Eastern Cougar Questions and Answers About the Five-Year Review March 2011

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Eastern Cougar Questions and Answers About the Five-Year Review March 2011 U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service Eastern cougar Questions and answers about the five-year review March 2011 The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (Service) has completed a review of all available information about the eastern cougar, which has been on the endangered species list since 1973. The review concludes that the eastern cougar is extinct. Although cougars are seen occasionally in the East, no evidence exists that they are the subspecies known as eastern cougars. 1. What was the historical range of the eastern cougar? The eastern cougar range extended Robert Savannah from Maine south to Georgia, east into eastern Missouri and eastern Illinois, and north to Michigan and Ontario, Quebec, and New Brunswick, Canada. 2. Why did eastern cougar populations Service biologists at that time believed become extinct? change in classification must undergo it was possible that the eastern cougar European immigrants killed cougars a formal rulemaking process, including still survived in a few remote areas of to protect themselves and their the opportunity for public comment. its historical range. livestock. Many states offered a bounty 4. Can the public comment on the 7. What would the Service consider to encourage the killing of cougars. five-year status review for the eastern proof of the existence of an eastern The white-tailed deer, the primary cougar? cougar population? prey of the cougar, was nearly extinct There is no formal public comment Even small populations of cougars, in eastern North America by the late period on the 5-year status review; but, such as those in Florida and North 1800s. The last records of eastern the Service will accept and consider and South Dakota, leave substantial cougars are believed to be in Maine information electronic mailed to physical evidence (tracks, photographs, (1938) and New Brunswick (1932). [email protected]. Decisions scat, hair, genetic samples, road 3. Why did the U.S. Fish and Wildlife are made on the best available scientific mortalities, cougars shot or caught in Service initiate a review of the eastern and commercial information. traps). cougar, and what is its purpose? 5. When was the status of the eastern Service biologists assembled 108 The Endangered Species Act (ESA) cougar last reviewed? records dating from 1900 to 2010 with requires the Service to conduct a The Service has not prepared a formal a high level of confirmation that the review of each protected species every status review of the eastern cougar described animals were cougars. After 5 years to ensure the accuracy of its since its recovery plan was published in careful examination, the biologists classification. The review is based on 1982. The Service prioritized its limited concluded all reported cougars were the best scientific and commercial data resources to protect at-risk species animals that escaped or were released available at the time of the review. At with known populations. from captivity or that dispersed from the conclusion of a review, the Service the western United States. can affirm that the species is correctly 6. Why did the Service write a classified, recommend reclassification recovery plan for the eastern cougar There is no evidence that a breeding of a species (endangered to threatened; in 1982 when biologists believed the population of cougars occurs in the threatened to endangered), or subspecies was extinct? eastern United States or eastern recommend removal of the species Although no breeding population of Canada other than those in Florida from the endangered species list. Any eastern cougar was known in 1982, (Florida panther). 8. What would the Service consider a 11. Will the Service consider hunters and/or unafraid of humans. viable population of eastern cougars? reintroducing other cougar subspecies They may behave differently from wild The Service’s recovery plan for the to the eastern states? cougars. We recommend caution and eastern cougar calls for at least three No. The Service does not have the notifying state and local wildlife officials self-sustaining populations in the authority under the ESA to replace the when a cougar is observed. United States, each with a minimum of extinct eastern cougar subspecies by 50 breeding adults. introducing another cougar subspecies. 17. What is the next step now that the five-year review is completed? 9. Why are cougars occurring with 12. Can private individuals or Service biologists will prepare a increasing frequency in the Midwest? organizations reintroduce cougars to the proposal to remove the eastern cougar Cougar populations in most western eastern states? from the endangered species list. states have been increasing in recent If the eastern cougar is removed from The proposal will be published in the decades. These are a different the federal endangered species list, the Federal Register, and the public will be subspecies than the extinct eastern introduction of cougars to the eastern invited to provide substantive scientific cougar. Cougars have reoccupied their states would fall under the jurisdiction information about eastern cougars. historic breeding range in North and of the states. Following review of the comments, the South Dakota and possibly elsewhere. Service will make a final determination, While individual animals dispersing 13. What are the differences among and that determination will be from western populations have been the puma, panther, mountain lion, published in the Federal Register. The documented in a number of Midwest catamount, cougar and painter? timing of these actions will depend on states, some of these animals could be These are different names for funding and staffing availability. released or escaped pets. Although cougars. The different names are young males may sometimes disperse interchangeable and do not describe 18. If the eastern cougar is removed from hundreds of miles, female cougars separate subspecies. the endangered species list, will it be normally do not move far from where legal to hunt or kill cougars found in the they are born. Thus, cougars are slow 14. Has genetic analysis shown historical range of the eastern cougar? to colonize new areas and establish significant differences among the State laws govern hunting and killing breeding populations. approximately 15 subspecies of cougar animals not protected by federal law. in North America? Contact your state wildlife agency to The Cougar Network <http://www. Recent genetic analysis has raised find out what laws apply in your state. cougarnet.org> documents cougar doubts about the validity of so many confirmations, many of them east subspecies. But, a complete subspecies 19. How many species have been of established cougar populations. analysis, including consideration removed from the endangered species According to The Cougar Network, of morphology, unique ecological list since the 1973 ESA was passed? cougars of wild origin have been settings and habitats, and geographic Of the species for which the Service confirmed from Minnesota and distinctiveness between populations, has the lead, 38 plants and animals Wisconsin south to Louisiana. has not been conducted. found in the United States have been removed from the list. Of these, 13 10. Will the range of cougars continue to 15. Is it legal to have a cougar as a pet? recovered; nine animals were removed expand into eastern North America? How many cougars are kept as pets? from the list due to extinction (although Cougars once had the greatest States have the authority to regulate some were believed to be extinct when distribution of any land mammal in possession, protection and hunting they were placed on the list); and 16 North and South America. They are of species not protected by federal were removed for reasons such as the adaptable and can live in grasslands, law. Some people estimate that more discovery of new information. forest, desert, mountainous regions and than 1,000 cougars are held in private swamps. They require large contiguous captivity in the eastern United States. 20. Where can I find more information areas with adequate large prey to meet The Service’s review accounted for only about the eastern cougar? their social, reproductive and energy 110 to 135 captive cougars in 15 of the For more information about the needs. 21 states surveyed, although it is likely eastern cougar, see http://www.fws.gov/ that many additional cougars are kept northeast/ecougar. There are likely many places in eastern as pets without authorization. North America with adequate habitat U.S. Fish & Wildlife Service to support populations of cougars. It is 16. Do cougars pose a threat to humans 1 800/344 WILD unknown at this time whether cougars and pets? www.fws.gov will continue to expand their range Like any wild carnivore, cougars can eastward. Given human densities in attack and kill other animals and March 2011 eastern North America, the return of humans. Big cats are usually secretive a top-level predator such as the cougar and usually avoid inhabited areas. will depend on public awareness and However, cougars raised in captivity acceptance. and released to the wild may be poor .
Recommended publications
  • The Essentials: What You Need To
    The Essentials: What you need to understand LD 125 An Act To Prohibit the Aerial Spraying of Glyphosate and Other Synthetic Herbicides for the Purpose of Silviculture Comments from Robert G. Wagner, Professor and head of Forestry and Natural Resources, Purdue University, and formerly Henry W. Saunders Distinguished Professor, School of Forest Resources, University of Maine. Fields of expertise: Academic and research leadership, industry/university partnerships, silviculture, forest management, forest regeneration, vegetation ecology and management Forest managers must be able to In order to successfully manage forests to achieve ecological or economic goals for the people of Maine, determine which tree species make foresters must be able to promote the kinds of tree species needed to achieve specific forest management up future forest goals. This is a core principle that determines whether forestry is a viable business or public enterprise or whether it is a total failure. Decades of research from around the world (Wagner et al. 2006) have clearly shown that effectively managing vegetation is vital to the success of forest regeneration. Indeed, one of the longest running studies in the world, the Austin Pond study in northern Maine, has clearly demonstrated the important role that herbicides play in providing for successful conifer regeneration over many decades (Olson et al. 2012, Bataineh et al. 2013). The inability to use herbicides, especially glyphosate, will lead to forest regeneration failures in many places that will have negative repercussions for many decades to come. Herbicides are vital for preventing Invasive plant species are threatening native tree regeneration in forests across the United States.
    [Show full text]
  • Table of Contents Endangered Cats of North America
    Table of Contents Endangered Cats of North America From the forests of eastern Canada to the scrublands of Mexico, wild cats were once prevalent throughout North America. These creatures were among the most beautiful, graceful, and revered Executive animals found on the planet. Summary.................... 2 Today, however, the future of many North American cats is uncertain. Humans have rapidly populated and developed many areas of the continent, destroying natural areas to build roads and Common Issues in North cities, converting wild lands for agriculture and grazing, and degrading habitats to extract natural American Cat Conservation.... 6 resources. Fear and intolerance, the sentiments that fueled historic predator extermination pro- Why Care About Cats?...... 7 grams, still complicate efforts to conserve North America’s wild cats and to find solutions that Habitat Loss, Degradation, accommodate both wildlife and human needs. and Fragmentation................ 8 Conserving wild cats offers the opportunity to protect some of North America’s most beloved Roads and Road Mortality...... 10 animals, the wild places they inhabit, and the many diverse species that share their homes. As we Public Perception of Cats.......... 12 enter the twenty-first century, humans hold the power to influence the future of North America’s felines and the unique places they inhabit. Reintroduction of Endangered Cats........................ 14 The Endangered Cats of North America report takes a thoughtful look at the different wild cat species Working With Private of North America and the most pressing threats to their survival. Even more importantly, the Landowners................................ 16 report provides concrete suggestions for what can be done to save these cats.
    [Show full text]
  • USFWS 2011 Cougar
    Eastern puma (=cougar) (Puma concolor couguar) 5-YEAR REVIEW: Summary and Evaluation Mark McCollough U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service Maine Field Office Orono, Maine March 2011 5-YEAR REVIEW Species reviewed: Eastern puma (=cougar) (Puma concolor couguar) TABLE OF CONTENTS 1.0 GENERAL INFORMATION ................................................................................................ 1 1.1 Reviewers .................................................................................................................. 1 1.2 Methodology Used to Complete the Review ............................................................ 1 1.3 Background ............................................................................................................... 2 1.3.1 FR notice announcing initiation of this review ............................................ 2 1.3.2 Listing history .............................................................................................. 2 1.3.3 Associated rulemakings/actions ................................................................... 2 1.3.4 Review history ............................................................................................. 2 1.3.5 Species’ Recovery Priority Number at start of 5-year review ..................... 3 1.3.6 Recovery plan .............................................................................................. 3 2.0 REVIEW ANALYSIS ........................................................................................................... 3 2.1 Application of
    [Show full text]
  • Long Extinct Eastern Cougar to Be Removed from Endangered Species List Correcting Lingering Anomaly
    News bulletin Media contact: 01/22/2018 Meagan Racey, 413-253-8558, [email protected] (For the Southeast) Phil Kloer, 404-679-7299, [email protected] Long Extinct Eastern Cougar to be Removed from Endangered Species List Correcting Lingering Anomaly Cougars in the East are Florida panthers, released or escaped captives, or animals dispersing from the West The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service is removing the extinct eastern cougar subspecies (Felis concolor couguar) from the Federal List of Threatened and Endangered Wildlife, correcting a lingering anomaly that listed the species despite it likely having gone extinct many decades before the Endangered Species Act (ESA) was even enacted. Data from researchers, 21 states and Canadian provinces across the subspecies’ former eastern North American range indicate the eastern cougar likely disappeared forever at least 70 years ago. The removal of the extinct subspecies from the endangered species list will take effect February 22, 2018. Extinct animals and plants cannot be protected under the Endangered Species Act, which is meant to recover imperiled wildlife and plants and their habitats. Additionally, under law, the eastern cougar listing cannot be used as a method to protect other cougars. During a 2011 review of the subspecies’ status under the ESA, and subsequent 2015 proposal to delist, no states or provinces provided evidence of the existence of an eastern cougar population, nor did analysis of hundreds of reports from the public suggest otherwise. While many suspected cougar sightings are probably mistakenly identified bobcats or other animals, cougars do occasionally occur in eastern North America, but they are cougars of other subspecies: either Florida panthers, animals dispersing from western populations, or animals that have been released or escaped from captivity.
    [Show full text]
  • Eastern Puma Questions Put Florida Panther in Perilаннаfriday, July 8
    7/11/2016 Eastern puma questions put Florida panther in peril ­­ Friday, July 8, 2016 ­­ www.eenews.net Eastern puma questions put Florida panther in peril ­­ Friday, July 8, 2016 ­­ www.eenews.net Published: Friday, July 8, 2016 The Eastern puma, which hasn't roamed the Northeast in nearly 80 years, is finally poised to be removed from the endangered species list. The big cat is extinct, right? Not so fast. What if the cougar ­­ the inspiration for Penn State's Nittany Lion and countless other mascots ­­ didn't exist in the first place? That's what some scientists enlisted by the Fish and Wildlife Service to review the delisting proposal for the Eastern puma are suggesting. They argue that for thousands of years, only one species of cougar roamed North America. All the pumas, mountain lions, panthers and ghost cats that called the Eastern Seaboard home until the early 1900s were all just different names for a now­vanished population of Puma concolor. While these reviewers' comments will be focused on the science underpinning the proposal, Endangered Species Act experts worry their feedback could also have serious implications for the endangered Florida panther ­­ another cat that has been long, and perhaps incorrectly, considered a cougar subspecies. "In terms of the scientific literature, there never really was an Eastern cougar," said John Laundré, an adjunct member of the State University of New York, Oswego's biological sciences faculty. "Unfortunately, we're still stuck with these archaic divisions of the cougar genome. We talk about the Florida panther as something that's unique, and it really genetically isn't." http://www.eenews.net/greenwire/stories/1060039970/print 1/3 7/11/2016 Eastern puma questions put Florida panther in peril ­­ Friday, July 8, 2016 ­­ www.eenews.net Laundré is one of six big­cat researchers who was contacted by the agency in late June to comply with a peer review policy that FWS and the National Marine Fisheries Service, which jointly implement the Endangered Species Act, instituted in 1994.
    [Show full text]
  • Cougar Common Name: Cougar
    Species Status Assessment Class: Mammalia Family: Felidae Scientific Name: Puma concolor cougar Common Name: Cougar Species synopsis: The eastern cougar (Puma concolor couguar) has long been considered a subspecies of the North American cougar. A recent genetic study found all North American subspecies to be a single subspecies (Culver et al. 2000) but taxonomy remains in question (USFWS 2011). The cougar is known by many common names, including puma, mountain lion, catamount, and panther. Historic records indicate that the eastern cougar once occurred from eastern Canada southward into Tennessee and South Carolina, where its range merged with the Florida panther (P. c. coryi). The present distribution of the species in the United States is limited to the western states. Since the 1990s, five breeding colonies have been established east of the Rocky Mountains. Cougars from one of these, Black Hills, South Dakota, have been documented in Michigan and Minnesota as well as in Kansas, Oklahoma, Iowa, Illinois, Wisconsin and Missouri. In the west, cougars are still quite common in areas of the Rocky Mountain states and in British Columbia as well as in Alberta, the Great Basin, Cascades and Sierra Nevada and have colonized urban-suburban-wildland habitat matrixes into Seattle (Kertson et al. 2011), the Bay Area of California (Wilmers et al. 2013) and Los Angeles (Santa Monica National Recreation Area, National Park Service 2014). With the exception of Florida, the cougar has been considered extirpated from east of the Mississippi River since 1900 (McCollough 2011). The Adirondacks were the final stronghold for cougars in the Northeast, with the last record in 1903 (Whitaker and Hamilton 1998).
    [Show full text]
  • Connecticut Wildlife May/June 2015 Connecticut’S 2015 Wildlife Action Plan Almost Complete
    May/June 2015 CONNECTICUT DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY AND ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION BUREAU OF NATURAL RESOURCES DIVISIONS OF WILDLIFE, INLAND & MARINE FISHERIES, AND FORESTRY May/June 2015 Connecticut Wildlife 1 Volume 35, Number 3 ● May/June 2015 Eye on Connecticut Wildlife the Wild Published bimonthly by Connecticut Department of Energy and Environmental Protection Bureau of Natural Resources Wildlife Division Volunteers Are Crucial! www.ct.gov/deep Commissioner While reading this issue of Connecticut Wildlife, you will notice a common Robert Klee thread. Many of the articles highlight projects in which volunteers play Deputy Commissioner an important role. The Wildlife Division is fortunate to have a long list of Susan Whalen Chief, Bureau of Natural Resources volunteers, whether they are a passionate individual or part of an organized William Hyatt group. These dedicated people are ready, willing, and able to help out, Director, Wildlife Division whenever we ask and even at a moment’s notice. In this time of tight budgets Rick Jacobson and shrinking staff numbers, the assistance of these volunteers on various Magazine Staff projects is invaluable, and for that, the Wildlife Division is extremely Managing Editor Kathy Herz grateful. Production Editor Paul Fusco Contributing Editors: Mike Beauchene (Inland Fisheries) We would never survive without volunteers. They are not only critical to Penny Howell (Marine Fisheries) helping us implement Connecticut’s Wildlife Action Plan (see page 3), they Christopher Martin (Forestry) also help us leverage additional funds and, most importantly, assist with Circulation Trish Cernik the stewardship of literally thousands of species in a multitude of habitats Wildlife Division across our diverse state.
    [Show full text]
  • Eastern Cougar
    Eastern cougar Status Federal status: G5TH NH, Endangered NH state status: SH, Nit listed ME state status: SH, Special concern The Eastern cougar (Puma concolor couguar) is the currently recognized subspecies that was historically found in the northeast U.S. The Eastern cougar is believed by the USFWS (1990) to be extinct throughout its historic range due to predation by humans, habitat loss, and low deer populations in the 1800s. It is identified by IUCN as critically endangered and in CITES Appendix I as most critically endangered. It has recently been suggested there are only six subspecies of Puma concolor based on genetic analysis across all populations. If this assessment is accepted, then all cougars inhabiting North and Central America north of Nicaragua will be classified as Puma concolor couguar. In other words, the eastern cougar would no longer be a different subspecies than cougars in other parts of the U.S. The total population of all cougars in the U.S. and Canada is estimated to be 16,000. The panel indicated that the range-wide viability outcome depends on whether or not the eastern cougar is a true subspecies. Assuming it is a valid subspecies, the outcome range- wide and for the WMNF would be E because it is believed to be extirpated throughout its range. This will not change over next 20 years. If the taxonomy is changed so all North American cougars are considered to be one subspecies; or if eastward migration of cougars from the west continues, the outcome would be different range-wide. Regardless the WMNF outcome is E now and likely to remain E into the future as cougar have not been documented on the Forest in decades and are not known near enough to reestablish a population in the next couple decades.
    [Show full text]
  • Eastern Cougar Habitat Suitability Analysis
    EASTERN COUGAR (Puma concolor couguar) © 1990 Michael McNelly HABITAT SUITABILITY ANALYSIS FOR THE CENTRAL APPALACHIANS Kristin Taverna, Jason E. Halbert, and David M. Hines Appalachian Restoration Campaign A Project of Heartwood © Copyright 1999 Appalachian Restoration Campaign PO Box 2786 Charlottesville, VA 22902 (804) 971-3898 (804) 970-1806 fax [email protected] www.heartwood.org/ARC HEARTWOOD PO Box 1424 Bloomington, IN 47402 (812) 337-8898 (812) 337-8892 fax [email protected] www.heartwood.org 2 EASTERN COUGAR (Puma concolor couguar) A HABITAT SUITABILITY ANALYSIS FOR THE CENTRAL APPALACHIANS Kristin Taverna, Jason E. Halbert, and David M. Hines Appalachian Restoration Campaign A Project of Heartwood Abstract: The Appalachian Restoration Campaign (ARC) is dedicated to the restoration and protection of Central Appalachian wildlands by developing an interconnected system of reserves in which human activity is compatible with ecological recovery and health. The core of this project is the Central Appalachian Assessment (CAA), focusing on a regional study area that encompasses portions of six states throughout the Central Appalachians. Part I of this Assessment includes an examination of the current landscape within the study area and its suitability for supporting the eastern cougar (Puma concolor couguar). Suitable cougar habitat still exists within the Central Appalachians, yet prior studies have not examined the location or availability of habitat. The cougar stands out as an umbrella species for habitat management due to its extensive home range. If we protect the habitat that falls under this protective “umbrella”, we could effectively provide for the habitat needs of a number of other species throughout the region.
    [Show full text]
  • State of the Mountain Lion a Call to End the Trophy Hunting of America’S Lion STATE of the MOUNTAIN LION 1 Front Cover: a Wild Mountain Lion in Montana
    State of the Mountain Lion A call to end the trophy hunting of America’s lion STATE OF THE MOUNTAIN LION 1 Front cover: A wild mountain lion in Montana. ImageBroker/ Alamy Stock Photo Abstract State of the Mountain Lion: A Call to End Trophy Hunting of America’s Lion details the current plight of mountain lions (Puma concolor)—who are also commonly known as cougars, catamounts and panthers—across the United States. This report provides a valuable resource to support the long term protection and conservation of mountain lions with never-before amalgamated materials, including: Geographic information system (GIS) maps that identify potential suitable habitat and optimal population sizes for mountain lions, by state A detailed legal review of mountain lion regulations in every U.S. state The report highlights major threats to the species, including rampant trophy hunting which kills thousands of mountain lions each year in the U.S., and reports on the tens of thousands legally killed over the past three decades. The HSUS’sState of the Mountain Lion delves into mountain lion biology, current state-management efforts and the majority public’s highly positive perceptions of this iconic species. The report dispels commonly held myths and provides valuable coexistence strategies for residents, recreationists and ranchers. Mountain lions, once the most common large mammal in North and South America, are restricted to breeding populations in only 16 states. The report details how they are managed in those jurisdictions, which includes the West, parts of the Midwest and Florida. State of the Mountain Lion provides important policy recommendations for decision Hollywood mountain makers to better protect mountain lions and conserve the species for lion.
    [Show full text]
  • Mammal SGCN Conservation Reports Vermont’S Wildlife Action Plan 2015
    Appendix A5 Mammal SGCN Conservation Reports Vermont’s Wildlife Action Plan 2015 Species ........................................ page Species ......................................... page Masked Shrew..................................... 2 Southern Flying Squirrel .................... 73 Water Shrew ....................................... 6 Northern Flying Squirrel .................... 76 Smoky Shrew ...................................... 9 Rock Vole ......................................... 80 Long-tailed or Rock Shrew ................. 13 Woodland Vole ................................. 85 Pygmy Shrew .................................... 17 Muskrat ............................................ 88 Hairy-tailed Mole ............................... 20 Southern Bog Lemming ..................... 92 Little Brown Bat/Myotis ...................... 23 Northern bog lemming ...................... 97 Indiana Bat ....................................... 27 Wolf ................................................ 100 Small-footed Bat ............................... 32 Gray Fox ......................................... 107 Northern Long-eared Bat ................... 37 American Marten ............................. 113 Silver-haired Bat................................ 43 Long-tailed Weasel .......................... 118 Tri-colored bat .................................. 48 Northern River Otter ........................ 121 Big Brown Bat ................................... 52 Canada Lynx .................................... 124 Eastern Red Bat ...............................
    [Show full text]
  • Mountain Lion Status in Iowa
    MOUNTAIN LION/COUGAR STATUS IN IOWA 1995 – 2013 The mountain lion/cougar (or puma, (2013), the Iowa DNR confirmed two panther, and various other names) is the mountain lion reports (Table 1). One largest of the three wildcats historically mountain lion was captured on game documented in Iowa. The lynx and the cameras multiple times in Warren bobcat are the other two. The mountain County, while the second mountain lion lion/cougar probably occurred was shot in early December in Sioux throughout most of the state originally, County. Table 2 shows the number of but nowhere in great numbers. The lynx confirmed mountain lions in Iowa by has been extirpated and the bobcat is year. The following methods have been established in Iowa again after nearly used to confirm the presence of being extirpated. The last historical mountain lions in Iowa to date: roadkills, record of a mountain lion/cougar in Iowa shot and killed, verified camera pictures, was one that was shot in 1867 in and sightings (Table 3). Appanoose County near the town of Cincinnati, Iowa. It is important to note that an average of 2 to 4 sightings per week is reported to Since the mid-1990’s, the DNR has us in the Clear Lake office from received several reports of large “cat” locations all over the state. This does like sightings which led some to believe not count all of the reports other DNR that a few “free ranging” mountain staff receive in their regions throughout lions/cougars may again be occurring in the state as well.
    [Show full text]