Chap. 8.] the KING's REVENUE. 280 Clergy

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Chap. 8.] the KING's REVENUE. 280 Clergy Chap. 8.] THE KING's REVENUE. 280 clergy. I shall only here observe that this is now done in consequence of the statute 25 Hen. VIII, c. 20. As head of the church, the king is likewise the dernier resort in all ecclesi- astical causes; an appeal lying ultimately to him in chancery from the sentence of every ecclesiastical judge: which right was restored to the crown by statute 25 Hen. VIII c 19, as will more fully be shewn hereafter. (34) CHAPTER VIII. OF MHE KING'S REVENUE. HAVING, in the preceding chapter, considered at large those branches of the king's prerogative, which contribute to his royal dignity, and constitute the executive power of the government, we proceed now to examine the king's fiscal prerogatives, or such as regard his revenue; which the British constitution hath vested in the royal person, in order to support his dignity and maintain his power: being a portion which each subject contributes of his property, in order to secure the remainder. This revenue is either ordinary or extraordinary., The king's ordinary reve- nue is such as has either subsisted time out of mind in the crown; or else has been granted by parliament by way of purchase or exchange for such of the king's inherent hereditary revenues, as were found inconvenient to the subject. When I say that it has subsisted time out of mind in the crown, I do not mean that the king is at present in the actual possession of the whole of this revenue. Much (nay, the greatest part) of it is at this day in the hands of sub- jects; to whom it has been granted out from time to time by the kings of England: which has rendered the crown in some measure dependent on the people for its ordinary support and subsistence. So that I must be obliged to recount, as part of the royal revenue, what lords of manors and other subjects *frequently look upon to be their own absolute inherent rights; because [*282] they are and have been vested in them and their ancestors for ages, though in reality originally derived from the grants of our ancient princes. I. The first of the king's ordinary revenues which I shall take notice of is of an ecclesiastical kind; (as are also the three succeeding ones) viz.: the custody of the temporalties of bishops: by which are meant all the lay revenues, lands and tenements (in which is included his barony,) which belong to an archbishop's or bishop's see. And these, upon the vacancy of the bishopric, are immediately the right of the king, as a consequence of his prerogative in church matters; whereby he is considered as the founder of all archbishoprics and bishoprics, to whom during the vacancy they revert. And for the same reason, before the dis- solution of abbeys, the king had the custody of the temporalties of all such abbeys and priories as were of royal foundation (but not of those founded by subjects) on the death of the abbot or prior. (a) Another reason may also be given why the policy of the law hath vested this custody in the king; because, as the successor if not known, the lands and possessions of the see would be liable to spoil and devastation if no one had a property therein. Therefore, the law has given the king, not the temporalties themselves, but the custody of the temporalties, till such time as a successor is appointed; with power of taking to himself all the intermediate profits, without any account of the successor; and with right of presenting (which the crown very frequently exercises) (a) 2 Inst. 15. (34) Appeals are now taken in these cases to the judicial committee of the privy council 179 282 FROM BIsmOPRIcs, TITHES, ETC. [Book I. to such benefices and other preferments as fall within the time of vacation. (b) This revenue is of so high a nature that it could not be granted out to a sub- ject, before, or even after, it accrued: but now by the statute 15 Edw. III, st. 4, c. 4 and 5, the king may, after the vacancy, lease the temporalties to the dean and chapter; saving to himself all advowsons, escheats, and the like. Our ancient kings, and particularly William Rufus, were not only remarkable for r*2 , 3 ] keeping the bishoprics a long time *vacant, for the sake of enjoying t J the temporalties, but also committed horrible waste on the woods ana other parts of the estate; and to crown all, would never, when the see was filled up, restore to the bishop his temporalties again, unless he purchased them at an exorbitant price. To remedy which, King Henry the First (c) granted a charter at the beginning of his reign, promising neither to sell, nor let to farm, nor take any thing from the domains of the church, till the suc- cessor was installed. (1) And it was made one of the articles of the great charter, (d) that no waste should be committed in the temporalties of bishop- rics, neither should the custody of them be sold. The same is ordained by the statute of Westminster the first; (e) and the statute 14 Edw. III, st. 4, c. 4, (which permits, as we have seen, a lease to the dean and chapter,) is still more explicit in prohibiting the other exactions. It was also a frequent abuse that the king would, for trifling, or no causes, seize the temporalties of bishops, even during their lives, into his own hands: but this is guarded against by statute 1 Edw. III, st. 2, c. 2. This revenue of the king, which was formerly very considerable, is now by a customary indulgence almost reduced to nothing: for, at present, as soon as the new bishop is consecrated and confirmed, he usually receives the restitution of his temporalties quite entire, and untouched, from the king; and at the same time does homage to his sovereign: and then, and not sooner, he has a fee sim- ple in his bishopric, and may maintain an action for the profits. (f) II. The king is entitled to a corody, as the law calls it, out of every bishopric, that is, to send one of his chaplains to be maintained by the bishop, or to have a pension allowed him till the bishop promotes him to a benefice. (g) This is also in the nature of an acknowledgment to the king, as founder of the see, since he had formerly the same corody or pension from every abbey or priory of [*2841 royal foundation. (2) It is, I *apprehend, now fallen into total disuse ; [ J though Sir Matthew Hale says, (h) that it is due of common right, and that no prescription will discharge it. III. The king also, as was formerly observed, (i) is entitled to all the tithes arising in extraparochial places : (k) though perhaps it may be doubted how far this article, as well as the last, can be properly reckoned a part of the king's own royal revenue; since a corody supports only his chaplains, and these extra- parochial tithes are held under an implied trust, that the king will distribute them for the good of the clergy in general. IV. The next branch consists in the first-fruits, and tenths, of all spiritual preferments in the kingdom; both of which I shall consider together. These were originally a part of the papal usurpations over the clergy of this kingdom; first introduced by Pandulph, the pope's legate, during the reigns of King John and Henry the Third, in the see of Norwich; and afterwards attempted to be made universal by the popes Clement V and John XXII, about the beginning of the fourteenth century. The first-fruits, primitit, or annates, (b) Stat. 17 Edw. H. c. 14. F. N. B. 82. (c) Matt. Paris. (d) 9 Hen. III. c. 5. (e) 3 Edw. I. c. 21. C)co. Litt. 67, 341. (g) F. N. B. 280. (h) Notes on F. N. B. above cited. (i) Page 113. 2 Inst. 647. (1) [But Queen Elizabeth kept the see of Ely vacant nineteen years, in order to retain the revenue. Strype, vol. 4, 351.] (2) [So where the foundation was not royal, it was usual for the founders to give their heirs a corody, viz.: a charge upon the particular monastery or abbey sufficient to prevent them from starving. And those persons, disinherited of the lands by their relations, were there sub- sisted during life.] 180 Chap. 8.] REVENUE FROM BISHOPRICS, ETC. 284 were the first year's whole profits of the spiritual preferment, according to a rate or valor made under the direction of Pope Innocent IV, by Walter, bishop of Norwich, in 38 Hen. III, and afterwards advanced in value by commission from Pope Nicholas III, A. D. 1292, 20 Edw. I; (1) which valuation of Pope Nicholas is still preserved in the exchequer. (m) (3) The tenths, or decimce, were the tenth part of the annual profit of each living by the same valuation; which was also claimed by the holy see, under no better pretence than a strange mis- application of that precept of the Levitical law, which directs (n) that the Levites "should offer the tenth part of their tithes as a heave-offering to the Lord, and give it to Aaron the high priest." But *this claim of the pope [*25 met with a vigorous resistance from the English parliament; and a L*2851 variety of acts were passed to prevent and restrain it, particularly the statute of 6 Hen.
Recommended publications
  • Copyrighted Material
    33_056819 bindex.qxp 11/3/06 11:01 AM Page 363 Index fighting the Vikings, 52–54 • A • as law-giver, 57–58 Aberfan tragedy, 304–305 literary interests, 56–57 Act of Union (1707), 2, 251 reforms of, 54–55 Adelaide of Saxe-Meiningen, queen of reign of, 50, 51–52 William IV, 268, 361 Alfred, son of King Aethelred, king of Áed, king of Scotland, 159 England, 73, 74 Áed Findliath, ruler in Ireland, 159 Ambrosius Aurelianus (Roman leader), 40 Aedán mac Gabráin, overking of Dalriada, 153 Andrew, Prince, Duke of York (son of Aelfflaed, queen of Edward, king Elizabeth II) of Wessex, 59 birth of, 301 Aelfgifu of Northampton, queen of Cnut, 68 as naval officer, 33 Aethelbald, king of Mercia, 45 response to death of Princess Diana, 313 Aethelbert, king of Wessex, 49 separation from Sarah, Duchess of York, Aethelflaed, daughter of Alfred, king of 309 Wessex, 46 Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, 57, 58, 63 Aethelfrith, Saxon king, 43 Anglo-Saxons Aethelred, king of England, 51, 65–66 appointing an heir, 16 Aethelred, king of Mercia, 45, 46, 55 invasion of Britain, 39–41 Aethelred, king of Wessex, 50 kingdoms of, 37, 42 Aethelstan, king of Wessex, 51, 61–62 kings of, 41–42 Aethelwold, son of Aethelred, king of overview, 12 Wessex, 60 Anna, queen of Scotland, 204 Aethelwulf, king of Wessex, 49 Anne, Princess Royal, daughter of Africa, as part of British empire, 14 Elizabeth II, 301, 309 Agincourt, battle of, 136–138 Anne, queen of England Albert, Prince, son of George V, later lack of heir, 17 George VI, 283, 291 marriage to George of Denmark, 360–361 Albert of
    [Show full text]
  • 18-Commentarium-Privatum-CCRR-III-Pars-2.Pdf
    ARCHIVES D'HISTOIRE OBLATE sous la direction de MAURICE GILBERT, O.M.I. et GASTON CARRIERE, O.M.I. ------------------------ 1 8 ------------------------- COMMENTARIUM PRIVATUM CONSTITUTIONUM ET REGULARUM Ilia PARS ★ ★ auctore JOS. RESLE, O.M.I. O OTTAWA EDITIONS DES ETUDES OBLATES 1961 PARS TERTIA CONSTITUTIONUM ET REGULARUM CAPUT SECUNDUM DE SPECIALI CONGREGATIONIS REGIMINE ; sive de regimine inferiore seu locali Introductio. 1. Ordo rerum. Ante divisionem Congregationis in provincias et vicariatus (in Capitulo generali l86o) tota materia de regimine Societatis absolvebatur in unico capite "Du gouvernement de la Société" sive "De Societatis gubernio", quod fuit caput primum hujus partis tertiae. Et quidem in isto capite agebant imprimis de. gubernio centrali sive generali Congregationis (de quo habentur in editione la Constitutionum sex priores paragraphi) et postea de gubernio inferiore sive locali (de quo habentur octo paragraphi subséquentes quibus additur per modum . ■complementi paragraphus de ordine praecedentiae). V. Fundator secutus est in hoc — quoad dispositionem generalem rerum — Constitutiones et Regulas S. Alphonsi quae prae manibus habuit anno 1818. Facta divisione Congregationis in provincias, pristinum caput I scindi­ tur in duo capita abhinc editione 2a (185(3), ita quidem ut caput I agat de regi­ mine superiore Congregationis, scilicet generali et provinciali, caput II vero de regimine inferiore seu locali. 2. Titulus capitis. In Constitutionibus et Regulis S. Alphonsi paragraphus respectiva, i.e. V, ferebat hunc titulum "Del Rettore locali, ed altri Officiali", quem titulum P. de Mazenod assumpsit fere ad litteram in ms. I (1818); "§ 6 - Des supérieurs particuliers et autres officiers." In ms. "Honorat" primitus quidem idem omnirïo legebatur, sed postea textus correctus est hoc modo; "Des Supérieurs locaux et autres officiers." Abhinc ms, II (inter annos 1821-1825) ista paragraphus scinditur in plures, ita ut pro Superioribus localibus et pro variis officialibus localibus habeantur totidem paragraphi distinctae.
    [Show full text]
  • The Sovereign Grant and Sovereign Grant Reserve Annual Report and Accounts 2017-18
    SOVEREIGN GRANT ACT 2011 The Sovereign Grant and Sovereign Grant Reserve Annual Report and Accounts 2017-18 Presented to Parliament pursuant to Section 2 and Section 4 of the Sovereign Grant Act 2011 Ordered by the House of Commons to be printed 27 June 2018 HC 1153 © Crown copyright 2018 This publication is licensed under the terms of the Open Government Licence v3.0 except where otherwise stated. To view this licence, visit nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open- government-licence/version/3 Where we have identified any third party copyright information you will need to obtain permission from the copyright holders concerned. This publication is available at www.gov.uk/government/publications Any enquiries regarding this publication should be sent to us using the contact details available at www.royal.uk ISBN 978-1-5286-0459-8 CCS 0518725758 06/18 Printed on paper containing 75% recycled fibre content minimum. Printed in the UK on behalf of the Controller of Her Majesty’s Stationery Office. Produced by Impress Print Services Limited. FRONT COVER: Queen Elizabeth II and The Duke of Edinburgh visit Stirling Castle on 5th July 2017. Photograph provided courtesy of Jane Barlow/Press Association. CONTENTS Page The Sovereign Grant 2 The Official Duties of The Queen 3 Performance Report 9 Accountability Report: Governance Statement 27 Remuneration and Staff Report 40 Statement of the Keeper of the Privy Purse’s Financial Responsibilities 44 The Certificate and Report of the Comptroller and Auditor General to the Houses of 46 Parliament and the Royal
    [Show full text]
  • Ebook Download What a Thing to Say to the Queen
    WHAT A THING TO SAY TO THE QUEEN: A COLLECTION OF ROYAL ANECDOTES FROM THE HOUSE OF WINDSOR PDF, EPUB, EBOOK Thomas Blaikie | 192 pages | 03 Nov 2015 | Aurum Press Ltd | 9781781314418 | English | London, United Kingdom What a Thing to Say to the Queen: A Collection of Royal Anecdotes from the House of Windsor PDF Book Before then, it was maintained using the monarch's official income paid by the Civil List. Australian Women's Weekly. Humorous story about a fictional Prince and Princess of Wales who travel across the United States: riding freight trains, washing dishes, stealing art, fighting forest fires, and becoming enmeshed in a presidential campaign. As Windsor is right next to Heathrow, planes can be heard roaring past at all hours. Christmas Lifestyle 15 Christmas gifts for male teachers that they'll actually be excited to receive Now To Love Yesterday pm. Stories and anecdotes about British royals and their connection to the tradition of afternoon tea. There is a computerised inventory of the Royal Collection which identifies assets held by the Queen as Sovereign and as a private individual. Hypothetical questions have been asked in Parliament about what should happen to the collection if the UK ever becomes a republic. And no one but these royal biographers, royal reporters, and other insiders are quite so invested in telling the story of who the royal family is as a real family — brothers, in-laws, and a year-old grandmother who has owned 30 corgis in her lifetime. President George Bush Sr had been asked to pull out a small platform for the Queen to stand on.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 the Public Life of a Twentieth Century Princess Princess Mary Princess Royal and Countess of Harewood Wendy Marion Tebble
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by SAS-SPACE 1 The Public Life of a Twentieth Century Princess Princess Mary Princess Royal and Countess of Harewood Wendy Marion Tebble, Institute of Historical Research Thesis submitted for Degree of Master of Philosophy, 2018 2 Table of Contents Abstract 3 Acknowledgements 5 Abbreviations 7 Acronyms 8 Chapters 9 Conclusion 136 Bibliography 155 3 Abstract The histiography on Princess Mary is conspicuous by its absence. No official account of her long public life, from 1914 to 1965, has been written and published since 1922, when the princess was aged twenty-five, and about to be married. The only daughter of King George V, she was one of the chief protagonists in his plans to include his children in his efforts to engage the monarchy, and the royal family, more deeply and closely with the people of the United Kingdom. This was a time when women were striving to enter public life more fully, a role hitherto denied to them. The king’s decision was largely prompted by the sacrifices of so many during the First World War; the fall of Czar Nicholas of Russia; the growth of socialism; and the dangers these events may present to the longevity of the monarchy in a disaffected kingdom. Princess Mary’s public life helps to answer the question of what role royal women, then and in the future, are able to play in support of the monarchy. It was a time when for the most part careers of any kind were not open to women, royal or otherwise, and the majority had yet to gain the right to vote.
    [Show full text]
  • Queen's Or Prince's Consent
    QUEEN’S OR PRINCE’S CONSENT This pamphlet is intended for members of the Office of the Parliamentary Counsel. Unless otherwise stated: • references to Erskine May are to the 24th edition (2011), • references to the Companion to the Standing Orders are to the Companion to the Standing Orders and Guide to Proceedings of the House of Lords (25th edition, 2017), • references to the Cabinet Office Guide to Making Legislation are to the version of July 2017. Office of the Parliamentary Counsel September 2018 CONTENTS CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION CHAPTER 2 QUEEN’S CONSENT Introduction. 2 The prerogative. 2 Hereditary revenues, the Duchies and personal property and interests . 4 Exceptions and examples . 6 CHAPTER 3 PRINCE’S CONSENT Introduction. 7 The Duchy of Cornwall . 7 The Prince and Steward of Scotland . 8 Prince’s consent in other circumstances . 8 Exceptions and examples . 8 CHAPTER 4 GENERAL EXCEPTIONS The remoteness/de minimis tests . 10 Original consent sufficient for later provisions . 10 No adverse effect on the Crown. 11 CHAPTER 5 THE SIGNIFICATION OF CONSENT Signification following amendments to a bill. 13 Re-signification for identical bill . 14 The manner of signification . 14 The form of signification . 15 CHAPTER 6 PRACTICAL STEPS Obtaining consent. 17 Informing the Whips . 17 Writing to the House authorities . 17 Private Members’ Bills. 17 Informing the Palace of further developments . 18 Other. 18 CHAPTER 7 MISCELLANEOUS Draft bills . 19 Consent not obtained . 19 Inadvertent failure to signify consent . 19 Consent in the absence of the Queen. 20 Consent before introduction of a bill . 20 Queen’s speech . 20 Royal Assent .
    [Show full text]
  • DISPENSATION and ECONOMY in the Law Governing the Church Of
    DISPENSATION AND ECONOMY in the law governing the Church of England William Adam Dissertation submitted in part fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy of the University of Wales Cardiff Law School 2009 UMI Number: U585252 All rights reserved INFORMATION TO ALL USERS The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. Dissertation Publishing UMI U585252 Published by ProQuest LLC 2013. Copyright in the Dissertation held by the Author. Microform Edition © ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved. This work is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code. ProQuest LLC 789 East Eisenhower Parkway P.O. Box 1346 Ann Arbor, Ml 48106-1346 CONTENTS SUMMARY............................................................................................................................................................IV ACKNOWLEDGMENTS..................................................................................................................................VI ABBREVIATIONS............................................................................................................................................VII TABLE OF STATUTES AND MEASURES............................................................................................ VIII U K A c t s o f P a r l i a m e n
    [Show full text]
  • Jus Cogens: the Determination and the Gradual Expansion of Its Material Content in Contemporary International Case-Law
    JUS COGENS: THE DETERMINATION AND THE GRADUAL EXPANSION OF ITS MATERIAL CONTENT IN CONTEMPORARY INTERNATIONAL CASE-LAW ANTÔNIO AUGUSTO CANÇADO TRINDADE∗ ∗ Ph.D. (Cambridge - Yorke Prize) in International Law; Former President of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights; Judge Elect of the International Court of Justice (The Hague); Professor of International Law at the University of Brasilia, Brazil; Member of the Institut de Droit International, and of the Curatorium of the Hague Academy of International Law. 3 I. Introductory Observations In my General Course on Public International Law, delivered at The Hague Academy of International Law in 2005, I characterized the doctrinal and jurisprudential construction of international jus cogens as proper of a new jus gentium, the International Law for Humankind. I sustained, moreover, that, in my understanding, and by definition, international jus cogens goes beyond the law of treaties, extending itself to the law of the international responsibility of the State, and to the whole corpus juris of contemporary International Law, and reaching, ultimately, any juridical act. In encompassing the whole International Law, it projects also over domestic law, invalidating any measure or act incompatible with it. Jus cogens has direct incidence on the very foundations of a universal International Law, and is a basic pillar of the new jus gentium1. On the occasion of this XXXV Course of International Law organized by the OAS Inter-American Juridical Committee here in Rio de Janeiro (August 2008), I purport, at first, to review the origins and content of that concept within the framework of the fundamental values of the international community.
    [Show full text]
  • The Ultimate Insider Trader Is the Queen
    Click here for Full Issue of EIR Volume 23, Number 22, May 24, 1996 to be "philo-Semitic," but in reality he was "philo-banker." 1.,1 Edward had a geopolitical vision in the Venetian tradition, and it was one of brutal simplicity: the encirclement of'Ger­ The ultimateinsider many with a hostile coalition, and the destruction of theWa­ tion-states of Europe. With this ambition driving him, Edward traderis the Queen VII set up the Anglo-Franco-Russian alliance that becatt\.e' known as the Triple Entente. His policies led directly to expIO-l I·, sion of world war in 1914. by Scott Thompson One of Edward VII's leading financialadvisers was HUrl-' garian Jewish banker Baron Hirsch, who purchased an intro­ Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II is the wealthiest crone in the duction to Edward in 1890 from Crown Prince Rudolf of world, who gives new meaning to the phrase, "stinking rich." Austria. When Baron Hirsch died in 1896, his position as Her total wealth is divided into two parts. One is a Venetian­ leading adviser passed on to his executor, another Jewish stylefondo, that is, it is inalienable and must be passed on to banker, Ernest Cassel, whose daughter and heiress, Edwina, her heir, free from inheritance tax. The second part of her would ultimately marry Lord Louis Mountbatten, a chief in­ wealth consists of her private collection of castles, jewelry, fluence on Prince Philip and Prince Charles. and art, and a portfolio of blue chip stocks and bonds and real The Rothschilds and the Sassoons, also Jewish bankers, estate investments around the world.
    [Show full text]
  • Civil List Act, 1936. [26 GEO
    Civil List Act, 1936. [26 GEO. 5. & 1 EDW. 8. CH. 15.] ARRANGEMENT OF SECTIONS. A.D. 1936. Section. 1. Payment of hereditary revenues to the Exchequer. 2. Annual payment for Civil List. 3. Provision for the Queen in the event of His Majesty marrying, and for His Majesty's family. 4. Provision for His Royal Highness the Duke of York and his family. 5. Power of His Majesty to assent to certain payments out of revenues of Duchy of Cornwall during minority of any future Duke of Cornwall, &c. 6. Constitution of Royal trustees. 7. Appropriation of Civil List. 8. Payments by Treasury in respect of retired allow- ances. 9. Provision as to certain officers of the Household. 10. Meaning of " net revenues of Duchy of Cornwall ". 11. Charge of payments under this Act. 12. Adjustments in respect of parts of years. 13. Continuance of enactments, commencement, repeal and short title. SCHEDULE. [Price 2d. Net] A 7 [26 GEO. 5. & Civil List Act, 1936. [Cx. 15.] 1 EDW. 8.] CHAPTER 15. An Act to make provision for the honour and A.D. 1936. dignity of the Crown and the Royal Family, and - for the payment of certain salaries, allowances and pensions ; to enable His Majesty to assent to arrangements on behalf of any son of His Majesty being Duke of Cornwall for the pay- ment of certain sums out of the revenues of the Duchy during the minority of the said Duke ; and for purposes connected with the matters aforesaid. [21st May 1936.] Most. Gracious Sovereign, WHEREAS Your Majesty has been graciously pleased r r to signify to Your faithful Commons in Parliament
    [Show full text]
  • A Brief History of Medieval Roman Canon Law in England
    A BRIEF HISTORY OF MEDIEVAL ROMAN CANON LAW IN ENGLAND In discussing the influence of the Canon law in England, the period of time open for our investigation is those cen- turies between the Norman Conquest and the Reformation, or from the middle of the iith to the middle of the i6th century. After the break with Rome by Henry VIII all direct connection with the Vatican is severed. How was the Canon law regarded prior to the Reformation? The investigator who examines simply the field of jurisdiction which the English State allowed the Church to appropriate, and who then finds that in England the Church was not suffered by the State to possess "certain considerable por- tions of that wide field of jurisdiction claimed by Canonists as the heritage of ecclesiastical law,"1 will probably abandon his investigation with the belief that the Canon law had scarcely any authority in England, so great was the English hostility manifested against it by the State. But, to get at the truth of the matter, is not this the question to be investigated when considering the influence of the Canon law in England: did the English ecclesiastical courts "hold themselves free to accept or reject, and did they in some cases reject, the Canon law of Rome?"2 The answer is, that the English ecclesiastical courts possessed no such power as that of accepting or rejecting the Canon law-they acknowledged its binding authority on them. Although England curtailed greatly the claims, of jurisdic- tion advanced by the Church, yet the fact is that within the limits of that curtailed ecclesiastical jurisdiction, the English Church, as a provincial church subordinated (by its own admissions) to the supreme head of the Western Latin Church, administered and rendered obedience to Roman medieval Canon law in the English spiritual courts.
    [Show full text]
  • The Origins of Historical Jurisprudence: Coke, Selden, Hale
    Articles The Origins of Historical Jurisprudence: Coke, Selden, Hale Harold J. Berman CONTENTS INTRODUCTION ............................................. 1652 I. T HISTORICAL BACKGROUND OF ENGLISH LEGAL PHILOSOPHY, TWELFTH TO SEVENTEENTH CENTURIES ......................... 1656 A. Scholastic Jurisprudenceand Its Sixteenth-Century Rivals ......... 1656 B. Richard Hooker's "Comprehensive" Legal Philosophy ........... 1664 C. The Legal Theory of Absolute Monarchy: James I and Bodin ...... 1667 II. SIR EDWARD COKE: HIS MAJESTY'S LOYAL OPPONENT .............. 1673 A. Coke's Acceptance of James' Premises and the Sources of His Opposition to James' Conclusions ...................... 1673 B. Coke's Philosophy of English Law ......................... 1678 C. Coke's Historicism .................................... 1687 D. Coke's Concept of the English Common Law as Artificial Reason .... 1689 III. JOHN SELDEN'S LEGAL PHILOSOPHY .......................... 1694 t Robert NV.Woodruff Professor of Law, Emory Law School; James Barr Ames Professor of Law, Emeritus, Harvard Law School. The valuable collaboration of Charles J. Reid, Jr., Research Associate in Law and History, Emory Law School, is gratefully acknowledged. 1651 1652 The Yale Law Journal [Vol. 103: 1651 A. Coke to Selden to Hale ................................. 1694 B. Selden ' Historicity Versus Coke's Historicism ................. 1695 C. The Consensual Characterof Moral Obligations ............... 1698 D. The Origins of Positive Law in Customary Law ................ 1699 E. Magna Cartaand
    [Show full text]