University of South Florida Scholar Commons
FORUM : the Magazine of the Florida Humanities Florida Humanities
7-1-2013
Forum : Vol. 37, No. 02 (Summer : 2013)
Florida Humanities Council.
Jon Wilson
Kathleen Ochshorn
Lee Irby
Gilbert King
See next page for additional authors
Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarcommons.usf.edu/forum_magazine
Recommended Citation Florida Humanities Council.; Wilson, Jon; Ochshorn, Kathleen; Irby, Lee; King, Gilbert; Pittman, Craig; Rivers, Larry Eugene; Lehane, Dennis; Owens, Janis; Evans, Mary Anna; Niko, D. J.; Lister, Michael; McGrath, Campbell; Witek, Terri; Haskins, Lola; Grunwald, Michael; Link, William A.; Crow, Tracy; Vickers, Lu; Georgiadis, Bonnie; Crawford, Robert L.; Brueckheimer, William; Libby, Gary R.; Lascarso, Laura; Hiaasen, Carl; Flinn, Alex; Cole, Henry; Fogelin, Adrian; Ochitree, Dianne; Kemy, Kathleen; Kirby, David; Dangond, Edgardo; and O'Reilley, Barbara, "Forum : Vol. 37, No. 02 (Summer : 2013)" (2013). FORUM : the Magazine of the Florida Humanities. 17. https://scholarcommons.usf.edu/forum_magazine/17
This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Florida Humanities at Scholar Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in FORUM : the Magazine of the Florida Humanities by an authorized administrator of Scholar Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Authors Florida Humanities Council., Jon Wilson, Kathleen Ochshorn, Lee Irby, Gilbert King, Craig Pittman, Larry Eugene Rivers, Dennis Lehane, Janis Owens, Mary Anna Evans, D. J. Niko, Michael Lister, Campbell McGrath, Terri Witek, Lola Haskins, Michael Grunwald, William A. Link, Tracy Crow, Lu Vickers, Bonnie Georgiadis, Robert L. Crawford, William Brueckheimer, Gary R. Libby, Laura Lascarso, Carl Hiaasen, Alex Flinn, Henry Cole, Adrian Fogelin, Dianne Ochitree, Kathleen Kemy, David Kirby, Edgardo Dangond, and Barbara O'Reilley
This article is available at Scholar Commons: https://scholarcommons.usf.edu/forum_magazine/17 THE MAGAZINE OF THE FLORIDA HUMANITIES COUNCIL
Featuring Winners of the Florida Book AWAR DS
Florida books win Pulitzer and Edgar awards
The haunting case that drew Thurgood Marshall to Florida Dennis Lehane’s tropical workshop A place to imagine lost Spanish galleons 2013 Board of Directors letter From the Director John Belohlavek, Chair Tampa B. Lester Abberger Tallahassee Rachel Blechman Miami We live in a fascinating place. To me, no other Michael Cavendish Jacksonville state captures the utopic/dystopic qualities of modern American Charles Clary Destin life—the light and the dark, the dreams and the nightmares— David Colburn Gainesville better than the “Sunshine State.” As a harbinger of the America José Fernández Orlando to come, it is not surprising that the dissonance and dynamics Casey Fletcher Bartow of American culture occur more vividly here at the edge of the Norma Goonen Davie continent where people come to reinvent themselves, start over, Mary Anne Hodel Orlando or just retire in the sunshine. Kerry Kirschner Sarasota Nowhere is our complex state better reflected than in this Deborah Kynes, Secretary Dunedin year’s Florida Book Awards. R. Andrew Maass Longboat Key From Weeki Wachee mermaids, to prohibition’s gangsters, to Osvaldo Monzon Stuart racially charged violence in Central Florida, the award-winning Darryl Paulson Palm Harbor writers mine history and legends to provide us with a more Michael Pender Bradenton nuanced look at our state. Nancy Kason Poulson Fort Lauderdale Florida Book Award juries preempted two national awards Mercedes Quiroga Miami Shores this year—the Pulitzer Prize and the Edgar Award. Weeks after Steve Seibert, Vice-Chair Tallahassee winning the first-place award for nonfiction, Gilbert King won Brenda Simmons-Hutchins Jacksonville the Pulitzer for The Groveland Boys, the story of Thurgood Kathryn Starkey New Port Richey Marshall’s courageous battle to exonerate four young African Margo Stringfield Pensacola American men accused of raping a young white woman. Eckerd Penny Taylor Naples College writer-in-residence Dennis Lehane cast his literary eye Robert Taylor Palm Bay on Florida in his latest novel, Live by Night, a prohibition tale set Samuel Vickers Jacksonville in Ybor City. The book, fusing a gripping plot with a fine sense Glenda Walters Lynn Haven of place, won the prestigious EdgarAward, given annually for the year’s best mystery novel. FHC Staff Others also probe Florida’s darker side. But reflecting the Janine Farver Executive Director dual nature of our state, this year’s winners also capture light, Barbara Bahr Technology Manager joy, and beauty, as in Lu Vickers’ and Bonnie Georgiadis’s Weeki Laurie Berlin Director of Administration Wachee Mermaids; and as in the Cici and Hyatt Brown collection Alex Buell Program Coordinator of lush paintings in Reflections II: Watercolors of Florida 1835- Brenda Clark Outreach Coordinator, Teaching Florida 2000, by Gary R. Libby. Danica Kelly Data/Fiscal Assistant All of the work, delightful or disquieting, opens another Lisa Lennox Website Administrator window so that we may better embrace—or confront, as the case Brenda O’Hara Fiscal Officer may be—truths about the intriguing place where we live. Barbara O’Reilley Communications Director & Editor/FORUM Patricia Putman Associate Director Jennifer Snyder Program Coordinator, Teaching Florida Diane Wakeman Director, Teaching Florida
To advertise in FORUM, contact: [email protected] FHC FORUM / Vol. XXXVII, No. 2, Summer 2013 © 2013 Florida Humanities Council The magazine of the Florida Humanities Council 599 Second Street South, St. Petersburg, FL 33701-5005 (727) 873-2000 Website: www.floridahumanities.org The Florida Humanities Council is a nonprofit organization funded by the National Endowment for the Humanities, the State of Florida, and private contributors. FHC FORUM is published three times a year and distributed to the friends of the Florida Humanities Council and interested Floridians. If you wish to be added to the mailing list, please request so in writing or via the website. Views expressed by contributors to the FORUM are not necessarily those of the Florida Humanities Council. The Florida Humanities Council (FHC) would like to acknowledge the generous support of the National Endowment for the Humanities; the State of Florida, Department of State, Division of Cultural Affairs; the Florida Council on Arts and Culture; and the National Endowment for the Arts. table of contents 2 Investing in Dreams 4 4 FLORIDA NONFICTION A lonely, dangerous fight for justice By Jon Wilson Gold Gilbert King, Devil in the Grove: Thurgood Marshall, the Groveland Boys, and the Dawn of a New America EXCERPT Silver Craig Pittman,The Scent of Scandal: Greed, Betrayal, and the World’s Most Beautiful Orchid EXCERPT Bronze Larry Eugene Rivers, Rebels and Runaways: Slave Resistance in 19th-Century Florida EXCERPT 10 Enid Shomer’s fictional worlds reflect a poet’s eye By Kathleen Ochshorn 10 Tourist Season EXCERPT 12 GENERAL FICTION Dennis Lehane developed writing chops in Florida By Lee Irby Gold Dennis Lehane, Live by Night EXCERPT Silver Janis Owens, American Ghost EXCERPT 12 Bronze Mary Anna Evans, Plunder EXCERPT 16 POPULAR FICTION Gold D.J. Niko, The Tenth Saint Silver Michael Lister, Blood Sacrifice EXCERPT Bronze Mary Anna Evans, Plunder 18 Humanities Alive News and Events of the Florida Humanities Council 20 POETRY Gold Campbell McGrath, In the Kingdom of the Sea Monkeys Silver Terri Witek, Exit Island Bronze Lola Haskins, The Grace to Leave 22 21 GENERAL NONFICTION Gold Michael Grunwald, The New New Deal Silver William A Link, Links Bronze Tracy Crow, Eyes Right: Confessions of a Woman Marine 22 VISUAL ARTS Gold Lu Vickers and Bonnie Georgiadis, Weeki Wachee Mermaids EXCERPT Silver Robert L Crawford and William Brueckheimer, The Legacy of a Red Hills Hunting Plantation Bronze Gary R. Libby, Reflections II: Watercolors of Florida 1835-2000 EXCERPT 24 YOUNG ADULT Gold Laura Lascarso, Counting Backwards Silver Carl Hiaason, Chomp Bronze Alex Flinn, Bewitching 28 26 CHILDREN’S LITERATURE Gold Henry Cole, Unspoken Silver Adrian Fogelin, Summer on the Moon Bronze Dianne Ochitree and Kathleen Kemly, Molly, by Golly! 28 28 My Favorite Florida Place Imagining the ghost galleons of long ago in Apalachee Bay. By David Kirby 32 Bridging Cultures Leaving Colombia but craving a taste of home. By Edgardo Dangond
FLORIDAHUMANITIES.ORG FLORIDA HUMANITIES COUNCIL FORUM 1 Investing in Dreams
By Barbara O’Reilley
efore launching the Florida Book of rape by a white woman in a small Central Florida town Award program in 2006, Wayne Wiegand in 1949. FORUM writer Jon Wilson interviewed King visited several other states to learn how about delving into this chapter of Florida history. Read his their book competitions worked. The gripping account in the coming pages. CommonwealthB Club of California, sponsor of that Another of this year’s FBA recipients also won a state’s program, provided a special tour that left him top national award: Live by Night by bestselling author inspired. Dennis Lehane won an “Edgar” from the Mystery “I was conducted into a two-story atrium lined with Writers of America. In it Lehane tells the story of 1920s shelves holding the books that had won the California rumrunners in Tampa’s Ybor City. While this is Lehane’s Book Awards over the previous 75 years,” recalled first Florida-based book, his connection with Florida Wiegand, now retired as an emeritus professor of library doesn’t start here. He actually honed his writing craft as and information studies at Florida State University. a college student in Florida. Learn more in our article by “My guide led me to one bank of shelves, picked out a writer Lee Irby. book, opened it to the title page, and placed it in my In addition to King and Lehane, you’ll meet more hands. I quickly realized I held a first edition of the 1940 than 20 other FBA honorees in the coming pages and see Pulitzer Prize-winner Grapes of Wrath, inscribed: ‘To the samples of their work. You’ll also get to know Enid Shomer, Commonwealth Club of California, John Steinbeck.’ who received the 2013 Florida Lifetime Achievement The thought immediately crossed my mind that someday, Award for Writing, sponsored by the Florida Humanities perhaps not in the far distant future, I might hold a Council. The multitalented Shomer writes poetry, short Florida Book Award winner that also won a Pulitzer.” stories, and novels with great insight and wit. She cites That dream came true this year:Devil in the Grove: Florida as a central inspiration, as our article by writer Thurgood Marshall, the Groveland Boys, and the Dawn of Kathleen Ochshorn points out. a New America, by Gilbert King, received a Florida Book And don’t miss poet David Kirby’s description of Award gold medal—and a 2013 Pulitzer Prize. Read this his favorite Florida place (with its ghost galleons, sails powerful book, and you’ll understand why. With page- flapping in the breeze) or Edgardo Dangond’s account of turning intensity, it tells the story of Thurgood Marshall’s yearning for a taste of home after his family moved here role in seeking justice for four young black men accused from Colombia. Photo by Stacy Ferris
Some of this year’s award-winning books on display in the Governor’s Mansion.
2 FORUM FLORIDA HUMANITIES COUNCIL Enid Shomer speaks at the Florida Book Awards luncheon in the Governor’s Mansion in March—and receives a standing ovation.
As in past years, FBA recipients got together at a luncheon hosted at the Governor’s Mansion and coordinated by FBA co-directors Andrew and Lisa
Frank and executive committee chair Gloria Colvin. Photos by Stacy Ferris There was a special moment this year when Enid Shomer received a standing ovation after her remarks in accepting the Florida Lifetime Achievement Award for Writing. Shomer discussed how to put a dollar sign on what the arts are “worth.” Read our excerpt of Shomer’s remarks below— and enjoy the rest of this issue.
BARBARA O’REILLEY is editor of FORUM.
As someone who has spent her life teasing truth and arts funding generates ten dollars in the economy at beauty and therefore justice from words, I can tell you that large. That’s a spectacular return. More than in any the reason the impact of the arts is so difficult to measure business I know of—at least any legal business! And is because they are, on the one hand, quite literally beyond in addition to this measurable growth, investment rubies and pearls. The arts are a human flowering that in arts and artists, in writers, composers, painters, enriches all our lives; they are the engine that drives dancers, museums, etc., gives a huge social return as our dreams and shapes our mythology. They provide the well, adding definition and detail to our aspirations, narratives that help us to understand ourselves. It’s often and wisdom and depth to our understanding. The arts said that people read fiction to learn how to live; that they make us better people, more capable of sympathy and listen to music to feel grief and joy, but at one remove. I empathy. Without the arts, it’s much easier to dismiss personally believe that all of that is true, and that we love other people’s suffering. It’s only through story, whether the arts because they allow us to experience strong emotions in journalism or cinema or a novel, that we learn the in a safe way. Of course, this is part of how they entertain us. specifics that mitigate against snap judgments of each On the other hand, and paradoxically, while the arts other. I hope you’ll keep on believing in and lobbying are beyond price, so important as not to be for sale, we know for public funding of all the arts. They are good for our from solid economic research that every dollar spent on souls and great for the economy. —Enid Shomer
FLORIDAHUMANITIES.ORG FLORIDA HUMANITIES COUNCIL FORUM 3 FLORIDA NONFICTION
A LONELY, DANGEROUS FIGHT FOR JUSTICE
By Jon Wilson
Thurgood Marshall’s legendary sense of humor failed him. Now he was just another “uppity Negro,” abducted and bouncing in the back seat of a car barreling down a dirt road through the Tennessee backcountry. The NAACP civil rights lawyer had just won stunning victories in a racially explosive court case. In retribution, local cops—likely Ku Klux Klansmen minus hoods and robes—were speeding him toward a place where nothing good ever happened. The year was 1946. Marshall knew he was bound for a lynching ground.
The drama starts early in Gilbert King’s book,Devil in 17-year-old white woman claimed she was raped by four black the Grove: Thurgood Marshall, the Groveland Boys, and the men, setting in motion racially fueled violence, the deaths of Dawn of a New America, winner of this year’s Florida Book two of the accused, and a local legal process stacked in favor of Award Gold Medal for Florida Nonfiction—and the 2013 white supremacists. Pulitzer Prize for General Nonfiction. In a time and place where racial justice had yet to take In the nick of time, Marshall’s legal colleagues, who hold, a lack of solid evidence didn’t matter. Based on the had followed the KKK car, showed up on the dead-end woman’s claim, Lake County Sheriff Willis McCall, his road to rescue him. But within three years, the man who deputies, and white residents immediately went after the black would become the first black U.S. Supreme Court justice men. A posse killed one, and whites burned down houses in again found himself in an equally frightening situation in a black community. A local court convicted the other three, Central Florida—in the small town of Groveland. There, a two of whom had confessed after being tortured. The judge
4 FORUM FLORIDA HUMANITIES COUNCIL F LORIDA B OOK A WARD W INNERs • FLORIDA n onfICTION
sentenced two of the men to death and handed down a As part of his research, King, 51, a resident of New life sentence for the other. York City, visited Lake County a half-dozen times to Marshall succeeded in overturning the death- understand the setting. He also tried to interview Norma sentence convictions. But then Sheriff McCall, while Padgett, whose accusations of rape sparked the Groveland transporting the two men for retrial, shot and killed case. But King said Padgett declined to be interviewed, one and badly wounded the other, claiming that both remarking, “Let sleeping dogs lie.” handcuffed prisoners had tried to escape. King’s work on the book wasn’t his first exposure to Until Devil in the Grove was published last year, Florida. He established a strong connection in 1981, when Marshall’s role in the Groveland case wasn’t widely sports brought him to Tampa’s University of South Florida known. He is more popularly remembered as the lead to play baseball. “I quickly realized that the players at USF lawyer in the U.S. Supreme Court case, Brown vs. Board were just bigger and better than I was, and my career was of Education. Described as the most important civil mercifully cut short,’’ he said. rights case of the 20th century, this 1954 court decision Two math credits short of graduation, King left USF paved the way for school integration. in 1985 for a job back in New York. But the English major But before that high-profile ruling, the Groveland still remembers USF professor Kenneth Kay, a loveable case represented one of Marshall’s “countless battles for curmudgeon who drilled hundreds of students in the art of human rights in stifling antebellum courthouses where expository writing. “To this day, I can still hear his voice in white supremacy ruled,” author King wrote in Devil in the back of my head, asking, ‘What the hell does this mean? the Grove. For decades afterward, Marshall dramatically What exactly are you trying to say?’” recounted the details of Groveland to his law King continued to practice his craft through colleagues. King’s gripping book tells the wider public ghostwriting on many topics—sports, science, history, about a grim time in Florida and Marshall’s part in it. and memoirs, for example. His own first book came out “I think that’s been the most satisfying of the in 2008, The Execution of Willie Francis, a story of racial reactions to this book [that] people generally come injustice in Louisiana. “It’s fair to say that I am very much away with a better understanding of Thurgood drawn to spectacular but mostly forgotten criminal cases, Marshall’s contributions toward civil rights,” King said and writing about them in a way that enables people to have in a recent email interview. a better understanding of American history,” King said in a “Thurgood Marshall was one of the greatest 2012 interview for the website Saltyeggs.com. Americans I’ve ever read about. I believe that he Floridians generally have reacted positively to the transcended race. And the Groveland story had book. King did get threats before a reading in Groveland, everything—crime, courtroom drama, heroes, villains, but none amounted to anything, he said, adding that the characters who had a change of heart halfway through Groveland talk “was one of the best ones I had.” the trial—and a last-ditch effort to save a young man At its heart, Devil in the Grove is a story about from the electric chair,” King said. America, King said. “I never saw it as African-American In researching the book, King collected a history. If anything, I hope people come away with a deeper mountain of information. Because of his tenacious sense of respect and appreciation for some of the heroes in requests, he gained access to rarely seen files of the this story—the young lawyers, white and black, who only NAACP’s Legal Defense Fund, FBI files, and audio wanted a fair shake in court. They didn’t ask for special recordings of interrogations. Such facts fueled the story, favors or consideration—only equal justice under the law. but King didn’t let them make it ponderous. His book And they put their lives on the line for the principles they is described by critics as a page-turner reading more like believed in.” a Southern Gothic novel. “The trick is to bring the research in so that JON WILSON is an author and semiretired journalist who lives in readers experience the depth, but they are never bogged St. Petersburg. He is a frequent contributor to FORUM. down by it,” King said. “The story is dramatic enough on its own. When [the accused] Walter Irvin is in the Read excerpt of on Page 6. hospital and tells the story of being shot by both Sheriff Devil in the Grove Willis McCall and Deputy James Yates, after pretending to be dead because he’s handcuffed to the body of his Go to FloridaHumanities.org to read our best friend, there’s not much more for me to do other complete Q&A with Gilbert King, than set the table for readers.” author of Devil in the Grove.
FLORIDA HUMANITIES COUNCIL FORUM 5 FLORIDA NONFICTION
Excerpt from: Devil in the Grove: Thurgood Marshall, the Groveland Boys, and the Dawn of a New America
By Gilbert King
f all the and the Klan in order to save the lives lynching photos of young men falsely accused of capital [Thurgood] Marshall had crimes—even if it killed him. And seen, though, it was the Groveland nearly did. imageO of Rubin Stacy strung up by his By the fall of 1951, Marshall had neck on a Florida pine tree that haunted already filed and had begun trying in him most when he traveled at night lower courts what would become his into the South. It wasn’t the indentation most famous case, Brown v. Board of of the rope that had cut into the flesh Education, when he was again riding below the dead man’s chin, or even the rails toward Groveland. It was the bullet holes riddling his body, that on such a journey to the South that caused Marshall…to stir in his sleep. one of Marshall’s colleagues noticed It was the virtually angelic faces of the the “battle fatigue” setting in on the white children, all of them dressed in lawyer. “You know,” Marshall said to their Sunday clothes, as they posed, him, “sometimes I get awfully tired of grinning and smiling, in a semicircle And like Harper Lee’s heroic trying to save the white man’s soul.” around Rubin Stacy’s dangling corpse... lawyer, Atticus Finch, Thurgood Battling personal demons as well as the Seventeen-year-old Norma Lee Marshall found himself at the center of devils who brought bullets, dynamite, Padgett had that look—chin held a firestorm. It would bring the National and nitroglycerin into the Groveland high, lips pursed—when in her best Guard to Lake County, Florida, where fray, the lawyer saw death all around dress she slowly rose from the witness mob violence drove hundreds of blacks him in central Florida. So intense did box to identify for the jury the three from their lives in Groveland, and in the violence in Groveland become that Groveland, Florida, boys whom she had the aftermath it would prompt four on one of Marshall’s visits, J. Edgar accused of rape. Like the “sworn truth” sensational murders of innocents, among Hoover insisted that FBI agents provide of the fictitious Mayella Ewell, the white them a prominent NAACP executive. the NAACP attorney with around- teenage accuser in Harper Lee’s To Kill Despite the fact that Marshall brought the-clock protection. Usually, though, a Mockingbird, Norma Lee’s dramatic the Groveland case before the U.S. Marshall negotiated Florida alone, testimony against the Groveland Boys Supreme Court, it is barely mentioned despite the number of death threats he tore a county apart. Her pale index in civil rights history, law texts, or daily received. finger extended, it dipped from boy to the many biographies of Thurgood boy as she spoke out each name, like a Marshall. Nonetheless, there is not a From Devil in the young schoolteacher counting heads Supreme Court justice who served with Grove: Thurgood in class, and her breathy cadence sent a Marshall or a lawyer who clerked for Marshall, the chill through the courtroom. him that did not hear his renditions, Groveland Boys, and always colorfully told, of the Groveland the Dawn of a New “…the nigger Shepherd…the nigger story. The case was key to Marshall’s America © 2012 by Irvin…the nigger Greenlee…” perception of himself as a crusader for Gilbert King civil rights, as a lawyer, willing to stand up to racist judges and prosecutors, King murderous law enforcement officials,
6 FORUM FLORIDA HUMANITIES COUNCIL R B F A T .
SILVER GOLD GOLD Florida Non ction General Fiction General Non ction e Scent of Scandal: e New, Greed, Live by Night New Deal: Betrayal, enn e Hidden and the e ane Story of World’s Most Change in the Beautiful Obama Era Orchid c ae ra g P tt an r n a d
University Press . pf.co of Florida . arper o n .co . c ae gr n a d.co
SILVER SILVER GOLD General Non ction Poetry Popular Fiction
Links: My Family Exit Island e Tenth Saint in American History err te . . o a . n
University Press . pf.co of Florida . a on.g .ed at r . pg oo .co
GOLD GOLD SILVER Poetry Visual Arts Visual Arts e Legacy In the Weekie of a Red Kingdom Wachee Hills of the Sea Mermaids Hunting Monkeys c er Plantation a p e onn e Ro ert . ra ford c rat eorg ad a R. r ec e er
University Press University Press . arper o n .co . pf.co of Florida . pf.co of Florida
BRONZE GOLD SILVER Visual Arts Young Adult Literature Popular Fiction
Re ections II: Blood Watercolors Counting Sacri ce: of Florida Backwards a John Jordan 1835-2000 Mystery a ra a car o ar R. c ae ter