DOCSLIB.ORG

Crashing the Archive: a Research-Creation Intervention Into the SAW Video Mediatheque

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text

Load more

Crashing the Archive: A Research-Creation Intervention into the SAW Video Mediatheque Mélanie Hogan A Thesis In the Department of Communication Studies Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements For the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy at Concordia University Montréal, Québec, Canada April 2012 © Mélanie Hogan, 2012 CONCORDIA UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF GRADUATE STUDIES This is to certify that the thesis prepared By: Mélanie Hogan Entitled: Crashing the Archive: A Research-Creation Intervention into the SAW Video Mediatheque and submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY (Communication) complies with the regulations of the University and meets the accepted standards with respect to originality and quality. Signed by the final examining committee: –––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––– Chair Dr. S. Shaw –––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––– External Examiner Dr. C. Fisher –––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––– External to Program Dr. H. Wasson –––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––– Examiner Dr. J. Pidduck –––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––– Examiner Dr. K. Sawchuk –––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––– Thesis Supervisor Dr. M. Soar Approved by –––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––– Dr. W. Buxton, Graduate Program Director April 12, 2012 –––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––– Dr. B. Lewis, Dean, Faculty of Arts and Science ii Abstract Crashing the Archive: A Research-Creation Intervention into the SAW Video Mediatheque Mélanie Hogan, Ph.D. Concordia University, 2012 Video Cache is a research creation intervention emerging from my doctoral research into defunct and crashed online archives, in the context of Canadian video art, which has a rich history of self-preservation and of documenting itself as an art movement. From major art galleries to personal collections; Canada has long privileged video as a tool for creative resistance, expression, and experimentation. Video Cache serves to track the SAW Video Mediatheque (based in Ottawa), from its launch to its crash and back online again, by updating its context and addressing in a practical way what it means to ‘activate’ the online archive. Much of my intervention occurred after the crash and during the two years the site was offline. It involved varied methodological entry points including in depth interviews with SAW Video staff and media archaeology to locate digital traces of the site. Key here is Video Cache’s success in simultaneously documenting the project and intervening to address archival loss: while it was the ‘cache’ that made the Mediatheque’s traces visible and re-visit-able, it was the ‘crash’ that signalled its ongoing archival value. Video Cache was created in collaboration with Penny McCann, Director of SAW Video in Ottawa, Groupe intervention video (GIV) in Montreal, and Nikki Forrest at wayward.ca. iii Acknowledgments This thesis was first and foremost made possible by my collaborators at SAW Video. I am especially indebted to SAW Video Director and Video Cache collaborator, Penny McCann. I also acknowledge the invaluable contributions made by Anatoly Ignatiev, Kevin Morris and Douglas Smalley, as well as the insights of Michael Lechasseur, in collectively remembering and documenting the Mediatheque. Thank you to all the artists who participated in Video Cache and thank you to those who were also able to attend the event. Video Cache was also made possible by Groupe intervention video, who hosted and paid fees for the event. I would like to thank Anne Golden and everyone at GIV for their ongoing support of women in media arts and video. Thank you to Nikki Forrest for embarking on this Wayward project with me, and for driving back and forth to Ottawa to make this happen as smoothly as it did. Thank you to my committee: Dr. Matt Soar, Dr. Kim Sawchuk, Dr. Julianne Pidduck, Dr. Caitlin Fisher and Dr. Haidee Wasson. Special thank you to my supervisor Dr. Soar who provided incredible feedback for this project, and, with Dr. Sawchuk, encouraged me to push the bounds of research-creation. Dr. Soar was crucial not only to the quality of the project, but also for me to be able to recognise the value of why we do what we do. I would also extend my gratitude to the editors of FlowTV for validating my project early on, and to Rachel Somers Miles and Geert Lovink for the support offered at Video Vortex 6 Amsterdam. I also thank Corina MacDonald for the Art Engine interview, which helped put Video Cache on the art map. iv Without the financial support from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council and from the Communication Studies department at Concordia University, this project would have been impossible. Thank you to Graduate Studies for the conference funding throughout the years, and for the Accelerator Award that got me here today. Special thank you to Leslie Shade, Charles Acland, Liz Miller, Matt Soar, and Kim Sawchuk who have pushed me creatively, politically, and intellectually throughout my three consecutive graduate diplomas and degrees in Communication Studies at Concordia University. For keeping me sane and for inspiring me on a daily basis, I thank Andrea Zeffiro, Tamara Shepherd, Jacquie Wallace, M.E. Luka, Kenza Oumlil, Antonia Hernández, and the rest of the PhD gang. Thank you to M.E. Luka, Brian Downey, and Andrea Zeffiro for the eagle-eye copy editing. With the promise of being fun again soon, thank you for putting up with me these past five years: M-C MacPhee, Frédérick Belzile, Gisèle Trudel, Paul Juricic, Jeff Traynor, Sophie Bellissent, Robert Vincent, Dayna McLeod, Sébastien Hogan, Mike Hogan, Anne Boivenue, Andria Hickey, and the rest of you... And to those who it would be impossible to ever thank enough: Suzanne St-Pierre, Nancy Tobin and Minou: Thank you. For the effort and commitment put into this project, I dedicate my thesis to Lucienne St-Pierre and Mavis Wall... avec tout l’admiration du monde. v List of Figures ...................................................................................................................ix Introduction: The Crash and the Cache..........................................................................1 Chapter 1: Literature Review.........................................................................................10 The Archive as Subject.................................................................................................. 13 The Archive as Living....................................................................................................23 The Archive as Database................................................................................................30 The Archive as Volatile..................................................................................................35 The Archive as Dumpster...............................................................................................42 The Archive as Time Machine ...................................................................................... 50 Literature Summary....................................................................................................... 57 Chapter 2: Methodology and Intervention....................................................................60 Surveying Online Traces: Canadian Video Art..............................................................60 Web Archaeology...........................................................................................................64 Digs................................................................................................................................69 Google Cache............................................................................................................ 72 The Internet Archive Wayback Machine (IWM)........................................................ 79 Interviews.......................................................................................................................88 Creation as Research......................................................................................................94 Homaging the Crash via a Database-less Content Management System...............104 Video Cache Screening at Groupe Intervention Video.............................................111 Multi-Modal Documentation: Catalogue, Infographics, Screen Grabs, etc...........112 Chapter 3: SAW Video’s Mediatheque.........................................................................114 vi The Mediatheque Trajectory: An Overview.................................................................114 Early Video Experiments for a Living Archive........................................................... 123 Standards and Guidelines for Canadian Culture Online .............................................130 The Business of Canadian Art: a ‘Mixed Approach’...................................................133 Archival Labour...........................................................................................................139 Technical Requirements: Launching Standards for an Online Archive.......................143 Curatorial Channels .................................................................................................... 153 Three-Year Contracts for a ‘Permanent Archive’ ......................................................160 The Crash.....................................................................................................................166 Activating the Archive: Video Cache ..........................................................................175
Recommended publications
  • Author Index | Title Index | Back Issues Editorial | Next Article Home | E-Mail the Editor

    Author Index | Title Index | Back Issues Editorial | Next Article Home | E-Mail the Editor

    D-Lib Magazine October 2001 Volume 7 Number 10 ISSN 1082-9873 Public Access to Digital Material Brewster Kahle, Internet Archive Rick Prelinger, Prelinger Archives Mary E. Jackson, Association of Research Libraries [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] Introduction The goal of universal access to our cultural heritage is within our grasp. With current digital technology we can build comprehensive collections, and with digital networks we can make these available to students and scholars all over the world. The current challenge is establishing the roles, rights, and responsibilities of our libraries and archives in providing public access to this information. With these roles defined, our institutions will help fulfill this epic opportunity of our digital age. For the second time in history, people are laying plans to collect all information -- the first time involved the Greeks and culminated in the Library of Alexandria, which is attributed with being the centerpiece of the world's first university, illuminating human nature in a way never possible before. Now reports on how much total information there is [Lesk and Lyman] are leading many once again to take steps in building libraries that hold complete collections. The move to digital technologies for storage, access, and coordination of distributed efforts makes this possible. While digital libraries are springing up in every corner, a recent experience may serve as an example of both advances and hurdles involved in building complete collections. Over the last five years, the Internet Archive has built some of the largest text and moving images collections in existence by developing cost-effective mechanisms of collection, cataloging, and preservation.
  • Propuesta De Digitalización De Soportes Cinematográficos Subestándar Para Su Aplicación En Un Entorno De Archivo No Dedicado

    Propuesta De Digitalización De Soportes Cinematográficos Subestándar Para Su Aplicación En Un Entorno De Archivo No Dedicado

    -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Propuesta de digitalización de soportes cinematográficos subestándar para su aplicación en un entorno de archivo no dedicado. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Sabrina Menéndez Máster gestión de contenidos digitales Universidad de Barcelona Tutor: Miquel Térmens Barcelona, junio 2012 Resumen ejecutivo Se propone un modelo para el desarrollo de un plan de digitalización de filmaciones cinematográficas domésticas o familiares enfocado a facilitar su difusión vía web que, por su amplitud y objetivos, está indicado para el tratamiento de colecciones pequeñas y medianas custodiadas en entornos de archivo no especializado en el ámbito audiovisual, pero lo suficientemente abierto para permitir su aplicación en todo tipo de instituciones. La propuesta parte de un acercamiento teórico a los soportes implicados en el proceso: película cinematográfica subestándar, es decir, el formato original en el que se presen- tan las colecciones de cine doméstico y familiar, caracterizado por el uso de películas de ancho inferior al estándar cinematográfico de 35mm, y vídeo digital, formato final de los contenidos generados tras un proyecto de digitalización. Además, se realiza un aná- lisis de diferentes proyectos de digitalización llevados a cabo por todo tipo de organiza- ciones, tanto a nivel nacional como internacional, con especial atención a las iniciativas relacionadas con el
  • Memorabilia. Collecting Sounds With…

    Memorabilia. Collecting Sounds With…

    Research > MEMORABILIA. COLLECTING MEMORABILIA. COLLECTING SOUNDS WITH… Memorabilia. Collecting Sounds with... is a new series from SOUNDS WITH… Ràdio Web MACBA that seeks to break through to unearth and reveal private collections of music and sound memorabilia . The Rick Prelinger documentary series is being presented this spring at the Museu d'Art Contemporani de Barcelona (MACBA) in a prospective conference/listening format, where four collectors have been 01. Conversation with Rick Prelinger on his film collection invited to share the concerns and particular characteristics that have driven them to build their personal collections. This is a When and why did you become interested in ephemeral films? Did you collect anything historiography of sound collecting that reveals the unseen and else before? What drew your attention to that kind of material? passionate work of the amateur collector while reconstructing multiple parallel histories such as the evolution of recording I've always collected things, but I think understanding the systems that underlie formats, archival issues, the sound collecting market and the collections and learning what the arrangement of things can reveal were more evolution of musical styles beyond the marketplace. interesting to me than the things themselves, at least in the beginning. I collected everything kids collect and more – rocks, shells, road maps, 45 rpm This is a conversation by email between Rick Prelinger, Anna records, and the weekly radio surveys listing the top 40 or 60 songs. Later, I Ramos, Vicki Bennett and Jon Leidecker, which took place on collected found photographs from the trash outside photo labs. Most of these April 2011.
  • Michael Loebenstein)

    Michael Loebenstein)

    FIAF Day 1 Session 1 Opening remarks symposium (Michael Loebenstein) Thank you for attending this year’s FIAF symposium. The benefit of having the broad topic of ‘rights’ as a symposium topic is that it allows for both repetition – discussion of key common concerns and issues – as well as for the discussion of new ideas, for envisioning an exciting future of archives thriving and succeeding in their core work. Fairly Legal – and the title is a toned-down version of the original proposal to call it “Barely Legal” which our lawyer thought was a bit too provocative! -- will hopefully serve both purposes: describe intellectual property and moral issues, impasses, obstacles film archives face while collecting. preserving and sharing their holdings; and offer ideas on how to navigate this difficult and at times obscure and even threatening terrain. We’ll shortly hear more from a broad range of speakers, from FIAF archives as well as fellow archivists and curators from outside our federation but let me take the opportunity at the beginning of this session to outline a couple of thoughts about the ‘politics and ethics’ of our dealings with collection material in the year 2015. It is also a bit of a personal journey for me through the last decade of my life in FIAF. In 2005 as a young curator from Vienna with as background in digital media and film history I attended the FIAF congress in Ljubljana, Slovenia, where controversy erupted around Alex Horwath’s ‘intervention’ titled “The Market vs The Museum”. It was a passionate and personal statement about the struggle (or the impossible feat) to reconcile the ethics of the film museum and its appreciation of the originality of the film experience with the commodification that is at the core of what we now call the “digital economy”.
  • Markland Technologies

    Markland Technologies

    Markland Technologies http://www.marklandtech.com/index.html Go MAR APR JUN 34 captures 1 1 Apr 03 - 9 Oct 08 2002 2003 2004 About Us: The United States has been thrust into a new era where protecting our way of life here at home is priority one. Markland Technologies is committed to the delivery of integrated security solutions to meet these new era challenges. Our innovative emerging technologies and expert services are focused solely to provide our customers with the tools necessary to protect personnel, data and infrastructure assets. Delmar R. Kintner, CEO and Director, has over 35 years of experience in the areas of technical marketing and emerging technology development project management with United States government customers in the Department of Defense and various other government agencies and departments. He has BS/MS degrees in Electrical Engineering and has been involved in numerous successful startup companies. Ken Ducey, CFO/President, has led over a dozen small companies to substantial revenue growth. He has headed the commercialization of a number of technologies ranging from computer software to medical devices, and has extensive experience working with a variety of financial institutions.Robert Tarini, Director, has over 20 years of experience in the areas of acoustic remote sensing and product development with scientific customers within the United States government and Pacific Rim countries. He has a BS degree in Electrical Engineering and has been involved in numerous successful past and ongoing United States government
  • Interview with Rick Prelinger

    Interview with Rick Prelinger

    Interview with Rick Prelinger By Sophie Cook, Beatriz Bartolomé Herrera and Papagena Robbins Rick Prelinger wears many hats: he is an archivist and an activist, a writer and a filmmaker; he has preserved the eccentricities and banalities of American cultural heritage and projected them back to the world via both Open Access digital repositories and carefully curated programs of ephemeral and orphaned films. He is perhaps best known as the founder of the Prelinger Archives, a collection of about 60,000 industrial, advertising, educational, and amateur films, which encourage and facilitate not only preservation, but appropriation by allowing free access, downloading and reuse of its materials. Prelinger founded the archive in 1982 in New York, and the original collection was acquired by the Library of Congress in 2002. As a board member of the Internet Archive, he has made over 6,000 of these films available for free online. He also co- founded an appropriation-friendly workshop, the Prelinger Library, with Megan Shaw Prelinger, in San Francisco in 2004. The library houses an unusual collection of 19th and 20th century American vintage ephemera, periodicals, maps, and books; and—along with the Prelinger Archives—it has become an important research and reference center for those interested in vernacular American history. His passion as a collector has led to the production of several archival compilation films, including 2004’s Panorama Ephemera and 2013’s No More Road Trips?, as well as several multi-part film programs—Lost Landscapes of San Francisco (2006-2015), Lost Landscapes of Detroit (2010-2012), Yesterday and Tomorrow in Detroit (2014 and 2015), Lost Landscapes of Oakland (2014), and the forthcoming, Lost Landscapes of Los Angeles (2015).
  • Preserving Interactives

    Preserving Interactives

    Preserving Interactives White Paper May 2018 Author Erwin Verbruggen Sound and Vision Published with support from the Dutch Media Innovators programme. Cite as: Verbruggen, Erwin, Preserving Interactives (Hilversum, NL: Netherlands Institute for Sound and Vision, 2018). Words of thanks: To the panel / workshop participants & organizers: Marcel Privé (Archiefweb), Dan Tucker (Sheffield Doc/Fest), Hugues Sweeney, Loc Dao & Janine Steele (National Film Board of Canada), William Uricchio, Katerina Cizek, Sandra Rodriguez & Sarah Wolozin (MIT Open Documentary Lab), Myriam Achard (Phi Centre), Caspar Sonnen, Lieven Heeremans, Mikey Zbieranowski (IDFA DocLab), Jason Brush, Jesse de Vos (Sound and Vision), Patricia Aufderheide (American University), Rick Prelinger (Prelinger Archives), Nancy McGovern (MIT Libraries), Jason Scott (Internet Archive), Annet Dekker (UvA), Ingrid Kopp (Immerse), Mandy Rose (UWE Bristol), Jessica Brillhart, Alexandre Brachet & Margaux Missika (Upian), Marianne Lévy-Leblond, Gilles Freissinier & Stéphane Nauroy (ARTE France), Dragan Espenschied (Rhizome), Bruno Felix & Remco Vlaanderen (Submarine Channel), Klaus Rechert (Freiburg University), Brett Gaylor (Mozilla Foundation), Roel Wouters (Studio Moniker), Cal Lee (Chapel Hill University), David Desrimais (Jean Boîte Editions), John MacFarlane (POV) and Tatiana Villacob. To the reviewers & contributors: Caspar Sonnen & Mikey Zbieranowski (IDFA DocLab), Jesse de Vos, Rasa Bočytė, Johan Oomen (Sound and Vision), Thomas Drugeon (Ina), Maureen Pennock (British Library),
  • Reading-The Internet Archive-PDF

    Reading-The Internet Archive-PDF

    A Summary on the Internet Archive By Akshat Kukreti Introduction • The Internet Archive (IA) contains a collection of historical websites of the world. • Users can access the archived websites through the Wayback Machine. • http://www.archive.org • Founded by Brewster Kahle and Bruce Gilliat in 1996. Motivation behind IA • Preservation of Digital Information • The average of a document on the internet is 75 days [Kahle 96], after that it is lost. “404 Document not found” • Digital information is easier to store and search in. • How authentic is a document found on the internet? • Where to go from the current document? • A Digital Library What is currently archived • Texts • Audios • Videos • Software Founders and Contributors • People – Brewster Kahle – Bruce Gilliat – Rick Prelinger • Institutions – Alexa Internet • Gathers and analyses data on web content and web usage • Uses it’s crawler to gather data on web content • Uses Alexa Toolbar for gathering data on web usage • Donates copies of web crawls to IA Technology • Capture Technology – The IA has developed tools for capturing web content – Crawler requirements: • Obeys the instructions given in a site’s robots.txt • Can run on multiple machines • Aggregates the crawl data into large files for easier management – Heritrix : A Java-based open source Web Crawler Technology • How the crawler works – Finds documents (files) based on seed URLs and downloads them to the Archive’s server – Looks for reference links and adds them to the list of files to be captured. – Relative paths are made absolute before being added to the list – The process is repeated for reference links – The crawler makes sure that the same page is not retrieved again.
  • UCSC Biobibliography - Rick Prelinger 4/20/19, 23�32

    UCSC Biobibliography - Rick Prelinger 4/20/19, 2332

    UCSC Biobibliography - Rick Prelinger 4/20/19, 2332 Curriculum Vitae April 20, 2019 (last update 2018-01-03) Rick Prelinger Professor Porter College RESEARCH INTERESTS Critical archival studies; personal and institutional recordkeeping; access to the cultural and historical record; media and social change; appropriation, remix and reuse; useful cinema (advertising, educational, industrial and sponsored film); amateur and home movies; participatory documentary; digital scholarship; cinema and public history; cinema and cultural geography; urban history and film; history of wireless communication; media archaeology TEACHING INTERESTS Useful cinema and ephemeral media; amateur and home movies; found footage; history of television; personal media; critical archival studies; access to cultural record EMPLOYMENT HISTORY Jul 1 2017 - Present Professor, Department of Film & Digital Media, UC Santa Cruz Jul 1999 - Present Director of Moving Images, Consultant, Advisor, and other positions (intermittent between 1999-2016). Currently pro bono consultant and member of the Board of Directors, Internet Archive, San Francisco, California. 1984 - Present Founder and President, Prelinger Associates, Inc. (succeeded by Prelinger Archives LLC) Fall 2013 - Spring 2017 Acting Associate Professor, Department of Film & Digital Media, UC Santa Cruz Oct 3 2005 - Dec 2006 Head, Open Content Alliance, a group of nonprofit organizations, university libraries, archives, publishers, corporations and foundations dedicated to digitizing books and other cultural resources in an open-access environment. OCA was headquartered at Internet Archive and supported by Yahoo, Microsoft Corporation and the Alfred P. Sloan Foundation. Fall 1998 - Winter 1999 Instructor, MFA Design Program, School of Visual Arts, New York, N.Y. Sep 1989 - Aug 1995 Director of Archival Development, Home Box Office (1990-95) and The Comedy Channel (1989-90), New York, N.Y.
  • Archives Archives

    Archives Archives

    Lison, Mars, Medak, Prelinger Archives ARCHIVES LISON MARS MEDAK PRELINGER Archives IN SEARCH OF MEDIA Götz Bachmann, Timon Beyes, Mercedes Bunz, and Wendy Hui Kyong Chun, Series Editors Pattern Discrimination Markets Communication Machine Remain Archives Archives Andrew Lison, Marcell Mars, Tomislav Medak, and Rick Prelinger IN SEARCH OF MEDIA University of Minnesota Press Minneapolis London meson press In Search of Media is a joint collaboration between meson press and the University of Minnesota Press. Bibliographical Information of the German National Library The German National Library lists this publication in the Deutsche Nationalbibliografie (German National Bibliography); detailed bibliographic information is available online at portal.d-nb.de. Published in 2019 by meson press (Lüneburg, Germany ) in collaboration with the University of Minnesota Press (Minneapolis, USA). Design concept: Torsten Köchlin, Silke Krieg Cover image: Sascha Pohflepp ISBN (PDF): 978-3-95796-150-1 DOI: 10.14619/1501 The digital edition of this publication can be downloaded freely at: meson.press. The print edition is available from University of Minnesota Press at: www.upress.umn.edu. This Publication is licensed under CC-BY-NC-4.0 International. To view a copy of this license, visit: creativecommons.org/ licenses/by-nc/4.0/ Contents Series Foreword vii Introduction: Contesting “The Archive,” Archives, and Thanatarchy ix Andrew Lison [ 1 ] Archives of Inconvenience 1 Rick Prelinger [ 2 ] System of a Takedown: Control and De-commodification in the Circuits of Academic Publishing 47 Marcell Mars and Tomislav Medak Authors 69 Series Foreword “Media determine our situation,” Friedrich Kittler infamously wrote in his Introduction to Gramophone, Film, Typewriter.
  • The Open Book: Digital Form in the Making

    The Open Book: Digital Form in the Making

    The Open Book: Digital Form in the Making By Mary E. Murrell A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the Requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy In Anthropology In the Graduate Division Of the University of California, Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor Paul Rabinow, Chair Professor Charles K. Hirschkind Professor Corinne P. Hayden Professor Mary C. Gallagher Professor Ramona Naddaff Fall 2012 The Open Book: Digital Form in the Making © 2012 by Mary E. Murrell Abstract The Open Book by Mary E. Murrell Doctor of Philosophy in Anthropology University of California, Berkeley Professor Paul Rabinow, Chair This dissertation attempts to put anthropology in conversation with “the book.” It does so through an empirical specification of mass book digitization, the industrial- scale, retrospective conversion of books into digital form. Such mass digitization is the work of research libraries, Internet companies, non-profit organizations, national governments, and the computer scientists, digital librarians, and the lawyers and administrators who advise, encourage, and support them. The dissertation approaches mass digitization as a venue for plumbing the turbulent waters of what I consider the “contemporary book”: an arena of experimentation arising from the productive, seismic encounter of the modern book apparatus with an emergent assemblage in motion around the production, authorization, storage, preservation, circulation, and production of knowledge. By the “contemporary book,” I refer to the modern book apparatus (dispositif) as it is being worked upon, reconfigured, and called into question in the early twenty-first century. The activities of the digitizers I studied are based upon a shared conviction that the book and its institutions are “closed” and need to be “opened”: books are “inaccessible” or “locked up” by virtue of their materiality (their printedness); by the institutions that store and keep them (physical libraries); and by the state’s often misguided regulation (copyright).