DOCSLIB.ORG

Darren W. Schmidt Phd Thesis

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Darren W. Schmidt Phd Thesis View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by St Andrews Research Repository REVIVING THE PAST: EIGHTEENTH-CENTURY EVANGELICAL INTERPRETATIONS OF CHURCH HISTORY Darren W. Schmidt A Thesis Submitted for the Degree of PhD at the University of St Andrews 2009 Full metadata for this item is available in Research@StAndrews:FullText at: http://research-repository.st-andrews.ac.uk/ Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: http://hdl.handle.net/10023/829 This item is protected by original copyright This item is licensed under a Creative Commons Licence Reviving the Past: Eighteenth-Century Evangelical Interpretations of Church History Darren W. Schmidt A Dissertation Submitted For the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy St Mary‘s College, University of St Andrews 24 February 2009 ABSTRACT This study addresses eighteenth-century English-speaking evangelicals‘ understandings of church history, through the lens of published attempts to represent preceding Christian centuries panoramically or comprehensively. Sources entail several short reflections on history emerging in the early years of the transatlantic Revival and subsequent, more substantial efforts by evangelical leaders John Gillies, Jonathan Edwards, John Wesley, Joseph and Isaac Milner, and Thomas Haweis. Little scholarly analysis exists on these sources, aside from the renaissance of interest in recent decades in Edwards. This is surprising, considering the acknowledged prominence of history-writing in the eighteenth century and the influence attributed, then and now, to the works of authors such as Gibbon, Hume, and Robertson. The aim is, first, to elucidate each of the above evangelicals‘ interpretations of the Christian past, both in overview and according to what they said on a roster of particular historical events, people and movements, and then to consider shared and divergent aspects. These aspects range from points of detail to paradigmatic theological convictions. Secondarily, evangelical church histories are analyzed in relation to earlier Protestant and eighteenth-century ‗enlightened‘ historiography, in part through attention to evangelical authors‘ explicit engagement with these currents. This contextualization assists in determining the unique qualities of evangelical interpretations. Is there, then, evidence of a characteristic evangelical perspective on church history? An examination of this neglected area illumines patterns and particulars of evangelicals‘ historical thought, and these in turn communicate the self-perceptions and the defining features of evangelicalism itself. Findings support the primary contention that evangelical leaders made use of a dynamic pattern of revival and declension as a means of accounting for the full history of Christianity. Beyond displaying the central place of ‗revival‘ for evangelicals, these church histories demonstrate evangelicalism‘s complex relationship— involving both receptivity and critique—with Protestant and Enlightenment currents of historical inquiry. 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT ...................................................................................................................................................... 2 DECLARATIONS .......................................................................................................................................... 3 TABLE OF CONTENTS ............................................................................................................................. 4 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ............................................................................................................................ 6 ABBREVIATIONS ........................................................................................................................................ 7 Chapter One – Introduction .......................................................................................................................... 8 I. Scope and Methodology ....................................................................................................................... 12 II. Historiographical Background ........................................................................................................... 21 A. The Reformation ............................................................................................................................. 21 B. The Confessional Period ................................................................................................................ 32 C. ‗Enlightened‘ Historiography ......................................................................................................... 39 III. Evangelicalism and Revival ............................................................................................................... 46 Chapter Two – Church History and the Transatlantic Evangelical Revival: From Contemporaneous Accounts to John Gillies‘ Historical Collections .......................................................... 49 I. Contemporaneous Accounts ............................................................................................................... 49 II. John Gillies‘ Historical Collections ......................................................................................................... 55 III. Comparative Features ........................................................................................................................ 75 Chapter Three – Church History and Sacred Drama: Jonathan Edwards‘ History of the Work of Redemption ......................................................................................................................................................... 81 I. The History‘s Structure .......................................................................................................................... 84 II. Interpretive Details .............................................................................................................................. 90 III. Features .............................................................................................................................................. 110 Chapter Four – The Progress of ‗Iniquity‘ and ‗Godliness‘: John Wesley‘s Concise Ecclesiastical History and Historical Sermons ............................................................................................................................... 117 I. The Concise Ecclesiastical History ........................................................................................................... 120 II. Sermons ............................................................................................................................................... 139 III. Features .............................................................................................................................................. 145 4 Chapter Five – Evangelicalism through the Ages: Joseph and Isaac Milners‘ History of the Church of Christ ............................................................................................................................................................... 151 I. Preliminary Writings ............................................................................................................................ 153 II. Prefatory Material............................................................................................................................... 159 III. Interpretive Details .......................................................................................................................... 163 IV. Features .............................................................................................................................................. 192 Chapter Six – Evangelical Church History Reprised: Thomas Haweis‘ Impartial and Succinct History ......................................................................................................................................................................... 201 I. Newton, Haweis, and Gospel-Centred Church History ............................................................... 203 II. Prefatory Material............................................................................................................................... 208 III. Interpretive Details .......................................................................................................................... 211 IV. Features .............................................................................................................................................. 236 Chapter Seven – Conclusion ...................................................................................................................... 244 BIBLIOGRAPHY ....................................................................................................................................... 264 I. Primary Sources: .................................................................................................................................. 264 II. Secondary Sources: ............................................................................................................................ 266 A. Books ............................................................................................................................................... 266 B. Articles ............................................................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Evangelical Revivals in New Zealand, and an Outline of Some Basic Principles of Revivals
    EVANGELICAL REVIVALS IN NEW ZEALAND -----//----- A History of Evangelical Revivals in New Zealand, and an Outline of Some Basic Principles of Revivals. -----//----- by Robert Evans and Roy McKenzie. -----//----- Published by the Authors, in conjunction with ColCom Press. PREFACE Many years of experience in the Lord's work, and the relative ease of retirement from parish responsibilities, have provided both of us with the time to carry out a work of love in presenting to the public this history of evangelical revivals in New Zealand. It is an aspect of the work of God which we believe is of enormous importance, both for church and for society, but which has been widely neglected for many years. The research for this book has relied, in the first instance, upon our privately-owned library resources. The main public libraries to which we are indebted are the New South Wales Uniting Church Archives Library and the Camden Library of the United Theological College, both in North Parramatta, the Hewitson Library of the Knox Theological Hall in Dunedin, the John Deane Memorial Library of the Bible College of New Zealand in Auckland (formerly The New Zealand Bible Training Institute), the Moore College Library (Anglican) in Sydney, and the Alexander Turnbull Library in Wellington. We also acknowledge the help of Miss Ferne Weimer, Director of the Billy Graham Center Library, in Wheaton, Illinois. We have also been indebted to many individuals. Chief amongst these have been the Rev. Dr. J. Graham Miller, now living in Wangaratta, Victoria, Dr. Brett Knowles of Dunedin, and the Rev. John Thomson, now living in Nelson.
    [Show full text]
  • Revisiting Azusa Street: a Centennial Retrospect Edith L
    Revisiting Azusa Street: A Centennial Retrospect Edith L. Blumhofer n April 2006 North American Pentecostals mark the cen- Pentecostals the second largest group of Christians in the I tenary of an event that stands at the core of their myth of world, trailing only Roman Catholics. Such numbers are noto- origins. It happened in Los Angeles and takes its name from its riously difficult to verify, but by any measure Pentecostal location—Azusa Street, an unremarkable thoroughfare that be- Christianity has experienced notable dramatic growth. Was the came a byword to thousands of devout women and men who Azusa Street revival the source of the charismatic flavor of mingled with the merely curious be- much of contemporary world Chris- tween 1906 and 1908 at a modest tianity? Is the story line simple and building known as the Azusa Street one-dimensional—from Azusa Mission. There from mid-April 1906 Street to the world? Or was Azusa through at least 1908, revival meet- Street one of multiple sources of ings ran almost continuously. Along contemporary Pentecostalism? Is with traditional revival rhetoric about Azusa Street primarily a North sin and salvation, visitors heard ex- American story? The Azusa Street hortations to pursue heart purity and centennial offers a fitting occasion spiritual power. But more compel- to explore the import of a 1906 re- ling than the rhetoric or the hearty vival that has assumed a larger-than- singing and agonized prayers that life place in the collective memory filled the hours were the gifts of the of North American Pentecostals. Holy Spirit in action.
    [Show full text]
  • Good News Autumn 2013
    Autumn 2013 Good News Working to see what Christ is going to do in Scotland tomorrow! THE GLORIES OF CHRIST - HIS GLORY AS MEDIATOR ORDINATION AND INDUCTION OF MR DONNIE MACKINNON A DIFFERENT TAKE - THE MYSTERY OF PROVIDENCE NEWS - CAMPS, WEEKENDS, MEN UNDER CARE OF PRESBYTERY SEMESTER IN SCOTLAND - BLOG POST RPCS YOUNG PEOPLE ON GO TEAMS RP MISSION TEAM TO UGANDA RPCS 2013 REFORMATION TOUR QUOTES MAN TO MAN & WOMAN TO WOMAN Good News editorial ‘Good News’ is the official church magazine of the Reformed Presbyterian Church of Scotland and is published four times a year. The goal of the publication is simple, to inform and encourage those who are either participating or interested in the life of the RPCS. www.rpcscotland.org You can download it free from the rpcscotland.org And what you have heard from website. If you wish to get a copy posted, the cost is £10.00 per annum. me in the presence of many witnesses entrust to faithful men who will be able contents to teach others also. 2 Timothy 2:2 page 2 Stirling Reformed Fellowship One of the signs of a healthy church is the character, con- page 3 Editorial viction, and courage of its membership and leaders. One page 4 The Glories of Christ of the signs of a healthy denomination is whether it is, by the grace of God, entrusting the gospel to faithful men, page 5 Mr Donnie Mackinnon who are then called by Christ to teach others those same truths. page 6 Craig Scott in America For the past 150 years the RPCS has not undertaken this page 7 Reformation Tours task of teaching such faithful men.
    [Show full text]
  • GOD BLESS AMERICA! 1 By: Robert H
    1 GOD BLESS AMERICA! 1 By: Robert H. Lescelius www.peachtreebaptist.org The September 11th tragedy had an interesting effect religiously on our nation. It presents a good case study of where America stands before God. There was a display of patriotism and religious expression. “God Bless America,” almost became our new national anthem. It was sung everywhere, even at the seventh inning stretch of baseball games. We saw TV productions around the song, and we witnessed the amazing sight of our congressmen and women singing it on the steps of the Capital. It was on billboards and bumper stickers. “God Bless America!” The prayer expressed the desire that God protect and prosper the United States of America in the face of a new and formidable danger. This religious and patriotic fervor didn’t last too long. Polls revealed that church attendance, for instance, returned to the pre-9/11 rate in the weeks after. Yet it could be said, even today, that Americans in general want God to bless America. Politicians still end their speeches with, “God bless America!” What kind of blessing do we want? Generally, we can say that America wants the blessing of deliverance from the fear of weapons of mass destruction, hijacked airplanes and disrupted travel, vulnerability to terrorist intimidation, and a slumping economy. Positively, we would like to see America prospering economically and socially at home and the image of a triumphant America again recognized throughout the world. I would like to see these “blessings” myself. This is the blessing we want. But what is the blessing we really need ? The greatest blessing America needs is spiritual.
    [Show full text]
  • The Christian Church in American History
    1 The Christian Church in American History Through the 1930’s (Callao Christian Church, 19th-21st centuries) By Josh Stucki Restoration Movement Literature You may copy and distribute this book in its original state. 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS Pg. 3 – Chapter 1 – 1000AD-1802 “America’s Almost-Godless Beginning” Pg. 12 – Chapter 2 – 1793-1832 “Christians United by Going Back to the Bible” Pg. 20 – Chapter 3 – 1833-1859 “The Amazing Debates” Pg. 27 – Chapter 4 – Early 1800’s “Why the Restoration Movement Cut Ties with Denominationalism” Pg. 31 – Chapter 5 – Until 1863 “A Faithful Example: Racoon John Smith” Pg. 36 – Chapter 6 – 1866-1905 “The Civil War and its Aftermath” Pg. 41 – Chapter 7 – 1906-1920’s “The Birth of the Non-Instrumental Church of Christ” Pg. 45 – Chapter 8 – 1930’s “The Split with Liberalism” Pg. 53 – Bibliography 3 CHAPTER 1 1000AD through 1803AD “America’s Almost-Godless Beginning” America almost began godless. Yes, it’s true. But thankfully the Lord had another plan: It has always been His practice to use people, and those people who were faithful shut down some of the devil’s darkest moves in history. At the time of the birth of our nation, these people that God used were not Reformers. These men were not philosophers. They did not fancy themselves theologians, Doctors of Theology, or anything of the kind. Our church’s modern ancestry stems from a few brave people who decided to do ONE thing above all – go back to the Bible and the Bible alone. It is therefore these people through who we look back on American history – because it can accurately be said – that if these men had not gone back to the Bible – America would have very likely been a godless country forever from its birth.
    [Show full text]
  • April – June 2019
    The Bulwark Magazine of the Scottish Reformation Society APRIL - JUNE 2019 // £2 April - June 2019 1 The Bulwark Magazine of the Scottish Reformation Society The Magdalen Chapel A CHRISTIAN VIEW OF 41 Cowgate, Edinburgh, EH1 1JR Tel: 0131 220 1450 Email: [email protected] www.scottishreformationsociety.org Registered charity: SC007755 THE FIRST Chairman Committee Members » Rev Kenneth Macdonald » Rev Maurice Roberts WORLD WaR Vice-Chairman » Rev Alasdair Macleod » Mr Allan McCulloch Part II » Mr Matthew Vogan Secretary » Rev Douglas Somerset » Rev John Keddie Rev. John MacLeod, Portmahomack Treasurer » Rev David Campbell » Rev Andrew Coghill » Dr Robert Dickie CO-OPERATION OBJECTS OF THE SOCIETY In pursuance of its objects, the Society may co- (a) To propagate the evangelical Protestant faith operate with Churches and with other Societies and those principles held in common by those Churches and organisations adhering to This is the second part of a paper delivered at the whose objects are in harmony with its own. th the Reformation; Aberdeen Branch meeting on 30 March 2018. The first two sections were introductory and looked Magazine Editor: Rev Douglas Somerset All literary contributions, books for review and (b) To diffuse sound and Scriptural teaching on at the decades leading up to World War One. papers, should be sent to: the distinctive tenets of Protestantism and Roman Catholicism; The Magdalen Chapel 41 Cowgate, Edinburgh III. THE WAR ITSELF (c) To carry on missionary work among EH1 1JR 1. The war which was not over in a few weeks be over within six weeks. The Germans adherents of the latter faith with a view to [email protected] winning them to the doctrines of grace and to That there should be a war was not a did indeed get, rapidly, to within thirteen the fellowship of the true Gospel; complete surprise, because there were miles of Paris.
    [Show full text]
  • James Renwick Willson 1780-1853
    W&M ScholarWorks Dissertations, Theses, and Masters Projects Theses, Dissertations, & Master Projects 1987 "An Inordinate Sense of History": James Renwick Willson 1780-1853 Elizabeth F. Carson College of William & Mary - Arts & Sciences Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.wm.edu/etd Part of the History of Religion Commons, and the United States History Commons Recommended Citation Carson, Elizabeth F., ""An Inordinate Sense of History": James Renwick Willson 1780-1853" (1987). Dissertations, Theses, and Masters Projects. Paper 1539625410. https://dx.doi.org/doi:10.21220/s2-w8ja-5y68 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Theses, Dissertations, & Master Projects at W&M ScholarWorks. It has been accepted for inclusion in Dissertations, Theses, and Masters Projects by an authorized administrator of W&M ScholarWorks. For more information, please contact [email protected]. "An inordinate sense of history" James Renwick Willson 1780—1853 A Thesis Presented to the Faculty of the Department of History The College of William and Mary in Virginia In Partial Fulfillment Of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts by Elizabeth F. Carson 1987 ProQuest Number; 10627920 All rights reserved INFORMATION TO ALL USERS The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. In the unlikely event that the author did not send a com plete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. uest. ProQuest 10627920 Published by ProQuest LLC (2017). Copyright of the Dissertation is held by the Author.
    [Show full text]
  • John Howie of Lochgoin
    JOHN HOWIE OF LOCHGOIN HIS FOREBEARS AND HIS WORKS By D. HAY FLEMING & 6 FROM THE PRINCETON THEOLOGICAL REVIEW JANUARY 1909 N M iiiaiiiiDUUU2/7948* Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2011 with funding from National Library of Scotland http://www.archive.org/details/johnhowieoflochgl909flem : THE PRINCETON THEOLOGICAL REVIEW Volume VII January 1909 Number i JOHN HOWIE OF LOCHGOIN : HIS FOREBEARS AND HIS WORKS. Throughout Scotland and beyond it, John Howie has been a power for good for more than a century. Strictly speaking, he ought to be described as John Howie in Loch- goin, not of Lochgoin, as he was merely the tenant, not the that moor-land owner ; but the Howie family have occupied farm for so many generations that they are constantly and naturally spoken of as the Howies of Lochgoin; and of the many Johns in that family the author of The Scots Worthies is preeminently known as John Howie of Loch- goin. There is no certainty as to the precise year, not even as to the precise century, in which the Howie's first went to Lochgoin; nor is there any certainty as to the district or country from which they came. The origin of the Howies, indeed, like that of many of the oldest landed Scottish fam- ilies, is lost in the haze of antiquity. In one passage, the author of The Scots Worthies thus refers to the origin of his family "Our house had been very ancient in suffering for relig- ion; (some have said that our first progenitors in this land 1 fled from the French persecution in the 9th century)." It will be noticed that he does not vouch for the truth of 'Memoirs, 1796, p.
    [Show full text]
  • Covenanter Witness Feb
    Reformed eological Journal Volume 33 NOVEMBER 2017 REFORMED THEOLOGICAL JOURNAL Edited for the faculty of the REFORMED THEOLOGICAL COLLEGE Rev. Professor R.L.W. McCollum, B.Agr., M.Th. Rev. Professor W.D.J. McKay, B.A., B.D., M.Th., Ph.D. Rev. Professor W. Peel, B.A., M.Th. Rev. Professor W.N.S. Wilson, M.A., M.Th., Ph.D. Rev. C.K. Hyndman, B.A. Rev. A.N. Kerr, M.B., B.D., M.Th. Rev. E. Donnelly, B.A., M.Th., D.D., Professor Emeritus By EDWARD DONNELLY KNOX HYNDMAN DAVID McKAY Editorial address: Articles, books for review and correspondence should be sent to the Reformed Theological Journal, 37 Old Holywood Road, Belfast, BT4 2HJ, Northern Ireland. E-mail address: [email protected] The Journal is produced only in digital format which is available free of charge in multiple formats (PDF, Epub, etc) at http://rtj.rpc.org The Reformed Theological Journal is stored on microfilm at Widener Library, Harvard Divinity School, U.S.A., and is available for purposes of research. ISSN 0268 – 4772 REFORMED THEOLOGICAL JOURNAL REFORMED THEOLOGICAL COLLEGE FOUNDED 1854 Theological Seminary of the Reformed Presbyterian Church of Ireland 37 Knockbracken Road, Belfast, Northern Ireland, BT8 6SE Vol. 33 NOVEMBER 2017 © Reformed Theological Journal CONTENTS MARTIN LUTHER: HIS LIFE AND WORK by Gareth Burke . 1 FIVE TRUTHS THAT SHOOK THE WORLD by David McKay . 12 CIVIL DISOBEDIENCE by Norris Wilson . 22 ROMANS 7 REVISITED An exegesis and interpretation of Romans 7:7-25 by Kenneth Stewart . 31 TELLING TALES A Survey of Scottish Covenanter Historiography by David G.
    [Show full text]
  • The Great Awakening
    The Great Awakening The beginning rumblings of the First Great Awakening began about 1730 and continued for over twenty years. There is a phenomenon that has shaped America in the past more than any other event; they were called The First and Second Great Awakenings. Between them was a massive decline in the Christian faith. This was the waning. The return of the strength of Christianity is made evident by a study of both of these awakenings. An awakening is another word for a massive Christian revival. However, an awakening is a deeply felt and far reaching phenomenon. To call an awakening merely a revival falls far short of the mark. A revival usually affects those who are already believers. Generally, the progression is revival, movement, awakening. The revival affects the believers. The movement spreads the revival to many churches. An awakening affects entire communities and even an entire nation. An awakening increases interest in matters of faith. An awakening touches people deep inside and causes them to realize that they have a desperate need for God which leads them to experience God in ways that they had not known. Out of an awakening comes whole new religious movements and groups or denominations. In the First Great Awakening many cried out, some fell down, or fainted, some seemed to have fits. There was a great concern for the individual’s soul. The concern for one’s soul seemed to spread from one person to another almost by contact. Just the reports of what was shared in the public meetings brought to the listeners a great concern for their own souls.
    [Show full text]
  • Tenets of Wesleyan Evangelical Revival in Mainline Protestant Churches in Nigeria
    Sociology and Anthropology 6(12): 855-867, 2018 http://www.hrpub.org DOI: 10.13189/sa.2018.061201 Tenets of Wesleyan Evangelical Revival in Mainline Protestant Churches in Nigeria Eugene Ikechukwu Ukaoha1,2 1Department of Religion and Cultural Studies, University of Nigeria, Nsukka, Nigeria 2West Africa Theological Seminary, Lagos, Nigeria Copyright©2018 by authors, all rights reserved. Authors agree that this article remains permanently open access under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0 International License Abstract This paper focuses on the Wesleyan Century England and America was the precursor of the Evangelical Revival, which is the precursor of the mainline Protestant mission churches in Nigeria. According to Protestant Missions in Nigeria. The main purpose of this Achunike [1], “Wesley is the spiritual and intellectual work is to examine how the mainline Protestant Churches father of modern Holiness and Pentecostal Movement that in Nigeria align themselves with the main tenets of the issue from Methodism within the 19th century.”Achunike Wesleyan Revival. The study therefore employed the [1] stresses that Wesleyan theology is based on two crisis historical and phenomenological approach. Personal experience of Conversion or Salvation from actual communications or oral interviews and participant committed sins, and Sanctification or Cleansing from the observation were the instruments used. The main findings Adamic nature, the inbred or inward root of sin, which of this study among others show that: The main doctrinal Wesleyans variously call “Entire Sanctification,” “Second emphases of the Wesleyan Evangelical Revival are new Blessing,” Perfect Love,” according to Burgess[2]. This birth/conversion experience and sanctification/holiness of was the brand of Christianity transported to Nigeria.
    [Show full text]
  • Holy Spirit Movements Through History
    Holy Spirit Movements through History Study Guide Sam Hey Geoff Waugh © 1998, 2015 Citipointe Ministry College, PO Box 2111 Mansfield, Qld 4122, Australia. Renewal Journal Publications Acknowledgement: We would like to thank the contribution made by the staff of the Citipointe Ministry College in the compilation and development of this unit. This subject was prepared and compiled by Geoff Waugh and developed by Sam Hey PhD This book is adapted from material prepared for external and internal study. It is now superseded and replaced by more recent developments. However, it is a useful resource on this topic for your personal and group studies. Please contact the college to enquire about current courses. We value your positive comment or review on Amazon and Kindle to inform and bless others. Amazon: ISBN: 978-1726386517 Study Guides Signs and Wonders: Study Guide The Holy Spirit in Ministry Revival History Holy Spirit Movements through History Renewal Theology 1 Renewal Theology 2 Ministry Practicum See details on www.renewaljournal.com – free PDF available Renewal Journal Publications www.renewaljournal.com Logo: basin & towel, lamp & parchment, in the light of the cross 2 Flashpoints of Revival Expanded 2nd edition See www.renewaljournal.com 3 Contents General Introduction Subject Overview TOPIC 1 Introduction TOPIC 2 Movements of the Spirit in the Old Testament TOPIC 3 Movements of the Spirit and Renewal in the New Testament TOPIC 4 The Ante-Nicene Church and early charismatic renewal Monasticism and renewal in the Middle Ages TOPIC
    [Show full text]