CHPLD Cover 14 Feb 08.Mdi
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Compact High Power Laser Dazzler (CHPLD) Case Study Table of Contents I. Executive Summary II. Body 1. Introduction a. Purpose b. Methodology b. Constraints 2. Background 3. Discussion 1 - CHPLD Chronology of Events a. CHPLD-related events and documents 2001 through summer 2005 (1) The first USMC DEW NLW expressions of need (2) The COMMARFOREUR expression of dazzler need (3) The Full Spectrum Effects Platform (F-SEP), a.k.a. “Project Sheriff” (4) Expressions of Congressional concern with USMC push-back on Sheriff b. II MEF Fwd Dazzler UUNS of 9 Jun 05 (1) II MEF (Fwd) Dazzler UUNS submission (2) 3rd Bn, 6th Mar LRNLW UUNS submission (3) II MEF (Fwd) UUNS follow-up communications (4) MCCDC’s elimination of urgency in fulfillment of II MEF (Fwd)’s UUNS (5) Renewed Congressional interest in USMC dazzler-related needs (6) MCCDC Force Protection Integration Branch NLW priorities (7) Air Force Research Lab best of breed side by side evaluation (8) MCCDC FPI preselects GBD-IIIC in spite of test data and II MEF UUNS (9) Department of the Navy (DoN) JAG law of armed conflict approval (10) Laser Safety review Board Approval (LSRB) approval of the GBD IIIC (11) I MEF (Fwd) continued urgent need for the CHPLD (12) NSWCDD Laser Safety Program (G73) testing of the CHPLD (13) NSWCDD and JNLWD dissemination of the CHPLD evaluation (14) Renewed I MEF (Fwd) efforts to solve the Dazzler need with CHPLDs (15) Northrop Grumman Corporation (NGC) “Project 208” (16) I MEF (Fwd) discovery that DC, CDI’s guidance had been ignored c. I MEF (Fwd) CHPLD-related UUNSs of Dec 06 (1) Small Unmanned Combat Air Vehicle (SUCAV) 1 (2) Mobile Acoustic Sniper Detection and Neutralization System (MASDANS) d. I MEF (Fwd) Compact High Power Laser Dissuasion (CHPLD) UUNS of 1 Dec 06 (1) I MEF (Fwd) CHPLD UUNS submission (2) MARCENT intervention on behalf of I MEF (Fwd) (3) 2nd NSWCDD Laser Safety Program (G73) test of the CHPLD (4) Presentation of the CHPLD to the LSRB on 16 Feb 07 (5) Independent testing of the CHPLD by Laser Compliance 4. Discussion 2 - Dazzler safety, effectiveness, and production considerations a. Dazzler safety and effectiveness considerations b. Dazzler production considerations 5. Discussion 3 – CHPLD Case Study-relevant activities a. Recent Dazzler press and political activities (1) Magazine and newspaper articles relating to dazzlers and CHPLD (2) 28 Jun 07 Senator Biden and Senator Bond letter sent to SECDEF (3) 30 Jul 07 CMC response to Sen. Biden (and Sen. Bond) b. JNLWD and MCCDC patterns regarding the handling of NLW requests (1) Long/Mid-Range Acoustic Devices (LRAD/MRAD) parallel at MCCDC (2) “StunStrike” Anti-IED proprietary information sharing by JNLWD 6. CHPLD Case Study Conclusions a. CHPLD Chronology Conclusions b. CHPLD Analysis Conclusions 7. CHPLD Case Study Recommendations a. Immediate USMC change recommendations b. Concurrent DoD change recommendations c. Proposed supporting legislation 2 III References a.1. Article – Tampa Bay Tribune (Lardner), 31 Jan 07 a.2. Article – Defense Technology International (CHPLD) (Axe), Mar 07 a.3. Article – AP - Marines Fail to Get Gear to Troops, 25 May 07 a.4. Article – Seattle Times (Mundy), 24 Jun 07 a.5. Article – Seattle Times (Mundy), 1 Jul 07 a.6. Article – Defense Technology International (SUCAV) (Axe), Jul 07 a.7. Article – MCCLL GBD-IIIC Injury Reports, 3 Aug 07 a.8. Article – Associated Press - CMC Admits Flaws, 3 Aug 07 a.9. Article – Inside the Pentagon (Castelli), 23 Aug 07 a.10. Article – AP - Pentagon Rejects Ray Gun Weapon in Iraq, 30 Aug 07 a.11. Article – Inside the Pentagon - UUNS Audit, 18 Oct 07 a.12. Article – World Politics Review (Axe), 20 Nov 07 a.13. Article - Government Security News - CHPLD, 26 Nov 07 a.14. Article – Wired - Noah Shachtman - How Technology Almost Lost the War, 27 Nov 07 a.15. Article – AP - General: Anbar Ready for Handover, 10 Jan 08 b.1. Book – Barnett, Thomas P.M. (05). Blueprint for Action. New York: Berkley Publishing. b.2. Book – Barnett, Thomas P. M. (04). The Pentagon’s New Map. New York: Putnam. b.3. Book – Bugliarello, George (03). The Biosoma. New York: Polytechnic University. b.4. Book – Christensen, Clayton M. (02). Innovators Dilemma. Boston: Harv Bus School. b.5. Book – Christensen, Clayton M. (04). Seeing What’s Next. Boston: Harvard Bus School. b.6. Book – Christensen, Clayton M. (03).The Innovators Solution. Boston: Harv Bus School. b.7. Book – Col Qiao & Col Wang (99). Unrestricted Warfare. Panama: Pan Am Publishing. b.8. Book – Friedman, Thomas L. (05). The World is Flat. New York: Farrar-Strauss-Giroux. b.9. Book – Kao, John (07). Innovation Nation. New York: Free Press. b.10. Book – Krulak, Victor H. (99). First to Fight. Bluejacket Books. b.11. Book – Kruzweil, Raymond (05). The Singularity is Near. London: Penguin Books. b.12. Book – McKenzie, Kenneth F. (00). Revenge of the Melians. Washington, DC: NDU. b.13. Book – Patreus and Nagl (06). FMFM 3-24 Counterinsurgency. Wash., DC: U.S. Army. b.14. Book – Small Wars Manual (40) - NAVMC 2890. Washington, DC: Gov Print Office. b.15. Book – West, Francis J. “Bing” (72). The Village. New York: Pocket Books. 3 c.1. Congress – Thornberry to OFT – F-SEP, 13 Jan 05 c.2. Congress - Snowe to CNR - LRAD, 20 Jan 04 c.3. Congress - USD(ATL) to Thornberry - F-SEP, 27 Jan 05 c.4. Congress – Snowe to SECDEF - LRAD, 18 Mar 05 c.5. Congress – Snowe to SECNAV – F-SEP, 12 Apr 05 c.6. Congress – ASN(RDA) to Snowe - F-SEP, 7 Jun 05 c.7. Congress – Larson to ASA(ALT) - F-SEP, 9 Aug 05 c.8. Congress – Sherwood to CMC - Dazzler, 26 Aug 05 c.9. Congress – Congress - Dodd to Army OLA - CHPLD, 30 Aug 05 c.10. Congress – Dodd-Larson to DoD - CHPLD, 10 Jan 07 c.11. Congress – USMC OLA to Larson, 20 Feb 07 c.12. Congress – Sen. Biden and Sen. Bond to SECDEF, 28 Jun 07 c.13. Congress – CMC to Sen. Biden and Sen. Bond, 30 Jul 07 c.14. Contract – [Customer Name Omitted] 9 CHPLDs, 11 Oct 06 c.15. Contract – USMC 28 CHPLDs, 11 Oct 06 c.16. Contract – Navy SEALS 1 CHPLD, 26 Mar 07 c.17. Contract – ATC 2 CHPLDs, 17 May 07 c.18. Contract – Navy-SAIC 1 CHPLDs, 27 Jul 07 c.19. Contract – ATC 3 CHPLDs, 17 Oct 07 c.20. Contract – DOS 26 CHPLDs, 28 Nov 07 c.21. Contract – Army 14 CHPLDs, 24 Jan 08 c.22. Contract – ATC 2 CHPLDs, 27 Aug 07 c.23. Contract – DEW 3 CHPLDs, 17 Oct 07 e.1. E-Mail – CG, 3rd MAW to DC, CDI, Apr 03 e.2. E-Mails – All Available Dazzler-Relevant E-Mail, 05 – 07 e.3. E-Mail – MCCDC message announcing Sound Commander decision, 24 Aug 06 e.4. E-Mail – DC, CDI to CG, I MEF (Fwd), 13 Sep 06 e.5. E-Mail – Exchange between I MEF (Fwd) and MCCDC on LRAD, early Sep 06 e.6. E-Mail – Ti Casazza to GCE Advocate S&T Advisor, 31 Jan 08 l.1. Letter – CG, 1st Mar Div to DC, CDI requesting Sheriff, 29 Aug 04 l.2. Letter – CG, II MEF to DC, CDI requesting Sheriff, 7 Oct 04 l.3. Letter – Director OFT to DC, CDI, 25 Jan 05 l.4. Letter – Eye Exams of LE Systems Employees 2005-2007, 19 Aug 05 l.5. Letter – LE Systems to CG, I MEF (Fwd), 24 Dec 06 l.6. Letter – LE Systems to CMC, 9 Apr 07 l.7. Letter – DC, CDI to LE Systems, 20 Apr 07 l.8. Letter – CMC to Sen. Biden and Sen. Bond, 30 Jul 07 l.9. Letter – Sen. Biden and Sen. Bond to CMC, 19 Sep 07 l.10. Letter – CMC to Sen. Bond, 21 Sep 07 l.11. Legal – DoN JAG Approval of GBD-IIIC & CHPLD, 22 Dec 05 l.12. Legal – Army JAG Approval of GBD-III, 14 Feb 06 4 o.1. Order – MCO 3500.27B Operational Risk Management (ORM) o.2. Order – MCO 5100.8 Occupational Safety and Health (OSH) Policy o.3. Order – MCO 5100.29A Safety Program o.4. Order – MCO 7510.5A FWA Oversight, Awareness, Prevention and Remedies o.5. Order – MCO 5800.13A Investigations of Allegations Against Senior Officials o.6. Order – MCWP 5-1 Marine Corps Planning Process (MCPP) o.7. Order – OPNAVINST 5100.27A/MCO 5104.1B, 24 Sep 02 p.1. Presentation – ONR Red Team Report, 18 Sep 04 p.2. Presentation – JNLWD-NGC Project 208, 6 Dec 05 p.3. Presentation – I MEF (Fwd) rationale for LRAD 500 solution, 28 Aug 06 p.4. Presentation – Draft DDR&E presentation cancelled by USMC, 13 Mar 07 p.5. Paper – MCWL Situation Report, 7 Jan 05 p.6. Paper – The ONR Green Perspective, 1 Nov 05 p.7. Paper – Penn State ARL AHD LMUA Final Report, 7 Aug 06 p.8. Paper – Naval Audit Service report on the USMC UUNS Process, 28 Sep 07 p.9. Paper – Five Examples of USMC Gross Mismanagement, Aug 07 p.10. Paper – NGC-AFRL-JNLWD HORNET, Dec 06 p.11. Paper – GCE Advocate MRAP Case Study, 22 Jan 08 r.1. Requirement – NLW UUNS, 18 Dec 01 r.2. Requirement – Laser Sniper UNS, 18 Dec 01 r.3. Requirement – GACAWS UNS, 13 May 02 r.4. Requirement – COMARFOREUR Letter, 18 Feb 03 r.5. Requirement – CG, 1st Mar Div Sheriff Letter, 29 Aug 04 r.6. Requirement – CG, II MEF Sheriff Letter, 7 Oct 04 r.7. Requirement – II MEF FSEBW UUNS, 14 Oct 04 r.8.