Taxation of Partnership - Legal National Reports for the Nordic Tax Research Council´S Annual Meeting, 2015 in Aarhus
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Nordic Tax J. 2015; aop Report Open Access Axel Hilling (Ed.) Taxation of Partnership - Legal national reports for the Nordic Tax Research Council´s annual meeting, 2015 in Aarhus DOI 10.1515/ntaxj-2015-0007 from which to choose. Capital companies comprise of pub- Received Aug 31, 2015; accepted Sep 18, 2015 lic limited companies and private limited companies, both of which are regulated by the Danish Companies Act (selsk- Abstract: This joint report includes the five legal national absloven). Unlimited companies (such as sole trader busi- reports on the taxation of partnership in the Nordic coun- nesses or partnerships), known in Denmark as personal tries. The general contents of these reports are summa- companies (personselskaber), are an alternative to capi- rized and thoroughly analyzed in Liselotte Madsen’s Gen- tal companies. The fundamental difference between these eral report, published in this issue of the NTaxJ. For addi- two types of company is the owners’ liability. Liability is tional information, details on legislative measures etc. we limited in relation to capital companies, while in the case find it important, however, to also publish the national re- of unlimited companies at least one owner is liable for the ports in full length. We hope you will find it valuable as whole of the company’s debt Friis Hansen and Krenchel well. (2014). The respective national reports appear in alphabetic or- In Denmark, there are four common types of unlimited der, in regard to the country which regulation is presented. companies, namely partnerships, limited partnerships, Name of the country reporter and contact information are partner companies, and jointly owned shipping firms. It presented in the beginning of each report. is important to be aware of the fact that personal compa- Keywords: Partnership; shared liability partnerships; lim- nies are not regulated by company law legislation but are ited partnerships; internal partnerships; shipping partner- regulated by company law practice. Therefore, the regula- ships; Nordic taxation tion of personal companies is established by nonbinding rules of practice Friis Hansen and Krenchel (2014); Madsen (2011). 1 Denmark A partnership (interessentskab) is a cooperation that is based on an agreement between at least two partici- pants about the operation of a common business enter- By Inge Langhave Jeppesen prise (Friis Hansen and Krenchel 2014). Partnerships are defined in detail in §2(1) of the Danish Act on Undertak- 1.1 Corporate legal regulations ings Carrying on Business for Profit (lov om visse erhvervs- drivende virksomheder) as: “... a business activity, where all the participants are personally liable, unlimited and 1.1.1 Company law rules for personal companies jointly and severally, for the activity’s obligations”. In re- lation to practice, there is a modified subsidiary liability. Freedom of contract applies in the Danish company law. This means that the participants first become liable when This means that the owners can choose the form of com- a claim has been brought against the partnership and has pany that best suits the type of business they wish to op- not been paid within reasonable time Friis Hansen and erate. There are a number of different types of company Krenchel (2014). Resulting from joint liability, a partner who pays off a debt belonging to the partnership can then make a subsequent claim against the other partners. Due Axel Hilling (Ed.): Associate Professor, Department of Business to a lack of company law regulation, it can be difficult to Law, Lund University School of Economics and Management, Swe- den; Email: [email protected] determine whether a business association is a partnership Inge Langhave Jeppesen: Professor, University of Southern Den- or joint ownership. Joint ownership is recognized as exist- mark, Kolding, Denmark; Email: [email protected] © 2015 Axel Hilling et al., published by De Gruyter Open. This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 License. Unauthenticated Download Date | 2/3/16 8:26 AM 2 Ë Axel Hilling et al. ing where a number of people jointly own a common asset own a ship together. According to §102 of the Marine Act without forming a company. If, on the other hand, in the (søloven), when a ship is owned by a number of joint own- course of regulating a business enterprise it is established ers, each joint owner only takes on personal liability for that there are business activities involving the participa- the company’s obligations that is equivalent to his or her tion of the association’s participants, then this is consid- share of the company’s capital. As the use of jointly owned ered a partnership and, thus, a company Friis Hansen and shipping firm is quite limited, it will not be discussed in Krenchel (2011). further detail here. A limited partnership (kommanditselskab) is defined in §2(1) of the Danish Act on Undertakings Carrying on Business for Profit as: “a business activity, where one or 1.1.2 Company law rules for formation, changes in more participants, the general partners, take on unlim- ownership, and selling of a business ited personal liability; and, if there are several participants who are jointly and severally liable for the business’ obli- The fact that there is no legal regulation of personal com- gations, they do so while one or more participants, the panies also means that, as a starting point, there are no limited partners, have limited personal liability for the provisions regulating, for example, the formation of per- business’ obligations”. Therefore, a limited partnership is sonal companies. Instead, activities such as establishing a characterized by the fact that not all the participants have personal company simply happen according to an agree- taken on unlimited liability because the limited partners’ ment between at least two company participants. liability is limited to the value of their deposits. This is A partnership is established when at least two peo- an indirect subsidiary liability. This means that it is only ple come together to operate a business. There will of- the limited partnership or its bankruptcy estate that may ten be an agreement that regulates the relationship be- require the limited partners to pay off the residual liabil- tween the partners, but this is not necessarily the case. ity Friis Hansen and Krenchel (2014). The general part- From the outset, there is a declaratory understanding that ner will often be a Danish private limited lability company a partner cannot withdraw from the business association with a minimum amount of capital. and, therefore, a partner’s withdrawal can only happen A partner company (partnerselskab) is an in-between by agreement with the other partner or partners. Entry option, between a limited partnership and a capital com- into and withdrawal from a partnership is based on an pany, being comprised of, on the one hand, a general part- agreement between the partners, including whether en- ner who takes on unlimited liability and, on the other, par- try or withdrawal must be accompanied by a payment. If ticipants who own shares and have limited personal liabil- consent in relation to a change of debtor is not received, ity. Under §5(1)(21) of the Danish Companies Act, a partner then the partner who is withdrawing becomes liable for the company is defined as a limited partnership, “... where partnership’s debt, as it exists immediately prior to with- the company’s limited partners have invested a particular drawal Madsen (2011). amount of capital, which is divided into shares ...“. With In the case of limited partnerships, the consequences the necessary adjustments, a partner company is regulated of withdrawal are different if it is a general partner ora by the provisions of the Danish Companies Act in accor- limited partner who seeks to withdraw from the partner- dance with §358. This means that the Danish Companies ship. A general partner cannot withdraw from a limited Act sets out the framework for a partner company’s oper- partnership without the consent of all the limited part- ation. One consequence of the Act’s regulation is that, in- ners. However, a general partner can terminate the limited ter alia, a partner company must be formed with a mini- partnership upon giving reasonable notice. On the other mum capital of DKK 500,000 of which DKK 125,000 must hand, a limited partner’s liability is limited to his or her in- be liquid. It also means that a Memorandum of Associa- vestment or share in the partnership (kommanditanparten) tion must be drafted and filed with the Danish Business and, therefore, it is assumed that he or she may freely as- Authority (Erhvervsstyrelsen), so that the partner company sign the share to another. However, the limited partner can achieve legal capacity. In addition, company rules cannot terminate the limited partnership Madsen (2011). (vedtægter) and rules about minority protection must be drawn up. Further, it is a requirement that a partner com- pany has a management structure that corresponds to a public limited company Madsen (2011). A jointly owned shipping firmpartrederi ( ) is the only form of company that may be used when several persons Unauthenticated Download Date | 2/3/16 8:26 AM Taxation reports for the Nordic Tax Research Council´s annual meeting Ë 3 1.2 Tax law regulation In cases of a specific liability limitation, depending on the agreements in existence, the number of creditors and 1.2.1 Qualification of companies the size of the creditors’ claim in relation to the associa- tion’s total debt, it can mean that the association is not a Under Danish tax law, a company’s liability to tax is pro- personal company Madsen (2011). vided for in §1 of the Corporation Tax Act (selskabsskat- In Danish tax law, particularly in relation to limited teloven).