Maghrebi Rivalries Over Sub‑Saharan Africa. Algeria and Tunisia
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
NO. 54 NOVEMBER 2020 Introduction Maghrebi Rivalries Over Sub-Saharan Africa Algeria and Tunisia Seeking to Keep Up with Morocco Isabelle Werenfels The Covid-19 pandemic has moved relations with Sub-Saharan Africa further up the Maghreb countries’ agenda and consolidated existing trends. Morocco is the Maghreb state with the most sophisticated Sub-Sahara policy. Its motivations include attractive growth markets in Africa, frustration over restricted access to Europe, stalemated in- tegration in the Maghreb and the wish to see the Western Sahara recognised as Moroc- can. Morocco’s Sub-Sahara policy has heightened tensions with Algeria and awakened ambitions in Tunisia. Algiers, as a significant funder and security actor in the African Union (AU) and “protector” of the Western Sahara independence movement, is seek- ing to thwart Rabat’s advances. Tunis for its part is trying to follow in Rabat’s foot- steps, hoping that closer relations with Africa will boost economic growth. The Euro- pean Union should treat these trends as an opportunity for African integration and triangular EU/Maghreb/Sub-Sahara cooperation. This could counteract Algeria’s feel- ing of growing irrelevance, strengthen Tunisia’s economy, put Morocco’s hegemonic ambitions in perspective, and thus mitigate the negative dynamics of the rivalry. The Africa policies of the Maghreb states and diplomatic role in Africa. Mohammed differ significantly in their intensity, vis- VI took personal charge of the country’s ibility, motivations, and priorities. On a Africa policy, backing it with intense travel broader level they reflect each state’s gen- diplomacy and strategic appearances, for eral domestic and foreign policy capacities. example at the 5th AU-EU Summit in 2017 This is visible not least in the way the coun- in Abidjan. Rabat has achieved notable suc- tries market their Africa policies. cesses with its soft power approach, which For some time Morocco has had the most encompasses economic, development co- dynamic and progressive Africa policy of the operation, migration and religious compo- three countries. King Hassan II, who ruled nents. In January 2017 Morocco was re- from 1961 to 1999, had already put out admitted to the AU after 33 years, against feelers to West Africa. But it is under his the objections of heavyweights like South son Mohammed VI (since 1999) that Morocco Africa and Algeria but strongly supported has proactively pursued a key economic by numerous West African states as well as Rwanda. Morocco quit the AU’s predeces- of its military, logistical and financial sup- sor in protest in 1984 after it accepted the port for anti-colonial movements. Close Western Sahara into membership. development cooperation with the newly Morocco has enormously expanded its independent African states and significant presence in Sub-Saharan Africa in the past engagement in the Non-Aligned Movement decade, above all economically. It is one also boosted Algeria’s standing across the of the continent’s largest African investors, continent. alongside South Africa, Kenya and Nigeria, Since its civil war in the 1990s, which and the biggest African investor in West coincided with the end of the Cold War Africa, where Moroccan insurance compa- order, Algiers has failed to restore its lost nies, telecommunications providers, and grandeur and its policy of “strategic depth” banks enjoy significant market shares. Mo- in Africa. The security sphere represents a rocco also exports agricultural and renew- partial exception. Here Algeria plays a rele- able energy technology, especially to West vant role within the AU institutions, and Africa, and is increasingly looking to East Algiers has also engaged as a mediator in and Central Africa too, for example Ethio- African conflicts with some success. Eco- pia, Rwanda and Cameroon. Since 2017 nomic initiatives under President Abdelaziz Rabat has also been seeking accession to Bouteflika between 1999 and 2019 – such the Economic Community of West African as an ambitious investment conference in States (ECOWAS), to date without success. Algiers at the end of 2016 – have been less One central driver of this policy is the successful. Although Algeria was a found- desire to open up new markets for Moroc- ing member of the AU’s development agency can businesses, especially those controlled NEPAD (now AUDA), its engagement has by the royal family. Two relevant aspects remained modest, despite having had con- here are the limited access to the European siderable material resources at its disposal Single Market and marginal economic inter- until a few years ago. action across the closed border with Algeria. From 2013, Algeria’s engagement in Morocco’s desire for recognition of its claim Africa was hampered by Bouteflika’s severe to the Western Sahara is at least as impor- health problems, which ended his travel- tant for its “turn to Africa”. Related to this is ling diplomacy. Yet even before that, the the regional rivalry with Algeria that goes Algerian President had shown waning in- beyond the Western Sahara question, where terest in Africa, despite having belonged Algeria functions as the “protector” of the decades ago to the architects of Algeria’s independence movement, the Polisario. early foreign policy and its support for anti- Both states are seeking to exploit new op- colonial movements. portunities created by changes in the larger His successor Abdelmadjid Tebboune, regional context, such as the ousting of the in office since December 2019, announced Libyan leader and advocate of greater Afri- Algeria’s “return to Africa” at his first AU can unity Mu’ammar al-Qadhafi, who played Summit in February 2020. While this is an extremely active role in African diplo- probably motivated by a desire not to leave macy, development, and security questions. the field entirely to Morocco, external secu- rity challenges also lead Algiers to look to the south: instability in Mali, chaos in Neighbour Algeria Irritated Libya, pressure of migration on its southern borders, and the European and US military Morocco’s rise on the continent could be presence in the Sahel. The latter Algiers described as close to traumatic for Algeria, observes with suspicion. whose influence has waned substantially. However a contoured Africa strategy During the first decades after independence comparable to Morocco’s is not currently in 1962 Algeria enjoyed great prestige in observable. And the prospects of one emerg- large parts of Sub-Saharan Africa on account ing are not especially good. Algerian deci- SWP Comment 54 November 2020 2 sion-makers are preoccupied with signifi- the fundamental problems of the young cant internal and economic challenges – democracy – slow decision-making, an for which they have to date been unable to overwhelmed parliament, and a lack of present strategies. political continuity – this is inevitably a protracted process. Tunisia Seeking to Catch Up Institutional Power Play Tunisia has been observing Morocco’s Africa policy increasingly closely and en- Morocco’s confidence, Algeria’s defence of viously. In ministries and business circles its legacy and Tunisia’s reawakening inter- one hears that Tunisia could in fact offer est are also reflected within the African comparable or better expertise, for example institutions and organisations. The demise in the IT, real estate development, and of Libyan dictator Qadhafi in 2011 made banking sectors, in technical planning of Algeria the unchallenged Maghreb heavy- major infrastructure projects, and in weight within the AU. But Morocco health and education services. now contributes at least as much financial- After a good two decades where Sub- ly and expects relevant positions and Saharan Africa played a marginal role, influence in AU organs. Tunisia has been gradually awakening from For almost two decades an Algerian has its slumber. Following the removal of the held the post of AU Commissioner for Peace Ben Ali regime in 2011 the transitional and Security, who also oversees the AU’s government attempted to revive the African Peace and Security Council (PSC). Morocco diplomatic engagement of the era of Presi- joined the PSC in 2018 and held its rotating dent Habib Bourguiba (1957–1987). But chair in 2019. Where Rabat is represented this was a brief episode of little strategic in AU bodies there is often conflict over import. For example Tunis was unable to formulations that (could potentially) relate prevent the decision of the African Devel- to the Western Sahara conflict, and over opment Bank in 2013 to move its head- the presence of the Sahrawi Republic as a quarters back to Abidjan. member of the AU. Although Morocco Tunisia has nevertheless incrementally has not to date succeeded in excluding the expanded its engagement in Sub-Saharan Polisario from the AU, the fronts have Africa, as demonstrated by its joining hardened. Influential countries like South ECOWAS in 2017 as an observer, and its Africa maintain their unequivocal backing accession to the Common Market for East- for the Polisario, but thirteen AU members ern and Southern Africa (COMESA) in 2018. explicitly support Morocco’s claim to the In 2017 the then prime minister, Youssef Western Sahara, having opened consulates Chahed, visited Niger, Mali and Burkina in the Moroccan-occupied part since 2019. Faso. The new prime minister appointed in Algeria is home to an important AU in- autumn 2020, Hichem Mechichi, announced stitution, the African Centre for the Study that he would step up economic diplomacy and Research on Terrorism (ACSRT). Morocco in Africa. The country’s president, Kaïs and Tunisia now have their own too: The Saïed, to date has shown only limited inter- African Migration Observatory founded in est in Sub-Saharan Africa. 2018 is based in Rabat, the AU Institute for So far it is the private sector that presses Statistics in Tunis. In 2020 Morocco also hardest for a clearer orientation on Africa, achieved a minor victory in relation to Afri- first and foremost the Tunisia-Africa Busi- can representation in the United Nations, ness Council (TABC).