DOCSLIB.ORG

CREATIVITY AS an ADAPTIVE PROCESS in the MAKING of a CIVIC PARADE EVENT in MANCHESTER: an ETHNOGRAPHY a Thesis Submitted To

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
CREATIVITY AS an ADAPTIVE PROCESS in the MAKING of a CIVIC PARADE EVENT in MANCHESTER: an ETHNOGRAPHY a Thesis Submitted To CREATIVITY AS AN ADAPTIVE PROCESS IN THE MAKING OF A CIVIC PARADE EVENT IN MANCHESTER: AN ETHNOGRAPHY A thesis submitted to the University of Manchester for the degree of PhD Social Anthropology in the Faculty of Humanities 2014 JESSICA SYMONS SCHOOL OF SOCIAL SCIENCES School of Social Sciences Department of Social Anthropology CONTENTS Contents .................................................................................................................................................................... 2 Abstract ..................................................................................................................................................................... 4 Declaration .............................................................................................................................................................. 5 Copyright .................................................................................................................................................................. 5 Acknowledgments ................................................................................................................................................ 6 Prelude: the story of my fieldwork ................................................................................................................ 7 Chapter 1: Setting the Scene ........................................................................................................................... 13 The constituent parts of Manchester Day Parade ............................................................................. 15 Parade makers ............................................................................................................................................. 16 Parade as an event ..................................................................................................................................... 19 Organising parade...................................................................................................................................... 21 Interpreting parade ................................................................................................................................... 23 Parade roles .................................................................................................................................................. 26 Instrumentalised creativity ........................................................................................................................ 30 Chapter 1 conclusion .................................................................................................................................... 37 Chapter breakdown .................................................................................................................................. 38 Chapter 2: Producing culture ......................................................................................................................... 40 Making Manchester through culture ...................................................................................................... 41 Making culture through creativity .......................................................................................................... 47 Making the public make culture ............................................................................................................... 57 Chapter 2 conclusion .................................................................................................................................... 61 Chapter 3: Conceptualising parade ............................................................................................................. 63 Parades as assemblies .................................................................................................................................. 65 Manchester Day Parade as a parade .................................................................................................. 72 Parade as an event ......................................................................................................................................... 79 Parade as organised entity ......................................................................................................................... 86 The artist-led account .............................................................................................................................. 89 The art car account .................................................................................................................................... 90 2 the street theatre account ...................................................................................................................... 91 The community project account .......................................................................................................... 92 The city records account ......................................................................................................................... 93 Chapter 3 conclusion .................................................................................................................................... 95 Chapter 4: Making parade ............................................................................................................................... 97 Imagining parade ............................................................................................................................................ 97 Parade as an ‘art object’ ............................................................................................................................ 106 Parade as an emergent entity ................................................................................................................. 110 Chapter 4 conclusion ................................................................................................................................. 124 Chapter 5: Whose narrative is it anyway? ............................................................................................. 127 Community groups on parade ................................................................................................................ 127 Looking for synergy .................................................................................................................................... 133 Making with synergy .................................................................................................................................. 137 Collaborative making with ‘the italians’ ............................................................................................ 150 People as emergent entities .................................................................................................................... 157 Chapter 5 conclusion ................................................................................................................................. 159 Chapter 6: Creativity is the engine, ideas are the fuel ...................................................................... 161 Parade artists as ‘creative guides’ ........................................................................................................ 169 Ideas and creativity .................................................................................................................................... 174 Control over ideas ....................................................................................................................................... 178 Chapter 6 Conclusion ................................................................................................................................. 183 Conclusion: On creativity .............................................................................................................................. 186 Bibliography ....................................................................................................................................................... 188 Final wordcount: 72148 3 ABSTRACT Creativity as an Adaptive Process in the Making of a Civic Parade Event in Manchester: An Ethnography This thesis uses insight drawn from fieldwork among people developing a civic parade in Manchester over 2011-12 to analyse what happens in the translation of ideas into entities for display. It argues for creativity as an adaptive process, a responsive, dynamic activity manifested by parade makers, as they sought to realise the imagined event. It traces the roles that underpinned parade production and how people made sense and use of allocated responsibilities, while working within and through organisational boundaries. It situates the parade as an ‘art object’ (Gell 1998), constituted of assemblages at different scales (De Landa 2006), each embedded in a web of relationships to show how: a civic attempt to bring a public into being provides insight on the constituting organisational structures; the operational style of the arts organisation commissioned to produce the parade, led to imagining it into existence; and how two community groups responded to the parade parameters according to their own social dynamics. The thesis builds on ethnographic analyses of collaborative activities to consider how organisational shapes combine and how their constitutions substantially affect evolving entities. Situating creativity as an adaptive process separates creative activities from
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Anya Gallaccio
    Anya Gallaccio 1963 Born in Paisley, Scotland Lives and works in London, UK Education 1985-1988 Goldsmiths’ College, University of London, UK 1984-1985 Kingston Polytechnic, London, UK Residencies and awards 2004 Headlands Center for the Arts, Sansalitos, California, US 2003 Nominee for the Turner Prize, Tate Britain, London, UK 2002 1871 Fellowship, Rothermere American Institute, Oxford, UK San Francisco Art Institute, California, US 1999 Paul Hamlyn Award for Visual Artists, Paul Hamlyn Foundation Award, London, UK 1999 Kanazawa College of Art, JP 1998 Sargeant Fellowship, The British School at Rome, IT 1997 Jan-March Art Pace, International Artist-In-Residence Programme, Foundation for Contemporary Art, San Antonio Texas, US Solo Exhibitions 2015 Lehmann Maupin, New York, US 2014 Stroke, Jupiter Artland, Edinburgh, UK SNAP, Art at the Aldeburgh Festival, Suffolk, UK Blum&Poe, Los Angeles, US 2013 This much is true, Artpace, San Antonio, Texas, US Creation/destruction, The Holden Gallery, Manchester, UK 2012 Red on Green, Jupiter Artland, Edinburgh, UK 2011 Highway, Annet Gelink Gallery, Amsterdam, NL Where is Where it’s at, Thomas Dane Gallery, London, UK 2010 Unknown Exhibition, The Eastshire Museums in Scotland including the Dick Institiute, the Baird Institute and the Doon Valley Museum, Kilmarnock, UK 2009 Inaugural Exhibition, Blum & Poe Gallery, Los Angeles, CA, US Lehmann Maupin Gallery, New York, US 2008 Comfort and Conversation, Annet Gelink Gallery, Amsterdam, NL That Open Space Within, Camden Arts Center, London, UK Kinsale
    [Show full text]
  • The Democratic Image Online Projects Exhibitions Workshops Commissions Events 2 About Look 07
    THE DEMOCRATIC IMAGE ONLINE PROJECTS EXHIBITIONS WORKSHOPS COMMISSIONS EVENTS 2 ABOUT LOOK 07 LOOK 07 WAS CONCEIVED BY REDEYE AND IS A PROGRAMME OF ACTIVITIES CONCERNED WITH THE REVOLUTION IN PHOTOGRAPHY. AS CAMERA OWNERSHIP IS SKYROCKETING WORLDWIDE, LOOK 07 DESCRIBES WHAT PEOPLE ARE SAYING WITH THIS NEW LANGUAGE; WHO’S MAKING THE MOST INTERESTING PICTURES NOW; WHO’S LOOKING AT THEM; HOW THE PUBLIC IS USING PHOTOGRAPHY AS A NEW MEANS OF EXPRESSION AND THE PLACE OF THE PROFESSIONAL PHOTOGRAPHER IN ALL THIS. LOOK 07 IS… A SYMPOSIUM WORKSHOPS The Democratic Image Symposium investigates the Look 07 brings together photographers, artists and revolution in photography with some of the world’s non-professionals for exciting projects that will be top speakers on the subject. exhibited in galleries and online. ONLINE WORK COMMISSIONS Look 07’s online gallery, Flickr gallery and blog New work commissioned from a broad range of keep the conversation going. photographers and artists will make its mark upon the city. It will also lead to an open competition. EXHIBITIONS A large number of new, lens-based exhibitions will EVENTS span Greater Manchester, many tying in with the An engaging mix of gallery talks and special symposium’s theme of The Democratic Image. events celebrate different aspects of photography. WHO’S SUPPORTING LOOK 07? Look 07 gratefully acknowledges the support of the We would also like to thank our media partners, Arts Council of England, the Association of Greater The Associated Press and Metro newspaper, and Manchester Authorities, Manchester City Council, our new media supporter, Manchester Digital the Paul Hamlyn Foundation and Redeye – The Development Agency with funds from the ERDF.
    [Show full text]
  • An Evaluation of the Impacts and Legacies of Enquire and Watch This Space 2 3
    An evaluation of the impacts and legacies of enquire and Watch this Space 2 3 Inspiring Education Summary The impacts and legacies of the • The programmes helped both national programmes at a glance and local government departments to in Galleries The evaluation of the enquire and Watch achieve their objectives in support of young The impact of two this Space programmes from 2004-9 has • The programmes increased young people’s people, education and the arts. They have demonstrated how a modest investment can access to, and interest in, the contemporary contributed to the development of education pioneering programmes lead to extensive participation in art by children visual arts, artists, galleries and museums in policy and to other programmes and their on the relationship between and young people, improve the quality of gallery their local area. achievements have been recognised by and museum education and teaching, and have Ofsted in its report, Drawing Together: art, galleries, schools and an ongoing impact on young people’s • They provided both gallery educators and craft and design in schools 2005/08 (2009) young people education and career options. artists at the beginning of their careers, and teachers and youth workers with little • The research findings about the learning These Strategic Commissioning programmes (1) previous experience of working with galleries benefits to children and young people of have enabled substantial sector development and museums, invaluable experience, insights engaging with contemporary art are an and organisational change through research, and skills. ongoing resource to inform effective practice professional training and partnerships. These and advocacy. legacies will support further participation and • They showed gallery educators, artists and educational opportunities into the future, across teachers new and creative ways to work with • The research and development model, which England.
    [Show full text]
  • Tpn-Update-Digest-100422.Pdf
    CONTEMPORARY VISUAL ARTS MANCHESTER ACE ACTIVITY REPORT Overview During the summer of 2009 Contemporary Visual Arts Manchester (CVAM) was focused on a research phase. We needed to understand some of the possibilities before embarking on a programme of development. During the research phase a brief was drawn up for an economic impact report that would dovetail with some work that the Renaissance North West Museums group had already completed. We also undertook a research trip to the Low Countries to: ‐ Look at urban places comparable to Manchester but further developed in ‘platforming’ of contemporary visual arts ‐ Make contacts with similar Umbrella organisations in Holland and Belgium ‐ Develop ideas for future CVAM activities ‐ Experience how other European cities use non‐art spaces for contemporary arts ‐ Foster a group identity within the Manchester arts organisations involved ‐ Witness cross‐institutional contemporary art co‐operation in European cities ‐ Hear from European arts festivals of their working situations with local arts authorities and sites A very successful trip to Liverpool followed when we met up with colleagues from LARC. However, at the end of August our co‐ordinator secured a research post and left. It took until November before a new co‐ordinator was found and planning recommenced for the visioning day and completion of the economic impact research Future agenda includes: Visioning session – We have a visioning day set up with a facilitator to help us work through the following and develop a clear action plan for this year and beyond. • Digital opportunities – how can we exploit them • Profile of contemporary visual arts in the city • Developing the contemporary visual arts ecology in the city • Long Night • Economic Impact Study – this will report soon and we want to maximise the impact of that work.
    [Show full text]
  • The Urban Weekender
    THE URBAN WEEKENDER From interactive digital artworks to late nights at the gallery, from the future of urban music to the hotly anticipated new novel from one of America’s best known writers, from unmissable performance art to tours of the underground art scene; this is your indispensable guide to the long weekend in Manchester. UNMISSABLE by Rafael Lozano-Hemmer, one of the world’s most exciting electronic artists. FRI 1 Here, the gallery hosts an evening of live electronica by Marconi Union alongside OCTOBER what’s being billed as ‘interactive activity’ from Lewis Sykes in its glass-roofed atrium. Friday also sees the launch of Un-convention, one of the UK’s most The weekend starts here, with a eclectic independent music industry programme of performance art, after-hours events that contains much for those who electronica and nothing less than the future just love (rather than work in) new music. sounds of urban music. Leave the working Employing such unconventional spaces as week behind and get into the city for the a barge, Salford Lads’ Club and a church, Abandon Normal Devices (AND) Festival, and featuring the likes of Bill Drummond, an event described by The Guardian as ‘a Jarvis Cocker, Jon McClure, Brian Travers boldly freewheeling art and film festival’. and Kevin Cummins – all doing ‘interesting AND launches with a series of special things in the most unexplored places in late night events right across the city – our the city’ – Un-convention is a hot ticket. Oh pick is Lawrence Malstaf’s unmissable yes, and there’s a travelling circus, music and claustrophobic performance, Shrink.
    [Show full text]
  • Role: Art Assembly Producer
    Art Assembly Producer Recruitment Pack, 2021 Role: Art Assembly Producer Deadline for Applications: 12noon Friday 3 September 2021 Interviews: Monday 20 September 2021 Fixed fee, freelance: £10,000 (inclusive of all taxes and expenses) Based on an estimation of: 50days work depending on experience Role begins: as soon after appointment is confirmed Role expected to complete: August 2022 The Art Assembly Producer A Manchester collective of gallery, museum and education partners (Castlefield Gallery, Home, Manchester Art Gallery, the Whitworth and The Manchester College, Shena Simon Campus) are working with the Art Fund to realise Art Assembly, in Manchester, during the summer of 2022. We are looking for someone to join the partnership team as a freelance Art Assembly Producer. You will work with and support the partners to imagine, and deliver, a series of exciting new co- commissions, alongside a discussion and live programme, all to be presented at the Art Assembly one-day festival. Purpose of role Working closely with the partners and wider collaborators, The Art Assembly Producer will manage and produce the delivery of a series of co-commissions. Working with the partners the role will also support the development of the Art Assembly discussion and live programme. You will support and contribute to the work of the programme team. Core to the role will be working collaboratively with the Art Assembly Communications Consultant and Evaluator. Effective promotion of Art Assembly and measuring the impact of the programme will be vital to the success of the one-day festival. We are looking for someone with a genuine interest in contemporary visual art, and enthusiasm for lifelong learning and education.
    [Show full text]
  • Asia Triennial Manchester 14 Brochure
    www.asiatriennialmanchester.com Asia Triennial Manchester 2014 27 Sep / 23 Nov Festival Guide Partners and Supporters Welcome to Asia Triennial Manchester I would like to warmly welcome you to the Lead funders and Partners: third edition of Asia Triennial Manchester (ATM14). ATM14 includes 54 artists from 12 countries across 14 venues and is a collaboration with a range of sites and partners focusing on three main clusters in IWM North (part of Imperial War Museums) Harmonious Venue partners: at The Quays, Manchester city centre, Bury Society: and Rochdale. ATM14 aims to challenge perceptions about Asia and with the recent Exhibition partners: challenging global events, makes its theme of Conflict and Compassion a timely one. This Triennial includes artists who live in, work in or address issues surrounding Asia as well as this Triennial’s artistic theme. At IWM North, I have curated an exhibition that features new commissions that sit alongside existing work by artists who are challenging current political Headline partners: perspectives and cultural mindsets about Asia. As many acknowledge that this is the ‘Chinese Century’, the Centre for Chinese Contemporary Art (CFCCA) is staging the largest exhibition of Chinese contemporary art in the UK to date featuring over 30 of some of the most With support from: important artists from Taiwan, Mainland China and Hong Kong. Castlefield Gallery, Manchester Craft and Design Centre, Touchstones Rochdale, Bury Art Museum + Sculpture Centre and Dark Border Developments at IWM North explore our theme with artists who range from the emerging to the celebrated, whilst Cornerhouse has devised the official ATM14 film programme.
    [Show full text]
  • Visual Arts Graduates and Infrastructures for Professional Development
    9 Staying and making it in regional creative cities – visual arts graduates and infrastructures for professional development Abigail Gilmore, David Gledhill and Ivan Rajković Introduction This chapter investigates the experiences of creative graduates working in managed artist studio spaces in Manchester in the North West of England. It considers their trajectories and career development after art school and explores their professionalisation, recognition and success in relation to the opportunities provided by studio spaces and the broader arts infrastructure and creative economy in Manchester and beyond. It attempts to understand the relationship between training, teaching and learning within higher education and the strategies and realities of emerging and established visual artists in a regional city. In doing so, it critically examines how creative human capital, mediated by the community of practice offered by a managed studio space, moves through the structural relations of ‘town’ and ‘gown’, which impact on the careers and mobility of artist-practition- ers and their opportunities for market entry and professional development. The relationship between universities and creative economies can be understood as a variety of symbiotic activities, which reveal the character and prosperity of places and the people that live and work in and visit them. Research on higher education and its relationship to local creative economies has shown how univer- sities contribute to the infrastructure for arts and cultural provision, for example through museums and performing arts spaces on campus and academic research on arts and cultural activities (Chatterton 1999; Chatterton and Goddard 2000; Powell 2007). They also contribute through the knowledge, training and skills development supported by academic research, teaching and learning that is trans- ferred to places through the mobile human capital of students, graduates and staff (Florida et al.
    [Show full text]
  • Curators and Venues Announced for Hayward Gallery Touring's British
    Press release Date: Tuesday 2 October 2018 Contact: Filipa Mendes - [email protected] / 020 7921 0919 Curators and Venues Announced for Hayward Gallery Touring’s British Art Show 9 Opening in Manchester, then touring to Wolverhampton , Aberdeen and Plymouth . Hayward Gallery Touring is pleased to announce the participating cities and the appointment of Irene Aristizábal and Hammad Nasar as the curators for the forthcoming edition of British Art Show, which will open in Manchester in 2020, and then tour to Wolverhampton, Aberdeen and Plymouth . The exhibition is the biggest touring exhibition of contemporary art in the UK and it is acknowledged as one of the most important recurrent exhibitions of contemporary art produced in this country. British Art Show 8 attracted over over 300,000 visitors in its tour to four cities from October 2015 to January 2017. Irene Aristizábal and Hammad Nasar were selected by a panel of curators from the Hayward Gallery and the participating cities. They bring international experience to the role and have each worked on major exhibitions in the UK, Europe, America and Asia. British Art Show is widely recognised as a significant marker of recent developments in contemporary art, unrivalled in its scope and national reach. The exhibition introduces a wide public to a new generation of British artists, or artists practising in Britain, providing a vital overview of the most exciting art produced in this country during the previous five years. British Art Show 9 will tour to venues including Castlefield Gallery, HOME, Manchester Art Gallery and The Whitworth; Wolverhampton Art Gallery; University of Wolverhampton School of Art ; Aberdeen Art Gallery; The Box, Plymouth plus other venues in the city.
    [Show full text]
  • Higher Education and the Creative Economy Beyond the Campus
    Higher Education and the Creative Economy Beyond the campus Edited by Roberta Comunian and Abigail Gilmore ISBN: 978-1-138-91873-3 (hbk) ISBN: 978-1-315-68830-5 (ebk) First published 2016 Chapter 9 Staying and making it in regional creative cities – visual arts graduates and infrastructures for professional development Abigail Gilmore, David Gledhill and Ivan Rajković (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0) BK-DEP-GILMORE_OA-160424-Ch 9.indd 1 17/10/16 7:54 PM 9 Staying and making it in regional creative cities – visual arts graduates and infrastructures for professional development Abigail Gilmore, David Gledhill and Ivan Rajković Introduction This chapter investigates the experiences of creative graduates working in managed artist studio spaces in Manchester in the North West of England. It considers their trajectories and career development after art school and explores their professionalisation, recognition and success in relation to the opportunities provided by studio spaces and the broader arts infrastructure and creative economy in Manchester and beyond. It attempts to understand the relationship between training, teaching and learning within higher education and the strategies and realities of emerging and established visual artists in a regional city. In doing so, it critically examines how creative human capital, mediated by the community of practice offered by a managed studio space, moves through the structural relations of ‘town’ and ‘gown’, which impact on the careers and mobility of artist-practition- ers and their opportunities for market entry and professional development. The relationship between universities and creative economies can be understood as a variety of symbiotic activities, which reveal the character and prosperity of places and the people that live and work in and visit them.
    [Show full text]
  • Report on Cultural Organisations to The
    Manchester City Council Item 2 Cultural Engagement Task and Finish Group 15 August 2012 Manchester City Council Report for Resolution Report to: Cultural Engagement Task and Finish Group – 15 August 2012 Subject: What are cultural organisations in the city doing? What work is Manchester Art Gallery doing to directly engage residents of the city in arts and culture? Report of: Fran Toms, Head of Culture Summary: This report responds to the purpose detailed for meeting three in the work programme for the Cultural Engagement Task and Finish Group; To investigate the work which organisations in Manchester undertake to engage residents in their work, including but not limited to museums, theatres and art galleries. To consider the different ways in which the Council influences external organisations that the Council contributes funds to directly as well those which it does not fund. To focus on how well the organisations engage hard to reach groups, including young people and people from deprived or isolated communities and explore what measures are already in place or could be implemented to support the engagement more fully. To invite representatives from various arts organisations to give their views on the work they do to engage with members of the public, how the Council fulfils its role in this and ways in which they would improve this work. Recommendations 1. That the Committee note the contents of the report and are invited to lead a discussion to examine the detail of the work. Wards Affected: All Contact Officers: Name: Fran Toms
    [Show full text]
  • Art Galleries Committee – 12 February 2020 Subject: Manchester City G
    Manchester City Council Report for Resolution Report to: Art Galleries Committee – 12 February 2020 Subject: Manchester City Galleries’ report and revenue budget 2020/21 Report of: Director of Manchester City Galleries and the Deputy Chief Executive and City Treasurer Summary This report details Manchester City Galleries’ performance during 2019, outlines how we plan to deliver our vision in 2020/21 within the context of our strategic plan, and presents a draft revenue budget for 2020/21 for the approval of the Art Galleries Committee. Recommendations The Committee is recommended to: 1. Approve the contents of the report, including the draft gross budget for 2020/21 of £3.55m, with cash limit budget contribution from Manchester City Council of £2.21m. 2. Recommend the budget to Executive for approval as part of the Council’s budget setting process. 3. Delegate authority to the Director of Manchester Art Gallery in consultation with the Executive Member for Skills, Culture and Leisure, to approve a new Collection Development Policy (as proposed in section 3.5). Wards Affected: All Manchester Strategy outcomes Summary of the contribution to the strategy A thriving and sustainable city: We provide support for the creative economy supporting a diverse and through our public programme, training and distinctive economy that creates development opportunities for young people, and jobs and opportunities contribute to economic growth and prosperity of Manchester by championing creativity, supporting creative industries, and through cultural tourism. A highly skilled city: world class We develop and nurture skills within our workforce and home grown talent sustaining and support the development of skills and creativity the city’s economic success of Manchester residents through our programme of events, workshops, activities and exhibitions.
    [Show full text]