Lars Von Trier's Critique of the Musical Genre

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Lars Von Trier's Critique of the Musical Genre Ken Woodgate ‘Gotta Dance’ (in the Dark): Lars von Trier’s Critique of the Musical Genre This chapter investigates Lars von Trier’s critique of the musical in his film Dancer in the Dark (2000) both through various aspects of the outer musical itself and through the obvious refer- ences to the classic Broadway/Hollywood musicals 42nd Street and The Sound of Music. Particu- larly important is the cross-cultural perspective: the outer musical presents a European’s view of America which is counterposed to an Americanised view of Europe. The outer musical serves to discredit the inner ones, and hence the film argues against the musical genre. Nevertheless, a metacritical reading of the film will identify the limits of von Trier’s dismissive critique. Of all genres of performance, the musical must be the most self-referential. Putting on a show is, along with falling in love, the musical’s favorite theme. Actors who spontaneously burst into song gain some kind of credibility if they are seen to be mounting their own song-and-dance show. But the ease with which the musical mirrors itself might well be seen, from a rationalistic point of view, as a form of theatrical narcissism, or even syllogism. Does the classic musical say anything, apart from the fact that it is fun to sing and dance? And given that the vast majority of people in the modern industrial- ised world choose to avoid public performances of dancing and absolutely all performances of singing, it could easily be argued that the musical’s promise of fun is simply an illusion of an illusion, an indulgent celebration of theatri- cal posturing. It is strange, to say the least, for a realist director to make a film with song and dance numbers in it. But this is precisely what Lars von Trier did in his film Dancer in the Dark (2000). Along with Thomas Vinterberg, von Trier co-wrote Dogme 95, that controversial manifesto calling for a return to rigor- ous realism in filmmaking: To DOGME 95 the movie is not illusion! Today a technological storm is raging of which the result is the elevation of cosmetics to God. By using new technology anyone at any time can 394 Ken Woodgate wash the last grains of truth away in the deadly embrace of sensation. The illusions are everything the movie can hide behind. 1 Dogme 95 can be seen as a recent manifestation of the anti-Hollywood, anti- illusionist tendencies that previously occurred in such movements as Russian Constructivism, Italian Neorealism and the French nouvelle vague. The most obvious hallmarks of Dogme films are a disregard for continuity editing, the avoidance, as much as possible, of post-synchronised sound (point 2 of Dogme’s ‘Vow of Chastity’), and the extensive use of the hand-held camera (point 3), which results in a highly characteristic swish-pan movement from frame to frame. Given that the musical has never been and can never be successfully or seriously integrated into a realist program, von Trier’s approach implies from the outset a critical compromise between two quite distinct generically deter- mined codes. Von Trier has never actually called Dancer in the Dark a Dogme film; indeed, he stated in 1998 that he had moved on from the stric- tures of the program.2 Nevertheless, the hallmarks previously mentioned are abundantly evident in Dancer in the Dark. The film is set in semi-rural Washington State in 1964, and Selma, a Czech immigrant, works in a metal-stamping factory, trying to support her- self and her son Eugene. Together they live in a small bungalow at the back of a property belonging to the local policeman Bill and his spendthrift wife Linda. Selma has an hereditary eye problem and is slowly going blind. She is trying to save enough money to enable her son to undergo an operation that will make sure that he does suffer the same fate as she. In the free time that is left to her, Selma goes to the cinema to watch musicals and participates in the local amateur theatrical group’s production of The Sound of Music, in which she has been given role of Maria. One evening, Bill reveals to Selma that he is in desperate financial trouble and unable to support his wife’s lifestyle. Selma also reveals a secret: she is stashing away her money for her son’s operation. Bill takes the money some time later, and tells his wife that Selma has been making advances in his di- 1 Dogme 95: The Official Dogme 95 Website at <http://www.dogme95.dk/> (accessed 18 July 2006). 2 ‘The manifesto itself was without any value, but it states a couple of limitations which can be useful to work from. I have always thought that the most important rule was that picture and sound should be recorded simultaneously. It excludes manipulation – you cannot cheat afterwards in the editing room. I am still using it as a principle when shooting.’ Jørn Rossing Jensen, ‘Dogme Is Dead! Long Live Song and Dance!’, in Lars von Trier: Interviews, ed. by Jan Lumholdt (Jackson: U. P. of Mississippi, 2003), p. 130. .
Recommended publications
  • Ominous Faultlines in a World Gone Wrong: Courmayeur Noir in Festival Randy Malamud
    Ominous Faultlines in a World Gone Wrong: Courmayeur Noir In Festival Randy Malamud In the sublime shadows of the Italian Alps, Courmayeur Confidential, Mulholland Drive, The Dark Knight trilogy), Noir In Festival’s 23-year run suggests America’s monop- hyper-noir (even ‘noirer’ than noir! Sin City, Django Un- 1 oly on this dark cinematic tradition may be on the wane. chained), and tech noir (The Matrix, cyberpunk) it remained The roots of film noir wind broadly through the geogra- a made-in-America commodity. phy of film history. One assumes it’s American to the core: Courmayeur’s 2013 program proved that contemporary Humphrey Bogart, Orson Welles, Dashiell Hammett. But noir, like anything poised to thrive nowadays, is indubita- au contraire, the term itself (obviously) emanates from bly global. Its December event featured Hong Kong film- a Gallic sensibility: French critic Nino Frank planted the maker Johnny To’s wonderfully macabre comedy, Blind flag when he coined ‘‘film noir’’ in 1946. He was discussing Detective (with the funniest crime reenactment scenes American films, but still: it took a Frenchman to appreci- ever); Erik Matti’s Filipino killer-thriller On the Job; and 2 ate them. Or maybe the genre is German, growing out Argentinian Lucı´a Puenzo’s resonantly disturbing Wakol- of Weimar expressionism, strassenfilm (street stories), da, an adaptation of her own novel about Josef Mengele’s 3 Lang’s M. 1960 refuge in a remote Patagonian Naziphile community. In fact, film noir is a hybrid which began to flourish in The Black Lion jury award went to Denis Villeneuve’s 1940s Hollywood, but was molded by displaced Europeans Enemy, a Canadian production adapted from Jose´ Sarama- (Billy Wilder, Alfred Hitchcock, Otto Preminger) and go’s Portuguese novel The Double (and with a bona fide keenly inflected by their continental aesthetic and philo- binational spirit).
    [Show full text]
  • Dogme 95 and the Representation of Reality Zsolt Gyenge Moholy-Nagy University of Art and Design, Budapest (Hungary) Email: [email protected]
    Acta Univ. Sapientiae, Film and Media Studies, 1 (2009) 6979 Illusions of Reality and Fiction or the Desired Reality of Fiction: Dogme 95 and the Representation of Reality Zsolt Gyenge Moholy-Nagy University of Art and Design, Budapest (Hungary) email: [email protected] Abstract. The paper identies a two channel strategy developed by the authors of the Danish Dogme lms having as goal the generation of the illusion of reality. The rst channel is aiming at the visual layer of the movies, which shows a rm decision to break with the style of the traditional ction lms. The second channel of this strategy is concerned with the narration of the lms. In this regard Dogme contrary to what had been declared in the Vow of Chastity chose one of the most popular lm and TV genres: melodrama. On the one hand Dogme lms created a highly self-reexive visual style and then they combined it on the other hand with a genre which calls for extreme audience identication. Documentarism and deeply conventionalized stories are put together in most Dogme lms to create the reality of ction. Movie is not an illusion states the Manifesto,1 and thus it makes us clear that the movement tries to say something about one of the major themes of cinema and lm theory (and of visual communication in general): the representation of reality. It is well known that the initiators of Dogme 952 1The two founding documents of the Dogme 95 are the Manifesto and the Vow of Chastity. Until recently they were to be found on the ocial website (www.dogme95.dk) of the movement, which in February 2009, during the nal revision of this paper, became unavailable.
    [Show full text]
  • Éloge D'un Cinéma Pauvre, Politique Et Populaire
    ÉLOGE D’UN CINÉMA PAUVRE, POLITIQUE ET POPULAIRE Mémoire de fin d’études Antoine Garnier Département Production – Promotion Ennio Morricone 2018 Mai 2018 Sous la direction de : Pascal Caucheteux, Christophe Rossignon et Christine Ghazarian « Si on veut s’exprimer en apportant un point de vue différent, il faut trouver des idées pour contourner les problèmes, il faut que l’imagination soit au pouvoir, que l’envie de faire un film soit assez forte pour le faire avec presque rien. » Marin Karmitz1 1 Luc DELISSE, Frédéric SOJCHER (sous la dir.), Films à petits budgets : Contrainte ou liberté, Éditions du Rocher, coll. Caméra Subjective, 2007, p. 139 1 REMERCIEMENTS Je tiens tout d’abord à remercier les directeurs du département production de la Fémis, Pascal Caucheteux, Christophe Rossignon et Christine Ghazarian, pour leur présence et leur disponibilité durant ces quatre années à l’école. Je remercie les personnes avec qui j’ai eu la chance de m’entretenir pour les besoins de ce travail : Emmanuel Chaumet, Daniel Sauvage, Paul-Anthony Mille, Eric Altmayer, Vincent Le Port et Antonin Peretjatko. Pour leur aide précieuse pour la rédaction de ce mémoire je voudrais également remercier Caroline San Martin et Marielle Alluchon. Mais aussi l’ensemble du personnel de la Fémis, les assistantes d’années, les personnes en charge des moyens techniques ainsi que les gardiens qui m’ont permis de passer quatre années formidables. Je remercie les amis que j’ai rencontrés au sein de l’école. Ceux du premier jour, Pierre et Pierre-Jean, mais aussi ceux que j’ai appris à connaître le temps faisant, Clément, Flavia, Armin, Thomas, Luce, Magalie et d’autres.
    [Show full text]
  • The Mutual Influence of Science Fiction and Innovation
    Nesta Working Paper No. 13/07 Better Made Up: The Mutual Influence of Science fiction and Innovation Caroline Bassett Ed Steinmueller George Voss Better Made Up: The Mutual Influence of Science fiction and Innovation Caroline Bassett Ed Steinmueller George Voss Reader in Digital Media, Professor of Information and Research Fellow, Faculty of Arts, Research Centre for Material Technology, SPRU, University University of Brighton, Visiting Digital Culture, School of of Communication Sussex Fellow at SPRU, University of Media, Film and Music, Sussex University of Sussex Nesta Working Paper 13/07 March 2013 www.nesta.org.uk/wp13-07 Abstract This report examines the relationship between SF and innovation, defined as one of mutual engagement and even co-constitution. It develops a framework for tracing the relationships between real world science and technology and innovation and science fiction/speculative fiction involving processes of transformation, central to which are questions of influence, persuasion, and desire. This is contrasted with the more commonplace assumption of direct linear transmission, SF providing the inventive seed for innovation– instances of which are the exception rather than the rule. The model of influence is developed through an investigation of the nature and evolution of genre, the various effects/appeals of different forms of expression, and the ways in which SF may be appropriated by its various audiences. This is undertaken (i) via an inter- disciplinary survey of work on SF, and a consideration the historical construction of genre and its on-going importance, (ii) through the development of a prototype database exploring transformational paths, and via more elaborated loops extracted from the database, and (iii) via experiments with the development of a web crawl tool, to understand at a different scale, using tools of digital humanities, how fictional ideas travel.
    [Show full text]
  • The Undead Subject of Lost Decade Japanese Horror Cinema a Thesis
    The Undead Subject of Lost Decade Japanese Horror Cinema A thesis presented to the faculty of the College of Fine Arts of Ohio University In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree Master of Arts Jordan G. Parrish August 2017 © 2017 Jordan G. Parrish. All Rights Reserved. 2 This thesis titled The Undead Subject of Lost Decade Japanese Horror Cinema by JORDAN G. PARRISH has been approved for the Film Division and the College of Fine Arts by Ofer Eliaz Assistant Professor of Film Studies Matthew R. Shaftel Dean, College of Fine Arts 3 Abstract PARRISH, JORDAN G., M.A., August 2017, Film Studies The Undead Subject of Lost Decade Japanese Horror Cinema Director of Thesis: Ofer Eliaz This thesis argues that Japanese Horror films released around the turn of the twenty- first century define a new mode of subjectivity: “undead subjectivity.” Exploring the implications of this concept, this study locates the undead subject’s origins within a Japanese recession, decimated social conditions, and a period outside of historical progression known as the “Lost Decade.” It suggests that the form and content of “J- Horror” films reveal a problematic visual structure haunting the nation in relation to the gaze of a structural father figure. In doing so, this thesis purports that these films interrogate psychoanalytic concepts such as the gaze, the big Other, and the death drive. This study posits themes, philosophies, and formal elements within J-Horror films that place the undead subject within a worldly depiction of the afterlife, the films repeatedly ending on an image of an emptied-out Japan invisible to the big Other’s gaze.
    [Show full text]
  • Rebel Or Outlaw? Shared Leadership in a Filmmaking Company Strandgaard, Jesper
    Rebel or Outlaw? Shared Leadership in a Filmmaking Company Strandgaard, Jesper Document Version Final published version Publication date: 2011 License CC BY-NC-ND Citation for published version (APA): Strandgaard, J. (2011). Rebel or Outlaw? Shared Leadership in a Filmmaking Company. imagine.. CBS. Link to publication in CBS Research Portal General rights Copyright and moral rights for the publications made accessible in the public portal are retained by the authors and/or other copyright owners and it is a condition of accessing publications that users recognise and abide by the legal requirements associated with these rights. Take down policy If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us ([email protected]) providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim. Download date: 27. Sep. 2021 Rebel or Outlaw? Shared Leadership in a Filmmaking Company By Jesper Strandgaard December 2011 Page 1 of 47 Creative Encounters Working Paper # 68 Abstract How can organizations innovate and break with conventions without losing their legitimacy? Organizing for legitimacy (serving tradition and convention) often contrasts organizing for innovation and is often perceived a choice between two evils. This paper suggests that leaders can reconcile the legitimacy-innovation tension by combining and addressing them as two complimentary processes. An ethnographic case study depicts how shared leadership in a highly successful filmmaking company, confronts the legitimacy-innovation tension and, based on a combination of ‘out-of-fashion’ and contra-intuitive actions, their search for new solutions makes them balance between being a rebel or an outlaw. Keywords Filmmaking, Innovation-legitimation balance, Rebel identity Page 2 of 31 Creative Encounters Working Papers # 68 Rebel or Outlaw? Shared Leadership in a Filmmaking Company.
    [Show full text]
  • Playing with Our Emotions: Genre, Realism and Reflexivity in the Films
    Playing With Our Emotions: Genre, Realism and Reflexivity in the Films of Lars von Trier by Tamar Ditzian A Thesis submitted to the Faculty of Graduate Studies of The University of Manitoba in partial fulfilment of the requirements of the degree of MASTER OF ARTS Department of English, Film and Theatre University of Manitoba Winnipeg Table of Contents Acknowledgements...............................................................................................................i Abstract................................................................................................................................ii Introduction........................................................................................................................1 Chapter I: Mixed Feelings About Dancer in the Dark..................................................13 Chapter II: Dogville as Brechtian Melodrama?............................................................57 Conclusion......................................................................................................................108 Works Cited.....................................................................................................................113 Acknowledgements First and foremost, I wish to extend my deepest gratitude to my advisor, Dr. Brenda Austin-Smith, for her patience and infinite optimism, particularly in the face of those embarrassing early drafts. Her critical questioning and challenging of my ideas and of their expression, from which (thankfully) I had no respite
    [Show full text]
  • Dogme 95 Cinema Series to Premiere at MAD on Occasion of Movement’S 20Th Anniversary
    Dogme 95 Cinema Series to Premiere at MAD on Occasion of Movement’s 20th Anniversary The Director Must Not Be Credited: 20 Years of Dogme 95 explores lasting effects of iconoclastic movement New York, NY (January 21, 2015)—This March, the Museum of Arts and Design is pleased to present The Director Must Not Be Credited: 20 Years of Dogme 95, a cinema series exploring the enduring legacy of the game-changing film movement. Premiering on March 13, 2015, the twentieth anniversary of Danish filmmakers Lars von Trier and Thomas Vinterberg’s revolutionary manifesto, the series features nine, rarely screened films recognized by the Dogme 95 committee—many of which never received US distributions. Together, these films highlight the growth of Dogme 95 into a worldwide movement that spanned genres and forever changed the ways in which narrative feature films are made. On March 13, 1995, Lars von Trier showered the audience of a conference celebrating the 100th anniversary of cinema with pamphlets outlining his newly crafted Dogme 95 manifesto. Co-written with fellow filmmaker Thomas Vinterberg, the manifesto, dubbed the Vow of Chastity, outlined ten dogmatic rules that encouraged a return to traditional values of story, acting and theme, embraced emerging video technology, and banned the use of elaborate special effects in cinema. At its core, the Dogme manifesto aimed to restore a transparency to filmmaking and challenge mainstream cinematic conventions of the time. “Dogme 95 is arguably one of the most important cinematic movements since the French New Wave,” says Jake Yuzna, MAD’s Director of Public Programs.
    [Show full text]
  • Scms 2015 Conference Program Preliminary Draft
    SCMS 2015 CONFERENCE PROGRAM PRELIMINARY DRAFT Please review the preliminary draft of the 2015 Montreal Conference Program and send your minor corrections or changes (affiliation, order of presentations, format issues or spelling corrections) to [email protected] by January 9, 2015 at 5PM CT. SCMS cannot accommodate requests for changes in the scheduled day or time of the panels or workshops. Please note that corrections will not be made to the preliminary draft. They will be included in the final printed program that will be available at the conference. To look up author names select the Find button on the tool bar and enter the author's name in the upper left corner of the search box and return. You can also use Ctrl + F to locate the author's name. Note: Open call panel chair assignments are not final. Volunteer chairs are still being assigned. Room numbers are for administrative use only. Due to possible changes in room assignments, the names of the rooms will be included in the final printed program only. REGISTRATION Conference presenters who have not become members and paid the conference registration fee by January 30, 2015 at 5PM CT will be deleted from the final printed program. To register: https://cmstudies.site- ym.com/?page=conf_registration CANCELLATION/REFUND POLICY All cancellation notifications and requests for conference registration refunds must be submitted online by 5PM CT, Friday, February 25, 2015. No cancellations by phone or email. Conference registration refunds will be processed at 80% of the amount paid.
    [Show full text]
  • Classified by Genre: Rhetorical Genrefication in Cinema by © 2019 Carl Joseph Swanson M.A., Saint Louis University, 2013 B.L.S., University of Missouri-St
    Classified by Genre: Rhetorical Genrefication in Cinema By © 2019 Carl Joseph Swanson M.A., Saint Louis University, 2013 B.L.S., University of Missouri-St. Louis, 2010 Submitted to the graduate degree program in Film and Media Studies and the Graduate Faculty of the University of Kansas in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. Chair: Catherine Preston Co-Chair: Joshua Miner Michael Baskett Ron Wilson Amy Devitt Date Defended: 26 April 2019 ii The dissertation committee for Carl Joseph Swanson certifies that this is the approved version of the following dissertation: Classified by Genre: Rhetorical Genrefication in Cinema Chair: Catherine Preston Co-Chair: Joshua Miner Date Approved: 26 April 2019 iii Abstract This dissertation argues for a rethinking and expansion of film genre theory. As the variety of media exhibition platforms expands and as discourse about films permeates a greater number of communication media, the use of generic terms has never been more multiform or observable. Fundamental problems in the very conception of film genre have yet to be addressed adequately, and film genre study has carried on despite its untenable theoretical footing. Synthesizing pragmatic genre theory, constructivist film theory, Bourdieusian fan studies, and rhetorical genre studies, the dissertation aims to work through the radical implications of pragmatic genre theory and account for genres role in interpretation, evaluation, and rhetorical framing as part of broader, recurring social activities. This model rejects textualist and realist foundations for film genre; only pragmatic genre use can serve as a foundation for understanding film genres. From this perspective, the concept of genre is reconstructed according to its interpretive and rhetorical functions rather than a priori assumptions about the text or transtextual structures.
    [Show full text]
  • Le Cinéma Remoderniste Histoire Et Théorie D'une Esthétique Contemporaine
    UNIVERSITÉ SORBONNE NOUVELLE – PARIS III Mémoire final de Master 2 Mention : Études cinématographiques et audiovisuelles Spécialité : Recherche Titre : LE CINÉMA REMODERNISTE HISTOIRE ET THÉORIE D'UNE ESTHÉTIQUE CONTEMPORAINE Auteur : Florian MARICOURT n° 21207254 Mémoire final dirigé par Nicole BRENEZ Soutenu à la session de juin 2014 LE CINÉMA REMODERNISTE HISTOIRE ET THÉORIE D'UNE ESTHÉTIQUE CONTEMPORAINE Florian Maricourt Illustration de couverture : Photogramme extrait de Notre espoir est inconsolable (Florian Maricourt, 2013) Une chanson que braille une fille en brossant l'escalier me bouleverse plus qu'une savante cantate. Chacun son goût. J'aime le peu. J'aime aussi l'embryonnaire, le mal façonné, l'imparfait, le mêlé. J'aime mieux les diamants bruts, dans leur gangue. Et avec crapauds. Jean Dubuffet Prospectus et tous écrits suivants, 1951 En ces temps d'énormité, de films à grand spectacle, de productions à cent millions de dollars, je veux prendre la parole en faveur du petit, des actes invisibles de l’esprit humain, si subtils, si petits qu’ils meurent dès qu’on les place sous les sunlights. Je veux célébrer les petites formes cinématographiques, les formes lyriques, les poèmes, les aquarelles, les études, les esquisses, les cartes postales, les arabesques, les triolets, les bagatelles et les petits chants en 8mm. Jonas Mekas Manifeste contre le centenaire du cinéma, 1996 i am a desperate man who will not bow down to acolayed or success i am a desperate man who loves the simplisity of painting and hates gallarys and white walls and the dealers in art who loves unreasonableness and hot headedness who loves contradiction hates publishing houses and also i am vincent van gough Billy Childish I am the Strange Hero of Hunger, 2005 Je tiens à remercier chaleureusement les cinéastes remodernistes qui ont aimablement répondu à mes questions, en particulier Scott Barley, Heidi Elise Beaver, Dean Kavanagh, Rouzbeh Rashidi, Roy Rezaäli, Jesse Richards et Peter Rinaldi.
    [Show full text]
  • Review Essay: Cognitivism Goes to the Movies
    s6_PROJ-040106 4/5/10 4:27 PM Page 83 Review Essay: Cognitivism Goes to the Movies Robert Sinnerbrink Paisley Livingston and Carl Plantinga, eds., The Routledge Companion to Philos- ophy and Film (London and New York: Routledge, 2009), xix + 672 pp., $152.00 (cloth). Carl Plantinga, Moving Viewers: American Film and the Spectator’s Experience (Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 2009), xii + 280 pp., $21.33 (paperback). Torben Grodal, Embodied Visions: Evolution, Emotion, Culture, and Film (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2009), viii + 324 pp., $30.78 (paperback). In just under twenty five years, analytic philosophy of film and cognitivist film theory have joined forces in a formidable research paradigm, one that has moved from keen rival to would-be victor in the battle for the “arts and minds” (to quote Gregory Currie) of film theorists and students of the moving image. David Bordwell’s Narration in the Fiction Film (1985), Noël Carroll’s “The Power of Movies” (1985), and Bordwell’s “A Case for Cognitivism” (1989), pioneered the wave of film theory during the 1990s that based itself, not on Lacanian psychoanalysis or various maîtres à penser, but rather on analytic philosophy and cognitive psychology. Noël Carroll’s Mystifying Movies (1988) famously at- tacked what he and Bordwell later dubbed “grand theory” (psychoanalytic, semiotic, and ideologico-critical film theory of the 1970s and 1980s). Bordwell and Carroll followed up with their jointly edited landmark volume Post-Theory: Reconstructing Film Studies (1996), which advocated the kind of empirical mid- dle-level theorizing—shaped by analytic and cognitivist approaches—that aimed to define the future of the discipline.
    [Show full text]