Direct Effect of Parasitism by Dinarmus Acutus Thomson on Seed Predation by Acanthoscelides Perforatus (Horn) in Canada Milk-Vetch
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Technical Notes Direct effect of parasitism by Dinarmus acutus Thomson on seed predation by Acanthoscelides perforatus (Horn) in Canada milk-vetch A. BOE, B. MCDANIEL, AND K. ROBBINS AbOhCt Canada milk-vet& (Ash@us canudenh L.) ir a widespread Materials and Methods North American legume considered to be good forage in some In July 1987,4 inflorescences with mature pods were collected regions but potentially dangerour to livestock when it containa from each of 10 genotypes of Canada milk-vetch in a 250-space- high levels of 3-nitropropionlc acid. Larvae of the seed predator plant nursery establsihed on a Vienna loam, nearly level [fine- Acunthosceikks pqforutus (Horn) (Coleoptera:Brucbidw) oc- loamy, mixed Udic Haploborolls] at Brookings, S. Dak., in May curred in 77% of the mature pods from 10 genotypes of the legume 1985. The seed source for the nursery was a vigorous population growing in 8 nursery at Brook&, S. Dak., in autumn 1987. from a native prairie approximately 10 km northeast of Brookings, Dhuvnus u&us Thomson (Hymenoptera: Pteromalidae) par&- S. Dak. Inflorescences were placed in covered glass jars and main- ized 48% of the A. perforatus larvae and reduced numben of seeds tained at room temperature. Adults of the hymenopterous parasi- consumed by A. pcrjorotwhrvae by 23%. This study identifiedD. toid D. acutus began to emerge in large numbers from the pods in acutus aa a puaaitoid of A. pcrforroiurand indicated pursitoidn August 1987, but only a few adults of A. perforotus emerged during nuy play an import8nt role in recruitment of n8tive legumes. fall 1987. In January 1988,30 random pods from each inflores- Key Words: Astragalus canadensis L., Dinarmus acutus, Acan- cence of each genotype were carefully split along their septa, and thosc~ pafoatus, parasitoid, seed predation the 2 locules of each pod were examined under a dissecting micro- Canada milk-vetch (Astragalus canadensis L.) is the New scope at 10 to 30 magnifications. World’s most widely dispersed astragalus, ranging from the Gulf Frequencies of pod infestations by A. perforatus and parasitism Coast in eastern Texas to the Appalachians and lower St. Law- of A. perforatus by D. acutus were determined for 20 pods per rence River, west to the southern Rocky Mountains and the Great inflorescence (80 pods per genotype). Unparasitixed bruchid- infested locules contained a larva, pupa, adult or exit hole, and and Columbia Basins (Bameby 1964). It is perennial, rhixomatous, and usually quite robust. This legume is considered good forage in empty pupal case of A. perforatus. Parasitized bruchid-infested some regions (Hermann 1966), but can be toxic to livestock when it locules contained a larva, pupa, adult, or exit hole and exuviae of contains high levels of 3-nitroproprionic acid (James et al. 1980). D. acutus, and the mummitied remains of the parasitized bruchid Bruchid beetles (Coleoptera:Bruchidae) are important seed larva. The effect of parasitism by D. acutus on seed predation by A. predators of many North American legumes (Johnson 1970, Green pe@rotus was determined by counting intact seeds and testas of and Pahnbald 1975, Boe and Wynia 1985). The bruchid Acan- bruchiddestroyed seeds in unparasitixed and parasitized bruchid- thoscelidesperforatuss (Horn) has been reared from seeds of Can- ada milk-vetch (Johnson 1970), but its effects on seed production infested locules of a sample of 10 pods per infIorescence for 6 genotypes (40 pods per genotype). Analysis of variance was con- are unknown. ducted on inflorescence means for percentage and number of intact Lists of parasitoids of North American Bruchidae have been seeds in locules infested by parasitized and unparasitized larvae of compiled (Cushman 1911, Johnson 1970, Center and Johnson 1975), but little is known about effects of parasitoids on population A. perforatus. dynamics of North American legumes attacked by bruchid beetles. Results and Discussion Canada milk-vetch has forage and soil conservation potential, but evaluation for these purposes is dependent on adequate seed Seventy-seven percent of the pods of the 10 genotypes had at supplies of adapted ecotypes. Studies are needed to determine least 1 locule infested by A. perforotus and the overall mean genetic, physical environment, and biotic influences on seed pro- percentage seed loss to bruchid predation was 44% (Table 1). These duction. Objectives of this study were to quantify the effect of data showed A. perforatuscan seriously reduce viable seed produc- predation by A. perforatus on seed production of C. milk-vetch tion in Canada milk-vetch. Green and Pahnbald (1975) found seed and determine parasitism rate of A. perforatus by the small wasp predation by AcanthosceIidesfratercul~ (Horn) exceeded 60$&in Dinarmus acutus Thomson (Hymenoptera: Pteromalidae) in a natural populations of Astragalus cibarius Sheld. and Astragalus field nursery at Brookings, South Dakota. utahensis (Tom) T. and G., and postulated seed predation influ- enced population dynamics of these legumes. Authors are associate profewor, professor, and agricultural research technician, ‘vely, Plant Science Dep., South Dakota State Univ., Brookinga 57007. Thirty-six percent of the pods contained insects in both locules, “#iF authors extend their gratitude to Dr. C.D. Johmon, Northern Arizona Univ., but multiple occupancies in locules were infrequent (only 3 locules for providing identification of Acanthoscelide~ptyforatus;to Dr. E.E. Grirrcll, SF- tematic Entomology Laboratory, USDA, U.S. National Muacum, Washin on, D.C., contained 2 normal A. perforatus larvae). Since seed predation for providing idcntifmtion of Df-us acutw; and to Dr. R. Kibckhe? cr. Dr. G. levels were high, cannibalism (Nelson and Johnson 1983) and/ or Larson, and R. Bortncm for critically reviewing the mamucript. Contribution from the S. Dak. State Univ. Agric. Exp. %a., Brookings, SD 57007. competition (Boe et al. 1988) for food resources may have influ- Journal Paper No. 2329. Manuscnpt accepted 27 April 1989. 514 JOURNAL OF RANGE MANAGEMENT 42(6), November 1999 Table 1. Pod infestationand meedpred8tlon by the bruchid batk ha- bruchid beetles, and parasitic Hymenoptera is critical to under- thc&&.rpe+wu in a mmery of cmula adIk-vetckat Brook@, standing the ecology and population dynamics of native rangeland South Dakota and the infhncc of purultim by Dburmua mutm on legumes. seedpredationbytbebeetk. Seed predation levels in this space-plant nursery were compar- able to those described for native stands of several other legumes. Seed predation in infested” Legume seed predation by bruchid beetles may exceed 50% (Green locules IllfCStd Overall ~ccd* Parasitized3 and Palmbald 1975, Boe and Wynia 1985) and occasionally reach Pods predation beetles Unparasitized Parasitized nearly 100% (Rogers and Garrison 1975) in natural plant commun- m ities, but considerable variation occurs among years and 10cati0n~ 77 f 144 44f 16 48*24 85 f 7 62 f 17 (Baskin and Baskin 1977). Seed predation in 37 populations of American licorice (Glycyrrhiza kpidora Pursh) from North and ‘Muns I’ * ksantlydiienllt at the 0.05 level. ~McaM0 ?+ 24 mflorcsccnccs;10 pods per inflomceacc. South Dakota ranged from 7 to 7 1% with an overall mean of 41 f ‘Meam of 40 intlorcscewr; 20 pods per infloreacencc. 2% (Boe and Wynia 1985). The impact of bruchid beetles on ‘Standarddeviation. long-term seed production and the efficacy of hymenopterous cnced larval survival. parasitoids for reducing seed losses in cultivated nurseries and seed Fortycight percent of A. perforarus larvae were parasitized by increase fields of native legumes can only be determined after more D. acutus. D. acutus is found throughout the continental U.S. It extensive evaluation. has been reared from Bruchidius ater (Marsham) and &uchus brachiazis Fahr. (Krombein et al. 1979) and recorded from seed lots Literature Cited of legumes containing A. fraferculus and A. griseolus (Fall) (John- Buneby, R.C. 1964. Atlas of North American Asrragulus. Memoirs of the son 1970), but A. perforatus is a new host record. New York Botanical Garden Vol. 13. The New York Botanical Garden. Seeds of Canada milk-vetch are small (approximately 1.5 Bask&~, J.M., and C.C. Bukin. 1977. Predation of Cassia marilandica mg/seed), and individual larvae of A. perforurus consumed the seeds by Sennius ubbreviutw (Co1eoptera:Bruchidae). Bull. Torr. Bot. Club. 104~614. cotyledons, plumules, radicles, and parts of testas of 2 to 12 seeds. Boe, A., and R. Wynh. 1985. Seed predation. seedling emergence, and Unparasitized A. perforatus larvae destroyed 85% of the seeds in rhkomchamct&sticsofAmcrkanlicoricc. J. RangcManagc.38:~. locules they infested compared to 62% when parasitized by D. Boe, A.B., B. MCDmiel, and K. Robbim. 1988. Patterns of American act&us (Table 1). Uninfested locules contained 6.9 f 0.2 intact licorice seed predation by Acanrhoscelides ounrohu (Horn) (Coleoptcra:- seeds, and locules infested by parasitized beetles contained signifi- Bmchidae) in South Dakota. J. Range Manage. 41342-345. cantly (X0.05) more intact seeds (2.6 f 0.2) than locules (1.1 f Center, T.D., and C.D. Johnson. 1975. Host plants and parasites of some Arizona seed-feeding insects. Ann. Entomol. Sot. Amer. 69: 195-201. 0.2) infested by unparasitized beetles. D. acufus had a direct influ- Cheeke,P.R.,and L.R. Sbull. 1985. Natural toxicants in feeds and poison- ence on the present generation seed crop of Canada milk-vetch by ous plants. Avi Pub. Co., Inc. Westport, Corm. reducing the number of seeds consumed by larvae of A. perforatus. Cusbman, R.A. 1911. Notes on the host plants and parasites of some North Since normal larvae of the cabbage white butterfly (Pieris rapae American Bruchiie. J. Fcon. Entomol. 4489-509. (L.)) consumed more food than those parasitized by the solitary Green, T.W., and I.G. PaImbald. 1975. Effects of insect seed predators on braconid parasitoid Apanteks rubecula Marsh (Rahman 1970), we Astragalus cibarius and Astragalus utahensb (L-quminosae). Ecology 56: 1435-1440.