Latin American & Iberian Library Collections at LANE Institutions
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Page | 1 A LANE REPORT Latin American & Iberian Library Collections at LANE Institutions: 1999‐2009 10 years of Comparative Data With Historical Information Since 1966 Miguel Valladares Dartmouth College Page | 2 Index Introduction 4 Libraries considered in this report 5 Part 1 – OCLC Records: Books Published in Spanish Language Latin America Table 01. Argentina: 1999‐2009 7 Table 02. Argentina: historical data, 1966‐2009 8 Table 03. Mexico: 1999‐2009 9 Table 04. Mexico: historical data, 1966‐2009 10 Table 05. Caribbean countries: current and historical data (1966‐2009) 11 Table 06. Uruguay and Paraguay: current and historical data (1966‐2009) 12 Table 07. Bolivia and Chile: current and historicaldData (1966‐2009) 13 Table 08. Peru and Ecuador: current and historical data (1966‐2009) 14 Table 09. Venezuela and Colombia: current and historical data (1966‐2009) 15 Table 10. Central America: Costa Rica and El Salvador: current and historical data (1966‐2009) 16 Table 11. Central America: Guatemala and Honduras: current and historical data (1966‐2009) 17 Table 12. Central America: Nicaragua and Panama: current and historical data (1966‐2009) 18 Table 13. Total Central America: current and historical data (1966‐2009) 19 Spain. Table 14. Spain: 1999‐2009 20 Table 15. Spain: historical data, 1966‐2009 21 Table 16. Books about Latin America published in Spain 22 Books in Spanish Language Published in Other Countries Table 17. USA, Europe and other world countries. current and historical data (1966‐2009) 23 Part 2 – OCLC Records: Books Published in Portuguese Language Table 18. Brazil: 1999‐2009 25 Table 19. Brazil: historical data, 1966‐2009 26 Table 20. Portugal: current and historical data (1966‐2009) 27 Table 21. Books published in other countries 28 Table 22. Total Portuguese language 29 Part 3 – OCLC Records: Books Published in Other Languages: (L. A. & Iberian Studies) Table 23. Indigenous languages of Latin America: current and historical data (1966‐2009) 31 Table 24. Catalan, Basque and Galician languages 32 Table 25. Books published in English, French, German and Italian languages 33 Part 4 – Data Total: Synthesis of all tables Table 26. Data totals: 1999‐2009 35 Table 27. Data totals: 1988‐1998 37 Table 28. Data totals: 1977‐1987 39 Table 29. Data totals 1966‐1976 41 Table 30. Global data totals 1966‐2009 43 Chart 01 ‐ 1999‐2009: Total collection by language in percentage for Borrow Direct & LANE 44 Chart 02 ‐ 1966‐2009: Total collection percentage for Borrow Direct & LANE 46 Page | 3 Part 5 ‐ Duplication among Borrow Direct Institutions plus Harvard Table 31. Spanish language 49 Table 32. Portuguese language and other languages 50 Table 33. Totals 51 Chart Key to explain Charts # 3‐10 52 Chart 03. Duplication (percentage) ‐ 1999‐2009: Brown 53 Chart 04. Duplication (percentage) ‐ 1999‐2009: Columbia 54 Chart 05. Duplication (percentage) ‐ 1999‐2009: Cornell 55 Chart 06. Duplication (percentage) ‐ 1999‐2009: Dartmouth 56 Chart 07. Duplication (percentage) ‐ 1999‐2009: Penn 57 Chart 08. Duplication (percentage) ‐ 1999‐2009: Princeton 58 Chart 09. Duplication (percentage) ‐ 1999‐2009: Yale 59 Chart 10. Duplication (percentage) ‐ 1999‐2009: Harvard 60 Table 34. Unique Records in Borrow Direct Institutions (1999‐2009) 61 Part 6. Search Criteria Used in This Report 1. Search strings used in this report 64 2. Library codes 70 3. Language codes 70 4. Country codes 71 5. Search strings to find duplication 72 6. Subjects and call numbers codes to be used in different search strings 73 7. Call numbers 74 Page | 4 Introduction This report analyzes Latin American and Iberian Collections held by LANE libraries with the ultimate goal of providing a useful tool that will facilitate and promote cooperation in collection building. Data is obtained by searching OCLC Worldcat First Search database. The scope of this report is to analyze the number of books held in each institution since 1966, grouped in periods of 10 years by language, country of origin and year of publication (Parts 1, 2 and 3). For major countries (Argentina, Mexico, Brazil and Spain) annual data since 1999 is also provided. By “books” this report refers only to monographs. Multi‐volume titles are only counted once. This report excludes any other material collected in different formats such as periodical, microfilms, videos, DVD, etc. Data on Latin America countries are separated from data on Iberian countries in different categories as much as possible throughout this report to respect the different methodologies used by many LANE institutions. Every LANE institution is included in this report except Temple University (no records found in OCLC) and all European libraries. LANE Institutions with many libraries in OCLC have been included. To obtain a potential national comparison, two libraries outside of LANE have been also included: University of Texas‐Austin and Stanford University. (See Libraries considered in this report (below) and Part 6:2 Library Codes) For Books published in any country in Spanish or Portuguese languages, data results do not include any subject parameter. For books published in other languages (English, French, Italian and German), data results are obtained by including subject parameters. (See Part 6.1 Search String used in this report, where there is a brief explanation of the criteria used) Part 4 includes a synthesis of previous tables providing total figures in single tables and charts that include percentages. Part 5 provides data showing duplication among all Borrow Direct institutions plus Harvard. Duplication as understood in the OCLC database means institutions that have exactly the same book. This data does not include same books published in different years, or same books published in different countries or same intellectual work published again years later. Part 6 describes the parameters used in this report. If someone wants to customize, modify or improve data from this report, they can reuse the search strings included in this part. Although the OCLC database is a very powerful tool for comparing information among many different institutions, we need to read carefully this data due to some inherent problems: 1) Many institutions have large backlogs of material not included yet in OCLC. LANE Institutions have included few books published in 2009. Major research libraries may have old collections without processing. 2) OCLC database may include many different records for the same book. 3) The same record may include two different years or two different countries or two different languages. Unfortunately this report talks mainly about quantity‐‐ not quality. Although no single tool is known to help define what is a “good” Latin American Collection, quantity is used often in Area Studies as the quintaesence that provides the definition of what is a good library. My intention in writing this report is basically to provoke the contrary: to Page | 5 spark a conversation among institutionsthat leads to a collaboration that will help users from the East of United States to access more and better resources from Latin America and Iberia culture. Libraries Considered In This Report Borrow Direct U.S. and Canada Research Libraries U.S libraries Libraries Libraries at LANE at LANE outside LANE BROWN UNIV CITY COL, CUNY LIBRARY OF CONGRESS STANFORD UNIV LIBR COLUMBIA UNIV HARVARD UNIV NEW YORK PUB LIBR UNIV OF TEXAS AT AUSTIN CORNELL UNIV NEW YORK UNIV DARTMOUTH COL RUTGERS UNIV PRINCETON UNIV SUNY (NEW YORK) UNIV OF PENNSYLVANIA UNIV OF CONNECTICUT YALE UNIV UNIV OF MASSACHUSETTS UNIV OF PITTSBURGH UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO SUNY CUNY Different Library Units Considered. Numbers for different libraries within the same institution are included as a unit. Data for Temple University could not be found in OCLC OCLC LIBRARY NAME HOLD. YSM SUNY AT STONY BROOK YES RBN BROWN UNIV YES UCW UNIV OF CONNECTICUT YES CUNY YES AUM UNIV OF MASSACHUSETTS AMHERST YES VVB ‐ XMC ‐ VWB ‐ VDB ‐ ZXC ‐ PAU UNIV OF PENNSYLVANIA YES XQL ‐ ZGM ‐ ZHC ‐ ZHM ‐ VVJ ‐ PIT UNIV OF PITTSBURGH YES YKC ‐ CTX ‐ VYL ‐ XME ‐ ZNC ‐ IXA UNIV OF TEXAS AT AUSTIN YES XQM ‐ ZQC ‐ VSI ‐ VMY TXQ UNIV OF TEXAS, TARLTON LAW LIBR YES ZCU COLUMBIA UNIV YES UTO UNIV OF TORONTO YES ZCL COLUMBIA UNIV LAW SCH, DIAMOND YES GXR YALE UNIV, LAW SCH LIBR YES COO CORNELL UNIV YES YUS YALE UNIV LIBR YES DRB DARTMOUTH COL YES EB0 YALE UNIV NO HMM HARVARD UNIV NO YUSGB YALE UNIV LIBR NO HUL HARVARD UNIV NO GXK YALE UNIV, ANTHROPOLOGY LIBR NO HLS HARVARD UNIV, HARVARD COL LIBR YES GXL YALE UNIV, ART & ARCHITECTURE LIBR NO HFL HARVARD UNIV, FINE ARTS LIBR YES YU# YALE UNIV, DIVINITY SCH LIBR NO HVL HARVARD UNIV, LAW SCH, LIBR YES RQP YALE UNIV, LATIN AM PROJ NO HMU HARVARD UNIV, LOEB MUSIC LIBR YES YUU YALE UNIV, MUSIC LIBR NO TOZ HARVARD UNIV, TOZZER LIBR YES MHUAM HARVARD UNIV ART MUS NO BHA HARVARD UNIV, DIVINITY SCH LIBR NO HHG HARVARD UNIV, HOUGHTON LIBR NO DLC LIBRARY OF CONGRESS YES NYP NEW YORK PUB LIBR RES LIBR YES ZYU NEW YORK UNIV YES PUL PRINCETON UNIV YES NJR RUTGERS UNIV YES STF STANFORD UNIV LIBR YES NAM SUNY AT ALBANY YES BUF SUNY AT BUFFALO YES BNG SUNY AT BINGHAMTON YES Page | 6 Part 1: OCLC Records for Books Published in Spanish Language Page | 7 Table 01: Argentina: 1999‐2009. [Library Holdings: Books in Spanish language published in Argentina from 1999 to 2009. Total column is obtained by adding all years] Argentina 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Total BROWN RBN 166 141 169 121 151 91 158 77 197 110 2 1.383 COLUMBIA 587 596 626 524 765 838 844 746 695 367 81 6.669 CORNELL COO 609 563 504 435 626 649 595 651 535 332 96 5.595 DARTMOUTH 545 828 784 441 541 652 673 713 734 555 175 6.641 PRINCETON PUL 552 547 616 648 978 1.129 1.055 1.066 909 592 111 8.203 PENN PAU 449 332 385 274 425 504 467 396 333 207 48 3.820 YALE GXR YUS 988 976 997 706 1.221 1.310 1.249 1.270 1.134 532 13 10.396 TOTAL Borrow 3.896 3.983 4.081 3.149 4.707 5.173 5.041 4.919 4.537 2.695 526 42.707 NO Borrow Direct 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Total HARVARD 1.467 1.599 1.780 1.380 1.792 1.833 1.923 2.076 1.601 814 104 16.369 L.C.