£ Open Space 443,907 Tspt/ Hways 671,608 Education 733,651 Housing 539 1,849,705
pre08/09 08/09 Amount not Site/development Developer Planning ref spent
£ 03/04075/GRG4 and 2007/08 Barbican centre/Kent St car park Barbican Venture (York) Ltd 03/04082/GRG4 83,819.16 83,819.16
2007/08 Land at Water Lane Persimmon Homes Ryedale 238,215.07 238,215.07
2008/09 Stoneplan Construction, Dalton Terrace, York. Wilton Homes 07/01733/FUL 6,813.00 6,813.00
2008/09 Northfield Open Air School Beckfield Lane York YO2 5RQ City of York Council 02/01307/FUL05/00320/GRG3 21,889.00 21,889.00 05/00478/FULM 2008/09 Car Park adjacent Foss Bank, Heworth Green. Persimmon Homes Ltd 05/02695/FULM 14,812.00 14,812.00
2008/09 Green Belt Garage, New Lane, Huntington. Woodgreen Developments 02/03378/FUL 12,426.00 12,426.00
2008/09 Land Bounded By Fossway Sturdee Grove & Byland Ave Alfred McAlpine Homes 00/00700/REM 65,933.00 65,933.00
443,907.23
Amount not Site/development Developer Planning ref spent
£
1997/98 Naburn Lane, Fulford, retail development BAA McArthur/Glen York Ltd 97/01350/FUL 20,901.30 20,901.30
1999/00 90 Picadilly, erection of hotel Landmark Development Projects Ltd 99/00136/FUL 50,888.06 50,888.06
2000/01 Northminster Business Park, Northfield Lane, Upper Poppleton, York Northminster Properties Ltd 99/03061/FUL 39,638.65 39,638.65
2003/04 York College for Girls 62-68 Low Petergate Geo Houlton & Sons (Holdings) Ltd 02/03723/FUL 3,050.65 3,050.65
2003/04 Fosslands farm 03/03451/FUL 26,319.03 26,319.03
2003/04 Former MOD site, New Road, Hessay. LEDA Properties Ltd 98/01401/FUL 6,043.16 6,043.16 2005/06 53 Piccadilly, York - Erection of six storey Hotel (Quality Inn) Hollin Hill Properties Ltd 99/02908/FUL 25,699.47 25,699.47
2005/06 Offices on the corner of Audax Road and Audax Close, Clifton. F R Evans Ltd 03/02732/FUL 4,848.35 4,848.35
2006/07 108-110 Bootham Ascot Developments 04/04114/FULM 1,727.81 1,727.81
2006/07 Rear of 229, 235 & 237 Strensall Rd, Earswick. Oakgate Group Plc 01/01991/OUT 17,756.44 17,756.44 03/04075/GRG4 and 2006/07 Barbican centre/Kent St car park Barbican Venture (York) Ltd 03/04082/GRG4 209,086.85 209,086.85
2007/08 Hungate redevelopment scheme Hungate York Regeneration Ltd 02/03741/OUT 18,986.44 18,986.44
2007/08 The Raylor Centre James Street, York, YO10 3DW H B Raylor & Co Ltd 06/01171/FULM 8,067.42 8,067.42
2007/08 York Corporation Depot, Foss Islands Road. Keyland Gregory (Retail) York 03/00737/GRG4 45,730.89 45,730.89
2008/09 The Sidings, The Village, Strensall. Hogg Builders 02/03176/FUL 3,540.03 3,540.03
2008/09 Site at junction of Dixon Ln and George St. Evans of Leeds Ltd 00/02062/FUL 88,823.42 88,823.42
02/01307/FUL 571,107.97 05/00478/FULM 2008/09 Car Park adjacent Foss Bank, Heworth Green. Persimmon Homes Ltd 05/02695/FULM 10,000.00 10,000.00 Hogg Builders. The Sidings, The Village, Strensall. Erection of 10 dwelling and 2008/09 garages with new access from the Village. Hogg Builders 02/03176/FUL 3,500.00 3,500.00
2008/09 Site at junction of Dixon Ln and George St. Evans of Leeds Ltd 00/02062/FUL 87,000.00 87,000.00
100,500.00
Amount not Site/development Developer Planning ref spent
£
2003/04 Poppleton Park 76776.77 76,776.77
2005/06 S106 Land at Slessor Road S Harrison Development Ltd 02/01722/FUL 123575.74 123,575.74
2005/06 S106 80 Alma Terrace EDU at Fulford SC Wharfedale Homes Ltd 03/03086/FUL 23588.52 23,588.52
2005/06 Charles Church Fulford (Filling Station Main Road) Persimmon Homes Ltd 04/01508/FUL 25842.08 25,842.08
2005/06 Speculation Street (INL club) Kevin James Mohan 03/00376/FUL 35836.69 35,836.69
2005/06 188 Speculation Street Kevin James Mohan 03/00376/FUL 1022.67 1,022.67 2006/07 Rear of 229,235 and 237 Strensall Road Earswick Oakgate Group Plc 01/01991/OUT 34691.93 34,691.93
2006/07 Wrigley Dev Ltd (Gimcrack Hotel) RS Construction 02/03282/FUL 22839.68 22,839.68
2006/07 Warehouse 83A Front Corner Developments (Faxton Ltd) 06/01261/FULM 12056.27 12,056.27
2006/07 18 Murton Way Osbaldwick George Wimpey North Yorkshire Ltd 03/01305/FUL 101936.11 101,936.11
2006/07 106 Moss Street Depot (Ref 196) Edu Yorkshire Community Housing Ltd 03/02996/FUL 11650 11,650.00
2007/08 60 Lawrence Street Moorside Developments Ltd 03/02325/OUT 30797.04 30,797.04
2007/08 84 Bootham Sec Educ ref 191 R U Developments 03/01890/FUL 7590.21 7,590.21
2007/08 Dixons YD Walmgate Educ S106No208 Miller Homes (Yorkshire) Ltd 03/02025/FUL 53544.98 53,544.98
561748.69 Tropicwatch Ltd. Car Park Adj Woolpack House, The Stonebow. Erection of 2008/09 Wilton4 new residentialHomes. Stoneplan town houses Construction, Dalton Terrace, York. Erection of Tropicwatch Ltd 05/02677/FUL 7781.00 7,781.00 three storey comprising of 3 townhouses and 3 apartments with associated 2008/09 parking. Stoneplan Construction 07/01733/FUL 13099.00 13,099.00
2008/09 122 STRENSALL ROAD HUNTINGTON YORK YO32 9SJ Hogg Builders (York) Ltd 06/01020/FUL 15531.00 15,531.00
2008/09 Northfield Open Air School Beckfield Lane York YO2 5RQ City of York Council 05/00320/GRG3 23786.00 23,786.00
2008/09 Land to the side and rear of 30 Calf Close Haxby, York. Antler Homes (Yorkshire) Ltd 06/00027/FULM 23342.00 23,342.00
2008/09 New China Palace, 162 Gale Lane. Mr M Eleftheriou 02/01307/FUL03/02435/FUL 2000.00 2,000.00 05/00478/FULM 2008/09 Car Park adjacent Foss Bank, Heworth Green. Persimmon Homes Ltd 05/02695/FULM 52816.00 52,816.00
2008/09 The Sidings, The Village, Strensall. Hogg Builders 02/03176/FUL 26484.00 26,484.00
2008/09 44 Clarence St Martin Kaye 02/02717/FUL 7063.00 7,063.00
171902.00
Housing 539.00
1,455,429.89 394,275.00 1,455,430.00 394,275.29
- 0.11 - 0.29 Extract of FOI 6390
Total Spent Spent Spent Spent Spent Total Total
Year of Receipt Received 2008/09 2009/10 2010/11 2011/12 2012/13 Spend Remaining £ £ £ £ £ £ £ £
2008/09 507,776 31,665 45,084 30,077 0 6,675 113,501 394,275 pre 2008/09 OS 83,819 C Backies 238,215 Educ 561,749 Hsg 539 CES 571,108 1,455,430
Total 5 years and older 1,849,705 S106 receipts received prior to 31 March 2009 which are unspent
Dear City of York Council,
Please provide me with the following information:-
1. A list of all S106 monies received five years ago and over, which have not been spent. 2. The names of the developers who paid these monies. 3. The site/development to which these payments related to. 4. The planning permission reference numbers in respect of these sites. 5. All of the above should be cross-referenced.
Yours faithfully,
Paul S Cordock
Site/development Planning ref Balance
£ 1997/98 Naburn Lane, Fulford, retail development 97/01350/FUL 20,901.30 1999/00 90 Picadilly, erection of hotel 99/00136/FUL 50,888.06 2000/01 Northminster Business Park, Northfield Lane, Upper Poppleton, York 99/03061/FUL 39,638.65 2001/02 Ebor Chase, 292 Bishopthorpe Road - 34 Flats and 4 affordable flats 98/01361/FUL 539.00 2003/04 York College for Girls 62-68 Low Petergate 02/03723/FUL 3,050.65 2003/04 Fosslands farm 03/03451/FUL 26,319.03 2003/04 Former MOD site, New Road, Hessay. 98/01401/FUL 6,043.16 2005/06 53 Piccadilly, York - Erection of six storey Hotel (Quality Inn) 99/02908/FUL 25,699.47 2005/06 Offices on the corner of Audax Road and Audax Close, Clifton. 03/02732/FUL 4,848.35 2006/07 108-110 Bootham 04/04114/FULM 1,727.81 2006/07 Rear of 229, 235 & 237 Strensall Rd, Earswick. 01/01991/OUT 17,756.44 2006/07 Barbican centre/Kent St car park 03/04075/GRG4 and 209,086.85 03/04082/GRG4 2006/07 Warehouse 83A Front 06/01261/FULM 12056.27 2006/07 18 Murton Way Osbaldwick 03/01305/FUL 101936.11 2006/07 13 Bishophill Senior, York YO1 6EF. Renewal of previously approved planning 06/00261/FULM (01/00144/FUL) 19152 permission 01/00144/FUL for conversion to form 14 flats. 2007/08 Barbican centre/Kent St car park 03/04075/GRG4 and 83,819.16 03/04082/GRG4 2007/08 Hungate redevelopment scheme 02/03741/OUT 18,986.44 2007/08 The Raylor Centre James Street, York, YO10 3DW 06/01171/FULM 8,067.42 2007/08 York Corporation Depot, Foss Islands Road. 03/00737/GRG4 45,730.89 2007/08 60 Lawrence Street 03/02325/OUT 30797.04 2007/08 84 Bootham 03/01890/FUL 7590.21 2008/09 Northfield Open Air School Beckfield Lane York YO2 5RQ 05/00320/GRG3 21,889.00 2008/09 Car Park adjacent Foss Bank, Heworth Green. 02/01307/FUL 05/00478/FULM 14,812.00 05/02695/FULM 2008/09 Green Belt Garage, New Lane, Huntington. 02/03378/FUL 12,426.00 2008/09 Land Bounded By Fossway Sturdee Grove & Byland Ave 00/00700/REM 65,933.00 2008/09 The Sidings, The Village, Strensall. 02/03176/FUL 3,540.03 2008/09 Site at junction of Dixon Ln and George St. 00/02062/FUL 88,823.42 2008/09 Car Park adjacent Foss Bank, Heworth Green. 02/01307/FUL 05/00478/FULM 10,000.00 05/02695/FULM 2008/09 The Sidings, The Village, Strensall. Erection of 10 dwelling and garages with new 02/03176/FUL 3,500.00 access from the Village. 2008/09 The Sidings, The Village, Strensall. 02/03176/FUL 26484.00 2008/09 Site at junction of Dixon Ln and George St. 00/02062/FUL 87,000.00 2008/09 Northfield Open Air School Beckfield Lane York YO2 5RQ 05/00320/GRG3 23786.00 2008/09 Car Park adjacent Foss Bank, Heworth Green. 02/01307/FUL 05/00478/FULM 52816.00 05/02695/FULM
1145643.76 FOI ? Yes Yes Yes
£ £ Open Space 443,907 198,879 -245,028 Tspt/ Hways 671,608 671,608 0 Education 752,803 274,618 -478,185 Housing 539 539 0 1,868,857 1,145,644 -723,213
Amount not Site/development Planning ref spent Revised Difference Reason
£ £ £ Barbican centre/Kent St car park 03/04075/GRG4 and 2007/08 03/04082/GRG4 83,819.16 83,819.16 Land at Water Lane 2007/08 Ryedale DC (Persimmon) 238,215.07 - - 238,215.07 transfer to earmarked reserve Dalton Terrace, York. 2008/09 07/01733/FUL 6,813.00 - - 6,813.00 not a s106 Northfield Open Air School Beckfield Lane York YO2 5RQ 2008/09 02/01307/FUL05/00320/GRG3 21,889.00 21,889.00 Car Park adjacent Foss Bank, Heworth Green. 05/00478/FULM 2008/09 05/02695/FULM 14,812.00 14,812.00 Green Belt Garage, New Lane, Huntington. 2008/09 02/03378/FUL 12,426.00 12,426.00 Land Bounded By Fossway Sturdee Grove & Byland Ave 2008/09 00/00700/REM 65,933.00 65,933.00
443,907.23 198,879.16 -245,028.07
Site/development Amount not Planning ref spent
£ Naburn Lane, Fulford, retail development 1997/98 97/01350/FUL 20,901.30 20,901.30 90 Picadilly, erection of hotel 1999/00 99/00136/FUL 50,888.06 50,888.06 Northminster Business Park, Northfield Lane, Upper Poppleton, York 2000/01 99/03061/FUL 39,638.65 39,638.65 York College for Girls 62-68 Low Petergate 2003/04 02/03723/FUL 3,050.65 3,050.65 Fosslands farm 2003/04 03/03451/FUL 26,319.03 26,319.03 Former MOD site, New Road, Hessay. 2003/04 98/01401/FUL 6,043.16 6,043.16 53 Piccadilly, York - Erection of six storey Hotel (Quality Inn) 2005/06 99/02908/FUL 25,699.47 25,699.47 Offices on the corner of Audax Road and Audax Close, Clifton. 2005/06 03/02732/FUL 4,848.35 4,848.35 108-110 Bootham 2006/07 04/04114/FULM 1,727.81 1,727.81 Rear of 229, 235 & 237 Strensall Rd, Earswick. 2006/07 01/01991/OUT 17,756.44 17,756.44 Barbican centre/Kent St car park 03/04075/GRG4 and 2006/07 03/04082/GRG4 209,086.85 209,086.85 Hungate redevelopment scheme 2007/08 02/03741/OUT 18,986.44 18,986.44 The Raylor Centre James Street, York, YO10 3DW 2007/08 06/01171/FULM 8,067.42 8,067.42 York Corporation Depot, Foss Islands Road. 2007/08 03/00737/GRG4 45,730.89 45,730.89 The Sidings, The Village, Strensall. 2008/09 02/03176/FUL 3,540.03 3,540.03 Site at junction of Dixon Ln and George St. 2008/09 00/02062/FUL 88,823.42 88,823.42
02/01307/FUL 571,107.97 571,107.97 Car Park adjacent Foss Bank, Heworth Green. 05/00478/FULM 2008/09 05/02695/FULM 10,000.00 10,000.00 The Sidings, The Village, Strensall. Erection of 10 dwelling and garages with new 2008/09 access from the Village. 02/03176/FUL 3,500.00 3,500.00 Site at junction of Dixon Ln and George St. 2008/09 00/02062/FUL 87,000.00 87,000.00
100,500.00 100,500.00
Site/development Amount not Planning ref spent
£ Poppleton Park 2003/04 ?? Pre LGR 76776.77 y - - 76,776.77 Manor contribution Land at Slessor Road 2005/06 02/01722/FUL 123575.74 y - - 123,575.74 Westfield / York High Alma Terrace 2005/06 03/03086/FUL 23588.52 y - - 23,588.52 Fulford Secondary Main road Fulford Filling Station 2005/06 04/01508/FUL 25842.08 y - - 25,842.08 Fulford Secondary Speculation Street (INL club) 2005/06 03/00376/FUL 35836.69 y - - 35,836.69 Fulford Secondary 188 Speculation Street 2005/06 03/00376/FUL 1022.67 y - - 1,022.67 Fulford Secondary Rear of 229,235 and 237 Strensall Road Earswick 2006/07 01/01991/OUT 34691.93 y - - 34,691.93 Huntington Secondary Gimcrack Hotel 2006/07 02/03282/FUL 22839.68 y - - 22,839.68 Fulford Secondary Warehouse 83A Front 2006/07 06/01261/FULM 12056.27 n 12,056.27 - MB to check Acomb Primary 18 Murton Way Osbaldwick 2006/07 03/01305/FUL 101936.11 c 101,936.11 - Fulford expansion new 106 Moss Street Depot 2006/07 03/02996/FUL 11650 y - - 11,650.00 Fishergate / Scarcroft 13 Bishophill Senior, York YO1 6EF. Renewal of previously approved planning 2006/07 permission 01/00144/FUL for conversion to form 14 flats. 06/00261/FULM (01/00144/FUL) 19152 n 19,152.00 - 60 Lawrence Street 2007/08 03/02325/OUT 30797.04 n 30,797.04 - 84 Bootham 2007/08 03/01890/FUL 7590.21 n 7,590.21 - Dixons Yard Walmgate 2007/08 03/02025/FUL 53544.98 y - - 53,544.98 Fulford Autism Unit
580900.69 171,531.63 - 409,369.06 Car Park Adj Woolpack House, The Stonebow. Erection of 4 new residential 2008/09 town houses 05/02677/FUL 7781.00 y - - 7,781.00 Fishergate & legal Dalton Terrace, York - erection of three storey comprising of 3 townhouses 2008/09 and 3 apartments with associated parking. 07/01733/FUL 13099.00 y - - 13,099.00 Scarcroft / Millthorpe (10648, 16270) 122 STRENSALL ROAD HUNTINGTON YORK YO32 9SJ 2008/09 06/01020/FUL 15531.00 y - - 15,531.00 Huntington School Northfield Open Air School Beckfield Lane York YO2 5RQ 2008/09 05/00320/GRG3 23786.00 n 23,786.00 - Pre school - may have to repay (5 years) Land to the side and rear of 30 Calf Close Haxby, York. 2008/09 06/00027/FULM 23342.00 y - - 23,342.00 Joseph Rowntree (OSP) New China Palace, 162 Gale Lane. 2008/09 02/01307/FUL03/02435/FUL 2000.00 y - - 2,000.00 York High (5 years) Car Park adjacent Foss Bank, Heworth Green. 05/00478/FULM 2008/09 05/02695/FULM 52816.00 n 52,816.00 - Foundation Stage The Sidings, The Village, Strensall. 2008/09 02/03176/FUL 26484.00 n 26,484.00 - ??? 44 Clarence St 2008/09 02/02717/FUL 7063.00 y - - 7,063.00 Joseph Rowntree
171902.00 103086.00 -68816.00
539.00 539.00 -
2008/09 ??? 1,628,610.20 I am writing to request an internal review of City of York Council's handling of my FOI request 'Section 106 Agreement Monies receive five years ago or more which are unspent'.
Thank you for the information provided, however, I wish to point out a discrepancy in the total amount of unspent S106 monies over 5 years old.
A recent FOI reply by COYC gave the total amount of unspent S106 monies from earlier than 2008/09, as £1,455,430. The total amount shown on the information you have provided to me is only £1,145,643.76 - a difference of £309,786.24.
Could you please check your figures, and explain the difference ?
Balances over 5 years P Cordock CYC £ £
FOI 6390 pre 2008/09 1,455,430 1,455,430.00 2008/09 394,275.29 1,849,705.29
Take out Education - 478,185 projects funded Clifton Backies - 238,215 earmarked reserve Unilateral undertaking - 6,813 not a s106 C Stuart added 19,152 omitted by mistake - 704,061
1,145,644
FOI 6844 2008/09 & before 1,145,644 1,145,644
Difference 309,786 - 0 Clifton Backies (£238,215)
Clifton Backies is a nature reserve managed by the Clifton Backies Nature Reserve Management Board
It was established by the transfer of land by the developer as Public Open Space and a commuted sum to cover future maintenance.
The lump sum is held by the council in an earmarked reserve and is available to spend by CBNRMB
In this respect it is not an unspent s106 balance