Arxiv:2009.04811V1 [Physics.Gen-Ph]
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE DIRAC EQUATION AND THE MAJORANA DIRAC EQUATION Louis H Kauffman Department of Mathematics, Statistics and Computer Science 851 South Morgan Street University of Illinois at Chicago Chicago, Illinois 60607-7045 and Department of Mechanics and Mathematics Novosibirsk State University Novosibirsk, Russia <kauff[email protected]> Peter Rowlands Physics Department University of Liverpool Oliver Lodge Laboratory Oxford Street Liverpool L69 7ZE <[email protected]> arXiv:2009.04811v1 [physics.gen-ph] 7 Sep 2020 1 Introduction We discuss the structure of the Dirac equation and how the nilpo- tent and the Majorana operators arise naturally in this context. This provides a link between Kauffman’s work on discrete physics, iterants and Majorana Fermions [4, 5, 6, 7, 11, 8, 10, 9] and the work on nilpotent structures and the Dirac equation of Peter Rowlands [17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22]. We give an expression in split quaternions for the Majorana Dirac equation in one dimension of time and three dimensions of space. 2 Louis H Kauffman , Peter Rowlands In [13] Majorana discovered a version of the Dirac equation that can be expressed entirely over the real numbers. This led him to speculate that the solutions to his version of the Dirac equation would correspond to particles that are their own anti- particles. It is the purpose of this paper to examine the structure of this Majorana-Dirac Equation, and to find basic solutions to it by using the nilpotent technique. We succeed in this aim and describe our results. The Majorana-Dirac equation can be written as follows: (∂/∂t +ˆηη∂/∂x + ǫ∂/∂y +ˆǫη∂/∂z ǫˆηηmˆ )ψ =0 − where η and ǫ are the simplest generators of iterant algebra with η2 = ǫ2 = 1 and ηǫ + ǫη = 0, and ˆǫ, ηˆ form a copy of this al- gebra that commutes with it. This combination of the simplest Clifford algebra with itself is the underlying structure of Majorana Fermions, forming indeed the underlying structure of all Fermions. We show how to make nilpotent formulations for Majorana Dirac equations and consequently how to solve these equations via Ma- jorana operators. Here is a concise background about Fermions that will be of use for the rest of this paper. The operator algebra for a Fermion is given by creation and annihilation operators U † and U satisfying 2 2 the equations U = (U †) = 0 and UU † +U †U = 1 [23]. Call an al- gebra generated by U and U † a Fermion algebra if it satisfies these equations. For this introduction make the following well-known re- mark: Suppose that we are given a Clifford algebra with generators a and b so that s2 = b2 = 1 and ab + ba = 0. It is assumed that a† = a and that b† = b. Then we obtain a Fermion algebra from this Clifford algebra by defining U = (a+ib)/2 and U † = (a ib)/2 − where i = √ 1. The reader will have no difficulty verifying this − assertion. It has been suggested [12, 3] that electrons or other Fermions might behave, under certain circumstances, as if the electron was composed of two particles corresponding to this decomposition into The Dirac Equation and the Majorana Dirac Equation 3 operators a and b. Furthermore, since a and b are invariant un- der conjugation ( ), it has been suggested that the particles cor- † responding to a and b are Majorana Fermions, particles that are their own anti-particles. The reason for this nomenclature goes back to the paper of Majorana [13] where he constructed a ver- sion of the Dirac equation based on real Clifford algebra so the solutions could model particles that were their own anti-particles. It has been a subject of speculation whether such particles exist. The recent suggestion that electrons themselves are composed of Majorana particles is startling to say the least. Some experimental evidence is availiable for this hypothesis in terms of the behaviour of electrons in nano-wires [1, 14]. Thus we call the operators a and b the Majorana operators related to the Fermion algebra. Note that a = (U + U †) and b = (U U †)/i. − While it has been natural to say that the operators a and b are Majorana operators, their relationship to the Majorana Dirac equation has hitherto been obscure. One purpose of this paper is to show how indeed there are real solutions to the Majorana Dirac equation that are built in terms of the Majorana operators. This paper is organized as follows: Section 2 introduces the Dirac equation, its nilpotent reformulation and the appearance of algebraic Fermion operators as nilpotent algebra elements support- ing solutions to the Dirac equation. We explain the formulation of the Majorana-Dirac operator as described above. In Section 3 we use a nilpotent reformulation of the Majorana-Dirac opera- tor to find real solutions to the Majorana-Dirac equation and we show how the Clifford algebra of Majorana operators is related to these solutions. In a separate section we give real solutions to the Majorana-Dirac equation specialized to one dimension of space and one dimension of time. We rewrite this specialization in terms of light-cone coordinates and compare our results with the Feyn- man Checkerboard model [2, 6]. In Section 4 we reformulate the Dirac equation in terms of spacetime algebra by which we mean a Clifford algebra generated by elements e1,e2,e3,e4 where all pairs 4 Louis H Kauffman , Peter Rowlands of distinct generators anti-commute and the first three generators square to 1 while the last (e ) squares to 1. We prove that the 4 − Dirac operator can be written in the form ∂/∂t + e1∂/∂x + e2∂/∂y + e3∂/∂z + e4m and that it can be converted to the nilpotent form if and only if there is an element µ such that µ2 = 1 and µe ,µe ,µe ,µe are − 1 2 3 4 generators for a new spacetime algebra. We then use this result to classify all possible spacetime algebras that can be used to make Majorana-Dirac operators. In Section 5 we discuss the physics of our results from the point of view of Peter Rowlands. Section 6 is a concluding summary. 2 The Dirac Equation and Majorana Fermions We construct the Dirac equation. If the speed of light is equal to 1 (by convention), then energy E, momentum p and mass m are related by the (Einstein) equation E2 = p2 + m2. Dirac constructed his equation by looking for an algebraic square root of p2 + m2 so that he could have a linear operator for E that would take the same role as the Hamiltonian in the Schroedinger equation. We will get to this operator by first taking the case where p is a scalar (we use one dimension of space and one dimension of time.). Let E = αp + βm where α and β are elements of a possibly non-commutative, associative algebra. Then E2 = α2p2 + β2m2 + pm(αβ + βα). Hence we will satisfiy E2 = p2+m2 if α2 = β2 = 1 and αβ+βα =0. This is a familiar Clifford algebra pattern. Note that this algebra can be represented by 2 2 matrices with × 1 0 α = − 0 1 The Dirac Equation and the Majorana Dirac Equation 5 and 0 1 β = . 1 0 Then, because the quantum operator for momentum is i∂/∂x and − the operator for energy is i∂/∂t, we have the Dirac equation i∂ψ/∂t = iα∂ψ/∂x + βmψ. − Let = i∂/∂t + iα∂/∂x βm O − so that the Dirac equation takes the form ψ(x, t)=0. O Now note that i(px Et) i(px Et) e − = (E αp βm)e − . O − − We let ∆ = (E αp βm) − − and let U = ∆βα = (E αp βm)βα = βαE + βp αm, − − − then U 2 = E2 + p2 + m2 =0. − This nilpotent element leads to a (plane wave) solution to the Dirac equation as follows: We have shown that ψ = ∆ψ O i(px Et) for ψ = e − . It then follows that (βα∆βαψ) = ∆βα∆βαψ = U 2ψ =0, O from which it follows that i(px Et) ψ = βαUe − is a (plane wave) solution to the Dirac equation. 6 Louis H Kauffman , Peter Rowlands In fact, this calculation suggests that we should multiply the operator by βα on the right, obtaining the operator O = βα = iβα∂/∂t + iβ∂/∂x αm, D O − and the equivalent Dirac equation ψ =0. D i(px Et) In fact for the specific ψ above we will now have (Ue − )= 2 i(px Et) D U e − = 0. This idea of reconfiguring the Dirac equation in relation to nilpotent algebra elements U is due to Peter Rowlands [17]. Rowlands does this in the context of vector (Clifford) and quaternion algebra. Note that the solution to the Dirac equation that we have found is expressed in Clifford algebra. It can be articu- lated into specific vector solutions by using a matrix representation of the algebra. We see that U = βαE + βp αm with U 2 = 0 is − the essence of this plane wave solution to the Dirac equation. This means that a natural non-commutative algebra arises directly and can be regarded as the essential information in a Fermion. It is natural to compare this algebra structure with algebra of creation and annihilation operators that occur in quantum field theory. To this end we recapitulate and start again in the next subsection. 2.1 U and U † i(px Et) We start with ψ = e − and the operators Eˆ = i∂/∂t and pˆ = i∂/∂x so that Eψˆ = Eψ andpψ ˆ = pψ. The Dirac operator − is = Eˆ αpˆ βm O − − and the modified Dirac operator is = βα = βαEˆ + βpˆ αm, D O − so that ψ = (βαE + βp αm)ψ = Uψ.