassady and co‐counsel. 825 1.4 Continue researching iOS 6.1.6 to disprove Apple's misleading suggestion to Judge Koh that it was available for 03/28/2017 J. Austin Curry iPhone 4 and 4S. 825 1.2

Review draft of amended complaint and discuss same with co‐ counsel; email J. Summers outlining legal research for him to 03/31/2017 J. Austin Curry perform regarding restitution damages. 825 3.3 Review D. Tejtel's edits to the amended complaint and 04/03/2017 J. Austin Curry provide feedback to team. 825 1.8 Begin drafting assigned section of response to motion to 04/19/2017 J. Austin Curry dismiss. 825 3.8 Teleconference with co‐counsel to discuss Apple's motion to 04/19/2017 J. Austin Curry dismiss. 825 0.4

Legal research regarding the inapplicability of dismissal under 04/19/2017 J. Austin Curry Rule 12 of a party's claim for injunctive relief. 825 3.7 Review Apple's motion to dismiss and discuss with B. 04/19/2017 J. Austin Curry Caldwell and J. Summers. 825 2.6 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 21 of 106

Participate in conference concerning Apple's positions 05/16/2017 J. Austin Curry regarding motion to stay discovery. 825 1 Read J. Koh's order denying Apple's motion to dismiss and 07/28/2017 J. Austin Curry discuss with B. Caldwell and J. Cassady. 825 2.6 Discuss restitution issues related related to MTD ruling with 07/30/2017 J. Austin Curry team. 825 1.1 Consider division of labor and confer with team regarding 07/31/2017 J. Austin Curry same. 825 2.3

Propose Dr. Mark Jones as an candidate for the technical 08/02/2017 J. Austin Curry expert in this case and distribute his resume internally. 825 0.8 08/02/2017 J. Austin Curry Review draft email to opposing counsel. 825 0.3

Discuss case strategy with co‐counsel, including discovery 08/02/2017 J. Austin Curry related to iOS 6.1.6, source code, and performance data. 825 1.2 Correspond with opposing counsel to begin negotiating a 08/02/2017 J. Austin Curry protective order covering source code. 825 1.3 08/03/2017 J. Austin Curry Review and edit the ESI search terms. 825 1.6 08/07/2017 J. Austin Curry Review the most recent edits to the ESI search terms. 825 0.3 Discuss draft CMC statement and discovery plan with co‐ 08/08/2017 J. Austin Curry counsel. 825 1.2 Correspond with opposing counsel about source code 08/08/2017 J. Austin Curry protective order. 825 0.2 Talk to J. Cassady about source code protective order 08/08/2017 J. Austin Curry provisions and disputes. 825 1.6 08/09/2017 J. Austin Curry Draft source code protective order. 825 3.9 Correspond with opposing counsel, including draft source 08/10/2017 J. Austin Curry code protective order. 825 0.7 Seek quotes of document vendors and send responses to D. 08/10/2017 J. Austin Curry Warshaw and D. Tejtel. 825 2.4 Draft and circulate retention agreement for Dr. Jones to co‐ 08/10/2017 J. Austin Curry counsel. 825 2.7 Review email from opposing counsel and write proposed 08/14/2017 J. Austin Curry response for J. Manning. 825 1.7 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 22 of 106

08/14/2017 J. Austin Curry Continue discussing draft CMC statement with co‐counsel. 825 1.1 08/16/2017 J. Austin Curry Review and edit filing regarding discovery disputes. 825 1.6 Correspond with opposing counsel regarding source code 08/16/2017 J. Austin Curry protective order. 825 0.1 Correspond with co‐counsel regarding the timing of seeking 08/16/2017 J. Austin Curry discovery provided in the VirnetX case. 825 2.4 08/17/2017 J. Austin Curry Review and edit plaintiffs' first set of interrogatories. 825 2.4 Discuss edits and issues regarding interrogatories with D. 08/17/2017 J. Austin Curry Tejtel. 825 1.3 Draft additional interrogatory and circulate to D. Tejtel for inclusion in plaintiffs' first set of interrogatories and discuss 08/21/2017 J. Austin Curry same with J. Summers. 825 2.8 Correspond with opposing counsel about source code 08/21/2017 J. Austin Curry protective order. 825 0.2 Circulate draft interrogatories to co‐counsel and discuss 08/23/2017 J. Austin Curry same. 825 0.4

08/25/2017 J. Austin Curry Correspond with co‐counsel regarding interrogatories. 825 0.3

08/25/2017 J. Austin Curry Correspond with co‐counsel regarding interrogatories. 825 0.3 Legal research regarding contention interrogatories in N.D. 08/25/2017 J. Austin Curry Cal. and discuss same with co‐counsel. 825 2.9 Correspond with J. Loy regarding the draft source code 08/27/2017 J. Austin Curry protective order. 825 0.1 Continue corresponding with J. Loy regarding source code 08/28/2017 J. Austin Curry protective order issues. 825 0.1 08/28/2017 J. Austin Curry Review all documents in Apple's first production. 825 3.9

Review edits to the VirnetX v. Apple source code protective orders to see instances where Apple proposed and then later 08/28/2017 J. Austin Curry abandoned restrictions governing source code. 825 1.8 08/28/2017 J. Austin Curry Discuss case issues with D. Tejtel. 825 0.4 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 23 of 106

Finalize interrogatories incorporating everyone's feedback, discuss same with co‐counsel, and serve on opposing 08/29/2017 J. Austin Curry counsel. 825 2.8

Continue reviewing documents in Apple's first production 08/29/2017 J. Austin Curry and circulate notes on hot documents to team. 825 2.7

Discuss interrogatories, Apple's counter‐proposal regarding 9/1/2017 J. Austin Curry ESI search terms, and document hosting with co‐counsel. 825 1.1 Meet and confer with opposing counsel regarding search 09/01/2017 J. Austin Curry terms. 825 1.2 Continue the meet and confer with opposing counsel 09/05/2017 J. Austin Curry regarding plaintiffs' proposed ESI search terms. 825 1.3

Teleconference with co‐counsel and Justine Hastings to 09/05/2017 J. Austin Curry evaluate her as a potential expert witness for damages. 825 0.8 Draft email J. Loy regarding the impropriety of the many, draconian restrictions he inserted into the source code 09/08/2017 J. Austin Curry protective order and discuss with team. 825 1.7 Review edits to source code protective order sent by J. Loy 09/08/2017 J. Austin Curry and discuss same with co‐counsel. 825 5.2

Document instances in which Apple improperly withheld producing documents because they allegedly contain source 09/08/2017 J. Austin Curry code and discuss same with J. Cassady. 825 3.2

Correspond with co‐counsel summarizing the meet and confer, detailing Apple's insistence on restricting personal identifying information, and asking for guidance on how this 09/18/2017 J. Austin Curry type of information is typically handled in class action cases. 825 3.3 Meet and confer with J. Loy to discuss source code protective 09/18/2017 J. Austin Curry order disputes. 825 1.3 Teleconference with co‐counsel to discuss all current issues 09/19/2017 J. Austin Curry in the case. 825 1.6 09/19/2017 J. Austin Curry Correspond with Dr. Jones about the case. 825 1.5 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 24 of 106

Review and edit ESI search terms and circulate to team with 09/20/2017 J. Austin Curry explanations underlying the changes. 825 3.6 Respond to email from J. Loy regarding various source code 09/25/2017 J. Austin Curry protective order disputes. 825 4.1 Review Apple's (lack of) responses to plaintiffs' first set of 09/28/2017 J. Austin Curry interrogatories. 825 0.4 Review Apple's responses to plaintiffs' first set of 09/28/2017 J. Austin Curry interrogatories. 825 1.2 Organize Apple's responses to plaintiffs' first set of 09/28/2017 J. Austin Curry interrogatories for work product purposes. 825 1.2

Review local rules governing motions for discovery disputes 09/29/2017 J. Austin Curry and email opposing counsel requesting meet and confer. 825 0.5 Review J. Manning's edits to the ESI search terms and provide 09/29/2017 J. Austin Curry feedback to team. 825 0.3

Meet and confer with Apple to discuss various deficiencies in 09/29/2017 J. Austin Curry Apple's discovery responses and disclosures. 825 1.5 Email J. Loy inquiring about status of source code protective 10/02/2017 J. Austin Curry order. 825 0.1 Discuss Apple's carefully worded representation that it does not track each customer's reasons for trading in devices with 10/03/2017 J. Austin Curry D. Tejtel. 825 0.8 Write email to team proposing a plan to overcome Apple's 10/03/2017 J. Austin Curry refusal to identify all class members. 825 2.3 Write email to opposing counsel requesting identification of 10/03/2017 J. Austin Curry all class members. 825 2.8 Review draft email from D. Tejtel to opposing counsel 10/03/2017 J. Austin Curry regarding document requests. 825 0.4 Review email from J. Loy regarding source code protective 10/03/2017 J. Austin Curry order issues and discuss with J. Cassady. 825 1 Discuss source code protective order disputes with W. McCarty and have him begin drafting an opposed motion for 10/04/2017 J. Austin Curry entry of a source code protective order. 825 1.8 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 25 of 106

Email J. Loy regarding ongoing source code protective order disputes and propose a solution to resolve the remaining 10/05/2017 J. Austin Curry disputes. 825 3.6

Review email from opposing counsel regarding their refusal 10/06/2017 J. Austin Curry to identify class members and discuss with J. Summers. 825 2.6

Review and edit email from J. Summers to opposing counsel 10/09/2017 J. Austin Curry regarding the identification of class members. 825 1.9 Ghostwrite proposed email for D. Tejtel to send to opposing counsel regarding Apple's refusal to produce documents 10/10/2017 J. Austin Curry related to RFP 20. 825 1.5 10/10/2017 J. Austin Curry Discuss new potential class rep with co‐counsel. 825 0.7 10/11/2017 J. Austin Curry Email J. Loy about the source code protective order. 825 0.2 Teleconference with co‐counsel to discuss current case 10/11/2017 J. Austin Curry issues. 825 0.8 Teleconference with co‐counsel to discuss document review 10/11/2017 J. Austin Curry and coding. 825 1.1

10/12/2017 J. Austin Curry Email J. Loy about the source code protective order disputes. 825 1.4 Email opposing counsel regarding various discovery issues 10/12/2017 J. Austin Curry Apple is ignoring. 825 3.4 Write module regarding Apple's dilatory source code production for J. Manning to include in her email to opposing 10/13/2017 J. Austin Curry counsel. 825 1.8

Discuss email from opposing counsel complaining about the 10/13/2017 J. Austin Curry number of discovery issues with co‐counsel. 825 2 Write module regarding Apple's dilatory source code production for J. Manning to include in her email to opposing 10/13/2017 J. Austin Curry counsel. 825 1.8

10/14/2017 J. Austin Curry Begin reviewing documents in Apple's second production. 825 3.8

10/15/2017 J. Austin Curry Continue reviewing documents in Apple's second production. 825 5.9 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 26 of 106

Continue reviewing documents in Apple's second production 10/16/2017 J. Austin Curry and circulate notes on hot documents to team. 825 4.7 Email W. McCarty regarding status of source code protective order negotiations, instructing him to modify the protective 10/16/2017 J. Austin Curry order to reflect agreements. 825 0.4 10/17/2017 J. Austin Curry Discuss discovery joint letter brief with J. Summers. 825 1 Meet and confer with opposing counsel to discuss various, 10/17/2017 J. Austin Curry outstanding discovery issues. 825 1.5 Review memorandum prepared by D. Tejtel regarding Apple's spurious claim that class members' identities are barred by 10/17/2017 J. Austin Curry the ECPA. 825 2.3 Review and edit joint letter brief on interrogatories and class 10/18/2017 J. Austin Curry member identities. 825 2.5

Email Dr. Jones seeking information required by the 10/23/2017 J. Austin Curry protective order to begin the clearance process for him. 825 1.6 Review and edit joint letter brief regarding document 10/23/2017 J. Austin Curry discovery disputes. 825 0.7 10/23/2017 J. Austin Curry Email co‐counsel about coordinating with experts. 825 0.5 10/24/2017 J. Austin Curry Discuss protective order provisions with Dr. Jones. 825 2.2

10/25/2017 J. Austin Curry Teleconference with co‐counsel to discuss litigation strategy. 825 1.7 Draft substance of administrative motion to seal for J. 10/25/2017 J. Austin Curry Manning. 825 1 Review Dr. Jones's required submissions under the protective 10/30/2017 J. Austin Curry order and send to opposing counsel. 825 0.3

10/31/2017 J. Austin Curry Write declaration in support of administrative motion to seal. 825 0.8 10/31/2017 J. Austin Curry Discuss Dr. Jones's disclosure with J. Manning. 825 0.2 Review Apple's edits to the joint letter brief and discuss same 11/02/2017 J. Austin Curry with co‐counsel. 825 1.4 11/03/2017 J. Austin Curry Begin writing subpoena to Akamai. 825 2.6 11/07/2017 J. Austin Curry Prepare for hearing in front of Judge Cousins. 825 5.9 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 27 of 106

Review order from Judge Cousins and prepare proposed 11/07/2017 J. Austin Curry order as ordered and discuss same with co‐counsel. 825 4.4

11/07/2017 J. Austin Curry Teleconference with co‐counsel to discuss discovery hearing. 825 1 Prepare for and argue at discovery hearing in front of Judge 11/08/2017 J. Austin Curry Cousins and debrief team regarding same. 825 6.2 Email opposing counsel proposed order incorporating Judge 11/09/2017 J. Austin Curry Cousins's rulings. 825 0.4 Review and edit proposed discovery order to incorporate 11/09/2017 J. Austin Curry Judge Cousins's rulings. 825 2.1 11/09/2017 J. Austin Curry Teleconference to discuss varioius case issues. 825 1.4 Review date ranges for ESI terms and provide feedback to 11/10/2017 J. Austin Curry team regarding the same. 825 0.5 Correspond with opposing counsel regarding filing a 11/13/2017 J. Austin Curry replacement proposed order. 825 0.4 Prepare for meet and confer regarding source code 11/13/2017 J. Austin Curry protective order disputes. 825 1.3 Email with opposing counsel regarding source code 11/13/2017 J. Austin Curry production deadlines. 825 0.2 Review Apple's analytics on search terms and discuss same 11/13/2017 J. Austin Curry with team. 825 0.8 11/15/2017 J. Austin Curry Review edits to replacement proposed order. 825 0.2 Teleconfernece with co‐counsel to discuss current case 11/16/2017 J. Austin Curry issues. 825 0.8

Edit joint letter brief on Apple's deficient responess to 11/16/2017 J. Austin Curry plaintiffs' interrogatories and circulate internally for review. 825 2.6

11/17/2017 J. Austin Curry Review and discuss D. Tejtel's edits to joint letter brief. 825 0.6

Review Apple's production to identify missing buyer surveys 11/20/2017 J. Austin Curry and email opposing counsel requesting the same. 825 1.8 Email team regarding plan to wait to file joint letter brief until 11/21/2017 J. Austin Curry Apple supplements its responses. 825 0.6 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 28 of 106

Review documents in Apple's most recent document 11/22/2017 J. Austin Curry production. 825 2.5 Continue discussing Akamai subpoena topics with J. 11/29/2017 J. Austin Curry Summers. 825 0.3 Teleconference with co‐counsel to discuss pressing case 11/29/2017 J. Austin Curry issues. 825 1.4 Coordinate source code review with Dr. Jones and email opposing counsel providing requisite notice under the 11/29/2017 J. Austin Curry protective order. 825 2.1 Email opposing counsel regarding relevance of missing buyer 12/01/2017 J. Austin Curry surveys. 825 0.8 Email J. Loy regarding logistics concerning Dr. Jones's 12/01/2017 J. Austin Curry upcoming source code review. 825 0.2

Review spreadsheets in Apple's most recent document 12/04/2017 J. Austin Curry production and email team summarizing information. 825 3.4 12/04/2017 J. Austin Curry Discuss Apple's Akamai costs with J. Cassady. 825 1.3 Email technical documents in Apple's production to Dr. Jones 12/06/2017 J. Austin Curry to inform his upcoming source code review. 825 3.4 Email questions to opposing counsel regarding recently 12/06/2017 J. Austin Curry produced spreadsheets. 825 2.8

12/06/2017 J. Austin Curry Teleconference with co‐counsel to discuss case issues. 825 0.9

12/13/2017 J. Austin Curry Teleconfernece with co‐counsel to discuss case issues. 825 1.3

Search public information for data related to price dimunition of iPhone 4 and 4S devices surrounding the FaceTime Break 12/13/2017 J. Austin Curry and send summary email regarding findings to co‐counsel. 825 3.5 Email opposing counsel regarding status of buyer survey discovery dispute and questions related to produced 12/13/2017 J. Austin Curry spreadsheets. 825 0.6 Serve Akamai subpoena on D. Judson and schedule a call 12/13/2017 J. Austin Curry regarding same. 825 0.8 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 29 of 106

Call D. Judson regarding subpoena to Akamai and send follow 12/15/2017 J. Austin Curry up email regarding same. 825 0.8 Email opposing counsel regarding ongoing buyer survey 12/15/2017 J. Austin Curry discovery dispute. 825 0.7 Email opposing counsel questions regrarding latest 12/20/2017 J. Austin Curry spreadsheets. 825 0.4

12/20/2017 J. Austin Curry Email opposing counsel memorializing meet and confer. 825 0.2 Collect technical documents from Apple's production 12/20/2017 J. Austin Curry requested by Dr. Jones. 825 1.8

12/20/2017 J. Austin Curry Begin reviewing Apple's most recent document production. 825 1.9

12/20/2017 J. Austin Curry Teleconference with co‐counsel to discuss case issues. 825 1.4 12/20/2017 J. Austin Curry Discuss discovery strategy with D. Tejtel. 825 0.5 Review public information related to Apple's intentional throttling of devices and discuss how same impacts current 12/21/2017 J. Austin Curry litigation with co‐counsel. 825 2.4 Email opposing counsel regarding ongoing buyer survey 12/21/2017 J. Austin Curry discovery dispute. 825 0.3 Email opposing counsel regarding their attempts to evade 12/22/2017 J. Austin Curry discovery. 825 1.3 Email opposing counsel regarding buyer survey discovery 12/22/2017 J. Austin Curry dispute. 825 0.3 12/22/2017 J. Austin Curry Follow‐up call with co‐counsel to discuss case issues. 825 1 Email opposing counsel explaining why plaintiffs should not have to wait until January to resume discussions of 12/22/2017 J. Austin Curry longstanding discovery disputes. 825 0.6 Call with Dr. Jones to discuss how Apple implemented the 12/27/2017 J. Austin Curry FaceTime Break. 825 2.6 12/27/2017 J. Austin Curry Review and edit joint letter brief. 825 2.8 12/27/2017 J. Austin Curry Discuss case issues with B. Caldwell. 825 1.2 Email co‐counsel about Dr. Jones's findings in his source code 12/27/2017 J. Austin Curry review and flag issues for discussion. 825 1.8 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 30 of 106

Email J. Loy regarding missing source code, as identified by 12/29/2017 J. Austin Curry Dr. Jones. 825 2.1

Email opposing counsel regarding Apple's refusal to identify 12/29/2017 J. Austin Curry all individuals involved in the FaceTime Break. 825 1.8 12/29/2017 J. Austin Curry Call with Dr. Hastings to discuss damages issues. 825 0.9 Email opposing counsel regarding all outstanding discovery 12/29/2017 J. Austin Curry disputes. 825 2.2 Forward correspondence with D. Judson to J. Loy at his 12/29/2017 J. Austin Curry request. 825 0.2 304.4 01/02/2018 J. Austin Curry Finalize letter brief and send to opposing counsel. 825 2.6

Review Apple's most recent document production and email team hot document showing how Apple could have fixed 01/02/2018 J. Austin Curry FaceTime for iOS 6 users but chose not to. 825 4.6 Meet and confer with opposing counsel regarding Apple's 01/02/2018 J. Austin Curry deficient discovery responses. 825 1.5 Coordinate de‐duping project with M. Delaney and D. 01/03/2018 J. Austin Curry Warshaw. 825 1.7 Review Akamai's objections to subpoena and email D. Judson 01/03/2018 J. Austin Curry regarding same. 825 0.1 Discuss new discovery to propound on Apple with D. Tejtel 01/03/2018 J. Austin Curry and J. Summers. 825 2.6 Continue emailing opposing counsel regarding various 01/04/2018 J. Austin Curry discovery disputes. 825 1.4 Review Apple's edits to plaintiffs' 30(b)(6) notice and discuss 01/05/2018 J. Austin Curry with D. Tejtel. 825 0.5

01/05/2018 J. Austin Curry Discuss draft interrogatories with J. Summers and D. Tejtel. 825 0.8 01/06/2018 J. Austin Curry Review Apple's privilege log. 825 0.9 01/08/2018 J. Austin Curry Discuss document review with team. 825 0.6 Discuss Apple's objections to plaintiffs' 30(b)(6) notice with J. 01/08/2018 J. Austin Curry Manning. 825 0.3 Meet and confer with opposing counsel regarding Apple's 01/09/2018 J. Austin Curry objections to Plaintiffs' 30(b)(6) notice. 825 1.8 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 31 of 106

Email opposing counsel memorializing meet and confer and 01/09/2018 J. Austin Curry proposing a way to avoid another discovery dispute. 825 3.5 01/10/2018 J. Austin Curry Call with co‐counsel to discuss various case issues. 825 1.2 Discuss discovery dispute regarding plaintiffs' 30(b)(6) notice with J. Summers and W. McCarty and instruct them on 01/10/2018 J. Austin Curry preparing joint letter brief regarding same. 825 2.2 Email D. Judson regarding status of Akamai's response to 01/10/2018 J. Austin Curry plaintiffs' subpoena. 825 0.1 Legal research about the amendments to Rule 26, particularly with respect to taking discovery about the existence of discovery, and discuss same with W. McCarty and J. 01/10/2018 J. Austin Curry Summers. 825 1.3 Discuss Apple's privilege log with W. McCarty and instruct him on letter to send to Apple regarding its improper 01/10/2018 J. Austin Curry assertions of privilege. 825 1.6 01/10/2018 J. Austin Curry Edit joint letter brief and serve on Apple. 825 4.2 Email document produced by Apple apparently related to 01/10/2018 J. Austin Curry trade‐in value with team. 825 0.6 01/11/2018 J. Austin Curry Call with David Judson to discuss subpoena to Akamai. 825 0.5 Review edits to joint letter brief from D. Tejtel and serve on 01/11/2018 J. Austin Curry opposing counsel. 825 0.3 01/11/2018 J. Austin Curry Email J. Loy about status of Akamai deposition. 825 0.4 Review Apple's edits to the joint letter brief and discuss same 01/11/2018 J. Austin Curry with co‐counsel. 825 2.3 Email K. Seffield‐Whitehead regarding the parties' meet and 01/11/2018 J. Austin Curry confer. 825 2.6 Email J. Loy inquiring about status of supplemental source 01/11/2018 J. Austin Curry code production. 825 1.1 Meet and confer with D. Judson regarding subpoena to 01/11/2018 J. Austin Curry Akamai and summarize call for team. 825 0.4 01/12/2018 J. Austin Curry Email J. Loy regarding source code production. 825 0.3 01/12/2018 J. Austin Curry Discuss de‐duping project with D. Warshaw. 825 0.3 01/12/2018 J. Austin Curry Continue editing joint letter brief and serve on Apple. 825 3.3 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 32 of 106

Review and edit W. McCarty's letter to Apple regarding 01/12/2018 J. Austin Curry improper assertions of privilege. 825 0.8

Draft email to K. Sheffield Whitehead regarding her 01/12/2018 J. Austin Curry representations to the Court and discuss with D. Tejtel. 825 0.8

01/13/2018 J. Austin Curry Discuss who should argue at upcoming hearing with team. 825 0.4 Review documents in Apple's most recent document 01/14/2018 J. Austin Curry production. 825 5.6 Continue reviewing documents in Apple's most recent 01/15/2018 J. Austin Curry production. 825 6.4 Continue reviewing document in Apple's most recent 01/16/2018 J. Austin Curry production and summarize hot documents for team. 825 5.2 Review email from opposing counsel and send email in 01/16/2018 J. Austin Curry response. 825 1.5

Email J. Loy following up on his refusal to acknowledge prior 01/17/2018 J. Austin Curry emails seeking status of source code production. 825 0.1 01/17/2018 J. Austin Curry Weekly case strategy call with co‐counsel. 825 0.8 01/19/2018 J. Austin Curry Discuss order from Judge Cousins with J. Summers. 825 0.3

01/19/2018 J. Austin Curry Discuss upcoming 30(b)(6) deposition with D. Warshaw. 825 1 Meet and confer with opposing counsel to discuss Apple's 01/22/2018 J. Austin Curry improper assertions of privilege. 825 0.8 01/22/2018 J. Austin Curry Prepare for upcoming hearing. 825 5.6 Review and edit supplemental brief ordered by Judge 01/22/2018 J. Austin Curry Cousins. 825 0.5 Discuss possible narrowing of discovery on third parties with 01/22/2018 J. Austin Curry co‐counsel. 825 0.4

01/22/2018 J. Austin Curry Prepare for discovery argument in front of Judge Cousins. 825 6.8

01/23/2018 J. Austin Curry Prepare for discovery argument in front of Judge Cousins. 825 8.4

01/23/2018 J. Austin Curry Review Apple's supplemental responses to interrogatories. 825 0.4 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 33 of 106

Discuss the extent to which Apple monitors users' devices 01/23/2018 J. Austin Curry with S. Jain. 825 0.2 01/23/2018 J. Austin Curry Continue preparing for upcoming hearing. 825 4.3 Review documents recently produced by Apple and explain 01/24/2018 J. Austin Curry them to co‐counsel. 825 1.3 Prepare for and argue at discovery hearing in front of Judge 01/24/2018 J. Austin Curry Cousins. 825 8.8 Review production document suggesting that a user might have experienced FaceTime not working even after 01/26/2018 J. Austin Curry upgrading to iOS 7 and discuss with co‐counsel. 825 1.7 Email opposing counsel regarding ongoing discovery 01/26/2018 J. Austin Curry disputes. 825 0.2

Email team regarding issues related to liability and damages 01/26/2018 J. Austin Curry theories based on newly discovery information. 825 5.2 Draft new RFPs related to Apple's original decision to have certificiates expire and circulate to team with accompanying, 01/26/2018 J. Austin Curry explanatory notes. 825 3.6

Continue searching for documents in Apple's productions related to Apple's decision to make the fix in iOS 6.1.6 available only to iPod Touch 4th Generation users and share 01/29/2018 J. Austin Curry findings regarding same with W. McCarty. 825 4.4

Email team proposals on how to deal with issues related to liability and damages based on discussions with team and 01/29/2018 J. Austin Curry documents identified in Apple's production. 825 5.5 Review hot document identified by W. McCarty related to 01/29/2018 J. Austin Curry damages. 825 0.3 Discuss potential issues with liability and damages theory with W. McCarty and J. Summers and search for documents 01/29/2018 J. Austin Curry in Apple's production regarding same. 825 4.3 Email opposing counsel regarding source code questions they 01/30/2018 J. Austin Curry keep ignoring. 825 0.8 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 34 of 106

Review Apple's amended privilege log and newly produced documents that were originally, improperly withheld as 01/31/2018 J. Austin Curry privileged. 825 1.6

Review results of D. Warshaw's de‐duping project and discuss further de‐duping needs in the case related to spreadsheets that will contain class member identities that should have 01/31/2018 J. Austin Curry been previously produced. 825 1.1 01/31/2018 J. Austin Curry Weekly case strategy call with co‐counsel. 825 1.3 Review draft RFPs and instruct M. Delaney on finalizing them 02/01/2018 J. Austin Curry for service. 825 0.4 Locate in document production buyer surveys that Apple initially withheld and send to J. Manning to relay to J. 02/01/2018 J. Austin Curry Hastings. 825 3.5 Review documents to identify candidates for 30(b)(1) depositions and propose discovery plan to team regarding 02/01/2018 J. Austin Curry same. 825 3.7

Email J. Loy regarding his continued refusal to acknowledge 02/01/2018 J. Austin Curry questions seeking status of source code production. 825 0.1 Update team on latest thinking regarding possible issues 02/01/2018 J. Austin Curry related to liability and damges theories. 825 2 02/01/2018 J. Austin Curry Email proposed 30(b)(1)s and RFPs to team for review. 825 0.4 Discuss potential issue regarding 30(b)(6) notice with J. 02/02/2018 J. Austin Curry Summers. 825 0.4

Review Apple's declaration regarding its efforts to identify 02/02/2018 J. Austin Curry FaceTime value documents and discuss same with team. 825 1.1 02/02/2018 J. Austin Curry Discuss source code questions with Dr. Jones. 825 0.2 Review Apple's proposal regarding inspection of clients' 02/02/2018 J. Austin Curry devices and discuss same with team. 825 1.6 Continue discussing client device inspection issues with J. 02/03/2018 J. Austin Curry Manning. 825 0.7 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 35 of 106

Review Apple's most recent document production identifying 02/05/2018 J. Austin Curry new class members and discuss same with D. Warshaw. 825 0.6 Discuss discovery dispute regarding class members' state information with opposing counsel and summarize call for 02/05/2018 J. Austin Curry team. 825 1.4 02/06/2018 J. Austin Curry Review and edit joint case management statement. 825 1.3 Search Apple's customer care logs to disprove argument from opposing counsel that FaceTime inoperability could be caused by a virus or malware and share findings regarding 02/06/2018 J. Austin Curry same with J. Manning. 825 2.6 Email D. Judson seeking status of Akamai's repsonse to 02/07/2018 J. Austin Curry subpoena. 825 0.2 02/07/2018 J. Austin Curry Weekly case strategy call with co‐counsel. 825 1.2 Review draft report from J. Hastings and discuss same with 02/07/2018 J. Austin Curry Dr. Hastings and team. 825 3.6 Review Apple's responses to plaintiffs' second set of 02/09/2018 J. Austin Curry interrogatories and discuss same with Dr. Jones. 825 1.7 Assist D. Warshaw in preparation for his upcoming 02/09/2018 J. Austin Curry deposition. 825 2

02/12/2018 J. Austin Curry Email J. Loy regarding status of source code computers. 825 0.2 02/12/2018 J. Austin Curry Continue assisting D. Warshaw for his deposition. 825 0.6

Email opposing counsel regarding ongoing discovery dispute 02/12/2018 J. Austin Curry related to state information of class members. 825 0.8 Discuss Apple's most recent opposition to providing state 02/12/2018 J. Austin Curry information of class members with J. Manning. 825 1.4

Send email to A. Pilmer regarding his most recent objection 02/12/2018 J. Austin Curry to providing state information of class member. 825 0.8 02/13/2018 J. Austin Curry Review Apple's subpoena to Akamai. 825 0.2 Email A. Pilmer inquiring about status of discovery dispute 02/13/2018 J. Austin Curry related to class members' states. 825 1.8 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 36 of 106

Discuss A. Pilmer's new objections to providing class 02/15/2018 J. Austin Curry members' state information with J. Manning. 825 1 Email D. Judson regarding status of Akamai's response to 02/20/2018 J. Austin Curry plaintiffs' subpoena. 825 0.1 Email D. Judson regarding status of Akamai's response to 02/21/2018 J. Austin Curry plaintiffs' subpoena. 825 0.1 Call with co‐counsel and Dr. Hastings to discuss damages and 02/21/2018 J. Austin Curry various case issues. 825 2.4 Draft argument script for J. Manning related to Apple's refusal to provide state information for upcoming hearing in front of Judge Cousins and provide supporting 02/21/2018 J. Austin Curry documentation regarding same. 825 3.4 Email opposing counsel regarding Apple's subpoena to 02/21/2018 J. Austin Curry Akamai. 825 0.4 Discuss hearing with J. Manning and Judge Cousins's order directing parties to continue negotiating protocol for 02/23/2018 J. Austin Curry inspection of clients' devices. 825 1.8 Discuss issues with Verizon trade‐in data with D. Pearson and 02/23/2018 J. Austin Curry instruct him on project regarding same. 825 1.9

Review and propose edits to Apple's proposal for inspecting 02/26/2018 J. Austin Curry clients' devices and discuss same with client. 825 4.6

Meet and confer with J. Manning and opposing counsel 02/27/2018 J. Austin Curry regarding protocol for inspecting clients' devices. 825 1.5 Prepare for and meet and confer with A. Pilmer to discuss 02/27/2018 J. Austin Curry forensic imaging protocol. 825 2.4 Edit proposal for forensic imaging and discuss same with J. 02/28/2018 J. Austin Curry Manning. 825 3.7

02/28/2018 J. Austin Curry Weekly status call with team to discuss current case issues. 825 1.1

03/01/2018 J. Austin Curry Email opposing counsel regarding dates for depositions. 825 1.2

03/02/2018 J. Austin Curry Email J. Loy to notice Dr. Jones for a source code review. 825 0.5 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 37 of 106

Email opposing counsel regarding Andrew Vyrros deposition 03/02/2018 J. Austin Curry and dates and locations for other witnesses. 825 1.4 Review and edit arguments drafted by D. Pearson regarding suitability of Verizon data for damages model and circulate 03/02/2018 J. Austin Curry same to team. 825 4.6 Compare competing proposals for client device inspection 03/02/2018 J. Austin Curry protocols. 825 2.8 Review and edit responses to interrogatories and requests 03/03/2018 J. Austin Curry for admission. 825 3.3 03/05/2018 J. Austin Curry Search for location of A. Vyrros for possible subpoena. 825 3.8 Review documents produced showing performance metrics 03/06/2018 J. Austin Curry for various versions of iOS. 825 4.7 Email D. Judson regarding Akamai's failure to respond fully to 03/06/2018 J. Austin Curry subpoena. 825 0.4

03/07/2018 J. Austin Curry Weekly status call with team to discuss current case issues. 825 0.9

03/10/2018 J. Austin Curry Review new Akamai documents and discuss with Dr. Jones. 825 0.7 03/12/2018 J. Austin Curry Revise second 30(b)(6) deposition. 825 5.6 Meet and confer with opposing counsel regarding various 03/12/2018 J. Austin Curry discovery issues. 825 2.5 Legal research regarding whether a party can serve more 03/12/2018 J. Austin Curry than one 30(b)(6) deposition in N.D. Cal. 825 2.8 Weekly status call with team to discuss current case issues 03/14/2018 J. Austin Curry and call with Dr. Hastings to discuss report. 825 1.6 Call with J. Manning, D. Warshaw, and D. Tejtel to discuss 03/22/2018 J. Austin Curry possibility of amending complaint. 825 1.6

04/16/2018 J. Austin Curry Weekly status call with team to discuss current case issues. 825 0.5 04/16/2018 J. Austin Curry Prepare for deposition of Dallas De Atley. 825 7.6 04/17/2018 J. Austin Curry Continue preparing for De Atley deposition. 825 6.4 04/18/2018 J. Austin Curry Take deposition of Dallas De Atley. 825 8.9 04/19/2018 J. Austin Curry Email team summary of Dallas De Atley deposition. 825 3 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 38 of 106

Review letter from W. McCarty to A. Pilmer regarding 04/24/2018 J. Austin Curry documents that should have been produced. 825 0.7 Email A. Pilmer requesting supplementation of Interrogatory 04/27/2018 J. Austin Curry No. 16. 825 3.3

04/27/2018 J. Austin Curry Call with team to discuss case developments and tasks. 825 1.2 04/27/2018 J. Austin Curry Review and edit motion for class certification. 825 3.6 04/30/2018 J. Austin Curry Create firm resume for class certification briefing. 825 2.5 Review Apple's inconsistent statements regarding its ESI 05/01/2018 J. Austin Curry produciton and discuss with D. Tejtel. 825 3.7 Review Apple's responses to interrogatories and requests for 05/01/2018 J. Austin Curry admission. 825 0.8 Review forensic report for devices SDDF001 and SDDF003 and lodge objections to preserve clients' privacy per the 05/01/2018 J. Austin Curry inspection protocol. 825 6.8 Correspond with J. Manning regarding compliance issues 05/02/2018 J. Austin Curry with the inspection protocol. 825 2.4 Review additional production from the forensic inspector and 05/03/2018 J. Austin Curry lodge objections. 825 4.6

05/04/2018 J. Austin Curry Email team with critical change to the class certification brief. 825 1.6 Review all FaceTime Break documents in chronological order 05/04/2018 J. Austin Curry with W. McCarty. 825 5.5 Review production from forensic inspector and discuss 05/08/2018 J. Austin Curry readability issues with J. Manning and S. Jain. 825 0.6 Review email from Apple contesting plaintiffs' objections to 05/09/2018 J. Austin Curry unreadable data and discuss with team. 825 2.4

05/09/2018 J. Austin Curry Lodge objections to unreadable data from forensic inspector. 825 1.6 05/09/2018 J. Austin Curry Email A. Pilmer regarding deposition scheduling. 825 0.2

05/09/2018 J. Austin Curry Weekly status call with team to discuss current case issues. 825 1.1 Email opposing counsel regarding objections to non‐readable 05/10/2018 J. Austin Curry data from forensic inspector. 825 3.1 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 39 of 106

Organize project aimed at identifying gaps in Apple's 05/11/2018 J. Austin Curry document production. 825 3.8 05/21/2018 J. Austin Curry Review Apple's third amended privilege log. 825 0.4 05/22/2018 J. Austin Curry Prepare deposition outline for W. McCarty. 825 6.4

05/23/2018 J. Austin Curry Weekly status call with team to discuss current case issues. 825 0.7 Discuss feasibility of attending depositions with short notice 05/25/2018 J. Austin Curry with team. 825 0.7 Review proposed deposition notices and circulate 05/25/2018 J. Austin Curry counterproposal. 825 1.7

Meet with J. Cassady and W. McCarty regarding written 05/29/2018 J. Austin Curry discovery follow‐ups and future deposition notices. 825 0.6 Email team regarding proposed selection of witnesses to 05/29/2018 J. Austin Curry notice for deposition. 825 1.8 05/29/2018 J. Austin Curry Review performance documents with J. Cassady. 825 2.7 Email opposing counsel regarding their refusal to include the 05/30/2018 J. Austin Curry firm's distribution list on correspondence. 825 2

05/31/2018 J. Austin Curry Review Apple's supplemental responses to interrogatories. 825 0.5 Meet and confer with opposing counsel regarding various 05/31/2018 J. Austin Curry discovery issues. 825 1.4 Call with D. Tejtel and S. Jain to prepare for meet and confer 05/31/2018 J. Austin Curry with opposing counsel. 825 1 Revise letter from D. Tejtel to opposing counsel regarding 06/01/2018 J. Austin Curry meet and confer follow up. 825 0.6 06/04/2018 J. Austin Curry Email opposing counsel noticing six depositions. 825 0.3 Review document production analytics to identify gaps in 06/04/2018 J. Austin Curry Apple's document production. 825 3.7 Continue discussing discrepancies in Apple's ESI collection 06/04/2018 J. Austin Curry and production with team. 825 4 06/05/2018 J. Austin Curry Prepare for meet and confer with J. Manning. 825 0.5 Meet and confer with J. Lerner regarding various discovery 06/05/2018 J. Austin Curry disputes. 825 1.2 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 40 of 106

Teleconference with team to discuss upcomign depositions 06/06/2018 J. Austin Curry and other tasks. 825 1.1 06/06/2018 J. Austin Curry Discuss forensic imagining issues with S. Jain. 825 0.6 Edits motion for protective order regarding plaintiffs' raw 06/06/2018 J. Austin Curry data. 825 2.5 06/08/2018 J. Austin Curry Locate resell documents produced by Apple. 825 1 Meet and confer with A. Pilmer about discrepancies in 06/11/2018 J. Austin Curry Apple's ESI collection and production. 825 0.3

06/14/2018 J. Austin Curry Review and edit proposed order for ESI discrepancy issues. 825 0.3 Locate correspondence related to ESI declaration and send to 06/15/2018 J. Austin Curry W. McCarty and D. Tejtel. 825 0.8 06/15/2018 J. Austin Curry Review Apple's opposition to class certification. 825 3.8

Review declaration from A. Pilmer regarding Apple's ESI 06/15/2018 J. Austin Curry collection and discuss same with D. Tejtel and W. McCarty. 825 1.6 Review Apple's document production for evidence that they did or did not produce documents according to search terms in A. Pilmer's declaration and discuss the same with 06/16/2018 J. Austin Curry document vendor. 825 3.8 Review Apple's document production for evidence that they did or did not produce documents according to search terms in A. Pilmer's declaration and discuss the same with 06/16/2018 J. Austin Curry document vendor. 825 3.8

06/18/2018 J. Austin Curry Review declaration of A. Rubin and discuss with Dr. Jones. 825 2.1 Review Apple's document production for evidence that Apple used more restrictive search term connectors than what was 06/18/2018 J. Austin Curry represented to the Court. 825 4.6 06/19/2018 J. Austin Curry Prepare for hearing. 825 4.8

06/20/2018 J. Austin Curry Prepare for and argue at hearing regarding Apple's ESI. 825 5.6 06/21/2018 J. Austin Curry Prepare for J. Wood deposition. 825 6.6 Debrief team on hearing and discuss possible steps to hold 06/21/2018 J. Austin Curry Apple accountable. 825 1.7 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 41 of 106

06/22/2018 J. Austin Curry Take deposition of J. Wood. 825 7.8 Email opposing counsel regarding their refusal to provide 06/25/2018 J. Austin Curry deposition witnesses. 825 2.4 Write new requests for production and discuss with W. 06/27/2018 J. Austin Curry McCarty. 825 4 06/28/2018 J. Austin Curry Discuss choice of law section of brief with team. 825 1.4 Review iOS agreement for potential nationwide certifiability 06/29/2018 J. Austin Curry argument and discuss with team. 825 1.5 Discuss document custodians for second set of RFPs with D. 06/29/2018 J. Austin Curry Tejtel. 825 0.4 Discuss issues regarding nationwide certifiability with D. 06/29/2018 J. Austin Curry Pearson and begin revising section. 825 3.5

Continue working on class certification reply, including legal research contrary to proposed argument that iOS agreement 07/02/2018 J. Austin Curry favors nationwide certifiability. 825 4.7 Prepare deposition outline for W. McCarty for Rubin 07/02/2018 J. Austin Curry deposition. 825 4.1 Team call regarding class certification reply and motions to 07/05/2018 J. Austin Curry strike. 825 1 07/05/2018 J. Austin Curry Review W. McCarty's edits to RFPs and discuss same. 825 0.8 Discuss filing motion to strike declaration of A. Rubin with 07/05/2018 J. Austin Curry team and begin drafting same. 825 2.8 07/05/2018 J. Austin Curry Write email to J. Loy regarding source code issues. 825 3.7 Circulate new set of RFPs to team and detail relevant 07/05/2018 J. Austin Curry background to provide context for purpose of RFPs. 825 2.6 07/06/2018 J. Austin Curry Continue working on class certification reply. 825 5.8 Correspond with D. Judson regarding unacceptable delay in 07/06/2018 J. Austin Curry Akamai's production. 825 1.5 07/07/2018 J. Austin Curry Continue working on class certification reply. 825 3.9 07/07/2018 J. Austin Curry Continue working on motion to strike Rubin. 825 5.5 07/07/2018 J. Austin Curry Discuss wording of new set of RFPs with team. 825 0.8 07/09/2018 J. Austin Curry Continue working on class certification reply. 825 5.6 Meet and confer with opposing counsel regarding various 07/09/2018 J. Austin Curry discovery issues. 825 0.6 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 42 of 106

Continue working on motion to strike Rubin and class 07/10/2018 J. Austin Curry certification reply. 825 6.9 Discuss Trexler deposition with W. McCarty and legal research regarding unique Daubert issues revealed in 07/10/2018 J. Austin Curry deposition. 825 1.6 07/10/2018 J. Austin Curry Revise new set of RFPs and circulate to the team. 825 0.8 Review Rubin "errata" and discuss how it impacts motion to 07/10/2018 J. Austin Curry strike. 825 2.8

07/11/2018 J. Austin Curry Discuss whether to file motion to strike Rubin with team. 825 1.7 07/11/2018 J. Austin Curry Continue working on reply class certification brief. 825 4.4 Continue working on briefs for class certification and striking 07/12/2018 J. Austin Curry Rubin. 825 6.2 07/23/2018 J. Austin Curry Email team to coordinate expert report work. 825 1.6 07/25/2018 J. Austin Curry Revise motion to set expert discovery schedule. 825 0.3 Discuss performance section of Dr. Jones report with H. 07/30/2018 J. Austin Curry Hamad. 825 1.6 08/07/2018 J. Austin Curry Review authentication RFAs. 825 0.9

08/23/2018 J. Austin Curry Discuss Hastings report with J. Cassady and W. McCarty. 825 1.3 Locate spreadsheets identifying class members and circulate 08/23/2018 J. Austin Curry to team. 825 2.2 Discuss status of expert reports with D. Tejtel and W. 08/27/2018 J. Austin Curry McCarty. 825 1.8

Discuss large data processing task with staff for Dr. Hastings 08/28/2018 J. Austin Curry to identify total number of unique class members. 825 1.4 08/28/2018 J. Austin Curry Review Dr. Jones's report with W. McCarty. 825 4.7 09/05/2018 J. Austin Curry Team call to discuss current case issues and tasks. 825 0.8 Review document production in support of J. Vidrine 09/05/2018 J. Austin Curry deposition. 825 2.6 Review the spreadsheets Apple recently produced and compare against prior productions to identify which updated 09/06/2018 J. Austin Curry spreadsheets are still outstanding. 825 2.4 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 43 of 106

Review Apple's expert reports as part of preparing to defend 09/06/2018 J. Austin Curry Dr. Jones's deposition. 825 3.8 Correspond with counsel for Apple regarding stipulation 09/07/2018 J. Austin Curry regarding class member information. 825 3.1 Review the updated spreadsheets Apple produced and 09/11/2018 J. Austin Curry identify spreadsheets that still need updated. 825 4.1 Email Apple identifying spreadsheets that were promised to 09/11/2018 J. Austin Curry be updated but were not produced. 825 0.6 Email Dr. Jones about his availability to give deposition 09/12/2018 J. Austin Curry testimony. 825 0.2 Continue coordinating dates and availability with counsel for 09/13/2018 J. Austin Curry Apple and Dr. Jones for a deposition. 825 0.3 09/14/2018 J. Austin Curry Review and edit letter brief. 825 4.2 Email opposing counsel asking for a redline on the stipulation 09/14/2018 J. Austin Curry concerning class member identities. 825 0.1

09/18/2018 J. Austin Curry Review class certification order and debrief with team. 825 4.6 Continue reviewing Dr. Rubin's report in preparation for 09/19/2018 J. Austin Curry defending Dr. Jones's deposition. 825 3.8 09/23/2018 J. Austin Curry Prepare to defend Dr. Jones's deposition. 825 6.8 Discuss filing a motion for reconsideration with D. Warshaw 09/24/2018 J. Austin Curry and J. Summers. 825 0.8 09/24/2018 J. Austin Curry Defend Dr. Jones's deposition and debrief with team. 825 8.8 Discuss filing new complaints with D. Warshaw and J. 09/25/2018 J. Austin Curry Summers and email team concerning the same. 825 2.1 Team call to discuss strategy regarding reconsideration and 09/25/2018 J. Austin Curry filing new complaints. 825 0.7 Write questions for W. McCarty to ask in Dr. Rubin's 09/25/2018 J. Austin Curry deposition. 825 4.3

09/25/2018 J. Austin Curry Discuss potential reconsideration issues with J. Summers. 825 0.6 Assist J. Summers in writing motion for reconsideration and 09/26/2018 J. Austin Curry legal research regarding same. 825 2.7 Confer with W. McCarty regarding deposition of Apple expert 09/26/2018 J. Austin Curry Dr. Rubin. 825 0.6 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 44 of 106

Discuss issues with filing in other cases due to statute of limitations and cross jurisdictional tolling with D. Tejtel and B. 09/26/2018 J. Austin Curry Caldwell. 825 2.4 Confer with W. McCarty regarding deposition of Apple expert 09/27/2018 J. Austin Curry Dr. Rubin. 825 0.8 Discuss issues with motion for reconsideration with J. 09/28/2018 J. Austin Curry Summers, D. Warshaw, S. McCrae, and B. Caldwell. 825 1.8 Review memorandum concerning time bar issues with 09/28/2018 J. Austin Curry various states written by M. Lee. 825 0.4 Teleconference with team to discuss motion for 10/01/2018 J. Austin Curry reconsideration. 825 1

Email opposing counsel requesting production of updated 10/01/2018 J. Austin Curry spreadsheets with class member information. 825 0.4

10/01/2018 J. Austin Curry Review motion for reconsideration drafted by J. Summers. 825 3.4

Discuss potential trial ramifications of Dr. Hasting's reliance 10/01/2018 J. Austin Curry on information from A. Simon with J. Cassady. 825 0.7

Discuss whether to have Dr. Jones review forensic inspection 10/01/2018 J. Austin Curry reports with co‐counsel, as it relates to summary judgment. 825 0.6 Write plan strategizing plaintiffs' response to Apple's attempts to take late discovery on third party ecoATM and 10/01/2018 J. Austin Curry circulate to team. 825 1.6 Email team regarding the sequencing of arguments in the 10/02/2018 J. Austin Curry motion and reply for reconsideration. 825 0.2

10/02/2018 J. Austin Curry Discuss substance of reconsideration motion with co‐counsel. 825 0.3 10/03/2018 J. Austin Curry Discuss Apple's motion to seal with B. Caldwell. 825 1.2 Begin discussing selection of lead trial counsel with co‐ counsel per Judge Koh's ruling requiring lead counsel to 10/03/2018 J. Austin Curry confer on motions to seal. 825 1.6 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 45 of 106

Review Apple's proposals regarding sealing information with respect to the Court's orders on sealing information and the 10/03/2018 J. Austin Curry public availability of such information. 825 2.8 Meet and confer with opposing counsel regarding motions to 10/04/2018 J. Austin Curry seal. 825 0.8 10/09/2018 J. Austin Curry Discuss summary judgment issues with D. Tejtel. 825 1.4 10/10/2018 J. Austin Curry Team call to discuss all current issues. 825 0.8 10/11/2018 J. Austin Curry Begin reviewing summary judgment response. 825 3.1

10/12/2018 J. Austin Curry Continue reviewing and editing summary judgment response. 825 3.3 10/14/2018 J. Austin Curry Email J. Lerner regarding various discovery issues. 825 3.6 Discuss Akamai's progress on responding to subpoena with D. 10/14/2018 J. Austin Curry Pearson. 825 0.4 Meet and confer with J. Lerner and B. Caldwell to discuss 10/15/2018 J. Austin Curry motion to seal. 825 0.2

Compile list of exhibits, reports, and deposition testimony 10/15/2018 J. Austin Curry potentially needing to be sealed for opposing counsel. 825 2.3 Discuss forensic inspector's counsel's email indicating that it was overruling our objections with team and possible actions 10/15/2018 J. Austin Curry to take. 825 4.2 Team call to discuss issues related to Apple's motion for 10/15/2018 J. Austin Curry summary judgment. 825 1.3 Finish editing response to Apple's motion for summary 10/15/2018 J. Austin Curry judgment. 825 1.6 Review Apple's response to motion for reconsideration and 10/17/2018 J. Austin Curry discuss with J. Summers. 825 2.6

10/18/2018 J. Austin Curry Weekly team call to discuss current case issues and tasks. 825 0.4 Compare differnet versions of Apple's alleged ESI search 10/18/2018 J. Austin Curry terms and identify discrepancies. 825 4.4 Review data regarding Apple's document production for 10/18/2018 J. Austin Curry identifying gaps. 825 2.1 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 46 of 106

Legal research regarding statute of limitations applicability to 10/18/2018 J. Austin Curry amended complaints. 825 2.4 10/24/2018 J. Austin Curry Team call to discuss tasks. 825 1 Review Apple's reply brief in support of its motion for summary judgment and discuss with D. Tejtel and B. 10/25/2018 J. Austin Curry Caldwell. 825 2.6 10/29/2018 J. Austin Curry Review and edit mediation brief. 825 3.2

10/29/2018 J. Austin Curry Discuss mediation strategy with B. Caldwell and D. Tejtel. 825 2.7

10/31/2018 J. Austin Curry Begin assisting B. Caldwell for summary judgment hearing. 825 4.6 10/31/2018 J. Austin Curry Begin reviewing draft 23(f) petition. 825 2 11/01/2018 J. Austin Curry Continue reviewing 23(f) petition. 825 4.1 11/02/2018 J. Austin Curry Team call to discuss Rule 23(f) petition. 825 1.1 Review Apple's estimates of California‐only class and calculate estimate that number based on information 11/02/2018 J. Austin Curry provided by Apple. 825 3.7 11/08/2018 J. Austin Curry Prepare for mediation. 825 4.6 11/09/2018 J. Austin Curry Mediate with Apple. 825 6.2 Review Court's order staying case and discuss with co‐ 11/09/2018 J. Austin Curry counsel. 825 0.2 637.1 Discuss status of updated spreadsheets with for identifying 03/25/2019 J. Austin Curry class members with J. Manning. 875 1.4 Edit email to be sent from J. Manning to J. Learner requesting 03/25/2019 J. Austin Curry updated spreadsheets. 875 1.2

Correspond with B. Caldwell regarding procedural history of 04/23/2019 J. Austin Curry Plaintiffs' request for updated spreadsheets. 875 1.7 Send internal email documenting factual misrepresentations made by Apple regarding the spreadsheet issues in its 04/24/2019 J. Austin Curry portion of the CMC. 875 1.3 Discuss procedural question regarding Dkt. No. 299 with 04/29/2019 J. Austin Curry team. 875 0.6 Respond to email from E. Novikov regarding the spreadsheet 06/18/2019 J. Austin Curry issue. 875 2.8 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 47 of 106

07/18/2019 J. Austin Curry Discuss SJ hearing with team. 875 1.6 Review Judge Koh's order denying summary judgment and 08/21/2019 J. Austin Curry discuss with team. 875 6.9 Write letter brief requesting the Court to compel Apple to 08/27/2019 J. Austin Curry produce updated spreadsheets. 875 6.7 Discuss Apple's proposal regarding updated spreadsheets 08/27/2019 J. Austin Curry with team. 875 1.7

08/28/2019 J. Austin Curry Discuss ideas for possible motions in limine with B. Caldwell. 875 2.6 Review updated spreadsheets produced by Apple to moot 09/04/2019 J. Austin Curry Plaintiffs' motion to compel. 875 4.9 Discuss the inherent limitations of the spreadsheets with 09/11/2019 J. Austin Curry team. 875 0.8

Discuss the process behind de‐duping the serial numbers in 09/11/2019 J. Austin Curry the spreadsheets to confirm accuracy of the final number. 875 2.9 Discuss adequacy of the updated spreadsheets for purposes 09/20/2019 J. Austin Curry of identifying class members with J. Lerner. 875 1.6 09/23/2019 J. Austin Curry Review and edit mediation statement. 875 2.7 09/25/2019 J. Austin Curry Discuss upcoming mediation with team. 875 0.8 09/26/2019 J. Austin Curry Discuss mediation strategy with team. 875 0.6 09/26/2019 J. Austin Curry Discuss mediation strategy with B. Caldwell. 875 3.8 Calculate the amount of money Apple saved by breaking 10/01/2019 J. Austin Curry FaceTime. 875 4.9 10/01/2019 J. Austin Curry Discuss mediation strategy with team. 875 1.1 Propose issuing trial subpoenas and timing of service with 10/02/2019 J. Austin Curry team. 875 0.7

Recalculate the amount of money Apple saved by breaking 10/02/2019 J. Austin Curry FaceTime in view of discussion with W. McCarty. 875 2.8 Discuss trial themes and strategy and elements of proof with 10/02/2019 J. Austin Curry B. Caldwell and W. McCarty. 875 3.8 Discuss mediation with B. Blaise and instruct her on legal 11/5/2019 J. Austin Curry research task. 875 3.3 11/9/2019 J. Austin Curry Legal research federal and state mediation privileges. 875 4.8 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 48 of 106

11/11/2019 J. Austin Curry Discuss Apple's settlement demands with team. 875 1.3 Continue researching the applicability of state and federal 11/12/2019 J. Austin Curry mediation privileges. 875 3.7 Review upcoming trial deadlines and discuss responsibilities 11/13/2019 J. Austin Curry with members of trial team. 875 2.4 Review Apple's positions in its discovery dispute filings for 11/15/2019 J. Austin Curry applicability of Rule 37. 875 4.4

Review B. Blaies's memorandum regarding applicability of 11/17/2019 J. Austin Curry state and federal mediation privilege and discuss with team. 875 3.4 Discuss with J. Cassady possible ethical alternatives class counsel could offer Apple in lieu of their unethical settlement 11/17/2019 J. Austin Curry demands. 875 3.5

11/25/2019 J. Austin Curry Prepare for and participate in weekly trial preparation call. 875 1.2 Discuss possible motions in limine to file with B. Caldwell, J. 12/10/2019 J. Austin Curry Cassady, and W. McCarty. 875 3.7

Discuss motions in limine with N. Nestelbaum and collect and 12/11/2019 J. Austin Curry send him past motions in limines as examples. 875 2.6 12/12/2019 J. Austin Curry Review Daubert motions filed by Apple. 875 3.8

12/13/2019 J. Austin Curry Review motions in limine drafted by N. Nestelbaum and edit. 875 6.7 Legal research regarding exclusion of evidence germane to 12/13/2019 J. Austin Curry Plaintiffs' motions in limine. 875 1.7

12/17/2019 J. Austin Curry Review Apple's responses to Plaintiffs' motions in limine. 875 3.5

12/18/2019 J. Austin Curry Work on joint jury instruction submission with J. Lerner. 875 12.8

12/19/2019 J. Austin Curry Work on joint jury instruction submission with J. Lerner. 875 13.2

12/20/2019 J. Austin Curry Work on joint jury instruction submission with J. Lerner. 875 12.4

12/24/2019 J. Austin Curry Discuss Apple's motion to exclude Dr. Jones with W. McCarty. 875 2.3 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 49 of 106

12/24/2019 J. Austin Curry Legal research regarding Apple's motion to exclude Dr. Jones. 875 3.2 Review and edit W. McCarty's brief in opposition to Apple's 12/26/2019 J. Austin Curry motion to exclude Dr. Jones. 875 4.9

12/27/2019 J. Austin Curry Review response to Apple's motion to exclude Dr. Hastings. 875 4.5

Discuss pretrial matters (Daubert motions, motions in limine, 12/28/2019 J. Austin Curry and jury instructions) with J. Cassady and B. Caldwell. 875 4.7 167.9 Review Apple's replies in support of its motions to exclude 01/03/2020 J. Austin Curry Dr. Jones and Dr. Hastings. 975 2.0 Begin preparing for pretrial hearing and discuss same, including argument responsibilities, with B. Caldwell, J. 01/06/2020 J. Austin Curry Cassady, and W. McCarty. 975 6.6 01/07/2020 J. Austin Curry Continue preparing for pretrial hearing. 975 4.3 01/08/2020 J. Austin Curry Continue preparing for pretrial hearing. 975 2.8 Continue preparing for pretrial hearings and discuss arguments made in court filings with W. McCarty, B. 01/09/2020 J. Austin Curry Caldwell, and J. Cassady. 975 5.1 Prepare for pretrial conference with B. Caldwell, J. Cassady, 01/10/2020 J. Austin Curry and W. McCarty. 975 6.0 Continue preparing for pretrial hearing and discuss same 01/13/2020 J. Austin Curry with J. Cassady and B. Caldwell. 975 5.8 Call with J. Lerner regarding jury instructions and continue 01/14/2020 J. Austin Curry preparing for pretrial hearing. 975 6.7 01/15/2020 J. Austin Curry Prepare for pretrial conference. 975 10.2 Pretrial conference in front of Judge Koh and settlement 01/16/2020 J. Austin Curry conference in front of Judge Cousins. 975 6.6 Begin working on proffer ordered by the Court regarding witnesses that Apple misrepresented as having no 01/17/2020 J. Austin Curry "connection" to the case. 975 6.4 Continue writing proffer regarding witnesses Apple misrepresented as having no connection to the case, including gathering evidence from this case showing these 01/20/2020 J. Austin Curry witnesses' involvement in the FaceTime Break. 975 7.2 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 50 of 106

01/21/2020 J. Austin Curry Continue writing witness proffer. 975 7.5 01/22/2020 J. Austin Curry Continue writing witness proffer. 975 3.6 1/23/2020 J. Austin Curry Continue writing witness proffer. 975 3.5

Finalize and file proffer regarding witnesses Apple 1/24/2020 J. Austin Curry misrepresented as having no "connection" to the case. 975 1.0 Meet with J. Cassady and B. Caldwell to discuss trial themes and gather most critical documents evidencing the FaceTime 02/11/2020 J. Austin Curry Break. 975 6.30 08/28/2020 J. Austin Curry Discuss upcoming hearing on preliminary approval for settlement with J. Cassady; email team regarding same. 975 1.6 TOTAL: 1202.6 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 51 of 106

TAB E Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 52 of 106

Hamad M. Hamad ‐ Time Detail Grace v. Apple, Inc. ‐‐ No. 5:17‐cv‐00551‐LHK Inception through 10.31.20

Date Name Task Rate Hours Correspond with team regarding preparation of expert 07/23/2018 Hamad Hamad report. 565 0.3 Confer with team regarding performance issues and testing 07/24/2018 Hamad Hamad relevant to expert report preparation. 565 0.3 Begin to research and analyze performance testing data and documents produced by Apple and confer with team 07/24/2018 Hamad Hamad regarding same. 565 4.4

Begin to research and analyze public documentation and news sources related to iPhone performance degradation 07/24/2018 Hamad Hamad and regression surrounding the release of iOS 7. 565 3.4 Confer with team regarding research and analysis of performance issues and testing relevant to expert report 07/25/2018 Hamad Hamad preparation. 565 1.1 Continue to research and analyze performance testing data and documents produced by Apple and confer with team 07/25/2018 Hamad Hamad regarding same. 565 5.8

Continue to research and analyze public documentation and news sources related to iPhone performance degradation 07/25/2018 Hamad Hamad and regression surrounding the release of iOS 7. 565 2.2

07/26/2018 Hamad Hamad Correspond with expert regarding preparation of report. 565 0.1 Continue to research and analyze performance testing data and documents produced by Apple and confer with team 07/26/2018 Hamad Hamad regarding same. 565 5.6 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 53 of 106

Continue to research and analyze public documentation and news sources related to iPhone performance degradation 07/26/2018 Hamad Hamad and regression surrounding the release of iOS 7. 565 1.6

Continue to research and analyze public documentation and news sources related to iPhone performance degradation 07/27/2018 Hamad Hamad and regression surrounding the release of iOS 7. 565 3.6 Continue to research and analyze performance testing data and documents produced by Apple and confer with team 07/27/2018 Hamad Hamad regarding same. 565 5.8 Continue to research and analyze performance testing data and documents produced by Apple and confer with team 07/28/2018 Hamad Hamad regarding same. 565 0.9 Begin to draft summary of analysis of performance data for 07/30/2018 Hamad Hamad expert report. 565 1.8 Research market on iPhone 4 and 4s running iOS 6 and iOS 7 and Apple's ability to sign past iOS versions and confer and 07/30/2018 Hamad Hamad correspond with team regarding same. 565 2.9 Continue to research and analyze performance testing data and documents produced by Apple and confer with team 07/30/2018 Hamad Hamad regarding same. 565 2.7 Continue to research and analyze performance testing data and documents produced by Apple and confer with team 07/31/2018 Hamad Hamad regarding same. 565 1.1 Continue to draft summary of analysis of performance data 07/31/2018 Hamad Hamad for expert report. 565 2.2 Prepare for and attend conference with expert and team regarding performance testing, results, data, and expert 08/01/2018 Hamad Hamad report preparation related to same. 565 2.1 Research and analyze Apple third party developer testing 08/01/2018 Hamad Hamad statements, tools, and guidance. 565 1.4 Continue to draft and revise analysis of performance testing results and expert report sections on performance testing, 08/02/2018 Hamad Hamad results, and data. 565 3.2 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 54 of 106

Research iPhone model hardware specifications, iOS 7 and 7.1 performance complaints, and computing delay 08/02/2018 Hamad Hamad perception. 565 3.9 Review Court order and correspondence regarding expert 08/03/2018 Hamad Hamad report deadlines. 565 0.8 Research Apple's position on importance of performance for 08/03/2018 Hamad Hamad iOS applications. 565 2.9 Continue to draft and revise analysis of performance testing results and expert report sections on performance testing, 08/03/2018 Hamad Hamad results, and data. 565 6.8 Review Court order and correspondence regarding expert 08/07/2018 Hamad Hamad report deadlines. 565 0.2 Correspond with team regarding preparation of technical 08/22/2018 Hamad Hamad expert report. 565 0.2 Correspond with team regarding Apple performance data for 08/23/2018 Hamad Hamad expert report. 565 0.2 Analyze, revise, and edit revised draft of technical expert 08/23/2018 Hamad Hamad report. 565 6.2 Research materials concerning performance issues and supporting Apple engineer statements regarding 08/23/2018 Hamad Hamad performance metrics. 565 4.2 Continue to revise and edit revised draft of technical expert 08/24/2018 Hamad Hamad report and confer with team regarding same. 565 8.3

Correspond and confer with team and expert regarding strategies concerning performance issues related to technical 08/24/2018 Hamad Hamad expert report and Apple's produced performance data. 565 2.1

Prepare for and attend conference with expert and team 08/27/2018 Hamad Hamad regarding preparation of technical expert report. 565 4.7

Correspond and confer with team and expert regarding strategies concerning performance issues related to technical 08/27/2018 Hamad Hamad expert report and Apple's produced performance data. 565 7.3 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 55 of 106

Correspond and confer with team and expert regarding technical expert report draft and supporting performance 08/28/2018 Hamad Hamad data exhibits. 565 3.8 Revise and edit draft of technical expert report and supporting exhibits and confer and correspond with team and expert concerning same in preparation for service of 08/28/2018 Hamad Hamad expert report. 565 8.9

Confer with team regarding expert deposition and 09/07/2018 Hamad Hamad supplemental reports concerning late‐produced documents. 565 0.2 Confer and correspond with expert regarding deposition 09/07/2018 Hamad Hamad scheduling. 565 0.2 Review Apple document regarding motivation for breaking 09/07/2018 Hamad Hamad FaceTime. 565 0.3 Correspond with expert and team regarding deposition 09/12/2018 Hamad Hamad scheduling. 565 0.2 Analyze Court's order granting‐in‐part and denying‐in‐part motion for class certification and confer with team regarding 09/20/2018 Hamad Hamad same. 565 0.6 Confer and correspond with team regarding strategies 09/21/2018 Hamad Hamad concerning Court's class certification order. 565 0.3 Conduct research regarding procedure to amend class 09/21/2018 Hamad Hamad certification order and analyze results of research. 565 0.4 Research regarding scope and applicability of work product doctrine in class action litigation; correspond with team and 12/05/2018 Hamad Hamad co‐counsel regarding same. 565 1.1 Research regarding scope and applicability of work product doctrine in class action litigation; correspond with team and 12/06/2018 Hamad Hamad co‐counsel regarding same. 565 0.9 Correspond with team and co‐counsel regarding scope and applicability of work product doctrine in class action 12/28/2018 Hamad Hamad litigation. 565 0.6

Correspond with team regarding scope and applicability of 01/22/2019 Hamad Hamad work product doctrine in class action litigation. 565 0.1 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 56 of 106

Correspond with team regarding scope and applicability of 02/04/2019 Hamad Hamad work product doctrine in class action litigation. 615 0.4 TOTAL: 118.3 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 57 of 106

TAB F Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 58 of 106

Warren J. McCarty ‐ Time Detail Grace v. Apple, Inc. ‐‐ No. 5:17‐cv‐00551‐LHK Inception through 10.31.20

Date Name Task Rate Hours

Confer with A. Curry regarding protective order provisions; research NDCAL case law regarding source code protective order provisions; review NDCAL model protective orders regarding source code discovery; draft correspondence to Apple counsel regarding protective order negotiations and model protective order; confer with A. Curry regarding 10/04/2017 Warren J. McCarty correspondence with Defendants. 450 5.2 Confer with A. Currey regarding protective order dispute; review email correspondence between A. Curry and J. Loy regarding protective order disputes and continue analyze disputes against local sample protective orders; prepare draft correspondence to J. Loy regarding protective order 10/05/2017 Warren J. McCarty compromise. 450 2.7 Review opposing counsel redline to source code protective order; confer with A. Curry regarding provisions related to source code printing limits; revise source code protective order language and correspond with 10/16/2017 Warren J. McCarty opposing counsel regarding edits. 450 1.8

Review opposing counsel redline to source code protective order; run 10/18/2017 Warren J. McCarty final proofread of source code protective order and prepare for filing. 450 0.6 Review redline to source code protective order; confer with team regarding source code protective order; correspond with Apple counsel regarding source code protective order; prepare source code protective 10/19/2017 Warren J. McCarty order for filing. 450 1.1 Begin draft letter brief section addressing 30(b)(6) dispute and circulate 01/10/2018 Warren J. McCarty same. 450 2.3 Confer with A. Curry regarding 30(b)(6) dispute and meet and confer background and collect email correspondence and review same regarding 01/10/2018 Warren J. McCarty 30(b)(6) topics and definitions. 450 3.6 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 59 of 106

Conduct legal research regarding privilege log requirements and implied waiver of attorney‐client privilege; begin draft letter to opposing counsel 01/11/2018 Warren J. McCarty regarding same. 450 2.7 Begin document review and tagging project for document batch no. 23; complete document review and tagging project for document batch no. 01/16/2018 Warren J. McCarty 23. 450 5.1

01/16/2018 Warren J. McCarty Begin document review and tagging project for document batch no. 27. 450 2.1 Prepare for and attend conference call with co‐counsel regarding Apple 01/17/2018 Warren J. McCarty document review project. 450 1.2 Continue document review and tagging project for document batch no. 27; complete document review and tagging project for document batch 01/17/2018 Warren J. McCarty no. 27. 450 3.8 Begin document review and tagging project for document batch no. 34; complete document review and tagging project for document batch no. 01/29/2018 Warren J. McCarty 34. 450 4.3 Continue review updated ESI production for technical documents regarding certificate expiration; compile list of newly produced 02/08/2018 Warren J. McCarty documents regarding certificate expiration. 450 4.7 Continue review updated ESI production for technical documents regarding certificate expiration; confer with co‐counsel regarding 02/09/2018 Warren J. McCarty updated. 450 6.9 Set‐up and attend call with co‐counsel J. Manning regarding motion for 03/09/2018 Warren J. McCarty class certification fact section. 450 0.5 03/09/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review and revise draft of motion for class certification. 450 0.4 Review and tag Apple 2.16.18 document production bates numbers APL‐ 03/09/2018 Warren J. McCarty GRACE_00168387 ‐ APL‐GRACE_00169900. 450 3.6 Finish document review batch number Apple 2.2.2018 Production ‐Emails 03/09/2018 Warren J. McCarty Part I00001. 450 3.3

Research and review procedural considerations related to fact sections in 03/09/2018 Warren J. McCarty motions for class certification in Northern District of California. 450 0.5 Marshal and catalogue relevant factual support for citation in fact 03/09/2018 Warren J. McCarty background section of motion for class certification. 450 1.2 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 60 of 106

Confer with co‐counsel regarding draft motion for class certification and review pertinent local rules regarding pages limits and procedures for 03/22/2018 Warren J. McCarty filing the same. 450 0.8

03/22/2018 Warren J. McCarty Begin draft outline of fact section for draft motion for class certification. 450 4.8 Continue search and collection of documentary support for fact section of 03/22/2018 Warren J. McCarty motion for class certification. 450 2.8 Continue draft outline of fact section for draft motion for class 03/23/2018 Warren J. McCarty certification. 450 3.2 Search for and collect additional documentary support for draft fact 03/24/2018 Warren J. McCarty section for motion for class certification. 450 2.5 Confer with co‐counsel D. Tejtel regarding draft fact section for motion 03/24/2018 Warren J. McCarty for class certification. 450 0.2

03/25/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review and revise draft fact section for motion for class certification. 450 0.8 04/12/2018 Warren J. McCarty Begin draft deposition outline for G. Thirumalai deposition 450 1.9 Attend call with V. Glaze regarding G. Thirumalai deposition preparation 04/12/2018 Warren J. McCarty and document collection 450 0.4 Confer with A. Curry regarding D. De Atley deposition strategy and 04/13/2018 Warren J. McCarty logistics. 450 0.5 Confer with B. Caldwell regarding G. Thirumalai deposition strategy and 04/13/2018 Warren J. McCarty logistics. 450 0.2

04/14/2018 Warren J. McCarty Continue prepare draft deposition outline for G. Thirumalai deposition. 450 2.1

04/14/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review D. De Atley document collection and send same for printing. 450 0.7 04/14/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review and collect documents for G. Thirumalai deposition. 450 2.3 04/17/2018 Warren J. McCarty Confer with A. Curry regarding D. De Atley deposition outline. 450 1.2 04/17/2018 Warren J. McCarty Prepare for D. De Atley deposition during travel to deposition. 450 6 04/18/2018 Warren J. McCarty Attend D. De Atley deposition. 450 8

04/19/2018 Warren J. McCarty Continue collect and review documents for G. Thirumalai deposition. 450 2.4

04/19/2018 Warren J. McCarty Continue prepare deposition outline for G. Thirumalai deposition. 450 2.8 04/20/2018 Warren J. McCarty Attend G. Thirumalai deposition 450 8 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 61 of 106

Begin review G. Thirumalai deposition transcript during travel from G. 04/20/2018 Warren J. McCarty Thirumalai deposition. 450 3 04/23/2018 Warren J. McCarty Confer with A. Curry regarding D. De Atley deposition follow‐up. 450 0.7 04/23/2018 Warren J. McCarty Continue review G. Thirumalai deposition transcript. 450 1.1 04/23/2018 Warren J. McCarty Draft internal memorandum regarding G. Thirumalai deposition. 450 0.6 04/23/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review D. De Atley deposition transcript. 450 0.8 Begin draft letter to Apple counsel regarding D. De Atley deposition 04/23/2018 Warren J. McCarty unpreparedness. 450 0.9 Draft letter to Apple counsel regarding document production gaps and 04/24/2018 Warren J. McCarty transmit same. 450 3.1

04/24/2018 Warren J. McCarty Confer with A. Curry regarding Apple deficient document production. 450 0.4 Finalize draft letter to Apple counsel regarding D. De Atley deposition 04/24/2018 Warren J. McCarty unpreparedness and transmit same. 450 2.7

04/24/2018 Warren J. McCarty Conduct legal research regarding 30(b)(6) deposition requirements. 450 0.6 Review Apple document production pertaining to certain date ranges in 04/24/2018 Warren J. McCarty 2013. 450 1.8

04/26/2018 Warren J. McCarty Confer with A. Curry regarding Apple response to interrogatory no. 14. 450 0.4 04/26/2018 Warren J. McCarty Conduct legal research regarding FRCP 33(d) requirements. 450 0.7 Draft letter to Apple counsel regarding deficient response to 04/26/2018 Warren J. McCarty interrogatory no. 14. 450 0.6 Draft follow‐up correspondence to Apple counsel regarding deficient 05/01/2018 Warren J. McCarty interrogatory response. 450 0.4 Review Apple supplemental interrogatory responses and review newly 05/01/2018 Warren J. McCarty cited documents 450 0.8 Correspond with trial team regarding analysis of iPhone performance 05/01/2018 Warren J. McCarty data 450 0.7

05/02/2018 Warren J. McCarty Draft firm profile document supporting motion for class certification 450 2.9 Continue review iPhone performance testing data and circulate notes 05/03/2018 Warren J. McCarty regarding same 450 1.3 Finalize edit of draft firm profile and declaration in support of motion for 05/03/2018 Warren J. McCarty class certification 450 0.4 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 62 of 106

Investigate document production deficiencies and itemize problematic 05/07/2018 Warren J. McCarty areas 450 5.3 Draft follow‐up letter to Apple counsel regarding Apple's deficient 05/07/2018 Warren J. McCarty document production 450 2.8

05/07/2018 Warren J. McCarty Confer with A. Curry regarding Apple's deficient document production 450 0.6 Finalize draft letter to Apple counsel regarding deficient document 05/08/2018 Warren J. McCarty production 450 0.7

05/09/2018 Warren J. McCarty Coordinate draft and service of deposition notice for Justin Wood 450 0.4 Review and revise draft Amended Responses and Objections to Apple's 05/11/2018 Warren J. McCarty 2nd Set of Interrogatories 450 1.1 05/15/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review Apple production of internal messages 450 0.3

Review correspondence with Akamai counsel regarding response to 05/17/2018 Warren J. McCarty Plaintiffs' subpoena and document production pursuant thereto 450 0.4 05/18/2018 Warren J. McCarty Prepare document list for Akamai deposition 450 0.8 Draft and send letter to Apple counsel regarding document production 05/18/2018 Warren J. McCarty deficiencies 450 0.5 05/19/2018 Warren J. McCarty Begin prepare outline for Akamai deposition 450 2.6 05/21/2018 Warren J. McCarty Locate and organize hot documents for team discovery meeting 450 1.6 05/21/2018 Warren J. McCarty Continue prepare deposition outline for Akamai deposition 450 1.7

05/21/2018 Warren J. McCarty Continue review Akamai production in anticipation of Akamai deposition 450 1.1 Travel to San Francisco for team discovery meeting; attend afternoon and 05/21/2018 Warren J. McCarty evening portion of team discovery meeting 450 7.7 05/22/2018 Warren J. McCarty Continue prepare deposition outline for Akamai deposition 450 2.3 05/22/2018 Warren J. McCarty Attend third‐party Akamai deposition 450 6.5 05/23/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review Akamai deposition rough transcript 450 0.7 05/23/2018 Warren J. McCarty Draft and circulate to team recap of Akamai deposition 450 0.6 Meet with A. Curry and J. Cassady regarding written discovery follow‐ups 05/29/2018 Warren J. McCarty and future deposition notices 450 0.6 Review letter from T. Greene regarding ESI search terms and confer with 05/30/2018 Warren J. McCarty team regarding same 450 0.3 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 63 of 106

Confer with S. Reich and A. Curry regarding ESI search terms and 05/30/2018 Warren J. McCarty document production issues 450 0.4 05/30/2018 Warren J. McCarty Draft letter to Apple regarding document production issues 450 2.3 05/31/2018 Warren J. McCarty Begin draft letter brief regarding Apple ESI collection 450 2.3 Confer with A. Curry regarding follow‐up items from discovery meet and 05/31/2018 Warren J. McCarty confer 450 1.3 05/31/2018 Warren J. McCarty Attend discovery meet and confer with Apple 450 2.4

05/31/2018 Warren J. McCarty Prepare for discovery meet and confer with A. Curry and D. Tejtel 450 1.1

05/31/2018 Warren J. McCarty Analyze differences between various ESI search terms run by Apple 450 0.7 Review and revise draft correspondence to Apple following May 31st 06/01/2018 Warren J. McCarty meet and confer regarding discovery deficiencies 450 0.7 06/01/2018 Warren J. McCarty Draft ESI discovery letter brief and circulate to team 450 3.4 Review correspondence from T. Greene regarding Apple's use of ESI 06/01/2018 Warren J. McCarty search terms 450 0.2

06/01/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review Apple document production for iOS performance documents 450 5.1

06/01/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review rough deposition transcript of third party Brightstar deposition 450 0.8 06/02/2018 Warren J. McCarty Conduct legal research regarding discovery proportionality 450 1.1 06/03/2018 Warren J. McCarty Revise draft of ESI discovery letter brief and circulate to team 450 0.4

06/04/2018 Warren J. McCarty Draft email to Apple counsel regarding Thirumalai deposition errata 450 0.6 Review objections and correspondence with third party Akamai counsel 06/04/2018 Warren J. McCarty regarding discovery requests 450 0.8

06/05/2018 Warren J. McCarty Draft email response to Apple counsel regarding ESI discovery letter brief 450 0.6 Confer with S. Reich regarding letter to Apple regarding deficient 06/06/2018 Warren J. McCarty response to interrogatory number 14 450 1.2 Draft and revise letter to Apple regarding deficient response to 06/06/2018 Warren J. McCarty interrogatory number 14 and transmit to Apple counsel 450 0.8

06/07/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review deposition transcript of third party Akamai witness David Hale 450 0.5 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 64 of 106

06/08/2018 Warren J. McCarty Confer with team regarding Apple's production of iPhone resale data 450 0.9

06/11/2018 Warren J. McCarty Attend meet and confer with Apple counsel regarding ESI discovery brief 450 0.5 06/11/2018 Warren J. McCarty Confer with team regarding ESI discovery letter brief 450 0.4

06/13/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review discovery materials in preparation for team discovery meeting 450 1.6 06/13/2018 Warren J. McCarty Attend team discovery meeting 450 0.9 06/13/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review updated draft of letter brief regarding ESI search terms 450 0.3 06/13/2018 Warren J. McCarty Conduct legal research regarding class action injunctive relief 450 1.1 Confer with A. Curry regarding new discovery requests and J. Wood 06/13/2018 Warren J. McCarty deposition 450 1 Send follow‐up email to Apple counsel regarding deficient discovery 06/14/2018 Warren J. McCarty responses 450 0.2 Attend team call regarding briefing responsibilities for response to 06/18/2018 Warren J. McCarty motion for class certification 450 0.7 06/19/2018 Warren J. McCarty Prepare topics and questions for Justin Wood deposition 450 2.2

06/20/2018 Warren J. McCarty Continue collect and prepare exhibits for Justin Wood deposition 450 1.8 Attend call with co‐counsel D. Tejtel regarding draft reply in support of 06/20/2018 Warren J. McCarty motion for class certification 450 0.5 Collect documents to cite in Plaintiffs' reply in support of its motion for 06/20/2018 Warren J. McCarty class certification and circulate same to team 450 0.8

06/20/2018 Warren J. McCarty Confer with A. Curry regarding hearing on ESI discovery letter brief 450 1.1 Prepare letter to Apple counsel regarding deficient responses to requests 06/21/2018 Warren J. McCarty for production numbers 7, 12, and 13 450 2.9

06/21/2018 Warren J. McCarty Confer with A. Curry regarding Justin Wood deposition preparation 450 0.7 06/22/2018 Warren J. McCarty Attend Justin Wood deposition by telephone 450 7.5 Review draft fact sections in response motion in support of class 06/23/2018 Warren J. McCarty certification 450 1.5 Attend team call regarding briefing responsibilities for response to 06/25/2018 Warren J. McCarty motion for class certification 450 0.7 06/25/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review Justin Wood deposition transcript 450 0.5 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 65 of 106

Draft email discovery request to Apple counsel regarding Justin Wood 06/25/2018 Warren J. McCarty deposition testimony 450 0.6 Confer with A. Curry regarding Justin Wood deposition and follow‐up 06/25/2018 Warren J. McCarty discovery requests 450 0.2 Edit draft reply brief in support of motion for class certification and 06/26/2018 Warren J. McCarty circulate to team 450 3.5 06/26/2018 Warren J. McCarty Begin prepare Rubin deposition outline 450 4.8 Confer with D. Tejtel regarding draft reply brief in support of motion for 06/26/2018 Warren J. McCarty class certification 450 0.3 06/27/2018 Warren J. McCarty Begin prepare exhibits for Rubin deposition 450 3.5 Prepare for meet and confer with Apple counsel regarding deficient 06/28/2018 Warren J. McCarty document production 450 0.8 Attend meet and confer with Apple counsel regarding deficient document 06/28/2018 Warren J. McCarty production 450 1.1 Review draft Requests for Production and prepare new Requests for 06/28/2018 Warren J. McCarty Production 450 0.9 Draft email to A. Pilmer regarding date range restrictions in Apple's 06/28/2018 Warren J. McCarty document production 450 0.4 Correspond with Apple counsel regarding discovery letters and meet and 06/28/2018 Warren J. McCarty confer scheduling 450 0.7 06/29/2018 Warren J. McCarty Continue prepare Rubin deposition outline 450 1.9 06/29/2018 Warren J. McCarty Continue collect and review exhibits for Rubin deposition 450 2.3

06/29/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review and respond to co‐counsel email regarding new ESI custodians 450 0.2 06/30/2018 Warren J. McCarty Continue prepare for Rubin deposition 450 1.1 Continue prepare deposition questions and exhibits for deposition of Dr. 07/01/2018 Warren J. McCarty Rubin. 450 3.9

07/01/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review and revise class certification reply brief regarding damages model. 450 0.4 Draft correspondence to Apple counsel regarding iOS performance 07/02/2018 Warren J. McCarty documents. 450 0.4 Continue prepare deposition questions and exhibits for deposition of Dr. 07/02/2018 Warren J. McCarty Rubin. 450 11.6 07/03/2018 Warren J. McCarty Prepare for and attend deposition of Apple expert Dr. Rubin 450 10.5 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 66 of 106

07/03/2018 Warren J. McCarty Confer with A. Curry regarding deposition of Apple expert Dr. Rubin 450 0.8 07/03/2018 Warren J. McCarty Call with B. Caldwell regarding Dr. Rubin deposition 450 0.4 07/04/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review rough transcript of Dr. Rubin deposition 450 1.2 Begin draft letter brief regarding Apple RFP responses and date ranges 07/04/2018 Warren J. McCarty restrictions 450 2.9

07/04/2018 Warren J. McCarty Draft email to Apple counsel regarding materials considered by Dr. Rubin 450 0.3 Draft email to Apple counsel regarding regarding iOS performance 07/05/2018 Warren J. McCarty documents 450 0.1 Correspond with Apple counsel regarding meet and confer times 07/05/2018 Warren J. McCarty regarding Apple iOS performance documents 450 0.5 07/05/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review and revise draft third requests for production 450 0.6 Continue draft letter brief regarding Apple RFP responses and date range 07/05/2018 Warren J. McCarty restrictions 450 2.3 Prepare for and attend call with trial team regarding deposition of Apple 07/06/2018 Warren J. McCarty expert Ms. Trexler 450 0.8 07/07/2018 Warren J. McCarty Correspond with Dr. Hastings regarding Trexler deposition 450 0.2 07/07/2018 Warren J. McCarty Begin draft of sections of motion to strike Dr. Rubin 450 3.7 07/08/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review Apple 7/6/18 letter regarding performance documents 450 0.4 07/08/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review and revise draft motion to strike Dr. Rubin 450 1.3 Correspond with Apple counsel regarding meet and confer times 07/08/2018 Warren J. McCarty regarding Apple iOS performance documents 450 0.1 Continue prepare deposition questions and exhibits for deposition of Ms. 07/09/2018 Warren J. McCarty Trexler 450 10.7

07/09/2018 Warren J. McCarty Prepare for and attend call with Dr. Hastings regarding Trexler report 450 1.1 Draft and send correspondence to Apple counsel regarding production of 07/10/2018 Warren J. McCarty performance data 450 0.3 07/10/2018 Warren J. McCarty Prepare for and attend deposition of Apple expert Ms. Trexler 450 9.8

07/10/2018 Warren J. McCarty Confer with A. Curry regarding deposition of Apple expert Ms. Trexler 450 0.9

07/10/2018 Warren J. McCarty Confer with A. Curry regarding motions to strike Dr. Rubin and Ms. Trexler 450 0.6 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 67 of 106

Conduct legal research regarding expert qualifications and motions to 07/10/2018 Warren J. McCarty strike 450 1.1 Review and revise draft motion to strike Dr. Rubin and circulate to trial 07/10/2018 Warren J. McCarty team 450 2.3 Correspond with trial team regarding strategy regarding filing motions to 07/10/2018 Warren J. McCarty strike Apple's experts 450 0.7 Revise and finalize third set of requests for production and prepare for 07/10/2018 Warren J. McCarty service 450 0.5 07/11/2018 Warren J. McCarty Attend call with trial team regarding Hastings reply report 450 0.5

07/11/2018 Warren J. McCarty Attend call with trial team regarding motions to strike Apple experts 450 0.6 Confer with A. Curry and D. Pearson regarding motions to strike Apple 07/11/2018 Warren J. McCarty experts 450 0.7 07/11/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review and edit draft motion to strike Apple expert Ms. Trexler 450 0.9 07/11/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review and revise draft case management statement 450 0.3 07/11/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review draft Dr. Hastings reply report 450 0.7

07/11/2018 Warren J. McCarty Draft letter brief regarding Apple's objections to RFP numbers 12 and 13 450 3.3 07/12/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review final deposition transcript of Dr. Rubin 450 0.8 07/12/2018 Warren J. McCarty Continue edit draft motion to strike Ms. Trexler 450 0.7 Attend call with trial team regarding Reply brief in support of class 07/12/2018 Warren J. McCarty certification 450 0.6

07/12/2018 Warren J. McCarty Rework and finalize draft motion to strike Apple expert Dr. Rubin 450 2.6 Revise and edit draft motion to strike Dr. Rubin in light of Apple's 7.13.18 07/16/2018 Warren J. McCarty errata 450 2.9 Coordinate filing motion to strike Dr. Rubin report with S. Jain and D. 07/19/2018 Warren J. McCarty Pearson 450 0.3 07/20/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review deposition transcript of G. Choy. 450 0.8 07/25/2018 Warren J. McCarty Begin draft outline of technical expert report 450 0.5 Confer with expert Dr. Jones regarding expert report and source code 07/26/2018 Warren J. McCarty review 450 0.7 07/27/2018 Warren J. McCarty Correspond with Apple counsel regarding source code review 450 0.2 Meet with H. Hamad regarding performance testing for use in technical 07/28/2018 Warren J. McCarty expert report 450 1.2 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 68 of 106

07/29/2018 Warren J. McCarty Continue draft outline of technical expert report 450 0.9 Begin collect and review evidence regarding FaceTime technical issues for 07/29/2018 Warren J. McCarty use in technical expert report 450 1.6 07/30/2018 Warren J. McCarty Continue draft outline of technical expert report 450 0.7 Begin prepare materials and outline in advance of 8/1/18 meeting with 07/30/2018 Warren J. McCarty technical expert Dr. Jones 450 2.5

07/31/2018 Warren J. McCarty Prepare for meet and confer with Apple counsel regarding 30(b)(6) topics 450 0.7 Attend team call regarding outstanding discovery issues and upcoming 07/31/2018 Warren J. McCarty meet and confer with Apple counsel 450 1 Continue prepare materials and outline in advance of 8/1/18 meeting 07/31/2018 Warren J. McCarty with technical expert Dr. Jones 450 4.5 Attend meet and confer with Apple counsel regarding discovery issues 07/31/2018 Warren J. McCarty and deposition testimony 450 1.7 07/31/2018 Warren J. McCarty Conduct document review of third party Akamai production 450 2.2

07/31/2018 Warren J. McCarty Prepare writeup for trial team regarding third party Akamai production 450 0.5 08/01/2018 Warren J. McCarty Prepare for technical meeting with Dr. Jones. 450 1.3 08/01/2018 Warren J. McCarty Attend technical meeting with Dr. Jones. 450 7.4 Review proposal regarding search term custodians for Plaintiffs second 08/01/2018 Warren J. McCarty set of RFPs and letter brief regarding same. 450 0.5 08/02/2018 Warren J. McCarty Continue technical meeting with Dr. Jones. 450 2.2 Confer with H. Hamad regarding iPhone performance data and analysis 08/02/2018 Warren J. McCarty for Dr. Jones report. 450 1.4 08/02/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review final draft of G. Choy deposition transcript. 450 0.7 Review and edit Plaintiffs' requests for admission set three and Plaintiff 08/03/2018 Warren J. McCarty Potter's interrogatories set one. 450 0.8 Continue edit and revise technical modules for Dr. Jones technical expert 08/03/2018 Warren J. McCarty report. 450 4.5 08/03/2018 Warren J. McCarty Phone call with Dr. Jones regarding source code review. 450 0.9 Continue edit and revise technical modules for Dr. Jones technical expert 08/04/2018 Warren J. McCarty report. 450 4.8 Continue edit and revise technical modules for Dr. Jones technical expert 08/06/2018 Warren J. McCarty report. 450 3.6 08/07/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review Apple opposition to Motion to Strike Dr. Rubin. 450 0.6 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 69 of 106

08/07/2018 Warren J. McCarty Begin draft reply in support of Motion to Strike Dr. Rubin. 450 1.1 Confer with Dr. Jones and H. Hamad regarding expert reporting deadline 08/07/2018 Warren J. McCarty adjustments. 450 0.8 08/08/2018 Warren J. McCarty Revise and edit draft letter brief regarding deposition requests. 450 1.5 08/08/2018 Warren J. McCarty Draft final set of requests for production. 450 0.8 08/08/2018 Warren J. McCarty Draft final set of interrogatories. 450 0.3 08/08/2018 Warren J. McCarty Attend weekly litigation team meeting. 450 0.8 08/08/2018 Warren J. McCarty Continue draft reply in support of Motion to Strike Dr. Rubin. 450 7.5 08/08/2018 Warren J. McCarty Draft final set of requests for admission. 450 0.7

08/09/2018 Warren J. McCarty Edit and finalize draft reply in support of Motion to Strike Dr. Rubin. 450 2.3

Correspond with Apple counsel regarding meet and confer times to 08/09/2018 Warren J. McCarty discuss Apple objections and responses to Plaintiffs third set of RFPs. 450 0.3

08/09/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review Apple objections and responses to Plaintiffs third set of RFPs. 450 0.6

08/12/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review Apple production APL‐GRACE_00173212 ‐ APL‐GRACE_00173308. 450 1.1 Prepare for meet and confer with Apple regarding objections to requests 08/13/2018 Warren J. McCarty for production. 450 0.8 Attend meet and confer with Apple counsel regarding objections to 08/13/2018 Warren J. McCarty requests for production. 450 1.6 08/14/2018 Warren J. McCarty Attend weekly litigation team meeting. 450 0.7 Draft memorialization email to Apple counsel regarding objections to 08/14/2018 Warren J. McCarty requests for production. 450 0.9 Meet with J. Cassady to prepare for hearing on Plaintiffs' discovery letter 08/16/2018 Warren J. McCarty briefs. 450 0.9 Continue edit and revise technical modules for Dr. Jones technical expert 08/18/2018 Warren J. McCarty report. 450 6.9 Confer with Dr. Jones regarding source code printing and expert report 08/19/2018 Warren J. McCarty source code citations. 450 0.6

08/20/2018 Warren J. McCarty Correspond with Apple counsel regarding source code protective order. 450 0.3 Attend call with D. Tejtel and J. Cassady regarding discovery letter brief 08/21/2018 Warren J. McCarty issues and hearing presentation. 450 0.7 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 70 of 106

Attend call with J. Manning and J. Cassady regarding discovery letter brief 08/21/2018 Warren J. McCarty issues and hearing presentation. 450 0.8

08/21/2018 Warren J. McCarty Call with J. Cassady regarding preparation for discovery brief hearing. 450 0.7 Correspond with Apple counsel regarding Apple objections and responses 08/22/2018 Warren J. McCarty to Plaintiffs third set of RFPs. 450 0.5

08/22/2018 Warren J. McCarty Call with J. Cassady regarding preparation for discovery brief hearing. 450 0.4

08/22/2018 Warren J. McCarty Call with J. Cassady regarding outcome of discovery brief hearing. 450 0.9 Continue collect documents and technical information for Dr. Jones 08/23/2018 Warren J. McCarty expert report. 450 6.8 08/23/2018 Warren J. McCarty Attend weekly litigation team meeting. 450 0.6 Continue collect documents and technical information for Dr. Jones 08/24/2018 Warren J. McCarty expert report. 450 7.2 08/26/2018 Warren J. McCarty Edit and review expert report of Dr. Jones. 450 5.5 08/27/2018 Warren J. McCarty Call with Dr. Jones and H. Hamad regarding expert report draft. 450 0.9 08/27/2018 Warren J. McCarty Edit and review expert report of Dr. Jones. 450 8.6 Correspond with Apple counsel regarding Apple objections and responses 08/27/2018 Warren J. McCarty to Plaintiffs third set of RFPs. 450 0.2

08/27/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review and edit joint notice to Court regarding additional depositions. 450 0.7 Confer with J. Cassady and D. Pearson regarding additional deposition 08/27/2018 Warren J. McCarty requests to Apple. 450 0.4 Finalize exhibits and copies of expert report of Dr. Jones for service on 08/28/2018 Warren J. McCarty Apple. 450 0.8 08/28/2018 Warren J. McCarty Continue edit and review expert report of Dr. Jones. 450 12.3 08/28/2018 Warren J. McCarty Confer with H. Hamad regarding expert report of Dr. Jones. 450 0.7 08/28/2018 Warren J. McCarty Prepare exhibits to expert report of Dr. Jones. 450 0.6 08/30/2018 Warren J. McCarty Begin prepare outline for J. Vidrine deposition. 450 1.3 08/31/2018 Warren J. McCarty Begin preparing document list for J. Vidrine deposition. 450 0.5 08/31/2018 Warren J. McCarty Continue prepare outline for J. Vidrine deposition. 450 0.8

09/02/2018 Warren J. McCarty Confer with trial team regarding deposition of Apple witness D. Caldbeck. 450 0.6 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 71 of 106

09/02/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review prior deposition testimony of Apple witness D. Caldbeck. 450 0.8 09/03/2018 Warren J. McCarty Begin prepare outline for deposition of Apple witness J. Vidrine. 450 3.1 Begin search for and prepare deposition exhibits for Apple witness J. 09/03/2018 Warren J. McCarty Vidrine. 450 3.6

09/04/2018 Warren J. McCarty Continue prepare outline for deposition of Apple witness J. Vidrine. 450 4.1 Correspond with Apple counsel regarding Apple document production in 09/04/2018 Warren J. McCarty response to RFP Nos. 33‐56. 450 0.3 Continue search for and prepare deposition exhibits for Apple witness J. 09/04/2018 Warren J. McCarty Vidrine. 450 2.8

09/04/2018 Warren J. McCarty Confer with J. Cassady regarding deposition of Apple witness D. Caldbeck. 450 0.8 Review Apple document production APL‐GRACE_00175140 ‐ APL‐ 09/04/2018 Warren J. McCarty GRACE_00175166. 450 1.1 Correspond with trial team regarding Apple document production APL‐ 09/04/2018 Warren J. McCarty GRACE_00175140 ‐ APL‐GRACE_00175166. 450 0.3 Prepare for and attend trial team call regarding expert discovery, 09/05/2018 Warren J. McCarty depositions, and case strategy. 450 1.2 09/05/2018 Warren J. McCarty Draft deposition questions for Apple witness D. Caldbeck. 450 0.4 09/05/2018 Warren J. McCarty Continue prepare for deposition of Apple witness J. Vidrine. 450 8.5 Correspond with trial team regarding Apple document production APL‐ 09/06/2018 Warren J. McCarty GRACE_00175167 ‐ APL‐GRACE_00176733. 450 0.7 Review Apple document production APL‐GRACE_00175167 ‐ APL‐ 09/06/2018 Warren J. McCarty GRACE_00176733. 450 1.8

09/06/2018 Warren J. McCarty Research case law regarding spoliation of documentary evidence. 450 0.8

09/06/2018 Warren J. McCarty Confer with trial team regarding deposition of Apple witness J. Vidrine. 450 0.4 09/06/2018 Warren J. McCarty Continue prepare for deposition of Apple witness J. Vidrine. 450 0.8 09/06/2018 Warren J. McCarty Attend deposition of Apple witness J. Vidrine. 450 9.1 Continue review Apple document production APL‐GRACE_00175167 ‐ APL‐ 09/07/2018 Warren J. McCarty GRACE_00176733. 450 3.3 Review Apple response to Plaintiff Potter's Fourth Set of Request for 09/07/2018 Warren J. McCarty Production. 450 0.2 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 72 of 106

Review Apple response to Plaintiff Potter's Third Set of Request for 09/07/2018 Warren J. McCarty Admission. 450 0.3 Prepare for and attend call with trial team to discuss the Court Order 09/18/2018 Warren J. McCarty granting in‐part Plaintiffs' Motion for Class Certification. 450 1.5 Review Court Order granting in‐part Plaintiffs' Motion for Class 09/18/2018 Warren J. McCarty Certification. 450 0.8 09/23/2018 Warren J. McCarty Begin prepare outline for deposition of Apple expert Dr. Rubin. 450 4.9 Begin search for and prepare deposition exhibits for Apple expert Dr. 09/24/2018 Warren J. McCarty Rubin. 450 0.4

09/24/2018 Warren J. McCarty Continue prepare outline for deposition of Apple expert Dr. Rubin. 450 5.5 09/25/2018 Warren J. McCarty Continue prepare for deposition of Apple expert Dr. Rubin. 450 9.6

09/26/2018 Warren J. McCarty Confer with A. Curry regarding deposition of Apple expert Dr. Rubin. 450 0.6 09/26/2018 Warren J. McCarty Attend deposition of Apple expert Dr. Rubin. 450 10.3 09/26/2018 Warren J. McCarty Continue prepare for deposition of Apple expert Dr. Rubin. 450 1.2

09/27/2018 Warren J. McCarty Confer with A. Curry regarding deposition of Apple expert Dr. Rubin. 450 0.8

10/04/2018 Warren J. McCarty Correspond with team regarding lead counsel role and trial assignments. 450 0.6 10/04/2018 Warren J. McCarty Attend call with trial team regarding lead counsel designation. 450 0.7

10/08/2018 Warren J. McCarty Research case law regarding Apple motion for summary judgment. 450 0.3 Attend call with D. Tejtel regarding liability aspects of Apple motion for 10/08/2018 Warren J. McCarty summary judgment. 450 1.1

Conduct research and draft strategy email regarding liability arguments in 10/08/2018 Warren J. McCarty opposition to Apple motion for summary judgment. 450 3.6

10/08/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review draft opposition to Apple motion for summary judgment. 450 0.9

Continue research liability issues regarding opposition to Apple motion 10/11/2018 Warren J. McCarty for summary judgment; confer with D. Tejtel regarding same. 450 0.5 Conduct document review for evidence in opposition to Apple motion for 10/11/2018 Warren J. McCarty summary judgment. 450 2.8 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 73 of 106

Edit and revise draft opposition brief regarding Apple motion for 10/11/2018 Warren J. McCarty summary judgment. 450 1.7 Research rules regarding sealing procedure for filing opposition to Apple 10/15/2018 Warren J. McCarty motion for summary judgment. 450 0.8 Prepare for and attend team call regarding opposition brief to Apple 10/15/2018 Warren J. McCarty motion for summary judgment. 450 0.9 Prepare for and attend call with Apple counsel regarding sealing 10/15/2018 Warren J. McCarty procedures. 450 0.6 Continue edit and revise draft opposition brief regarding Apple motion 10/15/2018 Warren J. McCarty for summary judgment. 450 3.9 Coordinate with team, Apple, and third party Akamai regarding sealing procedures and evidence in opposition to Apple motion for summary 10/16/2018 Warren J. McCarty judgment. 450 2.2 10/16/2018 Warren J. McCarty Review Apple response to motion for reconsideration. 450 0.8 Prepare for and attend call with Apple counsel regarding sealing procedures for brief in opposition to Apple motion for summary 10/17/2018 Warren J. McCarty judgment. 450 0.5 Continue edit and review response in opposition to Apple's motion for 10/17/2018 Warren J. McCarty summary judgment. 450 1.1 Email with Akamai counsel regarding motion to seal exhibits; call with 10/17/2018 Warren J. McCarty Akamai counsel regarding same. 450 0.9

Coordinate with S. Jain regarding sealing procedures and exhibit 10/18/2018 Warren J. McCarty collection for attachment to opposition summary judgment brief. 450 0.7 Email correspondence with Apple counsel regarding exhibits to be sealed 10/18/2018 Warren J. McCarty and citation to deposition transcripts to be sealed. 450 0.6 Assist in preparation of B. Caldwell declaration in support of opposition 10/18/2018 Warren J. McCarty brief to summary judgment motion. 450 0.4 Review joint motion and declaration to be attached to opposition brief 10/18/2018 Warren J. McCarty regarding motion for summary judgment. 450 0.5 Finalize edits to opposition brief regarding Apple motion for summary 10/18/2018 Warren J. McCarty judgment. 450 3.1 Collect exhibits to be served on Akamai; email correspondence with 10/19/2018 Warren J. McCarty Akamai counsel regarding same. 450 0.4 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 74 of 106

Prepare for and attend team call regarding case status, mediation, and 10/31/2018 Warren J. McCarty summary judgment hearing. 450 1 Review third party Akamai production and analyze Akamai and Apple 10/01/2019 Warren J. McCarty contract amounts relevant to the FaceTime Break. 500 0.8

Confer with A. Curry regarding Akamai production and calculation of 10/01/2019 Warren J. McCarty amount of money Apple saved by breaking FaceTime. 500 1.2

Revise PowerPoint presentation concerning Akamai and Apple contract 10/01/2019 Warren J. McCarty negotiations to account for additional Akamai document productions. 500 1.3

Continue review third party Akamai document production to analyze and 10/02/2019 Warren J. McCarty certain approximate damages issues in anticipation of mediation. 500 2.9

Review deposition transcript of Akamai executive David Hale concerning 10/02/2019 Warren J. McCarty contract negotiations with Apple surrounding the FaceTime Break. 500 0.7

10/02/2019 Warren J. McCarty Confer with A. Curry regarding trial strategy, witnesses, and trial roles. 500 3.1

Review Apple Daubert motion concerning Dr. Jones; research case law regarding motions to strike expert testimony and Daubert; research case law concerning technical expert analysis of source code and testing data; 12/23/2019 Warren J. McCarty begin draft Dr. Jones portion of opposition to Apple Daubert motion 500 6.7 Continue draft Dr. Jones portion of opposition to Apple Daubert motion; confer with J. Cassady and A. Curry regarding same; circulate draft to co‐ 12/24/2019 Warren J. McCarty counsel 500 2.5 Continue draft Dr. Jones portion of opposition to Apple Daubert motion; circulate edits to team and confer with team regarding declarations, 12/26/2019 Warren J. McCarty exhibits, and filing procedure 500 1.6 Continue draft Dr. Jones portion of opposition to Apple Daubert motion; 12/27/2019 Warren J. McCarty continue edit and revise entire draft opposition brief 500 4.2 Review J. Koh order concerning Daubert motions and confer with co‐ counsel regarding page limits, sealing issues, and final edits to draft 12/27/2019 Warren J. McCarty opposition brief to Apple's Daubert motion 500 0.9 TOTAL: 601.7 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 75 of 106

TAB G Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 76 of 106

Nicholas Nestelbaum ‐ Time Detail Grace v. Apple, Inc. ‐‐ No. 5:17‐cv‐00551‐LHK Inception through 10.31.20

Date Name Task Rate Hours Discuss motions in limine with Austin Curry, and the new project that I will be working on. Draft three motions in 12/11/2019 Nick Nestelbaum limine for Austin Curry. 475 0.50 Discuss motions in limine with Austin Curry, and the new project that I will be working on. Draft three motions in 12/12/2019 Nick Nestelbaum limine for Austin Curry. 475 8.00 TOTAL: 8.50 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 77 of 106

TAB H Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 78 of 106

Daniel R. Pearson ‐ Time Detail Grace v. Apple, Inc. ‐‐ No. 5:17‐cv‐00551‐LHK Inception through 10.31.20

Date Name Task Rate Hours

Confer with A. Curry regarding research project related to 02/23/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Verizon buyback data; research issues related to same. 500 2.7 Continue researching issues related to Verizon buyback data; 02/26/2018 Daniel R. Pearson confer with A. Curry regarding same. 500 1.7 Draft language responding to Verizon data produced via 02/28/2018 Daniel R. Pearson subpoena; research issues related to same. 500 4.1 Meet and confer with opposing counsel regarding various 03/12/2018 Daniel R. Pearson discovery issues. 500 2.5 Research and draft correspondence regarding Apple's 04/27/2018 Daniel R. Pearson deficient interrogatory responses. 500 3.1

Research and draft correspondence to Akamai regarding its 04/30/2018 Daniel R. Pearson deficient response to Plaintiffs' subpoena. 500 2.1 Draft and send correspondence to D. Judson regarding 05/09/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Plaintiffs' subpeona to Akamai. 500 2.1

05/11/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Correspond with D. Judson regarding Akamai subpoena. 500 0.1 Correspond and confer with D. Judson and A. Curry regarding 05/14/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Akamai subpoena. 500 1.4

05/17/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Correspond with D. Judson regarding Akamai subpoena. 500 0.4 Correspond and confer with D. Judson regarding Akamai 05/18/2018 Daniel R. Pearson subpoena. 500 1.1 Correspond with D. Judson and team regarding document 05/20/2018 Daniel R. Pearson productions related to Akamai subpoena. 500 0.7 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 79 of 106

Research and draft correspondence to D. Judson regarding Akamai's deficient document production and subpoena 05/24/2018 Daniel R. Pearson response. 500 2.1 05/25/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Research issues related to Brightstar deposition. 500 1.2

Correspond with team and D. Judson regarding Akamai's 05/25/2018 Daniel R. Pearson deficient document production and subpoena response. 500 0.3 Prepare for Brightstar deposition; research issues related to 05/26/2018 Daniel R. Pearson same. 500 4.5 Prepare for Brightstar deposition; research issues related to 05/29/2018 Daniel R. Pearson same. 500 2.1 Prepare for Brightstar deposition; correspond with opposing 05/30/2018 Daniel R. Pearson counsel regarding same. 500 11.7 05/31/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Prepare for Brightstar deposition. 500 4.9 05/31/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Take Brightstar deposition. 500 2.5 Correspond with co‐counsel regarding Plaintiffs' subpoena to 06/01/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Brightstar. 500 0.2 Correspond with D. Judson regarding Plaintiffs' subpoena to 06/04/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Akamai. 500 0.2

06/06/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Discovery call regarding Best Buy deposition with co‐counsel. 500 0.9 Prepare for Best Buy deposition; confer with team regarding 06/11/2018 Daniel R. Pearson same. 500 8.2 06/12/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Prepare for Best Buy deposition. 500 4.1 06/12/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Take deposition of Best Buy. 500 4.2 06/13/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Weekly team discovery conference call. 500 1

06/18/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Review Apple's opposition brief regarding class certification. 500 2.1

06/18/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Teleconference with team regarding Apple's opposition brief. 500 1.1

Teleconference with J. Hastings and team regarding issues 06/20/2018 Daniel R. Pearson related to Apple's brief opposing class certification. 500 0.9 06/25/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Weekly team case management conference. 500 1.1 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 80 of 106

Teleconference with J. Hastings and team regarding issues 06/27/2018 Daniel R. Pearson related to Apple's brief opposing class certification. 500 0.9

06/28/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Teleconference with team regarding choice of law issues. 500 0.7

06/29/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Research choice of law issues related to class certification. 500 6.7 Edit and revise portion of Reply in support of motion to certify class regarding choice of law issues; research issues 07/02/2018 Daniel R. Pearson related to same. 500 7.6 Correspond with counsel for Akamai regarding Plaintiffs' 07/03/2018 Daniel R. Pearson subpoena. 500 0.6 Confer with team regarding strategy and preparation for D. 07/04/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Trexler deposition. 500 0.8

07/09/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Correspond with team regarding A. Zeinfeld deposition. 500 0.2

07/10/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Correspond with team regarding D. Trexler deposition. 500 0.6 07/11/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Edit and revise motion to strike Rubin. 500 4.2 Conference call with team regarding discovery issues and 07/11/2018 Daniel R. Pearson motions to strike. 500 1.1 07/12/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Edit and revise motion to strike Rubin. 500 2.1 Edit and revise Reply in support of Plaintiffs' motion for class 07/13/2018 Daniel R. Pearson certification. 500 2.3 Correspond with team regarding filing the motion to strike 07/19/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Rubin. 500 1.1 Research issues related to Jones expert report on 07/24/2018 Daniel R. Pearson performance of iOS 7.1 500 4.4 Edit draft requests for production; research issues related to 08/03/2018 Daniel R. Pearson same. 500 1.3 Research issues for Dr. Jones expert report; correspond with 08/03/2018 Daniel R. Pearson team regarding same. 500 3.3 08/22/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Research issues related to deposition limits. 500 2.4 Edit and revise damages report; research issues related to 08/23/2018 Daniel R. Pearson same. 500 6.2 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 81 of 106

Edit and revise damages report; research issues related to 08/24/2018 Daniel R. Pearson same. 500 2.4 Edit and revise damages report; research issues related to 08/27/2018 Daniel R. Pearson same. 500 6.6 Confer with J. Cassady and W. McCarty regarding additional 08/27/2018 Daniel R. Pearson deposition requests to Apple. 500 0.8 Edit and revise damages report; research issues related to 08/28/2018 Daniel R. Pearson same. 500 7.2 Edit and revise responses to requests for admission and 08/30/2018 Daniel R. Pearson interrogatories. 500 3.1 Correspond with team regarding expert deposition 09/06/2018 Daniel R. Pearson scheduling issues. 500 0.3 09/06/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Research issues regarding Caldbeck deposition. 500 0.4 Correspond with team regarding expert deposition 09/07/2018 Daniel R. Pearson scheduling issues. 500 0.4 Edit and revise responsive insert in draft letter brief related 09/07/2018 Daniel R. Pearson to expert discovery schedule. 500 1.8 Draft letter brief related to contact information of potential 09/07/2018 Daniel R. Pearson class members. 500 2.6 09/12/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Teleconference with team. 500 0.8 Correspond with team regarding expert deposition 09/12/2018 Daniel R. Pearson scheduling issues. 500 0.4 09/17/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Teleconference related to Hastings deposition. 500 1.1 09/18/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Teleconference related to Hastings deposition. 500 1.4 09/19/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Prepare for Hastings deposition. 500 6.2 09/19/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Review Malhotra expert report. 500 2.1 09/20/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Attend Hastings deposition. 500 7 09/21/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Research on state law issues. 500 4.9 09/21/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Teleconference related to Malhotra deposition. 500 0.7 09/22/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Teleconference related to Malhotra deposition. 500 1.1 09/23/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Research issues related to Jones deposition. 500 0.7

09/25/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Research issues related to motion for reconsideration. 500 2.1 Research issues related to cross‐jurisdictional tolling and 09/27/2018 Daniel R. Pearson statutes of limitations. 500 3.3 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 82 of 106

10/08/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Research issues related to restitution. 500 3.4 10/08/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Review Apple summary judgment papers. 500 1.2 Conference call regarding damages issues related to 10/09/2018 Daniel R. Pearson summary judgment. 500 0.8

Edit and revise response in opposition to Apple's summary 10/15/2018 Daniel R. Pearson judgment brief; correspond with team regarding same. 500 2.1 Conference call regarding damages issues related to 10/15/2018 Daniel R. Pearson summary judgment. 500 0.7 11/06/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Attend pre‐mediation teleconference. 500 2.4 Research issues related to drafting reply in support of Petitioner's 23(f) request; correspond with team regarding 11/20/2018 Daniel R. Pearson same. 500 3.1 Research issues related to drafting reply in support of Petitioner's 23(f) request; correspond with team regarding 11/21/2018 Daniel R. Pearson same. 500 3.5 11/27/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Draft reply in support of Petitioner's 23(f) request. 500 8.1 Continue drafting reply in support of Petitioner's 23(f) 11/28/2018 Daniel R. Pearson request; confer with J. Manning regarding same. 500 8.4 Continue drafting reply in support of Petitioner's 23(f) 11/29/2018 Daniel R. Pearson request. 500 7.4 Edit and revise reply in support of Petitioner's 23(f) request; 11/30/2018 Daniel R. Pearson correspond with team regarding same. 500 3.4 Review and revise reply in support of Petitioner's 23(f) 12/03/2018 Daniel R. Pearson request, correspond with team regarding same. 500 4.8 Review and revise reply in support of Petitioner's 23(f) 12/4/2018 Daniel R. Pearson request, correspond with team regarding same. 500 4.6

12/17/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Research related to potential new class representatives. 500 2.4

12/18/2018 Daniel R. Pearson Research related to potential new class representatives. 500 4.4 TOTAL: 239.9 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 83 of 106

TAB I Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 84 of 106

R. Seth Reich ‐ Time Detail Grace v. Apple, Inc. ‐‐ No. 5:17‐cv‐00551‐LHK Inception through 10.31.20

Date Name Task Rate Hours 02/09/2018 R. Seth Reich Discuss case with W. McCarty. 450.00 0.2 Research regarding appointment of special master; discuss Apple 05/08/2018 R. Seth Reich discovery issues with team 450.00 2 Research case law regarding withholding of non‐responsive 05/25/2018 R. Seth Reich documents 450.00 2.5 Review correspondence on ESI; reseach ESI issues; prepare letter 05/29/2018 R. Seth Reich regarding ESI issues 450.00 4.1 Review heat chart documents; review and revise letter on ESI issues; review Defendant's letter on ESI terms and compare to 05/30/2018 R. Seth Reich declaration 450.00 6.4 Detail differences in Defendant's ESI search terms in declaration and letter; review heat chart documentation; participate in meet 05/31/2018 R. Seth Reich and confer 450.00 6.8 06/01/2018 R. Seth Reich Research regarding ESI discovery violations 450.00 2.8 Review and revise letter on performance testing; research 06/04/2018 R. Seth Reich regarding ESI 450.00 3.5 Review discovery letters and emails on same; discuss with W. 06/06/2018 R. Seth Reich McCarty 450.00 0.2

06/11/2018 R. Seth Reich Research case law and strategize regarding injunctive relief for class 450.00 4.4 Review Apple's response to ESI letter; discuss same with W. 06/12/2018 R. Seth Reich McCarty; discuss injunctive relief with A. Curry 450.00 0.3 Review opposition to class cert; review documents for discovery 06/20/2018 R. Seth Reich issues; discuss hearing with team 450.00 4.9

Search document database for missing documents that show desire 06/21/2018 R. Seth Reich to reduce relay usage; discuss production issues with W. McCarty 450.00 6 06/25/2018 R. Seth Reich Discuss Wood depo with W. McCarty. 450.00 0.3 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 85 of 106

06/26/2018 R. Seth Reich Review Wood transcript 450.00 2.5 TOTAL: 46.9 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 86 of 106

TAB J Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 87 of 106

John F. Summers ‐ Time Detail Grace v. Apple, Inc. ‐‐ No. 5:17‐cv‐00551‐LHK Inception through 10.31.20

Date Name Task Rate Hours Begin researching Judge Koh class action and unfair competition cases to 02/07/2017 John F. Summers determine whether client should consent to Judge Cousins. 525 2.1 Research prior Judge Koh cases concerning unfair competition claims and class action certification for purposes of evaluating whether to consent to Judge 02/08/2017 John F. Summers Cousins. 525 6.1 Continue researching prior class action case law from Judge Koh and drafting memorandum concerning same in evaluating whether to consent to Judge 02/09/2017 John F. Summers Cousins. 525 2.8 02/13/2017 John F. Summers Continue research related to prior Judge Koh class action opinions. 525 5.5 02/14/2017 John F. Summers Finalize research concerning Judge Koh; circulate same to team. 525 1.1

Prepare for call concerning magistrate consent choice; confer with colleagues 02/15/2017 John F. Summers about consent; discuss risks and benefits from various Article III judges. 525 1.9 Review Apple's Motion to Dismiss; makes notes to same; compare arguments 03/23/2017 John F. Summers with memorandum prepared in advance of filing. 525 0.9 Review memorandum summarizing motion to dismiss arguments and potential 03/24/2017 John F. Summers responses; and participate in call concerning same. 525 1.6 Brainstorm with team concerning best approaches for addressing protective 03/28/2017 John F. Summers order issue. 525 0.4 Review proposed correspondence from A. Curry concerning protective order 03/29/2017 John F. Summers issue; provide input on same. 525 0.2

Research California case law concerning restitution; brainstorm potential 03/31/2017 John F. Summers approaches and theories based on facts for restitutionary requests. 525 4.8 Review case law regarding restitution; draft email memorandum about particular restitutionary theories for purposes of choosing best option in 04/03/2017 John F. Summers drafting amended complaint. 525 6.8 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 88 of 106

Research Protective Order issues regarding definition of "use"; conduct related research concerning subject matter waiver and work product; meet with team 04/05/2017 John F. Summers concerning best responses to letter from opposing counsel. 525 4.9 Continue research related to circumstances of in camera review based on 04/06/2017 John F. Summers allegation of Protective Order violation. 525 1.2 04/18/2017 John F. Summers Review documentary background material. 525 0.7 04/20/2017 John F. Summers Participate in call concerning motion to dismiss game plan. 525 0.5 Participate in conference concerning Apple's positions regarding motion to stay 05/16/2017 John F. Summers discovery. 525 1.1 Review publicly available trial transcripts for information indicating individuals likely to be have information supporting Plaintiff's claims and defenses for use 05/22/2017 John F. Summers in Initial Disclosures. 525 2.3 05/23/2017 John F. Summers Review protect order and send comments to A. Curry. 525 1.1 Continue review of publicly available trial transcripts for information related to 05/23/2017 John F. Summers initial disclosures. 525 3.5

08/31/2017 John F. Summers Research issues related to class action damages and various pressure points. 525 2.1

09/18/2017 John F. Summers Research damages‐related issues and how they related to class certification. 525 1.1 09/29/2017 John F. Summers Participate in discovery meet and confer with opposing counsel. 525 2.1 10/04/2017 John F. Summers Discuss trespass to chattels issue with A. Curry. 525 0.8 Discuss discovery issues with A. Curry; begin drafting email to opposing counsel 10/06/2017 John F. Summers concerning discovery issues. 525 1.5 10/09/2017 John F. Summers Draft email to opposing counsel concerning discovery issues. 525 1.1

10/17/2017 John F. Summers Participate in meet and confer; discuss same; begin drafting letter brief. 525 4.7 10/18/2017 John F. Summers Revise letter brief; send same to A. Curry for review. 525 1.2 11/15/2017 John F. Summers Draft letter brief concerning deficient interrogatory responses. 525 3.4

11/20/2017 John F. Summers Discuss discovery strategy with A. Curry; draft email to opposing counsel. 525 1.5 11/28/2017 John F. Summers Draft email to opposing counsel. 525 0.2 Draft email to opposing counsel concerning questions raised by document 12/05/2017 John F. Summers production. 525 0.8 12/11/2017 John F. Summers Prepare subpoena to Akamai 525 0.5 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 89 of 106

12/13/2017 John F. Summers Review Apple's interrogatory responses. 525 0.6 Review email from counsel concerning questions related to produced spreadsheets; investigate potential grounds for motion to compel interrogatory 12/14/2017 John F. Summers responses. 525 1.7 Draft Plaintiff's statement concerning Joint Letter Brief regarding interrogatory 12/27/2017 John F. Summers issues. 525 4.5 Revise Plaintiff's statement concerning Joint Letter Brief regarding 12/28/2017 John F. Summers interrogatory issues. 525 2.2 12/29/2017 John F. Summers Review emails regarding initial source code review. 525 0.3 01/02/2018 John F. Summers Draft letter brief concerning deficient interrogatory responses. 525 3.2 01/04/2018 John F. Summers Brainstorm and draft discovery requests. 525 2.4 01/05/2018 John F. Summers Draft interrogatories and send same to team. 525 0.4 01/19/2018 John F. Summers Discuss supplemental brief and proposed order with A. Curry. 525 0.3 01/21/2018 John F. Summers Draft supplemental brief and proposed order. 525 3.1 01/22/2018 John F. Summers Finalize supplemental brief and send same to team. 525 1.3 01/26/2018 John F. Summers Discuss issues related to source code analysis with A. Curry. 525 0.5 09/25/2018 John F. Summers Discuss potential reconsideration issues with A. Curry. 525 0.6

Begin reviewing the Court's certification order and brainstorming potential 09/25/2018 John F. Summers reconsideration approaches; begin research concerning same. 525 5.2 Continue researching and brainstorming brief; begin drafting motion to amend 09/26/2018 John F. Summers class definitions. 525 5.9 09/27/2018 John F. Summers Continue researching and drafting motion to amend class definitions. 525 6.8 09/28/2018 John F. Summers Participate in call with team concerning state survey analysis. 525 0.7 09/29/2018 John F. Summers Continue researching and drafting motion to amend class definitions. 525 5.7 09/30/2018 John F. Summers Continue researching and drafting motion to amend class definitions. 525 5.1 10/01/2018 John F. Summers Revise reconsideration brief after comments from team. 525 3.2 10/01/2018 John F. Summers Participate in call with team concerning reconsideration plan. 525 0.7 Correspond with team and revise motion for reconsideration and prepare same 10/02/2018 John F. Summers for filing. 525 7.6 Discuss Apple's Motion for Summary Judgment with D. Pearson and W. 10/08/2018 John F. Summers McCarty. 525 0.8

10/20/2018 John F. Summers Finalize initial draft of Reply in Support of Motion for Reconsideration. 525 5.2 10/20/2018 John F. Summers Draft Reply in Support of Motion for Reconsideration. 525 4.4 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 90 of 106

10/22/2018 John F. Summers Revise Reply in Support of Motion for Reconsideration; circulate same to team. 525 1.7 11/28/2018 John F. Summers Discuss issues related to 23(f) Reply with D. Pearson. 525 1.2 11/29/2018 John F. Summers Begin revising 23(f) reply. 525 2.1 11/30/2018 John F. Summers Continue revising 23(f) reply; circulate same. 525 1.1 TOTAL: 149.0 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 91 of 106

TAB NA -1 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 92 of 106

Beverly J. DeFeo ‐ Time Detail (Non‐Attorney) Grace v. Apple, Inc. ‐‐ No. 5:17‐cv‐00551‐LHK Inception through 10.31.20

Date Name Task Rate Hours Communicate with M. Delaney regarding preparation and 02/10/2017 Beverly J. DeFeo filing of attorney pro hac vice motions. 285 0.2

Communicate with J. Cassady regarding L. Koh research; 04/28/2017 Beverly J. DeFeo forward requested information for attorney review. 285 0.3

Communicate with M. Delaney regarding Apple's deadline to answer complaint based on date of order denying motion to 08/10/2017 Beverly J. DeFeo dismiss directing same to Fed. R. Civ. P. 12. 285 0.2

Communicate with A. Curry regarding Apple's filing of answer 08/11/2017 Beverly J. DeFeo to amended complaint circulating same for attorney review. 285 0.2 Review and index Apple's production of deposition and trial testimony obtained during the VirnetX litigation for J. 05/21/2018 Beverly J. DeFeo Cassady's review. 285 0.9

05/22/2018 Beverly J. DeFeo Update source code production transmittal and tracking log. 285 0.2 Review and index Apple's produced source code in 05/22/2018 Beverly J. DeFeo preparation for attorney and expert review. 285 1.6 Review case correspondence regarding Apple's production of 05/22/2018 Beverly J. DeFeo source code. 285 0.1 Circulate Apple's source code production correspondence for 05/22/2018 Beverly J. DeFeo attorney review. 285 0.1

Communicate with M. Delaney regarding status of case 05/31/2018 Beverly J. DeFeo pleading file and updates to same as requested by A. Curry. 285 0.1 Review and update case pleading file in preparation for A. 05/31/2018 Beverly J. DeFeo Curry's review. 285 0.3 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 93 of 106

Communicate with A. Curry and M. Delaney regarding 06/19/2018 Beverly J. DeFeo hearing regarding discovery letter brief. 285 0.2

Assist M. Delaney with review and organization of materials regarding discovery letter brief for A. Curry's review in 06/19/2018 Beverly J. DeFeo preparation for hearing regarding same. 285 1.8 Communicate with opposing counsel regarding compliance 07/11/2018 Beverly J. DeFeo with protective order. 285 0.1 Communicate with H. Hamad and M. Delaney regarding assistance with review and comparison of Apple's iPhone 4 07/25/2018 Beverly J. DeFeo testing information. 285 0.3

Communicate with H. Hamad and M. Delaney regarding transcription of Apple app developer conference video 08/27/2018 Beverly J. DeFeo transcript forwarding same for attorney review. 285 0.4 Review and organize various case materials forwarding same 08/27/2018 Beverly J. DeFeo for M. Jones review. 285 0.3 Communicate with J. Cassady regarding D. Caldbeck 08/28/2018 Beverly J. DeFeo deposition preparation. 285 0.3

Search Apple production regarding D. Caldbeck's references to 'bug' designating documents regarding same for J. Cassady's review in preparation for deposition of same; Caldbeck and hot; communicate with J. Cassady regarding 08/30/2018 Beverly J. DeFeo double‐tracking of the D. Caldbeck and J. Vidrine depositions. 285 1.9 Communicate with J. Cassady regarding scheduling of D. 08/30/2018 Beverly J. DeFeo Caldbeck and J. Vidrine depositions. 285 0.1

Search Apple production regarding D. Caldbeck documents designated as hot organizing same for J. Cassady's review in 08/30/2018 Beverly J. DeFeo preparation for deposition of same. 285 0.8 Communicate with HG Litigation regarding scheduling of D. 08/31/2018 Beverly J. DeFeo Caldbeck and J. Vidrine depositions. 285 0.3 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 94 of 106

Review case communications regarding J. Vidrine deposition logistics updating team and opposing counsel regarding 09/05/2018 Beverly J. DeFeo same. 285 2 12/07/2019 Beverly J. DeFeo Preparation of trial exhibit list. 295 3.10 12/08/2019 Beverly J. DeFeo Preparation of trial exhibit list. 295 5.80 12/11/2019 Beverly J. DeFeo Preparation of trial exhibit list; forward motion in limine 295 4.50 materials for N. Nestelbaum's review; 12/12/2019 Beverly J. DeFeo Prepare CMC and MTD for N. Nestelbaum review. 295 0.20 TOTAL: 26.3 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 95 of 106

TAB NA -2 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 96 of 106

Michael Delaney ‐ Time Detail (Non‐Attorney) Grace v. Apple, Inc. ‐‐ No. 5:17‐cv‐00551‐LHK Inception through 10.31.20

Date Name Task Rate Hours Review VirnetX trial transcripts for references to relay usage 02/02/2017 Michael P. Delaney for J. Cassady. 225 1 Review Court docket and update pleadings file; review case 02/06/2017 Michael P. Delaney management order and docket deadlines. 225 1.2 Prepare pro hac vice motions for B. Caldwell, A. Curry, J. Cassady, J. Summers and C. Stewart; file same with court; communicate with S. Ross regarding certificates of good 02/14/2017 Michael P. Delaney standing. 225 1.4 02/20/2017 Michael P. Delaney Update pleadings file. 225 0.2 Docket new deadlines per order from Judge Koh; revise 02/27/2017 Michael P. Delaney deadlines regarding ADR. 225 0.4 04/06/2017 Michael P. Delaney Docket Apple's answer to amended complaint. 225 0.1 04/28/2017 Michael P. Delaney Docket ADR phone conference deadline. 225 0.1 Revise interrogatory requests; serve same on opposing 05/08/2017 Michael P. Delaney counsel. 225 0.4 05/09/2017 Michael P. Delaney Docket Apple response to RFP deadline. 225 0.1 Review Judge Koh scheduling order and docket deadlines 05/18/2017 Michael P. Delaney accordingly. 225 0.6

08/29/2017 Michael P. Delaney Prepare incoming Apple document production for A. Curry. 225 0.8 Review case communication and docket deadlines for discovery letter brief hearing and deadline for submission of 11/07/2017 Michael P. Delaney proposed order. 225 0.6 Review amended discovery order and docket court deadlines 11/16/2017 Michael P. Delaney for Apple to produce documents. 225 0.7 12/02/2017 Michael P. Delaney Prepare Apple document production for A. Curry. 225 0.5 Draft third party subpoenas to Akamai Technologies for J. 12/10/2017 Michael P. Delaney Summers. 225 1.5 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 97 of 106

Communicate with J. Summers regarding Akamai subpoena 12/12/2017 Michael P. Delaney and revise same in preparation for service. 225 2.1

Communicate with A. Curry regarding Akamai subpoena and 12/13/2017 Michael P. Delaney serve same on opposing counsel; revise notice and subpoena. 225 1 Communicate with vendor regarding Apple document 12/15/2017 Michael P. Delaney productions. 225 0.2 12/19/2017 Michael P. Delaney Review and prepare native excel files for A. Curry. 225 0.5 Prepare Apple native excel files for A. Curry; docket last day 12/28/2017 Michael P. Delaney to serve discovery. 225 0.3 Communicate with A. Curry regarding Apple production; communicate with vendor regarding native files; prepare native Apple production for J. Summers in preparation of 01/02/2018 Michael P. Delaney filing with Court. 225 1.6

Communicate with A. Curry regarding Apple document 01/03/2018 Michael P. Delaney production; communicate with vendor regarding same. 225 0.7

Draft interrogatory requests and deposition notices for J. Summers; prepare Apple production documents in 01/04/2018 Michael P. Delaney preparation for discovery letter brief and send to J. Manning. 225 2 Communicate with A. Curry regarding Apple source code; 01/05/2018 Michael P. Delaney organize and prepare index to same. 225 0.4 01/08/2018 Michael P. Delaney Update production tracking chart. 225 0.3 01/09/2018 Michael P. Delaney Draft source code index. 225 1 01/10/2018 Michael P. Delaney Prepare exhibits to letter brief and distribute to team. 225 0.7 01/12/2018 Michael P. Delaney Review case communication and update case files. 225 0.4

Review case communication and communicate with J. Summers regarding supplemental brief regarding joint 01/22/2018 Michael P. Delaney discovery letter; revise brief and proposed order. 225 0.7 Review case communication and distribute Apple's 01/23/2018 Michael P. Delaney supplemental discovery brief. 225 0.3 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 98 of 106

Review court orders on discovery disputes and docket court 01/25/2018 Michael P. Delaney mandated deadlines; docket Apple 30(b)(6) deposition date. 225 0.4 01/29/2018 Michael P. Delaney Update production tracking chart. 225 0.2 Review case communication and update production tracking 01/31/2018 Michael P. Delaney chart and case files. 225 0.3

Review case communication and distribute court order regarding forensic analysis; docket deadline to file joint report regarding same; prepare Apple document productions and distribute to team; docket Apple response to interrogatories; revise second request for production of 02/01/2018 Michael P. Delaney documents; revise 30(b)(1) notices. 225 3 02/02/2018 Michael P. Delaney Revise discovery requests and 30(b)(1) notices. 225 1.6

Docket deadlines to respond to Apple's requests for admission and interrogatories; revise deposition notices and serve on opposing counsel; review case communication and communicate with vendor regarding document production; 02/05/2018 Michael P. Delaney prepare Apple production for A. Curry 225 3.7

02/06/2018 Michael P. Delaney Docket Apple's deadline to respond request for production. 225 0.1 Review case communication and distribute statement regarding discovery disputes to team; review case communication and docket hearing regarding discovery 02/07/2018 Michael P. Delaney disputes. 225 0.5 Update production tracking chart; review case 02/19/2018 Michael P. Delaney communication and update case files. 225 0.1 Communicate with A. Curry regarding case communication 02/22/2018 Michael P. Delaney and draft summary of case status. 225 0.7

Review case communications and update case files; update production tracking chart with third party and Apple 03/11/2018 Michael P. Delaney production; organize discovery responses for A. Curry. 225 2 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 99 of 106

04/14/2018 Michael P. Delaney Prepare deposition exhibits for D. DeAtley for W. McCarty. 225 2.5 04/14/2018 Michael P. Delaney Docket Apple 30(b)(6) deposition. 225 0.1 Communicate with court reporter regarding Atley and Thirumalai depositions and coordinate same; communicate with team regarding deposition exhibits and prepare same 04/16/2018 Michael P. Delaney for delivery. 225 2

Prepare deposition exhibits for G. Thirumalai for W. McCarty; 04/17/2018 Michael P. Delaney communicate with court reporter regarding same. 225 3

Review case communication and update pleadings and case 06/05/2018 Michael P. Delaney files; docket Wood deposition and Hale errata deadline 225 0.8 06/11/2018 Michael P. Delaney Update pleadings file 225 0.5 06/13/2018 Michael P. Delaney Update pleadings file 225 0.1 06/18/2018 Michael P. Delaney Update case files 225 0.8 Prepare case materials for A.Curry in preparation of 06/19/2018 Michael P. Delaney discovery letter brief hearing 225 1 06/20/2018 Michael P. Delaney Update case files 225 0.5 Prepare deposition exhibits for A. Curry in preparation for J. Wood deposition; communicate with W. McCarty regarding 06/20/2018 Michael P. Delaney same 225 0.7 Communicate with opposing counsel regarding Wood 06/21/2018 Michael P. Delaney deposition. 225 0.1 06/22/2018 Michael P. Delaney Docket Choy deposition date 225 0.1 Review case communication and docket date to Trexler deposition; communicate with W. McCarty regarding Rubin 07/02/2018 Michael P. Delaney deposition. 225 0.3 Review case communication and distribute Rubin rough 07/03/2018 Michael P. Delaney deposition to team; docket Trexler errata. 225 0.3

Communicate with W. McCarty regarding Trexler deposition; communicate with court reporter regarding same; 07/09/2018 Michael P. Delaney communicate with opposing regarding same. 225 0.6 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 100 of 106

Prepare document request for service and serve same on 07/10/2018 Michael P. Delaney opposing counsel. 225 0.3 07/10/2018 Michael P. Delaney Docket response to requests for production. 225 0.1 07/10/2018 Michael P. Delaney Draft third requests for production for W. McCarty. 225 0.5 Communicate with P. Gravely regarding Akamai production; prepare production documents and send to P. Graveley; communicate with S. Jain regarding ecoATM deposition 07/11/2018 Michael P. Delaney transcript. 225 0.6 Review case communication and distribute Rubin deposition 07/12/2018 Michael P. Delaney and exhibits to team. 225 0.2 Communicate with court reporter regarding Hastings deposition and exhibits; communicate with S. Jain regarding 07/13/2018 Michael P. Delaney same; distribute same to team. 225 0.8 Coordinate court reporter for G. Choy deposition; 07/16/2018 Michael P. Delaney communicate with D. Tejtel regarding same. 225 0.3 Communicate with court reporter and D. Tejtel regarding Choy deposition; communicate with opposing counsel 07/18/2018 Michael P. Delaney regarding same. 225 0.2 Communicate with W. McCarty regarding Rubin deposition; prepare witness materials for same; docket Rubin deposition 07/25/2018 Michael P. Delaney date 225 2.6 Communicate with H. Hamad regarding document production; review and organize articles for H. Hamad 07/25/2018 Michael P. Delaney research. 225 4.5 07/28/2018 Michael P. Delaney Prepare Rubin deposition exhibits for W. McCarty 225 1.5

07/28/2018 Michael P. Delaney Communicate with team regarding Akamai production. 225 0.1 Draft A. Rubin notice of deposition and subopoena for W. 07/29/2018 Michael P. Delaney McCarty and serve same on opposing counsel 225 0.8 Revise case communication and distribute Choy deposition to 08/02/2018 Michael P. Delaney team. 225 0.1 Review case communication and docket deadlines for expert 08/07/2018 Michael P. Delaney discovery. 225 1.9 Review Apple websites and prepare videos and presentations 08/07/2018 Michael P. Delaney for H. Hamad. 225 4.1 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 101 of 106

08/08/2018 Michael P. Delaney Draft 30(b)(1) notices for P. Gates and J. Vidrine. 225 0.8 08/09/2018 Michael P. Delaney Docket deadlines to written discovery responses. 225 0.3 Review case communication and update production tracking 08/10/2018 Michael P. Delaney chart. 225 0.2

Communicate with team regarding Akamai production; 08/13/2018 Michael P. Delaney communicate with vendor regarding same. 225 0.3 Review case communication and docket discovery hearing 08/15/2018 Michael P. Delaney and Apple response to letter brief. 225 0.2 08/20/2018 Michael P. Delaney Communicate with W. McCarty regarding source code. 225 0.1

Communicate with J. Cassady and prepare documents for 08/21/2018 Michael P. Delaney discovery hearing; communicate with S. Jain regarding same. 225 1.3 08/21/2018 Michael P. Delaney Prepare source code for M. Jones. 225 1.1 08/23/2018 Michael P. Delaney Prepare documents for M. Jones review. 225 1.7 Communicate with vendor regarding transcription of audio 08/24/2018 Michael P. Delaney file for H. Hamad. 225 0.3 Prepare deposition materials and exhibits to Caldbeck and Vidrine deposition exhibits; communicate with attorneys 09/04/2018 Michael P. Delaney regarding same. 225 2.4 Revise deposition notices of Vidrine and Caldbeck and serve 09/05/2018 Michael P. Delaney on opposing counsel. 225 0.4 Communicate with court reporter regarding Vidrine and 09/05/2018 Michael P. Delaney Caldbeck depositions. 225 0.2 09/06/2018 Michael P. Delaney Prepare expert reports for A. Curry. 225 0.7

Prepare Vidrine deposition materials for attorney review; 09/06/2018 Michael P. Delaney communicate with W. McCarty regarding same. 225 1.2 Prepare documents for production and serve on opposing 09/07/2018 Michael P. Delaney counsel. 225 2.3 09/07/2018 Michael P. Delaney Prepare draft letter brief for D. Pearson review. 225 0.5 09/11/2018 Michael P. Delaney Prepare Apple document production for A. Curry. 225 0.8

09/17/2018 Michael P. Delaney Review case communication and docket deposition dates 225 0.2 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 102 of 106

Review case communication and docket Vidrine errata due 09/17/2018 Michael P. Delaney date; communicate with team regarding same. 225 0.2

09/17/2018 Michael P. Delaney Review case communication and docket deposition dates. 225 0.2 Prepare materials in preparation for Hastings deposition for 09/18/2018 Michael P. Delaney D. Pearson. 225 2 Review case communication and update case and pleading 09/18/2018 Michael P. Delaney files. 225 2.7 Update and organize case and pleadings files for attorney 09/19/2018 Michael P. Delaney review. 225 1.3 Further update and organize case and pleadings files for 09/20/2018 Michael P. Delaney attorney review. 225 0.7 Review and revise deposition notices and subpoenas to Rubin 09/20/2018 Michael P. Delaney and Malhotra. 225 0.7 Communicate with court reporter regarding Malhotra and Rubin deposition; update deposition notice and subpoena for 09/24/2018 Michael P. Delaney Rubin. 225 1.3 Prepare deposition exhibits and notebook for W. McCarty in 09/24/2018 Michael P. Delaney preparation of Avi Rubin deposition. 225 0.8

Communicate with W. McCarty regarding Rubin notice and 09/25/2018 Michael P. Delaney subpoena; revise and serve same on opposing counsel. 225 0.3 Update and organize case and pleadings files for attorney 09/27/2018 Michael P. Delaney review. 225 0.3 Review case communication and update case and pleadings 10/03/2018 Michael P. Delaney files. 225 2 Docket Apple response deadline to motion for 10/03/2018 Michael P. Delaney reconsideration. 225 0.1 Review case communication and update case and discovery 10/08/2018 Michael P. Delaney files. 225 1.3 Review case communication and update case and discovery 10/10/2018 Michael P. Delaney files. 225 0.4 Docket response and reply deadlines to motion for summary 10/10/2018 Michael P. Delaney judgment. 225 0.1 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 103 of 106

Communicate with A. Curry regarding summary judgment response evidence; collect and prepare evidence for attorney 10/16/2018 Michael P. Delaney review. 225 2

10/16/2018 Michael P. Delaney Review court order to determine sealing status of evidence. 225 1 Review case communication and update case and pleading 10/17/2018 Michael P. Delaney files. 225 0.3 Review case communication and docket deadline to file reply 10/17/2018 Michael P. Delaney brief. 225 0.1 Review case communication and update case and pleading 10/19/2018 Michael P. Delaney files. 225 2 10/22/2018 Michael P. Delaney Docket new case mangement hearing date. 225 0.1 Review case communication and update case and pleading 10/22/2018 Michael P. Delaney files. 225 0.3 Review communication from M. Jones regarding errata; 10/24/2018 Michael P. Delaney communicate with A. Curry regarding same. 225 0.2 Communicate with A. Curry regarding summary judgment hearing; prepare briefing and exhibits to summary judgment 10/29/2018 Michael P. Delaney motions for B. Caldwell. 225 3.5 Continue preparation of summary judgment briefing and 10/30/2018 Michael P. Delaney exhibits for B. Caldwell. 225 0.5 10/30/2018 Michael P. Delaney Docket new mediation time. 225 0.1

Prepare motion to dismiss and class certification briefing for 10/30/2018 Michael P. Delaney B. Caldwell in preparation for summary judgment hearing. 225 1

11/12/2018 Michael P. Delaney Review court order and docket case management deadlines. 225 0.4 Communicate with D. Pearson regarding reply brief to 23(f) petition; review local rules regarding same; draft shell of 11/21/2018 Michael P. Delaney reply brief. 225 1.8 Communicate with opposing counsel regarding extracted text 12/19/2018 Michael P. Delaney files. 225 0.2

09/04/2019 Michael P. Delaney Prepare Apple document production for attorney review. 235 0.50 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 104 of 106

Review local and court rules and docket pretrial deadlines; 12/03/2019 Michael P. Delaney communicate with J. Cassady regarding same 235 1.00

Review Judge's standing order regarding pretrial deadlines; 12/04/2019 Michael P. Delaney prepare list of deadlines for J. Cassady; draft trial exhibit list 235 3.00

Update calendar for J. Cassady; docket additional pre‐trial deadlines; review potential exhibits and revise exhibit list; 12/06/2019 Michael P. Delaney communicate with J. Cassady regarding same. 235 2.50 Draft and revise trial exhibit list; communicate with B. DeFeo 12/07/2019 Michael P. Delaney and J. Cassady regarding same. 235 8.00 Revise trial exhibit list; communicate with B. DeFeo regarding 12/08/2019 Michael P. Delaney same 235 5.00 Revise trial exhibit list and witness list; communicate with J. 12/09/2019 Michael P. Delaney Cassady regarding same 235 5.30 Revise exhibit list; prepare documents for exhibit set; communicate with J. Cassady regarding same; communicate 12/10/2019 Michael P. Delaney with co‐counsel regarding exhibit list. 235 4.00 Review and revise trial exhibit list; prepare pre‐trial materials for attorney review; draft exhibits to pretrial order; prepare 12/11/2019 Michael P. Delaney and organize trial exhibits. 235 8.00 Review and revise exhibit list; prepare and organize trial 12/12/2019 Michael P. Delaney exhibits. 235 8.00

Review and revise trial exhibit list; prepare and organize trial exhibits; communicate with co‐counsel regarding pretrial 12/13/2019 Michael P. Delaney materials; assist with preparation of pretrial filings. 235 9.30

Prepare and organize trial exhibits; prepare deposition transcripts for attorney review; communicate with co‐ 12/16/2019 Michael P. Delaney counsel regarding pretrial materials 235 5.10 12/17/2019 Michael P. Delaney Prepare and organize trial exhibits; revise exhibit list 235 3.70 12/18/2019 Michael P. Delaney Prepare and organize trial exhibits 235 2.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 105 of 106

Prepare and organize exhibits; review Koh cases and research 12/19/2019 Michael P. Delaney verdict forms 235 1.80 Review case communication and update same for attorney 01/07/2020 Michael P. Delaney review 295 0.90 Prepare joint list of entities and individuals; communicate 01/09/2020 Michael P. Delaney with team regarding same 295 1.70 01/10/2020 Michael P. Delaney Docket additional bench trial deadlines 295 0.20 01/13/2020 Michael P. Delaney Prepare pleadings for B. Caldwell review. 295 0.10

Communicate with J. Cassady and A. Curry regarding deposition designation deadlines and objections to exhibits; 01/15/2020 Michael P. Delaney review local rules and judge's standing orders regarding same 295 1.70 Prepare document for attorney review in preparation for 01/16/2020 Michael P. Delaney pretrial hearing 295 1.00

Review pretrial order and docket pretrial deadlines; review 01/17/2020 Michael P. Delaney case communications and update same for attorney review. 295 1.80 Review exhibit lists and tag documents on trial exhibit lists; 01/21/2020 Michael P. Delaney prepare calendar of events for J. Cassady 295 1.30

Communicate with A. Curry regarding witness proffer; revise witness proffer; prepare exhibits to same; draft motion for 01/23/2020 Michael P. Delaney leave to extend deadline and propose order 295 3.00

Review court order and docket sealing deadlines; communicate with A. Curry and revise instruction to Apple MIL 3; communicate with co‐counsel regarding same; 01/24/2020 Michael P. Delaney communicate with A. Curry regarding witness proffer. 295 2.00

Revise joint list of entities and individuals; communicate with 01/27/2020 Michael P. Delaney J. Cassady regarding same; prepare Apple trial exhibits 295 3.00

Review court docket for examples of deposition and discovery designations and objections; communicate with J. 01/28/2020 Michael P. Delaney Cassady regarding same; prepare Apple trial exhibits 295 3.00 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-28 Filed 11/24/20 Page 106 of 106

02/03/2020 Michael P Delaney Prepare and organize Apple trial exhibits. 295 2.00 02/04/2020 Michael P Delaney Prepare and organize Apple trial exhibits. 295 1.00 TOTAL: 199.20 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-29 Filed 11/24/20 Page 1 of 2

EXHIBIT 4 Case 5:17-cv-00551-LHK Document 429-29 Filed 11/24/20 Page 2 of 2

In re APPLE FACETIME LITIGATION Expense Report Firm Name: CALDWELL CASSADY CURRY, PC Reporting Period: Inception - Oct. 31, 2020

EXPENSE DESCRIPTION CUMULATIVE TOTAL Copying (vendor) $1,551.09 Court Costs/Filing Fees $2,220.00 Court Reporter/Transcripts $3,210.20 Computer Research $1,264.00 Delivery/Courier $1,161.43 Printing/Binding $1,120.39 Travel: Airfare $2,838.85 Travel: Car rental/taxi/parking $5,733.59 Travel: Lodging $15,368.91 Travel: Meals $3,014.53

Cost Fund Deposit $240,700.00 TOTALS: $278,182.99