Contributions to the Petrography and Geochronology of Volcanic Rocks from the Leeward Hawaiian Islands
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
G. BRENT DALRYMPLE MARVIN A. LANPHERE J- U.S. Geological Survey, 345 Middlefteld Road, Menlo Park, California 94025 EVERETT D. JACKSON } Contributions to the Petrography and Geochronology of Volcanic Rocks from the Leeward Hawaiian Islands ABSTRACT the Pacific lithospheric plate moves over a fixed melting spot in the mantle, now centered near the island of Hawaii, from which magma is Petrographic and chemical analyses of basalt from Nihoa Island, supplied. Most of these hypotheses predict that the rate of propaga- Necker Island, French Frigate Shoals, and Midway Atoll, all in the tion of volcanism along the chain will be a direct function of the leeward part of the Hawaiian chain, confirm that these islands are relative motion between the Pacific plate and the asthenosphere. This subaerial remnants of tholeiitic shield volcanoes similar to those that melting-spot hypothesis recently was extended to include the Em- form the principal Hawaiian Islands. Chemistry suggests that Gard- peror Seamount chain, which on the basis of bathymetry (Chase and ner Pinnacles may be part of the alkalic cap on a tholeiitic shield. others, 1970; Jackson and others, 1972) appears to be a continuation Weighted mean potassium-argon ages of 7.0 ± 0.3 m.y. for Nihoa, of the Hawaiian chain of shield volcanoes, possibly bent northward 10.0 ± 0.4 m.y. for Necker, 11.7 ± 0.4 m.y. for French Frigate, and by a change in the direction of motion of the Pacific plate during 17.9 ± 0.6 m.y. for Midway demonstrate that the ages of these vol- Tertiary time (Morgan, 1972a, 1972b). Morgan proposed that the canoes increase northwestward, continuing the trend of increasing Hawaiian-Emperor, the Austral-Marshall, and the Line-Tuamoto age away from the active volcano of Kilauea shown by the main chains were all formed by motion of the Pacific plate over three fixed islands. The increase in age with distance along the chain, however, "plumes" in the mantle that convect upward at rates of ~2 m per appears to be nonlinear. The results support the general hypothesis yr and that supply heat to the volcanoes and provide the force that that the volcanoes of the Hawaiian chain have a common origin and drives the Pacific plate (Morgan, 1971). were formed as the Pacific plate moved northwestward over a melting McDougall (1971) suggested that the melting spot results from spot in the mantle. Key words: Hawaiian Islands, geochronology, diapiric upwelling of mantle material into a propagating fracture. potassium-argon, volcanic chain, melting spot, Pacific plate, petrog- According to his model, the melting spot is not fixed but moves at raphy, chemical analyses, basalt. about the same velocity as the Pacific plate but the opposite direction. Recent paleomagnetic data, however, indicate that Midway Atoll INTRODUCTION was formed at lat. 15° ± 4° N., which is significantly south of both its The Hawaiian Islands lie at the southeast end of a quasi-linear chain present latitude and the latitude predicted by McDougall's moving- of more than 50 shield volcanoes that trends west-northwest ~4,000 spot hypothesis, but is not significantly different from the present km across the Pacific Ocean (Fig. 1 A). Except for a few small islands latitude of Hawaii (Gromme and Vine, 1972). and atolls, most of the volcanoes west of the island of Kauai are now Shaw (1973) proposed that the Hawaiian melting spot is caused by completely below sea level. Jackson and orhers (1972) showed that viscous shear between the lithosphere and asthenosphere. His model the alignment of volcanoes in the chain is r..ot exactly linear but that includes a thermal feedback mechanism that results in episodes of individual volcanoes lie on short, sigmoidal loci that may reflect ex- melting and eruption, and cyclic irregularities in the volcanic tensional strain (Fig. IB). propagation rates that do not directly reflect the over-all rate of On the basis of the relative degrees of erosion, early workers pre- plate motion. More recently, Shaw and Jackson (1973) proposed dicted that the shield volcanoes of the Hawaiian chain increase in age that the Hawaiian melting spot is geographically stabilized by a northwestward from the active volcano of Kilauea on the island of gravitational anchor — a dense, downwelling residium that is Hawaii (Dana, 1849,1890; Stearns, 1946,1966). This prediction has formed as a result of the shear melting process. been quantitatively confirmed by K-Ar age measurements One corollary of the general melting-spot hypothesis is that the (McDougall, 1964; Funkhouser and others, 1968; Dalrymple, 1971; ages of the volcanoes in the Hawaiian-Emperor chain should in- McDougall and Swanson, 1972; Doell and Dalrymple, 1973). crease to the northwest and north. A second corollary of Wilson's Recent hypotheses for the origin of the Hawaiian chain are based (1963), Morgan's (1971), and McDougall's (1971) hypotheses is on the suggestion by Wilson (1963) that the volcanoes are formed as that all of the volcanoes in the chain should be of similar (or re- Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 85, p. 727-738,4 figs., May 1974 727 Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/gsabulletin/article-pdf/85/5/727/3418286/i0016-7606-85-5-727.pdf by guest on 01 October 2021 728 DALRYMI'LE AND OTHERS Figure 1. (A) Index map of the north Pacific showing the location of the Hawaiian and Emperor chains. (B) Loci (curved lines) of shield volcanoes in the Hawaiian and southernmost Emperor chains. Crosses mark major topographic highs that are presumably coincident with major volcanic centers (after Jackson and others, 1972). Bathymetry is schematic after Chase and others (1970). (C) K-Ar age of tholeiitic volcanism relative to distance from Kilauea for the Hawaiian-Emperor chain. Circles are based on ages published by McDougall (1964) for Haleakala, West Maui, East Molokai, West Molokai, Koolau, and Kauai volcanoes; Doell and Dalrymple (1973) for Koolau and Waianae volcanoes; McDougall and Swanson (1972) for Kohala Mountain; Clague and Dalrymple (1973) for Koko Seamount; and Jackson and others (1972) for Niihau. Dots are data from Table 1. lated) type and chemistry; the lava must also be derived from the two samples from Nihoa and Necker Islands, respectively. K-Ar ages mantle. This second condition is true for the principal Hawaiian of 15.7 ± 0.9 m.y. and 16.6 ± 0.9 m.y. on two Midway samples, Islands, and although the other islands and seamounts in the chain obtained in a prelimina ry stage of this study, were: quoted by Ladd and appear to be shield volcanoes of the Hawaiian type, petrologic and others (1967), who discounted the data because of an apparent chemical data are too few to be certain. The models of Shaw (1973) conflict with fossil evidence; this conflict is discussed below. Using a and Shaw and Jackson (1973) also include a mantle source for the variety of rock types, Clague and Dalrymple (15'73) obtained an age lava but provide more latitude for petrologic and chemical diversity of 46.4 ± 1.1 m.y. tor Koko Seamount, 300 km north of the if the mantle is laterally inhomogeneous. Thus, the geochronology Hawaiian-Emperor bend. Ozima and others (1970) reported K-Ar and petrology of individual volcanoes in the chain are a critical test ages of 41.8, 40.4, and 21.2 m.y. on three volcanic rocks from Suiko of the general hypothesis that the Hawaiian-Emperor chain is Seamount, 800 km north of the bend. According to their description, caused by movement of the Pacific plate over a melting spot in the however, the samples are badly altered and the ages probably are at mantle and also are important in deciding between several pro- best minimum values for the age of the seamount. posed mechanisms. Petrologic data on the islands and seamounts leeward of Kauai are Jackson and others (1972) haveshown that the westward increase equally scarce. Palmer (1927) collected and desc :ibed flows and dikes in age of volcanoes of the main Hawaiian Islands is not linear. The rate of basalt from Nihoa and Necker Islands and La Perouse Pinnacle on of tholeiitic volcanism along the two most recent loci, which include French Frigate Shoals and concluded that these islands were rem- all of the volcanoes from Kauai to Kilauea, has been accelerating. nants of larger basaltic volcanoes. Chemical analyses (Washington Beyond Kauai, few age data are available. Funkhouser and others and Keyes, 1926; Palmer, 1927) and petrographic examination (1968) reported K-Ar ages of 7.5 ± 0.4 m.y. and 11.3 ± 0.6 m.y. on (Palmer, 1927; Macdonald, 1949) indicate that the samples col- Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/gsabulletin/article-pdf/85/5/727/3418286/i0016-7606-85-5-727.pdf by guest on 01 October 2021 161" 56' 161° 55 164° 42' 30" I64°42 00 23° 1 35' 1 00 NIHOA ISLAND NECKER ISLAND y Tanager Peak (- Millers Peak 23° ' Ail 3d 1 Z^' /1 Shark Boy \ ! (C Annexation Peal^^^y—S \ \L — ' \ 23° / 34' 30' „ Summit Hill / \ \ ^0.5 KM \ 0 0.5 KM 23? N 1 1 03) - J OCf B I 1 I66°30 I66°20' 166° 10 I66°00 177°25 177° 20 1 1 1 i FRENCH FRIGATE MIDWAY ATOLL s SHOALS V>s s f Tern lsland -^~~^ V !,'V'P" < ' ' 1 ! -.y—x < v \ S 23° - i / \ 50 1 i \ / i \ \ \ I i \ 28° \ ' \ ^ vJ" \\ 15' i! ; v ->,/\East Island V, \ ¡\ La Perouse » I'Vi \\ ¡ I ] Pinnacle \ O \ \ \ \ \ Vx ) 1 S / j 1 w\ \ o / \ \ / \ V ?<> / \ \ •è'7 \ \ 1 / <\? r\ 23' ¿i*-J L ' 11 40 — ? # 1 // , 28° 0 5 10 KM 10 1 i i jyy C 1 1 , ^ 1 Figure 2.