Q 1 2 0 2 0

Quarterly MARKET & ECONOMIC PERSPECTIVE introduction

A Quarter Like We've Never Seen

As we sit down to write this piece in whatever amount of time economists early April 2020, we think it’s important spend putting together their detailed to acknowledge a few things. First, we forecasts, at the end of the day, they are are hoping you and your families are still just forecasts. We shouldn’t fully safe and well. Second, we understand rely on forecasts because unforeseen that there is a lot of anxiety about the events like COVID-19 can throw crisis itself as well as the downstream everything out the window. repercussions, both from a human and economic perspective; and there are still a lot of unknowns. Third, the virus is moving across the globe and events are changing rapidly. It is quite possible there will be some new information that makes this quarterly review moot by the time you read it, but we are going to move on with what we know now. Hopefully you have been using this time to do some activities you don’t have the time to enjoy normally, and maybe you are one of the many binge-watching Tiger King.

To show how unusual this quarter has been, it was January 11 when the Dow closed above 29,000 for the first time, expressing ’ optimism over the US/China trade deal. It was also only February 19 when the S&P 500 hit an all-time-high, capping the longest bull market in history. Less than 1.5 months later, its quarter end return was -19.6% (source: Morningstar Direct), highlighting the speed and sharpness of the market turnaround.

In our last quarterly review, we wrote about the challenges of making investment predictions. This recent experience reinforces our view that

Q1 2020 MARKET & ECONOMIC PERSPECTIVE

keeping a Understanding balanced approach the economic summary fallout Health crisis (Covid- Unlike the financial crisis of 2008-09 19) leads to which started on Wall Street and economic crisis moved onto Main Street, this current S&P hit an all-time crisis moved from Main Street to Wall high on February 19, Street. The story is we have a 2020; then global pandemic that is impacting experienced its supply and demand at different fastest move to a times and in different places. We bear market in have seen countries handle the history The longest bull market run in health crisis differently; we have

history has ended seen it even among states in our own country. What makes this crisis so This crisis has been more challenging is that our economy is about a flight to liquidity over set up for high connectivity while the a flight to quality health response calls for social distancing. positive signals From an economic perspective, we Unprecedented global have seen a multi-pronged approach monetary & fiscal policy from both a monetary and fiscal response to help stabilize policy perspective. On the monetary markets side, we have seen aggressive action While still negative YTD, from the Federal Reserve. equity markets have Acknowledging they were slow to act experienced recovery in the 2008-09 financial crisis they have been much more decisive this reasons for concern time by throwing the kitchen sink at Total cost of economic fallout the issue and have done so quickly. For example, they lowered Fed still unknown Funds rates twice (first to 1%-1.25% "Sell everything" approach in and then essentially to zero) and flight to liquidity drove down have announced or already prices of many/most securities; implemented several programs. high across markets Some of these programs, like quantitative easing, where the Fed is purchasing $500M in Treasuries and $200M in Agency Mortgage Backed Securities, were ones used during the Financial Crisis. However, they have also announced new and Q1 2020 MARKET & ECONOMIC PERSPECTIVE

unprecedented programs like the Corporate Credit Facility, where they are purchasing high grade corporate credit. The sum of these programs is to keep financial markets functioning. While the Fed has used a lot of bullets from their arsenal, there is still more they So, is the US economy about to can do. enter or already in a recession? The National Bureau of Economic Enter the US government and fiscal Research (NBER) is the non- policy measures. Specifically, the partisan group that officially government passed the Coronavirus determines the start and ending Aid, Relief and Economic Security period of recessions. As a rule of (C.A.R.E.S.) Act. Another thumb (not the official definition), unprecedented step, this $2T (that is a recession is often defined as two trillion with a T) package goes down consecutive quarters or six straight as the largest in US History, months of negative economic significantly larger than the $831B growth (GDP). Therefore, a American Recovery and Reinvestment recession is only announced after it Act of 2009. The CARES Act covers has already started, meaning it is direct cash payments to individuals entirely possible we are currently that qualify, expanded in one though it may not be unemployment insurance, support for formally announced for months. In small businesses and provides aid for the end, the duration and depth of state/local governments. Like what the health crisis will likely be the the Fed is doing, the CARES Act is major determinant of the economic meant to limit economic fallout. At outcome. the same time, we recognize the enormous debt burden these costs To keep things in perspective, the are creating, and we are thinking year-to-date return for the S&P 500 through various scenarios and how to through March 31, 2020 was -19.6%. mitigate the impact to investors. As a reference point, the annual return for the S&P 500 in 2008 was So, what’s next? While monetary and -37%. In other words, while seeing fiscal stimulus are definitely helping equities fall 20% is never fun, we to stem the tide, unfortunately they have seen declines like this before. are not a cure to what ails us in the As an advisor, our goal is to first place, the virus itself. Having a develop a -term financial plan vaccine, some other medication or that considers both your goals as method to limit the effects of the well as your tolerance for risk. virus, or simply seeing a reduction in Unless one of those items has its spread will help us know we are changed, we recommend sticking on the road to recovery, both from a with your plan and maintaining health and economic perspective. discipline through these turbulent times. Q1 2020 MARKET & ECONOMIC PERSPECTIVE

Overall, several themes continued as large cap outperformed U.S. Equity small cap stocks over the quarter (the Russell 2000 benchmark To show the swiftness of the decline suffered its worst quarter on in a picture, the chart below shows record), likely due to beliefs that just how quickly the S&P fell by 10% larger cap companies have more from its peak on February 19, the liquidity and access to capital fastest correction on record. during a crisis. From a sector perspective, energy stocks have been hit the hardest from the one- two combination of almost complete demand destruction (e.g. no one is driving or flying) and a price war between Russia and Saudi Arabia.

The S&P also broke the record for fastest decline to a bear market, defined as a drop by 20% from peak levels, taking only 22 days or 15 trading days (source: Payden and Rygel, looking at post-war history).

It’s also instructive to remember that the indexes shown above represent what happens in various slices of the markets, which is different from the economy. Said differently, equity markets are comprised of various stocks while the economy is the sum of the goods and services produced. For example, getting a at a salon is a service included in economic activity measurements, but isn’t measured by a particular . Also, consider that one way to measure a stock’s value is to look at its expected future cash flows. Therefore, it makes sense that the markets anticipate where the economy is expected to be, not necessarily where it is today.

Q1 2020 MARKET & ECONOMIC PERSPECTIVE

that China is a large portion of the index, it may come as a surprise that Non-U.S. China actually outperformed the US, declining -10.3%. However, other countries with larger weightings in Equity emerging markets did not fare as well including Taiwan (-19.6%), India International stocks as a whole (-31.8%), Brazil (-50.8%) and South underperformed their US Africa (-41.6%) (source: MSCI EM IMI). counterparts during the quarter.

Similar to in the US, large cap stocks Overall, international equities remain outperformed small cap and growth undervalued relative to both stocks outperformed value. historical averages and current US

valuations. Investors should also Not surprisingly, non-US markets keep in mind the return of have also been impacted by COVID- international equities can be driven 19. In the case of China, where the by the dollar’s relative strength or virus started, the impact was felt weakness versus foreign currencies earlier than places like Italy, which (the Wall Street Journal Dollar Index started seeing cases a little later. ended the quarter higher/stronger). Like the Fed, global central banks are Overall, almost all developed and taking action to support their emerging market currencies economies. depreciated versus the dollar over

the quarter. Within developed nations, the returns coming from different countries were quite diverse ranging from Denmark (-9.6%) to Austria (-38.2%). Some of the larger countries in the non-US indexes also experienced fairly disparate returns for the quarter. For example, Japan and Switzerland outperformed the US declining -17.4% and -12.2%, respectively, while the UK (-30.0%), Canada (-28.9%), and France (-28.0%) all underperformed the US (Source: MSCI World ex US IMI).

Emerging markets also underperformed the US over the quarter. Keep in mind that China is a significant part of most emerging market indexes (roughly one third weighting). Knowing that emerging markets underperformed the US and Q1 2020 MARKET & ECONOMIC PERSPECTIVE Global REITs Global REITs, as represented by the Dow Jones Global Select REIT, were one of the lower performers for the quarter, dropping -29.9%. US REITs performed slightly better (-28.5%) vs. their non-US counterparts (-32.5%). Overall, it’s important to remember that there are many different types of REITs, some of which may be more/less impacted by social distancing today and variations in potentially diminished demand going forward. For example, hotels (travel ban) are negatively impacted in the short run while retail (some temporary closings may become permanent) and office space (more people work from home) may experience longer term challenges. At the same time, cell towers and self-storage REITS appear to be less impacted by the virus in both the short term and long term.

Q1 2020 MARKET & ECONOMIC PERSPECTIVE

With the Fed Funds rate now at essentially zero, the only way they Global FIXED could move further is by going negative. While other central banks have resorted to this (e.g. Japan), the INCOME results haven’t been promising and the Fed has stated outright this isn’t Fixed income markets experienced something they really want to do.The greater variability in outcomes than chart below details the Fed Funds is normally seen. Specifically, most rate since around 2005. As the chart fixed income outside of cash or shows, with a 100 basis point rate Treasuries earned a negative return cut, the Fed Funds rate is now at this past quarter. No spread sector zero, the same place we ended up was spared, with high (i.e. during the financial crisis in 2008- non-investment grade) spreads 09. widening the most. Even investment grade fixed income and municipal bonds, which are higher- quality, saw negative returns during the quarter. This appeared to be a flight to liquidity over a flight to quality as some investors took a “sell everything” approach in a rush to cash.

The following chart shows the yields for the 3-month T-bill and the 10-year Treasury bond at the end of the last five quarters. You can see the dramatic decrease in Treasury yields from 12/31/19 to 3/31/20. Remember, prices move inversely with yields. Municipal bond returns fell during the quarter, leaving some to wonder if municipalities represented a significant credit risk. Overall, the financial strength of municipalities generally improved after the 2008- 09 financial crisis and the muni bond managers we spoke with express they are not seeing any changes in most muni bond fundamentals; however, certain sectors like nursing homes, healthcare facilities, and airports could be impacted. Interestingly, at . Q1 2020 MARKET & ECONOMIC PERSPECTIVE

the time this was written, municipal bond yields in aggregate are now higher than similar Treasuries (on both a pre-tax and tax equivalent yield basis).

In these volatile times, it is important to remember the purpose of fixed income in a portfolio. Overall, we view fixed income as a means to reduce overall portfolio volatility, given that equities are expected to have much higher volatility. Even with some fixed income sectors having negative returns for the quarter, they still provided a dampening to overall portfolio volatility. Our portfolio’s focus will continue to be on high quality bonds with an emphasis on short to intermediate duration government and corporate bonds, where default risk is relatively low. For some investors, muni bonds are attractive for their tax-free income. Q1 2020 MARKET & ECONOMIC PERSPECTIVE

AUTHORS

mario nardone, CFA ERIC STEIN, CFA

Q1 2020 MARKET & ECONOMIC PERSPECTIVE your XYIS team

This information is provided “AS IS” and without warranties of any kind either express or implied. To the fullest extent permissible pursuant to applicable laws, XY Investment Solutions, LLC (referred to as "XYIS") disclaims all warranties, express or implied, including, but not limited to, implied warranties of merchantability, non- infringement and suitability for a particular purpose. XYIS does not warrant that the information will be free from error. None of the information provided is intended as investment, tax, accounting or legal advice, as an offer or solicitation of an offer to buy or sell, or as an endorsement of any company, security, fund, or other securities or non-securities offering. The information should not be relied upon for purposes of transacting securities or other investments. Your use of the information is at your sole risk. Under no circumstances shall XYIS be liable for any direct, indirect, special or consequential damages that result from the use of, or the inability to use, the materials in this site, even if XYIS or an XYIS authorized representative has beenALAN advised of theBRANDON possibility of such damages.MARIO In no event shall XY Investment MOORESolutions, LLC haveMOSS any liability to youNARDONE for damages, losses and causes of action for this information. This information should not be considered a solicitation to buy, an offer to sell, or a recommendation of any security in any jurisdiction where such offer, solicitation, or recommendation would be unlawful or unauthorized.