CITY OF ROCK ISLAND DRAFT HISTORIC RESOURCES PLAN MARCH 30, 2016 PREPARED BY THE LAKOTA GROUP ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS HISTORIC RESOURCES PLAN STAKEHOLDER COMMITTEE CITY OF ROCK ISLAND STAFF Dennis Pauley, Mayor of Rock Island Thomas Thomas, City Manager Andrew Dasso, Plan Commission Ben Griffith, Planning and Redevelopment Administrator David Levin, Plan Commission/Realtor Brandy Howe, Urban Planner II Brent Bogen, Preservation Commission Chair Alan Fries, Urban Planner II Sue Swords, Preservation Commission Jeff Eder, Assistant City Manager, and Community and Avalon Thomas-Roebal, Renaissance Rock Island Economic Development Director Diane Oestreich, Rock Island Preservation Society Randall D. Tweet, Director of Public Works Linda Anderson, Rock Island Preservation Society Tom Ayers, Chief Building Official Sheila Solomon, Neighborhood Representative Joe Taylor, Quad Cities Convention and Visitor’s Bureau Angela Campbell, Rock Island Public Library ROCK ISLAND PRESERVATION COMMISSION Commissioners Leigh Ayers Brent Bogan, Chair Elizabeth Anne DeLong Paul Fessler Anthony Heddlesten Craig Kavensky Brian Leech Italo (Lo) Milani This (product or activity) has been financed in John Strieter part with federal funds from the Department Susan Swords of the Interior, administered by the Illinois Historic Preservation Agency. However, the contents and opinions do not necessarily Associate Members reflect the views or policies of the Department Linda Anderson of the Interior nor the Illinois Historic Preservation Agency, nor does the mention of trade names or commercial Jeff Dismer products constitute endorsement or recommendation by Daryl Empen the Department of the Interior nor the Illinois Historic Diane Oestreich Preservation Agency.. This program receives Federal financial assistance for identification and protection of historic properties. Under Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, and ROCK ISLAND CITY COUNCIL the Age Discrimination Act of 1975, as amended, the U.S. Department of the Interior prohibits discrimination on the Dennis Pauley, Mayor basis of race, color, national origin, or disability or age in its Ivory Deacon Clark, First Ward federally assisted programs. If you believe you have been Virgil J. Mayberry, Second Ward discriminated against in any program, activity, or facility as described above, or if you desire further information, please Paul (P.J.) Foley, Third Ward write to: Stephen L. Tollenaer, Fourth Ward Office of Equal Opportunity Kate Hotle, Fifth Ward National Park Service P.O. Box 37127 Joshua Schipp, Sixth Ward Washington, D.C. 20013-7127 Charles (Chuck) Austin III, Seventh Ward Or Equal Employment Opportunity Officer Illinois Historic Preservation Agency One Old State Capitol Plaza Springfield, IL 62701 2 ROCK ISLAND HISTORIC RESOURCES PLAN TABLE OF CONTENTS PLAN INTRODUCTION P.6 Rock Island Historic Preservation Chronology p. 8 Heritage Resources and Historic Preservation Defined p. 10 Benefits of Historic Preservation p. 10 What is a Heritage Resources Plan? p. 13 How to Use This Preservation Plan p. 14 Planning Process p. 14 HERITAGE RESOURCES PLAN P.18 Rock Island Historic Preservation Vision p. 18 Preservation Plan Overview p. 20 Goals, Policies and Initiatives p. 22 Implementation p. 44 HERITAGE RESOURCES P.54 Historic Context p. 54 Historic Resources p. 60 Existing Landmarks and Districts p. 66 STATE OF THE CITY P.74 City Planning p. 74 Local Preservation Ordinance and Design Management p. 84 Survey and Documentation p. 92 Incentives p. 96 City Departments, Agencies and Organizations p. 100 Community Engagement Summary p. 104 Issues Summary p. 110 APPENDICES P.116 Appendix 1: National Register Criteria for Evaluation p. 118 Appendix 2: Definitions p. 120 Appendix 3: Historic Preservation Ordinance Review p. 124 INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION In 2015, the City of Rock Island, in collaboration with Rock Island citizens and stakeholders, initiated an eight-month process to create the community’s firstHistoric Resources Plan. The Plan comes at a time when the Quad Cities region has emerged from one of the more significant economic recessions in recent decades with many Midwestern legacy cities like Rock Island seeking ways to encourage growth and economic development while preserving and maintaining the assets that make their communities distinct from others — assets that include traditional neighborhoods, downtown commercial districts, churches, schools and other historic resources that contribute to a community’s sense of place and quality of life. This Historic Resources Plan is being created to provide a new strategic direction for historic preservation in Rock Island – one that builds on past preservation successes, strengthens public-private partnerships, and promotes more certainty in the roles preservation will play going forward in shaping Rock Island’s built environment and economic vitality. The historic preservation movement in Rock Island has had a long history. After the first state-sponsored surveys of Rock Island’s historic structures and landmarks of the 1970s, early preservation efforts centered on creating neighborhood walking tours and promotional Downtown Rock Island architecture activities; by the 1980s, eight properties had already been listed in the National Register of Historic Places and an extensive community- wide survey and inventory of buildings had been completed. In 1980, the Rock Island Preservation Society was founded, reflecting a growing interest and concern among property owners on maintaining Rock Island’s historic housing stock and in addressing community preservation issues in general (Rock Island Residential Neighborhoods, 1835 – 1955: A Summary Report, City of Rock Island Preservation Commission, 1998, page 6). As early efforts focused on identifying historically and architecturally significant properties, the City, along with the Preservation Society and other partners, recognized that new tools would be needed to preserve and protect historic resources. One such tool was the adoption of the Rock Island Preservation Ordinance in 1984, making Rock Island one of the first cities in Illinois to start a municipal historic Old Main, Augustana College preservation program, along with the cities and communities of Aurora, Evanston, Rockford, Quincy, Mt. Carroll, and Jacksonville. Rock Island would later become a Certified Local Government (CLG) in 1985. Today, the City of Rock Island has one locally-designated historic district, Highland Park, and 80 Landmark buildings encompassing a variety of building types and architectural styles. In addition, 6 ROCK ISLAND HISTORIC RESOURCES PLAN INTRODUCTION there are two National Register Districts, including the Broadway Historic District encompassing 550 mostly residential properties and Chippiannock Cemetery, the first cemetery to be listed in the National Register in Illinois. Although not within Rock Island’s corporate boundaries, the Rock Island Arsenal, formally established in 1862, is also listed in the National Register. There are also 14 buildings in Rock Island that are individually listed in the National Register. The responsibilities of administering the Rock Island preservation program rests with the Rock Island Preservation Commission and staff within the City’s Planning and Redevelopment Division, who oversee landmark designation proceedings, design review and various educational and outreach activities. Broadway Neighborhood Interestingly, given the history and track record of preservation success in Rock Island, the community has not adopted nor implemented a comprehensive historic preservation plan, even though many district and neighborhood plans prepared by the City over the last three decades address preservation issues in different ways. Therefore, the process for preparing the Historic Resources Plan represents a unique opportunity for the Rock Island community to assess the effectiveness of the current program, understand current issues and constraints to preservation, and consider a set of planning strategies and initiatives that address critical preservation planning concerns. A historic resources plan for Rock Island is an important opportunity for the community to address the following: • Review and assess existing survey, inventory and documentation efforts, and prioritize future historic district and landmark designation efforts. • Research and establish context statements for understanding, identifying, and evaluating the importance of historic resources that promote Rock Island’s unique character and sense of place, as well as tell the stories of the people who shaped the community’s development. • Update the Rock Island Preservation Ordinance to ensure clarity on City preservation procedures, design review and the make-up and operations of the Preservation Commission. Rock Island Lines Depot ROCK ISLAND HISTORIC RESOURCES PLAN 7 INTRODUCTION • Propose a program of ongoing community outreach, education and preservation advocacy that helps promote increased awareness of Rock Island’s historic resources and stakeholder buy-in in the long- term preservation of the City’s landmarks and districts. • Encourage use of existing incentives for historic preservation and consider the creation of new financial programs that facilitate property maintenance, rehabilitation, and adaptive use. • Identify opportunities for advancing heritage tourism in Rock Island and for improving various historic sites, neighborhoods and districts as compelling places