Mayors React to Mergers Differently
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
V 15, N26 Thursday March 11, 2010 Mayors react to mergers differently Weinzapfel, Goodnight Evansville Mayor take different tacts on Weinzapfel at an Obama municipal reforms rally in Evansville By BRIAN A. HOWEY on April 22, FRANKLIN, Ind. - This is the 2008. story of two mayors - Jonathan Weinza- pfel of Evansville and Greg Goodnight of Kokomo. Both are Democrats and both ran unsuccessful races for Congress. Both are viewed as rising stars in the party and Weinzapfel acknowledges he is gearing up for the 2012 gubernatorial race (unless Evan Bayh comes back). Earlier this week, with the prop- erty tax caps poised to be chiseled into the Indiana Constitution in eight months, both talked about government consolidation, which is the cation. primary thrust of the caps. Gov. Daniels designed the caps The 2010 version of “Vandy-Gov” - a similar pro- to force municipalities to rethink and reformat the way they posal failed in the mid-1970s - will be on the ballot, having operate. passed both the city and county councils, along with the Evansville Mayor Weinzapfel gave his State of county commissioners. the City address Tuesday night and when it came to the “The system of government we have today hasn’t gigantic moose on the table - whether Evansville and Van- changed much since our constitution was ratified in the derburgh County should merge when voters take up the 1850s,” Weinzapfel said. “Services are provided by an referendum in November along with the caps - the future overlapping series of political units: townships, cities and gubernatorial candidate took a pass. It was classic equivo- Continued on Page 3 Blue dogs walk the plank By MARK SCHOEFF JR. WASHINGTON - In his latest urgent push to over- haul the health care system, President Barack Obama is asking members of Congress to do something in the next couple of weeks that he has never had to do - cast a vote “We all know schools need that threatens a career. Obama has taken political risks, namely running for flexibility. We all know we need president. But while he was doing that, he was safely ensconced in the third to be able to keep teachers in the and fourth years of a Senate seat. If he lost in his quest for the White House, he classroom. Why hold our children would have a soft landing. If Americans reject what will likely hostage over UI?” be a nearly $1 trillion final health care - State Rep. Greg Porter HOWEY Politics Indiana Page 2 Weekly Briefing on Indiana Politics Thursday March 11, 2010 Howey Politics Indiana is a nonpartisan, by subscription Inter- net publication based in Indianapolis and published by NewsLink, Inc. It was founded in 1994 in Fort Wayne. Columnists articles are independent opinions and do not represent the views of the publisher. Brian A. Howey, Publisher Mark Schoeff Jr., Washington bill, Obama will suffer. He has ample time around, Ellsworth is undecided on Jack E. Howey, Editor time, however, before 2012 to shore how he will vote. The House may be Beverly Phillips, up his political foundation. forced to pass the Senate bill, which Associate Editor/Business Operations The context is more urgent many pro-life House members argue for those facing voters in November. contains weaker abortion language. Subscriptions: When he was a legislator in the Illinois “As I have said from the $350 annually HPI Weekly state house, Obama voted “present” very beginning, I will not support a bill $550 annually HPI Weekly & many times. The members of the if I believe it would result in federal HPI Daily Wire House who he is prodding to support funding for abortions,” Ellsworth said a Senate bill that makes them quesy in a statement released on Wednesday Contact Us: don’t have the same luxury. after HPI had made repeated calls to Howey Politics Indiana Three under intense pres- determine his position. “I am looking 6255 North Evanston Avenue sure are in the Indiana congressional carefully at the current language in Indianapolis, IN 46220 delegation - Democratic Reps. Brad the bill to ensure it meets my pro-life 317.627.6746 Ellsworth, 8th CD, Joe Donnelly, 2nd principles, and I will continue to work CD, and Baron Hill, 9th CD. to ensure pro-life concerns are ad- www.howeypolitics.com Ellsworth has the most to dressed.” lose. His position on health care re- With the health care margin [email protected] form may define his nascent campaign of victory so slim in the House - where Howey’s Mobile: 317.506.0883 for the Senate seat being vacated by 216 votes are needed - it wouldn’t Washington: 202.256.5822 Sen. Evan Bayh. Ellsworth voted in take much opposition to scuttle the Business Office: 317.627.6746 favor of the House version of the bill Senate measure. Donnelly has already that the chamber passed 220-215 in indicated that he is skeptical about the ©2010, Howey Politics Indiana. early November. version coming over from the other HPI is a subscription-based publica- Ellsworth held out his support side of Capitol. tion. All rights reserved. Photocopying, until the end, when he was satisfied “[I]f I’m asked to vote on Internet forwarding, faxing or repro- that the measure contained strong the Senate health care reform bill as ducing in any form, in whole or part, restrictions against federal funding is, I will vote no,” Donnelly said in a is a violation of federal law without of abortions. Ellsworth was a central statement. “The Senate version of permission from the publisher. figure in writing the abortion amend - health care reform does not meet my ment that was approved prior to a standards for assuring that no federal final vote on the health care bill. This funds are used for abortion-related HOWEY Politics Indiana Page 3 Weekly Briefing on Indiana Politics Thursday March 11, 2010 services.” health care refom” - lower costs, more Abortion is one of several objec- insurance choices, coverage of pre-ex- tions many House members have to isting conditions and deficit neutrality the Senate version. They may have to - echoed almost word-for-word Obama’s depend on the Senate to correct those description of the plan he has put problems through a controversial parlia- forward, which closely resembles the mentary maneuver called reconciliation, Senate bill. which allows a bill to pass with a simple Still, it will be a tough vote for majority rather than the supermajority Ellsworth (pictured at left), Donnelly and required to overcome a filibuster. Hill, with most polls showing that Ameri- Senate Republicans are taunting cans are skeptical about massive health House Democrats, warning them that if care reform legislation. Obama urges they pass the bill the Senate approved on Christmas Eve, members of Congress to join him on the policy plateau, far it may not be modified through reconciliation. Republicans above the messiness of politics. have several means at their disposal to block the revisions. “They’re obsessed with the sport of politics,” Hill acknowledges that the political machinations Obama said in a recent speech describing people in Wash- have been unsettling for some of his colleagues. ington other than himself. “And so that’s the environment “I understand the unease and confusion surround- in which elected officials are operating. My question to ing the process,” Hill said in a statement. “I’m also awaiting them is: When is the right time? If not now, when? If not word of how Congress will proceed. My vote on a final bill us, who?” is dependent upon several factors, many of which are in Obama went on to exhort people like Ellsworth, Hill limbo and could be contained in the measure rectifying the and Donnelly to stand up and be counted on health care. House and Senate bills.” “We weren’t sent (to Washington) just so every- Hill also said that he has been “consistently body can say how wonderful we are,” Obama said. “We straightforward in my support of an overhaul of our current were sent there to do what was hard. We were sent there health care system.” That foreshadows what is likely to be to solve the big challenges.” a “yes” vote. Obama sees himself as a paragon of public ser- That’s the same place where Ellsworth and Don- vice. I wonder if he would be as confident if we were eight nelly probably will wind up, too. Ellsworth’s “principles for months away from the 2012 election. v And? 2 mayors, from page 1 “The goal, of course, is to streamline City and counties. As I have mentioned, we continue to find ways County government in a way that allows us to make the for the city and county to cooperate and save money. But, most effective use of your tax dollars so we can build it begs the question of what else can be done.” infrastructure, provide services, enhance quality of life, and And then he began sounding like Tevye from “Fid- grow our economy.” dler on the Roof.” Well, that was it. No vision as to what a consolidat- “On the one hand, consolidation makes a lot of ed Evansville/Vanderburgh would look like from the mayor. sense,” Weinzapfel reasoned. “The city and county provide By the end of the speech, citizens and voters had no idea similar services in a compact geographical area. It’s fair to where Weinzapfel stood. It was hardly a clarion call for a ask if we need both a city council and a county council, or potential gubernatorial nominee. People look to good lead- both a sheriff’s department and a police department.” ers for leadership.