National Association of Health Services Executives
Celebrating Our Future by Remembering Our Past: NAHSE at 50
National Association of Health Services Executives
Celebrating Our Future by Remembering Our Past: NAHSE at 50
Diane M. Howard, Ph.D., FACHE, Editor
National Association of Health Services Executives 1140 Connecticut Avenue, NW Suite 505 Washington, DC 20036 www.nahse.org ISBN-13: 978-1727066630
ISBN-10: 1727066634
Copyright © 2018 by National Association of Health Services Executives
Cover design by Stacy Marshall Contents
NAHSE History Moves Forward ...... xi The Winds of Change ...... 1 The Importance of Historical Documentation ...... 3 The Long Hot Summer ...... 8 Early Hospitals in America ...... 13
Establishing the American Medical Association and National Medical Association ...... 14 Formalizing Standards ...... 17 The National Hospital Association ...... 18 Black Hospital Reform ...... 19 Leaders of the Hospital Reform Movement ...... 21
The NHA and the AHA ...... 24 The Role of Philanthropy ...... 27 The Demise of the NHA ...... 30 The National Conference of Hospital Administrators ...... 31 The Sequel: The National Association of Health Services Executives ...... 34
GeĴ ing the Work Study Program Started ...... 38 Meeting a National Need ...... 40 Planning a Covert Takeover ...... 44 Minority Employment in Management and Administrative Positions (MEMAP) ...... 46 The Howard University Health Administration Program ...... 48
The First National NewsleĴ er ...... 50 Race, Politics, and Hospitals ...... 53 St. Albans Naval Hospital ...... 57 Annual Health Care Symposiums ...... 58 A Year of Setbacks ...... 60
v AnnualContents NAHSE Meeting ...... 62 Severing Ties with the AHA ...... 63 Robert Merri Leaves the National Offi ce ...... 67 Coming Alive in 1975 ...... 69 A Rift with the Chicago Chapter ...... 70
RWJF Grant Funding Saves the Day ...... 72 Joint Commi ee of NAHSE and ACHA ...... 73 The First National Awards Luncheon ...... 77 NAHSE’s Second Executive Director ...... 77 National Black Hospital Fund (NBHF) ...... 80
A Solicitation from the UNCF ...... 85 Honoring the Founders in Dallas in 1976 ...... 85 The First NAHSE Retreat: ...... 87 1977—A Period of Transition ...... 89 Containing Hospital Costs ...... 92
Soliciting DHEW SUPPORT ...... 93 Special Health Career Opportunity Grant (SHCOG) ...... 95 The Congressional Black Caucus’ Health Brain Trust Meetings ...... 96 The 1977 Membership Campaign ...... 101 Eff ect of the Membership Campaign ...... 104
Institutional Membership Concerns During the Early Years ...... 105 Reuniting with the AHA ...... 110 The National Offi ce Closes ...... 111 The Second NAHSE Retreat ...... 116 At the Crossroads of Despair ...... 120
A Plan of Action for the AHA ...... 121 The ACHA Ad Hoc Commi ee on Minority Aff airs ...... 126 NAHSE External Affi liations ...... 129 National Offi ce Finds a New Home ...... 132 A Struggle within a Struggle ...... 138
vi NAHSE’s Second Policy Brief ...... 140 Charting the Future Direction of NAHSE ...... 142 Asking the AHA for More ...... 143 Building a Paid Membership ...... 144 The Forward Plan ...... 146
“Together We Stand” ...... 150 The National Offi ce Closes—Again ...... 152 AHA/NAHSE Joint Relations Commi ee Initiatives...... 153 1985: The Year of Commitment ...... 155 The Third NAHSE Retreat ...... 157
The Sugar Ditch Lawsuit...... 159 Implementing the AHA-NAHSE Joint Relations Initiatives ...... 160 The National Offi ce Finds New Home ...... 161 Minority Health Care Task Force Report ...... 162 The First NAHSE Educational Conference ...... 164
Urban Shelters & Health Care Systems ...... 165 Continuing the Services of USHCSI ...... 166 The Health Careers Opportunity Program Grant Application ...... 168 Focusing on Disparities ...... 171 Second Annual Education Conference ...... 172
The Question ...... 174 Twenty Years Later...... 176 Celebrating the Twentieth Anniversary ...... 179 Improving the Educational Conference ...... 182 Advancing Entrepreneurship ...... 185
1988 Election Results ...... 187 At Another Crossroads ...... 187 The NAHSE Health Administration Services Program ...... 191 O & J Associates, Inc...... 192 The New York Retreat ...... 194
vii The First NAHSE-ACHE Career A ainment Study ...... 195 A New Standard for Planning the Educational Conference ...... 199 1993: NAHSE’s 25th Anniversary Year ...... 201 The White House Task Force on Health Care Reform ...... 202 The First Annual Chief Executive Offi cer Conference ...... 203
The Institute for Diversity in Health Management ...... 205 Renewing the Focus on Public Policy ...... 206 Initiating the Student Case Competition ...... 207 Establishing a National Strategic Plan ...... 208 A Series of Firsts ...... 210
Advancing the Annual Education Conference ...... 212 The W.K. Kellogg Foundation Grant ...... 213 The Florence S. Gaynor Distinguished Lecture Series ...... 214 Developing a Comprehensive Public Policy Strategy ...... 216 1998: NAHSE Turns 30 ...... 217
NAHSE’s 30th Anniversary Statement ...... 218 The Second ACHE/NAHSE Career A ainment Study Results ...... 219 NAHSE’s Career A ainment Action Plan ...... 221 Nat’s Notes on NAHSE ...... 223 Assessing NAHSE’s Positives and Negatives ...... 225
The Return of the NAHSE Notes ...... 229 The Legacy Fund ...... 231 Establishing the NAHSE Hall of Fame ...... 233 Rejuvenating Public Policy ...... 234 In Support of a National Offi ce ...... 235
Challenges for the Future ...... 238 Hudgens Award Winners ...... 239 NAHSE and Members in the News...... 242 Magazine Articles Highlighting NAHSE and/or Members ...... 244 Other Collaborations ...... 260
viiii National Black Hospital Association ...... 260 Leadership and Management ...... 262 The Presidents Look Forward ...... 280 The National Offi ce ...... 285 The NAHSE Logo...... 288
Bylaws and Commi ee Structure ...... 288 The Entrepreneur Commi ee ...... 289 NAHSE Notes ...... 290 Evere V. Fox Student Case Competition ...... 291 Public Policy Commi ee ...... 292
Research Commi ee ...... 294 Student Summit and Student Forum ...... 294 Strategic Planning and Bylaws ...... 295 NAHSE Chapters ...... 296 Game Changers—How Can We Say Thank-You ...... 340
Demographic Profi le of NAHSE Members ...... 353 Summing Up—Conclusion ...... 360 National Education Themes ...... 362 Awards Listing ...... 365 Interview Participants ...... 371
NAHSE Milestones ...... 374 Evere V. Fox Student Case Competition Participants 1996–2017 ...... 388 Sponsors ...... 398 Listing of Names ...... 401 Subjects ...... 421
ix x NAHSE Hist ory Moves Forward
he NAHSE history project was in development for twenty years prior to its completion. Th anks to the meticulous note taking, collection and recording of correspondence and news- letters, and the cataloguing and safekeeping of 40 years of Tpictures, mementoes, and factoids, Nathaniel Wesley, Jr. single-handedly preserved the organization’s history. It is to no small feat that the organi- zation’s history survives because of his dutiful commitment to preserving the organization’s history in print. Th rough numerous personal and pro- fessional moves, Wesley moved NAHSE’s history with him in boxes and in remembrances as a personal witness to history. No one person has been as critical to the history project as he has been. His clear love for NAHSE and his personal interest in preserving its history led to the culmination of this book.
At the 2006 NAHSE CEO/Senior Executive Meeting in Las Vegas, Nat, as he is aff ectionately known, gave a presentation on “Legacy and Visions for African American Leadership in Healthcare and Economics.” At the conclusion of his presentation, a spontaneous request went out from Percy Allen, II, former NAHSE president and the chairman of the conference, that the history of NAHSE be written. With this request came an outpouring from the audience and a commitment of funds to support the documentation of NAHSE’s history for its 40th anniversary celebra- tion in 2008. Concurrently, without the knowledge of the senior execu- tives who were attending the meeting, the NAHSE Research Committee, composed of Charlotte Collins, Forrest Daniels, Rupert Evans, Diane Howard, Maude Lofton, and Velma Roberts, was working on a history project manuscript. No member of the Research Committee was in at- tendance at the CEO conference because of a meeting confl ict that had the academics in the group at the Seattle meeting of the Association of University Programs in Health Administration. Upon the conclusion of
xi the respective meetings and the realization that one task—the writing of the NAHSE history—was being pursued by two entities, the Research Committee directed its outline and discussion points to Nat. Rather than set up competing enterprises, the Research Committee deferred to the person who was the de facto organization historian, Nat Wesley.
On August 24, 2006, Percy Allen, II, FACHE celebrated his re- tirement as the President of Bon Secours Baltimore Health System in Baltimore, Maryland. After a distinguished career, Percy and his wife Fay, a licensed nurse, had decided to retire to their home in Virginia Beach, Virginia and serve as roaming ambassadors to NAHSE and other non-profi t organizations. At Percy’s retirement party, a host of NAHSE members came to celebrate the life, legacy, and contributions of the man who is lovingly referred to as “the godfather.” At a private reception held in a suite following Allen’s retirement dinner, he brokered the deal that became the NAHSE history project. He understood that there was an un- derlying misunderstanding about the history project between the parties that were simultaneously working on the project. He wanted to bring the parties together under a committee structure so that the project could be completed in time for the 40th anniversary celebration. He realized that he had commissioned the writing of the project at the CEO conference without appreciating that the NAHSE Research Committee had started the project and then backed off for fear of creating an internal organiza- tional battle over the project.
Th e history project was complicated by the fact that Wesley would be on a retainer for his services and the Research Committee members had volunteered to write the history at no cost to the organization. Percy could see that he needed to play Solomon by brokering a rela- tionship between Wesley and the Research Committee. Th rough a se- ries of e-mails and Executive Committee conference calls, the decision was made to have the parties collaborate on the project. Th e members of the Research Committee composed of Charlotte Collins, Rupert Evans, Diane Howard, Maude Lofton and Velma Roberts met with Nat Wesley at the 21st Annual Meeting in Baltimore on October 11, 2006 to “clear the air” on any misunderstandings about roles and responsibilities and to move forward on the project. xii On November 22, 2006 the Research Committee outline developed by Forrest Daniels was merged into the Wesley outline and the activities of the parties were merged. Th e Board of the National Association of Health Services Executives under the leadership of Christopher Mosley, NAHSE National president, approved the history project outline and budget during its December 1, 2006 executive committee meeting. Th e NAHSE History Project was offi cially sanctioned by the organization and its deliberations and writing began. Th e fi rst order of business was to assemble a timeline for deliverables of writing drafts. Th e book editor, George Rumsey who trained at the University of Chicago in English was selected as the book editor and the book publisher; Lewis Saltzman from Saltzman Printers was selected as the printer. On January 19, 2007, Nat Wesley and Elworth Taylor, the architect of the NAHSE annual meet- ing, met in Chicago at Rush University with Diane Howard and Maude Lofton to kick-off the collection of narratives that would be developed into this project. In advance of the meeting, Nat had assembled with care, all correspondence, pictures, and newsletters from 1968 to 1988, NAHSE’s fi rst twenty-years. With characteristic humor, sarcasm, and wit, the project started with the recollection of memory.
It was clear with this auspicious start that pulling memory from the organization’s founders, past-presidents, and past-committee members at the national and local levels was going to be painstaking; mainly because people had forgotten the past. A time capsule of national and internation- al events was developed as a tickler system to remind future interviewees of what events shaped where NAHSE was at the time they served in vari- ous capacities. Even with the time capsule, some memories of events were lost and so the history that appears in these pages is the recollections from written artifacts that remain and the perspectives of those who are alive to comment.
Th e timeline for the project included the initial brain dump of events over the 40-year period of NAHSE on January 19, 2007. From January 2007 to January 2008, Maude Lofton read through the histo- ry contained in the Nat Wesley library. Key issues were extracted over the 40-years and developed into narrative. While the Nat Wesley library
xiii was being reviewed, Diane Howard was interviewing the past presidents, chapter presidents, committee chairs, executive directors/managers, and various members of the Association, along with senior executives of affi l- iated organizations that had a relationship to NAHSE. Th ese interviews and quantitative data from NAHSEs membership surveys were developed into a profi le of the organization and then synthesized to look at the cur- rent state of aff airs in the organization and to forecast the organization’s future.
A panel of past presidents, current offi cers, and members of the Research Committee were selected as reviewers of the history manu- script. Two drafts of the manuscript were directed to the NAHSE History Review Panel for comment. Draft 1 was distributed in October 2007 and Draft 2 was distributed in March 2008. Conference calls and emails from the Panel provided commentary on manuscript changes and additions. Diane Howard, Maude Lofton, Elworth Taylor, and Nathaniel Wesley met in Chicago on May 5, 2008 to review the document and review the narrative. Photographs to be included in the book were selected from the Wesley library. Th e fi nal draft of the manuscript went to the book editor on July 10, 2008 and the manuscript was submitted to the publisher on August 29, 2008. Th e 20-month process was a labor of love for the par- ticipants and will serve as testimony to the leadership and fortitude of the Association’s founders, offi cers, committee chairs, and members.
In its fi rst edition, the Research Committee thanked those who pro- vided commentary for the book with special thanks to the History Project Review Panel which included Percy Allen II, Cliff ord Barnes, Jacqueline Burgess Bishop, Denise Brooks-Williams, Robert Currie, Patricia Golden Webb, Sandra Gould, Andre Lee, Deborah Lee-Eddie, Kevin Lofton, Howard Jessamy, Rodney Miller, Christopher Mosley, Everard Rutledge, Elworth Taylor, and the indomitable Nathaniel Wesley, Jr.
In the 2nd and 3rd editions of the book, the Committee thanked the generous support from Andrea Price and Compass Group, which includes Crothall Healthcare, Morrison Healthcare, and Th ompson Hospitality. Th e Research Committee, 2008–2011, members were Charlotte Collins, J.D., Forrest Daniels, DSc, MHA, FACHE; Rupert xiv Evans, DHA, FACHE; Diane Howard, Ph.D., FACHE (Chair); Maude Lofton, M.D., and Velma Roberts, Ph.D.
Th e NAHSE Annual Meeting in Orlando marks the 50th anniver- sary of the organization. A great deal has occurred since the 3rd history book edition in 2013. Andrea Price completed a successful presidential term in offi ce and passed the torch to Roy Hawkins who subsequently passed the torch to Anthony King who passed the torch to Richelle Webb Dixon, the Association president for the 50th anniversary milestone. Th e organization has offi cially advanced its leadership from being Baby Boomer led to being Generation X led. Th is change presents tremendous opportunities for a volunteer organization and allows the organization to embrace the moniker “empowering the next generation of healthcare leaders today.”
In 2018, NAHSE boasts a national offi ce in Washington, D.C. and 29 chapters from New England to Northern California. Th e mission of the organization continues to be promoting the advancement and devel- opment of Black health care leaders, and elevating the quality of health care services rendered to minority and underserved communities. As the organization prepares to move into its “generation next,” the organiza- tion mission and focus may be challenged by a younger and multicultur- al membership who remains committed to the organization’s founding principles.
As Richelle Webb Dixon wrote in her open letter to the membership as she entered the NAHSE presidency:
For fi fty years NAHSE has advocated and supported the promotion and advancement of minority healthcare leaders; for fi fty years, NAHSE has worked tirelessly to ensure that minority and under- served communities have access to quality healthcare services. Th is year we celebrate the visionaries who founded our organization, we honor members who humbly work to fulfi ll our mission and high- light young professionals whose passion and intellect will propel NAHSE into the next 50 years.
xv NAHSE was established in 1968 during the Civil Rights Movement. Today, more than ever, I feel we are reliving that move- ment. As an organization, we must continue our eff orts to ensure diversity is celebrated and that executive suites across this country refl ect the individuals and communities we serve. We must ensure that all individuals have access to aff ordable, quality healthcare services. In 2018, we continue the work that was begun more than fi fty years ago with a renewed commitment that NAHSE remains a relevant resource for generations to come.
Th e NAHSE founders would be proud to know that the organiza- tion is in good hands.
xvi ĕ e Winds of Change
AHSE celebrates its 50th anniversary in a vastly diff erent healthcare landscape in 2018. With the election of President Barack Obama in 2008, the fi rst African-American presi- dent, a post-racial era was believed to be in force. Th is Noptimism was short-lived and the introduction of the Aff ordable Care Act in 2010 extending health benefi ts and insurance to over 20 million Americans caused signifi cant rift within the public. Th e Tea Party move- ment with the intent to impose fi scal constraints on the government mor- phed into an anti-Obama movement. Th e U.S. House of Representatives and Senate subsequently changed control from Democrat to Republican and the spirit of cooperation on healthcare legislation was lost.
Th e British Petroleum deep water oil rig explosion in the Gulf of Mexico, 2010–2011 budget impasse, rise of Occupy Wall Street protests, combat troop withdrawal from Iraq, terrorist attack on the Libyan city of Benghazi killing four Americans, and Hurricane Sandy which devastated the East Coast occupied attention through 2012 as well as the reelection of President Obama. In 2013, President Obama along with former presi- dents Jimmy Carter and Bill Clinton commemorated the 50th anniversa- ry of Martin Luther King’s “I Have a Dream” speech. Later that year, Th e Aff ordable Care Act began registering people for the expanded federal government health insurance program (Kaiser Family Foundation, 2017).
In addition to the ACA, the promise of the Obama years brought about the focus on global warming with the Paris Climate Accord, the Iran Nuclear Disarmament deal, reestablishment of full diplomatic re- lations with Cuba, and prison reform. It also introduced Black Lives Matter movement and discussion of police brutality in poor, minority communities. Th e election of Donald Trump in 2016 ushered in a focus on reversing access to healthcare provided by ACA insurance coverage, di-
NAHSE — Th e History Project 1 sastrous hurricane season that all but destroyed Puerto Rico with minimal federal support, massive tax cuts, incarceration of migrants, separation of children from their parents at the Mexican border, and antagonisms and bombast directed at various minority groups.
Viewed in retrospect the winds of change of the 1960’s is not his- torically remote as we move to the end of the 2010’s. Organizations like NAHSE become more relevant and vibrant in the context of national and local politics that impact healthcare and the broader community.
Th e formation of the National Association of Health Services Executives fi ts squarely into the political and social turbulence of the 1960s. Th e assassinations of the U.S. President John F. Kennedy followed by that of Malcolm X, the President’s brother Robert F. Kennedy who was running for the Democratic nomination for President, then the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. spilled over into social unrest and burning and the destruction of property in major U.S. cities. In addition to the loss of these national fi gures, bombings in the South killed four young girls at the 16th Street Baptist Church in Birmingham, Alabama, Freedom Summer to register blacks to vote resulted in the death of three civil rights workers James Chaney, Andrew Goodman, and Michael Schwerner in Mississippi, the escalation of the Vietnam War, and the tension between non-vio- lence advocated by Dr. King and Stokely Carmichael’s black power move- ment of the Black Panther Party made the 1960s turbulence all the more dramatic. During this period the emergence of major books authored by blacks defi ned the philosophy of the times including Ralph Ellison’s Invisible Man, James Baldwin’s Nobody Knows My Name, Claude Brown’s Manchild in the Promised Land, and Alex Haley’s Th e Autobiography of Malcolm X. Th ese books and others were mandatory readings and helped shape the vision of NAHSE’s founders.
In 1968, Whitney Young, the president of the National Urban League, was the invited speaker at the American Hospital Association’s Annual Meeting in Atlantic City, New Jersey. In his speech, he made the connection between the blight in urban America and the role of non-profi t hospitals as economic engines in these communities. He challenged these hospitals to employ and promote black leadership and to administratively
2 NAHSE — Th e History Project refl ect the community in which they resided. Young’s eloquence in ad- vocating for employment opportunities for racial minorities in hospitals was the impetus for the formation of NAHSE. Nine members adjourned to an Atlantic City hotel room to make Whitney Young’s speech a reality. Th e nine NAHSE organizers had played by the rules, pursued advanced degrees in business and health management, and joined the professional organizations in the fi eld. Th ey had to use the AHA forum where one of its invited speakers had advocated for the elevation of minorities into hos- pital leadership to advance their economic condition and that of minority patients who needed access to health care services.