DOCSLIB.ORG

P. 1 Activity 2: Origin of the Species – Darwin's Finches

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
P. 1 Activity 2: Origin of the Species – Darwin's Finches THEME 2 – La Terre, la vie et l’organisation du vivant / 2B : Biodiversité, résultat et étape de l’évolution Activity 2: Origin of the species – Darwin’s finches English class related work: Charles Darwin - The Theory of Evolution – The Scopes Trial Darwin's finches (also known as the Galápagos finches) are a group of about 15 species bird. They are well known for their remarkable diversity in beak form and function. They are often classified as the subfamily Geospizinae. (use the video called “Evolution by natural selection” in the shared folder of your class, or go to https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s64Y8sVYfFY ) Watch the video one time, then read the text and answer the questions. 1. Describe the differences seen by Charles Darwin and John Gould regarding the collected birds. 2. Charles Darwin attributed these differences to different food sources available on the various islands. Can you explain why? 3. Why did Darwin conclude the finches must have evolved over time from the original mainland species? 4. Based on these results, can you give a definition of evolution by natural selection? Time to speak! Pick one classmate, and each of you will try to describe one of the following figures to each other. Your description must include the following items: - What kind of figure is it? (table, scheme, genealogic tree, graph…) - What is the main idea developed in the figures? (you can use numbers to describe it for example) Useful vocabulary: Finches (pinsons); beak (bec); slightly (légèrement); claw (griffe); mainland (continent); breeding (reproduction); to suit (pour convenir); p. 1 THEME 2 – La Terre, la vie et l’organisation du vivant / 2B : Biodiversité, résultat et étape de l’évolution The study of finches led to the development of one of the most important scientific theories of all time. In December 1831 a naturalist called Charles Darwin boarded the HMS Beagle, bound on a surveying voyage of South America. While the ship and crew carried out coastline surveys, Darwin was 5 free to explore the islands. In 1835 the Beagle arrived at the Galapagos islands, near Ecuador. What Darwin found there surprised him greatly. As well as giant tortoises and marine iguanas, Darwin collected and preserved a variety of different songbirds called finches. Upon returning to the UK he examined them together with ornithologist John Gould and made some fascinating discoveries. 10 The scientists observed that the birds were all similar to a single type of finch found on mainland South America, suggesting that these mainland finches had originally colonized the islands. However, the Galapagos finches were all slightly different from the original mainland species, and they were also different from each other. The finches on each island showed distinct variations in their overall size, beak shape and claw size. These differences were attributed to the different food sources 15 available on the various islands of the Galapagos. Some of the birds had long thin beaks, and sharp claws suited to catching and eating insects, while others had large powerful beaks suitable for cracking open nuts. Because of the distances between the islands, breeding between different species of finch was unlikely, and Darwin concluded that the finches must have evolved over time from the original mainland species to suit the conditions found on each individual island. In all, 13 of the birds brought 20 back by Darwin were identified as being entirely new species, all similar to each other, but with definite variations from their common ancestor. Darwin proposed that the variations seen both within and between the finch species arose by chance. Variations which gave any individual a competitive advantage made them more likely to survive 25 and therefore reproduce, outcompeting those with less advantageous characteristics. Darwin called this theory Natural Selection and he published it in his book “On the Origin of Species” in 1859. Evolution by natural selection is now widely agreed to be the most accurate theory to explain the origin and diversity of all life on Earth. p. 2 THEME 2 – La Terre, la vie et l’organisation du vivant / 2B : Biodiversité, résultat et étape de l’évolution 1. Describe the differences seen by Charles Darwin and John Gould regarding the collected birds. The Galapagos finches were all slightly different from the original mainland species, and they were also different from each other. The finches on each island showed distinct variations in their overall size, beak shape and claw size. 2. Charles Darwin attributed these differences to different food sources available on the various islands. Can you explain why? Some of the birds had long thin beaks, and sharp claws suited to catching and eating insects, while others had large powerful beaks suitable for cracking open nuts 3. Why did Darwin conclude the finches must have evolved over time from the original mainland species? Because of the distances between the islands, breeding between different species of finch was unlikely. Darwin concluded that the finches must have evolved over time from the original mainland species to suit the conditions found on each individual island. 4. Based on these results, can you give a definition of evolution by natural selection? Variations which give any individual a competitive advantage make them more likely to survive and therefore reproduce, outcompeting those with less advantageous characteristics. Darwin called this theory Natural Selection p. 3 .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Remarkable Nature of Edward Lear1
    The Remarkable Nature of Edward Lear1 ROBERT McCRACKEN PECK Senior Fellow The Academy of Natural Sciences of Drexel University Introduction Although he is best remembered today as a whimsical nonsense poet, adventurous traveler, and painter of luminous landscapes, Edward Lear (1812–1888) is revered in scientific circles as one of the greatest natural history painters of the 19th century (Figure 1). During his brief immer- sion in the world of science, he created a spectacular monograph on parrots, and a body of other work that continues to inform, delight, and astonish us with its remarkable blend of scientific rigor and artistic finesse. In 1988 the British government honored Lear with a set of postage stamps featuring four of his whimsical ink drawings. These included a self-caricature of the bearded artist flying on improbably miniscule wings and the wedding scene from his best-known poem, “The Owl and the Pussycat” (Figure 2). The affable Lear would have been pleased—and probably astonished—by his country’s philatelic atten- tion, but almost certainly disappointed by the Royal Mail’s choice of images marking the centennial of his death. He considered the illus- trated verse in his Book of Nonsense (1846), which ultimately earned him a place in Poet’s Corner in Westminster Abbey, a sideline to his more serious focus: natural history and landscape painting. The artist so feared that these flights of fancy would undermine his reputation in the scientific world that he hid behind the pseudonym “Derry-Down- Derry” until 1861, by which time his nonsense verse and illustrations had already won him a devoted following around the world.
    [Show full text]
  • Audubon and Others University Libraries--University of South Carolina
    University of South Carolina Scholar Commons Irvin Department of Rare Books & Special Rare Books & Special Collections Publications Collections 5-2001 Audubon and Others University Libraries--University of South Carolina Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarcommons.sc.edu/rbsc_pubs Part of the Library and Information Science Commons Recommended Citation University of South Carolina, "University of South Carolina Libraries - Audubon and Others, May 2001". http://scholarcommons.sc.edu/rbsc_pubs/30/ This Catalog is brought to you by the Irvin Department of Rare Books & Special Collections at Scholar Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Rare Books & Special Collections Publications by an authorized administrator of Scholar Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Department of Rare Books & Special Collections AUDUBON AND OTHERS a bicentennial exhibition of illustrated bird books Mezzanine Exhibit Gallery Thomas Cooper Library M~-JII!y, 2001 Among the greatest treasures of the antebellum South Carolina College was its set of Audubon's huge double-elephant folio Birds of America, published in parts between] 828 and 1838. Fewer than 130 complete sets, with all 435 plates, now survive. (On the original acquisition, by a one­ vote majority in the South Carolina legislature, see Davy-Jo Stribling Ridge, A Load of Gratitude: Audubon and South Carolina, ]985). The current exhibition, supported by the University's Bicentennial Commission, traces the development of bird illustration, to give a context for viewing Audubon's achievement. The exhibit i~ arranged chronologically, starting with European bird illustrations of the sixteenth century and concluding with Audubon and other 19th century illustrators. In addition to its main archival set of Birds of America, Thomas Cooper Library has a smaller group of Audubons donated by Miss Jennie Haddock Feagle (1896-1993).
    [Show full text]
  • 080052-20.005.Pdf
    ,{1leeuueyupey r{q 'u0liualle s,plr0,\aq] 0] ajtJplt^\ uetlelsnV ]0ssouanblun oql Fuuq0l padlaq.p|loM ]saMou, all] ul satnlus^pe slquo4 Buqlnsat suo]e]lsnllr pue suorle^resqo aql Sleui,Lleu pu8spllq u0 slloM pe1e4snllr,{lluacgruFeu ls0uaql }o aLu0s Jo.l0Llsllqnd puBloqlne 'plnOCurlol'j0 qlrrq aq11o frestariuue q]002 aq] slleu reo^ slql J0lDuru,tw?snd0rJlsSTt nIt 'k ohn Gould was born at Lynle, is rvith feeling ofthe purest a6ection England,on 14 September1804. As a thar 1... dedicaie this lovely bird to the child he moved with his parentsto memory of my late wife, who for nrany Stoke Hill in Surrey,and in this rural years hboriously rssisted me with her settinghe .rcquireda keen interestin pencil, accompaDicd n1c to Ausrralia,and cheerfully interested berscif in a)l my plantsand animals. In 1818, the family n.rovedto Pursurts. Windsor, where Gould's father was Arlival in Australia in royal gardens, employed the and Before Gould finished T'!rc Birds of young where Gould wasable to further Errrope,commenced in 1832,he turned his alreadykeen interest in plants and his attention to the birds ofAustralia.In wild creatures.At this tilne, he became 1837,he began.4 Sl,nopskqf theBids o.f proficient asa taxidermist,a calling that Australiaand tlrc Adjarcnt ldands atd, stood hiur in good stead throughout soon afterwards,The Birds of Anstralia his life. and thc Adjacent lsinads as a fully Gould's expertise in taxiderny illustratedfolio work. However,Gould undoubtedly contributed to his found that materialavailable to support intimate knowledge of bird anatomy, and perfect his sketches.He ftequently this project was totally inadequateand and his skill in selectingthe right pose checked the stomach contents of bird went to Australiahimself to accumulate for his many bird subjects.Just before specimens, and included any material for a completely new and his appointmentto the Museun of the undamagedinsects in his ever-growing most ambitious work, TIrc Birds of Zoological Society, he set up a collection.
    [Show full text]
  • Edward Blyth, Charles Darwin, and the Animal Trade in Nineteenth-Century India and Britain
    Journal of the History of Biology 30: 145±178, 1997. 145 c 1997 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands. Edward Blyth, Charles Darwin, and the Animal Trade in Nineteenth-Century India and Britain CHRISTINE BRANDON-JONES 11 York Road London SW11 3PX England Introduction Early professionals in the natural sciences found great dif®culty in establish- ing their social level and a steady income.1 The pursuit of science ± unlike other professions, such as law or medicine ± did not overcome low status, nor did it confer high status. Naturalists also differed from other professionals in that their profession did not usually generate income through fees: they required salaried employment, which in itself diminished their social standing. There was still the assumption that scientists were gentlemen of independent income. This resulted in the pitiful salaries that forced practitioners to take on more than one position, or to accept socially degrading side employment. Many naturalists, such as William Swainson, Alfred Russel Wallace, Henry Bates, John Gould, and Edward Blyth, found it necessary to supplement a scanty income with mercantile activities. Victorian society generally frowned on such activities and they could be easily held against a social marginal scien- tist on his uppers. This state of affairs led Edward Forbes to complain bitterly: ªPeople without independence have no business to meddle with science. It should never be linked with lucre.º2 This paper will illustrate the problems faced by early professional natural- ists, and the way in which they were forced to make a living, by examining the animal trading of the zoologist Edward Blyth, curator of the museum of 1 David Elliston Allen, ªThe Early Professionals in British Natural History,º in From Lin- naeus to Darwin: Commentaries on the History of Biology and Geology, ed.
    [Show full text]
  • Birds of America
    A GUIDE TO AUDUBON’S BIRDS OF AMERICA A Concordance Containing Current Names of the Birds, Plate Names with Descriptions of Plate Variants, a Description of the Bien Edition, and Corresponding Indexes by . . HISTORY OF THE BIRDS OF AMERICA DOUBLE ELEPHANT FOLIO BY JOHN JAMES AUDUBON, 1827–1838 OHN JAMES AUDUBON was born April , , at Les Cayes in the JFrench colony of Saint-Domingue (now Haiti) and died January , , at Minnie’s Land, his estate on the Hudson River just north of what were then the limits of New York City. He was the son of a French naval officer, Jean Audubon, and his mistress, Jeanne Rabine, who died shortly after giving birth to John James. When the little boy was six years old, his father took him home to France, where he was lovingly raised by his father’s tolerant wife, Anne Moynet Audubon. In , young Audubon went to the United States, and in , he married Lucy Bakewell. They had two sons, Victor Gifford, born in , and John Woodhouse, born in . Two daughters died in infancy. In , after various failed attempts to succeed in business, Audubon set- tled down to his life’s ambition, to paint every bird in the “United States and its Territories,” as he defined his own boundaries. Although he did not succeed in capturing every bird, the enormity of what he accomplished is staggering in its size and beauty. Audubon’s plan was to have prints made from his paintings, which he would sell on a subscription basis. In , therefore, Audubon made his way to Philadelphia, carrying his paintings with him in the hope of finding someone who would create prints from his work.
    [Show full text]
  • Remembering John Gould's Martyred Collectors
    “Sons of Science”: Remembering John Gould’s Martyred Collectors Patrick Noonan The Victorian era has been described as “The Heyday of Natural History” (Barber 2). It was a period of intense popular and academic enthusiasm for natural history that spanned the otherwise rigid divides of class and gender. Victorian natural history combined aesthetic, romantic and literary elements with a strong empirical focus on the collection and category- isation of specimens. For the elites and aspiring elites of Victorian Britain, the accumulation of vast collections of plant, animal and geological specimens from the far flung corners of empire also served as symbols of social legitimation, respectability and self-improvement. This emerging demand also created new markets and commercial opportunities for astute businessmen like the taxidermist, publisher and ornithologist, John Gould, who prospered by providing both physical specimens and published information to an extensive and growing list of collectors and subscribers. To supply these expanding domestic markets, Gould (like other natural history entrepreneurs) relied upon an extensive global network of collectors, correspondents and contributors. Bruno Strasser has observed that collecting was essentially “a collective practice,” with natural history specimens “travelling as gifts along social networks [as well as] . commodities that were purchased and distributed through commercial networks” (313). Being located at the centre of these networks, Gould and the other patrons and interpreters of Imperial science unquestioningly assumed a critical role as the definers, arbiters and namers of new species within their particular fields of expertise. The grand ambition of Victorian natural historians was nothing less than to document and classify “the entirety of nature” (Farber 51), and this bold task required a ceaseless supply of new and exotic species.
    [Show full text]
  • Elizabeth Gould Melissa Ashley
    ELIZABETH GOULD MELISSA ASHLEY n the morning of May 16, 1838, the hazy Lon- don skyline in darkness, Elizabeth Gould went O into the bedroom of her daughters, Louisa, six Elizabeth months, and Eliza, a toddler, and kissed them in their sleep. She crept into the adjacent room to farewell her son, Charles, aged four, who in the following week would be Gould sent to boarding school. Downstairs, drinking tea at the kitchen table and waiting to wish Elizabeth well, chatted A Natural History her mother and a cousin. During the next couple of years, these women would be entrusted with the care of Eliza- beth’s children while she studied the birdlife of Australia with her husband, John Gould. The Goulds were motivated to voyage to the colonies by the prospect of making ornithological history. John re- Cape petrel signed his position as keeper and stuffer of birds with the showing Zoological Society to become a corresponding member, the coveted title given to explorers like Alfred Russel Wallace, blood from William Swainson, Johann Natterer, and other far-fung feeding. adventurers. Despite more than ffty years of settlement, a Watercolor comprehensive inventory of Australia’s birdlife had not been and pencil attempted. For almost a decade Elizabeth and John had study by worked as a publishing team, producing seven collections of superbly illustrated hand-colored lithographs of birds Elizabeth from India, South America, Europe, and the South Pacifc. Gould. Elizabeth depicted the famous Galápagos fnches Charles Darwin had collected during his voyage on hms Beagle and “curious” novelty species like the toucan and trogon.
    [Show full text]
  • The Natural History of Edward Lear
    The natural history of Edward Lear The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters Citation McCracken Peck, Robert. 2012. The natural history of Edward Lear. Harvard Library Bulletin 22 (2-3). 1-68. Citable link https://nrs.harvard.edu/URN-3:HUL.INSTREPOS:37363352 Terms of Use This article was downloaded from Harvard University’s DASH repository, and is made available under the terms and conditions applicable to Other Posted Material, as set forth at http:// nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:dash.current.terms-of- use#LAA Te Natural History of Edward Lear Robert McCracken Peck lthough he is best remembered today as a whimsical nonsense poet, adventurous traveler, and painter of luminous landscapes, Edward Lear Ais revered in scientifc circles as one of the greatest natural history painters of all time. During his relatively brief immersion in the world of science, he created a spectacular monograph on parrots and a body of other work that continues to inform, delight, and astonish us with its remarkable blend of scientifc rigor and artistic fnesse. Tanks to the generosity of two discerning Harvard benefactors, Philip Hofer and William B. Osgood Field, Houghton Library holds the largest and most complete collection of Edward Lear’s original paintings in the world. Among the more than 4,000 items in this collection are some 200 sketches, studies, and fnished paintings devoted to parrots and other subjects of natural history. From April to August 2012 the Library will be exhibiting a representative sample of this work to commemorate the bicentennial of Lear’s birth.
    [Show full text]
  • Birds! a National Library of Australia Exhibition
    BIRDS! A NATIONAL LIBRARY OF AUSTRALIA EXHIBITION © National Library of Australia 1999 National Library of Australia Cataloguing-in-Publication entry Birds! Bibliography. ISBN 0 642 10706 8. 1. Birds in art—Exhibitions. 2. Ornithological illustration—Exhibitions. I. National Library of Australia. 704.943280749471 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The National Library of Australia acknowledges the generous support for and interest in the exhibition by the Canberra Ornithologists' Group, Nigel Lendon of Canberra, Graeme Chapman of Vincentia, and John Hawkins of Moss Vale. The Library also acknowledges the support of the following institutions: the State Library of New South Wales, the National Gallery of Australia, the Art Gallery of New South Wales, the Art Gallery and Museum of the Northern Territory, the Art Gallery of South Australia, the Museum of Victoria. Guest Curator: Elizabeth Lawson Curatorial Assistant: Irene Turpie Designer: Kathy Jakupec Printed by Goanna Print, Canberra BIRDS! 'So that the air ... should be populous natural world, their flight and birds we recognise, it equally reveals with vocal and musical creatures.' endurance also make them symbols passing artistic values and a of the human spirit. Their lives 'scientific' way of seeing which Giacomo Leopardi (1798-1837) seem to us numinous and eternal, contrasts strikingly, for instance, From James Thomson (trans.) and but they are dangerously threatened with Aboriginal bird drawings. Even Bertram Dobell (ed.), Essays, Dialogues and by our activities. today, a 'bird in the hand' is often Thoughts (Operette Morali and Pensieri) of Giacomo Leopardi. London: George This exhibition is about birds that held to be 'worth two in the bush', Routledge, [18—]. fly and sing in the Australian but the 'hand' of this exhibition is imagination.
    [Show full text]
  • The Monographic Literature of the Galliformes
    University of Nebraska - Lincoln DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln Paul Johnsgard Collection Papers in the Biological Sciences 1986 The Monographic Literature of the Galliformes Paul A. Johnsgard University of Nebraska-Lincoln, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/johnsgard Part of the Ornithology Commons Johnsgard, Paul A., "The Monographic Literature of the Galliformes" (1986). Paul Johnsgard Collection. 18. https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/johnsgard/18 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Papers in the Biological Sciences at DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. It has been accepted for inclusion in Paul Johnsgard Collection by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. i ".~II .' r I J THE MONOGRAPHIC LITERATURE OF THE GALLIFORMES PAUL A. JOHNSGARD Because of their extraordinarily diverse beauty and importance as sporting birds~ pheasants and their relatives have been the subjects of many of the world's finest ornithological books~ some of which also rank as among the most valuable from a book-collector's viewpoint. It is the purpose of this brief review to mention some of the landmark books or technical monographs dealing with major groups of Galliformes~ both from the standpoints of their informational contents and their relative availability or collector's value. Emphasis is placed on English-language publications, although a few important recent German publications are mentioned. Probably any review of galliform books should begin with that of D.G. Elliot, a wealthy American ornithologist who spent about 10 years in England, where he began his work on the first of two major ornithological monographs.
    [Show full text]
  • James Backhouse Correspondence
    BACKHOUSE RS.58 Presented to the Royal Society of Tasmania by A.J. Crosfield, 1933. JAMES BACKHOUSE CORRESPONDENCE 1831 - 1838 James Backhouse (1794-1869) was a Quaker missionary, of Darlington, and later, York, England. In 1831 he sailed for Australia, accompanied by George Washington Walker (1800-1859), with the financial support of the London Yearly Meeting. They arrived in Hobart in February 1832 and from then until their departure from Australia in 1838 they visited most of the scattered settlements throughout Australia. They spent three years in Van Diemens Land where they visited the penal settlements, reported to Lieut.-Governor Arthur on conditions and made suggestions for improvement of the prisons, chain gangs, assigned servants etc. They also encouraged the formation of benevolent services, such as the Ladies Committees for visiting prisoners on Elizabeth Fry's model, inspected hospitals and recommended humane treatment for the insane, as well as distributing religious tracts and school books. In 1833 they established a Monthly Meeting of the Society of Friends in Hobart and in 1834 the Hobart Yearly Meeting. In 1837 they bought property for a Meeting House in Hobart. James Backhouse also collected many botanical specimens and continued to correspond with the Tasmanian Society and the Royal Society. After his return to England, Backhouse published an account of his journeys as A Narrative of a Visit to the Australian Colonies (London, 1843) (See Australian Dictionary of Biography, Vol. 1.) The correspondence consists of letters addressed to James Backhouse and his companion relating to their missionary journey. Most are from people in official positions thanking the missionaries for their work, acknowledging books and reports, replying to requests for information or offering int~oductions, help and hospitality and also some discussion of religious matters and references to botany in which J.B.
    [Show full text]
  • John Gould with a Specimen of Count Raggi's Bird of Paradise, 1878
    Painting of John Gould with a specimen of Count Raggi's Bird of Paradise, 1878. ARTIST HENRY ROBERT ROBERTSON, 1839-1921 John Gould His Family and Life F ALL THE PROMINENT AND WIDELY JOHN AND ELIZABETH experienced ornithologists living in England Little is known about Elizabeth Coxen except that Oin the 19th century, the name John Gould she was born on 18 July 1804 in Ramsgate, England, became the best known. His humble beginnings the sixth of Nicholas and Elizabeth Coxen’s nine as a 13-year-old apprentice gardener in the Royal children. She was considered ‘an educated young Gardens at Windsor Castle contrasted greatly to so woman, with experience as the governess of a many other avian enthusiasts of his era who came prosperous family living in St James St, London’. from affluent families. Many of them graduated One biographer believed John Gould ‘had discovered university in medicine or theology and then the perfect partner to fulfil his publishing ambitions: chose not to follow their profession but instead to Elizabeth was determined, intelligent, educated, become amateur naturalists—in particular, active practical, obedient and she possessed the one ornithologists who lived a gentleman’s life. attribute he most desperately lacked, she could draw’. Gould met Elizabeth in 1828 and they were THE EARLY YEARS married in St James Church, Piccadilly, London, on AUTHOR John Gould was born on 1 September 1804 in 5 January 1829, both aged 24. It is on record that, Lyme Regis, a small fishing village in Dorset on the ‘In marrying Gould, Elizabeth entered a household GRAEME HYDE south coast of England.
    [Show full text]