Access Time of Emergency Vehicles Under the Condition of Street Blockages After a Large Earthquake
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ISPRS Annals of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, Volume IV-4/W1, 2016 1st International Conference on Smart Data and Smart Cities, 30th UDMS, 7–9 September 2016, Split, Croatia ACCESS TIME OF EMERGENCY VEHICLES UNDER THE CONDITION OF STREET BLOCKAGES AFTER A LARGE EARTHQUAKE N. Hirokawa a*, T. Osaragi b a Dept. of Mechanical and Environmental Informatics, Tokyo Institute of Technology, Meguro-ku, Tokyo, - [email protected] b School of Environment and Society, Tokyo Institute of Technology, Meguro-ku, Tokyo, - [email protected] KEY WORDS: Earthquake, Street Blockages, Agent-based Simulation, Emergency Vehicle, Accessibility, Information Collection ABSTRACT: The previous studies have been carried out on accessibility in daily life. However it is an important issue to improve the accessibility of emergency vehicles after a large earthquake. In this paper, we analyzed the accessibility of firefighters by using a microscopic simulation model immediately after a large earthquake. More specifically, we constructed the simulation model, which describes the property damage, such as collapsed buildings, street blockages, outbreaks of fires, and fire spreading, and the movement of firefighters from fire stations to the locations of fires in a large-scale earthquake. Using this model, we analyzed the influence of the street-blockage on the access time of firefighters. In case streets are blocked according to property damage simulation, the result showed the average access time is more than 10 minutes in the outskirts of the 23 wards of Tokyo, and there are some firefighters arrive over 20 minutes at most. Additionally, we focused on the alternative routes and proposed that volunteers collect information on street blockages to improve the accessibility of firefighters. Finally we demonstrated that access time of firefighters can be reduced to the same level as the case no streets were blocked if 0.3% of residents collected information in 10 minutes. 1. INTRODUCTION spreading and the strategy of firefighting. We can execute the simulation in a wide area in a comparatively short calculation In the field of street-network analysis, many studies have been time by using a grid spacing of 250 meters. However, it is carried out on traffic congestion and optimization strategies for difficult to make a detailed analysis considering the influence of route assignment. For instance, Li et al. (2009) analyzed the street-blockages on the accessibility. In addition, Ertugay and probe car data for 57 days in Beijing, and detected recurrent Duzgun (2006) proposed three indices (the zone-based technique, congestion points in each time/day. This method enables us to the isochrones-based technique, and the raster-based technique) detect the rule of congestion by controlling conditions pertaining and analyzed the access time from the locations of emergency to time, place, and so forth. Also, Claes et al. (2011) described a services, fire brigades and health services. There are some routing strategy based on forecast information. This strategy differences of calculation time and parameters. However, these forecasts the locations of vehicles using the delegate multi-agent approaches might underestimate the access time because system. The result of the simulation using forecast information impassable streets caused by street blockages were not showed vehicles travel 35% more efficiently than the other considered. Furthermore, Kugai and Kato (2007) proposed the strategies using real-time data. In addition, this strategy has high method to evaluate disaster mitigation performance in the street scalability and, thus, takes practical advantage since it was network by considering the distribution of the passable described through decentralized architecture. probability for fire engines. However, this study focused on not supporting firefighting activities just after a disaster but on the These studies focused on accessibility in daily life, but it is also urban development and improvement. important to analyze the accessibility on street networks after a large earthquake in Japan. After a large earthquake, rubbles of In this paper, we analyze the accessibility of firefighters collapsed buildings block many narrow street, and street immediately after a large earthquake by using a microscopic blockages obstruct the smooth accessibility of emergency simulation model. More specifically, we construct simulation vehicles. Additionally, the demands for the emergency models, which describe the property damage and the movement transportation increase since many fires occur at the same time in of firefighters from fire stations to the locations of fires via water different places, and many people are injured. In these sources. We integrate these models, agent technology, GIS circumstances, the accessibility of emergency vehicles is one of technology, a geo-database, and routing algorithm in similar way the most important issues for mitigating disaster. in Wang and Zlatanova (2016). Using this system, we analyze the influence of the street-blockage from the viewpoint of the access Hence, there are many studies on emergency vehicles for fire time of firefighters. Additionally, we focus on the alternative brigades and health services under the condition after a large- routes and propose that volunteers collect information on street scale earthquake occurs. For instance, Sekizawa et al. (2008, and blockages to improve the accessibility. Finally we demonstrate 2009) constructed the simulation system, which contains the effects of collecting street-blockage information on reducing firefighting operations model and fire spreading model. They the access time of firefighters. The originality of our research is analyzed the relationships between the damage from fire * Corresponding author This contribution has been peer-reviewed. The double-blind peer-review was conducted on the basis of the full paper. doi:10.5194/isprs-annals-IV-4-W1-37-2016 37 ISPRS Annals of the Photogrammetry, Remote Sensing and Spatial Information Sciences, Volume IV-4/W1, 2016 1st International Conference on Smart Data and Smart Cities, 30th UDMS, 7–9 September 2016, Split, Croatia little to consider the moving obstacles and many destination for speedV, and speedf is the speed of fire engine, one responder, TSP or MTSP, since we focused on assisting for and firefighter respectively. firefighters immediately after an earthquake occurrence. -In case the firefighters cannot arrive at the water source due to In this paper, we attempt to (1) focus on the accessibility of street blockage, the water source are excluded from the WS, and firefighters immediately after an earthquake, (2) consider not the destination is changed to another one based on Eq.1. only the single hazard but also the multi-hazards (such as -Firefighters try to move the fastest path on the street network in collapsed buildings, street blockages, and fire spreading) (3) the condition that all streets are passable. When they find street construct microscopic simulation model that can be estimated a blockages on the way to the destination, they memorize the single collapsed building, single street blockage, and so forth, and locations of street blockages. (4) propose the information collection and demonstrate the -When they cannot move on their route due to street blockages, effects. they try to search another fastest route except the impassable streets they have already known. -One trial of simulation is that all firefighters arrive at the 2. MODELING FIREFIGHTERS’ ACTIVITIES location of the fire or they notice that they cannot arrive due to AND PROPERTY DAMAGE IN A LARGE street blockages. EARTHQUAKE 2.1 Modeling of Firefighters’ Activities Earthquake Wait in (1) Decide (2) Move to Occurrence 10 minutes the Destination Woter Source It is highly important that firefighting activities are performed (3) Move to End (Output immediately after outbreaks of fires in order to decrease the Location of Fire Access Time) damage of fire spreading. Hirokawa and Osaragi (2015) analyzed Outline of Activity of Firefighters the relationships between the elapsed time from outbreaks of fires and fire scales using a fire spreading simulation. The result indicated that firefighters arrive at the location of the fire within There are an average of 26 minutes from the outbreak of the fire or they Some Fires in their cannot prevent its spread. Moreover, according to the Tokyo Fire Jurisdiction? YES NO Department, firefighters should remain at the fire station for a certain period of time to grasp the condition of the locations and Select the End the risk of fires. Thus, they have only about 10 minutes to move Highest Risk (Exclude to the location of the fire. Considering the above background, we Bldg from Analysis) model firefighters’ activities, which are moving to the locations of fires from a fire station, immediately after an earthquake (1) Decide the Destination occurrence by using agent-based technology. Specifically, firefighter first moves to a water source (dynamic destination), Exclude Seach Fastest Route and when he/she arrives, moves to the location of fire (static Water Sources That are Unreachable to Water Source destination). That is because the optimal water source is NO dynamically changed by the locations of streets blockages, which There are Some Next Street firefighter knows. Firefighters search the fastest path on the street Water Sources Is Passable? NO network which they think passable by