The English Morte D'arthur and the Persian Samak-E-Ayyar
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Cumhuriyet Üniversitesi Fen Fakültesi Cumhuriyet University Faculty of Science Fen Bilimleri Dergisi (CFD), Cilt:36, No: 3 Özel Sayı (2015) Science Journal (CSJ), Vol. 36, No: 3 Special Issue (2015) ISSN: 1300-1949 ISSN: 1300-1949 A Comparative Study of Two Romances: The English Morte d'Arthur and the Persian Samak-e-Ayyar Samira MODARRES English Language and Literature Instructor Payam Noor University of Firouragh Received: 01.02.2015; Accepted: 05.05.2015 ______________________________________________________________________________________________ Abstract. The present study endeavors to investigate the English romance Morte d'Arthur (1485) written by Sir Thomas Malory and Samak-e-Ayyar (12th c.) a Persian romance compiled by Faramarz ibn Khodadad and extract the most common elements of romance as manifested in these works. The elements studied in this paper include oral tradition, magic and witchcraft, nobleness and gentility, chivalric magnanimity and brotherly ethos, and masculinity. Keywords: Romance, Chivalry, Morte d'Arthur, Samak-e-Ayyar _____________________________________________________________________________ 1. INTRODUCTION Comparative literature has gained considerable attention in recent decades. It passes the geographical borders and adds a global dimension to literary studies. Investigating the literary works of different authors, especially when they come from different cultures, helps to look more carefully into the common concerns of different nations. It also paves the way for a variety of historical, cultural, anthropological, psychological, and political studies. The two works chosen for the present study belong to such variant cultures. Thomas Malory's Morte d'Arthur is an English romance written in 1469 and published in 1485 and Samak-e-Ayyar is a long Persian tale transcribed by Faramarz ibn Khodadad ibn Abdollah al-Kateb al-Arjani. Although romance is a basically European genre, Samak-e-Ayyar is usually referred to as a Persian romance. Accordingly, in the present study it is considered as a romance and the most important features of a romance found in both works have been discussed. Medieval studies constitute an enormous part of English literature. C. Maddern's Medieval Literature (2010) is an analytic companion and Medieval Romance, Medieval Contexts (2011) by Cichon and Purdie is another scholarly work in the field. Since its publication Morte d'Arthur has been the subject of various literary studies. R. S. Loomis in Development of Arthurian Romance (2000) examines the evolution of Arthurian legends in Western literature. In a volume of essays entitled Aspects of Malory (1981), T. Takamaya and D. Brewer provide a collection of scholarly works on Malory's prose. As its title suggests, D. Armstrong's Gender and the Chivalric Community in Malory’s Morte d’Arthur (2003) concentrates on two aspects of the work. There are however, few comparative studies that have been done on Morte d’Arthur. Dr. Jack Ross in a web article entitled "Malory and Scheherzade" (2007) studies Morte d'Arthur and The Thousand and One Nighs. Samak-e-Ayyar is an outstanding literary work which has been investigated in numerous scholarly books and articles. The most comprehensive work on Samak-e-Ayyar is done by Dr. Parviz Natel Kanlari who corrected and published the complete work in six volumes. Marina _____________ *Corresponding author. Email address: [email protected] Special Issue: The Second National Conference on Applied Research in Science and Technology http://dergi.cumhuriyet.edu.tr/cumuscij ©2015 Faculty of Science, Cumhuriyet University A Comparative Study of Two Romances: The English Morte d'Arthur and the Persian Samak-e- Ayyar Gaillard's Le Livre de Samak-e Ayyar (1987) studies the structure of the book. Y. Jalali Pendari and R. Hosseini in an article entitled "Stratagems and Schemes in Samak-e Ayyar " (2012) focus on old trickeries used in the story; F. Rostami in "A Female Based Reading of Tarikh-e Beyhaqi and Samak-e Ayyar" (2011) and M. Karami and S. Hessampour in "The image of woman in folktales of Samak-e-Ayyar and Darab Nameh" (2005) render comparative studies and female readings of the work and M. Jafarpour and M. Alavi Moghaddam in "A Comparative Study of Ritual and Warfare in Shahnameh and Samak-e Ayyar" (2012) suggest another comparative study. Malory's work is usually studied in comparison with other Arthurian legends, and similarly, Samak-e-Ayyar is normally compared with other Persian tales such as Amir Arsalan, Hussein Kurd, Darab Nameh, Iskandar Nameh, and Shahnameh. The present study endeavors to extract the most common elements of romance as manifested in both works; therefore, its focus is on the similarities. The elements discussed in this paper include oral tradition, magic and witchcraft, nobleness and gentility, chivalric magnanimity and brotherly ethos, and masculinity. 1.1. Romance Medieval romances were works of fiction developed in 12th c. France and spread to the literature of other countries. The earlier romances appeared in verse but later on more and more romances were written in prose and displaced the earlier epic and heroic forms. There are collections of features and motifs rather than a clear-cut definition for romance. Asserting the difficulty of giving an explicit definition for "romance", Whetter in a 2008 study reviews some of these interpretations and yet finds it haphazard: Severs's manual… states: 'The medieval romance is a narrative about knightly prowess and adventure'. Similarly, in John Stevens's influential study romance is defined by its idealism and distinguished by such traits as the 'mysterious challenge or call: the first sight of the beloved; the lonely journey through a hostile land; the fight'… Joanne Charbonneau… mentions the dominance of the adventure element (p. 48) Romance is therefore identified through some main characteristics: It is a long tale of high adventure. "The typical romance is about a thousand lines, more or less (or episodes of a similar length in longer romances)" (Cichon & Purdie, 2011, p. 12). It idealizes chivalry and focuses on a hero-knight and his noble deeds. This hero is a person of noble birth or rank who meets a variety of extraordinary challenges and his triumph benefits his nation/group. The story is set in an imaginary and vague land and includes the rescue of a captive lady or the knight's love for his lady. Romances derive mystery and suspense from supernatural elements. 1.2. Le Morte d'Arthur King Arthur has been surrounded by numerous tales. He is a legendary British leader who apparently lived in the 6th c. and defended Britons against Saxon invaders. In their 2009 work, Archibald and Putter write: The earliest sources associate him with the shadowy period around 500, when the Romans who had earlier colonized Britain withdraw and left the native Celtic population (the Britons) vulnerable to attack by Germanic tribes… in the first chronicle that mentions Arthur, the ninth- century Historia Brittonum (sometimes attributed to Nennius) he is already larger than life (p. 3). The Arthurian legends were one of the dominant narrative themes of Middle Ages. "The King Arthur in the later medieval texts is not the Arthur of earlier works. The current literary 1267 MODARRES figure known as Arthur found its shape after 1139 A.D. when "Geoffrey of Monmouth (Galfridus Monemutenis) completed his Historia Regum Britanniae ('History of the Kings of Britain') which glorified Arthur and made him an international warlord" (Green p 4) Malory in his Le Morte d'Arthur mediates the medieval Arthurian legacy to post-medieval English writers. Le Morte d'Arthur is a composition by Sir Thomas Malory (c 1405-1471) of traditional tales about the legendary King Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table beginning with Arthur's conception and birth, and concluding with his death. The characters of Arthur and his knights were already well-known in England. Malory interpreted existing French and English stories and added original material. He wrote eight individual romances which were assembled by William Caxton into a single epic. Each book within Le Morte d’Arthur focuses on a particular circumstance or character. Arthur, son of King Uther Pendragon and Igraine, is raised by another family but he takes his rightful place as king. Although he rules wisely and is counseled by Merlin the magician, Arthur makes enemies of other kings and is often at war. He establishes a code of ethics for the Knights of the Round Table, which helps maintain the peace of the kingdom. He has a brief love affair with Morgause, the queen of Orkney and one of Igraine’s three daughters – and, thus, Arthur’s half sister. He conceives an illegitimate child named Mordred. Arthur takes Guinevere as his queen and Lancelot, a French warrior and one of the Knights of the Round Table, becomes the courtly lover of Guinevere. Sir Gawain, one of Arthur's nephews, is an intensely loyal knight and encourages him to invade France. Mordred takes advantage of Arthur’s absence and makes himself King of England, claims Guinevere as his wife, and attacks Arthur's army. Upon learning of Mordred’s treachery, Arthur and his army return to England. Arthur kills Mordred but is mortally wounded by him. He is taken to the isle of Avalon to be healed, and he dies there. 1.3. Samak-e-Ayyar Samak-e-Ayyar is one of the oldest samples of story writing in Persian literature written in the 6th century A.H. and compiled by Faramarz ibn Khodadad ibn Abdollah al-Kateb al-Arjani (Mohammad Moein, Persian Lexicon 1996: Alam). It is transmitted orally and written down around the 12th century. Samak-e-Ayyar is generally known as a Persian romance but there is not a comprehensive agreement on the its genre; while some consider it as a romance (Meghdadi, 1999, p. 260), (Baraheni, 1989, p. 29), others disagree and insist that romance is a literary genre – or a literary kind, as some prefer – which belongs to 11th and 12th c.