<<

Non-Profit Org N E W M E X I C O US Postage PAID En viro nmen tal Law C ent er Santa Fe, NM 1405 Luisa St reet, Suite #5 | Santa Fe ,NM 875 05 Permit No. 259 505.989.9022 nmelc .org RETURN SERVICE REQUESTED

Twitter .com/NMELC Facebook .com/NMELC Impact Report

2New Mexic016o Environmental Law Cente r |

NMELC 2016 DOC KET 20 16 Clients:

Representation by Amigos Bravos CASE TYPE Colonias Development Council 16 Communities for Clean Water Uranium Mining Concerned Citizens for Nuclear Safety & Reclamation Earthworks Eastern Navajo Diné Against Uranium 9 Mining (ENDAUM) Federal Facilities Friends of Santa Fe County (LAN L/ KAFB) Gila Conservation Coalition 5 Gila Resources Information Project (GRIP) Air Quality Honor Our Pueblo Existence (H .O.P.E.) Individuals 5 Lea County Concerned Citizens Hardrock Mariano Lake Chapter Citizens Mining Mesquite Community Action Committee Multicultural Alliance for a Safe 4 Environment (MASE) Water Right s& Speculation New Mexico Health Equity Working Group Nuclear Watch New Mexico 4 Oil and Gas Accountability Project 2016 Year In Revie w: Oil & Gas Pajarito Village Association Drilling Red Water Pond Road Community Assoc. 3 Rio Bonito Preserve Pr otecting New Mexico’s communities Industrial Rio Grande Chapter of the Sierra Club Dairies Rio Valle Concerned Citizens and our air, land and water in the fight 5 SouthWest Organizing Project (SWOP) for environmental justice. Other Taos Pueblo TEWA Women United Turner Ranch Properties Cover photo: Protesting the proposed Santolina mega-development, courtesy of SWOP

2016 Unaudited Financial Report 2016NMELC Annual Report By the end of 2016 we knew the road ahead was going to be a ( Januar y1,2016 – Decembe r31,2016) rocky one. We didn’t know then just how difficult it would be. But as I write this letter in spring 2017, it’s clear that our environment – and low-income communities and communities of Bequests realized • • Special Events, Products, Interest 2017 Law Center Board of Directors color that often bear the brunt of environmental degradation – Fees &Cost • & market gains Michael Casaus, Albuquerque, President are going to be even more vulnerable over the next four years. reimbursements 5% 1% 5% Eileen Gauna, Albuquerque , Vice-Pre sident In New Mexico, we have been dealing since 2011 with an Ramón Padilla, Jr., Las Cruces, Secretary administration that favors the financial interests of industry Harry Browne, Treasurer, Silver City and development over the basic protections of individual Myron Armijo, Santa Ana Pueblo residents’ health and wellbeing. We fought hard every day Stuart Bluestone, Santa Fe of 2016 to preserve protective regulations, promote safe and 31% Sandy Buffett, sustainable industry practices, and to defend the right of the Individuals & Albuquerque public to participate in rulemaking processes. Green Business Susanne Hoffman-Dooley, Santa Fe Partners 58% Donna House, Alcalde As you’ll see in our Top 10 list of case highlights through the year, Foundations Renee Ingold, Fallbrook, CA we achieved a number of important successes. Environmental law A. Paul Mitchell, Albuquerque is a long game. Some victories, such as the hard-won termination Terry Odendahl, Boulder, CO of the Churchrock uranium permit, are meaningful outcomes for Kitty Richards, Albuquerque our clients. Other successes came in the form of simply preserving Juan Reynosa, Albuquerque the right to keep fighting. This is important, as while we are fighting , Frank Sanchez, Roswell often the destructive activity we are fighting against cannot move Total Income: $815,347 forward. Law Center Staff Administration We vow to fight just as hard when rollbacks of federal regulations & general • Jonathan M. Block, Staff Attorney and decimation of protective agencies such as the Environmental Juana Colón, Protection Agency itself threaten harm to the air we breathe, the Public Education Officer 7% water we drink, and the land we inhabit here in New Mexico. Eric Jantz, Staff Attorney And we promise to keep fighting our own state administration Janiece Jonsin, Administrative Assistant when necessary to protect our resources and our communities 15% Shelbie Knox, Development Officer as well. The fight can only happen with your support. Development Elizabeth Lee, Director of Philanthropy & fundraising Douglas Meiklejohn, Executive Director Yana Merrill, Director of Administration & Finance 78% Jaimie Park, Staff Attorney Program Expenses Baxter, Brisa and Lulu, Office Dogs General community & Native American Thank you for making it possible. representation If you have any questions about our accounting, please contact Douglas Meiklejohn Yana Merrill, Director of Exe cutive Director Administration and Finance, at [email protected] or call Total Expenses: $935,321 (505) 989-9022.

Foundation revenue does not include multi-year grants pledged in 2016 and does not include revenue from multi-year grants booked in earlier years, as required by Generally Accepted Accounting Principles. 2 ww w.nmelc.org Photo: ©2015 Marjorie Kamine 3 Cover photo: Protesting the proposed Santolina mega-development, courtesy of SWOP

2016 Unaudited Financial Report 2016NMELC Annual Report By the end of 2016 we knew the road ahead was going to be a ( Januar y1,2016 – Decembe r31,2016) rocky one. We didn’t know then just how difficult it would be. But as I write this letter in spring 2017, it’s clear that our environment – and low-income communities and communities of Bequests realized • • Special Events, Products, Interest 2017 Law Center Board of Directors color that often bear the brunt of environmental degradation – Fees &Cost • & market gains Michael Casaus, Albuquerque, President are going to be even more vulnerable over the next four years. reimbursements 5% 1% 5% Eileen Gauna, Albuquerque , Vice-Pre sident In New Mexico, we have been dealing since 2011 with an Ramón Padilla, Jr., Las Cruces, Secretary administration that favors the financial interests of industry Harry Browne, Treasurer, Silver City and development over the basic protections of individual Myron Armijo, Santa Ana Pueblo residents’ health and wellbeing. We fought hard every day Stuart Bluestone, Santa Fe of 2016 to preserve protective regulations, promote safe and 31% Sandy Buffett, sustainable industry practices, and to defend the right of the Individuals & Albuquerque public to participate in rulemaking processes. Green Business Susanne Hoffman-Dooley, Santa Fe Partners 58% Donna House, Alcalde As you’ll see in our Top 10 list of case highlights through the year, Foundations Renee Ingold, Fallbrook, CA we achieved a number of important successes. Environmental law A. Paul Mitchell, Albuquerque is a long game. Some victories, such as the hard-won termination Terry Odendahl, Boulder, CO of the Churchrock uranium permit, are meaningful outcomes for Kitty Richards, Albuquerque our clients. Other successes came in the form of simply preserving Juan Reynosa, Albuquerque the right to keep fighting. This is important, as while we are fighting , Frank Sanchez, Roswell often the destructive activity we are fighting against cannot move Total Income: $815,347 forward. Law Center Staff Administration We vow to fight just as hard when rollbacks of federal regulations & general • Jonathan M. Block, Staff Attorney and decimation of protective agencies such as the Environmental Juana Colón, Protection Agency itself threaten harm to the air we breathe, the Public Education Officer 7% water we drink, and the land we inhabit here in New Mexico. Eric Jantz, Staff Attorney And we promise to keep fighting our own state administration Janiece Jonsin, Administrative Assistant when necessary to protect our resources and our communities 15% Shelbie Knox, Development Officer as well. The fight can only happen with your support. Development Elizabeth Lee, Director of Philanthropy & fundraising Douglas Meiklejohn, Executive Director Yana Merrill, Director of Administration & Finance 78% Jaimie Park, Staff Attorney Program Expenses Baxter, Brisa and Lulu, Office Dogs General community & Native American Thank you for making it possible. representation If you have any questions about our accounting, please contact Douglas Meiklejohn Yana Merrill, Director of Exe cutive Director Administration and Finance, at [email protected] or call Total Expenses: $935,321 (505) 989-9022.

Foundation revenue does not include multi-year grants pledged in 2016 and does not include revenue from multi-year grants booked in earlier years, as required by Generally Accepted Accounting Principles. 2 ww w.nmelc.org Photo: ©2015 Marjorie Kamine 3 Im pact Report To p10 Stories of the Ye ar P

2016 O W S

f

1 o

Once again, the Law Center held the line at the State Legislature! Thanks to persistent efforts by executive y s e t

director Doug Meiklejohn and our many allies at the Roundhouse, not a single bad environmental bill got r u o

through in the 2016 session. C

o t o h 2 In a case that threatens drinking water for half a million residents of Albuquerque, the Law Center Photo: Kirtland AFB P entered into negotiations with the US Air Force to push for expedited cleanup of more than 24 million gallons of highly carcinogenic jet fuel that was discovered in 1999 to be leaking from a facility on the 7 Bringing the (former) might of the EPA down on local polluters, the agency decided to Kirtland Air Force Base. The toxic underground plume is moving toward several drinking water wells. investigate the Albuquerque Air Board for civil rights violations after Law Center staff The Air Force requested the confidential negotiations after the Law Center filed intent of notice to sue on attorney Eric Jantz and our client SouthWest Organizing Project (SWOP) filed a complaint behalf of SWOP, two state senators and several Albuquerque residents. against it for ignoring poor air quality in environmental justice neighborhoods. Following the EPA notice, the Board agreed to respond to complaints in writing and to engage in informal n ó l

o dispute resolution with SWOP . Since Trump took office, however, the Board has taken no substantive C

a

n or meaningful steps toward addressing the problems. a u J

, C

L 8 In an Inspection of Public Records Act request related to In 2016, the New Mexico State Engineer gave Augustin Plains Ranch, LLC E

M a chance to resubmit its failed application for more than 17 billion gallons

N proposed ground water regulation amendments, s taff

:

o of water annually. NMELC represents nearly 100 residents of west-central t

o attorney Jaimie Park discovered a literal "Hit List" of

h New Mexico in their effort to defeat the Ranch's speculative scheme. P protective environmental regulations that the state © Environment Department had targeted for attack. Jaimie filed comprehensive comments on the proposed amendments to surface and groundwater regulations, n ó l

o which constitute an attempt to limit public participation in C

a

n the permitting process and roll back standards for certain a u J

, contaminants. A hearing will be held in the future. C 3 we won our case to force the State to terminate a groundwater L

In a hard-fought and welcome victory, E M

N 9

discharge permit for a new, controversial uranium mine proposed near Church Rock, NM. Eight years after it began, the Law Center and our client, : o t

Without a valid permit, mining cannot begin at the site. o the Rio Bonito Preserve, closed a successful case that will h P help keep water running in the beautiful Rio Bonito, © 4 In a very disappointing decision, the New Mexico Supreme Court declined to hear our which flows through Lincoln County. appeal of the Pit Rule , which governs the storage and disposal of wastes at oil and gas drilling pits in the state. Serving as co-counsel with the New Mexico Wilderness 10 Culminating more than four years of fighting the statewide Alliance, representing Earthworks’ Oil and Gas Accountability Project, the Law Center Copper Rule, the Law Center presented oral argument had been fighting to overturn the Rule since it was gutted in 2013. before the state Supreme Court. The rule, adopted in 2013, is 5 In a major victory for our clients fighting the proposed Santolina mega-development P on the first regulation since the state’s I R G

the western edge of Albuquerque, the 2nd Judicial District Court denied three attempts by our adoption of its Water Quality Act in 1967 that allows an entire industry to f o

y

opponent to get our appeals of the Level A Master Plan dismissed. As of press time, we are waiting for intentionally pollute groundwater. The court’s ruling will set s e t r u

a ruling on our arguments against the scheme, including that the developers have not proven the project precedent for how New Mexico protects water at industrial o C

o

has water. Executive director Doug Meiklejohn and staff attorney Jaimie Park continue to fight approval sites throughout the state. As of publication , the court has t o h

of the next step in the developer’s path, the Level B Master Plan. not yet issued its decision. This was our last line of P defense – until the next governor takes office… 6 Law Center staff attorney Jon Block and our client, Nuclear Watch New Mexico, filed a lawsuit in federal court against the Department of Energy and Los Alamos National Security, the for-profit operator of Los Alamos National Laboratory, over failure to meet critical cleanup milestones under a 2005 “Consent Order” they agreed to with the New Mexico Environment Department . Our suit claims 12 violations of missed deadlines, of up to 675 days each . Our initial cost estimate of the alleged violations? $300 million and counting!

4 © Photo: Nuclear Watch NM © Background photo: NMELC, Shelbie Knox 5 Im pact Report To p10 Stories of the Ye ar P

2016 O W S

f

1 o

Once again, the Law Center held the line at the State Legislature! Thanks to persistent efforts by executive y s e t

director Doug Meiklejohn and our many allies at the Roundhouse, not a single bad environmental bill got r u o

through in the 2016 session. C

o t o h 2 In a case that threatens drinking water for half a million residents of Albuquerque, the Law Center Photo: Kirtland AFB P entered into negotiations with the US Air Force to push for expedited cleanup of more than 24 million gallons of highly carcinogenic jet fuel that was discovered in 1999 to be leaking from a facility on the 7 Bringing the (former) might of the EPA down on local polluters, the agency decided to Kirtland Air Force Base. The toxic underground plume is moving toward several drinking water wells. investigate the Albuquerque Air Board for civil rights violations after Law Center staff The Air Force requested the confidential negotiations after the Law Center filed intent of notice to sue on attorney Eric Jantz and our client SouthWest Organizing Project (SWOP) filed a complaint behalf of SWOP, two state senators and several Albuquerque residents. against it for ignoring poor air quality in environmental justice neighborhoods. Following the EPA notice, the Board agreed to respond to complaints in writing and to engage in informal n ó l

o dispute resolution with SWOP . Since Trump took office, however, the Board has taken no substantive C

a

n or meaningful steps toward addressing the problems. a u J

, C

L 8 In an Inspection of Public Records Act request related to In 2016, the New Mexico State Engineer gave Augustin Plains Ranch, LLC E

M a chance to resubmit its failed application for more than 17 billion gallons

N proposed ground water regulation amendments, s taff

:

o of water annually. NMELC represents nearly 100 residents of west-central t

o attorney Jaimie Park discovered a literal "Hit List" of

h New Mexico in their effort to defeat the Ranch's speculative scheme. P protective environmental regulations that the state © Environment Department had targeted for attack. Jaimie filed comprehensive comments on the proposed amendments to surface and groundwater regulations, n ó l

o which constitute an attempt to limit public participation in C

a

n the permitting process and roll back standards for certain a u J

, contaminants. A hearing will be held in the future. C 3 we won our case to force the State to terminate a groundwater L

In a hard-fought and welcome victory, E M

N 9

discharge permit for a new, controversial uranium mine proposed near Church Rock, NM. Eight years after it began, the Law Center and our client, : o t

Without a valid permit, mining cannot begin at the site. o the Rio Bonito Preserve, closed a successful case that will h P help keep water running in the beautiful Rio Bonito, © 4 In a very disappointing decision, the New Mexico Supreme Court declined to hear our which flows through Lincoln County. appeal of the Pit Rule , which governs the storage and disposal of wastes at oil and gas drilling pits in the state. Serving as co-counsel with the New Mexico Wilderness 10 Culminating more than four years of fighting the statewide Alliance, representing Earthworks’ Oil and Gas Accountability Project, the Law Center Copper Rule, the Law Center presented oral argument had been fighting to overturn the Rule since it was gutted in 2013. before the state Supreme Court. The rule, adopted in 2013, is 5 In a major victory for our clients fighting the proposed Santolina mega-development P on the first regulation since the state’s I R G

the western edge of Albuquerque, the 2nd Judicial District Court denied three attempts by our adoption of its Water Quality Act in 1967 that allows an entire industry to f o

y

opponent to get our appeals of the Level A Master Plan dismissed. As of press time, we are waiting for intentionally pollute groundwater. The court’s ruling will set s e t r u

a ruling on our arguments against the scheme, including that the developers have not proven the project precedent for how New Mexico protects water at industrial o C

o

has water. Executive director Doug Meiklejohn and staff attorney Jaimie Park continue to fight approval sites throughout the state. As of publication , the court has t o h

of the next step in the developer’s path, the Level B Master Plan. not yet issued its decision. This was our last line of P defense – until the next governor takes office… 6 Law Center staff attorney Jon Block and our client, Nuclear Watch New Mexico, filed a lawsuit in federal court against the Department of Energy and Los Alamos National Security, the for-profit operator of Los Alamos National Laboratory, over failure to meet critical cleanup milestones under a 2005 “Consent Order” they agreed to with the New Mexico Environment Department . Our suit claims 12 violations of missed deadlines, of up to 675 days each . Our initial cost estimate of the alleged violations? $300 million and counting!

4 © Photo: Nuclear Watch NM © Background photo: NMELC, Shelbie Knox 5

6

Thank you! Your generous support makes our work possible. 1 New Mexico 2016 Law Center Supporters 0 Environmental Law Center Green2 BusinessPartners Institutional Funders Ann Hardy Batum Spin Dunbar Diane Jacoby Susan Morgan Ira and Lorraine Schwartz Time and Talents Given By: Anonymous Anne E. Beckett Ellen and Bill Dupuy Patricia Jahoda Letitia Morris Norman A. Segel Diana Baker Albuquerque Community Foundation, Sage Fund Susan Bell Greg Dye and Estevan Trujillo Suzanne Jamison Susan Morris Donna J. Seifert Lynda Brown For more information about our Partner program, contact Elizabeth Lee Herb Block Foundation Reed and Melinda Benson Mary Dykton Kitty Jansen Linda G Mowbray Bruce Shah Lara Christensen at 505.989.9022 x118, or [email protected]. Brindle Foundation Jean L. Bergeron Kathleen Economy Amy Jenkins Virginia Mudd and Clifford Burke Geoff and Catherine Shandler Colin Cox Caprock Fund of Tides Foundation, on the Amy Bertelli Connie Eichstaedt & Alan Osborne Tom and Jervis Werner and Helen Muller Laurence Shandler , M.D., & Joan Shandler Jamie Douglass recommendation of Ms. Kappy Wells Crawford Best Elizabeth Elliston Sam and Isabel Jewell Ann Mumford Deborah Shapiro Bruce Frederick, Esq. Combined Federal Campaign of the National Paul and Ellen Biderman Bernard Ewell and Sali Randell Richard and Ella Jones James Murphy Patricia A. Sheely Robert L. Hiller, Esq. Capital Area Garland Bills Allison Muller Fabara Mark and Susan Kalin Paula Musetta Betsy Sheils Tracy M. Hughes, Esq. Con Alma Health Foundation Sallie Bingham Fairholm Builders, Inc. Norty and Summers Kalishman Phil Musser and Carol MacLennan Danielle Shelley Paul Hultin, Esq. Dawn Hill Fund Susan Binneweg and Owen Jones James Faris Marjorie Kamine Shirley Ann Myers Betsy and Tom Shillinglaw Marjorie Kamine Desert Southwest Combined Federal Campaign Fred and Daryl Black Stuart Feen and Sunny Sonnenschein Heather Karlson and Bill Leeson Julia and Albert Nathanson Linda Siegle Warren Marr Dottie J. Barrett Giving Account Billie Blair and Gene Weisfeld Maria Fellin Diane Karp Judith Naumberg Janet Simon Marilyn Maxwell Douglass Family Foundation Joyce Blalock Ella Joan Fenoglio Dr. Kirt Kempter Jean Neblett Pat Simons Pat McDaniel EMA Foundation Stuart M. Bluestone, Esq. Elizabeth Ferguson Cynthia Kiersnowski Sharon Kellum Neuman and Ken and Martha Simonsen Colin McKenzie James M. Ewell Charitable Foundation Michele Boccia & Lewis Sawatzky Kathleen Fiero Larry J King Richard Neuman Water Singing-on-the-Rocks Michelle Mosser W.K. Kellogg Foundation Tony Bonanno Kristina Fisher and Phil Carter Holly Kinley News Corp Giving Daryl and Lucia Smith Phil Musser Charlotte L. Kiser Charitable Trust Karen Bonime and Richard Weiner Barbara Fix Gayle Kinsey Betsy Nichols Jane Smith-Decker William Olson, P.E. Lannan Foundation Adriano Bravo Thomas & Nancy Florsheim Family Fdn Don Kirby and Joan Gentry Noble Leona Sonne Alice Sealey Max and Anna Levinson Foundation Jane Brickner Richard and Karen Ford Richard Klein and Claire Zoeller Steven Oakey Sherill Spaar John Stroud, Esq. Livingry Foundation Grace Brill and Daniel Schwartz Wallace and Valerie Ford Pat Klock Elizabeth O'Brien Theodore Spencer Cathie Sullivan Maki Foundation William Briney Lisa Foster Shelbie Knox and David Clark Christopher O'Connor Elliot Steinberg, Esq. Alice van Buren Mills Family Foundation Michael Browde Jennifer Fowler-Propst Sandra Koenig Terry Odendahl Natali Steinberg Roderick Ventura, Esq. Mumford Family Foundation Lynda and Donald Brown Lisa Freeman Ruth and Paul Kovnat William C. Olson Stephens and Associates Garret Vreeland New Cycle Foundation Polly Brown and David Fowler Martha Anne Freeman Patricia Kuhlhoff Peter and Jean Ossorio Eliza Stewart Emma Warren New Mexico Community Foundation Timothy Brown Dody Fugate Diana Lahm Dennis and Trudy O’Toole Jean Stokes Joan West Lynda Taylor Environmen t, Education and Harry Browne Jamie Gagan, M.D. Joan Bluestone Landorf Lois Owens Nancy Stone Social Justice Fund, New Mexico Community Fdn . J & M Buchholz Gwendolyn Gallagher and Don Krier Michael and Barbara Langner George and Elise Packard Gavin F. Strathdee Gifts Made in Memory Of: New Society Fund Judith Buckingham Faith Garfield Ellen LaPenna Ramon Padilla Kim Straus, Jack Lain & Jose Lain-Straus Winston O. Abbott New-Land Foundation Sandy Buffett Eileen Gauna David and Barbara Larson Ronald Parry Persis Suddeth James B. Alley Jr. The Dennis A. O'Toole Family Foundation David W Burling Nicholas Gentry Robin Laughlin Jim and Jan Patterson Cathie Sullivan Frank Bell Patagonia, Inc. Mary Ellen Burns-Gonzales Sheila Gershen Kirsten Lear David and Therese Patton Kristine Suozzi Florence Dobrinski ink we ll PrairieFire Foundation Virginia Burris Marvin J. Godner, M.D. Elizabeth Lee Charles and Sharon Pedersen Scott Swearingen Gene Haber pro duc tions Santa Fe Community Foundation Jay Bush and Peggy Rudberg The Golden Eye Lynn Lee Van and Katherine Perkins Karen and Bob Sweeney Sebia Hawkins Blair-Weisfeld Fund, Santa Fe Community Fdn . J.A. Carden Dick Goldsmith Ellen Leitzer Roger Peterson Jane Swift David Henderson Cabin Fund, Santa Fe Community Fdn. Mary Jo Carol Goodman Deirdre Lennihan Patricia Phelps T & E Incorporated Susan Hertel connec on Cabin Fund, Santa Fe Community Fdn. Michael Casaus Eda Gordon Greg and Amy Lewis Stephen and Rodene Phillips John and Katie Tauxe Gwen Ifill Castagnola Family Fund, Santa Fe Community Fdn. Ellen Casey and Nubia Domres Susan Gordon Edwina Lieb Glenn Conroy & Jane Phillips-Conroy Edwina Taylor Keith A. Kellum Helen R. Homans Advised Donor Fund, Liliana Castillo Tom Gorman Jason A. Lillegraven Sarah Piltch and David Heber Margo Taylor Geraldine Kilpatrick the z uni Santa Fe Community Fdn. John Catron Fancher Gotesky Michael W. and Diane Lilley Ellen Pinnes Fred Teitelbaum Walter Maslowicz Just Woke Up Fund, Santa Fe Community Fdn . Mr. and Mrs. Thomas B. Catron Joel and Cherrin Green Carlie Lines and B.C. Rimbeaux Ray and Carol Pittman Alice Temple and Frank Herdman Donald and Betty Meiklejohn New Cycle Foundation, Santa Fe Community Fdn. Chambers George Greer, M.D. & Requa Tolbert Debra Link Plastic Bottle Corporation Mr. and Mrs. Simon Teolis Elizabeth Meiklejohn Sanford and Jane Brickner Advised Fund, Rod Chambers Gila Tree Thinners Jane Lipman Dan and Nancy Potter Beverly Terry Robert J. Myers Santa Fe Community Fdn. Susan Chappell, Esq. Sharon Gross Lucy Lippard Charles M. Powers Aija Thacher Paul V. Thompson Second Anonymous Fund, Santa Fe Wendy Chase Jana Gunnell, M.D., MPH Larry and Julianne Littlefield V.B. and Rini Price Gordon and Mary Anne Thompson Mary Tony Young Community Fdn. Barbara Chatterjee Peter Hagen & Lindsay Faulkner Hagen John Loges & Lori Remegio-Loges Betty Pritchard Todd Tibbals and Andrea Escher Susan and Conrad De Jong Fund, Santa Fe KESHI Gifts Made in Honor Of: Peter and Elizabeth Chestnut Gail and Daryl Haggard Margaret Loyd Jennifer Pruett and Kennan Girdner Mary Toll Community Fdn. Tom and Carol Aageson P.R .Christie Jim Hannan Arabelle Luckhardt Sheila Pugach Jere and Harry Turner TW Family Fund, Santa Fe Community Fdn. Jessica Aberly Cecilia Clark Wendell and Harriett Harris Mr. and Mrs. Donald Lundgren Joan Quinn Robert Lawrence & Olive Wilkinson Schwab and Donegan Gift Fund Richard Ford, Ph.D. Jack and Cindy Clark Richard and Anna Harrison Sonia Macdonald Dr . Patrick and Stacy Quinn Turnipseed Sierra Club Foundation Taran Hunter Camille Coates Jonathan E. Hartshorne Ouida MacGregor Bonnie Raitt Mary Uhl Sulica Fund Robin Laughlin A.T. and Cinda Cole Don and Cheryl Hastings Kimberly Macloud Bishop Ricardo Ramirez Kristin and Ross Ulibarri Thornburg Foundation Douglas Meiklejohn Juana Col ón Steven Hecht Carol Madley Edward and Melanie Ranney United Church of Santa Fe Turner Foundation Meiklejohn Legacy Circle Carol Condie Gary Hein Laurie Maitre Mary Ray Eric Unzicker, MD United Way of Central New Mexico Rose Miller Philip and Quarrier Cook Karen Heldmeyer, Ph.D. Hal Malone Margaret and Lewis Reade Alice Van Buren LILLE Y L AW OFFIC ES United Way of Northern New Mexico Alan Osborne and Connie Eichstaedt Dianne C. Cress & Jon B. McCorkell Juliana Henderson Eileen Mandel Lee Reynis Roderick Ventura and Josette Haddad LAS CRUCES Individual Donors Michael and Jennie Crews Gregg Henry and Wenda Trevathan Michael Mandell Geri Rhodes Stephen Verchinski 2016 Bequests Anonymous Florence Cromwell Ellen and Bruce Herr Claire Mandeville Jean Richards Donna and John Vogel Elaine Hounsell Thomas and Carol Aageson Bill and Liz Crosman Matthew and Julia Meredith Hess Sarah Manges Kitty Richards and Chuck Logan Wendy Volkmann Bonnie Jacobs Rick and Kathy Abeles Margo Cutler Ann and Jerry Hicks James C . and Sherry Martin Ronald Rinker Garret and Sandra Vreeland Eugene and Jane Petchesky Fund at the Naomi Aberly Nancy Dahl Catherine Hill Alexandria J. Martinez Michael Ripberger Adair Waldenberg and Jon Peck Santa Fe Community Foundation Rachel Aberly Roger and Jeanne Daigger Christianne Hinks James A . McGrath Rhonda Rivera Richard & Carol Warren Richard and Barbara Davis Robert and Patricia Hinton Barbara McIntyre Edward Roden-Lucero L. Watchempino Esther Abeyta Meiklejohn Legacy Circle TBHEER NI N AT ERRDN AETWI OENL AL LA SR A TL VAAPDP ORRA DIS A AL ÍL ESX, PLELR C T Ann Aceves Nancy Day Paula Mays Hodges Alexander M. Meiklejohn Hilario Romero Anne Weaver and Stephen Thompson Anonymous - 5 Mercedes M. Agogino, Ph.D. Steven Dayton Susanne Hoffman-Dooley, JD, and Colin Meiklejohn David Rose and Ceil Murray Alan Webber and Frances Diemoz Blythe Baebler * Ann Alexander, MD, and Richard Khanlian Charles de Saillan Con Dooley, MD Douglas and Harriet Meiklejohn Rose Mountain, Inc. Maurice Webster Stuart Bluestone Daniel and Cynthia Allan Russ Deal Dave and Liddy Holland Stuart Meiklejohn Ellen Rosen and Bruce Reynolds Kappy Wells Sandy Buffett Kristina Alley, SFA Bryan and Beverley Dees Rosemary Holland Daniel Merians Dena Ross Stanley Wernick Mary Dykton Jonathan and Kathleen Altman Foundation Glen DeGarmo Anita Holtz Yana Merrill Patsie and Paul Milasevich Joan and Truel West Barbara Fix Arden and Heather Anderson Marcia and George deGarmo Elizabeth Hoobler Linda Milanesi Pamela Roy Peter T. White Don and Lorraine Goldman * Neal Apple and Vicki Allen Michael and Sheryl DeGenring Elaine Hounsell Betsy Millard Vicente Roybal Robert Wickham Harriett and Wendell Harris Amber Archer Allison Dellinger & Ches Hortenstine Donna House Matthew Miller Richard J. Rubin Anne Heath Widmark Elaine Hounsell * Michael Armstrong Anita Deming Ms. Jeanette Howard Robbie Miller Santy D. Sacco Richard and Martha Wilder Frances (Bonnie) Jacobs * Chris Baker Elaine Diers Hank and Bonney Hughes David Milliken Kent Salazar Paul Wilken Shelbie Knox Diana Baker Eileen Dodds Tracy M. Hughes Ralph Milnes David M. Salman Marie B. Wilkinson and Cyril Christo Michael and Diane Lilley Reid Bandeen and Vickie Peck David Doezema, M.D. Paul Hultin and Vicki Laszlo Karen Milstein, PhD, and Marjorie R. and William J. Salman John and Carolyn Wilson Ouida MacGregor Leslie Barclay Phyllis Dolhinow Tim Hunter Phil Milstein, MD Allen and Mary Anne Sanborn Emily Wolf Lois A. Mohr Paul Bardacke and Lisa Enfield Michael Donlan Joanna Hurley Charlotte Minter John McAllen Scanlan John H. Wood, Jr. Andrew Nowak * Susan Bardes David and Rebecca Donohue Jeffrey Huser and Debra A. Paul and Genevieve Mitchell Robert Schiller Patricia Wood Peter and Jean Ossorio Avelina Bardwell, MD Dale Doremus Colonna-Huser Lois Mohr and Tom Arner Rich Schrader & Carol Gish Schrader Peter and Maureen Wurzburger Eugene and Jane Petchesky * Fund Michele Barlow and Phil Polzer Jamie Douglass Don Hyde Dennis Montoya Merry Schroeder & David Matthews Michael Zimber David Rose Mike Batte and Wanda Kile Bruce Driver Charitable Fund Tova Indritz Andrew Mooney Mary Schruben Naida Zucker and Richard Spellenberg Eugene Simon * Stephen Dubner Renee Ingold Julia Moore Nan Schwanfelder *deceased 6 ww w.nmelc.org 7

6

Thank you! Your generous support makes our work possible. 1 New Mexico 2016 Law Center Supporters 0 Environmental Law Center Green2 BusinessPartners Institutional Funders Ann Hardy Batum Spin Dunbar Diane Jacoby Susan Morgan Ira and Lorraine Schwartz Time and Talents Given By: Anonymous Anne E. Beckett Ellen and Bill Dupuy Patricia Jahoda Letitia Morris Norman A. Segel Diana Baker Albuquerque Community Foundation, Sage Fund Susan Bell Greg Dye and Estevan Trujillo Suzanne Jamison Susan Morris Donna J. Seifert Lynda Brown For more information about our Partner program, contact Elizabeth Lee Herb Block Foundation Reed and Melinda Benson Mary Dykton Kitty Jansen Linda G Mowbray Bruce Shah Lara Christensen at 505.989.9022 x118, or [email protected]. Brindle Foundation Jean L. Bergeron Kathleen Economy Amy Jenkins Virginia Mudd and Clifford Burke Geoff and Catherine Shandler Colin Cox Caprock Fund of Tides Foundation, on the Amy Bertelli Connie Eichstaedt & Alan Osborne Tom and Carlyn Jervis Werner and Helen Muller Laurence Shandler , M.D., & Joan Shandler Jamie Douglass recommendation of Ms. Kappy Wells Crawford Best Elizabeth Elliston Sam and Isabel Jewell Ann Mumford Deborah Shapiro Bruce Frederick, Esq. Combined Federal Campaign of the National Paul and Ellen Biderman Bernard Ewell and Sali Randell Richard and Ella Jones James Murphy Patricia A. Sheely Robert L. Hiller, Esq. Capital Area Garland Bills Allison Muller Fabara Mark and Susan Kalin Paula Musetta Betsy Sheils Tracy M. Hughes, Esq. Con Alma Health Foundation Sallie Bingham Fairholm Builders, Inc. Norty and Summers Kalishman Phil Musser and Carol MacLennan Danielle Shelley Paul Hultin, Esq. Dawn Hill Fund Susan Binneweg and Owen Jones James Faris Marjorie Kamine Shirley Ann Myers Betsy and Tom Shillinglaw Marjorie Kamine Desert Southwest Combined Federal Campaign Fred and Daryl Black Stuart Feen and Sunny Sonnenschein Heather Karlson and Bill Leeson Julia and Albert Nathanson Linda Siegle Warren Marr Dottie J. Barrett Giving Account Billie Blair and Gene Weisfeld Maria Fellin Diane Karp Judith Naumberg Janet Simon Marilyn Maxwell Douglass Family Foundation Joyce Blalock Ella Joan Fenoglio Dr. Kirt Kempter Jean Neblett Pat Simons Pat McDaniel EMA Foundation Stuart M. Bluestone, Esq. Elizabeth Ferguson Cynthia Kiersnowski Sharon Kellum Neuman and Ken and Martha Simonsen Colin McKenzie James M. Ewell Charitable Foundation Michele Boccia & Lewis Sawatzky Kathleen Fiero Larry J King Richard Neuman Water Singing-on-the-Rocks Michelle Mosser W.K. Kellogg Foundation Tony Bonanno Kristina Fisher and Phil Carter Holly Kinley News Corp Giving Daryl and Lucia Smith Phil Musser Charlotte L. Kiser Charitable Trust Karen Bonime and Richard Weiner Barbara Fix Gayle Kinsey Betsy Nichols Jane Smith-Decker William Olson, P.E. Lannan Foundation Adriano Bravo Thomas & Nancy Florsheim Family Fdn Don Kirby and Joan Gentry Charles Noble Leona Sonne Alice Sealey Max and Anna Levinson Foundation Jane Brickner Richard and Karen Ford Richard Klein and Claire Zoeller Steven Oakey Sherill Spaar John Stroud, Esq. Livingry Foundation Grace Brill and Daniel Schwartz Wallace and Valerie Ford Pat Klock Elizabeth O'Brien Theodore Spencer Cathie Sullivan Maki Foundation William Briney Lisa Foster Shelbie Knox and David Clark Christopher O'Connor Elliot Steinberg, Esq. Alice van Buren Mills Family Foundation Michael Browde Jennifer Fowler-Propst Sandra Koenig Terry Odendahl Natali Steinberg Roderick Ventura, Esq. Mumford Family Foundation Lynda and Donald Brown Lisa Freeman Ruth and Paul Kovnat William C. Olson Stephens and Associates Garret Vreeland New Cycle Foundation Polly Brown and David Fowler Martha Anne Freeman Patricia Kuhlhoff Peter and Jean Ossorio Eliza Stewart Emma Warren New Mexico Community Foundation Timothy Brown Dody Fugate Diana Lahm Dennis and Trudy O’Toole Jean Stokes Joan West Lynda Taylor Environmen t, Education and Harry Browne Jamie Gagan, M.D. Joan Bluestone Landorf Lois Owens Nancy Stone Social Justice Fund, New Mexico Community Fdn . J & M Buchholz Gwendolyn Gallagher and Don Krier Michael and Barbara Langner George and Elise Packard Gavin F. Strathdee Gifts Made in Memory Of: New Society Fund Judith Buckingham Faith Garfield Ellen LaPenna Ramon Padilla Kim Straus, Jack Lain & Jose Lain-Straus Winston O. Abbott New-Land Foundation Sandy Buffett Eileen Gauna David and Barbara Larson Ronald Parry Persis Suddeth James B. Alley Jr. The Dennis A. O'Toole Family Foundation David W Burling Nicholas Gentry Robin Laughlin Jim and Jan Patterson Cathie Sullivan Frank Bell Patagonia, Inc. Mary Ellen Burns-Gonzales Sheila Gershen Kirsten Lear David and Therese Patton Kristine Suozzi Florence Dobrinski ink we ll PrairieFire Foundation Virginia Burris Marvin J. Godner, M.D. Elizabeth Lee Charles and Sharon Pedersen Scott Swearingen Gene Haber pro duc tions Santa Fe Community Foundation Jay Bush and Peggy Rudberg The Golden Eye Lynn Lee Van and Katherine Perkins Karen and Bob Sweeney Sebia Hawkins Blair-Weisfeld Fund, Santa Fe Community Fdn . J.A. Carden Dick Goldsmith Ellen Leitzer Roger Peterson Jane Swift David Henderson Cabin Fund, Santa Fe Community Fdn. Mary Jo Carey Carol Goodman Deirdre Lennihan Patricia Phelps T & E Incorporated Susan Hertel connec on Cabin Fund, Santa Fe Community Fdn. Michael Casaus Eda Gordon Greg and Amy Lewis Stephen and Rodene Phillips John and Katie Tauxe Gwen Ifill Castagnola Family Fund, Santa Fe Community Fdn. Ellen Casey and Nubia Domres Susan Gordon Edwina Lieb Glenn Conroy & Jane Phillips-Conroy Edwina Taylor Keith A. Kellum Helen R. Homans Advised Donor Fund, Liliana Castillo Tom Gorman Jason A. Lillegraven Sarah Piltch and David Heber Margo Taylor Geraldine Kilpatrick the z uni Santa Fe Community Fdn. John Catron Fancher Gotesky Michael W. and Diane Lilley Ellen Pinnes Fred Teitelbaum Walter Maslowicz Just Woke Up Fund, Santa Fe Community Fdn . Mr. and Mrs. Thomas B. Catron Joel and Cherrin Green Carlie Lines and B.C. Rimbeaux Ray and Carol Pittman Alice Temple and Frank Herdman Donald and Betty Meiklejohn New Cycle Foundation, Santa Fe Community Fdn. Carolyn Chambers George Greer, M.D. & Requa Tolbert Debra Link Plastic Bottle Corporation Mr. and Mrs. Simon Teolis Elizabeth Meiklejohn Sanford and Jane Brickner Advised Fund, Rod Chambers Gila Tree Thinners Jane Lipman Dan and Nancy Potter Beverly Terry Robert J. Myers Santa Fe Community Fdn. Susan Chappell, Esq. Sharon Gross Lucy Lippard Charles M. Powers Aija Thacher Paul V. Thompson Second Anonymous Fund, Santa Fe Wendy Chase Jana Gunnell, M.D., MPH Larry and Julianne Littlefield V.B. and Rini Price Gordon and Mary Anne Thompson Mary Tony Young Community Fdn. Barbara Chatterjee Peter Hagen & Lindsay Faulkner Hagen John Loges & Lori Remegio-Loges Betty Pritchard Todd Tibbals and Andrea Escher Susan and Conrad De Jong Fund, Santa Fe KESHI Gifts Made in Honor Of: Peter and Elizabeth Chestnut Gail and Daryl Haggard Margaret Loyd Jennifer Pruett and Kennan Girdner Mary Toll Community Fdn. Tom and Carol Aageson P.R .Christie Jim Hannan Arabelle Luckhardt Sheila Pugach Jere and Harry Turner TW Family Fund, Santa Fe Community Fdn. Jessica Aberly Cecilia Clark Wendell and Harriett Harris Mr. and Mrs. Donald Lundgren Joan Quinn Robert Lawrence & Olive Wilkinson Schwab and Donegan Gift Fund Richard Ford, Ph.D. Jack and Cindy Clark Richard and Anna Harrison Sonia Macdonald Dr . Patrick and Stacy Quinn Turnipseed Sierra Club Foundation Taran Hunter Camille Coates Jonathan E. Hartshorne Ouida MacGregor Bonnie Raitt Mary Uhl Sulica Fund Robin Laughlin A.T. and Cinda Cole Don and Cheryl Hastings Kimberly Macloud Bishop Ricardo Ramirez Kristin and Ross Ulibarri Thornburg Foundation Douglas Meiklejohn Juana Col ón Steven Hecht Carol Madley Edward and Melanie Ranney United Church of Santa Fe Turner Foundation Meiklejohn Legacy Circle Carol Condie Gary Hein Laurie Maitre Mary Ray Eric Unzicker, MD United Way of Central New Mexico Rose Miller Philip and Quarrier Cook Karen Heldmeyer, Ph.D. Hal Malone Margaret and Lewis Reade Alice Van Buren LILLE Y L AW OFFIC ES United Way of Northern New Mexico Alan Osborne and Connie Eichstaedt Dianne C. Cress & Jon B. McCorkell Juliana Henderson Eileen Mandel Lee Reynis Roderick Ventura and Josette Haddad LAS CRUCES Individual Donors Michael and Jennie Crews Gregg Henry and Wenda Trevathan Michael Mandell Geri Rhodes Stephen Verchinski 2016 Bequests Anonymous Florence Cromwell Ellen and Bruce Herr Claire Mandeville Jean Richards Donna and John Vogel Elaine Hounsell Thomas and Carol Aageson Bill and Liz Crosman Matthew and Julia Meredith Hess Sarah Manges Kitty Richards and Chuck Logan Wendy Volkmann Bonnie Jacobs Rick and Kathy Abeles Margo Cutler Ann and Jerry Hicks James C . and Sherry Martin Ronald Rinker Garret and Sandra Vreeland Eugene and Jane Petchesky Fund at the Naomi Aberly Nancy Dahl Catherine Hill Alexandria J. Martinez Michael Ripberger Adair Waldenberg and Jon Peck Santa Fe Community Foundation Rachel Aberly Roger and Jeanne Daigger Christianne Hinks James A . McGrath Rhonda Rivera Richard & Carol Warren Richard and Barbara Davis Robert and Patricia Hinton Barbara McIntyre Edward Roden-Lucero L. Watchempino Esther Abeyta Meiklejohn Legacy Circle TBHEER NI N AT ERRDN AETWI OENL AL LA SR A TL VAAPDP ORRA DIS A AL ÍL ESX, PLELR C T Ann Aceves Nancy Day Paula Mays Hodges Alexander M. Meiklejohn Hilario Romero Anne Weaver and Stephen Thompson Anonymous - 5 Mercedes M. Agogino, Ph.D. Steven Dayton Susanne Hoffman-Dooley, JD, and Colin Meiklejohn David Rose and Ceil Murray Alan Webber and Frances Diemoz Blythe Baebler * Ann Alexander, MD, and Richard Khanlian Charles de Saillan Con Dooley, MD Douglas and Harriet Meiklejohn Rose Mountain, Inc. Maurice Webster Stuart Bluestone Daniel and Cynthia Allan Russ Deal Dave and Liddy Holland Stuart Meiklejohn Ellen Rosen and Bruce Reynolds Kappy Wells Sandy Buffett Kristina Alley, SFA Bryan and Beverley Dees Rosemary Holland Daniel Merians Dena Ross Stanley Wernick Mary Dykton Jonathan and Kathleen Altman Foundation Glen DeGarmo Anita Holtz Yana Merrill Patsie and Paul Milasevich Joan and Truel West Barbara Fix Arden and Heather Anderson Marcia and George deGarmo Elizabeth Hoobler Linda Milanesi Pamela Roy Peter T. White Don and Lorraine Goldman * Neal Apple and Vicki Allen Michael and Sheryl DeGenring Elaine Hounsell Betsy Millard Vicente Roybal Robert Wickham Harriett and Wendell Harris Amber Archer Allison Dellinger & Ches Hortenstine Donna House Matthew Miller Richard J. Rubin Anne Heath Widmark Elaine Hounsell * Michael Armstrong Anita Deming Ms. Jeanette Howard Robbie Miller Santy D. Sacco Richard and Martha Wilder Frances (Bonnie) Jacobs * Chris Baker Elaine Diers Hank and Bonney Hughes David Milliken Kent Salazar Paul Wilken Shelbie Knox Diana Baker Eileen Dodds Tracy M. Hughes Ralph Milnes David M. Salman Marie B. Wilkinson and Cyril Christo Michael and Diane Lilley Reid Bandeen and Vickie Peck David Doezema, M.D. Paul Hultin and Vicki Laszlo Karen Milstein, PhD, and Marjorie R. and William J. Salman John and Carolyn Wilson Ouida MacGregor Leslie Barclay Phyllis Dolhinow Tim Hunter Phil Milstein, MD Allen and Mary Anne Sanborn Emily Wolf Lois A. Mohr Paul Bardacke and Lisa Enfield Michael Donlan Joanna Hurley Charlotte Minter John McAllen Scanlan John H. Wood, Jr. Andrew Nowak * Susan Bardes David and Rebecca Donohue Jeffrey Huser and Debra A. Paul and Genevieve Mitchell Robert Schiller Patricia Wood Peter and Jean Ossorio Avelina Bardwell, MD Dale Doremus Colonna-Huser Lois Mohr and Tom Arner Rich Schrader & Carol Gish Schrader Peter and Maureen Wurzburger Eugene and Jane Petchesky * Fund Michele Barlow and Phil Polzer Jamie Douglass Don Hyde Dennis Montoya Merry Schroeder & David Matthews Michael Zimber David Rose Mike Batte and Wanda Kile Bruce Driver Charitable Fund Tova Indritz Andrew Mooney Mary Schruben Naida Zucker and Richard Spellenberg Eugene Simon * Stephen Dubner Renee Ingold Julia Moore Nan Schwanfelder *deceased 6 ww w.nmelc.org 7 Non-Profit Org N E W M E X I C O US Postage PAID En viro nmen tal Law C ent er Santa Fe, NM 1405 Luisa St reet, Suite #5 | Santa Fe ,NM 875 05 Permit No. 259 505.989.9022 nmelc .org RETURN SERVICE REQUESTED

Twitter .com/NMELC Facebook .com/NMELC Impact Report

2New Mexic016o Environmental Law Cente r |

NMELC 2016 DOC KET 20 16 Clients:

Representation by Amigos Bravos CASE TYPE Colonias Development Council 16 Communities for Clean Water Uranium Mining Concerned Citizens for Nuclear Safety & Reclamation Earthworks Eastern Navajo Diné Against Uranium 9 Mining (ENDAUM) Federal Facilities Friends of Santa Fe County (LAN L/ KAFB) Gila Conservation Coalition 5 Gila Resources Information Project (GRIP) Air Quality Honor Our Pueblo Existence (H .O.P.E.) Individuals 5 Lea County Concerned Citizens Hardrock Mariano Lake Chapter Citizens Mining Mesquite Community Action Committee Multicultural Alliance for a Safe 4 Environment (MASE) Water Right s& Speculation New Mexico Health Equity Working Group Nuclear Watch New Mexico 4 Oil and Gas Accountability Project 2016 Year In Revie w: Oil & Gas Pajarito Village Association Drilling Red Water Pond Road Community Assoc. 3 Rio Bonito Preserve Pr otecting New Mexico’s communities Industrial Rio Grande Chapter of the Sierra Club Dairies Rio Valle Concerned Citizens and our air, land and water in the fight 5 SouthWest Organizing Project (SWOP) for environmental justice. Other Taos Pueblo TEWA Women United Turner Ranch Properties