Love it? Loathe it? Completely irrelevant? The Mercer Varsity 100: you decide
The Independent Cambridge Student Newspaper since 1947 | varsity.co.uk | Friday January 19 2007 | Issue 649
ARTS & Hutchinson cleared FEATURES of sexual assault FEATURES »Trinity Hall fellow to New year’s sue Cambridge daily resolutions two for “libellous” coverage weeks on Hutchinson “declined to speak to us »PAGE 12 ELLIOT ROSS but instead sold his story to a tabloid News Editor Sunday newspaper, whose reporter was at his house on the evening of A Cambridge academic cleared last the not guilty verdict”. month of sexual assault plans to sue Hutchinson described the reaction the Cambridge Evening News for of his students, three of whom what he called “three clear cases of returned from their year abroad to libel”. He may bring a further charge act as character witnesses, as of harassment. “absolutely amazing”, also praising Dr Peter Hutchinson, Deputy his “wonderful” colleagues in the Head of the Department of German University. One of Hutchinson’s stu- and Fellow of Trinity Hall, was dents, third year linguist Callum found not guilty by a jury at Hind, was critical of “unfair” Norwich Crown Court on December reportage in the local press. He said MUSIC 8 2006 after a previous trial in that all eight linguists in his year at Cambridge had to be adjourned for Trinity Hall visited Hutchinson as Dubstep: legal reasons. soon as the story broke to let him Hutchinson has spoken out know that they were “very much Entering the against “inaccurate and unbalanced” behind him”. Later in the term the press coverage of the case, and said same group took Hutchinson and his underground his barrister, who has advised him to wife out for dinner and gave him a take legal action against two nation- luxury hamper. »PAGE 19 al newspapers, considered the The accusations were brought by a reporting of the first trial “among young policewoman, a former stu- the most scurrilous he had experi- dent of Hutchinson, who had visited enced in over thirty years at the him in his college rooms in October Bar”. The CEN were “determined to 2005. She claimed to have been shame me in the local community”, assaulted by Hutchinson as she he told Varsity. “My aim is to pre- examined a mouse mat. She told the vent the newspaper from treating court “I felt his hand cup my buttock. anyone else in this way, with their He didn’t say anything, he sort of let intrusion of privacy, harassment, out a chuckly-type groan and pervy ridiculously one-sided view of the noises.” She said that Hutchinson case, and clearly libellous state- then tried to kiss her twice, attempts ments”, he said. that she resisted, latterly using a At the time of the trials, the CEN police training manoeuvre which carried headlines such as “Dirty don involved pressing her arm against wanted a quick feel, jury told” and his throat. “German lecturer: ‘I do pat bottoms’”. Hutchinson has always admitted But CEN Editor Murray Morse physical contact with the woman. dismissed suggestions of a vendetta But he argued, “that touching was Dr Peter Hutchinson: found not guilty last month DYLAN SPENCER-DAVIDSON as “rubbish”, defending the newspa- not primarily sexual, and I had no per’s coverage as “totally fair and reason whatsoever to believe that from me” contained sexual innuendo. quality of teaching that the Medieval accurate”. “I don’t know who has she would object”. Hutchinson pointed out that the and Modern Language students advised Hutchinson to pursue a The meeting between the two was nature of email correspondence deserve,” praising Hutchinson’s legal action against the newspaper” preceded by an exchange of emails. excluded facial expression and tone “outstanding reputation”. Asked he said, adding “whoever it is should Prosecution lawyer Chris Morgan of voice, but conceded “the banter whether he considered Hutchinson check their facts first”. He is “total- told the court that Hutchinson wrote and flirtation – on both sides – went to have been in breach of any code of ly confident” of mounting a success- of his tendency to “go a bit weak at a bit too far”. practice, Bampos stressed the col- returns... ful defence. the knees with blondes with a cer- Hutchinson expressed relief that lege’s adherence to the University’s Morse went on to say that the tain colour of eye who are just won- no moves had been taken to consider ‘Dignity at Work’ policy, but said »PAGE 10 CEN had offered Hutchinson the derful people as well”. Morgan his suspension. Dr Nick Bampos, that as the complaint was made from chance to give his full story after his argued that a separate email asking Senior Tutor at Trinity Hall, said outside the college, it was for the acquittal. He claimed that her to “Give your… cat a stroke “our first priority was to offer the court system to deal with.
Comment: A well-executed plan | Sport: Rugby triumph | Puzzles: Rotations are back!
Got a news story? Friday January 19 2007 2 NEWS [email protected] varsity.co.uk/news In Brief Academics bust chip and pin Scott’s last »Payments Association maintains that cardholders’ details are safe letters on show chip and pin terminal, but collecting lion pounds was fraudulently siphoned in protecting their PIN, or they were AMY HOGGART card details and PINs entered”. from customer accounts. attempting to defraud the bank by Captain Robert Scott’s final letters to his Worryingly, he claimed that the Open to such attacks, questions making false claims”. wife, written on his ill-fated expedition to Members of the University of experiment would be easy to recre- have been asked as to why the But it would be difficult to move the South Pole in 1912, have been dis- Cambridge Security Group have dis- ate: “Only moderate technical skill in machines were introduced and mar- back to signature cards as banks are played for the first time. The letters covered a new way of doctoring chip electronics is needed and it took keted as a safer alternative to the sign- apparently reluctant to reissue them. were given to the University’s Scott and pin machines to steal customer around a month for us to build and ing method. Murdoch acknowledges When asked how he personally pays Polar Research Institute by Scott’s data. The team opened up a chip and test the equipment. We estimate that that the terminals do incorporate anti- for goods, Murdoch said that he uses daughter-in-law, Lady Philippa Scott. pin terminal purchased on eBay and the equipment needed to perform this tampering protection, but that “when cash whenever possible, even though Director of the Institute, Prof. Julian replaced its internal hardware with attack would cost less than £250, and triggered they only prevent the termi- this “results in different risks”. He Dowdeswell, said they are “invaluable in their own, gaining complete control of is easily available from online elec- nal processing real transactions”. He added a recommendation that credit enabling us to continue our historical role the machine without displaying any tronics shops.” He added, explained that “this feature cards should be used in pref- as an international centre for the study evidence of external damage. “Everything we used is general pur- exists to protect the bank, erence to debit cards of the Polar Regions”. Jessica King Personal account details and PINs pose hardware with many legitimate not the customer”. as the legal pro- could then be copied and used to cre- uses, so buying it should not raise sus- While previous tection is bet- ate fake cards. picion. After this stage, building any signature-based ter. New look for Steven Murdoch and Saar Drimer, subsequent fake terminals would be transactions researchers at the group, which spe- much cheaper and faster, probably laid the respon- Fisher Square cialises in testing the security of elec- taking a few days to a week.” sibility on the But the importance of the discovery bank to Fisher Square, adjacent to the Soul was yesterday undermined by Sandra prove that Tree nightclub, will undergo a £350,000 “To demonstrate Quinn, Director of Corporate the cus- renovation. Cambridge City Council Communications at APACS, the UK tomer- has commissioned British sculptor their complete payments association. She told Varsity autho- Peter Randall-Page to transform the that they “have discovered that the rised pay- area. Mr Randall-Page’s work, control of the terminal the Cambridge Security ments, inspired by patterns in nature, has Group used isn’t in fact a chip and pin chip and pin been exhibited in the British Museum machine, they terminal and has none of the tamper- transactions and the Tate Gallery. The centrepiece responsive switches that the current allow banks will be a sculpture carved from red wired it up to terminals have”. She added that “the to assume that granite. Other planned innovations terminal manufacturer is writing a let- the customer is include a curve of steps and new-band- play Tetris” ter of complaint to Cambridge”. As liable, unless ed paving. Chrissy Collins well as arguing that “what is possible they can prove in lab conditions is unlikely to be suc- otherwise. cessful in the real world”, she detailed Murdoch tronic hardware, were responsible a variety of safety features designed to pointed out one Breakthrough in for the project. To demonstrate their prevent such fraud. negative effect of complete control of the machine, But the Security Group believes the move to chip nuclear research they wired it up to play Tetris, post- that theirs is not the only method of and pin in “the Cambridge scientists have developed a ing a video of the feat on the committing chip and pin fraud. Ross increasing number way to potentially store high-level YouTube website. Anderson, another member of the of complaints about nuclear waste for thousands of years. By With its internal mechanics com- group, said “There are many, many banks claiming to vic- forming a crystal from a combination of pletely altered, the terminal could ways in which chip and pin transac- tims of fraud that since radioactive material with more stable easily be swapped with one in-store tions can be attacked”. Murdoch added a PIN was used synthetic materials, the chance of leak- without any visible difference. that many of these would be “easier” either the cus- ages can be reduced. Research leader Dr Murdoch explained, “Since the new to achieve, citing the Shell chip and pin tomer was Ian Farnan said it could “make billions of electronics were designed by us, we fraud last May when magnetic infor- negligent pounds worth of savings and improve could write software which made the mation was copied from cards used in overall safety”.varsity Cat page Moss 2.pdf 12/1/07 10:42:09terminal behave just like a normal chip and pin transactions, and one mil- Steven Murdoch, part of the team which carried out the research Hood defeated by rebel dons Jamie Munk examines the drive for Oxbridge reform One could have forgiven Dr John their unique systems of self-gover- year heritage of academic democra- Hood for not pulling his party pop- nance in line with those of other cy be maintained, and respected by per with his usual enthusiasm this universities. HEFCE as a valid way of running New Year’s Eve. After two years Few in Cambridge will be their affairs. rigorously battling to push through lamenting the news from ‘the other The coming months should be his controversial plans to reform the place’. Had the reforms gone highly revealing. Hood is being university’s governance, the Oxford through, Cambridge would have called to Parliament early this year vice-chancellor was finally forced to been left on its own to face up to to give evidence to the Education C admit defeat on December 19. government calls to bring more and Skills Select Committee’s
M In a postal ballot of members of review of higher education, and it is Congregation, Oxford’s ‘parliament known that Gordon Brown, among Y of dons’, over 60 per cent voted “Few in others, has concerns over Oxford against the reforms. The major bone and Cambridge’s ability to govern CM of contention for the rebels was that Cambridge will themselves effectively. MY plans to increase the number of The debate will hinge on whether external members of the university’s be lamenting the the universities can prove their own CY governing council would fundamen- news from the competence, particularly on the CMY tally undermine the academic free- question of financial management. dom and the historic tradition of the In Cambridge, the Council is now in K university as an independent com- other place” the process of drawing up a green munity of scholars. paper proposing limited reforms to But the decision will do little to achieve such an end. And almost abate calls for university reform, before the postal result had come and many are already predicting external members onto its Council. through in Oxford, all sides were significant political repercussions. But with the rebel success, the talking of the need for rapproche- In the last few years the govern- University Council is more likely to ment so that the university can find ment has been leaning increasingly be able to stand firm in declaring the right way to reform. on both Oxford and Cambridge to its resolve to continue governing It is becoming increasingly clear reform their governance. And since itself internally. that while divisions remain on the the passing of new charity legisla- The Council has already declared kind of reform needed, there is a tion last year, both institutions now that it sees no need for major struc- broad consensus within both univer- face additional pressure from the tural changes, and many feel that sities that any change should be on Higher Education Funding Council Oxford and Cambridge should now their own terms rather than those of for England (HEFCE) to bring work together to ensure that an 800- the government.
Friday January 19 2007 Got a news story? varsity.co.uk/news [email protected] NEWS 3 Drink driver sentenced »Girton student jailed after high speed crash kills close friend
TOM PARRY-JONES News Editor
A Cambridge student was sen- tenced to six-and-a-half years in Ballare prison after pleading guilty to caus- ing death by dangerous driving in Plain one, purl one? November 2005. Ivan Mazour, 22, was driving his Not here, sunshine Mitsubishi Evolution VIII at 80mph Plain and purling is not often seen as through a 30mph area of Central a particularly hazardous pastime, London when he lost control, hitting but one politically-active knitter a lamp post and an oncoming BMW was told otherwise while out on the saloon. Police analysis showed that town at CUSU’s weekly Kinki club- he was “three times over the drink night. Jacob Bard-Rosenberg, more drive limit”, having drunk the widely known for his radical ram- equivalent of thirteen whiskies, and blings than his crocheting skills, was that there was “a quantity of sitting in the club working his magic cannabis in his system”. on a new beanie for a friend, when His front seat passenger, 21 year- his artistic reverie was interrupted old Charlie Green, was taken to by the arrival of the Ballare bounc- University College Hospital where ers. Our hat-weaving hero was told he was pronounced dead. Green’s that the tools of his trade constitut- fiance, Dookie Groves, was also in ed a health and safety hazard for the car returning home from a night other clubbers, and had them confis- out in the West End. Groves, also cated for the remainder of the 21, told the court that she had lost evening, in spite of protests that her “soulmate”, and that she had there weren’t any “no knitting” begged Mazour to slow down when signs warning of the prohibition. he began driving “crazy fast”. Her pleas were ignored and the car spun across the central reservation of the Piccadilly underpass into oncoming Downing traffic. The driver and five passen- Wreckage abandoned on the Piccadilly underpass after the accident METROPOLITAN POLICE gers in the BMW were injured, as Windy wilds of the was Ms Groves. Girton, is the son of the president of maintained that the offence carried She concluded by speaking of her college paddock Mazour, at the time of the incident the Russian oil company RAO the “most serious culpability” due to “memories of the joy he brought a third year Maths student at Rosneftegazstroi, also called Ivan “excess alcohol ... and greatly exces- us”. A website has been set up by As Cambridge was ravaged by gale- Mazour. Educated at Eton, he sive speed”. Mazour himself also Charlie Green’s friends to remem- force winds last week, at least the achieved six A-levels at grade ‘A’, addressed the court, saying “I am so ber his life through photos and students of Downing were benefit- before taking up his place at sorry for all the pain and grief and “thoughts and feelings”. ing from the sage advice of their Cambridge in 2003. Described by a tragedy I have caused to Charlie’s The incident had passed mostly domestic bursar. ‘Wing-commander’ fellow student in his year as “quite a family, his fiance, his friends, to all unnoticed by the Girton student Dick Taplin warned his college quiet guy”, Mazour had a penchant those injured and their families”. He body. Ashley Aarons, JCR cadets in an email to “take care when for expensive cars, owning a BMW has been disqualified from driving President at the time of the crash moving around”. He hadn’t earned M5 as well as the Mitsubishi for eight years. told Varsity that he “hadn't been his stripes for nothing: the former Evolution VIII that was involved in Green had been a student at the told about it” by the college. flying ace immediately spotted the the crash. London College of Fashion, and was Current JCR President Simon dangers of tile-shedding roofs and Prior to the incident Mazour described by the judge as a Burdus said that while there was flailing branches. Rookies, look to expressed concern on an internet “remarkable young man”. In court “nothing made of it” by the college the skies. forum for the passengers in a fellow his mother spoke of her grief. authorities, Charlie Green has been forum member’s wrecked car, a sen- “What can prepare you for the mentioned in special remembrance timent acknowledged by the judge. shock of sudden death? No second services in the Chapel. Andrew Anthony Pitts, sentencing, said “of chance, no fighting for recovery, Jefferies, Senior Tutor at the col- Madingley Rise course you did not intend to kill or just death.” She said that Marisha lege, refused to comment on the MET POLICE even harm Charlie Green that night Green attempted suicide following matter, saying it would not be Wheeling it out for Victim, Charlie Green - indeed he was your friend”. But he the trauma of her brother’s death. “appropriate”. your eyes only The University is warning its young English roses to avert their eyes this week following the return of a menac- Vice-Chancellor denies Harvard move ing threat to the streets of our fair town. A delinquent young man riding »Newspaper points to Alison Richard as likely candidate for Harvard presidency a bike has been spotted near the Old Observatory on Madingley Rise as a front-runner. lic expression of support for which claimed that Richard “does not exhibiting more of himself than is LIZZIE MITCHELL Richard, Vice-Chancellor of [Richard]” at Harvard. consider herself a candidate for the desirable to passing ladies. In the Cambridge since 2003, is the only seri- Cambridge professor Gillian Evans presidency of Harvard”. past, exhibitioners were an impor- A Harvard student newspaper has ous candidate currently employed by has expressed uncertainty over Of the other candidates listed as tant part of the life of the University, suggested that Cambridge Vice- an institution outside the USA. Richard’s suitability for the presiden- serious contenders for the post, all but college authorities are keen to Chancellor Alison Richard may leave Should she leave Cambridge for cy, saying that “Harvard has had a except one have so far refrained stress that the seeming return of this the University to take up the presi- Massachusetts, she would become taste of blood”, while calling Richard a from comment, and the Crimson gentleman, last seen a year ago, is a dency of Harvard University, a move “low profile Vice-Chancellor” who has reports that the selection committee wholly different matter. which would entail Richard abandon- “kept Cambridge out of the headlines is paying no attention to ing her current post three years “Harvard is quite effectively”. the candidates’ public before the end of her contract. Harvard anthropologist Professor statements in its deci- The Harvard Crimson has pub- ready for a David R. Pilbeam, who taught sion-making process. Selwyn lished a shortlist of 30 candidates for Richard at Cambridge, praised “a It is expected that the presidency, which has been under female wonderful person, academic, teacher, the new appoint- Unexpected snowball temporary stewardship since the last administrator, who would be an ment will be hits a little hard incumbent, Lawrence Summers, president” equally wonderful Harvard announced in resigned shortly after hypothesising President. I fear, however, that she early February. One Snowball reveller got more than that a lack of female mathematicians may feel that she already has the Were Richard to he bargained for after misunder- and scientists in the higher levels of best academic job in the world.” accept any offer, standing the concept of the event’s academia could be due to innate dif- Harvard’s first female president and In a statement issued by her office it is likely that one-way system. After a few tenta- ferences between men and women. the first for 370 years not to have a in the wake of recent speculation, she would take tive paces, his error was brought to With a decision imminent, sources Harvard degree. Richard affirmed “her deep and office on 1 July his attention by a resounding thump near to the presidential selection com- President of the Crimson, William unequivocal commitment to the 2007, the date in the face from a student security mittee have suggested Richard’s Ciro Marra, has told Varsity that University of Cambridge and to com- when academic guard. Speculation continues as to name as one of four which are under “Harvard is definitely ready for a pleting the full term of her appoint- appointments at whether this particular entertain- most serious consideration for the female president,” but added that ment, which ends in 2010”, a moderat- Harvard usually ment will be moved to the main stage post; the Crimson is pointing to her “there has been no major notable pub- ed version of last month’s statement take effect. for next year’s ball.
Got a news story? Friday January 19 2007 4 NEWS Call us now on 01223 353422 varsity.co.uk/news Return of the water vole Brothel ring crackdown »Ratty comes back to Cambridge after twenty year absence fails to impress councillors visitors. Mr Farmer did emphasise College recalled with a sense of nos- KATY LEE however that there was no sugges- talgia the heady days of the early tion “that the women were underage 1970s. “Voles were legion; I vividly Two Cambridge residents sentenced or coerced”. remember one of the furry fellows for managing a chain of brothels in No official records of turnover crawling up my punt pole.” the Romsey area have walked free have been found but the brothel But now, with the new location and from court. By the time a verdict chain is estimated to have brought in sightings of voles in the nearby Garret was passed on December 21, a total of over £500,000 over a period Hostel Lane there is hope that the old Andrew Reader and Stephen of twenty months, with Reader per- burrows will soon be repopulated and Pilsworth had already spent enough sonally receiving approximately that the rodents will be a familiar time in police custody to have served £2,000 each month. sight in Cambridge once more. out their sentences. There has been local protestation at A spokesman for the University A major operation to crack the the leniency of the sentences applied said “This particular ditch was found in this case and at the laws surround- to be a good habitat for these shy ing prostitution in general. creatures. It is a sunny, quiet, ideally “I would have Cambridgeshire County Councillor sloping bank, with no sign of cats, Geoffrey Heathcock has called for mink or foxes”. The conservation been gutted to reform of sentencing laws, telling project is planned for Summer 2007, Varsity that “a lot of money changed once funding has been obtained. see these people hands for these individuals, the police The creatures are often mistaken spent a significant amount of time for rats, and indeed in Kenneth walk” working on this case and had I been a Grahame’s The Wind in the Willows police officer I would have been gutted Ratty is in fact a water vole, known to see these people walk!” for his kind and friendly nature. County Cllr Alice Douglas and Unfortunately, since that book was brothel ring began in June 2004 after City Cllr Catherine Smart also high- written, American Mink have been Reader was discovered at Stansted lighted the need for a change in the A vole tests out the water temperature TERRY LONGLEY introduced into the country and they Airport with £3,700 in his luggage. law, claiming that “current laws have proven to be far worse enemies Undercover police officers posed as often force prostitutes into a criminal mates rest at just 220,000, a disas- than the Weasels and Stoats which “punters”, visiting the houses on sub-culture”. Cllr Douglas cited the TOM MORIATY trous demographic decline of 95 per troubled Mr Toad, Badger, Moley and Coleridge Road, Sedgwick Street recent murders of five prostitutes cent in the last 20 years alone. While Ratty. Their predations have ravaged and Thoday Street to question the in Ipswich and suggested that “reg- Cambridge’s scenic backs area is voles were once a common feature of the riverside population, while man- sex workers. Raids were conse- ulation of brothels, as long as there joining the fight against the extinc- agement of waterways and drainage quently carried out on the establish- is neither trafficking nor exploita- tion of one of Britain’s most endan- systems has also destroyed much of ments in January 2006, culminating tion involved, may be a way to bet- gered species. the natural habitat for the voles in in the arrests of Reader and ter protect sex workers from abuse. Water vole burrows have been “I vividly recent years. Pilsworth. Five maids, who under- Regulation would also help protect spotted along a ditch between Clare remember one Ruth Hawksley from the Wildlife took secretarial work for the broth- local communities from any related and King’s colleges following drainage Trust said, “Often ditches are man- els, were also arrested and conse- nuisance or disturbance.” work carried out last spring. Wildlife crawling up my aged by drainage engineers who quently sentenced. Reader was sen- The local sex industry is thriving experts hope that environmental want everything to look “tidy”, but tenced to three concurrent 18-month according to a 2004 investigation by improvements made to the area will punt pole” the same flood defence can be sentences and Pilsworth to three researchers from BBC Radio help to safeguard the future prospects achieved through more “wildlife nine-month sentences. Cambridgeshire, who found a total of the Cam’s water vole population, friendly” management”. Advertisements for the brothels, of 70 opportunities to pay for sex in whose numbers have declined rapidly If the conservation work is carried running under the names of “Elite” the county. One former brothel over the last forty years. Britain’s riverside landscapes, the out and the Backs become a suitable and “Elegance”, had been placed in manager commented that “from the From a population of around eight sighting of one has become some- habitat for water voles, look out for the Cambridge Evening News. John centre of Cambridge it would take million in 1960, water vole numbers thing of a rare treat for fans of the them sunbathing and floating down Farmer, the prosecutor, said it would ten minutes to find somewhere, and had.1)0-*,+2(*2" !" ! plummeted to 2.3 million % !$'"&