A Snapshot of the Changing Policy Landscape Supporting Materials Energy Consumers Australia & KPMG
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Australia’s Energy Transition A snapshot of the changing policy landscape Supporting Materials Energy Consumers Australia & KPMG August 2021 Context and purpose of this document Context for considering the changing energy policy landscape Energy Consumers Australia (ECA) has partnered with KPMG to deliver a report on ‘Australia’s Energy Transition’ which serves to provide ECA with a better understanding of the recent energy policies, interventions, projects and reforms that have recently been considered or implemented by state and territory jurisdictions. With respect to the changing policy environment in which states are increasingly implementing state-based interventions in addition or in place of the national framework, understanding the drivers and implications of state jurisdictional energy policy is an increasingly important factor for ECA in fulfilling their mission to be the national voice for residential and small business energy consumers. Our approach to describing jurisdictional policies in the ‘Australia’s Energy Transition: A snapshot of the changing policy landscape’ report The report includes a summary of each jurisdiction that covers the challenges and trends emerging in the jurisdiction, a snapshot of key household and market outcomes, the policy outlook and some high-level insights from our analysis. Our analysis of each jurisdiction has been informed by detailed consideration and research of the interventions recently implemented by the respective jurisdictional government. However, the report intends to provide a high-level scan of the current policy environment and capture broader trends in policy-making, and seeks to be accessible for a wide range of readers. Therefore, detailed descriptions of all of the policies considered, and research relating to the energy landscape in each jurisdiction has not been included in the report, and rather included in this supporting materials document. The purpose of this accompanying supporting materials document This accompanying document of supporting materials provides a more detailed summary of all of the policies considered in the report, serving to provide additional detail on the interventions that have informed our analysis of the policy outlook and energy landscape in each jurisdiction. This document serves to act as an accompanying resource to the main report, providing specific details of each of the policies considered and key additional information that has informed our summary of each jurisdiction. The structure of this document For each state and territory jurisdiction, this document provides a snapshot of household outcomes and the energy supply mix, and analysis of the supply-demand outlook (where sufficient information relating to reliability is publicly available). The focus of the ‘Australia’s Energy Transition’ report is on state and territory jurisdictions, as such this detail is not provided for the Commonwealth – an outline of our approach to the Commonwealth jurisdiction is provided on page 4. For each jurisdictional policy captured in the main report, a 2-page summary is provided in this document. These summaries provide a description of each policy, consider the scope of each policy’s objectives against the ‘learning-enabling-solving’ framework and outline the policy’s expected or historic impact on key consumer outcomes. © 2021 KPMG, an Australian partnership and a member firm of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated with KPMG International Cooperative (“KPMG International”), a Swiss entity. All rights reserved. The KPMG name and logo are registered trademarks or trademarks of KPMG International. Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation. 2 Document Classification: KPMG Public Jurisdictional energy policies considered in this report Policies designed to improve the Learning level of existing knowledge in a Enabling Policies aiming to remove a Solving Significant interventions with certain aspect of the energy sector barrier for the market to solve material market impacts to and inform future reforms, e.g. the issue. address a policy concern. trials. New South Wales New South Wales Tasmania New South Wales • Energy Infrastructure Roadmap • Energy Savings Scheme • Renewable Energy Action Plan • Net Zero Industry and Innovation Program • Emerging Energy Program • Solar for Low Income Households • Regional Community Energy • Empowering Homes Solar Battery Australian Capital Territory Victoria Victoria Loan Offer • Gas Phase-out • Victorian Default Offer • Neighbourhood Battery Initiative • Peak Demand Reduction Scheme • Community Solar • Renewable Energy Zones Development Plan • Next Generation Energy Storage Victoria Program Queensland • Solar Homes Program • Energy Efficiency Improvement Note that a number of the ‘enabling’ policies also Renewable Energy and Hydrogen Jobs Fund • Victorian Energy Upgrades Program Scheme • have learning objectives they achieve by removing barriers to facilitate the uptake of emerging Western Australia technologies and progress innovative models. Queensland Northern Territory Whole of System Plan • Solar 150 • Home and Business Battery Scheme • Similarly, jurisdictions also use a number of other • Renewables 400 South Australia tools, such as grant funding, to support learning • CleanCo Commonwealth Energy and Emissions Reduction Agreement activity, however these activities have not been • Wandoan South Battery Energy • National Gas Reservation Scheme • captured as policies in this report. Storage System • Underwriting New Generation • Smarter Homes Investments Program Western Australia • Technology Investment Roadmap Northern Territory • DER Roadmap • Australian Gas Security Mechanism • Electricity Market Priority Reform Program South Australia Commonwealth • Grid-Scale Storage Fund • ‘Big Stick’ Legislation • Home Battery Scheme • Snowy 2.0 • Retailer Energy Productivity Scheme • Default Market Offer • Hunter Power Project (Kurri Kurri Power Station) © 2021 KPMG, an Australian partnership and a member firm of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated with KPMG International Cooperative (“KPMG International”), a Swiss entity. All rights reserved. The KPMG name and logo are registered trademarks or trademarks of KPMG International. Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation. 3 Document Classification: KPMG Public Our approach to state vs. Commonwealth policy in this report National responsibilities in energy State vs. national approaches to energy policy making Energy market governance occurs within the context of Australia’s federal In recent times, the commitment of state jurisdictional governments to the system of government. Currently, states and territories have primary national approach has been tested, as individual state and territory responsibility for energy policy. The Commonwealth has primary responsibility governments have increasingly implemented jurisdiction specific reforms and for emissions reduction policy. initiatives. This is a reflection of the fact that different states are facing increasingly different pressures, as the energy landscapes in different states The Australian Energy Market Commission is accountable to the Energy Ministers’ Meeting which reports to the Energy National Cabinet Reform continue to take on different characteristics. In addition to this, state Committee. This council is chaired by the Commonwealth Energy Minister and jurisdictions have separate goals for addressing climate change and its members include all state and territory energy ministers. The Energy decarbonisation. These factors have driven states to introduce and rely on their Ministers’ Meeting coordinates government energy policy. own reforms, in addition to, or in some cases in place of, the national framework. Because energy policy is in the domain of the states and territories, consistent policy at the Commonwealth requires coordinated effort, for example, changes to the National Electricity Law require agreement among all the participating The scope of this report jurisdictions. The Australian Energy Market Agreement (AEMA) sets out how The focus of this report is to better understand the recent interventions by energy policy will be developed through the jurisdictions. state jurisdictions, recognising the factors driving state policy makers and the The Energy Council seeks to optimise long-term economic, social and implications of their decisions for consumers. As such, more detailed analysis environmental benefits to the community. It does this by: has been undertaken for each of the state and territory jurisdictions, as compared to the Commonwealth initiatives. • facilitating national oversight and coordination of governance, policy development and program management to address the opportunities and However, ECA and KPMG recognise the important role that Commonwealth challenges facing Australia’s energy and resources sectors continues to play, particularly in implementing significant ‘solving’ interventions that impact energy markets in all states and territories. Hence, it • providing national leadership on key strategic issues and effectively integrating these strategic priorities into Government decision-making in is useful to capture some of the recently introduced Commonwealth policies, relation to the energy and resources sectors although additional analysis regarding household outcomes, the energy supply mix and supply-demand outlook as they relate to the entire Australian energy