A Phase 1 Archaeological Impact Assessment (Aia) for the Proposed N2 National Route (N2-13) Between Grahamstown and the Fish
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
A PHASE 1 ARCHAEOLOGICAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT (AIA) FOR THE PROPOSED N2 NATIONAL ROUTE (N2-13) BETWEEN GRAHAMSTOWN AND THE FISH RIVER BRIDGE AS WELL AS SIX BORROW PITS AND THREE QUARRIES, EASTERN CAPE PROVINCE. Prepared for: Coastal and Environmental Services (CES) P.O. Box 934 Grahamstown 6140 Tel: 046 622 2364/7 Fax: 046 622 6564 Contact person: Ms Lara Crous Email: [email protected] Compiled by: Ms Celeste Booth Department of Archaeology Albany Museum Somerset Street Grahamstown 6139 Tel: 046 622 2312 Fax: 046 622 2398 Email: [email protected] Date: September 2013 1 CONTENTS 1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 5. 1.1. Purpose of the Study 5. 1.2. Brief Summary of Findings 5. 1.3. Summary of Recommendations 6. 2. BACKGROUND INFORMATION 8. 2.1. Developer 9. 2.2. Consultant 9. 2.3. Terms of reference 9. 3. HERITAGE LEGISLATIVE REQUIREMENTS 10. 4. BRIEF ARCHAEOLOGICAL BACKGROUND 11. 4.1. The Early Stone Age (ESA) (1.5 million-250 000 years ago) 12. 4.2. Middle Stone Age (MSA) (250 000 – 30 000 years ago) 13. 4.3. The Later Stone Age (LSA) (30 000 – recent) and Pastoralism within the last 2000 years 14. 4.3.1. The Later Stone Age 14. 4.3.2. Pastoralism 16. 4.4. Human Remains 17. 4.5. Rock Art (Paintings and Engravings) 17. 5. DESCRIPTION OF THE PROPERTY 18. 5.1. Location data 18. 5.2. Map 18. 6. ARCHAEOLOGICAL INVESTIGATION 21. 6.1. Methodology 21. 6.2. Results of Survey 21. 6.2.1. BORROW PIT 6 (BP6), BORROW PIT 7 (BP7), AND BORROW PIT 5 (BP5) 21. 6.2.1.1. BORROW PIT 6 (BP 6) 22. 6.2.1.2. BORROW PIT 7 (BP 7) 29. 6.2.1.3. BORROW PIT 5 (BP 5) 36. 6.2.3. QUARRY 7, BORROW PIT 10, AND QUARRY 6 38. 6.2.3.1. QUARRY 7 (Q7) 38. 6.2.3.2. BORROW PIT 10 41. 6.2.3.3. QUARRY 6 (Q6) 43. 6.2.4. BORROW PIT 18 (BP18), BORROW PIT 15 (BP15), AND QUARRY 1 (Q1) 45. 6.2.4.1. BORROW PIT 18 (BP18) 45. 6.2.4.2. BORROW PIT 15 (BP15) 47. 6.2.4.3. QUARRY 1 (Q1) 49. 6.2.5. N2 NATIONAL ROUTE 52. 6.2.5.1. N2 - BUILT ENVIRONMENT 54. i. N2 BE2 54. ii. N2 BE5 56. iii. N2 BE14 57. iv. N2 BE18 58. v. N2 BE20 60. 6.2.5.2. N2 – DRY PACKED STONE WALLING 62. i. N2 SW1 62. ii. N2 SW2 AND N2 SW3 64. 6.2.5.3. N2 – INFORMAL BURIAL GROUNDS 66. i. N2 G1 66. 7. DESCRIPTION OF SITES 67. 7.1. Stone Artefact Scatters 67. 7.1.1. Borrow Pit 6 (BP6) 67. 7.1.2. Borrow Pit 7 (BP7) 67. 7.2. Historical Artefact Scatter 67. 7.2.1. Borrow Pit 7 (BP7) 67. 7.3. Built Environment 68. 2 7.3.1. N2 BE2 68. 7.3.2. N2 BE5 68. 7.3.3. N2 BE14 68. 7.3.4. N2 BE18 68. 7.3.5. N2 BE20 69. 7.4. Dry Packed Stonewalling Structures 69. 7.4.1. N2 SW1 69. 7.4.2. N2 SW2 69. 7.4.3. N2 SW3 69. 7.5. Informal Burial Areas 70. 7.5.1. Quarry 6 (Q6) 70. 7.5.2. N2 G1 70. 8.1. GPS CO-ORDINATES AND SITES FOR THE PROPOSED UPGRADE OF THE N2 NATIONAL ROUTE, THE N2 ALTERNATIVE ROUTE, AS WELL AS THE ASSCIATED BORROW PITS AND QUARRIES, EASTERN CAPE PROVINCE. 71. 9. CULTURAL LANDSCAPE 75. 10. CONCLUSION 82. 11. RECOMMENDATIONS 83. 12. REFERENCES 86. 13. GENERAL REMARKS AND CONDITIONS 90. LIST OF APPENDICES: APPENDIX A: HERITAGE LEGISLATIVE REQUIREMENTS 91. APPENDIX B: GRADING SYSTEM 94. APPENDIX B: IDENTIFICATION OF ARCHAEOLOGICAL FEATURES AND MATERIAL FROM COASTAL AREAS: guidelines and procedures for developers 95. LIST OF TABLES TABLE 8.1. GPS CO-ORDINATES AND SITES FOR THE PROPOSED UPGRADE OF THE N2 NATIONAL ROUTE, THE N2 ALTERNATIVE ROUTE, AS WELL AS THE ASSOCIATED BORROW PITS AND QUARRIES, EASTERN CAPE PROVINCE. 71. LIST OF FIGURES Maps: Figure 1. 1:250 000 topographic map 3326 GRAHAMSTOWN showing the location of the N2-13 National route upgrade (black), the N2 alternative (orange), and the associated borrow pits (dark green dots) and quarries (light green dots). 19. Figure 2. Aerial view of the location of the proposed area N2 National Route (N2-13) road upgrade (white line) and associated borrow pits and quarries. Nearby archaeological sites stored in the Albany Museum Database have been plotted (3326BC 5, 3326BC 11, 3326BC 18). 20. Figure 3. Aerial view showing the locations of Borrow Pit 6 (BP6), Borrow Pit 7 (BP7), and Borrow Pit 5 (BP5) situated along the R67 road. 21. Figure 4. Close-up aerial view of the area proposed for Borrow Pit 6 (BP6) showing the plotted general GPS points, built environment, and isolated scatters of stone artefacts. 22. Figure 18. Close-up aerial view of the area proposed for Borrow Pit 7 (BP7) showing the plotted general GPS points, built environment, an isolated scatter of one stone artefact, and historical artefacts. 29. Figure 32. Close-up aerial view of the area proposed for Borrow Pit 5 (BP5) showing the plotted general GPS points. 36. Figure 35. Aerial view showing the locations of Quarry 7 (Q7) along the N2 National Route and, Borrow Pit 10 (BP10) 3 and Quarry 6 (Q6) situated in the Coombs. 38. Figure 36. Close-up aerial view of the area proposed for Quarry 7 (Q7) showing the plotted general GPS points. 38. Figure 40. Close-up aerial view of the area proposed for Borrow Pit 10 (BP10) showing the plotted general GPS points and existing diggings (red circle). 41. Figure 44. Close-up aerial view of the area proposed for Quarry 6 (Q6) showing the plotted general GPS points and the demarcated area housing the informal burial area (black block). 43. Figure 45. Aerial view showing the locations of Borrow Pit 18 (BP18), Borrow Pit 15 (BP15), and Quarry 1 (Q1). 45. Figure 46. Close-up aerial view of the area proposed for Borrow Pit 18 (BP18) showing the plotted general GPS points. 46. Figure 49. Close-up aerial view of the area proposed for Borrow Pit 15 (BP15) showing the plotted general GPS points. 47. Figure 52. Close-up aerial view of the area proposed for Quarry 1 (Q1) showing the plotted general GPS points. 49. Figure 65. Close-up aerial view of the location of the ruin of the structure situated on the Farm The Orchards 293 (N2 BE2). 54. Figure 68. Close-up aerial view of the location of the structure situated on the Farm Stony Vale 359 (N2 BE5). 56. Figure 70. Close-up aerial view of the location of the structure situated on the Farm Fraser’s Camp (N2 BE14). 57. Figure 72. Close-up aerial view of the location of the Fraser’s Camp Watch Tower fortification situated along the route proposed for the N2 Alternative (N2 BE18). 58. Figure 76. Close-up aerial view of the location of the structure and associated infrastructure on the farm Komsfountain 360 (N2 BE20). 61. Figure 78. Close-up aerial view of the location of the dry packed stone wall situated adjacent to the N2 National Route on the Farm Gilead 361 (N2 SW1). 62. Figure 85. Close-up aerial view of the location of the dry packed stone wall and circular feature on the Farm Komsfountain 360 (N2 SW2-3). Figure 88. Close-up aerial view of the location of the informal burial area on the farm Honeykop (N2 G1). Photographs: Figure 5. View of the existing borrow pit at the area proposed for Borrow Pit 6 (BP6). 23. Figure 6. View of the general landscape and dense thicket vegetation on site (BP6). 23. Figure 7. View of the general landscape and dense thicket vegetation (BP6). 24. Figure 8. Eskom power line and service road on northern boundary of the proposed site (BP6). 24. Figure 9. View of the results of the soil erosion occurring on site (BP6). 26. Figure 10. View of a stone artefact eroding out of the side of a 1.8 m deep donga (red circle, see Figure 14 for an example of the stone artefact) (BP6). 26. Figure 11. An example of a possible slightly smoothed lower grinding stone (BP6). 26. Figures 12 – 13. Examples of Middle Stone Age stone artefacts documented within the vicinity of the proposed Borrow Pit 6 (BP6) site (BP6). 27. Figures 14 – 15. Examples of stone artefacts documented within the vicinity of the proposed Borrow Pit 6 (BP6) site. 27. Figure 16. View of the disused water reservoir situated outside of the area proposed for the borrow pit (BP6). 28. Figure 17. View of the disused water trough situated outside of the area proposed for the borrow pit (BP6). 28. Figure 19. View of the existing borrow pit at the area proposed for Borrow Pit 7 (BP7). 30. Figure 20. View of the general landscape, vegetation cover, and kraal complex in the distance (BP7). 30. Figure 21. View of the general landscape and vegetation cover (BP7). 31. Figure 22. View of the general landscape and exposed areas allowing better archaeological visibility (BP7). 31. Figure 23. Close-up view of the disused trough within the kraal enclosure (BP7). 33. Figure 24. View of the area housing historical material in relation to the kraal complex (BP7). 33. Figure 25. Example of one isolated stone artefact scatter documented within the proposed borrow pit area (BP7).