DOCSLIB.ORG

THE THIN LINE BETWEEN PROPAGANDA and PERSUASION Ryan Daniel Jenkins Southern Illinois University Carbondale, [email protected]

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
THE THIN LINE BETWEEN PROPAGANDA and PERSUASION Ryan Daniel Jenkins Southern Illinois University Carbondale, Ryan@Ryanjenkins.Org Southern Illinois University Carbondale OpenSIUC Theses Theses and Dissertations 12-1-2013 THE THIN LINE BETWEEN PROPAGANDA AND PERSUASION Ryan Daniel Jenkins Southern Illinois University Carbondale, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: http://opensiuc.lib.siu.edu/theses Recommended Citation Jenkins, Ryan Daniel, "THE THIN LINE BETWEEN PROPAGANDA AND PERSUASION" (2013). Theses. Paper 1322. This Open Access Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Theses and Dissertations at OpenSIUC. It has been accepted for inclusion in Theses by an authorized administrator of OpenSIUC. For more information, please contact [email protected]. THE THIN LINE BETWEEN PROPAGANDA AND PERSUASION by Ryan Jenkins B.A., Southern Illinois University, 2005 A Thesis Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Masters in Fine Arts Degree. College of Mass Communications and Media Arts in the Graduate School Southern Illinois University Carbondale December 2013 THESIS APPROVAL THE THIN LINE BETWEEN PROPAGANDA AND PERSUASION By Ryan Jenkins A Thesis Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Masters in Fine Arts in the field of Mass Communication and Media Arts Approved by: Antonio Martinez, Chair Robert Spahr Michele Torre Graduate School Southern Illinois University Carbondale July 29, 2013 AN ABSTRACT OF THE THESIS OF RYAN JENKINS, for the Masters of Fine Arts degree in Mass Communication and Media Arts, presented on *29 July 2013, at Southern Illinois University Carbondale. TITLE: THE THIN LINE BETWEEN PROPAGANDA AND PERSUASION MAJOR PROFESSOR: Antonio Martinez In this paper, I discuss the line that divides propaganda and persuasion in relation to my thesis work, The Thin Line Between Propaganda and Persuasion. My intention is to show how easily images can transfer between propaganda and persuasion. I analyze this division between propaganda and persuasion by discussing propaganda as one-way communication process and persuasion as a two-way communication process. Then I discuss my relationship to photography, graffiti, and how my own work furthers the conversation of propaganda and persuasion in relation to other artists. In the next section, I contextualize my use of the database in parallel to news media photographs. Following this section I write about the construction of The Thin Line Between Propaganda and Persuasion. I conclude with the importance of analyzing image databases in context to propaganda and persuasion and it's relevance to my thesis work. iii DEDICATION This work is dedicated to my Grandfather Ralph Jenkins and my Father Ronald Jenkins. Without there support and inspiration this project would not of been possible. iv ACKNOWLEDGMENTS I would like to offer my sincerest thanks to my committee chair, Antonio Martinez and committee members Michele Torre and Robert Spahr. Their commitment to education is an inspiration and without them this project would not of been possible. v TABLE OF CONTENTS CHAPTER PAGE ABSTRACT......................................................................................................................... i DEDICATION......................................................................................................................ii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ...................................................................................................iii LIST OF FIGURES.............................................................................................................v CHAPTERS CHAPTER 1 – Introduction.....................................................................................1 CHAPTER 2 – My Relationships to Graffiti and Photography................................4 CHAPTER 3 – Propaganda Vs. Persuasion and Socialist Realism.......................9 CHAPTER 4 – The Image and the Database.......................................................16 CHAPTER 5 – Constructing the Image................................................................ 23 CHAPTER 6– Conclusion and Future Work.........................................................48 REFERENCES ............................................................................................................... 52 VITA .............................................................................................................................. 53 vi LIST OF FIGURES FIGURE PAGE Figure 1............................................................................................................................ 17 Figure 2............................................................................................................................ 17 Figure 3............................................................................................................................ 18 Figure 4............................................................................................................................ 25 Figure 5............................................................................................................................ 26 Figure 6............................................................................................................................ 28 Figure 7............................................................................................................................ 29 Figure 8............................................................................................................................ 30 Figure 9............................................................................................................................ 32 Figure 10..........................................................................................................................33 Figure 11.......................................................................................................................... 34 Figure 12..........................................................................................................................36 Figure 13..........................................................................................................................37 Figure 14..........................................................................................................................38 Figure 15..........................................................................................................................39 Figure 16..........................................................................................................................40 Figure 17..........................................................................................................................42 Figure 18..........................................................................................................................43 Figure 19..........................................................................................................................44 Figure 20..........................................................................................................................46 Figure 21..........................................................................................................................47 vii 1 CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION The line between propaganda and persuasion is not only thin, but also transparent. Exploring this subtle difference between propaganda and persuasion is what drives my creative process. Propaganda and Persuasion are both forms of communication which impact one's thinking. Propaganda is seen more as a deliberate organized attempt to influence and mold one's ideologies to further the goals of the propagandist. Persuasion, on the other hand, is understood as an open communication practice with people wanting to have their wants and needs satisfied by the persuader. Working in collage with propaganda and persuasion as a central topic has allowed me to explore particular types of images from daily national newspapers, such as civil protest, the aftermath of war, and images of physical conflict. A particular interest I have with this type of collage is the tremendous database one can build from appropriating these types of images. It allows for the reworking of these images time and time again to see to what end I can dissolve the thin, transparent line that divides propaganda and persuasion. By dissolving this line it will help to better understand when outlets of media or in their like switch from persuader to propagandist. The Thin Line Between Propaganda and Persuasion not only critiques the distinction between propaganda and persuasion but how photojournalism's original purpose as a means of persuasion can transform into propaganda through the use of repetition. In this paper, I discuss the line that divides propaganda and persuasion in relation to my thesis work, The Thin Line Between Propaganda and Persuasion. My intention is to show how easily images can transfer between propaganda and 2 persuasion. I analyze this division between propaganda and persuasion by discussing propaganda as one-way communication process and persuasion as a two-way communication process. Then I discuss my relationship to photography, graffiti, and how my own work furthers the conversation of propaganda and persuasion in relation to other artists. In the next section, I contextualize my use of the database in parallel to news media photographs. Following this section I write about the construction and materiality of The Thin Line Between Propaganda and Persuasion. I conclude with the importance of analyzing
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Deception, Disinformation, and Strategic Communications: How One Interagency Group Made a Major Difference by Fletcher Schoen and Christopher J
    STRATEGIC PERSPECTIVES 11 Deception, Disinformation, and Strategic Communications: How One Interagency Group Made a Major Difference by Fletcher Schoen and Christopher J. Lamb Center for Strategic Research Institute for National Strategic Studies National Defense University Institute for National Strategic Studies National Defense University The Institute for National Strategic Studies (INSS) is National Defense University’s (NDU’s) dedicated research arm. INSS includes the Center for Strategic Research, Center for Complex Operations, Center for the Study of Chinese Military Affairs, Center for Technology and National Security Policy, Center for Transatlantic Security Studies, and Conflict Records Research Center. The military and civilian analysts and staff who comprise INSS and its subcomponents execute their mission by conducting research and analysis, publishing, and participating in conferences, policy support, and outreach. The mission of INSS is to conduct strategic studies for the Secretary of Defense, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, and the Unified Combatant Commands in support of the academic programs at NDU and to perform outreach to other U.S. Government agencies and the broader national security community. Cover: Kathleen Bailey presents evidence of forgeries to the press corps. Credit: The Washington Times Deception, Disinformation, and Strategic Communications: How One Interagency Group Made a Major Difference Deception, Disinformation, and Strategic Communications: How One Interagency Group Made a Major Difference By Fletcher Schoen and Christopher J. Lamb Institute for National Strategic Studies Strategic Perspectives, No. 11 Series Editor: Nicholas Rostow National Defense University Press Washington, D.C. June 2012 Opinions, conclusions, and recommendations expressed or implied within are solely those of the contributors and do not necessarily represent the views of the Defense Department or any other agency of the Federal Government.
    [Show full text]
  • Propaganda Fitzmaurice
    Propaganda Fitzmaurice Propaganda Katherine Fitzmaurice Brock University Abstract This essay looks at how the definition and use of the word propaganda has evolved throughout history. In particular, it examines how propaganda and education are intrinsically linked, and the implications of such a relationship. Propaganda’s role in education is problematic as on the surface, it appears to serve as a warning against the dangers of propaganda, yet at the same time it disseminates the ideology of a dominant political power through curriculum and practice. Although propaganda can easily permeate our thoughts and actions, critical thinking and awareness can provide the best defense against falling into propaganda’s trap of conformity and ignorance. Keywords: propaganda, education, indoctrination, curriculum, ideology Katherine Fitzmaurice is a Master’s of Education (M.Ed.) student at Brock University. She is currently employed in the private business sector and is a volunteer with several local educational organizations. Her research interests include adult literacy education, issues of access and equity for marginalized adults, and the future and widening of adult education. Email: [email protected] 63 Brock Education Journal, 27(2), 2018 Propaganda Fitzmaurice According to the Oxford English Dictionary (OED, 2011) the word propaganda can be traced back to 1621-23, when it first appeared in “Congregatio de progapanda fide,” meaning “congregation for propagating the faith.” This was a mission, commissioned by Pope Gregory XV, to spread the doctrine of the Catholic Church to non-believers. At the time, propaganda was defined as “an organization, scheme, or movement for the propagation of a particular doctrine, practice, etc.” (OED).
    [Show full text]
  • Content and Context: Three Essays on Information in Politics
    CONTENT AND CONTEXT: THREE ESSAYS ON INFORMATION IN POLITICS by Ian Palmer Cook Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of the Kenneth P. Dietrich School of Arts and Sciences in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy University of Pittsburgh 2016 UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH KENNETH P. DIETRICH SCHOOL OF ARTS AND SCIENCES This dissertation was presented by Ian Palmer Cook It was defended on March 31, 2016 and approved by Jonathan Woon, Political Science Kristin Kanthak, Political Science George Krause, Political Science Kenneth Shotts, Graduate School of Business, Stanford University Dissertation Director: Jonathan Woon, Political Science ii Copyright c by Ian Palmer Cook 2016 iii ABSTRACT CONTENT AND CONTEXT: THREE ESSAYS ON INFORMATION IN POLITICS Ian Palmer Cook, PhD University of Pittsburgh, 2016 This dissertation explores the implications of information asymmetries in three specific political environments: primary campaign speeches; negotiating behavior; and testimony delivered in a congressional hearing. First, dog whistling can dramatically affect the outcome of elections, despite observers never being sure it actually occurred. I build a model that addresses how a whistle operates, and explore implications on candidate competition. I find that whistling lets candidates distinguish themselves from competitors in the minds of voters. Second, political negotiation frequently looks like two sides staring each other down, where neither side wishes to concede, claiming that doing so would incur the wrath of voters. Little theory or evidence exists to explain how voters allocate blame for different outcomes. We conduct a laboratory experiment to investigate how anticipation of blame drives negotiating behavior, and how observers allocate blame.
    [Show full text]
  • Powerful Words: Propaganda Can Change Your Mind
    109 E. Jones Street Raleigh, NC 27601 -- Email: [email protected] -- www.ncdcr.gov/archives -- Phone: Powerful Words: Propaganda Can Change Your Mind General Overview Propaganda is a powerful tool used to sway people’s opinions on certain issues. Examples of propaganda can be found in many different formats. A definition of propaganda is: Any technique that attempts to influence the opinion, emotions, attitudes, or behavior of a group in order to benefit the sponsor. Lesson Objectives Students will be able to: . Recognize propaganda in several different formats . Create propaganda . Analyze an ad . Become aware of the importance of archival collections Preparation Students should discuss the definition of propaganda, as well as, their immediate reactions to the word. Students should read the propaganda techniques on the worksheet provided. Activities Students should study the examples of propaganda. The following questions should provoke discussion. Is advertising propaganda? . Is propaganda always a bad thing? . What has not been addressed in each sample of propaganda? . What is the difference between propaganda and education? . Do your parents use propaganda on you? . Do you use propaganda on them? . In each sample what positive messages are sent? . In each sample what negative messages are sent? . Why would an archives save such materials? 109 E. Jones Street Raleigh, NC 27601 -- Email: [email protected] -- www.ncdcr.gov/archives -- Phone: Enrichment and Extension After a discussion about propaganda have the students bring in an example of current propaganda. Have the students create a piece of propaganda based on something in which they believe Create a collage of ads Using the samples of historical or current propaganda discuss the techniques used by the creator.
    [Show full text]
  • Media Manipulation and Disinformation Online Alice Marwick and Rebecca Lewis CONTENTS
    Media Manipulation and Disinformation Online Alice Marwick and Rebecca Lewis CONTENTS Executive Summary ....................................................... 1 What Techniques Do Media Manipulators Use? ....... 33 Understanding Media Manipulation ............................ 2 Participatory Culture ........................................... 33 Who is Manipulating the Media? ................................. 4 Networks ............................................................. 34 Internet Trolls ......................................................... 4 Memes ................................................................. 35 Gamergaters .......................................................... 7 Bots ...................................................................... 36 Hate Groups and Ideologues ............................... 9 Strategic Amplification and Framing ................. 38 The Alt-Right ................................................... 9 Why is the Media Vulnerable? .................................... 40 The Manosphere .......................................... 13 Lack of Trust in Media ......................................... 40 Conspiracy Theorists ........................................... 17 Decline of Local News ........................................ 41 Influencers............................................................ 20 The Attention Economy ...................................... 42 Hyper-Partisan News Outlets ............................. 21 What are the Outcomes? ..........................................
    [Show full text]
  • Propaganda As Communication Strategy: Historic and Contemporary Perspective
    Academy of Marketing Studies Journal Volume 24, Issue 4, 2020 PROPAGANDA AS COMMUNICATION STRATEGY: HISTORIC AND CONTEMPORARY PERSPECTIVE Mohit Malhan, FPM Scholar, Indian Institute of Management, Lucknow Dr. Prem Prakash Dewani, Associate Professor, Indian Institute of Management, Lucknow ABSTRACT In a world entrapped in their own homes during the Covid-19 crisis, digital communication has taken a centre stage in most people’s lives. Where before the pandemic we were facing a barrage of fake news, the digitally entrenched pandemic world has deeply exacerbated the problem. The purpose of choosing this topic is that the topic is new and challenging. In today’s context, individuals are bound to face the propaganda, designed by firms as a communication strategy. The study is exploratory is nature. The study is done using secondary data from published sources. In our study, we try and study a particular type of communication strategy, propaganda, which employs questionable techniques, through a comprehensive literature review. We try and understand the history and use of propaganda and how its research developed from its nascent stages and collaborated with various communications theories. We then take a look at the its contemporary usages and tools employed. It is pertinent to study the impact of propaganda on individual and the society. We explain that how individual/firms/society can use propaganda to build a communication strategy. Further, we theories and elaborate on the need for further research on this widely prevalent form of communication. Keywords: Propaganda, Internet, Communication, Persuasion, Politics, Social Network. INTRODUCTION Propaganda has been in operation in the world for a long time now.
    [Show full text]
  • Misinformation, Disinformation, Malinformation: Causes, Trends, and Their Influence on Democracy
    E-PAPER A Companion to Democracy #3 Misinformation, Disinformation, Malinformation: Causes, Trends, and Their Influence on Democracy LEJLA TURCILO AND MLADEN OBRENOVIC A Publication of Heinrich Böll Foundation, August 2020 Preface to the e-paper series “A Companion to Democracy” Democracy is multifaceted, adaptable – and must constantly meet new challenges. Democratic systems are influenced by the historical and social context, by a country’s geopolitical circumstances, by the political climate and by the interaction between institutions and actors. But democracy cannot be taken for granted. It has to be fought for, revitalised and renewed. There are a number of trends and challenges that affect democracy and democratisation. Some, like autocratisation, corruption, the delegitimisation of democratic institutions, the shrinking space for civil society or the dissemination of misleading and erroneous information, such as fake news, can shake democracy to its core. Others like human rights, active civil society engagement and accountability strengthen its foundations and develop alongside it. The e-paper series “A Companion to Democracy” examines pressing trends and challenges facing the world and analyses how they impact democracy and democratisation. Misinformation, Disinformation, Malinformation: Causes, Trends, and Their Influence on Democracy 2/ 38 Misinformation, Disinformation, Malinformation: Causes, Trends, and Their Influence on Democracy 3 Lejla Turcilo and Mladen Obrenovic Contents 1. Introduction 4 2. Historical origins of misinformation, disinformation, and malinformation 5 3. Information disorder – key concepts and definitions 7 3.1. Fake news – definitions, motives, forms 7 3.2. Disinformation, misinformation, malinformation 8 4. Distortion of truth and manipulation of consent 12 5. Democracy at risk in post-truth society – how misinformation, disinformation, and malinformation destroy democratic values 17 6.
    [Show full text]
  • Fake News, Lies, & Propaganda
    Pamela Pfeiffer, Public Services Librarian Matthew Koch, Professor of English Tarrant County College South Campus .Pam .Overview of what I present to students .Observations about points to emphasize .Matt .Focus on Fake News in ENGL 1301 .Reflections on the students’ experience . For students . Critical Thinking Conference March 2017 . Fake News Symposium October 2017 . ENGL 1301 classes Spring & Fall 2018 . For Faculty . First Week Back January 2018 Fake news is nothing new, but the volume and ability to spread it quickly to millions of people is new. According to research conducted by the Pew Research Center This is an information literacy issue (metaliteracy, media literacy, statistical literacy, advertising literacy) . This exercise is for students to check . Politicot.com out some websites that may or may not be reliable. DCGazette.com . TheOnion.com . (I used to just demonstrate, but now I have them check them themselves to . WSJ.com get a little practice.) . NYTimes.com . Authentic material mixed with fake . Imposter news sites designed to look like brands we already know . abcnews.com.co . Extremely biased news sites . Click bait/Sponsored Content . Manipulated content (altered photos) . Parody content . News corrections (are they mistakes or fake news?) . New definition? Something I don’t agree with . Others? Intentionally made up (it can be funny….) Arguably the most deceitful Florence-related fake news is political, however. Some commentators are claiming the hurricane is a hoax from “the left.” Rush Limbaugh went on a protracted rant about this during his radio show yesterday. “The forecast and the destruction and the potential doom and gloom is all to heighten the belief in climate change,” he said.
    [Show full text]
  • Democratic Resilience Against Disinformation And
    COMMITTEE ON THE CIVIL DIMENSION OF SECURITY (CDS) BOLSTERING THE DEMOCRATIC RESILIENCE OF THE ALLIANCE AGAINST DISINFORMATION AND PROPAGANDA Preliminary Draft Special Report by Linda SANCHEZ (United States) Special Rapporteur 013 CDS 21 E | Original: English | 31 March 2021 Founded in 1955, the NATO Parliamentary Assembly acts as a consultative interparliamentary organisation which is institutionally separate from NATO. This working document only represents the views of the Rapporteur until it has been adopted by the Committee on the Civil Dimension of Security. It is based on information from publicly available sources or NATO PA meetings – which are all unclassified. 013 CDS 21 E TABLE OF CONTENTS I. INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................ 1 II. A GROWING THREAT WITH A PERVASIVE IMPACT ON THE DEMOCRATIC RESILIENCE OF ALLIED SOCIETIES............................................................................ 2 A. DEFINING DISINFORMATION AND PROPAGANDA........................................................... 2 B. THE MISUSE OF TECHNOLOGICAL PROGRESS AND THE GROWING DISSEMINATION OF DISINFORMATION AND PROPAGANDA ......................................... 2 C. THE IMPACT OF DISINFORMATION AND PROPAGANDA ON THE DEMOCRATIC RESILIENCE OF ALLIED SOCIETIES .................................................................................. 4 III. THE PROLIFERATION OF ACTORS DISSEMINATING DISINFORMATION AND PROPAGANDA .............................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Chairman Wiggam, Vice Chairman John, Ranking Member Kelly, and Members of the State and Local Government Reform Committee
    Chairman Wiggam, Vice Chairman John, Ranking member Kelly, and members of the State and Local Government Reform Committee, I am testifying today in favor of HB 90 as an Ohio resident deeply concerned about the courses of action being taken under the current emergency powers and the dire effects it is having on all of us. My name is Kevin Freeman and I am a concerned citizen in Ohio calling to ask you for your support of HB 90. The overreaching orders issued over the past several months by the Governor and the Health Director have affected me in the following ways, stress, depression, suicidal ideation, financial hardship, and just overall sadness. Over the past eleven months Governor Dewine has unconstitutionally used his authority to impose mandates that have negatively affected the state of Ohio and its people. I am appalled that he has not once consulted with the legislature the entire time during this whole pandemic. I am also very disgusted by his willingness to ignore the rights of all Ohio Citizens. While I myself was not on unemployment, I know several people who were trying to get it and some of them were never able to and they suffered loss of wages due to this and their businesses being closed during the first couple of months of the pandemic. I watched as Governor DeWine and Lt. Governor Husted were on TV talking about that they knew people wanted an answer to the unemployment, but they unfortunately didn’t have an answer. To me this is unacceptable as I believe we all have a right to work, earn a living, and provide for our families.
    [Show full text]
  • WEAPONS of MASS DISTRACTION: Foreign State-Sponsored Disinformation in the Digital Age
    WEAPONS OF MASS DISTRACTION: Foreign State-Sponsored Disinformation in the Digital Age MARCH 2019 PARK ADVISORS | Weapons of Mass Distraction: Foreign State-Sponsored Disinformation in the Digital Age Authored by Christina Nemr and William Gangware Acknowledgements The authors are grateful to the following subject matter experts who provided input on early drafts of select excerpts: Dr. Drew Conway, Dr. Arie Kruglanski, Sean Murphy, Dr. Alina Polyakova, and Katerina Sedova. The authors also appreciate the contributions to this paper by Andrew Rothgaber and Brendan O’Donoghue of Park Advisors, as well as the editorial assistance provided by Rhonda Shore and Ryan Jacobs. This report was produced with support from the US Department of State’s Global Engagement Center. Any views expressed in this report are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the US State Department, Park Advisors, or its subject matter expert consultants. Any errors contained in this report are the authors’ alone. PARK ADVISORS | Weapons of Mass Distraction: Foreign State-Sponsored Disinformation in the Digital Age 0. Table of Contents 01 Introduction and contextual analysis 04 How do we define disinformation? 06 What psychological factors drive vulnerabilities to disinformation and propaganda? 14 A look at foreign state-sponsored disinformation and propaganda 26 Platform-specific challenges and efforts to counter disinformation 39 Knowledge gaps and future technology challenges PARK ADVISORS | Weapons of Mass Distraction: Foreign State-Sponsored Disinformation in the Digital Age 1 Introduction and 1. contextual analysis On July 12, 2014, viewers of Russia’s main state-run television station, Channel One, were shown a horrific story.
    [Show full text]
  • The Road to the White (Nationalist) House: Coded Racial Appeals in Donald Trump's Presidential Campaign
    Duke University The Road to the White (Nationalist) House: Coded Racial Appeals in Donald Trump’s Presidential Campaign i Table of Contents Preface............................................................................................................................................. ii 1. “Dog Whistle Politics”: Coded Racial Appeals in American Political Discourse..................... 1 a. Dog Whistling Dixie: George Wallace and his Political Descendants............................. 2 b. Donald Trump: Dog Whistle or Dog Scream?................................................................15 2. Sounding the Dog Whistle: Anti-Immigrant, Anti-Muslim, and Anti-Black.......................... 20 a. Anti-Immigrant: “The Latino Threat”............................................................................ 20 b. Anti-Muslim: “Radical Islamic Terrorism”.................................................................... 40 c. Anti-Black: Crime, Welfare, and the African American Other...................................... 49 3. Why the Whistle Worked: White Nationalist Postracialism and White Identity Politics........ 62 a. White Nationalist Postracialism...................................................................................... 63 b. “Wink Wink Wink”: Coded Appeals to White Nationalism.......................................... 75 c. White Identity Politics and the Post-Racial Illusion....................................................... 82 Conclusion....................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]