Taxonomic Studies on Fossil Remains of Ruminants from Tertiary
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
TAXONOMY AND DENTAL MORPHOLOGICAL STUDIES OF FOSSIL ARTIODACTYLS FROM TYPE LOCALITY OF DHOK PATHAN, PUNJAB, PAKISTAN MAHBOOB IQBAL DEPARTMENT OF ZOOLOGY UNIVERSITY OF THE PUNJAB LAHORE, PAKISTAN 2010 TAXONOMY AND DENTAL MORPHOLOGICAL STUDIES OF FOSSIL ARTIODACTYLS FROM TYPE LOCALITY OF DHOK PATHAN, PUNJAB, PAKISTAN By MAHBOOB IQBAL A THESIS SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF Doctor of Philosophy In the Faculty of Life Sciences, University of the Punjab, Lahore, Pakistan Supervisor Prof. Dr. Muhammad Akhtar Co-Supervisor Dr. Muhammad Akbar Khan DEPARTMENT OF ZOOLOGY UNIVERSITY OF THE PUNJAB LAHORE, PAKISTAN August, 2010 DEDICATION DEDICATED WITH LOVE TO MY PARENTS MY FAMILY (DR. SAMINA, UMAR & HADEEQA) AND ALL THOSE WHO LOVE, CARE AND PRAY FOR ME. ABSTRACT A taxonomic investigation of Late Miocene artiodactyl fauna of Dhok Pathan, the Middle Siwaliks, Pakistan, was undertaken. Comparative morphometric features of the late Miocene artiodactyls from the locality are studied in this thesis. The late Miocene artiodactyls are presented on the basis of description of abundant material from the Dhok Pathan type locality of the Dhok Pathan Formation, the Middle Siwaliks and the remains increasingly indicate taxonomic diversity. Quantitatively, the taxa of bovids are the most predominant. But cervids, tragulids, giraffids and suids are approximately as common as each other at Dhok Pathan. More than 130 artiodactyl fossil specimens were studied in this thesis from the Dhok Pathan type locality. All the described specimens include Skulls, horn cores, isolated teeth and fragments of maxillae or mandibles. These fossils document twenty three artiodactyl species belonging to fifteen genera and five families. This assemblage includes two new taxa: Miotragocerus large sp. and ?Hydaspitherium sp. Boselaphines, antilopines, reduncines, cervids, tragulids, giraffids and suids are abundant in the locality whereas tragelaphines and alcelaphines are absent. Biogeographically, the late Miocene artiodactyls indicate strong relationships with Eurasian and African late Miocene sites. In this study, paleoenvironmental interpretations of the type locality provide important evidence regarding late Miocene paleoenvironments. Most of these taxa indicate a predominance of woodland to savannah habitat during the deposition of the Dhok Pathan Formation. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS All praises with my deepest gratitude to Almighty Allah, whose uniqueness, oneness and wholeness in unchallengeable. All and every respect is for His Holy Prophet HAZRAT MOHAMMAD (Peace Be Upon Him), who enlightened us to understand the mystery of life. I acknowledge the depth of my gratitude and heart full thanks to highly learned and respected project Design Supervisor professor Dr. Mohammad Akhtar, Department of Zoology university of the Punjab under whose auspices I took a stride in completion of this work. He is also thanked for granting permission to use some bovids, suids, material collected by him and housed in the Dr. Abu Bakr Fossil Display and Research Centre and Paleontology laboratory of the university of the Punjab for this study. I feel great pleasure and honour to express my deep sense of gratitude to my respected and genius Co Supervisor Dr. Mohammad Akbar Khan assistant Professor Zoology GC University, Faisalabad for their constructive suggestions, guidance and encouragement during my research project. I feel highly privileged in taking the opportunity to thank Professor Dr. Asif Mehmood Qureshi, Prof. Mirza Afzal Baig and Prof. Abdul Qayyum Khan of Zoology Department Govt. College of Science Wahdat Road Lahore, for their moral support and encouragement and interest during the course of this work. I owe special thanks to Dr. Abdul majid Khan, Dr. Umar Farooq and Dr. Abdul Ghaffar who supported me at every critical stage during the course of my research project. I am also thankful to Mr. Abdul Rauf Malik Associate Prof. of Zoology Govt. College Talagang (Chakwal) providing Base Camp for the fossil Collection. I sincerely thank to Mr. sajjid Shah, Mr. Maqsood Ahmed and Mr. Abdul Razzaq for joining me in field trips, for the fossil collection and for serving me in the laboratory. Mr. Adeeb Babar is thanked for his help with the preparation for the maps and photographs. MAHBOOB IQBAL Dated: August, 2010 i LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS Ca Circa Myr Million years Ma Million years ago MN European Mammal Neogene zone scale GPTS Geomagnetic Polarity Time Scale GRTS Geomagnetic Reversal Time Scale DP1-DP17 Localities of Dhok Pathan from numbers1 to 17 AMNH American Museum of Natural History BMNH British Museum of Natural History PMNH Pakistan Museum of Natural History PUPC logy, Punjab University, Lahore, Pakistan. PC-GCUF Palaeontological Collection of GC University, Faisalabad, Punjab, Pakistan. P or p Upper or lower premolar M or m upper or lower molar GSI Geological survey of India GSP Geological Survey of Pakistan DP Deciduous Premolar W/L Width/Length ratio Fms/Fm Formations/Formation. r Right l Left mm Millimeters ii TABLE OF CONTENTS Abstract Acknowledgements List of Abbreviations Table of Contents List of Tables List of Figures Chapter 1 Introduction Geography Geology Stratigraphy and Chronology Biostratigraphy Siwalik Artiodactyls Objectives of Present Study Thesis Layout Chapter 2 Materials and Methods iii Taxonomic Description Chapter 3 Systematic Palaeontology Family Bovidae Tragoportax Tragoportax punjabicus Tragoportax browni Tragoportax cf. salmontanus Miotragocerus Miotragocerus large sp. Miotragocerus cf. gluten Pachyportax Pachyportax latidens Pachyportax cf. nagrii Selenoportax Selenoportax cf. vexillarius Prostrepsiceros Prostrepsiceros cf. vinayaki Gazella Gazella lydekkeri Kobus Kobus porrecticornis cf. Kobikeryx sp. Caprotragoides Caprotragoides cf. potwaricus Family Cervidae iv Cervus Cervus cf. sivalensis Cervus cf. triplidens Family Tragulidae Dorcatherium Dorcatherium majus Dorcabune Dorcabune anthracotherioides Dorcabune cf. nagrii Family Giraffidae Hydaspitherium Hydaspitherium cf. megacephalum Hydaspitherium cf. grande ?Hydaspitherium sp. Family Suidae Propotamochoerus Propotamochoerus hysudricus Hippopotamodon ?Hippopotamodon sp. Chapter 4 Palaeoenvironment and Paleobiogeography of the Dhok Pathan Artiodactyls Chapter 5 Conclusions References v Appendices LIST OF TABLES Table 1: Mammalian faunas of Dhok Pathan. Many species are under taxaonomic revision. Table 2: Comparison of the cranial measurements (mm) of the Siwalik Tragoportax. Table 3: Comparative measurements of the cheek teeth of T. punjabicus in mm. Table 4: Comparative measurements of the cheek teeth of T. browni Pilgrim in mm. Table 5: Comparative measurements of the cheek teeth of Miotragocerus sp. and Miotragocerus gluten (Pilgrim, 1937) in mm. Table 6: Comparative measurements of the cheek teeth of P. latidens (Lydekker) Pilgrim in mm. Table 7: Comparative measurements of the cheek teeth of S. cf. vexillarius in mm. Table 8: Comparative measurements (mm) of the cheek teeth of G. lydekkeri. Table 9: Comparative measurements of the cheek teeth of the Siwalik Cervus in mm. Table 10: Comparative measurements of the cheek teeth of D. majus and D. minus in mm (millimeters). vi Table 11: Comparative measurements of the cheek teeth of Dorcabune anthracotherioides and D. nagrii in mm. Table 12: Comparative measurements of the lower cheek teeth of the giraffids in the Dhok Pathan type locality. Table 13: Comparative measurements of the cheek teeth of Propotamochoerus hysudricus and ?Hippopotamodon sp. in mm (millimeters). APPENDICES Appendix 1: List of the studied artiodactyls from Dhok Pathan. Appendix 2: Studied material. Appendix 3: The published article. LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1. A. Location of the Potwar Plateau in northern Pakistan; the studied areas are encircled. B. Simplified geology map of the Dhok Pathan area indicating the fossiliferous localities around the Dhok Pathan Rest House (DP – abbreviation for Dhok Pathan) from where the studied material is recovered. Figure 2. Percentage of species represented in the Dhok Pathan mammalian fauna. Figure 3. Tragoportax punjabicus. 1. PUPC 86/149 opisthocranium: a) dorsal view, b) ventral view, c) occipital view. 2. PUPC 86/150 opisthocranium: ventral view. Scale bar equals 30 mm total. Figure 4. Tragoportax punjabicus. 3. PUPC 86/264 left horn core: a) lateral view, b) medial view. Scale bar equals 30 mm total. Figure 5. Tragoportax punjabicus. 4. PUPC 08/126 palatine parts of both maxillae with right P3-M3 and left P2-M3: occlusal view. 5. PUPC 83/275 right maxillary fragment with P3-M3. 6. PUPC 97/12 left mandible fragment with p2-p4. 7. PUPC 83/277 left mandible vii fragment with m3. a) occlusal view, b) lingual view, c) labial view. Scale bar equals 30 mm total. Figure 6. Tragoportax browni. 1. PUPC 86/204 opisthocranium: a) dorsal view, b) ventral view, c) occipital view. Scale bar equals 30 mm total. Figure 7. Tragoportax browni. 2. PC-GCUF 09/11 horn core, side indeterminate: a) anterior view, b) posterior view, c) medial view, d) lateral view. Scale bar equals 30 mm total. Figure 8. Tragoportax browni. 3. PUPC 86/151 left maxillary fragment with M1-M2. 4. PUPC 83/265 left mandible fragment with m2-m3. a) occlusal view, b) lingual view, c) labial view. Scale bar equals 30 mm total. Figure 9. Tragoportax cf. salmontanus. 1. PUPC 93/20 left horn core: a) anterior view, b) posterior view, c) medial view. Scale bar equals 30 mm total. Figure 10. Scatter diagram showing horn-cores and dental proportions of the