1

IN THE HIGH COURT OF AT DATED THIS THE 17TH DAY OF JANUARY 2013 PRESENT THE HON’BLE MR.K.SREEDHAR RAO, ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE AND THE HON’BLE MRS.JUSTICE B.V.NAGARATHNA WRIT PETITION No.18860/1997(GM)

BETWEEN :

1.BIMAL DESAI Age:40 YEARS S/O.NATUBHAI H DESAI AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS OCC.PRESIDENT (OPERATIONS) DESAI BROS.(P) LTD., NO.51, SJP ROAD, BANGALORE-2 ... PETITIONER

(BY SRI M.G.KUMAR, ADV.)

AND:

1.STATE OF KARNATAKA BY ITS SECRETARIES (A & A.H.DEPARTMENT, HORTICULTURE FOREST ECOLOGY AND ENVIRONMENT, P.W.D. AND HOME) BANGALORE-1

2.DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF HORTICULTURE , BANGALORE-1

3.BANGALORE CITY MUNICIPAL CORPORATION BY ITS COMMISISONER HUDSON CIRCLE, N.R.SQUARE BANGALORE-2

4.COMMISSIONER OF POLICE(BANGALORE) INFANTRY ROAD, BANGALORE

2

5.BANGALORE WATER SUPPLY AND SEWERAGE BOARD, BY ITS CHAIRMAN NO.19, 6TH CROSS,VASANTHNAGAR BANGALORE-52

6.CONSERVATOR OF FOREST (BANGALORE URBAN) ARANYA BHAVAN, MALLESHWARAM 18TH CROSS, BANGALORE-55

7.REGISTRAR GENERAL OF HIGH COURT HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA BANGALORE-1

8.THE ADMINISTRATOR JAWAHAR BAL BHAVAN CUBBON PARK, BANGALORE-1

9.KARNATAKA STATE LAWN TENNIS ASSOCIATION BY ITS SECRETARY CUBBON PARK, BANGALORE-1

10.PRESS CLUB OF BANGALORE BY ITS SECRETARY CUBBON PARK, BANGALORE-1

11.CENTURY CLUB BY ITS SECRETARY K.R.CIRCLE, CUBBON PARK BANGALORE-1

12.OFFICE OF THE SENIOR GENERAL MANAGER BANGALORE TELECOM DISTRICT RAJ BHAVAN ROAD, BANGALORE-1

13.ADVOCATE GENERAL'S OFFICE EMPLOYEES CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY'S CANTEEN, OPP.OFFICE OF THE CHIEF ELECTORAL OFFICER BUILDING, AMBEDKAR VEEDHI NEAR OLD KGID BUILDING ANNEXE, CUBBON PARK, BANGALORE-1

14.HARIPRASAD PROP.CANTEEN, NEAR HIGH COURT GENERATOR ROOM AMBEDKAR VEEDHI CUBBON PARK,BANGALORE-1

3

15.RAMANAND PROP.CANTEEN, NEAR HIGH COURT GENERATOR ROOM, AMBEDKAR VEEDHI CUBBON PARK, BANGALORE-1

16.NANDINI MILK BAR NEAR HIGH COURT GENERATOR ROOM AMBEDKAR VEEDHI CUBBON PARK, BANGALORE-1

17.KARNATAKA STATE BAR COUNCIL OLD KGID BUILDING AMBEDKAR VEEDHI CUBBONPARK, BANGALORE

18.OFFICE OF THE LAW REPORTING COUNCIL OLD KGID BUILDING AMBEDKAR VEEDHI CUBBON PARK, BANGALORE 1

19.OFFICE OF THE ADMINISTARTOR'S GENRAL OLD KGID BUILDING AMBEDKAR VEEDHI CUBBON PARK, BANGALORE

20.OFFICE OF THE CHIEF ELECTORAL OFFICE AND SPECIAL SECY TO THE GOVT DEPT OF PERSONNEL AND ADMINISTRATION REFORMS OLD KGID BUILDNG ANNEXE, AMBEDKAR VEEDHI, CUBBON PARK,BANGALORE

21.GENERAL POST OFFICE BY POST MASTER GENREAL RAJ BHAVAN ROAD, BANGALORE 1

22.KAVERI FRUIT JUICE STALL OPP M S BUILDING DR B R AMBEDKAR VEEDHI,BANGALORE

23.KARNATAKA ELECTRICITY BOARD BY ITS CHAIRMAN K R CIRCLE, CUBBON PARK BANGALORE

4

24.KARNATKA FISHERIES DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION BY ITS CHAIRMAN, CUBBON PARK OPP CENTURL CLUB,K R CIRCLE CUBBON PARK, BANGALORE 1

25.DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC LIBRARIES INDIRA PRIYA DARSHINI STATE CHILDREN LIBRARY CUBBON PARK BANGALORE-01

26.KARNATAKA GOVERNMENT SECRETRIAT CLUB BY ITS SECRETARY CUBBON PARK BANGALORE-01

27.MADDUR CATERERS(PVT)LTD VISHMAYA BEG,RESTAURANT K.G.S. CLUB CUBBON PARK BANGALORE-01

28.OFFICE OF THE SURVEY SETTLEMENT AND LAND RECORDS IN KARNATAKA K R CIRCLE CUBBON PARK BANGALORE-01

29.OFFICE OF THE INSPECTOR GENERAL OF REGISTRATION AND COMMISSIONER OF STAMPS IN KARNATAKA K R CIRCLE CUBBON PARK BANGALORE-01

30.OFFICE OF THE COMMISSIONER FOR PUBLIC INSTRUCTION NRUPATHUNGA ROAD BANGALORE-02

31.DIRECTORATE OF YOUTH SERVICES AND SPORTS STATE YOUGH CENTRE NRUPATHUNGA ROAD BANGALORE-02

5

32.THE P W D OFFICES K R CIRCLE BANGALORE-02

33.YOUNG MEN'S CHRISTIAN ASSOCIATION(Y M C A) BY ITS SECRETARY N T ROAD(NRUPATHUNGA ROAD) BANGALORE-02

34.OFFICE OF THE INSPECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE POLICE HEAD QUARTERS NRUPATHUNGA ROAD BANGALORE-02

35.RESERVE BANK OF BY ITS CHIEF GENERAL MANAGER NRUPATHUNGA ROAD BANGALORE-02

36.KARNATAKA PRADESH FARMERS FORUM (COLD STORAGE) & HOPCOMS EMPLOYEES CREDIT CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY LTD HUDSON CIRCLE BANGALORE

37.REGISTRAR OF CHIEF METROPOLITAN MAGISTRATE COURTS (BANGALORE) NRUPATHUNGA ROAD BANGALORE 2

38.KARNATAKA STATE SPORTS COUNCIL BY ITS CHAIRMAN KANTEERVA STADIUM KASTURBA ROAD BANGALORE 1

39.H D F C BANK BY ITS GENERAL MANAGER KASTURBA ROAD BANGALORE 1

40.VISWESWARAYA INDUSTRIAL & TECHNOLOGIES MUSEUM, KASTURBA ROAD BANGALORE 1

41.VISWESWARAYA INDUSTRIAL TRADE CENTRE KASTURBA ROAD,BANGALORE 1

6

42.ANURAG BOOK STALL NO.4, KASTURBA ROAD BANGALORE 1

43.VARGHESE STORES NO.4, KASTURBA ROAD BANGALORE 1

44.CAR KEY MAKERS NO.4, KASTURBA ROAD BANGALORE 1

45.SAI SERVICE CENTRE PETROL BANK KASTURBA ROAD BANGALORE 1

46.THE FISH CANTEEN OF KARNATAKA CO-OPERATIVE FISHERIES FEDERATION LTD AQUARIUM COMPOUND OPP.QUEEN'S STATUE, CUBBON PARK BANGALORE 1

47.INSPECTOR OF POLICE CUBBON PARK POLICE STATION KASTURBA ROAD BANGALORE 1

48.BANGALORE DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY REP. BY ITS COMMISSIONER SANKEY ROAD, BANGALORE ... RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI R.DEVDAS, AGA FOR R1, 2, 4-8, 18-20, 24-25, 28-32, 34, 37, 38 & R47, SRI Y.HARIPRASAD, CGC FOR R12, SRI R.SUBRAMANYA, ADV. FOR M/S.ASHOK HARNAHALLI ASSTS., FOR R3, SRI S.N.KESHAVAMURTHY, ADV. FOR R5, SRI S.N.MURTHY & SOMASHEKAR, ADV. FOR R9, SRI B.E.KOTIAN & G.SUKUMARAN, SRI H.JAYARAMASHETTY A. NANCY PRINCE, ADV. FOR R-10, 33 AND R45, M/S.SUNDARAMURTHY & SUNDAR MURTHY, ADV. FOR R11, SRI H.C.BETSUR, ADV. FOR R17, SRI S.S.SRIPATHY, ADV. FOR R24, SRI MALLIKARJUN S. ADAGAL, ADV. FOR R26 & 27, M/S.SAWANTH & SAWANTH FOR I.A.I, VYASARAO K.S. & B.L.ACHARYA & M.SUDHAKAR PAI, ADV. FOR R14, RAVI & RAVI, M.C.RAVIKUMAR & H.S.MOHAN KRISHNA, ADV. FOR R16, SRI UDAY HOLLA, MAYA HOLLA, V.R.HEGDE, S.V.BHAT, N.RAJANNA,

7

K.M.BALASUMBRAMANY, ADV. FOR R15, M/S.KASTURI ASSTS., K.MOHAN KUMAR, K.SUBHA ANANTHI, NATARAJ BALLAL, ADV. FOR R35, SRI R.MALLIKARJUN, ADV. FOR M/S.HEGDE ASSTS, ADV. FOR R40 SRI ABDUL KHADAR, ADV. FOR R48. R21, 22, 36, 39, 42, 43, 41 ARE SD)

THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO RESTRAIN ALL THE R-7 TO 46 FROM DUMPING GARBAGE, PAPER, FILTH, DIRT ETC., OR COMMITTING NUISANCES ETC., IN CUBBON PARK AREA, IN ANY MATTER AND DIRECT THE R- 1, 2, 3, 4 AND 47 TO PERMANENTLY BAN AND PREVENT HAWAKING OF ANY KIND IN THE CUBBON PARK AREA, AS IT BEING A NO HAWKING ZONE AND ETC.,

THIS WRIT PETITION COMING ON FOR ORDERS THIS DAY, ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MADE THE FOLLOWING:

ORDER

K.SREEDHAR RAO, Ag.C.J. (Oral) :

I.As.I/12 and II/12 are filed to recall the order dated

15.12.2011 by which order, the present writ petition was

dismissed. Office objections in IAs are not complied with.

However, a memo has been filed to dismiss the writ petition

as having become infructuous.

2. In view of the memo, the Writ Petition is dismissed as

having become infructuous.

Sd/- ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE

Sd/- JUDGE Sk/-