Beyond Bork News Reports That Left out More Truth Than They Told
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
INSIDE NOVEMBER 1987 FREE Reckless Record Review by Dr. Avalanche Local Press Sampler Community Calendar & Directory ANN ARBOR'S ALTERNATIVE NEWSMONTHLY a-lternative-pr< sampler- "There are 8 million stories in the naked city. Here's one of them..." AGENDA comes s clean by Laurie Jo Wechter Note: AGENDA first appeared in April, 1986. Next month's issue will be the 20th. The paper is financed through advertising, subscription and donation revenues. 10,000 copies are distrib- uted every month for free from over 130 loca- tions in the Ann Arbor/Ypsilanti area. Below, one editor takes a stab at explaining what makes AGENDA tick. Why AGENDA? It's hard giving a non-rhetorical answer to a question we've had to ask over and over again. We breathe, sleep, don't sleep AGENDA and it is a more personal question than it might seem at first glance. We started AGENDA in early 1986 because we were Myths Distort the Issues frustrated activists. Frustrated because we had a very hard time getting The Ann Arbor News or other media to provide adequate coverage of the issues and events we were concerned with. We also felt the occasional coverage they provided was incomplete, misleading or written with an "angle" in mind. We just got tired of Beyond Bork news reports that left out more truth than they told. So we started our own publication to provide an open by Glenn and Randi Metsch-Ampel community forum, filling an obvious journalistic void in Ann Arbor. Whether or not one is opposed to Judge Robert Bork's nomination We were flooded with material from day one. The Lately we feel like we've reached the end of our to the Supreme Court (which we are), there are three myths which have one month we were unable to publish (March, 1987), ability to live in limbo. We have stretched our debts been stitched so securely to Bork's coattails that they merit analysis in we received so many phone calls begging us to pub- and ourselves to a ridiculous point. The sad state of their own right. First there is the myth that society can be protected lish this or that article that we were convinced beyond our financial affairs (see page 12) is something of an from the imposition of a judge's own moral and political proclivities if a shadow of a doubt that there was a need for embarrassment. Nonetheless, we are proud of what we that judge will adhere to the text of the constitution and the intent of AGENDA. have accomplished and feel satisfied that if we are its framers. Then there is the myth that a new, inherently dangerous It has been AGENDA'S intention to print stories forced to close our doors, we'll know we gave precedent of evaluating a nominee's judicial philosophy has been set by that mainstream news sources don't, to report news AGENDA everything we had. Which is not to say the Bork confirmation hearings. And finally, there is the myth that that the establishment doesn't see fit to print. we're going to go down without a fight. We just need Bork has been maliciously gunned down by a number of special interest In light of this, an unconventional philosophy of more help from the community! groups who have hired the Democratic party as their assassin. As a publishing prevails. Most of the articles are written It is still too early to tell if we can Weather the group, these myths create an imposing obstacle which must be removed by informed and concerned people, not journalists. As current money crunch but if AGENDA goes down the in order to reach the issues they currently obscure and distort. editors, we have worked together with many people, tubes we won't be the first. In the '80s alone, two The first myth has in fact received a good deal of attention recently. helping them find a voice and focus. Working with alternative Ann Arbor publications, The Alchemist, It is the assertion that society can be protected from the imposition of such writers is very timeconsuming and demands a lev- and The Alternative Review, stopped publishing due a judge's own moral and political proclivities through strict construc- el of accessibility that is unheard of in most media. to lack of resources. Why? Perhaps the community tionism. This is an appealing myth because the courts have in the past We feel that the philosophy of AGENDA has been didn't understand the amount of funds and effort it given us many reasons to fear such judicial impositions. Two examples encouraged by the community, judging from the takes to publish a paper. are the Dred Scott Case, in which Black people were held to be neither amount of time and expertise donated by volunteers. After all, it looks like a newspaper takes just a true persons nor citizens, but property, and Plessy v. Ferguson, in Consequently, the paper continues to grow and thrive few hours to put together. But as Fred Astaire once which the Court placed the constitutional stamp of approval on the sys- in content and credibility. said, "When I see myself dancing on film it looks tem of apartheid, then the norm in this country. This has led people to wonder where all of our like I'm just standing still." In other words, it's an art Though appealing, strict constructionism has historically failed to backing comes from. Surprise! We have no backing. to look like what you do takes little effort. check the judicial impositions it claims to remedy. In fact, it has served No nifty foundation grants, no rich uncles, and no I thought about publishing a list of everything we as justification for such judicial impositions. Indeed, both the Dred Swiss bank accounts. But we would rather deprive our- do during a typical month, but it was just too long Scott and Plessy v. Ferguson decisions were wrapped in the mantle of selves of sleep and a normal life than put out a and boring. Fielding phone calls and doing errands is strict constructionism. substandard paper. Mind you, we know there are typos probably a full-time job itself. If you wonder why we In "God Save This Honorable Court," Lawrence Tribe deflates the and mistakes, but we care how AGENDA looks, reads don't just do this as a sideline, we dare you to come myth of strict constructionism: and basically comes across to the extent that we have by and hang out for a day. There isn't one day in a "The most serious flaw in both slavish adherence to the con- printed too many pages for our budget every month week that we're not working on the paper. I'm not stitutional text and the inevitable inconclusive inquiry into the intent (except this one) and spent a lot of time on making asking you to feel sorry for us. After all, it's our of those who wrote it is not just that these methods of judicial the paper look like it is well-to-do. choice to publish AGENDA, but it would help if reasoning ask the wrong questions, but that they abdicate responsibility Someday we hope to be paid a decent salary and people would stop asking what we do for a job for the choices that constitutional courts necessarily make. The Supreme not have to apologize for not being "committed besides the paper, eh?! Court just cannot avoid the painful duty of exercising judgment so as to enough" to do it for free. After all, no one asks a Well, that's my diatribe. There's lots more to say, give concrete meaning to the fluid Constitution, because the consti- doctor to treat patients for free. No one asks a mech- but as it says in our listing in the Community tutional rules and precepts that it is charged with administering lack anic to fix a car for free. Why do people always ex- Resource Directory, we can't afford the space! that certainty which permits anything resembling automatic application pect social workers, or teachers, or community organ- ...There is simply no getting around the fact that whenever the izers to do their work for starvation wages? (see BORK, page 4) *•*• « NEWS BRIEFS Protesters Win Court Ruling On October 6, the Michigan Supreme Lake. Repeated protests and arrests at the Court ruled that a judge had exceeded his site between 1984 and 1985 resulted in the syndrome will begin at 6 pm at the Federal Justice for All authority in imposing unlimited jail terms to issuance of a permanent injuction against Building in Ann Arbor and proceed to Ann stop a series of anti-nuclear protests from future protests. However the protests con- by Greg Scott Arbor City Hall. 1983 to 1984 near Walled Lake, Michigan. tinued and when protesters refused to pro- On Tues., Nov. 17, people from over 50 The event is co-sponsored by many local The original judge had held the protesters in mise to stay off the site they were held in national organizations and hundreds of local and national religious groups, unions, and contempt of court when they refused to state contempt and given open-ended jail sen- groups will be convening "Justice for All" political organizations including the Rainbow in court that they would obey an injunction tences. In the 4-3 decision the majority forums, hearings, and town meetings to Coalition, the Salvation Army, U.S. Catholic prohibiting the protests.