William Louis Abbott in Madagascar
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
museum anthropology william louis abbott in ethnographic and biological collections from Central madagascar: and Southeast Asia, especially Indonesia, until his Revisiting Archival and Museum return to the United States in 1910. In fact, during Resources of a Smithsonian Naturalist this early period of collecting in Madagascar, he from the 1890s developed an interest in similarities to the material culture of the “Malays,” which he later continued Paul Michael Taylor exploring during his much longer period of collecting smithsonian institution in the ethnological region then commonly called “Malaysia” (peninsular Malaya and island Southeast 3 abstract Asia). Abbott’s ethnographic collections from Madagas- This article introduces an important group of ethnographic, car form a little-known resource whose potential use- biological, and unpublished archival materials deriving from two expeditions to Madagascar by American natural- fulness is much greater when considered in light of ist William Louis Abbott (1860–1936). The first was from related archival material and biological collections. February to September 1890; the second from January to Those who may have examined his ethnographic or July 1895 when Abbott rushed back to Madagascar not only even archival material from Madagascar probably did to collect for the Smithsonian but also to join the Merina in not realize that many important keys to its interpreta- their unsuccessful war of independence against the tion can be found in Abbott’s recollections about encroaching French government. Beyond summarizing Madagascar written much later in his correspondence localities he visited and the current organization and use- from Kashmir or Southeast Asia and that other rele- fulness of his collections for research, the article attempts vant information can be found within records of bio- to interpret archival records to assess Abbott’s collecting logical specimens from the same Madagascar focus, biases, and purposes; his perspectives on contem- expeditions. Consequently, after first introducing Ab- poraneous events in Madagascar; and also the role that bott himself and examining his role as a “naturalist “naturalist” collectors such as Abbott played within the collector” and his relationship to museum anthropol- history of anthropology and of museums. Ethnographic ogy, this article attempts to present a broader view of information is embedded not only within the ethnographic the resources available from these expeditions, then collections but also within associated biological collections finally to present examples of how his ethnographic and archives. [Madagascar, William Louis Abbott, natural- collections can be used and reinterpreted today. At a ist, ethnographic collections, Smithsonian Institution] time when many lament the under-use of museum collections (e.g., Museums Association 2005), this article will hopefully provide one good example of This article introduces an important group of ethno- how our legacy of material culture collections in graphic, biological, and unpublished archival materi- museums may very profitably be reinterpreted using als deriving from two collecting expeditions to associated archival information and other data. Madagascar by American naturalist William Louis Abbott (1860–1936) (Figure 1).1 The first took place Naturalist Collector William Louis Abbott between February and September 1890. The second Abbott was by far the Smithsonian’s most prolific took place from January to July 1895, during France’s collector of Indonesian and Malaysian artifacts war with the Merina (or “Hova”), whom the antico- (Taylor 1995, 2002; Taylor and Hamilton 1993; also lonialist Abbott tried to join in their unsuccessful see examples in Taylor and Aragon 1991) and a major struggle for independence prior to France’s capture of collector of ethnographic and biological specimens the Merina kingdom’s capital at Antananarivo in Sep- (mostly mammals and birds) from every region in tember 1895 (and formal annexation of Madagascar which he traveled. Although the Asian Civilisations in 1896).2 Aware that he might be prosecuted for aid- Museum (2009) has recently published information ing the enemy, Abbott never returned to Madagascar on Malaysian and Indonesian collections Abbott but rather went on to assemble major Smithsonian donated to museums in Singapore, and Taylor Museum Anthropology, Vol. 38, Iss. 1, pp. 28–45 Published 2015. This article is a U.S. Government work and is in the public domain in the USA. Museum Anthropology published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc. on behalf of the American Anthropological Association. This is an open access article under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs License, which permits use and distribution in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited, the use is non-commercial and no modifications or adaptations are made. DOI: 10.1111/muan.12071 william louis abbott in madagascar Adornment,” “Architectural Objects and Furniture,” “Culinary Utensils,” et cetera. Thirteen objects were illustrated by line drawings within the catalogue.4 Abbott never prepared such a catalogue for any of his biological collections nor for his ethnographic collec- tions from Madagascar or any other place. By the time of his death in 1936, Abbott had become the largest single donor of collections to what is now the National Museum of Natural History, Smithsonian Institution. An eccentric millionaire, this Philadelphia native, who received an M.D. from the University of Pennsylvania (1884) but never profes- sionally practiced medicine, was as allergic to publicity as he was to “civilization.” This article draws from archival research on Abbott’s widely scattered field notes and correspondence (Taylor in press), primarily with his family and with Smithsonian officials, regard- ing his lifelong series of expeditions that began in East Africa and continued in Madagascar and other Indian Ocean islands and then Central Asia before he first arrived in Southeast Asia and began his longest period of explorations there. Abbott’s collecting was entirely Figure 1. William Louis Abbott (1860–1936). (National Anthropological self-financed because at the age of 26 he received a Archives, Smithsonian Institution.) large inheritance upon the death of his father in 1886. (2014a) recently described his expeditions to south- His papers are now found in the Smithsonian’s ern Thailand in the 1890s, Abbott’s earlier African National Anthropological Archives, and in the sepa- and Madagascar ethnographic interests and rate Smithsonian Archives, as well as in field records collections are much less well known, though as noted stored in the Smithsonian’s Mammals Library and its below, Mary Jo Arnoldi (2002) examined textiles he Botany Library; all four of these repositories contain collected in Madagascar (now at the Smithsonian), material relating to his Madagascar period. which is also referenced within the survey by Simon Information about Abbott’s collecting mission Peers (2004:148–149). Laurence Dorr’s (1997:3) com- and purposes must be inferred almost entirely from pilation of plant collectors in Madagascar and the his archival correspondence and his field notes Comoro Islands briefly notes that Abbott collected (which, in Madagascar, consisted only of object labels plants from other Indian Ocean islands and that he without any field journal), alongside the collections collected birds, mammals, and ethnographic material he assembled. Abbott himself seems to have consid- from Madagascar, but he states that he found no evi- ered that the role of the “naturalist” (collector or dence that Abbott collected any plants on his trips to expert in “natural history,” which in the United States Madagascar. Because Abbott’s zoological collections subsumes anthropology as well as geology and biol- received far greater attention and were extensively ogy) could be separate from that of the curator and published, he is best known as a zoological collector. scientist. Just as he expected biologists to “write up” Yet, the only publication Abbott himself authored the descriptions of species of birds and mammals he about his lifelong series of collecting expeditions is an sent back to the museum, he seems to have consid- article on his ethnographic collections from East ered it the task of ethnologists (not necessarily him- Africa (1887–89) within the Smithsonian’s annual self) to describe and study the ethnographic report for 1892. That publication (Abbott 1892) materials. In a 1911 essay “The American Hunter- included a catalogue of 247 objects collected, which Naturalist,” published in the popular magazine The were grouped into categories such as “Dress and Outlook, President Theodore Roosevelt praised the 29 william louis abbott in madagascar typical unpaid volunteer spirit of America’s explorers proposed that Abbott author this multipart narrative and naturalists. Yet, he compared Abbott unfavorably of his collections: with naturalist and author Charles Sheldon, upbraid- It occurred to me that possibly you might have ing Abbott for recording but not publishing his notes. an idea of producing such a narrative yourself, It is exasperating to think of certain of our natu- in which case you might not wish us to duplicate ralists and hunter-naturalists the value of whose it. As I understand Dr. Goode’s idea, it was to really extraordinary achievements will wholly or have a non technical account of your work. ... in part die with them unless they realize the Each separate expedition