“Neither United Nor Separated” Negotiating Difference in Ashutosh Gowariker’S Lagaan and Ketan Mehta’S Mangal Pandey

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

“Neither United Nor Separated” Negotiating Difference in Ashutosh Gowariker’S Lagaan and Ketan Mehta’S Mangal Pandey “Neither united nor separated” Negotiating Difference in Ashutosh Gowariker’s Lagaan and Ketan Mehta’s Mangal Pandey LUCIA KRÄMER HE PAST FIVE YEARS have seen an unprecedented rise of interest in popular Indian cinema among Western filmgoers and T film scholars. Not only has an increasing number of Indian films been released both for cinemas and home entertainment, there has also been a plethora of new books on what is generally known as ‘Bolly- wood’.1 The fact that most of these books are still conceived as introduc- tions to the history, conventions, and stars of popular Indian filmmaking 1 At the moment, the meaning of the word ‘Bollywood’ seems to be in flux. Originally coined by Indian film journalists as a playful and pejorative term referring to the Bombay film industry, ‘Bollywood’ is very often and somewhat incorrectly used to refer to popular Indian cinema as a whole (see, for example, Stadtler), and to con- trast it to New Indian Cinema and Indian parallel cinema. Wimal Dissanayake, by contrast, is one scholar who uses the term in a more restricted sense to designate films produced in Bombay in the wake of the liberalization of the Indian economy whose narratives and economics manifest particular effects of globalization and cultural nar- cissism. Although many Indian filmmakers reject the term because it implies that the films it denotes are derivative and defective when compared to Hollywood, according to Dissanayake “over the years it has come to assume more and more a neutral stance, appearing as a term of description rather than disapprobation.” See Florian Stadtler, “Cultural Connections: Lagaan and Its Audience Responses,” Third World Quarterly 26.3 (2005): 523, and Wimal Dissanayake, “Globalization and Cultural Narcissism: Note on Bollywood Cinema,” Asian Cinema 15.1 (2004): 143–44. See the titles by Dwyer, Ganti, Kabir, Manschot & deVos, Mishra, and Pendakur for recent introduc- tory books on ‘Bollywood’. 220 LUCIA KRÄMER º underlines the alien nature of this “cinema of interruptions”2 for Western spectators. Among the most unfamiliar yet typical features of the films are their average length of two and a half to three hours, convoluted plots with unexpected twists, and an episodic structure aimed at creating a fabric of thrills rather than a strictly coherent narrative. Moreover, popular Indian films often mix diverse genres, which can seem incompatible to Western eyes; this effect is exacerbated by the fact that the films usually also con- tain several song-and-dance sequences.3 In the genre mix, melodrama tends to be dominant – an impression supported by the unabashedly ver- bal nature of Indian cinema, where emotions are thus exteriorized to a de- gree rare in Western cinema today, and where the visual imagery is often doubled and/or elucidated by the dialogues. In this essay, I would like to investigate the negotiation of these cine- matic differences with regard to the Hindi films Lagaan (Tax, dir. Ashu- tosh Gowariker, 2001) and Mangal Pandey – The Rising (dir. Ketan Mehta, 2005), two historical films set in India at the time of British colonial rule. The main focus will lie on the analysis of the major verbal and visual imagery that is used in the films to represent difference between the Brit- ish colonizers and the Indian colonized. I will concentrate on the depiction of two British characters in the films who try to overcome racial, cultural, and national differences and whose attempts are doomed to failure owing to the historical situation in which the stories are set. However, beyond the film texts proper, Lagaan and Mangal Pandey are also representative ex- amples of recent developments within the Indian film industry and of the boom of Indian films in the West, and their reception illustrates the cur- rent negotiation of the differences between the Western and Indian cine- matic cultures in Western non-academic film criticism. At the end of the essay, I will therefore also have a look at the relation between the words of film criticism and the images and words of the films, and I will suggest 2 See Lalitha Gopalan, Cinema of Interruptions: Action Genres in Contemporary Indian Cinema (London: BFI, 2002): 16–22, on the aesthetics of interruption in popular Indian cinema caused by song-and-dance sequences, the interval and censorship. 3 From a Western point of view, the films therefore belong to the ailing genre of the musical. In the Indian genre system however, a musical would be a film containing more than eight musical numbers instead of the four to six that are the norm. .
Recommended publications
  • Movie Aquisitions in 2010 - Hindi Cinema
    Movie Aquisitions in 2010 - Hindi Cinema CISCA thanks Professor Nirmal Kumar of Sri Venkateshwara Collega and Meghnath Bhattacharya of AKHRA Ranchi for great assistance in bringing the films to Aarhus. For questions regarding these acquisitions please contact CISCA at [email protected] (Listed by title) Aamir Aandhi Directed by Rajkumar Gupta Directed by Gulzar Produced by Ronnie Screwvala Produced by J. Om Prakash, Gulzar 2008 1975 UTV Spotboy Motion Pictures Filmyug PVT Ltd. Aar Paar Chak De India Directed and produced by Guru Dutt Directed by Shimit Amin 1954 Produced by Aditya Chopra/Yash Chopra Guru Dutt Production 2007 Yash Raj Films Amar Akbar Anthony Anwar Directed and produced by Manmohan Desai Directed by Manish Jha 1977 Produced by Rajesh Singh Hirawat Jain and Company 2007 Dayal Creations Pvt. Ltd. Aparajito (The Unvanquished) Awara Directed and produced by Satyajit Raj Produced and directed by Raj Kapoor 1956 1951 Epic Productions R.K. Films Ltd. Black Bobby Directed and produced by Sanjay Leela Bhansali Directed and produced by Raj Kapoor 2005 1973 Yash Raj Films R.K. Films Ltd. Border Charulata (The Lonely Wife) Directed and produced by J.P. Dutta Directed by Satyajit Raj 1997 1964 J.P. Films RDB Productions Chaudhvin ka Chand Dev D Directed by Mohammed Sadiq Directed by Anurag Kashyap Produced by Guru Dutt Produced by UTV Spotboy, Bindass 1960 2009 Guru Dutt Production UTV Motion Pictures, UTV Spot Boy Devdas Devdas Directed and Produced by Bimal Roy Directed and produced by Sanjay Leela Bhansali 1955 2002 Bimal Roy Productions
    [Show full text]
  • Bollywood Lens Syllabus
    Bollywood's Lens on Indian Society Professor Anita Weiss INTL 448/548, Spring 2018 [email protected] Mondays, 4-7:20 pm 307 PLC; 541 346-3245 Course Syllabus Film has the ability to project powerful images of a society in ways conventional academic mediums cannot. This is particularly true in learning about India, which is home to the largest film industries in the world. This course explores images of Indian society that emerge through the medium of film. Our attention will be focused on the ways in which Indian society and history is depicted in film, critical social issues being explored through film; the depicted reality vs. the historical reality; and the powerful role of the Indian film industry in affecting social orientations and values. Course Objectives: 1. To gain an awareness of the historical background of the subcontinent and of contemporary Indian society; 2. To understand the sociocultural similarities yet significant diversity within this culture area; 3. To learn about the political and economic realities and challenges facing contemporary India and the rapid social changes the country is experiencing; 4. To learn about the Indian film industry, the largest in the world, and specifically Bollywood. Class format Professor Weiss will open each class with a short lecture on the issues which are raised in the film to be screened for that day. We will then view the selected film, followed by a short break, and then extensive in- class discussion. Given the length of most Bollywood films, we will need to fast-forward through much of the song/dance and/or fighting sequences.
    [Show full text]
  • Global Cinema
    GLOBAL CINEMA Edited by Katarzyna Marciniak, Anikó Imre, and Áine O’Healy The Global Cinema series publishes innovative scholarship on the transnational themes, industries, economies, and aesthetic elements that increasingly connect cinemas around the world. It promotes theoretically transformative and politi- cally challenging projects that rethink film studies from cross-cultural, comparative perspectives, bringing into focus forms of cinematic production that resist nation- alist or hegemonic frameworks. Rather than aiming at comprehensive geographical coverage, it foregrounds transnational interconnections in the production, dis- tribution, exhibition, study, and teaching of film. Dedicated to global aspects of cinema, this pioneering series combines original perspectives and new method- ological paths with accessibility and coverage. Both “global” and “cinema” remain open to a range of approaches and interpretations, new and traditional. Books pub- lished in the series sustain a specific concern with the medium of cinema but do not defensively protect the boundaries of film studies, recognizing that film exists in a converging media environment. The series emphasizes a historically expanded rather than an exclusively presentist notion of globalization; it is mindful of reposi- tioning “the global” away from a US-centric/Eurocentric grid, and remains critical of celebratory notions of “globalizing film studies.” Katarzyna Marciniak is a professor of Transnational Studies in the English Depart- ment at Ohio University. Anikó Imre is an associate
    [Show full text]
  • Concordia University Presents
    ConcordiaConcordia UniversityUniversity presentspresents THE 30th ANNUAL SOCIETY FOR ANIMATION STUDIES CONFERENCE | MONTREAL 2018 We would like to begin by acknowledging that Concordia University is located on unceded Indigenous lands. The Kanien’kehá:ka Nation is recognized as the custodians of the lands and waters on which we gather today. Tiohtiá:ke/ Montreal is historically known as a gathering place for many First Nations. Today, it is home to a diverse population of Indigenous and other peoples. We respect the continued connections with the past, present and future in our ongoing relationships with Indigenous and other peoples within the Montreal community. Please clickwww.concordia.ca/about/indigenous.html here to visit Indigenous Directions Concordia. TABLE OF CONTENTS Welcomes 4 Schedule 8-9 Parallel Sessions 10-16 Keynote Speakers 18-20 Screenings 22-31 Exhibitions 33-36 Speakers A-B 39-53 Speakers C-D 54-69 Speakers E-G 70-79 Speakers H-J 80-90 Speakers K-M 91-102 Speakers N-P 103-109 Speakers R-S 110-120 Speakers T-Y 121-132 2018 Team & Sponsors 136-137 Conference Map 138 3 Welcome to Concordia! On behalf of Concordia’s Faculty of Fine Arts, welcome to the 2018 Society for Animation Studies Conference. It’s an honour to host the SAS on its thirtieth anniversary. Concordia University opened a Department of Cinema in 1976 and today, the Mel Hoppenheim School of Cinema is the oldest film school in Canada and the largest university-based centre for the study of film animation, film production and film studies in the country.
    [Show full text]
  • The Country and the City the Perception of the Nri in Indian Cinema
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ENGLISH LANGUAGE, LITERATURE AND TRANSLATION STUDIES (IJELR) A QUARTERLY, INDEXED, REFEREED AND PEER REVIEWED OPEN ACCESS INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL http://www.ijelr.in (Impact Factor : 5.9745 (ICI) KY PUBLICATIONS REVIEW ARTICLE ARTICLE Vol. 5. Issue.2., 2018 (April-June) THE COUNTRY AND THE CITY THE PERCEPTION OF THE NRI IN INDIAN CINEMA NAYANA GEORGE MA English (2017-2019) The English and Foreign Languages University, Hyderabad Email: [email protected] ABSTRACT This paper seeks to explore and relate the notions of the country and the city as given in the works of Raymond Williams, particularly The Country and the City and Keywords, to the Bollywood film Dilwale Dulhaniya Le Jayenge (Aditya Chopra, 1995), among a few others. This film marked a turning point in Bollywood on a variety of fronts, but especially in the way the Non-Resident Indian came to be perceived and understood. The ideas elaborated in the twenty-fourth chapter, “The New Metropolis”, of The Country and the City resonates in the way the distinctions between the country and the city are expanded on a global scale when the underdeveloped countries— which in this particular case, is restricted to India— are seen as the countryside to the city that is the developed countries. Keywords: Raymond Williams, The Country and the City, Keywords, Dilwale Dulhaniya Le Jayenge, Bollywood, Indian Cinema.. Introduction Who is the NRI in Bollywood? The term “Non-resident Indian” or NRI is commonly used to describe people of Indian origin living overseas. In India, the NRI, like the Indian film industry, has made a marked transition in the past two decades from “being configured as an errant native seduced by the wealth and glamour of the West, at the expense of Indian values, to being an icon of the desirable cosmopolitan Indian citizen straddling the globe”.
    [Show full text]
  • Hollywood Films Have Inspiration for Hindi Film Industry
    PRLog - Global Press Release Distribution Hollywood Films Have Inspiration For Hindi Film Industry The Hollywood influence is evident in some of the forthcoming biggies like Paa, Action Replay, Agyaat and Pyaar Impossible. June 23, 2009 - PRLog -- Right from cult classics like Baazi (1951) to Sholay (1975) and Baazigar (1993) - and even Ghajini (2008) - all have some western movie as the stimulus. The Hollywood influence is evident in some of the forthcoming biggies like Paa, Action Replay, Agyaat and Pyaar Impossible. Guru Dutt's debut Baazi was inspired by the Rita Hayworth starrer Gilda (1946), while Sholay is widely called an 'Indian curry Western film', with inspiration from seven Hollywood films including - Once Upon A Time In The West (1968), Spaghetti Westerns, The Wild Bunch (1969), Pat Garrett & Billy the Kid (1973) and Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid (1969). Baazigar and Ghajini are said to be Indianised versions of A Kiss Before Dying (1991) Memento (2000) respectively. Paa supposedly draws its plot from the 1996 comedy-drama Jack, about a boy who ages faster than normal due to a disease, while Akshay Kumar-starrer Action Replay is an alleged take-off on the reverse-ageing drama The Curious Case of Benjamin Button. Promos of Ram Gopal Varma's horror thriller Agyaat suggest sequences from sci-fi horror Predator (1987). Pyaar Impossible is apparently sketched around reality TV series Beauty and the Geek and 1999s Notting Hill - on a relationship between a film actress and her fan. David Dhawan, Karan Johar and Abbas-Mustan are working on remakes of The Wedding Crashers (2005), Stepmom (1998) and The Italian Job (1969 and 2003).
    [Show full text]
  • Download (Binaural and Ambisonics B-Format Files)
    Cover Page The handle http://hdl.handle.net/1887/47914 holds various files of this Leiden University dissertation Author: Chattopadhyay, B. Title: Audible absence: searching for the site in sound production Issue Date: 2017-03-09 Part II: Articles The following 6 articles are published in this dissertation in their original form (i.e. as they were published, accepted or submitted in peer-reviewed journals). I have chosen to insert short postscripts or comments on the first page of each article and besides added some comments here and there inside the articles on the basis of new insights gained throughout my research process, serving as clarification or to critically comment on them and connect them to each other as well as to the topics discussed in the Introduction and Conclusion. These blue and green-colored postscripts establish the context in which the articles can be considered part of the main body of research for this dissertation. 45 46 Article 1: Chattopadhyay, Budhaditya (2017). “The World Within the Home: Tracing the Sound in Satyajit Ray’s Films.” Music, Sound, and the Moving Image Autumn issue (Accepted). This article deals with the first historical phase of sound production in India, as explained in the Introduction, namely: analogue recording, synchronized sound, and monaural mixing (1931– 1950s). Satyajit Ray emerged during this period and made full use of these techniques; hence, his work with sound is used as a benchmark here when studying this specific period of sound production. The article examines the use of ambient sound in the early years of film sound production, highlighting two differing attitudes, the first markedly vococentric and music-oriented, the second applying a more direct sound aesthetics to create a mode of realism.
    [Show full text]
  • Post Colonialism and Political Resistance in Lagaan: Once Upon a Time in India
    Turkish Journal of Computer and Mathematics Education Vol.12 No.7 (2021), 53-56 Research Article Post Colonialism And Political Resistance In Lagaan: Once Upon A Time In India 1 Arjun P Kumar, 2 Gopikrishnan S, 3 Arun S 1. P.G. Student, 2. P.G Student 3. Assistant Professor Department of English, Amrita Vishwa Vidyapeetham, Amrita puri Campus, India Article History: Received: 10 January 2021; Revised: 12 February 2021; Accepted: 27 March 2021; Published online: 16 April 2021 Abstract: Using the movie Lagaan as a case in point, the paper examines the post-colonial and political resistance in the 19th century. Lagaan is a Bollywood movie released in 2001 and is directed by Ashutosh Gowariker. The fictional story is set in a village in India and it explores the struggles faced by the citizens to earn their rights. Taking in account of the movie, the paper analyses the socio-political scenario of the country. Keywords: Post Colonialism, Political resistance, Lagaan Analysis: “Iss aetihasik jeet ke baad bhi itihas main Bhuvan ka naam kahi kho gaya” (Even after the historical win, Bhuvan lost his identity in the history of struggle) - Lagaan Indian film industry which is a collective formation of cinemas from various languages has evolved as a major form of entertainment. But as time passed, it has become a source of voice for the voiceless. The Indian directors chose the medium to speak about the socio-political background of the country. Though majority of the mass enjoyed a commercial treatment, there has always been a want for experiments. In the current scenario, movie critics play a major role in analysing the soul of the movie.
    [Show full text]
  • India As Filmed Space Where Histories Reside PRIYA JAIKUMAR
    India as Filmed Space Where histories reside PRIYA JAIKUMAR Where histories reside India as Filmed Space duke university press | Durham and London | 2019 © 2019 Duke University Press All rights reserved Printed in the United States of Amer i ca on acid- free paper ∞ Designed by Matthew Tauch Typeset in Garamond Premier Pro by Westchester Publishing Services Library of Congress Cataloging- in- Publication Data Names: Jaikumar, Priya, [date] Title: Where histories reside : India as filmed space / Priya Jaikumar. Description: Durham : Duke University Press, 2019. | Includes biblio- graphical references and index. Identifiers: LCCN 2018057039 (print) LCCN 2019014500 (ebook) ISBN 9781478005599 (ebook) ISBN 9781478004127 (hardcover : alk. paper) ISBN 9781478004752 (pbk. : alk. paper) Subjects: LCSH: India—In motion pictures. | Motion pictures—India— History. | Motion picture locations—India. | Motion pictures—Production and direction—India. | Motion picture industry—India—History. Classification: LCC PN1993.5.I8 (ebook) LCC PN1993.5.I8 J29 2019 (print) DDC 791.430954—dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2018057039 Cover art: Amit Pasricha, Champaner, 2013. TO TOM AND MEHA WITH LOVE We die containing a richness of lovers and tribes, tastes we have swallowed, bodies we have plunged into and swum up as if rivers of wisdom, characters we have climbed as if trees, fears we have hidden in as if caves. I wish for all this to be marked on my body when I am dead. I believe in such cartography—to be marked by nature, not just to label ourselves on a map like the names of rich men and women on buildings. We are communal histories, communal books.
    [Show full text]
  • Nation, Fantasy, and Mimicry: Elements of Political Resistance in Postcolonial Indian Cinema
    University of Kentucky UKnowledge University of Kentucky Doctoral Dissertations Graduate School 2011 NATION, FANTASY, AND MIMICRY: ELEMENTS OF POLITICAL RESISTANCE IN POSTCOLONIAL INDIAN CINEMA Aparajita Sengupta University of Kentucky, [email protected] Right click to open a feedback form in a new tab to let us know how this document benefits ou.y Recommended Citation Sengupta, Aparajita, "NATION, FANTASY, AND MIMICRY: ELEMENTS OF POLITICAL RESISTANCE IN POSTCOLONIAL INDIAN CINEMA" (2011). University of Kentucky Doctoral Dissertations. 129. https://uknowledge.uky.edu/gradschool_diss/129 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate School at UKnowledge. It has been accepted for inclusion in University of Kentucky Doctoral Dissertations by an authorized administrator of UKnowledge. For more information, please contact [email protected]. ABSTRACT OF DISSERTATION Aparajita Sengupta The Graduate School University of Kentucky 2011 NATION, FANTASY, AND MIMICRY: ELEMENTS OF POLITICAL RESISTANCE IN POSTCOLONIAL INDIAN CINEMA ABSTRACT OF DISSERTATION A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree Doctor of Philosophy in the College of Arts and Sciences at the University of Kentucky By Aparajita Sengupta Lexington, Kentucky Director: Dr. Michel Trask, Professor of English Lexington, Kentucky 2011 Copyright© Aparajita Sengupta 2011 ABSTRACT OF DISSERTATION NATION, FANTASY, AND MIMICRY: ELEMENTS OF POLITICAL RESISTANCE IN POSTCOLONIAL INDIAN CINEMA In spite of the substantial amount of critical work that has been produced on Indian cinema in the last decade, misconceptions about Indian cinema still abound. Indian cinema is a subject about which conceptions are still muddy, even within prominent academic circles. The majority of the recent critical work on the subject endeavors to correct misconceptions, analyze cinematic norms and lay down the theoretical foundations for Indian cinema.
    [Show full text]
  • Understanding Style and Artistry of Hansal Mehta- Through the Prism of Auteur Theory
    © 2019 JETIR June 2019, Volume 6, Issue 6 www.jetir.org (ISSN-2349-5162) UNDERSTANDING STYLE AND ARTISTRY OF HANSAL MEHTA- THROUGH THE PRISM OF AUTEUR THEORY 1st Author- Sparsh Sanwal Designation of 1st author -Post Graduate student Department of Media Studies, CHRIST (Deemed to be University) Abstract-A good director creates a playground and allows you to play. Similarly, the vision of contemporary film director Hansal Mehta succeeds in manifesting itself through all of his film capturing his style essential, which many consider phenomenal. Mehta is a contemporary director in the Hindi film industry, with ten films under his belt as a director and several other films worked in the capacity of the scriptwriter, he is known to cinema, but it has been only in very recent time that his work has been noticed, a few of them being: Shahid (2013), Citylights (2014), Aligrah (2015), and Simran (2017).Be it his earliest cookery shows KhanaKhazana on television or his first film Amrita, Hansal Mehta time and again showcased a unique perspective. A perspective that demands a study. The present research paper "Understanding style and artistry of Hansal Mehta: Through a prism of the auteur theory " attempts to get a clearer perspective of the filmmaker and his work through a close reading of his select films. The auteur theory explains the idea of a filmmaker being considered the author of his/her film. Indicating that a filmmaker with his intense contribution towards a film to be considered the author through a content analysis that theory will be tested out in the present research.
    [Show full text]
  • LET US ENTERTAIN YOU Your Ultimate Guide to This Month’S Superb Selection of Movies, TV, Music and Games
    LET US ENTERTAIN YOU Your ultimate guide to this month’s superb selection of movies, TV, music and games All on board and right at your fi ngertips Movies New Releases and Recent Movies p1244––1225 Made in Belgium p126 World Cinema p1227 TV Programmes See the full list p128-129 News and Sports See highlights on p129 Music See the full list on p1330 Games See the full list on p1330 Welcome! Switch on to switch off and relax on your Brussels Airlines fl ight today with our extensive range of top entertainment options. Thiss month’s linne-upp inccluddes Chhristtopphheer Nolaan’s viscerall massterppiecce DUUNKKIRRKK, movving family ddrama THHE GGLAASS CCAASTTLLEE, hilarious Belgiaan moockuumeentaryy KINNG OF THE BELGIANS, and longg-ruunnning Ameerican sitcom THE MIDDDLEE. © 2017 WARNER BROTHERS. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. ALL BROTHERS. WARNER 2017 © DUNKIRK DECEMBER 2017 123 LLH_123-130H_123-130 IFE.PDV.inddIFE.PDV.indd 123123 223/11/20173/11/2017 110:200:20 FEATURED MOVIES What Happened to Monday (2017) Director Tommy Wirkola Cast Noomi Rapace, Glenn Close, Willem Dafoe Languages EN, FR, DE, ES Noomi Rapace works overtime playing a set of identical septuplets in a dystopian world where families are limited to one child due to overpopulation. The seven siblings – named after the days of the week – have to avoid being put into a long sleep by the government while investigating the disappearance of one of their own. A Family Man (2017) Director Mark Williams Cast Gerard Butler, Alison Brie, Willem Dafoe Languages EN, FR, DE, ES, PT Headhunter Dane Jensen (Gerard Butler), whose entire life revolves around closing deals in a survival-of-the- fi tt est boiler room, batt les his top rival for control of their job placement company.
    [Show full text]