The Relationship Between Ethical Conflicts, Moral Distress, And
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
"# ! ! * &' $ % $ ,- ) *+ ) $ '( #$%& ! " ! = $$ 3 <$$ , '56 ! ;:6 : . $ , .86 7 456 2"3) 1 0 /!$ . " ! .$$ $%?! $ ">2 ) '( #$%& ! " ! .$$ $%?! 1@A2 $%2 ) '( #$ %& ! = ! $ "2 '( #$%& ! ! = ! $ ">2 "2 " ! ! = $$ 3 % # , '56 F'2 E ) $$ 3 &D C B ! , '56 .1 $ ">2 1@A2 ) '( #$%& . $ $ ">2 G!6 8 '( #$%&! " ! # (2$ . L? ! H E $ ) $ K( $% E $ ) $$ 3 (%6 ) @ 4>6 %2H ?%6 . $ $ ">2 G!6 "" 2 NOP ! '$ M' E $ ) /! $ ">2 G!6 "" 2 ! /S2 6 E R &# H%2 2 $ ) $% 2 $0"3 ) <2 1$ Q ."" ,.P 6". %6 ' 42 1 / >& ? $ 6 E 1" ! % " '( #$% & ! " ! '( #$%& " ! : Downloaded from ijme.tums.ac.ir at 1:57 IRST on Saturday October 2nd 2021 1 # <3 $ " ! <!# .'P GU %TP " ! <!# $ */0/ .(()*+,- : $%& "# ! ! : & * Email: irajshakerinia@ yahoo.com -, .(w) $% 2 ) $ "$ 2 3 E!`) = H 8 .1 Q 2 ) $ VL@2 $%2 ) i$ xy H E KA2 %"P b1 s X%02 "R .1 GP%W%2 { 6 z%2 ^% H Selig ! Corley 7 456 $ VL@2 ) &L $ $% < ,@ H <" "| 1|32 ) .(*) $% Q $ %"P <H!2 ! &>2 [\] K H Z@ 46 Y% 2 H %2 j }. ! Elpern 7 456 $ G $ .(_) 1 ^2 ) ? ,832 C r+y $>6 ) ) X% C .(+) $ n;# Jameton $ 2 3 (2 = Y% 2 E!`) :6 }. ! Redman $ ( ! b$ ^2 X%02 $% a = /! ! Soloman $ = "R q b(x) "$ :H "6@P $ " 4@D G832 H 4@D $>6 ) ) i$ wy Z@ 46 h32 }. .(f) ! e ,T>2 d '86 t ~2 ! . @2 G2 ( +*y h 2 $%?! 2H ! g ! Wilkinson .(•) $% R$ $$ 2 1$!52 k , /$ /! 1 j 5i ,.P X $ 2 rw $!L $$ 3 G>/2 X: ; Millette 9" 2 =8.2 - Z@ 46 j 5i ,.P X: ml 2H E o6 %@:2 ) H ( fr $>6 ) i$ wy 6 2$ o $$ n! ) KA2 . H 1@2 ! @? < @2 p $H% 2$ "a <@ ! < 4P .(€ _y) $$ X: $ 2 " MOP G832 H /Ua2 G832 . "R F>6 H =&# X0/ Wilkinson .1 ?%2 #$ ) $ 1 >%2 " ! K$>6 XP Jameton .$% 2 4'6 " ! G832 =6 H % 2 2H 1$!52 , /$ $ 2 q .O6 H Downloaded from ijme.tums.ac.ir at 1:57 IRST on Saturday October 2nd 2021 ) q <$$ 3 E!`) Sereika ! Erlen .(d e) $% . ,@6 ,.P ‚ •) $$ K@ $ %'2 2 ) . q ! ng '.P %R $ . ) 4>2 8 ' 42 ) .(e 1 < R$ $ X: 1 1$ "" 2 n6 b"$ 2 <$ $%2 %# %# n6 $%?%2 4 456 G $ H <$ Nathaniel .(r) „ ƒ 8;) #q .O6 6 < 4P $ t H s2? >6 <$ n;# H $>6 #2 p.6 ) 1 "u ! DP L $$ ! s'2 {!Sa2 "" 2 n6 ; ! "" 2 q g"6 ,.P < $ v%W%2 H # =.W $& $ 1 8 = 1a8 G%i$ .(_+ _x) H ,.P $ /! $ 2 X: G!T ; 1$ p% #$a& ." 2 ) H! 3"! R$ "u >! 1$!52 , /$ v% = O32 ".H XP paL ! $$ @ a8 q $ 1 < h32 .1 1 Moral distress 2 1W H! ƒ $ ) 12!42 Moral uncertainty 3 Moral dilemma 4 Institutional constraints 9 ) 4 0!) 8 56!)7 0 4 03!)! 2 /0 1 -. : , )* +) -1 156 '( #$%& ) …) 2H P.? [d I $% 2 $: '( #$%& & E '( #$%& Felton , /$ = . b(f• ) 1 <$$ ƒU6 .Je \ ] s ) $ $ 2 '( . '( ! Freudennberger z%6 = /! '( #$%& |= "@2 $$ $%?! % ! $% 2$ ! h 36 $ ! ‚.a? % , '56 X" %"P 156 }. ) ,( $ .(e]) 1 p ) &L ) %"P <H!2 ! (ff) $! " / " ! G4 456 †>6 $ H 3& 1 % " 2 '2%P &L Zi%O F'2 ,-32 $ s G832 H 8 1 /!Sa2 . ~2 ! Q <32 8. $%.52 .(f€ frI 1 &# " $%2 ) '( p $ Xg z@62 ,ta2 ! &L ) '( #$%& $ }. ! $ '( p = .(€_) % 2 N%a52 <.P " & $ z 52 OO6 G 82 ! 8; & z .(€f) $% 2 0"2 '( #$%& G2H$ = ! 1 DP > $ ) #$%& j =6{ X%'P 4452 H a $4P \] $ ,! 6 z 52 8; & z 1 O …a2 ! DP #$%& " 2 H p $ ! $% = " ! ; 2 = "R q .(fw) $$ $%?! $ ">2 "2 E4 " ! G832 H! $ &L OO6 G 82 ) DP #$%& 3 > " ! G>/2 KL = P $ . $ ƒS2 z 52 1 %'2 ! $ ">2 1@A2 z 52 " ! G{ ! H p $ ! = $$ h32 % 2 ) 7 456 $ .1$ $ ">2 "2 $% 2 M?%2 $$ $%?! <"" ,>6 ,2%P ) 1A| '( #$%& $> g H . „ ? $& 6!2 Gƒ H p $ ! DP a paL R$ 7 456 $ <""| 1|32 v d1 1 O X%02 Kobasa " 2H = . $ 1 4&%2 XP ! z%2 L $ 1 O …a2 q| L$ 2 Y@6 ,> 6 $ # '2 (2 %"P ! $ E!`) $ #: = .(f*) $% { L $ $& $$ $%2 ! ! .a? . ! p #$%& †%P .(f+) 86 ; }. ! P; Downloaded from ijme.tums.ac.ir at 1:57 IRST on Saturday October 2nd 2021 H { ?$ "R 1 $& $$ 3 ! $>2 2H ! $& P.? # H <$% $ '( H $& = .(€€) % . "" 2 :6 p 12 o6 ! 1@ - %6 2 =6 q02 H 1 z $ "a a H G!2 #` ! g (6 $T6 " ! F'2 G 8 /%2 U6 }. ! Kobasa < 4P . % 2 . p ) $& = GW>6 . H 1@2 1 E ! ,( ! =3% < $ ! H @ |6 " ! >/2 $ ; O .(f€) $ X .... ! 8. ‡%? <H@2 ! lK"| e0>6 /S2 H ! 1 0? a@. 1& $ ) '( #$%& †%P %) ! %##$ (6 ! .(€r) 1 < , }36 1} . $% " ! a 06 ">2 Z2!;/ $! | n = ! # H ! P.? $|| $ K N% G}32 ! NW ! " „) > 1a a 12 ! 1 "2 $ }. ! > & .(fx) 1 $ ">2 ) #$a& '( #$%& ) …) $ ƒS2 ,2%P 2 Hardiness 1.L ! . ! ) $& G i%O "& $ 3 Commitment 4 Control 5 Challenging 1 Occupational Burnout -) 1 >%2 ! H p 1 $! $ $ . $ ,- H ) >2? = H | 4>2 }. ! Maddi .$$ K@ $ q0@2 ) •Š $>6 ( . r) 1 0 /!$ <.P !}:"| BL '.? H " ! #`! < ;# E!`) < <$$ H! ! <$ &$O6 <% H $ ">2 ! M/? N:6 =$ E# ?%6 , 3!`) $% G%i = E!`) ? n! . > @D 2 # H $ (6 | = ! $% ˆ ) $%?! M' H $% ) M"2 E >?2 H! H # "6 $! $& nH $ %6 2 1 ) ". ! (NOP ! L? '$ | "a %# .(€w) "2$% # H <% BŒ <$ 06 ) H 0& E ! $$ 1@A2 ! ! 12 <$%. N %. q:L "@2 ) $>6 3 P p "2 G ƒU6 !$ 12!42 s@"2 ‰ %"P <$ 1W M'? ! ' j W%6 H B) ! # E ) ! ! K H! H ! $ 2 E| N E!`) z =?! %. N X& H 0?%2 $ " ! .(ee e• eŠ) "| 2 $ 7452 ) 2 7@D BŒ .$%. 2 "| 2 ,.P •&52 Œ " 2 # H H3& ‹$%L t H B) ! <$ >?2 g $%2 E 1 z%6 " ! X%02 ^D H B) .(e\) u ; H C %) <%5 $%2 $ G5 W%6 $%2 <$a# G%i 3!`) (ee) Kobasa 1 $ ! <$$ $ 2"3) < .(€• ‚ rf) $$ >/2 '| . 2 ! s.? 3!`) $% z%6 > G>?2 ; 2 =$ g $ ! Ž%& M/2 ?%6 o2 <$$ , 836 H 7 456 $ <""| 1| 32 ) ? 7 456 1 0 /!$ . . $ H # ."$ | 4 K ,L ! $ " : ? H =$ g $ & <$% „2 ">2 = ) $%@ z ?! $& ! " ! ‚ 4 K H 6 q| <$% " o2 . ) $ '( #$%& Downloaded from ijme.tums.ac.ir at 1:57 IRST on Saturday October 2nd 2021 <% $ $& < „L %. H (1$ 2 ‚d . 2 ! =; ? ! N &$O6 . ) $ '( #$%& ! " ! 2"3) ) *+ M 66 = ! ! H '( #$%& " E ) ‚e . $ , .8 6 '( #$%& ! " ! . ) " ! #<H (r€) 2"3) ! " ! a42 ‚l 1 < =!6 H ) :6 . F'2 E ) '( #$%& @P . :" ) ! @P .?6 E!`) = =2 M 66 = <$ %52 @P n! H a ' H <!# 6 $ < .?6 a ' ^i H B) ! < $# a ' Z$:2 &# <!# 6 H =6 "R $ ( 0 .?6 ! 2"3) G{S ^i ! 1&# " ! 9 ) 4 0!) 8 56!)7 0 4 03!)! 2 /0 1 -. : , )* +) (* $2 ;# $% p 42 ‰ 2"3) = .1 H% 1 />& 2"3) q . =!6 q €x 0 HL .1 \ 6 ] „# <. "2$ <$2 dŠ „-| 14 2 " $2 t F'2 E $ ) XP <"$ 3 2"3) = $ q <. ! 1 [] 6 e\ 2"3) = $ <. "2$ .$$ MW ƒ2 | 7 456 $ .1 $& $ { " ! 6{ 2"3) = $ $& <. R „# <. p ]/Š• $%2H ,| •@ !| / ) .1 6 E ; ! |„2 $%2H ! ]/Šl V S2 $%2H <$ (•@ ! / ) !$ a. n! H ; :" / ; ? 7 456 $ .(rr) 2 ]/Š• 1 = <"$ 3 y/x• MW 2 1$ . Ž%& & ?%6 1 ]/•r <2 1$ •@ ! K!? $ .1 $% N%'2 ) H 2"3) = K!? $ .1 E 1W 2"3) = ) M W ! 2"3) q H <. ! H% 2"3) q H d <. .1 < t „# <. .1 < t „# <. 2"3) E!`) p 42 H $ 8 $ 2 )1 +,-. +/"0$ &'()* % !"#$ &,-;4 4 )81 4 +"#61 4 ) 4 #3 # &"#6 9 7 # < : 5 $H 2 U6 . ~2 =2 1 />& q.0 # .q" . ‘ $ g5/ ! C. t $ $%@0 2$ ! G32H q $ 2 | = d C;) %$ 7 2 /! "" . C. .q$ 2 X: 8. . 2$ a 8;) e Downloaded from ijme.tums.ac.ir at 1:57 IRST on Saturday October 2nd 2021 .q" 2 =& . # H & ) l .q" 2 8. 1 $ 2 )1 3% +"=()( &'()* % !"#$ d >)% @&4 @, +% @, BC #3 ? A D .$%3 N%'2 =2 # H /2 z | = H q .q" = 2U6 $% /2 H q % | = H q d .X„ X.6 q q e .X% <@ M862 q $ | = H q l .qa =’.2 ! F '86 X$% # H $%2 $ ‡ "# ! K#"1 GPD ! s.? $ 4 456 2"3) $ ,- ) H *+ 132 >/2 = '( #$%& 2"3) 1&# <$ $%2 $% E $ 1 0 /!$ . p 42 ! 1 KS dd ,2 1 Tedium $% K%(32 NOP ! L? '$ M' H # X g G ;# I G8 / F D ?$ $ 5 ! = 2 r <. K!? $ . X: ! < q g"6 __yff # <. "2$ J 3 . G! (2 $ < Ma G. $%2 ! ! DP .a? #$%& H @"? $%2 $%2H '( #$%& ! " ! ! % z%6 2"3) = .$ 2 E:" .1 < q g"6 = ) 4452 = . &# ! .?6 }. +/"0$ 1"( L )M1 N/1 7 a@. MW < :" 2HH n! 2"3) % +13$ +E +3()F +".& +"=()( O+,-. ; 2 ; WL 7 456 $ .(rw) $! 1$ r= ]/\• L )M1 N/1 )E" ! < :" !$ a. <% 2"3) = ) 1"( K!? $ . H N%'2 y/x• •@ ! / Ma •Š /\] [\ / ] ! '( #$%& 2"3) q H e <. .1 < t „# <. •Š /]] •‡ /]l &'()* % !"#$ D " ! 2 )1 Tedium +E +3()F •Š /ee Š• /[ '( #$%& '% HIJC +G4 @1 4 >)% #3 @, Y@6 %g"2 5 7 9 : < H $%2 $%2H '( #$%& ! " ! a ‚ _ Downloaded from ijme.tums.ac.ir at 1:57 IRST on Saturday October 2nd 2021 K!? $ Q | <$ % ) a@. MW #$a& paL ‚ f .1 <2 w <. 2 w <. K!? <$$ H %# . N% H! ‰ =$ ‚ € P< $ ">2 ]/] / j $ 7 456 (2 .a? g H ‚ r (2 H ) '( #$%& $ 2 3 1 $% <$%& . 1 „)ƒ 7 456 $ $%?%2 <$%& DP g H ‚ w PI N4 +/"QI% B#)6 R#) 5 $% (n=TU ) +E +3()F +".& +"=()( O+,-. +/"0$ /5% ‚ * 9 : < )E" ; 7 456 = $ " 1 >.? 2"3) 10 $ ““ ““ y/•f ‚ y/xy _ 4 = ) $%2H O GPD ! s.? ““ ““ ‚ y/xw _ ‚ y/xy " ! $ %# …) ! (....! 12 ““ ““ _ ‚ y/xw y/•f '( #$%& . 1&# 7 456 #"" 132 .1$ ">2 P< 0.01 j $ a@. ““ 9 ) 4 0!) 8 56!)7 0 4 03!)! 2 /0 1 -. : , )* +) (+ 4 1& 3() Y-. X.