DOCSLIB.ORG

International Journal of English and Studies

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
International Journal of English and Studies SP Publications International Journal Of English and Studies (IJOES) An International Peer-Reviewed Journal ; Volume-3, Issue-3, 2021 www.ijoes.in ISSN: 2581-8333; Impact Factor: 5.421(SJIF) RESEARCH ARTICLE MONA LISA: MORE THAN A MYSTERIOUS SMILE ____________________________________________________________________________ Shubhashish Prakash Student of Law Address- 509/131, old Hyderabad, Lucknow _____________________________________________________________________________ Behind bulletproof glass in a gallery of the claimed to have the painting. Geri Louvre Museum in Paris, hangs one of the immediately contacted the police, who soon greatest masterpieces in the field of art, THE arrested Vincenzo Peruggia, an Italian MONA LISA painted by Leonardo da Vinci carpenter who had been working at the somewhere between 1503 and 1509. It has Louvre at the time of the theft. Peruggia been a part of the museum's collection since admitted that he had simply lifted the 1804 masterpiece from the four hooks upon which How did it become so famous? it hung, stuck it under his workman's tunic, Today whenever in a room, there is a and just walked out the door of the Louvre. talk about art, artists, paintings or anything related then, name Mona Lisa always pops Once the Mona Lisa was returned to out from somewhere. It is the most famous the Louvre, the French turned out in droves piece of artifacts of the modern era. to see her, and soon, so did people from all over the globe. The small, simple painting of But for centuries, the Mona Lisa a maybe-smiling woman had become an hung quietly in the Louvre, generally overnight sensation, and was the most unnoticed, but on August 21, 1911, it was famous work of art in the world. stolen right off the museum's wall in a heist Who is the woman in the painting? that shocked the art world. There have been various Author Seymour Reit says, "Someone speculations from being referred as some walked into the Salon Carré, lifted it off the prostitute to personification of the wall and went out with it! The painting was Bramante's Tempietto in Rome regarding stolen Monday morning, but the interesting the identity of the women in this painting. thing about it was that it wasn't 'til Tuesday at noon that they first realized it was gone." Mona Lisa the Prostitute It was argued by many that the After more than two years, in late subject in Mona Lisa was a prostitute 1913, a Florentine art dealer named Alfredo because she doesn't have eyelashes or Geri received a letter from a man who eyebrows, according to some history books, ISSN: 2581-8333 Copyright © SP Publications Page 18 SP Publications International Journal Of English and Studies (IJOES) An International Peer-Reviewed Journal ; Volume-3, Issue-3, 2021 www.ijoes.in ISSN: 2581-8333; Impact Factor: 5.421(SJIF) RESEARCH ARTICLE in Italy around the 16th century, the only was fondly called Salai or Little Devil and is women who were hairless on face with no rumored to be the gay lover of the legendary eyebrow, no eyelashes and no moustache, artist. Vinceti says , "You see it particularly were prostitutes and the way the hair on her in Mona Lisa's nose, her forehead and her head is worn in the painting, was the style of smile," he added, noting that these features prostitute or an unmarried woman. are similar to other Da Vinci paintings which used Salai as a model, namely St John But a French engineer Pascal Cotte the Baptist, St Anne, and The Incarnate used Infrared Reflectography technique and Angel.This theory is vastly opposed by found definitive proof that when Leonardo several art professors such as Martin Kemp, da Vinci painted the original portrait he professor emeritus of the history of art at included Mona Lisa's lashes and brows Trinity College, Oxford, questioned the which was probably accidently removed credibility of Vinceti's findings and said, during cleaning or restoration work. "This is a mish-mash of known things, semi- Moreover, the 3D scans reveal that the known things and complete fantasy." woman was originally painted with her hair tied back in a bun, even though today it Mona Lisa or Lisa Gheradini appears loose on her shoulders. Amongst all the theories in regard with the true identity of the woman who was This process also assisted in commissioned to sit for the portrait, the one revealing under drawings which shows that which has most facts asserted to its side and the fingers of the Mona Lisa's left hand were accepted by majority of historians, artists, originally painted in a slightly different professors, etc. Is that she was Lisa position than in the final portrait. And also Gherardini, wife of Francesco del Giocondo provided information about the materials also known as Lisa del Giocondo. used and techniques employed. The model, Lisa del Giocondo, was a member of the Gherardini family of Mona Lisa the Gay Lover Florence and Tuscany, and the wife of Silvano Vinceti, head of a research group wealthy Florentine silk merchant Francesco called the National Committee for Cultural del Giocondo. The painting is thought to Heritage said: "The Mona Lisa is have been commissioned for their new androgynous – half man and half woman. home, and to celebrate the birth of their The painting was based on two models. The second son, Andrea. first was Lisa Gherardini and the second was Salai, Leonardo's apprentice."Gian Giacomo "Mona" was a common Italian contraction Caprotti, the male apprentice of Da Vinci of " Madonna," meaning "my lady," the ISSN: 2581-8333 Copyright © SP Publications Page 19 SP Publications International Journal Of English and Studies (IJOES) An International Peer-Reviewed Journal ; Volume-3, Issue-3, 2021 www.ijoes.in ISSN: 2581-8333; Impact Factor: 5.421(SJIF) RESEARCH ARTICLE equivalent of the English "Madam," so the age of the Mona Lisa should probably be 23 title means "Madam Lisa" this means the or 24 years when the artwork was lady in the painting was from a high society produced—assuming the woman portrayed and was a noblewoman. really is Lisa del Giocondo because it was also at this age that she was pregnant. Lisa and Francesco had five children: Piero, Camilla, Andrea, Giocondo, In 1913 an English connoisseur and Marietta, four of them between 1496 Hugh Blaker acquired a painting from a and 1507. National Research Council of manor house in Somerset, where it was Canada did 3D scan of painting using thought to have been hanging for over a infrared technology. From the scans, it was century. This painting came to be known as revealed that the lady in the painting is Isleworth Mona Lisa. wearing a Guarnello, which is a kind of veil that a pregnant woman used to wear at that The Isle worth Mona Lisa is an early time moreover it seems that she has a slight sixteenth-century oil on canvas painting tummy with arms crossed around it, which depicting the same subject Lisa del suggests that she might have been pregnant. Giocondo but at a younger age. A recently discovered marginal note Physicist John F. Asmus, who had by Agostino Vespucci, one-time assistant to previously examined the Mona Lisa in the the diplomat and writer Niccolò Louvre and investigated other works by Machiavelli, records that Leonardo was Leonardo, published a computer image working on a painting of “Lisa del processing study in 1988 concluding that the Giocondo” in 1503. brush strokes of the face in the painting were performed by the same artist There are many other theories and responsible for the brush strokes of the face speculations regarding the inspiration of the Mona Lisa in the Louvre. behind painting like it was Da Vinci’s self- portrait as a woman or his mother’s portrait, A review of the painting in the etc. But they do not have a single relevant Deseret News describes its tonality as being proof and seem a bit farfetched. darker, and describes the colouring as being in "accordance with almost all the works Is this the original Mona Lisa? attributed to Leonardo–that of a golden A recent study based on painting glow–while the finish is of a most minute indicated that the estimated age of the Mona character". Lisa’s face was 32.3 ± 5.6 years but the real ISSN: 2581-8333 Copyright © SP Publications Page 20 SP Publications International Journal Of English and Studies (IJOES) An International Peer-Reviewed Journal ; Volume-3, Issue-3, 2021 www.ijoes.in ISSN: 2581-8333; Impact Factor: 5.421(SJIF) RESEARCH ARTICLE Italian curator Lorenzo Cecconi, who Rocks along with two versions of St. John also examined the painting in the 1920s, the Baptist and of Leda and the Swan, and said that "the fusion of the tints of the flesh, two versions each of drawings of Isabella d especially in the eyes; the line which designs 'Este, the Adoration of the Magi, and St. the nose, the mouth, and the oval of the face Anne. There are believes that he even were remarkable, and indicated that "this painted the second version of THE LAST may be a second work of the Great SUPPER, the one found in an abbey in Leonardo". Tongerlo, Belgium. In the same period, Renaissance But there are historians who believe scholar Arduino Colasanti thought "the that Da Vinci painted only one Mona Lisa upper part with the eyes and nose of the and also that the lady in the painting is Lisa face" were definitely by Leonardo, and del Giocondo and the reason that she seems noted collector Ludovico Spiridon stated more aged than she actually was at the time that "the face has been painted by Leonardo; of painting is that she during 1503, no doubt of this at all".
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Second Mona Lisa by Sage Weber Or Not Is Da Vinci's Work
    2 The Second Mona Lisa By Sage Weber or not is Da Vinci's work. "Mona Lisa: Leonardo's Earlier Ver- Redbird Writer Foundation member and art sion.” The foundation's website historian Stanley Feldman told the makes its case using visual widgets Leonardo Da Vinci's painting Associated Press, “So far, not one of painstaking side-by-side compari- of the Mona Lisa showed up a few scientific test has been able to dis- sons of the "Isleworth" with "Mona weeks ago and was said to be another prove that the painting is by Leo- Lisa," magnifying their similarities Volume 70 Issue 3 version of the portrait, just bigger nardo.” The analysis included regres- down to the small details. From France to America, and Back to France October 24, 2012 and with a different smile. This was sion tests, mathematical comparisons “The obvious resemblance, and looking at historical and archival easily visible to the untrained eye, By Shelby Snyder a very big deal for all the art fanatics volved with church things. stood what he was trying to records. “We have used methods that could be evidence that the work is Redbird Writers in the world. Also, the importance of sports say. It took him a few days to were not available to Leonardo 500 just another copy of the portrait of The Isleworth Mona Lisa, in the high school, and the fact be completely fluent with his which was once owned by Henry F. years ago,” he said. Lisa del Giocondo that was painted Around this time one Pulitzer, has been in a vault since it There's no doubt that the after da Vinci's masterpiece was year ago, French native Quen- you have patriotism.
    [Show full text]
  • Yes, Lisa Del Giocondo Was Da Vinci's "Mona Lisa" 20:59, January 15, 2008
    Yes, Lisa del Giocondo was da Vinci's "Mona Lisa" 20:59, January 15, 2008 German academics citing notes scribbled in the margin of a book by it owner in October 1503 have confirmed Lisa del Giocondo, the wife of a wealthy Florentine merchant, was the model for Leonardo da Vinci's "Mona Lisa." Lisa Gherardini, the wife of Francesco del Giocondo, has long been regarded as the most likely model for the 16th-century painting. But art historians have often wondered whether the smiling woman may actually have been da Vinci's lover, his mother or the artist himself. "All doubts about the identity of the Mona Lisa have been eliminated by a discovery by Dr. Armin Schlechter," a manuscript expert, the Heidelberg University library said in a statement on Monday. Until then, only "scant evidence" from sixteenth-century documents had been available. "This left lots of room for interpretation and there were many different identities put forward," the library said. The notes were made by a Florentine city official Agostino Vespucci, an acquaintance of the artist, in a collection of letters by the Roman orator Cicero. Art experts, who have already dated the painting to this time, say the Heidelberg discovery is a breakthrough and the earliest mention linking the merchant's wife to the portrait. "There is no reason for any lingering doubts that this is another woman," Leipzig University art historian Frank Zoellner told German radio. "One could even say that books written about all this in the past few years were unnecessary, had we known." "Source:Xinhua/Agencies" .
    [Show full text]
  • Art in Context Da Vinci to Banksy
    Art in Context Da Vinci to Banksy Year 12 2013 Time and Place § Artworks need to be examined in the context of the time and place in which they were produced. § Artworks can be interpreted in a number of ways often providing layers of meaning that may change over time because of the background and perspective of the viewer and the changing contexts in which the work is seen. § Commentaries by critics, historians and artists can help us to understand how and why art was created and how it can be interpreted. Leonardo was fond of this painting, he kept it (1452-1519) with him until his death Leonardo da Vinci in 1519 then it became Mona Lisa 1503-06 part of the collection of oil and Tempera on wood King Francois I 76.8 x 52.7cm Louvre Leonardo da Vinci is famous as one of the most gifted artists of all time. He was very interested in mathematics and the Mathematical proportions of the human body. Title /Subject It is generally accepted that this is the portrait of Lisa Gheradini, the wife of Francesco del Giacondo. Mona shortening of Madonna (my lady) The figure is sitting on a balcony overlooking a complex real and imaginary landscape. Her body is partially turned away from the viewer Historical / Cultural Context Height of the Renaissance Period at the beginning of the 16th Century in Italy. Portraiture was becoming more common as art was being commissioned by wealthy private citizens such as Francesco del Giacondo. The age of exploration was expanding. Leonardo and Michelangelo were expanding knowledge of the human body through observation and dissection § Materials/Technique § Mona Lisa was painted on a small panel of popular wood.
    [Show full text]
  • A Multidisciplinary Study of the Tongerlo Last Supper 0722
    A Multidisciplinary Study of the Tongerlo Last Supper and its attribution to Leonardo da Vinci’s Second Milanese studio Jean-Pierre Isbouts, Fielding Graduate University, Santa Barbara, CA, and Christopher Brown, Brown Discoveries, LLC, North Carolina This article presents the findings from a two-year study of the Last Supper canvas in the Abbey of Tongerlo, Belgium, including a detailed review of its provenance as well as a digital analysis and multispectral study conducted by the Belgian company IMEC in the Spring of 2019. The design of the study is a composite multidisciplinary approach, with traditional connoisseurship and literary research being augmented by scientific examination, using new digital processing and multispectral imaging techniques. The article argues that based on the available evidence, the Tongerlo Last Supper was produced in Leonardo’s Milanese workshop between 1507 and 1509, as a collaborative project involving the Leonardeschi Giampietrino, Andrea Solario and Marco d’Oggiono under Leonardo’s supervision. Furthermore, the infrared spectography scans suggest that the face of John in the painting may have been painted by Leonardo himself. The study was funded by IMEC Belgium; Fielding Graduate University of Santa Barbara, CA; Brown Discoveries, LLC of North Carolina, and conducted with the gracious permission of the Premonstratensian Abbey of Tongerlo, Belgium. Key words: Leonardo da Vinci (1452-1519); Last Supper; Technical Art History; Multispectral Imaging; the art of the Leonardeschi. Fig. 1. Studio of Leonardo da Vinci, Last Supper (after Leonardo), known as the Tongerlo copy, 1507-1509. Introduction For the last 450 years, the Tongerlo canvas of the Last Supper has been quietly occupying a wall in a chapel on the grounds of the Premonstratensian Abbey of Tongerlo near Westerlo, about an hour’s drive from the Belgian city of Antwerp.
    [Show full text]
  • Leonardo in Toscana
    1519•2019 © 2019 Toscana Promozione Turistica Design: CD&V - Firenze Art direction Marco Capaccioli Layout Paolo Valeri We thank all the institutions, the organizers, Fondazione Istituto Dramma Popolare di San Miniato the museum sites that collaborated on the project. Fondazione Palazzo Strozzi Fondazione ParSeC The following archives provided the images: Fondazione Sistema Toscana Istituto di BioRobotica - Scuola Superiore Sant’Anna Archivio Aboca Museo del Tessuto, Prato Archivio CD&V, Firenze Museo della Battaglia e di Anghiari - Comune di Associazione Ecomuseo della Montagna Pistoiese Anghiari Associazione Mus.e Firenze Museo Galileo Biblioteca Leonardiana di Vinci - Comune di Empoli Museo Leonardiano di Vinci Comune di Firenze, Musei Civici Fiorentini Unione dei Comuni Empolese-Valdelsa Comune di Pontedera Toscana Promozione Turistica Comune di Sansepolcro (The images of the Leonardian codes are drawn Dipartimento fotografico delle Gallerie degli Uffizi from facsimilari reproductions) www.visittuscany.com www.regione.toscana.it/celebrazionileonardodavinci www.toscanapromozione.it LEONARDO: DANGER AND SALVATION by Tomaso Montanari verse by Friedrich Hölderlin, rity. But in such a way that would fantastical, often ludicrous attri- al texts. The search for the bones personal Leonardo. Ignore the mar- to assuming our roles as sovereign dear to Martin Heidegger, have, in all likelihood, baffled him butions to Leonardo the painter – of Lisa del Giocondo (subject of keting, the breathless hyperbole, citizens. asserts that “where there is completely. from sophisticated commercial op- the hyper-famous portrait) as well the well-trodden path: Instead, go A danger/also grows the sav- erations surrounding doubtful (and as for The Battle of Anghiari (the directly to the source. The Lives of Today more than ever, to seek Leon- ing power”.
    [Show full text]
  • Mona Lisa Darkening Free
    FREE MONA LISA DARKENING PDF Sunny | 287 pages | 09 Apr 2009 | Penguin Putnam Inc | 9780425226476 | English | New York, United States Mona Lisa - The Alien Girl Found On The Moon In Beware of green. Volatile and evanescent, green is more than just a colour. It is the energy that connects us to the unknown. Remove green from the palette of art history and a bridge between life and death would disappear. To dabble in green is not merely to tread a path between being and unbeing, but to make inroads into the mysteries of each. Simultaneously the colour of putrefaction and of verdurous regeneration, green participates with unbiased vividity in decay and rebirth. Donning the deepest of shadowy green costumes, La Gioconda night-swims in the vitrine of our psyche and has long been recognised as Mona Lisa Darkening mystical commuter between the world of the living and that of the dead. Long Mona Lisa Darkening Leonardo reached for green, the colour had been assigned a special esoteric place in cultural imagination. Ancient Egyptians reserved green for the bold beryl complexion of their god of life and death, Osiris — ruler of the underworld, who held dominion Mona Lisa Darkening the passage of souls between this world and the next. Green was used for depictions of the ancient Egyptian god of life and death, Osiris Credit: Getty Images. Perennially young, Osiris was believed to be a serial resuscitator, both of himself and of the natural world. Verdigris, among the more common iterations of the colour, and the one of which Leonardo was most wary, is forged in a curious ritual that involves the slow sousing in wine of a brass or copper blade.
    [Show full text]
  • The Fading Evidence of Reality: Leonardo and the End
    Institute of Advanced Insights Study TheThe FadingFading EvidenceEvidence ofof Reality:Reality: LeonardoLeonardo andand thethe EndEnd Carlo Vecce Volume 10 2017 Number 10 ISSN 1756-2074 Institute of Advanced Study Insights About Insights Insights captures the ideas and work-in-progress of the Fellows of the Institute of Advanced Study at Durham University. Up to twenty distinguished and ‘fast-track’ Fellows reside at the IAS in any academic year. They are world-class scholars who come to Durham to participate in a variety of events around a core inter-disciplinary theme, which changes from year to year. Each theme inspires a new series of Insights, and these are listed in the inside back cover of each issue. These short papers take the form of thought experiments, summaries of research findings, theoretical statements, original reviews, and occasionally more fully worked treatises. Every fellow who visits the IAS is asked to write for this series. The Directors of the IAS – Veronica Strang, Rob Barton, Nicholas Saul and Chris Greenwell – also invite submissions from others involved in the themes, events and activities of the IAS. Insights is edited for the IAS by Nicholas Saul. Previous editors of Insights were Professor Susan Smith (2006–2009), Professor Michael O’Neill (2009–2012) and Professor Barbara Graziosi (2012–2015). About the Institute of Advanced Study The Institute of Advanced Study, launched in October 2006 to commemorate Durham University’s 175th Anniversary, is a flagship project reaffirming the value of ideas and the public role of universities. The Institute aims to cultivate new thinking on ideas that might change the world, through unconstrained dialogue between the disciplines as well as interaction between scholars, intellectuals and public figures of world standing from a variety of backgrounds and countries.
    [Show full text]
  • Leonardo Da Vinci Renaissance Man, Genius
    Leonardo Da Vinci Renaissance Man and Genius COMPILED BY HOWIE BAUM LEONARDO DA VINCI Born in 1452, in the village of Anchiano, in Tuscany, Italy, near the town of Vinci, now a museum. He was an illegitimate son of Ser Piero da Vinci, a successful notary and member of a prestigious family, and a young peasant woman - Caterina di Meo Lippi. Leonardo lived with his mother during the first years of his life. By 1457, at the age of five, he lived in the house of his grandfather, Ser Antonio, da Vinci. Leonardo’s father - Piero di Antonio da Vinci married another woman several months after the child’s birth and soon moved to Florence. He served as a notary for the Medici family. He married 3 more times and had a total of 13 children. Leonardo’s Uncle - Francesco da Vinci (shown at left) adopted him and through this act removed the stigma of his beloved nephew's illegitimate birth. An artistic genius, a pioneer of medical research, scientist, architect, engineer, and inventor of many machines and devices. Leonardo da Vinci truly was the ultimate Renaissance man. He was hundreds of years ahead of his time with his technological ideas and ambitions. WORKSHOP APPRENTICE Leonardo’s beginnings as an artist when he was 14, followed the traditional route of indenture in an established master’s workshop, from 1467 to 1476. In this case, it was in the studio of Andrea del Verrochio, a very successful artist in the orbit of the Medici family who was as accomplished a business man, as he was an artist.
    [Show full text]
  • Shmanners Ep269 Art Commissions.Docx
    Shmanners 269: Art Commissions Published July 9th, 2021 Listen here on themcelroy.family Travis: Hey Teresa, did you know that Batman's friend, Jim Gordon, loves buying art? Teresa: No. Travis: That's why they call him the Commissioner! [makes popping sound] Teresa: It's Shmanners. [theme music plays] Travis: [rushed] Hello internet, I'm your husband host, Travis McElroy! Teresa: And I'm your wife host, Teresa McElroy. Travis: And you're listening to Shmanners. Teresa: It's extraordinary etiquette... Travis: For ordinary occasions! Hello, my dove. Teresa: Hello, dear. How are you? Travis: That was such a bad joke, you know? Teresa: [laughs] Travis: [sighs] Teresa: Like, are you okay? Travis: Like, I know! It's just such a bad joke. And, like, I thought of it 'cause I thought of the word commissioner, commi—and it makes so much se— Teresa: It does. Travis: —but it's bad. [strained] It's so bad! [laughs] Teresa: I liked—I liked the little [makes popping sound]. Travis: [laughs] Well, when you know what you are. Um, yeah. Uh, and, you know, my tummy hurts a little bit. I don't know why. Teresa: I'm sorry about that. Travis: I'm just fine, I'm just old. Teresa: Let me take your mind off of things. Travis: Okay, please. Teresa: Imagine, if you would, a world... Travis: Uh-huh? Teresa: ... without art. Travis: No? That—why— Teresa: Okay. Travis: —is that supposed to make me feel better? I like art! Teresa: No. No, just taking your mind off of it.
    [Show full text]
  • Leonardo Da Vinci
    PRESS KIT Leonardo da Vinci Exhibition October 24, 2019-February 24, 2020 Hall Napoléon Press Contact Céline Dauvergne [email protected] Tel.: + 33 (0)1 40 20 84 66 / +33 (0)6 88 42 35 35 1 TABLE OF CONTENT Press Release page 3 The Exhbition Layout page 5 Mona Lisa : Beyond the Glass, page 9 Virtual Reality Experience Pictures available for the press page 11 Sponsors’ letters page 16 List of exhited masterpieces is available on demand : [email protected] PRESS RELEASE Exhibition October 24, 2019-February 24, 2020 Hall Napoléon Leonardo da Vinci To commemorate the 500-year anniversary of the death of Leonardo da Vinci in France, the Musée du Louvre is designing and holding a major retrospective of the painter’s career. The exhibition aims to illustrate how Leonardo placed utmost importance on painting, and how his investigation of the world, which he referred to as “the science of painting”, was the instrument of an art through which he sought to bring life to his paintings. Alongside its own collection of five paintings* by Leonardo, the largest in the world and 22 of his drawings, the Louvre will display more than 135 works, i.e. 160 works altogether (paintings, drawings, manuscripts, sculptures, objets d’art) from some of the most prestigious European and American institutions, including, the Royal Collection, the British Museum, the National Gallery in London, the Vatican Pinacoteca, the Biblioteca Ambrosiana in Milan, the Galleria Nazionale in Parma, the State Hermitage in Saint Petersburg the Gallerie dell'Accademia in Venice, the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York, and the Institut de France.
    [Show full text]
  • LEONARDO's PORTRAIT of MONA LISA DEL GIOCONDO 121 Do a Private Portrait for a Florentine Citizen
    Originalveroffentlichung in: Gazette des Beaux-Arts, 121 (1993), S. 115-138 LEONARDO’S PORTRAIT OF MONA LISA DEL GIOCONDO BY FRANK ZOLLNER "Ma il tempo crudele richiude sulla figura reale della Gioconda le sue porte infinite che I’arte sola puo sforzare e dischiudere perche ci si mostrino i baleni dell ’etemita”. II Marzocco, 21 December 1913 eonardo da Vinci’s portrait of Lisa del prompted numerous alternative identifications for Giocondo in the Louvre, the so-called the Louvre painting7. These attempts at alterna­ Mona Lisa (or “La Gioconda ”), is ar­ tive identifications and the idealization of Mona guably one of the best known images in Lisa have, in many, if not in most cases, distracted LWestern culture (fig. 1). Having said that, scholarlythere attention from more profound efforts to are few other incontestable statements to be made understand the portrait itself in its historical con­ about the painting. Not surprisingly, recent publi­ text. cations on portraiture avoid dealing with the The most recent alternative identification has Mona Lisa 1, because most problems regarding been proposed by Carlo Vecce, who believes that this portrait must still be considered unresolved 2. the Louvre painting actually depicts Isabella Gua- The identification of the sitter, traditionally based landa 8. Vecce’s hypothesis is far from unassail­ on Vasari’s description of the painting3, is still a able, since the reliability of his major sources matter of debate, because Vasari had probably - the Anonimo Gaddiano, Antonio de Beatis and never seen the portrait and his account is contra­ Ernea Irpino - can be questioned, and he has no dicted by at least one early source, the so-called new evidence to corroborate his identification 9.
    [Show full text]
  • Italian Renaissance Portraits That Disappoint: Isabella D'este
    Italian Renaissance Portraits that Disappoint: Isabella d’Este, Francesco del Giocondo and Other Displeased Patrons Faculty Research Working Paper Series Jonathan K. Nelson Syracuse University Florence and Harvard Kennedy School Richard Zeckhauser Harvard Kennedy School July 2019; Revised April 2021 RWP19-024 Visit the HKS Faculty Research Working Paper Series at: https://www.hks.harvard.edu/research-insights/publications?f%5B0%5D=publication_types%3A121 The views expressed in the HKS Faculty Research Working Paper Series are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect those of the John F. Kennedy School of Government or of Harvard University. Faculty Research Working Papers have not undergone formal review and approval. Such papers are included in this series to elicit feedback and to encourage debate on important public policy challenges. Copyright belongs to the author(s). Papers may be downloaded for personal use only. www.hks.harvard.edu Italian Renaissance Portraits that Disappoint: Isabella d’Este, Francesco del Giocondo and Other Displeased Patrons∗ Jonathan K. Nelson± and Richard J. Zeckhauserδ Abstract The successful fruits of Italian Renaissance patronage were often prominently displayed by the original owners and written up favorably by their contemporaries and ours. By contrast, paintings and sculptures that displeased or, worse, disgraced their patrons, though occasionally mentioned in publications about the patrons or artists, tended to get lost in historical accounts. As a result, standard assessments convey an unrealistically favorable picture. To facilitate a more balanced understanding of the patronage process, this essay addresses the risks inherent in commissioned portraits made in Italy from the late fifteenth through the late sixteenth century, including paintings by Andrea Mantegna, Domenico Ghirlandaio, and Leonardo da Vinci.
    [Show full text]