SATURDAY • FEBRUARY 14, 2004
Including The Bensonhurst Paper
Published every Saturday by Brooklyn Paper Publications Inc, 55 Washington Street, Suite 624, Brooklyn NY 11201. Phone 718-834-9350 • www.BrooklynPapers.com • © 2004 Brooklyn Paper Publications • 18 pages including GO BROOKLYN • Vol. 27, No. 6 BRZ • Saturday, Feb. 14, 2004 • FREE Just for frills FED FIX-UP FOR Valentine’s gift ideas for the guy with THIS WEEKEND love in his heart –- and sex on his mind! FORT HAMILTON Base getting $7.6 mil for MP station By Jotham Sederstrom mitted by the Pentagon of bases that could be The Brooklyn Papers closed. In response, Fossella last month added EXCLUSIVE eight new members to a local task force created to The Fort Hamilton Army Base has been defend against an earlier round of closings in awarded federal funding for the construc- 2001. tion of a new, $7.6 million headquarters for possible base closings, according to spokesmen “Bottom line is, what’s going to happen with for the base and Rep. Vito Fossella. the base realignment has nothing to do with the the Provost Marshal and Military Police, It was not clear whether the funding commit- The Bay Ridge Paper has learned. way we do business,” said Ray Aalbue, a ment would have any effect on the decision of the spokesman for the base. “We’re going to move Construction will begin shortly after the con- congressional committee. tract is awarded next January and continue well ahead with all the projects we have in place and Last month it was announced that a commis- look at the future as if we’re still going to be into 2006, nearly a year after a congressional base sion composed of military experts nationwide here.” closure commission announces its choices for would choose to either reject or accept a list sub- The 12,000-square-foot, two-story building will be four times as large as the building that cur-
/ Greg Mango / Greg rently houses the base’s law enforcement arm. The military police station will be constructed on the footprint of the National Guard headquar- ters, in building 401, which will be razed next year after the contract is awarded. The provost and military police are currently housed in a The Brooklyn Papers The Brooklyn Dems cry foul over Bullets fly: A 1950s “bullet bra,” on display at Olive’s Very Vintage boutique in Carroll Gar- building without lockers or a conference room, dens, will knock him dead. according to Aalbue. “The reason why it’s being constructed is be- By Lisa J. Curtis flannel pajama type (now 50 percent off!) or a dar- cause the present office is substandard according Fort Ham task force to Army regulations,” said Aalbue. “This building GO Brooklyn Editor ing diva — the G-strings by Gossard with sparkling crystal accents are a MUST ($27-$36). is going to be like any other precinct in the city. “Your husband called … he said to buy We suspect the “G” is short for your predictable re- By Jotham Sederstrom 60th Assembly District Com- congressional level,” said Gen- Everybody knows the precinct down the block.” anything you want.” action when she tries it on: “Goodness gracious!” The Brooklyn Papers mitteeman Ralph Perfetto and tile, who added that during elec- “This project represents the type of investment That’s the message on a discreet sign inside “And they’re comfortable, because they lay flat Bay Ridge Democrats Assemblywoman Adele Cohen tion time Republicans tend to that Vito has said is critical to strengthening Fort Bella Lingerie, a lavish boutique in Bay Ridge, on the skin,” points out practical Carla. charged last week that a task all expressed disbelief that the “dream up an issue.” Hamilton,” said Craig Donner, a spokesman for but as Valentine’s Day is here, it’s also a reminder The Catanzaro gals are glad to help guide you task force, created by Fossella in The closure commission won’t Fossella. “Getting the project included in the pres- force created by Rep. Vito 2001 and expanded last week, be formed until next March, more to those husbands, boyfriends — and girlfriends through the array of temptations in silk, lace and Fossella to block the closing ident’s budget is a crucial first step. Vito is already — who waited until the very last minute to run ribbons: the Loungewear Betty marabou-bedecked only counts among its ranks sev- than four months after fellow working with congressional leaders to make sure of the Fort Hamilton Army eral known Democrats, none of Ridge Republicans Fossella and the funding is available for the project to begin on (don’t walk) and buy some sexy underthings for baby doll sets (y’know, what the Fembots were Base is nothing more than a the ladies they love. wearing in “Austin Powers”?) are fun in demure whom are elected officials. state Sen. Marty Golden are up time.” To further cut to the lace, let us guide you pink or femme fatale black ($100 for set); the Mary political ruse designed to “This whole thing of trying for re-election. Federal funding has also been announced for through the frilly labyrinth of choices available in Green red silk chemise is flatteringly trimmed in benefit the congressman’s re- to save something that’s not be- Included on the 26-member active guard and reserve forces in Buffalo and Brooklyn. black lace, with matching robe ($63, $127 respec- election bid in November. ing threatened is a political ploy task force are Assemblyman Fort Drum, which will receive $52 million next At year-old Bella Lingerie, owners and sisters- tively); and the delightfully ruffled, mischievously Councilman Vincent Gentile, on the state Senate level and the See TASK FORCE on page 14 year. in-law Carla and Jessica Catanzaro maintain a revealing, black Arianne camisole ($40), em- gift registry — or database — of their customers’ broidered with hearts, can be paired with sizes and wish lists. So if your Juliet is already a matching thong boy short ($22), and it’s Bella customer, they may already know what both gorgeous and affordable. she’s secretly hoping for. “We try to carry all the lines If you’d like your gift to be a complete surprise, found in Manhattan stores,” ex- Bella Lingerie is brimming with every possible in- plains Carla. “We have a lot carnation of boudoir-wear, whether your lady’s the See LINGERIE on page 13 There’s more to INSIDE DOUBLE TRAGEDY City warned a year ago of deadly corner where two youths were crushed by truck
By Jotham Sederstrom The Brooklyn Papers Two Park Slope boys on their way home from school were run over and killed by a landscaping truck at Third Avenue and Ninth Street this week. And compounding the tragedy for the families of the fifth-graders came word that the city Depart- ment of Transportation ignored the recommendations of a study it commissioned a year ago that Mango / Greg called for traffic-calming measures at the deadly intersection. The 130-page Downtown Brooklyn Traffic Calming study warned that the intersection of The Brooklyn Papers The Brooklyn Third Avenue and Ninth Street, and / Jori Klein dozens of other hotspots, needed to Father-son heroes Angelo (left) and Anthony Augello with state Sen. Marty Golden and Engine 243/Ladder 168 firefighters Wednesday. be re-engineered with extended sidewalk corners, or neck-downs. Additionally, it called for some of the traffic signals to be changed so Papers The Brooklyn that pedestrians would have a head Victoria Flores listens to Hail Marys recited for her son, Vic- start before trucks got the green tor, 11, while being comforted by family members at Tues- light. day’s vigil. In July, the DOT released a list INTO THE FIRE of short-term, relatively low-cost solutions that were to be carried out within a year. On that list, accord- Father and son honored for daring rescue of woman, 87 ing to a review of that study, was the implementation of delayed traf- By Jotham Sederstrom halation and less serious burns at firehouse is a hero.” her unconscious in her second-floor fic signals on Third Avenue at The Brooklyn Papers Lutheran Medical Center. The Feb. 8 fire inside Rose DiGio- kitchen. Ninth Street, which, unlike neck- “Being a fireman’s son for 18 vanni’s home on 76th Street at 16th “My son followed me into a burn- The bravery of a retired fire- years, you kind of learn by osmosis,” Avenue broke out around 4 am, fire- ing building and I’m so proud of downs, cost absolutely nothing, ac- fighter and his 22-year-old son cording to transportation experts. said Anthony Augello who runs a fighters said. John DiGiovanni ran him for that,” said Angelo Augello. “The cost estimate on that item was recognized Wednesday, days Brooklyn theatrical group. The father across the street in only his underwear “And I’m happy that the firemen got was zero,” said Noah Budnick, after the pair battled waves of and son also helped rescue a woman to the home of Angelo Augello and us out of there.” projects director of Transportation black smoke to rescue an 87-year- two years ago after her Ford Explorer his wife, JoAnn, and two sons, Antho- Fire officials said the blaze was Alternatives, a watchdog group that old neighbor from flames that had collided with a luxury bus on the Van ny and 21-year-old Michael, who was likely started by a cigarette. believes the accident could have raged through her second-floor Wyck Expressway in Queens. not home at the time. Angelo was Angelo Augello, a Bay Ridge na- been avoided had the traffic-calm- apartment in Bensonhurst. Beneath a tin ceiling inside the 109- sleeping, but Anthony had just re- tive who wears a stud in his right ear ing measures been implemented. Angelo Augello, 49, and his son year-old firehouse on 18th Avenue at turned home around 3 am. and a tattoo on the back of his neck, “They just haven’t gotten around to Anthony received recognition along 86th Street, state Sen. Marty Golden Angelo and Anthony Augello ran said gruffly that he hadn’t done doing this one yet,” he said. with firefighters from Engine Co. passed out proclamations to Lt. Joe across the street and climbed the stairs something like that since he fought Last June, DOT representatives / Jori Klein 243 and Ladder 168 who pulled the Cilento and firefighters Scott Hourican to the apartment, but couldn’t get to fires professionally with Engine 253 said in a meeting at Borough Hall woman from the fire. and Albert Somma, who along with the woman because of the smoke. in Coney Island. He retired in 1997. that the recommendations included Rose DiGiovanni was listed in se- other firemen responded to a 911 call “It was like pitch-black smoke When Augello mentioned at the in the five-year, $1.2 million traffic- rious condition at Lutheran Medical placed by Angelo Augello. from top to bottom,” said Anthony. ceremony that he and his son had calming report would not be imple- Center before being transferred to “Their determination and their “It was still unbreathable, but I graduated from Bay Ridge’s Xaver- mented until 2009, because of the Papers The Brooklyn the Cornell-Weill burn center in spirit never gave up, even with fires called her name like five times.” ian High School, four or five other city’s budget crisis. Family members hold pictures of Flores (left), and his friend Manhattan. Her son, John DiGio- raging behind them,” said Golden, a After a struggle to find DiGiovan- firefighters acknowledged that it was See TRAGIC on page 15 Juan (Angel) Estrada, 10, who were killed by a truck Monday. vanni, 63, was treated for smoke in- former policeman. “Everyone in this ni, firefighters responded and found also their alma mater.
Receive The Paper by First Class Mail for $125 per year • View us online at www.BrooklynPapers.com Call The Papers at 718-834-9350 • Celia Weintrob, Publisher (ext 104) • Neil Sloane, Editor (ext 119) • Lisa J. Curtis, GO Brooklyn Editor (ext 131) • Vince DiMiceli, Senior Editor (ext 125) • Ed Weintrob, President (ext 105) 2 AWP THE BROOKLYN PAPERS • WWW.BROOKLYNPAPERS.COM February 14, 2004 Free Seminar For Senior Concerns Presented By The Law Firm of Susan A. Principato
You are cordially invited to a FREE seminar workshop to help you achieve your health care and financial goals and concerns. The presenter will be Susan A. Principato, an Elder Law Attorney with experience in all aspects of Health Care and Financial planning with regard to Medicaid eligibili- ty, wealth preservation, and asset protection for seniors and their families.
The topics to be discussed will be as follows:
$ Protecting & preserving assets while obtaining Medicaid eligibility $ Strategies to protect your homestead $ Creating a legacy for your family even if you require a Nursing Home or home care assistance $ Long term care insurance and Medicaid planning $ Wealth preservation for your health care and financial needs
Special guest speaker will be John A. Calabrese, CLTC, financial services representative from +less than $75/month Client Advisory Solutions, an office of MetLife Financial Services®. For more information 1 on Client Advisory Solutions, visit www.clientadvisorysolutions.com 2 /2 Months Free MetLife Building JOIN NOW FOR MEMBERSHIP THROUGH MAY 1, 2005 15 Bay Ridge Ave., Brooklyn, NY 11220 ONLY 2 DAYS AVAILABLE!! (One Block From the 69th Street Pier) FOR THE PRICE OF ONE YEAR SEATING IS LIMITED, PLEASE CALL MEMBERSHIP FEE IS PAID IN ADVANCE. VALID ONLY FOR NEW INDIVIDUAL MEMBERS. Thursday, February 26th 1:30 & 6:30 Registration 1-800-395-5762 Offer ends February 15 Saturday, February 28th REFESHMENTS WILL BE SERVED 11 AM Registration
The Law Firm of Susan A. Principato is not affiliated with MetLife or any of its affiliates. BROOKLYN HEIGHTS 43 CLARK STREET 718 625 0500 Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, One Madison Avenue, New York, New York 10010 METROTECH 333 ADAMS STREET 718 330 0007 PROSPECT PARK 17 EASTERN PARKWAY 718 789 4600 L0402FCAF(exp0206)(NJ; NY)MLIC-LD TRIBECA 80 LEONARD STREET 212 966 5432
Schedule your Tax Appointment by February 15th! TAXX Advisors LLC ALeading National Tax Preparation Firm www.pinnacletaxx.com $75 Flat Fee (Includes: Federal & State Individual Returns/All Schedules) April 15th: your way! Call your local office and schedule an appointment by February 15th, and mention this ad!
Park Slope 790A Union Street between 6th and 7th Avenues 718-789-3002
Bensonhurst 8754 Bay 16th Street between Bath and Benson Avenues 718-331-3700
Marine Park 2078 Flatbush Avenue off Avenue P 718-692-4425
This offer is valid for new clients only. February 14, 2004 THE BROOKLYN PAPERS • WWW.BROOKLYNPAPERS.COM AWP 3 Park Slope ‘brothel’ no longer ill-reputed Better Scores. Better Schools. By Deborah Kolben The Brooklyn Papers For the past decade, James Ripley West- moreland has been watching the comings and goings at a small hotel on his Park Slope street. With On warm summer nights, the attorney would sit on his stoop and cast an inquisitive eye at the couples and single men who would arrive at all ClassSize-8 hours. The reason for his attention was that unlike the neighborhood bed and breakfasts hosting out-of- you’ll town grandparents, the Lincoln Plaza Hotel, at 153 Lincoln Place, catered to a different crowd — namely the kind that pays by the hour. never For about $50 a pop, amorous couples could rent a shabby room in the 19th-century, red-brick, Romanesque Revival-style townhouse. have And rumor has it that single men looking for a little — ahem — company, could also find it at the Lincoln Plaza — for a price. more But those days are now over. Since Jan. 1, couples arriving for libidinous * * * ventures have been met with closed doors. After than GRE GMAT LSAT 30 years, Park Slope’s one and only reputed house of ill-repute has packed up and moved out. Classroom, Online, Tutoring A new owner bought the property last year and eight intends to turn it into an 11-units of either rentals or condominiums.
Just before the New Year, the green awning Callan / Tom students in a came down and love-seekers made way for con- struction workers starting on a gut renovation of the house. class. “It really was a house of ill-repute,” said Bernard Graham, president of the Park Slope The Brooklyn Papers The Brooklyn The Civic Council, who took a tour of the facility The former hotel and alleged brothel at 153 Lincoln Place in Park Slope along with local legislators just before it closed. has been sold and will be renovated. “I always heard the rumors that it was a broth- el,” Graham said, adding that he didn’t ultimate in believe it until he saw the place with his and structures. “They had very nice people working own eyes. “I went through with the devel- In a report issued at a Landmarks there,” said Westmoreland, son of retired personal oper at night — it’s just naked people run- Preservation Commission hearing in No- Gen. William Westmoreland, commander ning around, dingy, not an upscale type of vember, Bankoff called the Lincoln Place of U.S. forces in Vietnam from 1964 to thing.” proposal “appalling,” claiming the 1968, who is serving as unofficial attention. Advocating for a more appropriate use, changes to the building would be harmful spokesman for several homeowners along Councilman David Yassky worked with to its architectural character. the block between Sixth and Seventh av- the new developers, identified by the city “Their proposal was not appropriate for enues. Department of Buildings as the Foster the site,” Bankoff told The Brooklyn Pa- Despite the relatively hospitable rela- Family Trust, to help guide them through pers this week. tionship between the brothel and its neigh- the land use review process. Alain Kodsi, a spokesman for the de- bors, an incident five years ago sent a chill In order to convert the landmarked veloper, declined to comment for this arti- through the block. structure from a hotel to an apartment cle. In April, 1999, a woman was found building, the developers have sought var- While neighbors are anxious to pre- hanging by a belt in a shower of the hotel. ious city approvals to raise the copper- serve the house, and generally welcome Water seeping through the floor led police and-slate roof so that floors can be the conversion, some are also concerned to the discovery of the 44-year-old wom- Seats are limited. Call now to enroll. added, install a ramp, and add a rear ad- about the empty lot adjacent to the site an’s body. dition, according to Landmarks Preserva- and hope the developer does not build on Since then, things have been fairly qui- tion Commission spokeswoman Diane it. et at the hotel, tucked away next to the Jackier. “It’s a spot to watch,” said Graham. Brooklyn Conservatory of Music. RAISE YOUR SCORE WITH PROVEN TEST-TAKING STRATEGIES. Those changes were approved in No- Over the years, many neighbors turned “Oddly enough, the hotel was sort of vember, much to the chagrin of Simeon a blind eye to the hotel, annoyed mostly interesting,” said Westmoreland. www.PrincetonReview.com • 800-2Review Bankoff, executive director of the His- by the line of car services beeping their “I don’t think I will miss it, but it cer- *GMAT is a registered trademark of the Graduate Management Admission Council (GMAC). LSAT is a registered trademark of the Law School Admission Council, Inc. (LSAC). toric Districts Council, a non-profit or- horns at all hours. tainly was fun to sit on my stoop and see MCAT is a registered trademark of the Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC). GRE is a registered trademark of Educational Testing Service (ETS). The Princeton Review is not affiliated with Princeton University, GMAC, LSAC, ETS, or AAMC. ganization advocating for the preserva- But for the most part, there was little the activity — it’s a slice of New York tion of the city’s historic neighborhoods police activity at the site. that is gone forever.”
ROAD RUNNER BUSINESS CLASS
ARRIVE What makes the Maimonides at high-speed Internet Cardiac Institute one of the solutions that work. best in the world? • Static IP Addresses
• E-mail Solutions
• Web Hosting
• Remote Storage
• Teleworker Programs
• VPN
• Digital Cable
• Fiber Solutions
• Branch Office Connectivity
“After cardiac surgery, we continue to provide the best care to ensure your recovery. We use wireless Road Runner Business Class enables you and your employees to get Download of 2 MB File telemetry, which allows patients to begin walking business done quickly and efficiently so you can spend less time DIAL-UP Download time and promotes cardiac rehabilitation, all under the waiting and more time working. 4:30 supervision of a team of the most caring professionals We provide a full suite of Internet solutions designed to meet your you will ever see. Believe me, this is where you company’s needs. To find out which solutions are right for your ROAD RUNNER BUSINESS CLASS Download time want to trust your heart.” business, call today to schedule a no-obligation consultation. – Niki Vasilopoulos, RN :04 Open Heart Stepdown Unit
Order DTV and Road Runner and receive a FREE Installation, PREVENTION DIAGNOSIS TREATMENT REHABILITATION RESEARCH FREE TV and a 15% Discount on Digital Cable. To learn more about the Cardiac Institute go to: Call 1-877-RRWORK4 www.maimonidesmed.org Maimonides To make our team part of your care, call: 1-800-682-5558 MEDICAL CENTER THE CARDIAC INSTITUTE
Offer ends 4/30/04. Available to commercial customers in limited Time Warner Cable service areas who purchase Road Runner Business Class and digital cable service. Minimum one year term on both services required. *Modern Healthcare Magazine One of the top 100 heart hospitals in America* Free Installation offer does not include costs of construction to street or building and/or horizontal pulls. 15% discount offer applies to the first year of digital cable service charges only. Customer has choice of 20" TV or 13" TV/VCR Combo. Tax applies to installation. Some restrictions apply. LOONEY TUNES characters, names and all related indicia are trademarks of Warner Bros. ©2004. Monthly services charges vary according to the level of service. Not all options are available with all levels of service. CAM.0204.005-BSrrbc_bkpaprs 4 AWP THE BROOKLYN PAPERS • WWW.BROOKLYNPAPERS.COM February 14, 2004 NOT JUST NETS LETTERS: READERS REACT TO COVERAGE IN THE BROOKLYN PAPERS CB2 chair slams The Paper To the editor: other ill-informed individuals. LAST WEEK’S FRONT PAGE gent timelines in order to eval- nents that will ultimately deter- It is unfortunate and a dis- Not withstanding your foot- uate the Downtown Brooklyn mine whether the Downtown service to the members of ball metaphor, each board Plan and to come up with rec- Brooklyn Plan will come to Community Board 2 (CB2) member is responsible for his ommendations to the Land Use fruition. Those individuals and and your readers that you were or her own respective vote on committee. agencies responsible for imple- so ill prepared to write the edi- this and every other issue that It is the Land Use commit- mentation must incorporate the torial, “Neil Sloane/ CB2 is brought to the full board of tee’s responsibility to submit concerns of the community blows it bigtime,” that ap- Community Board 2 for vote. ULURP land use recommenda- and the recommendations peared in the Feb. 7 edition of All community board mem- tions to the full board. Many of made by the board if the imple- The Brooklyn Papers. Your bers were well aware of the the concerns raised by the com- mentation is to be successful. fact-less and irresponsible re- Downtown Brooklyn Plan and mittees were considered helpful While the outcome of the porting further adds to the mis- its importance on setting the di- builds to the Downtown CB2 vote did not proceed as THE NEW BROOKLYN information disseminated by rectional future for Downtown Brooklyn Plan and were ad- was preferred by many, our Brooklyn, the entire borough dressed accordingly in follow voices have been heard. And and indeed, the entire city. up correspondence from the in- will not be discounted! Community Board 2’s game volved city agencies. In regards to your comments plan for the Downtown Brook- At the public hearing some related to Mr. Diamondstone’s lyn Plan (DBP) began in No- of our local elected representa- proposal, if you were at the vember 2002 with the first of tives commented on their dis- meeting you would know that I ‘Absent’ member TWENTY MEETINGS relat- satisfaction with the plan and actually helped Mr. Diamond- ing to the DBP. To the credit of urged the community board to stone in his attempt to make his the city agencies, representa- vote against the plan in its en- motion by informing him that tives of the Department of City tirety. Clearly, that recommen- he was seeking a motion to di- Planning, Economic Develop- dation does come with sub- vide to which his response was says it wasn’t so ment Corporation and Housing stantial impact. “yes” and he returned to his Preservation and Development, There were board members seat. In Mr. Diamondstone’s To the editor: well. Rather that “duck” challenges, I have as well as representatives from for whom those recommenda- motion he did not specify how Your Feb. 7 editorial [“Neil Sloane/CB2 spent my entire professional life advocating for the Downtown Brooklyn Coun- tions weighed heavily. Add to the division was to take place! blows it bigtime”] and Deborah Kolben’s article those most in need, regardless of the popularity cil were always on hand to an- that the substantial opposition Although others from your [“Mum’s the word”] grossly mischaracterize the of my position. As a legal services attorney, a swer questions and deliver pre- from the community, albeit some paper have attended some of circumstances of my participation in the Com- counselor working with battered women, com- sentations whenever requested. based on misinformation, and the the meetings sponsored by the munity Board 2 vote on the Brooklyn develop- munity organizer and children’s rights advocate, These meetings and/or presen- equivocation of the board vote community board I don’t re- ment Plan. I am well accustomed to dealing head-on with tations were all informative and becomes more obvious. call that you were present and In fact, both pieces are patently untrue. You adversarial and contentious matters. Further, I delivered to community board The vote of the board does if you were how your report- owe your readers and me a front-page retraction applaud the right of dissenters to have been committee chairpersons, com- not negate the many positive ing on this project could be so and an accurate accounting of the events. present an admire peaceful protest. I fully antic- munity board members and recommendations made by the erroneous. You might consider Contrary to your irresponsible assertion, I ipated the presence of many protestors at the community-based organizations committees. Most reasonable reading the Brooklyn Heights was present in the auditorium for the vote and meeting. They did not deter me from being in many different forums. At- people would agree that this Courier’s Feb. 9 cover story Ms. Kolben was informed of this in writing. I present or from my duty to vote. tached to this letter is a list of plan, if implemented, must on this issue. was also fully prepared to vote and requested Your reporter had a duty to accurately report these meetings (I am sure I have proceed while strongly consid- Your apology to this board that I be permitted to do so after my name had the events, which she failed to do. Regarding omitted a few). Last week’s front page features commentary by Neil Sloane ering these recommendations. is anticipated. been mistakenly omitted from the roll call. Ms. Ms. Kolben’s attempt to contact me only on my The Downtown Brooklyn and Vince DiMiceli and reporting by Deborah Kolbin. The ar- What is interesting is that —Shirley Ann McRae, Blackshear, CB2’s secretary, informed Chair- cell phone, her generic message merely stated Plan Uniform Land Use Re- ticles are the subject of letters appearing in this week’s Paper. you define the many compo- Chairperson, CB2 person Shirley McRae publicly via the micro- that she was contacting all the members of the view Procedure (ULURP) phone of my request to vote. Ms. Kolben should board for general comments on he vote. It did was certified on Dec. 3, 2003 have known these facts if she was in attendance not seek any specific response to all the un- and received at the communi- and responsibly covering the proceeding. founded allegations she intended to assert. Giv- ty board office on Dec. 5. You would have learned these facts had you en that I was neither in the hallway during the Community board comment made the most minimal inquiry with the board vote nor “intimidated” by the protestors, Ms. was due Feb. 9, 2004. All office. Kolben’s source was entirely unreliable. Board members were encour- ‘Character assassination’ Your baseless assertions are particularly I believe that your paper’s willingness to ma- aged to attend the many com- galling since, as the mother of three young chil- lign me without any factual accuracy not only mittee meetings and the public dren, ages 5, 3 and four months, I went to great severely undermines your credibility and that of hearing at which representa- lengths to attend the meeting. Indeed, recogniz- your paper, but also trivializes the important tives from EDC and City ing the importance of the vote, I even left home matters at issue. Planning were present to hear by Paper spurs reader’s ire an ill child — something no mother relishes. Again, I demand that you act responsibly and community concerns. Your malicious and uninformed attack not print a prominent retraction and correction. Each committee met over To the editor: Foster’s resignation), much of what Sloane accuse Ms. Foster of Downtown vote only got the facts wrong, but my character as — Rachel Foster, Community Board 2 member the last two months under strin- The type of character assassi- you reported was unsubstantiated. “hid[ing] in the hallway” and nation you have engaged in with- You accuse Ms. Foster of “ducking” the vote because she a ‘clique’ call out checking your facts or the re- “ducking” the vote because she “felt pressured” and “intimidated” This letter is in response to liability of your “source” makes “felt pressured” and “intimidat- by certain plan protestors. In addi- Editor Neil Sloane’s column, it difficult to take The Brooklyn ed” by the protestors. You base tion, Mr. Sloane called for Ms. “CB2 blows it bigtime.” Papers seriously. The Communi- this information on one anony- Foster’s resignation on the front To the editor: ty Board 2 member, Rachel Fos- mous source. One single, anony- page of your newspaper. Neither The Executive Board the and ter, who you describe as “intimi- mous source does not good jour- reporter offers any reliable support Land Use committee of Commu- Readers cheer Paper, say dated” and “cowering” [CB2 nalism make. If you and your for such serious accusations and nity Board 2 recognized from the blows it bigtime,” Feb. 7] is not reporters had engaged in stan- demands. Instead, they fall back outset that only a “yes” vote on the same Community Board 2 dard, journalistic procedures of on the most questionable and un- overall up-zoning, the first item in member Rachel Foster whom I fact checking, you would have supportable of journalistic tricks, the proposed Brooklyn Down- have known both personally and avoided such outlandish claims. the alleged, hearsay statements of town Plan, would permit a modi- CB2 ‘betrayed public trust’ professionally for 17 years. Having known Ms. Foster per- a single anonymous source. fication, or “no” vote, on any oth- Ms. Foster has never been one sonally since our college days at To anyone familiar with Ms. er item in the plan, so it structured To the editor: would leave all of us short- ing into our streets that they are portation study that will tell the to avoid difficult situations or Cornell University in the late Foster’s professional background, its recommendation as a package I find the inability of Commu- changed. Where was the quality unable to mitigate the problems EDC what is possible in the area. shirk responsibilities. In fact, quite 1980s, I can attest to her character. the claims that she was “intimi- to approve the up-zoning first nity Board 2 to make an effective vision for the nation’s fourth- the plan would cause. This is un- The end result will be some- the opposite is true. She consis- She is a person who is deeply dated” by, or “cowered” at, last then selectively approve, modify statement on the Downtown Brook- largest city? Not in this tele- fortunate because we need more thing that we, as Brooklynites, tently shows strength and resolve committed to the social good. As week’s community board meeting or disapprove with recommenda- lyn rezoning proposals [“Mum’s phone book-sized snow job. jobs in this city, and there is will have to live with for the rest in meeting challenges head on, a Legal Services attorney who has is preposterous. As a Legal Ser- tions the attendant proposals. the word,” Feb. 7] to be an ap- Last week the CB2 members some room in the downtown of our lives. —Kenn Lowy, and is not afraid to make her voice done her share of trial work, she is vices attorney, Ms. Foster has At the Land Use committee palling betrayal of the public trust. were invited to a game of Russ- area for new office and residen- CB2 member, Brooklyn Heights known, no matter who or how not one to “cower” in adversarial spent many years fighting for the meeting of Jan. 21, the proposal The community board struc- ian roulette presented in the form tial space. ‘Not Just Nets’ many people may disagree. situations. A few protestors would rights of the poor, the victimized was discussed item by item with ture is meant to ensure that our of a dinner. The entire menu was But the current plan just does- I know that Ms. Foster ap- certainly not have deterred her. and the voiceless. Throughout her the chairperson of the Traffic and neighborhood’s non-elected lead- whole, underdone turkey and the n’t work. As you have reported, — Great issue! proaches her role as community I strongly urge you to investi- entire career, she has consistently Transportation committee, which board member both seriously gate this matter further and ac- ers have an actual voice in the unappetizing and only choice for last week Community Board 2 To the editor: stood up to the powerful on be- had voted “no” on the entire pro- and conscientiously. As a dec- knowledge in your next edition city’s processes. To hold only a us was this: eat the whole thing voted against the Land Use com- I am writing to thank you for half of the powerless. This is not posal, along with representatives ade-long resident of the Brook- of The Brooklyn Papers that single vote, producing a defeated — feet, feathers and all — or go mittee’s recommendation but your Jan. 31 issue that clearly a woman who would “cower” in of the Brooklyn Heights and lyn Heights-Cobble Hill commu- your pointed attack of Ms. Foster resolution, is not the kind of atten- hungry. Some of us would like to failed to pass a resolution voting lays out the massive changes the face of a few protesters. Boerum Hill associations. All of nity, I am proud to have Ms. was simply unsubstantiated and tion an issue this size deserves. It have had more of a choice than either ‘yes’ or ‘no’ on the plan as taking place in Brooklyn. I work We call on The Brooklyn Pa- their requests were incorporated Foster represent me, and my unwarranted. tells me that our community lead- this, maybe a wing or a drum- a whole. In my opinion, the vote with an organization named pers to investigate this matter. We in the Land Use committee’s rec- ers are instead too scared, too un- stick. As it happened, most of us was a strong condemnation of neighbors. —Elizabeth Plowe, —Jeneve Brooks-Klinger, have no doubt such an investiga- ommendations for the 'yes” vote Brooklyn Vision, founded to fa- Cobble Hill Manhattan willing or too uninformed to take preferred to pass up dinner. the plan as being inadequate for cilitate communication between tion will show the paper’s so- on the Brooklyn Downtown Plan. a stand on this issue. Unsatisfied — but hardly di- Brooklyn and for being poorly community organizations and in- Friend’s defense Shocking called reporting regarding Ms. It should be noted that [board What should have happened? vided — we now pass the thought out. Neil Sloane correct- crease the input that residents To the editor: To the editor: Foster’s conduct to be wholly in- member] Ken Diamondstone When the committee’s recom- Downtown Plan to Borough ly pointed out that 10 members have in planning developments In the last issue, I read your edi- We were shocked to read your accurate. And we can only pre- had been advocating for a “no” vote on the entire plan for some mendation was defeated, another President Marty Markowitz for of the community board failed to that will directly impact their torial account of the Community paper’s alleged “coverage” of sume that, having called for Ms. time. His request for an item-by- motion should have been made scrutiny. Marty, we invite you to show up for this important vote, lives, and the lives of their chil- Board 2 vote on the proposed plans the recent vote of Community Foster’s resignation, Mr. Sloane item vote at the board meeting and carried to vote on each of the look across the river to Lower and one “hid in the hallway.” dren and grandchildren. for Downtown Brooklyn. I was Board 2 on the proposed plans will himself resign when it is es- followed his plea to the board to committee’s points individually. Manhattan where this adminis- However, he neglected to men- The current planning process deeply disturbed at your overly per- for Downtown Brooklyn and, in tablished that he has violated his Then each recommendation of tration is spreading out a cordon tion that at last months general sonal and vitriolic attack on board particular, the severe criticism of core professional duty and re- vote “no” on the overall up-zon- doesn’t serve the interests of devel- ing. He knew that a “no” vote on the committee, made for or bleu banquet while we in Down- meeting CB2 Chairwoman opers or the public. The public per- member Rachel Foster. Not only board member Rachel Foster. sponsibility — reporting the truth. against points of the city’s plan, town Brooklyn are treated to … Shirley McRae told the board were your remarks intentionally Both the report by Deborah — Eileen Minnefor and the up-zoning would effectively ceives secret, backroom planning foreclose the possibility of vot- would be presented and voted fast food. We admire you for members who were present (no, that is suddenly revealed as a com- defamatory (i.e., calling for Ms. Kolben and commentary by Neil William S. Dixon, Brooklyn Heights standing up for Brooklyn past ing “yes” on any other aspect of on. At the end of the meeting, they weren’t all there then either) pleted project, leaving the public and present. You are a friend to the proposed Brooklyn Down- you would have had a much how important the upcoming feeling victimized and motivating clearer picture of CB2’s senti- all of us in this great borough. town Plan. vote was. She asked the mem- them to distrust and resist all de- ments about the plan in its parts Now the tough choices fall on After Diamondstone and his bers present to attend not only velopment. The developers expect and as a whole. you. We know you will add to clique orchestrated the ‘no’ vote on the meeting last week, but she this resistance, and so feel they I blame [CB2 Chairwoman] your laurels by becoming the the entire plan, including the pro- also encouraged them to show have to plan in secret and push for Shirley McRae for her utter indif- champion of a great Brooklyn of up for all of the committee meet- posed library adjacent to BAM, a more than they want in order to Says D’town Plan fails coalition of the same community ference and procedural inflexibil- the future, one that our children ings that month. She emphasized ity, and I cannot believe members and their children will be proud get the project they really want in groups that supported him is plan- that every committee would be the face of public resistance. abstained or hid: they all should to call home. discussing the Downtown Plan. ning to ask the city for the same lose their appointments. I am Oh, just one final thought: When there’s no communica- modifications that were included A few weeks ago the Land tion, there’s no trust, and without speechless that members of the let’s do the birth control planning Use committee spent over three in the positive Action Report of the trust the whole process is destined to view big picture Land Use committee. board found the vote confusing: now, not after the baby is born. hours trying to rewrite the draft any reasonably intelligent group —William Harris, CB2 member to result in destructive, costly If any person is to be blamed EIS, which is commendable. The struggles. There are better ways. of adults, especially those who meeting room was packed with To the editor: no vision, the people perish” yet rather than with vi- for the failure of CB2, it is Ken have dealt with committees and Redraw the Currently there is no coordi- Diamondstone and his clique of community board members. The nation in the planning process The Feb. 7 article headlined “Mum’s The Word” sion, we’re going into this with blinders on. subcommittees before (like all D’town plan real problem, however, is with rightly notes that the Downtown Brooklyn Plan is Critically absent are calculations of cumulative neighborhood groups that sur- CBers!) should have understood for all the developments going round the downtown area. To the editor: the plan itself. It should not be on, and the public is right to be “the most complex rezoning plan in city history.” Un- neighborhood impacts of those 14,000,000 square what was going on. Thank you for your coverage the job of the community board fortunately, the lead agencies, City Planning and the feet combined with those from Forest City Ratner’s — Lawrence Whiteside, CB2 As a Prospect Heights resi- concerned. Communicating the Land Use committee member of the Downtown Brooklyn Plan. to write or in this case, correct scale of the problem has been a Economic Development Corporation, selected the proposed arena, the associated 4,500 Atlantic Yards dent, looking forward to the con- Your map clearly shows how the plan. That job belongs to the plan’s submission date just prior to Christmas and housing units, the 2,500 apartments already being A letter by Ken Diamondstone sideration of the arena project by central effort for Brooklyn Vi- appears to the left on this page. much is going on in such a small EDC. It is the EDC that has sion. Thank you for making our New Year’s, effectively abbreviating the already scant built or approved within five blocks of the “core,” CBs 2, 6 and 8 (my board), I can area of our borough. As a mem- failed because they submitted a 60 days available for community board evaluation. the new Federal Courthouse, the several-million- Don’t like? Then only hope CB2 gets it act togeth- point. —Jim Vogel, Secretary, ber of the Traffic & Transporta- plan that is so flawed that it Brooklyn Vision Foundation If ultimately approved, the 22 proposals that con- square-foot proposed expansion at New York City er, for the sake of all Brooklyn tion committee of Community needs to go back to the drawing stitute the Downtown Brooklyn Plan may forever Tech, Forest City’s 1,000,000 square feet of com- just don’t go residents. —Robert Witherwax, Board 2, I was saddened to see board and be redone. Manhattanizing transform the character of Brooklyn Heights, mercial space at Atlantic Terminal, etc. To the editor: Prospect Heights the Draft EIS for Downtown The bottom line is that Brook- Brooklyn Boerum Hill, Cobble Hill, Concord Village and The upshot is that Deputy Mayor Dan Doctoroff, on I can assure your readers that D’town plan Brooklyn, submitted by the Eco- lyn deserves a real plan for the DUMBO/Vinegar Hill as the unintended conse- Jan. 23, confirmed that the Department of Transporta- just about all the development now nomic Development Corporation. Downtown area. A plan that will To the editor: quence of the 14,000,000 square feet of new devel- tion Economic development Corporation would “initi- under discussion for Downtown one big turkey They have submitted a plan work for new businesses, already I loved your editorial on opment they permit. ate a comprehensive transportation analysis, or ‘blue- Brooklyn and the vicinity will be To the editor: that is flawed in more ways than established businesses, residents Brooklyn’s identity [“Brooklyn’s Noise, stress, traffic congestion, increased densi- print’ study, of Downtown Brooklyn. The scope of built. The only question is whether Perfectly timed for the winter I have the time or space to write. and commuters. Downtown Brook- identity safe without the ‘Jersey ty and angry competition for scarce parking could work … is being finalized and details will be made it will be built in Downtown holiday season, EDC and co- It projects so much traffic flow- lyn needs and deserves a trans- Nets,” Jan. 31]. I love Brooklyn dampen the strong sense of community, which so available to the local community by early February. Al- Brooklyn and the vicinity — acces- sponsors sent to this board a pret- for what it is and what it’s not (i.e. characterize our neighborhoods. The big losers though the ‘blueprint’ study will not be completed be- sible by mass transit to tens of thou- tily packaged cluster bomb of 22 Manhattan). I don’t want to see it could be us. fore the Downtown Plan finishes ULURP, its findings sands of working people in need of complex proposals. To their sur- become Midtown Manhattan — Not reassuringly, the draft environmental impact will encompass all current traffic conditions as well as employment, with any tax revenues prise, this board swept aside much filled with cars, pollution, and statement (DEIS) of the plan considers impacts traffic impacts of future planned development.” going to New York City’s schools other business, both personal and high-rises buildings. At the same from just half the potential build out (6,700,000 Far better to have had this new study’s conclu- and other services — or on a green- civic, to render its study. Send us a letter time, I realize the need to im- square feet). Yet even this impoverished study con- sions before being asked to consider these massive field site on the suburban fringe. At the end of this hurry-up By mail: Letters Editor, Brooklyn Papers, prove some parts of Brooklyn. tains warnings of unmitigable congestion, and no zoning changes. And shouldn’t those who represent Suburban sprawl, and subur- process the board and the com- The questions is, ‘Who gets to de- evaluation of mass transit (the predominant mode of us urge the temporary withdrawal of these 22 zon- ban exclusionary zoning, is the munity did not like what it saw. 55 Washington St., Brooklyn, NY 11201 cide what is best for Brooklyn?’ transportation for the thousands of potential new ing applications and their resubmission only after real suburban nightmare for peo- Much as Downtown Brooklyn Does Bruce Ratner really workers and visitors) except to oddly suggest the study’s conclusions are public? ple who are less affluent than the needs renewal we also don’t Fax: (718) 834-9278. want to make Brooklyn better, or widening one subway staircase. Often, those who urge caution are labeled as op- Brooklyn Papers readers worried want to be worse off than we are By e-mail: [email protected] does he just want to make mon- The study concludes, “that the changes would not ponents of progress. Personally, I have consistently about style [“Ratner’s suburban right now. In the end, that now ey? Does he think that his mall result in significant adverse impact in neighborhood supported appropriate, contextual development and nightmare,” Vince DiMiceli, Feb. looks dubious. All letters must be signed and include on Atlantic was an improve- character” (page S-23 of the Executive Summary, DEIS). strongly encouraged economic growth as a CB2 7]. Those concerned that, even in We had hoped for some solid ment? I don’t think so and I Unfortunately, this assertion only applies to the member. Nevertheless, I also support the notion that Downtown Brooklyn, some peo- planning to emerge from this the writer’s home address and phone think most feel the same way. Downtown “core” study area containing just 1,200 meaningful planing requires that stakeholders un- ple will drive (as they do) and DEIS. Instead we were deceived number (only the writer’s neighborhood Do you believe anything can residents (many of whom the plan removes through derstand and accept the consequences of proposed compete for their parking spaces by the pretty wrapping — it be done to stop this or do you eminent domain, along with existing shops, school plans rather than a priori adopting them only to later are living in the wrong place. turned out that everything about and street name are published with the think that Brooklyn will become, and historic buildings). But no mention of the poten- learn the consequence. I see the re-development of this proposal, from the bite-sized as you put it, “a half-baked ver- tial change of the character of the neighborhoods of The borough president’s hearing on the Down- Downtown, in addition to the city investment to the half-baked letter). Letters may be edited and will sion of Manhattan”? the 150,000 who live adjacent to the “core.” town Brooklyn Plan is Feb. 18. slow turnaround of many resi- traffic and transit forecasts, not be returned. —Ian Crowley, Park Slope Biblically, we are admonished, “Where there is —Ken Diamondstone, CB2 member See LETTERS on page 16 February 14, 2004 THE BROOKLYN PAPERS • WWW.BROOKLYNPAPERS.COM BRZ 5 NOT JUST NETS 6 MONTHS OF ‘NOT JUST NETS’ COVERAGE AT WWW.BROOKLYNPAPERS.COM ‘Dribble-down’ theorist set to back Ratner’s Nets arena plan
By Deborah Kolben arena study to Ratner, made play in midtown Manhattan, — would attract many more The Brooklyn Papers several broad assumptions Zimbalist said vaguely that he people to live in New York. about the Nets coming to NEWS ANALYSIS was working with “various Neil DeMause, author of Call it the “dribble- Brooklyn — namely that a numbers” and would have to “Field of Schemes: How the down” theory, the founda- significant number of New “make an estimate as to what Great Stadium Swindle Turns tion of “Ratneromics.” Jersey fans would follow their at the intersection of Flatbush revenue in New Jersey and share [of New Jersey fans] Public Money Into Private Just as President Ronald team to Brooklyn, that a large and Atlantic avenues. moving it to New York.” would go to Brooklyn.” Profit,” has his doubts about Reagan had David Stockman number of New Yorkers at- “In normal circumstances, New Jersey fans, he added, Further asked how tax rev- Zimbalist’s Nets arena eco- THE NEW BROOKLYN to sell his “trickle-down” theo- tend the Nets games now and arenas do not have a positive and New Yorkers who spend enues could be factored in nomic forecast. ry, developer Brice Ratner has that the housing component of effect, but a tremendousness their dollars at the Continental given that most of the tax rev- “Do you really think that hired a noted sports economist Ratner’s development would fiscal drain,” Zimbalist told Airlines Arena will now travel enue generated by the arena anybody form Jersey will go to Zimbalist told The Papers tour the proposed arena site in — one who has regularly de- draw more people to New The Papers this week. and spend their money in will go to pay for its construc- games in Brooklyn?” asked De- he was still calculating the Prospect Heights and offered to scribed arenas and stadiums as York City. So what makes Ratner’s Brooklyn, generating more tax tion as well as the construc- Mause, who lives in Flatbush. numbers and couldn’t release hire him as a consultant. having no direct economic Ratner hired Zimbalist, a project different? revenue for the state and city. tion of surrounding office and “He is assuming that half a specific figure. “Mr. Zimbalist is one of the benefits on local economies, professor of economics at “This project will be differ- Asked what evidence he residential towers, Zimbalist the people who currently at- While DeMause said it was most respected experts on the no less — to help sell his plan Smith College, in Massachu- ent because tax revenue from had to show that large num- said simply, “Some of that tend Nets games would be a bit “offbeat” for Zimbalist to economics of arenas and to for a Downtown Brooklyn are- setts, who has written several the Nets that currently go to bers of New Jerseyans were money will come back to fi- coming to Brooklyn,” said work on a project like this, he have his input and support is na for the New Jersey Nets. books on sports economics, to New Jersey will go to New likely to follow the team that nance the project but not all of DeMause, who has discussed is eager to see the final results. extremely helpful,” said Rat- In a discussion with The conduct a study of the fiscal York,” he said. “You’re not deserted them across the river it.” the study with Zimbalist, and After seeing Zimbalist’s ner spokesman Barry Baum. Brooklyn Papers this week, impacts of the 19,000-seat creating a new team out of or, for that matter, how many Zimbalist also said the believes there are, and will be, name splashed across magazine Zimbalist is expected to de- Andrew Zimbalist, who next arena and office and residen- thin air, you’re moving a team New Yorkers currently schlep housing portion of the plan — far fewer interstate fans than and newspaper articles about liver his study to Ratner by mid- month will hand over his Nets tial complex he wants to build that currently generates a lot of to Jersey when the Knicks some 4,500 units are projected Zimbalist is assuming. the plan, Ratner invited him to March. — with Neil Sloane Beep’s ‘State of Boro’ Foes may sue focuses on Nets plan By Deborah Kolben 2001 to run for public advocate. chased a three-bedroom condominium in The Brooklyn Papers He recently defended the so-called the Atlantic Art Building, on Pacific A group of Prospect Heights resi- Williamsburg Seven, a group of residents Street, called the meeting with Siegel By Jotham Sederstrom dents fighting to save their homes arrested last year while protesting the “inspirational.” The Brooklyn Papers closing of Engine Company 212. “He opened people’s eyes to the seri- from condemnations that would Siegel was also instrumental in the ousness of what’s trying to be done,” During his State of the Borough make way for Bruce Ratner’s Nets formation of an all-civilian Civilian Goldstein said. address Sunday Borough President arena development have inter- Complaint Review Board and has repre- “It’s more than just people leaving Marty Markowitz touted Brooklyn’s viewed a noted civil liberties attor- sented several clients in police miscon- their homes. It is a civil rights issue and cultural renaissance and future as a ney to take up their cause. duct cases. the community needs to be involved,” he tourism hotspot while reminding an Norman Siegel, the former executive Daniel Goldstein, who recently pur- added. audience of about 500 that its director of the New York Civil Liberties schools are among the city’s most Union, who has championed victims of crowded and its auto-insurance rates police brutality and defended the right of among the nation’s highest. the Ku Klux Klan to protest in the city, may be gearing up to take on real estate But last month’s $300 million purchase mogul Ratner next. of the New Jersey Nets by developer Pol holds out hope “We’ve just begun,” Siegel told a Bruce Ratner was clearly the centerpiece group of nearly 100 Prospect Heights of his two-hour address, although the sub- residents who came out for a meet-and- ject wasn’t raised until halftime, when re- greet with the lawyer at an artist’s studio / Greg Mango / Greg tired Knicks and Nets star forward on Dean Street Wednesday night. of arena site bids Bernard King joined Markowitz for a “It’s not just about basketball and it’s staged pickup game before continuing on not just about the arena,” said Siegel, By Deborah Kolben with his stump speech. fielding questions from the audience. The Brooklyn Papers Markowitz scored a layup against the “The arena is the gimmick in his de- 6-foot-7 King in the Joseph Anzalone Papers The Brooklyn velopment plan for something larger,” Developer Bruce Ratner may have Theater at Edward R. Murrow High Borough President Marty Markowitz (left) greets Sen. Charles Schumer, of Park Siegel said, explaining that building the some competition for his planned School in Midwood. But a handful of Slope, during Markowitz’s State of the Borough address on Sunday. arena was merely a means for Ratner to Nets arena site, a city councilwoman those in attendance, who stand to be dis- get the state to condemn adjoining land. told Prospect Heights property own- placed by Ratner’s arena plan, booed The battle could take several years and ers this week. every mention of the Nets and said Mark- intermittently waved a yellow, 8-inch by Prospect Heights Action Coalition was the community must decide if it’s in it “The MTA is considering putting out a owitz was shooting from foul territory. 10-inch placard emblazoned with the posted to an e-mail group, telling people for the long haul, cautioned Siegel, who request for proposals,” said Councilwoman Callan / Tom “I will do everything in my power to words “Don’t Destroy our Homes.” A res- to restrain themselves. He estimated that said he could possibly challenge the con- Letitia James, referring to development make sure that as few people as possible ident of the Newswalk condominium, one about a dozen people from the coalition stitutionality of eminent domain. over the 11-acre stretch of Long Island Rail will be displaced, that any negative im- of the buildings surrounded by Ratner’s and other organizations attended the Ratner is proposing to construct a 22- Road storage yards running along Atlantic pacts are minimized and, most important- plan that will not be taken by eminent do- event. acre, Frank Gehry-designed arena, office Avenue east of Flatbush Avenue. ly, that they are treated with dignity and main, Puca said that some of the arena’s “They had decided not to have a loud, tower and residential village starting at James was speaking before a group of respect,” Markowitz said to applause most vocal opponents had planned to rally noisy protest,” said Vogel. “They had de- the intersection of Atlantic and Flatbush about 100 residents meeting Wednesday sprinkled with a few boos. at the event, but decided against it in favor cided to marshal their forces elsewhere. I avenues and stretching six blocks into night to discuss a potential lawsuit to block Papers File The Brooklyn “For 26 years, I have kept my promises of future endeavors. He declined to elabo- think they might have wanted to give their Prospect Heights. the arena plan. Bruce Ratner to Brooklynites. And I will keep this one, rate. people a day off.” The plan includes 17 buildings reach- She cited a “government source” as pro- too,” he said. “I don’t think this would have been the Save for the entertainment, which in- ing as high as 620 feet, dwarfing the viding her the information. me and expressed interest in developing Despite rumors that arena-plan protes- right way to go about it,” Puca said, cluded the Jackie Robinson Steppers — a nearby Williamsburgh Savings Bank The rail yards are the key component of commercial, residential and retail space for tors would be out in full force, a small adding that protesting at the event would 100-piece marching band that conspicu- tower. Ratner’s sweeping Atlantic Yards project, a local residents and wanted to know what holding pen outside of the school at 1600 have been disrespectful to some of ously played the Aretha Franklin hit, “R- A number of neighborhood groups $2.5 billion, Frank Gehry-designed profes- the process was,” she said. Ave. L remained empty for the entirety of Markowitz’s other talking points. E-S-P-E-C-T,” twice during the day — and residents are seeking to block the sional basketball arena flanked by soaring James declined to name the developers the event. Inside, activist Robert Puca and The smattering of vocal opposition was the event offered few surprises. plan, which would feature a 19,000-seat office towers and 4,500 residential units. but said they had “a record of building af- members of the Prospect Heights Action first unleashed when Sen. Charles Rather, much of the afternoon was a re- basketball arena to house his newly pur- The arena would house Ratner’s recent- fordable housing throughout the city.” Coalition and Brooklyn Vision were seat- Schumer, of Park Slope, praised Ratner hash of last year’s address, including the chased New Jersey Nets. ly purchased New Jersey Nets. Westchester Assemblyman Richard ed throughout the theater, adding to the and Markowitz for the $2.5 billion arena tagline, “Respect, it’s the Brooklyn atti- To build his complex, Ratner would Questions as to who owns the rights to Brodsky, who chairs the Committee on small chorus of boos. and residential and commercial village tude.” And much like last year, Markowitz also likely ask the state to use its powers build over the yards first surfaced last sum- Corporations, Authorities and Commis- “We prepared for it, certainly, and we plan. peppered his speech with the word “re- of eminent domain to seize the homes of mer when newspapers learned of Ratner’s sions, said it was too early to discuss a re- had a couple people” said Sharon Toomer, “They say, ‘Can one person change the spect,” which this year was uttered 26 approximately 850 people, including 400 plans to purchase the basketball team. quest for proposals. the borough president’s new director of world?’ Well, one person is going to times. residents of a homeless shelter, two re- Tom Kelly, a Metropolitan Transporta- “I don’t think that the decision-making communications. “But we didn’t expect change Brooklyn — that’s Marty Mar- The difference this time around was cently converted luxury condominium tion Authority (MTA) spokesman, denied process is yet understood,” said Brodsky too much.” kowitz.” that many of Markowitz’s dreams are buildings and one co-operative building. on Thursday that the agency had issued a who has aggressively campaigned for When King began speaking about the “I know some people might have a lit- inching closer to reality — from a plan to But neighbors are not willing to go request for proposals from developers and MTA reform. Nets’ anticipated move to his hometown, tle dissention,” Schumer said, but added dock Carnival Cruise Lines ships on the that easy or that fast. said the agency had no plans to do so. In addition to the LIRR tracks, Ratner’s a woman sitting near the front of the audi- that the development would create Brooklyn waterfront to snagging the bor- A group of homeowners have already The MTA is not required to request oth- plan would need the state to condemn more torium yelled, “U.S. Constitution.” When “10,000 jobs” and “3,000 to 4,000 units of ough’s first professional sports team since hired Manhattan attorney Jack Lester. If er proposals, he said, adding that once Rat- than two square blocks of private property. King politely replied, “I’m sorry, didn’t housing.” the Dodgers left after the 1957 season. Siegel were to come on board, he would ner submits his Atlantic Yards proposal, it It is not clear what role the city would play. hear you,” the woman repeated herself. James Vogel, a secretary for Brooklyn “The theme was respect for Brooklyn, represent the whole community, he said. would have to go before the full MTA “The question is will the governor “U.S. Constitution,” she said again. Vision, which serves as an umbrella or- but there was an undertone of ‘have re- A neighborhood decision on whether board for a vote. open the process … or will he grant fa- A mystified King continued with his ganization for block associations in the spect for Marty,’” said Vogel, who lives to hire Siegel was scheduled for the But James, a vocal opponent of the are- voritism to his law school class mate?” speech. Downtown Brooklyn area, said that days on Pacific Street between Fourth and Flat- weekend. na, said asking for proposals would “open James said, noting that Gov. George The opposition could have been worse, before the State of the Borough address, bush avenues, where, he said, Ratner Named executive director of the NY- up the process.” Pataki and Ratner attended Columbia said Puca, who sat in the fourth row, and an e-mail from someone within the plans to build a skyscraper. CLYU in 1985, Siegel stepped down in “A couple of developers have contacted Law School at the same time. Real estate brokers expect Tour center opens arena will up property values in Borough Hall By Deborah Kolben chewing gum, baseball caps and teddy bears. By Deborah Kolben ton Hill and Fort Greene, where three-story houses would not change if the project goes ahead. The Brooklyn Papers But while visitors may soon flock to the site, The Brooklyn Papers already sell for upwards of $1.5 million, the new When Ratner constructed both the Atlantic those arriving on the weekend will be disap- project could jack up prices even higher. Center mall and nearby Metrotech office campus Forget Bloomindales and the Empire pointed — the center is closed on Saturdays and As the controversy heats up over the con- In Park Slope, the colossal project will likely in Downtown Brooklyn, agents predicted they State Building. Sundays. That’s because it’s inside a city build- struction of a Frank Gehry-designed village drive prices up, said John Rutter, managing direc- would drive up property values. Tourists flocking to New York City will soon be ing, a Markowitz spokeswoman said, noting and professional basketball arena in Prospect tor for the Corcoran Group Park Slope — just as But Daniels said they ultimately had almost no crossing the East River in droves to discover the many of the details are still being worked out. Heights, there is one group that apparently the development on, and up-zoning of, Fourth effect. brownstones, boutiques and bistros of Brooklyn. Following the ribbon-cutting ceremony, most stands to benefit — property owners. Avenue has driven up prices of apartments on the “It’s like crystal ball gazing,” said Nancy A new, state-of-the-art tourism center at the foot attendees headed over to the first-ever NYC & “The long-term impact will be positive for mar- side streets between Fourth and Fifth avenues, McKieren, who runs her own real estate office in of Borough Hall — the first of its kind outside of Co. annual luncheon held outside Manhattan. ket values,” said Christopher Thomas, president of where a two-bedroom luxury apartment on Sackett Boerum Hill. “It all depends how the city plans it Manhattan — opened up for business Thursday. At the luncheon at the Brooklyn Marriott, William B. May Brooklyn, a large real estate firm Street is now selling for $955,000. — if the traffic is worked out, the subway station Packed with pamphlets detailing walks through Empire State Development Corporation Presi- with offices on Montague Street and Seventh Avenue. “This will increase values in Park Slope,” said planned out.” historic Fort Greene, shopping at the unique shops dent Charles Gargano announced plans for an Developer Bruce Ratner, who recently pur- Rutter, “as long as the infrastructure improves in While most agents agreed the project — espe- of Atlantic Avenue and galleries in hipster expansion of the Jacob Javits Convention Cen- chased the New Jersey Nets for $300 million, relation to what happens there.” cially with Gehry’s name attached to it — could Williamsburg, the new center will hopefully help ter on Manhattan’s west side and NYC &Co. wants to build 17 residential and commercial As part of the plan, Ratner intends to construct only send prices up, they also worried about the pull more of the 21 billion tourist dollars currently officials promised to promote tourism in the buildings centered around a professional basketball 4,500 units of housing, mostly near Vanderbilt increased traffic. spent citywide into the Borough of Kings. boroughs outside of Manhattan. arena at the intersection of Atlantic and Flatbush Avenue. So far there has not been any talk about “Traffic is already horrendous,” said McKieren. At a ribbon-cutting ceremony Thursday, Bor- But just as attention turned to boosting the avenues and extending into Prospect Heights. the addition of schools or traffic mitigation to han- Asked if the project could adversely affect qual- ough President Marty Markowitz, a driving borough, one of its great institutions is closing While it is not a done deal — Ratner still needs dle the tens of thousands of new residents and ity of life and thus drive prices down, Thomas force behind the tourism center, bragged about for good. a litany of approvals and faces a potential hurdle of commuters who would be brought to the area. pointed to the Manhattan neighborhoods of his beloved borough, touting the borough’s Joe Chirico, owner of Gage & Tollner, a lawsuits — property owners are busy speculating Eva Daniels has been selling real estate in Fort Greenwich Village and Chelsea. churches, cheesecake and Coney Island Cy- landmarked restaurant at 372 Fulton St., three on how the 22-acre project with office towers Greene for more than 20 years and says she doubts “Those are 19th-century period neighborhoods clones, Brooklyn’s minor-league baseball team. blocks from the tourism center, announced he reaching almost 60 stories tall might affect the sell- the project will have an adverse effect on property that coexist in the largest city in the country with “Brooklyn is the next great frontier for tourism would close the famed restaurant on Valentine’s ing prices of their homes. values, which started rising in the late 1990s when high-rise, non-contextual developments,” said expansion,” said Jonathan Tisch, chairman of the Day, after 125 years in business. Real estate agents say that at least in this respect, Manhattanites “discovered” the area. Thomas. city’s official tourism promoters, NYC & Co. The Brooklyn Tourism and Visitors Center, at the forecast is bright. Many residents are attracted to Fort Greene by “Yet neighborhoods maintain a character and I Staffed by volunteers trained by the con- 209 Joralemon St. near Court Street, is open In the already booming surrounding brownstone its relatively quiet, tree-lined streets, diversity and think that will continue to be true with Fort Greene, cierge at the New York Marriott Brooklyn, on Monday through Friday, from 10 am to 6 pm. neighborhoods of Boerum Hill, Park Slope, Clin- sense of community, Daniels said, all things she Clinton Hill and Prospect Heights.” Adams Street, the center sells Brooklyn T-shirts, For more information call (718) 802-3846. 6 BRZ THE BROOKLYN PAPERS • WWW.BROOKLYNPAPERS.COM February 14, 2004
8618 4th Ave. (bet. 86th & 87th Sts.) Two in van jump meter maid (718) 748-1977 FREE DELIVERY (min. $10.00) By Jotham Sederstrom of the men yelled, “Give me arguing inside a bar on Third notice, which could eventually (718) 748-1918 The Brooklyn Papers your money in your pocket or Avenue at 93rd Street. Fum- help police nab the feisty female. you won’t make it to 15th Av- Nobody appreciates a 62/68 BLOTTER ing, the woman picked up her According to the police enue.” drink and smacked it against complaint, the bar owner held parking ticket, but two The men escaped south on men in Bensonhurst were the side of her drinking bud- onto the woman’s credit card 15th Avenue with $643, say Martini toss tini glass was thrown into her dy’s face, police said. receipt, which she had used to particularly upset when a police, who described the pas- A Bay Ridge woman was face, causing lacerations. Fortunately, as the yelling — pay her bar tab, and, amazing- traffic agent tried to issue senger as about 6 feet tall and left shaken but not stirred fol- Police say that at midnight and drinking — picked up a ly, he also had a picture of the 50% OFF a summons to them last 220 pounds. lowing a fight in which a mar- on Feb. 1, two women began notch, the owner of the bar took woman. Wednesday. Angry drunk Roll or The 31-year-old woman Handroll Only A heavy drinker attacked a Sushi or Sashimi was handing out tickets along bartender after she refused to $ 50 18th Avenue at 77th Street at serve him any more booze, each 10:45 am when, cops say, just say police. ALL DAY LONG 2 after writing a ticket for an il- While on the job at a bar on legally parked van, a man Eighth Avenue at 72nd Street, shoved her from the back and the woman was approached 2ETIRE another pushed her against the by a thug who police de- vehicle. scribed as a skinny, white, 29- While the agent stood, dis- year-old man with blue eyes Dr. Peter Marascia oriented, one of the men ran and blond hair. Chiropractor away and the other jumped in Sometime around 2:30 am, IN 3TYLE Same Day Serving the Community for 20 Years Personalized the vehicle and sped off. The on Jan. 31, the man asked for traffic agent, meanwhile, suf- a drink and began chatting up Treatment Acute & Chronic Problems Service fered swelling to her left ankle We Accept All Cases the female bartender, 52, say- and chest. ing that 10 years earlier the • Low Back Pain • Scoliosis • Acute & Chronic Cases Nab rings two had worked together at • Neck Pain • Arm/Shoulder Pain • Sports Injuries Two men stormed into a another bar. • Headaches • Hip/Leg Pain • Work Injuries Bensonhurst store specializing Not impressed, the bar- 3TART 0LANNING • Sciatica • Arthritis/Bursitis • Auto Accident Injuries in religious items and put a tender cut the drinker off, GHI; Empire Blue Choice (PPO, POS); Empire BC/BS; Oxford; gun to the owner’s head before which sparked his fury. With- Magnacare; United Health Care; Multiplan; Medicare; storming out with jewelry. out notice, police say, he took FOR 9OUR 1199; PHCS; Health Net; Aetna; Healthfirst; Landmark; The Feb. 3 attack hap- his glass, now empty, and hit ACN; Workers Compensation pened at 5:25 pm, inside a the woman with it in the eye Auto Accident / No Fault; Attorney Cases store on 73rd Street at 18th before running wildly into the Avenue. The thugs viciously night. 2ETIREMENT FAMILY PLANS AVAILABLE FOR PATIENTS WITHOUT INSURANCE grabbed the 50-year-old Gang beating woman around the neck, A gang of at least seven 4th AVENUE FAMILY CHIROPRACTIC CENTER pulled out the gun and then 8415 Fourth Avenue (718) 745-9045 men attacked a 24-year-old shoved her to the ground, say man before making off with 4ODAY police. his $5,000 watch and $750, One of the men yelled, police say. “This is a real gun and if you The beating began after one move I’m going to shoot of the men demanded the vic- you.” tim, “Pay their bill,” according One of the suspects was de- to a police complaint filed scribed as a white male, about with the 62nd Precinct. When &2%% 3%-).!2 h#REATING 9OUR 2ETIREMENT 0LANv 190 pounds, and the other as he refused, at least six other black and about 160 pounds. men approached the victim as Both were described as about he tried to calm the situation AT 2IDGEWOOD 3AVINGS "ANK 5-foot-8. while standing on the corner The men stormed out as of Kings Highway and West fast as they blew in, taking Sixth Street in Gravesend. with them a wedding ring and All of the men dispersed another ring, valued at $4,000, sometime around 5:30 am, be- 7EDNESDAY PM &EBRUARY