Troy, Baden Culture and Corded Ware 261
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Troy, Baden Culture and Corded Ware 261 M Raiko Krauß1 The 4th millennium BC in many ways is a time of change in southeastern Europe. After the discontinuation of tell-settlements in the Carpathian Basin and the eastern Balkan area one can see the formation of archaeologically <;<$_<;\Z economy. Simultaneously, burial rites show a tradition whose roots lie as far back as the 5th millennium BC. Against the background of the changing settlement pattern, the transfer of technical innovations over wide areas of Europe is also noticeable – such as the use of the wheel and wagon, as well as a generally increased use of animal labour. Compared to the 5th!9@[[;;< ;@Z};Z[$_};¢6 monopoly leadership in the production and use of metals. At the end of the 4th millennium, interrelated cultural groups @9;*};)[}<!& Age culture. On the basis of new radiocarbon dates from a late Baden settlement in the west of present-day Romania, @9;;9;!;;Z}<!& Aegean and the Final Neolithic in central Europe will be discussed. !69;}<!&!99 _;_<RZ[<;;- Z9Z};¢$2 The chronomet- ric dating revolution, facilitated by calibrated radiocarbon dating, made this acknowledgment ;$_@}<!&9; Z[Z<@directly connect the two occurrences. Chronologically, the ‘Baden’ phenomenon occurs before Corded Z}<!&3 geographically, it is lo- @@$'/87&;; between the two areas.4 A short time after, calibrated radiocarbon dates revealed that Baden 9;<}<!& [<$5 The thesis that the Baden phenomenon emerged from the migra- tion of populations from northwestern Anatolia6 was thus fundamentally refuted. This resulted \<Z<@@;;Z @!69;$Z[ is now time for a renewed discussion concerning these relationships. A small, 15m266&@Z;6<^;- ;[<[@th and 1 Institute of Pre- and Protohistory and Mediaeval Archaeology, Eberhard Karls University, Tübingen, Germany; email: [email protected]. 2 Korfmann – Kromer 1993; Furholt 2003; Kromer et al. 2003. 3 Stadler et al. 2001. 4 &/87$ 5 ;"/07D#6/07D#6/0//5*7$ 6 &/875M50$ 262 Raiko Krauß $!>[ZZ7M 6&^!$ 3rd !9$"@ZZ@ on the cultural relationships between northwestern Anatolia and the Carpathian Basin.7 7 Krauß – Ciobotaru 2014. Troy, Baden Culture and Corded Ware 263 $!>[ZZ7M 6&^!$ @^@_2@!^;;- < @Z_2$'/<Z_;- @Z!_2<#- @Z<#;~X&$' ;[6$Z@Z!9 in its later variant, Kostolac, is of particular relevance to the topic of this volume. The feature ZZ<< 6;@Z}<!& 264 Raiko Krauß Age level.5_@@<[@Z}<!& of the Nagyrév Culture.9 [;<ZZ!>6Z 7M ~$M@@\$Z@ indentation- and scratch-ornamentation. Additionally, there are two conical spindle whorls, which [;Z!9$Z indentation- and scratch-ornamentation is also seen on a fully-reconstructed large vessel, which ;@ZZ!9~$7$'Z clear typological parallels, 1496@¢;$ The series consists of four AMS-dates from three cattle bones and one sheep bone, dating to the 5th to 26th centuries BC. 'ZZ!9Z 6&<$_Z!69[Z6 !7[ZZ7th century10;<!&&Zbegin- ning of the Baden development. The length of the ‘Baden’ phenomenon, particularly its end, has <$Z6&;@ ¢<6;;[Z!9;- ;<7!911 can no longer be upheld.12 In fact, it becomes apparent that the classical !&~/th century. Accordingly, the late phase of Baden Cul- ture in its southern variant Kostolac, and in its northern counterpart, the Bošáca variant, must date relatively later.13 Thus, in the northern Carpathian Basin region, a temporal parallelism between !9Z9$ There are now multiple data series from the northern region of the Carpathian Basin which, Z6&<ZZ!9 into the 26th<~_$$ The settlement of Bronocice, at the northern edge of the Beskids,14 is considered the north- [@!Z$_!- <Z!9;;< 7!9~<'$Z!!~< closed series of seven 1496<@¢Z/0 /<$;Z@@ @@@5M!9$15 This late onset of the end of Baden [<@Z!P&6_P^P$16 Accordingly the early classical Baden begins around 3200 calBC and ends around 2900 calBC, roughly corresponding to the range proposed by Stadler et al.17 of 3360–2930 calBC for the entire classical Baden. The new Hungar- @;;$/!9Zlater development Z!@Z#68/!9$5 _6;Z8!9ZZ!$_Z !;<<[<ZZ!&$19 Con- 5 %M9[$5M/$ 9 Krauß – Ciobotaru 2014, pls. 5–26. 10 De Capitani et al. 2002, 209–216. 11 9Z$//5 *77$ 12 <<//780*@& 5055$ 13 Cf. Siklósi 2009, 462–465. 14 Kruk – Milisauskas 1990. 15 Kruk – Milisauskas 1990, 223–227. 16 "$5$ 17 Stadler et al. 2001. 5 "$5[$$ 19 !M^&</$ Troy, Baden Culture and Corded Ware 265 ¢<@;6!&6!&6@6 within the 3640–3370 calBC time span. Graves with grave goods from classical Baden Culture <Z@Z77 M55!9$20*[<!M M[;;!&$9;Z!P&6_P^P Z6&;;;/th century and ends by the 27th or perhaps the 26th<!9$Q!;R;@" 9!@@;9[;;Z 9$'Z!9Z Z@<*@&$21 This may, however, be related to the fact that the later groups from the Baden Culture were not more widespread in the west.222324 $7!>;Z6&^!5$5$ 20 Siklósi 2009, 462–465. 21 //5 $ 22 %9$ 23 //$ 24 "$5$ 266 Raiko Krauß Material J13C Site/Reference Lab-Code Context 14C-Age [BP] Phase (species) [‰PDB] Foeni-Gaz22 1 Hd-29516 Feature 5 ~ 0/5 –21,2 Bad./Kostolac 2 *65/7 Feature 3 ~ 8/8 –27,2 Bad./Kostolac 3 *65/7 Feature 3 ~ 77/ –20.2 Bad./Kostolac 4 MAMS-11203 Feature 3 ~ /0 –17.3 Bad./Kostolac Bronocice23 1 DIC-1792 3-B4 charcoal 5/ n.d. ~! 2 DIC-1740 10-B5 charcoal 5/8 n.d. ~! 3 DIC-1795 4-B3 charcoal // n.d. ~! 4 DIC-979 56!0 charcoal /8 n.d. ~! 5 %'96/05 1-A5 charcoal / n.d. ~! 6 DIC-1794 86!5 charcoal 8/0 n.d. ~! 7 DIC-543 2-B2 charcoal 7/7 n.d. ~! 5 DIC-361 39-B1 charcoal / n.d. '>~! 9 DIC-977 6!5 charcoal 7/ n.d. '~! 10 DIC-1736 56-A1 charcoal 77/8 n.d. '~! 11 DIC-1797 6-B2 charcoal 7/0 n.d. '~! 12 DIC-1739 95-B1 charcoal 7/0 n.d. '~! 13 DIC-541 54-B1 charcoal /5 n.d. '~! 14 DIC-717 29-A3 charcoal /5 n.d. '~! U 1 %6775 ;85/ animal bone / –19.3 EC-Baden U U24 2 %6775/ 70;5/ human bone /7 –19.2 EC-Baden 3 Deb-13245 grave 50, pit 2019 human bone / –19.7 EC-Baden 4 %67750 pit 426 charcoal 7/ –24.5 EC-Baden 5 %67758 pit 2596 animal bone 77/7 –19.4 EC-Baden 6 %6775 pits 1072-1096 animal bone 78/ –20.2 EC-Baden 7 Deb-13292 grave 67, pit 426 human bone 75/ –19.7 EC-Baden 5 Deb-13374 pit 1036 animal bone 7//8 –19.9 EC-Baden 9 Deb-13244 pit 203 ~ /8 –20.3 !& 10 Deb-13412 pit 1612 ~ /0 –19.9 !& 11 %6758 grave 79, pit 2635 human bone / –19.4 !& 12 Deb-13411 pit 2060 animal bone / –19.5 !& 13 Deb-13395 grave 74, pit 2614 animal bone 8/ –20.3 !& 14 Deb-13379 well 1, pit 1099 human bone 5/0 –20.6 !& 15 Deb-13277 grave 23, pit 426 n.d. /8 –19.9 !& 16 Deb-13291 pits 2327-2346 animal bone /5 –20.4 !& 17 %677/5 ; 5 animal bone 85/ –20.9 !& Budakalász4 1 }^67 5 human bone 0/ –22.6 !&>! 2 }^67 grave 174 human bone / –21.7 !&>! 3 }^67 7 grave 75 human bone / / M/$5 !&>! 4 }^67 / 705 human bone 7/7 –19.6 !&>! 5 }^6708 grave 19 human bone 70/7 –20.1 !&>! 6 }^67 0 5 human bone 70 /7 M5$0 !&>! 7 }^675 757 human bone / –20.5 !&>! 5 }^670 grave 13a human bone /7 –21.6 !&>! 9 }^670/ grave 252 human bone / –23.1 !&>! 10 }^67 5 5 human bone /7 –21.5 !&>! 11 }^67 8 5 human bone /7 M$5 !&>! 12 }^6700 grave 142b human bone 8/ –22.3 !&>! 13 }^6705 grave 230 human bone 8 / –22.9 !&>! 14 }^675 grave 403 human bone /7 –21.0 !&>! _$@~Z!Z!699; ~}9}<9$ Troy, Baden Culture and Corded Ware 267 In the northwestern Carpathian Basin region, in particular, signs pointing to a symbiotic rela- ;@!9Z$[& of the Moravian Bošáca group is still clearly in the Baden tradition.25 Typological correlations are Z\;Z<;6; vessels in the Baden tradition.26 A boundary line, between the late Baden groups of the Carpathian !<Z9 <Z[$Z;<Z&- 6'&Z_<Z@impresso motif in the Baden tradition rather than the later, customary cording.27 In the northern Carpathian region, it is 9;6 ;@Z@![@9 $5 ;Z9;6 ;}6 Slovakian region to the Danube,2996;; within the Carpathian Basin after 2600 calBC.30 Only after the encroachment of the Bell-Beaker phenomenon in the Carpathian Basin, in the 26th/25th century, do Baden pottery elements become @QZR$';@;;@ 9;6;<$_@ >"6531*<6$32 Z@ZZ!9;^0th, or even the 26th<[<;<6;Z Baden Culture’s relationship to the south is also of great interest.33 In retrospect, a clear paral- @<<Z_<;[- <@;_<''Z~$$_;Z!9 ¢<;<Z}<!& Z}&_;$34 This phenomenon was determined 30 years <D#6Z<;;14C-data available at the time.35}&¢/th5th;6 phase.36 In the lower reaches of the Danube, the last offshoots of the Copper-Age tell-cultures !@9;'''$6Zth [^Z%~$$9;Z @"2XZ!<6; ~$$"6;<[$ !9%9;9XZ9- ;Z$_<Z9XZ!6 Kostolac-pottery are, indeed, blurred here as well.37 Moreover, with regards to burial customs 9XZ;;!;$_- [@;@!*@% 25 6/5$ 26 6/5;$'''$ 27 M//[$$78$/$ 5 /5/5$ 29 /5[$ $ 30 Furholt 2003, 136. 31 Bertemes – Heyd 2002. 32 &6*M&//5$ 33 9Z$ & /87 ;" /07 D#6 /07 D#6 /0 //5 Sherratt 2003.