DOCSLIB.ORG

Arranged Marriage: Clashing Cultures Or Violating Virtues? By: Sinead Schouten

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Arranged Marriage: Clashing Cultures Or Violating Virtues? By: Sinead Schouten Arranged Marriage: Clashing Cultures or Violating Virtues? By: Sinead Schouten The headline screams at you from the newspaper atop of the kitchen table. “Father sells teen daughter into marriage for cash, beer, meat!” it blares. “He faces felony charges!” Right away, most people would respond in the same manner. How cruel! How unjust! We’re outraged! This so isn’t America, it begs you to read more. The very act is so old-fashioned, primitive. Who would be foolish enough to pull off such a stunt in our modern society? The thing is, this happened in real life. And you’ve most likely heard of this local case not so far from our little Paso Robles. A man in Salinas sold his daughter for the accused “price”. (CNN) Just it wasn’t until you read further in the article that you realized the truth of the situation. Apparently this man was from one of the native culture in Mexico. No, not Mexican, but rather a little tribe that knew little about American laws and values. He married away this little girl to a man in whom she returned the interest. The beer and meat? For the reception. When his future son-in-law never held up his end of the deal with paying up the money, the man had gone to the police to sort it out. Irony struck, and he himself, along with the son-in-law, were brought under arrest. (CNN) It is moments like these where it is hard to ignore the bias the media holds for topics like this. The title leads the thinking that this is a matter of disgust, feeding into the image already in the populace’s heads. It is unfair the predisposition the West has to things like arranged marriage, for there is much more than the side we are most aware of. The definition of an arranged marriage is simple: “Arranged marriage (also called prearranged marriage) is a marriage arranged by someone other than the couple getting wedded, curtailing or avoiding the process of courtship.” (Wikipedia) There are three main types of arranged marriage: forced marriage, child marriage, and “shotgun” marriage. Forced marriage is family or community influenced. Child marriages are economic or politically influence, and shotgun weddings are because of sexual reasons. The Old Testament also talks about arranged marriage. Arranged marriage were to avoid premarital sex. If a girl’s virginity was taken away before marriage, the man who did it to her would either have to marry her or pay a fine. This was because lost virginity was a bad “selling point”, making another man not as willing to wed her. The family honor would also be soiled, and even more shame would be brought about if a child was born out of wedlock. It was essential to marry off the child before they were tempted and any of this happened. (Wikipedia) In Eastern Culture, arranged marriage is a very common and accepted thing. (Kali)There is motivation behind it as well. For one, arranged a marriage for your child is considered a parental duty. If the parents fail in this they are considered incompetent. The will of the family is thought of as more paramount than the starting love between the couple. There is also an unofficial age deadline that people hope to marry off their children by. If the parents to not meet this deadline, then the community might start to wonder if either the parents can’t do their job, or if there is something wrong with their child. The family and the family they wish to marry their child off to have their reputations at stake. There are other factors considered in matchmaking: vocation, wealth, religion, age difference, horoscope, medical conditions, clan links, height, language, dietary preference, etc. (Wikipedia) The statistics for arranged marriage are welcoming too. “Arranged marriages are often said to be more stable than love marriage since matchmaking is done on several levels of compatibility, instead of on a whim.” (Wikipedia) And the numbers are quite noticeable with “a 5-7% divorce rate versus the US average of 50%” (Seth) Perhaps the success of a marriage in both arranged and otherwise is merely based on the effort put into the relationship by both spouses. The West tells a different story though, being much more reserved on the subject. They see the main negatives of the issue. Some of the items are punishment, disinheritance, and possibly death. (Wikipedia) The punishment would be from the child not wanting to comply with their parent’s wishes. If they disobeyed and didn’t marry whom they were told to, they might be physically abused. Disinheritance is another reaction to pretty much the same topic. It is an insult to the family’s pride if the child turns down the couple that they spent their time fixing up for them, causing frustration. (Kali) That frustration might turn into being cut out of the family will or whatnot, or, at worst, your family refusing to acknowledge you. Death is, obviously, death. But usually in cases where things go to these extremes, there is more behind the story. Usually the family is in a desperate situation in which the couple must marry so the family can better themselves. In this case marriage is for the community, not the individual. The common Western viewpoint on arranged marriage consists of a main issue: infringement of freedom. We consider it taking away one of the most basic of our human choices, choosing who we want to love, and taking it away seems outrageous. (Kali) But the, we must think. Is this really an issue of humanity and taking away our primal rights? Or is it mainly a cultural issue that we must overcome? Seeing how other peoples have managed to accept it, we just go with the latter. It appears more of a way of life issue rather than that of being a human. All in all, things seem to be more a clash of cultures and not an issue of ethics. There are there reasons for arranged marriage, including social issues like poverty that have to be addressed. Life in the East is so different from that in the West that it is near impossible to compare. Not only are reasons for marriage not the same but the very expectations are so drastically different. People get married for different reasons than they do here in the West. Yes, love is a factor, but it is rather a benefit that comes with companionship afterwards. Westerners’ pictures of marriage orbit around romance, seeing how we don’t have the same social pressures. Understanding this fact, it is best that we acknowledge our cultural differences and except them. Let our society function as it may. But understand there is the possibility of love and freedom just as much on the other side of the world. BIBLIOGRAPHY ATTACHED > .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Arranged Marriages: an Inappropriate Fabrication
    Mako: NSU Undergraduate Student Journal Volume 2020 Spring Article 1 February 2020 Arranged Marriages: An Inappropriate Fabrication Karika Sethi Nova Southeastern University Michael D. Reiter Nova Southeastern University, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://nsuworks.nova.edu/mako Part of the Arts and Humanities Commons, Business Commons, Education Commons, Engineering Commons, Life Sciences Commons, Medicine and Health Sciences Commons, Physical Sciences and Mathematics Commons, and the Social and Cultural Anthropology Commons Recommended Citation Sethi, Karika and Reiter, Michael D. (2020) "Arranged Marriages: An Inappropriate Fabrication," Mako: NSU Undergraduate Student Journal: Vol. 2020 , Article 1. Available at: https://nsuworks.nova.edu/mako/vol2020/iss1/1 This Essay is brought to you for free and open access by NSUWorks. It has been accepted for inclusion in Mako: NSU Undergraduate Student Journal by an authorized editor of NSUWorks. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Sethi and Reiter: Arranged Marriages: An Inappropriate Fabrication Running head: ARRANGED MARRIAGES Arranged Marriages: An Inappropriate Fabrication Karika Sethi Nova Southeastern University Published by NSUWorks, 1 Mako: NSU Undergraduate Student Journal, Vol. 2020 [], Art. 1 ARRANGED MARRIAGES 2 Abstract This paper explores what an inappropriate relationship is and the taxonomy scale used to evaluate different relationships, specifically, arranged marriages. Arranged marriage is a topic that is considered taboo depending on global location. It is more prevalent in Eastern nations such as India, China, Oriental countries, and the Middle East. However, Western influence plays a significant role on what is and is not acceptable, as societal norms differ from place to place. What is defined as normal by culture is what helps to define if a relationship is or is not viewed as inappropriate.
    [Show full text]
  • (Arranged) Marriage: an Autoethnographical Exploration of a Modern Practice
    TCNJ JOURNAL OF STUDENT SCHOLARSHIP VOLUME XXII APRIL 2020 FIRST COMES (ARRANGED) MARRIAGE: AN AUTOETHNOGRAPHICAL EXPLORATION OF A MODERN PRACTICE Author: Dian Babu Faculty Sponsor: John Landreau Department of Women’s, Gender, and Sexuality Studies ABSTRACT This article uses autoethnography and family interviews to analyze the modern cultural practice of arranged marriage from my standpoint as a first generation Indian-American. Borrowing from Donna Haraway’s notion of situated knowledge, Edward Said’s theory of Orientalism, and W.E.B. Du Bois’ concept of double consciousness, this article presents the idea of immigrant consciousness and precedes to contend with the sociocultural circumstances, such as transnational migration, assimilation, and racism-classism, that have prompted the evolution of a modern iteration of arranged marriage. The central question that informs this paper is what does arranged marriage mean – and how can it be defended and/or criticized – in different circumstances and from different standpoints in the transnational South Asian context? INTRODUCTION Dating is foreign to me. Is that strange to hear? Let me qualify that statement: American dating is foreign to me. I am a first-generation Indian-American, Christian girl. I am the child of parents who immigrated from India to the United States and who were brought together through an arranged marriage. The practice of arranged marriage runs through most of my family history and dating is a relatively new practice to us collectively. Important to note, however, is that my family members’ individual histories, like all histories, do not run on one generalized path. I have family members who never married, who remarried, who had forced marriages, who had “love marriages,” who married young, who married non- Indian people, who divorced, and so on and so forth.
    [Show full text]
  • Position Paper on Forced Marriage Analysis of Arranged Marriage As Practiced in Jewish Communities
    8th February 2021 Position Paper on Forced Marriage Analysis of Arranged Marriage as Practiced in Jewish Communities Forward The shidduch system of arranged marriage as practised in the Charedi (also known as Ultra-Orthodox) part of the Jewish community has worked for many people in a range of Charedi communities. It has brought joy, satisfaction and belonging to many Jewish couples and enriched their lives. This paper is written for people using the shidduch system of arranged marriage. This paper is also written for the Jewish community, including Jewish community organisations, and as well as those working in the wider VAWG sector. We seek to explain our concerns with some aspects of the shidduch system, and to demonstrate that elements of the shidduch system can create social pressure and coercion to marry, inhibiting a person’s capacity to consent to a marriage. We call on various agencies of the UK Government and other organisations to implement our recommendations. We explore how social pressures can fit with the term “Forced Marriage” as defined in UK legislation. We write as observant Jews, and we have undertaken this work to reduce the harms inflicted on individuals in our community. We are confident that our community has the confidence to consider our recommendations with nuanced reflection. Dozens of people have given freely of their time to help with the shaping and editing of this paper. Rabbis, academics, VAWG sector professionals, specialists in education, legal scholars, and advocates. We thank you all. We are indebted to those who have trusted us with their stories, without which this paper would have no soul.
    [Show full text]
  • Chinese Marriage Traditions: Exploring Contemporary Changes
    Lund University Department of Sociology BIDS Chinese Marriage Traditions: Exploring Contemporary Changes Author: YueYi Qiu Bachelor Thesis: UTVK03, 15 hp Spring Term 2013 Tutor: Axel Fredholm 1 Abstract Author: YueYi Qiu Title: Chinese Marriage Traditions: Exploring Contemporary Changes Bachelor Thesis: UTVK03, 15 hp Tutor: Axel Fredholm Department of Sociology / BIDS ST 13 This thesis presents the transitions of Chinese people’s marriage concepts from before 1949 up to 1978 and explores the new marriage concepts now. The analysis part includes the high rates of divorce, left-over women and the bride price in China. I will mainly discuss why nowadays Chinese people have difficulties getting married, especially Chinese men. This analysis is based on two main theories; one is social exchange and another one is marriage squeeze. The analysis is based on the expensive bride price and how important it is for Chinese people especially for Chinese women. Key words: Chinese marriage, Gender inequality, social exchange, bride price 2 Acknowledgment First of all I want to give many thanks to my supervisor Axel Fredholm. Thanks to his detailed and professional guidance. From him I learned a lot. I also really appreciate his patience and encouragement. If without his help this paper will never carry out. I also want to thanks to my dear friends Caitlin McDermott, Elin Lorentzson, Lovisa Lang, Madelene Trang, PengFei Zhang, and thanks for all the comments, help, good ideas, encouragement, and friendship. If without you all my life will not be the
    [Show full text]
  • Wedding Customs in Monsoon Wedding Judson Michael Edwards
    Wedding Customs in Monsoon Wedding Judson Michael Edwards Course: English 230 Instructor: Ms. Andree Cosby Essay Type: Literary Analysis Monsoon Wedding is a movie by Mira Nair “set in modern-day Delhi,” and falls under the interesting category of “Punjabi comedy” (Howe WE37). Nair herself is from Delhi, which has been a Punjabi stronghold since 1947, when Muslims left the city for the newly formed country of Pakistan (WE37). The storyline is based on an arranged marriage between the characters of Aditi and Hemant: two upper middle class Punjabis. Punjabi weddings include a great deal of ancient traditions, many of which are apparent in Monsoon Wedding. This analysis will cover the Punjabi marriage traditions that are most apparent in Monsoon Wedding. Their families prearrange Aditi and Hemant’s marriage. Although they have never met, they are not being forced into marrying each other. At the chunni chandana ceremony, Aditi’s aunt even says, “Give them some privacy. I met C.L. only once, we got married right away!” It is their choice, and they seem to be completely comfortable with it. They trust their families to make a good match for them because “family [is] an important factor in the selection of a spouse” (Kapadia 136). Throughout the movie, it is apparent that there is a conflict between traditional Punjabi customs and more modern western ones. In one scene, Aditi’s father, Lalit, and the wedding planner P.K. Dubey, get into a bit of an argument over the color of the wedding tent. Lalit wanted a traditional colorful Punjabi tent, but Dubey has already put up a western-style white tent.
    [Show full text]
  • Marriage Laws Around the World
    1 PEW RESEARCH CENTER Marriage Laws around the World COUNTRY CODED TEXT Source Additional sources Despite a law setting the legal minimum age for marriage at 16 (15 with the consent of a parent or guardian and the court) for girls and 18 for boys, international and local observers continued to report widespread early marriage. The media reported a 2014 survey by the Ministry of Public Health that sampled 24,032 households in all 34 provinces showed 53 percent of all women ages 25-49 married by age 18 and 21 percent by age 15. According to the Central Statistics Organization of Afghanistan, 17.3 percent of girls ages 15 to 19 and 66.2 percent of girls ages 20 to 24 were married. During the EVAW law debate, conservative politicians publicly stated it was un-Islamic to ban the marriage of girls younger than 16. Under the EVAW law, those who arrange forced or underage marriages may be sentenced to imprisonment for not less than two years, but implementation of the law remained limited. The Law on Marriage states marriage of a minor may be conducted with a guardian’s consent. By law a marriage contract requires verification that the bride is 16 years of age, but only a small fraction of the population had birth certificates. Following custom, some poor families pledged their daughters to marry in exchange for “bride money,” although the practice is illegal. According to local NGOs, some girls as young as six or seven were promised in marriage, with the understanding the actual marriage would be delayed until the child [Source: Department of reached puberty.
    [Show full text]
  • Value Attitudes Toward Role Behavior of Women in Two Japanese Villages
    I I Value Attitudes toward Role Behavior of Women in erwo Japanese Villages GEORGE DE VOS University of California, Berkeley HIROSHI WAGATSUMA Kiinan University, Kobe, Japan HE recent accumulation of intensive data on Japanese rural culture has T revealed many regional differences in Japanese values and attitudes. Scholars concerned with Japanese culture are more aware that they must dis­ tinguish between what is broadly characteristic of the society as a whole and what is specific to smaller segments. The full range of variation, however, is still far from clear. The purpose of this paper is to demonstrate the value of using standardized projective tests, such as the Thematic Apperception Test, in studying inter­ community differences. Specifically, this paper reports results obtained by comparing TAT data from two Japanese communities in what is termed south­ western Japan. One is occupationally concerned with farming, the other with fishing. The over-all results obtained from the two villages are similar in many respects, but they also reveal certain consistent differences in attitudes con­ cerning role behavior in the primary family. INTRODUCTION: HISTORICAL COMPLEXITY IN THE CHANGING PATTERNS OF FAMILY RELATIONSHIPS IN RURAL JAPAN Japanese scholars (Ariga 1940; 1948; 1955; Ariga, et al. 1954; Fukutake 1949; 1954; Izumi and Gamo 1952; Kawashima 1948; Ogyu 1957; Omachi 1937) characterize pre-Meijil rural social organization as having two principal variant forms: a northeastern pattern emphasizing kinship and pseudo-kinship relations, and a southwestern pattern giving a greater role to communal organ­ izations not based on kinship. Although attitudes and values concerning the social position of women varied greatly within the northeastern pattern, they emphasized a relatively low position for females within a hierarchically organ­ ized patriarchal family structure (Befu and Norbeck 1958).
    [Show full text]
  • Romancing the Other: Non-Christian and Interfaith Marriage in Late Middle English Literature, 1300-1450
    ROMANCING THE OTHER: NON-CHRISTIAN AND INTERFAITH MARRIAGE IN LATE MIDDLE ENGLISH LITERATURE, 1300-1450 DISSERTATION Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of The Ohio State University By Jennifer Mary Gianfalla, M.A. ***** The Ohio State University 2009 Dissertation Committee: Approved by Professor Lisa J. Kiser, Advisor Professor Richard Firth Green Professor Karen A. Winstead ____________________________ Advisor English Graduate Program ABSTRACT This dissertation makes a significant contribution to postcolonial medieval studies by examining how fourteenth- and fifteenth-century Middle English authors use representations of non-Christian and interfaith marriages to enter a wider Christian European discourse centered around the threat of the religious Other. Because such marriages are not well documented historically in medieval England, my dissertation argues that their portrayal is not a reflection of actual practice, but rather a fantasy that allows these authors to engage actively in maintaining and defending the dominance of Christianity and the Catholic Church. As my readings show, these texts serve to bolster the Church’s campaign against non-Christians by moving this campaign to marriage’s domestic sphere. Marriage is thus not only politically important, as it enables alliances to be forged among kingdoms and nations; it is now also religiously important, as it becomes a means for the culture to fantasize about the extent to which Christianity can dominate. The texts I examine cover an extensive period of the later Middle Ages, ranging from 1300 to 1450; the period of one hundred fifty years indicates that authors maintained an interest in conversion as a consequence of marriage and suggests that this motif was pervasive.
    [Show full text]
  • Articles on Arranged Marriages Pros and Cons
    Articles On Arranged Marriages Pros And Cons Redemptive and heard Wade always sunburns apogamously and concelebrates his blackbirder. Lawrentian and tropistic interjaculatesMort always issued her dialog. pedantically and determines his obolus. Reflex and deferent Shep spyings, but Virgil petrologically Many families is chosen for visual contact or cons arranged marriages and articles on two The one on an extended family behaviors. You get family plan dear future properly. Being told us about open relationships all marriages since the pro: oxford university press, the values as well as a growing evidence that marrying. Not on arranged marriages are pros and cons of personal life partner may have been arranged marriages are shifting to be a calmer household. Pros and Cons in Single-Parent Families UniversalClass. Kim perry and cons of one can be worse off people marry the pro and kissing was the practice complain that are not have little correlation is. Top 5 Advantages and Disadvantages Of subject Marriage. Both of arranged, on the article for no need to rigorously linking to know the creation or other interactive articles and joint goals. Close friends and family accompany by bride saw the stupid to the bridal chamber where a probe of teasing is oven and tricks are played on the newlyweds. Many people rescue an arranged marriage measure into play first days of their relationship as deep it demand a business partnership. Human beings come to mortgage one pipe through the neighborhood in which does live, places they hot or houses of worship service attend. That families skip the home the articles on arranged marriages and cons of livelihood, be summed up our great little or password to deal with none of? Lemme me shelter in radio again.
    [Show full text]
  • Representing Immigrants in Unconventional Marriages Or Partnership BY: LAURA J
    Representing Immigrants in Unconventional Marriages or Partnership BY: LAURA J. DANIELSON April 2006 (Laura can also be reached at our London office) I. INTRODUCTION: As immigration practitioners, we are occasionally visited by clients who are in atypical or unconventional relationships, ranging from couples who are living apart, to those whose unions originated via mail-order catalogs, to those who are in same sex or transsexual relationships. Even conventional and traditional “arranged marriages” can pose obstacles in that proof of courtship is often absent. Obviously, not all of these arrangements will result in immigration benefits. This article will discuss each of these types of relationships and will offer suggestions on how best to proceed to ensure that the couple can remain together given the constraints of U.S. immigration law. The INA does not define the terms “marriage,” “spouse,” “husband” or “wife.” Case law has defined “spouse” as a party to a valid marriage that has not been legally terminated.1 A marriage is generally considered legally valid if recognized as such by the law of the jurisdiction where the marriage took place.2 There are two exceptions to this rule. The first, which is codified in the INA, is that no immigration or nationality benefits should accrue where the parties were not physically in one another’s presence at the time of marriage, unless the marriage has been consummated.3 As pointed out by Daniel Levy in his Immigration Briefing article entitled, “The Family in Immigration and Nationality Law: Part I,” this exception was designed to inhibit “mail order” or “proxy marriages.”4 Please note that consummation is not required except in situations where the parties were not in the presence of each other at the time of marriage.
    [Show full text]
  • Reading Across Cultures: Two Stories from Papua New Guinea on Arranged Marriages
    READING ACROSS CULTURES: TWO STORIES FROM PAPUA NEW GUINEA ON ARRANGED MARRIAGES DANIELA CAVALLARO University of Auckland 57 The issue of arranged marriages in a developing country may be a hazardous topic for a European to discuss. In her 1982 essay entitled “White woman listen! Black feminism and the boundaries of sisterhood”, Hazel V. Carby warns that Euro- American feminism often fails to comprehend the concerns of black women, due to its “Eurocentric (and often racist) framework” (1982: 226). In particular, Carby takes arranged marriages as an example of those family structures which the Western World considers “pathologic”, as opposed to the “Western nuclear family structure and related ideologies of ‘romantic love’” (215-216). The white nuclear family, Carby claims, is the measure by which other family structures are judged and often condemned by Western observers, who on the other hand ignore the actual struggles of women in developing countries (216-217). As a European woman lecturing in literature in Papua New Guinea, and interested in women’s issues, I initially found myself in the position of those Western observers that Carby criticized: faced with the existence in our own university community and in PNG at large of marriage customs I was not familiar with, customs that I considered a violation of women’s human rights, I would mainly note their negative consequences as reported in the local papers: low self-esteem on the part of women, abandonment, divorce and domestic violence. I also expected literary works, especially if written by women, to express their concerns with the customs and their desire to eliminate them.
    [Show full text]
  • Determinants of Marital Quality in an Arranged Marriage Society
    Determinants of Marital Quality in an Arranged Marriage Society Keera Allendorf Department of Sociology University of Illinois at Urbana Champaign 605 E. Springfield Ave. Champaign, IL 61820 USA Phone (217) 244-0811 Fax (217) 333-5225 [email protected] Dirgha Ghimire Population Studies Center University of Michigan 421 Thompson St. Ann Arbor, MI 48106 USA [email protected] Population Studies Center Research Report 12-758 May 2012 Determinants of Marital Quality in an Arranged Marriage Society 1 ABSTRACT Drawing on a uniquely large number of items on marital quality, this study explores the determinants of marital quality in Chitwan Valley, Nepal. Marital quality is measured with five dimensions identified through exploratory factor analysis, comprising satisfaction, communication, togetherness, problems, and disagreements. Gender, education, spouse choice, and marital duration emerge as the most important determinants of these dimensions of marital quality. Specifically, men, those with more schooling, those who participated in the choice of their spouse, and those who have been married longer have higher levels of marital quality. By contrast, caste, occupation, age at marriage, and number of children have little to no association with marital quality. However, while we identify key determinants of marital quality in this context, the majority of variation in marital quality remains unexplained. Determinants of Marital Quality in an Arranged Marriage Society 2 1. INTRODUCTION Marital quality is an important aspect of family life that shapes people’s health and well- being. Greater marital quality is associated with less depression (Williams, 2003), better self- rated health (Umberson, et al., 2006), less physical illness (Wickrama, et al., 1997), and other positive outcomes (Ross, et al., 1990).
    [Show full text]