Australian Masonry at the Crossroads

10th Canadian Masonry Symposium, Banff, Alberta, June 8 – 12, 2005 AUSTRALIAN MASONRY AT THE CROSSROADS A.W. Page1 1CBPI Professor in Structural Clay Brickwork, Faculty of Engineering & Built Environment, The University of Newcastle, NSW, 2308, Australia, [email protected] ABSTRACT Masonry in its various forms is widely used because of its aesthetic qualities, its strength and its physical characteristics related to thermal efficiency, sound transmission and fire resistance. However, in recent years, it has lost market share to alternative materials and systems in a number of areas. Despite having leading edge technology for unit manufacture, the Australian masonry industry is very traditional and conservative, and to some extent complacent. To remain competitive, the masonry industry must be able to adapt to change and be receptive to innovation. This applies not only to advances in materials technology and the development of new products and building systems, but also to changes in the regulatory framework to meet the demands of increased emphasis on thermal and acoustic performance, seismic resistance and sustainability. This is in a climate of decreasing support for, and activity in, pure and applied masonry research by universities and government research organisations such as CSIRO. These issues are discussed in the Australian context and in particular, the need for the industry to be pro-active and address these challenges. Many of the issues raised will also relate to the Canadian scene. KEYWORDS: industry, challenges INTRODUCTION Masonry in various forms has been used as a construction material for thousands of years. In the modern context, there is also a long tradition of masonry construction in Australia dating back to the first European settlement with the arrival of the First Fleet from England in 1788. Masonry, along with steel, concrete and timber is still one of the four primary construction materials used in buildings in Australia today [1]. It is used in a number of forms (fired clay, concrete, calcium silicate, natural stone and autoclaved aerated concrete) and in a wide variety of loadbearing and non-loadbearing applications. In some cases it serves as the primary structural element in structures such as 3-4 storey “walk-up” apartment buildings or low rise commercial structures (taller unreinforced masonry (URM) buildings are no longer permitted because of seismic design restrictions). In many other cases, masonry is used as veneer or infill in housing or high rise framed construction. Masonry in its various forms is still widely used because of its aesthetic qualities, strength and physical characteristics related to thermal efficiency, sound transmission and fire resistance. As Hogan [2] states, “the appeal of masonry also lies in less tangible properties, such as its handcrafted persona, its link with history, and its old-world charm. As it has for centuries, masonry continues to symbolize craftsmanship, permanence, and quality”. Despite these attractive features, for masonry to remain competitive, the industry must be able to adapt to change and be receptive to innovation. This applies not only to advances in materials technology and the development of new products and building systems, but also the changes in the regulatory framework to satisfy the increasing emphasis on thermal and acoustic performance, seismic resistance and more general aspects related to sustainability of building products and systems. In many respects, the Australian masonry industry is still very traditional and conservative and to some extent complacent in responding to the development of alternative systems (a good example of this was the emergence of tilt-up concrete construction in the 1980s which made major inroads into the use of masonry in light commercial construction without any coordinated response by the masonry industry). However, there is certainly the potential to develop new and innovative products and systems and to build upon the state-of-the-art technology that is used in the manufacture of masonry bricks and blocks. It is rather incongruous that masonry units manufactured using these sophisticated technologies are then delivered to the site and still assembled unit by unit (often by semi-skilled labour) using techniques which have remained essentially unchanged for generations. This paper gives an overview of the past and present Australian masonry scene and discusses the current challenges confronting the masonry industry. To some extent, masonry is at “the crossroads,” but provided the industry is prepared to meet the challenges ahead, there is immense potential for this versatile material in the future. These issues have already been presented in an Australian context [1], but many of the issues raised are universal and will also relate to the Canadian scene. MASONRY AS A MATERIAL Masonry in its various forms is one of the oldest building materials, dating back many thousands of years. From the beginning of recorded history the use of sun-dried earth bricks, crudely fired clay bricks as well as shaped stone blocks has been recorded. From ancient times to the present day, the basic nature of masonry has remained unchanged, with convenient sized masonry units being bonded together by some form of mortar to produce a composite walling material. Major technological advances such as effective kiln firing and the use of mortars containing lime and/or sand with pozzolanic properties resulted in larger and more durable structures. The industrial revolution also saw the development of Portland cement and the mechanization of much of the brickmaking (and later block making) process. The use of masonry in Australia dates back to the first white settlement in 1788. The supplies accompanying the First Fleet included brick moulds, along with 5000 bricks brought over in the Scarborough. One skilled brickmaker, James Bloodsworth, appeared on the convict list, and he was later to become a brickmaker and Superintendent of Works [3]. The first hand-made bricks were made in March 1788 by convicts at a spot about a mile from the settlement at the head of Long Cove (now Darling Harbour) [4]. This activity continued at an expanding rate both in Sydney and other subsequent penal settlements such as Newcastle and Port Macquarie. With the increasing availability of skilled labour, the volume and quality of bricks increased rapidly and the first private brickyard was opened by John Palmer in Woolloomooloo in 1802. Over the ensuing 100 years or so, with the progressive introduction of mechanization the quality and volume of bricks increased dramatically with a large number of privately owned brickyards being established in both the city and country areas (for example, in Sydney alone, in 1890 there were more than 113 brickyards in operation [3]). These economies of scale produced a cheaper product which resulted in masonry (both brick and natural stone) being a preferred building material for a wide range of applications. In the twentieth century, the advent of Portland cement resulted in the emergence of additional masonry materials in the form of concrete bricks and blocks, calcium silicate bricks, and most recently, autoclaved aerated concrete units. This, combined with further advances in clay brick making technology (firing and manufacturing methods, mechanisation, emission controls etc), has resulted in a wide range set of economical masonry products being available to the consumer. One major recent change in the clay masonry industry has been the conversion of manufacturers from dry pressed to extrusion brick forming (for example, in N.S.W., dry pressed product now only accounts for less than 2% of annual production). These changes have been accompanied by progressive rationalization of the industry, with a large number of small producers being replaced by a small number of large companies often producing the full range of clay and concrete products. This services a country which has one of the highest per capita consumption of masonry in the world, approximately three times that of the USA [5]. For example, in 2002/2003, Australian masonry production consisted of 1.64 billion clay brick units for structural purposes, 243 million clay pavers, together with 2.86 million tonnes of concrete bricks, blocks and pavers. FUTURE TRENDS FOR MASONRY IN AUSTRALIA In the short term, it is likely that current practices will continue. However, there is increasing pressure on the industry to remain competitive both in relation to the basic masonry materials, and the resulting walling systems. The traditional methods of on-site bricklaying will come under increasing threat because traditional construction methods require an additional wet trade on the job site. The cost and potential shortage of skilled labour and the move towards a system approach to buildings through prefabrication, panelisation etc. are also major factors. It is clear that to compete effectively the masonry industry needs to be innovative in its approach. This would be expedited if building product manufacturers marketed the final product (i.e. the masonry wall element as a structural system) rather than the individual components (bricks and mortar ingredients) which are then assembled on site by a third party. Other societal factors will also have an influence on future trends. The increasing emphasis on the sustainability aspects of buildings and building products will see the increased use of waste and recycled products in the manufacture of masonry

Load more