Science Sustainability
Science Education for Public Understanding Program SEPUP
University of California at Berkeley Lawrence Hall of Science
Ronkonkoma, New York SEPUP Staff Dr. Herbert D. Thier, Program Director Dr. Barbara Nagle, Co-Director Laura Baumgartner, Instructional Materials Developer Asher Davison, Instructional Materials Developer Manisha Hariani, Instructional Materials Developer Daniel Seaver, Instructional Materials Developer Dr. Marcelle Siegel, Instructional Materials Developer Marlene Thier, Teacher Education and CHEM Coordinator Dr. Peter Kelly, Research Associate (England) Dr. Magda Medir, Research Associate (Spain) Mike Reeske, Development Associate Miriam Shein, Publications Coordinator Sylvia Parisotto, Publications Assistant Roberta Smith, Administrative Coordinator Judy Greenspan, Administrative Assistant Donna Anderson, Administrative Assistant
Contributors / Developers Teacher contributors Daniel Seaver Barbara Nagle Victoria Deneroff Mark Klawiter Herbert D. Thier Manisha Hariani Nancy Dibble Angela Olivares Laura Baumgartner Mike Reeske Dan Jeung Veronica Peterson
Production
Book design, coordination, and layout: Miriam Shein Developmental editing: Devi Mathieu Cover design: Maryann Ohki Copyediting and permissions: Naomi Leite Production: Linda Hanlon-DiLorenzo Index: Laura Baumgartner Manufacturing: Kelvin L. Kean
Content and scientific review
Dr. Mark Christensen, Professor Emeritus, Energy and Resources Group, University of California at Berkeley Dr. Carolyn Cover-Griffith, Postdoctoral Fellow, Molecular and Cell Biology, University of California at Berkeley Dr. Robert E. Horvat, Professor of Science Education, Buffalo State College
Research assistance
Marcelle Siegel, Dieter Wilk
Cover photographs © Material World. All are from Material World: A Global Family Portrait (Sierra Club Books) unless otherwise noted. Reproduced with permission. Top left (Mali): Peter Menzel. Top right (Great Britain): David Reed. Market scene (India): Peter Ginter. Children running (Japan): Peter Menzel. Bottom left (India): Peter Menzel. Bottom center (Albania, from Women in the Material World [Sierra Club Books]): Catherine Karnow. Bottom right (Mexico): Peter Ginter. Flask sphere, top left (Mongolia): Leong Ka Tai. Flask sphere, bottom left (Iceland): Miguel Fairbanks.
Material World appears in this course by special arrangement with Sierra Club Books and Material World, Inc. SEPUP is grateful to both for their assistance throughout this project. Special thanks to Peter Menzel for his encouragement.
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 05 04 03 02 01
©2001 The Regents of the University of California ISBN: 1-887725-20-2
SEPUP Published by: Lawrence Hall of Science University of California at Berkeley Berkeley, CA 94720-5200 17 Colt Court e-mail: [email protected] Ronkonkoma, NY 11779 Website: www.sepuplhs.org Website: www.lab-aids.com Field Test Centers
The classroom is SEPUP’s laboratory for development. We are extremely appreciative of the following center directors and teachers who taught the program during the 1997–98 and 1998–99 school years. These teachers and their students contributed significantly to improving the course.
Anchorage, AK Donna L. York, Center Director Jocelyn Friedman, Andy Holleman, Shannon Keegan, Mark Lyke, Tim Pritchett, Gail Raymond, Lori Sheppard-Gillam, Deborah J. Soltis, Leesa Wingo
Brooklyn, NY Veronica Peterson, Center Director Bonnie L. Boateng, Regina Chimici, Jennifer Cordova, Geraldine Curulli, Sherry Dellas, Ian Harding, Edward Kosarin, Jeff Levinson, Len Monchick, Howard Paul, Lisa Piccarillo, Juan Urena, Kathy Wingate
Fresno, CA Jerry D. Valadez and Bill C. Von Felten, Center Co-Directors Staci Black, Nancy Dibble, Phyllis R. Emparan, Deborah L. Henell, Joel Janzen, Daniel Jeung, Scott Kruse, Dave Peters, Steve Wilson
Jefferson County, KY Pamela T. Boykin, Center Director Shannon Conlon, Craig A. DaRif, Nancy J. Esarey, Sherry Fox, Scott Schneider, Kevin Sharon, Melissa Spaulding, Megan Williams
Los Angeles, CA Irene C. Swanson, Center Director Justin Albert, Tammy Bird, Tom Canny, Will Carney, Roberto Corea, Victoria K. Deneroff, Elizabeth Garcia, Gaby Glatzer, Ray A. Harner, Barbara Hougardy, Finis Irvin, Eric Jackson, Karen Jin, Ronald Kimura, Christine Lee, William Mocnik, Ephran Moreira, Evelyn Okafor, Glenda Pepin, Jonathon Perez, Dennis Popp, Brian Smith, Tamara Spivak, Keith Sy, Lisa Trebasky, Muriel Waugh, Cynthia Williams
Riverside, CA Dr. Karen Johnson, Center Director Trish Digenan, Russell Ellis, Bonnie Ice-Williams, Patrick A. McCarthy, Deanna Smith-Turnage, Jay Van Meter
Winston-Salem, NC Dr. Stan Hill, Center Director Alison Cotarelo, Janet Crigler, Aubry Felder, Shelley Johnson, Cindy Kleinlein, Claire Kull, Pamela Lindner, Elizabeth Morgan, Vicki Nicholson, Jane Richards, Valerie Snell, Beverly Triebert
Wisconsin Julie Stafford, Center Director Mark Klawiter, Marian Schraufnagel
Independent Angie Olivares, Irvine, CA; Mike Reeske, San Diego, CA; John L. Roeder, Princeton, NJ Contents
Part 1 Living on Earth ...... 1
Activity 1 Sustainable Living 1.1 What Do We Want to Sustain? ...... 4 1.2 Survival Needs ...... 8 1.3 Burn a Nut...... 10 1.4 Lessons From a Small Island ...... 13 Activity 2 Survival Needs: Food 2.1 Observing Producers and Consumers ...... 16 2.2 The Web of Life...... 20 2.3 Population Estimation ...... 23 2.4 Where Have All the Otters Gone? ...... 26 2.5 Maintaining a Sustainable Environment...... 28 Activity 3 Survival Needs: Temperature 3.1 Bubble-Blowing Fungi ...... 30 3.2 Some Like It Hot ...... 33 3.3 Heat and the Laws of Thermodynamics ...... 38 3.4 Energy on the Move ...... 42 Activity 4 Energy Transfer 4.1 Are You in Hot Water? ...... 44 4.2 Holding Heat ...... 47 4.3 Competing Theories ...... 50 4.4 Shaking the Shot ...... 53 4.5 Count Rumford’s “Boring” Experiment ...... 57 Activity 5 Designing an Insulation System 5.1 Conducting Experiments on Insulation...... 60 5.2 The Can Challenge ...... 63 Activity 6 Living in Today’s World 6.1 Life in Other Countries...... 66 6.2 Energy Use and the Atmosphere ...... 70 6.3 Materials, Energy, and Sustainability ...... 73 Activity 7 Modeling Human Population Growth 7.1 Oodles of Models ...... 76 7.2 Deer Me! ...... 79 7.3 World Population Growth...... 83 7.4 Plants and People ...... 85 Activity 8 Population Dynamics 8.1 Population Curves ...... 88 8.2 A Population of Fruit Flies ...... 92 8.3 Sharing an Environment ...... 95 8.4 Deer Me, Deer Me! ...... 98 Activity 9 Changing Populations 9.1 Population Projections ...... 104 9.2 Comparing Countries ...... 108 9.3 Evaluating a Theory ...... 110 9.4 Population Size, Standard of Living, and Ecological Impact ...... 112 Activity 10 Providing for the Population 10.1 What Is Sustainable Development?...... 116 10.2 Taking a Closer Look From Far Away ...... 119 10.3 Development Decisions ...... 122
Part 2 Feeding the World ...... 129
Activity 11 Food Production 11.1 Growing Plants ...... 132 11.2 Will There Be Food Enough? ...... 135 11.3 Can Satellites Help Feed the World? ...... 139 11.4 Eating Patterns Around the World...... 144 Activity 12 Necessary Nutrients 12.1 Soil Nutrients and Fertilizer ...... 148 12.2 Dirty Differences ...... 152 12.3 Soil Components and Properties ...... 155 12.4 Mineral Mania...... 158 Activity 13 Cell Structure and Function 13.1 In and Out Nutrients...... 162 13.2 Inside the Membrane ...... 166 13.3 Moving Through Membranes ...... 169 13.4 Nature’s Crossing Guards...... 173 Activity 14 Earth’s Components 14.1 What’s It Made Of? ...... 176 14.2 Exploring the Physical Properties of Elements ...... 179 14.3 The Origins of the Periodic Table ...... 182 14.4 Specific Heat and Atomic Structure ...... 186 Activity 15 Classifying Elements 15.1 Modeling Molecules ...... 188 15.2 Trends in the Periodic Table ...... 190 15.3 Patterns in the Properties...... 193 15.4 Building Blocks of Chemical Change ...... 196 Activity 16 Photosynthesis 16.1 Do Plants Pass Gas? ...... 198 16.2 Highlights From the History of Botany ...... 202 16.3 Where’s It Happening? ...... 206 Activity 17 Plant Genetics and the Green Revolution 17.1 Modeling Inheritance ...... 208 17.2 Genes and Traits...... 210 17.3 Rearranging Rice Genes...... 212 17.4 Generation Next: Crossing the Offspring ...... 214 Activity 18 Breeding Improved Crops 18.1 Double Crossing Corn ...... 218 18.2 Breeding Rice ...... 221 18.3 Breeding Crops With Desirable Traits ...... 225 18.4 Cattle Calls ...... 228 Activity 19 Genetically Engineering Food 19.1 Genes, Chromosomes, and DNA ...... 230 19.2 Modeling DNA Structure ...... 233 19.3 Fight the Blight ...... 238 Activity 20 The Role of Cloning in Food Production 20.1 The Clone Zone ...... 242
Part 3 Using Earth’s Resources ...... 247
Activity 21 Identifying and Separating Hydrocarbons 21.1 Differentiating Liquids ...... 250 21.2 Origins and Uses of Petroleum ...... 253 21.3 Distillation of Simulated Crude Oil ...... 257 Activity 22 The Chemistry of Hydrocarbons 22.1 The Role of Carbon...... 262 22.2 Constructing Models of Hydrocarbons ...... 266 22.3 Molecular Mysteries ...... 268 Activity 23 Clothing Materials 23.1 Polymers for Clothing...... 270 23.2 Modeling a Simple Polymer ...... 274 23.3 Researching Oil Production and Use...... 276 23.4 Modeling Cross-Linked Polymers ...... 279 23.5 Creating a Cool Cross-Linked Polymer ...... 283 Activity 24 Material Resources: Metals 24.1 Extracting Metal From a Rock ...... 286 24.2 The Changing Technology of Materials Science...... 291 24.3 Material Use Around the World ...... 295 Activity 25 By-Products of Materials Production 25.1 Disposing of Toxic Heavy Metals...... 298 25.2 Who Wants Waste?...... 305 25.3 Chemical Production Poster Presentation...... 308 Activity 26 Catalysts, Enzymes, and Reaction Rates 26.1 Exploring a Catalyst ...... 310 26.2 Comparing Catalysts...... 313 26.3 Catalysts and Food Production ...... 319 26.4 Catalysis Paralysis ...... 322 Activity 27 Breakdown! 27.1 Degradability: Solution or False Promise? ...... 326 27.2 A Closer Look at Chemical Degradation...... 329 27.3 Give It to Them, They’ll Eat It ...... 334 Activity 28 Food Preservation 28.1 Return of the Bubble-Blowing Fungi...... 336 28.2 Chilling Choices ...... 341 28.3 Frigidly Steamy ...... 345 28.4 Keeping Cool...... 350 Activity 29 Refrigeration Technology 29.1 Wet and Cold ...... 354 29.2 In Search of the “Perfect” Refrigerant ...... 358 29.3 Cramped and Hot ...... 360 29.4 Unforeseen Consequences...... 365 Activity 30 Economy of Material Use 30.1 Material Resource Use and Sustainability...... 368 30.2 Additional Information on the Production and Use of Metals...... 371 30.3 You Can Bank On It ...... 373
Part 4 Moving the World...... 379
Activity 31 Fueling Trade-offs 31.1 How Much Energy Is There? ...... 382 31.2 Fuels for the Future ...... 385 31.3 Combustion...... 391 Activity 32 Fuel From Food 32.1 Biofuels ...... 394 32.2 The Ethanol Alternative ...... 399 Activity 33 Exothermic and Endothermic Interactions 33.1 Interaction Energy ...... 406 33.2 Quantitative Investigation of an Exothermic Interaction...... 409 33.3 Energy As You Like It ...... 413
33.4 Investigating the Decomposition of H2O2 ...... 417 Activity 34 Energy From the Nucleus 34.1 Cool Light ...... 420 34.2 Electromagnetic Wave Relationships ...... 423 34.3 Nuclear Radiation ...... 426 34.4 Using Radioactive Isotopes ...... 430 Activity 35 Mechanical Energy 35.1 Energy to Move Mountains ...... 434 35.2 Inertia ...... 438 35.3 Rambling Rates and Fumbling Forces...... 439 35.4 A Multitude of Machines ...... 442 35.5 Can I Drop You Off? ...... 444 Activity 36 Trade-offs of Energy Use 36.1 By-Products of Combustion ...... 450 36.2 How Air Quality Affects You ...... 453 36.3 Measuring Particulate Pollution...... 457 36.4 Effects of Radiation on DNA ...... 460 36.5 Not In My Back Yard...... 463 Activity 37 Global Perspectives on Sustainability 37.1 Energy Use and Sustainability ...... 466 37.2 Global Shuffle! ...... 472
Glossary...... 475 Index ...... 487 SB viii-1_ SB viii-1 7/18/12 9:47 PM Page viii SB viii-1_ SB viii-1 7/18/12 9:47 PM Page 1
Science and Sustainability is a different kind of science course. It not only covers many of the scientific concepts usually included in biology, chemistry, and physics classes, but also relates those concepts to issues of sustainability. Most likely, you have already explored many scientific concepts, but you may not be familiar with the term sustainability. Sustainability refers to the ability of populations of living organisms to continue, or sustain, a healthy existence in a healthy environment “forever.” Many of the activities of today’s human societies are not carried out in ways that promote sustainability. The scientific topics introduced in this course were chosen because they relate to sustainable development—that is, the use of environmental resources in a responsible way to ensure that they will continue to be available for use by future generations.
During this course you will participate in a wide range of activities, including many hands-on labs, current and historical readings, role-plays, and debates. You will also make frequent use of the book Material World, which provides a pictorial view of life in dozens of countries around the world. These activities will help you become more confident, competent, and independent in the design, analysis, and communication of issue-oriented science activities. You will be challenged to connect the various components of the course as you analyze risks, assess trade-offs, and make decisions that are based on scientific data.
Issues of science and sustainability impact your personal life, your local community, and the world as a whole. By considering some of these important issues in this course, you will gain the skills necessary for making decisions critical to your future and to the future of other living things on Earth. Some of the unsustainable practices of today’s societies have resulted in overcrowding in urban areas, decreased air and water quality, reduced biodiversity, increased starvation, and other global problems. This course will present you with choices that might help solve some of these problems. After evaluating the scientific evidence, you will determine which options are appropriate for the problem in question. In some cases, you will even be given a chance to develop your own solutions for a problem.
This course is divided into four parts: “Living on Earth,” “Feeding the World,” “Using Earth’s Resources,” and “Moving the World.” Each part focuses on the nature and implications of one theme related to sustainability. SB 2-3_ SB 2-3 7/18/12 9:46 PM Page 2 SB 2-3_ SB 2-3 7/18/12 9:46 PM Page 3
Part 1 Living on Earth
Sustaining the existence of Earth’s inhabitants requires that populations of each species survive long enough to produce and nurture the next generation. To survive, all organisms rely on other organisms and on Earth’s non-living resources, including air, water, and soil. In Part 1 of Science and Sustainability, you will begin investigating a wide range of questions about life on Earth:
• What do humans and all other living organisms require to survive?
• Why, scientifically speaking, do organisms have these needs?
• How do organisms, including humans, fulfill those needs?
• How have science and technology contributed to the survival of modern humans?
• How have human attempts to survive and prosper affected the survival of other organisms?
• How have human attempts to survive and prosper affected the quality of the air, water, or soil?
• What effect does population growth have on the ability of humans to survive?
• What is the outlook for human survival in the future?
• What can today’s human population do to increase the ability of future generations to survive?
Science and technology will continue to play an extraordinarily important role in our everyday lives. Part 1 of this course will introduce you to some fundamental scientific principles and processes. This information should help you better understand past scientific discoveries and their impact on society and the environment. It will also prepare you to evaluate the potential impact of future discoveries and inventions. SB 01 04-15_SB 01 04-15 7/18/12 9:52 PM Page 4
Sustainable Living 1
1.1 What Do We Want to Sustain?
Purpose Compare the possessions of families in four countries and consider which are essential for survival.
Introduction Sustainability, at its most basic level, means continued survival. People in different parts of the world own and use different types of materials and energy. Some of these materi- als are needed for survival; others are not. The book Material World contains photographs, statistics, and written descriptions that provide evidence of what life is like for average families in 30 countries around the world. At the beginning of the section on each coun- try is a “big picture” showing a typical family outside their home, surrounded by all their possessions.
The material goods that belong to an individual or a family serve many purposes. In this activity, you will examine the material possessions of families from four different coun- tries, then decide which possessions are essential for survival and which are not. You will also consider how non-essential possessions affect the sustainability of a society.
Prediction Work with your partner to come up with an estimate for the percentage of items found in a ? typical household that are essential for survival.
4 Activity 1 SB 01 04-15_SB 01 04-15 7/18/12 9:52 PM Page 5
What Do We Want to Sustain? 1.1
Materials For each team of two students 1 copy of Material World
Procedure 1. Take a few moments to look through Material World and get a sense of the information it provides.
2. Look at the locator map in Figure 1 and on pages 4–5 in Material World to see where each of the following countries is located: Thailand, Iceland, Ethiopia, and Guatemala. Based only on information from the maps, rank these four countries in order from “easiest to survive in” to “most difficult to survive in.”
3. Now, look carefully at the photographs in Material World of the families from Thailand, Iceland, Ethiopia, and Guatemala. Make a data table similar to the one on the next page to record your observations.
4. For each family, predict the purpose of one of the possessions you do not recognize.
5. Typically, essential natural resources are not considered personal possessions, but are instead shared by all members of the community. Describe any evidence in Material World that might indicate whether or not each family has an adequate supply of clean air, water, and soil.
6. Based on the information you now have, again rank the four countries in order from “easiest to survive in” to “most difficult to survive in.”
Figure 1 Locator Map