Human Rights in Estonia

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Human Rights in Estonia HUMAN RIGHTS IN ESTONIA TOGETHER WE ARE STRONGER! Sihtasutus Eesti Inimõiguste Keskus [email protected] anneta.humanrights.eewww.inimoigused.ee HUMAN RIGHTS 2014 IN ESTONIA 2015 Annual Report of the Estonian Human Rights Centre Foundation Estonian Human Rights Centre [email protected] www.humanrights.ee 2015 2014 Annual Report of the Estonian Human Rights Centre HUMAN RIGHTS IN ESTONIA 2014-2015 Annual Report of the Estonian Human Rights Centre HUMAN RIGHTS IN ESTONIA 2014-2015 HUMAN RIGHTS IN ESTONIA 2014-2015 Annual Report of the Estonian Human Rights Centre Edited by: Egert Rünne, Kari Käsper Translated by: Grete Anton Published by: Estonian Human Rights Centre. Copyright: Authors, Estonian Human Rights Centre, 2015 Designed by: Mihkel Ronk, koosolek.ee Authors of photos (creative commons license, flickr.com): erix!, mknobil, sandman, daily sunny, M.Markus, Magic Madzik, dandeluca, Elsie esq., russelljsmith, takomabibelot, Yortw, dicktay2000, PinkMoose ISSN 2228-1045 ISSN 2228-1053 Compiling and publishing of the report supported by The Integration and Migration Foundation Our People (MISA), Estonian Ministry of Culture and Embassy of the Kingdom of the Netherlands in Estonia. Views expressed in the report may not represent those of the The Integration and Migration Foundation Our People (MISA), Estonian Ministry of Culture and Embassy of the Kingdom of the Netherlands in Estonia. 2 HUMAN RIGHTS IN ESTONIA Prohibition of torture, inhuman or degrading 2014-2015 treatment and punishment 7 Contents Foreword ...................................................................................................................4 Ahto Lobjakas Prohibition of torture, inhuman or degrading treatment and punishment ....7 Epp Lumiste Prohibition of slavery and forced labour ............................................................17 Merle Albrant Right to a fair trial .................................................................................................27 Kari Käsper Right to respect for family and private life .........................................................35 Ann Väljataga Freedom of expression ..........................................................................................47 Dr. Katrin Nyman-Metcalf Freedom of assembly and association.................................................................57 Alari Rammo Prohibition of discrimination ..............................................................................67 Kelly Grossthal Right to education .................................................................................................79 Aivi Remmelg Right to free elections ...........................................................................................93 Egert Rünne National minorities and integration policy in Estonia ...................................103 Kristjan Kaldur The situation of LGBT persons in Estonia .......................................................115 Helen Talalaev Rights of refugees and asylum seekers ..............................................................125 Anni Säär Rights of the Child ..............................................................................................135 Helika Saar Situation of persons with disabilities ................................................................149 Tiiu Hermat 3 DearForeword reader! HUMAN RIGHTS IN ESTONIA treatment and punishment 7 2014-2015 Dear reader! uman rights in Estonia face pressure from two sides. On one hand it is set to have a correlation with the founding principles defined H by the community, the need to secure a living space for Estonian nationality, language and culture. These values cannot be clearly defined: there is a noticeable tendency, which cropped up in the course of the refugee crisis, an attempt to define what is Estonian through skin colour and other hereditary attributes, and not through language or something else an indi- vidual can learn – and is thus attainable for everyone. On the other hand the theme of living space is manifested on the level of existence of the state. “Only a certain disposition can make sure the state of Estonia will last through ages,” says this approach, placing all other considerations under the seal of right of communal existence. The first communal impulse has a parasitical existence on a level, which is democratic in essence. In Estonia, as has been referred, the egalitarian nature of democracy has been bent to serve the interests of a more narrowly defined (ethnic) group. It is unavoidably and apparently clear that groups and indi- viduals who do not share the same imperative, will find themselves, through the mediation of a seemingly democratic decision-making mechanism, in an unequal situation. In reality they have fewer rights, and additionally, their rights in the future will be qualified by the constitutionally in-coded require- ment to make sure the dominant ethnic community never loses the majority status on the territory of their state. Another pressure factor is similarly parasitical on the international law, fill- ing the right of self-determination narrowly with ethnic content. The prob- lem works both ways: besides instrumentalisation of democracy and nation- ality, or making them a tool for a narrow interest, practicing these both in a diminished way unavoidably distorts, if not disfigures, their content for the Estonian public. The threshold of values is lowered. 4 HUMAN RIGHTS IN ESTONIA DearForeword reader! 2014-2015 treatment and punishment 7 Human rights, in essence, belong to the sphere of the state based on rule of law. Along with democracy and international law the state based on rule of law is one of three foundations for the modern value-based world order. Historically, it is primary, as international law is hard to imagine in a world without democracy, and democracy, in turn, is hard to imagine without the foundation of equal rights of people. In practice, this forms a certain her- metically sealed circle: all three principles require the other two in one way or another. Human rights are the platform for ideal values, which can be deduced from practical functioning of the Western world order – its legal practice, conventions, constitutions, etc. Human rights are the historic fruit of this developing practice. The similarity of human rights to Kantian universal rights (applicable for all conceivable people at all times) is not coincidental – but nor is it causal. Immanuel Kant and his successors have derived their sys- tems from Western practices, and then universalised them. It is important to understand that this origin of universality is built into the definition of a state based on rule of law also when it in practice does not exceed the boundaries of one society. Every person on the territory of a state based on rule of law has fundamental rights guaranteed by law even when the political, economic and social rights of the state’s subject vary. These same fundamental rights also exist for repre- sentatives of state powers acting outside of their territory. In practice, this of course means tension between national interests and things like it, but already for a long time the Western states do not allow their representatives of state powers to kill the natives, etc. The challenge for Estonia is to acknowledge and detangle for ourselves the conflict contained in our constitution, which increasingly seems to blur the official policy on human rights. If the preamble of the constitution places the duty on the state, with its democracy and legal institutions, to serve a nation or a privileged community, then the founding values of the constitu- tion, as they have been understood by the Supreme Court, clearly dictate the need to respect democracy, state based on rule of law and international law as clear principles. The solution, in any time perspective, can only be to secure 5 DearForeword reader! HUMAN RIGHTS IN ESTONIA treatment and punishment 7 2014-2015 complete autonomy of human rights / state based on rule of law within theory and practice of the state’s activity, and keep it independent from communal imperatives, no matter how democratic or serving the norms of international law they are presented as. Most of the weak points that this annual report points to, but not all, are understandable in the context of this tension and struggle. The rights of national minorities, right to fair trial, sufficient access to legal counselling, depoliticization of top officials, exclusion of any kind of discrimination, pre- ventative empathy of officials in regards to minority problems (whether based on gender, sexuality or culture), political (state based on rule of law and dem- ocratic) control over security institutions, codifying the limits of tolerance for criminalization of xenophobia – all this to (today so topical) humane treat- ment of refugees and asylum seekers and guaranteeing them adequate legal help is a part of this set of problems. A state based on rule of law, if it actually works, can only be a mirage on the untouched horizon of power guaranteed by rights of individuals. For the state of Estonia – which, on top of it all, has been the member of the United Nations Human Rights Council for three years – human rights at peace time cannot under any excuse be a topic which has to be analysed or can be analysed from the point of view of security policy, preservation of Estonian language or culture, the nation state’s future, or anything similar. Ahto Lobjakas 6 HUMAN RIGHTS IN ESTONIA Prohibition of
Recommended publications
  • Country Background Report Estonia
    OECD Review of Policies to Improve the Effectiveness of Resource Use in Schools Country Background Report Estonia This report was prepared by the Ministry of Education and Research of the Republic of Estonia, as an input to the OECD Review of Policies to Improve the Effectiveness of Resource Use in Schools (School Resources Review). The participation of the Republic of Estonia in the project was organised with the support of the European Commission (EC) in the context of the partnership established between the OECD and the EC. The partnership partly covered participation costs of countries which are part of the European Union’s Erasmus+ programme. The document was prepared in response to guidelines the OECD provided to all countries. The opinions expressed are not those of the OECD or its Member countries. Further information about the OECD Review is available at www.oecd.org/edu/school/schoolresourcesreview.htm Ministry of Education and Research, 2015 Table of Content Table of Content ....................................................................................................................................................2 List of acronyms ....................................................................................................................................................7 Executive summary ...............................................................................................................................................9 Introduction .........................................................................................................................................................10
    [Show full text]
  • Pealkirjaregister • 2005 — Index of Titels • 2005
    PEALKIRJAREGISTER • 2005 — INDEX OF TITELS • 2005 PEALKIRJAREGISTER 1000 looma 2881 1001 looduslikku vahendit 2166 1001 natural remedies 2166 1003 great things about moms 496 1 1003 olulist tõsiasja emade kohta 496 101 teost Eesti Kunstimuuseumi kogudest 10 aastat ajalugu 3661 2972 10 aastat Sideametit 3657 101 works from the collection of the Art 10 Estonian novelists [Võrguteavik] 2271 Museum of Estonia 2972 10 Estonian poets [Võrguteavik] 2272 112 - kaitse end ja aita teist [Võrguteavik] 10 IEEE European Test Symposium 1379 3329 122 kasutatud autot 199 10 mõtet ajast 38 125 aastat Järvakandi klaasitööstust 10-aastane Keila SOS Hermann Gmei- 2602 neri Kool 3667 130 aastat hariduse andmist Tori koolis 10-minute clutter control 1632 2474 10-minute crystal ball 861 1300 math formulas [Võrguteavik] 2129 10-minute feng shui 1631 13th European Conference on Reading 10. aastapäeva konverentsi “Eestlase “Reading-writing-thinking” 5 religioossus - minevik, tänapäev, 13th scientific conference 2443 tulevik” ettekannete teeside kogumik 15 aastat ettevõtjate teenistuses 691 4481 15 aastat kutseharidust Taeblas 1329 100 aastat rahvuslikku lasteaeda Eestis 2092 15 years of enterprise advocacy 691 100 bright ideas for bathrooms 2975 151 võimalust olla lahe ema 4108 100 bright ideas for kitchens 2974 151 ways to become super mum 4108 100 fantastic things to do 3793 15th European-Japanese conference on 100 küsimust lastearstile 1384 information modelling and knowledge 100 kysymystä lastenlääkärille 1384 bases 3161 100 lemmikretsepti 4202 1905. aasta
    [Show full text]
  • Core Document Forming Part of the Reports of States
    CORE DOCUMENT FORMING PART OF THE REPORTS OF STATES PARTIES ESTONIA 2015 The purpose of this core document is to assist the treaty bodies in understanding the situation in Estonia. The document is presented to replace the previous core document, which was submitted in 2001. It contains information of both general and factual nature relating to the implementation of the treaties to which Estonia is party. Where possible, links to official texts of laws published in the Riigi Teataja (Estonian State Gazette) in English are included. 1 Table of Contents I. GENERAL INFORMATION ABOUT ESTONIA ......................................................................... 5 A. Geographical indicators ............................................................................................................... 5 B. Historical background ................................................................................................................. 5 C. Demographic, economic, social and cultural characteristics ....................................................... 7 1. Population ................................................................................................................................ 7 2. Education ................................................................................................................................. 9 3. E-governance ......................................................................................................................... 10 4. Digital society .......................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Estonia Statelessness
    Ending Childhood A Study on Estonia Statelessness: Working Paper 04/15 EUROPEAN NETWORK ON STATELESSNESS © European Network on Statelessness. All Rights Reserved. This paper and sections thereof may be distributed and reproduced without formal permission for the purposes of non-commercial research, private study, news reporting and training, provided that the material is appropriately attributed to the authors and the copyright-holder. This working paper was commissioned by the European Network on Statelessness (ENS) a civil society alliance with 100 members in over 30 countries, committed to addressing statelessness in Europe. Among other objectives, ENS advocates for the enjoyment of a right to a nationality by all. This working paper is part of a series that has been produced in support of the ENS Campaign “None of Europe’s children should be stateless” which was launched in November 2014. ENS wishes to acknowledge the generous support for this campaign received from the Sigrid Rausing Trust and the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR). This paper was researched and written by Aleksei Semjonov, Director; Jelena Karzetskaja, Lawyer; and Elena Ezhova, Lawyer – Legal Information Centre for Human Rights (an ENS Associate Member). European Network on Statelessness Club Union House, 253-254 Upper Street London, N1 1RY United Kingdom Charity Number 1158414 [email protected] www.statelessness.eu For further information about ENS, its activities or proposals for research or other collaboration, contact ENS Director Chris Nash at [email protected]. The Institute on Statelessness and Inclusion is an Expert Partner for the ENS Campaign ‘None of Europe’s Children should be stateless.
    [Show full text]
  • National Report on Drug Situation in Estonia 2001
    Institute of Experimental and Clinical Medicine Estonian Drug Monitoring Centre Estonian National Focal Point National Report on Drug Situation in Estonia 2001 Prepared by Estonian Drug Monitoring Centre National Focal Point Tallinn 2002 Estonian National Focal Point National Report on Drug Situation in Estonia 2001 Katri Abel (EDMC, National Focal Point) Andri Ahven (Ministry of Internal Affairs) Gleb Denissov (Statistical Office of Estonia) Niina Derman (Institute of International and Social Studies) Leeni Hansson (Institute of International and Social Studies) Nelli Kalikova (AIDS Prevention Centre) Marju Kiipus (Estonian Health Education Centre) Marianne Paimre (Estonian Foundation for Prevention of Drug Addiction) Ave Talu (EDMC, National Focal Point) Institute of Experimental and Clinical Medicine Estonian Drug Monitoring Centre National Focal Point Hiiu 42, Tallinn 11619, ESTONIA Tel +372 670 7099 Fax -+ 6706814 E- mail: [email protected] E- mail: [email protected] 2 SUMMARY _____________________________________________________________________________________________ SUMMARY The National Report on the Drug Situation in Estonia has been drafted by the Estonian Drug Monitoring Centre for the submission to the Ministry of Social Affairs of Estonia and the European Monitoring Centre for Drugs and Drug Addiction (EMCDDA). The First Estonian National Report gives an overall picture of the drug phenomenon in Estonia until 2001. This Report provides an overview of the political and legal framework, epidemiological situation, drug demand and supply and harms associated with drugs in Estonia until 2001. The data presented in the Report are key information to be used by the Ministry of Social Affairs of Estonia and the European Monitoring Centre for Drugs and Drug Addiction. Every year EMCDDA outlines specific key issues National Reports have to focus on, in 2001 such key issues are treatment modality and drug related-infectious diseases.
    [Show full text]
  • Russia's Hostile Measures in Europe
    Russia’s Hostile Measures in Europe Understanding the Threat Raphael S. Cohen, Andrew Radin C O R P O R A T I O N For more information on this publication, visit www.rand.org/t/RR1793 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data is available for this publication. ISBN: 978-1-9774-0077-2 Published by the RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, Calif. © Copyright 2019 RAND Corporation R® is a registered trademark. Limited Print and Electronic Distribution Rights This document and trademark(s) contained herein are protected by law. This representation of RAND intellectual property is provided for noncommercial use only. Unauthorized posting of this publication online is prohibited. Permission is given to duplicate this document for personal use only, as long as it is unaltered and complete. Permission is required from RAND to reproduce, or reuse in another form, any of its research documents for commercial use. For information on reprint and linking permissions, please visit www.rand.org/pubs/permissions. The RAND Corporation is a research organization that develops solutions to public policy challenges to help make communities throughout the world safer and more secure, healthier and more prosperous. RAND is nonprofit, nonpartisan, and committed to the public interest. RAND’s publications do not necessarily reflect the opinions of its research clients and sponsors. Support RAND Make a tax-deductible charitable contribution at www.rand.org/giving/contribute www.rand.org Preface This report is the collaborative and equal effort of the coauthors, who are listed in alphabetical order. The report documents research and analysis conducted through 2017 as part of a project entitled Russia, European Security, and “Measures Short of War,” sponsored by the Office of the Deputy Chief of Staff, G-3/5/7, U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • London School of Economics and Political Science Department of Government
    London School of Economics and Political Science Department of Government Historical Culture, Conflicting Memories and Identities in post-Soviet Estonia Meike Wulf Thesis submitted for the degree of PhD at the University of London London 2005 UMI Number: U213073 All rights reserved INFORMATION TO ALL USERS The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. Dissertation Publishing UMI U213073 Published by ProQuest LLC 2014. Copyright in the Dissertation held by the Author. Microform Edition © ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved. This work is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code. ProQuest LLC 789 East Eisenhower Parkway P.O. Box 1346 Ann Arbor, Ml 48106-1346 Ih c s e s . r. 3 5 o ^ . Library British Library of Political and Economic Science Abstract This study investigates the interplay of collective memories and national identity in Estonia, and uses life story interviews with members of the intellectual elite as the primary source. I view collective memory not as a monolithic homogenous unit, but as subdivided into various group memories that can be conflicting. The conflict line between ‘Estonian victims’ and ‘Russian perpetrators* figures prominently in the historical culture of post-Soviet Estonia. However, by setting an ethnic Estonian memory against a ‘Soviet Russian’ memory, the official historical narrative fails to account for the complexity of the various counter-histories and newly emerging identities activated in times of socio-political ‘transition’.
    [Show full text]
  • Longing to Return and Spaces of Belonging
    TURUN YLIOPISTON JULKAISUJA ANNALES UNIVERSITATIS TURKUENSIS SERIAL B, HUMANIORA, 374 LONGING TO RETURN AND SPACES OF BELONGING. IRAQIS’ NARRATIVES IN HELSINKI AND ROME By Vanja La Vecchia-Mikkola TURUN YLIOPISTO UNIVERSITY OF TURKU Turku 2013 Department of Social Research/Sociology Faculty of Social Sciences University of Turku Turku, Finland Supervised by: Suvi Keskinen Östen Wahlbeck University of Helsinki University of Helsinki Helsinki, Finland Helsinki, Finland Reviewed by: Marja Tiilikainen Marko Juntunen University of Helsinki University of Tampere Helsinki, Finland Helsinki, Finland Opponent: Professor Minoo Alinia Uppsala University Uppsala, Sweden ISBN 978-951-29-5594-7 (PDF) ISSN 0082-6987 Acknowledgments First of all, I wish to express my initial appreciation to all the people from Iraq who contributed to this study. I will always remember the time spent with them as enriching and enjoyable experience, not only as a researcher but also as a human being. I am extremely grateful to my two PhD supervisors: Östen Wahlbeck and Suvi Keskinen, who have invested time and efforts in reading and providing feedback to the thesis. Östen, you have been an important mentor for me during these years. Thanks for your support and your patience. Your critical suggestions and valuable insights have been fundamental for this study. Suvi, thanks for your inspiring comments and continuous encouragement. Your help allows me to grow as a research scientist during this amazing journey. I am also deeply indebted to many people who contributed to the different steps of this thesis. I am grateful to both reviewers Marja Tiilikainen and Marko Juntunen, for their time, dedication and valuable comments.
    [Show full text]
  • Summaries in English
    Summaries in English EDITOR IN-CHIEF'S COLUMN Children's welfare in the hands of the Riigikogu Aivar Jarne, editor in-chief of Riigikogu Toimetised, Chancellery of the Riigikogu, head of the Press service Population experts paint a fairly bleak picture when it comes to Estonia. The population pyramid, which should have a wide base since the young make up the largest part of the population, is in fact eroded. The burden of bearing the economy and general weal falls onto the shoulders of people who are in their middle years but approaching pension age. Some relief is provided by 15-19-year-olds, whose fairly sizeable ranks are about to enter the workforce. Since the 2000 census, the Estonian population has decreased every year by almost 6,000 people. Estonia's birth rate is negative as there are 15 deaths and only 10 births per 1,000 people. In this year alone, the gap has closed, but deaths still outstrip births. The necessary replacement rate to maintain the population at present levels has been calculated at 2.1 children for every woman of childbearing age; more is necessary to grow the population. Currently this figure stands at only 1.2. In order to tackle the population problem, population experts believe that the Western world and every Western country must give thought to how to stimulate the birth rate, increase the meaning of children to families and parents. Emotion-based values by itself will not be enough to counterbalance the time and money spent on raising a child. ESSAY Sovereignty in the European Union Mario Rosentau, University of Tartu doctoral student, attorney with Luiga, Mugu & Borenius The European Union is an association of democratic nation-states based on the rule of law.
    [Show full text]
  • Republic of Estonia Country Report Table of Contents
    m o c 30 km . s p a m - 20 mi d © Maardu Tallinn Rakvere Kohtla- Sillamäe Narva Kiviõli Järve Jõhvi Keila Tapa Haapsalu Paide Jõgeva Viljandi Tartu Pärnu Kuressaare Põlva Võru Valga Republic of Estonia Country Report Table of contents Executive Summary ............................................................................................................................................. 2 One of the three Baltic States occupied by the Soviet Union from 1940 until 1991, Estonia has made impressive economic and political progress since regaining independence. Read more. History ................................................................................................................................................................ 2 Estonia, slightly smaller in area than New Hampshire and Vermont combined, is bordered by Latvia, Russia, the Baltic Sea, and the Gulf of Finland. Read more. Government and Economy.................................................................................................................................. 3 Estonia is a mature, stable parliamentary democracy with legislative, executive, and judicial branches, of which the unicameral Parliament (Riigikogu) holds the most power. Its 101 members are popularly elected every four years. Read more. Foreign Policy ...................................................................................................................................................... 4 Estonia has good relations with its Baltic neighbors and is a member of the Council of Baltic
    [Show full text]
  • Cross-Border Crime and Estonia's Accession to the European Union*1
    Anna Markina Jüri Saar M.A. (Social Sciences), Doctor iuris, Lecturer of Sociology of Law, Docent of Criminology, Institute of Law, University of Tartu Institute of Law, University of Tartu Cross-Border Crime and Estonia’s Accession to the European Union*1 1. Introduction The issues of cross-border crime*2 related to Eastern Europe were already topical before the current enlarge- ment of the European Union. The majority of foreign criminologists and experts claim that crimes between the East and the West have increased considerably, diversified, and become more organised over the de- cades, with radical social change and broadening crime opportunities.*3 What will happen in cross-border crime after the accession of the ten countries, including Estonia and other former Soviet republics, is a question to which various answers have been given. Cross-border crime related to Estonia and the other Baltic states has mainly been examined in the context of the movement of offenders from these countries to the European Union and the resulting worsening of the crime situation in the old member states.*4 Such stereotypical assessment is rather prevalent both in Western European public opinion and among law enforcement professionals.*5 Here we can perceive the transfer of similar views to new circumstances, or unwillingness to alter earlier attitudes. This is illustrated by an organised crime report for 2002 prepared by Europol, which concludes among other things that Estonian 1 The article is based on the results of the survey Cooperation of Estonian Legal Protection Agencies with European Union Member States in Combating Cross-Border Crime (Situation before and after Accession to the European Union), conducted within the framework of public contract 03-175 in the Institute of International and Social Studies of the Tallinn Pedagogical University and the 8aculty of Law of the University of Tartu.
    [Show full text]
  • General Assembly Distr.: General 16 February 2021
    United Nations A/HRC/WG.6/38/EST/1 General Assembly Distr.: General 16 February 2021 Original: English Human Rights Council Working Group on the Universal Periodic Review Thirty-eighth session 3–14 May 2021 National report submitted in accordance with paragraph 5 of the annex to Human Rights Council resolution 16/21* Estonia * The present document is being issued without formal editing. GE.21-02086(E) A/HRC/WG.6/38/EST/1 I. Introduction1 1. The Estonian Government values the importance of ensuring and promoting human rights as enshrined in international instruments and cooperating in the field of human rights with international organisations and other States. Estonia is committed to fulfilling its reporting obligations to UN treaty bodies and other international organisations. Estonia has issued a standing invitation to the Special Procedures of the Human Rights Council. The Universal Periodic Review (UPR) provides a good basis for States to review their human rights activities and plan for the future. This third UPR and the mid-term report of 2018 continue the dialogue of the second UPR of 2016. Reporting process2 2. The report gives an overview of legislation, national action plans, policies and practices pertaining to human rights. References are made to recommendations by States in the course of the previous UPR. It has not been possible to address all human rights and fundamental freedoms in detail, and thus the report covers the issues that have deserved particular attention at national or international level in recent years. 3. This report has been compiled under the coordination of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs in cooperation with other Ministries that provided an overview of developments in their areas of governance.
    [Show full text]