DOCSLIB.ORG

Graham Final Thesis Strathclyde 210716

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Graham Final Thesis Strathclyde 210716 Global Concepts, Local Contexts __________________________________________________________________________________ A case study of international criminal justice policy transfer in violence reduction William Graham A thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements of Glasgow Caledonian University for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy July 2016 Dedication This thesis is dedicated to my wife Christine. I could not have achieved all that I have without her love and support over the past 35 years. i Abstract Global Concepts, Local Contexts A case study of international criminal justice policy transfer in violence reduction Glasgow has long experienced the issue of gang-related violence, especially in the east end of the city, an area of high social deprivation and related problems. Faced with apparent failure to deal with the problems of violence, in 2008, the police in Glasgow, in partnership with other statutory agencies, engaged in a process of policy transfer of the Cincinnati Initiative to Reduce Violence (US CIRV). They formed a multi-agency strategy, the Community Initiative to Reduce Violence (Glasgow CIRV), in order to tackle violence by targeting gangs and gang members both collectively and individually, in an attempt to encourage them to change their lifestyle. Glasgow CIRV operated for a period of three years (June 2008-July 2011), with some success in reducing violence and weapon carrying offences, however, in contrast to US CIRV, which is still in operation, it failed to achieve long-term sustainability. This research is an in-depth case study of the policy transfer between US CIRV and Glasgow CIRV and was initially guided by the question; ‘to what extent could the apparent long-term failure of Glasgow CIRV be explained by the policy transfer process?’ The model of policy transfer developed by Dolowitz and Marsh (1996 and 2000) was used to provide the theoretical and empirical framework to analyse the processes, mechanisms, ii and outcomes of the transfer of CIRV from Cincinnati to Glasgow. The transfer process was found to be a direct copy of the US CIRV project by Glasgow CIRV at the outset, however; it quickly became apparent that this process changed to one of emulation, due to differences, including the local context and legal constraints. The model of policy transfer proved to be a useful analytical tool with which to frame the empirical approach used in this case study. However, the model was found to have some limitations in terms of understanding the outcome of the policy transfer process. These limitations, which include its descriptive, linear, and finite framework, do not allow for the conceptualisation of one of the main findings of this research, an instance of ‘back- flow of policy transfer’, which requires a more cyclical approach; nor for the critical theorisation of what happens after a policy has been transferred, where the model stops, but the process may continue. This thesis therefore, extends existing knowledge in the field of criminal justice policy transfer by proposing an extension to the model beyond its linear and finite scope, by showing that transfer can be cyclical in nature and not be restricted to ‘one-way traffic’, identifying what it does not encapsulate, and reinforcing the significance of the local contexts, which cannot fail to have an impact on such transfer processes. iii Contents Dedication ...................................................................................................................................................... i Abstract ........................................................................................................................................................... ii Global Concepts, Local Contexts ....................................................................................................... ii Contents ......................................................................................................................................................... iv List of Tables ............................................................................................................................................... ix List of Figures .............................................................................................................................................. x List of Appendices .................................................................................................................................... xi Acknowledgements ................................................................................................................................ xii Declaration ................................................................................................................................................. xv Chapter 1 – Introduction ....................................................................................................................... 1 Glasgow and its Gangs ............................................................................................................................. 3 Cincinnati and its Gangs ......................................................................................................................... 5 Boston ............................................................................................................................................................... 7 Research Aims and Objectives ............................................................................................................. 8 Theoretical Framework .......................................................................................................................... 8 Thesis Structure ....................................................................................................................................... 10 Chapter 2 – Gangs Research and Their Definitions ............................................................ 14 Introduction ............................................................................................................................................... 14 Defining ‘gangs’ ....................................................................................................................................... 15 Historical Perspectives on Gangs Research .............................................................................. 21 Research in the UK .................................................................................................................................. 26 Territoriality ............................................................................................................................................. 29 Conclusions ................................................................................................................................................. 32 Chapter 3 - Policy Transfer: A Review of the Literature .................................................. 35 Introduction ............................................................................................................................................... 35 Early ‘Orthodox’ Policy Transfer Literature - Policy Diffusion, Convergence and Lesson-Drawing ....................................................................................................................................... 35 What is Policy Transfer? ...................................................................................................................... 39 I. Why and when do actors engage in policy transfer? ........................................................ 41 II. Who transfers policy? ...................................................................................................................... 45 iv III. What is transferred? ...................................................................................................................... 49 IV. From where are lessons drawn? .............................................................................................. 51 V. Degrees of Transfer .......................................................................................................................... 54 VI. When do actors engage in policy transfer and how does this affect the policy- making process? ...................................................................................................................................... 55 VII. What restricts policy transfer? ....................................................................................... 57 VIII.How can researchers begin demonstrating the occurrence of policy transfer? ........................................................................................................................................................................... 60 IX. How can policy transfer help our understanding of policy failure?62 Criticisms of Policy Transfer and Way Forward ..................................................................... 62 Policy Mobilities and Mutations ...................................................................................................... 65 Final Thoughts .......................................................................................................................................... 69 Chapter 4 - Methodology .................................................................................................................... 71 Introduction ..............................................................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Chapter 1 the Emergence of Gangs in the United States— Then and Now
    Chapter 1 The Emergence of Gangs in the United States— Then and Now CHAPTER OBJECTIVES î Examine the emergence of gangs in the United States. î Explore where gangs from New York, Chicago, and Los Angeles first emerged. î Identify the differences and similarities between each regions growth of gangs. î Examine the emergence of Black and Hispanic/Latino gangs. î Describe the newest gang trends throughout the United States. “The Cat’s Alleys,” the Degraw Street Gang, the Sackett Street gang, “The Harrisons,” the Bush Street Gang, and 21 other boys’ gangs were the subjects of a report of the New York State Crime Commission which told, last week, of its findings in the Red Hook section of Brooklyn. The boys who comprise the gangs have to undergo rigorous initiations before being qualified for membership. In one of the more exclusive gangs initiates, usually aged about nine, have to drink twelve glasses of dago-red wine and have a revolver pressed into their temples while they take the pledge. Source: Gangs (1927). Time, 9(13), 11. Introduction The above excerpt comes from a 1927 article in Time Magazine that identifies local gangs in New York City and their activities. However, gangs existed long before any established city in the United States. British crime chronicler, Luke Pike (1873), reported that the first 1 ch01.indd 1 12/23/15 9:08 AM 2 Chapter 1: The Emergence of Gangs in the United States—Then and Now set of active gangs were in Europe. During those times, they were better known as highway robbers.
    [Show full text]
  • KM Thesis-Master 20160925-Final
    The Construction of the Gang in British Columbia: Mafioso, Gangster, or Thug? An Examination of the Uniqueness of the BC Gangster Phenomenon By Keiron McConnell M.Sc. Public Order Policing, Leicester University, 2004 B.G.S., Open University of BC, 2002 Thesis Submitted in Partial Fulfilment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Policing, Security and Community Safety John Grieve Centre Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities © Keiron McConnell 2015 London Metropolitan University September 2015 Abstract This thesis explores the structure, demographics, and history of gangs in British Columbia (BC), Canada, through a social constructionist lens. The purpose of this research is for the reader to consider the current state of gangs in BC as inherently different from other places in the world, to assist in understanding why there may be misconceptions, and to promote the research and implementation of more appropriate context-specific interventions. Building on previous work conducted as a Vancouver Police officer of over 27 years, I participated in field observations with gang units in Toronto and Hobbema, Canada; Chicago and Los Angeles, USA; and London, England. I also examined gang typologies and definitions in academic literature as a segment of the historical context of gang research and highlight how these bodies of literature contribute to the social construction of gangs. A historical review of media-reported gang violence in BC from 1903 to 2012 demonstrates that gang violence is not a new phenomenon, and its history is an essential element in the constructed concept of the gang. As well, I conducted semi-structured interviews with participants who either police gangs, work with gangs, or were former gang members to get their perspectives on the issue.
    [Show full text]
  • History of Gangs in the United States
    1 ❖ History of Gangs in the United States Introduction A widely respected chronicler of British crime, Luke Pike (1873), reported the first active gangs in Western civilization. While Pike documented the existence of gangs of highway robbers in England during the 17th century, it does not appear that these gangs had the features of modern-day, serious street gangs. Later in the 1600s, London was “terrorized by a series of organized gangs calling themselves the Mims, Hectors, Bugles, Dead Boys [and they] fought pitched battles among themselves dressed with colored ribbons to distinguish the different factions” (Pearson, 1983, p. 188). According to Sante (1991), the history of street gangs in the United States began with their emer- gence on the East Coast around 1783, as the American Revolution ended. These gangs emerged in rapidly growing eastern U.S. cities, out of the conditions created in large part by multiple waves of large-scale immigration and urban overcrowding. This chapter examines the emergence of gang activity in four major U.S. regions, as classified by the U.S. Census Bureau: the Northeast, Midwest, West, and South. The purpose of this regional focus is to develop a better understanding of the origins of gang activity and to examine regional migration and cultural influences on gangs themselves. Unlike the South, in the Northeast, Midwest, and West regions, major phases characterize gang emergence. Table 1.1 displays these phases. 1 2 ❖ GANGS IN AMERICA’S COMMUNITIES Table 1.1 Key Timelines in U.S. Street Gang History Northeast Region (mainly New York City) First period: 1783–1850s · The first ganglike groups emerged immediately after the American Revolution ended, in 1783, among the White European immigrants (mainly English, Germans, and Irish).
    [Show full text]
  • A Nation Divided
    A Nation Divided The War for America‘s Soul By Rex Rammell 1 A Nation Divided The War for America‘s Soul (Fly leaf summary) With Social Security and Medicare bankruptcy imminent, over twelve trillion in federal debt, forty-seven million Americans without health insurance, a siege of illegal immigrants ranging from twelve to twenty million, Islamic extremists threatening annihilation of Americans, Congress with historic low approval rating — is it the beginning of the end of America? Dr. Rammell, a veterinarian and constitutionalist, puts his analytic skills to work and the diagnosis is ―critical‖. He dissects the facts, lays out the naked truth, and provides a plan to save America. ―America has a disease‖ he says, ―spread throughout the nation. That disease is socialism with unlimited federal power and it will take the entire strength and will of the people to overpower it.‖ How did America develop this disease and what is the cure? Dr. Rammell will lead you on a thorough analysis of where it all went wrong, the gigantic mess in which America finds herself, and what we must do to ultimately save her. While Congress is fighting over where to put the band aids, he proclaims, ―It is time for major surgery: Time for a transplant of the ‗original heart and soul of America‘ established by God.‖ A Nation Divided Copyright © by Rex Rammell, July 2008. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, without written permission from the publisher. 2 A Nation Divided The War for America‘s Soul Preface.………………………………………………………………...4 I.
    [Show full text]
  • Searching for You Bethany House, a Division of Baker Publishing Group, © 2018
    ORPHAN TRAIN BOOK THREE S E A RCHI NG FOR YOU Jody Hedlund 5 Jody Hedlund, Searching for You Bethany House, a division of Baker Publishing Group, © 2018. Used by permission. _Hedlund_SearchingforYou_LH_jck.indd 3 8/15/18 10:40 AM 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Library of Congress Cataloging- in- Publication Data is on file at the Library of Con- gress, Washington, DC. Library of Congress Cataloging- in- Publication Control Number: 0000000000 © 2018 by Jody Hedlund Published by Bethany House Publishers 11400 Hampshire Avenue South Bloomington, Minnesota 55438 www.bethanyhouse.com Bethany House Publishers is a division of Baker Publishing Group, Grand Rapids, Michigan Printed in the United States of America All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means— for example, electronic, pho- tocopy, recording— without the prior written permission of the publisher. The only exception is brief quotations in printed reviews. Library of Congress Cataloging- in- Publication Data Names: Hedlund, Jody, author. Title: Searching for you / Jody Hedlund. Description: Minneapolis, Minnesota : Bethany House, a division of Baker Publishing Group, [2018] | Series: Orphan train ; Book 3 Identifiers: LCCN 2018019436 | ISBN 9780764218064 (trade paper) | ISBN 9780764232749 (cloth) | ISBN 9781493416103 (e- book) Subjects: | GSAFD: Christian fiction. | Love stories. Classification: LCC PS3608.E333 S43 2018 | DDC 813/.6— dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2018019436 Scripture quotations are from the King James Version of the Bible. This is a work of fiction. Names, characters, incidents, and dialogues are products of the author’s imagination and are not to be construed as real.
    [Show full text]
  • The Irish-American Gangster in Film
    Farrell 1 THE IRISH-AMERICAN GANGSTER IN FILM By Professor Steven G. Farrell 1 Farrell 2 When The Godfather was released in the early seventies, it effectively created a myth of the virtually unbeatable Italian crime family for the American public that endured for the remainder of the century. This film also effectively eliminated all other white ethnic organized gangs from the silver screen, as well as from the public’s eye. Hollywood, as we shall see, had their history wrong in this case. The Italian Mafia was never as invincible as Hollywood depicted it on film, nor did they always have everything their own way when it came to illegal activities. It wasn’t until the close of the last century that the film industry began to expose the old-time hoods as being fallible and besieged on all sides from new criminal elements connected with newly arrived immigrant groups. The Cubans, Russians and the Colombian hoods, along with the longer established African and Mexican American gangs, had begun to nibble away at the turf long controlled by the almighty Italian mob. As the paradigm of the urban underworld began to shift to reflect the new realities of the global economy, another look at the past by historians and Hollywood is revealing that the Italian gang never had absolute power as it was once commonly believed. The Irish hoodlums, to single out the subject of this paper, were actually engaged in gangland activities years before the arrival of the Italians and the Irish also competed with the Italians up until recently.
    [Show full text]
  • The Old-Time Gangs of New York
    THE OLD-TIME GANGS OF NEW YORK BY HERBERT ASBURY HE old-time gangs of New York City the older thieves, to whom they surren­ had their genesis in the tenements, dered their loot. Tsaloons and dance-houses of the old The Chichesters, Roach Guards, Plug Five Points and Paradise Square district; Uglies, Shirt Tails and Dead Rabbits were but their actual organization into working organized in other bogus grocery-stores, units, and the consequent transformation and in time these emporiums came to be of the area into an Alsatia of vice and regarded as the worst dens of the Five crime, followed the opening of the cheap Points, and the centers of its infamy and green-grocery speak-easies which sprang crime. The Shirt Tails were so called be­ up around the Square and along the streets cause they wore their shirts on the outside which, debouching into it, formed the of their trousers, like Chinamen, and the Points. The first of these speak-easies was expressive appellation of the Plug Uglies opened, about 1810, by Rosanna Peers, in came from the enormous plug hats of the Center street, just south of Anthony, now members, which they stuffed with wool Worth street. Piles of decaying vegetables and leather and drew down over their ears were displayed on racks outside the door, to serve as helmets when they went into but Rosanna provided a back room in battle. The Plug Uglies were for the most which she sold the fiery liquor of the part gigantic Irishmen, and included in period, her chief source of revenue, at their membership some of the toughest lower prices than it could be obtained at characters of the Five Points.
    [Show full text]
  • Crime Wave for Clara CRIME WAVE
    Crime Wave For Clara CRIME WAVE The Filmgoers’ Guide to the Great Crime Movies HOWARD HUGHES Disclaimer: Some images in the original version of this book are not available for inclusion in the eBook. Published in 2006 by I.B.Tauris & Co Ltd 6 Salem Road, London W2 4BU 175 Fifth Avenue, New York NY 10010 www.ibtauris.com In the United States and Canada distributed by Palgrave Macmillan, a division of St. Martin’s Press, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York NY 10010 Copyright © Howard Hughes, 2006 The right of Howard Hughes to be identified as the author of this work has been asserted by him in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. All rights reserved. Except for brief quotations in a review, this book, or any part thereof, may not be reproduced, stored in or introduced into a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher. The TCM logo and trademark and all related elements are trademarks of and © Turner Entertainment Networks International Limited. A Time Warner Company. All rights reserved. © and TM 2006 Turner Entertainment Networks International Limited. ISBN 10: 1 84511 219 9 EAN 13: 978 1 84511 219 6 A full CIP record for this book is available from the British Library A full CIP record for this book is available from the Library of Congress Library of Congress catalog card: available Typeset in Ehrhardt by Dexter Haven Associates Ltd, London Printed and bound in Great Britain by TJ International,
    [Show full text]
  • Read an Excerpt
    Forevermore A Pat O’Malley Mystery By Jim Musgrave Other works by Jim Musgrave The Digital Scribe: A Writer’s Guide to Electronic Media Lucifer’s Wedding Sins of Darkness Russian Wolves Iron Maiden an Alternate History The Necromancers or Love Zombies of San Diego Freak Story: 1967-1969 The President’s Parasite and Other Stories The Mayan Magician and Other Stories Catalina Ghost Stories Copyright © 2013 Jim Musgrave All rights reserved. ISBN: 1482063492 ISBN-13: 978-1482063493 Forevermore By Jim Musgrave © 2013 by English Majors Publishing Published by English Majors Reviewers and Editors, LLC An EMRE Publishing, LLC Book Copyright 2013 All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the copyright owner, except for a reviewer who may quote brief passages in a review. This novel is a work of fiction. Names, characters, places and incidents are the product of the author's imagination or are used fictitiously, and any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, events, or locales is entirely coincidental. English Majors Publishers is a publishing house based in San Diego, California. Website: emrepublishing.com For more information, please contact: EMRE Publishing, LLC 6784 Caminito del Greco San Diego, CA 92120-2219 [email protected] Cover and book design by Graphicz X Designs (http://graphiczxdesigns.zenfolio.com) DEDICATION To my wife, Ellen. May our love remain a mysterious joy. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This is the first mystery in a series starring Pat O’Malley, a detective who is born out of the need to prove himself as a sleuth worthy of Edgar Allan Poe’s C.
    [Show full text]
  • The Bloody Ould Sixth Ward: Crime and Society in Five Points, New York
    The Bloody Ould Sixth Ward: Crime and Society in Five Points, New York Research Thesis Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for graduation “with Research Distinction in History” in the undergraduate colleges of The Ohio State University By: Sarah Paxton The Ohio State University June 2012 Project Advisor: Dr. Randolph Roth, Department of History A special thank you to my advisor, Dr. Randolph Roth, for his wisdom and direction during the development of this project A huge thank you, also, to my family and friends for their constant support despite having to listen to my incessant talk of 19th century crime. 2 1 Map 1: The Sixth Ward, 1851 1 Anbinder, Tyler. (April 2002). From Famine to Five Points. The American historical Review. Vol 107, No 2. Retrieved from: www.historycooperative.org/journals/ahr/107.2/ah0202000351.html 3 In lower Manhattan, New York, Worth and Baxter Street converge on a relatively calm intersection next to a Chinatown playground. In 1830, however, this intersection consisted of four streets. Little Water, Orange, Anthony, and Cross all created a five pointed intersection, giving its neighborhood the name “Five Points.” The streets created a triangle of space within the Five Points neighborhood, which locals dubbed ‘Paradise Park.’ The park name quickly became ironic. A part of the Sixth Ward of New York City, the Five Points neighborhood became the most notorious slum in American history. According the inquests of the New York City coroner, there were eighty-two total inquests filed in the Sixth Ward between 1833 and 1835. A second sample of coroner’s inquests, those filed between 1847 and 1849, showed two hundred and sixty eight inquests filed.
    [Show full text]
  • MAYHEM Between Immigrant Groups by FERGUS M
    Martin Scorsese’s realistic portrayal of MANHATTAN pre-Civil War strife—Gangs of New York— re-creates the brutal street warfare waged MAYHEM between immigrant groups BY FERGUS M. BORDEWICH when he was growing up on Lower Manhattan’s Eliza- pages, he was introduced to legions of once-notorious beth Street in the 1950s, Martin Scorsese noticed tantalizing gangsters, among them Bill “the Butcher” Poole, Red vestiges of a New York City that simply didn’t fit into the Rocks Farrell, Slobbery Jim, Sow Madden, Piggy Noles, Little Italy neighborhood he otherwise knew so well. Suds Merrick, Cowlegged Sam McCarthy, Eat ’Em Up There were the tombstones dating to the 1810s in the Jack McManus. Not all the thugs, he discovered, were graveyard at nearby St. Patrick’s church, cobblestone pave- male. Hell-Cat Maggie, legend has it, filed her front teeth ments that hinted at horse-drawn traffic, and the “very to points and wore artificial brass fingernails, the better to tiny, very ancient” basements he discovered beneath late- lacerate her adversaries. 19th-century tenements. “I gradually realized that the Ital- Behind much of the violence lay a clash that involved, ian-Americans weren’t the first ones there, that other peo- on the one hand, a population of largely protestant ple had preceded us,” says Scorsese. “This fascinated me. I Americans, some of them with 18th-century English and kept wondering, how did New York look? What were the Dutch roots in the New World, some of them more re- people like? How did they walk, eat, work, dress?” cent arrivals.
    [Show full text]
  • Private Eric Tipton a BIOGRAPHY
    On The Eve of Bristoe An Immersion Event Hosted by the Southern Guard Living History Association September 24-25, 2005 4 2nd New York VOLUNTEER INFANTRY The Tammany Regiment 3rd Brigade, Webb’s 2nd Division, 2nd Army Corps, Army of the Potomac Commanding Officer: Colonel James E. Mallon - Killed at Bristoe Station - October 14, 1863. Introduction Following the great bloodletting at Gettysburg in July 1863, the two opposing armies occupied quiet camps and countless picket posts in central Virginia, neither side making any attempt to bring on further hostilities. The fighting that did occur was relegated to desultory cavalry actions. This all changed in October 1863. This fall the rolling hills of the Piedmont will lend itself as a back drop for the Southern Guard Living History Association's Fall Picket post. The event will be 36 hours of first person starting with a ration and ammo issue and continuing with a 5 mile march, all night pickets and pure Civil War soldier life. 42nd New York VOLUNTEER INFANTRY The Tammany Regiment There are countless stories about color bearers. At Fredericksburg on December 13, 1862, the 42nd New York Volunteers (nicknamed the Tammany Regiment because of the political hall where it was recruited) were leveled by a devastating volley within ten yards of that field's famous stone wall. With most of the men blown off their feet and dazed survivors running back to shelter, Color Sergeant Michael Cuddy pulled himself up on his flagstaff. Shot through with several bullets, he jerked his banner high into the air, swept it in the Southern faces, and joined the rest of his dead guard.
    [Show full text]