DOCSLIB.ORG

Metrowest Phase 1- EAST Appraisal

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Metrowest Phase 1- EAST Appraisal MetroWest Phase 1 MetroWest Phase 1- EAST Appraisal Prepared for West of England July 2014 Burderop Park Swindon SN4 0QD +44 (0)1793 812479 +44 (0)1793 812089 Contents Section Page 1. Introduction ............................................................................................................................... 1‐1 1.1 What is MetroWest? .............................................................................................................. 1‐1 1.2 Business case requirements .................................................................................................. 1‐4 1.3 EAST assessment .................................................................................................................... 1‐4 1.4 Purpose and structure of this report ..................................................................................... 1‐5 2. The context and need for MetroWest Phase 1 ............................................................................ 2‐1 2.1 Introduction ........................................................................................................................... 2‐1 2.2 Understanding the current transport situation ..................................................................... 2‐1 2.2.1 Current transport and other policies ........................................................................ 2‐1 2.2.2 Current travel demand ............................................................................................. 2‐1 2.2.3 Current transport opportunities and constraints ..................................................... 2‐2 2.3 Understanding the future situation ....................................................................................... 2‐3 2.3.1 Future land uses and policies ................................................................................... 2‐3 2.3.2 Changes to the West of England transport system .................................................. 2‐3 2.3.3 Future travel demands.............................................................................................. 2‐4 2.4 The need for transport intervention ...................................................................................... 2‐4 2.4.1 Underlying causes ..................................................................................................... 2‐4 2.5 LTP and LEP objectives ........................................................................................................... 2‐4 2.6 Options considered for major schemes ................................................................................. 2‐5 3. MetroWest Phase 1 – WebTAG Appraisal Stage 1 – Steps 1 to 5 ................................................. 3‐1 3.1 Introduction ........................................................................................................................... 3‐1 3.2 Understanding the current rail situation ............................................................................... 3‐1 3.2.1 Current policy framework ......................................................................................... 3‐1 3.2.2 Current rail demand and levels of service ................................................................ 3‐1 3.2.3 Current rail opportunities and constraints ............................................................... 3‐3 3.3 Understanding the future rail situation ................................................................................. 3‐3 3.3.1 Future changes to the rail network and operation................................................... 3‐3 3.3.2 MetroWest Phase 2 .................................................................................................. 3‐4 3.3.3 Future rail demand ................................................................................................... 3‐4 3.4 The need for rail intervention ................................................................................................ 3‐6 3.5 Scheme‐specific objectives and geographical area of impact ............................................... 3‐7 3.6 MetroWest Phase 1 option generation and descriptions ...................................................... 3‐7 4. MetroWest Phase 1 – WebTAG Appraisal Stage 1 – Steps 6 ‐ EAST .............................................. 4‐1 4.1 Introduction ........................................................................................................................... 4‐1 4.2 Strategic Case ......................................................................................................................... 4‐1 4.2.1 Scale of Impact .......................................................................................................... 4‐1 4.2.2 Fit with wider transport and government objectives ............................................... 4‐2 4.2.3 Fit with other objectives ........................................................................................... 4‐3 4.2.4 Key uncertainties ...................................................................................................... 4‐3 4.2.5 Degree of consensus over outcomes ........................................................................ 4‐5 4.2.6 Summary of strategic case ........................................................................................ 4‐5 4.3 Economic Case ....................................................................................................................... 4‐5 4.3.1 Economic growth ...................................................................................................... 4‐5 4.3.2 Carbon emissions ...................................................................................................... 4‐9 METROWEST PHASE 1 EAST APPRAISAL III CONTENTS, CONTINUED Section Page 4.3.3 Socio‐distributional and regional impacts ................................................................. 4‐9 4.3.4 Local environment ................................................................................................... 4‐20 4.3.5 Wellbeing ................................................................................................................ 4‐22 4.3.6 Value for money ...................................................................................................... 4‐22 4.3.7 Summary of economic case..................................................................................... 4‐23 4.4 Managerial case.................................................................................................................... 4‐23 4.4.1 Implementation timetable ...................................................................................... 4‐23 4.4.2 Public acceptability .................................................................................................. 4‐23 4.4.3 Practical feasibility ................................................................................................... 4‐25 4.4.4 Quality of supporting evidence ............................................................................... 4‐26 4.4.5 Key risks ................................................................................................................... 4‐27 4.4.6 Summary of management case ............................................................................... 4‐27 4.5 Financial Case ....................................................................................................................... 4‐27 4.5.1 Affordability ............................................................................................................. 4‐27 4.5.2 Capital Cost (£m) ..................................................................................................... 4‐28 4.5.3 Revenue Costs (£m) ................................................................................................. 4‐28 4.5.4 Cost Profile .............................................................................................................. 4‐30 4.5.5 Overall cost risk and other costs ............................................................................. 4‐30 4.5.6 Summary of financial case ....................................................................................... 4‐30 4.6 Commercial Case .................................................................................................................. 4‐31 4.6.1 Flexibility of option .................................................................................................. 4‐31 4.6.2 Funding sources ....................................................................................................... 4‐31 4.6.3 Income generation .................................................................................................. 4‐31 4.6.4 Summary of commercial case ................................................................................. 4‐31 4.7 Summary and EAST forms .................................................................................................... 4‐31 Appendixes A LTB prioritisation B EAST Proformas Tables 2.1 Mode split data from CCAG bid 2.2 ORR Station usage information 3.1 ORR Historic patronage growth in West of England area 3.2 Network Rail LTPP Regional Urban Markets Study – Bristol area forecast growth 3.3 Options descriptions 4.1 Scale of impact 4.2 Fit against wider transport and government objectives 4.3 Fit against other objectives 4.4 Key uncertainties 4.5 Degree of consensus over outcomes 4.6 Economic growth 4.7
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Bristol Railway Work Update
    Bristol East Junction renewal This spring we begin renewing sections of main upgrade. It takes place over two straight track at Bristol East Junction, which weekends this spring: lies just outside Bristol Temple Meads in the • Saturday 25 and Sunday 26 April St Phillips area of the city. This is • Saturday 2 and Sunday 3 May preparatory work ahead of the full replacement of the junction next year. Weekend work will t hen be ongoing, though mostly concentrated around Saturday Ultimately the junction needs replacing due nights. until early autumn when we have two to its age, and this presents a fantastic further solid weekends planned for opportunity to remodel the layout at the September and October. Further detail same time. The full upgrade in summer about the remodelling of Bristol East 2021 will therefore not only increase Junction will be provided over the coming reliability, but it will also help to improve months. operational flexibility to support future rail growth. Working within the context of the current Overview pandemic we are carefully following The work we're starting this month to relay Government guidelines on COVID-19, t o This newsletter aims to update you on these straight sections of track at the fringes ensure the safety of our workers and prevent railway work in the Bristol area. There is a of thejunction will ease the workload for the spread of the virus. We are confident this whole programme of work for the next two next summer reducing the length of the work can be undertaken safely. years that is currently being planned.
    [Show full text]
  • Appendix F CAPABILITY MODELLING
    Ref: 139797 Version: 1.1 Date: June 2015 Appendix F CAPABILITY MODELLING Governance of Railway Investment Projects Ref: 139797 Version: 1.1 Date: June 2015 This page left deliberately blank Governance of Railway Investment Projects Group Strategy - Capability Analysis MetroWest Phase 2 Report Rhys Bowen Group Strategy – Capability Analysis MetroWest Phase 2 Report Document Control Scheme Name MetroWest Phase 2 Report Document Ref. No. Document V:\SAP-Project\CA000000 - MetroWest RSV8 TH\004 Report\Phase Two Location Version No. 1.0 Status Final Author Rhys Bowen Version Date 15/12/2014 Security Level Unrestricted Authorisation Control Lee Mowle Signature Date Project Manager –Capability Analysis (Document Owner) Alistair Rice Signature Date Major Schemes Project Manager - South Gloucester council Andrew Holley Signature Date Senior development Manager - Network Rail Group Strategy – Capability Analysis MetroWest Phase 2 Report DOCUMENT CONTROL & ADMINISTRATION Change Record Version Date Author(s) Comments 0.1 12/09/14 Rhys Bowen First Draft 0.2 17/09/14 Rhys Bowen Amended after diagrams added 0.3 18/09/14 Rhys Bowen Amended after review 0.4 23/09/14 Rhys Bowen Amended after review 0.5 26/09/14 Rhys Bowen Draft for external review 0.6 04/11/14 Rhys Bowen Final draft for internal review 0.7 07/11/14 Rhys Bowen Final draft for external review 0.8 28/11/14 Toby Hetherington Minor amendments to final draft. Further minor amendments and report 1.0 15/12/14 Toby Hetherington finalised. Reviewers Version Date Reviewer(s) Review Notes Structure
    [Show full text]
  • Summary of Comments - Lets Talk About Supported Transport
    APPENDIX C(1) Summary of comments - Lets talk about Supported Transport Aim of the consultation The consultation sought to engage a range of stakeholders in a debate about the savings the council needs to make with its spending on supported transport services and the opportunities to reconfigure these services following a tendering process and a reflection on some of the recent changes e.g. concessionary bus passes for older people. The consultation ran from 1 March 2011 and closed on 11 May – a period of just over 9 weeks. How was the consultation conducted The council used multiple channels to get the message out that it was seeking to engage people on these issues. The channels used were: • Press release • Leaflets on all buses, community transport vehicles, in doctors surgeries and newsagents • Posters at Park & Ride sites • A listing on the council’s Consultation Finder which details all the council’s consultation in one place on the internet: www.bristol.gov.uk/consultationfinder • Twitter • Facebook • Informed existing operators of supported transport services • Emails to equalities fora / letter to Bristol Older People’s Forum • Posters and information packs to all the council’s libraries In order to have an informed public debate about these issues, the ASK Bristol discussion site was used which gave an overview of the challenge and opportunities facing the council with these services. The site also allowed people to access detailed passenger, expenditure and subsidy information to help participants make an informed contribution to the debate. This information can be seen at: http://askbristol.wordpress.com/2011/03/02/lets-talk-about- supported-transport-services/ Access for those people NOT online For those people without internet access, paper copies of a briefing paper were sent to the council’s libraries along with a paper feedback form.
    [Show full text]
  • The Severn Beach Line
    el at * v a Standard network charges apply. Calls from mobiles may behigher. Callsfrommobilesmay apply. Standard networkcharges More information and news.Registerat specialdeals missoutonourlatest offers, Don’t Buy yourtrainticketsonlineat Earn Nectarpoints train times.Search Download ourapp to purchaseticketsandcheck 03457 000125* [email protected] GWR.com/contact Like us: us: Follow r T quieter times times facebook.com/GWRUK @GWRHelp (open 0600-2300daily) ace f GWR rain ering GWR.com/signup ear a T 16 May to 11 December 2021 ov GWR.com/Safety B8S W c in your App store inyour GWR.com our y ash W hands Redland Montpelier Sea Mills Down Clifton Shirehampton Avonmouth Severn Beach Severn Road Andrews St Bristol Temple Meads Temple Bristol Lawrence Hill Lawrence Stapleton Road Check before you travel, visit Travel with Confidence. Passenger Assist Large print timetables are available for our partially sighted customers. You can arrange help, check station accessibility, buy a ticket and reserve a seat by calling us on Call 03457 000 125* or email [email protected] Freephone 0800 197 1329 or by text relay * Standard network charges apply. Calls from mobiles may be higher. 18001 0800 197 1329 (open 0600 to 2300, 7 days a week, except Christmas Day). You may book assistance by completing the Access Ticket offi ce hours Ticket Bike online booking form available on our website. Station CRS Operator Category Weekdays Saturdays Sundays machine Toilets Car Park Rack Station accessibility Avonmouth AVN GW B Unstaffed Unstaffed Unstaffed D D All
    [Show full text]
  • Progress Report February 2019
    PROGRESS REPORT Published February 2019 Linking local communities with the rail industry To Cardiff Gloucester To Birmingham Severn Pilning To Cardiff Beach Welcome to the Severnside Community Yate Rail Partnership’s 2019 Progress Report Patchway To Swindon To Swindon Cam & Dursley St Andrew’s Road The Severnside Community Rail Partnership Our rail familiarisation programme for year-six To is the link between local communities and the primary school pupils is designed to ensure Bristol Parkway Cardiff Filton Abbey rail industry. We cover the network of routes those attending a school within walking Avonmouth Wood radiating from Bristol, bounded by Gloucester, distance of a station experience at least one Sea Mills Bath/Freshford, Weston-super-Mare, Taunton, rail journey so they have confidence to use the Pilning and the Severn Estuary; this includes the local railway independently, as they progress Shirehampton Montpelier Severn Yate To Swindon branch line to Severn Beach. to secondary school. We also negotiated an Redland Stapleton Road Beach innovative, low cost season ticket scheme for Bristol Parkway We work with local communities and a range of some secondary school pupils. Bristol Clifton Down Lawrence Hill partners to Toidentify andSwindon implement measures to Bristol Temple Meads To Swindon ensure that access to local stations is easy and A top prize-winning Partnership Temple Meads that stations are safe and welcoming. Many of our schemes have won Awards – Parson Street Bedminster Nailsea & Keynsham We have sponsored, organised and arranged Backwell and last October the Partnership’s work was Yatton Oldfield Park funding packages for community-based recognised nationally when we received the Worle Bath Spa improvements at over half the local stations.
    [Show full text]
  • Ten Year Rail Delivery Plan 2030 to 2045 25 Year SOBC
    TEN YEAR RAIL DELIVERY PLAN DECEMBER 2020 West of England 10 Year Rail Delivery Plan for Investment: 2020 – 2030 November 2020 Document Control Document title West of England 10 Year Rail Delivery Plan Version and date v1 24/04/2020 v2 27/04/2020 Shared with Network Rail v3 09/06/2020 Issued to Strategic Rail Programme Board 09/06/2020 v4 15/07/2020 Issued to Strategic Rail Programme Steering Group 12/08/2020 v5 23/09/2020 Issued to Strategic Rail Working Group 25/09/2020 v6 16/10/2020 Issued to Strategic Rail Working Group and Strategic Rail Programme Steering Group on 16/10/2020. Minor changes made. v7 10/11/2020 Minor changes made following Transport Board on 04/11/2020 and other comments. v7.1 27/11/2020 Minor changes following comments made at Leaders and Mayor’s meeting Author James White, WECA Reviewed by Tamsin Dangerfield, Network Rail Strategic Rail Programme Steering Group Strategic Rail Working Group 1 Contents Introduction Summary 1. Objectives for the 10 Year Rail Delivery Plan 2. What all schemes need to demonstrate 3. Beyond Coivd-19 - legacy and future planning 4. Existing schemes for delivery in the first five years of the 10 Year Rail Delivery Plan 5. Pipeline Projects, New Stations Fund, Restoring Your Railway and other schemes that could come forward 2020 to 2030 6. New schemes for delivery and development 2020 to 2030 – Table One 7. Business Case approach to delivering schemes 8. Governance 9. Programme 10. Funding 11. Risks 12. Longer term – 25 Year Strategic Outline Business Case 13.
    [Show full text]
  • Tfgb Bristol Bath Rapid Transit Plan
    A RAPID TRANSIT PLAN FOR BRISTOL AND BATH CONTENTS Executive Summary ........................................................ 2 Introduction: Bristol Deserves Rapid Transit ................... 5 A Phased Programme ..................................................... 10 Main Paper Aims and Constraints ..................................................... 14 1. Transport aims 2. Practicalities 3. Politics Proposed Rapid Transit lines ........................................ 19 Bristol .......................................................................... 19 Bath ............................................................................. 33 Staffing, Organisation and Negotiations ......................... 36 Suggested Programme (Bristol area only) ........................ 36 Appendix:TfGB’s Bristol Rapid Transit Map ..................... 37 tfgb.org v51 17-09-20 Map by Tick Ipate 1 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY These proposals for a twenty-first century transport system are not from a single- issue lobby group; Transport for Greater Bristol (TfGB) offers a comprehensive package of transport and environment measures which builds on the emerging good practice found across the region such as MetroWest, the City Bus Deal in Bristol and the well-organised bus-rail interchange at Bath Spa. As we emerge from the special circumstances of the Covid crisis we need modern transport planning for active travel, health, opportunity, inclusion, social justice, and action on climate change. It’s also good for business. Mass transit is again being discussed in
    [Show full text]
  • Severnnet Area Travel Plan Covering Royal Portbury Dock, Avonmouth and Severnside 2015 - 2020
    SevernNet Area Travel Plan Covering Royal Portbury Dock, Avonmouth and Severnside 2015 - 2020 SevernNet Area Travel Plan Document history Template Travel Plan This document has been issued and amended as follows: Verified Version Date Description Created by Approved by by 00_01 31.12.2014 Initial draft Abigail Philip Philip Wright, created. Smith Wright UA Leads 00_02 13.01.2015 Amendments Abigail Philip Philip Wright made based Smith Wright and Kate on UA Lead Royston feedback received. Contents 1 Executive Summary 1 2 Introduction 2 2.1 Implementing the Travel Plan 3 2.1.1 SevernNet 3 2.1.2 Travel Plan Working Group 3 2.1.3 Stakeholders 3 2.1.4 Budget 4 2.2 National Policy 4 2.3 Local Policy 4 3 Existing Travel Situation 5 3.1 Introduction 5 3.2 Site Location 5 3.3 About the organisation and its activities 7 3.3.1 Businesses in Severn Approach – South Gloucestershire 7 3.3.2 Businesses in Avonmouth – Bristol 8 3.3.3 Businesses in Royal Portbury Dock – North Somerset 8 3.4 Site Assessment and Access 8 3.4.1 Sustrans site audit 133 3.5 Reducing the need to travel 144 3.6 Travel Surveys 14 3.6.1 Strategic Employment Sites Case Study (SES) 155 3.7 Results of Travel Survey and Other Monitoring Activities 155 4 Travel Plan Objectives & Targets 188 4.1 Introduction 188 4.2 Objectives 188 4.3 Targets 188 5 Action Plan 199 6 Monitoring and Review 211 6.1 Introduction 211 6.2 Future travel surveys 211 6.3 Other future monitoring activities 211 6.4 Review 211 6.5 Useful information 222 Appendices 25 SevernNet Area Travel Plan 1 Executive Summary The Ports area continues to suffer from a severe shortage of public transport into [some parts] and across the area which effectively excludes non-car owners from work in many areas.
    [Show full text]
  • Aeb6-2D26570fe208
    Contents VISION 1 CHAPTER 5 WIDENING CHOICE 41 CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION 3 Moving People 41 Success to date 3 Public Transport 41 Community Involvement and Participation 3 Buses 41 Focused Participation 4 Bus-Based Park & Ride 45 Joint Working with Neighbouring Authorities 5 Community Transport 45 A Radical Strategy 7 Taxis 47 Working Towards the Solution: Key Elements 7 Coaches 48 Centre of Excellence Bid 8 Rail 49 CHAPTER 2 OBJECTIVES 11 Light Rapid Transit 52 National Guidance 11 Bristol Electric Railbus 56 Local Transport Plan Objectives 11 Ferries 58 European Objectives 11 Interchange 58 Air Quality Management 11 Benign Modes 59 Regional objectives 13 Walking 59 Former Avon Area 13 Cycling 63 Bristol Local Transport Plan 13 Safer Routes to School (and case study) 68 (including user priority groups) Disabled People 74 Social Exclusion (and case studies) 76 CHAPTER 3 PROBLEMS AND 17 Airport Surface Access Strategy 80 OPPORTUNITIES Community Car Clubs 80 Motorised Modes 81 CHAPTER 4 STRATEGY 29 Cars 81 Introduction 29 Powered Two Wheelers 82 The link between strategy and 29 Moving Goods 83 the 5 year programme Rail Freight 83 Five Year Plan 31 Road Freight 83 Technical Assessment of 32 Ports 86 Preferred Strategy (and case study) Waterways 86 Presenting the programme in detail 32 Major Highway Improvements 87 Callington Road Link 87 A38 to A370 Link 89 The image of the Rubik’s Cube® is used by permission of Severn Towns Ltd, London, England. Maps contained within this document are based upon the Ordnance survey mapping with the permission of the Controller of Her Majesty’s Stationery Office © Crown copyright.
    [Show full text]
  • Non-Technical Summary
    PORTISHEAD BRANCH LI NE PRELIMINARY ENVIRONMENTAL INFORMAT I O N R E P O R T V O L U M E 1 Non-Technical Summary PORTISHEAD BRANCH LINE PRELIMINARY NON-TECHNICAL SUMMARY ENVIRONMENTAL INFORMATION REPORT, VOLUME 1 Table of Contents Section Page 1 Non-Technical Summary ............................................................................................... 1-1 1.1 Introduction ............................................................................................................... 1-1 1.2 Study Area .................................................................................................................. 1-3 1.3 Scheme Development and Alternatives Considered ................................................. 1-9 1.4 Description of the Proposed Works ......................................................................... 1-11 1.5 Approach to the Environmental Statement ............................................................ 1-21 1.6 The Planning Framework ......................................................................................... 1-23 1.7 Air Quality ................................................................................................................ 1-24 1.8 Cultural Heritage ...................................................................................................... 1-25 1.9 Ecology and Biodiversity .......................................................................................... 1-28 1.10 Ground Conditions ..................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Portishead Branch Line (Metrowest Phase 1) TR040011 Applicant: North Somerset District Council
    Portishead Branch Line (MetroWest Phase 1) TR040011 Applicant: North Somerset District Council 8.4 Outline Business Case 2017, Part 1 of 3, Addendum to Outline Business Case The Infrastructure Planning (Applications: Prescribed Forms and Procedure) Regulations 2009, regulation 5(2)(q). NB. required by para 4.5 of NN NPS Planning Act 2008 Author: North Somerset District Council Date: November 2019 Document Purpose Part 1 of 3 comprises: o Addendum to Outline Business Case (May 2019) This document updates the Outline Business Case (December 2017). The document refers to the promoters business name North Somerset Council, rather than its legal name North Somerset District Council. 1 MetroWest Phase 1 Addendum to the Outline Business Case - 2nd May 2019 Contents Page 1. Background 2 2. Summary of the Outline Business Case (December 2017) 3 3. Summary of Changes to the Scheme since December 2017 4 2 1. Background 1.1 The Outline Business Case (OBC) for MetroWest Phase 1 was submitted to the Department for Transport in December 2017 as part of Large Local Major Scheme bid for funding. The OBC was subject to DfT technical scrutiny in early 2018. 1.2 The West of England (WoE) Councils comprising of Bath & North East Somerset, Bristol City, North Somerset and South Gloucestershire, together with the West of England Combined Authority are progressing plans to deliver a series of strategic enhancements to the local rail network over the next five years and beyond, through the MetroWest Programme. The aim of the MetroWest Programme is to establish a ‘Metro’ local rail network, similar to comparable sized city regions, through targeted investment in strategic rail corridors, including existing lines, freight only lines and dis- used lines.
    [Show full text]
  • Henbury Line the West of England Councils Are Getting on With
    Information Sheet 10 Issue 1: August 2013 Henbury Line The West of England councils are getting on with reopening the Henbury Line to passengers and have never ruled out aspirations for a loop service via the Severn Beach Line. Unfortunately it is not yet ready to carry regular passenger trains and neither are the potential station sites ready for use at short notice. We are, however, starting the detailed technical work required to justify reopening the line. Back in early 2012 we commissioned consultant Halcrow to look at options to improve local rail services. Reporting in Spring 2012 they recommended a phased approach to implementing MetroWest. Phase 2 includes re-introducing passenger services on the Henbury Line and half hourly services to Yate. A phased approach to rail improvements This phased approach to MetroWest was the Halcrow work and re-examine agreed by the West of England’s Joint whether the Henbury Line is best served Transport Executive Committee on 12 by a ‘spur’ or ‘loop’ service. Options for December 2012 and at the Local the most appropriate timetable, locations Transport Body Board on 14 June 2013 for up to two new stations, (see Information Sheet 9 on track/signalling improvements required, www.travelwest.info/infosheets). Hence forecasts of passenger numbers, Phase 1 is the main focus, working up operating costs and subsidies and value proposals for a reopened Portishead Line for money will all be looked at. The and half hourly services on the Severn results will help us to build a business case Beach Line and local station to Bath.
    [Show full text]