Scotland’s 2011 Census
RGS-IBG International conference London
Cecilia Macintyre, 27 August 2014 Overview
Some history
Processes to get to the final data set
Some of the key results so far
Results still to come
Census Data Explorer History
Census day - 27 March 2011
23rd census since 1801
Lots of planning and preparatory activity
“Traditional” census approach: 95% of census questionnaires hand-delivered, 5% by post
94% response rate - 20% questionnaires completed online
From 94% to 100%...
Load & Remove False Capture data Validation persons
Resolve Multiple Filter Rules Imputation Responses
Estimate Impute skeleton Assign output missing returns records areas
Derive variables Disclosure Outputs for output Control database Dual system estimation Census population: 5,295,403, estimated with 95 per cent confidence to be accurate to within +/- 23,000 (0.44 per cent).
See scotlandscensus website for more detail on methodology Quality assurance process
Carried out agreed series of simple univariate checks at early stages.
Benefits of early sight of data was that feedback could be provided to processing team
Developed systems and tools to be used throughout process and for dissemination of quality information
What did we find?
Processing had missed out some variables – back to the beginning
What we expected - respondents don’t do what you always expect
Initial findings raised issues with coding and ways in which some questions were answered What did we do about it? Carried out more in-depth checks , prioritising key data used in first release
Analysed data for issues which would cause problems in later processes, in particular edit and imputation
Recoded some text responses including ethnic group and language
Sometimes nothing – but will report quality to users Some issues identified
Issues with specific questions
• Marital status • Travel to school (and students in general) • Central heating and long term conditions write in
Geography issues • Best fit geography for datazones • Treatment of potentially disclosive slivers
Address coding • Workplace flows (ongoing)
Example
2001 Data zones can be created by either aggregating up:
• 2011 postcodes
• 2011 output areas.
2 versions of data zone creation
2011 Postcodes 2011 Output areas Geographic differences
1686 2436
700 1393
2011 Postcodes 2011 Output areas
Data zone boundary S01001102 S01001109 Uses of data zone population statistics
If you are looking to do a comparison of population or number of households over the years, the data set created from 2011 postcodes would be your best option.
However, for all future releases of the census data zone estimates will be of those aggregated from 2011 Output areas.
Data zone boundaries are currently being reviewed Additional data published
2001 Data zones: Population and Household Estimates – Comparison between 2001 and 2011 Censuses http://www.gro-scotland.gov.uk/statistics/theme/population/estimates/special-area/sape/2001- data-zones.html
Some issues to be aware of
The total population of datazones in a council area does not exactly match the published council area population
Difference in council population
Glasgow/North Lanarkshire 617 East Ayrshire/East Renfrewshire 127 Aberdeen City/Aberdeenshire 102 Geography – Output areas
46,351 output areas created for 2011 Created as groups of postcodes Minimum thresholds 50 persons and 20 households First release of results December 2012 Media coverage
“Edinburgh in baby boom as under- fives up 18%” Edinburgh Evening News
“What we learned from the Census 2011: More women, more OAPs, more people.” BBC online The Daily Record
“Scotland becomes ‘a “Almost two thirds of “Home alone: how single- more colourful country’” Scotland's residents are person households now 'Scottish only' ” STV prevail across Scotland” BBC online Herald online “Census shows decline in Gaelic speakers 'slowed' ” “Challenge to the Kirk as number of Scots without a BBC religion at new high” “Number of foreign nationals in Aberdeen triples” The Herald Evening Express Scotland’s population
More people: Scotland’s population was 5.3 million on 27 March 2011, the highestScotland’s ever Census Population grew by over 0.2 million (4.6 per cent) since 2001 An ageing populationRelease: 2A 17 per cent of population aged 65 and over (including 34,000 people aged 90 or over) 16 per cent of population aged under 15 (under 5s up)
New question - National identity
Proportion of population by national identity, Scotland, 2011
Ethnicity by National Identity Ethnicity and country of birth Language other than English spoken at home
Scots Polish Gaelic Urdu Punjabi Chinese French British Sign Language German Spanish Arabic Italian Cantonese Russian Hindi
0 10,000 20,000 30,000 40,000 50,000 60,000
Number of people aged 3 and over Gaelic speakers by Scottish Parliamentary Constituency
Na h-Eileanan an Iar has 14,092 speakers
Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch has 6,385 speakers
Glasgow Kelvin has 1,419 speakers Long term health condition
No condition
One or more conditions
Other condition
Physical disability
Deafness or partial hearing loss
Mental health condition
Blindness or partial sight loss
Learning difficulty
Developmental disorder
Learning disability
0 500000 1000000 1500000 2000000 2500000 3000000 3500000 4000000
Number of people Results still to come
Release 3 – remaining multi-variate tables on tenure and housing Origin-destination statistics Census microdata files (Samples of Anonymised Records) Alternative population statistics, eg workplace population Commissioned tables service Analytical reports Capturing the uses and benefits
Activity throughout 2014 to answer questions such as: What are you using the data for? How do you intend to use the data? What can NRS do to ensure you get the most out of it? What is in the way of your making best use?
Feeds Benefits Realisation for Census 2011 and also looking ahead to Beyond 2011 and the future of census statistics.
Census Data Explorer Quick, easy (and FREE!) online access to the results from Scotland’s 2011 Census
All the standard output tables for all the available geographies
Area profiles
Data visualisations and maps online
Range of supporting information
Questions/ further information
All data available at: www.scotlandscensus.gov.uk Also sign up there for our e-newsletter Follow us on Twitter: @NatRecordsScot
Enquiries: [email protected]
Do it all again in 2021? Thank you
Area profiles
“Data tourist”, eg community groups, teachers, local residents
“Snapshot” profiles of census results for a chosen area
Can choose another area to compare against (Scotland comparisons always available)