American Scientist the Magazine of Sigma Xi, the Scientific Research Society

A reprint from American Scientist the magazine of Sigma Xi, The Scientific Research Society This reprint is provided for personal and noncommercial use. For any other use, please send a request to Permissions, American Scientist, P.O. Box 13975, Research Triangle Park, NC, 27709, U.S.A., or by electronic mail to [email protected]. ©Sigma Xi, The Scientific Research Society and other rightsholders Perspective The Grammar of the Elements Did the Sanskrit alphabet influence Mendeleev’s periodic table? Abhik Ghosh and Paul Kiparsky mitri Ivanovich Mendeleev might have led Mendeleev to reference was not the first to recog- Sanskrit in this way. nize the periodicity of the In general terms, the origin of Men- chemical elements or even deleev’s periodic table is fairly well- Dto construct a primitive periodic table. known. As a freshly tenured profes- He did go much further than his peers, sor at Saint Petersburg University in however, in conceptualizing periodic- Russia in 1867, Mendeleev found him- ity as a fundamental law governing self responsible for teaching in organic the nature of the elements. Based on chemistry with no suitable textbook at that insight, whenever the properties hand. Characteristically, he set about of a given element didn’t fit the over- writing his own—Osnovy Khimii [Prin- all pattern, he famously left an empty ciples of Chemistry]—between 1868 spot in his table for an as yet undiscov- and 1870. During this period, while ered element. He used the prefixes eka, searching for a sensible order for dis- dvi, and tri, Sanskrit for the numbers cussing the chemistry of the approxi- es such as Sanskrit, and there is strong one, two, and three, to name these hypo- mately 65 elements known at the time, evidence that Mendeleev cultivated thetical elements, referring to the num- he hit upon the idea of the “periodic friends in that milieu. Further, the San- ber of places they were from a known, table.” His insight transformed chem- skrit alphabet is a two-dimensional pe- lighter element in the same group. istry from a trackless wilderness of dis- riodic array and, assuming Mendeleev Let that sink in. Not Greek. Not Lat- parate facts to something approaching saw it (an eventuality that we con- in. Not even German, the lingua franca a well laid-out garden. sider probable, as explained below), of science in continental Europe at the Less is known about Mendeleev’s it would have been an obvious source time. But Sanskrit, an ancient Indian exact eureka moment, which came of inspiration for the construction of language that few Europeans outside shortly before March 1, 1869. In one other periodic systems. certain rarefied circles had even heard popular account, the idea of the pe- Taking a longer view of things, it’s about. This unique decision led us, a riodic table occurred to Mendeleev fair to say that Mendeleev’s periodic chemist and a linguist, to explore what while playing solitaire using a set of system grew out of a larger project cards printed with the symbols and on possible chemical compounds, atomic weights of the elements. In an- which he had articulated in his 1861 Abhik Ghosh is a professor of inorganic and mate- other story, most likely apocryphal, “Essai d’une théorie sur les limites rials chemistry at the University of Tromsø–The the idea of the periodic table came des combinaisons organiques [Essay Arctic University of Norway and is fluent in San- to him in a dream, much as the cor- of a theory on the limits of organic skrit. His earlier forays into science education and rect structure of benzene supposedly combinations].” He called the communication include the popular science book came to August Kekulé in a dream (see project chemical mechanics in his 1861 Letters to a Young Chemist, which he edited, “The Many Guises of Aromaticity” in the book Organic Chemistry, in which he and Arrow Pushing in Inorganic Chemistry, January– February 2015 issue). credited the chemist Antoine-Laurent which he wrote with his former student Steffen To us, a third source of inspiration de Lavoisier with initiating the line Berg. Paul Kiparsky is a professor of linguistics at Stanford University and is a Sanskrit scholar. His seems plausible, one that would also of thinking. Lavoisier’s work also book P ini as a Variationist uncovered a major explain Mendeleev’s enigmatic use of had a linguistic vein, as though by dimension of Pāṇini’s grammar that was not the Sanskrit prefixes. Saint Petersburg constructing a nomenclature that knownāṇ even to the earliest commentators. Email at the time was a preeminent center of systematically reflected the chemical for Ghosh: [email protected] research on classical Oriental languag- composition of a substance (for © 2019 Sigma Xi, The Scientific Research Honor Society. 350 American Scientist, Volume 107 Reproduction with permission only. Contact [email protected]. Ti = 50 Zr = 90 ? = 180 V = 51 Nb = 94 Ta = 182 Cr = 52 Mo = 96 W = 186 Mn = 55 Rh = 104.4 Pt = 197.1 Fe = 56 Ru = 104.4 Ir = 198 Ni = Co = 59 Pd = 106.6 Os = 199 H = 1 Cu = 63.4 Ag = 108 Hg = 200 Be = 9.4 Mg = 24 Zn = 65.2 Cd = 112 B = 11 Al = 27.3 ? = 68 Ur = 116 Au = 197? C = 12 Si = 28 ? = 70 Sn = 118 N = 14 P = 31 As = 75 Sb = 122 Bi = 210? O = 16 S = 32 Se= 79.4 Te = 128? F = 19 Cl = 35.5 Br = 80 I = 127 Li = 7 Na = 23 K = 39 Rb = 85.4 Cs = 133 Tl = 204 Ca = 40 Sr = 87.6 Ba = 137 Pb = 207 ? = 45 Ce = 92 ?Er = 56 La = 94 ?Yt = 60 Di = 95 In = 75.6 Th = 118? Group I Group II Group III Group IV Group V Group VI Group VII Group VIII – – – RH4 RH3 RH2 RH – Series R2O RO R2O3 RO2 R2O5 RO3 R2O7 RO4 1 H = 1 2 Li = 7 Be = 9.4 B = 11 C = 12 N = 14 O = 16 F = 19 3 Na = 23 Mg = 24 Al = 27.3 Si = 28 P = 31 S = 32 Cl = 35.5 4 K = 39 Ca = 40 — = 44 Ti = 48 V = 51 Cr = 52 Mn = 55 Fe = 56, Co = 59 Ni = 59, Cu = 63 5 (Cu = 63) Zn = 65 — = 68 — = 72 As = 75 Se = 78 Br = 80 6 Rb = 85 Sr = 87 ?Yt = 88 Zr = 90 Nb = 94 Mo = 96 — = 100 Ru = 104, Rh = 104 Pd = 106, Ag = 108 7 (Ag = 108) Cd = 112 In = 113 Sn = 118 Sb = 122 Te = 125 I = 127 8 Cs = 133 Ba = 137 ?Di = 138 ?Ce = 140 — — — — — — — 9 (—) — — — — — — 10 — — ?Er = 178 ?La = 180 Ta = 182 W = 184 — Os = 195, Ir = 197 Pt = 198, Au = 199 11 (Au = 199) Hg = 200 Tl = 204 Pb = 207 Bi = 208 — — 12 — — — Th = 231 — U = 240 — — — — — De Agostini Picture Library/Bridgeman Images; Science History Images/Alamy Stock Photo; Abhik Ghosh The 1869 version of chemist Dmitri Ivanovich Mendeleev’s periodic table (top) shows his Böhtlingk interacted on a daily basis early attempts to organize the elements. Within a couple of years, he rotated the table by 90 is unknown. But we do know that the degrees and brought it into a form that is relatively recognizable to a modern audience (bot- two men shared an interest in Siberia tom). Note the use of question marks to indicate a missing element. Note also the absence of (Mendeleev’s birthplace) and pro- noble gases; the entire group of these elements was unknown at the time. moted research on the Arctic. Indeed Böhtlingk composed a remarkable example, sulfuric/sulfurous, sulfate/ we first need to consider how he may grammar of the Siberian language Ya- sulfite, and so on), the theory of have learned about a language that few kut (also known as Sakha), in which he chemical compounds could be reduced Europeans knew about at that time. applied the principles of Sanskrit gram- to a kind of grammar. Mendeleev It turns out that in the middle of the mar to extraordinary effect. Böhtlingk took this approach to a new level by 19th century Saint Petersburg Univer- also supported Mendeleev’s nomina- formulating generalizations about sity consisted of only four faculties tion for the Academy’s prestigious chemical formulas. (branches of learning), one of which Demidov Prize, which the chemist won Mendeleev’s search for a unifying was dedicated entirely to Oriental lan- for his first textbook, Organic Chemistry. language of chemistry may have led guages. Perhaps of greater significance The importance of Sanskrit to the him to linguistics, and ultimately he was Mendeleev’s friendship with the study of linguistics and European lan- may have been inspired by Sanskrit. eminent Indologist and philologist Otto guages was already well-known to Because of our familiarity with this von Böhtlingk, who worked at the Saint European philologists and linguists at ancient Indian language, we can see Petersburg Academy of Sciences during that time. They knew that Sanskrit is parallels that may have been over- the first decade of Mendeleev’s career. linguistically related to the great ma- looked in the past—parallels that may Böhtlingk is best known for his mag- jority of modern European languages indicate why Mendeleev paid homage num opus, a seven-volume Sanskrit- (with the exception of Finnish, Basque, to it in his life’s greatest work. German dictionary that he compiled and a handful of others) as well as over the course of 23 years (1853–1875), Farsi (but not Turkish and Arabic). In- Mendeleev’s Sanskrit Connection but he also translated and edited a deed, the recognition of this linguis- To understand why Mendeleev used whole raft of other major Sanskrit tic kinship—as famously expressed Sanskrit words in his periodic table, works.

Load more