DOCSLIB.ORG

The Territorial Imperative, and the Social Contract. the Bases

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Territorial Imperative, and the Social Contract. the Bases REVIEW ARTICLES Robert Ardrey. African genesis: A Personal Investigation into the Animal Origins and Nature of Man. The Fontana Library ed. (London and Glasgow: Collins, 1961. Pp. 416.) -------. The Territorial Imperative: A Personal Inquiry into the Animal Origins of Property and Nations. A Laurel ed. (New York: Dell, 1966. Pp. 355.) ------- The Social Contract: A Personal Inquiry into the Evolutionary Sources of Order and Disorder. The Fontana Library ed. (London and Glasgow: Collins, 1970. Pp. 405.) Reviewed by REYNALDO SILVESTRE* The Discipline of Sociobiology Political science focuses on the political structures and political relationships of human society. On this level alone, political science would be purely analytic and descriptive. To be able to add to political science the dimension of a tool in the formu Iat ion of political policy, the capacity to predict must be included. The development of this predictive capacity must necessarily involve all the other disciplines that focus upon the varied but interrelated aspects of social complexity. The discipline of economics, as history has forcefully revealed, cannot be excluded from political analysis, and the discipline of sociology is crucial to a comprehensive under­ standing of the suitability of various forms of government for various national cultures. With the objective of contributing to the enhancement of political science's predictive capacity, the comparatively new dis­ cipline of sociobiology is hereby presented. In the absence of a sufficiently detailed and comprehensively organized alternative, this presentation will draw exclusively upon the three interrelated books of Robert Ardrey: African Genesis, The Territorial Imperative, and The Social Contract. The bases of these works have been drawn, in turn, from a plethora of experi­ ments and studies on animals and animal behavior. The subjects range from amoebas and planarian worm, up to fishes, reptiles, birds, and chimpanzees. Some concentration is noted on emphasis *Presidential Center for Special Studies. 87 88/Philippine Political Science Journal December 1980 on animals which may be classified as vertebrate, mammalian, and primate. While the bases cited appear characterized by integrity and logic, and while Ardrey's conclusions appear characterized by the same integrity and logic in the main, we are constrained by the lack of extensive scholarly discussion to avoid any suggestion of conclu­ siveness. Rather, this presentation is made with the view that we have in these works not definitive theses, but matter for serious reflection and pursuit. Taken chronologically, we start this presentation with African Genesis. The Nature of Man The underlying thesis of this and the two other works cited is that certain basic aspects of human behavior and animal behavior are integrally interlinked. To understand one is to understand the other. Thus, to Ardrey, Our ancestry is firmly rooted in the animal world, and to its subtle, antique ways our hearts are yet pledged. Children of all animal kind, we inherited many a social nicety as well as the predator's way ... Man is a fraction of the animal world. We are not so unique as we should like to believe. And if man in a time of need seeks deeper knowledge concerning himself, then he must explore those animal horizons from which we have made our quick little march (pp. 7-8). Having stated this basic thesis, Ardrey now prefigures the broad outlines of his conclusions. The human drive to acquire possession is the simple expression of an animal instinct many hundreds of times older than the human race itself. We do not know that the roots of nationalism are dug firmly into the social territoriality of almost every species in our related primate family. We do not know that the status-seekers are responding to animal instincts equally characteristic of baboons, jackdaws, rock cod, and men. Responsible though we may be for the fate of summit con­ ferences, disarmament agreements, juvenile delinquents and new African states, we do not know that the first man was an armed killer, or that evolutionary survival from his mutant instant depended upon the use, the development, and the contest of weapons ( pp. 10-11). The thrust of this passage is a deliberate attempt to connect the experimental results of sociobiology with the fields of human psychology and politics. We shall comment on the validity of this and other propositions of Ardrey in the last portion of this paper. .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Dublin Gate Theatre Archive, 1928 - 1979
    Charles Deering McCormick Library of Special Collections Northwestern University Libraries Dublin Gate Theatre Archive The Dublin Gate Theatre Archive, 1928 - 1979 History: The Dublin Gate Theatre was founded by Hilton Edwards (1903-1982) and Micheál MacLiammóir (1899-1978), two Englishmen who had met touring in Ireland with Anew McMaster's acting company. Edwards was a singer and established Shakespearian actor, and MacLiammóir, actually born Alfred Michael Willmore, had been a noted child actor, then a graphic artist, student of Gaelic, and enthusiast of Celtic culture. Taking their company’s name from Peter Godfrey’s Gate Theatre Studio in London, the young actors' goal was to produce and re-interpret world drama in Dublin, classic and contemporary, providing a new kind of theatre in addition to the established Abbey and its purely Irish plays. Beginning in 1928 in the Peacock Theatre for two seasons, and then in the theatre of the eighteenth century Rotunda Buildings, the two founders, with Edwards as actor, producer and lighting expert, and MacLiammóir as star, costume and scenery designer, along with their supporting board of directors, gave Dublin, and other cities when touring, a long and eclectic list of plays. The Dublin Gate Theatre produced, with their imaginative and innovative style, over 400 different works from Sophocles, Shakespeare, Congreve, Chekhov, Ibsen, O’Neill, Wilde, Shaw, Yeats and many others. They also introduced plays from younger Irish playwrights such as Denis Johnston, Mary Manning, Maura Laverty, Brian Friel, Fr. Desmond Forristal and Micheál MacLiammóir himself. Until his death early in 1978, the year of the Gate’s 50th Anniversary, MacLiammóir wrote, as well as acted and designed for the Gate, plays, revues and three one-man shows, and translated and adapted those of other authors.
    [Show full text]
  • Coping with CROWDING by Frans B
    POPULATION GROWTH has been thought, since the time of Thomas Malthus, to produce dire consequences such as disease, scarcity and social deviancy. This dark view seemed confirmed by rodent studies. Yet little evi- dence suggests that people are similarly affected: we seem to handle large crowds quite well for the most part. Coping with CROWDING by Frans B. M. de Waal, Filippo Aureli and Peter G. Judge 76 Scientific American May 2000 Coping with Crowding Copyright 2000 Scientific American, Inc. n 1962 this magazine published a seminal But, one could argue, perhaps such a re- paper by experimental psychologist John lation is obscured by variation in national IB. Calhoun entitled “Population Density income level, political organization or some and Social Pathology.” The article opened other variable. Apparently not, at least for dramatically with an observation by the late- income. We divided the nations into three 18th-century English demographer Thomas categories—free-market, former East Block Malthus that human population growth is and Third World—and did the analysis automatically followed by increased vice and again. This time we did find one significant misery. Calhoun went on to note that al- correlation, but it was in the other direc- though we know overpopulation causes dis- tion: it showed more violent crime in the ease and food shortage, we understand virtu- least crowded countries of the former East ally nothing about its behavioral impact. Block. A similar trend existed for free-mar- This reflection had inspired Calhoun to ket nations, among which the U.S. had by conduct a nightmarish experiment.
    [Show full text]
  • Human Origins Studies: a Historical Perspective
    Evo Edu Outreach (2010) 3:314–321 DOI 10.1007/s12052-010-0248-7 ORIGINAL SCIENTIFIC ARTICLE Human Origins Studies: A Historical Perspective Tom Gundling Published online: 29 July 2010 # Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2010 Abstract Research into the deep history of the human within the field of paleoanthropology, but rather to identify species is a relatively young science which can be divided broad patterns and highlight a collection of “events” that into two broad periods. The first spans the century between are most germane in shaping current understanding of our the publication of Darwin’s Origin and the end of World evolutionary origin. These events naturally include the War II. This period is characterized by the recovery of the accretion of fossil material, the raw data which is the direct, first non-modern human fossils and subsequent attempts at if mute, testimony of the past. These fossil discoveries are reconstructing family trees as visual representations of the situated among technological breakthroughs, theoretical transition from ape to human. The second period, from shifts, and changes in the sociocultural context in which 1945 to the present, is marked by a dramatic upsurge in the human origins studies were conducted. It is only through quantity of research, with a concomitant increase in such a contextualized historical approach that we can truly specialization. During this time, emphasis shifted from grasp our current understanding of human origins. Foibles classification of fossil humans to paleoecology in which of the past remind us to be critical in assessing newly hominids were seen as parts of complex evolving ecosys- produced knowledge, yet simultaneously we can genuinely tems.
    [Show full text]
  • Primate Aggression and Evolution: an Overview of Sociobiological and Anthropological Perspectives JAMES J
    Primate Aggression and Evolution: An Overview of Sociobiological and Anthropological Perspectives JAMES J. McKENNA Attempts to explain the nature and causes of human aggression are hand­ icapped primarily because aggression is anything but a unitary concept. Aggression has no single etiology, no matter which mammalian species we consider or what kind of causation (developmental or evolutionary) we stress. Nevertheless, forensic psychiatrists are asked to evaluate instances of human aggression in ways that would send shivers up the spines of researchers who have been wrestling with the issue for over fifty years. This is not to say forensic psychiatry should be abolished nor to suggest be­ havioral scientists have not made progress in discovering causes of species aggression in genera}l and human violence in particular.2 But especially when predictive models are considered it does mean we are far from achiev­ ing highly reliable results.:l Particularly when one person is asked to assess the motivational state of another who has committed a serious aggressive act it becomes more evident just how much more data we need. Strangely, if a forensic psychia­ trist were asked to testify in a case in which, let us say, one monkey attacked another, the testimony would be based on more complete information than a case involving a human. This is because a plethora of context-specific data on nonhuman primates are available. These data illuminate a wide range of social, ecological, and endocrinological circumstances under which animals will be expected to act aggressively. Data on humans are much more complex, and sometimes they are absent altogether.
    [Show full text]
  • Mccarthy Era and the American Theatre Author(S): Albert Wertheim Source: Theatre Journal, Vol
    The McCarthy Era and the American Theatre Author(s): Albert Wertheim Source: Theatre Journal, Vol. 34, No. 2, Insurgency in American Theatre, (May, 1982), pp. 211 -222 Published by: The Johns Hopkins University Press Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/3207451 Accessed: 16/04/2008 16:42 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp. JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use provides, in part, that unless you have obtained prior permission, you may not download an entire issue of a journal or multiple copies of articles, and you may use content in the JSTOR archive only for your personal, non-commercial use. Please contact the publisher regarding any further use of this work. Publisher contact information may be obtained at http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=jhup. Each copy of any part of a JSTOR transmission must contain the same copyright notice that appears on the screen or printed page of such transmission. JSTOR is a not-for-profit organization founded in 1995 to build trusted digital archives for scholarship. We enable the scholarly community to preserve their work and the materials they rely upon, and to build a common research platform that promotes the discovery and use of these resources. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. http://www.jstor.org The McCarthy Era and the American Theatre Albert Wertheim Eric Bentley's Thirty Years of Treason, Lillian Hellman's Scoundrel Time, Lately Thomas's When Even Angels Wept, and Robert Goldston's The American Nightmare are only a few of the many studies that have been written about that unsettling and aberrant period of recent American history frequently known as the McCarthy era.1 The very titles of the books tell us immediately with what loathing and shame most Americans now look back to that time of political paranoia.
    [Show full text]
  • SCRAPBOOK of MOVIE STARS from the SILENT FILM and Early TALKIES Era
    CINEMA Sanctuary Books 790 - Madison Ave - Suite 604 212 -861- 1055 New York, NY 10065 [email protected] Open by appointment www.sanctuaryrarebooks.com Featured Items THE FIRST 75 ISSUES OF FILM CULTURE Mekas, Jonas (ed.). Film Culture. [The First 75 Issues, A Near Complete Run of "Film Culture" Magazine, 1955-1985.] Mekas has been called “the Godfather of American avant-garde cinema.” He founded Film Culture with his brother, Adolfas Mekas, and covered therein a bastion of avant-garde and experimental cinema. The much acclaimed, and justly famous, journal features contributions from Rudolf Arnheim, Peter Bogdanovich, Stan Brakhage, Arlene Croce, Manny Farber, David Ehrenstein, John Fles, DeeDee Halleck, Gerard Malanga, Gregory Markopoulos, Annette Michelson, Hans Richter, Andrew Sarris, Parker Tyler, Andy Warhol, Orson Welles, and many more. The first 75 issues are collected here. Published from 1955-1985 in a range of sizes and designs, our volumes are all in very good to fine condition. Many notable issues, among them, those designed by Lithuanian Fluxus artist, George Macunias. $6,000 SCRAPBOOK of MOVIE STARS from the SILENT FILM and early TALKIES era. Staple-bound heavy cardstock wraps with tipped on photo- illustration of Mae McAvoy, with her name handwritten beneath; pp. 28, each with tipped-on and hand-labeled film stills and photographic images of celebrities, most with tissue guards. Front cover a bit sunned, lightly chipped along the edges; internally bright and clean, remarkably tidy in its layout and preservation. A collection of 110 images of actors from the silent film and early talkies era, including Inga Tidblad, Mona Martensson, Corinne Griffith, Milton Sills, Norma Talmadge, Colleen Moore, Charlie Chaplin, Lillian Gish, and many more.
    [Show full text]
  • The Territorial Imperative
    Old School Ethological Model The blood-bespattered, slaughter-gutted archives of human history from the earliest Egyptian and Sumerian records to the most recent atrocities of the Second World War accord with early universal cannibalism, with animal and human sacrificial practices or their substitutes in formalized religions and with the world wide scalping, head-hunting, body-mutilating and necrophiliac practices of mankind in proclaiming this common blood lust differentiator, this mark of Cain that separates man dietetically from his anthropoidal relatives and allies him rather with the deadliest of Carnivora. Raymond Dart (1953) "The predatory transition from ape to man". International Anthropological and Linguistic Review I. Warfare and Evolution Old ethological & modern evolutionary models A strategic model of territoriality Chimpanzee coalitionary aggression Influential ethology books On Aggression, Konrad Lorenz (1966) African Genesis (1961), Robert Ardrey The Territorial Imperative, Robert Ardrey (1966) Lorenz's Hydraulic or Drive Discharge Theory: ¾ aggressive energy builds in the organism ¾ if the energy is not released the organism will be harmed ¾ the organism seeks a releasing mechanism (e.g., territorial intruder) ¾ aggression is expressed and the organism reestablishes equilibrium Reasoning behind the Phylogenetic Model: Humans are primates. Non-human primates are aggressive and territorial. Humans are aggressive and territorial. Non-human primate behavior is genetically determined. Therefore, human aggression, warfare, and territoriality are genetically determined. Strategic or conceptual models Under what conditions do we expect the behavior to manifest itself? What are the costs and benefits to the behavior? Does not require phylogenetic connections. Further, even if we find the behavior in closely related species or subspecies we would still have to explain the evolutionary logic behind the behavior.
    [Show full text]
  • And Others Annotated Index to the English Journal, First
    DOCUMENT RESUME ED 067 664 95 CS 200 140 AUTHOR Harvey, Robert C., Ed.; And Others TITLE Annotated Index to the English Journal, First Supplement: 1964-1970. INSTITUTION- National Council of Teachers of English, Urbana, Ill. SPONS AGENCY Office of Education (DUEW), Washington, D.C. PUB DATE Sep 72 NOTE 115p. AVAILABLE FROMNational Council of Teachers of English, 1111 Kenyon Road, Urbana, III. 61801 (Stock No..47826, $3.25 non-member, $2.95 member) EDRS PRICE MF-$0.65 HC-$6.58 DESCRIPTORS *Annotated Bibliographies; Composition (Literary) ; English Curriculum; *English Instruction; *Indexes (Locaters); Language; *Literature; Reading; *Resource Materials; Teaching Methods ABSTRACT In this index, which can be used as a guide to professional reading as well as a research tool, 1100 articles that originally appeared in the "English Journal" from 1964 to 1970 are annotated and indexed. Only those items that could be considered "articles" were included, excluding such items as letters to the editors, book reviews, etc. The table of contents is the main avenue of access, dividing the annotations into sections and categories. When an article has more than one major emphasis, it is cross-referenced. The annotations are intended to amplify the titles and briefly describe the content and emphasis of the articles. There are two indexes included: the "Literary Works and Their Authors," which provides quick access to articles discussing particular works or authors, and an "Author Index," which is an alphabetical list of the authors of the articles annotated. (JF) U.S. DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH. EDUCATION & WELFARE OFFICE 7. f EDUCATION THIS DOCUMENT VAS BEEN REPRO.
    [Show full text]
  • Warfare and Violence
    (ANTH 3388) WARFARE AND VVVIOLENCE ::: THE ANTHROPOLOGY AND HISTORY OF HUMAN CONFLICT J-Term 2012 Dr. David J. Wilson Afternoon session: 2:00 to 5:00 pm Office: 455 Heroy Evening session: 6:00 to 9:00 pm E-mail: [email protected] COURSE OBJECTIVES : From their origins in our primate ancestry through modern times, intergroup aggression, violence, and warfare appear to have been among the most constant features of human society. Utilizing data and theories from two of the subfields of anthropology—archaeology and ethnology—as well as from history and political science, this interdisciplinary course examines human aggressive behavior and warfare around the world from their earliest known occurrence, at ca. 16,000 B.C, to the most recent conflict in Iraq. Exemplary cases from prehistoric, historical, and recent times for North and South America, Oceania, the Mediterranean, Eurasia, and Africa form the core of the course. Throughout the course, we will examine and discuss violence and warfare both from an adaptive perspective and, where appropriate, from an ethical standpoint. INSTRUCTOR ’S BACKGROUND : B.A., Political Science, University of Washington; M.A., Spanish, San Diego State University; M.A. and Ph.D., Anthropology, University of Michigan. My archaeological research on the Peruvian north coast has focused on population growth and warfare as especially critical features in the origins and development of complex prehispanic societies in that area of the world. My recent book, INDIGENOUS SOUTH AMERICANS OF THE PAST AND PRESENT , deals with a number of ethnographic and archaeological cases of violent, warlike societies around South America and I have a long-standing interest in this theme at a worldwide level from my undergraduate background in Political Science and from teaching ANTH 3319/Human Ecology, ANTH 3313/South American Indians Past and Present, and ANTH 2302/People of the Earth at SMU.
    [Show full text]
  • Inventory Acc.12942 Marillyn Gray / Gateway Theatre Papers
    Acc.12942 January 2009 Inventory Acc.12942 Marillyn Gray / Gateway Theatre Papers National Library of Scotland Manuscripts Division George IV Bridge Edinburgh EH1 1EW Tel: 0131-466 2812 Fax: 0131-466 2811 E-mail: [email protected] © Trustees of the National Library of Scotland Papers, (1925-1997) of Scottish actor and theatre director Marillyn Gray (1930-2006) referred to as MG in the inventory. The collection chiefly relates to the Gateway Theatre, (1953-1965) in which Marillyn Gray was a regular performer. The Gateway papers came into her care at some point after the theatre closed possibly entrusted to her by, or after the death of, Sadie Aitken (1905-85) Gateway Theatre General Manager, some of whose papers are in the collection. Marillyn Gray was born in Edinburgh, attending Trinity Academy. After serving her apprenticeship at Perth Repertory theatre she had her first major role in 1951 with the Glasgow Citizens’ Spindrift written by Naomi Mitchison and Denis Macintosh, playing alongside Duncan Macrae and Fulton MacKay. Thereafter she became a stalwart at the Gateway Theatre in Edinburgh. She also worked for many years with Jimmy Logan’s variety shows, and made numerous appearances on radio and television. She later taught at the Drama Department of Queen Margaret College in Edinburgh, directing a number of their productions. The Gateway was gifted to the Church of Scotland by local businessman A.G. Anderson in 1944. Under the stewardship of director Rev George Candlish and manager Sadie Aitken it was officially opened as a theatre in October 1946 showing films and inviting companies such as Perth Theatre, Dundee Rep, Glasgow Citizens, and the Scottish National Players to visit.
    [Show full text]
  • 2001: a Space Odyssey by James Verniere “The a List: the National Society of Film Critics’ 100 Essential Films,” 2002
    2001: A Space Odyssey By James Verniere “The A List: The National Society of Film Critics’ 100 Essential Films,” 2002 Reprinted by permission of the author Screwing with audiences’ heads was Stan- ley Kubrick’s favorite outside of chess, which is just another way of screwing with heads. One of the flaws of “Eyes Wide Shut” (1999), Kubrick’s posthumously re- leased, valedictory film, may be that it doesn’t screw with our heads enough. 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968), however, remains Kubrick’s crowning, confounding achievement. Homeric sci-fi film, concep- tual artwork, and dopeheads’ intergalactic Gary Lockwood and Keir Dullea try to hold a discussion away from the eyes of HAL 9000. joyride, 2001 pushed the envelope of film at Courtesy Library of Congress a time when “Mary Poppins” and “The Sound of Music” ruled the box office. 3 million years in the past and ends in the eponymous 2001 with a sequence dubbed, with a wink and nod to As technological achievement, it was a quantum leap be- the Age of Aquarius, “the ultimate trip.” In between, yond Flash Gordon and Buck Rogers serials, although it “2001: A Space Odyssey” may be more of a series of used many of the same fundamental techniques. Steven landmark sequences than a fully coherent or satisfying Spielberg called 2001 “the Big Bang” of his filmmaking experience. But its landmarks have withstood the test of generation. It was the precursor to Andrei Tarkovsky’s time and repeated parody. “Solari” (1972), Spielberg’s “Close Encounters of the Third Kind” (1977) and George Lucas’s “Star The first arrives in the wordless “Dawn of Man” episode, Wars” (1977), as well as the current digital revolution.
    [Show full text]
  • Creatures of Cain
    © Copyright, Princeton University Press. No part of this book may be distributed, posted, or reproduced in any form by digital or mechanical means without prior written permission of the publisher. Introduction Human nature contains the seeds of humanity’s destruction. Or so it seemed to popular consumers of evolutionary theory in the late 1960s who maintained that the essential quality distinguishing the human animal from its simian kin lay in our capacity for murder. This startlingly pessimistic view enjoyed wide currency in the United States between 1966 and 1975 and be- came known, by its critics, as the killer ape theory. Readers at the time associated the concept of humans as mere animals with three men. Robert Ardrey published The Territorial Imperative in 1966, which leapt off bookshelves across the country. He styled himself an amateur scien- tist and believed his experience as a playwright gave him unique insights into the composition of human nature. Konrad Lorenz’s white- maned visage loaned him a distinguished appearance despite the black rubber boots he fa- vored when showing people around his farm. Lorenz, the author of On Aggres- sion, which appeared in English translation the same year as Ardrey’s Territo- rial Imperative, would later share the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine for his perceptive contributions to the scientific study of animal behavior. Desmond Morris unknowingly capitalized on the success of both authors when he published The Naked Ape the following year. Well known as the host of Granada TV’s popular Zootime program, based out of the London Zoo, Morris soon gave up scientific work to concentrate on writing scientific non- fiction and refining his surrealist painting.
    [Show full text]