Ire Doctors Going Too Far?
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
BELLA ABZUG REMEMBERED • KATE MILLETT ON AGING OTHE PROGRESSIVN THE WOMAN'ES QUARTERL HUEY • SUMMESR 1998 ning ire Doctors Going Too Far? ESTHETIC TYRANNY SURGERY'S MOST INTIMATE VIOLATION BURIED ALIVE AFGHAN WOMEN UNDER THE TALIBAN "PASSING" LIFE IN BLACK AND WHITE BOCK J 4 Books. 4 Bucks. And absolutely, positively no commitment! r-EVEN- THESTARS / ,LOOK i LONESOME, 12-3970. From the 18-3965. A new 56-2640. Covers 53-8519. Learn both 68-3544. From the BOO*! . founder of the Simple collection ot writings everything from food the theories and author of The Living Journal, An on sensuality, allergies to the link practice of this effective Celestine Prophecy, a essential guide for poverty, maturity, between certain foods healing alternative. profound new work. BOOK! simplifying all areas solitude, and more. and cancer prevention. QPB: $12.95 QPB: $17.95 ol your life QPB: $15.95 QPB: $16.95 QPB: $17.95 Conrmafwru \ Angela's FENG Ashes •"SHLJI A LESSON Frank BEFORE McCourt \ak2 DYING Hale Donald ffdsch 36-6067. This book 65-2903. The *62-7451. Here is the 48-0242. Dr Laszlo 17-0648. How cul- 16-6483. These best- 76-0676. Create a 57-2296 A young 45-0927. Learn the challenges the idea definitive guide to the new, Kreizler returns to tures across the sellers address Issues home environment black man unjustly techniques of a that there are things winning memoir maxim urn-flavor style of help solve a strange globe have addressed from ecology to sex in that supports your accused of murder hands-on system we can know— of an impoverished meatless cooking. and tragic crime, the timeless myster- question-and-answer health, career, and learns dignity in ttie face for healing, but shouldn't. childhood in Ireland. Hardcover: $29.95 QPB: $21.95 ies of the sacred. sessions with God spiritual growth of the electric chair. QPB: $16.95 QPB:$14.95 QPB: $18.95 QPB: $16.95 QPB: $18.95 QPB: $15.95 QPB: $17.95 QPB: $12 PSVCHUUXOTS YOGA! BOOK OF - RANDOM HOUSE SELF-TESTS BASICS^ /.'.£) Ui-Srv WORD InlfJIigfiJHf Career & fesnakj lets MENU J M •48-4095 53-9868 -96-7010 56-7023 Hardcover $29.95 QPB: $9.95 Hardcover: $22.95 QPB: $11.95 QPB: $17.95 QPB: $14.95 SCIENCE DESK REFERENCE •73-9363 75-9752 •37-1782 •93-5102 Hardcover S39 95 QPB: $13.95 Hardcover: $29.95 Hardcover: $19.95 QPB: $24.95 QPB: $19 95 QPB: $12.95 Errlst & Young LIFETIME O.K. Send me 4 books for $4. No Commitment. t.™ TaxGuide \tfigkb | Quality Paperback Book Club,8 Camp Hill, PA 17012-0001. Send me the 4 softcover choices I've listed below and i Sensitive GUIDE TO | enroll me in QPB. Bill me only $1 each, plus shipping and handling charges. I understand that I am not required to buy Person MONEY | another book. You will send me the QPB Review (if my account is in good standing) for at least six months. s-39 ! Indicate by number r II 11 II 1 | your 4 choices: | || | { Add to your immediate savings: Take a 5th book for only $2.99 #021 ; (plus shipping and handling). You'll still have 43-4248 '13-9688 To help us serve you, QPB: $10.95 Hardcover: $29.95 ] no obligation to buy any additional books. QPB: $19.95 please tell us what you like to read. *QPB Exclusive: The only softcover edition now available. QBBJ6-3-0 (Please print clearly.) A. Fiction HOW QPB MEMBERSHIP WORKS: B. Biography Each QPB Review lists our latest books, at up to 60% off Apt. C. Philosophy/Religion hardcover prices. You'll get it free 17 times a year (about D. History every 3 weeks). If you want the Selection, do nothing; it City State Zip E. Humor F. Reference will be sent automatically. If you want another book, or no Do you have a telephone? [ ] Yes [ ] No G. Hovrto book at all, complete the Reply Form always enclosed Have you ever bought anything by mail In the past? [ ] Yes [ ] No and return it by the date given. A shipping and handling H. Children's How have you paid for your mail-order purchases? (Check all that apply.) charge is added to each shipment. I. Business/Finance Return Privilege: If our Review is delayed and you receive [ ]CASH [ ] CREDIT CARD [ ] CHECK [ ] MONEY ORDER J. Cooking/Crafts the Selection without having had 10 days to notify us, K. Behavior just send it back and owe nothing. GUARANTEE OF SATISFACTION L. Science/Technology Cancellations: You can cancel at any time, just by notify- You may examine your introductory books for 10 days, free. If you are not M. Art/Photography ing us. We may cancel your membership if you choose satisfied, for any reason whatsoever, simply return the books and you will rtle 5 not to buy a book in any six-month period. be under no further obligation. *"° ' in Canacfa- THE PROGRESSIVE WOMAN'S QUARTERLY SUMMER 1998 VOLUME VII ON THE ISSUES This issue is dedicated to Bella Abzug FEATURES COVER STORY Should Physicians Be Designing Sex? - Mahin Hassibi, M.D. - 13 Playing God, are doctors going too far? The Tyranny of the Esthetic Martha Coventry - 16 Surgery's most intimate violation REFLECTIONS The Poet as Prisoner - Reza Baraheni - 21 pc Language and creative imagination in exile THE ABORTION WARS The Fire This Time - Mary Lou Greenberg - 24 When "pro-life" means death in Birmingham FRONTLINE REPORT Buried Alive - Jan Goodwin - 26 Afghan women under the Taliban SEXUAL POLITICS To Be Male or To Be Female, That Is the Question - Marilyn Stasio - 32 Gender-bending in Shakespeare CHANGES Out of the Loop and Out of Print - Kate Millett - 38 Meditations on aging PORTFOLIO Painted like a Man, Disappeared like a Woman - Marcy Rudo - 42 Luisa Vidal, the daughter of Modernism RACIAL REALITIES "Passing" - Toi Derricotte - 46 Life in black and white FOREVER BELLA In Her Own Words - 62 COLUMNS What's a Feminist To Do? - Merle Hoffman - 5 Zen and the Art of Motherhood - Phyllis Chesler - 8 DEPARTMENTS Feedback - 4 Talking Feminist The Nose Job - Sherryl Kleinman - 10 Loving Long-Distance - Westry Green - 11 Books Airless Spaces by Shulamith Firestone - Reviewed by Phyllis Chesler - 50 What Are We Fighting For? Sex, Race, Class and the Future of Feminism by Joanna Russ Reviewed by Ellen Cole - 51 Freud's Paranoid Quest: Psychoanalysis and Modern Suspicion by John Farrell Reviewed by Jaclyn Geller - 52 Film Women of a Certain Age: The Big 3-0, 4-0 and 5-0 - Molly Haskell - 54 Cover: Illustration by Lou Beach feedback ON THE ISSUES Lack of Outrage created a magazine for women with brains!! Jessica Caudwell - Sacramento, CA In "Hollywood Downsizes Women" [Spring Summer 1998 1998], Molly Haskell states that in 1997, Vol. VII • No. 3 with very few exceptions, film viewers saw Mary Daly not a "Christian" Publisher/Editor-in-Chief countless instances of exploitation and As I made clear in my interview Merle Hoffman abuse of women whisked past their eyes ["Manifesting the Goddess," Spring 1998], I Editor with "hardly a voice raised in protest." am not a Christian. I was deeply offended to Jan Goodwin It seems that with the right to make a be identified as such in the opening para- Art Director film comes the right to strip women of their graphs preceding the articles in the section Sharon Lee Ryder dignity, figuratively and literally. Women are titled "Should the Trinity Be a Quartet?" Editor at Large generally depicted as weak, unstable, inse- I left the catholic church and Christian- Phyllis Chesler cure, and submissive, and their lives almost ity in the early seventies. I have spent the Special Projects Advisor always revolve around a particular man, or better part of the past 35 years exposing and Julia Kagan men in general. Where there is a so-called analyzing gynocidal atrocities perpetrated Managing Editor strong female character, her strength and/or and legitimated by Christianity and other Mary Lou Greenberg independence are usually tempered by a patriarchal religions. Contributing Editors Eleanor Bader, Irene Davall, major character flaw or life crisis: The suc- Also, I am a Radical Elemental (not Katherine Eban Finkelstein, Molly Haskell, cessful, enterprising businesswoman is "Element") Feminist philosopher. Mahin Hassibi, bell hooks, Jane Garland Katz, depicted as callous and unlikable; the free- Mary Daly - Newton Centre, MA Flo Kennedy, Corona Machemer, Julianne Malveaux, thinker is plagued by loneliness and depres- Editor's Note: OTI apologizes for the typo, Fred Pelka, Marge Piercy, Arlene Raven sion, because her independence prevents her and for the mis-identification in the general Research Editor from remaining in relationships with men. introduction to the cover story. Daly was, of Lisa Vincenti There also seems to be a standard nudi- course, correctly identified in her article. Advertising Sales ty clause in all female film contracts. Even Lori Sokol during sex scenes, where nudity is entirely Webmaster Early Returns from Reader Survey Sara Yager relevant, any naked bodies that are shown Editor's Note: Following is a sampling of Assistant to the Publisher are female. Aside from the X-rating a film comments we've received in response to our Donna Matthew risks for a depiction of male nudity (for rea- Reader Survey [Spring 1998]. If you haven't Marketing Director sons I am unable to fathom), perhaps there yet responded, you have until June 30 to do so. Joy Silver is something else behind the lack of male nudity in films: If male actors appeared My reasons for reading OTI: It covers more ON THE ISSUES totally naked, Hollywood's "big" male stars than white women's issues; isn't afraid to The Progressive Woman's Quarterly wouldn't be so big after all.