DOCSLIB.ORG

Final Report Recommendations

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Final Report Recommendations Independent Commission ICB on Banking Final Report Recommendations September 2011 Independent Commission ICB on Banking Final Report Recommendations September 2011 Official versions of this document are printed on 100% recycled paper. When you have finished with it please recycle it again. If using an electronic version of the document, please consider the environment and only print the pages which you need and recycle them when you have finished. © Crown copyright 2011 You may re-use this information (excluding logos) free of charge in any format or medium, under the terms of the Open Government Licence. To view this licence, visit www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government- licence/ or e-mail: [email protected]. Where we have identified any third party copyright information you will need to obtain permission from the copyright holders concerned. Any enquiries regarding this publication should be sent to: Independent Commission on Banking Victoria House Southampton Row London WC1B 4AD This document is also available from our website at http://bankingcommission.independent.gov.uk/ ISBN 978-1-845-32-829-0 Produced by the Domarn Group, London. Final Report Contents Contents ...................................................................................................................... 1 List of acronyms .........................................................................................................5 Executive summary ...................................................................................................7 Chapter 1: Introduction ..........................................................................................19 Background..........................................................................................................................19 Outline of this report ........................................................................................................20 PART I: FINANCIAL STABILITY Chapter 2: Overview ...............................................................................................23 The Commission’s approach ..........................................................................................23 Structure ...............................................................................................................................24 Loss-absorbency ................................................................................................................27 An overview of the reform package ...........................................................................29 Chapter 3: Retail ring-fence ...................................................................................35 Purpose of the ring-fence ...............................................................................................35 Location of the ring-fence ..............................................................................................36 Height of the ring-fence ..................................................................................................62 The structure of banking groups .................................................................................76 Chapter 4: Loss-absorbency ..................................................................................79 Introduction.........................................................................................................................79 Overview ...............................................................................................................................80 Should banks have much more equity? ....................................................................86 Loss-absorbing debt .......................................................................................................100 How much loss-absorbing capacity do banks need? .........................................110 Recommendations ..........................................................................................................121 Chapter 5: Economic impact and implementation .........................................123 Introduction.......................................................................................................................123 Economic benefits of reform .......................................................................................124 What are the economic costs of reform? ................................................................133 Quantifying the costs and benefits ...........................................................................139 Competitiveness ..............................................................................................................145 Government shareholdings .........................................................................................147 The pace of economic recovery .................................................................................148 Implementation ...............................................................................................................149 Independent Commission on Banking | 1 Final Report PART II: COMPETITION Chapter 6: Overview .............................................................................................153 The Commission’s approach to competition issues ............................................153 Problems of competition and choice in retail banking .....................................154 Responses to the Interim Report .................................................................................155 Summary of competition recommendations ........................................................156 Financial stability and competition...........................................................................158 Chapter 7: Assessment of the market ................................................................165 Introduction.......................................................................................................................165 Concentration in UK banking markets .....................................................................166 Barriers to entry ................................................................................................................171 Switching and choosing providers............................................................................179 Pricing and transparency ..............................................................................................187 Importance of challengers ...........................................................................................192 Summary ............................................................................................................................197 Chapter 8: Competition recommendations .....................................................203 Market structure ..............................................................................................................203 Conditions for consumer choice: switching and transparency ......................218 Pro-competitive regulation..........................................................................................227 Market investigation reference ...................................................................................230 PART III: RECOMMENDATIONS Chapter 9: Recommendations ............................................................................233 Retail ring-fence ...............................................................................................................233 Loss-absorbency ..............................................................................................................237 Competition ......................................................................................................................239 GLOSSARY AND ANNEXES Glossary ...................................................................................................................243 Annex 1: Summary of responses to the Interim Report ..................................253 Financial stability measures: structure .....................................................................253 Financial stability measures: loss-absorbency ......................................................254 Competition measures ..................................................................................................254 Competitiveness ..............................................................................................................255 Annex 2: Other financial stability and competition reforms .........................257 Financial stability .............................................................................................................257 Competition ......................................................................................................................266 Other workstreams .........................................................................................................267 2 | Independent Commission on Banking Final Report Annex 3: The economic impact of the Commission’s financial stability recommendations ................................................................................269 Introduction and summary ..........................................................................................269 The economic importance of banks and the costs of banking crises ..........270 The effects of the recommendations on the banking system ........................272 Government guarantees of bank liabilities
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Transition Report 1998 Financial Sector in Transition
    3542 TR98 Cover 13/11/98 12:10 pm Page 2 Transition report 1998 Financial sector in transition Economic transition AlbaniaArmeniaAzein central and eastern Europe, the Baltic states rbaijanBelarusBosnand the CIS iaandHerzegovinaBProgress in transition ulgariaCroatiaCzec Economic performance Financial sector hRepublicEstoniaF in transition YRMacedoniaGeor giaHungaryKazakh stanKyrgyzstanLatvi aLithuaniaMoldova PolandRomaniaRus sianFederationSlova kRepublicSloveniaT ajikistanTurkmenist anUkraineUzbekist 3542 TR98 Chapter0a 13/11/98 12:17 pm Page i Transition report 1998 Financial sector in transition Transition report 1998 Financial sector in transition Chapter 1 Transition and volatility: a year of stresses and contrasts 1.1 Introduction 2 1.2 Political transition, economic governance and social stresses 3 1.3 The crisis in Russia 3 1.4 Key challenges of the coming years: building institutions and deepening reforms 5 1.5 Growth and volatility 7 1.6 The financial sector in transition 9 1.7 Conclusions and challenges ahead 10 Annex 1.1: The Russian crisis 12 Part I Progress in transition and economic performance Chapter 2 Progress in market-oriented transition 2.1 The year in transition 22 2.2 The dynamics of the next phase of transition 23 2.3 The transition indicators 25 2.4 General trends in transition 28 2.5 The key dimensions of transition 29 Annex 2.1: Legal transition indicators 39 Annex 2.2: Infrastructure transition indicators 44 Annex 2.3: Energy efficiency and greenhouse gas emissions 46 Chapter 3 Macroeconomic performance and prospects
    [Show full text]
  • Sounding the Alarm Round 2: Protecting Democracy in Ukraine
    Sounding the Alarm Round 2: Protecting Democracy in Ukraine A Follow-up Freedom House Report July 2012 David J. Kramer Robert Nurick Oleksandr Sushko Viktoria Syumar Damon Wilson and Matthew Schaaf 1301 Connecticut Ave, NW Washington, DC 20036 (202) 296-5101 120 Wall Street New York, NY 10005 (212) 514-8040 www.freedomhouse.org With support from Freedom_house_report.indd 1 03.07.2012 15:54:35 Sounding the Alarm Round 2: Protecting Democracy in Ukraine A Follow-up Freedom House Report July 2012 Table of Contents I. Introduction................................................................................................................................................................ 2 II. Electoral Environment.............................................................................................................................................. 5 III. Civil Society.............................................................................................................................................................. 7 IV. Media......................................................................................................................................................................... 9 V. Rule of Law, Selective Prosecutions, and Corruption........................................................................................... 12 VI. Conclusion and Recommendations...................................................................................................................... 15 Appendix I .....................................................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Electoral Laws and Patronage Politics in Ukraine
    Electoral Laws and Patronage Politics in Ukraine PONARS Eurasia Policy Memo No. 229 September 2012 Oleksandr Fisun Kharkiv National University Ukraine’s current political system can be considered a classic case of patronage politics. The persistence of patronage politics in Ukraine can be attributed not only to structural, historical, and cultural factors, but also to particular decisions regarding constitutional design, electoral rules in particular. In particular, the 2010 rollback of Ukraine’ s 2004 constitutional reforms have strengthened President Viktor Yanukovych’s ability to wield both formal and informal tools of governance, including by broadening the patron-client foundations of his regime. At the same time, however, this process also has appeared to lead to a weakening of the ruling party itself while spurring consolidation of the opposition. Ironically, Ukraine’s new bout of patronage politics may in the end promote rather than hinder the country’s ongoing political transformation. Resetting the Rules of Game The transformation of Ukraine’s political system from a premier-presidential system with a dual executive (2005-2010) to a super-presidential regime began with the 2010 restoration of the 1996 constitution. This involved a rollback of the 2004 constitutional reforms, which had led to the formalization of electoral competition between patron- client networks via a party list system and the expansive growth of major networks, such as the Party of Regions (PR), led by Yanukovych, and the Yulia Tymoshenko Bloc (BYuT), both of which formed effective political machines for the accumulation of votes and the nationwide redistribution of patronage. After winning the presidential election in 2010, Yanukovych commanded a relative party majority in the parliament, which his predecessors Leonid Kuchma and Viktor Yushchenko never had.
    [Show full text]
  • Ukraine: Current Issues and U.S. Policy
    Ukraine: Current Issues and U.S. Policy Steven Woehrel Specialist in European Affairs May 12, 2011 Congressional Research Service 7-5700 www.crs.gov RL33460 CRS Report for Congress Prepared for Members and Committees of Congress Ukraine: Current Issues and U.S. Policy Summary On February 7, 2010, Viktor Yanukovych defeated Prime Minister Yuliya Tymoshenko to win Ukraine’s presidency. International monitors praised the conduct of the election, although Tymoshenko charged that the election had been fraudulent. Yanukovych was able to quickly to form a new parliamentary majority in the current parliament by inducing dozens of supporters of the previous government to change sides. Government opponents charged that bribery and threats to the business interests of members were used to effect the change. The global economic crisis hit Ukraine hard. Ukraine’s real Gross Domestic Product (GDP) fell by an estimated 15% in 2009. The economy began to recover in 2010, with GDP increasing by 4.2%, due in part to a surge in demand for Ukrainian steel exports. However, living standards for many Ukrainians remain low, leading to a rapid drop in Yanukovych’s popularity when compared to the period soon after his inauguration. President Yanukovych has pursued closer ties with Russia, especially in the economic sphere. A major focus of his policy has been to seek reduced prices for natural gas supplies from Moscow. In April 2010, he agreed to extend the lease of the Russian Black Sea Fleet in Ukraine for 25 years in exchange for a reduction in gas prices. However, the impact of the deal on gas prices has been less than anticipated, as oil prices (on which Ukraine’s gas price is calculated) have soared due to unrest in the Middle East.
    [Show full text]
  • Elections, Decline of Democracy Arliamentary Elections Were the Biggest News from Pukraine in 2012
    No. 2 THE UKRAINIAN WEEKLY SUNDAY, JANUARY 13, 2013 5 2012: THE YEAR IN REVIEW In Ukraine: elections, decline of democracy arliamentary elections were the biggest news from PUkraine in 2012. But there was news also regarding the prosecution of opposition leader and former Prime Minister Yulia Tymoshenko and Ukraine’s further slide in terms of democratization, which could not but have a neg- ative effect on the country’s relations with the West. (Indeed, many observers said that Kyiv’s relations with the West are now worse than they have ever been during the 21 years of Ukraine’s renewed independence.) And then there were the numerous steps taken by President Viktor Yanukovych and his Cabinet to de-Ukrainianize Ukraine. In short, there was not much in the way of good news from Ukraine. Parliamentary elections Preparation for the October 28 elections of a new Verkhovna Rada got off to a good start on January 22, when Ukraine’s pro-Western opposition leaders signed an agreement to unite their candidates into a single list to compete for single-winner, single-mandate districts in the elections in order to take the reins of government away UDAR from the Donetsk clan before it consolidated power even The opposition in Ukraine’s new Parliament, elected on October 28, is led by (from left) Ukrainian Democratic further. Half of Ukraine’s 450 members of Parliament are Alliance for Reform Chair Vitali Klitschko, Batkivshchyna Party Chair Arseniy Yatsenyuk and Svoboda Party elected in single-winner, single-mandate districts (the so- Chair Oleh Tiahnybok. called majoritarian system), while the other half are cho- sen via closed-list voting for political parties, which will Front for Change and UDAR representatives to local elec- “Ruin is overcome, stability achieved!” was among the need to surpass a 5 percent barrier (the so-called propor- tion commissions, denial of registration for a candidate main themes of the Party of Regions during this year’s tional system).
    [Show full text]
  • Sounding the Alarm: Protecting Democracy in Ukraine
    Sounding the Alarm: Protecting Democracy in Ukraine A Freedom House Report on the State of Democracy and Human Rights in Ukraine April 2011 David J. Kramer Robert Nurick Damon Wilson with Evan Alterman i TABLE OF CONTENTS Foreword ii Executive Summary 1 Background 3 A Weak Foundation 4 Electoral Environment 6 Corruption 8 Role of the SBU 9 Judiciary 10 Media 12 Education, Culture, and Religion 14 In the Regions 15 Conclusions and Recommendations 16 Appendix I: List of Delegation Interlocutors 20 Appendix II: Assessment Team 22 Acknowledgments 23 About Freedom House 24 ii Foreword One year after Ukrainian citizens elected Viktor Yanukovych as their new president, Freedom House sent an independent team of experts to Kyiv, Kharkiv, and Lviv to assess the country’s democracy and human rights situation. The assessment was conducted one month after Freedom House downgraded Ukraine from Free to Partly Free in its Freedom in the World 2011 rankings.1 Until that point, Ukraine had been the only non-Baltic former Soviet state ranked in the Free category; it was one of only two countries worldwide to be downgraded to Partly Free for developments in 2010. Freedom House, with support from the Open Society Foundations, decided to conduct this assessment for several reasons. With a population of 46 million and shared borders with the European Union (EU) and NATO member states, as well as with Russia, Ukraine is a country of vast importance. If it becomes a more established, democratic, market-oriented member of the Euro-Atlantic community, it will have a positive effect on the wider region and become a success story for its neighbors to emulate.
    [Show full text]
  • The Ukrainian Weekly 2012, No.9
    www.ukrweekly.com INSIDE: l Viktor Yanukovych and organized crime – page 3 l Vitali Klitschko defeats Dereck Chisora – page 5 l Travels: Ukrainian folklore in Kazakhstan – page 11 THEPublished U by theKRAINIAN Ukrainian National Association Inc., a fraternal W non-profit associationEEKLY Vol. LXXX No. 9 THE UKRAINIAN WEEKLY SUNDAY, FEBRUARY 26, 2012 $1/$2 in Ukraine Euro-2012 in Ukraine World’s most influential women asked to help faces lodging crisis: secure release of Ukraine’s political prisoners shortages, high prices by Zenon Zawada Special to The Ukrainian Weekly KYIV – Ukraine is facing a lodging crisis for the 20 days it will host the Euro-2012 soccer champi- onship this summer, reported government offi- cials. A significant portion of the hotel rooms in the four host cities are already booked, according to media reports, with prices surging for the remainder. “We gave them a zero profit tax rate and prices are increasing nevertheless,” Vice Prime Minister of Infrastructure of Ukraine Borys Kolesnikov UNIAN/Valery Solovyov UNIAN/Oleg Gordienko UNIAN/Aleksandr Sinitsa said at a February 17 press conference, UNIAN Lina Kostenko Nina Matvienko Oleksandra Kuzhel reported. Between June 11 and July 1, the cities of Kyiv, KYIV – Three famous women of Ukraine – author Lina by courts but by voters.” Her unjust imprisonment, they stress, Lviv, Kharkiv and Donetsk will host Euro-2012, a Kostenko, singer Nina Matvienko and politician Oleksandra is dangerous not only because Ukraine’s government has tram- soccer championship between national teams Kuzhel – have sent an open letter addressed to the 20 most pled on her rights and freedoms, but because this lawlessness organized every four years by the Union of influential women of the world, calling for help in securing the has made every person in Ukraine vulnerable to the arbitrary European Football Associations (UEFA).
    [Show full text]
  • Project Progress Report 2 Project Progress Report Context
    DEVELOPMENT INITIATIVE FOR ADVOCATING LOCAL ASSOCIATION OF GOVERNANCE IN UKRAINE (DIALOGUE PROJECT) UKRAINIAN CITIES BY JOINT EFFORTS D I A L O G U E PROJECT PROGRESS REPORT 2 PROJECT PROGRESS REPORT CONTEXT The technical proposal for the DIALOGUE Project was being prepared in late 2009 in the full swing of the pre-election campaign for the 2010 presidential elections. The then Tymoshenko Government raised great hopes for the implementation of the long-overdue local government reform. With the active support of the then Prime Minister of Ukraine, the Cabinet of Ministers approved the Concept of the Local Government Reform and the work to prepare the legislation to promote the reform implementation started. The DIALOGUE Project was originally prepared to support the Government of Ukraine in its aspirations towards the implementation of the local government reform and was aimed at promoting the environment and development of the toolkit to plan and roll out this reform with the active participation of local governments and opportunities for them to provide their input. The March 2010 presidential elections dramatically changed the situation in the country. V. Yanukovych who was elected the President of Ukraine quickly reinstated the Soviet one-party traditions, and built up a central government vertical line of command right a er the local elections (autumn of 2010) and parliamentary elections (autumn of 2012). The Ukrainian parliament whose membership consisted of numerous political parties who ran the elections race quickly turned into the machine well manipulated by the Administration of President Yanukovych to make decision in his favour. The return to the majoritarian system of elections gave rise to a new class of parliamentarians – so-called “Tushkas” (MPs who change their aff iliation in the parliament in their own favour).
    [Show full text]
  • U.S. Dedicates New Embassy Compound in Kyiv WASHINGTON – U.S
    INSIDE: l Soprano Victoria Loukianetz debuts in D.C. – page 10 l Historic cemeteries in the Lemko region – page 11 l Wladimir Klitschko notches 50th KO – page 16 THEPublished U by theKRAINIAN Ukrainian National Association Inc., a fraternal W non-profit associationEEKLY Vol. LXXX No. 11 THE UKRAINIAN WEEKLY SUNDAY, MARCH 11, 2012 $1/$2 in Ukraine Ukrainian Canadian Congress New bill calls for transfer opens National Office in Ottawa of religious sites to UOC-MP by Zenon Zawada “No one is talking about the transfer of Special to The Ukrainian Weekly the Monastery of the Caves National Historic and Cultural Reserve now,” Mr. KYIV – The Party of Regions of Ukraine Kulyniak said at a January 31 briefing. “I and its allies have launched their latest am acquainted with the draft law, even campaign to aid the Russian Orthodox though it has not been passed to the Church (ROC) – through its proxy, the Ministry of Culture for elaboration and Ukrainian Orthodox Church – Moscow expert assessment so far.” Patriarchate (UOC-MP) – in gaining owner- As soon as President Viktor Yanukovych ship of Ukraine’s holiest sites with legisla- was elected two years ago, his government tion introduced in Parliament in mid-Janu- began issuing decrees setting the condi- ary. tions for the UOC-MP to take control of The proposed law “On Transferring those holiest sites that are currently owned Cultural Heritage Sites to Religious and administered by the state, including St. Organizations,” or Bill No. 9690, calls for Sophia Cathedral and the territory of the UCC transferring ownership from the state to Church of Tithes (Desiatynna Church).
    [Show full text]
  • Can Authoritarian Regimes Learn? the Cases of Belarus, Kazakhstan, Russia And
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by University of Birmingham Research Archive, E-theses Repository 1 CAN AUTHORITARIAN REGIMES LEARN? THE CASES OF BELARUS, KAZAKHSTAN, RUSSIA AND UKRAINE. BY STEPHEN HALL A Thesis submitted as part of the requirements for MARES Russian and East European Studies at the University of Birmingham Centre for Russian and East European Studies School of Government and Society College of Social Sciences University of Birmingham Date of Submission 09/2014 Word Count: 40,000 University of Birmingham Research Archive e-theses repository This unpublished thesis/dissertation is copyright of the author and/or third parties. The intellectual property rights of the author or third parties in respect of this work are as defined by The Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988 or as modified by any successor legislation. Any use made of information contained in this thesis/dissertation must be in accordance with that legislation and must be properly acknowledged. Further distribution or reproduction in any format is prohibited without the permission of the copyright holder. 2 ABSTRACT Authoritarian learning has received scant attention in academic literature. This analysis emphasises how authoritarian regimes in the former-Soviet Union (FSU) learn from one another to consolidate authoritarianism. The argument is that regimes use similar tactics and institutions to consolidate authoritarianism. The study uses the cases of Belarus, Kazakhstan, Russia and Ukraine to offer comprehensive analysis of authoritarian consolidation. Using a methodology of case studies, longitudinal analysis and discourse analysis, I show that these regimes have become more authoritarian, using similar tactics and building comparable institutions.
    [Show full text]
  • Ukrainian Parliamentarianism, Parliament and 2012 Rada Elections
    NATIONAL SECURITY & DEFENCE π 7-8 (136-137) CONTENT 2012 PARLIAMENT AND THE 2012 PARLIAMENTARY ELECTIONS IN UKRAINE: POLITICAL SITUATION, PUBLIC SPIRITS AND EXPECTATIONS Founded and published by: (Аnalytical report by the Razumkov Centre) ................................................... 2 1. PARLIAMENTARISM IN UKRAINE: INSTITUTIONAL SUPPORT, STATE AND TRENDS .........................................................................................3 2. UKRAINE’S 2012 PARLIAMENTARY ELECTIONS: UKRAINIAN CENTRE FOR ECONOMIC & POLITICAL STUDIES LEGISLATION, ELECTORAL SUBJECTS AND THEIR POWERS ...............................19 NAMED AFTER OLEXANDER RAZUMKOV 3. SOCIO-POLITICAL SITUATION IN THE COUNTRY BEFORE PARLIAMENTARY ELECTIONS ...........................................................28 Director General Anatoliy Rachok Editor Valeriya Klymenko 4. PUBLIC SPIRITS DURING THE ELECTION CAMPAIGN Layout and design Oleksandr Shaptala AND EXPECTATIONS FROM THE NEW PARLIAMENT ......................................55 Technical support Volodymyr Kekukh 5. CONCLUSIONS AND PROPOSALS ................................................................. 76 EXPERTS ON PARLIAMENT AND PARLIAMENTARY ELECTIONS IN UKRAINE ........ 80 This journal is registered with the State Committee of Ukraine for Information Policy, UKRAINIAN PARLIAMENTARISM: ISSUES AND POSSIBLE SOLUTIONS registration certificate KB №4122 (Interviews) ............................................................................................................ 86 Stepan HAVRYSH, Volodymyr LYTVYN,
    [Show full text]
  • Coalition Politics in Ukraine's Verkhovna Rada
    Running Header: Coalition Politics in Ukraine’s Verkhovna Rada As the Post-Soviet World Turns: Coalition Politics in Ukraine’s Verkhovna Rada from 2006-Present By Jillian Kozyra Nr1072144 Masters thesis written under the supervision of dr hab. Marek Kucia, prof. UJ September 2012 Krakow, Poland Coalition Politics in Ukraine’s Verkhovna Rada 2 Acknowledgements I would like to thank the following people for their many different ways of assisting me in writing this thesis: my adviser, dr. hab. Marek Kucia, for his support and trust along the way; my parents for scaring me into actually writing this, and for tempering the threats with patience as I muddled along; my big little sister, Alexandra, for many amusing stories and Skype chats with Sophie to keep my morale up; my little little sister, Nia, for providing a welcome distraction from work and adulthood, and for giving me glasses of water garnished with cheese for sustenance while I frantically wrote; Mairéad, my “other mother”, for allowing me to write in the most beautiful place imaginable, and for teaching me the fiddle to calm me down between bouts of writing; all of the the Mooneys, especially Ann and Granny, + Howard, for being my adoptive family and helping to keep me sane through their confidence in my abilities; Kirsty, for the panicked but encouraging, and always entertaining, marathon-writing-session gchats; Ronan, for helping me to actually get responses to the survey questionnaire; Jackie, for jokingly suggesting the first part of my title, never expecting that I’d actually keep it; and Blondie, for the constant cuddles , which I’m receiving even as I write this.
    [Show full text]